2020年12月23日水曜日

Kelton,burbank

coming uh together for a training on coveted relief and the deficit myth tonight um i'm jessica burbank i use she her pronouns and i'm actually the data lead for national organizing work here at people's action um so before we get into the training i just want to cover for those of you who don't know what people's action is so who is people's action we are a national network of 40 community powered organizations in over 30 states driven by the principles of racial gender environmental and economic justice our national organizing program threw down in the general election and made over 35 million voter contacts and ran the first ever uh national deep canvas program and now we're bringing deep canvassing to winning georgia and flipping the senate and fighting for comprehensive covid relief our member organizations and our federal campaigns uh have been doing amazing work laying the groundwork for events like this and organizing for public spending and uh fighting austerity measures and i know many of you on this call have volunteered with us before maybe you've had a deep canvas conversation um or you're familiar with deep canvassing but for those of you who aren't i just want to talk about deep canvassing for a second it's very different from your typical voter contact it's very different from what a campaign call might be like to turn out people to vote it's something that that george has described as george is our leader of people's action uh most campaign calls are like verbal leafleting you're just giving some information about the candidate when and where to vote and can you please you know vote and vote for this candidate deep canvassing is about getting to the heart of our of our issues and sharing personal stories and developing an emotional connection between you and the other person on the phone and ignoring sort of the the political rhetoric and uh making political decisions based on the evidence in our own lives um and it's been found to be one of the most if not the most uh persuasive tactics for canvassing um and so that's that before we get too into it i just want to share some ground rules of uh we're gonna ask you to share some stuff in the chat and just share things from your own personal lives um treat each other with respect and curiosity we're not here to to be rude to each other um and you know approach this event with you know we're here to learn something um there's no right or wrong question there's no bad question uh and you know hold a non-judgmental space and be respectful for others um and so catherine covered a tiny bit about me but i just want to start by sharing why i organize because it's important um i'm in this movement because i grew up in a working family i'm from a city called stamford not too far uh from new york city and my mom's a bookkeeper and my dad's a carpenter and when the financial crisis hit things got really hard um while my mom or dad didn't have college degrees they really wanted me to have the opportunity to go to college and earn a degree and despite them working hard and doing things right and making good decisions that was in jeopardy we were struggling to keep our house and at that point in time congress voted to give billions of dollars of public money to bail out folks in wall street a few miles away uh some of them were the same people who are responsible for the housing crisis that took away a lot of my dad's work congress did not vote to spend billions of dollars in public money to help working families like mine deal with the crisis and so i've said before that you have to make someone from a working family very angry to study economics and data and public policy um but that's really what happened i wanted to figure out why the heck things were the way they were why did our supposed democracy not work for for people like me and my family and so i studied political science and government and then i went on to graduate school at brown university to study public affairs and while i learned a lot uh what i find most compelling is that the people in the highest places who are supposed to be working on crafting the best public policies don't actually have a clue to what families like my need or what could have been done to solve the problems we face and they didn't even really seem to have strategies that would bring them closer to discovering these things and that's really what motivated me to join the bernie sanders campaign and then come on board with people's action because the people who are going to bring necessary change are people like the ones on this training tonight and so we're doing the work to further a movement of a multiracial working class group of people who are going to revive our democracy and build a government and an economy that works for everyone including families like mine and right now we find ourselves at another major crisis and we need organizing that meets the moment we are in and so what we'll cover in this training will inform strategic organizing that meets the moment we're in with the urgency required without sacrificing the long game which is the absolute necessity to change the dominant narrative around spending public dollars in this country and the goal here tonight is that you leave this training of course convinced of the deficit myth and that the federal government can and should pay for copied relief and you should also leave here tonight feeling like you can have a conversation with someone you know about the deficit myth and covet relief uh but if you joined us because you wanted to have maybe a nuanced debate about the efficacy of modern monetary theory according to the neoliberal economic school of thought this is not that event um everything we'll talk about tonight is intended to prepare for and inform taking action and so to run down the agenda really quick for what to expect in the training we're going to hear from one of our deep canvassing call leaders camille who will ground us in the work we're doing i'll say a few more words about how deep canvassing and public spending is very relevant and worthwhile and then stephanie kelton will share some really critical points about the deficit myth and covid relief and then we'll have a discussion about how public money works and a q a so please put your questions in the chat throughout the training we actually have moderators who are pulling those out and putting them into a place where we can revisit them during q a um and we're going to do a little demonstration of a persuasion conversation so you can see what that might look like and we'll finish just by sharing uh information about next steps and what happens after this training and a small warning is that we are going to talk about economics today we're going to talk about fiscal policy and monetary policy but you do not have to have any background or background knowledge to understand or participate i strongly feel that economics can and should be taught uh in public school years k through 12 and i think it's actually a disservice to our democracy that it's not i think we all have a stake in how our government executes and creates policy and how our economy functions and we should ask who benefits uh when the majority of people in america are not being taught about economics it's really given the people currently in power undue influence on how our country and economy runs so just by coming together to have this training we're actually taking a very radical action to fight against the designers and perpetrators of undemocratic systems in america uh but definitely you don't need to feel like you have to have any background knowledge or you need to be an economist to participate tonight that's not what this is for uh we're coming together because in many more ways than one americans uh are suffocating right now whether we're talking about the millions of americans who have had severe cases of covet 19 or we're referring to the millions of unemployed laid off for underemployed americans who are trying to make ends meet and pay bills and feed their families or if if we're talking about our neighbors who are still working uh and maybe risking their lives every day to do good work and try and make a living so to further ground us in the need for coveted relief i'm going to pass the mic to an amazing organizer someone who volunteers their time with people's action and an experienced deep canvasser i'm thrilled to introduce camille awesome thank you jessica um yeah like jessica said my name's camille johnson i use she her pronouns um normally i'm based in new york city um i'm in boulder colorado right now which i'll get into a little later but um yeah like jessica said i am uh one of the advanced call team leaders for uh people's actions deep canvassing program um proud volunteer um and yeah i i'm here because i'm a musician specifically a musician in theater so my industry fully shut down on march 12th of this year and i've i've been unemployed since then um and after many iterations of when we'll reopen when we'll reopen and keep kept getting pushed back and back it was just recently officially announced that it won't open again until may 31st of 2021 at the earliest so it's about a year and a half that my industry will basically be in full shutdown um and i've during this time the last nine months i've just watched my friends and my co-workers struggle to get support from our government i um i've been like i said living on unemployment and after the extended unemployment benefits ran out at the end of july i could no longer afford my apartment in new york city um so i ended up having to give it up and leave which is why i'm here in colorado um and i've you know i've been relying on these um these services that have been uh offered to me like the student loan relief um that's been huge for me and um also in addition my mental health care co-pays have been covered by the state and those uh the mental health care copays are no longer covered um and it's really hard to afford now um and the student loan relief is uh expiring pretty soon so those are all really scary things to think about um if i don't have support from our government um in addition my uh healthcare is um through a plan through my union which is the musicians union um and that relies on employer contributions um to my health fund which i am no longer getting my health fund is um has officially run out so my health care plan is no longer as of march um and that's pretty scary to think about i'm yeah i i'm really worried that if i don't have any uh support from from our government that like i don't know if i'm gonna be able to afford health care um as we know there's not many affordable health care options um out there so yeah i am along with that like i've i've noticed this trend where as artists we're usually pretty scrappy and we can hustle and we can make ends meet pretty pretty well usually and you know when we need extra money we normally go and get other jobs in the service industry and the retail business and those aren't options for so many people right now um i know a lot of friends who are had to move home to live with their parents who are older and higher risk and they cannot afford to go and work in a restaurant and and bring a potential infection home to their family so we're just left with no options um if if the government doesn't choose to support us so that all um that all kind of led me to this work that i'm doing with people's action to the deep canvassing program i felt like there was such a need in this country and people weren't people were not getting the support that they they deserve and doing this deep canvassing really allows me to feel like i have some agency again and to feel like i'm actually able to create a real change and to maybe affect a change that will get people the relief that they need um so that's why i'm here i think that we have the resources in this country we have the money and it needs to go to the people it needs to go to the working people and that's why i'm here um and thank you guys all for listening and i'm going to throw it back to jessica now thank you so much camille for being with us tonight and for sharing that story i think there's millions of people across the country who are in the exact same position or can relate to everything that you just said and at the end of the day if you're a worker who maintains the roads we drive on if you're a trucker uh who brings foods and and tools across the country if you're someone who makes art uh or someone who builds homes like my father does or does bookkeeping for small businesses like my mom does or you work in a factory and you build the cars we drive uh or make the devices we use if you raise a kid you're among the working people who really keep our country running and produce things of real value in the economy and we should ask why are these people precisely the people who are essential to our economy and make up the majority of the country the people that so many of our elected officials are failing to serve right now and unfortunately this dilemma is not unique to the moment we're in and especially now there's this dark cloud of austerity on the horizon and because of that we're going to talk about austerity a lot tonight and when i say austerity i mean people in power attempting to cut social programs that meet public needs like social security because there's some budget constraint or funding shortage or lack of tax revenue or claim that increasing the deficit will cause catastrophes and both democrats and republicans are signaling that a growing deficit is a reason for austerity in the near future you never really hear how are we going to pay for wars how are we going to account for the revenue lost when we give billionaires tax cuts how will we fund the wall street bailout but when it comes to things that benefit the american people we suddenly have to have a debate about how or who is going to pay for that um and so tonight we're going to expand on the tools that we have to make the case that actually the federal government footing the bill for social programs and stimulus packages like covet relief is the ethical and the economically sound thing to do right now and always the illusion that scarcity has been a major uh it's been a major barrier to progress um and so we're not making the case like ron johnson might believe uh that we're hyper focused on need in this country and we're taking an action that immediately serves that need while sacrificing some kind of long-term long-term economic stability uh it's actually good fiscal policy to make the decision to fund programs that ensure people are taken care of it's better for the economy when workers are employed and healthy and small businesses don't collapse so uh the first question is why isn't this a philosophy of congress when it comes to coveted relief right now and why hasn't it been the philosophy of congress for many years um and i think that shouldn't just be a rhetorical question we shouldn't endeavor to give real answers to it so uh put your thoughts in the chat whatever comes to mind of why congress is not taking this approach already and while we may have many answers for this i think it's really important for us to name one um is that it's good for corporations and billionaires workers who are struggling to get by and find work are workers who will work for really low wages with less benefits and do more dangerous work that might put their health at risk and because they need money to survive and feed their families uh they'll do this work and so when social programs are gone labor becomes extremely easy to exploit so billionaires and large corporations um have through lobbying efforts paid our elected officials to use their power to spend public money in ways uh that makes our economy really ripe for them to make profits but living conditions really bad for the majority of american people um so as much as this event is about debunking the deficit myth and winning coveted relief it's really about this breakthrough and how our democracy can be revitalized through addressing how public spending can and should serve public needs and to bring people together to organize around that because right now too many members of congress are not using their power to meet the needs of the people and at this point where we are at as a movement the progressive left is is quite complicated we are fighting for extraordinary popular policies like cash payments widespread coveted relief coveted recovery and raising the minimum wage other things like health care for all and taxing billionaires and now we get to enter this exciting phase of making the case for how we can actually make things happen and that's really where stephanie kelton's work uh is a huge reason why we can make that case around these policies that not only they're the moral thing to do but that they're the economically sound thing to do and our deep canvas approach is one of the most persuasive strategies in the country and by bringing this approach to making the case uh to american how we've been lied to what it's cost us and what the truth is and where we can go from here we can immediately alleviate suffering across the country through getting covert relief passed and we lay the groundwork of getting towards spreading an idea that public spending can and should serve public needs and make strides towards the long run strategy of winning an economic and political system that not only alleviates suffering but promotes human flourishing and so this is why we all should care about the deficit myth because exposing the truth about public spending and the deficit is key for pressuring for coveted relief and then for winning everything else like healthcare for all free college for all a green new deal and so after this training your response to the but how are you going to make it happen or but how are we going to pay for it question will be very different and so this is what makes stephanie kelton's work so extraordinary not only is she the most popular proponent of modern monetary theory she's one of the best economists at explaining very complicated things in a way that elicits understanding her work is uh changing the landscape of public policy and economics for the better um she's a graduate of the new school where she's now a senior fellow she's a professor of economics and public policy at stony brook university or at stony brook and she served as a chief economist from 2014 to 2016 at the senate budget committee and as an economic advisor for the bernie sanders 2016 presidential bid and now she's a new york times best-selling author for her book the deficit myth which i strongly recommend um i'm thrilled to introduce my personal hero and partner in this fight stephanie kelton thank you jessica and thank you all um for the opportunity to spend time with you this evening i think you are doing such important work and to the extent that i can be helpful to you tonight or you know on any kind of a future or uh ongoing basis i i am happy to do that i think that the work that you do is extraordinarily important and you know we are up against a lot uh and jessica has already mentioned senator ron johnson and i'm sure that many of you like me have been paying attention to the ongoing um negotiations surrounding another relief package and you know kind of lots of people we've heard from some today uh camille for example people are in distress they are in financial distress they are waiting to see if congress will step up to the plate and do something to help people you turn on the news and you can't escape the images of the miles long you know stretches of cars of people who are there to get food from food banks i mean there is so much need in this country 54 million americans are facing food insecurity it's unimaginable and congress is dragging its feet and bickering over the price tag and trying to pretend that somehow a trillion is a magical number and whatever they uh you know compromise on it's got to come under that price tag and so you know the horse trading is about how many additional weeks of unemployment extended benefits we have to subtract away if we want to add a direct cash payment or something like this so you know senator johnson ron johnson from wyoming gets up today and says look i'm a good guy i feel i want to help people but uh he said and i wrote it down we don't have an unlimited checkbook and so this is what jessica has been getting at here they use these myths and they hide behind them and they give them cover and they're powerful and the reason that they often work for our political leaders is because the rest of us don't know any better and if the federal government says you know we don't have the money to do this well who are we to say yes you do you know if if we don't know any better it happens around the world this isn't unique to the united states of america you might remember former prime minister theresa may in the uk famously saying you know there is no magic money tree well ted cruz went on to use that precise language you know they they make a mockery of the idea that the government can afford to step forward and commit resources to do even the most basic things like provide sufficient financial resources to help hospitals and maintain help states and uh cities maintain public services to help the unemployed right with um some cash assistance and so forth in an economy and the rest of us say well yeah how are they supposed to come up with the money to do this if we're all you know struggling financially households we see businesses right going under small businesses you see cities and states struggling and you go well yeah everybody's running out of money so why is the federal government any better positioned to step in and spend to send money to people to help if we're all in the same boat you know how are they any different and what i do in this book is to start off explaining the answer to that question what makes them different why is it that mayors and governors around this country are pointing their fingers at congress and saying you have to help us we need your help or we're going to lay off more they've already laid off 1.3 million workers and there's going to be a whole lot more to come if state and local governments don't get the help that they need from the federal government so why are governors and mayors pointing their finger at congress as if somehow congress is better off financially than they are well the answer is that congress is different the federal government is fundamentally different from a household from a private business from a state and a local government so what makes them different and where i start off in the book is with a chapter that's called don't think of a household and this is where you know we all need to keep this in mind that the what makes the federal government different from all the rest of us is that they have the sole legal authority to issue the currency that is the united states government is the issuer of our currency the u.s dollar none of us can legally create the thing right if we get caught trying to create it it's called counterfeiting it's illegal we go to jail the federal government creates our currency they're the issuer of the currency and all of the rest of us are merely what we want to think of as users of the currency we face real financial constraints right in order to pay the bills in order to stay current on our utility payment our car payment our student loan payment our mortgage our rent we gotta have the cash to do that in order for a business to stay profitable it's got to have enough revenue to cover all of its costs right in order to stay profitable state and local governments rely they are dependent upon tax revenue in order to cover expenses the federal government is different the federal government gets to issue the currency that the rest of us merely use so where you want to start your thinking is just recognizing that congress has the power of the purse they can do what the rest of us can't do they can commit to spending money that they do not have so think about the cares act right it's the best example because after coronavirus you know when that really started to hit hard in march congress moved four pieces of legislation really quickly through the house and the senate right the biggest one was the cares act that was 2.2 trillion dollars now congress didn't have 2.2 trillion dollars they didn't go out and get 2.2 trillion they didn't raise taxes they didn't go to china and ask do you have an extra 2.2 trillion lying around congress has the ability to commit to spending money that it doesn't have on hand right and so that piece of legislation was congress's way of saying to the federal reserve to its bank okay the federal reserve is the government's fiscal agent its bank said this is the way that congress instructs the federal reserve to make payments on behalf of the u.s treasury it writes a bill it did this with the cares act said get ready fed we are committing 2.2 trillion dollars and the federal reserve's job is to carry out all of the payments that have been authorized by congress on behalf of the u.s treasury now how do they do that people will say well the government is printing all this money well there's no physical nobody's printing up bills and wheeling them off somewhere in order to pay the bills you know this is the 21st century after all so we're doing this in digital form so to clear these payments if you got one of those twelve hundred dollar checks from the government you deposit that check what happens the numbers in your bank account increase you get an extra twelve hundred dollars in your account where did that twelve hundred dollars come from didn't come from anywhere it came from the banking system changing numbers in bank accounts crediting the balance so that you have an extra twelve hundred dollars if you're unemployed the federal government committed another six hundred dollars a week to top up your unemployment support you uh your income in this uh crisis you had an extra 600 credited to your bank account every week right congress can do that this is why the chairman of the federal reserve jerome powell says the difference between what we can do at the fed and what congress can do is this the fed can lend he says but the fed can't spend so the fed can make a loan right and when the fed makes loans well the borrower takes on debt right so the fed can do things to provide bridge loans and financial assistance that that lead to borrowing that increase debt what congress can do is a whole lot better right what congress can do is drive income directly into the pockets of people that they own they have that cash free and clear they don't have to pay it back they could do those paycheck protection programs right to help small businesses keep workers on payroll starts off as a loan but it's really a grant right it's forgivable so they get the cash free and clear same with the unemployment top up the same with the twelve hundred dollar check so when congress does this like the cares act what it's doing is it's spending more into the economy it's not raising taxes and so this adds to this thing we call the deficit i'm getting to the deficit myth here i'm pointing over my shoulder because i know the book is back there so we get worried right because we've been trained to think of the deficit as evidence of somehow you know government mismanaging its finances that this is fiscally irresponsible uh that it's reckless that it's dangerous that it is somehow going to cause problems in the future forget all of that okay that's that is incorrect set that aside let's talk about this deficit and what it really is the deficit is the difference between two numbers it's all it is okay one of the numbers is how many dollars the government is spending into the economy every year the other number is how many dollars the government is subtracting out of the economy each year mostly through taxation so the difference between two numbers if the government spends more money into the economy than it subtracts back out through taxation we label it a deficit so let's use very simple numbers suppose the government spends a hundred dollars into the economy it only taxes let's say ninety dollars back out somewhere it's recorded that the government has run a deficit and someone writes a minus 10 on a ledger and says this is the government's fiscal uh outcome right this is the balance on the government's ledger you say well hang on if they put 100 in they only took 90 out somebody got 10 right the government's deficit is nothing more than a financial contribution to some other part of our economy so every time you hear someone talk about the government deficit i want you to think wait that's a surplus right that's a financial surplus that's a deposit it's like the government dropping ten dollars into somebody's bucket right the question is who got the ten dollars because guess what every deficit is good for someone we're arguing over this thing that is in financial terms always good for someone right because the government's deficit is somebody else's financial surplus so what we want to do is get off of this obsession we have with ringing our hands over the deficit and start talking about deficits for whom deficits for what because republicans understand this perfectly well i promise you they do and they know they're pulling the wool over the eyes of people who don't understand it those tax cuts that the republicans passed in december of 2017 added some estimated 2 trillion 1.9 trillion to deficits over the course of the next decade so call it a 2 trillion dollar tax cut right now why would republicans do this if deficits are this terrible horrible very bad thing the answer is it's not a terrible horrible very bad thing and they know it they know that the government's deficit creates a financial windfall on the other side of the ledger somebody ends up with those dollars and when republicans did their tax cuts they knew exactly where they wanted those dollars to go into the hands of the people who least need the help right that's how they like to divert the deficit to to channel the the dollars into corporate uh big you know big corporations and the wealthiest people in this country so ask yourself well okay if every deficit is good for someone how would progressives or democrats use deficits if given the chance well right now we have you know in 2000 2020 we are running deficits that are um about 3.1 trillion dollars okay a lot of that is a consequence of deliberate legislative action taken by congress cares act and so forth to deal with coronavirus so those deficits did a lot of good for people who most need the help in our economy for struggling businesses for you know unemployed workers for people who uh lost income in the downturn now i'm not arguing that every penny went to good use but i'm saying it did a lot of good right so i i want to um make that point first right that we don't want to treat the deficit as something that we should be trying to bring down eliminate stamp out that surpluses would be better a deficit is like the government taking a blower and out of the blower come dollars and you just shoot them out into the economy now you can aim them right you can aim at the rich you can aim at uh you know programs to fund education and health care and do infrastructure or deal with climate change you can direct those dollars to better or uh more productive or less productive use but the deficit is going to result in somebody ending up with more dollars right when the government's budget goes into surplus the opposite happens a surplus works like a vacuum it hoovers dollars off of people's balance sheets out of our pockets now that might be a perfectly fine thing to do in certain circumstances and you might you know say look i want to take some dollars out of the pockets of people who have accumulated too much i think the wealth and income inequality that exists today has reached dangerous levels right it's corrosive not just to the functioning of our economy but to our democracy so i want to hoover some dollars out of the pockets of people who have simply taken too much right and that's a perfectly reasonable thing to do but what mmt helps us to see is that the purpose of removing dollars from wealthy people let's say is not so that the government can afford to fund education to fund health care to pay for infrastructure and make other investments in the economy government's the issue or the currency it doesn't need to treat the rich like a piggy bank it doesn't need to depend on the wealthy in order to fund government programs right it can always commit the funding the way it did in the cares act it commit any level of funding it chooses it can fund another three trillion to deal with uh you know relief and recovery and so forth so we want to think of the purpose of the tax for the federal government not as a source of revenue that's needed to cover the bills but rather a way for government to strategically remove dollars from the rest of us for one reason so that you mitigate inflationary pressure so the government wants to spend ambitiously and the economy is running out of um space let's say it's getting too close to full employment a full employment economy can't handle trillions and trillions of dollars of additional spending it will create inflationary pressures so taxes are one way for the government to say i'm going to come in and spend a lot of money on a big ambitious green new deal or an infrastructure program or something and i'm going to offset some of that spending by raising taxes in a certain strategic way that would be using taxes for the purpose of avoiding creating an inflation problem you'd use taxes to rebalance the distribution of wealth and income could use taxes to create incentives or disincentives to change behavior think of a tax to encourage people to put solar panels on their homes or buy energy efficient appliances or vehicles or or something like that but don't think of taxes for the federal government the way we think of taxes for state and local governments that's a lifeline to a state and local government they need the tax revenue to pay the teachers to pay the firefighters to keep essential workers uh you know on staff and so forth federal government is different as the issuer of the currency so the the debate that's happening today around relief uh for and support for the economy is not recognizing any of this it is pretending as if the government is financially constrained as if the deficit is the reason that congress would it that it would be irresponsible for congress to do more this is what senator johnson would have us believe i'd love to help people but i i'm not you know willing to go along with higher and higher levels of spending because of the deficit so we have an economy that is very depressed right we have uh at least 10 million workers who lost jobs in the pandemic and still don't have those jobs back we have an economy that is slowing uh we desperately need not just relief now and what the packages they're talking about are far too small to deal with the problem at hand we need more relief more robust relief and then we're going to need funding for recovery on the other side of coronavirus because this economy is going to continue to be weak for a period of time to come how long depends on a variety of things including the fiscal response so we need congress prepared not just to come and do this bill now to get relief but to be prepared to to stand ready to provide all of the fiscal support that is going to be necessary to keep to protect people's livelihoods to restore jobs to rebuild right this economy and that really does require a very big change in the philosophy around federal budgeting congress has to stop thinking of this in a zero-sum way there's only so much money available to put another dollar here we have to take a dollar here jessica said it already it's austerity this mindset is you know it's like gold standard thinking right when people say we're gonna find the money just think about that find the money where am i supposed to look for it right is it under the seat cushion is it in a hole in the ground we're not on a gold standard this is we have a monetary system that thank goodness right we always went off the gold standard to fight world war one we went off the gold standard to fight world war ii we went off the gold standard because that type of monetary system really does impose constraints on government's ability to spend more freely we don't have that uh problem today okay congress has thankfully uh a set of institutions in place that allow it to commit to spending whatever it deems appropriate right and the money will be there so i'm going to close on this the the answer that i usually give when people say you know how are you gonna pay for it is you know the votes fund the spending if you can find the votes you have found the money it's as simple as that so if you know uh senator sanders and senator hawley could go around and collect enough votes to support this 1200 payment that they have uh jointly um proposed then the money would be there it's just as simple as that the the votes always are there when it comes to defense right they're always there there's never a lack of votes and that funding always happens regularly every year there is an appropriation and an authorization for the military budget and they top it up over time because they feel generous and they say well we should probably put in a another 10 or 20 billion this year uh you know just because we can um it's only when it comes to other priorities that we think our pockets are empty that the hand ringing starts over the deficit we got to stop falling for this and democrats in particular need to stop falling for it because they've been playing you know charlie brown to lucy in the football for the last couple of decades at least and they continue to fall for this and every time they get in office they say you know we have to be the party of fiscal responsibility so we have to start working on the deficit and then republicans get in and they just disregard uh you know the deficit entirely and they focus on passing their agenda they're just laser focused say what do we want to accomplish let's pass our agenda democrats need to do that too what is it we want to accomplish approach the budgeting process in a mission-oriented way what do you want to see happen do you want to see child poverty rates cut in half in the next four years let's do that do you want to drive them to zero over some short period of time let's do that do you want to see everybody who wants to work in this country able to find a job right with a job that that they can provide for their family with a living wage and and benefits let's do that like what is it we're trying to accomplish set the mission and fit the budget to the mission instead of pretending that the budget is some fixed allotment and we can only incrementally fiddle around and nibble away at some of the the real problems that we face so in the book i have a chapter called the the deficits that matter and that's what i think we need to focus on there are so many deficiencies in our economy the the thing we call the federal deficit is not a problem it is not a problem it's not a problem today it wasn't a problem 10 years ago when we had the the deficit commission and the simpson bowls and all that kind of stuff it wasn't a problem then it isn't a problem now and it's not going to be a problem going forward we just have to flip that script and try to get everybody focused on the deficits that matter recognize that whatever is financially feasible if we have the know-how we have the workers if we have the raw materials if we have the capacity in our economy to do things the money can always be there we just have to find the votes thank you so much stephanie we have so many amazing questions coming in the chat but i want to start with this so you are a brilliant economist you could you know theoretically make so much money working for like goldman sachs but instead you've chosen um and not to go to places like harvard but instead to go to the new school and not to pursue working at places like goldman sachs where you make a lot of money but to tackle the deficit myth and do work that uh is really good for the people uh so where did you learn to care and and why are you tackling the deficit myth when you could be doing anything else hmm no it's a it's a funny question that you phrased it the way you did because um when i was finishing up my undergrad uh one of my well the the most influential professor in my life took me to lunch and he invited another professor along and the point of the lunch was to introduce me to this other professor and to have him give me some advice about where i should go to graduate school and so uh the the professor that i was introduced to said go to harvard and the professor who took me to lunch said no no no no don't listen to that so the two of them started you know kind of arguing about whether and why i should or should not uh try to uh get into harvard and you know i i think that it was easy for me i i have a stubborn streak um i don't have as uh my former boss senator sanders puts it um what did he say in the interview with the new york times editorial board i'm not someone who tolerates particularly well i think we're his exact words and i am i think cut from a similar cloth in that respect i just um i couldn't do it i could not do that type of training i i could not um i knew enough to be dangerous i suppose in the sense that i had enough of an understanding of you know how the financial system works how banking works and that if i went through a more conventional program that i was going to be asked to swallow a lot of uh stuff that you know is it's just wrong it's i don't know how else to say it and i didn't want to do that so um and the new school you know has a long tradition of um fighting the good fight and being i think on the right side of a lot of policy uh fights and advocating for um you know people who are are struggling there it's a it's an institution that's very special in in its history and so i felt more at home in a place like like that amazing all right now that we know that uh professor kelton is on our side generally um let's get into some of the questions there are some very good ones uh including i think we should start with this but how should we think about the deficit what is the deficit how does it exist in the world maybe you know what's the role of a treasury bond okay well so as i i said the deficit is just the difference between two numbers i mean we shouldn't make this harder than it is you know it's the word it's the word that gets in the way because the word has a connotation a deficit is a shortfall right if you're a sports fan and you turn on uh you know the game and you see that it's getting close to halftime and you hear the announcer say oh if the bills are going to come back and win this thing they're going to have to overcome a 14-point deficit oh my god you know that's what a deficit is it's something to overcome it's a problem situation but it's not when we're talking about the federal government's finances so we've chosen this really lousy word to describe the budget outcome at the end of the year what happened did the government add more than it subtracted or did it subtract more than it added that's all we're talking about and most of the time it's a pretty good thing that the government is making a contribution a financial contribution to some other part of the economy right it gets to add more dollars and it subtracts from the rest of us that lets somebody accumulate more financial assets but then you mentioned the bond part and this is where the the deficits lead to um an addition to this other thing that we call the national debt so when i say suppose the government spends a hundred dollars in and subtracts 90 away they've left ten dollars in some part of the economy except they don't leave that ten dollars when the government runs a deficit it sells bonds u.s government bonds treasuries and so those ten dollars that the government is making available through its deficit get subtracted back out and replaced with government bonds so think of 10 u.s treasuries now sitting on someone's um in someone's portfolio right so if the government does this let's say the government does uh infrastructure and it wants to build a bridge it can do two things right one thing is it could say well i don't want to add to the deficit because i i'm somehow you know opposed to that so i want to spend a trillion dollars on infrastructure but i don't want that spending to add to the deficit so i'm gonna um subtract a trillion dollars away from people by taxing so i'm going to take a trillion dollars away from some people in the economy i'm going to add a trillion dollars to other pockets so the construction workers who get hired to do the infrastructure the corporations who manufacture and sell cranes and concrete mixers and all that kind of stuff right they get paid a trillion dollars and some segment of u.s taxpayers you know you get your account uh subtracted with dollars so what happens well you fix some bridges that were crumbling and uh and that's it america gets crumbling infrastructure this segment of the population gave up some dollars and this segment of the population got some dollars and it's net to zero nobody has any net new dollars but we have some better infrastructure okay that's one way to do it the other way to do it is to say the government is going to fund the infrastructure investment it's going to just spend a trillion just like the cares act we're just gonna spend a trillion dollars so the government spends a trillion dollars some workers get jobs doing infrastructure repair and and so forth some companies get some additional dollars right for selling heavy machine equipment and that sort of thing and america gets better infrastructure so we get better safer bridges to drive across and somebody ends up with a trillion dollars right uh as a result now with the deficit it's a trillion dollars of bonds it's like saying the government is making uh some of its payments in the form of u.s treasuries so some people end up holding bonds now who are those people well there tend to be wealthier people right who have dollars that they can transform into u.s treasuries treasuries are interest bearing dollars so somebody's getting to give up their dollars to hold treasuries which amplify which pays some interest but look you hired some people workers did infrastructure investment they got paid the contractors got paid the corporations made some money and we got better infrastructure it's like you know you could do it either way but in the second way the government is actually increasing the financial assets out there somewhere in the economy as payment for the improved infrastructure now there's i love the phrasing of this question it was a question from the chat is there a point where debt spending becomes unsustainable or do we indeed have an infinite credit card and the word credit card is reminding me of obama's 2008 stump speech yeah so i don't you know you're right uh when i'll say it for those who who don't know what you're talking about but um when barack obama was running for president first time he was stumping around the country and he was you know lamenting this national debt that we have he said you know it's irresponsible he said it's unpatriotic it's like you take out a credit card from the bank of china right a credit card from the bank of china the government doesn't have a credit card don't don't analogize the federal government's finances to that of a individual household that gets you going on the wrong off on the wrong foot does the does congress have the capacity to commit to spending whatever it deems appropriate the answer is yes it can afford to purchase whatever is available and for sale in its own currency that's the limit right you can't buy what's not available so all the money in the world would not help the government get ventilators and ppe back in march it wasn't available you couldn't have it but you can afford to hire all unemployed workers who are looking for jobs that pay us dollars looking for a job in with wages paid in us dollars you can afford to hire everybody uh and employ everyone who wants a job but can't find one anywhere else in the economy so the upper limit is what's available and for sale in your own currency it's not the same as saying the government should go out and buy everything that's available for sale it's recognizing that that is the upper limit right it is what's available and for sale in your in your currency so is there a limit yes right you try to push beyond the limit the punishment is inflation it's not insolvency with a credit card if i charge up my credit card right and and i can't pay it the punishment for me is bankruptcy right that's not going to happen to the federal government united states the punishment is inflation not insolvency yeah i think there are so many questions about inflation so let's dig into those um yeah is inflation going to be a problem if we spend you know three trillion dollars on another covid relief package three trillion no but there is a limit okay look i'm drinking a glass of water i have to wipe the lipstick off i'm i'm holding up a glass of water yes this let's suppose this is a 12-ounce glass if we could agree that this is a 12-ounce glass and if if it were empty and i had a 12 ounce can of soda unopened we could agree that i could open that can and safely pour every drop of liquid into my empty 12-ounce glass it wouldn't overflow i wouldn't create a mess that's the capacity of the glass 12 ounces the economy has like a carrying capacity right there are also ecological constraints but there's a spending constraint and the government has to share space in the economy with everyone else who wants to spend and remember that households do the vast majority of spending in our economy accounting for some two-thirds to 70 percent of all spending it's us we take up most of the space in the glass but if the glass isn't full to the top in other words if we're not at full employment and there's extra space available then the government can pour some liquid into the glass take up that space and move us closer to full employment as you as you begin to run out of space right in the economy people are all working who is the government going to get to do infrastructure or you know if you want to do medicare for all and you want to pledge that everybody can have mental health care and dental and vision and long-term care if you don't have the doctors the nurses the optometrists the health care professionals if you don't have the beds and the capacity to make good on that promise then you can't deliver in spite of all the money in the world right so the limits are your economy's real productive capacity there is a constraint you can spend up to full employment you have to share your spending space with everyone else in the economy who wants to spend but you can safely spend up to the point of full employment and would three trillion dollars risk overflowing the glass and producing an inflation problem no we are too far from full employment um for that for that to happen so three trillion is i think almost all economists would agree a safe number at this point given how depressed our economy is and are there economic consequences to not spending money into the economy right now if we don't do another stimulus just incredible ones yeah like you know you you probably have heard this term scarring people talk about long-term scarring effects of um you know people who lost jobs that were we talked about this supposed to be temporary job losses maybe you were furloughed the expectation was that your boss was going to bring you back onto payroll uh restore your wages and benefits and so forth after we hit this pause button on the economy but now your your job is gone permanently you know the business has gone under it's not there for you to return to so how long can people remain unemployed before they become unemployable right because that's what happens employers do not like to hire the uh the long-term unemployed they don't they will hire around them they will do everything they can to avoid hiring someone who's been out of work for 12 or 16 months or more why because you know yes your skills can deteriorate your work habits can do they just employers don't like to do that and i'm just giving you one example i mean think about the small businesses whole cities are going to look very different um six months from now compared to you know the start of this year there was an article i was reading the other day it really broke my heart because i spent 17 years living in and immediately around kansas city and the stories were about how many businesses you know small business restaurants in particular right just going under in the kansas city area and i thought by the time i make it back to kansas city to see old friends i probably won't recognize much of the place you know it will have so changed with businesses going under and so what are you left with you're left with the larger and larger corporations who you know managed to survive through this fewer small businesses um more long-term unemployment those scarring effects um you know whole industries that are downsized if we don't get the support to the airlines and and retail and so yeah it's the the damages potentially um you know lasting and that just makes it that much harder to climb your way out of it yeah so this is not a question from the chat but i think it's a good time for it uh can you tell me about your views of spider-man well look i'm a huge uh of all the people in my family my son and i are the two complete you know marvel and dc i mean i like all of that stuff so i know you're bringing this up because i um i make some references to spider-man in the book right and i said look spider-man's a hero everybody knows spider-man's a hero why is he a hero because he you know he swoops in and saves the day when there's a crisis moment and nobody would think of spider-man as a hero if he refused to act he just sat there and and watched you know the the the train go careening over the you know the track is gone and he just was like yeah i'm gonna let it go over um he's a hero because he takes action and you know the stan lee line is that um with great power comes great responsibility and in the book i say that's what congress has they have great power it's called the power of the purse you know they have the power of the purse if they wanted to tonight they could walk away with a three trillion dollar bill that's much closer to what we need than this 900 whatever billion dollar i mean it changes almost by the minute right if they wanted to provide that level of support for this economy for people who are hurting in this economy to shore up incomes and protect families and communities and and get money to state and local governments they could with this with a stroke of a pen right it's just the votes all they have to do is vote for it and walk out they don't have to hurt anybody they don't have to say well we had to raise these taxes on this group of people and folks that they could just literally cast the votes provide the funding and walk away for the holidays feeling good about what they've done right to help like spiderman right we're rescuing families we're saving people we're saving lives we're literally saving lives people who are losing their healthcare people who can't feed their families people who are facing eviction we can deal with so much pain and distress in this economy and we have the power to do it and it's as simple as casting that vote and yet they won't do it and so that spider-man reference is about you know the responsibility side of this you have great power but it doesn't do anyone any good if you don't use it and what they're trying to do is use use it as um as frugally as possible and so it leads to a lot of gratuitous suffering and you know gratuitous suffering is the worst kind of suffering right because if you could make someone's pain if you could alleviate someone's pain that easily but you choose not to do it it's just then the the suffering is gratuitous it's not because it's unavoidable if it was unavoidable if we literally couldn't afford to do it then okay you you know there is some justification well what were we supposed to do we didn't have the power to to act but they do in many ways congress has also handicapped themselves supposedly i saw the word pay go in the chat throughout all of this so can you say more about how pay go is constraining us from uh you know having the federal government pay for necessary programs yeah i mean if if i operated my household budget on a pay-go basis it means i only spend cash that i have available to me right and if if i am spending every dollar of my income but i really want disney plus then i have to you know um cancel some other subscription right i have to find the money somewhere because i'm not going to put anything on my credit card paygo is this budgeting rule that wants to treat the federal government's finances like a household to constrain them in that sort of way so that pago says listen if you want to spend another dollar on anything you have to find the money so you either need to bring me a new dollar of revenue find some tax that you can increase to generate more revenue or you've got to carve money out of some other part of the budget because paygo says we are not adding to the deficit we will only spend that dollar if you can bring me you can free up a dollar from some other part of the budget or you go bring me new revenue so pay go makes it much more difficult to pass legislation why because you have to pick two fights and you have to win both fights so imagine when i was in the senate and i tell the story in the book um there was a discussion about a trillion dollar infrastructure bill and whether the bill should be written and introduced as a clean bill that is we just want to spend a trillion dollars or whether it should be paid for paid for means you don't add to the deficit right so paid for means like pay go pay as you go is why it's called pay go and so there was a debate over this if you made a clean bill if you wrote a clean bill it would be like the cares act you just have to go around and collect the votes from your colleagues and say i want you to vote for my infrastructure bill because we're going to spend a trillion dollars upgrading and fixing america's crumbling infrastructure go collect those votes if you get the votes you can spend the trillion pago says no you have to have two sets of votes you not only have to convince your colleagues to vote for your infrastructure spending you also have to convince them to vote for your pay for so here's what happens and i was in the senate um when this when this happened so the bill was written as um and paid for so the proposal was we want to spend a trillion dollars upgrading america's crumbling infrastructure and we plan to pay for it by closing some tax loopholes now these loopholes benefit the richest people in the country right these are not loopholes that probably any of us here tonight are taking advantage of so they only benefit a slice of the population but guess what happened you couldn't get the votes even many democrats wouldn't vote for the infrastructure bill because it required closing these tax loopholes so you gotta pick two fights and win both whereas if you get rid of paygo and you say listen i think i can safely spend a trillion dollars on infrastructure without the need for offsets i don't need them because the spending won't be inflationary it won't create any problems in the economy then you could make the case that you know a clean bill is the responsible way to go right let's just commit the trillion dollars let's spend let's get the infrastructure done and adhering to paygo is hard if you want to do um you know something on a green new deal or climate of any kind if you wanted um you know paid family leave if you want to do pay whatever you want to do under pay go you have to fully offset that spending and it just makes it that much harder to pass legislation of course the republicans don't do it they didn't do it with the tax cuts they don't we don't do it with defense spending but this is something that will get applied and used to create a barrier to entry so that progressive policies have to get over not just that first hurdle one set of votes but an extra hurdle right that that second set of votes and democrats will often say well we'll pay for it with cuts to defense right because the defense budget is so bloated and if you got 730 or so billion dollars just sitting there in defense and you say well i only want to spend you know 50 billion on my thing so why can't we just take 50 billion away from the defense budget okay fine but good luck right collecting the votes to cut the defense budget when 90 out of 100 senators are voting to increase funding for the pentagon so i'm not saying don't try don't get me wrong i'm not i'm not saying that i'm just saying i hope you have a plan b because if if passing your agenda is contingent on carving money out of defense or closing loopholes or a wealth tax or something that you don't even have to vote for in your own party then you're gonna get what nothing right of your agenda so why not be prepared to do what republicans are always prepared to do use the deficit use it when it's safe to do so use it to accomplish parts of your agenda i'm not saying you can do everything that way but i'm saying there is enough low-hanging fruit there's enough space fiscal space available especially in a depressed economy to accomplish a lot of the progressive agenda in this moment there is an enormous opportunity in a depressed economy to start picking off some of your priorities the easy way right one set of votes yeah i think a lot of us are about to see family through the holidays uh hopefully you know loved ones and people you live with and it's a good time to have a conversation about coveted relief on the floor and what the deficit myth really is so i've made a bunch of calls this election season and working for bernie so i have a good sense of the questions that come up in the how are you going to pay for it conversation so i'm going to take on the persona of someone who's skeptical of the deficit myth so that you can sort of see what a conversation might look like and then envision how this might go when you see your families who are not on this call uh over the holidays so let's assume stephanie has introduced herself and she said you know i'm calling about coping relief and we need you know about three trillion and i say something like well well doesn't that mean that we're indebted to china more now i'm sorry you're we're in conversation yeah yeah so so by spending three trillion dollars now we have to we are in debt and we have to pay the money back to china is that how this works that's what you're telling me okay so no so what you want to do is remind people that the federal government doesn't have to borrow dollars from anyone in order to spend that's the most important part and you know to some extent this is really uh where i think we need to start pushing because we've sort of accepted that any time the government budget moves into deficit that it requires the government to borrow and that this uh the result is an increase in the national debt and i'm arguing and i argue in the book that this is not inherently problematic that those bonds are merely part of the savings of the non-government part of the economy yes some of those bonds are held abroad right they're they're helped by foreigners but the vast majority are are not um but they the bottom line is those bonds are part of our wealth they're part of our savings they're not uh it's they're not a problem right think of those bonds as part of the broader money supply so but but again where you want to push is the government doesn't have to borrow there's no reason for the government to borrow when it does that it's choosing okay it's choosing to do something it's choosing to make some of its payments in the form of treasuries that's all that's happening it's a payment right and we use the word borrowing and i would flip it i would say no it's not right to think of it as borrowing think of it as paying what the government is doing is it can issue two instruments it can issue dollars or it can issue bonds and sometimes the government chooses to make some of its payments by issuing treasuries and those are just a monetary instrument like cash but the bonds provide some interest to the holder so it's a safe asset part becomes part of their wealth their savings and it provides some interest government wouldn't have to do that but it chooses to do so and then you could have a whole other conversation about why why the government decides to subsidize bondholders uh with a reward in the form of interest income for for what um the purpose of well that's another conversation now let's suppose i'm very skeptical of cash relief giving direct cash payments to people right now would it be better for them to just you know get a job and work for it when things get better or or do something else change their career path to something essential right now um why should we give them cash payments okay well the cash payments are uh jobs are not available that's the problem in the current economy right you cannot simply walk out and say today i'm going to go get a job there are not jobs available for everyone who wants to work and so part of the way that we're supporting the unemployed is through you know unemployment benefits but there are huge numbers there are millions of people who have lost income in this downturn in the economic crisis but haven't lost a job right their hours have been cut so you can't meet your you can't make your rent you can't buy food you're technically employed but you've lost so much income that you're really struggling and so these direct cash payments are a lifeline for people in those situations now someone might ask uh you know are we going to have to pay all this money back to someone someday uh like obama or we're having our children inherit the debt or something so look again the i i will say this what people worry about is this thing called the debt right that this are we gonna have to pay it back what i'm saying is the bonds are the form of payment it's a form of payment right so there's not in a sense the question is inapplicable because the spending has already happened all of the checks have already cleared the payments have been made there's nothing to pay back when you when you have government bonds they mature at some point 10-year bond a 30-year bond at some point the bond matures and what happens when the bond matures is that it converts back into government currency so you've made a payment in the form of one instrument a government bond and at some point you the government is saying i'll give you back the cash and i'll take the bond away right the bond is gone and i replace it with cash i'm the issuer of both i'm not going to run out of my own currency i'm not going to run into a situation where i can't make the payments the risk to worry about if there is one is inflation it's never going to be insolvency it's never going to be well how am i going to come up with the money to pay that back or that you have to come to me say oh the taxpayer is ultimately going to be on the hook for all this no it's not the way it works right the government can service any um debt obligation it has it can make any payment as it comes due as long as those payments are due in a currency that it and only it has the capacity to issue right so whether it's social security or um interest payments or a maturing bond government can make good on all of those because it's the issuer of the currency amazing seeing that we have about nine minutes left i want to pass it to you to recap any of the key points that that we should take away and really uh you know be talking about with the people we know before we get into the this explicitly cove and really deep canvassing what should what should we be thinking about and talking about with people right now well i i mean that you can that it is appropriate to expect the government to act that they have the capacity to act that um crying broke is not gonna fly you know the picture of the image on the front of the book is uncle sam with the pockets turned inside out you know that's an image of a that's our national symbol right and he's broke and the point of putting the deficit myth above that is to say this isn't right this is a myth right the federal government has the capacity to step up and do whatever it takes to support our economy to support families to support communities and you know you mentioned you know what are the are there long-term costs is there's some cost of inaction and i talked mostly about you know narrower economic costs and scarring a labor market and so forth because that's the wonky economic answer but you know what matters more is what's what is this going to do to families it tears them apart things like spousal abuse child abuse alcoholism suicide depression all of those things accompany you know um families in distress communities in crisis people who are are um suffering so all of that stuff um you know can be not entirely avoided i don't want to oversell you know um just how much we can mitigate the damage but my goodness right we can we can get our arms around this problem and we we you know our our government can step up and do so much to mitigate the pain uh so i think recognizing just don't take no for an answer absolutely they have the ability that the capacity they can afford it that finding the money is never the issuer that step out of that frame you know you don't want to ever find yourself arguing that the deficit is bad that it's dangerous that that's a problem never lean into any of that right um the federal government's issue or the currency and you know we didn't talk about europe but very often people will say well what about greece right look at greece or look at zimbabwe or look at that you know they'll use all of these um other examples and try to say this is what you know this is our fate if we continue to to spend this kind of money to support the economy it is not the case right greece got into trouble along with other european countries in 2010 there was that debt crisis right that gripped nations in what we call the euro zone but these are countries that in january of 1999 gave up their sovereign currencies greece gave up the drachma it was the issuer of the dragma it started using the euro so no longer the issue of the currency the greek government transformed itself into a currency user so it became more like you know california or georgia it's now operating with a currency that it can't issue and it's borrowing in a currency they can't issue so when financial markets in order to be able to cover deficits the greek government had to go out and get the euro from somewhere right and it has to pay an interest rate that lenders feel comfortable lending money to the greek government that is not the case for the united states of america right you know the currency is sure you don't have to borrow in the first place and if you do decide to borrow you can always set the terms in other words you can set the rate the interest rate that you're willing to pay on any bonds that you decide to issue so you know get that clear boy make it clear that the the federal government has the capacity to do what governors and mayors can't do what households can't do what businesses can't do then and the distinction the point of distinction is that of issuer versus user and just keep that really clear once you do that you'll be able to to answer almost any question that comes up right because you say well what about if the debt gets too big well what's too big you can always make the payments right so it's inflation it's inflation it's inflation if you don't have a long-term inflation problem you don't have a long-term debt or deficit problem thank you so much professor carlton for being with us tonight and sharing all of this and also just working with people's action behind the scenes to make sure this deep canvassing um is effective and has an impact on the deficit and it's like an overwhelming sort of idea or topic to grapple with sort of the first time you hear all of these things um but it really urges the question okay what do we do about this now what do we do next the first time i read the book i was like we absolutely need to organize behind these ideas because everything hinges on this and so right now that means coping relief so i want everyone to just take the next minute uh to think about what your family needs from copic relief what's on the line here and put what comes to mind in the chat we all either need covered relief ourselves or we know someone who needs that relief so let's just take a couple minutes and and put that in the chat student debt really yeah small business relief retraining universal health care rent relief it doesn't have to be strictly financially no it can be any anything you need corporate relief to help with during the crisis monthly payments financial assistance child care and child support mental health care college cost expenses medical expenses paying bills credit card health and now i want everyone to just think what are you ready to do to make sure that we get to a place where we have the relief we need and so everyone in this call even if you're a people's action volunteer before this or this is your first event with people's action and you're someone who who follows mmt and follows professor kelton uh you can join us uh to do unprecedented organizing work debunking the deficit myth conversation by conversation with real people in america who are constituents of congress um through educational and agitation deep canvassing conversations and win the immediate relief now around covid and in the long-term work to change the dominant narrative around public spending and i wish it was simple as you know we have the answers uh congress knows that their secrets out and and now go to deficit spend all of the popular policies but it's actually going to take a lot more work and of course uh one of our biggest barriers to progress right now is is mitch mcconnell in the republican held senate we have bills collecting dust on his desk because he's the senate majority leader and he gets to decide which bills uh go to a vote and he's continuously blocked covert relief packages and so if we want to win uh you know covet relief we need to win the races in georgia to get the senate majority um a lot of these conversations are about coveted relief and sometimes the deficit comes up on those um but we won't win everything if we win georgia but we will probably see cash relief in a larger stimulus and we'll see more bills coming to the floor of the senate uh including you know the i can't breathe act and john lewis's voting right act not just covet relief um so we'll be able to take a stab at austerity as well if we can get more bills on the floor um but it's really all on the ballot on george on on january 5th so link will be in the chat and it will be in the follow-up email to join our deep canvas calls into georgia to talk to georgians about everything that's at stake to debunk the deficit myth if they're concerned about that and to make sure we get coveted relief passed and win the majority and next what i want to pitch is that this is night isn't just a one-time thing we're really building a cohort of organizers who will explicitly organize around debunking the deficit myth and advocating for public spending and so we're going to meet every other week starting sunday the 20th where we'll debrief this call and this training tonight and if you can't join sunday there's going to be a google form that'll add to the event and you can just sign up there so we know you're interested um and we also have more covent teaching trainings coming up including a discussion on the federal jobs guarantee so those are all on the mobilized and lastly we talked about uh money today and unfortunately we can't get the federal reserve to credit people's actions account so we can send all the texts and make all the calls we have to fundraise so join the holiday fundraising party or you can give right now and all the money will go to conversations that are transforming america so thank you everyone so much for coming tonight i hope you either join our organizing cohort uh meet with us sunday join our calls into georgia um and join our fundraising party over the holidays so thank you so much for joining thank you to professor kelton for being with us tonight thank you to our moderators in the chat sharing information and kicking out anyone doing troll-like things and thank you to catherine for making sure all of the tech and organizationally everything went smoothly so thank you everyone we'll see you soon we'll be following up with an email with all of the extra questions that we didn't get to touch on throughout this event um writing up responses to those and making sure to include all the links to the events that i just talked about so thank you everyone happy to be doing this work with you all to debunk the def sigma [Music] [Music] me [Music] [Music] me [Music] 英語 (自動生成)

0 件のコメント:

コメントを投稿