2022年9月17日土曜日

2022/11/07 The Good Dream is Factual MMT Warren Mosler

2022/11/07
there's another option and that's what we are we are that other option which makes infinitely more sense but sometimes powerful ideas can make a real difference and most of the great achievements of humankind started out as someone's dream of a better world let's dream and dream big it may make a difference in the lives of millions of ordinary people someday the man I call a realistic optimist the big dreamer Warren Mosler I'm gonna do something a little bit unusual I'd like to yield five minutes to my time to steel arching what we're missing is that what we're suffering in the United States right now is nothing short of a money famine an epidemic crisis of suicide in this country we have an opioid crisis which is really just suicide on the installment plan of what we're talking about is real people and because they're eating maybe they don't notice that the rest of the people are starving we're not paying enough attention to the fact that there is a money famine unemployment is always an unspent income story people talk about robots that's a Productivity story it's not an unemployment story though mmm tea is the only valid explanation of inflation there is I'd like to also let you know that what you're going out with has been subject to intense scrutiny for 25 years you know you're going out with something that's been scrutinized by people at federal reserve people at Treasury finance ministers and serious professors of economics and Finance from all over why do politicians on both sides of the aisle continue to say that they can for things they believe it because you believe it and they want to get elected and they've created their own monster not not to let an important teaching moment go by I'm gonna review because you're the people who are going to be going out there trying to do this and so what I'm going to do is review it one more time what I think are the important points and then we'll go through a few ways to do it so you're gonna get one last lecture and we'll have set of an instruction here so number one the month for me the money story starts with the government trying to provision itself lots of money stories starting in a lot of ways but if you just think of it as always starting with the government trying to provision itself and how does it do it okay there are different ways to do it throughout history one way is just to go out and take slaves okay another way the British did they provision their Navy by going to bars late at night and hitting people over the heads and dragging them onto ships what's called impressing sailors we pretend to be more civilized as I like to say we as a monetary system so how does the government do it so clean sheet of paper what you do is you establish a tax okay and something payable and something that people don't have okay so what you want to do is transfer resources from the private sector to the public sector you want people who are out there doing whatever they're doing to suddenly be working for the government you need soldiers you need police you need public public health workers you need two people in education how do you get these people out of the private sector into the public sector you are first thing you do is you levy a tax you need a tax liability it has to be coercive and for this example I'll just use a property tax you put a tax on everybody's house and you make it payable in your new unit of account your thing your tax credit the thing that is used to pay the tax the dollar or the yen or the euro they're all tax credits okay now now what's happened you've created something okay what's happened is you've created sellers of real goods and services who now need your tax credit or they're going to lose their house right you've created unemployment people looking for paid work unemployment is not about people looking to volunteer at the American Cancer Society it's about people looking for work because they need or want the money and the problem with government when you want to provision yourself is that there's no unemployment no unemployment in terms of your currency there might be people willing to work for other things but not for your currency you need unemployment in terms of your currency people looking to earn your unit of account so you levy attacks now people need your you know count all these people show up looking for work all those people are unemployed you now hire the unemployed that your tax created and they are now provisioning your government you've got your soldiers and your public health workers and everything else that you want okay that's where the story begins so where do we get residual unemployment it's because the government hasn't hired all of the people that tax cause to be unemployed you want it to hire the United States government wants to hire two or three million people the levies at three and a half trillion dollar tax and all of a sudden there's 25 million unemployed or something like that the tax was way too large for the number of people they actually wanted to hire okay well they only tired the three million or whatever they wanted and they leave the other twenty or twenty five million whatever it is unemployed these are people who would show up for paid work if it was around now you can argue whether that number is fifteen million or twenty five million it's a big number but the point is that they are there because the government put on a tax that was that for whatever reason was too large for the number of people they wanted to employ and so now you know what are we gonna do we've made a mistake okay we can either hire those people we're just crediting our council dollars that's not a problem but we don't want 22 five million people in government so we have to lower the tax so they can get back into the private sector if we want more people in government if we decide we need two million three million more and public services and a lot of people have had a lot of good ideas for more public services and I have a lot of good ideas for more public services okay we can hire those but we're not going to be hiring all of them because the taxes are a lot more powerful than spending they create a lot more unemployed than that amount of spending will we'll take out of the economy all right so then we have to make our fiscal adjustments either increase public spending or lower taxes to get all these people you know employed now if we don't want them all in the government there's another 510 million whatever and we want those people to go back into the private sector how do we do that we can lower taxes so that the private sector will have the there'll be enough spending in the private sector and spending drives employment so they can then hire these people okay but they won't because they don't want to hire people who are unemployed in that sense by causing people to come unemployed the government has damaged them not physically maybe not even emotionally but just in terms of their marketability they've damaged them employers don't like to hire people who are unemployed they want to hire people who are already working they know they come in on time they know they're don't get in fights they're clean whatever they'd rather hire people already working so what we do is we establish a transition job for the purpose of promoting the transition from the public sector unemployment from the unemployment to private sector employment okay now it's not that the private sector doesn't want these people or don't want to hire them I mean they might not but it's they can't okay that's the whole point of the tax to create unemployed that can't be hired by the private sector the private sector doesn't have the means to because if they did you wouldn't be able to have anybody working for you in the public sector okay the whole point of the exercise is to force people coercively out of the private sector into the public sector we forced out too many more than we want to employ in the public sector so then we have to lower the tax allow for the aggregate demand to grow so that they have the wherewithal to hire these people and then you have to put them in a transition jobs so that they can then get the higher paying jobs in the private sector now I say your alternative is to either hire them or lower the tax and they'll go back okay some people will say we should just have them all in the public sector that's fine I'm not arguing with that but we're looking at a you know a country of 340 million people 200 million voters there might be people you know the political decision might be we want to hire some of them and then have the rest go back to the private sector it might be a consensus in the country we want them all to go back to the private sector I'm allowing for all of that you can allow for that when you talk to people you're going to talk to people who are going to want all the unemployed to go in a private sector you're gonna talk to people who want all the unemployed to go in a public sector we accommodate that I mean that's that's included in this whole exercise so anyway that's the way you know I started in the so the very purpose of taxation is to create unemployment okay unemployment is always an unspent income story people talk about robots that's a Productivity story it's not an unemployment story that well productivity does not create unemployment it's unspent income that creates unemployment productivity can create unspent income which then creates unemployment if a business replaces people with robots and profits go up and then they don't spend the profits then you will have residual unemployment okay but that's a good thing because that means we can either lower taxes or increase public spending to offset the unspent income problem and then not have unemployment so productivity increases if the money doesn't get spent means we can all either have our taxes lowered or we can have additional public services okay so it's not a bad thing productivity is always a good thing the problem is that one of the main problems of this reverse understanding is they turn good things into bad things they turn productivity increases where we can just push one button and get everything done into a bad thing now unemployment it's a good thing we can push one button and get everything done we don't have to do that we can do other things okay but we have to make the fiscal adjustment to offset the unspent income that comes with any of these uh policies trade is the same way I heard something earlier about the trade deficit is draining off all this spending which is true well what's the appropriate policy response to allow unemployment and then try and create more unemployment and then force everybody's wages down to be more competitive to export more you know there's another option and that's what we are we are that other option which makes infinitely more sense which is you make a fiscal adjustment you lower taxes or you increase public services so now we have enough money to buy everything we produce domestically plus whatever the rest of the world wants to send us that's what happened in 1999 we had unemployment under 4 percent we had inflation under 2 percent not that that particularly matter but it tells you we weren't overheating and we had record imports of 390 billion dollars back when that was huge money ok how did we do that well we had enough money to spend on both everything we could produce domestically we bought everything kept unemployment down plus whatever the rest of the world wanted to send us ok where did that income come from we had lots of savings it came from deficit spending ok where was the deficit spending wasn't a government government was running a surplus of 2 percent of GDP it was a private sector deficit spending the private sector was deficit spending 7 percent of GDP chasing these ridiculous business plans of all these kaam companies and then the whole y2k thing where you have to change your computers or the world was going to end right but it was deficit spending spending more than income that it was offsetting the savings desires and it allowed us to have enough money to have full employment reasonably speaking you know plus record import at the same time ok a trade deficit does not have to result in unemployment that's the worst policy option it's a good thing it allows us to have lower taxes or more public spending to sustained full employment those are good things that happen and it makes sense that a trade deficit would be a good thing okay imports are real benefits you get things exports a real cost you have to give them to somebody else why would that be bad if you get more import your getting more things well it puts people out of work that's because we got an unspent income problem in this case it's the foreigners who aren't spending the income you lower taxes or you increased public spending you make your fiscal adjustment and a good thing becomes a better thing you got full employment better jobs and all the imports okay and it's always sustainable it's never not sustainable okay and then mmt is always prepared at least I am to answer the new questions that come up and I know we talked about some of these the first no I think we got different people here the latest thing coming up is that we've got this big debt over the low interest rate I promoted a zero rate policy I think that's worth the way to go the government doesn't pay interest on the dollars it spends that haven't been collected for taxes otherwise called the public debt it promotes price stability and we use fiscal adjustments that's mean y-sustain aggregate demand instead of trying to fool with interest rates which have massive distributional issues and all kinds of things but the what the answer to that is look the low interest rates have caused debt to explode and now we've got a huge private sector debt overhang because of the low interest rates well number one we don't because debt service as a percent of income is low so in that sense that's not the problem there lots of problems but that's not one of them but the low interest rate you don't get any borrowing unless there's a saver I can't borrow $20 from me unless I have $20 I don't want to spend and if you borrow $20 from a bank they've created new money new bank deposits there's still a saver or you can't do that okay it might be you you might borrow the 2020 hour let's say you borrow two hundred thousand dollars from the bank you might be the saver you might just stick it in your leave it in your bank account fine okay you're the saver but if you want to buy something with it a house or a car whoever you bought that from has to be the saver because he'd rather have the money than the car and then that when the day ends he's got the $200,000 and if he buys something from somebody else somebody else has it it doesn't disappear so you can't go into debt and you know unless you're the serum from yourself but you can't go into debt unless there's a saver so that whole debt overhang actually is driven by a gain in savings desires which is entirely counterintuitive to most people how could low interest rates create a strong or savings desire well let's look at Japan the highest public sector debt ratio in the world 250% and they've had zero rates for 30 years it's created huge savings have been associated with the zero rate pendulum so we see around the world that what it's a so the association is there and we know logically the causation is there that it's the saver who's doing it and so although it's counter to ative it's there in the data it's there any evidence so I was I I was saying this to a presentation that I penned a group of pension fund money managers and one of them asked me that he said well I thought the lower interest rates would cause people to save less so I said okay you're a pension manager what do you do with your pension fund when interest rates come down what happens to your contributions says well we have to put more in so we can get the same benefit at the end is it ok you just answered your own question you've got to save more for the end result if interest rates are lower well how big a factor are our pension funds massive okay why are they there because we have tax advantage reasons to save government has decided to give you to allow you to put pre-tax money into your pension fund into your IRA we're encouraging all the savings right okay when you encourage savings what is that that's a demand leakage that's money that's unspent income that causes unemployment okay and and so what do you have to do to offset it to has to be debt or there's going to be unemployment so the somebody has to spend more than your income so it winds up being the public sector so the people who are yeah the irony here is the people who are totally against public sector debt are the ones who are all in favor pushing hard for tax advantaged savings and they're creating the finger against not that they're right in either case well why do they do this because they believe you need savings to have money for investment when it's the other way around investment creates the savings long to create the deposits so anyway we're here to straighten these things out if you get into any of these discussions you know send me an email or something I do it all the time I spend half my day helping people you know activists get it straight you can go up against anybody you know if you've got me on the other end for the other wire I don't care where they are and immediately they start yelling Zimbabwe and by Mark Wright how many have you heard that okay so so what do you say about inflation well first of all because you start with there's different ways to start and I just got to relay this story I was on Fox Business News trying to push my payroll tax holiday in 2010 and in anyway Stuart Varney was interviewing me on and you go watch it I'm sure I'm not telling it exactly correctly and if they wanted somebody on who was promoting big deficits Krugman couldn't make it or something so they got a hold of me and so they put me on there somebody wanted larger deficits he said oh so you want a larger deficit I said yes my proposal is for a trillion dollar tax cut I want to eliminate FICA taxes it's a highly regressive punishing tax it would add six hundred fifty dollars a month every working family on average and so they could make their mortgage payments which would end the banking crisis and he goes oh so you're one of those big government big spending liberals it's like I just you know I just put myself you know like thousand miles right of the Tea Party under this as far as they're concerned and I have a big spending liberal right so the guy next to me goes US Stuart you know he he says tax cut he goes oh oh okay so I know who you're dealing with this is a guy who's an astute business guy so when you're dealing with people they hear they don't hear you they have they're expecting something and they just immediately yell Zimbabwe even if you had said something highly deflationary right so number one MMT is the only valid explanation of inflation there is and I mean one that actually you know there's no dispute about and you don't have to give them this explanation but the currency is a monopoly you put a tax on people come to work you decide what they're gonna get paid whether it's ten dollars a day or a hundred dollars a day you know the government very all the congressmen think the government needs to get our money to be able to spend but we know we need the government's money to be able to pay the tax we collectively as the economy we need their money they've got it they that's a monopolist monopolist set price they tell us the terms of exchange when they spend whether they know it or not the source of the price level can only come from that there's nothing else left you know there's nothing else and when you don't think of that when you haven't understood that it's a monopoly in the government's prices you come up with something called inflation expectations theory and that's what they all rely on and just so you know what it is they have no idea where the price level came from but they know what it is and what it's been and therefore the only way it can possibly change is if expectations change and so they try and manage expectations but it's a default position because they don't have anything else and all their models show it's indeterminate okay and so so on inflation we've got the only understanding of inflation no-one has any understanding of where the price level comes from or why it changes we know it changes because the government changes what it pays when it spends now it might be good policy to change what you pay and have a little inflation it might not but we know how it works number one number two what you're going to be promoting is the idea of the transition job or the job guarantee and all you have to rec say is look right now we're using unemployment to control inflation and if you but the problem is employers don't like to hire people who are unemployed and so it doesn't do a good job of controlling inflation we're using employed buffer stock we're using a job guarantee where all these people will be employed there'll be a lot more attractive to employers in a private sector it becomes a better device to control inflation a better tool for inflation control well what we can say is having an employed buffer stock rather than unemployed provides superior price stability to what we have now okay I can't tell you how much better but it's obviously better and every economist will agree that it's better because the people are can move better from unemployment to private-sector employment you know so you don't run out of labor and get labor bottlenecks and labor shortages when unemployment still 10% which is what happens in Europe all the time because they can't move these people okay so all you have to say look our proposal reduces inflation compared to what we have now okay it's the old thing you don't have to outrun the bear I only have to outrun you right you know that story okay what we're doing is comparing what we have to what we're proposing and we're proposing superior price stability and that you know goes without saying and so that will help you when somebody says well what about inflation well yes we're concerned also and so what we're proposing provides better price stability and we're not going to have fiscal adjustment to get that buffer stock to get the people in the job guarantee down to zero we're going to keep it at two or three percent or some low number and they're all working and we'll get the saint's we'll have better price stability than trying to get unemployment down that low because the people are working I'd like to also let you know that what you're going out with has been subject to intense scrutiny for 25 years okay when I take this and start talking to staff positions at the Federal Reserve Bank the head of Monetary Affairs you know it's getting a hard look Vince Reinhart was head of Monetary Affairs for Greenspan and for Bernanke before left for several years through the crisis and you know he helped me write one of my speeches that I gave okay so this has passed a lot of scrutiny I've been all over the world with it I've been on panels all over the world with economics professors from Italy the United States Spain all places you know for a long time and I don't think and so as Randi and Stephanie and some others but from my experience I don't think and I've been writing for a long time so I've come to see economics I don't think a single word has been refuted I don't know is any correct me if I'm wrong have you seen anything no okay and it's you know there have been people who have criticized it but it's been you know not not valid criticism it basically hasn't been a word refuted and it'd be pretty hard to do because I'm fairly careful when I do it to make sure I'm sticking to things that are beyond dispute I don't put them in there and when I when I do talk about something that might be disputed like I did this morning and that talk I say right away tell me if I'm wrong on this I'm kicking this around but this stuff that's down there you know you're going out with something that's been scrutinized by people at federal reserve people at Treasury finance ministers and serious professors of economics and Finance from all over I there's there's an important thing I'm going to tell you in a minute you know remind me to tell you how it started but there are two sound bites that I gave to Stephanie a few years ago to help Bernie Sanders if you wanted to talk about the deficit the first one was to say everybody asks it starts there are only two things you need to answer to respond to questions about well that's going to add to the public debt okay or the deficit you say well look the public debt is just the dollars spent by the government that haven't yet been used to pay taxes and first of all they don't know how to respond or anything but that's what it is it's just a dollar spent that haven't used to be a taxes and they never heard that and then they you wait and you see what the next question is and if you say well how do you pay it back Oh you know we already spent it those are just the dollars we've spent that people have they can use it to pay taxes or they can hang on to it there are no other choices well what about all those Treasury bonds and everything those are the dollars we spent that are in accounts at the Federal Reserve called Treasury bonds and if they want they can move into other accounts called reserves or they can have cash but they just sit there and one of those you know has dollars spent that haven't been used to pay taxes and until they want to use them to pay taxes they're going to be out there forever in a private sector till somebody pays taxes with okay the the and then there's a few takeoffs on there we'll practice this a little bit later the other thing is well you know look if there's not the only possible long-term deficit problem is an inflation problem or short-term okay the only problem only financial problem that's I should say the only financial problem possible from deficit is a inflation problem okay and so if somebody's telling you this deficit spending is going to do this and that you say well it's the only possible problem we can see from this deficit spending on entitlements Social Security so we have to cut it the only possible problem is an inflation problem okay you know there's no other problem we're not going to bounce the checks we're not going to fall it could be an inflation problem that's the only possible problem and right now the CBO the Fed and the precious free market tips Treasury market is forecasting between 1 and 3/4 and 2% in long-term inflation that's with no adjustments to entitlements no just everything exactly the way it is the debts going to be eleventy-seven trillion and okay fine it's gonna be a 2 percent inflation according to the Fed the CBO and the Treasury market and so if you're telling me there's an entitlement problem now the burden of proof is on you to show me those forecasts are wrong all right so who do I have this conversation with a guy named Professor Michael Woodford does that ring a bell to anybody ok number who has voted the number one most influential mainstream economist for central bankers in the world he's the one behind all the Jackson Hole stuff and the people they run everything by so I had a conversation with him on the phone a couple of years ago I say exactly that I said you know what one thing that could earns me is that the you know the headline debit securities accounts credit reserve accounts remember that when you grow up I said look the only possible problem you can get from deficit spending is financial problem is inflation he goes he takes about three seconds he goes yeah of course all the accounts clear at the Fed that's not gonna be a problem I said well you know with the long-term forecast now at 2% for the Fed the CBO and it was one and three-quarter fight Treasury market seems to me the burden of proof of somebody who's claiming we have an entitlement problem now is on them to prove that those inflation forecasts are wrong he goes yeah you're absolutely right I mean he there was no question no pushback and he was the number one mainstream economist in the world financial economist for all the central bank's so you're safe going out with this it's not you're not gonna you're not gonna lose this point I don't you know I don't want to send you out there vulnerable to getting hit with something you don't understand all right so what what what I want to do here to continue on this as part of your continuing education here is well come up with some of the questions you get that you might feel you don't have good sound bite answers for so for example how are you gonna pay for it alright and somebody says to me how are you gonna pay for it I say well we're gonna credit the appropriate account at the central bank just like we do for all government spending this all the only way government spends is to credit accounts now they might not know what that means but they know they've got an answer to their question it's a little like deposition you don't want to say something that leads to something else that they might catch you on it so you just say that and then they say well don't you have to tax or something it's like no that process is operationally independent the guy did the guy taxing is changing numbers down at the Fed and the guy spending is changing numbers up they don't even have each other's phone number and they don't or email and whatever okay and the guy buying in debt management buying and selling bonds is debiting and crediting securities accounts and reserve accounts he doesn't have talked to either the other two they don't know each other if they're in different buildings different places okay so they're operationally independent they said well okay now you know might you cause inflation or something like that you say yeah that might be the only problem but you asked me how we're gonna pay for it this is how we pay for it well if you spend and don't tax might you cause a place in yes we might do that but right now you know what to get out of a hole the first thing you got to do is stop digging we are inflation is lower than the Federal Reserve wants they're trying to find ways to drive it up if we did that they'd probably send us a nice letter thanking us for helping them meet their inflation target you know if you do too much possibly but you just ask me how you're going to pay for it okay and so does anybody have questions like the how are you gonna pay for it question that you'd like to have some more information on how to respond yeah okay but when you do that let me stop right so you have to say the tax you let me care if I don't ever say even though it's not wrong I will say the you know you need tax liabilities the government needs to have tax liabilities to be able to spend they need to know not what I'm telling you I'm telling you the government has to have tax liabilities they don't need the actual money but you have to have a tax you have to need the money okay so the government needs to have you need their money and that's why they tax take it to create unemployment yeah yeah and then you could say right right right now if instead of the government needs you to need their money so they have to take they have to put a hole in your pocket okay and so if you just took your money and threw it away that would be okay then then you wouldn't have to give to the government okay but they can't trust you to do that you know if you just went to the bank and change your number down you know they'd be okay but but they can't trust you to do that take the money out throw it away we'll trust you they can't do that okay so it's a matter of enforcement they have to make sure you need the money by taking it away from you okay and so they put a tax on your house or a tax on your car or an income tax doesn't drive the model so easily it's more complicated but it does the same thing at the end of the day it takes it's a debit on the economy and that's why they have to tax imputed income if you work for somebody else and you don't pay to either they'll tax you anyway they have to do that or the tax doesn't work okay and so if they catch you so so yeah so I don't like to say that taxes don't fund spending because the word fund is ambiguous and even though you're right you can be dead right okay so it's it's better to say the government doesn't need your money to be able to spend okay not that it doesn't fund it is that they don't need it to be able to spend okay but they need you not to have it they don't they don't use it to spend but they need you not to have it so that they can spend they have to create a shortage to be able to spend you create a shoe it's like you create a vacuum to be able to suck in the air you have to create a shortage to be able to spend and taxes are more powerful than spending a tax of a dollar allows the government to spend maybe a dollar twenty-five because if you're taxed you need the money not only to pay tax but you want to save some because taxation creates high anxiety and a lot of people including Congress who zhang has anxiety about not having enough investment money stupid as it is and so they give you a tax advantage reason not to spend your money but all these things conspire to make taxes more powerful than spending so if they you know tax you a dollar they might be able to spend a dollar twenty-five and I don't mean you I mean the whole economy now what develops later is that there are people with a lot of money and taxing them it's not powerful at all it doesn't change their spending okay you would tax them for social equity because it affects social relations but not because it's going to give the government any fiscal space or create a need for money in the economy so that you could spend more okay so uh so does that help with hope let's try and let me know you yeah it's Warren dot Mosler at gmail.com let me know how it works because you know all this kind of why politicians I'm Wilson I'll continue to say about that for things yep that they believe Obama is that they're saying you don't I tell ya okay so my opinion they believe it because you believe it and they want to get elected and they've created their own monster in the pre the prior politicians the prior economists have created this monster that believes it and if you're not up there believing it as well they're gonna vote for somebody else because you're just crazy okay and so there's enough people like that doesn't have to be every voter but it's enough to make the difference between who gets elected and who does it I think a few people in here have tried running for office campaigning you know on an mm2 position and I'm sure they come up against that all the time it he just uh Jim sturgeon told the story maybe Randy about he had a student who came up to him and said look I have to drop out in your class he goes why said because you said yesterday we went off the gold standard in 1971 or something when I told my husband he said no that's ridiculous you can't go back to that class anymore and so I yeah was that you or said Jim it's Jim sturgeon yeah okay so you're up against a mindset that's been created and the politicians don't fight the mindset they go with it most of the time you could have their to be expected to go with it they're not the kind that bucked the mindset or they wouldn't be there you know that's what's got them there that's one of the problems and it's one of the strengths of our political system they reflect the will of the people you know the way I explained it I don't know if it'll work but look you look how do you get your Social Security check you look at your TV screen you've got two thousand dollars in your account and all of a sudden you've got four thousand the monitor changes from two thousand to four thousand what happens the government just changes the number on your screen from 2000 from a 2 to a 4 okay they didn't take a gold coin and hid it in or somebody's tax money or bring it in they just changed your number up and when you pay a social security tax your employer they just change your number down okay so that number they changed up doesn't come from anywhere you know any more than the score and a football game comes from anywhere you kick a field goal you get three points where does it come from does it cover and they changed your number down they don't get anything there's no gold coin dropping into a bucket the Social Security trust fund is a ledger that keeps track of what they did it's an accounting of what happened it's not about money it's it they just accounting it's a record-keeping where when they pay you they change the number down and when somebody when this guy makes this number smaller they make this number larger you know they take 2,000 out of your account they make this number 2,000 larger they pay you 2,000 they make this 2,000 smaller it keeps track and when it gets to zero all that means is they've taken out as much as they've paid out and then if they pay out more it goes negative it doesn't like ring a bell and somebody gets an electric shock okay now there is a law in Congress that says they need approval to do that that's a political constraint it's kind of unthinkable they would wouldn't just go through it because they do that all the time that's like the debt ceiling right so it's not a law that doesn't it's any kind of binding thing but um so I don't know if any of that imagery helps yeah so so what's that quote about that I saw today by these people people are reluctant to do things that affect their livelihood well how's that going so I mean yeah yeah yeah right so look at Bernie Sanders against Hillary Clinton well he's Santa Claus you know it's childish I'm the adult in the room we're gonna be responsible we know how this works okay what happens you know you'd think but I mean not that no one voted for Sanders but he didn't win and maybe he didn't win because she bought all the super-delegates yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah right yeah right right and one of my other proposals is just to raise Social Security to a minimum of $2,000 a month you know yeah yeah there's no reason not to there's no they worry about moral hazard when you give people money they won't work but you know if you're 70 years old if you know when you're thirty that when you're 70 you're gonna get $2,000 a month so you're not gonna work I don't think so that doesn't make any sense so raising Social Security doesn't carry the moral hazard issue now let me tell you something about my proposals in 2010 I was proposing this payroll tax holiday and I did I tell you the Fox news story or was that in the last session okay I can't remember anymore so it actually got to Troy Nash was a grad student here and hit one of his buddies was this kid I think isn't it was Ricky love or something who was President Obama's personal assistant and he got to Obama with and he liked the idea so and they actually passed it in 2010 and went into effect in 2011 not to halt tax but they cut 2 percent which was about 1 percent of GDP you know half percent anyway I was enough to support the economy for the next two years and so the economy didn't cost him the election and then in 2013 they just let it expire it was 150 billion increase he I was 1% of GDP there's a big number so I was hoping for 5% of GDP but anyway and it was the only legislation it's my understanding passed by the Obama administration on a bipartisan basis in the entire eight years okay so these are bipartisan things we're dealing with my last paper on the job guarantee which I called the transition job proposed a transition job for Europe funded by the European Union okay secured by tax credits from the individual government so they didn't have to show negative capital at the ECB and it's managed by the central bank as a additional tool for price stability and we showed econometrics they in their own report showing that the interest rate hasn't been all that good of a tool for price stability particularly on the downside and that we showed how this tool would improve price stability in the European Union so they could meet their 2% target or whatever it was and it was published in a journal of economic models or something which is leading mainstream journal okay so these ideas are not heterodox okay the way they are they're not they're mainstream ideas properly packaged not that the mainstream will accept them all but there's nothing in them that it's not mainstream okay I had something this morning somebody was talking about investment in interest rates and there was this you know the new view versus the old view or the old view is based on fixed exchange rates the new view is on today's floating exchange rate we have a different regime it doesn't make the old ones wrong they're just in a different context and you can look at most of the mainstream models and show you can disagree with assumptions but you can also show that some of them are in fixed exchange rate context it should be floating some of them don't include the currency which is a monopoly they would all agree that a monopoly would have effects XY and Z like unemployment that's their main argument against monopoly well once they recognize the currency is a monopoly there's your unemployment which is what we're talking about right a single supplier price setter so there's these things are ready to go they're ready to go and they're not they're not at odds with anyone else is saying once you put them in context yeah everybody's trying to give me more work any other ideas I'm 68 years old yes yeah well well you know one thing I if anybody does it which would be a good idea please run it by me so first just to make sure just to do a quick check for four let's make sure it's nothing we did later have to like not retract but have to answer to you have to explain because that's happened before also but um you know that's a very good idea you know you know who gets publishing atlanticus out Tom Paley somebody who's a harsh critic totally unjustified the stuff he says you know is silly but anyway he gets published in the Atlantic but ya know that's a good idea you know I don't know how you do that one you know I think the hardest thing for us to face down is the concept of the public-private Federal Reserve where the we've got libertarians fighting us with this we've got Green Party and other folks on the Left that have been infected by the Alex virus and that we've got the independence which make up you know 43% of the electorate so when we go out there to talk you've got the green party that actually has codified it into their platform but they want to end the fed yeah and while they may not be a viable political party at this point the people that are in their aesthetic to our causes they just been extremely misled by horrific economic methods and legends how can we I mean I know the answers but they're not short yeah and so because they're not short within five minutes I've lost their attention unless I'm out there dropping the elbow of truth or yelling yeah yeah you know and that seems to be the only way I keep their attention yeah there's got to be an easier softer way to making the point of the public private aspect of the Federal Reserve and how people don't need to die for their fetishes we like this if you could talk a little bit about maybe simplifying I mean Randy was on with me a couple times and to give great response Rohan give a tremendous response unfortunately none of them were as succinct as you tend to make these points you know they're all genius but for the layperson that they heard of bumper sticker slogan at the fireside and they're burning snacks while you're smoking out yeah and they literally have no concept of Federal Reserve can you well you know when I when I used to visit the Fed I tried to get them to do it you know just for public information once you let people know and Bernanke said it when he was asked he said we take our marching orders from Congress so you have that but that's they don't believe it and saw this conspiracy serious stuff there's a lot of it you know and they'll after that they'll tell you the World Trade Center was demolition and we never went to the moon and maybe we didn't I don't know but you know but it seems to me like all part of the same thing right and it's just gonna be people like that I guess it's gonna take someone from credible in their minds explaining it and we're not credible in their minds to explain it so we can say things like look all the profits go to the Treasury all the you know officers are appointed by the president approved by Congress and they're controlled entirely by the federal reason Act say it looks like government to me you know and then I can cite the advantage of saying look I I owned a bank and I own shares in the Fed and it was just a bank deposit there's no ownership or interest or anything paid they just paid me a flat six percent interest on my hundred thousand dollars joy Turner was and never called me once about policy you know and so uh but everybody can't say that I mean I can say that but because I did but so I have first-hand experience and yeah I mean it's definitely enough so and you should say that it's just start off flick say look this is a major obstacle the same people saying this or saying these other things you know the chairman of the Federal Reserve has said he you know a soft federally controlled it's the Federal Reserve Act Congress and controls and they're federal regulators and regulate when they come in regulate the banks all the profits go to the government was private why would all the profits not some of the profits there no do you know and so and but you can start off by saying yeah that's a tough one because you know everybody believes in a conspiracy theory doesn't want to hear anything no matter what I say so when you start with that you can usually get a little more attention you know because they don't want to be one of those you know they are of the worst kind but you know and there's a there's a page on the internet that debunks at that just explains exactly what I said from some authority that you could print copy print yeah because a gift as people sound Annette I remember seeing it but I remember who is from but it was a very definitive thing from a credible source just for the average person so I try to do that family is kindness listen to me after listening to all of you and the other thing that the question that I have that I can't answer is if we implement things that we were going to do with our knowledge of MMT guarantee and other things how will this affect the international markets and I have no idea yeah okay so what would I like to start with this okay so let's say we do this and we have good jobs for everybody and a good economy you know good public infrastructure a good health care people can send their kids to school they can you know have a nice place to live like what do you care about the world nobody it what you know why would something happening over in some of the country worry you at that point prevent you from doing this okay so you so they're worried about international capital markets you say well why would a price changes of stocks or bonds and markets overseas make why would we care about that you know what would the importance be as long as we have all these other things do you have an investment in some bonds in China or something that you're asking me about you know what why where's this question coming from you know well how would this affect the polar ice cap or something well do you have some stake in the polar ice cap because I'll look it up but I'm it's not really no so will this cause the dollar to go down okay so you asked okay if you've got a good job and you're making good money and you can afford nice things a nice place to live sending your kids to school dressing them and you know why why the fact that it buys fewer euro or more euro why does that bother you so maybe you're saying the price of a European vacation might go higher okay well then you say okay well that's true but that could happen anyway the euro just went up 20 percent with what we have okay the dollar has gone down before by 30 40 percent with what we have those markets fluctuate you know for whatever reason and and you say I'll bet you didn't even know that happened and if you went to Europe and things cost you know twelve dollars instead of ten dollars it probably went to made that big a difference to you it's just not the first-order importance of what we're concerned about you know in and it's just as likely to go the other way nobody can predict foreign exchange markets you know might be eight dollars next time or twelve dollars the next time that's always going to be the case if you're gonna go on a trip to Europe the value of that euro could be anywhere and they could change their prices could change and a lot of it most of it depends on their policy not ours so yeah said help okay but but always point out first look here's what the world's gonna look like here now was that question again yeah because the fish don't have tax liabilities if Paul still here okay he wrote that in the introduction to full employment and price stability he used to school of fish as an example yeah there's no unemployment in nature there's no unemployment in non-monetary societies you go to an Indian tribe or you go to Africa before the British went in or you know you military there's never unemployment everybody's doing something as cheap stationed in Australia on the back there's no unemployment if they bring in a tractor there's suddenly brothers sitting around doing nothing no they just everybody's doing something okay but you impose a tax now there's unemployment it's always a monetary phenomenon unemployment is the monetary phenomena that we're concerned on you know with all this discussion it's social security eccentric okay you know we'll never run money with its problem inflation the onus is on them to prove it we've got it but it actually stops there instead of going further which case really make some policy issues here so the one way you will get inflation out there is if you've got you know a certain amount of elderly but no caregivers now something there's an inflation in caregiving crisis so in some sense this actually goes further in a sense thing right but if but if there's no no yeah sure but if yeah if you can out bottleneck but if you you know if you encourage more robots and more productivity it just frees up people to do all that you know and so and that's presumably in all these long-term inflation forecasts it's already in there so now the other thing is you know what what happens if you overspend well the inflation you know you might get inflation and but we and so how do you score a program okay well let's score a medicare-for-all send it to the CBO and see how it's change no tax let's see how it changes their inflation forecast I'm pretty sure it'll either stay the same or go down okay in which case you don't have to do anything I haven't scored it I'm pretty sure well now people gonna have a lot more money but most of its gonna get saved because right now there's a star for savings as because we've had chronic underfunding of pension funds and all kinds of savings and financial assets to the point of Steve was talking about people don't have enough money to even get to the next paycheck so they're taking our payday loans so it's you know it's gonna be filling up the savings and then maybe at some point who knows down the road you get a tenth or two inflation if you don't adjust the spending I don't even think you will that the savings is the productivity increase is so enormous on the supply side because you're gonna get you know 50 percent more those people you're going to displace five hundred billion dollars worth of people earning salaries to do something else which will have supply side effects and so it's like you've got five hundred billion dollars that's being spent to have people dig holes and fill them in and now they're going to be doing something more productive and so that's a huge deflationary effect also so I can't see anything but deflation from everything except some balances will go up but I I see all the real-world effects of it as massively deflationary due to time constraints we're going to end it

there's another option and that's what we are we are that other option which makes infinitely more sense but

0:11

sometimes powerful ideas can make a real difference and most of the great

0:17

achievements of humankind started out as someone's dream of a better world let's

0:24

dream and dream big it may make a difference in the lives of millions of

0:30

ordinary people someday the man I call a realistic optimist the big dreamer

0:36

Warren Mosler I'm gonna do something a little bit unusual I'd like to yield five minutes to my time to steel arching

0:43

what we're missing is that what we're suffering in the United States right now is nothing short of a money famine an

0:51

epidemic crisis of suicide in this country we have an opioid crisis which

0:58

is really just suicide on the installment plan of what we're talking about is real people and because they're

1:05

eating maybe they don't notice that the rest of the people are starving we're not paying enough attention to the fact

1:11

that there is a money famine unemployment is always an unspent income

1:18

story people talk about robots that's a Productivity story it's not an unemployment story though mmm tea is the

1:24

only valid explanation of inflation there is I'd like to also let you know

1:32

that what you're going out with has been subject to intense scrutiny for 25 years

1:37

you know you're going out with something that's been scrutinized by people at

1:44

federal reserve people at Treasury finance ministers and serious professors

1:50

of economics and Finance from all over why do politicians on both sides of the aisle continue to say

1:57

that they can for things they believe it because you believe it and they want to get elected and they've created their

2:03

own monster not not to let an important teaching moment go by I'm gonna review

2:12

because you're the people who are going to be going out there trying to do this and so what I'm going to do is review it

2:19

one more time what I think are the important points and then we'll go through a few ways to do it so you're

2:25

gonna get one last lecture and we'll have set of an instruction here so number one the month for me the money

2:32

story starts with the government trying to provision itself lots of money

2:37

stories starting in a lot of ways but if you just think of it as always starting with the government trying to provision

2:43

itself and how does it do it okay there are different ways to do it throughout history one way is just to go

2:50

out and take slaves okay another way the British did they provision their Navy by

2:55

going to bars late at night and hitting people over the heads and dragging them onto ships what's called impressing

3:01

sailors we pretend to be more civilized as I like to say we as a monetary system so how does the government do it so

3:08

clean sheet of paper what you do is you establish a tax okay

3:14

and something payable and something that people don't have okay so what you want

3:20

to do is transfer resources from the private sector to the public sector you want people who are out there doing

3:25

whatever they're doing to suddenly be working for the government you need soldiers you need police you need public

3:32

public health workers you need two people in education how do you get these people out of the private sector into

3:38

the public sector you are first thing you do is you levy a tax you need a tax

3:43

liability it has to be coercive and for this example I'll just use a property tax you put a tax on everybody's house

3:50

and you make it payable in your new unit of account your thing your tax credit

3:56

the thing that is used to pay the tax the dollar or the yen or the euro

4:03

they're all tax credits okay now now what's happened you've created

4:10

something okay what's happened is you've created sellers of real goods and

4:16

services who now need your tax credit or they're going to lose their house right you've created unemployment people

4:24

looking for paid work unemployment is not about people looking to volunteer at the American Cancer Society it's about

4:30

people looking for work because they need or want the money and the problem

4:35

with government when you want to provision yourself is that there's no unemployment no unemployment in terms of

4:42

your currency there might be people willing to work for other things but not for your currency you need unemployment

4:48

in terms of your currency people looking to earn your unit of account so you levy attacks now people need your you know

4:54

count all these people show up looking for work all those people are unemployed you now hire the unemployed that your

5:01

tax created and they are now provisioning your government you've got your soldiers and your public health workers and everything else that you

5:07

want okay that's where the story begins

5:13

so where do we get residual unemployment it's because the government hasn't hired

5:18

all of the people that tax cause to be unemployed you want it to hire the

5:24

United States government wants to hire two or three million people the levies at three and a half trillion dollar tax

5:29

and all of a sudden there's 25 million unemployed or something like that the tax was way too large for the number

5:37

of people they actually wanted to hire okay well they only tired the three million or whatever they wanted and they

5:43

leave the other twenty or twenty five million whatever it is unemployed these are people who would show up for

5:49

paid work if it was around now you can argue whether that number is fifteen million or twenty five million it's a

5:55

big number but the point is that they are there because the government put on

6:00

a tax that was that for whatever reason was too large for the number of people

6:06

they wanted to employ and so now you know what are we gonna do we've made a

6:11

mistake okay we can either hire those people we're just crediting our council dollars

6:17

that's not a problem but we don't want 22 five million people in government so we have to lower the tax so they can get

6:24

back into the private sector if we want more people in government if we decide we need two million three million more

6:29

and public services and a lot of people have had a lot of good ideas for more public services and I have a lot of good

6:35

ideas for more public services okay we can hire those but we're not going to be hiring all of them because the taxes are

6:42

a lot more powerful than spending they create a lot more unemployed than that amount of spending will we'll take out

6:48

of the economy all right so then we have to make our fiscal adjustments either

6:53

increase public spending or lower taxes to get all these people you know

6:59

employed now if we don't want them all in the government there's another 510 million whatever and we want those

7:04

people to go back into the private sector how do we do that we can lower taxes so that the private sector will

7:11

have the there'll be enough spending in the private sector and spending drives

7:17

employment so they can then hire these people okay but they won't because they

7:22

don't want to hire people who are unemployed in that sense by causing

7:27

people to come unemployed the government has damaged them not physically maybe

7:32

not even emotionally but just in terms of their marketability they've damaged them employers don't like to hire people

7:38

who are unemployed they want to hire people who are already working they know they come in on time they know they're don't get in fights they're clean

7:45

whatever they'd rather hire people already working so what we do is we establish a transition job for the

7:51

purpose of promoting the transition from the public sector unemployment from the

7:58

unemployment to private sector employment okay now it's not that the

8:03

private sector doesn't want these people or don't want to hire them I mean they might not but it's they can't okay

8:10

that's the whole point of the tax to create unemployed that can't be hired by the private sector the private sector

8:16

doesn't have the means to because if they did you wouldn't be able to have anybody working for you in the public sector okay the whole point of the

8:24

exercise is to force people coercively out of the private sector into the public sector we forced out too many

8:30

more than we want to employ in the public sector so then we have to lower the tax allow

8:36

for the aggregate demand to grow so that they have the wherewithal to hire these people and then you have to put them in

8:41

a transition jobs so that they can then get the higher paying jobs in the private sector now I say your

8:48

alternative is to either hire them or lower the tax and they'll go back okay some people will say we should just have

8:54

them all in the public sector that's fine I'm not arguing with that but we're looking at a you know a country of 340

9:01

million people 200 million voters there might be people you know the political

9:06

decision might be we want to hire some of them and then have the rest go back to the private sector it might be a

9:12

consensus in the country we want them all to go back to the private sector I'm allowing for all of that you can allow

9:17

for that when you talk to people you're going to talk to people who are going to want all the unemployed to go in a

9:22

private sector you're gonna talk to people who want all the unemployed to go in a public sector we accommodate that I

9:28

mean that's that's included in this whole exercise so anyway that's the way

9:35

you know I started in the so the very purpose of taxation is to create unemployment okay unemployment is always

9:44

an unspent income story people talk about robots that's a Productivity story it's not an

9:49

unemployment story that well productivity does not create unemployment it's unspent income that creates unemployment productivity can

9:57

create unspent income which then creates unemployment if a business replaces

10:03

people with robots and profits go up and then they don't spend the profits then you will have residual unemployment okay

10:10

but that's a good thing because that means we can either lower taxes or

10:16

increase public spending to offset the unspent income problem and then not have

10:21

unemployment so productivity increases if the money doesn't get spent means we

10:27

can all either have our taxes lowered or we can have additional public services okay so it's not a bad thing

10:33

productivity is always a good thing the problem is that one of the main problems of this reverse understanding is they

10:39

turn good things into bad things they turn productivity increases where we can just push one button and get everything

10:45

done into a bad thing now unemployment it's a good thing we can push one button and get everything done

10:50

we don't have to do that we can do other things okay but we have to make the fiscal adjustment to offset the unspent

10:57

income that comes with any of these uh policies

11:03

trade is the same way I heard something earlier about the trade deficit is draining off all this spending which is

11:10

true well what's the appropriate policy response to allow unemployment and then try and create more unemployment and

11:17

then force everybody's wages down to be more competitive to export more you know there's another option and that's what

11:24

we are we are that other option which makes infinitely more sense which is you make a fiscal adjustment you lower taxes

11:30

or you increase public services so now we have enough money to buy everything we produce domestically plus whatever

11:36

the rest of the world wants to send us that's what happened in 1999 we had unemployment under 4 percent we had

11:43

inflation under 2 percent not that that particularly matter but it tells you we weren't overheating and we had record

11:51

imports of 390 billion dollars back when that was huge money ok how did we do

11:57

that well we had enough money to spend on both everything we could produce domestically we bought everything kept

12:04

unemployment down plus whatever the rest of the world wanted to send us ok where did that income come from we had lots of

12:11

savings it came from deficit spending ok where was the deficit spending wasn't a government government was running a

12:16

surplus of 2 percent of GDP it was a private sector deficit spending the private sector was deficit spending 7

12:22

percent of GDP chasing these ridiculous business plans of all these kaam companies and then the whole y2k thing

12:30

where you have to change your computers or the world was going to end right but it was deficit spending spending more than income that it was offsetting the

12:37

savings desires and it allowed us to have enough money to have full employment reasonably speaking you know

12:45

plus record import at the same time ok a trade deficit does not have to result in

12:51

unemployment that's the worst policy option it's a good thing it allows us to have lower taxes or more public spending

12:58

to sustained full employment those are good things that happen and it makes sense

13:03

that a trade deficit would be a good thing okay imports are real benefits you

13:09

get things exports a real cost you have to give them to somebody else why would that be bad if you get more import your

13:16

getting more things well it puts people out of work that's because we got an unspent income problem in this case it's

13:22

the foreigners who aren't spending the income you lower taxes or you increased public spending you make your fiscal adjustment and a good thing becomes a

13:28

better thing you got full employment better jobs and all the imports okay and

13:34

it's always sustainable it's never not sustainable okay and then mmt is always

13:45

prepared at least I am to answer the new questions that come up and I know we

13:50

talked about some of these the first no I think we got different people here the latest thing coming up is that we've got this big debt over the low interest rate

13:56

I promoted a zero rate policy I think that's worth the way to go the government doesn't pay interest on the

14:02

dollars it spends that haven't been collected for taxes otherwise called the public debt it promotes price stability

14:09

and we use fiscal adjustments that's mean y-sustain aggregate demand instead

14:14

of trying to fool with interest rates which have massive distributional issues and all kinds of things but the what the

14:22

answer to that is look the low interest rates have caused debt to explode and

14:28

now we've got a huge private sector debt overhang because of the low interest rates well number one we don't because

14:35

debt service as a percent of income is low so in that sense that's not the

14:40

problem there lots of problems but that's not one of them but the low interest rate you don't get any

14:46

borrowing unless there's a saver I can't borrow $20 from me unless I have

14:51

$20 I don't want to spend and if you borrow $20 from a bank they've created

14:56

new money new bank deposits there's still a saver or you can't do that okay

15:03

it might be you you might borrow the 2020 hour let's say you borrow two hundred thousand dollars from the bank

15:08

you might be the saver you might just stick it in your leave it in your bank account fine okay you're the saver but if you

15:14

want to buy something with it a house or a car whoever you bought that from has to be the saver because he'd rather have

15:21

the money than the car and then that when the day ends he's got the $200,000 and if he buys something from somebody

15:28

else somebody else has it it doesn't disappear so you can't go into debt and

15:33

you know unless you're the serum from yourself but you can't go into debt unless there's a saver so that whole

15:38

debt overhang actually is driven by a gain in savings desires which is

15:44

entirely counterintuitive to most people how could low interest rates create a strong or savings desire well let's look

15:53

at Japan the highest public sector debt ratio in the world 250% and they've had zero rates for 30 years it's created

16:01

huge savings have been associated with the zero rate pendulum so we see around

16:07

the world that what it's a so the association is there and we know logically the causation is there that

16:12

it's the saver who's doing it and so although it's counter to ative it's there in the data it's there any

16:18

evidence so I was I I was saying this to a presentation that I penned a group of

16:24

pension fund money managers and one of them asked me that he said well I thought the lower interest rates would

16:30

cause people to save less so I said okay you're a pension manager what do you do

16:35

with your pension fund when interest rates come down what happens to your contributions says well we have to put

16:41

more in so we can get the same benefit at the end is it ok you just answered your own question you've got to save

16:47

more for the end result if interest rates are lower well how big a factor

16:52

are our pension funds massive okay why are they there because we have tax

16:57

advantage reasons to save government has decided to give you to allow you to put

17:04

pre-tax money into your pension fund into your IRA we're encouraging all the savings right okay when you encourage

17:11

savings what is that that's a demand leakage that's money that's unspent

17:16

income that causes unemployment okay and and so what do you have to do to offset

17:22

it to has to be debt or there's going to be unemployment so the somebody has to spend more than your income so it winds up being

17:29

the public sector so the people who are yeah the irony here is the people who are totally against public sector debt

17:36

are the ones who are all in favor pushing hard for tax advantaged savings and they're creating the finger against

17:42

not that they're right in either case well why do they do this because they believe you need savings to have money

17:48

for investment when it's the other way around investment creates the savings long to create the deposits so anyway

17:54

we're here to straighten these things out if you get into any of these discussions you know send me an email or

18:00

something I do it all the time I spend half my day helping people you know activists get it straight you can go up

18:06

against anybody you know if you've got me on the other end for the other wire I don't care where they are and

18:17

immediately they start yelling Zimbabwe and by Mark Wright how many have you

18:24

heard that okay so so what do you say about inflation well first of all

18:31

because you start with there's different ways to start and I just got to relay

18:38

this story I was on Fox Business News trying to push my payroll tax holiday in 2010 and in anyway Stuart Varney was

18:45

interviewing me on and you go watch it I'm sure I'm not telling it exactly correctly and if they wanted somebody on

18:54

who was promoting big deficits Krugman couldn't make it or something so they got a hold of me and so they put me on there somebody wanted larger deficits he

19:01

said oh so you want a larger deficit I said yes my proposal is for a trillion dollar tax cut I want to eliminate FICA

19:07

taxes it's a highly regressive punishing tax it would add six hundred fifty dollars a month every working family on

19:14

average and so they could make their mortgage payments which would end the banking crisis and he goes oh so you're

19:20

one of those big government big spending liberals it's like I just you know I

19:26

just put myself you know like thousand miles right of the Tea Party under this as far as they're concerned and I have a

19:31

big spending liberal right so the guy next to me goes US Stuart you know he he says tax cut he goes oh oh okay so I

19:39

know who you're dealing with this is a guy who's an astute business guy so when you're dealing with people they hear they don't hear you they have they're

19:46

expecting something and they just immediately yell Zimbabwe even if you had said something highly deflationary right so number one MMT is the only

19:58

valid explanation of inflation there is and I mean one that actually you know there's no dispute about and you don't

20:06

have to give them this explanation but the currency is a monopoly you put a tax on people come to work you decide what

20:12

they're gonna get paid whether it's ten dollars a day or a hundred dollars a day you know the government very all the

20:18

congressmen think the government needs to get our money to be able to spend but we know we need the government's money

20:24

to be able to pay the tax we collectively as the economy we need their money they've got it they that's a

20:29

monopolist monopolist set price they tell us the terms of exchange when they spend whether they know it or not

20:35

the source of the price level can only come from that there's nothing else left you know there's nothing else and when

20:42

you don't think of that when you haven't understood that it's a monopoly in the government's prices you come up with something called inflation expectations

20:48

theory and that's what they all rely on and just so you know what it is they have no idea where the price level came

20:54

from but they know what it is and what it's been and therefore the only way it can possibly change is if expectations

21:00

change and so they try and manage expectations but it's a default position because they don't have anything else

21:06

and all their models show it's indeterminate okay and so so on

21:12

inflation we've got the only understanding of inflation no-one has any understanding of where the price

21:18

level comes from or why it changes we know it changes because the government changes what it pays when it spends now

21:25

it might be good policy to change what you pay and have a little inflation it might not but we know how it works

21:30

number one number two what you're going to be promoting is the idea of the transition job or the job guarantee and

21:37

all you have to rec say is look right now we're using unemployment to control

21:43

inflation and if you but the problem is employers don't like to hire people who

21:48

are unemployed and so it doesn't do a good job of controlling inflation we're

21:53

using employed buffer stock we're using a job guarantee where all these people will be

21:58

employed there'll be a lot more attractive to employers in a private sector it becomes a better device to

22:06

control inflation a better tool for inflation control well what we can say is having an employed buffer stock

22:14

rather than unemployed provides superior price stability to what we have now okay

22:20

I can't tell you how much better but it's obviously better and every economist will agree that it's better

22:25

because the people are can move better from unemployment to private-sector employment you know so you don't run out

22:33

of labor and get labor bottlenecks and labor shortages when unemployment still 10% which is what happens in Europe all

22:40

the time because they can't move these people okay so all you have to say look our proposal reduces inflation compared

22:48

to what we have now okay it's the old thing you don't have to outrun the bear

22:53

I only have to outrun you right you know that story okay what we're doing is comparing what we

22:58

have to what we're proposing and we're proposing superior price stability and

23:04

that you know goes without saying and so that will help you when somebody says

23:10

well what about inflation well yes we're concerned also and so what we're proposing provides better price

23:16

stability and we're not going to have fiscal adjustment to get that buffer

23:22

stock to get the people in the job guarantee down to zero we're going to keep it at two or three percent or some

23:28

low number and they're all working and we'll get the saint's we'll have better price stability than trying to get

23:34

unemployment down that low because the people are working I'd like to also let

23:43

you know that what you're going out with has been subject to intense scrutiny for

23:50

25 years okay when I take this and start talking to staff positions at the

23:57

Federal Reserve Bank the head of Monetary Affairs you know it's getting a hard look Vince Reinhart was head of

24:03

Monetary Affairs for Greenspan and for Bernanke before left for several years through the

24:09

crisis and you know he helped me write one of my speeches that I gave okay so

24:14

this has passed a lot of scrutiny I've been all over the world with it I've been on panels all over the world with

24:20

economics professors from Italy the United States Spain all places you know

24:27

for a long time and I don't think and so as Randi and Stephanie and some others

24:32

but from my experience I don't think and I've been writing for a long time so I've come to see economics I don't think

24:38

a single word has been refuted I don't know is any correct me if I'm wrong have you seen anything no okay

24:45

and it's you know there have been people who have criticized it but it's been you know not not valid criticism it

24:52

basically hasn't been a word refuted and it'd be pretty hard to do because I'm fairly careful when I do it to make sure

24:59

I'm sticking to things that are beyond dispute I don't put them in there and

25:04

when I when I do talk about something that might be disputed like I did this morning and that talk I say right away

25:09

tell me if I'm wrong on this I'm kicking this around but this stuff that's down there you know you're going out with

25:15

something that's been scrutinized by people at federal reserve people at

25:22

Treasury finance ministers and serious professors of economics and Finance from

25:28

all over I there's there's an important thing I'm going to tell you in a minute

25:35

you know remind me to tell you how it started but there are two sound bites

25:44

that I gave to Stephanie a few years ago to help Bernie Sanders if you wanted to

25:49

talk about the deficit the first one was to say everybody asks it starts there

25:55

are only two things you need to answer to respond to questions about well that's going to add to the public debt

26:01

okay or the deficit you say well look the public debt is just the dollars spent by the government that haven't yet

26:07

been used to pay taxes and first of all they don't know how to respond or anything but that's what it is it's just

26:12

a dollar spent that haven't used to be a taxes and they never heard that and then they you wait and you see what the next

26:18

question is and if you say well how do you pay it back Oh you know we already spent it those are

26:23

just the dollars we've spent that people have they can use it to pay taxes or they can hang on to it there are no

26:28

other choices well what about all those Treasury bonds and everything those are the dollars we spent that are in accounts at the Federal Reserve called

26:35

Treasury bonds and if they want they can move into other accounts called reserves or they can have cash but they just sit

26:40

there and one of those you know has dollars spent that haven't been used to pay taxes and until they want to use

26:46

them to pay taxes they're going to be out there forever in a private sector till somebody pays taxes with okay

26:52

the the and then there's a few takeoffs on there we'll practice this a little bit later the other thing is well you

26:59

know look if there's not the only possible long-term deficit problem is an

27:04

inflation problem or short-term okay the only problem only financial problem

27:09

that's I should say the only financial problem possible from deficit is a inflation problem okay and so if

27:16

somebody's telling you this deficit spending is going to do this and that you say well it's the only possible problem we can see from this deficit

27:22

spending on entitlements Social Security so we have to cut it the only possible problem is an inflation problem okay you know there's

27:30

no other problem we're not going to bounce the checks we're not going to fall it could be an inflation problem that's the only possible problem and

27:36

right now the CBO the Fed and the precious free market tips Treasury

27:43

market is forecasting between 1 and 3/4 and 2% in long-term inflation that's

27:49

with no adjustments to entitlements no just everything exactly the way it is the debts going to be eleventy-seven

27:55

trillion and okay fine it's gonna be a 2 percent inflation according to the Fed the CBO and the Treasury market and so

28:03

if you're telling me there's an entitlement problem now the burden of proof is on you to show me those

28:08

forecasts are wrong all right so who do I have this conversation with a guy

28:13

named Professor Michael Woodford does that ring a bell to anybody ok number who has voted the number one most

28:19

influential mainstream economist for central bankers in the world he's the one behind all the Jackson Hole stuff

28:25

and the people they run everything by so I had a conversation with him on the phone a couple of years ago I say

28:32

exactly that I said you know what one thing that could earns me is that the you know the

28:39

headline debit securities accounts

28:44

credit reserve accounts remember that when you grow up I said look the only possible problem

28:56

you can get from deficit spending is financial problem is inflation he goes he takes about three seconds he goes

29:02

yeah of course all the accounts clear at the Fed that's not gonna be a problem I said well you know with the long-term

29:08

forecast now at 2% for the Fed the CBO and it was one and three-quarter fight Treasury market seems to me the burden

29:13

of proof of somebody who's claiming we have an entitlement problem now is on them to prove that those inflation

29:20

forecasts are wrong he goes yeah you're absolutely right I mean he there was no question no pushback and he was the number one

29:26

mainstream economist in the world financial economist for all the central bank's so you're safe going out with

29:32

this it's not you're not gonna you're not gonna lose this point I don't you know I don't want to send you out there vulnerable to getting hit with something

29:39

you don't understand all right so what what what I want to do here to continue

29:47

on this as part of your continuing education here is well come up with some

29:53

of the questions you get that you might feel you don't have good sound bite answers for so for example how are you

29:59

gonna pay for it alright and somebody says to me how are you gonna pay for it I say well we're gonna credit the

30:05

appropriate account at the central bank just like we do for all government spending this all the only way government spends is to credit accounts

30:10

now they might not know what that means but they know they've got an answer to their question it's a little like deposition you don't want to say

30:17

something that leads to something else that they might catch you on it so you just say that and then they say well

30:22

don't you have to tax or something it's like no that process is operationally

30:27

independent the guy did the guy taxing is changing numbers down at the Fed and the guy spending is changing numbers up

30:33

they don't even have each other's phone number and they don't or email and

30:39

whatever okay and the guy buying in debt management buying and selling bonds is debiting and crediting securities

30:45

accounts and reserve accounts he doesn't have talked to either the other two they don't know each other if they're in different buildings different places

30:50

okay so they're operationally independent they said well okay now you

30:55

know might you cause inflation or something like that you say yeah that might be the only problem but you asked

31:01

me how we're gonna pay for it this is how we pay for it well if you spend and don't tax might you cause a place in yes

31:08

we might do that but right now you know what to get out of a hole the first thing you got to do is stop digging we are inflation is lower than the

31:15

Federal Reserve wants they're trying to find ways to drive it up if we did that they'd probably send us a nice letter thanking us for helping them meet their

31:21

inflation target you know if you do too much possibly but you just ask me how

31:26

you're going to pay for it okay and so does anybody have questions like the how

31:34

are you gonna pay for it question that you'd like to have some more information on how to respond yeah okay but when you

31:50

do that let me stop right so you have to

31:55

say the tax you let me care if I don't ever say even though it's not wrong I

32:01

will say the you know you need tax liabilities the government needs to have

32:10

tax liabilities to be able to spend they need to know not what I'm telling you I'm telling you the government has to

32:17

have tax liabilities they don't need the actual money but you have to have a tax you have to need the money okay so the

32:23

government needs to have you need their money and that's why they tax take it to

32:29

create unemployment yeah

32:35

yeah and then you could say right right

32:40

right now if instead of the government needs you to need their money so they have to take they have to put a hole in

32:46

your pocket okay and so if you just took your money and threw it away that would be okay then then you wouldn't have to

32:52

give to the government okay but they can't trust you to do that you know if

33:01

you just went to the bank and change your number down you know they'd be okay but but they can't trust you to do that

33:06

take the money out throw it away we'll trust you they can't do that okay so it's a matter of enforcement they have

33:12

to make sure you need the money by taking it away from you okay and so they put a tax on your house or a tax on your

33:19

car or an income tax doesn't drive the model so easily it's more complicated

33:24

but it does the same thing at the end of the day it takes it's a debit on the economy and that's why they have to tax

33:30

imputed income if you work for somebody else and you don't pay to either they'll tax you anyway they have to do that or

33:36

the tax doesn't work okay and so if they catch you so so yeah so I don't like to

33:46

say that taxes don't fund spending

33:52

because the word fund is ambiguous and even though you're right you can be dead right okay so it's it's better to say

34:00

the government doesn't need your money to be able to spend okay not that it

34:06

doesn't fund it is that they don't need it to be able to spend okay but they need you not to have it they don't they

34:13

don't use it to spend but they need you not to have it so that they can spend they have to create a shortage to be

34:20

able to spend you create a shoe it's like you create a vacuum to be able to suck in the air you have to create a shortage to be able to spend and taxes

34:26

are more powerful than spending a tax of a dollar allows the government to spend

34:32

maybe a dollar twenty-five because if you're taxed you need the money not only to pay tax but you want to save some

34:38

because taxation creates high anxiety and a lot of people including Congress

34:44

who zhang has anxiety about not having enough investment money stupid as it is and so they give you a tax advantage reason not to spend your

34:50

money but all these things conspire to make taxes more powerful than spending

34:56

so if they you know tax you a dollar they might be able to spend a dollar twenty-five and I don't mean you I mean

35:02

the whole economy now what develops later is that there are people with a lot of money and taxing them it's not

35:09

powerful at all it doesn't change their spending okay you would tax them for social equity because it affects social

35:15

relations but not because it's going to give the government any fiscal space or create a need for money in the economy

35:21

so that you could spend more okay so uh so does that help with hope let's try

35:29

and let me know you yeah it's Warren dot Mosler at gmail.com let me know how it works because you know all this kind of

35:36

why politicians I'm Wilson I'll continue to say about that for things yep that

35:45

they believe Obama is that they're saying you don't I tell ya okay so my

35:53

opinion they believe it because you believe it and they want to get elected and they've created their own monster in

36:00

the pre the prior politicians the prior economists have created this monster that believes it and if you're not up

36:06

there believing it as well they're gonna vote for somebody else because you're just crazy okay and so there's enough

36:11

people like that doesn't have to be every voter but it's enough to make the difference between who gets elected and who does it I think a few people in here

36:18

have tried running for office campaigning you know on an mm2 position and I'm sure they come up against that

36:23

all the time it he just uh Jim sturgeon told the story maybe Randy about he had

36:29

a student who came up to him and said look I have to drop out in your class he

36:34

goes why said because you said yesterday we went off the gold standard in 1971 or something when I told my husband he said

36:41

no that's ridiculous you can't go back to that class anymore and so I yeah was that you or said Jim it's Jim

36:47

sturgeon yeah okay so you're up against a mindset that's been created and the

36:52

politicians don't fight the mindset they go with it most of the time you could

36:58

have their to be expected to go with it they're not the kind that bucked the mindset or they wouldn't

37:03

be there you know that's what's got them there that's one of the problems and it's one of the strengths of our

37:10

political system they reflect the will of the people you know the way I

37:15

explained it I don't know if it'll work but look you look how do you get your

37:20

Social Security check you look at your TV screen you've got two thousand dollars in your account and all of a sudden you've got four thousand the

37:25

monitor changes from two thousand to four thousand what happens the government just changes the number on

37:32

your screen from 2000 from a 2 to a 4 okay they didn't take a gold coin and hid it in or somebody's tax money or

37:38

bring it in they just changed your number up and when you pay a social security tax your employer they just

37:44

change your number down okay so that number they changed up doesn't come from anywhere you know any more than the

37:50

score and a football game comes from anywhere you kick a field goal you get three points where does it come from does it cover and they changed your

37:57

number down they don't get anything there's no gold coin dropping into a bucket the Social Security trust fund is

38:02

a ledger that keeps track of what they did it's an accounting of what happened

38:07

it's not about money it's it they just accounting it's a record-keeping where when they pay you they change the number

38:12

down and when somebody when this guy makes this number smaller they make this number larger you know they take 2,000

38:18

out of your account they make this number 2,000 larger they pay you 2,000 they make this 2,000 smaller it keeps

38:23

track and when it gets to zero all that means is they've taken out as much as

38:29

they've paid out and then if they pay out more it goes negative it doesn't like ring a bell and somebody gets an

38:35

electric shock okay now there is a law in Congress that says they need approval to do that that's a political constraint

38:41

it's kind of unthinkable they would wouldn't just go through it because they do that all the time that's like the debt ceiling right so it's not a law

38:48

that doesn't it's any kind of binding thing but um so I don't know if any of

38:54

that imagery helps yeah so so what's that quote about that

39:11

I saw today by these people people are reluctant to do things that affect their livelihood well how's that going so I

39:18

mean yeah yeah yeah right so look at

39:27

Bernie Sanders against Hillary Clinton well he's Santa Claus you know it's childish I'm the adult in the room we're

39:32

gonna be responsible we know how this works okay what happens you know you'd think but I mean not that no one voted

39:40

for Sanders but he didn't win and maybe he didn't win because she bought all the super-delegates yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah

39:57

right yeah right right

40:05

and one of my other proposals is just to raise Social Security to a minimum of $2,000 a month you know yeah yeah

40:11

there's no reason not to there's no they worry about moral hazard when you give people money they won't

40:17

work but you know if you're 70 years old if you know when you're thirty that when you're 70 you're gonna get $2,000 a

40:23

month so you're not gonna work I don't think so that doesn't make any sense so raising Social Security doesn't carry

40:28

the moral hazard issue now let me tell you something about my proposals in 2010 I was proposing this payroll tax holiday

40:35

and I did I tell you the Fox news story or was that in the last session okay I

40:41

can't remember anymore so it actually got to Troy Nash was a grad student here

40:49

and hit one of his buddies was this kid I think isn't it was Ricky love or something who was President Obama's

40:54

personal assistant and he got to Obama with and he liked the idea so and they actually passed it in 2010 and went into

41:01

effect in 2011 not to halt tax but they cut 2 percent which was about 1 percent

41:07

of GDP you know half percent anyway I was enough to support the economy for the next two years and so the economy didn't cost him the

41:12

election and then in 2013 they just let it expire it was 150 billion increase he I was 1% of GDP there's a big number so

41:19

I was hoping for 5% of GDP but anyway and it was the only legislation it's my

41:29

understanding passed by the Obama administration on a bipartisan basis in the entire eight years okay so these are

41:36

bipartisan things we're dealing with my last paper on the job guarantee which I

41:41

called the transition job proposed a transition job for Europe funded by the

41:47

European Union okay secured by tax credits from the individual government so they didn't

41:52

have to show negative capital at the ECB and it's managed by the central bank as

41:57

a additional tool for price stability and we showed econometrics they in their

42:05

own report showing that the interest rate hasn't been all that good of a tool for price stability particularly on the

42:10

downside and that we showed how this tool would improve price stability in

42:15

the European Union so they could meet their 2% target or whatever it was and it was published in a journal of

42:21

economic models or something which is leading mainstream journal okay so these

42:26

ideas are not heterodox okay the way they are they're not they're mainstream

42:33

ideas properly packaged not that the mainstream will accept them all but there's nothing in them that it's not

42:39

mainstream okay I had something this morning somebody was talking about investment in interest rates and there

42:46

was this you know the new view versus the old view or the old view is based on fixed exchange rates the new view is on

42:52

today's floating exchange rate we have a different regime it doesn't make the old ones wrong they're just in a different

42:58

context and you can look at most of the mainstream models and show you can

43:03

disagree with assumptions but you can also show that some of them are in fixed exchange rate context it should be

43:08

floating some of them don't include the currency which is a monopoly they would all agree that a monopoly would have

43:15

effects XY and Z like unemployment that's their main argument against monopoly well once they recognize the

43:20

currency is a monopoly there's your unemployment which is what we're talking about right a single supplier price

43:26

setter so there's these things are ready to go they're ready to go and they're

43:32

not they're not at odds with anyone else is saying once you put them in context yeah everybody's trying to give me more

44:00

work any other ideas I'm 68 years old

44:05

yes yeah well well you know one thing I

44:24

if anybody does it which would be a good idea please run it by me so first just to make sure just to do a quick check

44:32

for four let's make sure it's nothing we did later have to like not retract but

44:38

have to answer to you have to explain because that's happened before also but

44:43

um you know that's a very good idea you know you know who gets publishing atlanticus out Tom Paley somebody who's

44:52

a harsh critic totally unjustified the stuff he says you know is silly

44:58

but anyway he gets published in the Atlantic but ya know that's a good idea you know I don't know how you do that

45:06

one you know I think the hardest thing for us to face down is the concept of

45:13

the public-private Federal Reserve where the we've got libertarians fighting us

45:19

with this we've got Green Party and other folks on the Left that have been infected by the Alex

45:25

virus and that we've got the independence which make up you know 43%

45:30

of the electorate so when we go out there to talk you've got the green party that actually has codified it into their

45:37

platform but they want to end the fed yeah and while they may not be a viable

45:42

political party at this point the people that are in their aesthetic to our causes they just been extremely misled

45:48

by horrific economic methods and legends how can we I mean I know the answers but

45:55

they're not short yeah and so because they're not short within five minutes I've lost their attention

46:01

unless I'm out there dropping the elbow of truth or yelling yeah yeah you know and that seems to be the only way I keep

46:06

their attention yeah there's got to be an easier softer way to making the point

46:12

of the public private aspect of the Federal Reserve and how people don't need to die for their fetishes we like

46:18

this if you could talk a little bit about maybe simplifying I mean Randy was on with me a couple

46:24

times and to give great response Rohan give a tremendous response unfortunately

46:29

none of them were as succinct as you tend to make these points you know they're all genius but for the layperson

46:36

that they heard of bumper sticker slogan at the fireside and they're burning snacks while you're smoking out yeah and

46:43

they literally have no concept of Federal Reserve can you well you know

46:48

when I when I used to visit the Fed I tried to get them to do it you know just for public information once you let

46:54

people know and Bernanke said it when he was asked he said we take our marching orders from Congress so you have that

47:00

but that's they don't believe it and saw this conspiracy serious stuff there's a

47:05

lot of it you know and they'll after that they'll tell you the World Trade Center was demolition and we never went

47:11

to the moon and maybe we didn't I don't know but you know but it seems to me like all part of the same thing right and it's just gonna be people like that

47:20

I guess it's gonna take someone from credible in their minds explaining it

47:25

and we're not credible in their minds to explain it so we can say things like look all the profits go to the Treasury

47:31

all the you know officers are appointed by the president approved by Congress

47:37

and they're controlled entirely by the federal reason Act say it looks like government to me you know and then I can cite the

47:45

advantage of saying look I I owned a bank and I own shares in the Fed and it was just a bank deposit there's no ownership or interest or

47:53

anything paid they just paid me a flat six percent interest on my hundred thousand dollars joy Turner was and

47:59

never called me once about policy you know and so uh but everybody can't say

48:05

that I mean I can say that but because I did but so I have first-hand experience and yeah I mean it's definitely enough

48:14

so and you should say that it's just start off flick say look this is a major obstacle the same people saying this or saying these other things

48:19

you know the chairman of the Federal Reserve has said he you know a soft

48:24

federally controlled it's the Federal Reserve Act Congress and controls and they're federal regulators and regulate

48:30

when they come in regulate the banks all the profits go to the government was private why would all the profits not

48:35

some of the profits there no do you know and so and but you can start off by saying yeah that's a tough one because

48:42

you know everybody believes in a conspiracy theory doesn't want to hear anything no matter what I say so when

48:47

you start with that you can usually get a little more attention you know because they don't want to be one of those you

48:55

know they are of the worst kind but you know and there's a there's a page on the

49:02

internet that debunks at that just explains exactly what I said from some

49:07

authority that you could print copy print yeah because a gift as people sound Annette I remember seeing it but I

49:15

remember who is from but it was a very definitive thing from a credible source

49:23

just for the average person so I try to do that family is kindness listen to me

49:29

after listening to all of you and the other thing that the question that I

49:34

have that I can't answer is if we implement things that we were going to

49:41

do with our knowledge of MMT guarantee and other things how will this affect

49:49

the international markets and I have no idea yeah okay so what would I like to

49:56

start with this okay so let's say we do this and we have good jobs for everybody and a good economy you know good public

50:04

infrastructure a good health care people can send their kids to school they can you know have a nice place to live like

50:12

what do you care about the world nobody it what you know why would something happening over in some of the

50:17

country worry you at that point prevent you from doing this okay so you so

50:24

they're worried about international capital markets you say well why would a price changes of stocks or bonds and

50:30

markets overseas make why would we care about that you know what would the importance be as long as we have all

50:35

these other things do you have an investment in some bonds in China or something that you're asking me about

50:41

you know what why where's this question coming from you know well how would this affect the polar ice cap or something

50:47

well do you have some stake in the polar ice cap because I'll look it up but I'm it's not really no so will this cause

50:57

the dollar to go down okay so you asked okay if you've got a good job and you're

51:03

making good money and you can afford nice things a nice place to live sending your kids to school dressing them and

51:08

you know why why the fact that it buys fewer euro or more euro why does that

51:15

bother you so maybe you're saying the price of a European vacation might go higher okay well then you say okay well

51:21

that's true but that could happen anyway the euro just went up 20 percent with what we have okay the dollar has gone

51:27

down before by 30 40 percent with what we have those markets fluctuate you know

51:32

for whatever reason and and you say I'll bet you didn't even know that happened and if you went to Europe and things

51:38

cost you know twelve dollars instead of ten dollars it probably went to made that big a difference to you it's just

51:43

not the first-order importance of what we're concerned about you know in and it's just as likely to go the other way

51:50

nobody can predict foreign exchange markets you know might be eight dollars next time or twelve dollars the next time that's always going to be the case

51:56

if you're gonna go on a trip to Europe the value of that euro could be anywhere and they could change their prices could

52:01

change and a lot of it most of it depends on their policy not ours so yeah said help okay

52:10

but but always point out first look here's what the world's gonna look like here now was that question again yeah

52:41

because the fish don't have tax liabilities if Paul still here okay he

52:48

wrote that in the introduction to full employment and price stability he used to school of fish as an example yeah there's no unemployment in nature

52:54

there's no unemployment in non-monetary societies you go to an Indian tribe or you go to Africa before the British went

53:01

in or you know you military there's never unemployment everybody's doing something as cheap stationed in

53:07

Australia on the back there's no unemployment if they bring in a tractor there's suddenly brothers sitting around

53:12

doing nothing no they just everybody's doing something okay but you impose a tax now there's unemployment it's always

53:19

a monetary phenomenon unemployment is the monetary phenomena that we're concerned on you know with all this

53:24

discussion it's social security eccentric okay

53:29

you know we'll never run money with its problem inflation the onus is on them to

53:35

prove it we've got it but it actually stops there instead of going further

53:41

which case really make some policy issues here so the one way you will get

53:46

inflation out there is if you've got you know a certain amount of elderly but no

53:51

caregivers now something there's an inflation in caregiving crisis so in some sense this actually goes further in

53:58

a sense thing right but if but if there's no no yeah sure

54:04

but if yeah if you can out bottleneck but if you you know if you encourage

54:09

more robots and more productivity it just frees up people to do all that you

54:14

know and so and that's presumably in all these long-term inflation forecasts it's already in there so now the other thing

54:22

is you know what what happens if you overspend well the inflation you know you might get inflation and but we and

54:28

so how do you score a program okay well let's score a medicare-for-all send it to the CBO and see how it's change

54:33

no tax let's see how it changes their inflation forecast I'm pretty sure it'll either stay the same or go down okay in

54:41

which case you don't have to do anything I haven't scored it I'm pretty sure well now people gonna have a lot more money but most of its gonna get saved because

54:47

right now there's a star for savings as because we've had chronic underfunding

54:52

of pension funds and all kinds of savings and financial assets to the point of Steve was talking about people

54:59

don't have enough money to even get to the next paycheck so they're taking our payday loans so it's you know it's gonna

55:04

be filling up the savings and then maybe at some point who knows down the road you get a tenth or two inflation if you

55:11

don't adjust the spending I don't even think you will that the savings is the productivity increase is so enormous on

55:18

the supply side because you're gonna get you know 50 percent more those people you're going to displace five hundred

55:24

billion dollars worth of people earning salaries to do something else which will

55:30

have supply side effects and so it's like you've got five hundred billion dollars that's being spent to have

55:36

people dig holes and fill them in and now they're going to be doing something more productive and so that's a huge

55:41

deflationary effect also so I can't see anything but deflation from everything

55:46

except some balances will go up but I I see all the real-world effects of it as massively deflationary

55:54

due to time constraints we're going to end it

0 件のコメント:

コメントを投稿