Watch, listen and understand how private debt is created always and everywhere. There are two sectors in the economy private sector or non-govt sector and the govt sector. Money comes from the latter! @ProfSteveKeenpic.twitter.com/NvtH6EpZ1c
Hello, welcome Renegade Inc.
This is a Renegade short and
it's on the subject of whether
we should be running government
surplus or not.
We're here with Professor Steve
Keen. He's going to walk us
through it. Steve I want to
come with this argument: we
should run a government
surplus. It's a good idea
because the government then can
invest, they've got more money,
they tax us less etc...
Is that the case.
K:
No unfortunately.
I wish it was that simple but I
think with people what people
do is they think like their own
household where they can
actually spend less than they
earn and it all works out nice
and easily. So is this
extrapolating a household
budget into a government
budget? That's actually
everybody is doing. Let's
actually think at this scale so
we talk about an entire economy
and we say let's divide it in
two and call this the private
sector and the government
sector and see what actually is
involved if the government is
going to run a surplus.
To run a surplus it has to tax
you more than it spends on
you.
R:
No, I don't like the idea.
K:
OK what else happens as a
result is let's say it's a 50
billion pound surplus then that
means they're taking 50 billion
pounds out of circulation.
R:
That's money out of the
economy...
K:
which can also mean
if the money turns over twice a
year that can reduce total
spending by 100 billion pounds.
R:
Right.
K:
So you've actually reduced GDP
and reduced the amount of money
in circulation.
R:
So when that money is taken out
where does the private economy
go to make up the shortfall.
K:
What they've done is they've
gone to the banks and they've
borrowed from the banks,
either households or firms,
and if you just borrow and
simply keep it constant then
you have a 50 billion increase
in your money from the bank
credit which you can spend.
But that credit causes an
increase in the level of debt
you owe.
R:
What sort of debt?
K:
Private debt.
And this is what's exploded and
this is what's caused the
financial crisis and that's
what caused the current slump
in the economy.
R:
So we can get historical
context let's just have a look
at the private debt from the
U.K., specifically private debt
from the eighteen hundreds.
K: 1:52
What you see is that the data
starts 1980, from 1880 and 1980
there's no trend.
There's booms and slumps
overall but there's no trend in
the level of private debt.
It stays below 75 percent of
GDP.
R:
But there are some
irregularities here.
What's happened?
K:
Then in 1980,
79-80 we have a new
conservative government that
believes that we should treat
the economy like a household
and trust our own surpluses
and liberates the financial
sector that let capitalism rip.
What actually happened from
that point is that it wasn't
capitalism it ripped it was the
financial sector.
We went from a debt level of 55
percent of GDP to 195
percent back in 2010.
And from that point on nobody
wants to borrow any money
anymore. Credit demand has
evaporated and we're in almost
permanent slump.
R:
So while we're looking at
graphs, let's quickly look at
the US. When the US did try to
run surpluses or run surpluses
what happened?
K:
Well over 120 years
of data, it's run surpluses
sustained on two occasions.
The first in the 1920s.
And that led to the Great
Depression because the money
coming out people borrowed from
banks speculate on stock
market, stock market bubbles
then it crashes.
You've still got the debt.
We had the Great Depression.
The second occasion was under
Clinton.
R:
Right.
K:
What looked like responsible
spending was actually taking
money out of the private sector
who borrowed from the banking
sector to speculate on housing,
drove up the debt, we then had
the crisis of 2007-2008.
R:
So as we stand here today the
government want to run a
surplus. The conservative
government in the UK think a
government surplus is a good
idea. What's your message? 3:21
K:
It's a wrong idea because to
actually have a monetary
economy your money factories
have to be producing more money
for us to spend.
So what's the element that's
missing in here? What we're
listing out is the government
is the only institution that
owns its own bank.
The Central Bank.
And the Central Bank finances
what the government wants to do
and can finance it indefinitely
so long as we continue
accepting British pounds as
forms of payment within
Britain, which we do.
So if the government runs a
deficit it's actually injecting
money into the economy,
and unlike money coming from
the banking sector it doesn't
come with an obligation to
repay. It comes with an
obligation to pay tax,
but not to pay it all back.
Right. So it's actually a
sleeping giant.
Yeah.
This is the way we could
actually finance, for example,
university education.
R:
So when journalists
persistently ask the
Labour opposition
at the moment here in the UK
they say to them you know how
are you going to pay for it.
What's your answer?
Tuition fees for instance they
want to scrap all tuition.
K:
The government runs a deficit
financed by the central bank,
spends money into the economy,
it stimulates the economy and
it gives us an educated youth
that are not encumbered by
private debt as they are under
the current scheme.
R:
Decent investment idea.
Lastly, a government surplus,
a good idea?
K:
No. Government is one of our
two money factories. A
government running a surplus is
a government destroying money
and telling us to grow at the
same time.
R:
Thanks for clearing it up.
That's it Renegade Inc. This is
a Renegade Short. This was
Steve Keen and a government
surplus is a terrible idea.
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿