2018/10/12ケルトン Pelosi's "Big Idea" Trashed By Bernie's Economist Stephanie Kelton
The Jimmy Dore Show
D:
so let me just so a lot of people think that oh my god we have this 21 trillion dollar deficit and that we're gonna we have to pay that back with our taxes but that's not really true right?
Kelton:
no it's not it's not true at all like i'm sitting at my husband's desk he happens to have a post-it note pad here so can i like let's just say that i'm the government and i'm gonna spend two two dollars two billion whatever we want to call these i'm just put these into the economy.
so here they go i'm handing them to you you're the economy now you have these two i spent them in but i'm going to take one back from you and i'm going to call that a tax.
so i collected this one back it's gone but you still have this one okay so i'm running a deficit i put two in i take one out it's my deficit but you're sitting holding this and this is your surplus now this is the money i spent into the economy and didn't tax back okay this is your dollar.
but now i'm going to borrow this dollar from you so i'm going to get a different color paper called a treasury bond and i'm going to take this from you and i'm going to give you this so now you have blue instead of orange that's me borrowing from you.
okay but the the money to buy the treasury bond came from the government spending the money to buy this came from the fact that i gave you this so i'm providing both the money that you use to pay your taxes and the money you use to buy bonds from me.
D:
多くの人が、21兆ドルの赤字を抱えていて、それを税金で返さなければならないと思っていますが、実際にはそうではありませんよね?
ケルトン :
私は夫の机に座っていますが、夫はたまたまここに付箋紙を持っていました。そこで、私が政府だと仮定して、22億ドルを使います。
これをあなたにお渡しします。あなたは経済人です。私が使った2つのお金をあなたは持っていますが、私はあなたから1つ取り返します。
私はこの1つを回収し、それはなくなってしまいましたが、あなたはまだこの1つを持っています。つまり、私は赤字を出しており、私は2つを投入し、1つを取り出しました。
私はこのドルをあなたから借りようと思い、国庫債券という色の違う紙を手に入れて、これをあなたから受け取り、これをあなたに渡します。
でも、国債を買うお金は政府が出したもので、これを買うお金は私があなたに渡したものですから、あなたが税金を払うのに使うお金と、私から国債を買うのに使うお金の両方を提供していることになります。
…
Kelton:
25:07 yeah the budget should reflect the priorities and so yes that's correct if your priorities that the democrats swept in presumably they would write a budget that looks quite different from the one the republicans would write. they would put more resources in education and infrastructure and these sorts of things medicaid food stamps you know whatever and and so and take some money out of defense or other areas of the budget so there'd be some shuffling but there would also maybe even be some augmenting um in total so they're saying to the agencies they're saying look we've just authorized all this spending go start spending into the economy and all of it's going in but some of it just starts coming back automatically because people pay their taxes so the government is collecting some of what it spent that's gone right when you collect it back you don't need it anymore you just throw it away so now i've collected your tax i took it out i can i can always spend new money back in. but the taxes go out and at the end of whatever period we're measuring like a fiscal year there will be a difference between how much was spent in and how much came back and we tossed it out the difference is either the surplus or the deficit so if we're putting more into the economy then we're taxing back out the government is running a deficit which means people end up holding some extra of these and because the government requires itself to borrow whenever it runs a deficit it starts swapping these for these so now they go they go like this right so it's all kind of happening in real time all the time it's not in sort of on day one this and on day two it's always all happening at the same time but at the end of the fiscal year we net it all out and we figure out how much more did we put into the economy than we took out. and we label it a deficit but you know what jimmy when we do that when when congressional budget office and the wall street journal and all these publications when they report he government's budget deficit they're looking at the situation they're telling the story from the perspective of the government the government's finances were in deficit but they never tell the story from the perspective of the economy the not government part of the story so if instead of a headline reading government uh deficits projected to go from 800 billion to a trillion next year instead the headline could read government i'm sorry non-government surpluses projected to go from 800 billion to a trillion next year and we'd all go right on you know like that would put it that would chill people out.
ケルトン
25:07 予算は優先事項を反映したものでなければなりません。その通り、もし民主党が優先事項を採用した場合、共和党が作成する予算とは全く異なるものになるでしょう。教育やインフラ、医療費やフードスタンプなどに多くの資源を投入し、国防費や他の予算分野から資金を削減するでしょう。つまり、多少の入れ替えはあっても、多少の増強はあるでしょう。国民は税金を払っているので、政府は使った分の一部を回収していますが、回収してももう必要ないので捨ててしまいます。しかし、税金は出て行きます。会計年度のような測定期間の終わりには、使った金額と戻ってきた金額の間に差が生じます。政府が赤字を出しているということは、人々が余計なものを持っているということです。政府は赤字を出すたびに借金をしなければならないので、これらと交換し始め、今ではこのようになっています。しかし、年度末にはすべてを差し引きして、経済に投入した量が、排出した量よりもどれだけ多いかを計算します。そして、それを赤字と呼ぶのです。しかし、ジミー、議会予算局やウォール・ストリート・ジャーナルなどが政府の財政赤字を報告するとき、彼らは状況を見て、政府の視点から話をしています。政府の財政は赤字でしたが、経済の視点から話をすることはありません。 来年は政府の黒字が8000億円から1兆円になると予測されている、というような見出しにすれば、みんなが納得して、人々を冷静にさせることができるでしょう。
www.DeepL.com/Translator(無料版)で翻訳しました。
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
2018/10/12ケルトン
MMT with Stephanie Kelton on The Jimmy Dore Show
welcome to the jimmy door show we have very special guest with us today her name is stephanie kelton she's a professor of public policy and economics at stony brook university she's also chief economist on the 2015 u.s senate budget committee for the minority party staff and an economic advisor to bernie sanders 2016 presidential campaign she founded the new economic perspectives blog and is a leading proponent of modern monetary theory politico named her one of the 50 thinkers doers and visionaries transforming american politics in 2016. welcome stephanie kelton thanks for being here thank you for having me all right so i i know what trickle down economics is right so that's what what um what ronald reagan brought us to in the united states which was if you give more money to the richest people in the country they'll spend so much it will trick it'll trickle down sir may i have a trickle just a little it sounds horrible and it is and that's why we're uh but before that we were doing um a version of keynesian economics if i'm correct so you can correct me that's why you're here but that's like demand side it's like what fdr did he put money in the pockets of workers and so then they went out and spent it and i was always told that was a demand economy how am i doing so far you're doing well oh okay so now there is housing grade okay so now there is a new theory um coming along and it's called modern monetary theory and uh it's it really it shifts it turns your head upside down on how people have normally come to think about economics because people still even though we're not on the gold standard people still think like we are and we still act like we are so if you can explain what i'm talking about how about that?
Kelton:
yeah so i mean there is there definitely is a big divide in terms of the way different economists approach you know how government can be influential in the economy um you talked about trickle-down economics this is you said trace back to ronald reagan that is for sure correct so the idea being that the tax cuts go mostly to the so-called job creators so you have to skew the benefits to the people that we most revere the people who will go out and do the big spending into the economy hire workers and give that big boost.
keynesians tend to be i think associated more with big government spending but you could be a keynesian and also be in favor of tax cuts but you would want to see tax cuts that are skewed like you said to the people who you could put more money in their pockets and they'll go out and spend and a tax cut would be just fine thing to do if you were putting more money in the hands of the pockets of the people who are the real job creators and in our economy the real job creators are the american consumers because that's where most of the demand comes from i said it it's you it's me it's regular old people who make less than a million dollars a year and spend virtually everything.
they get so if you give an extra um you know bit of money to those folks they're gonna turn around and spend virtually all of it back into the economy creating demand for the goods and services that our businesses produce they get swamped with customers their revenues go up their profits go up and lo and behold they decide i better hire some more people i need to invest some more because i'm swamped with demand for my stuff so that's a pretty keynesian way to do it it's just i think we've come to believe um over time that republicans are always the party that favors tax cuts and democrats are always the party that favors more government spending and mmt kind of comes in and says actually both would work provided that um you're spending on things that will materially boost economic activity they're not boondoggle projects you're doing good types of spending into the economy providing things that people actually value and that will lead to some job creation and if you want to do some tax cuts as well that's okay too but make sure the tax cuts go where they'll do the most good in the economy and that means to the people who will turn around and spend virtually everything and not turn around and pad their 401ks buy more real estate buy more shares of stock and the like.
D:
so what modern modern interior mm-hmm what modern monetary theory. i think hinges on or the kind of way people are need to start thinking about this in a different different way is that the budget of your house is much different than the budget of a government that prints prints its own currency. right and so go can you explain the difference?
Keton:
yeah so that's why the federal government could afford to do both to spend more into the economy and also provide some additional tax cuts if it wants to sort of create more jobs and see more activity because unlike a household it can spend more and take in less at the same time and still end up all right. whereas if you and i went around doing that time after time oh i'm going to take fewer hours this week i'm not going to work as much i'm going to let my hours fall and my income will go down and oh by the way i'm going to spend more as well. we'd run into real problems but because the federal government isn't like a household it isn't like a city like detroit it's not like puerto rico it's not like the state of kansas. the federal government is where the money comes from so because you know and everybody actually deep down in their core they know this everyone knows that the that congress has the power of the purse we use the term the power of the purse and somehow we just sort of don't connect the dots and come to fully appreciate what that means which is that they can never run out of money and we can.
D:
so people don't really uh understand it's hard for me to wrap my mind around it too that since the government the united states government prints our own currency that's why we can deficit spend when we go into a recession unlike countries like greece right so greece right now and is in trouble because when their economy tanks they can't spend deficit spend to boost the economy because they don't print their own money they're on the euro so when they want to deficit spend they actually have to borrow the money that they actually have to pay back whereas the united states just prints the money now that's going to blow a lot of people's minds right?
Kelton:
so yeah it does tend to blow a lot of people's minds and not only does greece have to go out and borrow the euro which is a foreign currency effectively for the country of greece now but they have to borrow the euro on the terms that are set by capital markets right so the the bond vigilantes that people sometimes worry about those people who finance the greek government when they need to borrow can demand higher and higher interest rates and say listen you're greece i don't know if you're gonna be able to pay me back or not so if i'm gonna lend you money i need six seven eight percent i mean this is what happened in in the uh debt crisis during the debt crisis right and interest rates are going up double digits and and in the us on the other hand the u.s is spending its own currency into the economy taxing some of it back and then voluntarily choosing to swap out some of the money it's spent into the economy for these treasury bonds and we label that borrowing and we say somehow you know this is going to be a problem no the government doesn't even have to do that it's borrowing its own currency back and it can set the terms at which it borrows in other words we have our own central bank so we could have the federal reserve say we're not going to let the government borrow at rates in excess of two percent ever we did that historically we had something in the 1950s and 40s called the treasury fed accord and we just instructed the central bank to serve the people we said your job is to maintain interest rates at certain low rates so that governments were able to borrow the money not drive up interest rates and so forth so completely different game for the united states compared to greece.
D:
so let me just so a lot of people think that oh my god we have this 21 trillion dollar deficit and that we're gonna we have to pay that back with our taxes but that's not really true right?
Kelton:
no it's not it's not true at all like i'm sitting at my husband's desk he happens to have a post-it note pad here so can i like let's just say that i'm the government and i'm gonna spend two two dollars two billion whatever we want to call these i'm just put these into the economy so here they go i'm handing them to you you're the economy now you have these two i spent them in but i'm going to take one back from you and i'm going to call that a tax so i collected this one back it's gone but you still have this one okay so i'm running a deficit i put two in i take one out it's my deficit but you're sitting holding this and this is your surplus now this is the money i spent into the economy and didn't tax back okay this is your dollar but now i'm going to borrow this dollar from you so i'm going to get a different color paper called a treasury bond and i'm going to take this from you and i'm going to give you this so now you have blue instead of orange that's me borrowing from you okay but the the money to buy the treasury bond came from the government spending the money to buy this came from the fact that i gave you this so i'm providing both the money that you use to pay your taxes and the money you use to buy bonds from me.
D:
so yes yes i i'm i'm you know i the more i listen to you the more i'm following this here there's one more thing i want to add so the point is that we since we print our own money that deficits don't really necessarily matter and that the only thing you really have to be careful of is that you don't print too much money because then let's say that the economy is already humming at it's like a peak exp if you put more money in then that'll make inflation happen right and so that's what you need to be careful of so let me show here's ellen greenspan you you actually like to show this video clip during your talk so i got it and i'm gonna play it here and you can explain it to people what he's saying so he's being uh questioned by paul ryan and paul ryan is trying to get him to admit that uh social security is a bad idea and that uh we should have private savings for social security instead of this public idea and so uh he's gonna say he he's trying to get uh greenspan to admit that yes social security could run out of money and that's why we have to do it this way but he doesn't actually go along with paul ryan and i'm going to play it right now for our people here we go let's watch this so having personal retirement accounts is another way of making a future retiree benefits more secure for their retirement and also do you believe that personal retirement accounts as a component to a system of solvency does help improve solvency because when you have a personal retirement account policy it's a company with a benefit offset with that feature in place do you believe that personal retirement accounts can help us achieve solvency for the system and make those future retiree benefits more secure well i wouldn't say that the pay-as-you-go benefits are insecure in the sense that there's nothing to prevent the federal government from creating as much money as it wants and paying it to somebody the question is okay so i'm going to stop it there okay so he says so greenspan says no there's really no danger of pay as you go meaning social security right that's what you mean there's no danger of it running out of money because the united states government can print as much money as it wants and then give it to anybody it wants he just said that which kind of blows paul ryan out of the room right uh yeah i think it drained all of the color out of paul ryan's face as soon as he said it yes it was a great moment so then he goes on so so that's alan greenstep and admitting kind of your economic theory he's kind of admitting what you and other people are are pushing now modern monetary theory or you're working on i don't say pushing but you're working on now um so he's kind of admitting that the basis of what your modern monetary theory is is actually correct so so a couple of things it's so he knows it's not a theory he was the chairman of the federal reserve the guy knows where the money comes from right so he knows it's a reality and not only that he this guy follows iran this is a true believer libertarian you know i mean this this is a guy who would very much like that not to be the case in a sense that there were real hard constraints on government's ability to do more for the economy and so in a way it drives him crazy that this is the case but he's under oath and to his credit he gives an honest answer so okay so that's fat tax you're right he does know how it works so now he's going to go and and so now he's going to go on and ex and explain more and i don't know a thing what he's talking about but i'm sure you will and you can tell us what he means so here's what he says next after that how do you set up a system which assures that the real assets are created which those benefits are employed to purchase so it's not a question of security it's a question of the structure of a financial system which assures that the real resources are created for retirement as distinct from the cash the cash itself is nice to have but it's got to be in the context of the real resources being created at the time those benefits are paid so that you can purchase real resources with the benefits which of course are cash so i don't know what he's talking about can you tell me what he means but it seems to still upset paul ryan so that's got to be good so what is he saying that was crystal clear jimmy i have no idea but i think that was the biggest word salad yeah yeah so but so here's what he said so let's go back the first thing he does is take the affordability question off the table right he says there's absolutely nothing to prevent the federal government from caring for every future retiree the disabled and their dependents as promised in full on time for the rest of eternity nothing to stop us from doing that so we've completely put that aside then he goes on to make what is the really important point and the point that i wish we were debating instead of what we always end up debating the really important point he's raising is this greenspan knows demographics are changing in this country baby boomers are moving into retirement leaving behind fewer and fewer people to produce the stuff that all of us will continue to buy so boomers will retire they won't make stuff but they'll still want to buy stuff and greenspan says the question is how do you set up a system which assures that the real assets the real stuff is getting produced in the economy are available how do we make sure that we're going to have a productive enough economy in 5 10 20 30 years so that when those checks go out people can spend that money into the economy without wait for it shortages and inflation if there's not enough stuff if we're not a productive enough economy then we're going to have the old problem of too much money chasing too few goods and it's as simple as that so that's what he was saying so he's saying that yeah we can always make sure the cash payments go to the people that that's no problem the problem is are there going to be is there going to be stuff being produced in our economy for them to go by and if there's not enough stuff a surplus of stuff then that's going to create shortages which will create hyperinflation that he's saying that's the same right is that what he's saying exactly so if he were if we were listening to alan greenspan on this we would be having a fierce debate in this country not about cutting people's benefits and reforming social security which is just code for cutting benefits and focusing on the the the pay for how are we going to afford it we can't afford it it's the money problem it's the money problem it's not a money problem it's a productivity problem and we could fix it we could address it if we were having a fierce debate about whether republicans or democrats or whomever has the best plan who's got the best economic plan to make us a more productive um economy going forward who wants to invest in infrastructure and education and r d and make the case that these are the things that do more to boost long-term growth and productivity for an economy than anything else the republicans will say hogwash it's tax cuts and deregulation but that's their story they're sticking with it but at least we would be debating the right thing which is how to how to have a healthy economy a healthy productive economy well it's obvious that the republicans only pay lip service to the deficit right.
so uh what even dick cheney famously said was quoted as saying deficit reagan proved deficits don't matter because ronald reagan was supposed to be a fiscal conservative but he exploded the deficit and…
17:56
Kelton:
nothing bad happened and that's why cheney said that they don't matter in the sense that they bring about armageddon.
you know when when when we first uh you know when hamilton first said we're going to buy up some state debts and we're going to have a national debt there was no national debt before hamilton did that so we have a small national debt. and of course over time 500 billion becomes a trillion and all the hair is on fire and everybody's saying this is the worst thing in the world it's unsustainable and then a little bit of time passes and it's two and a half then it's five then it's seven everybody's hair on fire then you know obama comes in and we go from seven to 11 to now 15 to 20 to 21 and everybody all along continues to say the end is near this is unsustainable and nothing bad happens.
right inflation stays right around the fed's two percent target interest rates go wherever the fed tells them to go it's like you know what what is what are we upset about you know.
D:
so which also proves your theory that since nothing bad has happened since ronald reagan started exploding deficits it's kind of proving your theory right?
Kelton:
well if you're if you mean that it's proving that there's not this tipping point that the harvard economists a few years ago persuaded most of the policy-making world that if um countries allow their debt ratio their debt relative to their gdp if they allow that ratio to get at 90 percent and higher that that's where the vulnerability sets in and countries that allow their debt to get up to 90 percent of their gdp reach a tipping point and then you tip over and slow growth and all these bad sorts of things happen well you know look at japan. japan is sort of the perfect example with a debt to gdp ratio today of about 240 percent their debt is near a quadrillion i don't know how many zeros i do actually but that's a lot of zeros a quadrillion in debt and they got no inflation and interest rates below one percent and life goes on.
D:
wait a minute how are did you what is it is that a real number add three yeah add three zeros to a trillion and you get a quadrillion so uh to a high yeah so from 100 trillion the next zero up is a quadrillion so their debt is exponentially larger than our debt well but it's that's not dollar denominated that's yen denominated but yeah in yen they're at about a closing in on a quadrillion okay all right so now here's a couple other things that i need explained so when we say that the government borrows money now you already kind of explained that before with the blue and the orange post-it so they don't actually go to a so they don't for instance we just decided to spend 80 billion dollars more on our military budget now the secretary treasury doesn't call up jamie dimon and said i need 80 billion dollars that's not he doesn't borrow it from a bank per se right they issue what they call treasury bonds and what it is is people buy those as investments they're just a bond right and then they can and then they can cash them in later for the interest that it is accrued that's how the government borrows is my correct well i mean yeah there there's a dealer market there are certain banks that participate in the in the auctions they're dealers and so when the government holds an auction sells bonds there are dealers that are required to bid and in fact you have guaranteed buyers for the bonds because they're required to bid for them what the fed does so so that you have you have your own treasury and you have your own central bank and the treasury and the central bank coordinate behind the scenes and they make sure that every that bond auctions don't fail that treasury checks don't bounce and so forth so we talked about this a little bit before about how it's not like when you and i go to finance a car or make a purchase we go out and find somebody who's willing to extend credit to us and then we pre-arrange the financing and then we have the money and then we go out and spend the government is already spending the money into the economy and what's happening in the background after the authorization to spend all that money has been given is these agencies the treasury and the fed are working it out to make sure the payment's always clear that's that's kind of amazing that's actually kind of amazing um well it's it's reassuring too because the last thing we'd want are a bunch of you know government employees checks bouncing and yeah yeah well here's the second question to that though so if we print our own currency currency why do we even have to do the treasury bond thing why don't we just print it so i i that it's a good question i'm not sure i have a good answer we're just sort of trapped in uh the habit of doing it i mean we've been doing it this way for so long and i think that probably the answer has a lot to do with the fact that um the people who buy these are the financiers i mean treasuries uh are a nice way to get a a little bit of a free ride right you get a subsidy from the government they give you interest for holding blue instead of orange and they don't have to volunteer to do that but you know people some people will say oh it's the poor fixed income the savers living on their fixed incomes we have to get interest rates up because grandma is getting punished when the fed keeps interest rates so low and so what we really want to do is look out for the poor saver who's trying to get by on a on a fixed income you know she spot all these treasuries well okay there are some people out there yes who hold treasures but the vast majority of these things are held by the very very wealthy okay all right so that clears that up for me so now if alan greenspan understands how this works so let me uh alright so let me i'm going to try to explain how the budget actually works and then you correct me where i'm wrong so the legislators get together and they decide spending priorities right now one of our spending priorities is 715 billion dollars for military budget that nobody in the country actually wants except you know the one percent who are stockholders and you know those defense contractor companies so they they write a budget they have all this we're going to spend this much on medicare this much on medicaid this much on um the pentagon budget this much on infrastructure so they just and they just decide and then they don't wait for the financing like you said the financing is just automatic because the banks are have to have to give us the money and what we have to give them back is interest on that money but that we print anyway so am i close is that close to so what what what a budget really should reflect is our priorities and right now it's not it's it's reflecting a false priority that we have to do some kind of belt tightening correct yeah the budget should reflect the priorities and so yes that's correct if your priorities that the democrats swept in presumably they would write a a budget that looks quite different from the one the republicans would write they would put more resources in education and infrastructure and these sorts of things medicaid food stamps you know whatever and and so and take some money out of defense or other areas of the budget so there'd be some shuffling but there would also maybe even be some augmenting um in total so they're saying to to the agencies they're saying look we've just authorized all this spending go start spending into the economy and all of it's going in but some of it just starts coming back automatically because people pay their taxes so the government is collecting some of what it spent that's gone right when you collect it back you don't need it anymore you just throw it away so now i've collected your tax i took it out i can i can always spend new money back in but the taxes go out and at the end of whatever period we're measuring like a fiscal year there will be a difference between how much was spent in and how much came back and we tossed it out the difference is either the surplus or the deficit so if we're putting more into the economy then we're taxing back out the government is running a deficit which means people end up holding some extra of these and because the government requires itself to borrow whenever it runs a deficit it starts swapping these for these so now they go they go like this right so it's all kind of happening in real time all the time it's not in sort of on day one this and on day two it's always all happening at the same time but at the end of the fiscal year we net it all out and we figure out how much more did we put into the economy than we took out and we label it a deficit but you know what jimmy when we do that when when congressional budget office and the wall street journal and all these publications when they report the government's budget deficit they're looking at the situation they're telling the story from the perspective of the government the government's finances were in deficit but they never tell the story from the perspective of the economy the not government part of the story so if instead of a headline reading government uh deficits projected to go from 800 billion to a trillion next year instead the headline could read government i'm sorry non-government surpluses projected to go from 800 billion to a trillion next year and we'd all go right on you know like that would put it that would chill people out so it sounds like the whole monetary system is it is really kind of based on an agreement that we all like it's not really based on anything real it's kind of just based on we agree that this is what this is worth and how stuff is going to work but is that i mean am i crazy to say something like that or is there any truth to what i just said well it's based on the fact that you know the government has the power to make and enforce the tax laws in our country and so we're all subject to the government's tax laws so it turns out that these things they're spending into the economy are needed by us you know we keep thinking the government needs our money to do xyz the government doesn't need our money we need their money right the the tax is imposed by them on us so we got to earn these things somehow in order to pay our taxes and it's because they very kindly normally put more of these things into the economy than they take out that we're able to walk around with some extra that we're able to hold on to some of these and accumulate them and hold them as part of our savings so if the government just decided no more of that behavior right we're just running surpluses from now on they would just be sucking the green paper i'm sorry orange paper out faster than they put it in and our balances would all start dwindling down so okay there's one more thing i want you to tell people how this works so when we loaned money to the banks when they went uh when we had the stock market crash and the banks went belly up and they're too big to fail meaning if these banks go out of business it will hurt our economy so much that the reverberations would be too painful for us to bear so the government's just going to go ahead and give them whatever amount of money it takes to make them whole right that's the idea well i'll go with that that's a that's a fair enough okay but the way they give them the money is so they they give them the money they lend them they print money lend it to the bank the bank then takes that money we've lent it and then buys treasuries from the united states government which they get interest on and so they use that interest to pay off the loan that they got from us is that correct it's kind of beautiful i mean yeah so a lot of things happened uh to deal with the way that the the fed um and the government dealt with the situation after the financial crisis but yeah we had a bunch of stuff that was um fancifully called quantitative easing where the fed you know if you like hit the print key a lot and bought up treasuries and mortgage-backed securities from the banks taking those off their balance sheets giving them effectively cash instead paying them interest on their excess reserve balances which is just a way of topping up banks um balances with additional monies and so yes it more or less works the way you just described so that to me and correct me if i'm wrong that's why you're here to me that sounds like a scam well you say scam they say liquidity infusion i mean you know uh it it is it is a way of injecting cash onto balance sheets of institutions perceived worthwhile worthy and needy yeah but this is why people say things like you know when when some of these candidates have been asked lately how are you going to pay for this how are you going to pay for this you have this big progressive agenda some of these candidates have started saying well we didn't have any problem finding you know trillions of dollars when the banks needed to be bailed out i don't know if you saw um you know with the 10 year anniversary of lehman there were a lot of pieces written and published in the last few days and uh matt taibbi has a really good one in rolling stone and he goes back through some of the estimates you know just how much did the fed end up intervening like what dollar amount do we put on that and the highest estimate that's been um provided by the levy economics institute in research was 29 trillion that there when they looked at it they say the fed gave as much as right intervene to the tune of 29 trillion you go okay if we can do that surely we can do something for veterans something for infrastructure something for hungry kids yeah so when barack obama instructs you know goes along with the quantitative easing giving uh the banks 29 trillion dollars and then turns around and literally does a pay freeze for federal employees saying that they we have to pay for this that's bad economic thinking right oh for sure yeah i mean there were you know and now there are debates everybody's sort of going back and and looking at how policymakers responded to the great uh recession and and a lot of people i think are trying to do some revisionist um history here and and trying to sort of reshape the role that they played in the whole thing and say oh we really tried to do more for homeowners oh we really tried to do more in terms of the stimulus yeah so there's a lot of that going on.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
ジミードアショーへようこそ。今日は特別ゲストがいます。彼女の名前はステファニーケルトンです。彼女はストーニーブルック大学の公共政策と経済学の教授であり、2015年の米国上院議員予算委員会のチーフエコノミストでもあります。バーニーサンダース2016年大統領選挙の顧問彼女は新しい経済展望ブログを設立し、現代貨幣理論の主要な支持者であり、2016年にアメリカの政治を変革する50人の思想家と先見者の1人に彼女を指名しました。ステファニーケルトンを歓迎しますここにいてくれてありがとう私を大丈夫にしているので、経済学のトリクルダウンが正しいことを知っているので、ロナルド・リーガンが米国で私たちにもたらしたのは、国で最も裕福な人々にもっとお金を与えた場合でした。お金をかけすぎて騙されて騙されてしまうかもしれません少し騙されているかもしれませんそれは恐ろしいように聞こえますそしてそれが私たちがええとそういう理由です正しいのであなたは私を訂正することができますそれがあなたがここにいる理由ですしかしそれは需要側のようなものですそれは彼が労働者のポケットにお金を入れたのと同じですそしてそれから彼らは出て行ってそれを使いました私はこれまでのところうまくやっていますかあなたは大丈夫です今は住宅グレードがあります今は新しい理論がやって来ていますそしてそれは現代貨幣理論と呼ばれていますそしてそれは本当にそれがシフトしてあなたの頭を逆さまにします人々は通常、経済学について考えるようになりました。金本位制ではない人々はまだ私たちのように考えており、私たちはまだ私たちのように行動しているので、私が話していることを説明できれば、それはどうですか?
ケルトン:
ええ、つまり、トリクルダウン経済学について話したように、政府が経済にどのように影響を与えることができるかを知っているさまざまなエコノミストのアプローチ方法に関しては、間違いなく大きな隔たりがあるということです。減税は主にいわゆる雇用創出者に行われるという考えは確かに正しいので、外出して経済に多額の支出をする人々を最も尊敬する人々への利益を歪めなければなりません。その大きな後押しを与えます。
ケインズ派は政府の多額の支出に関連していると思う傾向がありますが、ケインズ派であり、減税にも賛成する可能性がありますが、より多くのお金を投入できる人々に言ったように、減税が歪曲されているのを見たいと思いますあなたが本当の雇用創出者であり、私たちの経済では本当の雇用創出者である人々のポケットの手にもっとお金を入れていれば、彼らのポケットと彼らは出て行って使うでしょうそして減税はちょうど良いことですアメリカの消費者です。なぜなら、需要のほとんどがそこから来るからです。私が言ったのは、年に100万ドル未満を稼ぎ、事実上すべてを費やしているのは私です。
彼らはそうなるので、あなたがそれらの人々に少しのお金を与えると、彼らは振り返り、実質的にすべてを経済に戻し、私たちのビジネスが生み出す商品やサービスの需要を生み出し、彼らは顧客でいっぱいになります収入が増えて利益が上がっていくのを見て、彼らは私がもっと多くの人を雇うほうがいいと決めているのを見ます。私は自分のものの需要に溢れているので、もっと投資する必要があります。共和党は常に減税を支持する政党であり、民主党は常により多くの政府支出を支持する政党であり、mmtのようなものが入ってくると信じるようになり、実際には両方がうまくいくと言っています。彼らの経済活動を大幅に後押しします」人々が実際に評価し、雇用創出につながるものを提供するために、経済に良いタイプの支出をしているプロジェクトを後押ししないでください。減税も行いたい場合は、それでも構いませんが、減税が確実に行われるようにしてください。彼らが経済で最も良いことをする場所、つまり、振り返って事実上すべてを費やし、振り返って401ksを埋めない人々にとって、より多くの不動産を購入し、より多くの株式を購入するなどです。経済で最も良いことをするでしょう、そしてそれは、向きを変えて事実上すべてを使い、振り返って401ksを埋めない人々にとって、より多くの不動産を購入し、より多くの株を購入するなどを意味します。経済で最も良いことをするでしょう、そしてそれは、向きを変えて事実上すべてを使い、振り返って401ksを埋めない人々にとって、より多くの不動産を購入し、より多くの株を購入するなどを意味します。
NS:
だから、どのような現代の現代のインテリアmm-うーん、どのような現代の貨幣理論。私は、人々がこれについて別の方法で考え始める必要があるかどうかにかかっていると思います。あなたの家の予算は、自国通貨を印刷する政府の予算とは大きく異なるということです。そうですね、違いを説明できますか?
Keton:
そういうわけで、連邦政府は、家計とは異なり、より多くの支出とより少ない摂取を行うことができるため、より多くの雇用を創出し、より多くの活動を見たい場合は、経済により多くを費やすために、またいくつかの追加の減税を提供するために両方を行う余裕があります同時に、それでも大丈夫になります。一方、あなたと私が何度も何度もそのことをやっていたとしたら、今週はもっと少ない時間しかかからないでしょう。私はあまり仕事をしません。私の時間を減らして収入が減ります。私ももっと使うつもりです。私たちは本当の問題にぶつかるでしょうが、連邦政府は家庭のようではないので、デトロイトのような都市のようではなく、プエルトリコのようでもありません。カンザス州のようでもありません。
NS:
ですから、人々は私がそれについて頭を悩ませることが難しいことを本当に理解していません。ギリシャのような国とは異なり、米国政府は自国通貨を印刷しているので、不況に陥ったときに支出が不足する可能性があります。彼らの経済が戦うとき、彼らは自分のお金を印刷しないので経済を後押しするために赤字支出を使うことができないので、彼らはユーロにいるので、彼らが赤字支出をしたいとき、彼らは実際に借りなければなりません。彼らが実際に返済しなければならないお金に対して、米国は今、多くの人々の心を吹き飛ばすであろうお金を印刷するだけですよね?
ケルトン:
そうそう、それは多くの人々の心を吹き飛ばす傾向があり、ギリシャは外に出て、現在ギリシャの国にとって効果的に外貨であるユーロを借りなければならないだけでなく、設定された条件でユーロを借りなければなりません資本市場によって正しいので、借りる必要があるときにギリシャ政府に資金を提供する人々について人々が時々心配する債券警戒は、ますます高い金利を要求し、あなたがギリシャだと聞いてあなたが行くかどうかわからないと言うことができます私に返済できるかどうかわからないので、私があなたにお金を貸すつもりなら、私は6、7、8パーセントが必要です。つまり、これは債務危機の権利の間にええと債務危機で起こったことであり、金利は二桁上昇しています。一方、私たちでは、u。sは自国通貨を経済に費やし、その一部に課税し、経済に費やしたお金の一部をこれらの国債と交換することを自主的に選択しています。問題は、政府が自国通貨を借り戻すことすらする必要がなく、借りる条件を設定できるということです。言い換えれば、私たちには独自の中央銀行があるので、連邦準備制度に私たちのことを言わせることができます。歴史的に1950年代と40年代に財務準備制度と呼ばれるものがあり、中央銀行にあなたの仕事は政府が金利を引き上げずにお金を借りることができるように、特定の低金利で金利を維持するなど、米国にとってギリシャとはまったく異なるゲームです。
NS:
ですから、多くの人が、この21兆ドルの赤字があり、税金でそれを返済しなければならないと思っているのですが、それは本当ではありませんか?
ケルトン:
いいえ、そうではありません。私が夫の机に座っているように、彼はたまたまここにポストイットのメモ帳を持っているので、私は政府であり、2ドルを費やすつもりだと言ってみましょう。私たちがこれらと呼びたいものは何でも20億私はこれらを経済に入れているのでここに行きます私はあなたにそれらを渡しますあなたは経済です今あなたは私がそれらを使ったこれらの2つを持っていますが私は1つを取るつもりですあなたから戻ってきて、私はそれを税金と呼ぶつもりなので、私はこれを集めましたそれはなくなっていますが、あなたはまだこれを持っているので私は赤字を実行しています私は2つ入れます私は1つを取り出しますそれは私の赤字ですがあなたはこれを持って座って、これはあなたの余剰です今これは私が経済に費やしたお金であり、課税しませんでしたこれはあなたのドルですが今私はmあなたからこのドルを借りるつもりなので、国債と呼ばれる別の色の紙を手に入れます。これをあなたから受け取ります。これを渡すので、オレンジではなく青になります。それは私があなたから借りているのですが、国債を買うお金は政府がこれを買うために使うお金から来ました私があなたにこれを与えたという事実から来たので私はあなたがあなたの税金を支払うために使うお金とあなたが私から債券を買うために使うお金。私はあなたから借りても大丈夫ですが、国債を買うお金は政府がこれを買うために使うお金から来ました私があなたにこれを与えたという事実から来たので私はあなたがあなたの税金を支払うために使うお金とあなたが私から債券を買うために使うお金。私はあなたから借りても大丈夫ですが、国債を買うお金は政府がこれを買うために使うお金から来ました私があなたにこれを与えたという事実から来たので私はあなたがあなたの税金を支払うために使うお金とあなたが私から債券を買うために使うお金。
NS:
だからはいはい私はあなたが知っている私はあなたに耳を傾けるほど私はこれをフォローしている私はここにもう1つ追加したいことがあります必ずしも重要ではなく、本当に注意しなければならないのは、あまりお金を印刷しないことだけです。それなら、経済がすでにハミングしているとしましょう。それからもっとお金を入れれば、ピーク経験のようです。それはインフレを正しく起こさせるでしょう、そしてそれはあなたが注意する必要があることですそれで私はあなたがあなたの話の間にこのビデオクリップを実際に見せたいと思っているエレングリーンスパンをここに見せましょう彼が言っていることを人々に説明できるので彼はポール・ライアンに質問され、ポール・ライアンは、社会保障は悪い考えであり、この公的な考えの代わりに社会保障のために私的貯蓄をするべきだと彼に認めさせようとしているので、彼は彼がしようとしていると言うつもりですはい、社会保障がお金を使い果たす可能性があることを認めるためにええとグリーンスパンを得るために、それが私たちがこのようにしなければならない理由ですが、彼は実際にはポールライアンと一緒にいません、そして私は今ここで私たちの人々のためにそれをするつもりですこれを見てみましょう。個人の退職金口座を持つことは、将来の退職者の退職後の給付をより安全にするもう1つの方法です。また、ソルベンシーシステムのコンポーネントとしての個人の退職金口座は、ソルベンシーの向上に役立つと思いますか。個人年金口座ポリシーそれ」その機能で利益が相殺されている会社は、個人の退職金口座がシステムのソルベンシーを達成し、将来の退職者の利益をより安全にするのに役立つと思いますか?従量制の利益とは言えません連邦政府が望むだけのお金を生み出し、誰かにそれを支払うことを妨げるものは何もないという意味で安全ではないので、私はそれをそこで止めます。社会保障の権利を意味するあなたが行くにつれて支払う危険性それはあなたがそこに意味することです」米国政府は好きなだけお金を印刷して、好きな人にそれを渡すことができるので、お金がなくなる危険はありません。彼がそう言ったとたんにポール・ライアンの顔からすべての色を排出しましたそれは素晴らしい瞬間だったので彼は続けますそれはアラン・グリーンステップであり、あなたと他の人々が何であるかを認めているようなあなたの経済理論を認めています今現代貨幣理論を推し進めている、またはあなたが取り組んでいる私は推し進めているとは言いませんが、あなたは今取り組んでいるので、彼はあなたの現代貨幣理論が実際に正しいことを認めているので、いくつかのことがありますだから彼はそれを知っている」彼が連邦準備制度理事会の議長だったという理論ではないので、彼はお金がどこから来るのかを知っているので、それが現実であることを知っています、そして彼がイランに従うだけでなく、これはあなたが知っている真の信者のリバータリアンです政府が経済のためにより多くのことをする能力に本当に厳しい制約があったという意味でそうではないことを非常に望んでいる男は、ある意味で彼を夢中にさせますが、彼は誓いを立てています彼の信用彼は正直な答えを与えるので大丈夫ですそれはあなたが正しい脂肪税です彼はそれがどのように機能するかを知っているので今彼は行くつもりですそして今彼は続けて元に行きそしてもっと説明するつもりですそして私は知りません彼が話していることですが、きっとあなたはそうするでしょう、そしてあなたは彼が何を意味するのかを私たちに伝えることができますので、ここで」sその後、彼が言うことは、実際の資産が作成され、それらの利益が購入に使用されることを保証するシステムをどのように設定するので、セキュリティの問題ではなく、金融システムの構造の問題であり、現金自体が持っているのが良い現金とは異なり、実際のリソースは退職のために作成されますが、実際のリソースを購入できるように、それらの利益が支払われるときに作成される実際のリソースのコンテキストにある必要があります。もちろん現金なので、彼が何を言っているのかわかりませんが、彼が何を意味するのか教えてもらえますが、それでもポール・ライアンを動揺させているようです。私はそれがサラダの最大の言葉だったと思います彼が言ったことは、彼が最初に行うことは、手頃な価格の質問をテーブルから外すことです。彼は、連邦政府が将来のすべての退職者とその扶養家族を完全に時間通りに約束したように世話するのを妨げるものは絶対にないと言います。永遠の残りの部分は私たちがそれをするのを妨げるものではないので、私たちはそれを完全に脇に置いて、彼は本当に重要なポイントと私たちがいつも本当に議論することになるのではなく、私たちが議論したいと思っているポイントを作り続けます彼が提起している重要な点は、このグリーンスパンは、この国で人口統計が変化していることを知っているということです。
'まだ物を買いたいと思うでしょう、そしてグリーンスパンは問題は、経済で実際のものが生産されている実際の資産が利用可能であることを保証するシステムをどのように設定するかです。
5 10 20
30年で十分な経済があり、それらのチェックが出たときに、人々はそのお金を経済に費やすことができます。お金が多すぎて商品が少なすぎるという古い問題があり、それはそれと同じくらい簡単なので、彼はそう言っていたので、そうだと彼は言っています。問題はありません問題は、私たちの経済で彼らが通り過ぎるために生産されているものがあるだろうということです、そして十分なものがない場合は余剰のものが不足を引き起こし、それは彼が言っているハイパーインフレーションを生み出すでしょうそれは同じ権利です。彼が言っていることは、もし私たちがこれについてアラン・グリーンスパンを聞いていたら、人々の利益を削減し、利益を削減するための単なるコードである社会保障を改革することについてではなく、この国で激しい議論をするでしょう。どのように私たちがそれを買うことができるかについての支払いに焦点を当てる私たちはそれを買う余裕がないそれはお金の問題ですそれはお金の問題ですそれはお金の問題ではありませんそれは生産性の問題を修正することができます。共和党か民主党か、または投資を希望する将来のより生産的な経済を実現するための最良の経済計画を持っている人が誰であるかについて激しい議論をしている場合は、それに対処できます。インフラストラクチャーと教育とrdで、これらは経済の長期的な成長と生産性を高めるために何よりも多くのことをしていると主張します。それで、少なくとも私たちは、健全な経済を健全な生産的経済にする方法について正しいことを議論するでしょう。共和党は赤字の権利に対してのみリップサービスを支払うことは明らかであるため、ディック・チェイニーでさえ有名に言ったことは、ロナルド・リーガンは財政的に保守的であるはずだったので、赤字は問題ではないことを証明したと述べたと引用されましたが、彼は赤字を爆発させ、何もしませんでした悪いことが起こったので、チェイニーは、彼らがアルマゲドンをもたらすという意味では問題ではないと言ったのです。国の債務を抱えるハミルトンがそれを行う前は国の債務はなかったので、私たちは小さな国の債務を抱えており、もちろん時間の経過とともに5000億が1兆になり、すべての髪が燃えています。
'持続不可能で少し時間が経ち、2年半、5年、7人、みんなの髪の毛が燃えている、オバマが入ってくるのを知っている、7から11、今は15、20、21、そしてみんな終わりが近づいていると言い続けていますこれは持続不可能であり、悪いことは何も起こりません正しいインフレはFRBの2%の目標金利の周りにとどまりますまた、ロナルド・レーガンが赤字を爆発させ始めて以来、悪いことは何も起こらなかったので、あなたがそれがそこにあることを証明していることを意味するのであれば、それはあなたの理論を正しく証明しているようなものであるというあなたの理論を証明します数年前にハーバードエコノミストが政策決定の世界のほとんどを説得したのはこの転換点ではありません。債務がgdpの最大90%に達することを可能にする脆弱性が設定され、国が転換点に達した後、転倒して成長を遅らせると、これらすべての悪い種類のことがよく起こります。今日の負債とgdpの比率が約240%である完璧な例では、彼らの負債は4兆近くになります。実際にゼロをいくつ実行するかはわかりませんが、それは
'たくさんのゼロが1兆ドルの借金を抱えていて、インフレも金利も1%未満でなく、人生は1分待っています。実際の数は3を追加し、1兆に3つのゼロを追加するとどうなりますか。数兆から高いええ、100兆から次のゼロまでは数兆なので、彼らの債務は私たちの債務よりも指数関数的に大きくなりますが、それはドル建てではなく、円建てですが、円で言えば、彼らはほぼ終わりに近づいています兆で大丈夫ですので、ここで私が説明する必要がある他のいくつかのことを説明します。政府がお金を借りていると言うとき、あなたはすでに以前に青とオレンジのポストでそれを説明したので、実際には行きませんにそう彼らはしません」たとえば、私たちは軍事予算にさらに800億ドルを費やすことに決めました。今、国務長官はジェイミーダイモンを呼び出さず、800億ドルが必要だと言いましたが、彼は銀行自体からそれを借りていません。彼らが国債と呼んでいるもの、そしてそれが何であるかというと、人々はそれらを投資として購入するのです。彼らはただの債券であり、それから彼らはそれが発生するという利益のために後でそれらを現金化することができます。つまり、ディーラー市場があり、彼らがディーラーであるオークションに参加している特定の銀行があります。したがって、政府が債券を販売するオークションを開催する場合、入札する必要のあるディーラーがあり、実際には、彼らはあなたがあなた自身の財務を持ち、あなたがあなた自身の中央銀行を持ち、財務と中央銀行が舞台裏で調整し、彼らがすべての債券オークションが行わないようにするために、連邦政府が行うことを彼らに入札する必要があります財務チェックがバウンスしないなどの失敗があったので、これについて少し前に話しましたが、あなたと私が車の資金を調達したり購入したりするときは、外出してクレジットを提供してくれる人を見つけます。私たちそしてそれから私達は資金調達を事前に手配しそしてそれから私達はお金を手に入れそしてそれから私達は出て行ってそして政府はすでにそのお金を経済に使っているそしてそのお金をすべて使う許可が与えられた後のバックグラウンドで何が起こっているかこれらの機関は、財務省と連邦政府が支払いを確実にするためにそれを解決しています」私たちが最後に望んでいるのは、公務員がバウンスをチェックしていることを知っていることです。私たちは自分の通貨を印刷しますなぜ私たちは国債のことをしなければならないのですかなぜ私たちはそれを印刷しないのですかええと、それをする習慣は私たちが意味する長い間このようにしてきましたが、おそらく答えは、これらを購入する人々が金融業者であるという事実と関係があると思います。つまり、財務省は、少しだけ無料で取得するための良い方法です。右に乗ると、政府から補助金がもらえます。彼らはオレンジの代わりに青を保持することに関心を持っており、そうすることを志願する必要はありません。連邦準備制度が金利を非常に低く維持しているときにおばあちゃんが罰せられるので、私たちが金利を上げなければならない収入です。債券でうまくやっていくと、彼女はこれらすべての宝物をうまく見つけていることを知っています。宝物を持っている人もいますが、これらのものの大部分は非常に裕福な人によって保持されています。アラン・グリーンスパンがこれがどのように機能するかを理解しているなら、私は大丈夫です。予算が実際にどのように機能するかを説明しようと思います。それから、私が間違っているところを訂正して、立法者が集まり、彼らは今、支出の優先順位を決定します。私たちの支出の優先順位の1つは、国の誰もが実際に望んでいない軍事予算の7150億ドルです。これは私たちですメディケアにこれだけ費やすつもりですこれだけメディケアにこれだけ多くのペンタゴン予算をインフラストラクチャに費やすので、彼らはただ決定し、あなたが言ったように資金調達を待つことはありません銀行は私たちにお金を与えなければならず、私たちが彼らに返済しなければならないのはそのお金への関心ですが、とにかく私たちが印刷するので私はそれに近いので、予算が実際に反映すべきものは私たちの優先順位と権利です今では、ある種のベルト締めを正しく行わなければならないという誤った優先順位を反映しているのではありません。そうです、予算は優先順位を反映する必要があります。そうです」民主党員が一掃したあなたの優先順位が、おそらく共和党員が書いたものとはかなり異なるように見える予算を書くなら、彼らは教育とインフラストラクチャにもっと多くのリソースを投入し、あなたが知っているメディケイドフードスタンプなどのようなものは正しいです防衛や予算の他の領域からいくらかのお金を取り、シャッフルが発生する可能性がありますが、合計でいくつかの拡張umが存在する可能性もあるので、彼らは私たちがちょうど見ているように見えると言っている機関に言っていますこのすべての支出を承認すると、経済への支出が始まり、すべてが入りますが、人々が税金を支払うため、一部は自動的に戻ってくるので、政府は支出したものの一部を集めています。
'もう必要ないので、捨てるだけなので、税金を徴収しました。取り出しました。いつでも新しいお金を使うことができますが、税金はなくなり、会計年度のように測定している期間の終わりに年は、費やされた金額と戻ってきた金額の間に違いがあり、その違いは黒字か赤字のどちらかであると私たちはそれを捨てました。は赤字を出しているので、人々はこれらの余分なものを持ってしまうことになります。政府は赤字を出すたびに借りることを要求しているので、これらをこれらと交換し始めます。いつも1日目と2日目はそうではありません」常にすべてが同時に起こっていますが、会計年度末に私たちはそれをすべて相殺し、私たちが取り出したよりもどれだけ多くを経済に投入したかを把握し、それを赤字とラベル付けしますが、あなたはいつジミーなのか知っています議会の予算局とウォールストリートジャーナル、そしてこれらすべての出版物が政府の財政赤字を報告するとき、彼らが政府の観点から物語を語っている状況を見ているとき、私たちはそれをしますが、政府の財政は赤字でしたが彼らは経済の観点から物語を語ることは決してないので、政府を読む見出しの代わりに、赤字が来年8000億から1兆に達すると予測された場合、見出しは政府を読むことができます。申し訳ありませんが、非政府の黒字は来年8000億から1兆に達すると予測されています。それは人々を冷やすものになるので、通貨システム全体が本当に親切であるように思えます。私たち全員が好きな合意に基づいているのは、実際には何にも基づいていないということです。これは、これが価値があり、どのように機能するかということに同意するだけですが、私は次のようなことを言うのは夢中ですそれとも、私が今言ったことに真実はありますか?それは、政府が私たちの国の税法を制定し施行する力を持っていることをあなたが知っているという事実に基づいています、そしてそれで私たちは皆政府の税法の対象となりますこれらのことを彼らは経済への再支出は私たちによって必要とされていますあなたは私たちが政府がxyzをするために私たちのお金を必要としていると考え続けていることを知っています政府は私たちのお金を必要としません私たちは彼らのお金を必要としますどういうわけか私たちの税金を支払うためのものであり、それは彼らが非常に親切に通常これらのものの多くを彼らが取り出すよりも経済に投入するので、私たちがこれらのいくつかを保持することができるいくつかの余分なものを持って歩き回ることができますそしてそれらを蓄積し、私たちの貯蓄の一部として保持するので、政府がその行動をこれ以上正しく決定しなかった場合、私たちはこれから余剰を実行しているだけです彼らはただ緑色の紙を吸うでしょうそれを入れると、私たちの残高はすべて減少し始めるので、大丈夫です」もう1つ、これがどのように機能するかを人々に伝えてほしいのです。銀行にお金を貸したとき、銀行が暴落し、銀行が腹を立てて、銀行が大きすぎて、これらの銀行が意味を失ったとき、廃業すると経済に大きな打撃を与えるので、反響は耐えられないほど痛いので、政府は先に進んで、彼らを完全に正しくするために必要な金額を彼らに与えるつもりです。それは私がよく考えていることです。それはそれで十分大丈夫ですが、彼らが彼らにお金を与える方法は、彼らが彼らに貸すお金を与えるので、彼らは彼らにお金を印刷し、銀行にそれを貸し、そして私たちがそのお金を取ります」それを貸して、それから彼らが興味を持っている米国政府から国債を買うので、彼らは私たちから得たローンを返済するためにその利子を使うのは正しいです」ある種の美しいということは、そうですね。金融危機後の連邦準備制度と政府の対応方法に対処するために多くのことが起こりましたが、量的緩和と呼ばれるものがたくさんありました。連邦準備制度は、印刷キーを何度も押して、銀行から国庫やモーゲージ担保証券を購入し、それらをバランスシートから外して、超過準備残高の利子を支払う代わりに、効果的に現金を提供していることを知っています。銀行に追加の金銭を追加することで、多かれ少なかれあなたが説明したように機能するので、私が間違っている場合は私に訂正してください。それがあなたの理由です。詐欺のように聞こえますが、詐欺とは言いますが、流動性注入と言います。つまり、価値があり、困窮していると認識されている機関のバランスシートに現金を注入する方法です。しかし、これが人々が物事を言う理由です。最近、これらの候補者の一部がこれにどのように支払うのかを尋ねられたとき、あなたはこれにどのように支払うのかを知っているように、あなたはこの大きな進歩的な議題を持っていますこれらの候補者の一部は問題がなかったとよく言い始めました銀行を救済する必要があったときに何兆ドルも知っていることを私は知りません」リーマンの10周年を記念して、ここ数日でたくさんの作品が書かれ、出版されたのを見たことがありますか。マット・タイービはローリングストーンで本当に優れた作品を持っています。彼はいくつかの見積もりを振り返ります。あなたは、FRBがどれだけ介入することになったのかを知っています。レビー・エコノミックス・インスティテュートが研究で提供したのは29兆でした。彼らがそれを見ると、FRBは29兆の調子に十分な介入を与えたと彼らは言っています。ベテランのためにインフラストラクチャのために何か空腹の子供のためにそうそうそうバラクオバマがあなたに指示するときあなたは銀行に29兆ドルを与える量的緩和と一緒に行くことを知っていますこれは悪い経済的思考です確かにそうですあなたが知っていたということですそして今はみんなの議論があります」ある種の過去に戻って、政策立案者が大不況にどのように対応したかを見て、そして私が思う多くの人々はここでいくつかの修正主義の歴史をやろうとしていて、彼らが全体で果たした役割を再形成しようとしていますそして、ああ、私たちは本当に住宅所有者のためにもっとやろうとしたと言います。ああ、私たちは本当に刺激の観点からもっとやろうとしたので、それはたくさん起こっています。
00:00
welcome to the jimmy door show we have
00:01
very special guest with us today her
00:03
name is stephanie kelton she's a
00:04
professor of public policy and economics
00:07
at stony brook university she's also
00:09
chief economist on the 2015 u.s senate
00:12
budget committee for the minority party
00:14
staff and an economic advisor to bernie
00:16
sanders 2016 presidential campaign she
00:19
founded the new economic perspectives
00:21
blog and is a leading proponent of
00:24
modern monetary theory politico named
00:26
her one of the 50 thinkers doers and
00:29
visionaries transforming american
00:31
politics in 2016. welcome stephanie
00:34
kelton thanks for being here
00:36
thank you for having me all right so
00:39
i
00:40
i know what trickle down economics is
00:42
right so that's what what um
00:45
what ronald reagan brought us to in the
00:47
united states which was if you give more
00:50
money to the richest people in the
00:51
country
00:52
they'll spend so much it will trick
00:54
it'll trickle down sir may i have a
00:55
trickle just a little it sounds horrible
00:58
and it is and that's why we're uh but
01:00
before that we were doing um
01:02
a version of keynesian economics if i'm
01:05
correct so you can correct me that's why
01:06
you're here but that's like demand side
01:08
it's like what fdr did he put money in
01:10
the pockets of workers and so then they
01:12
went out and spent it
01:14
and i was always told that was a demand
01:15
economy how am i doing so far
01:18
you're doing well oh okay
01:20
so now
01:22
there is housing grade okay so now there
01:24
is a new theory um
01:27
coming along and it's called modern
01:28
monetary theory
01:30
and
01:31
uh it's it really
01:33
it shifts it turns your head upside down
01:36
on how people have normally
01:38
come to think about economics
01:40
because people still even though we're
01:42
not on the gold standard
01:44
people still think like we are and we
01:46
still act like we are so if you can
01:48
explain
01:50
what i'm talking about how about
01:52
that yeah so i mean there is there
01:55
definitely is a big divide in terms of
01:58
the way different economists approach
02:01
you know how government can be
02:03
influential in the economy um you talked
02:05
about trickle-down economics this is you
02:08
said trace back to ronald reagan that is
02:10
for sure correct so the idea being that
02:12
the tax cuts go mostly to the so-called
02:15
job creators so you have to skew the
02:18
benefits to the people that we most
02:20
revere the people who will go out and do
02:22
the big spending into the economy hire
02:24
workers and give that big boost
02:26
keynesians
02:28
tend to be i think associated more with
02:30
big government spending but you could be
02:33
a keynesian and also be in favor of tax
02:36
cuts but you would want to see tax cuts
02:38
that are skewed like you said to the
02:40
people who you could put more money in
02:42
their pockets and they'll go out and
02:44
spend and a tax cut would be just fine
02:46
thing to do
02:47
if you were putting more money in the
02:49
hands of the pockets of the people who
02:51
are the real job creators and in our
02:53
economy the real job creators are the
02:55
american consumers because that's where
02:58
most of the demand comes from i said it
03:00
it's you it's me it's regular old people
03:04
who make less than a million dollars a
03:08
year and spend virtually everything they
03:10
get so if you give an extra um you know
03:13
bit of money to those folks they're
03:15
gonna turn around and spend virtually
03:17
all of it back into the economy creating
03:19
demand for the goods and services that
03:21
our businesses produce they get swamped
03:23
with customers their revenues go up
03:25
their profits go up and lo and behold
03:27
they decide i better hire some more
03:28
people i need to invest some more
03:30
because i'm swamped with demand for my
03:32
stuff so that's a pretty keynesian way
03:35
to do it it's just i think we've come to
03:36
believe
03:38
um over time that republicans are always
03:40
the party that favors tax cuts and
03:42
democrats are always the party that
03:44
favors more government spending and mmt
03:47
kind of comes in and says actually both
03:49
would work provided that um you're
03:52
spending on things that will materially
03:55
boost economic activity they're not
03:57
boondoggle projects you're doing good
04:00
types of spending into the economy
04:02
providing things that people actually
04:04
value and that will lead to some job
04:06
creation and if you want to do some tax
04:08
cuts as well that's okay too but make
04:10
sure the tax cuts go where they'll do
04:12
the most good in the economy and that
04:14
means to the people who will turn around
04:16
and spend virtually everything and not
04:18
turn around and pad their 401ks buy more
04:20
real estate buy more shares of stock and
04:22
the like
04:23
so
04:24
what modern modern interior mm-hmm what
04:27
modern monetary theory i think hinges on
04:29
or the kind of way people are need to
04:32
start thinking about this in a different
04:33
different way
04:34
is that the budget of your house is much
04:37
different than the budget of a
04:38
government that prints prints its own
04:40
currency
04:41
right and so
04:42
go can you explain the difference
04:44
yeah so that's why the federal
04:46
government could afford to do both to
04:48
spend more into the economy and also
04:51
provide some additional tax cuts if it
04:53
wants to sort of create more jobs and
04:56
see more activity because unlike a
04:58
household it can spend more and take in
05:01
less at the same time and still end up
05:03
all right whereas if you and i went
05:05
around doing that time after time oh i'm
05:07
going to take fewer hours this week i'm
05:09
not going to work as much i'm going to
05:10
let my hours fall and my income will go
05:12
down and oh by the way i'm going to
05:13
spend more as well we'd run into real
05:16
problems but because the federal
05:18
government isn't like a household it
05:20
isn't like a city like detroit it's not
05:23
like puerto rico it's not like the state
05:25
of kansas the federal government is
05:28
where the money comes from so because
05:31
you know and everybody actually deep
05:33
down in their core they know this
05:35
everyone knows
05:37
that the that congress has the power of
05:39
the purse we use the term the power of
05:41
the purse and somehow we just sort of
05:44
don't connect the dots and come to fully
05:46
appreciate what that means which is that
05:49
they can never run out of money and we
05:51
can so people don't really uh understand
05:54
it's hard for me to wrap my mind around
05:55
it too
05:57
that since the government the united
05:59
states government prints our own
06:00
currency that's why we can deficit spend
06:03
when we go into a recession unlike
06:06
countries like greece right so greece
06:08
right now and is in trouble because when
06:10
their economy tanks they can't spend
06:13
deficit spend to boost the economy
06:16
because they don't print their own money
06:17
they're on the euro so when they want to
06:20
deficit spend they actually have to
06:22
borrow the money that they actually have
06:23
to pay back whereas the united states
06:26
just prints the money now
06:29
that's going to blow a lot of people's
06:30
minds right
06:31
so yeah it does tend to blow a lot of
06:34
people's minds and not only does greece
06:35
have to go out and borrow the euro which
06:38
is a foreign currency effectively for
06:41
the country of greece now but they have
06:43
to borrow the euro on the terms that are
06:46
set by capital markets right so the the
06:50
bond vigilantes that people sometimes
06:52
worry about those people who finance the
06:54
greek government when they need to
06:56
borrow can demand higher and higher
06:58
interest rates and say listen you're
07:00
greece i don't know if you're gonna be
07:02
able to pay me back or not so if i'm
07:04
gonna lend you money i need six seven
07:06
eight percent i mean this is what
07:08
happened in in the uh debt crisis during
07:10
the debt crisis right and interest rates
07:12
are going up double digits and and in
07:14
the us on the other hand the u.s is
07:17
spending its own currency into the
07:19
economy taxing some of it back and then
07:22
voluntarily
07:24
choosing to swap out some of the money
07:26
it's spent into the economy for these
07:28
treasury bonds and we label that
07:30
borrowing and we say somehow you know
07:33
this is going to be a problem no the
07:35
government doesn't even have to do that
07:36
it's borrowing its own currency back and
07:38
it can set the terms at which it borrows
07:41
in other words we have our own central
07:43
bank so we could have the federal
07:45
reserve say we're not going to let the
07:47
government borrow at rates in excess of
07:49
two percent ever we did that
07:51
historically we had something in the
07:53
1950s and 40s called the treasury fed
07:55
accord and we just instructed the
07:57
central bank to serve the people we said
07:59
your job is to maintain interest rates
08:02
at certain low rates so that governments
08:05
were able to borrow the money not drive
08:07
up interest rates and so forth so
08:10
completely different game for the united
08:12
states compared to greece so let me just
08:15
so a lot of people think that oh my god
08:17
we have this 21 trillion dollar deficit
08:20
and that we're gonna we have to pay that
08:22
back with our taxes but that's not
08:24
really true right
08:27
no it's not it's not true at all like
08:29
i'm sitting at my husband's desk he
08:31
happens to have a post-it note pad here
08:33
so can i like let's just say that i'm
08:36
the government and i'm gonna spend two
08:40
two dollars two billion whatever we want
08:42
to call these i'm just put these into
08:43
the economy so here they go i'm handing
08:46
them to you you're the economy now you
08:48
have these two i spent them in but i'm
08:50
going to take one back from you and i'm
08:52
going to call that a tax so i collected
08:54
this one back it's gone but you still
08:56
have this one okay so i'm running a
08:58
deficit i put two in i take one out it's
09:02
my deficit but you're sitting holding
09:04
this and this is your surplus
09:06
now this is the money i spent into the
09:09
economy and didn't tax back okay this is
09:12
your dollar but now i'm going to borrow
09:15
this dollar from you so i'm going to get
09:17
a different color paper called a
09:19
treasury bond and i'm going to take this
09:21
from you
09:23
and i'm going to give you this so now
09:24
you have blue instead of orange that's
09:27
me borrowing from you okay but the the
09:30
money to buy the treasury bond
09:32
came from the government spending the
09:35
money to buy this
09:36
came from the fact that i gave you
09:38
this so i'm providing both the money
09:41
that you use to pay your taxes and the
09:44
money you use to buy bonds from me
09:47
so
09:49
yes
09:50
yes i i'm i'm you know i the more i
09:53
listen to you the more i'm following
09:55
this here there's one more thing i want
09:56
to add so
09:58
the point is that
10:00
we since we print our own
10:02
money that deficits don't really
10:05
necessarily matter
10:07
and that the only thing you really have
10:09
to be careful of
10:11
is that you don't print too much money
10:14
because then
10:15
let's say that the economy is already
10:17
humming at it's like a peak exp
10:19
if you put more money in then
10:22
that'll make inflation happen
10:24
right
10:25
and so that's what you need to be
10:26
careful of so let me show here's ellen
10:29
greenspan you you actually
10:31
like to show this video clip during your
10:33
talk so i got it and i'm gonna play it
10:35
here and you can explain it to people
10:37
what he's saying so he's being uh
10:39
questioned by paul ryan
10:42
and paul ryan is trying to get him to
10:44
admit that uh social security is a bad
10:46
idea
10:47
and that uh we should have private
10:49
savings for social security instead of
10:51
this public idea and so uh he's gonna
10:54
say he he's trying to get
10:56
uh greenspan to admit that yes social
10:58
security could run out of money and
11:00
that's why we have to do it this way but
11:01
he doesn't actually go along with paul
11:03
ryan and i'm going to play it right now
11:05
for our people here we go let's watch
11:06
this so
11:07
having personal retirement accounts is
11:09
another way of making a future retiree
11:12
benefits more secure for their
11:14
retirement
11:15
and also do you believe that personal
11:17
retirement accounts as a component to a
11:19
system of solvency does help improve
11:22
solvency because when you have a
11:23
personal retirement account policy it's
11:25
a company with a benefit offset with
11:27
that feature in place do you believe
11:29
that personal retirement accounts can
11:30
help us achieve solvency for the system
11:32
and make those future retiree benefits
11:34
more secure well i wouldn't say that the
11:39
pay-as-you-go benefits are insecure in
11:42
the sense that
11:46
there's nothing to prevent the federal
11:48
government from creating as much money
11:49
as it wants and paying it to somebody
11:51
the question is
11:53
okay so i'm going to stop it there
11:55
okay so he says so greenspan says no
11:57
there's really no danger of pay as you
12:00
go meaning social security right that's
12:01
what you mean there's no danger of it
12:03
running out of money because the united
12:05
states government can print as much
12:06
money as it wants and then give it to
12:08
anybody it wants he just said that which
12:10
kind of blows paul ryan out of the room
12:12
right
12:13
uh yeah i think it drained all of the
12:15
color out of paul ryan's face as soon as
12:17
he said it yes it was a great moment so
12:20
then he goes on so so that's alan
12:22
greenstep and admitting
12:24
kind of your economic theory he's kind
12:27
of admitting what you and other people
12:29
are are pushing now modern monetary
12:32
theory or you're working on i don't say
12:34
pushing but you're working on now
12:36
um so he's kind of admitting that the
12:39
basis of what your modern monetary
12:41
theory is is actually correct
12:43
so so a couple of things it's so he
12:46
knows it's not a theory he was the
12:48
chairman of the federal reserve the guy
12:50
knows where the money comes from right
12:52
so he knows it's a reality and not only
12:54
that he this guy follows iran this is a
12:57
true believer libertarian you know i
13:00
mean this this is a guy who would very
13:03
much like that not to be the case in a
13:05
sense that there were real hard
13:07
constraints on government's ability to
13:09
do more for the economy and so in a way
13:12
it drives him crazy that this is the
13:14
case but he's under oath and to his
13:17
credit he gives an honest answer
13:19
so okay so that's fat tax you're right
13:22
he does know how it works
13:26
so now
13:27
he's going to go and and
13:30
so now he's going to go on and ex and
13:32
explain more and i don't know a thing
13:36
what he's talking about but i'm sure you
13:37
will and you can tell us what he means
13:39
so here's what he says next after that
13:42
how do you set up a system which assures
13:45
that the real assets
13:48
are created which those benefits
13:52
are employed to purchase
13:54
so it's not a question of security it's
13:57
a question of the structure
13:59
of a financial system which assures that
14:02
the real resources
14:04
are created for retirement
14:07
as distinct from the cash the cash
14:09
itself
14:10
is nice to have
14:12
but
14:13
it's got to be in the context of the
14:16
real resources
14:17
being
14:18
created
14:19
at the time
14:21
those benefits are paid so that you can
14:24
purchase real resources
14:26
with the benefits which of course are
14:28
cash so i don't know what he's talking
14:31
about can you tell me what he means but
14:33
it seems to still upset paul ryan so
14:35
that's got to be good so what is he
14:37
saying
14:38
that was crystal clear jimmy i have no
14:40
idea
14:43
but i think that was the biggest word
14:45
salad yeah
14:46
yeah so but so here's what he said so
14:49
let's go back the first thing he does is
14:51
take the affordability question off the
14:53
table right he says there's absolutely
14:56
nothing to prevent the federal
14:57
government from caring for every future
15:00
retiree the disabled and their
15:01
dependents
15:02
as promised in full on time for the rest
15:05
of eternity nothing to stop us from
15:07
doing that so we've completely put that
15:09
aside then he goes on to make what is
15:11
the really important point and the point
15:13
that i wish we were debating instead of
15:15
what we always end up debating the
15:17
really important point he's raising is
15:19
this
15:20
greenspan knows demographics are
15:22
changing in this country baby boomers
15:24
are moving into retirement leaving
15:26
behind fewer and fewer people to produce
15:28
the stuff that all of us will continue
15:31
to buy so boomers will retire they won't
15:33
make stuff but they'll still want to buy
15:35
stuff and greenspan says the question is
15:38
how do you set up a system which assures
15:40
that the real assets the real stuff is
15:43
getting produced in the economy are
15:45
available how do we make sure that we're
15:47
going to have a productive enough
15:49
economy in 5 10 20 30 years so that when
15:53
those checks go out people can spend
15:55
that money into the economy without wait
15:58
for it
15:59
shortages and inflation if there's not
16:01
enough stuff if we're not a productive
16:03
enough economy then we're going to have
16:05
the old problem of too much money
16:07
chasing too few goods and it's as simple
16:09
as that
16:10
so that's what he was saying so he's
16:12
saying that yeah we can always make sure
16:15
the cash payments go to the people that
16:17
that's no problem the problem is are
16:20
there going to be is there going to be
16:22
stuff being produced in our economy for
16:24
them to go by and if there's not enough
16:26
stuff a surplus of stuff then that's
16:28
going to create shortages which will
16:30
create hyperinflation that he's saying
16:33
that's the same right is that what he's
16:34
saying exactly so if he were if we were
16:37
listening to alan greenspan on this we
16:39
would be having a fierce debate in this
16:41
country not about cutting people's
16:44
benefits and reforming social security
16:46
which is just code for cutting benefits
16:48
and focusing on the the the pay for how
16:51
are we going to afford it we can't
16:52
afford it it's the money problem it's
16:53
the money problem it's not a money
16:54
problem it's a productivity problem and
16:57
we could fix it we could address it if
16:59
we were having a fierce debate about
17:01
whether republicans or democrats or
17:03
whomever has the best plan who's got the
17:06
best economic plan to make us a more
17:08
productive um economy going forward who
17:11
wants to invest in infrastructure and
17:13
education and r d and make the case that
17:16
these are the things that do more to
17:17
boost long-term growth and productivity
17:19
for an economy than anything else the
17:21
republicans will say hogwash it's tax
17:24
cuts and deregulation but that's their
17:26
story they're sticking with it but at
17:27
least we would be debating the right
17:30
thing which is how to how to have a
17:32
healthy economy a healthy productive
17:34
economy
17:35
well
17:37
it's obvious that the republicans only
17:40
pay lip service to the deficit
17:42
right so
17:44
uh what even dick cheney famously said
17:46
was quoted as saying deficit reagan
17:48
proved deficits don't matter because
17:51
ronald reagan was supposed to be a
17:52
fiscal conservative but he exploded the
17:54
deficit and nothing bad happened and
17:57
that's why cheney said that they don't
18:00
matter in the sense that they bring
18:01
about armageddon you know when when when
18:04
we first uh you know
18:06
when hamilton first said we're going to
18:08
buy up some state debts and we're going
18:10
to have a national debt there was no
18:12
national debt before hamilton did that
18:14
so we have a small national debt and of
18:16
course over time 500 billion becomes a
18:19
trillion and all the hair is on fire and
18:22
everybody's saying this is the worst
18:23
thing in the world it's unsustainable
18:25
and then a little bit of time passes and
18:26
it's two and a half then it's five then
18:28
it's seven everybody's hair on fire then
18:31
you know obama comes in and we go from
18:33
seven to 11 to now 15 to 20 to 21 and
18:37
everybody all along continues to say the
18:39
end is near this is unsustainable and
18:42
nothing bad happens right inflation
18:44
stays right around the fed's two percent
18:46
target interest rates go wherever the
18:48
fed tells them to go it's like you know
18:51
what what is what are we upset about you
18:53
know
18:54
so
18:55
which also proves your theory that
18:59
since nothing bad has happened since
19:01
ronald reagan started exploding deficits
19:04
it's kind of proving your theory right
19:07
well if you're if you mean that it's
19:09
proving that there's not this tipping
19:12
point that the harvard economists a few
19:14
years ago persuaded most of the
19:16
policy-making world that if um countries
19:19
allow their debt ratio their debt
19:21
relative to their gdp if they allow that
19:23
ratio to get at 90 percent and higher
19:26
that that's where the vulnerability sets
19:28
in and countries that allow their debt
19:31
to get up to 90 percent of their gdp
19:33
reach a tipping point and then you tip
19:35
over and slow growth and all these bad
19:37
sorts of things happen well you know
19:39
look at japan japan is sort of the
19:41
perfect example with a debt to gdp ratio
19:44
today of about 240 percent their debt is
19:48
near a quadrillion i don't know how many
19:50
zeros i do actually but that's a lot of
19:52
zeros a quadrillion in debt and they got
19:57
no inflation and interest rates below
19:59
one percent and life goes on
20:02
wait a minute
20:04
how are did you what is it
20:06
is that a real number add three yeah add
20:08
three zeros to a trillion and you get a
20:10
quadrillion
20:12
so
20:13
uh to a high yeah so from 100 trillion
20:15
the next zero up is a quadrillion
20:18
so their debt is exponentially larger
20:21
than our debt
20:22
well but it's that's not dollar
20:24
denominated that's yen denominated but
20:26
yeah in yen they're at about a closing
20:29
in on a quadrillion okay
20:32
all right so now here's a couple other
20:33
things that i need
20:35
explained
20:36
so when we say that the government
20:38
borrows money now you already kind of
20:40
explained that before with the blue and
20:42
the orange post-it
20:45
so
20:46
they don't actually go to a so they
20:48
don't for instance we just decided to
20:50
spend 80 billion dollars more on our
20:53
military budget now the secretary
20:55
treasury doesn't call up jamie dimon and
20:57
said i need 80 billion dollars that's
20:59
not he doesn't borrow it from a bank per
21:01
se right they issue what they call
21:03
treasury bonds and what it is is people
21:05
buy those as investments they're just a
21:07
bond right and then they can and then
21:10
they can cash them in later for the
21:12
interest that it is accrued that's how
21:14
the government borrows is my correct
21:17
well i mean yeah there there's a dealer
21:19
market there are certain banks that
21:21
participate in the in the auctions
21:23
they're dealers and so when the
21:25
government holds an auction sells bonds
21:28
there are dealers that are required to
21:29
bid and in fact you have guaranteed
21:32
buyers for the bonds because they're
21:33
required to bid for them what the fed
21:36
does so so that you have you have your
21:38
own treasury and you have your own
21:40
central bank and the treasury and the
21:42
central bank coordinate behind the
21:44
scenes and they make sure that every
21:46
that bond auctions don't fail that
21:48
treasury
21:50
checks don't bounce and so forth so we
21:52
talked about this a little bit before
21:54
about how it's not like when you and i
21:56
go to finance a car or make a purchase
21:58
we go out and find somebody who's
22:00
willing to extend credit to us and then
22:02
we pre-arrange the financing and then we
22:04
have the money and then we go out and
22:05
spend the government is already spending
22:07
the money into the economy and what's
22:10
happening in the background after the
22:13
authorization to spend all that money
22:14
has been given is these agencies the
22:17
treasury and the fed are working it out
22:19
to make sure the payment's always clear
22:22
that's that's kind of amazing
22:24
that's actually kind of amazing um well
22:26
it's it's reassuring too because the
22:28
last thing we'd want are a bunch of you
22:30
know government employees checks
22:32
bouncing and yeah
22:34
yeah well here's the second question to
22:36
that though
22:37
so if we print our own currency currency
22:39
why do we even have to do the treasury
22:41
bond thing why don't we just print it
22:45
so i i
22:47
that it's a good question i'm not sure i
22:49
have a good answer we're just sort of
22:51
trapped in
22:52
uh the habit of doing it i mean we've
22:56
been doing it this way for so long and i
22:59
think that probably the answer has a lot
23:01
to do with the fact that um the people
23:04
who buy these are the financiers i mean
23:07
treasuries uh are a nice way to get a a
23:11
little bit of a free ride right you get
23:13
a subsidy from the government they give
23:14
you interest for holding blue instead of
23:18
orange and they don't have to volunteer
23:20
to do that but you know people some
23:22
people will say oh it's the poor fixed
23:25
income the savers living on their fixed
23:27
incomes we have to get interest rates up
23:29
because grandma is getting punished when
23:32
the fed keeps interest rates so low and
23:34
so what we really want to do is look out
23:36
for the poor saver who's trying to get
23:37
by on a on a fixed income you know she
23:40
spot all these treasuries well okay
23:42
there are some people out there yes who
23:44
hold treasures but the vast majority of
23:46
these things are held
23:48
by the very very wealthy okay all right
23:51
so that clears that up for me
23:53
so now if alan greenspan understands how
23:56
this works
23:58
so let me
23:59
uh
24:00
alright so let me i'm going to try to
24:02
explain how the budget actually works
24:04
and then you correct me where i'm wrong
24:06
so the legislators get together and they
24:08
decide spending priorities right now one
24:10
of our spending priorities is 715
24:13
billion dollars for military budget that
24:15
nobody in the country actually wants
24:17
except you know the one percent
24:19
who are stockholders and you know those
24:21
defense contractor companies
24:23
so they they write a budget they have
24:25
all this we're going to spend this much
24:27
on medicare this much on medicaid this
24:29
much on
24:30
um the pentagon budget this much on
24:33
infrastructure so they just and they
24:35
just decide
24:36
and then they don't wait for the
24:38
financing like you said
24:40
the financing is just automatic because
24:43
the banks are have to have to give us
24:46
the money
24:47
and what we have to give them back is
24:48
interest on that money
24:50
but that we print anyway
24:53
so
24:53
am i close is that close to so what what
24:56
what a budget really should reflect is
24:57
our priorities
24:59
and right now it's not it's it's
25:01
reflecting a false priority that we have
25:02
to do some kind of belt tightening
25:05
correct
?
Kelton:
25:07 yeah the budget should reflect the 25:09 priorities and so yes that's correct if 25:12 your priorities that the democrats swept 25:14 in presumably they would write a a 25:17 budget that looks quite different from 25:19 the one the republicans would write they 25:21 would put more resources in education 25:23 and infrastructure and these sorts of 25:25 things medicaid food stamps you know 25:28 whatever and and so and take some money 25:30 out of defense or other areas of the 25:32 budget so there'd be some shuffling but 25:34 there would also maybe even be some 25:36 augmenting um in total so they're saying 25:39 to 25:40 to the agencies they're saying look 25:42 we've just authorized all this spending 25:44 go 25:45 start spending into the economy and all 25:50 of it's going in but some of it just 25:52 starts coming back automatically because 25:54 people pay their taxes so the government 25:56 is collecting some of what it spent 25:58 that's gone right when you collect it 26:00 back you don't need it anymore you just 26:01 throw it away so now i've collected your 26:03 tax i took it out i can i can always 26:05 spend new money back in but the taxes go 26:08 out and at the end of whatever period 26:10 we're measuring like a fiscal year there 26:13 will be a difference between how much 26:15 was spent in and how much came back and 26:18 we tossed it out the difference is 26:20 either the surplus or the deficit so if 26:22 we're putting more into the economy then 26:24 we're taxing back out the government is 26:26 running a deficit which means people end 26:28 up holding some extra of these and 26:31 because the government requires itself 26:33 to borrow whenever it runs a deficit it 26:36 starts swapping these for these so now 26:40 they go they go like this right so it's 26:42 all kind of happening 26:44 in real time all the time it's not in 26:47 sort of on day one this and on day two 26:49 it's always all happening at the same 26:52 time but at the end of the fiscal year 26:54 we net it all out and we figure out how 26:57 much more did we put into the economy 26:59 than we took out and we label it a 27:00 deficit 27:02 but you know what jimmy when we do that 27:04 when when congressional budget office 27:06 and the wall street journal and all 27:08 these publications when they report 27:10 the government's budget deficit they're 27:13 looking at the situation they're telling 27:15 the story from the perspective of the 27:17 government the government's finances 27:20 were in deficit but they never tell the 27:22 story from the perspective of the 27:24 economy the not government part of the 27:27 story so if instead of a headline 27:29 reading 27:30 government uh deficits projected to go 27:33 from 800 billion to a trillion next year 27:36 instead the headline could read 27:39 government 27:40 i'm sorry 27:42 non-government 27:43 surpluses projected to go from 800 27:46 billion to a trillion next year and we'd 27:47 all go right on you know like 27:50 that would put it that would chill 27:52 people out.
ケルトン
25:07 予算は優先事項を反映させるべきで、もし25:12 優先事項が民主党に支配されていたとしたら、25:14 共和党が書く25:19 予算とは全く異なる25:17 予算を書くでしょう。 共和党は、教育25:23やインフラ、25:25のようなものに、より多くの資源を投入し、25:30には国防や他の予算分野から資金を引き上げるとしています。 25:54 人々は税金を払っているので、25:56 政府は使ったお金の一部を回収していますが、25:58 それがなくなったときには、26:00 回収してももう必要ないので、26:01 捨ててしまいます。 26:08 そして、26:10 会計年度のように測定している期間の終わりには、26:13 投入された金額と戻ってきた金額との間に差が生じ、26:18 その差が26:20 剰余金か赤字のどちらかになります。 26:26 赤字を出しているということは、人々は 26:28 結局これらの余分なものを持っていることになり、26:31 政府は赤字を出すたびに 26:33 借り入れをしなければならないので、26:36 これらのものと交換し始めるのです。 26:47 初日にこれをやって、2日目にこれをやってというようなものではなく、常にすべてが同じ26:52の時間に起こっているのですが、26:54年度末にはすべてをネットで計算し、26:57経済に投入した額が搬出した額よりもどれだけ多いかを把握し、それを27:00赤字とします。 27:08 これらの出版物が政府の財政赤字を報告するとき、彼らは27:13状況を見ていて、27:15政府の財政が赤字だったという27:17政府の観点から話をしているが、27:22経済の観点から話をすることはない27:24政府ではない27:27話の部分である。 もし、27:30 政府の赤字は27:33 来年には8000億円から1兆円になると予測 27:36 その代わりに、27:39 政府 27:40 すみません 27:42 非政府 27:43 来年の黒字は27:46 億円から1兆円になると予測 27:47 みんなで27:50のように続けていけば、27:52 人々を冷静にさせることができるでしょう。
www.DeepL.com/Translator(無料版)で翻訳しました。
D:
27:54 so 27:56 it sounds like 27:58 the whole monetary 28:00 system is it is really kind of based on 28:03 an agreement that we all 28:05 like it's not really based on anything 28:07 real it's kind of just based on we agree 28:10 that this is what this is worth and how 28:11 stuff is going to work but is that i 28:14 mean am i crazy to say something like 28:16 that or is there any truth to what i 28:17 just said 28:18 well it's based on the fact that you 28:21 know the government has the power to 28:24 make and enforce the tax laws in our 28:27 country and so we're all subject to the 28:30 government's tax laws so it turns out 28:32 that these things they're spending into 28:34 the economy 28:35 are 28:36 needed by us you know we keep thinking 28:38 the government needs our money to do xyz 28:41 the government doesn't need our money we 28:43 need their money right the the tax is 28:46 imposed by them on us so we got to earn 28:49 these things somehow in order to pay our 28:52 taxes and it's because they very kindly 28:55 normally put more of these things into 28:57 the economy than they take out that 28:59 we're able to walk around with some 29:01 extra that we're able to hold on to some 29:03 of these and accumulate them and hold 29:05 them as part of our savings so if the 29:06 government just decided no more of that 29:08 behavior right we're just running 29:10 surpluses from now on they would just be 29:12 sucking the green paper i'm sorry orange 29:15 paper out faster than they put it in and 29:18 our balances would all start dwindling 29:19 down 29:21 so okay there's one more thing i want 29:23 you to tell people how this works so 29:27 when we loaned money to the banks when 29:29 they went uh when we had the stock 29:31 market crash and the banks went belly up 29:33 and they're too big to fail meaning if 29:35 these banks go out of business it will 29:36 hurt our economy so much 29:38 that the reverberations would be too 29:40 painful for us to bear so the 29:41 government's just going to go ahead and 29:43 give them whatever amount of money it 29:45 takes to make them whole right that's 29:47 the idea 29:49 well i'll go with that that's a that's a 29:51 fair enough okay but the way they give 29:53 them the money 29:55 is so they they give them the money they 29:57 lend them they print money lend it to 29:59 the bank the bank then takes that money 30:01 we've lent it 30:02 and then buys treasuries from the united 30:05 states government which they get 30:07 interest on 30:08 and so they use that interest to pay off 30:10 the loan that they got from us 30:12 is that correct it's kind of beautiful i 30:16 mean yeah so a lot of things happened uh 30:18 to deal with the way that the the fed um 30:22 and the government dealt with the 30:23 situation after the financial crisis but 30:25 yeah we had a bunch of stuff that was um 30:28 fancifully called quantitative easing 30:30 where the fed you know if you like hit 30:32 the print key a lot and bought up 30:35 treasuries and mortgage-backed 30:37 securities from the banks taking those 30:39 off their balance sheets giving them 30:41 effectively cash instead 30:43 paying them interest on their excess 30:46 reserve balances which is just a way of 30:48 topping up banks um balances with 30:51 additional monies and so yes it more or 30:54 less works the way you just described 30:57 so that to me 30:59 and correct me if i'm wrong that's why 31:00 you're here 31:01 to me that sounds like a scam 31:07 well you say scam they say liquidity 31:10 infusion i mean 31:12 you know 31:13 uh 31:14 it it is it is a way of injecting 31:18 cash onto balance sheets of 31:20 institutions perceived 31:24 worthwhile worthy and needy yeah 31:28 but this is why people say things like 31:30 you know when when some of these 31:31 candidates have been asked lately how 31:33 are you going to pay for this how are 31:34 you going to pay for this you have this 31:35 big progressive agenda some of these 31:36 candidates have started saying well we 31:38 didn't have any problem finding you know 31:40 trillions of dollars when the banks 31:42 needed to be bailed out i don't know if 31:43 you saw um you know with the 10 year 31:46 anniversary of lehman there were a lot 31:47 of pieces written and published in the 31:50 last few days and uh matt taibbi has a 31:52 really good one in rolling stone and he 31:55 goes back through some of the estimates 31:57 you know just how much did the fed end 31:59 up intervening like what dollar amount 32:02 do we put on that and the highest 32:04 estimate that's been um provided by the 32:07 levy economics institute in research was 32:09 29 trillion that there when they looked 32:12 at it they say the fed gave as much as 32:15 right intervene to the tune of 29 32:17 trillion you go okay if we can do that 32:20 surely we can do 32:22 something for veterans something for 32:24 infrastructure something for hungry kids 32:26 yeah so when barack obama 32:30 instructs you know goes along with the 32:32 quantitative easing giving 32:34 uh the banks 29 trillion dollars and 32:36 then turns around and literally does a 32:38 pay freeze 32:39 for federal employees saying that they 32:41 we have to pay for this 32:44 that's bad economic thinking right 32:46 oh for sure yeah i mean there were you 32:49 know and now there are debates 32:50 everybody's sort of going back and and 32:52 looking at how policymakers responded to 32:55 the great uh recession and and a lot of 32:57 people i think are trying to do some 32:59 revisionist um history here and and 33:02 trying to sort of reshape the role that 33:05 they played in the whole thing and say 33:06 oh we really tried to do more for 33:08 homeowners oh we really tried to do more 33:10 in terms of the stimulus yeah 33:13 so there's a lot of that going on.
00:00ジミードアショーへようこそ00:01今日私たちと一緒に非常に特別なゲストがいます00:03名前はステファニーケルトンです彼女は00:04公共政策と経済学の教授です00:07ストーニーブルック大学で彼女も00
::
092015年のチーフエコノミスト米国上院議員00:12少数党の予算委員会00:14スタッフとバーニーの経済顧問00:16サンダース2016年大統領選挙キャンペーン彼女00:19新しい経済的展望00:21ブログを設立しました00:24現代貨幣理論の主要な支持者00:26彼女は50人の思想家の1人であり、00:29ビジョナリーは2016年にアメリカの00:31政治を変革しました。ようこそステファニー00:34ケルトンここにいてくれてありがとう00:36ありがとう00:39
i
00:40経済学のトリクルダウンが00:42正しいことを知っているので、それが何であるか00:45ロナルド・レーガンが00:47の米国で私たちにもたらしたものは、00:51の国で最も裕福な人々に00:50のお金をもっと与えると、00:52彼らは多額の費用を費やして00:54をだまします00:55トリクルダウンが少しあるかもしれませんが、それは恐ろしい00:58に聞こえます。そのため、私たちはええと、01:00前にケインズ経済学のバージョンを実行していました。もし私が01:05正しければ、あなたは私を正すことができます。だから01:06あなたはここにいますが、それは需要側のようです01:08それは彼が01:10に労働者のポケットにお金を入れたようなものです01:12出て行って、それを使いました01:14そして私はいつもそれが需要であると言われました01:15経済私はこれまでどのようにやっていますか01:18あなたは大丈夫です01:20だから今01:22があります住宅グレードは大丈夫なので、01:24は新しい理論です。27がやって来て、それは現代と呼ばれています01:28貨幣理論01:30と01:31ええとそれは本当に01:33それはシフトしますそれはあなたの頭を逆さまにします01:36人々が通常どのように経済学について考えるようになるかについて01:38
01:40私たちがまだゴールドスタンダードではないのに01:42人々はまだ私たちのように考えているので01:46私たちはまだ私たちのように行動します01:48あなたが01:50を説明することができれば私は01:52について話しているので、そうです、01:55は間違いなく01:58の点で大きな隔たりです02:01あなたは政府がどのように影響力を持つことができるか知っています02:01経済学では02:05トリクルダウン経済学について話しましたこれはあなたです02:08確かに正しい02:10であるロナルドレーガンにさかのぼると言ったので、02:12減税は主にそうなるという考えです-02と呼ばれる:15人の雇用創出者なので、02:18の利益を人々に偏らせる必要があります02:20外出して行う人々を尊敬します02:22経済への多額の支出は02:24の労働者を雇い、その大きな後押しをします02:26ケインズ派02:28は、02:30の大きな政府支出に関連していると思う傾向がありますが、02:33ケインズ派であり、減税に賛成することもできます02:36減税が見たいと思います02
:38あなたが02:42のポケットにもっとお金を入れることができる02:40の人々にあなたが言ったように歪んでいて、彼らは出て行き、02:44を費やして減税はちょうどいいでしょう02:46
02:51が本当の雇用創出者である人々のポケットの02:49の手にもっとお金を入れていたら、02:47を実行し、02:53経済では、本当の雇用創出者は02:55アメリカの消費者です。それは02:58需要のほとんどは私が言ったからです03:00それはあなたですそれはあなたですそれは私ですそれは私です03:13彼らがいる人々に少しのお金を知っている03:15振り返って、事実上すべてを03:17経済に戻し、03:19私たちの企業は彼らが圧倒される03:23顧客で彼らの収入が上がる03:25彼らの利益が上がるそして見よ03:27彼らは私がもう少し雇うほうがよいと決める03:28私はもう少し投資する必要がある03:30私は私の03:32のものに対する需要に溢れているので、それはかなりケインズ的な方法です03:35それを行うには03:36に来たと思います03:38ええと、共和党員は常に03:40減税を支持する党と03:42民主党員は常に、03:44がより多くの政府支出を支持し、mmt
03:47のようなものがやって来て、実際には両方の03:49がうまくいくと言っています。
52実質的に経済活動を後押しするものへの支出03:57あなたがうまくやっているブーンドッググルプロジェクト04:02経済への支出の種類04:02人々が実際に価値があるものを提供する04:04そしてそれ04:06の作成につながり、減税を行いたい場合は04:08の削減も問題ありませんが、04:10に、経済で最も良い04:12の減税が行われるようにします。そして、04:14は、04:16を振り返り、事実上すべてを費やし、04:18を振り返って、401ksを埋める人々にとって、04:20の不動産は、より多くの株式を購入し、04:22のような04:23だから04:24何現代の現代インテリアmm-うーん何04:27現代の貨幣理論私は04:29または人々が04:32別の方法でこれについて考え始める必要がある方法にかかっていると思います04:33別の方法04:34は、あなたの家の予算が、独自の04:40通貨を印刷する04:38政府の予算とは大幅に異なるということです。あなたは違いを説明します04:44ええそういうわけで連邦政府は04:48が経済により多くを費やすために両方をする余裕がありましたそしてまた04:53はそれが一種のことを望むなら04:51はいくつかの追加の減税を提供します04:58世帯とは異なり、より多くの支出と05:01の取り込みを同時に行うことができ、それでも05:03で終わる可能性があるため、より多くの雇用を創出し、04:56はより多くの活動を見ることができます。05何度も何度もやっているああ、私は05:07今週はもっと時間がかからないだろう05:09はあまり働かないだろう05:10は私の時間を減らして、私の収入は行くだろう05:12ダウン、ちなみに私は05:13に行くつもりですが、実際の05:16の問題に遭遇することもありますが、連邦政府は05:18政府が家庭のようではないため、05:20はそうではありません。デトロイトのような都市ではありません。プエルトリコのように05:23ではありません。カンザス州の05:25のようではありません。
33彼らの核心で彼らはこれを知っています05:35誰もが05:37その議会が05:39の力を持っていることを知っています私たちは05:41の力という用語を使用しますドットを接続せず、完全に05になります。46それが意味することを理解してください05:49彼らは決してお金を使い果たすことはできませんそして私たち05:51は人々が本当にええと理解しないようにすることができます05:54私が私の心を包むのは難しいです05:55それも05
:57政府が統一された05:59は、政府が私たち自身の06:00通貨を印刷しているので、ギリシャのような06:06の国とは異なり、不況に陥ったときに06:03を赤字で使うことができるのです。
06:10に彼らの経済タンクが経済を後押しするために06:13の赤字を使うことができないので困っています06:16彼らは自分のお金を印刷しないので06:17彼らはユーロにいるので彼らが06:20の赤字支出をしたいのですが、実際には06:22に借りて、06:23に返済する必要がありますが、米国の06:26は今すぐお金を印刷します06:29多くの人の06:30の心を吹き飛ばそうとしている06:31だから、そうそう、それは多くの06:34の人の心を吹き飛ばす傾向があり、ギリシャの06:35だけでなく、外に出てユーロを借りなければならない06:
38は現在ギリシャの国06:41にとって実質的に外貨ですが、資本市場によって設定された06:46の条件でユーロを借りるために06:43を持っているので、06:50の債券は時々人々が06を警戒します:52
06:56の借金が必要なときに、06:54のギリシャ政府に資金を提供している人々は、06:58の金利をどんどん高く要求し、07:00のギリシャだと聞いてください。
07:02返済できるかどうかはわかりませんが、07:04の場合は、お金を貸してください。6、7、07:06、8%が必要です。つまり、07:08が債務危機で起こったことです。
07:10債務危機の権利と金利07:12は二桁上昇しており、07:14の一方で、私たちは07:17に自国通貨を07:19経済に費やし、その一部に課税し、それから07:22自発的に07:24お金の一部を交換することを選択します07:26それはこれらの07:28国債のために経済に費やされました問題になるだろう07:35政府はそれをする必要さえありません07:36それはそれ自身の通貨を借り戻していますそして07:38それはそれが借りる条件を設定することができます07:41言い換えれば私達は私達を持っています中央の07:43銀行を所有しているので、連邦政府の07:45予備金に、07:47政府に07:49を超える金利での借入を許可しないと言わせることができます。51歴史的に、1950年代と40年代の07:53には、07:55合意に基づく財務省と呼ばれるものがあり、07:57中央銀行に、私たちが言った人々にサービスを提供するように指示しました。07:59あなたの仕事は金利を維持することです08:02政府08:05が08:07の金利を引き上げずにお金を借りることができたように、特定の低金利で08:10米国の08:12州では、ギリシャとはまったく異なるゲームなので、08:
15とても多くの人が、なんてことだと思っています08:17この21兆ドルの赤字があります08:20そしてその08:22を税金で返済しなければならないと思いますが、08:24は本当ではありません右08:27いいえ、そうではありません08:29私は夫の机に座っています08:31たまたまここにポストイットのメモ帳があります08:33だから私は好きだと言ってみましょう'm
08:36政府と私は2つの08:402ドル20億を費やすつもりです08:42これらを呼んでください私はこれらを08:43経済に入れるだけなのでここに行きます08:46それらを渡しますあなたにとってあなたは今経済ですあなたは08:48私がそれらを使ったこれらの2つを持っていますしかし私はあなたから1つを取り戻すつもりですそして私は08:52それを税金と呼ぶつもりなので私は08を集めました:54これはなくなったがあなたはまだ08:56これは大丈夫なので私は08:58の赤字を実行している私は2つを入れて1つを取り出す09:02私の赤字ですがあなたは09:04を持って座っていますこれとこれはあなたの余剰です09:06今これは私が09:09経済に費やしたお金であり、税金を払い戻さなかったこれは09:12あなたのドルですが今私は09:15このドルをから借りるつもりですあなたはそう私は09:17を09と呼ばれる別の色の紙を手に入れるつもりです:19国債と私はあなたからこれを09:21取るつもりです09:23そして私はあなたにこれを与えるつもりですだから今09:24あなたはオレンジの代わりに青を持っています09:27私はあなたから借りています大丈夫ですが09:30国債を購入するためのお金09:32はこれを購入するために09:35のお金を費やした政府から来ました09:36は私があなたに09:38これを与えたという事実から来たので私は両方のお金を提供しています09
:41あなたが税金を払うのに使うお金と09:44あなたが私から債券を買うのに使うお金09:47だから09:49はい09:50はい私はあなたが知っている私はもっと私を知っている09:53
09:55をフォローすればするほど、09:56に追加したいことがもう1つあります。
t本当に10:05は必然的に10:07が重要であり、あなたが本当に持っているのは10:09
10:11に注意するのは、10:14はあまりお金を印刷しないということです。なぜなら、10:15は、経済がすでに10:17でハミングしているとしましょう。その時のお金10:22インフレを起こす10:24正しい10:25そしてそれはあなたが10:26注意する必要があるものですそれでここにあなたが実際に10:31好きなエレン10:29グリーンスパンを見せましょうあなたの10:33の話の間にこのビデオクリップを見せて、私はそれを手に入れました、そして私はそれをここで再生するつもりです10:37彼が言っていることを人々に説明することができます:42そしてポールライアンは彼を10:44に連れて行こうとしています。アイデアとそうええと、彼は10になるつもりです:54は彼が10:56ええとグリーンスパンを得ようとしていると言いますはいソーシャル10:58セキュリティはお金を使い果たす可能性がありますそして11:00それは私たちがこのようにしなければならない理由ですしかし11:01彼は実際にはうまくいきませんポールと一緒に11:03ライアンと私は今それをプレイするつもりです11:05ここにいる私たちの人々のために11:06これを見てみましょう11:07個人年金口座を持つことは11:09将来の退職者を作る別の方法11:12は、11:14の引退11:15に対してより安全なメリットがあります。また、11:19のソルベンシーシステムのコンポーネントとしての個人の11:17のリタイアメントアカウントは、11:22のソルベンシーの向上に役立つと思いますか。
11:23個人年金口座のポリシー11:25は、11:27で利益が相殺された会社であり、その機能は11:29個人年金口座で11:29できると思いますか。30は、システムの支払能力を達成し、11:32の将来の退職者給付をより安全にするのに役立ちます。11:39の従量制給付は、11:42では安全ではないとは言えません。
11:46連邦政府が11:49必要なだけのお金を生み出し、誰かに支払うことを妨げるものは何もありません11:51質問は11:53大丈夫なので、そこで止めます11:
55大丈夫そう彼は言うのでグリーンスパンはノーと言います11:57あなたが12:00に行くので実際に支払う危険はありません12:05は、政府が12:06のお金を好きなだけ印刷して、それを12:08に渡すことができると述べています。彼は、12:10の種類がポールライアンを部屋から吹き飛ばすと言っただけです。13ええと、12:17とすぐに、ポール・ライアンの顔から12:15の色がすべて消えたと思います。そうだと言ったので、12:20、それから続けて、アラン12:22グリーンステップそして12:24種類のあなたの経済理論を認める彼は12:27あなたと他の人々が12:29が現代貨幣理論を推進していることを認める12:27またはあなたが取り組んでいることを認める12:34推進しているとは言わないしかし、あなたは今12:36
umに取り組んでいるので、彼はあなたの現代貨幣12:41理論が実際に正しい12:43であることを認めています。彼が12:48の連邦準備制度の議長だったのは理論ではないことを知っている12:50はお金がどこから来るのかを知っている12:52だから彼はそれが現実であり、この男がイランをフォローしているのは12:54だけではないことを知っている12です:57あなたが知っている真の信者のリバータリアン私は13:00は、これは非常に13:03のようになり、13:05の意味ではそうではないということを意味します。
:09経済のためにより多くのことをするので、ある意味で13:12は、これが13:14の場合であることに夢中になりますが、彼は誓いを立てており、13:17の功績により、彼は正直な答えを出します13:19あなたが正しい脂肪税13:22彼はそれがどのように機能するかを知っています13:26だから今13:27彼は行くつもりですそしてそして13:30だから今彼は続けるつもりですそして元と13:32はもっと説明しますそして私はしません13:36彼が何について話しているのかわからないが、13:37はきっとあなたがそうするだろうし、彼が何を意味するのか教えてくれるだろう13:39
13:45に実物資産が13であることを保証するシステム:これらの利益13:52が13:54を購入するために使用される48が作成されるので、セキュリティの問題ではありません。13:57金融システムの構造13:59の問題であり、14:02の実際のリソースを保証します14:
04は引退のために作成されます14:07現金とは異なり、現金14:09自体14:10は14:12があればいいのですが、14:13は14:16の実際のリソースのコンテキストにある必要があります14:17
14:18作成された14:21の時点で14:21これらの特典が支払われるので、14:24実際のリソースを購入できます14:26もちろん14:28の現金であるため、彼が何であるかわかりません14:31について話しているのですが、14:33はまだポール・ライアンを動揺させているようです。いいえ14:40アイデア14:43しかし、それが最大の言葉だったと思います14:45サラダええ14:46ええそうですが、これが彼の言ったことです14:49最初に戻ってみましょう14:51手頃な価格の質問を14:53から外します右のテーブルは、連邦政府が14:57連邦政府が将来のすべての世話をすることを妨げるものは絶対にない、と彼は言います。
15:07から私たちを止めるものは何もないので、15:09を完全に脇に置いて、15:11が本当に重要なポイントであり、15:13が私たちが議論したいと思っているポイントにします。
15:15の代わりに、彼が提起している15:17の本当に重要なポイントについて常に議論することになるのは、15:19です。この15:20グリーンスパンは、この国のベビーブーム世代が15:22変化していることを知っています。24は引退に移行しており、15:26を生産する人はますます少なくなっています。15:28私たち全員が15:31を購入し続けるので、ブーマーは引退します。
15:35のものを購入したいのですが、グリーンスパンは質問は15:38だと言います。15:40に実際の資産が15:43経済で生産されることを保証するシステムをどのように設定しますか。
15:47が510 20
30年で十分に生産的な15:49経済になることを確認して、15:53のチェックが出たときに、人々が15:55そのお金を待つことなく経済に費やすことができるようにしますか?
15:58それのために15:59不足とインフレ16:01十分なものがない場合16:03十分な経済がない場合16:05お金が多すぎるという古い問題が発生します16:07追跡する商品が少なすぎる16:09は16:10と同じくらい単純なので、彼は16:12と言っているので、16:15の現金支払いが16:17の人々に確実に送られるようにすることができます。それは問題ではありません。問題は16:20です。16:24が通過するために16:22のものが私たちの経済で生産され、16:26のものが十分でない場合は、余剰のものがあります。それは16:28が不足を引き起こし、16:30がハイパーインフレーションを引き起こし、16:33と言っているのと同じです。私たち16:39は、この16:41の国で、人々の16:44の利益を削減し、社会保障を改革することについてではなく、激しい議論をするでしょう16:46これは16:48の利益を削減するためのコードであり、16:51の支払いに焦点を当てています。16:52の余裕はありません。16:53のお金の問題です。お金ではない16:54の問題それは生産性の問題であり、16:57私たちはそれを修正することができます17:06の生産性を高めるための17:06の最良の経済計画を持っているのは誰ですか?17:11はインフラストラクチャと17:13の教育に投資したいと考えており、17:16はこれらがそれは17:17に多くのことをし、経済の長期的な成長と生産性を17:19に押し上げます。24カットと規制緩和が、それは彼らがそれに固執している彼らの17:26の話ですが、少なくとも17:27に、17:32の健全な経済を健全な生産性にする方法である正しい17:30のことを議論するでしょう17
:34経済17:35よく17:37共和党だけが赤字にリップサービスを支払うことは明らかです17:42正しいので17:44ええとディックチェイニーでさえ有名に言ったことは17:46は赤字レーガンと言ったと引用されました17
:48は、17:51のロナルドレーガンが17:52の財政保守主義者であるはずだったので、赤字は問題ではないことを証明しましたが、彼は17:54の赤字を爆発させ、悪いことは何も起こりませんでした。
:00は、18:04が最初に18:06を知っているときに、ハミルトンが最初に18に行くと言ったときに知っているアルマゲドンについて18:01をもたらすという意味で重要です。08いくつかの州の債務を買い取り、18:10に国債を取得する予定です。ハミルトンが18:14を実行する前に、18:12の国債はありませんでした。したがって、国債は少なく、18:16のコースがあります。500十億は18:19兆になり、すべての髪が燃えています。18:22誰もが、これは世界で最悪の18:23であり、持続不可能であると言っています。そして半分それから5そして18:28それは7人のみんなの髪の毛が燃えているそして18:31あなたはオバマが入ってくるのを知っていますそして私たちは18:337から11に今15から20から21そして18:37に行きます18:39の終わりがこれに近いと言うことは持続不可能であり、18:42悪いことは何も起こりません。48フィードは、あなたが18:51を知っているように、私たちがあなたについて何を怒っているのかを知っているように彼らに伝えます。
01ロナルド・レーガンは赤字を爆発させ始めました19:04それはあなたの理論が正しいことを証明しているようなものです14年前、19:16の政策決定の世界のほとんどを説得して、19:19の国が債務比率を許可した場合、19:23の比率が90%以上になることを許可した場合、債務比率はgdpに対して19:21になります19
:26そこで脆弱性が19:28を設定し、債務19:31がgdp
19:33の最大90%を取得できる国では、転換点に到達してから19:35以上の成長の鈍化、そしてこれらすべての悪い19:37のようなことがよく起こります19:39日本を見てください日本は19:41の完璧な例であり、今日の債務とgdpの比率は約240%です負債は1兆近くの19:48です私は実際に19:50のゼロがいくつあるかわかりませんが、それは1兆の19:52のゼロがたくさんあり、19:57のインフレなしと19:59未満の金利があります1パーセントで人生は続く20:02ちょっと待って20:04どうですか20:06実数は3を足しますええ20:08を3つのゼロを1兆に足しますそしてあなたは20:10兆を手に入れます20:12そう20:13ええと高いそうそう100兆から20:15次のゼロアップは4兆20:18なので、彼らの負債は私たちの負債よりも指数関数的に大きくなります20:22よく、それはドルではありません20:24はそれと呼ばれます」s円建てですが、20:26ええ、彼らは約20:29で、数千億ドルで大丈夫です20:32大丈夫です。ですから、政府が20:38でお金を借りていると言うとき、あなたはすでに20:40のようなもので、以前は青と20:42でオレンジのポストイット20:45なので、20:46は実際には行かないと説明しました。だから彼らは20:48ではない、例えば私たちは20:50に20:53の軍事予算にさらに800億ドルを費やすことに決めた。
20:59である800億ドルは、21:01ごとに銀行から借りていないわけではありません。彼らは、21:03国債と呼ばれるものを発行し、21:05は、彼らがただの投資としてそれらを購入します。
21:07債券を正しく発行してから、21:10に、後で21:12の利息を現金化して、21:14の政府が借りるのが私の正しい21:17です。つまり、ディーラーがいるということです。
21:19市場21:21がオークションに参加する特定の銀行があります21:23彼らはディーラーです。したがって、21:25政府がオークションを開催するとき、債券を販売します21:2821:28に必要なディーラーがあります。
29入札し、実際には21:32のバイヤーが債券の購入者を保証しました。これは、21:33のバイヤーが、21:38の自己資金を所有し、あなた自身の21:40中央銀行と財務省、および21:42中央銀行は21:44の舞台裏で調整し、21:46の債券オークションが失敗しないようにします。21:48財務省21:50の小切手はバウンスしないなどの理由で、21:52は、21:54の少し前に、あなたと私が21:56に車の融資をしたり、購入したりするときの様子について話しました。
22:00にクレジットを提供してくれる人を見つけ、22:02に資金を事前に手配し、22:04にお金を持って出かけ、22:05に政府がすでに支出している22
:07経済へのお金と、22:14にすべてのお金を使う許可が与えられた後、バックグラウンドで22:10が起こっているのは、これらの機関が22:17の財務省と連邦政府がそれを解決していることです22:
19支払いが常に明確であることを確認するために22:22それは一種の驚くべきことです22:24それは実際には一種の驚くべきことです22:26それは22:28最後のことなのでそれも安心です22:30政府職員が22:32のバウンスをチェックしていることを知っている22:34そうですね22:36の2番目の質問です22:37ですが、自国の通貨を印刷すると22:39なぜですか財務22:41ボンドのことをしなければならないのでしょうか22:45印刷してみませんか22:47良い質問です22:49良い答えがあります22:52に閉じ込められた22:51のようなものですええとそれをする習慣は22:56が長い間このようにやってきたことを意味しますそして私は22:59おそらく答えは23:01にたくさんあると思います23:04これらを購入する人々が金融業者であるという事実と関係があります23:07財務省ええと23:11少しの無料乗車を取得するための良い方法です23:13から補助金を受け取ります彼らが23:14に与える政府は、23の代わりに青を保持することに関心を持っています。18オレンジと彼らはそれをするために23:20を志願する必要はありませんがあなたは人々が23:22の人々がああそれは貧しい固定された23:25の収入だと言うでしょう23:32連邦準備制度理事会が金利を非常に低く保ち、23:34になるとおばあちゃんが罰せられるため、金利は23:29上昇します。債券であなたは彼女が23:40これらすべての宝物をよく見つけていることを知っています23:42そこに23:44宝物を持っている人がいますが23:46これらのものの大部分は23:48持っています非常に裕福な大丈夫です23:51それで私はそれをクリアします23:53だから今アラングリーンスパンが23:56これがどのように機能するかを理解しているなら23:58だから私に23:59ええと24:00大丈夫だから私にさせてください私は24にしようとします:02予算が実際にどのように機能するかを説明します24:04そしてあなたは私が間違っているところを私に訂正します24:06立法者が集まり、彼らは今24:08支出の優先順位を決定します私たちの支出の優先順位の1つは71524です:
24:15国の誰も実際に24:17を望んでいない軍事予算のための130億ドルあなたが株主である1パーセント24:19を知っていて、それらの24:21防衛請負業者会社24:23を知っているので、彼らは予算を書きます彼らは24:25を持っているので、24:27をメディケアに、これをメディケイドに、24:29を24:30に、ペンタゴンの予算を24:33のインフラストラクチャに費やすので、彼らは24:27
:35は24:36を決定するだけで、24:40と言ったように、24:38の資金調達を待つことはありません。24:43銀行は24:43を提供する必要があるため、資金調達は自動的に行われます。46お金24:47と私たちが彼らに返さなければならないのは、そのお金24:50に対する24:48の利息ですが、とにかく24:53を印刷するので、24:53
amに近いので、24:56予算が実際に反映すべきものは24:57私たちの優先順位24:59であり、今のところ25:01は、ある種のベルト締めを行うために25:02を持っているという誤った優先順位を反映しています25:05正しい
25:07ええ予算は25:09の優先順位を反映する必要があるので、そうです。民主党員が25:14を席巻した25:12の優先順位が、おそらく共和党員が25:19とはかなり異なるように見える25:17の予算を書く場合は正しいです。 25:21は、教育25:23とインフラストラクチャに、より多くのリソースを投入します。25:25のようなものは、あなたが知っているメディケイドのフードスタンプです。防衛または25:32予算の他の領域から30なので、シャッフルがありますが、25:34は、合計で25:36を増やすこともあるので、25:39から25:40と言っています。彼らが言っているエージェンシーに25:42を見てください私たちはちょうどこのすべての支出を承認しました25:44行く25:45経済への支出を開始し、それのすべての25:50が入りますが、それのいくつかはちょうど25:52が来始めます25:54の人が税金を支払うので、政府は25:58に費やした金額の一部を集めているので、自動的に戻ってきます。 26:03の税金を徴収したので、取り除いたので、いつでも26:05に新しいお金を戻すことができますが、税金は26:08になり、期間の終わりには26:10になります。会計年度のように再測定すると、26:13は、26:15が費やされた量と戻ってきた量の差になり、26:18は、差が26:20であるため、黒字または赤字のどちらかです。 26:22私たちは経済にもっと力を入れていますそして26:24私たちは政府に課税しています26:26赤字を実行していますこれは人々が26:28これらの余分なものを保持することを意味しますそして26:31政府が26:33赤字になるたびに借りる必要があります26:36これらをこれらと交換し始めるので今26:40彼らはこのように行くので26:42すべての種類がリアルタイムで26:44すべての種類が起こっています26:47ではなく、1日目と2日目26:49は、常にすべて同じ26:52の時間に発生しますが、会計年度末26:54に、すべてを相殺して計算します。どのように26:私たちが取り出したよりもはるかに多くのことを26:59に経済に投入し、27:00の赤字27:02とラベル付けしましたが、27:04、議会の予算局27:06とウォールストリートジャーナルとすべての27:08これらの出版物は27:10政府の財政赤字を報告するとき、彼らは27:13政府の観点から、27:15に物語を語っている状況を見ています。財政27:20は赤字でしたが、27:24経済の観点から、27:27の話は決して政府ではないので、27:29の見出しの代わりに27:30の政府を読んでいるとしたら赤字は27:33に8000億から来年には1兆に達すると予測されています27:36代わりに見出しは27:39政府27:40申し訳ありません27:42非政府27:43の黒字は8,0027:460億から来年には1兆に達すると予測されており、27:50のように、27:52の人々を27:54から27:54に冷やすので、27:47はすべてうまくいくと思います。 :56それは27:58のように聞こえます全体の金銭的な28:00システムはそれが28:03に基づいているということです私たちは28:10に同意します。これはこれが価値のあることであり、28:11のものがどのように機能するかということですが、28:14は、28:16のようなことを言うのに夢中なのか、それとも私が何かに真実があるのかということです。 28:17は28:18と言ったばかりですが、これは28:21政府が、28:27の国で税法を制定し、施行する権限を持っていることを知っているという事実に基づいています。 28:30政府の税法なので、28:32彼らが28:34に費やしているこれらのもの28:34経済28:35は私たちが必要としている28:36私たちが考え続けていることを知っている28:38政府はxyzを行うために私たちのお金を必要としている28:41政府は私たちを必要としない私たち28:43が彼らのお金を正しく必要としているので、税金は28:46に課せられているので、28:52の税金を支払うために、なんとかして28:49を稼ぐことができました。通常、これらのものの多くを28:57の経済に投入しますが、28:59は、これらの29:03を保持して蓄積できる、29:01の追加で歩き回ることができます。 29:05を貯蓄の一部として保持しているので、29:06政府が、その29:08の行動をこれ以上正しく決定しなかった場合、29:10の余剰金を実行しているだけで、29:12の吸い込みになります。緑の紙i 'm申し訳ありませんがオレンジ29:15紙を入れるよりも早く出し、29:18残高がすべて減少し始めます29:19ダウン29:21だから、もう1つ欲しいことがあります29:23これがどのように機能するかを人々に伝えてください29:27私たちが銀行にお金を貸したとき29:29株式がクラッシュしたとき、彼らはええと行きました29:31市場が崩壊し、銀行は腹を立てました29:33そして彼らは大きすぎて失敗しません29:35これらの場合銀行は廃業する29:36は私たちの経済に大きな打撃を与える29:38反響は私たちが耐えられないほど痛いので、29:41政府は先に進み、29:43は彼らに何でも与える29:45が彼らを完全に正しくするために必要な金額それは29:47ですアイデア29:49まあそれは29:51は十分に公平ですが、彼らが29:53にお金を与える方法です29:55は、彼らが彼らにお金を与えるためです29:57彼らは彼らにお金を貸します彼らはお金を印刷します29:59銀行にそれを貸します銀行はそれからそのお金を受け取ります30:05は、30:08に30:07の利子を受け取る政府を示しているので、その利子を使用して30:10に返済します。ええ、30:18に、連邦政府と政府が金融危機後の30:23の状況に対処する方法に対処するために、多くのことが起こりましたが、30:25ええ、私たちはたくさんのことをしました。ええと30:28は空想的に定量的イージング30:30と呼ばれ、30:32の印刷キーをたくさん押して、30:35の財務省と住宅ローンで裏付けられた30:37の証券を銀行から購入しました。 :貸借対照表から39をオフにして、30:41を効果的に現金化し、代わりに30:43を超過した30:46の準備金の利息を支払います。それは多かれ少なかれ30:54はあなたが今説明したように機能します30:57それで私には30:59そして私が間違っているなら私を訂正しますそれが理由です31:00あなたはここにいます31:01それは詐欺のように聞こえます31:07よくあなたは彼らが流動性を言う詐欺を言います31:10注入私は意味します31:12あなたが知っている31:13ええと31:14それはそれが認識された31:20機関の貸借対照表に31:18現金を注入する方法です31:24価値のある価値のある貧しいええ31:28しかし、これが人々が31:30のようなことを言う理由です。 31:34あなたはこれにお金を払うつもりですあなたはこの31:35の大きな進歩的な議題を持っていますこれらの31:36候補のいくつかはよく言い始めました:42救済する必要があった31:43リーマンの10年31:46周年であなたが知っているええと見たかどうかはわかりません31:50最後の数で書かれ公開された作品の31:47がたくさんありました日とええとマットタイービはローリングストーンで31:52本当に良いものを持っていますそして彼は31:55いくつかの見積もりをさかのぼります31:57あなたはフィードエンド31:59がどのくらいの金額のように介入したかを知っています32 :02私たちはそれを付けますか、そして研究で32:07賦課金経済研究所によって提供された最高の32:04見積もりは、彼らが32を見たときにそこにあった32:0929兆でした:12それで彼らは、連邦準備制度が29 32:17兆の曲に32:15の権利を与えたと言っています。それができれば、大丈夫です。 24インフラストラクチャー何かお腹を空かせた子供たちのために32:26ええ、バラク・オバマ32:30が指示すると、32:32の量的緩和が32:34になり、銀行に29兆ドル、32:36が振り返り、文字通り32:38連邦準備制度の従業員のための32:39の支払い凍結32:41私たちはこの32:44の支払いをしなければならないということは悪い経済的思考です32:46確かにそうです32:50みんなのような議論であり、32:52は、政策立案者が32:55の大不況にどのように対応したかを見ており、32:57の多くの人々が32:ここで59の修正主義者の歴史と33:02は、33:05が全体として果たした役割を再形成しようとして、33:06ああ、33:08の住宅所有者のためにもっとやろうとしたああ、本当にやろうとした刺激に関しては33:10ええ33:13だから、たくさんのことが起こっています。
Kelton:
25:07 yeah the budget should reflect the 25:09 priorities and so yes that's correct if 25:12 your priorities that the democrats swept 25:14 in presumably they would write a a 25:17 budget that looks quite different from 25:19 the one the republicans would write they 25:21 would put more resources in education 25:23 and infrastructure and these sorts of 25:25 things medicaid food stamps you know 25:28 whatever and and so and take some money 25:30 out of defense or other areas of the 25:32 budget so there'd be some shuffling but 25:34 there would also maybe even be some 25:36 augmenting um in total so they're saying 25:39 to 25:40 to the agencies they're saying look 25:42 we've just authorized all this spending 25:44 go 25:45 start spending into the economy and all 25:50 of it's going in but some of it just 25:52 starts coming back automatically because 25:54 people pay their taxes so the government 25:56 is collecting some of what it spent 25:58 that's gone right when you collect it 26:00 back you don't need it anymore you just 26:01 throw it away so now i've collected your 26:03 tax i took it out i can i can always 26:05 spend new money back in but the taxes go 26:08 out and at the end of whatever period 26:10 we're measuring like a fiscal year there 26:13 will be a difference between how much 26:15 was spent in and how much came back and 26:18 we tossed it out the difference is 26:20 either the surplus or the deficit so if 26:22 we're putting more into the economy then 26:24 we're taxing back out the government is 26:26 running a deficit which means people end 26:28 up holding some extra of these and 26:31 because the government requires itself 26:33 to borrow whenever it runs a deficit it 26:36 starts swapping these for these so now 26:40 they go they go like this right so it's 26:42 all kind of happening 26:44 in real time all the time it's not in 26:47 sort of on day one this and on day two 26:49 it's always all happening at the same 26:52 time but at the end of the fiscal year 26:54 we net it all out and we figure out how 26:57 much more did we put into the economy 26:59 than we took out and we label it a 27:00 deficit 27:02 but you know what jimmy when we do that 27:04 when when congressional budget office 27:06 and the wall street journal and all 27:08 these publications when they report 27:10 the government's budget deficit they're 27:13 looking at the situation they're telling 27:15 the story from the perspective of the 27:17 government the government's finances 27:20 were in deficit but they never tell the 27:22 story from the perspective of the 27:24 economy the not government part of the 27:27 story so if instead of a headline 27:29 reading 27:30 government uh deficits projected to go 27:33 from 800 billion to a trillion next year 27:36 instead the headline could read 27:39 government 27:40 i'm sorry 27:42 non-government 27:43 surpluses projected to go from 800 27:46 billion to a trillion next year and we'd 27:47 all go right on you know like 27:50 that would put it that would chill 27:52 people out.
ケルトン25:07 予算は優先事項を反映させるべきで、もし25:12 優先事項が民主党に支配されていたとしたら、25:14 共和党が書く25:19 予算とは全く異なる25:17 予算を書くでしょう。 共和党は、教育25:23やインフラ、25:25のようなものに、より多くの資源を投入し、25:30には国防や他の予算分野から資金を引き上げるとしています。 25:54 人々は税金を払っているので、25:56 政府は使ったお金の一部を回収していますが、25:58 それがなくなったときには、26:00 回収してももう必要ないので、26:01 捨ててしまいます。 26:08 そして、26:10 会計年度のように測定している期間の終わりには、26:13 投入された金額と戻ってきた金額との間に差が生じ、26:18 その差が26:20 剰余金か赤字のどちらかになります。 26:26 赤字を出しているということは、人々は 26:28 結局これらの余分なものを持っていることになり、26:31 政府は赤字を出すたびに 26:33 借り入れをしなければならないので、26:36 これらのものと交換し始めるのです。 26:47 初日にこれをやって、2日目にこれをやってというようなものではなく、常にすべてが同じ26:52の時間に起こっているのですが、26:54年度末にはすべてをネットで計算し、26:57経済に投入した額が搬出した額よりもどれだけ多いかを把握し、それを27:00赤字とします。 27:08 これらの出版物が政府の財政赤字を報告するとき、彼らは27:13状況を見ていて、27:15政府の財政が赤字だったという27:17政府の観点から話をしているが、27:22経済の観点から話をすることはない27:24政府ではない27:27話の部分である。 もし、27:30 政府の赤字は27:33 来年には8000億円から1兆円になると予測 27:36 その代わりに、27:39 政府 27:40 すみません 27:42 非政府 27:43 来年の黒字は27:46 億円から1兆円になると予測 27:47 みんなで27:50のように続けていけば、27:52 人々を冷静にさせることができるでしょう。
www.DeepL.com/Translator(無料版)で翻訳しました。
Part.2 別動画
everybody welcome to part two of our interview with stephanie kelton stephanie kelton is a brilliant economist and she worked for his bernie sanders he was an advisor for his 2016 presidential campaign she's here explaining to us how money works if greenspan understands how this works like you understand barack obama must understand how this works like you understand so what's in it for him and trump just did the same thing by the way they gave a trillion dollar tax cut and then he he froze payee for the federal employees again which what do you get out of doing that what did they get out of doing that I don't know cuz it would be so easy to do the opposite of that and have more voters behind you you know there it's it's like it goes way way back to the Reagan years when the Republicans used to talk about playing Santa Claus yeah and you know the two Santa's theory and all this kind of stuff that it was understood that if you can do things when you have power that even if you're giving the the lion's share of the benefits to the people at the very top do something for the broad middle and those at the bottom and you carry everybody you have a better chance right of carrying everybody along with you in your program and having you know voter support and all that kind of stuff but they don't they don't seem to care I mean 31 percent approval or whatever and he's just keeps hammering away at the people at the bottom and it'd be so easy to give up throw him a bone so I mean FDR understood this and it's it's it's weird how they just you know FDR says famously said here that he didn't bring socialism to America he saved capitalism and what he told his rich friends is if you don't give some of your money away to these people now the people the workers the the general people in the population that you're gonna they're gonna take all of it away like they did in Russia right so they went a lot or he got enough of him to go along with it and it worked right so he put money in the pockets of you know so I just don't understand again it's these like you can't have your cake and eat it too in a sense and like Bill Clinton Barack Obama like Barack Obama smarter than me so how come if he understands the is it a class thing like Chris Hedges says he just comes from a different class and they just think differently I don't know I mean I didn't work for him or have any role in that administration I know Gene Sperling was a true believer I think that my understanding from people that did work in the administration that I've spoken with I think that President Obama listened to Gene Sperling on a lot of things and you know he wanted that grand bargain I mean do you really wanted that thing right that was going to be a sort of signature achievement it was sort of an only Nixon can go to China only a Democrat can do the thing with entitlements and whether it was more of a political calculation or more of I believe I genuinely have to do this because the economics don't make sense you know he really believed that the thing is unsustainable and so the people know what that is the grand bargain tell people what that was well this was this idea that Republicans and Democrats were going to come together to tighten the noose and and to say look we're gonna put everything it was the everything's on the table sort of thing there's an in for a while we were hearing about shared prosperity well pretty soon it became shared sacrifice right everybody's gonna hurt we're gonna hurt all of you okay that makes they get hurt the bank's didn't get hurt no the banks didn't get hurt yeah at all no so this was we're gonna put we're gonna make some tough tough decisions on entitlements and that's there so the grand bargain was Barack Obama then the Democrats were willing to cut Social Security and Medicare that was the big and that's the thing that they're not supposed to do and now under any situation and they were willing to do that right that's the grand bargain right and it really I mean if you're if you're honest I think you have to say it was the Tea Party that saved us from ending up with the grandeur was yes they said it wasn't enough it wasn't deep enough we won't vote for it so we really have the Tea Partiers to thank for the fact that we didn't guts or cut Social Security Medicare so reverse is I'm really glad that we got to talk to you and I know you don't have a lot of time but I have one more question Nancy Pelosi has vowed by the way she's going back as leader from California where the bluest state we have a supermajority here Democrats we keep electing corporatists Dianne Feinstein and Nancy Pelosi which tells me that the Democratic Party is just lost right so she's gonna go back to Congress and she is already committed to a thing called pay go which pay go means is that you can never do what you're saying although the Republicans do it all the time they come in and they they spend money or cut taxes and they don't care how much it adds to the deficit and they do all their pet projects and the Democrats never get to do it and what Nancy Pelosi is saying is we're gonna do Pago meaning whatever program we decide to pay for we have to either raise taxes or cut that something else equal out of the budget which cripples our progressive agenda correct I could not say better exactly it cripples the progressive agenda it commits the government is saying for every one we put in we're going to take that up one back out nothing net for you and and it hamstrings your ability to I think moved any kind of progressive legislation and not going to do big ambitious things if under up hey go you know is that is that Nancy Pelosi just being misguided is she just doesn't understand how stuff works no no she's a believer did she went on to the House floor after Pete Peterson died right the billionaire fixed the dead and the Peterson foundation and the can kicks back with the little guy in the can costume running around college campuses telling young people that Social Security is never going to be there for them this guy funds all of this apparatus of you know probe Institute's designed to to go after Social Security and Medicare and after he died recently Nancy Pelosi took to the House floor to give you know a big a big speech lamenting his death and thanking him for all of the great and important work he did to bring the importance of fiscal responsibility and the dangers of the deficit and all that kind of stuff so I think she's a believer so that's so no matter if Bernie Sanders gets elected president he has to deal with someone like Nancy Pelosi even if there's a blue wave and they take over Congress Nancy Pelosi's not gonna ever so that means we'll never have Medicare for all is what that means because she would according to Nancy Pelosi we'd have to raise taxes 32 trillion dollars anyway she's it's just and right so right now in New York Andrew Cuomo just defeated Cynthia Nixon so now is Cynthia Nixon supposed to tell progressives to vote for Andrew Cuomo who the New York Times editorial board called stone ax the sleaziest move sleazy and one of the lowest dealers in politics we're supposed to go vote for that guy now is that what's gonna happen with the Democrats I don't know what's gonna happen I live in New York now and I voted yesterday I doubt she's going to be speaking out vocally as a champion for rounding up votes for Andrew Cuomo baha'i okay it's just it's just a head scratcher to me how yeah people who can vote for Cynthia Nixon can then bring themselves to vote for the Democrat version of Donald Trump which is Andrew Cuomo so and that's why would this will never happen and we'll all be dead soon because climate change is coming and the Democrats didn't do anything about that either when they had complete control people forget that Barack Obama had complete control of government and a filibuster-proof Senate for a few months and imagine if what if the Republicans had that what they would do they would cram everything in the world in those two months in and they would get it done the Democrats couldn't even get a goddamn public option you know why cuz their donors don't want him to have it which is why we got Donald Trump he is as Chris Hedges says a Vistage of a broken democracy so trying to fix the tope you know voting for Democrats is not gonna fix this problem right I I don't know Jimmy I gotta say I got a belief what's the alternative who are we gonna vote for like right now in 2018 or in 2020 how do we get to where we want to be I don't know the answer to that but I see some really inspiring candidates who happen to be running as Democrats but they're you know they're winning seats Jimmy they are they're winning seats their winning seats in the state legislature we just had a big victory here in the state of New York yesterday we got the IDC where we're doing some things it's incremental it's frustrating I don't know how to do it in one fell swoop but I wish we could yeah I know so the incremental is we're gonna get us killed because climate change is coming so incremental ISM isn't working that's what we've been doing Bernie now Bernie asked for a so you know what Bernie would start off his campaign speeches he would say sounds like you're ready for a revolution and then he turned around and back Tillery Clinton and now he's really doing incremental ISM like you said that's what we're all doing now is incremental ISM well when I meant I didn't mean incremental ISM in terms of what we what we reach for with policy I meant incremental victory so you win some you lose when we can CRO mental progress is what I meant in terms of getting the kinds of candidates I think you and I both want to see more of elected to office yeah okay well it's so it's I'm really disappointing it's not happening there is no progressive takeover of the Democratic Party they've met you know how many corporate Democrats that they've effectively primary one Joe Crowley that's it anyway and now as you know Cortes has to tell people to vote for Andrew Cuomo because she's a Democrat it's gross it's disgusting you know but anyway that's not I don't want you here to talk about economics and you did and you did a great job hey let me ask I'm here to throw paper that's good but can I let me ask you one more economic question so now I don't want to put my money in the stock like so retirement money I'm supposed to put my money in 401ks and what do people do if the cuz I know it's gonna crash again right well it probably will crash again but the reality is that it's it will go up after it crashes and your young guy so but I've been told and isn't this true that they've pulled all that they've done all the tricks they can and because though the interest rates are so low so the next time it crashes there is less stuff for them to do and it might not be it not we might not come out of it like we did this last time is that no no never underestimate the creativity of a central banker really oh yeah I mean we haven't even warmed up here in the US they got some real stuff going on in Japan and the ECB and Europe oh yeah these other countries central banks are buying stocks they're buying corporate bonds they will find things to buy for lucky maybe they'll buy student loan debt and we'll figure out how to get them to write it off after they buy it I have a paper on that so was Jill Stein write about that that the we could have done quite enough quantitative easing on student debt so she was right in the sense that we could cancel it but she wasn't right in the way that she talked about it because unfortunately she talked about it as if you could carry it out the same way the Fed did quantitative easing quantitative easing was an asset swap it was the Fed buying Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities but it didn't cancel those things right people still continue to pay their mortgage and so forth so you didn't get off the hook as because of what the Fed did so in our research paper we show how the Fed could actually buy the student loan debt and then tell students tell people who pay their debt you don't have to pay back okay I mean the paper walks through how you could actually do that really oh yeah okay well thanks again for spending this much time with us I appreciate you doing this and you know you you're the leading thinker on this and it's really an honor to have you here so thanks for doing this I'm happy to do it thanks Jimmy okay please make sure you're subscribed even if you think you are subscribed there's a good chance you're not so please check it only takes a second and then click that bell and that's how you know you'll get a notice every time we drop a video they still won't notify you every time we drop a video but that's the best we can do plus if you like the show you want to support it please become a patron we give you hours of bonus material every week and come see a live show go to jimmy dore comedy calm for our live schedule. [Music]
00:00 everybody welcome to part two of our 00:01 interview with stephanie kelton 00:02 stephanie kelton is a brilliant 00:05 economist and she worked for his bernie 00:07 sanders he was an advisor for his 2016 00:10 presidential campaign she's here 00:11 explaining to us how money works if 00:15 greenspan understands how this works 00:16 like you understand barack obama must 00:19 understand how this works like you 00:20 understand so what's in it for him and 00:23 trump just did the same thing by the way 00:24 they gave a trillion dollar tax cut and 00:26 then he he froze payee for the federal 00:29 employees again which what do you get 00:31 out of doing that what did they get out 00:33 of doing that I don't know cuz it would 00:36 be so easy to do the opposite of that 00:38 and have more voters behind you you know 00:42 there it's it's like it goes way way 00:44 back to the Reagan years when the 00:46 Republicans used to talk about playing 00:48 Santa Claus yeah and you know the two 00:50 Santa's theory and all this kind of 00:52 stuff that it was understood that if you 00:54 can do things when you have power that 00:56 even if you're giving the the lion's 00:58 share of the benefits to the people at 01:00 the very top do something for the broad 01:03 middle and those at the bottom and you 01:06 carry everybody you have a better chance 01:08 right of carrying everybody along with 01:11 you in your program and having you know 01:13 voter support and all that kind of stuff 01:15 but they don't they don't seem to care 01:16 I mean 31 percent approval or whatever 01:19 and he's just keeps hammering away at 01:22 the people at the bottom and it'd be so 01:26 easy to give up throw him a bone so I 01:29 mean FDR understood this and it's it's 01:33 it's weird how they just you know FDR 01:37 says famously said here that he didn't 01:39 bring socialism to America he saved 01:41 capitalism and what he told his rich 01:43 friends is if you don't give some of 01:46 your money away to these people now the 01:48 people the workers the the general 01:51 people in the population that you're 01:52 gonna they're gonna take all of it away 01:54 like they did in Russia right so they 01:56 went a lot or he got enough of him to go 01:58 along with it and it worked right so he 02:00 put money in the pockets of you know so 02:04 I just don't understand again it's these 02:06 like you can't have your cake and eat it 02:08 too in a sense and like Bill Clinton 02:11 Barack Obama like Barack Obama 02:13 smarter than me so how come if he 02:16 understands the is it a class thing like 02:18 Chris Hedges says he just comes from a 02:20 different class and they just think 02:21 differently I don't know I mean I didn't 02:24 work for him or have any role in that 02:28 administration I know Gene Sperling was 02:30 a true believer I think that my 02:34 understanding from people that did work 02:35 in the administration that I've spoken 02:37 with I think that President Obama 02:40 listened to Gene Sperling on a lot of 02:42 things and you know he wanted that grand 02:45 bargain I mean do you really wanted that 02:48 thing right that was going to be a sort 02:49 of signature achievement it was sort of 02:51 an only Nixon can go to China only a 02:53 Democrat can do the thing with 02:55 entitlements and whether it was more of 02:59 a political calculation or more of I 03:01 believe I genuinely have to do this 03:03 because the economics don't make sense 03:05 you know he really believed that the 03:08 thing is unsustainable and so the people 03:11 know what that is the grand bargain tell 03:13 people what that was well this was this 03:15 idea that Republicans and Democrats were 03:18 going to come together to tighten the 03:20 noose and and to say look we're gonna 03:23 put everything it was the everything's 03:25 on the table sort of thing there's an in 03:27 for a while we were hearing about shared 03:29 prosperity well pretty soon it became 03:30 shared sacrifice right everybody's gonna 03:33 hurt we're gonna hurt all of you okay 03:35 that makes they get hurt the bank's 03:36 didn't get hurt 03:37 no the banks didn't get hurt yeah at all 03:40 no so this was we're gonna put we're 03:43 gonna make some tough tough decisions on 03:45 entitlements and that's there so the 03:47 grand bargain was Barack Obama then the 03:49 Democrats were willing to cut Social 03:51 Security and Medicare that was the big 03:53 and that's the thing that they're not 03:54 supposed to do and now under any 03:56 situation and they were willing to do 03:58 that right that's the grand bargain 04:00 right and it really I mean if you're if 04:04 you're honest I think you have to say it 04:05 was the Tea Party that saved us from 04:08 ending up with the grandeur was yes they 04:11 said it wasn't enough it wasn't deep 04:13 enough we won't vote for it so we really 04:15 have the Tea Partiers to thank for the 04:17 fact that we didn't guts or cut Social 04:20 Security Medicare so reverse is I'm 04:24 really glad that we got to talk to you 04:26 and I know you don't have a lot of time 04:27 but I have one more question Nancy 04:29 Pelosi has vowed by the way she's going 04:31 back as leader from California where the 04:36 bluest state we have a supermajority 04:37 here Democrats we keep electing 04:40 corporatists Dianne Feinstein and Nancy 04:42 Pelosi which tells me that the 04:44 Democratic Party is just lost right so 04:47 she's gonna go back to Congress and she 04:49 is already committed to a thing called 04:51 pay go which pay go means is that you 04:54 can never do what you're saying 04:55 although the Republicans do it all the 04:57 time they come in and they they spend 04:59 money or cut taxes and they don't care 05:01 how much it adds to the deficit and they 05:03 do all their pet projects and the 05:05 Democrats never get to do it and what 05:07 Nancy Pelosi is saying is we're gonna do 05:09 Pago meaning whatever program we decide 05:12 to pay for we have to either raise taxes 05:14 or cut that something else equal out of 05:17 the budget which cripples our 05:18 progressive agenda correct I could not 05:22 say better exactly it cripples the 05:24 progressive agenda it commits the 05:26 government is saying for every one we 05:28 put in we're going to take that up one 05:30 back out nothing net for you and and it 05:33 hamstrings your ability to I think moved 05:36 any kind of progressive legislation and 05:38 not going to do big ambitious things if 05:40 under up hey go you know is that is that 05:43 Nancy Pelosi just being misguided is she 05:46 just doesn't understand how stuff works 05:47 no no she's a believer did she went on 05:51 to the House floor after Pete Peterson 05:54 died right the billionaire fixed the 05:58 dead and the Peterson foundation and the 06:00 can kicks back with the little guy in 06:02 the can costume running around college 06:04 campuses telling young people that 06:06 Social Security is never going to be 06:07 there for them this guy funds all of 06:10 this apparatus of you know probe 06:12 Institute's designed to to go after 06:15 Social Security and Medicare and after 06:18 he died recently Nancy Pelosi took to 06:21 the House floor to give you know a big a 06:24 big speech lamenting his death and 06:26 thanking him for all of the great and 06:28 important work he did to bring the 06:30 importance of fiscal responsibility and 06:33 the dangers of the deficit and all that 06:34 kind of stuff so I think she's a 06:36 believer so that's so no matter if 06:40 Bernie Sanders 06:41 gets elected president he has to deal 06:43 with someone like Nancy Pelosi even if 06:46 there's a blue wave and they take over 06:47 Congress Nancy Pelosi's not gonna ever 06:49 so that means we'll never have Medicare 06:52 for all is what that means because she 06:54 would according to Nancy Pelosi we'd 06:55 have to raise taxes 32 trillion dollars 06:57 anyway she's it's just and right so 07:02 right now in New York Andrew Cuomo just 07:05 defeated Cynthia Nixon so now is Cynthia 07:08 Nixon supposed to tell progressives to 07:10 vote for Andrew Cuomo who the New York 07:12 Times editorial board called stone ax 07:14 the sleaziest move sleazy and one of the 07:16 lowest dealers in politics we're 07:19 supposed to go vote for that guy now is 07:21 that what's gonna happen with the 07:22 Democrats I don't know what's gonna 07:25 happen I live in New York now and I 07:27 voted yesterday I doubt she's going to 07:31 be speaking out vocally as a champion 07:33 for rounding up votes for Andrew Cuomo 07:37 baha'i okay it's just it's just a head 07:42 scratcher to me how yeah people who can 07:44 vote for Cynthia Nixon can then bring 07:45 themselves to vote for the Democrat 07:47 version of Donald Trump which is Andrew 07:49 Cuomo so and that's why would this will 07:53 never happen and we'll all be dead soon 07:54 because climate change is coming and the 07:57 Democrats didn't do anything about that 07:58 either when they had complete control 08:00 people forget that Barack Obama had 08:02 complete control of government and a 08:03 filibuster-proof Senate for a few months 08:05 and imagine if what if the Republicans 08:08 had that what they would do they would 08:09 cram everything in the world in those 08:12 two months in and they would get it done 08:13 the Democrats couldn't even get a 08:15 goddamn public option you know why cuz 08:17 their donors don't want him to have it 08:18 which is why we got Donald Trump he is 08:21 as Chris Hedges says a Vistage of a 08:23 broken democracy so trying to fix the 08:26 tope you know voting for Democrats is 08:28 not gonna fix this problem right I I 08:33 don't know Jimmy I gotta say I got a 08:36 belief what's the alternative 08:38 who are we gonna vote for like right now 08:39 in 2018 or in 2020 how do we get to 08:43 where we want to be I don't know the 08:45 answer to that but I see some really 08:47 inspiring candidates who happen to be 08:49 running as Democrats but they're you 08:52 know they're winning seats Jimmy they 08:54 are they're winning 08:55 seats their winning seats in the state 08:56 legislature we just had a big victory 08:58 here in the state of New York yesterday 08:59 we got the IDC 09:01 where we're doing some things it's 09:04 incremental it's frustrating I don't 09:06 know how to do it in one fell swoop but 09:08 I wish we could yeah I know so the 09:10 incremental is we're gonna get us killed 09:14 because climate change is coming so 09:16 incremental ISM isn't working that's 09:19 what we've been doing Bernie now Bernie 09:21 asked for a so you know what Bernie 09:22 would start off his campaign speeches he 09:25 would say sounds like you're ready for a 09:27 revolution and then he turned around and 09:29 back Tillery Clinton and now he's really 09:31 doing incremental ISM like you said 09:32 that's what we're all doing now is 09:33 incremental ISM well when I meant I 09:36 didn't mean incremental ISM in terms of 09:38 what we what we reach for with policy I 09:40 meant incremental victory so you win 09:43 some you lose when we can CRO mental 09:47 progress is what I meant in terms of 09:49 getting the kinds of candidates I think 09:50 you and I both want to see more of 09:52 elected to office yeah okay well it's so 09:57 it's I'm really disappointing it's not 10:01 happening there is no progressive 10:02 takeover of the Democratic Party they've 10:05 met you know how many corporate 10:06 Democrats that they've effectively 10:08 primary one Joe Crowley that's it 10:11 anyway and now as you know Cortes has to 10:13 tell people to vote for Andrew Cuomo 10:15 because she's a Democrat it's gross it's 10:17 disgusting 10:18 you know but anyway that's not I don't 10:20 want you here to talk about economics 10:22 and you did and you did a great job hey 10:24 let me ask I'm here to throw paper 10:25 that's good but can I let me ask you one 10:28 more economic question so now I don't 10:31 want to put my money in the stock like 10:33 so retirement money I'm supposed to put 10:35 my money in 401ks and what do people do 10:37 if the cuz I know it's gonna crash again 10:39 right well it probably will crash again 10:42 but the reality is that it's it will go 10:46 up after it crashes and your young guy 10:48 so but I've been told and isn't this 10:52 true that they've pulled all that 10:53 they've done all the tricks they can and 10:55 because though the interest rates are so 10:57 low so the next time it crashes there is 10:59 less stuff for them to do and it might 11:02 not be it not we might not come out of 11:03 it like we did this last time is that no 11:05 no never 11:07 underestimate the creativity of a 11:08 central banker really oh yeah I mean we 11:12 haven't even warmed up here in the US 11:14 they got some real stuff going on in 11:16 Japan and the ECB and Europe oh yeah 11:19 these other countries central banks are 11:21 buying stocks they're buying corporate 11:24 bonds they will find things to buy for 11:26 lucky maybe they'll buy student loan 11:28 debt and we'll figure out how to get 11:30 them to write it off after they buy it I 11:32 have a paper on that so was Jill Stein 11:35 write about that that the we could have 11:37 done quite enough quantitative easing on 11:39 student debt so she was right in the 11:42 sense that we could cancel it but she 11:45 wasn't right in the way that she talked 11:46 about it because unfortunately she 11:48 talked about it as if you could carry it 11:50 out the same way the Fed did 11:52 quantitative easing quantitative easing 11:54 was an asset swap it was the Fed buying 11:57 Treasuries and mortgage-backed 11:58 securities but it didn't cancel those 12:00 things right people still continue to 12:02 pay their mortgage and so forth so you 12:04 didn't get off the hook as because of 12:06 what the Fed did so in our research 12:09 paper we show how the Fed could actually 12:10 buy the student loan debt and then tell 12:14 students tell people who pay their debt 12:16 you don't have to pay back okay I mean 12:19 the paper walks through how you could 12:20 actually do that really oh yeah okay 12:23 well thanks again for spending this much 12:26 time with us I appreciate you doing this 12:28 and you know you you're the leading 12:30 thinker on this and it's really an honor 12:32 to have you here so thanks for doing 12:33 this I'm happy to do it thanks Jimmy 12:36 okay 12:39 please make sure you're subscribed even 12:42 if you think you are subscribed there's 12:43 a good chance you're not so please check 12:45 it only takes a second and then click 12:47 that bell and that's how you know you'll 12:48 get a notice every time we drop a video 12:50 they still won't notify you every time 12:52 we drop a video but that's the best we 12:54 can do plus if you like the show you 12:56 want to support it please become a 12:57 patron we give you hours of bonus 12:59 material every week and come see a live 13:02 show go to jimmy dore comedy calm for 13:04 our live schedule. 13:05


18:00
返信削除ip service to the deficit right so uh what even dick cheney famously said was quoted as saying deficit reagan proved deficits don't matter because ronald reagan was supposed to be a fiscal conservative but he exploded the deficit and nothing bad happened and that's why cheney said that they don't matter in the sense that they bring about armageddon you know when when when we first uh you know when hamilton first said we're going to buy up some state debts and we're going to have a national debt there was no national debt before hamilton did that so we have a small national debt and of course over time 500 billion becomes a trillion and all the hair is on fire and everybody's saying this is the worst thing in the world it's unsustainable and then a little bit of time passes and it's two and a half then it's five then it's seven everybody's hair on fire then you know obama comes in and we go from seven to 11 to now 15 to 20 to 21 and everybody all along continues to say the end is near this is unsustainable and nothing bad happens right inflation stays right around the fed's two percent target interest rates go wherever the fed tells them to go it's like you know what what is what are we upset about you know so which also pr
チック・チェイニーの有名な言葉に、「レーガンは赤字が問題ではないことを証明した」というものがあります。なぜなら、ロナルド・レーガンは財政保守主義者のはずなのに、赤字を爆発させて何も悪いことが起こらなかったからです。ハミルトンが最初に、州の借金を買い取って国の借金を作ろうと言ったときのことを思い出してみてください。そして、少し時間が経つと、2.5倍になり、5倍になり、7倍になり、みんなの髪の毛が燃え上がります。インフレ率は連邦政府の目標値である2%の周りに留まり、金利は連邦政府が指示するところに行くので、私たちは何に動揺しているのかということになります。
返信削除