| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
42:16
The past several years shocked both our national and global economies. As the government undertakes massive spending programs to counteract the damage, the national debt, the deficit, and inflation have become issues of national debate. We’ve invited Stephanie Kelton, author of The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People's Economy to take us behind the rhetoric and make the case for a different way of looking at the way we raise and spend money at the federal level.
この数年、我が国のみならず世界経済にも衝撃が走りました。政府はそのダメージに対抗するために大規模な支出計画を実施し、国の借金、赤字、インフレが国民的な議論になっています。今回は、『The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People's Economy』の著者であるステファニー・ケルトン氏をお招きし、レトリックの背後にある、連邦レベルでのお金の調達と消費の方法について、異なる観点から論じていただくことになりました。
if you haven't heard about anchor let me
tell you a little bit about it it is the
easiest way to make a podcast
i've just joined and i can't tell you
how much i love it and here's a few
reasons why it's free
it's super easy to create and record
podcasts right from your computer
literally anyone can do it
anchor handles all of the distribution
all you have to do is record or upload
your podcast
and then they send it out to spotify and
apple podcasts and everywhere else and
get this anchor can help you get paid
for podcasting without any minimum
listener number
everything you need to make your podcast
is in one place at anchor
download the free anchor app or go to
anchor dot fm to get started
hello it's alyssa milano and i can't
wait for you to read my new book sorry
not sorry it's a collection of essays
where i share my unapologetic thoughts
on life culture activism and motherhood
you'll learn some things about me that i
know you've never heard before and share
in my story as an activist this book is
such a big part of my heart and so are
you and thank you for that sorry not
sorry is available now everywhere books
are sold
[Music]
hi i'm alyssa milano and this is sorry
not sorry
[Music]
the past several years shocked both our
national and global economies
as the government undertakes massive
spending programs to counteract the
damage the national debt the deficit and
inflation have become issues of national
debate i've invited stephanie kelton
author of the deficit myth modern
monetary theory and the birth of the
people's economy to take us behind the
rhetoric and make the case for a
different way of looking at the way we
raise and spend money at the federal
level
when things break
we have an opportunity
we can pick up the pieces and put them
back together the old way
or we can look for better ways to build
west virginia senator joe manchin
dealing a devastating blow to his
party's nearly two trillion dollar top
priority sinking build back better bill
in a sunday interview i cannot vote to
continue with this piece of legislation
i just can't new numbers tonight show an
inflationary wave is still building in
the u.s economy the labor department
reports consumer prices jumped more than
six percent in october from a year ago
that was the biggest increase in 31
years we've been seeing once again the
calls that oh we're going to have a debt
problem and the deficit is blowing up
uh how should we be thinking about
things instead i'm stephanie kelton and
i'm a professor of economics and public
policy at stony brook university and i'm
fighting to show why money is really no
object for the federal government and
why anything we can actually do as a
people we can afford as a nation
sorry
not sorry
[Music]
thank you so much for joining us i'm
sorry not sorry before we get started i
think it would be super useful to just
have a quick vocabulary lesson on some
economic terms that many people probably
don't no don't understand so will you
help us out with some words can you
explain what the national debt
the deficit and inflation each mean
okay since inflation is on everyone's
mind let's do that one first
so
when economists talk about inflation
first thing you should know is that we
have all these different ways of
measuring inflation so if somebody asks
you what is the inflation rate you could
give them
seven or ten different answers and all
of them would be correct
so what do we mostly mean we mostly mean
that prices are going up and not just
the price of one or two things but
the prices of things just generally in
the economy so we construct these things
called price indices and people maybe
have heard of a cpi
a consumer price index that's the most
popular one
and it's just a basket of goods that is
supposed to represent the average buying
behavior of a consumer so we typically
spend things money on things like
housing
and transportation and food and
entertainment and so it's like what does
the average consumer spend money on each
month and then we put all those things
in a basket and we track the movement in
the prices of all the things inside the
basket over time to see if the basket of
goods is getting more expensive
less expensive around the same cost and
when things generally are getting more
and more expensive then we say that
there is consumer inflation
okay and debt national debt okay let's
do the deficit first because then that
leads us into the debt so the deficit is
just the difference between two numbers
that makes it really easy okay so this
thing we call the government deficit is
the difference between how many dollars
the government spends into the economy
each year
versus how many dollars the government
subtracts back out of the economy mostly
through taxation so to keep the numbers
really simple if the government were to
spend a hundred dollars into the economy
and only tax ninety dollars back out we
would say the government has run a
deficit and we would say the deficit is
ten we might write a minus ten and say
the government's budget is in deficit
they spent more than their tax revenue
debt okay so the deficit happens each
year every year we get a figure for the
government deficit the difference
between how much they spent that year
and how much they collected in taxes
national debt is the historical record
it's like looking in the rear view
mirror and saying from the beginning of
the country's inception
how many times has the government run a
deficit so it's like a running total it
tells you
the history of all the times the
government added more dollars to the
economy than it subtracted back out so
the way i think about this thing we call
the national debt
is it's just the dollars that were spent
into the economy but not taxed back out
and they currently exist in the form of
u.s government bonds called treasuries
so it's the treasury bond market that
people are really talking about when
they talk about the national debt and
what about the relationship between the
debt and the deficit
so when the government is running
deficits each year it means it is
increasing the number of dollars it
spends into the economy
less taxes so the national debt is
increasing but remember
the deficit itself is like a deposit of
dollars into the economy so when the
government is depositing more and more
dollars into the economy each year
the historical record of that the
national debt increases
you argue
actually that managing economies at the
state and local level is fundamentally
different from doing so at the national
level can you explain the main
difference for my listeners
yes
so the main difference is that the
federal government's budget
works differently that congress has
something called the power of the purse
okay they are the issuer think of the
federal government as the issuer of our
currency in fact you and i can't create
the us dollar right if we try to
manufacture the dollar it's called
counterfeiting it's illegal we go to
jail
mayors and governors
can't manufacture the currency if they
could then when covet hit mayors would
have taken care of their own city
budgets and governors would have taken
care of their own state budgets but they
couldn't they needed the federal
government to step in provide some
support and so why is the federal
government able to do what states and
local governments can't do
and the answer is the government is the
issuer of the dollar
when the economy screeched to a halt in
mid-march businesses shut down almost
overnight and quickly millions of
workers became unemployed
within weeks the government moved to
provide trillions of dollars of stimulus
relief to workers and businesses
throughout the economy
twelve hundred dollar checks to anyone
who makes less than seventy five
thousand dollars this is another six
hundred dollars a week for four months
congress approving another
484 billion dollars for loans
so where does all this money come from
is it taxpayer funds is the government
printing a bunch of new cash
as you might expect there's a lot more
to know and state and local governments
like the rest of us are what i call a
user of the currency or user of the
dollar they can't manufacture it they
don't have the ability to issue the
currency so they have to go out and get
it from somewhere and the main place
that cities and states get their
currency is from the rest of us in the
form of tax payments property tax sales
tax income tax and the like
okay and you touched on this a little
bit but just to go more in depth how
does increased federal spending
potentially lead to
inflation
it's not just federal spending that
could create inflationary pressures it's
any spending and so what you're seeing
right now for example is a lot of us
have been trying to buy a lot of goods
through the pandemic we spent less money
on things like services going to the
salon going to hotels and restaurants
and bars and we spent more on cars and
computers and furniture turning our
spare bedrooms into home offices and
that sort of thing so goods have to be
produced and manufactured and shipped
and so as many of us spent more on goods
that created some supply pressure some
bottlenecks and it created some
inflationary pressures so it's not just
government spending it's any form of
spending that can lead to inflationary
pressures
but government could potentially be a
source of inflation if the government
had sent out let's say 14 000 checks
instead of 1400 checks to most people in
march of this year you can imagine the
potential for much higher inflation as a
result of that
[Music]
is music a big part of your life well
let me tell you about anchor spotify's
podcasting platform it's free there are
creation tools that allow you to easily
and quickly record and edit right from
your phone or computer
best of all with anger you can create a
music plus talk show with music plus
talk you can add any songs from spotify
directly to your episodes alongside talk
segments featuring your commentary music
plus talk is a whole new way to create
with all of the music that you love and
anchor will even help publish your show
to spotify so you can reach hundreds of
millions of listeners so you got an idea
for music plus talk show just head over
to anchor dot fm slash music plus talk
that's anchor dot f m slash m u s
i c p l u s
t a l k to sign up for anchor
and make your own music plus talk show
for free
i want to switch gears for a second and
discuss in an op-ed in the new york
times back in april you discussed the
president's infrastructure plan and you
wrote that democrats are thinking about
fiscal responsibility the wrong way
how so
well
because
what we often hear and what we're
hearing from the administration right
now frankly is that the buildback better
act is fiscally responsible because it's
quote unquote paid for and what that
means in washington speak
is that it doesn't increase the deficit
that the government has a plan
to remove a dollar from someone's hands
for every dollar that they plan to spend
into someone else's hands so what
president biden has said is
i'd like to do
child care i'd like to do elder care i
would like to make two years of college
free i'd like to spend money in all
these different ways that strengthen the
social safety net and help build a
better economy and to keep all of that
spending from increasing the government
deficit i'm gonna remove money from
people who make more than four hundred
thousand dollars a year from big
corporations and so forth that keeps the
spending deficit neutral it means that
it doesn't have an impact on the
government's budget and what i suggested
in that piece is that's the wrong way to
think about fiscal responsibility
there's nothing inherently irresponsible
about doing things the way congress did
the cares act in march of last year that
was 2.2 trillion dollars of spending it
all added to the deficit and i would
argue that it was fiscally responsible
to do that
so what's not fiscally responsible
is pushing the economy too far is
spending too much into an economy that
can't safely absorb that spending and
causing an inflation problem in other
words the way to evaluate whether the
government is being responsible when it
passes legislation isn't to say does it
add to the deficit oh that's bad it's
does the spending create other problems
in the economy does it exacerbate income
inequality does it fuel inflation that
would be a problem in the economy that
sort of thing so we're just thinking the
wrong way about what it means to manage
the government's spending in a
responsible way yeah i think though that
when you're dealing with such
unprecedented times to look at the
responsibility of our government
and what we need
to come out of this not only as a nation
that is okay but one that actually comes
out of it
better off than when we went into it i
think part of
this and i think part of the insecurity
of the country that we are seeing now i
think a lot of people are seeing it for
the very first time even though you know
as activists we've been saying that it's
been there for years i do have to say
the recognition about the word
responsibility and what the government
is supposed to help the people of its
country with i think is it's really
important and to be able to
to look back on this time and say we had
to take risks because this was such an
unprecedented time but this is what came
out of it that was really positive and i
think we will see people's lives change
from buildback better i don't i'm not
necessarily sure
what it means for the fiscal
responsibility of our of our government
and
our financial institutions but i do
think
it will
impact people's lives and at the end of
the day
isn't that what we should be doing
yes it is and i would argue that you're
exactly right in terms of the way we
should be thinking about and evaluating
these government interventions you know
did they lift people up did they save
jobs did they help families hold
together through the pandemic did they
lift kids out of poverty
and maybe most importantly
thanks to the american rescue plan we're
on track
to cut child poverty in america in half
this year
[Applause]
and then the process
all this was all going on the economy
created
more than 1 million
300 000 new jobs in 100 days
you look at what we actually
accomplished and as an economist i
marvel i do marvel at what the
government did this time because it's so
different
how congress responded after the
financial crisis in 2007-2008
that was a one-and-done they did a
fiscal package and then they sort of
just walked away from it this time you
know i mentioned earlier the cares act
that was immediately as soon as the
pandemic hit in march of last year
congress just without hesitation or
delay cranked out a 2.2 trillion dollar
package and you remember that included
1200 dollar checks that went to most
people it included
600
a week in federal unemployment insurance
for people who lost jobs in the pandemic
and it expanded the unemployment
benefits to include people who were
previously left out like gig workers and
so forth so for the very first time we
had a recession a serious downturn in
the economy and poverty rates went down
not up as unemployment increase and then
congress came back in march of last year
and did another package 900 billion and
then they came back in march of this
year with only democrats supporting it
and did 1.9 trillion and this is when we
got the child tax credit and so you've
got a lot of families now who are
receiving millions of people getting 300
a week to help with a child some people
who have two or three kids are getting
six or nine hundred dollars a week and
we have lifted almost half of the kids
in this country out of poverty with a
single provision in a piece of
legislation and so you look at that and
you say that expires this month in
december right it's the end of the year
it expires now congress has the
opportunity in the buildback better act
to make sure it doesn't expire and you
think how could they not when the choice
is to let all of these kids fall back
into poverty or simply extend that
provision it seems like it ought to be a
no-brainer
i know this is probably a big ass but
can you briefly explain what modern
monetary theory is to our listeners
yeah it's so when you think about
economics i mean if to the extent that
people think about economics there are
all these different schools of thought
maybe people have heard of like the
austrian school or um the keynesian
school of economics modern monetary
theory is a school of economic thought
it's a framework it's a way of thinking
about the economy it's basically a
framework that emphasizes the fact
that the us government is no longer on a
gold standard our currency the us dollar
is not tethered to gold or to any other
finite uh resource something that you
could run out of we have what's called a
floating exchange rate a fiat currency
and mmt or modern monetary theory is
about describing how the monetary system
works now since nixon took us off the
gold standard in 1971
and says okay we should recognize that
the monetary system works different now
that there's more policy space available
to use fiscal and monetary policy to
uplift our people to accomplish more and
the government's budget doesn't work
like a household budget and mmt is about
explaining why that's so
and how would applying it to our
economic policy change how our economy
and how our government manages it
if you're trapped in a gold standard
framework then you're asking questions
like where will we find the money to pay
for that so someone has a great idea
like keeping kids out of poverty
repairing infrastructure providing some
free college or health care for all and
the first question everyone asks is how
are you going to pay for it where is the
money going to come from you literally
hear politicians say how will you find
the money as if we're still on a gold
standard as if you actually have to go
find gold and discover money in order to
pay for things so mmt shifts that
thinking it says that asking how will
you pay for it is the wrong question
it turns out
that finding the money is the easy part
the hard part is managing our real
resources so mmt would have us ask not
how will you pay for it but how will you
resource it if you want universal health
care for example it's easy for congress
to simply pay the medical bills and
cover the pharmaceutical drug costs and
so forth and reimburse pharma company
that's easy to do the hard part if
you're promising health care for
everyone is making sure that you have
enough doctors and nurses and hospital
beds and
specialists mental health care
professionals and all the rest of it
because what you're really promising is
to deliver something real the financing
is the easy part but how will you
resource it if you want free college the
hard part is making sure you have enough
faculty and staff and
classrooms and dormitories and all of
the things that you need to deliver
healthcare or free college right so mmt
just helps us by getting the easy part
out of the way how will you pay for it
and then it becomes about managing
inflation risk and real resources
and in your book the deficit myth which
i really enjoyed you argued that a
federal deficit is actually healthy for
an economy can you go into that a little
bit
yes so look what i like to say is that
really
deficit is totally thinking right now is
the concept of the government's deficit
and the reason is that governments
around the world are increasing their
deficit spending right now and that has
the potential to make a lot of people
nervous
and we don't want that and it's
important that we're able to breathe
through this moment and to start to
think about and look at government
deficits in a new way
[Music]
that's what people need to understand
every deficit is good for someone why
because go back to the definition of the
deficit the difference between two
numbers right how many dollars the
government spends into the economy
compared to how many dollars they
subtract back out
mostly through taxation so when the
government does this thing called
running a deficit it just means that
they are adding more than they're
subtracting
so if the government is adding more than
it's subtracting what it means is that
someone's getting something the
government's deficits appear as
financial surpluses in some other part
of the economy think about the
republican tax cuts in 2017 donald trump
is president republicans control the
house and the senate and they push
through these huge tax cuts not because
they think and they know that it's going
to add close to 2 trillion to the
deficit they don't do that thinking oh
this is going to be bad for someone they
do that knowing this is going to be good
for someone right our deficits the
government's deficits are the surpluses
that go somewhere else in the economy a
government deficit is a financial
contribution it's like the government
making a deposit into some other part of
the economy so when republicans run
deficits they like to divert that
surplus into the hands of the people who
frankly least need the help the windfall
goes to the people at the very top goes
to big corporations but look at the
cares act or look at the 1.9 trillion
dollar covid bill that was done under
the bidet administration with democrats
only that 1.9 trillion went to a very
different constituency both deficits
were good for someone but they were good
for very different groups of the
population
thank you for explaining that that makes
a lot of sense so i guess my next
question is then why do some of those on
the right and by saying those on the
right i'm also including joe manchin and
kristen cinema and other conservative
democrats in this group why do they
insist that it is so dangerous
well i think it's an excuse i think it's
a convenient excuse because
not enough of the american population
has
been educated about the way a government
deficit works and so most americans
still think that a government deficit is
evidence of some kind of fiscal
irresponsibility that the government's
not managing its budget the way it ought
to it's being irresponsible so if
somebody like joe manchin says gee i
don't know if i can support this next
round of spending because it adds to the
deficit he can come across as
kind of the grown-up in the room as very
sensible whether he believes it or not i
don't know i think that maybe he does i
i know for a fact that he's got us an
aide a senior aide who every day
sends him an update i think a text
message
on how much the national debt has
increased compared to yesterday so
literally 24-hour updates so it's
possible that he's a true believer i
don't know but i do know that the
deficit and the national debt are very
convenient political excuses that allow
lawmakers to say look i would love to
support
child care and elder care and all the
rest of the stuff but i i just can't
bring myself to vote for this because we
got to worry about the national debt we
got to worry about the deficit and it's
like a get out of jail free card for
these guys
it really is amazing to me to think that
anyone could vote against
a their own self-interest right when you
see
the american people go to the polls but
also how an elected official could vote
against the best interest of their
constituents it's just mind-boggling to
me i like to think that they all have
these hearts of service and they lead
from a place of service and maybe that's
how they all got in there but at a
certain point
you look at people like mansion and
cinema i just marvel at their inability
to
do what is right for their constituents
i have the trillion dollar question for
you are you ready
it may be a dumb question ring it
so if
i've always wondered this if a federal
government can just create more money to
do the things it wants to do is money
even like a real thing why do we have it
at all and really why have any
limitations on it
well so humans made it up either there
are no two ways about that money does
not exist in nature humans had to invent
this thing
and governments invented
currencies historically because they
wanted to we could say provision
themselves with certain things a
government might want a standing army or
infrastructure roads and things like
that
and you need people to build these
things and to be fighters in your army
and so forth and so how do you do that
one way to do it is to compel people to
work and provide the state with the
resources it wants by imposing taxes and
that's what happened historically
governments impose obligations on a
population it could be a tax or a fee or
a fine or any other kind of financial
obligation and say you have to pay me
in this currency and the people then say
i don't have the currency and the
government then says oh i can help you
with that i will hire you to fight in my
army or build my infrastructure i will
pay you in this currency that i created
and invented and then you give me back a
portion of it to settle your obligation
your tax or your fees or whatever to the
state and so the reason really that we
have money in from inception is because
some entity
early entities before states even but
later states wanted to provide
themselves provision themselves with
resources and the currency was the way
to do that
but why can't we just make more
well we do and that's the point right
we've just been talking about
basically 5 trillion in change
that congress has had manufactured
on its behalf right on behalf of the u.s
treasury we created the government
created more than five trillion dollars
to shore up the economy to help us you
know through the pandemic not that we're
through the pandemic obviously we are
not through the pandemic but these bills
that congress writes are basically a set
of instructions that go to the
government's bank the federal reserve
and the legislation says to the fed get
ready we are ordering a brief lesson on
the federal reserve system or 1.9
trillion reserve or the fed is the
central bank of the united states as the
central bank it determines our nation's
monetary policy this means the fed
determines how much money is floating
around in the u.s economic ecosystem
ready to be spent on goods or services
by controlling the money supply the fed
is able to influence both interest rates
and the health of the overall economy
the fed's goal is to keep two important
economic metrics in check unemployment
and inflation
and that's where it comes from the the
fed's job is to make all of the payments
that have been authorized by congress on
behalf of the u.s treasury and they do
that i don't hope i don't scare anyone
they do that using nothing more than a
computer keyboard to change the numbers
in the bank account in the appropriate
direction so when that twelve hundred
dollar check goes out somebody's typing
the numbers in and the balance in
somebody's account increases by twelve
hundred dollars so we do
make the money
as congress authorizes
it's so outside of what i do i can't
even wrap my head around it but i do
want to i want to talk more about and we
touched on it before but i want to talk
more about the inflation that america is
currently experiencing because i think
it's
being used as a talking point from the
right and i think it's scaring the
people on the left so just go through
how bad is it and should the government
even be doing something to rain it in
okay so how bad is it it depends who you
are people don't like to pay more for
gas for example and it's hard on some
people right when you're used to paying
let's say 40 to fill up the tank and
maybe you have to drive long distances
to work and all of a sudden it's 85
that's a real hardship for people it's a
hardship when people are not making a
living wage as well exactly so for
people who are on a very tight budget
when food prices go up even what might
to us seem like a fairly small increase
in prices for a lot of people that's a
big bite out of the household budget
so the question i guess is what is
causing what's driving all of this
inflation and i think that most
economists and other experts
agree that you know but for covid we
don't have an inflation problem we don't
have inflation running at 6.2 percent
which is where we are today but for
covet so what happened well the economy
is a global economy first of all and it
doesn't work like your car i could take
my car park it in the garage throw the
keys in a drawer go to europe for 18
months come back pull the keys out stick
it in the ignition start the car and
drive off and everything would work
perfectly you can't do that with an
economy you can't shut down parts of the
economy pack on and expect everything to
just work right away it doesn't work
like that so
the pandemic created what everybody is
hearing about which are all of these
problems in the supply chain we have for
decades seen corporations
decide how am i going to produce
whatever it is a car or computers or
iphones or whatever it is how do i want
to produce my stuff and they said well
i want to try to produce it at the
lowest possible cost i want to look for
parts in the world where environmental
standards are the weakest i wanna so i'm
gonna split up production and do a
little bit here in this country and a
little bit here in this country and then
i'm gonna have the parts assembled and
put together and then eventually i'm
gonna have a whole car at the end of the
day right but the chips are manufactured
in southeast asia and this other thing
is manufacturing this other country and
when there's a break in the supply chain
because there's a coveted outbreak in
vietnam or malaysia and they shut a
factory down and they're not producing
the computer chips because the
semiconductor plant is shut down then
the auto manufacturer can't get the
parts they need to finish producing and
so prices go up when you say what should
we be doing about the inflation it
almost is more like saying what should
we be doing to end the pandemic globally
because you don't get out of this until
the pandemic is under control you're not
we're not going to escape this we're
going to have supply chain problems
which means we're going to have
inflation problems for as long as we
have a covet problem
and we've seen huge profiteers during
these crises especially during the
pandemic
and i'm just always struck by this stat
that fewer than a thousand americans now
hold more than two-thirds of our
national wealth
how
does that happen and how badly does it
hurt us
it happens over a long period of time
and through many different mechanisms
some people would say it's basically
that the economy has been rigged in
favor of large corporations and of the
wealthy many of whom draft the
legislation that ends up benefiting them
whether it's the trade laws the tax laws
uh labor laws we have built a system
over a period of decades you can call it
shifting to a neo-liberal economic
philosophy but that's what we've done we
have created a system that enables the
accumulation of wealth by a smaller and
smaller group of people and it rises to
the very top how does it happen it
happens because those who are producing
the output the income the revenue that
becomes the profits are producing more
and more profit that is going to those
at the very top
and they're writing the rules
i think that's the most important part
there was a recent report that showed
that new housing construction is
starting to contract
and i think part of that is because
there's a lack of physical and human
resources you've argued that the federal
government should consider loosening
immigration laws as an economic decision
can you explain that and tell us
what it would mean for our economy
sure
so
i think there are easy ways to argue in
favor of different immigration policy
independent of saying we need more
workers okay but that was just one thing
that i included in that piece that you
referred to earlier
people are all hearing about labor
shortages i don't think there's a labor
shortage i think what we have is a
shortage of employers who are prepared
to pay the wages and provide the safety
measures and so forth that will bring
workers into the labor force and willing
to take some of these jobs but if you
believe that we actually have a problem
of not enough workers to do the work
that needs to be done then an obvious
solution is that there are millions of
people around the world who would love
nothing more than to come to this
country and work and contribute take
jobs and so immigration policy is just
low-hanging fruit in terms of how to
accommodate
the need for more workers
and my last question which i ask to all
of my guests
is what gives you hope
young people who i think see the world
that they're inheriting and
they don't want that world
and they're willing to stand up and and
to fight for the kind of world that they
want they don't accept excuses they
don't accept no
they look at what's happening with
climate i think in particular and
they're terrified and they're willing to
stand up and say that there is no way
that we're going to let this happen and
so young people give me hope
stephanie kelton you give me hope thank
you for all you do and for being a part
of the podcast here in the u.s so much
for having around the world
governments did some extraordinary
things
they sent money to people directly to
help them buy food and pay rent they
provided free covid testing and expanded
health care to cover more of the
population
they gave money to businesses to help
keep them afloat while much of the
economy was temporarily shut down
they offered debt relief to millions of
people who borrowed money to go to
college
they did all of this
and more
without raising taxes
or having a prolonged battle over the
usual question
of how to pay for it
to me
this was exciting
and i'm an economist so i don't say that
a lot
[Music]
who is the economy for
those on the right through the policy
they support seem to think that the
economy is for the very richest
americans a recent article on
inequality.org revealed that the richest
745 americans hold about five trillion
dollars in wealth the rest of america
holds about three trillion if you want
to talk about a deficit
there it is
there is a wealth deficit
in america where the richest are
hoarding the money we do have and making
it harder for the rest of us to afford
things
fewer than 1 000 people hold about
two-thirds of our wealth
think about that
and think about how damaging it is to
our economy to our communities and to
our families
we can do better we have enough money in
america and a near unlimited ability
to make more
but if it keeps going to the people who
already have more money than some entire
nations
then what the hell are we even doing
we need monetary policy that works for
the 330 million
not for the less than 1 thousand
that would make america great again
sorry not sorry is executive produced by
alyssa milano that's me our producer is
ben jackson audio editing and
engineering by mache lewandowski and
music by josh cook alicia eagle and milo
bouliari
don't forget to rate review and spread
the word
sorry
not sorry.
all you have to do is record or upload 00:29 your podcast 00:30 and then they send it out to spotify and 00:32 apple podcasts and everywhere else and 00:36 get this anchor can help you get paid 00:38 for podcasting without any minimum 00:41 listener number 00:42 everything you need to make your podcast 00:45 is in one place at anchor 00:48 download the free anchor app or go to 00:50 anchor dot fm to get started 00:55 hello it's alyssa milano and i can't 00:58 wait for you to read my new book sorry 01:00 not sorry it's a collection of essays 01:02 where i share my unapologetic thoughts 01:05 on life culture activism and motherhood 01:08 you'll learn some things about me that i 01:10 know you've never heard before and share 01:12 in my story as an activist this book is 01:15 such a big part of my heart and so are 01:17 you and thank you for that sorry not 01:19 sorry is available now everywhere books 01:21 are sold 01:25 [Music] 01:33 hi i'm alyssa milano and this is sorry 01:37 not sorry 01:40 [Music] 01:59 the past several years shocked both our 02:01 national and global economies 02:04 as the government undertakes massive 02:06 spending programs to counteract the 02:08 damage the national debt the deficit and 02:11 inflation have become issues of national 02:14 debate i've invited stephanie kelton 02:16 author of the deficit myth modern 02:19 monetary theory and the birth of the 02:21 people's economy to take us behind the 02:24 rhetoric and make the case for a 02:27 different way of looking at the way we 02:29 raise and spend money at the federal 02:32 level 02:35 when things break 02:37 we have an opportunity 02:39 we can pick up the pieces and put them 02:41 back together the old way 02:44 or we can look for better ways to build 02:46 west virginia senator joe manchin 02:48 dealing a devastating blow to his 02:50 party's nearly two trillion dollar top 02:52 priority sinking build back better bill 02:55 in a sunday interview i cannot vote to 02:58 continue with this piece of legislation 03:00 i just can't new numbers tonight show an 03:03 inflationary wave is still building in 03:05 the u.s economy the labor department 03:08 reports consumer prices jumped more than 03:10 six percent in october from a year ago 03:13 that was the biggest increase in 31 03:16 years we've been seeing once again the 03:18 calls that oh we're going to have a debt 03:20 problem and the deficit is blowing up 03:22 uh how should we be thinking about 03:24 things instead i'm stephanie kelton and 03:26 i'm a professor of economics and public 03:28 policy at stony brook university and i'm 03:30 fighting to show why money is really no 03:33 object for the federal government and 03:35 why anything we can actually do as a 03:37 people we can afford as a nation 03:40 sorry 03:41 not sorry 03:42 [Music] 03:45 thank you so much for joining us i'm 03:47 sorry not sorry before we get started i 03:49 think it would be super useful to just 03:52 have a quick vocabulary lesson on some 03:55 economic terms that many people probably 03:58 don't no don't understand so will you 04:01 help us out with some words can you 04:03 explain what the national debt 04:06 the deficit and inflation each mean 04:10 okay since inflation is on everyone's 04:13 mind let's do that one first 04:15 so 04:16 when economists talk about inflation 04:18 first thing you should know is that we 04:20 have all these different ways of 04:21 measuring inflation so if somebody asks 04:23 you what is the inflation rate you could 04:25 give them 04:26 seven or ten different answers and all 04:29 of them would be correct 04:30 so what do we mostly mean we mostly mean 04:33 that prices are going up and not just 04:35 the price of one or two things but 04:38 the prices of things just generally in 04:41 the economy so we construct these things 04:44 called price indices and people maybe 04:46 have heard of a cpi 04:47 a consumer price index that's the most 04:50 popular one 04:51 and it's just a basket of goods that is 04:53 supposed to represent the average buying 04:57 behavior of a consumer so we typically 05:00 spend things money on things like 05:02 housing 05:03 and transportation and food and 05:06 entertainment and so it's like what does 05:08 the average consumer spend money on each 05:10 month and then we put all those things 05:12 in a basket and we track the movement in 05:15 the prices of all the things inside the 05:18 basket over time to see if the basket of 05:20 goods is getting more expensive 05:22 less expensive around the same cost and 05:26 when things generally are getting more 05:28 and more expensive then we say that 05:30 there is consumer inflation 05:33 okay and debt national debt okay let's 05:36 do the deficit first because then that 05:37 leads us into the debt so the deficit is 05:41 just the difference between two numbers 05:43 that makes it really easy okay so this 05:45 thing we call the government deficit is 05:48 the difference between how many dollars 05:50 the government spends into the economy 05:53 each year 05:54 versus how many dollars the government 05:56 subtracts back out of the economy mostly 05:59 through taxation so to keep the numbers 06:01 really simple if the government were to 06:03 spend a hundred dollars into the economy 06:06 and only tax ninety dollars back out we 06:09 would say the government has run a 06:10 deficit and we would say the deficit is 06:13 ten we might write a minus ten and say 06:16 the government's budget is in deficit 06:18 they spent more than their tax revenue 06:21 debt okay so the deficit happens each 06:23 year every year we get a figure for the 06:26 government deficit the difference 06:28 between how much they spent that year 06:30 and how much they collected in taxes 06:32 national debt is the historical record 06:36 it's like looking in the rear view 06:37 mirror and saying from the beginning of 06:40 the country's inception 06:42 how many times has the government run a 06:45 deficit so it's like a running total it 06:47 tells you 06:48 the history of all the times the 06:51 government added more dollars to the 06:52 economy than it subtracted back out so 06:55 the way i think about this thing we call 06:57 the national debt 06:59 is it's just the dollars that were spent 07:01 into the economy but not taxed back out 07:04 and they currently exist in the form of 07:07 u.s government bonds called treasuries 07:10 so it's the treasury bond market that 07:13 people are really talking about when 07:14 they talk about the national debt and 07:17 what about the relationship between the 07:20 debt and the deficit 07:22 so when the government is running 07:24 deficits each year it means it is 07:26 increasing the number of dollars it 07:29 spends into the economy 07:32 less taxes so the national debt is 07:34 increasing but remember 07:36 the deficit itself is like a deposit of 07:39 dollars into the economy so when the 07:41 government is depositing more and more 07:43 dollars into the economy each year 07:45 the historical record of that the 07:48 national debt increases 07:51 you argue 07:52 actually that managing economies at the 07:55 state and local level is fundamentally 07:57 different from doing so at the national 08:00 level can you explain the main 08:02 difference for my listeners 08:04 yes 08:05 so the main difference is that the 08:07 federal government's budget 08:09 works differently that congress has 08:11 something called the power of the purse 08:13 okay they are the issuer think of the 08:16 federal government as the issuer of our 08:19 currency in fact you and i can't create 08:22 the us dollar right if we try to 08:23 manufacture the dollar it's called 08:25 counterfeiting it's illegal we go to 08:27 jail 08:28 mayors and governors 08:30 can't manufacture the currency if they 08:32 could then when covet hit mayors would 08:36 have taken care of their own city 08:37 budgets and governors would have taken 08:39 care of their own state budgets but they 08:41 couldn't they needed the federal 08:43 government to step in provide some 08:45 support and so why is the federal 08:47 government able to do what states and 08:49 local governments can't do 08:51 and the answer is the government is the 08:54 issuer of the dollar 08:57 when the economy screeched to a halt in 08:59 mid-march businesses shut down almost 09:01 overnight and quickly millions of 09:03 workers became unemployed 09:06 within weeks the government moved to 09:08 provide trillions of dollars of stimulus 09:10 relief to workers and businesses 09:12 throughout the economy 09:14 twelve hundred dollar checks to anyone 09:15 who makes less than seventy five 09:17 thousand dollars this is another six 09:19 hundred dollars a week for four months 09:21 congress approving another 09:23 484 billion dollars for loans 09:27 so where does all this money come from 09:29 is it taxpayer funds is the government 09:31 printing a bunch of new cash 09:33 as you might expect there's a lot more 09:35 to know and state and local governments 09:38 like the rest of us are what i call a 09:41 user of the currency or user of the 09:43 dollar they can't manufacture it they 09:45 don't have the ability to issue the 09:46 currency so they have to go out and get 09:48 it from somewhere and the main place 09:50 that cities and states get their 09:52 currency is from the rest of us in the 09:54 form of tax payments property tax sales 09:57 tax income tax and the like 10:00 okay and you touched on this a little 10:01 bit but just to go more in depth how 10:04 does increased federal spending 10:06 potentially lead to 10:08 inflation 10:09 it's not just federal spending that 10:12 could create inflationary pressures it's 10:14 any spending and so what you're seeing 10:16 right now for example is a lot of us 10:19 have been trying to buy a lot of goods 10:21 through the pandemic we spent less money 10:23 on things like services going to the 10:25 salon going to hotels and restaurants 10:28 and bars and we spent more on cars and 10:31 computers and furniture turning our 10:33 spare bedrooms into home offices and 10:35 that sort of thing so goods have to be 10:38 produced and manufactured and shipped 10:41 and so as many of us spent more on goods 10:45 that created some supply pressure some 10:47 bottlenecks and it created some 10:49 inflationary pressures so it's not just 10:51 government spending it's any form of 10:54 spending that can lead to inflationary 10:56 pressures 10:58 but government could potentially be a 11:00 source of inflation if the government 11:03 had sent out let's say 14 000 checks 11:07 instead of 1400 checks to most people in 11:10 march of this year you can imagine the 11:13 potential for much higher inflation as a 11:16 result of that 11:33 [Music] 11:38 is music a big part of your life well 11:40 let me tell you about anchor spotify's 11:43 podcasting platform it's free there are 11:46 creation tools that allow you to easily 11:48 and quickly record and edit right from 11:50 your phone or computer 11:52 best of all with anger you can create a 11:54 music plus talk show with music plus 11:56 talk you can add any songs from spotify 11:59 directly to your episodes alongside talk 12:02 segments featuring your commentary music 12:06 plus talk is a whole new way to create 12:09 with all of the music that you love and 12:11 anchor will even help publish your show 12:14 to spotify so you can reach hundreds of 12:17 millions of listeners so you got an idea 12:21 for music plus talk show just head over 12:23 to anchor dot fm slash music plus talk 12:27 that's anchor dot f m slash m u s 12:32 i c p l u s 12:34 t a l k to sign up for anchor 12:38 and make your own music plus talk show 12:41 for free 13:01 i want to switch gears for a second and 13:04 discuss in an op-ed in the new york 13:06 times back in april you discussed the 13:09 president's infrastructure plan and you 13:11 wrote that democrats are thinking about 13:14 fiscal responsibility the wrong way 13:17 how so 13:18 well 13:19 because 13:20 what we often hear and what we're 13:22 hearing from the administration right 13:24 now frankly is that the buildback better 13:29 act is fiscally responsible because it's 13:32 quote unquote paid for and what that 13:34 means in washington speak 13:36 is that it doesn't increase the deficit 13:39 that the government has a plan 13:41 to remove a dollar from someone's hands 13:44 for every dollar that they plan to spend 13:47 into someone else's hands so what 13:49 president biden has said is 13:51 i'd like to do 13:53 child care i'd like to do elder care i 13:55 would like to make two years of college 13:58 free i'd like to spend money in all 13:59 these different ways that strengthen the 14:01 social safety net and help build a 14:03 better economy and to keep all of that 14:06 spending from increasing the government 14:08 deficit i'm gonna remove money from 14:12 people who make more than four hundred 14:13 thousand dollars a year from big 14:15 corporations and so forth that keeps the 14:18 spending deficit neutral it means that 14:20 it doesn't have an impact on the 14:22 government's budget and what i suggested 14:25 in that piece is that's the wrong way to 14:27 think about fiscal responsibility 14:29 there's nothing inherently irresponsible 14:32 about doing things the way congress did 14:34 the cares act in march of last year that 14:37 was 2.2 trillion dollars of spending it 14:40 all added to the deficit and i would 14:43 argue that it was fiscally responsible 14:45 to do that 14:46 so what's not fiscally responsible 14:50 is pushing the economy too far is 14:53 spending too much into an economy that 14:55 can't safely absorb that spending and 14:59 causing an inflation problem in other 15:01 words the way to evaluate whether the 15:03 government is being responsible when it 15:06 passes legislation isn't to say does it 15:09 add to the deficit oh that's bad it's 15:12 does the spending create other problems 15:15 in the economy does it exacerbate income 15:17 inequality does it fuel inflation that 15:20 would be a problem in the economy that 15:22 sort of thing so we're just thinking the 15:24 wrong way about what it means to manage 15:27 the government's spending in a 15:28 responsible way yeah i think though that 15:31 when you're dealing with such 15:32 unprecedented times to look at the 15:35 responsibility of our government 15:38 and what we need 15:40 to come out of this not only as a nation 15:44 that is okay but one that actually comes 15:46 out of it 15:47 better off than when we went into it i 15:50 think part of 15:52 this and i think part of the insecurity 15:55 of the country that we are seeing now i 15:58 think a lot of people are seeing it for 15:59 the very first time even though you know 16:01 as activists we've been saying that it's 16:03 been there for years i do have to say 16:06 the recognition about the word 16:09 responsibility and what the government 16:11 is supposed to help the people of its 16:15 country with i think is it's really 16:18 important and to be able to 16:20 to look back on this time and say we had 16:23 to take risks because this was such an 16:25 unprecedented time but this is what came 16:27 out of it that was really positive and i 16:29 think we will see people's lives change 16:32 from buildback better i don't i'm not 16:34 necessarily sure 16:36 what it means for the fiscal 16:38 responsibility of our of our government 16:40 and 16:41 our financial institutions but i do 16:44 think 16:44 it will 16:46 impact people's lives and at the end of 16:48 the day 16:49 isn't that what we should be doing 16:52 yes it is and i would argue that you're 16:56 exactly right in terms of the way we 16:58 should be thinking about and evaluating 17:00 these government interventions you know 17:02 did they lift people up did they save 17:04 jobs did they help families hold 17:06 together through the pandemic did they 17:08 lift kids out of poverty 17:10 and maybe most importantly 17:13 thanks to the american rescue plan we're 17:14 on track 17:16 to cut child poverty in america in half 17:20 this year 17:25 [Applause] 17:34 and then the process 17:37 all this was all going on the economy 17:39 created 17:41 more than 1 million 17:42 300 000 new jobs in 100 days 17:48 you look at what we actually 17:51 accomplished and as an economist i 17:53 marvel i do marvel at what the 17:55 government did this time because it's so 17:57 different 17:58 how congress responded after the 18:00 financial crisis in 2007-2008 18:03 that was a one-and-done they did a 18:05 fiscal package and then they sort of 18:07 just walked away from it this time you 18:09 know i mentioned earlier the cares act 18:12 that was immediately as soon as the 18:13 pandemic hit in march of last year 18:16 congress just without hesitation or 18:18 delay cranked out a 2.2 trillion dollar 18:21 package and you remember that included 18:23 1200 dollar checks that went to most 18:25 people it included 18:27 600 18:28 a week in federal unemployment insurance 18:32 for people who lost jobs in the pandemic 18:34 and it expanded the unemployment 18:36 benefits to include people who were 18:38 previously left out like gig workers and 18:40 so forth so for the very first time we 18:44 had a recession a serious downturn in 18:47 the economy and poverty rates went down 18:49 not up as unemployment increase and then 18:52 congress came back in march of last year 18:55 and did another package 900 billion and 18:58 then they came back in march of this 18:59 year with only democrats supporting it 19:02 and did 1.9 trillion and this is when we 19:05 got the child tax credit and so you've 19:07 got a lot of families now who are 19:09 receiving millions of people getting 300 19:12 a week to help with a child some people 19:15 who have two or three kids are getting 19:17 six or nine hundred dollars a week and 19:19 we have lifted almost half of the kids 19:21 in this country out of poverty with a 19:24 single provision in a piece of 19:26 legislation and so you look at that and 19:27 you say that expires this month in 19:30 december right it's the end of the year 19:32 it expires now congress has the 19:34 opportunity in the buildback better act 19:36 to make sure it doesn't expire and you 19:38 think how could they not when the choice 19:41 is to let all of these kids fall back 19:43 into poverty or simply extend that 19:45 provision it seems like it ought to be a 19:48 no-brainer 19:49 i know this is probably a big ass but 19:52 can you briefly explain what modern 19:55 monetary theory is to our listeners 19:58 yeah it's so when you think about 20:00 economics i mean if to the extent that 20:02 people think about economics there are 20:04 all these different schools of thought 20:06 maybe people have heard of like the 20:08 austrian school or um the keynesian 20:11 school of economics modern monetary 20:13 theory is a school of economic thought 20:16 it's a framework it's a way of thinking 20:18 about the economy it's basically a 20:21 framework that emphasizes the fact 20:23 that the us government is no longer on a 20:26 gold standard our currency the us dollar 20:28 is not tethered to gold or to any other 20:32 finite uh resource something that you 20:35 could run out of we have what's called a 20:36 floating exchange rate a fiat currency 20:40 and mmt or modern monetary theory is 20:43 about describing how the monetary system 20:46 works now since nixon took us off the 20:48 gold standard in 1971 20:51 and says okay we should recognize that 20:53 the monetary system works different now 20:55 that there's more policy space available 20:58 to use fiscal and monetary policy to 21:01 uplift our people to accomplish more and 21:05 the government's budget doesn't work 21:06 like a household budget and mmt is about 21:09 explaining why that's so 21:11 and how would applying it to our 21:13 economic policy change how our economy 21:17 and how our government manages it 21:20 if you're trapped in a gold standard 21:22 framework then you're asking questions 21:25 like where will we find the money to pay 21:28 for that so someone has a great idea 21:29 like keeping kids out of poverty 21:32 repairing infrastructure providing some 21:34 free college or health care for all and 21:37 the first question everyone asks is how 21:40 are you going to pay for it where is the 21:42 money going to come from you literally 21:43 hear politicians say how will you find 21:45 the money as if we're still on a gold 21:48 standard as if you actually have to go 21:50 find gold and discover money in order to 21:53 pay for things so mmt shifts that 21:56 thinking it says that asking how will 21:58 you pay for it is the wrong question 22:00 it turns out 22:02 that finding the money is the easy part 22:04 the hard part is managing our real 22:07 resources so mmt would have us ask not 22:10 how will you pay for it but how will you 22:12 resource it if you want universal health 22:15 care for example it's easy for congress 22:18 to simply pay the medical bills and 22:20 cover the pharmaceutical drug costs and 22:23 so forth and reimburse pharma company 22:25 that's easy to do the hard part if 22:28 you're promising health care for 22:30 everyone is making sure that you have 22:32 enough doctors and nurses and hospital 22:34 beds and 22:36 specialists mental health care 22:37 professionals and all the rest of it 22:39 because what you're really promising is 22:41 to deliver something real the financing 22:44 is the easy part but how will you 22:45 resource it if you want free college the 22:48 hard part is making sure you have enough 22:50 faculty and staff and 22:52 classrooms and dormitories and all of 22:55 the things that you need to deliver 22:58 healthcare or free college right so mmt 23:01 just helps us by getting the easy part 23:04 out of the way how will you pay for it 23:06 and then it becomes about managing 23:08 inflation risk and real resources 23:12 and in your book the deficit myth which 23:14 i really enjoyed you argued that a 23:17 federal deficit is actually healthy for 23:20 an economy can you go into that a little 23:23 bit 23:24 yes so look what i like to say is that 23:26 really 23:27 deficit is totally thinking right now is 23:30 the concept of the government's deficit 23:33 and the reason is that governments 23:35 around the world are increasing their 23:38 deficit spending right now and that has 23:41 the potential to make a lot of people 23:43 nervous 23:44 and we don't want that and it's 23:46 important that we're able to breathe 23:48 through this moment and to start to 23:51 think about and look at government 23:52 deficits in a new way 23:56 [Music] 24:00 that's what people need to understand 24:02 every deficit is good for someone why 24:04 because go back to the definition of the 24:06 deficit the difference between two 24:08 numbers right how many dollars the 24:10 government spends into the economy 24:12 compared to how many dollars they 24:13 subtract back out 24:15 mostly through taxation so when the 24:17 government does this thing called 24:19 running a deficit it just means that 24:21 they are adding more than they're 24:23 subtracting 24:25 so if the government is adding more than 24:26 it's subtracting what it means is that 24:28 someone's getting something the 24:31 government's deficits appear as 24:34 financial surpluses in some other part 24:36 of the economy think about the 24:37 republican tax cuts in 2017 donald trump 24:42 is president republicans control the 24:44 house and the senate and they push 24:46 through these huge tax cuts not because 24:49 they think and they know that it's going 24:50 to add close to 2 trillion to the 24:53 deficit they don't do that thinking oh 24:56 this is going to be bad for someone they 24:58 do that knowing this is going to be good 25:00 for someone right our deficits the 25:03 government's deficits are the surpluses 25:06 that go somewhere else in the economy a 25:08 government deficit is a financial 25:10 contribution it's like the government 25:12 making a deposit into some other part of 25:15 the economy so when republicans run 25:17 deficits they like to divert that 25:19 surplus into the hands of the people who 25:22 frankly least need the help the windfall 25:25 goes to the people at the very top goes 25:27 to big corporations but look at the 25:29 cares act or look at the 1.9 trillion 25:32 dollar covid bill that was done under 25:34 the bidet administration with democrats 25:36 only that 1.9 trillion went to a very 25:40 different constituency both deficits 25:42 were good for someone but they were good 25:45 for very different groups of the 25:47 population 25:49 thank you for explaining that that makes 25:51 a lot of sense so i guess my next 25:53 question is then why do some of those on 25:56 the right and by saying those on the 25:58 right i'm also including joe manchin and 25:59 kristen cinema and other conservative 26:02 democrats in this group why do they 26:04 insist that it is so dangerous 26:08 well i think it's an excuse i think it's 26:10 a convenient excuse because 26:13 not enough of the american population 26:16 has 26:18 been educated about the way a government 26:21 deficit works and so most americans 26:24 still think that a government deficit is 26:26 evidence of some kind of fiscal 26:28 irresponsibility that the government's 26:29 not managing its budget the way it ought 26:32 to it's being irresponsible so if 26:34 somebody like joe manchin says gee i 26:37 don't know if i can support this next 26:39 round of spending because it adds to the 26:40 deficit he can come across as 26:43 kind of the grown-up in the room as very 26:45 sensible whether he believes it or not i 26:48 don't know i think that maybe he does i 26:51 i know for a fact that he's got us an 26:54 aide a senior aide who every day 26:57 sends him an update i think a text 27:00 message 27:01 on how much the national debt has 27:03 increased compared to yesterday so 27:05 literally 24-hour updates so it's 27:07 possible that he's a true believer i 27:09 don't know but i do know that the 27:11 deficit and the national debt are very 27:14 convenient political excuses that allow 27:17 lawmakers to say look i would love to 27:19 support 27:20 child care and elder care and all the 27:22 rest of the stuff but i i just can't 27:25 bring myself to vote for this because we 27:27 got to worry about the national debt we 27:29 got to worry about the deficit and it's 27:31 like a get out of jail free card for 27:33 these guys 27:35 it really is amazing to me to think that 27:37 anyone could vote against 27:39 a their own self-interest right when you 27:42 see 27:43 the american people go to the polls but 27:45 also how an elected official could vote 27:48 against the best interest of their 27:51 constituents it's just mind-boggling to 27:53 me i like to think that they all have 27:56 these hearts of service and they lead 27:58 from a place of service and maybe that's 28:00 how they all got in there but at a 28:02 certain point 28:03 you look at people like mansion and 28:05 cinema i just marvel at their inability 28:08 to 28:10 do what is right for their constituents 28:12 i have the trillion dollar question for 28:14 you are you ready 28:17 it may be a dumb question ring it 28:20 so if 28:22 i've always wondered this if a federal 28:24 government can just create more money to 28:27 do the things it wants to do is money 28:30 even like a real thing why do we have it 28:33 at all and really why have any 28:36 limitations on it 28:38 well so humans made it up either there 28:40 are no two ways about that money does 28:42 not exist in nature humans had to invent 28:45 this thing 28:46 and governments invented 28:49 currencies historically because they 28:52 wanted to we could say provision 28:54 themselves with certain things a 28:56 government might want a standing army or 28:58 infrastructure roads and things like 29:00 that 29:01 and you need people to build these 29:03 things and to be fighters in your army 29:05 and so forth and so how do you do that 29:07 one way to do it is to compel people to 29:10 work and provide the state with the 29:12 resources it wants by imposing taxes and 29:15 that's what happened historically 29:17 governments impose obligations on a 29:20 population it could be a tax or a fee or 29:23 a fine or any other kind of financial 29:26 obligation and say you have to pay me 29:29 in this currency and the people then say 29:32 i don't have the currency and the 29:33 government then says oh i can help you 29:35 with that i will hire you to fight in my 29:38 army or build my infrastructure i will 29:41 pay you in this currency that i created 29:43 and invented and then you give me back a 29:46 portion of it to settle your obligation 29:48 your tax or your fees or whatever to the 29:51 state and so the reason really that we 29:54 have money in from inception is because 29:58 some entity 29:59 early entities before states even but 30:02 later states wanted to provide 30:04 themselves provision themselves with 30:06 resources and the currency was the way 30:09 to do that 30:10 but why can't we just make more 30:12 well we do and that's the point right 30:14 we've just been talking about 30:16 basically 5 trillion in change 30:19 that congress has had manufactured 30:22 on its behalf right on behalf of the u.s 30:25 treasury we created the government 30:27 created more than five trillion dollars 30:29 to shore up the economy to help us you 30:31 know through the pandemic not that we're 30:33 through the pandemic obviously we are 30:35 not through the pandemic but these bills 30:37 that congress writes are basically a set 30:40 of instructions that go to the 30:42 government's bank the federal reserve 30:45 and the legislation says to the fed get 30:47 ready we are ordering a brief lesson on 30:49 the federal reserve system or 1.9 30:52 trillion reserve or the fed is the 30:54 central bank of the united states as the 30:56 central bank it determines our nation's 30:58 monetary policy this means the fed 31:00 determines how much money is floating 31:02 around in the u.s economic ecosystem 31:04 ready to be spent on goods or services 31:07 by controlling the money supply the fed 31:09 is able to influence both interest rates 31:11 and the health of the overall economy 31:14 the fed's goal is to keep two important 31:16 economic metrics in check unemployment 31:19 and inflation 31:25 and that's where it comes from the the 31:27 fed's job is to make all of the payments 31:30 that have been authorized by congress on 31:32 behalf of the u.s treasury and they do 31:34 that i don't hope i don't scare anyone 31:37 they do that using nothing more than a 31:39 computer keyboard to change the numbers 31:42 in the bank account in the appropriate 31:44 direction so when that twelve hundred 31:45 dollar check goes out somebody's typing 31:48 the numbers in and the balance in 31:50 somebody's account increases by twelve 31:52 hundred dollars so we do 31:54 make the money 31:55 as congress authorizes 32:26 it's so outside of what i do i can't 32:29 even wrap my head around it but i do 32:30 want to i want to talk more about and we 32:33 touched on it before but i want to talk 32:35 more about the inflation that america is 32:37 currently experiencing because i think 32:39 it's 32:40 being used as a talking point from the 32:43 right and i think it's scaring the 32:45 people on the left so just go through 32:48 how bad is it and should the government 32:50 even be doing something to rain it in 32:53 okay so how bad is it it depends who you 32:56 are people don't like to pay more for 32:58 gas for example and it's hard on some 33:01 people right when you're used to paying 33:04 let's say 40 to fill up the tank and 33:06 maybe you have to drive long distances 33:07 to work and all of a sudden it's 85 33:10 that's a real hardship for people it's a 33:12 hardship when people are not making a 33:14 living wage as well exactly so for 33:16 people who are on a very tight budget 33:18 when food prices go up even what might 33:21 to us seem like a fairly small increase 33:23 in prices for a lot of people that's a 33:26 big bite out of the household budget 33:29 so the question i guess is what is 33:31 causing what's driving all of this 33:33 inflation and i think that most 33:35 economists and other experts 33:38 agree that you know but for covid we 33:41 don't have an inflation problem we don't 33:44 have inflation running at 6.2 percent 33:46 which is where we are today but for 33:48 covet so what happened well the economy 33:51 is a global economy first of all and it 33:53 doesn't work like your car i could take 33:56 my car park it in the garage throw the 33:58 keys in a drawer go to europe for 18 34:01 months come back pull the keys out stick 34:04 it in the ignition start the car and 34:06 drive off and everything would work 34:08 perfectly you can't do that with an 34:10 economy you can't shut down parts of the 34:13 economy pack on and expect everything to 34:16 just work right away it doesn't work 34:18 like that so 34:20 the pandemic created what everybody is 34:23 hearing about which are all of these 34:25 problems in the supply chain we have for 34:28 decades seen corporations 34:30 decide how am i going to produce 34:33 whatever it is a car or computers or 34:35 iphones or whatever it is how do i want 34:37 to produce my stuff and they said well 34:40 i want to try to produce it at the 34:42 lowest possible cost i want to look for 34:44 parts in the world where environmental 34:46 standards are the weakest i wanna so i'm 34:49 gonna split up production and do a 34:52 little bit here in this country and a 34:53 little bit here in this country and then 34:55 i'm gonna have the parts assembled and 34:57 put together and then eventually i'm 35:00 gonna have a whole car at the end of the 35:02 day right but the chips are manufactured 35:04 in southeast asia and this other thing 35:06 is manufacturing this other country and 35:08 when there's a break in the supply chain 35:10 because there's a coveted outbreak in 35:13 vietnam or malaysia and they shut a 35:15 factory down and they're not producing 35:17 the computer chips because the 35:18 semiconductor plant is shut down then 35:21 the auto manufacturer can't get the 35:23 parts they need to finish producing and 35:25 so prices go up when you say what should 35:28 we be doing about the inflation it 35:31 almost is more like saying what should 35:33 we be doing to end the pandemic globally 35:36 because you don't get out of this until 35:39 the pandemic is under control you're not 35:42 we're not going to escape this we're 35:43 going to have supply chain problems 35:45 which means we're going to have 35:46 inflation problems for as long as we 35:48 have a covet problem 35:50 and we've seen huge profiteers during 35:53 these crises especially during the 35:55 pandemic 35:56 and i'm just always struck by this stat 36:00 that fewer than a thousand americans now 36:02 hold more than two-thirds of our 36:04 national wealth 36:06 how 36:07 does that happen and how badly does it 36:10 hurt us 36:13 it happens over a long period of time 36:15 and through many different mechanisms 36:18 some people would say it's basically 36:21 that the economy has been rigged in 36:23 favor of large corporations and of the 36:26 wealthy many of whom draft the 36:29 legislation that ends up benefiting them 36:32 whether it's the trade laws the tax laws 36:35 uh labor laws we have built a system 36:38 over a period of decades you can call it 36:41 shifting to a neo-liberal economic 36:43 philosophy but that's what we've done we 36:47 have created a system that enables the 36:50 accumulation of wealth by a smaller and 36:53 smaller group of people and it rises to 36:56 the very top how does it happen it 36:58 happens because those who are producing 37:01 the output the income the revenue that 37:03 becomes the profits are producing more 37:06 and more profit that is going to those 37:09 at the very top 37:11 and they're writing the rules 37:13 i think that's the most important part 37:16 there was a recent report that showed 37:18 that new housing construction is 37:20 starting to contract 37:23 and i think part of that is because 37:25 there's a lack of physical and human 37:27 resources you've argued that the federal 37:30 government should consider loosening 37:32 immigration laws as an economic decision 37:35 can you explain that and tell us 37:38 what it would mean for our economy 37:40 sure 37:41 so 37:42 i think there are easy ways to argue in 37:45 favor of different immigration policy 37:48 independent of saying we need more 37:50 workers okay but that was just one thing 37:53 that i included in that piece that you 37:55 referred to earlier 37:56 people are all hearing about labor 37:58 shortages i don't think there's a labor 37:59 shortage i think what we have is a 38:01 shortage of employers who are prepared 38:04 to pay the wages and provide the safety 38:06 measures and so forth that will bring 38:08 workers into the labor force and willing 38:11 to take some of these jobs but if you 38:13 believe that we actually have a problem 38:16 of not enough workers to do the work 38:18 that needs to be done then an obvious 38:20 solution is that there are millions of 38:24 people around the world who would love 38:27 nothing more than to come to this 38:29 country and work and contribute take 38:32 jobs and so immigration policy is just 38:35 low-hanging fruit in terms of how to 38:38 accommodate 38:39 the need for more workers 38:42 and my last question which i ask to all 38:46 of my guests 38:47 is what gives you hope 38:51 young people who i think see the world 38:54 that they're inheriting and 38:57 they don't want that world 38:59 and they're willing to stand up and and 39:03 to fight for the kind of world that they 39:04 want they don't accept excuses they 39:08 don't accept no 39:10 they look at what's happening with 39:12 climate i think in particular and 39:14 they're terrified and they're willing to 39:16 stand up and say that there is no way 39:19 that we're going to let this happen and 39:21 so young people give me hope 39:24 stephanie kelton you give me hope thank 39:26 you for all you do and for being a part 39:28 of the podcast here in the u.s so much 39:30 for having around the world 39:32 governments did some extraordinary 39:34 things 39:36 they sent money to people directly to 39:39 help them buy food and pay rent they 39:42 provided free covid testing and expanded 39:45 health care to cover more of the 39:47 population 39:48 they gave money to businesses to help 39:51 keep them afloat while much of the 39:53 economy was temporarily shut down 39:57 they offered debt relief to millions of 39:59 people who borrowed money to go to 40:01 college 40:03 they did all of this 40:04 and more 40:06 without raising taxes 40:08 or having a prolonged battle over the 40:11 usual question 40:13 of how to pay for it 40:15 to me 40:17 this was exciting 40:18 and i'm an economist so i don't say that 40:21 a lot 40:24 [Music] 40:30 who is the economy for 40:32 those on the right through the policy 40:34 they support seem to think that the 40:36 economy is for the very richest 40:38 americans a recent article on 40:41 inequality.org revealed that the richest 40:43 745 americans hold about five trillion 40:46 dollars in wealth the rest of america 40:49 holds about three trillion if you want 40:52 to talk about a deficit 40:54 there it is 40:55 there is a wealth deficit 40:58 in america where the richest are 41:01 hoarding the money we do have and making 41:04 it harder for the rest of us to afford 41:06 things 41:07 fewer than 1 000 people hold about 41:09 two-thirds of our wealth 41:11 think about that 41:13 and think about how damaging it is to 41:16 our economy to our communities and to 41:19 our families 41:21 we can do better we have enough money in 41:24 america and a near unlimited ability 41:27 to make more 41:29 but if it keeps going to the people who 41:32 already have more money than some entire 41:35 nations 41:36 then what the hell are we even doing 41:39 we need monetary policy that works for 41:42 the 330 million 41:45 not for the less than 1 thousand 41:48 that would make america great again 41:55 sorry not sorry is executive produced by 41:57 alyssa milano that's me our producer is 42:00 ben jackson audio editing and 42:02 engineering by mache lewandowski and 42:04 music by josh cook alicia eagle and milo 42:08 bouliari 42:09 don't forget to rate review and spread 42:11 the word 42:13 sorry 42:14 not sorry.
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿