— 地域通貨花子1 (@TiikituukaHana) September 23, 2022
Watch, listen and understand how private debt is created always and everywhere. There are two sectors in the economy private sector or non-govt sector and the govt sector. Money comes from the latter! @ProfSteveKeen pic.twitter.com/NvtH6EpZ1c
— Ashish Barua आशिष बरूआ #MMT 📈📊 (@barua_ashish) September 21, 2022
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
K:
実際に貨幣経済が成立するには、貨幣工場が、私たちが使うための貨幣をもっと生産しなければならないから、それは間違った考えです。
R:
では、ここに欠けている要素は何でしょうか?
K:
私たちがリストアップしているのは、政府が自前の銀行を所有する唯一の機関であるということです。中央銀行です。中央銀行は、政府がやりたいことに資金を提供し、英国内での支払い手段として英国ポンドを受け入れ続けている限り、無限に資金を提供することができます。ですから、政府が赤字を出すと、実際には経済にお金を注入することになります。銀行部門からのお金と違って、返済の義務はありません。納税の義務はありますが、すべてを返済する義務はありません。
R:
なるほど。だから、実は眠れる巨人なんです。
K:
そうですね。
R:
例えば、大学教育の資金を調達する方法です。だから、ジャーナリストが労働党の野党にしつこく尋ねると、イギリスでは、「どうやってお金を払うつもりなんだ?その答えは?例えば、授業料ですが、彼らはすべての授業料を廃止したいと考えています。
K:
政府は中央銀行から資金調達して赤字を出し、経済に資金を投入します。まともな投資のアイディアだ。最後に、政府の黒字についてだが、これは良い考えだろうか?政府は2つの貨幣製造所のうちの1つである。政府が黒字を出すということは、政府がお金を破壊し、同時に我々に成長しろということだ。
R:
ありがとう、すっきりした。以上、Renegade Inc.これはRenegade Shortです。これはSteve Keenで、政府の黒字はとんでもない話だ。
0:07
Hello, welcome Renegade Inc.
0:08
This is a Renegade short and
0:09
it's on the subject of whether
0:10
we should be running government
0:12
surplus or not.
0:13
We're here with Professor Steve
0:14
Keen. He's going to walk us
0:15
through it. Steve I want to
0:16
come with this argument: we
0:18
should run a government
0:19
surplus. It's a good idea
0:21
because the government then can
0:22
invest, they've got more money,
0:23
they tax us less etc...
0:25
Is that the case.
0:27
No unfortunately.
0:28
I wish it was that simple but I
0:29
think with people what people
0:30
do is they think like their own
0:32
household where they can
0:33
actually spend less than they
0:35
earn and it all works out nice
0:36
and easily. So is this
0:37
extrapolating a household
0:38
budget into a government
0:39
budget? That's actually
0:40
everybody is doing. Let's
0:41
actually think at this scale so
0:42
we talk about an entire economy
0:44
and we say let's divide it in
0:45
two and call this the private
0:46
sector and the government
0:48
sector and see what actually is
0:49
involved if the government is
0:50
going to run a surplus.
0:52
To run a surplus it has to tax
0:54
you more than it spends on
0:56
you. No, I don't like the idea.
0:57
OK what else happens as a
0:58
result is let's say it's a 50
1:00
billion pound surplus then that
1:01
means they're taking 50 billion
1:03
pounds out of circulation.
1:05
That's money out of the
1:06
economy... which can also mean
1:07
if the money turns over twice a
1:08
year that can reduce total
1:10
spending by 100 billion pounds.
1:12
Right.
1:12
So you've actually reduced GDP
1:14
and reduced the amount of money
1:15
in circulation.
1:16
So when that money is taken out
1:18
where does the private economy
1:19
go to make up the shortfall.
1:21
What they've done is they've
1:22
gone to the banks and they've
1:23
borrowed from the banks,
1:25
either households or firms,
1:27
and if you just borrow and
1:28
simply keep it constant then
1:29
you have a 50 billion increase
1:31
in your money from the bank
1:32
credit which you can spend.
1:34
But that credit causes an
1:35
increase in the level of debt
1:36
you owe. What sort of debt?
1:38
Private debt.
1:39
And this is what's exploded and
1:40
this is what's caused the
1:41
financial crisis and that's
1:42
what caused the current slump
1:45
in the economy.
1:45
So we can get historical
1:46
context let's just have a look
1:47
at the private debt from the
1:49
U.K., specifically private debt
1:50
from the eighteen hundreds.
1:52
What you see is that the data
1:54
starts 1980, from 1880 and 1980
1:57
there's no trend.
1:58
There's booms and slumps
1:59
overall but there's no trend in
2:00
the level of private debt.
2:01
It stays below 75 percent of
2:03
GDP.
2:04
But there are some
2:04
irregularities here.
2:05
What's happened?
2:06
Then in 1980,
2:07
79-80 we have a new
2:10
conservative government that
2:11
believes that we should treat
2:12
the economy like a household
2:14
and trust our own surpluses
2:16
and liberates the financial
2:18
sector that let capitalism rip.
2:20
What actually happened from
2:21
that point is that it wasn't
2:22
capitalism it ripped it was the
2:23
financial sector.
2:24
We went from a debt level of 55
2:25
percent of GDP to 195
2:28
percent back in 2010.
2:31
And from that point on nobody
2:32
wants to borrow any money
2:33
anymore. Credit demand has
2:34
evaporated and we're in almost
2:35
permanent slump.
2:36
So while we're looking at
2:37
graphs, let's quickly look at
2:39
the US. When the US did try to
2:41
run surpluses or run surpluses
2:43
what happened?
2:44
Well over 120 years
2:46
of data, it's run surpluses
2:47
sustained on two occasions.
2:49
The first in the 1920s.
2:52
And that led to the Great
2:52
Depression because the money
2:54
coming out people borrowed from
2:55
banks speculate on stock
2:56
market, stock market bubbles
2:58
then it crashes.
2:59
You've still got the debt.
3:00
We had the Great Depression.
3:01
The second occasion was under
3:03
Clinton. Right.
3:04
What looked like responsible
3:05
spending was actually taking
3:06
money out of the private sector
3:08
who borrowed from the banking
3:09
sector to speculate on housing,
3:11
drove up the debt, we then had
3:13
the crisis of 2007-2008.
3:15
So as we stand here today the
3:16
government want to run a
3:17
surplus. The conservative
3:19
government in the UK think a
3:20
government surplus is a good
3:21
idea. What's your message?
3:23
It's a wrong idea because to
3:24
actually have a monetary
3:25
economy your money factories
3:27
have to be producing more money
3:28
for us to spend.
3:30
So what's the element that's
3:31
missing in here? What we're
3:32
listing out is the government
3:33
is the only institution that
3:34
owns its own bank.
3:36
The Central Bank.
3:37
And the Central Bank finances
3:39
what the government wants to do
3:41
and can finance it indefinitely
3:42
so long as we continue
3:43
accepting British pounds as
3:44
forms of payment within
3:46
Britain, which we do.
3:47
So if the government runs a
3:49
deficit it's actually injecting
3:51
money into the economy,
3:52
and unlike money coming from
3:53
the banking sector it doesn't
3:54
come with an obligation to
3:55
repay. It comes with an
3:57
obligation to pay tax,
3:58
but not to pay it all back.
3:59
Right. So it's actually a
4:00
sleeping giant.
4:01
Yeah.
4:02
This is the way we could
4:03
actually finance, for example,
4:04
university education.
4:05
So when journalists
4:06
persistently ask the
4:08
Labour opposition
4:10
at the moment here in the UK
4:11
they say to them you know how
4:13
are you going to pay for it.
4:14
What's your answer?
4:15
Tuition fees for instance they
4:16
want to scrap all tuition.
4:17
The government runs a deficit
4:18
financed by the central bank,
4:20
spends money into the economy,
4:21
it stimulates the economy and
4:22
it gives us an educated youth
4:24
that are not encumbered by
4:25
private debt as they are under
4:26
the current scheme.
4:28
Decent investment idea.
4:31
Lastly, a government surplus,
4:32
a good idea?
4:32
No. Government is one of our
4:34
two money factories. A
4:35
government running a surplus is
4:36
a government destroying money
4:38
and telling us to grow at the
4:39
same time.
4:40
Thanks for clearing it up.
4:41
That's it Renegade Inc. This is
4:42
a Renegade Short. This was
4:43
Steve Keen and a government
4:44
surplus is a terrible idea.



0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿