7. MMT In the Public Sphere
[Music] [Applause] [Music] I'm super at this power but I really follow three great presentations you just heard and so you know this is about community the public sphere so I'm gonna try to make some remarks about Bill said we don't play the game and I because that really does capture what MMD economists I think are we really just don't play and you said to articulate how the modern monetary system actually works right weights for being destructive and in doing that pulling back some layers and exposing some truths that make some people very true and once you get a certain sort of conditions in place I mean as simple as saying and they were mostly were here he'd say the currency is a simple public monopoly and they even say everything else follows from that so if we can come to terms with the way it needs to say our currency is a simple public monopoly then it's going to lead us to some places that may make us very uncomfortable not just as economists but its policy makers and as thinkers who have been telling different stories for a long period of time and now all of a sudden they're forced to reckon with these new voices who are telling narratives telling stories articulating from an economic perspective a different vision of how it all works and what the implications are and then these guys exit guys they're mostly guys then these guys have to figure out what am I going to do now how am I going to continue to tell the story that creates anxiety about the deficit or the national debt or continues to push politicians to explain how things are going to be paid for in an environment where the layers are being peeled back and people are beginning to recognize that maybe not just the answers that we've been given are wrong but that we've been asking the wrong questions as well and so we do try you know we go out very stiff our necks out we say things that others won't say comfortable repeating the safe stories whether it's the simple barter exchange in order to try to explain to students where money comes from.
how Hartman's are supposed to work the quantity theory of money what causes inflation these are simple models.
18
商學研究 第二巻 第三
一一三八
てゐるのである。
此の點を考察してハルトマン Hartmann は、狭義の法制上の貨幣を定義して曰く
「貨幣とは究極の強制的決済手段として役立つべき本来の職分を、法制上有する物なり」と。
此の究極の強制的決済手段なりとする貨幣概念は、或る點に於て法制的支拂手段たる概念に従属するも
る。何となれば、もし裁判上の判決によつて、貨幣以外の物による給付の代りに貨幣による給付が定められたる
時は、自然一定の貨幣種類に關する契約は存在し得ずして、法制的支排手段が直ちに、給付の目的物となるが故
である。同時に他の點に於て、究極の強制的決済手段としての貨幣の性質の考察からして、法制的支排手段の概
念の撰張と深刻味とが生じ、従つて一般的に貨幣概念の携張と深刻味とが生ずる。もし吾人が支排なる語を決濟
Solution と同義に解するならば、 吾人は法制的支排手段は、唯に法制的支力を備へざる貨幣に對して法制的
支手段たるのみではなく、又一の債務關係の他の凡ての財産法上の内容(貨幣以外のもの)に對しても同様に、
法制的支拂手段として存する事を知るのである。或る一の債務關係に於て、ある貨幣以外の特殊の給付が約定せ
らるるや否や、その特殊の給付物麗は契約上の決済手段である。若しその特殊の給付の契約が何等かの理由によ
りて効力を失ひ、且それによりて債務者が債務履行の責任を免れざるならば、共給付は、法制的支排手段にて履
行せられなければならない。即一の債務關係の内容に関する契約が効力を失ふ場合に、契約上の決済手段の代り
れ、法制的支拂力を備へたる貨幣が之に代るのである。
す
Cash in East Asia - 158 ページ
Frank Rövekamp, Moritz Bälz, Hanns Günther Hilpert · 2017
次の書籍のコンテンツと一致: – 158 ページ
For the sake of academic and historical truth, it is Gustav
Hartmannwho should be credited with the “State Theory of
Money”.21 The majority of economists has criticised this view as being too narrow22 and instead favours a functional ...
Cash in East Asia
Frank Rövekamp、 Moritz Bälz、 Hanns Günther Hilpert 編集
https://books.google.co.jp/books?id=pyIzDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA158&dq=Money+is+knapp+hartmann&hl=ja&newbks=1&newbks_redir=0&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiMv8vR5Z35AhWFL6YKHZUBBT8Q6AF6BAgEEAI#v=onepage&q=Money%20is%20knapp%20hartmann&f=false
Money is a creation of the legal system; it has appeared in history in various forms: a theory
of money can therefore only be a work of legal history."
18
From this starting-point, it was well justified and consistent for him to re-iterate:
Money is a creation of the state. Only legal tender is money and all legal tender is money.19
Following this definition, the term "money" is equivalent to that of legal tender-
for all practical purposes.20 It was, however, a now almost forgotten German law
professor at that time in Basel-who had made the same discovery using partially
the same wording decades before Knapp. For the sake of academic and historical truth,
it is Gustav Hartmann who should be credited with the "State Theory of Money" 21
The majority of economists has criticised this view as being too narrow ²² and
instead favours a functional understanding of money: anything that is generally
accepted as a medium of exchange, a unit of account, and a store of value has to be
treated as money.23 Good reasons exist to follow this path in economic analysis, but
18 Friedrich Georg Knapp, Staatliche Theorie des Geldes, (Leipzig: Duncker & Humblot, 1905),
p. 1: "Das Geld ist ein Geschöpf der Rechtsordnung; es ist im Laufe der Geschichte in den
verschiedensten Formen aufgetreten: eine Theorie des Geldes kann daher nur rechtsgeschichtlich
sein." [Money is a creation of the legal system; in the course of history, it has emerged in most
different forms: that is why a theory of money can only be a phenomenon of legal history.]
1⁹Knapp, note 18 above, p. 123, in specific for banknotes.
20In essence agreeing, Frederic A. Mann, The Legal Aspects of Money, fifth edn., (Oxford:
Clarendon Press, 1992), p. 16 et seq.; Olaf R. Dahlmann, Das Recht des Geldes, (Berlin: Metzner,
1960), p. 400; Hermann Fögen, Geld- und Währungsrecht, (Munich: Beck, 1969), p. 7; Karsten
Schmidt, "Vorbem. zu §§ 244 ff.", in: J. von Staudingers, Kommentar zum Bürgerlichen
Gesetzbuch mit Einführungsgesetz und Nebengesetzen, Zweites Buch, 13. Bearbeitung, (Berlin:
Sellier and Walter de Gruyter, 1997/8), A 3, A 12, for money signs (tokens) as consequence of the
two-pronged definition (A. 11); idem, note 17 above, p. 88 & 90 with reservations.
21 Gustav Hartmann, Über den rechtlichen Begriff des Geldes und den Inhalt von Geldschulden,
(Braunschweig: Leibrock, 1868), pp. 4, 7, 12, 48; (critical) review by Otto Karlowa, Kritische
Vierteljahresschrift für Gesetzgebung und Rechtswissenschaft vol. 11 n. 4 (1869), p. 526, but
agreeing that the recognition by the legal system is essential for the virtue of being money (at 536
et seq.); see already before him: Johann Christian Ravit, Beiträge zur Lehre vom Gelde, (Lübeck:
Aschenfeldt, 1862), p. 12, but less clear.
22See, for example, Joseph A. Schumpeter, Das Wesen des Geldes, ed. F.A. Mann, (Göttingen:
Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1970), p. 56; from a legal perspective, see Frank Vischer, Geld- und
Währungsrecht im nationalen und internationalen Kontext, (Basel: Helbing Lichtenhahn, 2010),
p. 4, 17 et seq.; for clearly a different view, see Carl Menger, Untersuchungen über die Methode
der Sozialwissenschaften, und der politischen Oekonomie, (Leipzig: Duncker & Humblot, 1883),
p. 176, with comprehensive citations from (ancient) history (p. 172-174); discussion at: Helmut
Siekmann, "Deposit Banking and the Use of Monetary Instruments", in: David Fox and Wolfgang
Ernst (eds), Money in the Western Legal Tradition, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016),
p. 489, at 510 et seq; Wray, note 17 above, pp. 631-652 with in-depth analysis of various authors
and emphasizing the “government budget constraint” in view of creating money.
23 See, for example, Alan J. Auerbach and Laurence J. Kotlikoff, Macroeconomics, second edition,
(Cambridge MA, London: The MIT Press, 1998), p. 172 et seq; Frederic S. Mishkin, The
Economics of Money, Banking, and Financial Markets, eleventh edition, (Harlow: Pearson,
2016), pp. 96-98; Rudolf Richter, Geldtheorie, second edition, (Berlin-Heidelberg: Springer
Verlag, 1990), p. 103 et seq., & 108; already discussed in nineteenth century by Ravit, note
21 above, p. 527 et seq.
貨幣は法体系の創造物であり、歴史上さまざまな形で現れてきた。
それゆえ、貨幣論は法制史の作品であるとしか言いようがない」。
18
この出発点から、彼が改めて述べることは十分に正当であり、一貫していた。
貨幣は国家の創造物である。法定通貨のみが貨幣であり、すべての法定通貨は貨幣である19。
この定義に従えば、「貨幣」という用語は、あらゆる実用的な目的のために、法定通貨と同等である20。
しかし、この発見をしたのは、今ではほとんど忘れられてしまったが、バーゼルのドイツ人法学者であった。学問的、歴史的な真実のために。
この「貨幣の国家理論」21は、グスタフ・ハルトマンによってもたらされた。
経済学者の大多数は、この見解は狭すぎる²²と批判しており、むしろ貨幣の機能的な理解を支持している。
その代わりに、貨幣の機能的理解を支持する。
交換媒体、会計単位、価値の貯蔵として一般に受け入れられているものはすべて貨幣とし て扱われなければならない23 。
経済分析においてこのような道を歩むには十分な理由がある。
18 Friedrich Georg Knapp, Staatliche Theorie des Geldes, (Leipzig: Duncker & Humblot, 1905),
p. 1: "Das Geld ist ein Geschöpf der Rechtsordnung; es ist im Laufe der Geschichte in den verschiedensten Formen.
ゲルトの理論が成り立つのは、あくまでも歴史的経緯によるものである。
である。" [貨幣は法体系の創造物であり、歴史の中で、それは最も異なる形で出現してきた。
だから貨幣論は法制史の現象でしかありえないのである]。
1⁹前掲Knapp, 注18, p.123, 具体的には銀行券の場合。
20 本質的に同意するのは、Frederic A. Mann, The Legal Aspects of Money, fifth edn., (Oxford:
Clarendon Press, 1992), p.16 et seq.; Olaf R. Dahlmann, Das Recht des Geldes, (Berlin: Metzner,
1960), p. 400; Hermann Fögen, Geld- und Währungsrecht, (Munich: Beck, 1969), p. 7; Karsten
Schmidt, "Vorbem. zu §244 ff.", in: J. von Staudingers, Kommentar zum Bürgerlichen
J. von Staudingers, Kommentar zum Bürgerlichen Gesetzbuch mit Einführungsgesetz und Nebengesetzen, Zweites Buch, 13. Bearbeitung, (Berlin:
Sellier and Walter de Gruyter, 1997/8), A 3, A 12, 貨幣記号(トークン)については、二元的な定義(A. 11)の帰結として
A. 11); idem, note 17 above, p. 88 & 90 with reservations.
21 Gustav Hartmann, Über den rechtlichen Begriff des Geldes und den Inhalt von Geldschulden,
(Braunschweig: Leibrock, 1868), pp.4, 7, 12, 48; (批判的)レビュー:Otto Karlowa, Kritische
Vierteljahresschrift für Gesetzgebung und Rechtswissenschaft vol.11 n.4 (1869), p. 526, ただし、法学的な承認が必要であることには同意している。
しかし、法律制度による承認が貨幣としての美徳に不可欠であることに同意している(at 536
et seq.); 彼以前にすでに参照。Johann Christian Ravit, Beiträge zur Lehre vom Gelde, (Lübeck:
Aschenfeldt, 1862), p. 12, しかし、あまり明確ではない。
貨幣の法的概念と金銭債務の内容について 2018/7/30 1868
グスタフ・ハートマン
https://www.amazon.co.jp/rechtlichen-Begriff-Geldes-Inhalt-Geldschulden/dp/027421721X/ref=sr_1_1?__mk_ja_JP=カタカナ&crid=DWCNPJQKXBME&keywords=gustav+hartmann&qid=1659087648&sprefix=gustav+hartmann+%2Caps%2C166&sr=8-1
1835年3月31日にブラウンシュヴァイクのフェッヘルデで生まれ、1894年11月16日にテュービンゲンで亡くなったグスタフ・ハートマンは、ドイツの法律家でした。
小野論稿
7 ハルトマン(Gustav Hartmann, 1835.3.31-1894. 11. 16)
ハルトマンは、1835年に、ブラウンシュワイクのBecheldeで生まれた。ゲルマニストのホイスラー(Heusler, 1834-1921)の翌年の生まれである。
1853 年から、ゲッチンゲン大学で法律学を学んだ(Francke, Thöl)。同地で、1857 年に学位をえて、1860年には、ハビリタチオンを取得し(Zur Lehre von den Erbverträgen und von den gemeinschaftlichen Testamenten, zwei Abhandlungen aus dem gemeinen Rechte. Braunschweig, 1860)、1864 年まで、私講師として勤めた。1864 年に、バーゼル大学の正教授となった。1872年に、フライブルク大学に移り、1878年に、ゲッチンゲン大学、1885年に、チュービンゲン大学に移った。1894 年に、チュービンゲンで亡くなった。1886年から、AcP誌の共同編者をした。
あまり大きくはないが、金銭に関するモノグラフィーで著名である。イェーリングを彷彿させる感性のある学者であった30)。
Ueber den rechtlichen Begriff des Geldes und den Inhalt von Geldschulden, 1868, 139S.
Internationale Geldschulden, Beitrag zur Rechtslehre vom Gelde, 1882.
また、売買のような物給付における偶然について、普通法的な「偶然」を現代的な帰責事由に整理したものである。 Juristischer Casus und seine Prästation bei Obligationen auf Sachleistung insbesondere beim Kauf, 1884(Jhering's Jahrb. Bd. 22, S. 417ff.; Neud. 1970).
債務の本質論や、英米法とドイツ法の契約理論の相違について論じたものがある。英米契約法との詳細な比較は、のちのユダヤ系法学者(たとえば、Rheinstein)まで行われたことはなく、先駆的な研究である。
Die Obligation. Untersuchungen über ihren Zweck u. Bau, 1875. Die Grundprincipien der Praxis des Englisch-Amerikanischen Vertragsrechts gegenüber der Deutschen gemeinrechtlichen Vertragsdoktrin, 1891.
ほかに、Über Begriff und Natur der Vermächtnisse im römischen Rechte. Akademische Antrittsschrift, 1872. Werk und Wille bei stillschweigendem Konsens, 1888.
無意識の哲学で著名な哲学者のハルトマン(Karl Robert Eduard von Hartmann, 1842-1906)とは、生年、没年ともに近いが、関係は明確ではない。
30) Pfaff, Hartmann, Gustav, ADB Bd. 50(1905), S.28ff.; Degenkolb, AcP 84, 1f. 358
22例えば、Joseph A. Schumpeter, Das Wesen des Geldes, ed. F.A. Mann, (1992)を参照。F.A. Mann, (Göttingen:
Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1970), p.56; 法律的な観点からは、Frank Vischer, Geld- und Währungsrecht, p. 22参照。
Währungsrecht im nationalen und internationalen Kontext, (Basel: Helbing Lichtenhahn, 2010)を参照のこと。
p. 4, 17 et seq.; 明らかに異なる見解としては、Carl Menger, Untersuchungen über die Methode
der Sozialwissenschaften, und der politischen Oekonomie, (Leipzig: Duncker & Humblot, 1883)を参照。
p. 176, (古代)歴史からの包括的な引用あり (p. 172-174); 討論あり。ヘルムート
Siekmann, "Deposit Banking and the Use of Monetary Instruments", in: ヘルムート・ジークマン、「預金銀行と通貨手段の使用」、David Fox and Wolfgang
Ernst (eds), Money in the Western Legal Tradition, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016),
p. 489, at 510 et seq; Wray, note 17 above, pp.631-652 with in-depth analysis of various authors
と、貨幣を生み出すという観点から「政府の予算制約」を強調している。
23 例えば、Alan J. Auerbach and Laurence J. Kotlikoff, Macroeconomics, second edition.を参照。
(Cambridge MA, London: The MIT Press, 1998), p.172 et seq; Frederic S. Mishkin, The Economics of Money, Banking, the Future, and the Future.
Economics of Money, Banking, and Financial Markets, eleventh edition, (Harlow: Pearson,
2016)、96-98頁;ルドルフ・リヒター、ゲルトテオリー、第2版、(Berlin-Heidelberg: シュプリンガー
Verlag, 1990)、103頁ほか、および108頁;19世紀にはすでにラビット、注
21, p. 527 et seq.
they're simple stories people are accustomed to hearing them we're all in our safe space when we were telling these stories and then this you know row crew comes and kind of knocks that narrative ideals and push staff and sometimes name-calling and and then you know but I don't know any other way to do this I didn't know any other way to do this as a young graduate student starting off at Cambridge University and sitting in the classroom and if someone heard this story but suffered through it a second time if you haven't if we haven't you know this is how I started it was a student at Cambridge University and I was in a classroom with 40 or so other graduate students and I was listening to little employer - - it was a professor and Cambridge University he was teaching the is-lm model stand there came another stop and I had enough of a background having been a student of brandy race for a period of time and with a student of John Henry's magnets Minsky and the sparks I I knew just enough to be dangerous.
and what I felt sitting in that classroom was that we weren't getting the whole picture that we were getting a nice safe story about you know how it was all supposed to work and I thought that we deserve better I thought we deserve the full story so hiatus my hand and I opposed what I thought was a and then his response was to put me back in my place and he said in front of all of my peers as I posed this question if you are the type of person who wants to talk about money and thinks that money is important you are probably the same time a person who enjoys sitting in your basement and being yourself with a rubber hose [Laughter] [Music] there's another story it's something Laughter] [Music] there's another story it's something what is it we're not lived here no important passed away recently so you should look into his work it's a fascinating journey right tell us the story you can find us on YouTube you should go watch this video because it's really remarkable he's talking about a mentee an M&P economist and he refers to UMKC and he says there's this group of economists out there they say the most incredible things they're absolutely right everything they say is right he says but he said they were in Siberia there anything you can't see they put them there because they're telling a story he said he learned a lesson a long time ago and the lesson was that she never touched the money question he never touched him a question and he said he was a student graduate student at MIT guess who he was in the school paul krugman so they were contemporaries in graduate school and he said he lived here has interesting money you want to talk about I'm telling you if you go there but it's not okay you know in a different category in terms of the banks do all this fraud some of these little things so you know we do say these things we don't shy away from him we just embrace we're trying to understand the world around us we're trying to help them articulate and narrative that was others better understanding the world around them and to get us in a position where ultimately we get better public policy as we resolve so bill has four years referred to these sorts of positions in these positions as career limiting gestures that's what Bernard memorizing MKC get eliminated our careers by taking these holding these reviews articulating these views and their nominee invite us to come to Princeton and Harvard and we we get rid of Dangerous Ideas and all that stuff I believe were actually pretty useful to the mainstream establishment economists why because we can't use that they in called extreme allowing them to take slightly more aggressive views on things and still appear respectable we push them and I think that you know what you've seen in stocks presentation is that we're having on the discourse both in the policy sphere and we can begin to achieve after all these years so I'll just say very quickly you know we've pushed people that were warned would refer to as the headline progressives to take positions that they didn't hold ten years ago or five years ago or sometimes a year ago into the debt crisis of people you know who were writing about the possibility of us.
and now they've changed their views and I don't think that the reason that their views changed it's because they have they need a better understanding of basic u.s. different countries because of our contributions I don't think that there's any way around like Reutimann who were writing about the u.s. potentially ending up like Greece now say that's a crazy when he comes to debt sustainability has written some most important papers from MTV you know your comments Olivier Atlanta January of this year at the ABA presidential address he delivers remarks that the policy discussion almost overnight what does he do he gets up and says actually it appears that sustainable trajectory given that the relationship between interest rates and growth rates for the last three decades it is reasonable to expect that the new terminal look much like the recent past and therefore we would probably sustain not just trillion-dollar deficits but perhaps even because it was but stop bringing that paper five years before he didn't almost the exact same paper might Scott gets there for better reasons because he has a different understanding of how the interest rate is actually set but the so much of what actually goes in that paper was was preempted by Scott by make in many years so I think we're having the role of taxes and then T is the only game in town when it comes to just a full-throated candy this has been a hard and this ears the hell out of people in policy circles because their whole aim is figuring out how to achieve orders legislation passed and taxes are the key [Music] [Music] has openly embraced this TV it was teenager.
and so but then that's a student device I haven't even had a piece like that and and uses the description that we use it's important helps physical space the way that we talk about physical space we talk about the capacity of the economy to resort new spending we help the need for offsets provided that there is a space meaning that it won't generate an acceleration you can do this who's now using language like that people into your Bernstein talk about fiscal space in a way that is soon close to the way that we're talking about it and so now you started saying things like it's perceived physical space but that holds us back it's the perception in the minds of lawmakers that there's no to space you know because the budget is a trillion dollars because the National that is 22 or so well.
we need to do is get over the perception.
if there's no physical space because he's saying you know they're they're actually yes I think that's progress as well I'm printing money and the monetary transit transmission mechanism do you draw me too much so he wasn't even asked about an entity Pavel was asked about M&T Kuroda was asked about mmt Jan Eagleman is asked about MMT.
the question gets published but with Draghi he just invoked it on his own right.
I know it was a press conference for what it was but he said there might be things out there like modern monetary theory and I think that a lot of progress has been made that didn't debate or so ago with Noah Smith.
we debated in the pages of Bloomberg on deathlessness.
and we just had a back and forth exchange.
and we published it and be kind of on the retention.
and animating has come up twice so their outlook to the program is the head of the Minneapolis.
he sends an email after the debate with no and he said it develop us okay so I'm not we all know this to be the case and he said MMT has amassed a better track record when it comes to predictability the best in all of macroeconomics.
he said no school comes close over the last 20 years.
but he said that doesn't mean next 20.
we'll look at the same so I realize you're right like me odd.
people are seeing literature is there so much of what we people who are open-minded enough to wrestle with new ideas without being so reactionary that you can just do call it for day money and up straight from Zimbabwe there are other decent intellectual people who don't think they already have all the answers and it's those people and I had a long batting fourth with Olivier Blanchard.
I will continue to new names but there's a lot that happens behind the scenes that you'll don't know but it's important that the work is being respected in ways that I think should make itself proud and we can't always put that out there publicly but you know I like it you know you're part of something that's important and and then we are continuing to progress so I want to say something about the Senate resolution because somebody brought it up but the the idea that MMT is now ready invoked like light ahd like sunrise would agree that there are references to be made of our work in the context of taking on the fossil fuel industry that is shaking people a lot it's making them nervous and to the extent that they do and something that is going to help pave the way to get us to something like that it's very disconcerting and so when I showed up to record a podcast with Christie's four months or something ago I walked in and he's sitting there in the studio and he's on his phone and he looks up and he says silver 500 living senators newman ET and i said finally and he said yeah five senators are just a resolution condemning him you know.
and I didn't know why he turned the poison oak on I couldn't believe it right I'd like to you that this is the public sphere this is where we have I think the biggest challenges ahead of us now are figuring out how to in a sense operationalize these insights so how do we get lawmakers to drop this paint word nonsense to stop the silly game and to transform the federal editing process in a way that it is no longer paying homage to an arbitrary artificial revenue constraint but replacing it with a real inflation strength which is what we wanted from the very and that last thing.
I'm gonna say is that progress is being made there too I'm not going to be in a position to say that a lot more work but you should know that there are people in the house and in the Senate both elected members of Congress and they're very smart staffers who are starting to think in a really different way a battle of the nature of the feedback that they see when they want to send a bill to CBO instead of saying we want to do in the structure here's our border tell us if it's going to have to the deficit they're starting to understand that this is a phony game and then the right way to proceed is to say this is the spending bill these are getting offset we're proposing please let us know and we have a quickly inflation rates and that's truly progress in terms of you know the policy.
[Music] [Applause] [Applause] so I guess you know they're done now to a discussion by words you know I have a couple friends here who I know from a really really long time ago who was there second to hear the MMT Collinson we're above the three of us were trained in a Leadership School where we met congressman Custer Cortes and one of the things that we were taught that I think really represents a strong affinity that I feel with with MNT is the sense that you know we refuse to kind of let them tell us to stay in your place and when they don't invite us to party.
you just create a better party so maybe in terms of the public sphere in the conversation you know we have the media we have academia government and kind of all of these after this spaces and you know I think many of us and especially you all have been able to be in all of these different avenues so I'm wondering to hear from you all how in this last year or it seems as though nmt has really got into this new place how are the one of those ethical thinking like what are there any good ones that have emerged is the conversation public kind of moving in different directions or is social media becoming at large place how should we understand that question me okay so so you know you all would even to be amongst many politicians and governments and media and activists so just different vantage points and on about where the public discourse of right now so you know all the road and the disability where what are the new avenues that are no should we consider growth we need academia in terms of which there has always been interest from our friends especially in Europe it's me Spain Austria but I hate also pelicans are increasing appetite from different parties of the world talk to us and went to many companies regressive wave in their corners of the world from Belgium to Australia I think I think that you know we have a lot a lot more to do to develop these world networks it takes long order but I think that's where everything need to spend our efforts to be loops Isle of denial networks in the oil or networks Madrid and they give us such a common projects project and so there is interest out there and we just need to be able to reach out and then advance these ideas that the possible that's one thing that I've noticed is appetite and breathing interest there are also some fun things that are happening like the hybrid tivity school is running an end of the TV workshop you know I didn't know and is raining okay.
so it's so fantastic it's taking the life of the time it's a genuine Athenian yep so maybe you know things that you don't like but what I'm noticing is really getting surprise pieces of information then people are interested they taking them discussed behind closed doors within their investors co-writing the most than we have seen previously again Thank You parklands I keep thinking that you know maybe it's so wonderful that we have a textbook but we've got our student committee can't authorize this assist college I love activists after a while I reckon if ever imagined so mr. project but using how to develop their research program and so and this says nothing to come from different community colleges in the university and even around interested call and imitation to people so when we speak about fraud you know it seems like that end of itself is such a nice socially constructed idea as well and where we thought of seems to be up to the public won't have the power to do so do you feel like what we consider abroad the the frame commercial enterprise that the right pointer is something has expanded to truly get at what the kind of behavior that's happening so some Economist's are finally taking predation seriously because it's not called a prime healthcare release and study and we're pretty bunch of us trying to get over there and get the point predation is often more dangerous than fraud because pronation means you've got enough political juice that you've been able to get do declare legal right so we see both of them as having extensive overlap the Supreme Court has been an effort to get convictions against elite all of that and our journey and so we I think one of the other things is that in part because of the history everybody is at the table um Casey takes institutions that's an important thing and thinks in terms of the influence of institutions the incentive structures they create but beyond that the humanity or destruction of humanity that it creates so that we also have thought of as an advantage of that wouldn't they call Caesarea yeah so I mean a lot of those same lines I think convention the macro theory to be you know kind of insights into a theory that's much more than the macro analysis but really challenging the entire notion that supply and demand and the market is would be dictates prices where where is that alignment now between the insights of our momentum Africa ideas and some sorts of micro foundations okay so yeah Freddy is the first guy well my goodness and so one of the things Freddie's microphone that's right [Laughter] so it's one of the bridges that is talking about where you have the neoclassical moving much more in our direction it's also occurring on my crease night so you have the x-ray of the world begin the situated this is a very modern background in jargon and fresh water kind of person so the most extreme version of it and he's saying you know the two things we really really really need are symmetrical information and the fact that people pay levels right and we were not joking the marvels of modern macro that were in use there were yes there were some exceptional but the ones they are actually use that no possibility he literally Clifford the ball in a mob.
you can imagine that much difficulty they had explaining bank failures and it turns out I know this is shocking but financial crises turned out to have a lot to do with but I think historically and for understand if you don't understand of micro aspects of them then you create a macro model that is insane right then literally back you do and said it isn't that the models give us the wrong answer it's they don't even allow us to ask the right questions and in that used the rubber hose want to get and said and they took the rubber months out they need an amount of macro folks and beat the nonlinearities as well so yes this is another area where it turns out drawing predation our enormous work to whether your financial capacities that is a classic micro abomination we now have the other side saying yes those things are really important but they have absolutely no they have no really right and you know think it looks remember going to read because you know that's not going to fit the journals I think whatever read so yeah we get around the questions questions for example that when the sessions are that they saw was suggesting that China is important amenity period expendable that worth by readings in any idea is there any intrinsic connection to be and social rights agenda that must've you renowned if all of you my vision thing they want to be my goodness you talk about Argentina a very wise economist background finance the undead we're pretty minute because it's like the clock briefly about Tina Argentina wasn't fixed exchange rates that track currency wasn't being artificially you location international investors and when in dark and then with the policies that were conservative here that policies vary but reelected and stole assets and that caused me to start to appreciate one of the big problems that you know they the exchange rate from the rate of inflation all of a sudden they started problem literally essence.
and I guess I won't really secure the dentures when the equator the simple thing did the exact traditional means 60 70 percent then even tried I don't want to get too far weeds of simply gone rate believe in one of the states all its the fixing the monetary base especially Scott said that don't ask funny stuff if you have a simple [Applause] and what's happening is is I know where would you be sure talking about emergency and it basically does everything else it's coming out of people that think they don't wendy is then read somebody else's talk about it none of them actually have ever been anything it's pretty delivered by the mainstream as well because they really wants to go away and the way it's done that serious or to not take this seriously we in academics you don't take somebody seriously is to criticize that without thinking you know demonstrated many eventually so alright and has been in terms of D Cabral Argentina has identity problem the earliest literature than mid 90s was saying the basic things.
[Music] so the advice to educated never met yeah I'm not sure I heard it fully but in years of the Keith's new body cavity we have a capital centric regime of how we regulate things particularly in a prompt corrective action statute and we've forgotten a small little time called County and that all frauds virtually of their sophisticated operating through counting assets minus liabilities equal capital so if I overstate assets under state liabilities or I'll give up I get a fictional capital and so they created the statute back in 1991 it said boy a prompt corrective actually don't need notes they can regulators now because we mandated closure at one-and-a-half percent capital that's what they do and on average the institution is insolvent by 22 percent when they get one point five percent reported calendar so we have a system that relies on non existence brought to deal the real world in which accounting fraud assembly everything Trinity planless a few questions what about the normative aspects of MMD and can't be with everybody these are the line which is like you know we're there description is straight so the policy prescription you don't have to explains the monetary systems will clearly be countries like China unemployed the power the conference they have very specific economic projections and so I think that the the amenity project is naturally wedded to opium rights for any Morgan for guaranteeing economic rights and economic security certainly the power of the state the building first it's continually used for our other enemies that not to Aaron's face economic right so it I don't I don't have any statistics emphasis about all my ideas of goals and objectives and they need to like wrestle back the bad guys already know this big moment for hundreds of years that use it for many years you want to laugh whenever the people are in charge they need to be able to use this as well we can't stop the bad guys doing it no way anything that so what we have today there's a cement information bill said they already burgers already hooked their dues raise their hands and both and it's done they know that so it must also know that we don't offer and so the information is asymmetrical work time is you know it's an educational project we're trying to get informed blame your sanity so that way to make sources are denied in the face elimination but it isn't that's the area no position to tell us they want an infinite series of Saudis choice you choose and then writing nonsense Chris Matthews about how they saved those security once you know something I mean you saw do something with that knowledge and we you know think about Morris in the UK or Trump near the United States using spending I mean people suffer very particular people understanding something is just the beginning of a larger process of what kind of society we want you know okay so that's you know that's my take on that we want to know the respect and give dignity to everybody or we want to use this these insights just to you know create a very exclusive although circle we have already towards a difference I think that's everything so thank you everybody [Applause] [Music] the loss of its pants so good there no problem Oh Applause] 1:26:39 [Music] I'm super at this power but I really 1:26:51 follow three great presentations you 1:27:06 just heard and so you know this is about community the public sphere so I'm gonna 1:27:13 try to make some remarks about Bill said 1:27:22 we don't play the game and I because 1:27:28 that really does capture what MMD economists I think are we really just 1:27:36 don't play and you said to articulate 1:27:45 how the modern monetary system actually works right weights for being destructive and in doing that pulling 1:27:53 back some layers and exposing some truths that make some people very true 1:27:59 and once you get a certain sort of conditions in place 1:28:06 I mean as simple as saying and they were mostly were here he'd say the currency is a simple public monopoly and they 1:28:13 even say everything else follows from that so if we can come to terms with the 1:28:19 way it needs to say our currency is a simple public monopoly then it's going to lead us to some 1:28:25 places that may make us very uncomfortable not just as economists but its policy makers and as thinkers who 1:28:33 have been telling different stories for a long period of time and now all of a 1:28:38 sudden they're forced to reckon with these new voices who are telling narratives telling stories articulating 1:28:45 from an economic perspective a different vision of how it all works and what the 1:28:53 implications are and then these guys exit guys they're mostly guys then these 1:28:58 guys have to figure out what am I going to do now how am I going to continue to 1:29:04 tell the story that creates anxiety about the deficit or the national debt 1:29:10 or continues to push politicians to explain how things are going to be paid 1:29:17 for in an environment where the layers are being peeled back and people are 1:29:24 beginning to recognize that maybe not just the answers that we've been given 1:29:29 are wrong but that we've been asking the wrong questions as well and so we do try 1:29:35 you know we go out very stiff our necks out we say things that others won't say 1:29:41 comfortable repeating the safe stories whether it's the simple barter exchange 1:29:47 in order to try to explain to students where money comes from.
how Hartman's are supposed to work the quantity theory of 1:29:53 money what causes inflation these are simple models they're simple stories people are accustomed to hearing 1:29:59 them we're all in our safe space when we were telling these stories and then this 1:30:04 you know row crew comes and kind of knocks that narrative ideals and 1:30:13 push staff and sometimes name-calling and and then you know but I don't know 1:30:22 any other way to do this I didn't know any other way to do this as a young graduate student starting off at 1:30:29 Cambridge University and sitting in the classroom and if someone heard this story but suffered through it a second 1:30:37 time if you haven't if we haven't you know this is how I started it was a student at Cambridge University and I 1:30:43 was in a classroom with 40 or so other graduate students and I was listening to 1:30:49 little employer - - it was a professor 1:30:58 and Cambridge University he was teaching the is-lm model stand there came another stop and I had enough of a background 1:31:06 having been a student of brandy race for a period of time and with a student of John Henry's magnets Minsky and the 1:31:13 sparks I I knew just enough to be dangerous and what I felt sitting in 1:31:18 that classroom was that we weren't getting the whole picture that we were getting a nice safe story about you know 1:31:26 how it was all supposed to work and I thought that we deserve better I thought we deserve the full story so 1:31:34 hiatus my hand and I opposed what I thought was a and then his response was 1:31:51 to put me back in my place and he said in front of all of my peers as I posed 1:31:57 this question if you are the type of person who wants to talk about money and 1:32:04 thinks that money is important you are probably the same time a person who 1:32:09 enjoys sitting in your basement and being yourself with a rubber hose 1:32:16 [Laughter] [Music] 1:32:32 there's another story it's something 1:32:41 what is it we're not lived here no important passed away recently so you 1:33:05 should look into his work it's a fascinating journey right tell us the 1:33:12 story you can find us on YouTube you should go watch this video because it's really remarkable he's talking about a 1:33:19 mentee an M&P economist and he refers to UMKC and he says there's this group of 1:33:25 economists out there they say the most incredible things they're absolutely 1:33:30 right everything they say is right he says but he said they were in Siberia there 1:33:38 anything you can't see they put them there because they're telling a story he 1:33:55 said he learned a lesson a long time ago and the lesson was that she never 1:34:00 touched the money question he never touched him a question and he 1:34:05 said he was a student graduate student at MIT guess who he was in the school paul 1:34:13 krugman so they were contemporaries in graduate school and he said he lived 1:34:20 here has interesting money you want to talk about 1:34:29 I'm telling you if you go there but it's 1:35:00 not okay you know in a different 1:35:15 category in terms of the banks do all 1:35:44 this fraud some of these little things 1:35:50 so you know we do say these things we don't shy away from him we just embrace 1:35:56 we're trying to understand the world around us we're trying to help them articulate and narrative that was others 1:36:02 better understanding the world around them and to get us in a position where ultimately we get better public policy 1:36:08 as we resolve so bill has four years referred to these sorts of positions in 1:36:16 these positions as career limiting gestures that's what Bernard memorizing MKC get 1:36:23 eliminated our careers by taking these holding these reviews articulating these 1:36:29 views and their nominee invite us to come to Princeton and Harvard and we we 1:36:43 get rid of Dangerous Ideas and all that 1:36:49 stuff I believe were actually pretty useful to the mainstream establishment economists 1:36:58 why because we can't use that they in called extreme allowing them to take 1:37:05 slightly more aggressive views on things and still appear respectable we push 1:37:14 them and I think that you know what you've seen in stocks presentation is that we're having on the discourse both 1:37:23 in the policy sphere and we can begin to 1:37:34 achieve after all these years so I'll just say very quickly you know 1:37:41 we've pushed people that were warned would refer to as the headline progressives to take positions that they 1:37:47 didn't hold ten years ago or five years ago or sometimes a year ago into the 1:37:53 debt crisis of people you know who were writing about the possibility of us and 1:38:00 now they've changed their views and I don't think that the reason that their 1:38:07 views changed it's because they have they need a better understanding of 1:38:12 basic u.s. different countries because of our contributions I don't think that 1:38:17 there's any way around like Reutimann who were writing about the u.s. potentially 1:38:25 ending up like Greece now say that's a crazy when he comes to debt 1:38:33 sustainability has written some most important papers from MTV 1:38:45 you know your comments Olivier Atlanta January of this year at the ABA 1:38:51 presidential address he delivers remarks that the policy discussion almost 1:38:58 overnight what does he do he gets up and says actually it appears that sustainable trajectory 1:39:07 given that the relationship between interest rates and growth rates for the last three decades it is reasonable to 1:39:14 expect that the new terminal look much like the recent past and therefore we 1:39:19 would probably sustain not just trillion-dollar deficits but perhaps even because it was but stop bringing 1:39:47 that paper five years before he didn't almost the exact same paper might Scott 1:39:53 gets there for better reasons because he has a different understanding of how the interest rate is actually set but the so 1:40:03 much of what actually goes in that paper was was preempted by Scott by make in 1:40:09 many years so I think we're having 1:40:17 the role of taxes and then T is the only game in town when it comes to just a 1:40:24 full-throated candy this has been a hard 1:40:34 and this ears the hell out of people in policy circles because their whole aim 1:40:40 is figuring out how to achieve orders legislation passed and taxes are the key 1:40:50 [Music] 1:41:00 [Music] 1:41:14 has openly embraced this TV it was 1:41:42 teenager and so but then that's a student device I haven't even had a 1:41:49 piece like that and and uses the description that we use it's important 1:41:55 helps physical space the way that we talk about physical space we talk about 1:42:02 the capacity of the economy to resort new spending we help the need for 1:42:08 offsets provided that there is a space meaning that it won't generate an 1:42:14 acceleration you can do this who's now using language like that people into your Bernstein 1:42:21 talk about fiscal space in a way that is soon close to the way that we're talking 1:42:26 about it and so now you started saying things like it's perceived physical 1:42:31 space but that holds us back it's the perception in the minds of lawmakers that there's no to space you 1:42:40 know because the budget is a trillion dollars because the National that is 22 or so well we need to do is get over the 1:42:50 perception if there's no physical space because he's saying you know they're they're actually yes I think that's progress as well I'm 1:43:01 printing money and the monetary transit transmission mechanism do you draw me 1:43:06 too much so he wasn't even asked about an entity Pavel was asked about M&T 1:43:13 Kuroda was asked about mmt Jan Eagleman is asked about mu T the question gets 1:43:20 published but with Draghi he just invoked it on his own right I know it was a press conference 1:43:27 for what it was but he said there might be things out there like modern monetary theory and I think that a lot of 1:43:40 progress has been made that didn't debate or so ago with Noah Smith we 1:43:46 debated in the pages of Bloomberg on deathlessness and we just had a back and 1:43:51 forth exchange and we published it and be kind of on the retention and animating has come up twice 1:44:00 so their outlook to the program is the head of the Minneapolis 1:44:13 he sends an email after the debate with no and he said it develop us okay so I'm 1:44:19 not we all know this to be the case and he said MMD has amassed a better track 1:44:28 record when it comes to predictability the best in all of macroeconomics he 1:44:34 said no school comes close over the last 20 years but he said that doesn't mean 1:44:46 next 20 we'll look at the same so I realize you're right people are seeing 1:45:07 literature is there so much of what we 1:45:15 people who are open-minded enough to wrestle with new ideas without being so 1:45:21 reactionary that you can just do call it for day money and up straight from Zimbabwe there are 1:45:27 other decent intellectual people who don't think they already have all the 1:45:34 answers and it's those people and I had a long 1:45:40 batting fourth with Olivier Blanchard I will continue to new names but there's a 1:45:46 lot that happens behind the scenes that you'll don't know but it's important 1:45:51 that the work is being respected in ways that I think should make itself proud 1:45:57 and we can't always put that out there publicly but you know I like it you know 1:46:03 you're part of something that's important and and then we are continuing to progress so I want to say something 1:46:13 about the Senate resolution because somebody brought it up but the the idea 1:46:19 that MMT is now ready invoked like light ahd like sunrise would agree that there 1:46:26 are references to be made of our work in the context of taking on the fossil fuel 1:46:34 industry that is shaking people a lot it's making them nervous and to the 1:46:40 extent that they do and something that is going to help pave the way to get us 1:46:47 to something like that it's very disconcerting and so when I showed up to 1:46:53 record a podcast with Christie's four months or something ago I walked in 1:46:58 and he's sitting there in the studio and he's on his phone and he looks up and he says silver 500 living senators newman 1:47:07 ET and i said finally and he said yeah five senators are just a resolution 1:47:12 condemning him you know and I didn't 1:47:18 know why he turned the poison oak on I couldn't believe it right I'd like to 1:47:24 you that this is the public sphere this is where we have I think the biggest 1:47:29 challenges ahead of us now are figuring out how to in a sense operationalize 1:47:36 these insights so how do we get lawmakers to drop this paint word 1:47:42 nonsense to stop the silly game and to 1:47:47 transform the federal editing process in a way that it is no longer paying homage 1:47:53 to an arbitrary artificial revenue constraint but replacing it with a real 1:48:00 inflation strength which is what we wanted from the very and that last thing I'm gonna say is 1:48:06 that progress is being made there too I'm not going to be in a position to say that a lot more work but you should know 1:48:13 that there are people in the house and in the Senate both elected members of Congress and they're very smart staffers 1:48:20 who are starting to think in a really different way a battle of the nature of the feedback that they see when they 1:48:27 want to send a bill to CBO instead of saying we want to do in the structure here's our border tell us if it's going 1:48:35 to have to the deficit they're starting to understand that this is a phony game 1:48:40 and then the right way to proceed is to say this is the spending bill these are 1:48:46 getting offset we're proposing please let us know and we have a quickly 1:48:51 inflation rates and that's truly progress in terms of you know the policy.
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿