now in terms of adding that development
finance there are two types of theories
right there was a mainstream approach
and there is a right approach relying on
foreign capital it's basically not
sustainable a classic sort of a Ponzi
scheme right there now data suggests the
developing nations need to rely on
domestic resources the growth rate has
been around 10% on average since the
1980s
right now China grow at at six point
seven percent of growth rate there is
paramount evidence that China has
managed to create a Schumpeter
Schumpeterian Keynesian credit
investment income creation process which
has led to economic prosperity but the
credit driven investment like growth
eventually run out of steam due mostly
to demand constraint if we really want
to rebalance the economy have a
consumption-driven economy we need to
provide jobs to you know the workers the
ability to impose liabilities nay the
universe Hank and issue the money used
to pay down these liabilities gives
power to the authority that can be used
to further the social good alright so
this is sort of you know some of the
basic is what we have talked about in
terms of sovereign power the government
has in issuing its own currency in
paying for any real goods and services
or any resources right so the mainstream
approach as John talked about in his
2004 article the two views on obstacles
to development pointed out that you know
the mainstream approach is the apt ation
of dictation of Harrod doma growth model
that was in the 40s and 50s which
focuses on the need to increase the
resources available to support growth
since developing nations like the will
all the ability to increase domestic
savings or attract foreign capital and
so this is sort of the January and
strout's very famous 1960s - gap model
right basically talked about developing
nations don't have sufficient domestic
savings or foreign exchanges so they
have to rely on foreign foreign aid
right except that you know when you have
President Trump that came along and said
you know we need to for the American
interest first
then that's probably not gonna happen to
have you know the sufficient amount of
foreign aid that goes to the developing
nations I feel like I'm allowed to
mention this name because young Crego
did it twice right Trump right I know it
gives people a headache so so based on
this sort of analysis right the so aim
of the Lim policy is to trying to
implement policies that would increase
dramatic scenes right for example remove
the so-called financial repression right
let the financial market determine the
real the determined interest rate so
that would increase attract household
savings or trying to engage in financial
liberalization right provide a good
environment hospitable hospitable
environment to attract foreign investors
but this approach is both flawed
theoretically right and it's also
empirically shaky it just doesn't happen
so extended savings can't finance
investment we all know that right credit
drives investment investment produces
income and income create savings we can
put you know the cart before the horse
and I wrote a piece in 2012 which I
basically talked about financing or
extending credit to entrepreneurs to
deploying real resources for production
and income generation must take
precedence over savings and cannot be
constrained by the limited amount of
exert existing savings I'm sorry that
I'm doing self referencing but I felt
that I said it very nicely five years
ago and I can I can do it any better
today so butts too dark also you don't
point out the importance of bank credit
the role of banks in the process of
growth is to supplies finances where a
savings and financial markets provide
funding right so it's very clear there
on the other hand right relying on
foreign capital it's basically not
sustainable as Ron Kray go again
pointing out in his 2004 to 2014 papers
that if we wanted to continue attract
new flows right and at the same time we
have the outflow of interest payment if
we wanted to make sure that we have the
net flows right then we need to make
sure that the natural grows at the rate
that it's at least equal to the rate of
interest pay on the existing debt right
that amounts to attracting new flows who
pay interest on the odet right a classic
sort of a Ponzi scheme right there so
this is clearly not sustainable and also
it's simply a mirage to trying to get
this net resource transfers from the
developed world to developing world so
this trial took out from the United
Nations data and what he basically
showed is as 2016 we had a net resource
transfer out of developing nations to
the developed world in the amount of 500
billion dollars and you add all the
resources outflow from 1980s to 2012
that added up to 16 trillion dollars
which include four trillion dollars in
interest payment to the developed
nations lenders and so you know that
really dropped that 125 billion on
average eight per year and so again
relying on external borrowing or
external capital that is not doable it's
not supported by any empirical evidence
we do not have next resource transfer
developing world in the 80s we don't
have it today
now data suggests the developing nations
need to rely on domestic resources and
as John Craig Oh point out one most
important unutilized resources in the
developing world is their human capital
right the labor I just checked out some
that I are all data even though
developing world have been you know
having this low unemployment rate about
five percent but they have huge informal
sector right ranging from Mongolia
seventeen percent of the input informal
employment to total employment ratio to
Guatemala which has about 70 percent of
informal employment so this is exactly
what Ron mentioned this robinsons idea
of disguise unemployment so these are
really the untapped resources to be
utilized but also importantly looking at
the financial aspect we need to develop
well-functioning financial sector to
extend credit you know as tomato pizza
granting credit operates and not as an
order on economic system to accommodate
self to the purpose of the entrepreneur
as an order on the goods which he needs
it means instructing instructing him
entrusting him sorry with productive
forces it only does the economic
development could arise so on the
financial side we need to bail
the financial sector that would extend
credit in order to initiate production
and income generation and there's a
large body of research even coming from
the mainstream that talked about you
know we need banks right we need
financial institutions to allocate
resources and so on and so forth but
without the state support it would be I
would argue it would be difficult if
it's not impossible for the private
sector single handedly to provide that
kind of financing it's not even clear
where the financial development drives
economic growth or the other way around
there's a lot of debates and the
empirical evidence that has been mixed
on this front so that again puts the
importance of the role of the state
right in providing development in
general and in providing development
finance again Crego talked about in his
2004 paper that the key to development
is to promote technical progress and the
form of managerial organization and
learning support by the framework of
state support and direction that
provides risk sharing and so and so
forth and he specifically talked about
you know a strong government state
provided financing and risk sharing for
heavy capital investments undertaking by
enterprises and that refers to the
specific South Korean case that the
state banks tribal necks Nexus is the
root of Korea's a success and if you
look at domestic saving before the
industrial take off in South Korea their
savings national savings rate it's about
10 percent of GDP in 1962 and once the
industrialization took place they are
saving rose to about 28 percent of GDP
by the 1980s so that okay and clear
shows that you know the state extended
credits through banks say oh banks they
directly banks in order to initiate the
count of entrepreneur investment which
then drives income which then bring
about savings I just wanted to make it a
little bit more explicit from what we
just sort of saw that sorry I thought it
was a I thought it was a reminder
okay yeah sure I'll be quick hmm sorry
right so you know Korea's case Japan's
case in China's case for that matter
really showcases that you know the state
direct the the credit expansion which
basically stand ready to guarantee
unlimited financing and risk bearing and
that's all what you know sort of started
the development process and I would
argue that China provides a very
interesting case study now one thing to
bear in mind is yes China used to have
this kind of pact exchange rate system
up into 2005 but still China has been
implementing the very tight caps of
control which means you know the
external sort of forces can't really to
a very large extent terminate exchange
rates right and China has been running
trade surpluses over the years and China
also has accumulated you know three to
four trillion dollars of foreign
exchange reserves and all this would
help challenges maintain the kind of
sovereign power in issuing its own
currency and so that's kind of important
point to keep in mind this is charge to
show that you know China has maintained
very healthy growth event to very
recently the growth rate has been around
10% on average since the 1980s right now
trying to grow at at six point seven
percent of growth rate which is you know
much lower than what it used to be but
still you know it's envious to the rest
of the world right so what I would argue
is you know in up into the 90s trying to
really have this kind of state economy
where state planning economy where the
state provided you know financing
through the so-called stay old
commercial banks extended credits to the
state or enterprises to produce you know
to invest right to produce jobs and so
and so forth at the onset of the market
reform the stay or enterprises accounted
for about 80 percent of output and
almost 60 percent or 80 percent of the
employment
and it's really sort of a job guarantee
just through the stay oh you know
enterprises not you know the government
directly hire workers per se but it does
it right through the state or
enterprises so the state old commercial
banks today still accounting for about
you know forty to sixty percent to
directly forty to sixty percent of their
loans to the state-owned enterprises and
also thus they all commercial banks
accounted for about half of the whole
total banking assets so in other words
the states do play a very primary role
in the entire banking sector right and
so the state-owned enterprises then in
turn use the kind of bank credit that
they get from the stay o commercial
banks to finance their investment which
amperage on at thirteen percent of
growth rate for the fixed capital
information between 1990 and 2015 and
that also contribute significantly to
the over 50 percent of investment to GDP
ratio now her increase 2008 article
incisively summarizes that the financial
system stimulated permanently high
investment with all this multiplier
effect for the other sectors of the
economy due to a high savings rate large
increase in income led to both height
savings and not the other way around
this is paramount evident there is
paramount evidence that China has
managed to create a Schumpeter champey
terian Keynesian credit investment
income creation process which has led to
economic prosperity but the credit
driven investment like growth eventually
ran out of steam due mostly to the main
constraint because we all know you know
investments the double edge that was
double blade double double age like
sorry blade right and it created demian
but it also created large supply
capacity right which needs to be
absorbed by final consumption either
domestically or by the rest of the world
and that didn't happen and so by 2012
China's growth has been slowing down
and data to GDP ratio has increased
tremendously to right now about two
hundred fifty four percent of the GDP
and that created the so-called that you
know crisis right by the mainstream
media they all said you know the sort of
Minsky moment debt crisis I would call
it that conundrum because I don't think
there will be sort of a really you know
debt deflation type of crisis that would
be you know erupting soon in China but I
do think that especially for the private
sector
Merl in that could have some long-term
negative implications in any case the
corporate sector is the one that I think
most pragmatic in terms of the entires
of the that Canadian because the
capacity to pay for these debt
obligations in the private sector has
been green de Lee has been declining and
one of the most important reason is
because as China engaging the so-called
rebalancing trying to slow down is
fixing vestment it bring down the
corporate profits and that makes it you
know difficult for them to meet their
obligations also the late local
governments are the ones that you know
have the large debt problems and the
main reason for that is structural right
the local governments receive our forty
percent of tax revenues they remit sixty
percent to the central government but
the local governments accounted for 80
percent of locals expenditure so there's
structural mismatch between you know
their tax revenues and they're spending
obligations now the current programs
that the Chinese come and implemented
trying to resolve this debt problem they
simply shift that from one sector to the
other or shift from once they branch to
the other so for example one of the
measures was to develop the so-called
you know municipal bond market through
2015 the local governments now are
allowed to issue bonds in the bonds
market but that you know Stu doesn't
solve the problem right instead of
having bank loans for the local
governments they're now just you know
raising bonds issuing bonds in the
market so instead of a bank credit
crisis now is a bond crisis and so on so
forth right from you know local
government to the state-owned
enterprises which is basically the
public-private initiative but none of
this really solve the issue right of the
the debt problem so this is a picture of
the different sectors and their share of
the national debt so as you see the last
year that I have the data here the
state-owned enterprises have about one
hundred and one debt to GDP ratio and
private cooperation fifty five household
twenty-eight local government twenty-one
sorry forty and the central government
twenty one percent so this is sort of a
different sort of breakdown so what
should the government do what could the
government do right having you know as
we talked about the sovereign power to
issue currency I think it's time to come
we need to take a much more direct role
and much more in an instrumental role in
solving this problem to do with the
depth to the flow problem right the
increasing the expansion of credit the
government's deficit spend right as
young Craig oh sorry as Randy ray and
Eric Des Moines wrote in their book
chapter a government spending led
expansion would allow the private sector
to expand without creating fragile
balance sheet government deficit would
add safety gerod debt to private
portfolios even as it raised profits
through the cholesky and equation and
income and employment through government
spending multiplier so right now this is
a secular balance in China if you look
at the last year and think that I
haven't done sixteen basically the
public deficit of three point seven
percent of GDP as well as the external
balance of one point seven percent of
GDP allowed the private sector to net
save in the amount in the order of five
percent of the GDP but you know as you
see from this chart that the Chinese
external balance has been going down
over the years largely
you know thanks to the stagnation of you
know global extra--go lobotomy and I
think China needs to rely more on the
central government in order to allow the
private sector so they not safe so
that's the another point that the
central government's deficit spend in
order to allow the rest of economy to
deal average and to not save it also
needs to do this to relieve the Esso
ease from the obligations to invest
because China's the Chinese government
has been you know torn between this
kind of to Mission Impossible sort of
you know in order to develop the
leverage you have to somehow let the
private enterprises to earn enough
profits and earnings and for that they
have to increase investment but at the
same time the Chinese government wanted
to rebalance the economy away from
investment to final consumption and so
that it's kind of you know a
straightjacket that they are operating
in between and so that gets the last
point if we really want to rebalance the
economy have a consumption-driven
economy we need to provide jobs to you
know the workers right right now China's
unemployment rate is very low official
unemployment is about five percent four
point seven percent right just like
other developing nations but that
official data does not include eleven
sorry it doesn't include a 110 million
rural immigrants to the urban sector so
if we add that and if we add other sort
of layoffs from as the state-owned
enterprises they're not included in
official unemployment rate we could have
an employment unemployment of twelve
point nine percent so again you know and
in China by the way if you're talking
about new five percent infirmary that's
to translate to about ten million people
right who could have worked but not so I
think that it's very important that you
know in the past the Government Center
comments through the SOE provide job
guarantees to urban workers and that
system is no longer in place but I think
you know the way to really provide
sustainable stable balanced growth we
still need to resort to kind of some
transformation of the old model so that
is to do it's a the flow to do with the
stop problem the current debt problem
block grants or increase the taxing
power to the local governments that
write offs with corporate governance
reform in the SOS if they really wanted
to you know do that route I don't see
any problem have the state-owned
enterprises take on other sort of
investments drop provide provisions and
whatnot but if that is not what the
government wants right then what the
companies to do is to directly you step
into the sort of investment and job
creation kind of tasks and capital
injections to the state enterprises and
also the asset management operations if
we wanted to solve this you know sort of
banking
their debt binge so I think I kind of
used up my time and that's pretty much
it yeah thank you so much for attention
[Applause]
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿