https://carbonlaw.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/211001-Carbon-language_concept-note.pdf
https://carbonlaw.eu/current
Concept note 2 | Paul Maidowski
01.10.2021, [415.53 ppm CO2]
Learning to cool Earth: systems thinking and mirrors to sustain complex societies
Carbon language | Concept note 2 01.10.2021, [415.53 ppm]
An inability to manage complexity leads to performative governance. To shift to substantive governance, MEER offers institutions ways to rethink or redesign the boundaries of civilization. The underlying question is whether we can govern the technosphere—the built environment— and rebuild the global economy to export entropy at TOA fast enough to cool Earth. This requires shifting away from the current trajectories of overshoot and collapse, first outlined 50 years ago in the global models World Dynamics and Limits to Growth (LTG) (Forrester 1971; Meadows et al. 2004). Carbon language seeks to build mind-sized world models to make such existing knowledge actionable in statecraft and society (Bardi 2013) (see Figures 1 and 2).
Here carbon language and MEER connect: one teaches dynamics, the other shows how to affect them. MEER challenges the key finding in LTG and climate science and policy that we cannot affect Earth's energy imbalance (EEI) directly through positive local action (see Figures 5 and 6). In Dennis Meadows' words, MEER transforms global warming from an intractable global problem that cannot be addressed because CO2 as a persistent pollutant is well mixed in the atmosphere and accumulates for all future human time, exceeding our limits in space and time, into a universal problem (like air pollution) where local action at relevant scales and timescales is possible. This stunning claim deserves critical analysis. Such systemic analysis is indispensable if we hope to moderate the growth and collapse civilization (see Figure 1):
Civilization grows spontaneously; ignoring approaching limits causes collapse
Figure 1: Growth. Civilization G uses energy at rate Ɛ to do reversible work (sustenance) and irreversible work (growth). Reinforcing feedback loop R1 (growth) drives carbon emissions and CO2 levels; ecological pressures erode G and Ɛ, slowing or reversing growth. Thermal inertia in oceans and ice sheets delays feedbacks in R1 by 20-50 years, leading to overshoot and collapse. Balancing loop B1 (current climate policy) increases efficiency and decreases carbonization of energy. It defeats its own stated policy objective because carbon emissions increase when more energy is available to do irreversible work (growth through rebound effects—the Jevons paradox). Balancing loop B2 (mirrors) increases resilience and Earth's albedo while avoiding the delays of the carbon cycle. Like B1, it risks defeating its own policy objective because resilience and climate stabilization allow civilization to continue to sustain itself and grow rather than tip into a phase of sustained collapse. What seems to be required is a mix of decreasing efficiency and growth to build resilience and carbon-free energy technologies extremely fast, while stabilizing Earth to slow carbon cycle disruption. Own illu. (see Garrett 2012; Garrett et al. 2020; Meadows 2018)
カーボン・ランゲージ|コンセプトノート2 2021年10月01日、【415.53ppm】。
複雑性を管理できないと、パフォーマティブ・ガバナンスになる。実質的なガバナンスに移行するために、MEERは文明の境界を再考し、再設計する方法を各機関に提案している。その根底にあるのは、テクノスフィア(構築された環境)を統治し、グローバル経済を再構築して、地球を冷却するのに十分な速さでTOAにおけるエントロピーを輸出できるかどうかという問題である。そのためには、50 年前に世界的なモデルである World Dynamics と Limits to Growth (LTG) (Forrester 1971; Meadows et al. 2004) で初めて示された、オーバーシュートと崩壊という現在の軌道から脱却することが必要です。カーボン・ランゲージは、このような既存の知識を国家運営や社会で実用化するために、マインドサイズの世界モデルを構築しようとしています(Bardi 2013)(図1、図2参照)。
ここで、カーボン・ランゲージとMEERは、一方はダイナミクスを教え、他方はそれにどのように影響を与えるかを示している。MEERは、LTGや気候科学・政策における重要な発見である、地球のエネルギー不均衡(EEI)に積極的な地域活動によって直接影響を与えることはできないということに挑戦しています(図5、6参照)。デニス・メドウズの言葉を借りれば、MEERは地球温暖化を、難分解性の汚染物質であるCO2が大気中によく混ざり、未来の人類の時間すべてにわたって蓄積し、空間的にも時間的にも我々の限界を超えるため対処できない地球規模の問題から、(大気汚染のように)適切なスケールと時間スケールで局所的行動が可能な普遍的問題に変えるものである。この驚くべき主張は、批判的な分析に値する。文明の成長と崩壊を緩やかにするためには、このような体系的な分析が不可欠である(図1参照)。
文明は自然に成長する。限界に近づいていることを無視すると崩壊する。
図1:成長。文明Gは、可逆的な仕事(維持)と不可逆的な仕事(成長)をするために、速度Ɛでエネルギーを使用する。フィードバックループR1(成長)が炭素排出量とCO2濃度を増加させ、生態学的圧力がGとƐを侵食し、成長を減速または反転させる。海洋と氷床の熱慣性により、R1 のフィードバックが 20-50 年遅れ、オーバーシュートと崩壊に至る。ループB1(現在の気候政策)のバランスをとることは、効率を上げ、エネルギーの炭化を減少させる。なぜなら、より多くのエネルギーが不可逆的な仕事(リバウンド効果による成長、ジェボンズのパラドックス)に利用可能になると、炭素排出量が増加するからである。バランスループB2(鏡)は、炭素サイクルの遅れを回避しながら、回復力と地球のアルベドを増加させる。なぜなら、回復力と気候の安定化によって、文明は持続的な崩壊の段階に陥るのではなく、それ自体を維持し、成長し続けることができるようになるからです。必要なのは、炭素循環の崩壊を遅らせるために地球を安定化させながら、レジリエンスとカーボンフリーのエネルギー技術を極めて速く構築するために、効率を下げ、成長を促すという組み合わせだと思われる。自分のイリュージョン (Garrett 2012; Garrett et al. 2020; Meadows 2018 を参照)。
Deep mitigation – Concept note 2 1 I'm telling you that we're putting our children onto a global school bus that will with 98% probability end in a deadly crash. Hans Joachim Schellnhuber, in: We're killing our best friends. (Terra X 2019). [411 ppm CO2] Abstract: This note proposes two projects that aim at deep mitigation, preserving the planet to which life is adapted. One teaches theory, the other shows how to translate theory into practice. The goals are to cool Earth to meet the 1°C climate target and learn to sustain complex societies. (1) Carbon language teaches a basic understanding in dynamic complexity needed to design effective policy. It responds to calls for new language and ways of thinking. A guide to systems thinking is published in print or online ('Learning carbon language in 30 days'). (2) Project MEER:reflection proposes cutting edge climate policy to mitigate heat, the most urgent existential threat to humanity and biosphere. Ground-based glass mirrors redirect solar radiation away from Earth to cool the biosphere, exporting entropy at the top of the atmosphere (TOA) (see Figures 5 and 6). The use of cheap, durable and abundant materials offers states and citizens globally the chance to develop concrete visions for rebuilding the global economy. At a build rate of up to 1000 km2 per day for several decades, MEER is the largest engineering project proposed in history. The hope is to stabilize society and Earth (see Figure 1). Agency and new drivers of change come into focus through MEER. If millions of Fridays for future protesters on average install 10-20 m2 of mirrors every year for several decades to compensate their CO2 emissions, a novel form of public art and protest emerges. The resulting network of millions of mirror fields will cause local cooling and learning effects in education, public policy, and industry. This project tests the idea of social tipping points (Otto et al. 2020). (2a) To make this an option, emergency action needs to start now to build MEER, from technology R&D, modeling, planning, financing to governance and international negotiations. In the race against Arctic tipping points, MEER should be built at scale to refreeze the Arctic. (2b) Planning but not building MEER is possible, if emergency action to redirect the world economy cannot start now. (2c) If MEER is rejected or unworkable, other options are needed. Decarbonization and carbon dioxide removal cannot replace solar radiation management. The plausible global alternative, stratospheric aerosol injection (SAI), is transient and controversial. Recommendation: Slow or sub-scale action will not stop the disintegration of Earth's system. Starting MEER in several decades, after modern civilization collapses in Pliocene to Eocenelike climates, bears tremendous risk. Option (2a) and Arctic refreezing are strongly preferred. Next steps differ by actor but a focus on analysis, systemic risk & systems thinking affects all. 1Paul Maidowski. Learning to cool Earth: systems thinking and mirrors to sustain complex societies. Deep mitigation - Concept note 2. 1 October 2021. Available at: https://carbonlaw.eu/current 2See also the literature outlined in: PM. Sustaining civilization while stabilizing Earth: Adaptive mitigation. Concept note 1. 2 May 2021. Available at: https://carbonlaw.eu/current. 1/15 2

0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿