2021年9月17日金曜日

IItomo: ミッチェル#29 乗数効果 at once, and orthodoxy, which uses the notion of logical time in its…

IItomo: ミッチェル#29 乗数効果 at once, and orthodoxy, which uses the notion of logical time in its…

と、論理的時間の概念を使って厳密なモデルを作る正統派とがある。論理時間では、最良の取引を得るために、時間を遡って契約を結び直すことができる。ウォルラスの競売人モデルでは、競売人は入札や申し出を受け付けるが、取引可能なすべての財やサービスの均衡価格表が決まるまでは何も起こらない。均衡価格が確定すると、すべての交換が行われます。これにより、不均衡な価格での偽装取引が行われないようになっている。このようなモデルでは、より良い機会があるかもしれないと購入を先延ばしにする理由がないので、お金を使う余地がありません。また、均衡価格は必要な情報をすべて明らかにするので、不確実性もありません。事実上、時間は交換が行われている間の一瞬に縮まります。すべての交換は物々交換になります。対照的に、異端論では、お金が重要です。-クラワーが説明するように、私たちは使うためにお金が必要です。お金で商品を買い、商品でお金を買うが、商品では商品を買えない。-成功をお金で測る。マルクスは、資本主義の生産はM-C-P-C'-M'の形をとっていると主張している。つまり、投入物(C)を購入し、商品(C')を生産するために、後でより多くのお金(M')で売れることを期待して、今、お金(M)が投入されるのである。
-不確実な将来に対してお金を保有することができます。お金は生産プロセスを開始するために必要であり、企業と消費者の両方の支出を賄うために必要です。しかし、お金は決断を先延ばしにすることもできます。お金は安全な保管場所であり、収入と支出の間のリンクを断ち切り、セイの法則を無効にします。不確実性が高まると、同時に流動性への需要も高まり、財やサービスの需要と供給のギャップが大きくなります。お金は決して中立ではありませんが、重要な意味で困難な時代ほど重要なのです。MMTでは、こうした貨幣の機能に加えて、貨幣と主権者の力との関連性を加えていますが、これは他のヘテロドックス的な貨幣へのアプローチや正統派の貨幣にはほとんど見られないものです。国家もまた、その支出を賄う必要があり、公共圏に資源を移すために貨幣システムを組織する上で重要な役割を果たしています。国家が財政的な制約を受けないようにするためには、通貨主権が決定的に重要であるため、貨幣は国家にとっても中立ではありえません。主権通貨の場合、新古典派の考え方である「リカード的等価性」は成り立ちません。政府が支出を増やしたり、税金を減らしたりした場合、民間企業が将来の増税を見越して自らの支出を減らすのは不合理である。ソブリン政府は、今日の支出(または減税)のために将来増税する必要はない。そして実際、現実の世界ではそのようなことはありません。ほとんどのソブリン政府の通常の状況は、ほぼ継続的に赤字を計上し、債務の大部分を返済することは、あったとしてもめったにないことを観察している。これには、第21章で述べた理由があります。いずれにしても、重要なのは、経済をその資源の継続的な完全雇用に近い状態にすることです。

今年使われなかった労働資源は、将来使うために蓄えておくことはできませんし、今年使った労働資源を後から税金でなんとか賄うこともできません。公共部門で使用するために今年動員された資源は、小切手を切ったり、銀行口座をマークアップしたりして、直ちに支払われます。民間企業が、政府支出による収入の増加に反応して、家計や企業の支出を削減するのは非合理的である。むしろ、公的支出の増加に伴って民間支出が増加する方がはるかに合理的である。このような考え方が、ケインズの乗数の概念を支えている。すべてのもっともらしい経験的な見積もりによると、政府支出にはリカード効果ではなく乗数効果があることを示している。

MMTはまた、中央銀行は常にオーバーナイト金利を目標にして運営すると教えているが、これはNMCだけでなくヘテロドックスの考え方とも一致する。しかし、他の条件が同じであれば、財政赤字は超過準備を増加させ、オーバーナイト金利に下方圧力をかけることになるが、これは新古典派のクラウディングアウト理論が示唆する結果とは全く逆である。クラウディングアウト理論では、限られた融資可能な資金をめぐって、政府の借り入れと民間の借り入れが競争すると仮定している。これは、政府金融を完全に誤解しているだけでなく、以下のようにも考えられます。
https://iitomo2010.blogspot.com/2021/09/29-at-once-and-orthodoxy-which-uses.html

ミッチェル#29 乗数効果 at once, and orthodoxy, which uses the notion of logical time in its…

at once, and orthodoxy, which uses the notion of logical time in its rigorous models. In logical time, one can go backward and forward in time to re-contract in order to get the best deals. In the Walrasian auctioneer models, the auctioneer takes bids and offers but nothing happens until the equilibrium price list for all tradeable goods and services is settled. Once equilibrium prices are established, then all exchanges take place. This ensures there is no false price trading at disequilibrium prices. In such models, there is no room for money, since there is no reason to postpone purchases to see whether a better opportunity might come along. And there is no uncertainty because the equilibrium prices reveal all the information that is needed. Effectively, time collapses to the instant during which the exchanges take place. All exchange reduces to barter. By contrast, in heterodoxy, money matters: •We need money to spend, as Clower explains. Money buys goods and goods buy money but goods do not buy goods. •We measure success in terms of money. Marx argues that capitalist production takes the form of M-C-P-C'-M': money (M) is advanced now to buy inputs (C) and produce (P) commodities (C') with an expectation that these can be sold for more money (M') later.

•We can hold money against an uncertain future. Money is needed to start the production process, to finance spending by both firms and consumers. However, money also allows one to defer decisions; it is a safe repository that breaks the link between income and spending, nullifying Say's Law. When uncertainty rises, the demand for liquidity simultaneously rises and there is a growing gap between the supply and demand for goods and services. Money is never neutral, although in an important sense it matters more in troubled times. In addition to these functions of money, MMT adds the link between money and sovereign power, which is largely lacking in other heterodox approaches to money, as well as in orthodoxy. The state also needs to finance its spending and plays an important role in organising the monetary system to move resources to the public sphere. Money cannot be neutral for the state either, since currency sovereignty is critically important to ensure that the state is not financially constrained. The neoclassical notion of Ricardian Equivalence cannot hold in the case of a sovereign currency. If a government spends more or taxes less, it would be irrational for the private sector to cut its own spending in anticipation of future tax hikes. Sovereign governments do not need to raise taxes in the future to pay for spending (or tax cuts) today. And indeed, they do not do so in the real world. We observe that the normal situation for most sovereign governments is to run nearly continuous deficits and rarely, if ever, pay down a significant portion of their debt. This is for reasons discussed in Chapter 21. What matters, in any case, is to run the economy near to continuous full employment of its resources. Any labour resources not used this year cannot be stockpiled for future use, nor can those labour resources used this year be somehow paid for by taxes later. Any resources mobilised this year for use in the public sector are paid for immediately, by cutting cheques or by marking up bank accounts. It would be irrational for the private sector to react to greater receipts from government spending by cutting back household and business spending. Rather, it is far more rational to increase private spending alongside rising public spending. These ideas underpin the concept of the Keynesian multiplier. All plausible empirical estimates demonstrate that there is a multiplier effect, not a Ricardian effect, of government spending. MMT also teaches that central banks always operate with an overnight interest rate target, which is consistent with heterodox as well as NMC thinking. This implies that central banks must coordinate operations with the fiscal authorities, offsetting the effects of fiscal operations on reserves (either by accommodating bank demand or by paying interest on reserves).3 However, all else being equal, budget deficits increase excess reserves that would place downward pressure on overnight rates, which is precisely the opposite result to that implied by the neoclassical crowding-out theory. Crowding-out theory assumes that there is competition between government borrowing and private borrowing for a limited supply of loanable funds. This completely misunderstands government finance, as well as

ーーーー

to increase, capitalist spending must rise. Aggregate profits are determined by total capitalist spending (capitalists get what they spend). This is without reference to micro-level pricing behaviour. If capitalist spending is zero (in the simple model) then aggregate profits are zero. No amount of pricing power can affect aggregate profits in such a condition. How can we reconcile the microeconomic outcomes with the macroeconomic conditions? Given that macro profits are determined by investment in the simple model, micro-level pricing power determines the distribution of profits among capitalists. Those that have more pricing power can get their desired mark-up; those with less market power set lower mark-ups and might even make losses. Obviously, outcomes affect expectations of the future, which in turn, affect investment and thus profits in the future. This means that theorists must be careful in aggregating up from individual decisions, whether they are those of consumers or capitalists. The example of a zero capitalist spending environment demonstrates that administered pricing per se does not create profits. Treatment of money, time and expectations The key components of the 'fundamentalist' Keynesian approach to money include: The presence of true uncertainty. The existence of market institutions, notably money, money contracts, and sticky money wages. Money serves both as a medium of exchange and a store of value. In addition, money must have two essential properties: (a) a negligible elasticity of production, so that minimal labour is required in its production. This means that when the demand for money to hoard rises, and aggregate demand falls, total employment falls; (b) a negligible elasticity of substitution so that when the demand for money to hoard rises, this cannot be satisfied by other goods or assets.

BOX 29.1  WHY DIDN'T KEYNES REJECT PERFECT COMPETITION IN THE GENERAL THEORY? Keynes did not reject the neoclassical assumption of perfect competition. His strategy was usually to accept as much common ground as possible with (neo)Classical thinkers and then to reject only those assumptions that he believed to be critical to the point he was trying to make. His followers are divided on the wisdom of such a strategy. Some, especially those who have read the work of Kalecki, insist that this was a mistake. It would have been much simpler and more realistic to simply reject the notion of perfect competition and instead include different degrees of competition across industries. Even orthodox economists accept the conclusion that in the absence of perfect competition, markets do not clear because the optimal strategy for firms with market power is to restrict output in order to control price. Prices and wages, then, are not set to clear markets. However, Keynesian fundamentalists argue that the degree of competition is irrelevant to his model. All that is needed is that output and employment are both functions of expected effective demand. Then Say's Law is broken. Furthermore, as Keynes argued, wages and prices are sticky: people will not use money contracts nor hold money as a temporary store of purchasing power, unless prices are relatively sticky. They have to have some confidence that flow supply prices do not vary much. Flow supply prices are the prices that are required to induce producers to produce additional output. These prices must be sticky, but at a price high enough to cover costs with a margin. On the other hand, spot prices might be more flexible. These are the current prices at which output can be sold out of inventory. They may not be high enough to induce more production. Only if spot prices rise higher than flow supply prices will more output be forthcoming. So, while spot prices can be relatively flexible, flow supply prices need to be fairly rigid to maintain conditions that are conducive to production. Also Keynes argued, being able to hold money and to write contracts, along with stickiness of price, allows individuals to delay decisions to the future. If money prices could fluctuate wildly, it would be too

risky to hold money in order to delay decisions since one would not know how much the money held would be worth in terms of resources or output. A 'perfect' market in labour with flexible wages would not be compatible with a monetary economy. Money could not serve as the link between the present and the future, unless there is some stickiness. The following propositions result from the key components of the fundamentalist Keynesian approach: If uncertainty exists, then even in the long run, there may be no equilibrium at full employment. The stickiness of the money wage is essential if money is to play its peculiar role of acting as the unit of account in which contracts are written and also serving as a store of value. If wages and prices are fully flexible, then money will not matter in the long run; but something else would take its place. Being able to hold money and to write contracts in money terms, along with stickiness of prices, allows individ-uals to delay decisions to the future. A perfect labour market with flexible wages would not be compatible with a monetary economy. We hold money because we do not trust our guesses about the future and it provides us with a reliable store of value so long as wages and prices are relatively sticky in terms of money. (Note that this does not require that inflation is zero but only that we can with reasonable confidence project money's value into the future.) The existence of true uncertainty makes it impossible to optimise or maximise because we simply do not know the future. Inevitably we undertake decisions by exercising bounded rationality. This might lead us to conclude that the safest thing to do is to fall back on opinions and expectations of others. We use conventions and weight of argument to decide what to do, without knowing if this is optimal. Some post-Keynesians, in particular Paul Davidson, argue that the future is non-ergodic. What this means is that even if we had all the probability distributions for past outcomes, these cannot be applied to the future because the probabilities for the future could be, and probably will be, different from those calculated from the past. The easiest way to think about this is to remember that the future is yet to be created, and no matter what humans have done in the past, they could choose to do something different in the future. To some degree we could say that we know quite a lot about the past and even about the present, but we simply cannot know the future, at least, until it occurs. Minsky had a slightly different view on uncertainty. The uncertainty we face is over the correctness of our model of the way the world works.2 The uncertainty is not just about the data and probabilities, but rather about the correct model of the world. We know our model can be wrong. Hence, we build in margins of error and the best margin of safety is to hold highly liquid assets like cash. It might turn out that our model of the world is wrong, but holding liquid assets provides a cushion of safety. Joan Robinson used to joke that time exists to keep everything from happening at once. This does capture a key difference between heterodoxy, which uses the concept of historical time where everything cannot happen at once, and orthodoxy, which uses the notion of logical time in its rigorous models. In logical time, one can go backward and forward in time to re-contract in order to get the best deals. In the Walrasian auctioneer models, the auctioneer takes bids and offers but nothing happens until the equilibrium price list for all tradeable goods and services is settled. Once equilibrium prices are established, then all exchanges take place. This ensures there is no false price trading at disequilibrium prices. In such models, there is no room for money, since there is no reason to postpone purchases to see whether a better opportunity might come along. And there is no uncertainty because the equilibrium prices reveal all the information that is needed. Effectively, time collapses to the instant during which the exchanges take place. All exchange reduces to barter. By contrast, in heterodoxy, money matters:

•We need money to spend, as Clower explains. Money buys goods and goods buy money but goods do not buy goods.

•We measure success in terms of money. Marx argues that capitalist production takes the form of M-C-P-C'-M': money (M) is advanced now to buy inputs (C) and produce (P) commodities (C') with an expectation that these can be sold for more money (M') later.

•We can hold money against an uncertain future. Money is needed to start the production process, to finance spending by both firms and consumers. However, money also allows one to defer decisions; it is a safe repository that breaks the link between income and spending, nullifying Say's Law. When uncertainty rises, the demand for liquidity simultaneously rises and there is a growing gap between the supply and demand for goods and services. Money is never neutral, although in an important sense it matters more in troubled times. In addition to these functions of money, MMT adds the link between money and sovereign power, which is largely lacking in other heterodox approaches to money, as well as in orthodoxy. The state also needs to finance its spending and plays an important role in organising the monetary system to move resources to the public sphere. Money cannot be neutral for the state either, since currency sovereignty is critically important to ensure that the state is not financially constrained. The neoclassical notion of Ricardian Equivalence cannot hold in the case of a sovereign currency. If a government spends more or taxes less, it would be irrational for the private sector to cut its own spending in anticipation of future tax hikes. Sovereign governments do not need to raise taxes in the future to pay for spending (or tax cuts) today. And indeed, they do not do so in the real world. We observe that the normal situation for most sovereign governments is to run nearly continuous deficits and rarely, if ever, pay down a significant portion of their debt. This is for reasons discussed in Chapter 21. What matters, in any case, is to run the economy near to continuous full employment of its resources. Any labour resources not used this year cannot be stockpiled for future use, nor can those labour resources used this year be somehow paid for by taxes later. Any resources mobilised this year for use in the public sector are paid for immediately, by cutting cheques or by marking up bank accounts. It would be irrational for the private sector to react to greater receipts from government spending by cutting back household and business spending. Rather, it is far more rational to increase private spending alongside rising public spending. These ideas underpin the concept of the Keynesian multiplier. All plausible empirical estimates demonstrate that there is a multiplier effect, not a Ricardian effect, of government spending. MMT also teaches that central banks always operate with an overnight interest rate target, which is consistent with heterodox as well as NMC thinking. This implies that central banks must coordinate operations with the fiscal authorities, offsetting the effects of fiscal operations on reserves (either by accommodating bank demand or by paying interest on reserves).3 However, all else being equal, budget deficits increase excess reserves that would place downward pressure on overnight rates, which is precisely the opposite result to that implied by the neoclassical crowding-out theory. Crowding-out theory assumes that there is competition between government borrowing and private borrowing for a limited supply of loanable funds. This completely misunderstands government finance, as well as monetary policy operations. If interest rates do go up in the presence of budget deficits, it is because the central bank has raised its target rate. Conclusion In this chapter we continued our discussion of the history of economic thought by delving more deeply into the main modern schools of thought. We began with the orthodox approaches, including New Classical, Real Business Cycle, and New Keynesian. We explained how each developed as a response to perceived weaknesses in the older Monetarist and IS-LM approaches, and then looked at the weaknesses in each of these approaches. In the next chapter we will study the current 'synthesis' that attempts to integrate parts of each of these three schools. We next discussed in detail the shared fundamental building blocks of the modern heterodox schools of thought, and briefly contrasted these with the foundations of mainstream, orthodoxy. 


References 

Domar, E.D. (1946) "Capital Expansion, Rate of Growth, and Employment", Econometrica, 14(2), April, 137–47.

Friedman, M. (1968) "The Role of Monetary Policy", The American Economic Review, 58(1), March, 1-–17. Friedman, M. (1970) "The Counter-Revolution in Monetary Theory", IEA Occasional Paper, No. 33, Institute of Economic Affairs. London. Kalecki, M. (1971) Selected Essays on the Dynamics of the Capitalist Economy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.78–9. Lucas, R.E. (1972) "Expectations and the Neutrality of Money", Journal of Economic Theory, 4(2), 103–24. Mankiw, N.G. (2016) Macroeconomics, 9th edn, New York: Worth. Pasinetti, L. (1962) "Rate of profit and Income Distribution in Relation to the Rate of Economic Growth", Review of Economic Studies, XXIX (4), October, 267–279. Sraffa, P. (1960) Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities: Prelude to a Critique of Economic Theory, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Endnotes 1. Aggregate income does not depend on distribution unless capital is homogenous with what Marx called a constant organic composition of capital; this requires essentially the same ratio of hours of labour employed directly in production to the hours of labour embodied in the capital used. On the other hand, Keynes has no such problem in the exposition of the General Theory since he measures everything in labour hours and a nominal wage unit. 2. Minsky credited Lucas and the NC approach for recognising that agents in the model have a model of the model, but he rejected the NC presumption that the model held by agents is the correct one. He argued that in the real world, everybody knows the model held is wrong. This is why it is prudent to hedge one's bets by building in margins of safety. 3. If interest is not paid on reserves, the central bank ensures excess reserves are kept near zero while offering treasury bonds through open market operations as the interest earning alternative. If the central bank pays a rate of interest on reserves equal to the target rate, there is no need to drain excess reserves by offering bonds. Visit the companion website at www.macmillanihe.com/mitchell-macro for additional resources including author videos, an instructor's manual, worked examples, tutorial questions, additional references, the data sets used in constructing various graphs in the text, and more.

3 件のコメント:

  1. これは、政府の財政と金融政策運営を完全に誤解しています。財政赤字の中で金利が上がるとしたら、それは中央銀行が目標金利を引き上げたからです。

    おわりに

    本章では、経済学の歴史に引き続き、現代の主な学派について深く掘り下げていきました。まず、オーソドックスなアプローチとして、新古典派、リアルビジネスサイクル、ニューケインジアンを取り上げました。それぞれのアプローチが、旧来のマネタリストやIS-LMアプローチの弱点を補う形で発展したことを説明し、それぞれのアプローチの弱点を見ていきました。次の章では、これら3つの流派のそれぞれの部分を統合しようとする現在の「統合」について学びます。次に、現代の異端の学派に共通する基本的な構成要素について詳しく説明し、これらを主流の正統派の基礎と簡単に対比させました。

    返信削除
  2. What matters, in any case, is to run the economy near to continuous full employment of its resources. Any labour resources not used this year cannot be stockpiled for future use, nor can those labour resources used this year be somehow paid for by taxes later. Any resources mobilised this year for use in the public sector are paid for immediately, by cutting cheques or by marking up bank accounts. It would be irrational for the private sector to react to greater receipts from government spending by cutting back household and business spending. Rather, it is far more rational to increase private spending alongside rising public spending. These ideas underpin the concept of the Keynesian multiplier. All plausible empirical estimates demonstrate that there is a multiplier effect, not a Ricardian effect, of government spending. MMT also teaches that central banks always operate with an overnight interest rate target, which is consistent with heterodox as well as NMC thinking. This implies that central banks must coordinate operations with the fiscal authorities, offsetting the effects of fiscal operations on reserves (either by accommodating bank demand or by paying interest on reserves).3 However, all else being equal, budget deficits increase excess reserves that would place downward pressure on overnight rates, which is precisely the opposite result to that implied by the neoclassical crowding-out theory. Crowding-out theory assumes that there is competition between government borrowing and private borrowing for a limited supply of loanable funds. This completely misunderstands government finance, as well as monetary policy operations. If interest rates do go up in the presence of budget deficits, it is because the central bank has raised its target rate. Conclusion In this chapter we continued our discussion of the history of economic thought by delving more deeply into the main modern schools of thought. We began with the orthodox approaches, including New Classical, Real Business Cycle, and New Keynesian. We explained how each developed as a response to perceived weaknesses in the older Monetarist and IS-LM approaches, and then looked at the weaknesses in each of these approaches. In the next chapter we will study the current 'synthesis' that attempts to integrate parts of each of these three schools. We next discussed in detail the shared fundamental building blocks of the modern heterodox schools of thought, and briefly contrasted these with the foundations of mainstream, orthodoxy.

    返信削除
  3. いずれにしても、重要なのは、経済をその資源の継続的な完全雇用に近い状態にすることです。今年使われなかった労働資源は、将来使うために蓄えておくことはできませんし、今年使われた労働資源を後から税金でなんとか賄うこともできません。公共部門で使用するために今年動員された資源は、小切手を切ったり、銀行口座をマークアップしたりして、直ちに支払われます。民間企業が、政府支出による収入の増加に反応して、家計や企業の支出を削減するのは非合理的である。むしろ、公的支出の増加に伴って民間支出が増加する方がはるかに合理的である。このような考え方が、ケインズの乗数の概念を支えている。すべてのもっともらしい経験的な見積もりによると、政府支出にはリカード効果ではなく乗数効果があることを示している。MMTはまた、中央銀行は常にオーバーナイト金利を目標にして運営すると教えているが、これはNMCだけでなくヘテロドックスの考え方とも一致する。しかし、他の条件が同じであれば、財政赤字は超過準備を増加させ、オーバーナイト金利に下方圧力をかけることになるが、これは新古典派のクラウディングアウト理論が示唆する結果とは全く逆である。クラウディングアウト理論では、限られた融資可能な資金をめぐって、政府の借り入れと民間の借り入れが競争すると仮定している。これは、政府の財政と金融政策運営を完全に誤解しています。財政赤字の中で金利が上昇するとすれば、それは中央銀行が目標金利を引き上げたからです。おわりに この章では、経済思想史の続きとして、現代の主要な思想家をより深く掘り下げていきました。まず、オーソドックスなアプローチとして、新古典派、リアルビジネスサイクル、ニューケインジアンを取り上げました。それぞれのアプローチが、旧来のマネタリストやIS-LMアプローチの弱点を補う形で発展したことを説明し、それぞれのアプローチの弱点を見ていきました。次の章では、これら3つの流派のそれぞれの部分を統合しようとする現在の「統合」について学びます。次に、現代の異端の学派に共通する基本的な構成要素について詳しく説明し、これらを主流の正統派の基礎と簡単に対比させました。

    返信削除