![]() | sorata31@財務省から国民を守る党 (@sorata311) |
|
深夜にヤバいもの見つけてしまった。インターネット・アーカイブからMMTが生まれた瞬間を発掘した。モズラーがポストケインジアンたちの議論に参加した一番最初の記録だ。
web.archive.org/web/1999100300… | |
https://twitter.com/sorata311/status/1286349671955341312?s=21
これを読むと、モズラーは最初の時点で「租税貨幣論」「スペンディングファースト」「国債の役割は財源ではなく金利誘導」というアイデアをポストケインジアンたちに紹介している。
PKT jan96 discussions sorted: Currency Definition (inflation)
https://web.archive.org/web/19991003002206/http://csf.colorado.edu/mail/pkt/96/jan96/0256.htmlCurrency Definition (inflation)
- Messages sorted by: [ date ][ thread ][ subject ][ author ]
- Previous message: Robert Vienneau: "Re: "Marx for Dummies""
- Next in thread: John Gelles: "Re: Currency Definition (inflation)"
mosler@gate.net
I am a new subscriber. I have been working in the financial
markets for about 23 years.
markets for about 23 years.
Given that fiat money begins as a tax credit, the driving force is the fact
that the private sector needs the government's money to be able
to pay its taxes. This leads to the conclusion that the currency is
defined exogenously by the government with its spending policy.
The few pk inflation discussions I have read do not seem to consider this.
Are there any references available?
(It also means that from inception a government must spend, or otherwise
provide, at least enough of its fiat money to the private sector to be able
to collect the taxes due. This accounting identity means that a balanced
budget defines a minimum level of spending.)
that the private sector needs the government's money to be able
to pay its taxes. This leads to the conclusion that the currency is
defined exogenously by the government with its spending policy.
The few pk inflation discussions I have read do not seem to consider this.
Are there any references available?
(It also means that from inception a government must spend, or otherwise
provide, at least enough of its fiat money to the private sector to be able
to collect the taxes due. This accounting identity means that a balanced
budget defines a minimum level of spending.)
Consider a model that appears in my paper, "Soft Currency
Economics." (http://inca.gate.net/~mosler/softecon.html)
In it the government offers a job, at an unchanging rate of pay,
to all takers. This defines the currency, and establishes what I
call a supplementary labor force, which acts as a classic stabilizer.
All other prices are allowed to float, allowing the market to
allocate through price.
Economics." (http://inca.gate.net/~mosler/softecon.html)
In it the government offers a job, at an unchanging rate of pay,
to all takers. This defines the currency, and establishes what I
call a supplementary labor force, which acts as a classic stabilizer.
All other prices are allowed to float, allowing the market to
allocate through price.
Currently, governments attempt to target spending and taxing,
and let employment and prices float. My model attempts to fix
unemployment and inflation at 0 and let the deficit float. It is not meant
as a complete solution, but to open discussion.
and let employment and prices float. My model attempts to fix
unemployment and inflation at 0 and let the deficit float. It is not meant
as a complete solution, but to open discussion.
I am also looking for references for the concept that sovereign debt
in local fiat currency is a monetary function. It serves as interest
rate support, not funding. A government offers to borrow its own fiat
currency not because it needs it to spend, but because it wishes the
interbank rate to be higher than 0 bid.
in local fiat currency is a monetary function. It serves as interest
rate support, not funding. A government offers to borrow its own fiat
currency not because it needs it to spend, but because it wishes the
interbank rate to be higher than 0 bid.
Thank you.
Warren B. Mosler
Director of Economic Analysis
III Finance
Director of Economic Analysis
III Finance
See:
- Previous message: Robert Vienneau: "Re: "Marx for Dummies""
- Next in thread: John Gelles: "Re: Currency Definition (inflation)"
https://web.archive.org/web/20000413135544/http://csf.colorado.edu/mail/pkt/96/jan96/index.html#265
PKT jan96 discussions sorted by thread
- Most recent messages
- Messages sorted by: [ date ][ subject ][ author ]
- Other mail archives
Starting: Tue 02 Jan 1996 - 00:40:32 MDT
Ending: Wed 31 Jan 1996 - 17:51:58 MDT
Messages: 328
Ending: Wed 31 Jan 1996 - 17:51:58 MDT
Messages: 328
- Re: get a life Steve.Keen@unsw.EDU.AU
- depreciation & replacement in Marx Mathew.B.Forstater@jupiter.cc.gettysburg.edu
- Product and Labour Markets Elias.Karagiannis@spg.org
- Doctor Blames Economic Theorists Peter Kelson
- Re: Doctor Blames Economic Theorists John Gelles
- Megaeconomic Causes of Budget Deficits Gernot Kohler
- Debt as distributor Mason A. Clark
- New Web Page for Progressive Economists Norman R. McLeod
- Re: Debt as distributor Thornton Wheeler
- Re: Debt as distributor John Gelles
- Re: Debt as distributor Thornton Wheeler
- Re: Debt as distributor Thornton Wheeler
- The Global Resource Bank Proposal JPOZZI@aol.com
- The World according to Uncle Milt Mason A. Clark
- Paul Davidson as a Megaeconomist Gernot Kohler
- Optimum Exchange Rate System (Part 3) Leigh Harkness
- EEA Call for Papers (fwd) John Adams
- Friction-Free Economy (Consume but Don't Work) John Gelles
- A PKT Session at the EEA Ric Holt
- Re: Rules Of Thumb LYNN TURGEON, PROFESSOR EMERITUS OF ECONOMICS, HOFSTRA UNIVERSITY, ECOELT@VAXB.H
- Re: Rules Of Thumb Doug Henwood
- Re: Rules Of Thumb Mason A. Clark
- On inflation and interest rates Michael Perelman
- Re: Rules Of Thumb (Costa Rica) Juan Manuel Villasuso
- Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Alan G. Isaac
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Paul Davidson
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Alan G. Isaac
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Alan G. Isaac
- Query Kevin Quinn
- Re: Query Doug Henwood
- Re: Query MOSS@vaxvmsx.babson.edu
- Re: Real vs Nominal interest rates John Gelles
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) bill mitchell
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Alan G. Isaac
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) bill mitchell
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Steve.Keen@unsw.EDU.AU
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Leigh Harkness
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Alan G. Isaac
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Leigh Harkness
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Alan G. Isaac
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Leigh Harkness
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Alan G. Isaac
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation (was: Rules of Thumb) Leigh Harkness
- Turn in your reports, please. Mason A. Clark
- Re: Rules Of Thumb (Costa Rica) Doug Henwood
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation Juan Manuel Villasuso
- The Missing Liberal Agenda John Gelles
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation Mason A. Clark
- econ. & financial data diskettes CarrierD@aol.com
- Re: Rules Of Thumb Paul Davidson
- Re: Rules Of Thumb (Costa Rica) Paul Davidson
- Re: Rules Of Thumb (Costa Rica) Doug Henwood
- life-cycle-of-lists Ric Holt
- real interest rates / assa Randy Wray
- Kaldor and the rate of interest GREG RANSOM
- Kaldor and the rate of interest GREG RANSOM
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation Juan Manuel Villasuso
- Debt and Depression Mason A. Clark
- Re: Debt and Depression C.N.Gomersall
- Re: Debt and Depression Timothy Canova
- call for names for fed openings Timothy Canova
- Re: call for names for fed openings Doug Henwood
- Re: call for names for fed openings Christopher Niggle
- Alvin Hansen GREG RANSOM
- Re: Interest Rates and Inflation Robert Vienneau
- Re: Optimum Exchange Rate System Gernot Kohler
- Apology Mason A. Clark
- Re: Query Robert Peter Burns
- real interest rates/assa Ric Holt
- rule of thumb Ric Holt
- RE: rule of thumb GREG RANSOM
- New Year Resolution and Pkt Guidelines Ric Holt
- Real vs Nominal interest rates (fwd) Paul Davidson
- Re: Real vs Nominal interest rates (fwd) Arindrajit DuBe
- Re: flat earth econ I Randy Wray
- rule of thumb John Vertegaal
- Monthly Reminder Gary Langer
- RE: Interest Rates and Inflation Alan G. Isaac
- Re: flat earth econ I Doug Henwood
- Re: Inflation & Interest Rates (was: Rules Of Thumb) Bruce McFarling
- Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Alan (fwd) Paul Davidson
- real rates/flat earthism Randy Wray
- profit rate Eigo Murakami
- Re: Real vs Nominal interest rate (fwd) Robert Vienneau
- Flat Tax LONNIE K. STEVANS, DEPT. OF BCIS/QM
- From Lynn Turgeon Ric Holt
- Minsky Paul Davidson
- Re: Flat Tax John Gelles
- M-G-M' and Megaeconomic Leakage Gernot Kohler
- Re: Minsky Ric Holt
- Economic Policy Analysis Discussion mckeever
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates JAMES C. W. AHIAKPOR
- Re: flat earth econ I Mason A. Clark
- Interest Rates Mason A. Clark
- Re: finance v. industry Timothy Canova
- Alan's two economy experiment Paul Davidson
- Another Eastern Session Ric Holt
- Baby Boomer Rights and Expectations John Gelles
- Re: Megaeconomic Leakage and International Payments System Leigh Harkness
- Amen Mason A. Clark
- Re: Megaeconomic Leakage and International Payments System Mason A. Clark
- Monthly Review LYNN TURGEON, PROFESSOR EMERITUS OF ECONOMICS, HOFSTRA UNIVERSITY, ECOELT@VAXB.H
- New Column: "Chinese Mirrors" James K. Galbraith
- "Chinese Mirrors" James K. Galbraith
- Re: Flat Tax John Gelles
- Email Ver. Galbraith's "Chinese Mirrors" John Gelles
- Austrians vs. Post Keynesians GREG RANSOM
- Austrians vs. Post Keynesians GREG RANSOM
- Austrians vs. Post Keynesians GREG RANSOM
- Re: real rates and flat earths Randy Wray
- Austrians vs. Post Keynesians GREG RANSOM
- Re: real rates and flat earths Mason A. Clark
- Re: real rates and flat earths Doug Henwood
- Re: real rates and inflation Doug Henwood
- Re: real rates and flat earths GREG RANSOM
- Post Keynesian Conference, June 27-July3 Paul Davidson
- Post Keynesian Conference, June 27-July3 Paul Davidson
- Re: International Payments System Gernot Kohler
- Re: Megaeconomic Leakage Gernot Kohler
- CB -- How free to set rates? Gernot Kohler
- Re: real rates and flat earths Doug Henwood
- Re: real rates and flat earths Doug Henwood
- course outlines for alternative introductory courses VORST1@ccm.UManitoba.CA
- Re: International Payments System Leigh Harkness
- Re: Megaeconomic Leakage Leigh Harkness
- Re: Megaeconomic Leakage mckeever
- real rates Randy Wray
- Galbraith's "Chinese Mirrors" John Gelles
- China travels James K. Galbraith
- Re: Megaeconomic Leakage Leigh Harkness
- Russian Interest in deposit insurance mckeever
- deposit insurance mckeever
- Re: Harkness Foreign Currency "Invisible Hand" Thornton Wheeler
- Re: Megaeconomic Leakage mckeever
- Re: CB -- How free to set rates? Timothy Canova
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al Basil Moore
- Re: PKT digest 908 Randy Wray
- Liabilities of posting students' homework mckeever
- Re: PKT digest 908 aisaac@american.edu
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al aisaac@american.edu
- Print Money - why not? Mason A. Clark
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al Doug Henwood
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al MARIO SECCARECCIA
- Job Exports and Mega Aggregate Demand Gernot Kohler
- further query re Henwood re Japnese interest rates Gregoire de Nowell
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al Doug Henwood
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al MARIO SECCARECCIA
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al MARIO SECCARECCIA
- testing Randy Wray
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al Doug Henwood
- Posting liability mckeever
- Re: Megaeconomic Leakage Leigh Harkness
- Commerce, Complexity & Evolution Draft Program (Sydney, Australia) Steve.Keen@unsw.EDU.AU
- Disparity and Decline John Gelles
- Larry Summers on globalization Doug Henwood
- Get Serious about Aggregate Demand John Gelles
- comentarios-sugerencias Carlos Manuel Tinoco Sierraalta
- Macro Workshops at the New School NAME GARRETT BEKKER
- taxes & growth Doug Henwood
- RE: taxes & growth GREG RANSOM
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al MARIO SECCARECCIA
- Which Comes First: Money or Things It Can Buy? John Gelles
- "You Have New Mail" John Gelles
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al GREG RANSOM
- "Marx for Dummies" Michael Lam
- Currency Definition (inflation) mosler@gate.net
- Meek and Money Ric Holt
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al Doug Henwood
- Re: Meek and Money Ric Holt
- Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al MARIO SECCARECCIA
- megaeconomics, rates, and the wonders of www CHU@bear.com
- posting homework on the web... Gregoire de Nowell
- Re: posting homework on the web... Ric Holt
- Marx and Keynes Ric Holt
- Free Trade, Domestic Jobs, Foreign Aid John Gelles
- Indian economists Roger Koppl
- Global Resource Bank JPOZZI@aol.com
- Re: Larry Summers on globalization/technology Gernot Kohler
- Re: Global Resource Bank mosler@gate.net
- (no subject) mosler@gate.net
- Re: Job Exports and Mega Aggregate Demand mosler@gate.net
- Re: Larry Summers on globalization/technology mosler@gate.net
- Keynes, Malthus, & Mandeville Doug Henwood
- Re: Indian economists John Adams
- Re: The "lot" (Gelles) mosler@gate.net
- Keynes and Fiat Money John Gelles
- The Classics and the Neutrality of Money Goncalo Fonseca
- von Mises and Money Goncalo Fonseca
- Re: Indian economists John Adams
- Re: von Mises and Money John Gelles
- Thanks for the Indian economists Roger Koppl
- Re: L. Moss on Marx and Keynes Christopher Niggle
Last message date: Wed 31 Jan 1996 - 17:51:58 MDT
Archived on: Tue May 19 1998 - 11:00:29 MDT
Archived on: Tue May 19 1998 - 11:00:29 MDT
- Messages sorted by: [ date ][ subject ][ author ]
- Other mail archives

Messages sorted by: [ date ][ thread ][ subject ][ author ]
返信削除Next message: mckeever: "Liabilities of posting students' homework"
Previous message: Basil Moore: "Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al"
Wed, 24 Jan 1996 20:19:16 -0700 (MST)
Randy Wray (lwray@du.edu)
Frankly, I am tired of this issue, and suspect almost all others on
pkt are also done with it. Alan wonders if there is a PK position;
yes, and it has been stated many times by Paul, Roy Rotheim (over a
year ago), and others; it is based on Keynes. If you don't like Paul's
interpretation, look at the GT. Real rates are a residual; more than
that, they are a confusion, obtained by dividing one type of price by
the garbage can index.
Is there any empirical test. Of course not. You argue that real rates
matter, but they are purely subjective with a different real rate for
each person. Actually, there are of course a whole bunch of real rates
for every individual: dividing the nominal rate of each type of asset
by some price index change that is expected. further, of course no one
would use the CPI since that is irrelevant to individual behavior--no
one buys the whole basket. Thus, Alan divides by the candybar index;
my granny divides by the price index of those little glass pitchers
she collects, Paul divides by the garbage can index, etc. You have an
absurd, untestable theory. In retrospect we can always calculate an
expost real rate by dividing by CPI, but you deny that is relevant to
any decision. Thus, we are talking angels on pinheads. If there is
indeed a theory behind this, PKT is not the place for an examination
of it. I will read any serious paper you care to send.
The alternative is of course Keynes's NOMINAL q-c+l+a analysis,
clearly discussed in the GT, in much of Paul's writing, and by me in a
Cambridge Jnl article. The equalization is of expected nominal
returns, comprised of the four components. An expected change of the
CPI can of course affect one or more of these components--in nominal
terms--and thus cause adjustment of desired balance sheet positions.
There is never any reference to "real" returns, and no need to do so.
After the fact, one could do it, but it is a meaningless operation.
I promise, that is it from me on this topic.
randy wray
Next message: mckeever: "Liabilities of posting students' homework"
Previous message: Basil Moore: "Re: Real vs. Nomin
メッセージの並び順 日付 ] [ スレッド ] [ 件名 ] [ 著者
返信削除次のメッセージ: mckeever: "生徒の宿題を掲示することの責任"
前のメッセージです。Basil Moore: "Re: Real vs. Nominal Interest rates -- reply to Doug and Al"
1996年1月24日(水) 20:19:16 -0700 (MST)
ランディ・レイ (lwray@du.edu)
率直に言って、私はこの問題に飽き飽きしていて、他のほとんどの問題を疑っています。
PKTもそれで終了です。アランはPKのポジションがあるかどうかを疑問に思っています。
はい、そしてそれはポール、ロイ・ロートハイムによって何度も述べられています(over a
年前)など、ケインズをベースにしています。ポールの
解釈は、GTを見てください。実質レートは残差であり、それ以上に
それは、彼らは価格の1つのタイプを分割することによって得られる混乱であることを
ゴミ箱指数を
経験的なテストはありますか?もちろんありません あなたは、実質レートが
の実質率が異なる純粋に主観的なものです。
一人一人が 実際には、もちろん、実質的なレートの束があります
各個人のために:各タイプの資産の名目レートを割る
さらに、当然のことながら、誰も
それは個人の行動とは無関係なので、CPIを使用するだろう - いいえ
はバスケット全体を買う。このように、アランはキャンディバーの価格指数で割っています。
私のおばあさんは小さなガラスのピッチャーの価格指数で割っています
彼女が集めている、ポールがゴミ箱のインデックスで割っている、などなど あなたには
不条理で検証不可能な理論 振り返ってみると、私たちは常に
CPIで割ることで実質レートをExpostしていますが、あなたはそれが関係していることを否定しています。
どんな決定でも このように、ピンヘッドに天使の話をしているのです。もし
因果応報
そのうちの あなたが気になって送ってくる真面目な論文ならどんなものでも読みます。
代替案はもちろんケインズのNOMINAL q-c+l+a分析である。
GTで明確に議論され、ポールの文章の多くで、そして私によって
Cambridge Jnlの記事。等化は、期待される公称
の4つの要素から構成されるリターン。の期待値の変化は
CPIはもちろん、これらの構成要素のうちの1つ以上に影響を与えることができる--名目上では。
その結果、望ましいバランスシートポジションの調整を引き起こすことになる。
実際の」リターンへの言及は決してないし、その必要もない。
実際のところ、人はそれを行うことができたが、それは無意味な操作である。
私は約束します、それはこのトピックについての私からのそれです。
ランディ・レイ
次のメッセージ: mckeever: "生徒の宿題を掲示することの責任"
前のメッセージです。バジル・ムーア「Re: リアル vs. ノミン