2021年7月13日火曜日
JP
yan liang kelton
1
アバターの画像
Vested Interest and Limits to Reform - MMT - John Henry
124 回視聴2017/11/11
3
0
共有
保存
Michabo Sustainable Harmony
チャンネル登録者数 7530人
First International Conference on Modern Monetary Theory 2017
Important comments very pertinent to MMT Job Guarantee Programs.
John F. Henry
Professor Emeritus - California State University Sacramento
Research Professor 2005 to 2014 – UMKC
Veblen-Commons Award 2016 - Association for Evolutionary Economics
MA and Ph.D. Economics - McGill University
コメントはオフになっています。詳細
文字起こし
I'm not hostile to the WPA I could make
a presentation all the great things that
the WPA accomplished but that's not my
objective I want to speak to issues that
I think JG the job guarantee program
adherence should pay attention to even
within the framework of a capitalist
economy governments could should they
choose generate a near fully employed
economy because I don't think we I don't
think we want a new WPA Roosevelt
Tugwell others were also averse to
large-scale government project they saw
these projects as actually antagonistic
to the economic order Harry Hopkins I
would not have us compete by public
works with private industry
those cultural projects educational
projects I would argue in the long run
were actually if not more more important
than the infrastructure the construction
of buildings and what-have-you
they were at least as important the CWA
was extremely impressive actually given
two months of existence and the first
such project that the government
undertook why was it canceled very
quickly get the economy moving and then
stand back get out of the way that was
the eye that was the objective
why aren't labor unions pushing for a
job guarantee program the program WPA
did pay market wages but in the South
market wages for blacks and whites in
particular in the South were
significantly different an anti-racist
program has to be included in the jobs
guarantee not just anti-racist gender
issues all environmental issues
without reservations but a model for the
job guarantee programs that are being
floated and of course job guarantee
programs have an a relationship a very
close relationship to MNT because we all
know that in fact even within the
framework of a capitalist economy
governments could should they choose
generate a near fully employed economy
I'm not precisely sure what full
employment means so I'll just say nearly
full employee anybody who wants a job
can get a job right and there's any
number of papers that have circulated
any number of presentations discussions
etc with the title something like we
need a new WPA right everybody's
familiar with that well I'm going to put
forward some let's say reservations
about the WPA several of which are not
discussed in the jg or mmt literature
right because I don't think we I don't
think we want a new WPA and you'll know
why when I'm go through the argument now
a a good deal of my criticisms are
somewhat related to Veblen's concept of
the vested interests but also we have to
talk a little bit about Keynes and I'll
bring in Hyman Minsky at a particular
point now the first thing I want to do
is discuss very quickly the economic
leadings of some of the major figures in
the roosevelt administration including
Roosevelt himself if you look at and
professor sturgeon will appreciate this
Rexford Tugwell who was the
institutionalists in the
Roosevelt administration individuals
such as Carter glass of glass steagle
the Banking Act of 1933 and so on what
you will find is the terrifying
realization that what what what you will
find is that the leading figures of the
New Deal administration were balanced
budget sound money men as they called
themselves okay
Roosevelt came into office on a balanced
budget program in his first period he
slashed government spending including
military spending interestingly enough
and we know that in 1937 when the
economy looked as if it might be
recovering he reverted to his balanced
budget mantra again spending with Slash
including spending on the WPA and the
result was the 1938 reversal right back
into a depression Roosevelt
Tugwell others were also averse to
large-scale government projects work
projects they saw these projects such as
the WPA they saw these projects as
actually antagonistic to the economic
order and to the liberal ideology that
dominated in the 1930 that is you didn't
want government activity to be
associated with anything that was
remotely of a socialist nature and put
socialists in quotation marks or for
that matter because you had criticisms
from both the left and the right or of a
fascist nature because if you look at
the Italian program starting in the
1920s you say wait a minute
that's like the WPA in certain respects
right
I don't want to strip stretch that too
far but in any case they in the
administration basically there was
actually little support for programs
like the wpa wpa2 of the WPA in a bit
now I'm not hostile to the WPA right I
could make a presentation all the great
things that the WPA accomplished but
that's not my objective I want to speak
to issues that I think JG the job
guarantee program adherence should pay
attention to right based upon the WPA
program okay now WPA accomplished great
deal infrastructure like buildings of
all sorts lots of post offices they love
post offices and you'll know why in a
second right federal theater project
federal arts project federal music
project federal writers prize it wasn't
just building post offices and schools
and football stadiums right now those
cultural projects educational projects
adult literacy programs and things of
that sort I would argue in the long run
we're actually if not more more
important than the infrastructure the
construction of buildings and
what-have-you they were at least as
important and if you look at the federal
theater project in particular under
highly Flanagan that was the most
radical aspect of the works project
Progress Administration the WPA that's
where you saw challenges to capitalism
put forward in the theater and that's
where you saw and I'm coming back to
this the only anti-racist program within
the New Deal administration if you leave
Eleanor
Roosevelt aside because she was not a
racist right but she wasn't an organizer
of the WPA okay I remind you that Kings
right even while he was participating in
the fight against the German military
machine in World War two
he agreed to chair the council for the
encouragement of music and the arts
which was organized in 1940 right in
England he was very keen on the arts and
he saw that as a an integral important
aspect of the modern economic and social
order okay now prior to the WPA
the Roosevelt administration organized
the Civil Works Administration the CWA
right organized in November 1933 under
the directorship of Harry Hopkins ended
in April of 1934 right
but essentially ended or began to end in
February 1934 to active months of
existence that's all right that's all
right now this is the first time that
the government served as what Keynes
labeled the entrepreneurs in chief right
where the government took an active role
in organizing aspects of the economy
that's Keynes references entrepreneurs
it's actually Hubert Henderson's terms
but forget that a very successful
program in the first month it employed
two million unemployed at its peak in
mid January 1934 four million had been
put on the federal payroll in its short
existence 250,000 miles of roads were
built or improved twelve million feet of
sewer line laid that's very important
given the United States of the day
school buildings constructed renovated
playgrounds hospitals etc 50,000
teachers
hired to teach adult education classes
the list is long and it's very
impressive two months of active
existence secondly wages were paid at
prevailing rates with a minimum wage
specified wait wages vary based upon
skills and region etc black and white
workers were paid the same wage
okay keep bear that in mind all right
let's go
administrators of the CWA established a
catalogue of skills and attempted to
match skills with the jobs at hand right
now the question is the CWA was
extremely impressive actually given two
months of existence and the first such
project that the government undertook
why was it canceled very quickly why was
it canceled well the first problem with
the CWA was that it was an emergency
program
lots of most of the New Deal programs we
emergency right let me quote the
National Resources Planning Board which
we could talk about at length if we
chose but we don't National Resources
Planning Board the emergency nature the
New Deal programs proved problematic and
stabilizing employment a series of
emergency programs the public works
construction may be self-defeating and
achieving the aim of employment
stabilization throughout the entire
period discussed there was no definitely
continuing policy to guide the planners
administrators of federal state local
government each program was said it as
if it were the last now if you go to
Cannes probably no she's doing something
else
bubbly mature tournament there oh oh
you're here I thought you were okay
Pavlina has a paper of 2012 or whatever
where she brings in Keynes's on-the-spot
Employment Program
this is very similar to hyman minsky
taking workers as they are a continuing
program right not an emergency program
not a temporary now of course
jg adherents want a continuing program
but it's very important that that be
built into the economy as whole forget
about pump priming the neoclassical
version of Keynes or anything of that
sort it's so anyway there's a there's a
whole lot of things one could say about
the CDA why was it canceled so quickly
Roosevelt program Roosevelt
administration never had any intent to
implement programs that would conflict
with or at least so they as they saw it
the capitalist economy basically or
capitalist interests right business
interest get the economy moving and then
stand back get out of the way that was
the I that was the objective Roosevelt
and Hopkins on the CWA we must be
careful it does not become a habit with
this country government employment we
must not take the position that we are
going to have permanent depression in
this country and it is very important
that we have somebody to say quite
forcefully that's quite forcefully to
these people right so anyway objections
to the CWA this is interesting you would
you might expect the business community
to have objections since the CWA because
they were hiring unemployed workers the
fear was that this would drive up wages
for all workers right your pool of the
reserve army is diminishing
maybe wages are going to rise cost of
production going to rise that's
understandable the AF of L which was the
leading labor organization at the time
right also objected because they thought
that the program is going to drive wages
down right now this raises a question
then I have never thought about until
about three months ago two months ago
okay
why aren't labor unions pushing for a
job guarantee program
why haven't they in the past you know I
I don't have an answer it's not a
rhetorical question or anything but I
think it should be addressed what is the
issue with labor unions okay now how
much time do I have
good ok now go to the WPA finally okay
major shortcomings right first of all
limited in scope emergency etc emergency
measure right Harry Hopkins I quote the
director of the WPA policy from the
first was not to compete with private
business
hence we could neither work on private
property set up a rival merchandising
system nor form a work outlet through
manufacturing even though manufacturing
had contributed to relief rules hundreds
of thousands of workers accustomed to
operating machines and to doing nothing
else for a living okay so you don't want
to be in competition with the private
sector right so you got to find stuff
that is non-competitive right so what do
you do well you build buildings you
construct roads you construct hospitals
you set up medical programs you set up
the federal theater project you set up
etc etc etc fine
well and good of the 3,000 structures
that were built under WP auspices 1400
were post offices ask why
right and the bulk of the remainder were
school buildings it's perfectly
reasonable that school buildings right
but I ask why post offices well
non-competitive right the post office is
a government program right so you need
buildings in which males can be
deposited and moved along right market
wages the program WPA did pro
pay market wages but in the South market
wages for blacks and whites in
particular in the South were
significantly different in other words
the wage policy of the WPA maintained
the racist relationships within the
labor market right it goes beyond that
okay I want to talk a little bit about
the Agricultural Adjustment Act of 1933
the Agricultural Adjustment Act which
Professor surgeon knows a lot about
actually because he's a farmer the AAA
right in the south at the time South was
segregated oh maybe I don't know how
many people are familiar with US history
it was segregated by law right by law
this is the Jim Crow system this is that
part ID right okay the large farmers in
the South depended upon mainly tenant
farming and sharecropping and the bulk
of the sharecroppers in particular were
black okay now did the AAA touch the
segregationist agricultural system in
the South thing the answer is no tenant
farmers sharecroppers and farm labor in
general were excluded from the
Agricultural Adjustment Act and the
fairly fair wage per Labor Standards Act
of 1937 down the road there was not one
civil rights program contained within
the New Deal in other words here's a
problem right I'll make it a very
general issue
Jadey programs have to be mindful that
any such program is going to have to be
implemented within the framework of the
existing social order right the social
order in the United States is still of a
racist nature it may not be as Extreme
as that of the 1930s but it's still
racist and of course over the last
couple of years
that has become increasingly prominent
again racism or an anti-racist program
has to be included in the jobs
guaranteed program right
not just anti-racist gender issues or
environmental issues I think that the
j.g adherence of course are aware of the
environmental issues I don't hear much
about racism I don't hear much about
gender issues but if you're going to do
something that's more substantial than
just providing jobs those issues have to
be included I could talk about the
banking I can go back to the issue of
racism again but I'm not gonna do it job
classifications in the CWA you tried to
match skills to the job in the WPA it
was willy nilly right and this conforms
to Minsky taking workers as they are
right now what was necessary are were
much more extensive training programs in
addition to obviously learning on the
job you know you can learn new skills
but training programs now the j.g
programs that I've read about always
include training programs and I think
that that's that's absolutely necessary
and should be emphasized use value
exchange value okay am I done one more
one more point they the WPA could not
engage in activities that were designed
to produce what are called commodities
use values stuff right for exchange
exchange was ruled out they could only
produce use values stuff right post
offices school buildings football
stadiums were still suffering from the
University of Arkansas a football
stadium that's sort of an inside joke of
a sort but in any case used
values right now I gotta I gotta read a
quote sorry right
Harry Hopkins WPA projects were those
that are socially useful which are
important to the nation which are
outside the ordinary scope of our
economic system I would not have us
compete by public works with private
industry socially useful important but
not competitive what the WPA and other
programs demonstrated and this was
actually argued as a consequence of
World War one developments is that
government if its use could in fact
organize an economy on the basis of
use-values
only you don't require exchange to
operate an economy exchange is a
relatively recent development right and
historically significantly only within
the last four hundred years or so that's
a short time right you can organize it
now if you do that of course you're
outside a capitalist framework and
there's the problem and I'm out of time
and if anybody if anybody wants
if anybody wants larger paper on this
issue that incorporates more stuff send
me an email if you can find me real
fighting
42:25
再生中
Magna Carta's Legal Legacy: Conversation with Chief Justice Roberts & Lord Judge
Library of Congress
13万 回視聴
6 年前
9:32
再生中
AMADEUS REMASTERED HD - MOZART INSULTS SALIERI BY PLAYING HIS OWN PIECE BETTER THAN HE DID
Elsa Anna Arendelle
190万 回視聴
1 年前
2:17:02
再生中
辻田真佐憲+西田亮介(司会:東浩紀)「メディアはどうしたら自由になるのか? 総務省接待から五輪開会式まで——ゲンロン特別無料放送:『新プロパガンダ論』で時事を語る」
ゲンロン YouTube Official
11万 回視聴
3 か月前 に配信済み
再生中
【評価値放送】豊島将之竜王vs藤井聡太王位(お~いお茶杯王位戦・七番勝負第2局1日目)佐藤天彦九段vs池永天志五段(ALSOK杯王将戦・二次予選)(順位戦C級1組・3回戦)【将棋/Shogi】
見る将棋チャンネル Shogi
267 人が視聴中
ライブ配信中
16:49
再生中
Tucker on NSA spying allegations: This is a huge problem for the country
Fox Business
124万 回視聴
5 日前
新着
16:15
再生中
【番組冒頭+延長パート一部公開】辻田真佐憲×西田亮介×東浩紀【緊急特番】「酒類提供店との取引停止を要請?! そんなイジメみたいなことできるのかよ?!」(2021/7/8収録) #ゲンロン210708
ゲンロン YouTube Official
2.1万 回視聴
4 日前
新着
18:55
再生中
【将棋講座 特別編#2】基本と組合わせる二の矢!端歩を受けられた時の藤井システム講座
女流棋士 山口恵梨子ちゃんねる
11万 回視聴
3 か月前
54:29
再生中
落合貴之議員登場!菅政権の「中小企業をぶっ潰す」に大反論!(室伏謙一×落合貴之)
「新」経世済民新聞 三橋貴明 公式チャンネル
2.1万 回視聴
2 日前
新着
42:05
再生中
完全映画『バック・トゥ・ザ・フューチャー』徹底解説 初級編 / OTAKING explains "Back to the Future"
岡田斗司夫
16万 回視聴
1 年前
Relaxing Jazz: Sweet Jazz & Bossa Nova for Work, Study, Reading
BGM channel
304 人が視聴中
ライブ配信中
#09【ドラクエ11S】″壁画の美女″の真相を暴きに行くよ
アズちゃん
156 人が視聴中
ライブ配信中
【見るだけで強くなる】四間飛車の指し方を教えます!
将棋放浪記【プロ棋士】
8.1万 回視聴
1 か月前
RADIO SAKAMOTO 陰謀論に対する処方箋【20210704-OA 斎藤幸平 國分功一郎】
J-WAVE CHANNEL
2.7万 回視聴
1 週間前
辻田真佐憲+西田亮介(司会:東浩紀)「2021年の夏はどうなる? コロナと五輪に翻弄される日本社会のゆくえ――ゲンロン特別無料放送:『新プロパガンダ論』で時事を語る #2」
ゲンロン YouTube Official
8.2万 回視聴
2 週間前 に配信済み
【ルソーは大嘘つき!?】ジャングルにライオンいましたっけ?【今なら大炎上!?】
山田五郎 オトナの教養講座
16万 回視聴
2 週間前
公式戦を自ら徹底解説!女流棋士の頭の中【大成建設杯清麗戦 vs香川愛生女流三段】
女流棋士 山口恵梨子ちゃんねる
25万 回視聴
7 か月前
小林秀雄入門!文系の天才と理系の天才による歴史的対談!二人が語る人生の極意とは?【人間の建設】【小林秀雄】【岡潔】【スケザネ図書館】【書庫】
文学系チャンネル【スケザネ図書館】読書・書店Youtube
11万 回視聴
5 か月前
【魔界への誘い】あなたに魔手を伝授します
将棋放浪記【プロ棋士】
3.7万 回視聴
3 日前
新着
【ドッキリ】プロ棋士が瞬時に神読みを披露!→実は盤上に異変が起こっていました……【藤森哲也/でんがん/ヨビノリたくみ】
女流棋士・香川愛生チャンネル
13万 回視聴
1 週間前
月曜コーヒー: Good Morning Positive Music - Jazz Coffee Background Music to Start the Day
BGM channel
88 人が視聴中
ライブ配信中
登録:
コメントの投稿 (Atom)
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿