| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
39:35 チャーネバ
56:35 (~ 1:15:05 )カブー
1:29:55 カブー
1:33:24 チャーネバ
文字起こし okay that's okay we're gonna give people another minute or two to join and then we'll get started you're now live on facebook okay thank you if everyone had the same opinions idea sorry okay why don't we begin and people to come in it's a beautiful day where i am um in the champlain valley of uh vermont um abnaki territory and uh my name is matthew burke i am a postdoc at the university of vermont with the gund institute and uh this is a project of uh or a program put together by the ecozoic for policy ecozoic policy project leadership for the ecozoic with support from the gund institute um [Music] and i'm so excited to have this this group and i know people continue to pile in we also have uh facebook live going now so we'll have people joining in in different ways we are recording and the chat is functional we're going to ask though if people can keep their questions toward the end we'll do a series of presentations from our our panelists and then we'll begin to take questions and we're going to try to leave plenty of time for a discussion and a question and answer and we should wrap up around a quarter to six so this session is called renew new england jobs guarantee and we're looking especially at the proposal coming out of renew new england alliance that's centered on a jobs guarantee to meet basic human needs this is a multi-state coalition and we have joshua kesten here today who's going to say a little bit about renew new england and kind of get us going with this proposal and what this coalition is all about josh kesten is the policy director at renew new england and is also organizing at the state local and regional level for a transformative green new deal centered around both racial justice and a jobs guarantee and josh will i'll hand it over to josh who will present uh some intro comments on renew new england and then introduce our panelists so thank you so much josh it's you thanks so much uh matthew and uh really super excited to be here um so yeah so my primary uh background in this work is uh actually as an organizer with the sunrise movement and now um as matthew mentioned i'm i'm currently working at renew um so i'm just gonna give a quick intro on uh renew just to give everyone a sense of like what we're up to here in new england and then i've been yeah and then i'll uh introduce the other panelists um we've got a really incredible panel up here today and um yeah after that i'm really looking forward to hearing what everyone has to say and hopefully we can have a lively discussion um so okay so what is renew um so renew was formed uh early on last year um in order to address uh the overlapping crises of you know racism justice mass unemployment um widespread economic exploitation and deprivation uh as well as the coronavirus uh pandemic and of course um you know the very the very real uh an imminent prospect of um severe and irreversible ecological collapse uh and our premise you know for launching renew was that these social uh social and environmental crises that i just mentioned are you know routinely treated as and distinct problems um but we thought uh when we factored a series of problems that have to be addressed holistically um so we brought oh i just got uh the notice that my internet connection is unstable can everyone hear me okay yeah okay here now it's coming and going but for now it seems okay or or maybe not go ahead okay cool feel free to just cut in and i'll connect on my phone it'll be okay um so uh yeah so as i was saying we we brought together over 150 organizations across new england into a coalition so we're talking about frontline communities racial justice advocates labor unions indigenous nations housing justice organizers youth climate activists and we're guided by a majority by park regional council that represents uh the coalition members in all six uh new england states
and we as the coalition went through an extensive grassroots-led process to determine our shared policy goals for the region and then we produced a really detailed map of what a serious green new deal for new england would actually look like and unsurprisingly you know that map that vision revolves around a jobs guarantee uh and so i should say a little bit about why we saw the jobs guarantee as so uh so central to our project and what you know concretely it could look like right here where we live um so so so here's the thing like the way we've all been conditioned to think about labor is just completely backwards and we're so used to the backwards narrative that it sometimes feels like kind of natural or even inevitable um okay so so what do i mean by that so well we're used to just reflexively assuming um jobs are always scarce asking why people think that's the case and when you really start thinking about it one fact that like immediately pops out at you is that it can't be the case the job scarce plot of work that needs to be done like all you have to do is glance around at society right now there's just huge building energy efficient housing to make sure everyone has a home for example or manufacturing and installing solar panels and wind turbines for another example or you know here's another huge chunk of work retrofitting homes and buildings to be like just dramatically more energy efficient and then of course like we haven't even gotten into all of the work that would be required to design and build a regional mass transit system that's like efficient and convenient enough to supplant personal vehicles and then of course there's just you know the massive expansion of care work and social reproduction that really needs to be done like you know elder care providers school teachers uh home health aides nurses etc like because you know like there are lots of older people why are medical care mental health care and lots of younger people who require education and child rearing work those needs not being met right now that's a lot of addition work needs to be done for global uh anxiety you know uh parks and and libraries and community centers and public spaces you know for no other because we want people to be able to enjoy those things um so you know the point that i'm trying to make is that it simply can't be the case the jobs are scarce because there isn't enough work to be done like there's so much work to be done so so what does that mean um well i think it means we're kind of in a strange situation right now and i think you know interestingly i think it's stranger than we often recognize you know in which on the one hand we have mass unemployment and on the other hand we've got huge amounts of essential work that just isn't getting done and so that's the reason that the renew coalition decided to put the jobs guarantee right at the center of you know our great new deal policy framework because really what the green new deal means you know in a deep sense is like just it's about reversing our backwards understanding of what work is like we can either have you know an economy designed like as it currently is to create jobs only when doing so would further enrich people and corporations that are already extremely wealthy or on the other hand we can have an economy designed to create jobs in order to meet social needs uh health care child care food like transportation clean air and of course like the enormous unmet need um to provide a livable climate that minimizes um you know the frequency and the severity of of droughts famines climate displacement uh wars over increasingly scarce resources extreme weather events and so forth like we're all familiar with the standard catalog of terrors that we'll be confronting if we don't rapidly get commission emissions under control um so anyway so our work at renew and and and i think at the green with with green new deal at organizers more generally is really i think at its most fundamental level um a challenge to uh you know the prevailing right-wing conception of what work is and what it should mean and of course it's also a challenge not just to the kinds of things that we consider as work or the kinds of work we do but also to the way that we treat workers which is why um you know strong labor practices so i'm talking about good salaries high quality benefits collective bargaining rights it's why all of that stuff is baked into all of the pieces of legislation that we've written and that we're fighting for all across the region um okay so that feels like a good segue for me to introduce uh the other panelists um all of whom have thought really really deeply about the meaning of work and the way that workers are treated and i'm really like genuinely really excited to be part of a discussion with all of them this afternoon um so first up we've got uh stephanie yoo who's the deputy director of the public assets institute which is a montpelier based non-partisan non-profit fiscal policy think tank working to improve the lives of everyday
vermonters and stephanie has worked as a fiscal analyst for the michigan senate a private sector financial analyst and in state government as a budget manager for the michigan department of treasury um and executive director of the west virginia commission for national and community service and then next up is liz medina who's the executive director of the vermont state labor council afl-cio and has previously served as the co-chair of the goddard college staff union uaw 2322 and then last year liz launched an oral history podcast called on mass which is part of the labor radio network in an effort to build up working class culture so next up we've got pavlina cerneva who is an associate professor of economics at bard college and a research scholar at the levy economics institute in new york specializing in modern monetary theory and public policy and her book which is called the case for a jobs guarantee for a job guarantee which is was was released last year is really the ultimate guide to the benefits of one of the most uh transformative public policies being discussed today and then we have fadel kaboob who's an associate professor of economics at denison university and the president of the global institute for sustainable prosperity um his research focuses on the political economy of the middle east and the fiscal and monetary policy dimensions of job creation programs so clearly like an extremely qualified panel um and uh yeah so happy to pass it off to any of these uh other panelists for their thoughts okay i think i'm up am i up yes please go ahead steph thank you thanks for the introduction and for that good food for thought josh i appreciate it um so as josh said public assets institute is really thinking about state level um economic fiscal policy from the perspective of of everyday people and so what are the impacts so so you know the the economy is not the stop stock market what is happening to people and how are they experiencing the economy um and i think one of the things that that josh just made me think of is um is part of that conversation around what we think of as work or or jobs what we think of as good jobs how we value those jobs also thinking about why we think private jobs are somehow better than public jobs or or we treat them like those are real jobs and public jobs are less real and less valuable and less worth protecting um so i think it's you know i think this is a great conversation i'm glad to be a part of it so i think my my role here is to kind of ground the the like the labor landscape in vermont what it's looked like over the last decade or more and sort of set the stage for for what that means in terms of thinking about where um where something like a jobs guarantee might make the biggest difference and sort of where the holes are but i think any conversation about the labor landscape um really has to start with this with with the the issue that the pandemic has obviously thrown things into just a lot of turmoil and we're really talking about a very different world than than it was a year ago so i think that's that's sort of the kind of starting place which is that we don't quite know what it where we'll land after this um i think one good thing about that is that it really opens up the possibilities for a lot of conversations we're having conversations about the role of government and about sort of our obligations to one another and what work is important what's essential um so i think that really does open up the possibilities for a lot of conversations i do always come bearing charts so i will share my screen and and sort of start to jump into that and try to kind of give you a quick overview of the labor landscape in vermont all right so um the the uh sort of starting off with this idea that the pandemic has really thrown things into just chaos i think this really gives you a sense i'm sure you've all seen some chart like this right where it's like this giant spike in unemployment unprecedented scale but i think the thing to note about this is that we're still you know we're still sort of way above the worst of the great recession so this is still at a scale even though we've come way way down from the peak we're still at a scale that is really pretty extreme for what we're talking about um so so but i also want to bring this conversation back to sort of state policy in the role of government vermont is one of the few states that has something like this enshrined in statute which is the purpose of the state budget right and the state's obligations to its citizens and so one of the and they list these things that every that you know that citizens are that not citizens i don't want to limit limited to citizens but that vermonters residents of vermont you know are entitled to these things which includes dignified work right uh so the three i have sort of three main takeaways that uh for this that i'd like to make here sort of what are the main points um the first is that the labor market in vermont is is pretty uneven right like it's not one labor market it's not one labor landscape
what's happening in the northwest corner is very different from what's happening in the south or the northeast kingdom so that's the first point the second point is that wages are low in vermont which is a big part of the problem when we talk about what the what the labor market what looks like what what jobs there are the third thing is that there's lots of people that are left out of the traditional labor market so so we talk a lot about sort of the increasing gig workers or self-employed people vermonters with disabilities are another group that often gets overlooked in the labor market and then you know i'm sure again you've sort of seen the stories and the headlines of the pandemic's disproportionate impact on women which is also holds true in vermont so just to kind of dig into each of these things a little bit more um so the labor market is uneven and so throughout the state so much of vermont hasn't recovered from the great recession and by recovered we mean you know they're still below they haven't they haven't recovered the lost ground the number of jobs or the people employed that they lost during the great recession and obviously and that was sort of going into this pandemic pandemic recession and the pandemic has has obviously worsened conditions throughout the state so you can see um really only half the counties have gained jobs since the great recession and again you know there's a conversation about what you know what does it mean to add jobs if the jobs that you're adding aren't that you know aren't good quality jobs what does that mean for people but again sort of you see this real really big difference between different parts of the state and and similarly the employment piece so again the jobs are sort of the payroll based jobs and then employment is the people working so it's not sort of a one-to-one map because the jobs piece is where the jobs are located and the employment piece is where the employees live right so so you're not going to see exactly the same pattern but you do see this this this unevenness the fact that in some areas there's growth and in some areas they're really struggling and continue to struggle um post-grade recession and then i think sort of just going back for 30 years a lot of the jobs that we've been adding over the last 30 years or really in the service services jobs and so while they're while it's not always true it's pretty true that most of those jobs tend to pay less tend to have more turnover right so these are sort of jobs that you wouldn't necessarily expect people to be in long term and so you can kind of see from this all of that job growth over the last 30 years is really in the services and then you can clearly see sort of the fall off in 2020 as a result of the pandemic and and the other piece where it's not where it hasn't been especially even is obviously the pandemic has had disparate impacts on different sectors right like we know that there are certain sectors that pretty much shut down completely um or that had really big impacts and while many of them have recovered some ground it you know they're still well below where they were pre-pandemic so the the second point this idea that that wages are low so again i think sort of going to the spirit of the conversation i think you know we certainly believe that vermonters and everyone else right should have a livable income at every stage of their lives so when they're kids if they're working full-time if they're temporarily unemployed if they're permanently unable to work and you know up to and including a secure retirement right so at every phase of their lives they should have enough to meet their basic needs and so that involves sort of a lot of levels of wage policy which you know starting with sort of the floor that minimum wage should be a livable wage but i think this slide really gets to this idea that even the average wages in vermont are pretty low so this is so this line represents the u.s average of both wages and prices of things and this sort of price price basket includes housing which so you know vermont's prices are pretty average relative to the rest of the
us but wages are really low and and again we know that that rents do tend to be a little bit higher than average in vermont but uh only about a third of vermont households are renters so and and again it's it's pretty different across the landscape of vermont so you can see how that chittenden average wage really brings up the average wage for the state and that you see a lot of the the other counties um wages are much lower than that so on the third point i think you know this idea that that many are left out of the vermont labor force so just to kind of give sort of the baseline demographics for the vermont labor force i think people hear a lot about sort of the aging of the workforce in vermont you know i what i see here is the biggest difference is really the racial demographics in vermont obviously compared to the rest of the country we really our demographics really haven't changed that much over the last 30 years unlike the rest of the country as a whole and then you also see that the education level that vermonters tend to be tend to have more bachelor's degrees per capita than the us as a whole so so that just sort of gives you a sense of who we're talking about and and you know part of this this is relevant vermont um so we we look at the uh vermonters with disabilities pictures and only about half of them are working and of the the half that are working only half are working full-time so that's one big group that tends to get overlooked in the labor market um we mentioned this issue of the pandemic having a disproportionate effect on women that's been true that the that of the traditionally unemployed people in vermont that that among the states actually vermont has the highest share that are women so about 70 of those unemployed of those collecting traditional unemployment benefits are women in vermont and so that's um a big group again it's sort of a question of what happens from here vermont was starting from a pretty good place and that we have pretty good labor force participation by women relative to the rest of the country but um you know sort of how long it takes to this to recover and how much of this has to do with caregiving responsibilities and some of those other things that again sort of tend not to have monetary value in our economy but but are obviously work that needs doing and has needed doing this year especially um so so that's another piece and then the other piece which we don't tend to have a lot of uh hard data for but is true in the rest of the country and is true here as well which is that bypoc vermonters tend to tend to stay unemployed longer after recessions and you know there's more of an impact on buyback vermonters in terms of the job prospects after you know after a recession and then the last point i think in terms of the uneven sort of picture of this this is the same sort of this is the same unemployment claims chart that i showed at the beginning but what i what we did here is sort of break it out by the type of unemployment benefits that people are receiving so what you see there is that the red band is those that aren't traditionally covered by unemployment and this is sort of another area where that term is even sort of misleading right um where in general a lot of workers don't qualify in normal times a lot of workers don't qualify for unemployment benefits and even if those who qualify many don't get them but in this case you know there was this expansion by the federal government to open it up to more and a lot of that ban that self-employed and gig workers so you can see that sort of red band stays pretty steady and there's quite a few of those people who wouldn't normally be part of the unemployment system who are still requiring benefits now so again sort of coming back to this still 30 000 vermonters receiving unemployment benefits um and um and you know again a pretty big number and a good chunk of them are these people who wouldn't traditionally be included in that so sort of a quick overview of of sort of where we've been and and where we are and how much the pandemic has just sort of thrown things into upheaval but so so i think that we're still sort of absorbing the impact of of the pandemic but i think there's also opportunity in that you know there's a lot of gaps in labor policy i think that josh called out and then i'm sure many of you will will bring up but again what what we choose to call work how we value it you know the undervaluing of caregiving and other essential work i mean we clearly saw this you know vermont actually did provide some hazard pay to essential workers unlike a lot of states but it was still relatively minimal um vermont also provided some you know comparable stimulus payments to undocumented workers which not a lot of states did so you know there are again sort of these gaps where where people get missed and left out but i think um you know
and then there's also this question of what what are the why are vermont's wages low what are the forces that keep those wages low that push those wages low that stop them from going and what can we do about that and a lot of that has to do with labor policy i think you also mentioned the child care system which it which again we know it's both too expensive for parents and not paying and can't pay the workers a livable wage the provider's livable wage so you know that child care system is broken in in multiple ways and the unemployment system as well this is a temporary expansion of it it's certainly i mean i think the goal and what you're talking about in terms of a jobs guarantee is that you know going forward you have minimal use minimal need for the unemployment system i mean there's probably always some need um but that you you really minimize the use because you keep people connected to to the labor market as much as possible um and that people who want to work can work so you know i think that's really the goal and sort of what we're talking about here there's kind of a long list and a quick overview but hopefully that help that's helpful to sort of set the stage of of this conversation thank you so much steph that was fantastic and uh it's really helpful to to get these numbers in vermont and understand where where we are at the moment especially uh given all the the struggles that you you brought to the table here i'd like to go to liz medina welcome liz thank you um thank you stephanie that was really insightful we have a lot of work clearly it's still to do here in vermont so um thank you for having me here my name is liz medina i am the executive director of vermont state labor council afl-cio which is our state's federation of labor unions um i also produce as mentioned a podcast featuring workers oral histories called on mass and my first season actually focused on depression era oral histories funded by the federal writers project which was under the ewpa and bringing people together to read and perform those stories was a wonderful rich experience for those involved and hopefully for people who listened as well so therefore when i heard that a jobs guarantee was at the heart of the renew coalition of which the vermont afl-cio is part it felt like kismet a jobs guarantee has been a dream of labor of every leader we cherish of every person who has had to work for a living and knows the pain of not having work it took over a quarter of our country being out of work during the great depression starving standing in bread lines and thousands marching in the streets for our country to do something substantial for working people in 1933 the national industrial recovery act or nera was passed which recognized the right to organize and launch the pwa which was followed by the wpa the right to organize combined with a federal jobs program albeit temporary created the conditions necessary for workers to organize on mass and in 1934 over 1.4 million workers were involved in strike actions a mass labor movement was forming creating a power base for fdr and the new deal democrats to pass the kind of bold legislation that made the post-war period the most prosperous in our nation's history with the lowest levels of income inequality we've seen since we've begun measuring them in 1915 which lasted until the 1980s and so the growth of the labor movement and the successes of the wpa led to bolder visions in particular vision for a future in which one's ability to make a living wasn't dependent upon the manipulations of the market by a few a philip randolph president of the brotherhood of sleeping car porters began developing proposal for a jobs guarantee an idea that catalyzed the march on washington for jobs and freedom in 1963. there were also several legislative efforts that enshrined the notion that every american ought to have the right to a job with dignity such as the employment act of 1946 and the humphrey hawkins full employment act of 1970 but unfortunately they remain toothless and aspirational in their final forms an intense backlash from the capitalist class and their captured politicians has resulted in the steady decline of union density since its peak in 1954.
this decline has marginalized our country's only movement capable of realizing a jobs guarantee one which is broad diverse and moreover labor-based so i'm briefly rehashing this history which i'm sure all of you know um to remind us that we need to rebuild the labor movement in order to win a jobs guarantee a jobs guarantee has overwhelming majority support among u.s voters so we've won the narrative however instead of following the direction of the rank and file too many unions in labor organizations have instead obsiquisly followed the direction of the corrupt and corporatized democratic party we don't want to merely catch a coin that is flung at us once in a while especially when we're facing multiple global crises such as a global pandemic nor should we be satisfied with only a universal basic income we need dignity and democracy in our workplaces and communities rather than trusting the democratic party and a few tech ceos to determine our future working people deserve to not only be included but to be leaders in such decisions and that means we need to retain our strategic role at the point of production rebuilding the labor movement means rediscovering and reigniting our true source of power which is us the working class we know what we want we want comfortable homes nutritious food for our families excellent health care for all clean air and water the irony is that we can produce everything we need but we have an oligarchy in this country hoarding resources in power with a jobs guarantee we can redirect these desperately needed resources back into our communities creating as many jobs as we need to provide for our basic needs we need to have conversations about why we need a jobs guarantee with our union brothers sisters and siblings to start we need to seize every moment and platform to highlight the need for a jobs guarantee on a national level this pandemic has shown the need for more health care workers social workers and many other essential workers who are being stretched then working without reprieve in dangerous conditions on a local level we need to seize any opportunities in our workplace struggles for instance back in 2018 the aft-affiliated vermont federation of nurses and healthcare professionals went out on strike the nurses didn't solely focus on wages and benefits important as those are they also highlighted the issue of an alarmingly high patient to nurse ratio at the university of vermont medical center nurses gained vast community support over the issue of safe staffing which enabled them to win community support to go on strike the strike made everyone in the state aware of the need for more well-paid nursing jobs in vermont it's only a small step to go from that issue of safe staffing to a call for a jobs guarantee we need to talk to our co-workers friends and neighbors i've spoken with too many working vermonters who are given impossible workloads a conversation with a diversion case manager in very stands out in particular when collecting oral histories of working vermonters this person shared that they were close to reaching 100 cases they were called to do social work it ran deep into their family's upbringing and ethos however they were constantly stressed out by the fact that they couldn't offer as much help as was needed for each client because of the overwhelming caseload they worked around the clock coming home only to do more work never even having the chance to settle down and hang out with their partner during their evenings it was a pattern in the field and they were close to completely burning out because of chronic understaffing and lack of resources our social work system ends up serving no one meanwhile we have thousands of vermonters out of work feeling rejected and without purpose the reality of our oppressive capitalist system in our lives is dark and painful despite the many fictions our oppressors tell us we are made to believe we live in a meritocracy but most of us are barely getting by despite our best efforts and the vast wealth that we produce perhaps the hardest part is to stop putting all the blame on ourselves and to realize we are all connected to other forces and people beyond ourselves i've been on this journey myself like many others in my generation i struggled with a period of unemployment in my early stages of my career
i had to move back home and for me back home is returning to an economically depressed rust belt town where empty buildings and storefronts loom large that period remains the darkest in my life yet i refuse to let shame and fear control me and that is why i am personally invested in the fight for a jobs guarantee so a jobs guarantee can prevent our brothers sisters siblings union and non-union from being worked to death a jobs guarantee could counter the despotic power of employers by giving choices to workers a jobs guarantee could help to build unity among unemployed and employed workers whom employers often pit against each other in order to maintain their power a jobs guarantee could help build unity among all kinds of workers the kind of unity we need to rebuild the labor movement and make a jobs guarantee a reality in the words of a philip randolph salvation for a race nation or class must come from within freedom is never granted it is one justice is never given it is exacted randall's ultimate vision was a freedom budget the center of which was a jobs guarantee the time has come to honor both ourselves and our movement for bearers the time has come for us to win a jobs guarantee and the freedom and justice that comes with it thank you we have a lot of talking to do thank you so much liz that was fantastic and i really appreciate this the deep historical knowledge that you bring to this this conversation um and appropriate to connect freedom to unity as we're talking about it here in vermont um [Music] from this specific angle right so so so appreciate it thank you liz uh i'd like to invite uh pablina chernova um to uh uh provide some comments and then from there we'll go to uh farrell caboodle thank you pablina
チャーネバ:
thank you everyone uh thank you so much for the invitation for the comments you set the stage for what i'm going to say and i think my job here is to bring the bird's eye view picture the macro picture to the analysis but i just think um the themes are so important and the first of course is that the scarcity of job is really not because there's no work to do as josh was pointing out we've got ton more than we have people to do them um my perspective would be that the scarcity of jobs is there um not just because of lack of vision that we are not valuing the public sector work and the importance of um the direct contribution that government can make but doesn't but the scarcity is there also because of inaction because of a mission and also because of policy specific policy so i want to bring that perspective how economists think about unemployment how they reproduce these false frames that it is natural that it is unavoidable and even perhaps even necessary i think this is really important to debunk the second thing i want to talk about is that there is a certain sense in which unemployment is perennial it is with us it is typical to this economic system the system that has this very peculiar heartbeat a system that grows and shrinks and grows and shrinks and it's subject to all sorts of uh vagaries of market vigor is from trade to technology etc and the collateral damage is always people it's always jobs but there's nothing unavoidable about that you know that we do have very direct means and methods of creating employment when jobs are sacrificed for one reason or another right um so that's that's the second uh part this this the the third the third uh issue i want to discuss is how i i'm hearing um in this conversation this dire need to create um support for ongoing essential work that is be that is not being done that our society needs and that we are regularly told that we can't have these things from child care to elderly care to infrastructure to social care to environmental work we're constantly told we can't have those things and this is extremely important to keep in mind as we re-envision the future of work what kind of society we have but i want to also shine a light on another aspect of the job guarantee and that is that it is a public option it is that ultimate guarantee that whatever your circumstance whoever you are um they will be uh an option in the public sector at a basic dignified wage benefit package so those those i think in the discussion we can proceed to talk about that they they probably should be seen as somewhat separate things because essential ongoing permanent sector work must be there at all times but there will always be this heartbeat to the economy that will mean that some people will be losing their jobs and gaining their jobs
and we want to also make sure that that is no longer part of our macroeconomic world right that we have an option for people who need jobs whatever the circumstance and and finally i want to say a few things about how just like liz was saying how once you imagine a world in which the employment is a right and everyone has access to that right that really represents a new social contract and it it does um change the rules of the game the labor market how we live how we relate to each other but very important point that was made is that in fact the fates of the working people and the unemployed are indelibly intertwined they cannot be separated so i had a powerpoint presentation but i'm not going to do this it's just going to be dull and boring but i think it's um you know several things to to point out it is absolutely essential that we organize around this idea because it is extremely popular and i have numbers and i'm happy to share them um that it's not just popular but it is the job guarantee garners bipartisan support even conservative support is upwards of fifty percent and um uh this these surveys are recent and being replicated around the world just this morning i was looking at a new one from france 79 support for a green job guarantee in france yougov did a survey last year 70 plus percent in the uk in the united states in the recent years it's been consistently in the 70 percent so it is even though at the federal level we might there are there are movements at the federal level right um whether the federal government pursues a job guarantee policy i think it's still good local politics to organize around it okay so the next thing that i wanted to say is that um from a macro bird's eye view perspective there are a couple of things to keep in mind um of course each of our struggles is going to be much easier and each of our um our activism is going to be easier if of course we have the umbrella policy which can kind of empower the local job guarantees if we have the federal policy and in the recent resolution that was advanced by a representative ayanna presley they were like three core components that we want to keep in mind first that the right to employment is a basic human right but also that it is paid by public money and that it is for public employment for the public good so that would be kind of the aspirational at the aspirational context and then there's the macroeconomic context and here i just want to spend a few minutes to talk a little bit about um how economists i'm sorry to say are the villain um and we got to reject the frame that unemployment is natural and where it comes from is these um old calcified theoretical notions that unemployment is just something that is unavoidable that the market can create only so many jobs that um policy really does not have a lot of levers to push unemployment below what the market deems to be the natural level because if policy attempts to do that it might generate undesirable inflation some people are familiar with this some people who don't watch the feds are surprised to hear this that actually the central bank has a unemployment rate that's a policy that's a positive unemployment rate of some percentage 3.5 4.5 percent that is the policy guide that tells them when they need to step on the brakes and remove whatever stimulus they might be offering in the economy for fear of seeing inflation and of course when you think about this you know what the channel is that too many people have jobs too many people have incomes too much spending power and perhaps too much to eat and thus we have to fight inflation by actually um sacrificing employment or tolerating some positive level of unemployment that is so ingrained in the macroeconomic model in the way orthodox economists think the way models are put together whether they're the congressional budget office whether they're the central bank there is this notion lurking in these macro models that unemployment is natural and is desirable for macroeconomic stability and price stability and so in my work and you know worker fidel and our colleagues
you know we try to debunk this idea that in fact we do have alternatives we can create jobs we can use the job guarantee itself to provide the kind of economic stabilization and even price stabilization that currently unemployment is used for um and so in our work we at the macro level the policy level we reject the necessity of an unemployment as a policy tool and that we we argue that the unknown that the job guarantee will be that buffer it will be that powerful force that will increase when there are recessions just naturally it's a demand given policy when when people need work they tap into the job guarantee it is that very expenditure by the public sector that provides economic stability and it's so much better than just throwing money at the problem right when the person has employment the whole world is different and when they rely on unemployment however generous it is and so um the job guarantee is the stabilizer that grows in downturns um that provides employment when jobs flee due to trade or whatever and that shrinks when economic life returns to the community when the private firms and mom and pop shops start springing up and they start offering employment so it is actually that buffer that that increases and and shrinks in the same way that unemployment does and so from the really the bird's eye view picture um the public sector is always responsible for unemployment the public sector is always responsible uh for the social costs of unemployment for providing however meager support and assistance um for the unemployed you know for anti-poverty programs the unemployed are part and parcel of the public sector whether the government recognizes this or not we are responsible collectively for the social fallout of unemployment and all of the human costs in my work i kind of catalog and document them and they are very large it is a very expensive proposition to tolerate unemployment and its social costs it is a much better policy to inoculate against those and provide a job to a job seeker a good job a decent pay with good benefits okay so uh so at the macro level we have two choices we either either tolerate the system based on unemployment that you know unemployment yo-yos it grows rings or we have a public option that provides the requisite missing job opportunities that kind of policy commitment that this would be done at all times not just in the middle of a pandemic but also in the so-called full fully employed economy right there's still people seeking work even in the best of times that kind of policy commitment that they will be employment opportunities there at all times does represent a new social contract and so i want to just run through what i think might be some of these pillars of the social of the new social contract and the first one is based on this discussion that we've we've had so far that unemployment is really vandalism um this is a term that uh bill victoria an economist used to argue unemployment is vandalism it's we you know we accept uh from the macro level or the policy level this vandalism is some sort of necessary and because we have direct employment and direct action um it is certainly not necessary um the second part is that if the public sector is responsible for the social cost then it actually has an obligation to do things better to not quote unquote support a system based on neglect and devastation whether it's environmental whether it is human and then you know pay for the costs real or financial for this kind of um neglect but it actually has a responsibility and obligation to pay for investment in those communities for investment in in people um in our most precious resources this the the next part of the social contract is that yes the job guarantee is our economic stabilizer which means that our overall economy is more stable with with direct employment than without it and by by by implementing it we actually can establish a new labor standard what that means is when a person has a public option for a job that pays 15 an hour at a minimum with medicare with social security with paid vacation that's the standard the person who doesn't have that they have an option and if the employer who doesn't offer those benefits wish to retain those workers they have to match the standard so it is it is important it is foundational to establish a standard through employment in addition to the other ways in which we attempt to establish the labor standard in other words we have a minimum wage policy all well and good we have to raise the minimum wage but if you can get a minimum wage policy minimum wage job you don't benefit from that standard so we need both the legal legislated wage but we also need the employment option that you can access that right we can have i mean i think you know healthcare needs to be separate from employment that has to be part of the social wage that has to be part of the standard that we aspire to but if you're working you should have days of rest and you should have paid leave right and then that becomes the standard okay so the public option establishes the minimum floor of what we consider to be a dignified work the second aspect is you explain it very well that when we have public um employment we actually value different things we value socially useful things we value people we value the public good the environment uh the very many things that don't have immediate commercial return profit return and must be done nonetheless in fact that's what our care economy is right the environment doesn't pay but the environment um nurtures us so we are we have neglected in fact what seems to be important okay uh all right finally um we reject the threat of unemployment i think here liz talked very articulately about how we are connected if we if we refuse this idea that unemployment is necessary to discipline workers
we have a completely different paradigm of how we value workers and how we um support them in their jobs and how we promote them it's not the threat and fear of losing your livelihood but there are other ways in which now we are you know quote unquote motivate if you will right it becomes not a punitive uh paradigm uh but also as we said you know it's we we we remove an important power of the firm um that the unemployment um in sort of pitting workers against each other and preventing or organization so i think that this is i just really loved listening to you know uh this is recognition that you know you union work is so um in a way contingent on having tight full employment okay um next we reject trade-offs you know we're told technology is going to take away your jobs uh trade is going to take you away your jobs the green transition is going to take you away your jobs and people are fearful of that and they don't pursue the kind of policies we need but now we have we have an answer and fidel will talk about the importance of the job guarantee in the environmental movement um and finally um we embrace democratic design that in fact these policies must be uh implemented from the ground up in in cities in towns and localities where people know exactly what they need the kind of work that must be done who can do it and can do this the assessment and implementation that is necessary to make these policies resilient and to address uh specific community needs so i think that um last but not least we kind of reinstate and reinform our commitment to this basic human right that was part of the conversation a new deal it was the economic bill of rights had the right to employment as the first pillar and we left that conversation um i think in part because uh economists convinced us that full employment is three percent unemployment and there's the most that we can do uh but we need to sort of return to that uh commitment and um re-articulate it through through the job guarantee so i'm just gonna end here and pass it on to fidel
カバーブ:
thank you pavlina this was a wonderful set of presentations really enjoyed it and i'd like to add a few more components and transition us into talking more about the job guarantee in the context of a green new deal at the national level or at the at the local level um but first i'd like to comment on on a few of the things that that were already said i mean the the mainstream economist that pavlino was referring to let's remember that these guys were wrong about inequality they were wrong about climate change they're wrong about inflation they're wrong about almost everything that they're wrong about the financial crisis call their bluff i mean why are we still listening to these guys and giving them air time on on bloomberg so that's number one number two um the main argument that they have which is you know too much government spending on unemployment on climate action we'll just bankrupt the country we'll have hyperinflation we'll turn into a venezuela well the last 10 years have demonstrated that large government deficits you know large government spending in the u.s in europe and japan and the uk did not lead to inflation you know japan has the highest debt to gdp ratio in the world 260 percent and they have negative interest rates and they have deflation for the last 30 years so call their bluff they have no idea what they're talking about the ecb has acknowledged this finally they said we really don't know what determines interest rates and why are these things happening we thought it was just japan something strange happening there but apparently it's deeper than that the fed also here in the us said we don't actually have a reliable theory of inflation translation in plain english we have no idea what how these things work so call their bluff and and let's have a progressive movement that tackles the issues that matter we're told that you know we have millions of people who actually want to work we have the planet is on fire we have the technology the resources the brain power to get things done and somehow we're told we can't do any of this right we've done it before during the the new deal and uh and liz presentation was a wonderful reminder of what we're capable of doing we've done it with pen and paper we didn't have the logistical capabilities and and it wasn't just building bridges it was taking care of people something that a lot of people don't remember from about the wpa workers they made something like more than two million home visits wellness checks taking care of people people who were you know coming back from uh surgery um mothers that recently delivered or people who just needed elderly care or child care this was part of building infrastructure and i'm glad that we're sort of coming back to this conversation this week that infrastructure is also people it's also the care economy and to to look at the the numbers of people that we currently have not just during the pandemic pre-pandemic when we were so-called close to full employment or at full employment the lowest level since the 60s when you actually dig into the hidden unemployment statistics right before the pandemic there were not only millions of people who are still officially unemployed but millions of people who couldn't take a job not because they didn't want to didn't have the skills because they didn't have reliable transportation and the job didn't pay enough for them to to buy a car or to have access to public transportation millions of people couldn't take jobs not because they didn't want to didn't have the skills but because the jobs didn't pay enough for somebody to take care of their kids or take care of their elderly family members to so we're excluding millions of people from the economy because of how low the standards are the labor standards so completely applaud the calls for uh a labor movement to be at the center of this discussion and and some of you have have seen the series that we've been doing this uh month with the rosa luxembourg foundation i'm happy to drop the the links on the chat and this afternoon we just had a a fantastic panel with sarah nelson with carl rosen and and keon laboratory all of them from the labor movement are saying we can't have the pro act we can't have none of the all the big things that we're calling for without a united movement that recognizes who is us and who is them it's not this union against that union is not this it's us against the vested interests that are controlling and suffocating the system so i'll say a few words about the the big thing that they usually push back on on the job guarantee in the green deal i'm dropping this link in the chat that for people who are interested in some of the details this is part of the kind of job guarantee mmt literature that paulina and stephanie kelton and others are part of which is the simple message that we're told that the government doesn't have the resources to pay for this it's got to be the private sector creating jobs that the government is limited in terms of its spending capacity by tax revenues and a little bit of borrowing whatever wall street will let the government borrow or we're disciplined by wall street beyond that if the government spends more it's going to cause hyperinflation well what mmt and what the job guarantee literature is is teaching us is that there's plenty of additional spending capacity that the federal government can tap into that's how we tapped into it during world war ii during the new deal era during financing the care paying for the cares act paying for the 1.9 trillion dollars and paying for all the wars and all the tax cuts we have that additional spending capacity we're just told every time it's about jobs it's about the middle class that this is going to bankrupt the country we're going to turn into a venezuela or something like that so call their bluff on that because what we know from the mmt literature the job guarantee literature is that what determines how much additional spending we can safely have is the potential risk of inflation which is determined by two very important things for for all of us to have on the map here one is if we run out of productive capacity we hit the inflation risk meaning if we run out of skilled workers if we run out of materials and equipment and technology and we want to spend more will cause inflation the good news about that is that productive capacity is producible we can train more people we can bring more people into the labor force and this is how the job guarantee becomes a guarantee against the risk of inflation because it helps us produce the things that we need to become a resilient society resilient economy um the second thing that determines the risk of inflation which is very important for for this conversation and for this movement is what we call abusive market power concentration of market power within key sectors within key corporations that allows them to raise prices simply because they can and exclude people simply because they can't think of health insurance companies think of your your telecom companies josh was having internet issues earlier i was having internet issues earlier you complain all you want it's the same crappy service the bill goes up every other month and there's nothing you can do about it because they divided the country into little territories and they do as they please that kind of inflation and abusive pricing behavior in the healthcare industry and the oil and gas industry the energy sector it's not going to go away if we eliminate the job guarantee or not have a green new deal that type of inflation goes away if you tax and regulate it out of existence in other words the 535 people we elect in this democracy if they do their job they can eliminate that kind of inflation from the system by democratizing the system if we have a government of the people by the people for the people but if it's you know brought to you by super pacs then this is what we get so if we're successful at having a clear vision about what the additional spending capacity is and set the priorities straight in terms of how to decarbonize what kind of infrastructure we need what kind of care economy we need we do have the spending capacity but we're only going to tap into it if we recognize that you know
we have these forces that suffocate that spending capacity by causing inflation and risking additional inflation if we attempt to spend on the things that matter to us but every time we spend on the things that matter to them a war a tax cut whatever it is it's not inflationary but if we spend on the things that matter to millions of people for the planet all of a sudden it's unaffordable and all that so it's important for the movement to recognize what their line of defense is what their arguments are and call their bluff and change the narrative and part of changing the narrative is this tagline uh that my colleagues and i are working on kind of to quantify this which is the following the cost of doing nothing is way more expensive than the cost of doing the right thing which is a green new deal and a job guarantee and a care economy and all of that so when you quantify it you actually realize we're spending already trillions of dollars on the opioid crisis alone just in the last four years there's a white house report that put it at 2.5 trillion dollars in the last four years of of the report this came out in 2017 or 18. 2.5 trillion dollars that's the cost of doing nothing that's just dealing with the negative consequences of the you know the the diseases of despair and all of that and we know as as uh it was mentioned earlier every time we have higher unemployment than any part of the country in any part of the world you know crime goes up uh depression suicide uh anxiety all kinds of child abuse domestic violence the divorce all of these social costs we're already paying for it right it's just not and and when you introduce a job guarantee when you address the root causes of poverty and unemployment and we're not saying we're going to eliminate all of these social problems but you're going to put a major major um you know downward pressure on all of those costs and all of that economic and social social pain so the job guarantee within the green new deal movement is not a nice add-on feature to put into it it's a core component of a green new deal because the green new deal is about two things in the u.s context about addressing inequality and addressing the climate crisis these are the two biggest crises that we have and related to it is the crisis of socio-economic exclusion for millions of people so how do we engage in this massive decarbonization and transformation of the economy and do it in a way that brings millions of people into a prosperous and sustainable and dignified work environment and living conditions and the job guarantee is a core feature of that and that includes the millions of people who will lose jobs during this transition and the fossil fuel industry in the transportation industry but the thing that we have to recognize is that when we transform an economy whether it's a green new deal or an industrial revolution or a fourth industrial revolution as they call it this internet of things and all that all of these transformation technological transformations are not new they started with the industrial revolution and the industrial revolution did displace workers but you know we're not going to turn into luddites and stop technology we should be embracing technological transformation we should be embracing robotics and automation as long as we know why we're doing it so i'm all for having robots do all the repetitive and dangerous and precarious work but have people do the care work the meaningful dignified work with decent wages and benefits and retirement and pension and all of that so that becomes a social and political discourse that we must have instead of saying let's build walls let's stop technological innovation so we can preserve painful precarious low-paying jobs so we have to have a clear vision about what we want in this energy transition that being said when we transition to decarbonize the economy away from fossil fuels there will be resistance and there is resistance from workers in those industries and it's completely understandable because they've been thrown under the bus before not necessarily just them but other workers and other manufacturing and so on because they're being told we want you to transition with us to this new economy green economy and we promise there will be jobs in the solar industry there'll be jobs and and wind turbines in this new economy of the future but we're not guaranteeing that those jobs will actually be there for them in their own communities so the job guarantee vision is take people as they are where they are and do on the job paid training to transition the economy so we're not telling people learn how to code move to san francisco and maybe there'll be a job for you in the it sector so take people as they are where they are that has to be part of our vision for every local community to rethink and reimagine and redesign its own economy based on that core element which says we're not going to throw people under the bus we're not going to tell people to move out of town and go find a job somewhere else in the private sector pay for your training and education out of pocket get into student debt and then maybe and how are you going to do this for workers who are relatively close to retirement they have a major pension maybe waiting for them in the fossil fuel industry we have to have the federal government under right and guarantee a just transition not with empty words but by saying you're transitioning with the same pension plan you're going to have a jobs and and benefits package and income package that's comparable to your fossil fuel employment right now yes it's going to be expensive which means unions are not going to be able to pay for it employers are not going to be able to pay for it and the only way we rapidly transition into this new universe is for the federal government to underwrite and guarantee that transition states can participate in this guarantee it could be part state part federal but the federal government can afford it can do this tomorrow and when you talk to fossil fuel workers and other labor unions who are publicly you know hesitant to endorse a job guarantee or especially the green new deal behind closed doors they say we've been burned before you know the labor movement in general so all of these political empty words about a just transition and of course we want to clean energy and we want the clean air we want we drink the water we we breathe the air of course we want the future clean energy system but not on our backs right you have to guarantee this transition so i think this applies not just to fossil fuel workers but other industries that will be affected in the transportation industry um and in other industries the dairy industry whatever industry we see as uh at risk in this in this category we can't throw people under the bus and we have to make sure we we do this on on a massive and rapid scale and then the final thing i want to say which was brought up earlier this this thing that you hear from you know talking heads on tv and economist in particular who say well you can't have a job guarantee because we need unemployment to discipline people otherwise you know the the whole system will you know we're not going to have productive workers without unemployment which is bs nonsense because we have tons of studies by businesses employers who actually tell you we don't actually hire the unemployed when you ask them who do you want to hire their top choice is somebody who's already working for a competitor right they're not even looking at the especially long-term unemployed their number two choice is somebody who's working but maybe in another industry not even in the same related industry number three they say well maybe young college graduates uh or somebody who's recently unemployed like recently just a few weeks ago or something like that but if you go into long-term unemployment the code is unemployable by which they mean women minorities returning citizens people without you know qualifications or education high school degrees or or people with disabilities and so on this is where the job guarantee comes in as a guarantee for those individuals who are you know typically last to be hired during the economic boom and first to be fired during a recession so that's the the kind of the buffer automatic stabilizer that pavlina was talking about earlier it's guaranteeing employment no matter what the private sector thinks and we're not shifting the burden on you to get the skills to get the education and to compete in this endless cycle of unemployment we're guaranteeing that you transition and help us build the resources that the community needs that the market is neglecting and is not interested in producing that the state or the federal government is not interested in in producing this is how we use the you know people as they are where they are do on the job training so that we produce the resources that the community needs and all of it today the majority of it will be in the green transition area will be in the care economy caring for people caring for the planet caring for the elderly for children so i see that as a core feature of the green new deal we've we've done this before in the the new deal era we know how to do it better today the the real obstacles are political obstacles ideological obstacles which is why it's important to have these conversations to have a coherent vision for all of us to push in the same direction um and and with that i'll i'll stop here and open it up for for comments and and discussion thank you again for for this session
:カバーブ
チャーネバ:
みなさん、ありがとうございました。コメントをお寄せいただき、ありがとうございます。私が言うことの舞台になりました。ここでの私の仕事は、鳥瞰図の画像をマクロ画像に分析することだと思いますが、私はただ考えています。テーマはとても重要です。もちろん、最初のことは、仕事が不足しているのは、ジョシュが指摘していたように、仕事がないからではないということです。仕事の不足は、私たちが公共部門の仕事を評価していないというビジョンの欠如と、政府ができるが直接貢献できないことの重要性のためだけではありません。しかし、使命のために行動を起こさなかったため、また政策固有の政策のために不足しているので、経済学者が失業についてどのように考えているか、これらの誤ったフレームをどのように再現するかという視点を持ち込みたいと思います。必要な場合でも、これは私が話したい2番目のことを暴くために本当に重要だと思います失業は永続的であるという特定の感覚があるということですそれは私たちと一緒ですこの経済システムに典型的ですこの非常に独特な心拍を持っているシステム成長し、縮小し、成長し、縮小し、市場の活力のあらゆる種類の変動の影響を受けるシステムは、貿易から技術などであり、付随的な損害は常に人々であり、それは常に仕事ですが、そこにあります」なんらかの理由で仕事が犠牲になったときに、私たちには雇用を創出するための非常に直接的な手段と方法があることをあなたが知っていることについて避けられないことは何もありません。この会話で私が聞いているのは、私たちの社会が必要としていることは行われておらず、子供からこれらのものを手に入れることはできないと定期的に言われている、進行中の重要な仕事に対するこの切実なサポートを作成する必要があるということです。高齢者へのケア、インフラへのケア、社会へのケア、環境への取り組み、私たちは常にできると言われています」そういうものがあり、仕事の未来を再考する上で非常に重要なことですが、仕事の保証の別の側面にも光を当てたいと思います。公的オプションそれは、あなたが誰であれ、あなたの状況が何であれ、基本的な威厳のある賃金給付パッケージで公的部門のオプションになるという究極の保証です。重要な継続的な恒久的なセクターの仕事は常にそこになければならないので、いくぶん別々のものとして見られるべきですが、経済へのこの鼓動は常にあり、それは一部の人々が仕事を失い、仕事を得るということを意味しますええと、それらは基本的な威厳のある賃金給付パッケージで公共部門のオプションになるので、議論で私が考える人々は、本質的な継続的な恒久的部門の仕事のために、おそらくそれらはいくぶん別個のものとして見られるべきであると話し続けることができます常にそこにいる必要がありますが、経済には常にこの鼓動があり、それは一部の人々が仕事を失い、仕事を得るということを意味しますええと、それらは基本的な威厳のある賃金給付パッケージで公共部門のオプションになるので、議論で私が考える人々は、本質的な継続的な恒久的部門の仕事のために、おそらくそれらはいくぶん別個のものとして見られるべきであると話し続けることができます常にそこにいる必要がありますが、経済には常にこの鼓動があり、それは一部の人々が仕事を失い、仕事を得るということを意味します仕事と彼らの仕事を得ること仕事と彼らの仕事を得ること
そして、それがもはや私たちのマクロ経済の世界の一部ではないことを確認したいと思います。どのような状況でも仕事を必要とする人々のためのオプションがあります。最後に、リズがかつて言っていたように、いくつかのことを言いたいと思います。あなたは雇用が権利であり、誰もがその権利にアクセスできる世界を想像します。それは本当に新しい社会契約を表しており、それはゲームのルールを変えます。重要なのは、実際に働く人々と失業者の運命は消えることなく絡み合っているので、それらを分離することはできないので、パワーポイントのプレゼンテーションをしましたが、これを行うつもりはありません。と思う」非常に人気があり、数字があり、人気があるだけでなく、仕事の保証の獲得者であることを共有できてうれしいので、このアイデアを中心に整理することが絶対に不可欠であることを指摘する必要があります。超党派の支持は保守的な支持でさえ50%以上であり、ええと、これらの調査は最近のものであり、今朝世界中で複製されています。私はフランス79からの新しいものを探していました。フランスでのグリーンジョブ保証のサポートyougovは最後に調査を行いました。近年、米国の英国では70%以上が一貫して70%であるため、連邦レベルでは、連邦政府が追求するかどうかにかかわらず、連邦レベルでの動きがあるかもしれません。仕事の保証方針私はそれだと思います」それを取り巻く組織化はまだ良い地方政治なので、次に言いたかったのは、マクロ鳥瞰図の観点から、覚えておくべきことがいくつかあるということです。もちろん、私たちのそれぞれの闘争はもちろん、連邦政府の方針と、代表的なアヤンナ・プレスリーによって進められた最近の決議で、地元の雇用保証に力を与えることができる包括的な方針があれば、私たちの活動ははるかに簡単になります。それらは、雇用の権利は基本的人権であるだけでなく、公的資金によって支払われること、そしてそれは公益のための公的雇用のためであるということを最初に心に留めておきたい3つのコアコンポーネントのようなものでした。野心的な文脈での野心的なそしてそれからそこにsマクロ経済の文脈で、ここで少し話をしたいと思います。申し訳ありませんが、失業率は自然であり、どこから来ているのかというフレームを拒否する必要があります。失業率は避けられないものであり、市場は非常に多くの雇用しか創出できないため、失業率を市場が自然なレベルと見なすレベルよりも低くするための手段が実際には多くないという、これらの古くからの計算された理論的概念これを行おうとすると、望ましくないインフレが発生する可能性があります。これに精通している人もいれば、連邦政府を監視していない人もいます。実際、中央銀行の失業率は、3.5パーセントの正の失業率であるという方針です。 4.4。5%は、インフレを恐れて経済に提供している可能性のある刺激を取り除き、ブレーキを踏む必要がある場合に通知するポリシーガイドです。もちろん、これについて考えると、チャネルが何であるかがわかります。多くの人が仕事をしている人が多すぎる人は収入が多すぎて購買力が多すぎて食べられないので、実際に雇用を犠牲にするか、マクロ経済モデルに正統な方法で根付いているポジティブなレベルの失業を許容することでインフレと戦わなければなりませんエコノミストは、モデルが議会の予算事務所であるかどうかにかかわらず、モデルをまとめる方法を考えています。中央銀行に関しては、失業は自然であり、マクロ経済の安定と価格の安定にとって望ましいというこのマクロモデルに潜んでいる概念があります。私の仕事では、労働者のフィデルと同僚を知っています。
実際、私たちには雇用を創出できる代替案があるというこの考えを覆そうとしていることをご存知でしょう。雇用保証自体を使用して、現在失業が使用されているような経済安定化、さらには価格安定化さえも提供できます。マクロレベルでは、政策レベルでは、政策ツールとしての失業の必要性を拒否し、雇用保証がそのバッファーになるという未知のことは、当然のことながら不況が発生したときに増加する強力な力になると主張します。人々が仕事を必要とするときに彼らが仕事を利用するときに与えられた政策の要求は、経済の安定を提供するのは公共部門によるまさにその支出であり、それはsは、人が雇用を持っているときに問題にお金を投げるよりもはるかに優れています。世界全体が異なり、失業に依存している場合は、それがどれほど寛大であっても、雇用保証は、景気後退時に成長する安定剤です。貿易などで仕事が逃げ出し、民間企業やママやポップショップが湧き出て雇用を提供し始めると経済生活がコミュニティに戻ると縮小するので、実際には同じように増減するのはそのバッファーですその失業はそうするので、本当に鳥から」公共部門は常に失業に責任があります公共部門は常に失業の社会的費用に責任がありますが、失業者が貧困対策プログラムのために知っている失業者へのわずかな支援と支援は一部です。政府がこれを認識しているかどうかにかかわらず、私たちは失業の社会的崩壊と私の仕事のすべての人的費用に集合的に責任があります私はそれらをカタログ化して文書化しますそしてそれらは非常に大きいですそれは許容するのは非常に高価な提案です失業とその社会的費用それらに対して接種し、求職者に仕事を提供することははるかに良い方針です良い仕事良い仕事と良い利益がありますそうですねマクロレベルでは2つの選択肢がありますどちらかシステムを許容しますに基づくあなたが知っている失業失業はそれが鳴り響くか、私たちは必要な失業の機会を提供する公的な選択肢を持っています。 -完全雇用経済と呼ばれていますが、最高の時期でも仕事を求めている人はまだいます。彼らは常にそこでの雇用機会になるというそのような政策コミットメントは新しい社会契約を表しているので、私は自分の考えを実行したいと思います。新しい社会契約の社会のこれらの柱のいくつかかもしれません、そして最初のものは失業が本当に破壊主義であるという私たちがこれまでに持ってきたこの議論に基づいていますええと、これは経済学者がビクトリアに使用した用語です失業は破壊主義であると主張することはそれです」マクロレベルまたはポリシーレベルから、この破壊行為はある種の必要性があり、直接雇用と直接行動があるため、公共部門が責任を負う場合、それは確かに必要ではありません。社会的費用は、実際には、それが無視と荒廃に基づいてシステムをサポートするかどうかを引用符で囲まずに引用しないように、より良いことをする義務があります。sそれが人間であるかどうかにかかわらず、あなたはこの種のumの怠慢のために実際のまたは財政的な費用を支払うことを知っていますが、実際には私たちの最も貴重な資源の人々への投資のためにそれらのコミュニティへの投資に支払う責任と義務があります社会保障の次の部分は、はい、雇用保証は私たちの経済安定剤であるということです。つまり、私たちの経済全体は、直接雇用がない場合よりも直接雇用がある場合の方が安定しており、それを実施することによって、実際に新しい労働基準を確立することができます。つまり、ある人が最低15時間支払う仕事の公的オプションを持っていて、社会保障付きのメディケアと有給休暇があります。これは、オプションがあることを持っていない人の標準であり、雇用主が基準に適合しなければならない労働者を維持したいという利益を提供するので、労働基準を確立しようとする他の方法に加えて、雇用を通じて基準を確立することが基本的であることが重要です。最低賃金政策はすべて順調に進んでいますが、最低賃金を引き上げる必要がありますが、最低賃金政策の最低賃金の仕事を得ることができれば、その基準の恩恵を受けられないため、法定賃金の両方が必要ですが、雇用オプションも必要ですあなたは私たちが持つことができるその権利にアクセスできるということです私はあなたがヘルスケアが私たちが目指している基準の一部でなければならない社会的賃金の一部でなければならない雇用から分離される必要があることを知っていると思います仕事をやり直すには、休息をとる必要があり、休暇を正しく支払う必要があります。そうすれば、それが標準の大丈夫になるので、公共のオプションは、私たちが威厳のある仕事と見なすものの最小フロアを確立します。私たちは公共の雇用を持っています私たちは実際にさまざまなことを大切にします私たちは社会的に有用なことを大切にします私たちは人々を大切にします私たちは公共の利益を大切にします環境ケア経済は正しいです環境はそうではありません」支払うが、環境は私たちを育てているので、私たちは実際に重要と思われることを無視しています大丈夫ですええと、最終的に私たちは失業の脅威を拒否します私はここでリズは私たちが拒否した場合に私たちがどのように接続されているかについて非常に明確に話しました労働者を訓練するために失業が必要であるというこの考え
私たちは、労働者をどのように評価し、どのように彼らの仕事を支援し、どのように彼らを促進するかについて、まったく異なるパラダイムを持っています。それはあなたの生計を失うことへの脅威や恐れではありませんが、今あなたが知っている他の方法があります。あなたが正しければ、それは懲罰的なパラダイムではありませんが、私たちが知っているように、私たちは、失業が労働者を互いに争い、防止または組織化するという会社の重要な力を取り除きます。これは私があなたの話を聞くのが本当に好きだったということですええと、これはあなたがあなたが組合の仕事がタイトな完全雇用を持っていることを条件とする方法でとてもうんざりしていることを知っているという認識ですテクノロジーはあなたの仕事を奪うだろうと言われましたええと貿易はあなたをあなたの仕事を奪うでしょう緑の移行はあなたをあなたの仕事を奪うでしょうそして人々はそれを恐れていますそして彼らはそうしません必要な種類のポリシーを追求しますが、答えが得られました。フィデルは、環境運動における雇用保証の重要性について話し、最後に、これらのポリシーは実際には人々がそれを行うことができ、これらの政策を回復力のあるものにし、特定のコミュニティに対処するために必要な評価と実施を行うことができる、実行しなければならない種類の作業を正確に知っている町や地域の都市に根を下ろします最後になりましたが、会話の一部であったこの基本的人権へのコミットメントを復活させ、再通知する必要があると思います。それは、経済的権利章典が最初の柱として雇用する権利を持っていたということでした。その会話を残しましたええと私は部分的に思うのでええとエコノミストは、完全雇用は3%の失業であり、私たちにできることはほとんどあると私たちに確信させましたが、私たちはそのコミットメントに戻って、仕事の保証を通じてそれを明確にする必要があるので、ここで終了します。それをfidelに渡します
カバーブ:
ありがとうパヴリーナこれは本当に楽しんだ素晴らしいプレゼンテーションのセットでした。さらにいくつかのコンポーネントを追加して、全国レベルまたはでのグリーンニューディールの文脈での雇用保証についてもっと話すように移行したいと思います。地方レベルのええと、最初に私がすでに言ったことのいくつかについてコメントしたいと思います私はパブリノが言及していた主流派経済学者を意味しますこれらの人は不平等について間違っていたことを覚えておきましょう彼らは気候変動について間違っていました彼らはインフレについて間違っている彼らは金融危機について間違っているほとんどすべてについて間違っている彼らのブラフと呼んでいる私はなぜ私たちはまだこれらの人に耳を傾け、ブルームバーグで彼らに放送時間を与えているのですか?ナンバーワンナンバー2ええと、彼らが持っている主な議論は、気候変動対策のための失業に政府が多額の支出をしていることを知っているということです。ヨーロッパと日本と英国の米国での大規模な政府支出がインフレにつながらなかったことを知っている大規模な政府赤字は、日本が世界で最も高い債務対gdp比を持っていることを知っています過去30年間、彼らのブラフと呼んでください。彼らはecbについて何を話しているのかわからないので、ついに彼らは私たちが本当にそうしないと言ったことを認めました。何が金利を決定するのか、そしてなぜこれらのことが起こっているのかを私たちは日本だけで何か奇妙なことが起こっていると思ったが、明らかにここ米国の連邦準備制度理事会は私たちが実際にインフレ翻訳の信頼できる理論を持っていないと言ったよりも深い英語私たちはこれらのものがどのように機能するのかわからないので、彼らのブラフと呼んで、私たちが実際に働きたいと思っている何百万人もの人々がいることを知っていると言われている問題に取り組む進歩的な動きをしましょう火事私たちは物事を成し遂げるための頭脳の力を持った技術を持っています、そしてどういうわけか私たちはニューディールの間に私たちが以前にやったこの権利のどれもできないと言われましたそしてええとリズのプレゼンテーションは素晴らしい思い出させました私たちができることペンと紙でそれをやったのですが、私たちにはロジスティック機能がありませんでした。橋を架けるだけでなく、多くの人が覚えていない何かを世話していたのです。 200万人以上の家庭訪問ウェルネスチェックで、最近出産した母親の手術から戻ってきたことを知っている人や、高齢者介護や育児が必要な人の世話をしています。これはインフラストラクチャの構築の一部でした。今週この会話に戻ってきたのは、インフラストラクチャも人であるということです。sまた、ケア経済と、いわゆる完全雇用に近い、または完全雇用での完全雇用でのパンデミック前のパンデミックの間だけでなく、実際に60年代以来の最低レベルにある人々の数を調べることパンデミックの直前に隠された失業統計を掘り下げてみると、まだ正式に失業している何百万人もの人々だけでなく、就職したくないという理由で就職できなかった何百万人もの人々がいました。信頼できる交通手段がなく、仕事は彼らが車を購入したり公共交通機関にアクセスしたりするのに十分なお金を払っていませんでした。仕事がしなかったので誰かが子供の世話をしたり、年配の家族の世話をしたりするのに十分なお金を払うので、労働基準が非常に低いため、何百万人もの人々を経済から除外しています。この議論の中心となる運動、そしてあなた方の何人かは、私たちが今月ローザ・ルクセンブルグ財団と一緒にやってきたシリーズを見てきました。私はチャットにリンクを落としてうれしいです。今日の午後はちょうどカール・ローゼンとケオン・ラボラトリーのサラ・ネルソンとの素晴らしいパネルがありました。労働運動の全員が、私たちが求めているすべての大きなもののどれもがなければ、私たちがプロの行動をとることはできないと言っています。誰が私たちで誰が彼らであるかを認識する統一された運動」その組合に対するこの組合はこれではないので、システムを制御し窒息させている既得権益に反対しているので、彼らが通常グリーンディールの雇用保証に押し戻す大きなことについていくつかの言葉を述べます私はチャットにこのリンクを落としています。詳細のいくつかに興味がある人にとって、これはポーリーナやステファニーケルトンなどがその一部である仕事保証mmt文学の一部であり、私たちがしている簡単なメッセージです政府にはこれを支払うための資金がない、それは民間部門が雇用を創出しなければならないと言った。政府は税収による支出能力の点で制限されており、壁通りが政府に許可するものは何でも借りる借りるか、私たち」それを超えてウォール街によって再訓練された政府がより多くを費やすと、それはハイパーインフレを引き起こしますmmtと仕事保証の文献が私たちに教えていることは、連邦政府が利用できる追加の支出能力がたくさんあるということですそれは私たちが利用した方法ですそれは第二次世界大戦中の新しい取引時代のケアの資金調達中のケア法の支払い1.9兆ドルの支払いとすべての戦争とすべての減税の支払い私たちが持っている追加の支出能力は毎回言われています仕事については、これが私たちの国を破産させるのは中産階級についてです。mmtの文献から私たちが知っていることは、私たちが安全に持つことができる追加の支出の量を決定するのは、決定されるインフレの潜在的なリスクであるということです。私たち全員がここで地図上に持つべき2つの非常に重要なことは、生産能力が不足した場合、インフレリスクにぶつかることです。つまり、熟練労働者が不足した場合、材料、設備、技術が不足した場合、より多くを費やしたいのはインフレを引き起こすという良いニュースは、生産能力が生産可能であり、より多くの人々を訓練することができ、より多くの人々を労働力に引き込むことができるということです。私たちは私たちがなるために必要なものを生産します弾力性のある社会弾力性のある経済ええと、この会話とこの動きにとって非常に重要なインフレのリスクを決定する2番目のことは、主要企業内の主要セクター内の市場支配力の乱用市場支配力集中であり、単純に価格を上げることができます彼らは健康保険会社のことを考えられないという理由だけで人々を排除することができるのであなたの通信会社のことを考えてくださいジョシュは以前にインターネットの問題を抱えていました私は以前にインターネットの問題を抱えていました先月とそこに彼らは国を小さな領土に分割し、ヘルスケア業界と石油・ガス業界のエネルギー部門におけるそのようなインフレと虐待的な価格設定行動を喜ばせるので、あなたがそれについてできることは何もありません。雇用保証を排除するか、課税してその存在を規制すればそのタイプのインフレがなくなるというグリーンニューディールがない、言い換えれば、この民主主義で私たちが選んだ535人が仕事をすれば、その種のインフレを排除することができます私たちが人々のために人々によって人々の政府を持っているならば、システムを民主化することによってシステムですが、それがあなたがスーパーパックによってあなたにもたらされたことを知っているなら、これは私たちがそうするなら私たちがそうするものです追加の支出能力が何であるかについて明確なビジョンを持ち、どのような種類のインフラストラクチャが必要か、どのようなケア経済が必要かという観点から優先順位をまっすぐに設定することに成功しました。あなたが知っていると私たちが認識した場合、それを利用する
私たちには、インフレを引き起こし、私たちにとって重要なことに費やそうとすると追加のインフレのリスクを冒すことによってその支出能力を窒息させるこれらの力がありますが、私たちが彼らにとって重要なことに費やすたびに、それが何であれ減税しますインフレですが、地球にとって何百万もの人々にとって重要なことに突然費やすと、それは手ごろな価格ではなくなります。彼らの防衛線が何であるかを認識し、彼らのブラフを呼び出して物語を変更する運動にとって重要なのは、このタグラインです。私の同僚と私はこれを定量化するために取り組んでいます。次の何もしないことのコストは、グリーンニューディール、雇用保証、ケアエコノミーなどの正しいことを行うためのコストよりもはるかに高価です。したがって、それを定量化すると、私たちがすでに費やしていることに実際に気づきます。過去4年間だけでオピオイド危機だけで数兆ドルが2017年に発表されたレポートの最後の4年間で2.5兆ドル、つまり18.2.5兆ドルとなるホワイトハウスのレポートがあります。何もしない」sあなたが絶望の病気とそのすべてを知っているというあなたの否定的な結果に対処するだけで、あなたが知っている世界のどの地域でも、国のどの地域よりも高い失業率があるたびに、先に述べたように私たちは知っています犯罪が増えるうつ病自殺不安あらゆる種類の児童虐待家庭内暴力離婚私たちがすでに支払っているこれらの社会的費用のすべてが正しくないだけでなく、貧困の根本原因に対処するときに雇用保証を導入するとき失業と私たちはこれらの社会問題のすべてを排除するつもりだと言っているのではありませんが、あなたはあなたが知っている主要な主要なumをこれらのすべてのコストとそのすべての経済的および社会的社会的苦痛に下向きの圧力をかけるつもりなので、グリーンニューディール運動内の仕事の保証はそれに入れるための素晴らしいアドオン機能ではありませんグリーンニューディールはuの2つのことについてであるため、グリーンニューディールのコアコンポーネント。不平等への対処と気候危機への対処に関する状況これらは私たちが抱える2つの最大の危機であり、それに関連するのは何百万もの人々の社会経済的排除の危機です。何百万人もの人々を繁栄し、持続可能で威厳のある労働環境と生活条件に導く方法でそれを行い、雇用保証はその核となる特徴であり、この移行中に失業する何百万人もの人々と化石燃料が含まれます運輸業界の業界ですが、私たちが認識しなければならないのは、経済を変革するとき、それがグリーンな新しい取引、産業革命、または第4の産業革命は、このモノのインターネットと呼ばれ、これらすべての変革技術変革は新しいものではなく、産業革命から始まり、産業革命は労働者を置き換えましたが、あなたは私たちを知っていますラッダイトに変わってテクノロジーを停止するつもりはありません。テクノロジーの変革を受け入れる必要があります。なぜそれを行うのかがわかっている限り、ロボット工学と自動化を受け入れる必要があります。不安定な仕事ですが、人々にケアの仕事をさせて、まともな賃金と利益、退職と年金などの意味のある威厳のある仕事をしてもらいましょう。そうすれば、壁を作ろうと言う代わりに、社会的および政治的な議論になります。技術革新を止めて、痛みを伴う不安定な低賃金の仕事を維持できるようにするため、化石燃料から経済を脱炭素化するために移行するときに抵抗があり、そこにあると言われているこのエネルギー移行で私たちが望むものについて明確なビジョンを持っている必要がありますそれらの業界の労働者からの抵抗であり、彼らは必ずしも彼らだけでなく他の労働者や他の製造業などの前にバスの下に投げ込まれたので、私たちと一緒にこの新しいものに移行してほしいと言われているので、それは完全に理解できます経済グリーン経済と私たちは、太陽エネルギー産業に仕事があることを約束します。将来のこの新しい経済には仕事と風力タービンがありますが、私たちはそれらの仕事が実際に彼ら自身のコミュニティで彼らのためにあることを保証しないので、仕事保証のビジョンは人々を彼らがいる場所に連れて行き、経済を移行するために仕事を支払った訓練をすることです。コードをサンフランシスコに移すと、ITセクターであなたの仕事があるかもしれないので、人々をその場に連れて行ってください。それは、すべての地域コミュニティが自分たちの経済を再考し、再考し、再設計するという私たちのビジョンの一部でなければなりません。私たちがバスの下に人を投げ込むつもりはないというそのコア要素に基づいて人々に町を出て、民間部門のどこかで仕事を見つけるように言わないでください。あなたの訓練と教育にお金を払って、学生の借金になります。比較的退職間近で、彼らは化石燃料業界で彼らを待っているかもしれない大きな年金を持っています。私たちは連邦政府を権利の下に置き、空の言葉ではなく、あなたが同じ年金制度で移行していると言うことによって、公正な移行を保証しなければなりません。今あなたの化石燃料の雇用に匹敵する仕事と福利厚生のパッケージと収入のパッケージを持っているつもりですそうです」sは高額になるため、組合はそれを支払うことができなくなります。雇用主はそれを支払うことができなくなります。この新しい宇宙に急速に移行する唯一の方法は、連邦政府がそれを引き受けて保証することです。遷移状態はこの保証に参加できますが、連邦政府は明日これを行うことができます。公に化石燃料労働者や他の労働組合と話すときは、雇用保証を支持することを躊躇していることを知っています。密室でのグリーンニューディール彼らは私たちが言っている一般的に労働運動を知る前に燃やされたので、これらの政治的な空の言葉はすべて、ちょうど移行についてであり、もちろん私たちはエネルギーをきれいにしたい、そして私たちはきれいな空気を望んでいます私たちは水を飲みたいです私たちはもちろん空気を吸います将来のクリーンエネルギーシステムが必要ですが、私たちの後ろではなく、この移行を保証する必要があるので、これは化石燃料労働者だけでなく、運輸業界や他の業界で影響を受ける他の業界にも当てはまると思います私たちは、このカテゴリーでこれが危険にさらされていると考えています。人々をバスの下に投げ込み、これを大規模かつ迅速に行うことを確認する必要があります。それから、私が言いたい最後のことは、テレビで頭を話していることを知っているあなたから聞いたこのことです。特にエコノミストは、人々を懲戒するために失業が必要なため、仕事の保証はありません。そうしないと、システム全体で、失業なしで生産的な労働者がいないことがわかります。これは、私たちが持っているのでナンセンスです。誰を雇いたいのかと尋ねると、実際には失業者を雇っていないと実際に言っている企業の雇用主によるたくさんの研究は、すでに競争相手のために働いている人であり、彼らは特に長い間見ていません-失業者の2番目の選択肢は誰かです。働いていますが、同じ関連業界の3番目でもない別の業界でも、おそらく若い大学卒業生か、ほんの数週間前のように最近失業している人などですが、長期失業に陥った場合はコードは失業中です。つまり、女性の少数派が資格や教育の高校の学位を知らない人や障害のある人を市民に返すことを意味します。これは、あなたが通常最後に知っている個人の保証として仕事の保証が入る場所です。景気循環の間に雇用され、不況の間に最初に解雇されるので、パブリナが以前に話していた種類のバッファー自動安定装置は、民間部門が何を考えていても雇用を保証します。教育を受け、失業のこの無限のサイクルで競争するためのスキルを取得するためにあなたの負担をシフトしないでください私たちはあなたが移行し、市場が無視していて興味がないコミュニティが必要とするリソースを構築するのを助けることを保証します州または連邦政府がこれを作成することに興味がないことを作成する際に、私たちはあなたが知っている人々を職業訓練で行っている場所で使用する方法であり、コミュニティが必要とするリソースとそのすべてを今日作成しますその大部分はグリーントランジションエリアにあり、地球をケアする人々をケアするケアエコノミーで子供をケアする高齢者をケアするので、グリーンニューディールの核となる特徴として私たちはニューディール時代にこれを以前に行ったことがありますが、今日それをより良くする方法を知っています。本当の障害は政治的障害、イデオロギー的障害です。そのため、私たち全員が同じことを推進するための一貫したビジョンを持つためにこれらの会話をすることが重要です。方向性ええと、それで私はここで立ち止まり、コメントと議論のためにそれを開きますこのセッションをありがとうございました
:カバーブ
thank you so much fidel that was that was outstanding yeah um i want to bring this back to uh renew um so we've got a couple of contexts that really uh have come out for me one is the inherent instability of our moment right whether whatever the source is um we can expect more of these types of events of this type of uh collective experience in the future right this return to normal i think is is is is a myth right there there's not going to be anything that that looks like that and secondly this idea of of dignified work as a basic human right i think it's so key to sort of frame this whole conversation and thinking about it especially i think in terms of the the work of care is so key right now and i'm really excited about bringing that that perspective to this conversation as we're thinking about renew new england and the work that needs to be done across communities of this region at the state level at the local level that's where i'd like to go and and start with a conversation um from here i'll also invite people to we're a small group that's great people can write in uh questions into the the chat or otherwise just raise your hand and we'll have an opportunity to uh to share some discussion uh but i'd like to start with with that question and maybe bringing josh back in and then whomever among our panel how do you see that care work um coming out and being manifested i guess from the in the relationship between the federal project the federal work right getting into the communities paulina you've written about sort of a democratic tendency of of this type of project how are the communities themselves engaging with this uh job guarantee directing the work so that we can be sure that it's actually the work that needs done and uh that is responsive to the moment so josh maybe i'll start with you and then we can we can open it up to anyone yeah um i mean i think the place to start uh with with that i mean there's a lot on the table there it's a good question but i think the place to start is that um you know what what pavlina said about uh a jobs guarantee being extremely politically popular and a good issue to organize around like that's reflected in polls but it's also like very much reflected in my own personal experience like i'm i'm an organizer for the most part and what i do is community organizing and you know i think it's really interesting that um uh you know good jobs for all plays really well in community meetings on the doors during campaigns just in one-on-one conversations like people actually are already very much in favor of this idea but the challenge you know in these conversations is typically about raising people's expectations about what's possible like lots of people who i talk to the main objection is that they just don't think anything is possible and that's not too surprising honestly like 50 years of neoliberalism means like all of our imaginations about what is possible is just radically constrained and and that's why i think you know the legislation that we've written and introduced and are organizing around that's why i think that legislation is so helpful because you know the legislation is so concrete uh because you can bring the conversation back down to earth and say look like if we passed such and such a law in massachusetts we'd create tens of thousands of jobs retrofitting a million homes uh over the next decade to increase energy efficiency and make homes healthier and safer safer like removing rodent feces and asbestos uh and like if we pass this other law in rhode island for example we'd shut down all polluting industries and like use the and transition the workers give them uh as as fidel was saying like give them um like free job training give them pensions during the job training like work with them one-on-one to talk about like what is the kind of work you'd like to do and you know when you concretize the conversation in those in with community organizing when you like bring it down to the actual like very specific level of like this piece of legislation would do x y and z and would get this closer to a jobs guarantee people that's how you sort of like expand people's imagination in terms of what's possible and that's how you it's it's that sort of like deep community organizing that changes people's perceptions of like what they can win collectively um yeah i think that's where i'd start thank you uh could someone else like to follow on that okay i would add something i mean i if i could yeah i'm also hearing this theme of sort of um some of the process issues and all the things that get in the way of what people are interested in achieving and what actually happens and i think you know i look at it as sort of the the very small scale scale of the vermont state house and sort of why business as usual is all that ever sort of happens and sort of really sort of nibbling around the margins of things and i just you know i it's not the most it's not the most interesting part of it but the process questions of sort of how those things get operationalized i think are a relevant piece of it too maybe i can say something about this um in my experience um the idea that the public sector can just go out and plant some trees for some reason is very like remote like people have so when they think about local job creation they think well which is the company that creates the jobs you know how can we get more people in that company like okay if we do infrastructure you know like there is some infrastructure traditional like you know to build but the social and environmental work is not the first thing that comes to mind when we talk about what the public sector can do and so you know i'm doing a project with some of my students you know are doing um you know proposals for local towns and you know in our conversation all of a sudden one of the policy makers comments was like they had a light bulb it's like oh yeah i would i've been thinking about having a pavilion for such a long time where it's a place where you know the community would meet an artist and you know uh there would be like after-school activities and it's just um it's i think that the job guarantee opens up this vision of the kind of work and i think that's a place also to go to because when when people realize that actually yeah that is a job it can be a job that could prioritize um the way we go about creating these opportunities and we you know people can leave the straight jacket of how do you appease a company to give them the you know the right trainees or get the right grant for the exact jobs placement and job development but we do face a bit of a problem because um while we must push at the local level and there are costs that these localities are bearing because they're dealing with unemployment and with poverty and with homelessness and all of that there are costs that we can um reduce by creating jobs there are some limits to the physical space that that they operate with i mean vermont is a unique case because you're not tied to the balanced budget amendment and so it's a perfect place to really begin um you know to you know you know to appropriate some budgets and create some local opportunities but there is there is i think that funding issue that um it has to be much more surgically implemented and it has to be crafted in a in a much more careful way than if we had federal funding that comes from you know biden's packages and says here you go create some jobs and now we can deploy those funds for local job creation i mean i i'm sorry if somebody else wants to jump in but you know i vermont as laboratory is often sort of the way we talk about it and think about it because and so i think that while i recognize the scale of some of these things i also think you know we're talking about a lot about how we use these federal funds as a catalyst right like to sort of jump start some of these things and what that might look like and also just not letting vermont hide behind the excuse either that we don't have the fiscal capacity that there's a whole lot more we could do and that we also sort of buy into this idea that whatever the money's not there the people don't don't want it whatever and sort of hide behind those excuses so you know i just like let's go vermont like i'm you know start it somewhere like somebody's got to start it so let's try it right yeah thank you um you pablina you you'd discuss and anyone can jump on this question as well um you discussed the idea of a non-profit model and a social enterprise model in terms of implementation right um and i'll drop a few other resources for folks into the chat here in a moment but i wonder if you could just describe a little bit more on your view on a grassroots community-led jobs guarantee approach which seems like it would be especially relevant both from an organizing perspective and from uh you know a regionally appropriate perspective yeah i think that just implementing a job guarantee at a national local level would need to have a multi-prong approach and that in some ways you because we are thinking about creating employment opportunities with the person in mind that there will have to be multiple approaches to this you know you could have a federal agency that does the job creation and provides a lot of federal employment we could have federal government providing funding to localities and municipalities and say okay hire anyone you need to hire to do what you are doing and you don't have the staffing needs and the funding resources but there's also that other reality that there are on the ground organizations that are already dealing with social deprivations and there are already community groups who are doing the community gardens who are doing the after-school activities who are going to you know nursing homes and you know and so why not empower and mobilize them uh cooperatives too um you know should not be outside the purview of kind of support and job creation and so in a way the idea was that we don't have to reinvent the wheel and we can simply tap in the local potential and resources and um uh you know create you know use those as sites for job creation but um i think again it's more of a horses for courses kind of approach you know if you're thinking about youth unemployment you know you might be thinking about very specific apprenticeships so i'm not you know entirely opposed to having uh private uh companies participate in some of these on-the-job training but you know here we're really talking about public money for the public good and uh you know the missing gaps sort of you know the public services i think can be filled with both non-profit and municipal work and federal employ you know employment there was a definitely a strong focus here on on the green jobs and uh on and then also in the chat related to ecological restoration for example i mean a lot of this does come around to the type of work and the type of jobs and our current moment and what's needed um so i'm wondering you know in terms of meeting people where they are and meeting the needs again of of communities um what what specific type of work might we prioritize and organize around and what what types of jobs recognizing that this isn't all about infrastructure jobs and in the way it's conventionally thought of right there's there's work that people need to be able to do immediately that doesn't necessarily require a lot of training what type of work especially in in the in green jobs the environment and so on that we really ought to be prioritizing and then how do we get people involved with that type of work um i'm happy to address some of these uh questions so i'm i'm part of a coalition here in appalachia called reimagine appalachia which is ohio west virginia pennsylvania and um in kentucky about 100 organizations and the blueprint if you if you look at the reimagine appalachia website the blueprint is sort of a mini green new deal for the region which includes restarting the ccc administration and i'm happy to report that there will be a bill coming out soon uh for a 21st century ccc administration uh to uh repair the damage of of the last century and create thousands of jobs in in these four states alone and to invest in regenerative agriculture and local uh food production uh which reduces the carbon footprint for transportation and so on uh so this is just one example another component of this ccc bill will be a re-entry component where the jobs training program starts on day one of incarceration not after people are released with no jobs no housing no so it reduces also it addresses other issues related to unemployment mental health and so on so we're looking at a comprehensive vision that creates jobs that sustain people that allow people to transition back into decent jobs and decent wages with dignity but also helps us repair some of the damage of the last century and so so another component of of the green jobs proposal by by the coalition reimagine appalachia is broadband infrastructure number three it's the uh investing in renewable energy production locally which includes the manufacturing of the technology locally so that's how you accelerate the decarbonization both of transportation the decarbonization of consumer use of electricity and heating and cooling but also decarbonization of industrial production production itself and doing this on an industrial scale this also requires i mean on a green new deal kind of national framework and and this addresses some of the questions in the chat about consumerism and all that because american society is a consumer society if we continue to con consume at this rate we're not going to save the planet we're doomed so a lot of it at the global level has to do with reducing uh use of energy you're reducing waste i mean why do we need a piece of salad driven all the way from california to the east coast right so local agriculture is important but also investing in research and development because even if we take today's technology solar panels and wind turbines and we actually scale this up to meet the energy needs of the us and and the rest of the world we're going to have an ecological disaster in terms of extractivism especially in the global south so we need to invest in research and development in material science research and development so that we actually produce what we call a circular economy where every product you buy comes with a user manual that includes a few pages to say this is my living will this is how you dispose of me this is how you bring me back into life into a circular economy that's really and we're not there yet to be honest we don't even know what we're going to do with the solar panels when they go you know obsolete in 40 years landfills we haven't invested enough research and development into that so this has to be part of the answers the technology we have is good but not good enough we can go far with what we have we can jump start this transition but we also have to commit the the resources to figure out how do we create a truly circular economy so mmt as some people are said in the in the chat yes we deal with the risk of inflation and we we say yes government spending we can safely spend more but we're not implying we should spend more and consume more at the same pace with the ecological impact we're saying we have the capacity just like we sent people to the moon we can do the same and figure out how to invent a circular economy and how would how to fix the the damage so we have the tools but we're not saying you know let's consume at the same rate and and you know burn the hell out of the planet which we could do if we wanted but that's not what we're advocating for maybe i mean maybe i can also uh answer your question if you want to bring it to the you know even smaller area like a town level like what would you do um so as i said i you know i have my students looking at two communities uh in new york with the idea that new york was once the forerunner of the new deal and yet we're not doing the new deal projects now to be a forerunner but um but what they're doing is uh just like steph's analysis showed you know who are the unemployed you know who are the underemployed i mean that's i think the first step you need to know like who you're going to be creating jobs for um then we were looking at very specific deprivation so one of the communities for example has a lot of single moms that are unemployed another community it's not the case um um this community that has a lot of single moms that are unemployed has a lot of pollution issues and asthma way above national average okay the other another the other community actually has a lot more problems with mental health issues okay and then the community that has more health mental health issues actually have a lot more environmental groups like they actually do have like these non-profits and social groups that are doing environmental work but they don't actually have enough doing sort of the mental health support work and so i think that these are the sort of things that you could do at the local level to figure out like what are the gaps and the social needs that you uh might address with job creation and um i i do think that um if this debate you know about biden's infrastructure plan you know what's like infrastructure like it's so important like it's just we just have to you know draw the line and i feel the same way i want to talk about green jobs so in a book i argue the job you do is always green because if you take care of a person like that's green like you know you you are essentially you know not allowing human waste to neglect the sort of social class that we have and of course you have to also think about the envelope within which you know we're organically connected to the natural environment but it's also us and so like suppose we weatherized all homes but we had homeless people would that be a green policy like they all weatherized but we've got people on the street right or supposedly everybody had a good job but we were polluting the environment just like the comment uh you know in the in the box um so it's just they're not separable and so when we talk about green work i think uh addressing care needs very much falls under green work it's not just environmental care needs other people care and so if you want to think about you know what kind of funding might be coming down the pipeline from from biden and we'll see how the politics play out but uh you know there will be some things that will be ongoing like the public health crisis is not going to go away tomorrow just because you know we have vaccination rates um there will be people on the ground that will have to do some sort of logistical support so we can keep thinking about that and that would be an obvious place where i think there will be money uh at the local place so these would be just some examples of how you might think about like local job creation that is public service it's not you know it and it is addressing some specific need thank you pablina and i know you probably need to go soon uh so i i do want to say thank you so much for joining us yeah i'll try to tune in through the phone but um i do need to step away from my computer um i hope you enjoyed this thank you so it's been fantastic to have you join us so thank you so much um we'll go to andrew had a question and then i'd like to invite uh any of the panelists to ask one another a question and then we'll probably wrap it up andrew go ahead hi thank you so much can you hear me yes okay great um i wanted i was just writing in the chat that um i'm very interested in the role um both state employees unions as well as the national unions um might be able to play in a federal jobs guarantee program as well as a regional jobs guarantee program i'm i'm also interested uh i think uh pavlina talked about a federal agency being created or the federal government giving money to states or non-profits joining together as three different sorts of paths to a job guarantee and i'm interested in how unions may have played a part in other job guarantee programs and how they might play a part in a new job guarantee program i'm sorry if that's several questions at once yeah um i'll take a stab at some of that if that's all right um so i this is actually making me think of my days when i served as americorps vista here in vermont actually and um for those of you who may not know about americorps vista um it's a way for various non-profits who need additional staffing to get an extremely low paid young person to help them with all kinds of uh work that would fall under the care economy um you know removing invasive species working and supporting a library which is what i did i'm putting on um you know continuing education programs um stocking food shelves and organizing food shelves um so you know the role of these jobs however you know i'm not saying we use this same framework but these jobs are unfortunately not well paid very very low paid and cannot sustain a family or anything like that and so um we talked about you know frame uh starting at a minimum setting a minimum pavlina of 15 an hour in benefits but we know that for a lot of unionized workers in particular um that is not going to be attractive for for so many um and so the role of unions is to really improve all the jobs that are available including possibly any jobs in the public sector that would be created under a job guarantee and um you know right now there's actually a lot of organizing happening nationally of non-profits um who are doing this kind of care work but unfortunately um you know their workers are usually underpaid uh with the you know sometimes unfortunately excuse that you know this because this is mission driven work um you know you should be in it um for the nature of the work and not for the money well the fact of the matter is we still need to you know um put a roof over a head and food on our tables um and you know you need a better paying job increasingly to do that these days um wages are notoriously low as steph showed us here in vermont so um you know i think the unions are just to organize organize and that's why i also highlighted the importance of not only having a jobs guarantee but also expanding and protecting the right to organize that's what really brought the new deal to its height and that's what we need to really make a robust jobs guarantee i believe absolutely i'll i'll add a few thoughts to this i mentioned earlier this rosa luxembourg series that we're we're doing this month especially today's panel i highly recommend taking a look at that andrew where you heard labor leaders talking specifically about why and how to organize for a job guarantee from a from a labor movement perspective one of the one of the things that we was mentioned this afternoon is fighting for the legal right for sympathy strikes to build the labor movement so that you know when when one union takes a hit when one industry takes a hit the rest of the labor movement is there to support uh and that is that is not legal today and and that's just not right uh and if we organize to get this to push back against these laws in these regulations then we're on to something in terms of building this uh this movement in terms of the role of labor unions for example in protecting um prevailing wage laws which sustain certain standards for wages and and and this has been you know under attack in state after state after state across the country when you have an organized labor movement not just in the construction industry but across the board we can set those minimum standards and the job guarantee can help us build towards that so when you when you create a job guarantee program at the local level and you end up hiring a few people who will be technically doing construction type work they can you know claim the prevailing wage legislation as the standard for their wages they can join a union they can join a union apprenticeship program unions can be part of the design of a job guarantee to build resources for the community and do the on-the-job paid training this is something that you know our generation completely forgot that it used to be normal for people to get a job join a union on day one and become an apprentice learn the skills on the job not go get the training pay for it out of pocket and then maybe if you're lucky you find a job so this role we can reclaim the role of unions in the apprenticeship and the job training program not just in construction and manufacturing and in the trades but across the board including healthcare including elderly care child care this is the the world that we should be allowed to imagine and to create uh the the the problem is that we have we have been so beaten and weakened as as people as a movement for for decades that we're not even allowed to think about the possibilities of how we organize this um so i'll leave it at that there's there's plenty of uh additional discussion to be had about how labor unions should um what role they they can play in and next week by the way at 1pm we're having the third and final installment of this series and will be breakout sessions so that i would invite all of you to join us and we'll have a lot of labor leaders joining us and academics and policy people and organizers to unpack a lot of these questions including the question that andrew was asking today thanks so much farel and i added a few other i added a link to that um uh roselux session also um to ayanna presley's uh press announcement and the renew new england as well as several faqs on the jobs guarantee uh that really provide a lot of the the basics um so i really appreciate the focus here on sort of the systemic issue that we're both dealing with and that we're proposing um and also the cultural piece right like really the the fundamental uh constraint of reimagining and and how deep some of this goes at a very cultural uh level and i know that's we should all check out on mass and liz medina's radio labor radio for more on that so i'd like to briefly we're just about out of time but briefly invite any of the panelists if you'd like to say a last word um and then i'll turn it over to gary steward who's with the organizing committee with uh vermont renews and uh gary's gonna provide some ideas about how people can continue to get involved with renew new england so steph liz fadell or josh i don't i don't have all that much to to add just want to thank the fellow panelists for a really really rich discussion i certainly learned a lot and yeah really really appreciate all of your time thank you yeah and i will definitely second that thank you all so much for taking some time out on a well what is here at least a very beautiful afternoon and uh thanks also liz for dropping in the podcast link check it out you can actually listen to that while you're outside so that will be nice uh gary please close us off and thank you all once again and i look forward to continuing this work together thanks man and thanks for the extraordinary panel excuse me extraordinary panelists for just an incredibly rich dialogue uh so much to uh get galvanized about so thank you so much for uh contributing a great way of looking forward and doing some productive work again i'm gary steward i'm an active member of champlain valley gsa with the ecosocialist working group as well as the socialist education working group and i've been very active with renewed new england vermont again for those who may not be familiar renew new england alliance which renew vermont is part of is composed of at least 150 different organizations focusing on a judge transition from fossil fuel economy and an exploitive economy to one that focuses on job justice environmental justice racial justice gender justice to create an ecologically just and sustainable society and really excited to let you know some of the things that renew vermont is involved with uh just a sec here uh first um we've been introducing a number of bills um in this legislative excuse me session uh since the main focus will be on kobit uh this year um a lot of these bills even once they get approved won't be able to be acted on until next year but we have some great bills coming in and that we can build on next year there are some things that people can actually become involved with one we're asking people to sell senator leahy to back the thrive agenda uh i can put that in the chat room um the thrive agenda is basically the same what we've been talking about here and uh there's a bill that has been introduced and should be voted on this session in congress let me get that here to you and really it is basically a green new deal um for workers so uh let me go back so it's just very easy just click on that and sign it and uh and we have a good ally in senator leahy so that is very good we're also supporting a vermont bipod led and land access and opportunity act and with that one you would email your legislator uh let me make a copy of that and then connect you here so then you can participate in that as well let me uh get that for you i thought that okay just a sec here we go may make a copy of that and come here just click on that and you'll be able to do that and let me go back again um again that is uh a joint you know effort led by seating power vermont to urge the house committee on general housing and military affairs to take up house bill 273 the vermont bipock-led land access and opportunity act to help uh communities within the uh community to have better access to getting land which is a real issue here uh within vermont um the next is to support our regenerative economy bill i know matt you've been very involved with that as well and that is has been introduced let me uh share this link to where you can contact your legislator if you're in vermont to support that let's see here okay so we've been doing some really good work to address um regenerative agriculture and regenerative uh economics here in vermont uh in in our legislation legislative body they don't like hearing the green new deal but what basically what renew vermont and renew new england alliance are doing is a green new deal uh and lastly let me get here real quick and our housing justice petition yes we're looking at housing justice for all vermonters this is a issue that we do need people to support for affordable safe equitable and healthy housing for all vermonters and again this is something that all the member states within the renewed new england alliance are supporting as well and let me put that right here and then really lastly is that we have one more coming event that's coming up and which is may day and we have some exciting things coming up for mayday uh which is focusing on just transition and vermont this is part of the thrive agenda and i'm going to put a link to that event once my computer uh speeds up a bit uh it's a little bit slow right now uh okay here we go but anyway we do have an event that is coming up um later uh for may day and uh we would like for y'all to participate uh in that if you're in the state of vermont i'll just have to wait for the computer to proceed i'm sorry about that it's a little slow right now but uh anyway that's pretty much it and the only other thing i would say is if if you're in new england uh check what your uh organization sister organization is doing that if it's part of the renew new england alliance then plug in to their efforts on focusing on green justice zones uh sustainable will green retrofitting of housing and food security here in vermont we have working committees who are working on these and we are looking for people to participate in these organ and these working groups so if you are interested um you can contact matt or you can contact me i'll put my email in and we're looking for community leaders um whatever's right uh to be part of this process so uh thank you very much uh let's see here forgive me putting in my information and uh feel free to contact us thank you man for this opportunity absolutely thank you so much gary and uh thanks to our captioner um so i appreciate your help thank you so much to the whole l4e team and of course our panelists and uh leaving you with uh some music that fidel just dropped in here so all right thanks a lot everyone thank you everyone thank you i love the music [Laughter] me too if you share your screen the sound will be better we've got to leave it in the ground you solar all around save ourselves we need a new deal that's what we need we need a new deal we need we don't need you hanging around how much money can you use yourself we need a new it was that's what we need that's what we need [Music] we need a green deal come on get clean we meet it up right now [Music] we need what we need [Music] that's what we need yeah yeah all right all right that was the rally song for the movement where did you find every movement this is my friend and that's uh recorded in my living room there wow allen is a as a community organizer labor organizer and um artist singer songwriter so he wrote the song you're a very special guest in a very special panel today and still going here let me turn that off thank you for sharing that thank you yeah here's here's the link if you want to save it and play it it's cool better quality when you play it on your own computer all right y'all thanks so much thank you yeah thank you so much for your presentation it was a pleasure to be here thank you all right bye bye love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com JGP会議 Fadhel Kaboubさんのツイート 36 ~ 46 分 https://twitter.com/fadhelkaboub/status/1380249353571475468?s=21 39:35 チャーネバ 56:35 (~ 1:15:05 )カブー 1:29:55 カブー 1:33:24 チャーネバ JPk9 +ビニールのプロジェクトJGP2021 / 04/08限定公開11回放送•2021/04/0900共有れ遅い遅い1件のコメントmecom公開コメントを入力... me com me com3時間前(編集分け)39:35チャーネバ56:35(〜1:15:05)カブー1:29:55カブー1:33:24チャーネバ立って大丈夫それは大丈夫です私たちは人々に参加するためにもう1、2分与えるつもりですそしてそれから始めましょうあなたは今Facebookに住んでいます大丈夫みんなが同じ意見を持っていたらありがとう大丈夫申し訳ありません大丈夫なぜ私たちは始めませんかそして人々がそれに来るのは私がええとシャンプランバレーにいる美しい日ですvermont um abnaki territory and uh my name is matthew burke私はバーモント大学のポスドクで、銃を持った研究所があります。これは、ええと、エコゾイックがまとめたプログラムです。ガンドインスティテュートum [音楽]と私からのサポートこのグループができてとても興奮しています。人々が山積みになっていることも知っています。Facebookのライブも行われているので、さまざまな方法で参加してもらい、チャットは機能します。人々が最後まで質問を続けることができれば、パネリストから一連のプレゼンテーションを行い、それから質問を取り始め、議論と質疑応答のために十分な時間を残そうとします。このセッションはニューイングランドの雇用保証の更新と呼ばれるように、4分の1から6程度にまとめる必要があります。特に、基本的な人間のニーズを満たすための雇用保証を中心としたニューイングランドの更新同盟からの提案に注目しています。多国間連合と私たちは今日ここにジョシュア・ケステンを持っていますニューイングランドの更新について少しお話しし、この提案を実行に移します。この連合のすべては、ニューイングランドの更新の政策責任者であり、州の地方および地域レベルで組織されています。人種的正義と雇用保証の両方を中心とした変革的なグリーンニューディールとジョシュはそれをジョシュに引き渡します。ジョシュはニューイングランドの更新に関するいくつかのイントロコメントを提示し、パネリストを紹介します。マシューとええと、ここにいることにとても興奮しています。ええと、この作品の私の主なバックグラウンドは、実際には日の出の動きの主催者としてであり、マシューが言ったように、私は現在、更新で働いています。私'ニューイングランドで私たちが今ここにいるような感覚をみんなに与えるために、更新について簡単に紹介します。それから私はそうです、そして私は私たちが持っている他のパネリストを紹介します今日ここに本当に素晴らしいパネルがあり、その後はええとmみんなの言うことを聞くのを本当に楽しみにしています、そしてうまくいけば、私たちは活発な議論をすることができますええと、更新とは何ですか?更新は、ええと、人種差別の正義を知っているあなたの重複する危機に対処するために、ええと、昨年の初めに形成されました大量失業、広範囲にわたる経済的搾取と剥奪、コロナウイルス、パンデミック、そしてもちろん、深刻で不可逆的な生態系の崩壊の差し迫った見通しを非常に現実的に知っています。社会的ええと、私が今述べた社会的および環境的危機は、あなたが日常的に扱われ、明確な問題として扱われていることを知っていますが、私たちは、全体的に対処しなければならない一連の問題を考慮したときに、ええと思いました。インターネット接続が不安定です誰もが私を聞くことができます大丈夫ええ大丈夫今ここでそれは行き来していますが今のところそれは大丈夫かまたは多分先に進まないようですニューイングランドの150以上の組織を連合にまとめたと言っていたので、人種的正義が労働組合を擁護し、正義の主催者である若者の気候活動家を収容している先住民族のコミュニティについて話しているのです。ニューイングランドの6つの州すべての連合メンバーを代表する公園地域評議会によって過半数に導かれ、連合としての私たちは、地域の共有政策目標を決定するために広範な草の根主導のプロセスを経て、実際にニューイングランドの深刻なグリーンニューディールが実際にどのように見えるかについての詳細な地図そして当然のことながら、ビジョンが仕事の保証を中心に展開している地図を知っているので、なぜ私たちが仕事の保証をとても中心的なものとして見たのかについて少し言う必要があります私たちのプロジェクトとあなたが具体的に知っていることは、私たちが住んでいるここのように見えるかもしれないので、これは私たち全員が労働について考えるように条件付けられた方法のようなものです後ろ向きの物語に慣れているので、自然な、あるいは避けられないような感じがすることもあります。それで、どういう意味ですか?それはどういう意味ですか?私たちは反射的に、umの仕事が常に不足していると仮定して、なぜそうだと思うのかを尋ねるのに慣れていますそして、あなたが本当にそれについて考え始めるとき、あなたがすぐにあなたに飛び出すような1つの事実は、あなたがしなければならないすべてのように行われる必要がある仕事の乏しいプロットが今社会を見回すだけであるということはあり得ないということですたとえば、誰もが家を持っていることを確認するための巨大な建物のエネルギー効率の高い住宅があります。または、別の例としてソーラーパネルと風力タービンを製造および設置するか、家と建物を劇的にエネルギー効率が高くなるように改造する別の巨大な作業があります。そしてもちろん、私たちが持っていないように個人の車両に取って代わるのに十分効率的で便利な地域の大量輸送システムを設計および構築するために必要なすべての作業に取り掛かることさえできます。もちろん、介護作業と社会的再生の大幅な拡大を知っているだけです。あなたが知っているように行う必要があります高齢者ケアプロバイダー学校の先生ええと在宅医療助手看護師などあなたは多くの高齢者がなぜ医療メンタルヘルスケアであり、教育と子育ての仕事を必要とする多くの若い人々がそれらのニーズを必要としているのか知っている今は会っていない」公園や図書館、コミュニティセンター、公共スペースなど、他に類を見ない世界的な不安を解消するために、多くの追加作業を行う必要があります。やろうとしているのは、やらなければならない仕事がたくさんあるように、やるべき仕事が足りないので、仕事が不足しているということはあり得ないということです。 「今は奇妙な状況にあります。興味深いことに、私たちがよく知っているよりも奇妙だと思います。一方では大量の失業があり、他方では膨大な量の重要な仕事があります。それはまだ終わっていないので、それは」更新連合が雇用保証をあなたの中心に置くことを決定した理由は、私たちの素晴らしいニューディール政策の枠組みを知っています。なぜなら、グリーンニューディールが深い意味であなたが知っていることはまさにそれのようなものだからです。仕事がどのようなものかについての逆の理解を逆転させることについては、現在のように設計された経済を知ってもらうことができます。そうすることで、すでに非常に裕福な人々や企業をさらに豊かにすることができます。社会的ニーズを満たすために雇用を創出するように設計された経済を持っているええと、輸送のきれいな空気のようなヘルスケアのチャイルドケア食品、そしてもちろん、干ばつの頻度と深刻さを知っている人を最小限に抑える住みやすい気候を提供するための巨大な満たされていないニーズのような気候変動を飢饉します。私たち全員が直面するであろうテロの標準的なカタログに精通しているように、ますます不足している資源の異常気象などをめぐって戦争をします。とにかくコミッションの排出量を急速に管理しているので、私たちの仕事は更新され、そして私は、より一般的には、主催者でのグリーンニューディールとのグリーンでの取り組みは、最も基本的なレベルでの挑戦だと思います。仕事とは何か、それが何を意味するのかという右翼の概念、そしてもちろんそれは、私たちが仕事と見なす種類や仕事の種類だけでなく、労働者の扱い方にも挑戦します。なぜあなたは強い労働慣行を知っているので、私は高給、高品質の利益、団体交渉権について話しているのです。それが、私たちが書いたすべての法律にすべてのものが組み込まれている理由です。地域全体で再戦しているので、仕事の意味や労働者の扱い方について本当に深く考えている他のパネリストを紹介するのは良いセグエのように感じます。私は本当に今日の午後、みんなと話し合うことに本当に興奮しているように、最初にステファニー・ユウがいます。■モンペリエを拠点とする非党派の非営利財政政策シンクタンクである公共資産研究所の副所長は、日常のバーモンターの生活を改善するために働いており、ステファニーはミシガン州上院の民間部門の財政アナリストの財政アナリストとして働いてきました。ミシガン州財務省の予算マネージャーおよび国家およびコミュニティサービスのための西バージニア委員会の事務局長として州政府に勤務し、次はバーモント州労働評議会afl-cioの事務局長であり、以前はゴダード大学職員組合uaw2322の共同議長を務めた後、昨年、リズは労働総同盟文化を構築するために労働無線ネットワークの一部である大衆に呼びかけた口頭歴史ポッドキャストを立ち上げました。バード大学の経済学の准教授であり、現代貨幣理論と公共政策を専門とするニューヨークのレビー・エコノミックス・インスティテュートの研究者であるパヴリーナ・セルネバと、仕事の保証のための仕事の保証の場合と呼ばれる彼女の本を手に入れました昨年リリースされたものは、今日議論されている最も革新的な公共政策の1つの利点への究極のガイドであり、その後、フェーデルカブーブがいます。sデニソン大学の経済学准教授であり、持続可能な繁栄のための世界研究所の所長である彼の研究は、中東の政治経済と雇用創出プログラムの財政および金融政策の側面に焦点を当てており、非常に有能なパネルのようです。そして、ええと、そうそう、彼らの考えのためにこれらのええと他のパネリストのいずれかにそれを渡すのはとても幸せです私は私が思うm up am i up yesどうぞよろしくお願いしますsteph紹介してくれてありがとう、そしてその良い食べ物を考えてくれてありがとうjoshジョシュが言ったように、公共資産研究所は本当に国家レベルの経済財政政策を日常の人々とその影響は何であるかというと、経済は株式市場の停止ではないことを知っているので、人々に何が起こっているのか、そして彼らはどのように経済を経験しているのか、そして私はジョシュがちょうど私に考えさせたものの1つはええと、私たちが仕事や仕事と考えるものについての会話の一部です。私たちが良い仕事と考えるものは、私たちがそれらの仕事をどのように評価するかについても考えています。本当の仕事と公的な仕事はあまり現実的ではなく、価値も低く、保護する価値も低いので、私は思うこれは素晴らしい会話だと思います。参加できてうれしいので、ここでの私の役割は、過去10年以上のバーモント州の労働環境のようなものを地面に置くことだと思います。仕事の保証のようなものが最大の違いを生む可能性がある場所と穴がどこにあるのかを考えるという観点から、それが何を意味するのかについての準備を整えましたが、労働環境についての会話は本当に始めなければならないと思いますこれで、パンデミックが明らかに物事を多くの混乱に陥れ、1年前とは非常に異なる世界について話しているという問題がありますので、それは一種の出発点だと思いますそれは、私たちがどこにいるのかよくわからないということですこの後着陸する私はそれについての1つの良いことは私たちが政府の役割とお互いへの義務の種類について話している多くの会話の可能性を本当に開くことだと思いますそしてどんな仕事が重要であるか本質的なええと、それは本当に多くの会話の可能性を開くと思います私はいつもチャートを持って来るので、私は私の画面を共有し、それに飛び込んで、あなたに簡単な概要を与えるようにしますバーモント州の労働環境は大丈夫です。パンデミックが本当に物事を混乱に陥れたというこの考えから始めたのですが、これは本当にあなたにこのようなチャートを見たことがあると確信しています。それはどこで'失業率の前例のない規模でのこの巨大な急上昇のようなものですが、これについて注意すべきことは、私たちがまだ最悪の大不況をはるかに上回っていることを知っているということです。ピークからかなり下がったので、私たちが話していることに対してまだかなり極端な規模になっているので、私はこの会話を政府の役割である種の国家政策に戻したいと思いますバーモント州は、州の予算権と市民に対する州の義務の目的であるこのようなものが制定法に定められている数少ない州の1つであり、市民がそれであると知っているすべてのことをリストしています。私は市民ではありません市民に限定したいのですが、あなたが知っているバーモント州のバーモント州の住民は、威厳のある仕事を含むこれらの権利を持っています。最初の要点は、バーモント州の労働市場は、1つの労働市場ではなく、1つの労働風景ではないように、かなり不均一であるということです。北西の隅で起こっていることは、南または北東の王国で起こっていることとは大きく異なります。それが最初のポイントです。2番目のポイントはバーモント州の賃金が低いということです。これは、労働市場がどのように見えるか、どのような仕事があるかについて話すときの問題の大きな部分です。従来の労働市場から取り残されている人がたくさんいるので、増加しているギグ労働者や障害のある自営業者のバーモント州は、労働市場で見過ごされがちな別のグループです。バーモント州でも当てはまるパンデミックの女性への不均衡な影響の話と見出しを見たことがあると思いますので、これらのそれぞれをもう少し掘り下げて、労働市場は不均一であるため、州全体でバーモント州の多くは大不況から回復しておらず、回復したということは、彼らがまだ下にいることを知っているということです。失われた土地を取り戻したのは、大不況の間に失った仕事や雇用者の数であり、明らかにこのパンデミックなパンデミック不況に陥っていました。パンデミックは明らかに州全体の状況を悪化させたので、あなたは本当にええと見ることができます大不況以来、郡の半分だけが仕事を獲得しており、あなたが追加している仕事が質の良い仕事ではないことを知っているのではない場合、仕事を追加することは何を意味するのかについてあなたが知っていることについての会話があることを再び知っていますそれは人々にとって意味がありますが、州のさまざまな部分と同様に雇用の部分の間でこの本当に大きな違いが見られるので、仕事は一種の給与ベースの仕事であり、雇用は働く人々です。仕事の部分は仕事が配置されている場所であり、雇用の部分は従業員が正しく住んでいる場所であるため、1対1のマップのようなものではありません。したがって、まったく同じパターンは表示されませんが、これは表示されます。この不均一性は、一部の地域では成長があり、一部の地域では本当に苦労しており、学年後の不況に苦しんでいるという事実です。それから、私たちが行ってきた多くの仕事は、30年前に戻ったようなものだと思います。過去30年間、または実際にサービスサービスの仕事に追加しているので、常に真実であるとは限りませんが、これらの仕事のほとんどは、支払いが少なくなる傾向があり、売上高が増える傾向があるので、これらはあなたのような仕事です。だろう」必ずしも人々が長期的になることを期待しているので、このことから、過去30年間の仕事の成長のすべてが実際にサービスにあることがわかり、2020年の結果としての一種の落ち込みをはっきりと見ることができます。パンデミックや、特にそうではない他の部分は、明らかにパンデミックがさまざまなセクターにさまざまな影響を及ぼしていることは明らかです。影響があり、それらの多くはある程度の根拠を取り戻していますが、あなたは彼らがまだパンデミック前の場所をはるかに下回っているので、2番目のポイントは賃金が低いというこの考えです。もう一度会話の精神に行くと思います。バーモンターや他のすべての人が持っているべきだと私たちは確かに信じていると思います。生活のあらゆる段階で住みやすい収入があるので、子供である場合、フルタイムで働いている場合、一時的に失業している場合、恒久的に働くことができず、安全な退職権を含むことを知っているので、彼らの生活のあらゆる段階で、彼らは基本的なニーズを満たすのに十分でなければなりません。最低賃金は住みやすい賃金でなければならないというフロアのようなものですが、このスライドは、バーモントの平均賃金でさえかなり低いというこの考えに本当に到達していると思います。したがって、この線は、賃金と物価の両方の米国平均を表しています。この種の価格バスケットには住宅が含まれているため、バーモントの価格は他の地域と比べてかなり平均的ですが、賃金は非常に低く、バーモントの平均よりも家賃が少し高くなる傾向があることもわかっていますが、ええと、バーモントの世帯の約3分の1だけが賃貸人です。sバーモント州の風景全体でかなり異なるので、そのチッテンデンの平均賃金が実際に州の平均賃金をどのように引き上げるか、そして他の多くの郡の賃金がそれよりもはるかに低いことがわかります。多くの人がバーモント州の労働力から除外されているというこの考えを知っていると思います。バーモント州の労働力のベースライン人口統計を示すためだけに、バーモント州の労働力の高齢化について多くの人が耳にしていると思います。私がここで見ている最大の違いは、バーモント州の人種的な人口統計が、他の国と比べて明らかに私たちの人口統計が実際に持っていないことです。過去30年間で、国全体とは異なり、大幅に変化しました。また、バーモント州の教育レベルは、私たち全体よりも1人あたりの学士号が多い傾向があることがわかります。ある種、私たちが誰について話しているのかを知ることができます。これの一部が関連するバーモント州であることがわかっているので、障害のあるバーモント州の写真を見て、そのうちの約半分だけが機能していて、その半分は半分しか働いていないので、フルタイムで働いているので、労働市場で見過ごされがちな1つの大きなグループです。パンデミックが女性に不釣り合いな影響を及ぼしているというこの問題について言及しました。確かに、バーモント州の伝統的な失業者のそれは、州の中で実際にバーモント州が女性であるという最も高いシェアを持っているので、伝統的な失業手当を集めている人々の約70人がバーモント州の女性であり、それは大きなグループです繰り返しになりますが、ここからバーモント州がかなり良い場所から始まっていて、国の他の地域に比べて女性の労働力参加がかなり良いということは、一種の問題ですが、これまでにどれくらいの時間がかかるか知っていますか?回復し、これのどれだけが介護の責任と関係があるか、そして再び私たちの経済に金銭的価値を持たない傾向があるが、明らかにやらなければならない仕事であり、今年は特にそうする必要があります's別の作品、そして私たちが多くのハードデータを持っていない傾向があるが、国の残りの部分に当てはまり、ここでも当てはまる他の作品は、bypocvermontersがより長く失業している傾向があるということです不況の後、あなたは不況の後を知った後、仕事の見通しの観点から買い戻しバーモンターにもっと影響があることを知っていますそしてそれから私がこれの不均一な種類の絵に関して私が思う最後のポイントはこれと同じ種類です最初に示したのと同じ失業保険金請求チャートですが、ここで行ったことは、人々が受けている失業手当の種類によって分類されているため、赤い帯はそうではないものであることがわかります。t伝統的に失業でカバーされており、これはその用語が誤解を招くような権利でさえある別の分野であり、一般に多くの労働者が通常の時間に資格を持たず、多くの労働者が失業手当の資格を持たない場合でも多くの資格を持っている人はそれらを取得しませんが、この場合、あなたはそれをより多くに開放するために連邦政府によってこの拡大があったことを知っていますそしてあなたがその種の赤を見ることができるようにその多くは自営業者とギグワーカーを禁止しますバンドはかなり安定していて、そうしない人もかなりいます。通常、今でも給付を必要としている失業制度の一部であるため、失業給付を受け取っているこのまだ3万人のバーモンターに戻ってくるようなものです。かなりの数があり、そのかなりの部分がこれらの人々です。伝統的にはそれに含まれていなかったので、私たちがどこにいたのか、どこにいるのか、そしてパンデミックが物事を激変させたのかについての簡単な概要のようなものですが、私たちはそうだと思いますまだパンデミックの影響を吸収しているようなものですが、労働政策には多くのギャップがあることを知っているという機会もあると思います。あなたの多くが育てることは確かですが、私たちが仕事と呼ぶものを私たちがどのように評価するかをあなたは知っていますあなたは介護や他の重要な仕事の過小評価を知っています多くの州とは異なり、バーモント州はまだ比較的最小限でしたが、文書化されていない労働者に匹敵する刺激の支払いを知っている州も多くありませんでした。私はあなたが知っていると思いますそしてそれからバーモントがなぜであるかというこの質問もあります賃金が低い賃金を低く抑え、賃金を低く抑えて進まないようにする力とは何か、そしてそれについて私たちに何ができるか、そしてその多くは労働政策に関係していると思います。これもまた、親にとっては高額であり、支払わず、労働者に住みやすい賃金を支払うことができないことを私たちは知っています。したがって、育児制度はさまざまな方法で壊れており、失業制度もこれです。それの一時的な拡大それは確かに私が目標だと思うことを意味しますそしてあなたが仕事の保証に関して話していることはあなたが将来的にあなたが失業システムの最小限の使用しか必要としないことを知っているということですおそらく常に必要なものもありますが、労働市場とのつながりを可能な限り維持し、働きたい人は働くことができるので、使用を最小限に抑えることができます。それが本当に目標であり、一種の目標だと思います。ここで話しているのは、長いリストと簡単な概要ですが、この会話のステージを設定するのに役立つことを願っています。素晴らしいステフに感謝します。これらを入手することは本当に役に立ちます。バーモント州の数字と、私たちが現在どこにいるのかを理解してください。特に、あなたがここでテーブルにもたらしたすべての苦労を考えると、私はリズメディナに行きたいです。多くの作業が明らかにそれです」まだここバーモントでやっているので、ここにいてくれてありがとう。私の名前はリズ・メディナです。私はバーモント州労働評議会afl-cioの事務局長です。労働組合連合はまた、前述のように、労働者のオーラルヒストリーを大衆に呼びかけたポッドキャストを制作し、私の最初のシーズンは、実際には、ewpaの下にあった連邦作家計画によって資金提供された大恐慌時代のオーラルヒストリーに焦点を当て、人々を集めて読んで演奏しましたそれらの話は関係者にとって、そして願わくば聞いた人々にとっても素晴らしい豊かな経験だったので、仕事の保証がバーモントafl-cioがその一部である更新連合の中心であると聞いたとき、それは仕事をキスしたように感じました保証は、私たちが大切にしているすべてのリーダーの労働の夢であり、生計を立てるために働かなければならなかったすべての人の労働の夢であり、大恐慌の飢餓の間に立っている間に私たちの国の4分の1以上が仕事を失ったことの痛みを知っていますパンのラインと何千もの行進1933年に私たちの国が労働者のために実質的な何かをするための街路は、pwaを組織して立ち上げる権利を認めた全国産業復興法またはネラが可決され、その後、一時的ではあるが連邦雇用プログラムと組み合わせて組織する権利が続いた。労働者が集団で組織するために必要な条件を作成し、1934年に140万人以上の労働者がストライキに関与し、大量労働運動が形成され、fdrとニューディール民主党がポストを作ったような大胆な法律を可決するための権力基盤を作りました-戦争期間は、私たちの国の歴史の中で最も繁栄し、私たちが以来見た中で最も低いレベルの所得格差があります。1980年代まで続いた1915年にそれらの測定を開始したため、労働運動の成長とwpaの成功は、より大胆なビジョン、特に生計を立てる能力が操作に依存しない未来のビジョンにつながりました。眠れる車ポーターの兄弟のフィリップ・ランドルフ大統領の数人による市場の提案は、1963年にワシントン大行進を触媒するアイデアを保証する仕事の提案を開発し始めました。1946年の雇用法や1970年のハンフリーホーキンスの完全雇用法など、すべてのアメリカ人が尊厳のある仕事をする権利を持つべきであるという考えを祀ったいくつかの立法努力もありましたが、残念ながら彼らは最終的な形で歯がなく、野心的なままです資本家階級と彼らの捕らえられた政治家からの激しい反発は、1954年のピーク以来、組合密度の着実な低下をもたらしました。だから私はこの歴史を簡単に再ハッシュしているので、雇用保証を勝ち取るために労働運動を再構築する必要があることを私たちに思い出させるためにあなたが知っていると確信しています。しかし、ランクの指示に従って、労働組織の多くの組合を提出する代わりに、腐敗した企業化された民主党の指示に従って、私たちは一度投げられたコインを単に捕まえたくありません。しばらくの間、特に私たちが世界的なパンデミックなどの複数の世界的な危機に直面している。また、将来の労働者にふさわしい決定を下すために民主党と少数の技術者を信頼するのではなく、職場やコミュニティに尊厳と民主主義が必要なベーシックインカムだけに満足すべきではない。含まれるだけでなく、そのような決定のリーダーになることは、生産の時点で戦略的役割を維持する必要があることを意味します。労働運動を再構築することは、私たちが望む労働者階級である私たちの真の力の源を再発見し、再燃させることを意味します私たちは家族のために快適な家に栄養価の高い食べ物を望んでいますすべてのきれいな空気と水のための優れたヘルスケア皮肉なことに私たちは必要なものすべてを生産することができますが、私たちはこの国に寡頭制を持っています基本的なニーズを満たすために必要な数の仕事を生み出すために必要なリソースをコミュニティに戻す必要がありますなぜ私たちは組合の兄弟姉妹や兄弟と仕事の保証が必要なのかについて話し合う必要があります私たちはすべての瞬間とプラットフォームをつかんで強調する必要があります全国レベルでの雇用保証の必要性このパンデミックは、より多くの医療従事者、ソーシャルワーカー、および地域レベルで危険な状況で休むことなく働いている他の多くの不可欠な労働者の必要性を示しています。私たちの職場は、たとえば2018年に、看護師と医療専門家の後方に所属するバーモント連盟がストライキに出かけました。バーモント大学の医療センターでは、看護師に対する患者と看護師の比率が驚くほど高いという問題も強調されているため、賃金と福利厚生にのみ焦点を当てています。ストライキを続けるストライキにより、州内のすべての人がバーモント州でより高給の看護職の必要性を認識しました。安全な人員配置の問題から、私たちの同僚と話し合う必要がある雇用保証の呼びかけに移るのはほんの小さな一歩です-労働者の友人や隣人私は不可能な作業負荷を与えられている非常に多くの働くバーモンターと話したことがあります特に、ソーシャルワークを行うように呼ばれた100のケースに近づいていることをこの人が共有した、働くバーモンターのオーラルヒストリーを収集するとき、迂回ケースマネージャーとの会話は非常に際立っていますそれは彼らの家族の育成と精神に深く浸透しました、しかし彼らは彼らができなかったという事実によって絶えずストレスを感じていました。圧倒的なケースロードのために、各クライアントに必要なだけの支援を提供します。彼らは家に帰って24時間働き、夜中に落ち着いてパートナーとたむろする機会さえなく、より多くの仕事をするだけでした。慢性的な人員不足とリソースの不足のために、フィールドと彼らは完全に燃え尽きそうになりました。その間、私たちのソーシャルワークシステムは誰にもサービスを提供しませんでした。私たちの抑圧者が私たちが実力主義に住んでいると信じさせられていると私たちに告げる多くのフィクションにもかかわらず、人生は暗くて苦痛ですが、私たちのほとんどは最善の努力と私たちが生み出す莫大な富にもかかわらずほとんどうまくいかないでしょうすべての責任私たち自身、そして私たち全員が私たち自身を超えて他の力や人々とつながっていることを理解するために私は私は私の世代の他の多くの人と同じようにこの旅を続けてきました。キャリアの初期段階で失業期間に苦しんでいました。家に帰らなければなりませんでした。家に帰ると、経済的に落ち込んだ錆びたベルトの町に戻ります。店先は大きく迫っていますが、その期間は私の人生で最も暗いままですが、私は恥と恐れに私を支配させることを拒否します。そのため、私は仕事の保証のための戦いに個人的に投資しているので、仕事の保証は私たちの兄弟姉妹の兄弟組合と非労働組合が死ぬまで働くことからの雇用保証は、労働者に選択を与えることによって雇用者の専制的な力に対抗することができます。雇用保証は、雇用者が彼らの力を維持するためにしばしばお互いに対立する失業者と雇用労働者の間の団結を構築するのに役立ちます。間の団結を構築するのに役立つ可能性がありますあらゆる種類の労働者私たちが労働運動を再構築し、仕事をするために必要な種類の団結は、レース国家または階級のためのフィリップ・ランドルフの救済の言葉で現実を保証します。厳密に言えば、ランドルの究極のビジョンは自由予算であり、その中心は私たち自身と無記名者のための私たちの運動の両方を尊重する時が来たという仕事の保証でした私たちが仕事の保証と来る自由と正義を勝ち取る時が来ましたそれで私たちはたくさんの話をしてくれてありがとう本当に素晴らしかったたくさんのリズに感謝しますそして私はあなたがこの会話にもたらした深い歴史的知識に本当に感謝していますそして私たちのように自由を団結に結びつけるのに適切ですここバーモントum [音楽]でこの特定の角度からそれについて話しているので、ありがとうございますlizuh私はuhpablina chernovaumを招待したいと思いますuhuhいくつかのコメントを提供し、そこから私たちはに行きますええと、ファレル・カブドルありがとうパブリナありがとうみんなありがとうええと、コメントの招待に感謝しますあなたが私が言うことの舞台を設定しましたそしてここでの私の仕事は鳥瞰図の写真をマクロの写真に持ってくることだと思います分析ですが、テーマはとても重要だと思います。もちろん、最初のことは、ジョシュが指摘していたように、やるべき仕事がないからといって、仕事が不足しているわけではないということです。私の見解では、公的部門の仕事を評価していないというビジョンの欠如と政府の直接的な貢献の重要性のためだけでなく、仕事の不足がそこにあるということです。作ることはできますが、しませんしかし、使命のために行動を起こさなかったため、また政策固有の政策のために不足しているので、経済学者が失業についてどのように考えているか、これらの誤ったフレームをどのように再現するかという視点を持ち込みたいと思います。必要な場合でも、これは私が話したい2番目のことを暴くために本当に重要だと思います失業は永続的であるという特定の感覚があるということですそれは私たちと一緒ですこの経済システムに典型的ですこの非常に独特な心拍を持っているシステム成長し、縮小し、成長し、縮小し、市場の活力のあらゆる種類の変動の影響を受けるシステムは、貿易から技術などであり、付随的な損害は常に人々であり、それは常に仕事ですが、そこにあります」なんらかの理由で仕事が犠牲になったときに、私たちには雇用を創出するための非常に直接的な手段と方法があることをあなたが知っていることについて避けられないことは何もありません。この会話で私が聞いているのは、私たちの社会が必要としていることは行われておらず、子供からこれらのものを手に入れることはできないと定期的に言われている、進行中の重要な仕事に対するこの切実なサポートを作成する必要があるということです。高齢者へのケア、インフラへのケア、社会へのケア、環境への取り組み、私たちは常にできると言われています」そういうことを考えておくと、仕事の未来を考え直す上で非常に重要ですが、仕事の保証の別の側面にも光を当てたいと思います。公的オプションそれは、あなたが誰であれ、あなたの状況が何であれ、基本的な威厳のある賃金給付パッケージで公的部門のオプションになるという究極の保証です。重要な継続的な恒久的なセクターの仕事は常にそこになければならないので、いくぶん別々のものとして見られるべきですが、経済へのこの鼓動は常にあります。それがもはや私たちのマクロ経済の世界の一部ではないことを確認してくださいどんな状況でも仕事が必要な人のためのオプションがあります。最後に、雇用が権利であり、誰もがその権利にアクセスできる世界を想像すると、リズが言っていたように、いくつかのことを言いたいと思います。本当に新しい社会契約を表しており、それは私たちがお互いにどのように関係しているかを生きる方法を労働市場のゲームのルールに変えますが、非常に重要な点は、実際には労働者と失業者の運命は消えないように絡み合っているので、パワーポイントのプレゼンテーションをしましたが、これを行うつもりはありません。退屈で退屈なだけですが、いくつかのことを知っていると思います。このアイデアは非常に人気があり、私には数字があり、私は人気があるだけでなく、保守的なサポートでも50%以上の超党派のサポートを獲得していることを共有できてうれしいです。これらの調査は最近のものであり、今朝私が見ていた世界中で複製されています。フランスからの新しいものフランスyougovでのグリーンジョブ保証のサポートは昨年、米国の英国で70%以上の調査を行いましたが、近年は一貫して70%であるため、連邦レベルでは連邦政府が雇用保証政策を追求するかどうかにかかわらず、連邦レベルでの動きがあるかもしれません私はそれを取り巻く組織化はまだ良い地方政治だと思いますそれで私が言いたかった次のことはマクロ鳥からのそのええとです」視点から見ると、覚えておくべきことがいくつかあります。もちろん、私たちの闘争はそれぞれはるかに簡単になり、もちろん私たちが親切にできる包括的な方針を持っていれば、私たちの活動はそれぞれ簡単になります。私たちが連邦政策を持っていて、代表的なアヤンナ・プレスリーによって進められた最近の決議では、雇用の権利は基本的人権であるということを最初に心に留めておきたい3つのコアコンポーネントのようでした。また、それは公的資金によって支払われ、それは公共の利益のための公的雇用のためであり、それは野心的な文脈で一種の野心的なものになるでしょうそしてそれからマクロ経済の文脈がありますそしてここで私は話をするために数分を費やしたいと思いますええと、どのように経済学者が私をしているのかについて少し申し訳ありませんが、失業率は自然であり、失業率は避けられないものであり、市場は非常に多くの雇用しか創出できないという古い石灰化した理論的概念が原因であるというフレームを拒否する必要があります。政策は、失業率を市場が自然なレベルとみなす水準よりも低くするための手段を実際には多く持っていません。なぜなら、政策がそうしようとすると、望ましくないインフレが発生する可能性があるからです。これを聞いて驚いたのは、実際には中央銀行の失業率は、3.54の正の失業率であるという方針です。5%は、インフレを恐れて経済に提供している可能性のある刺激を取り除き、ブレーキを踏む必要がある場合に通知するポリシーガイドです。もちろん、これについて考えると、チャネルが何であるかがわかります。多くの人が仕事をしている人が多すぎる人は収入が多すぎて購買力が多すぎて食べられないので、実際に雇用を犠牲にするか、マクロ経済モデルに正統な方法で根付いているポジティブなレベルの失業を許容することでインフレと戦わなければなりませんエコノミストは、モデルが議会の予算事務所であるかどうかにかかわらず、モデルをまとめる方法を考えています。中央銀行に関しては、失業は自然であり、マクロ経済の安定と価格の安定にとって望ましいというこのマクロモデルに潜んでいる概念があります。したがって、私の仕事では、労働者のフィデルと同僚は、この考えを実際に非難しようとしていることを知っています。雇用を創出できる代替案があります。雇用保証自体を使用して、現在失業が使用されているような経済安定化、さらには価格安定化を提供できます。したがって、マクロレベルでは、ポリシーレベルで必要性を拒否します。政策手段としての失業の問題であり、雇用保証がそのバッファーになるという未知のことは、不況が自然に発生したときに増加する強力な力になるだろうと私たちは主張します。人々が仕事を必要とするときに彼らが仕事の保証を利用するときに与えられた政策を要求することは経済的安定を提供する公共部門による非常に支出であり、それは人が全世界で雇用されているときに問題にお金を投げるよりもはるかに優れています失業に依存している場合は、それがどんなに寛大であっても、雇用保証は不況で成長する安定剤であり、貿易などのために仕事が逃げるときに雇用を提供し、民間企業が経済生活がコミュニティに戻ると縮小しますママとポップショップが生まれ始め、彼らは雇用を提供し始めます。それで、実際には、失業と同じように増減するのは、実際の鳥からのバッファーです。公共部門は常に失業に責任があります公共部門は常に失業の社会的費用に責任がありますが、失業者が貧困対策プログラムのために知っている失業者へのわずかな支援と支援は一部です。政府がこれを認識しているかどうかにかかわらず、私たちは失業の社会的崩壊と私の仕事のすべての人的費用に集合的に責任があります私はそれらをカタログ化して文書化しますそしてそれらは非常に大きいですそれは許容するのは非常に高価な提案です失業とその社会的費用それらに対して接種し、求職者に仕事を提供することははるかに良い方針です良い仕事良い仕事と良い利益がありますそうですねマクロレベルでは2つの選択肢がありますどちらかシステムを許容しますに基づくあなたが知っている失業失業はそれが鳴り響くか、私たちは必要な失業の機会を提供する公的な選択肢を持っています。 -完全雇用経済と呼ばれていますが、最高の時期でも仕事を求めている人はまだいます。彼らは常にそこでの雇用機会になるというそのような政策コミットメントは新しい社会契約を表しているので、私は自分の考えを実行したいと思います。新しい社会契約の社会のこれらの柱のいくつかかもしれません、そして最初のものは失業が本当に破壊主義であるという私たちがこれまでに持ってきたこの議論に基づいていますええと、これは経済学者がビクトリアに使用した用語です失業は破壊主義であると主張することはそれです」マクロレベルまたはポリシーレベルから、この破壊行為はある種の必要性があり、直接雇用と直接行動があるため、公共部門が責任を負う場合、それは確かに必要ではありません。社会的費用は、実際には、それが無視と荒廃に基づいてシステムをサポートするかどうかを引用符で囲まずに引用しないように、より良いことをする義務があります。sそれが人間であるかどうかにかかわらず、あなたはこの種のumの怠慢のために実際のまたは財政的な費用を支払うことを知っていますが、実際には私たちの最も貴重な資源の人々への投資のためにそれらのコミュニティへの投資に支払う責任と義務があります社会保障の次の部分は、はい、雇用保証は私たちの経済安定剤であるということです。つまり、私たちの経済全体は、直接雇用がない場合よりも直接雇用がある場合の方が安定しており、それを実施することによって、実際に新しい労働基準を確立することができます。つまり、ある人が最低15時間支払う仕事の公的オプションを持っていて、社会保障付きのメディケアと有給休暇があります。これは、オプションがあることを持っていない人の標準であり、雇用主が基準に適合しなければならない労働者を維持したいという利益を提供するので、労働基準を確立しようとする他の方法に加えて、雇用を通じて基準を確立することが基本的であることが重要です。最低賃金政策はすべて順調に進んでいますが、最低賃金を引き上げる必要がありますが、最低賃金政策の最低賃金の仕事を得ることができれば、その基準の恩恵を受けられないため、法定賃金の両方が必要ですが、雇用オプションも必要ですあなたは私たちが持つことができるその権利にアクセスできるということです私はあなたがヘルスケアが私たちが目指している基準の一部でなければならない社会的賃金の一部でなければならない雇用から分離される必要があることを知っていると思います仕事をやり直すには、休息をとる必要があり、休暇を正しく支払う必要があります。そうすれば、それが標準の大丈夫になるので、公共のオプションは、私たちが威厳のある仕事と見なすものの最小フロアを確立します。私たちは公共の雇用を持っています私たちは実際にさまざまなことを大切にします私たちは社会的に有用なことを大切にします私たちは人々を大切にします私たちは公共の利益を大切にします環境ケア経済は正しいです環境はそうではありません」支払うが、環境は私たちを育てているので、私たちは実際に重要と思われることを無視しています大丈夫ですええと最終的に私たちは失業の脅威を拒否します私はここでリズは私たちが拒否した場合に私たちがどのように接続されているかについて非常に明確に話しました労働者を懲戒するために失業が必要であるというこの考えは、労働者をどのように評価し、どのように彼らの仕事を支援し、どのように彼らを促進するかについて、まったく異なるパラダイムを持っています。それはあなたの生計を失うことの脅威や恐れではありませんが、他の方法があります。これは、引用符で囲まれていないことを知っています。あなたが正しいとしたら、それは懲罰的なパラダイムではなく、私たちが言ったように、あなたはそれを知っています。私たちは、失業率が労働者同士を対立させたり、防止したり、組織化したりするという会社の重要な力を取り除きます。これは、あなたの話を聞くのが本当に好きだったと思います。これはあなたがあなたを知っているという認識です。労働組合の仕事は、完全雇用を厳しくすることを条件としているので、次はトレードオフを拒否します。テクノロジーはあなたの仕事を奪うと言われています。貿易はあなたの仕事を奪うでしょう。グリーン移行はあなたをあなたの仕事から奪うつもりであり、人々はそれを恐れています、そして彼らはそうしません必要な種類のポリシーを追求しますが、答えが得られました。フィデルは、環境運動における雇用保証の重要性について話し、最後に、これらのポリシーは実際には人々がそれを行うことができ、これらの政策を回復力のあるものにし、特定のコミュニティに対処するために必要な評価と実施を行うことができる、実行しなければならない種類の作業を正確に知っている町や地域の都市に根を下ろします最後になりましたが、会話の一部であったこの基本的人権へのコミットメントを復活させ、再通知する必要があると思います。それは、経済的権利章典が最初の柱として雇用する権利を持っていたということでした。その会話を残しましたええと私は部分的に思うのでええとエコノミストは、完全雇用は3%の失業であり、私たちにできることはほとんどあると私たちに確信させましたが、私たちはそのコミットメントに戻って、仕事の保証を通じてそれを明確にする必要があるので、ここで終了します。それをfidelに渡してくださいありがとうpavlinaこれは本当に楽しんだ素晴らしいプレゼンテーションのセットでした、そして私はさらにいくつかのコンポーネントを追加して、全国でのグリーンニューディールの文脈での雇用保証についてもっと話すことに移行したいと思いますレベルまたはローカルレベルでええと、最初に私はすでに言われたことのいくつかについてコメントしたいと思います私はパブリノが言及していた主流派経済学者を意味しますこれらの人は彼らの不平等について間違っていたことを覚えておきましょう気候変動について間違っていた彼らはインフレについて間違っていた彼らが財政危機について間違っていることのほとんどすべてについて間違っているのは彼らのブラフと呼んでいます私はなぜ私たちはまだこれらの人に耳を傾け、ブルームバーグで彼らに放送時間を与えているのですか?気候変動対策での失業への政府支出が多すぎることをご存知でしょう。ハイパーインフレが発生する国を破産させます。過去10年間で、政府が大規模な赤字を出していることを示しています。ヨーロッパと日本と英国はインフレを引き起こしませんでしたあなたは日本が世界で最も高い債務対gdp比を持っていることを知っています260%そして彼らは負の金利を持っていますそして彼らは過去30年間デフレを持っているので彼らは何を知らない彼らのブラフと呼んでください彼ら'ecbについて話していると、最終的に金利を決定するものが本当にわからないと彼らは言った、そしてなぜこれらのことが起こっているのか私たちはそこで何か奇妙なことが起こっているのは日本だと思ったが、明らかに私たちのここでも供給されているよりも深い平易な英語でのインフレ翻訳の信頼できる理論は実際にはないので、これらがどのように機能するのかわからないので、ブラフと呼び、重要な問題に取り組む進歩的な動きをしましょう。何百万人もの人々が実際に働きたいと思っています私たちは地球が燃えています私たちは物事を成し遂げるための頭脳の力を持った技術を持っていますそしてどういうわけか私たちはこの権利のどれもできないと言われていますニューディール中に以前にそれを行ったことがあり、ええと、リズのプレゼンテーションは、私たちができることを思い出させてくれました。私たちにはロジスティック機能がなく、それだけではありませんでした。橋を架けることは、多くの人がwpaの労働者について覚えていないことを世話していました。彼らは、200万回以上の自宅訪問のようなものを作りました。最近出産した母親や、高齢者のケアや育児が必要な人は、インフラストラクチャの構築の一部でした。今週、インフラストラクチャも人であるという会話に戻ってきてうれしいです。sまた、ケア経済と、いわゆる完全雇用に近い、または完全雇用での完全雇用でのパンデミック前のパンデミックの間だけでなく、実際に60年代以来の最低レベルにある人々の数を調べることパンデミックの直前に隠された失業統計を掘り下げてみると、まだ正式に失業している何百万人もの人々だけでなく、就職したくないという理由で就職できなかった何百万人もの人々がいました。信頼できる交通手段がなく、仕事は彼らが車を購入したり公共交通機関にアクセスしたりするのに十分なお金を払っていませんでした。仕事がしなかったので誰かが子供の世話をしたり、年配の家族の世話をしたりするのに十分なお金を払うので、労働基準が非常に低いため、何百万人もの人々を経済から除外しています。この議論の中心となる運動、そしてあなた方の何人かは、私たちが今月ローザ・ルクセンブルグ財団と一緒にやってきたシリーズを見てきました。私はチャットにリンクを落としてうれしいです。今日の午後はちょうどカール・ローゼンとケオン・ラボラトリーのサラ・ネルソンとの素晴らしいパネルがありました。労働運動の全員が、私たちが求めているすべての大きなもののどれもがなければ、私たちがプロの行動をとることはできないと言っています。誰が私たちで誰が彼らであるかを認識する統一された運動」その組合に対するこの組合はこれではないので、システムを制御し窒息させている既得権益に反対しているので、彼らが通常グリーンディールの雇用保証に押し戻す大きなことについていくつかの言葉を述べます私はチャットにこのリンクを落としています。詳細のいくつかに興味がある人にとって、これはポーリーナやステファニーケルトンなどがその一部である仕事保証mmt文学の一部であり、私たちがしている簡単なメッセージです政府にはこれを支払うための資金がない、それは民間部門が雇用を創出しなければならないと言った。政府は税収による支出能力の点で制限されており、壁通りが政府に許可するものは何でも借りる借りるか、私たち」それを超えてウォール街によって再訓練された政府がより多くを費やすと、それはハイパーインフレを引き起こしますmmtと仕事保証の文献が私たちに教えていることは、連邦政府が利用できる追加の支出能力がたくさんあるということですそれは私たちが利用した方法ですそれは第二次世界大戦中の新しい取引時代のケアの資金調達中のケア法の支払い1.9兆ドルの支払いとすべての戦争とすべての減税の支払い私たちが持っている追加の支出能力は毎回言われています仕事については、これが私たちの国を破産させるのは中産階級についてです。mmtの文献から私たちが知っていることは、私たちが安全に持つことができる追加の支出の量を決定するのは、決定されるインフレの潜在的なリスクであるということです。私たち全員がここで地図上に持つべき2つの非常に重要なことは、生産能力が不足した場合、インフレリスクにぶつかることです。つまり、熟練労働者が不足した場合、材料、設備、技術が不足した場合、より多くを費やしたいのはインフレを引き起こすという良いニュースは、生産能力が生産可能であり、より多くの人々を訓練することができ、より多くの人々を労働力に引き込むことができるということです。私たちは私たちがなるために必要なものを生産します弾力性のある社会弾力性のある経済ええと、この会話とこの動きにとって非常に重要なインフレのリスクを決定する2番目のことは、主要企業内の主要セクター内の市場支配力の乱用市場支配力集中であり、単純に価格を上げることができます彼らは健康保険会社のことを考えられないという理由だけで人々を排除することができるのであなたの通信会社のことを考えてくださいジョシュは以前にインターネットの問題を抱えていました私は以前にインターネットの問題を抱えていました先月とそこに彼らは国を小さな領土に分割し、ヘルスケア業界と石油・ガス業界のエネルギー部門におけるそのようなインフレと虐待的な価格設定行動を喜ばせるので、あなたがそれについてできることは何もありません。雇用保証を排除するか、課税してその存在を規制すればそのタイプのインフレがなくなるというグリーンニューディールがない、言い換えれば、この民主主義で私たちが選んだ535人が仕事をすれば、その種のインフレを排除することができます私たちが人々のために人々によって人々の政府を持っているならば、システムを民主化することによってシステムですが、それがあなたがスーパーパックによってあなたにもたらされたことを知っているなら、これは私たちがそうするなら私たちがそうするものです追加の支出能力が何であるかについて明確なビジョンを持ち、どのような種類のインフラストラクチャが必要か、どのようなケア経済が必要かという観点から優先順位をまっすぐに設定することに成功しました。私たちが私たちにとって重要なことに費やそうとするが、私たちが彼らにとって重要なことに費やすたびに、インフレを引き起こし、追加のインフレのリスクを冒して、その支出能力を窒息させるこれらの力があることをあなたが知っているなら、それを利用する戦争はインフレではないものは何でも減税しますが、地球にとって何百万もの人々にとって重要なことに突然費やすと、それは手ごろな価格ではなくなります。彼らの防衛線が何であるかを認識し、彼らのブラフを呼び出して物語を変更する運動にとって重要なのは、このタグラインです。私の同僚と私はこれを定量化するために取り組んでいます。次の何もしないことのコストは、グリーンニューディール、雇用保証、ケアエコノミーなどの正しいことを行うためのコストよりもはるかに高価です。したがって、それを定量化すると、私たちがすでに費やしていることに実際に気づきます。過去4年間だけでオピオイド危機だけで数兆ドルが2017年に発表されたレポートの最後の4年間で2.5兆ドル、つまり18.2.5兆ドルとなるホワイトハウスのレポートがあります。何もしない」sあなたが絶望の病気とそのすべてを知っているというあなたの否定的な結果に対処するだけで、あなたが知っている世界のどの地域でも、国のどの地域よりも高い失業率があるたびに、先に述べたように私たちは知っています犯罪が増えるうつ病自殺不安あらゆる種類の児童虐待家庭内暴力離婚私たちがすでに支払っているこれらの社会的費用のすべてが正しくないだけでなく、貧困の根本原因に対処するときに雇用保証を導入するとき失業と私たちはこれらの社会問題のすべてを排除するつもりだと言っているのではありませんが、あなたはあなたが知っている主要な主要なumをこれらのすべてのコストとそのすべての経済的および社会的社会的苦痛に下向きの圧力をかけるつもりなので、グリーンニューディール運動内の仕事の保証はそれに入れるための素晴らしいアドオン機能ではありませんグリーンニューディールはuの2つのことについてであるため、グリーンニューディールのコアコンポーネント。不平等への対処と気候危機への対処に関する状況これらは私たちが抱える2つの最大の危機であり、それに関連するのは何百万もの人々の社会経済的排除の危機です。何百万人もの人々を繁栄し、持続可能で威厳のある労働環境と生活条件に導く方法でそれを行い、雇用保証はその核となる特徴であり、この移行中に失業する何百万人もの人々と化石燃料が含まれます運輸業界の業界ですが、私たちが認識しなければならないのは、経済を変革するとき、それがグリーンな新しい取引、産業革命、または第4の産業革命は、このモノのインターネットと呼ばれ、これらすべての変革技術変革は新しいものではなく、産業革命から始まり、産業革命は労働者を置き換えましたが、あなたは私たちを知っていますラッダイトに変わってテクノロジーを停止するつもりはありません。テクノロジーの変革を受け入れる必要があります。なぜそれを行うのかがわかっている限り、ロボット工学と自動化を受け入れる必要があります。不安定な仕事ですが、人々にケアの仕事をさせて、まともな賃金と利益、退職と年金などの意味のある威厳のある仕事をしてもらいましょう。そうすれば、壁を作ろうと言う代わりに、社会的および政治的な議論になります。技術革新を止めて、痛みを伴う不安定な低賃金の仕事を維持できるようにするため、化石燃料から経済を脱炭素化するために移行するときに抵抗があり、そこにあると言われているこのエネルギー移行で私たちが望むものについて明確なビジョンを持っている必要がありますそれらの業界の労働者からの抵抗であり、彼らは必ずしも彼らだけでなく他の労働者や他の製造業などの前にバスの下に投げ込まれたので、私たちと一緒にこの新しいものに移行してほしいと言われているので、それは完全に理解できます経済グリーン経済と私たちは、太陽エネルギー産業に仕事があることを約束します。将来のこの新しい経済には仕事と風力タービンがありますが、私たちはそれらの仕事が実際に彼ら自身のコミュニティで彼らのためにあることを保証しないので、仕事保証のビジョンは人々を彼らがいる場所に連れて行き、経済を移行するために仕事を支払った訓練をすることです。コードをサンフランシスコに移すと、ITセクターであなたの仕事があるかもしれないので、人々をその場に連れて行ってください。それは、すべての地域コミュニティが自分たちの経済を再考し、再考し、再設計するという私たちのビジョンの一部でなければなりません。私たちがバスの下に人を投げ込むつもりはないというそのコア要素に基づいて人々に町を出て、民間部門のどこかで仕事を見つけるように言わないでください。あなたの訓練と教育にお金を払って、学生の借金になります。比較的退職間近で、彼らは化石燃料業界で彼らを待っているかもしれない大きな年金を持っています。私たちは連邦政府を権利の下に置き、空の言葉ではなく、あなたが同じ年金制度で移行していると言うことによって、公正な移行を保証しなければなりません。今あなたの化石燃料の雇用に匹敵する仕事と福利厚生のパッケージと収入のパッケージを持っているつもりですそうです」sは高額になるため、組合はそれを支払うことができなくなります。雇用主はそれを支払うことができなくなります。この新しい宇宙に急速に移行する唯一の方法は、連邦政府がそれを引き受けて保証することです。遷移状態はこの保証に参加できますが、連邦政府は明日これを行うことができます。公に化石燃料労働者や他の労働組合と話すときは、雇用保証を支持することを躊躇していることを知っています。密室でのグリーンニューディール彼らは私たちが言っている一般的に労働運動を知る前に燃やされたので、これらの政治的な空の言葉はすべて、ちょうど移行についてであり、もちろん私たちはエネルギーをきれいにしたい、そして私たちはきれいな空気を望んでいます私たちは水を飲みたいです私たちはもちろん空気を吸います将来のクリーンエネルギーシステムが必要ですが、私たちの後ろではなく、この移行を保証する必要があるので、これは化石燃料労働者だけでなく、運輸業界や他の業界で影響を受ける他の業界にも当てはまると思います私たちは、このカテゴリーでこれが危険にさらされていると考えています。人々をバスの下に投げ込み、これを大規模かつ迅速に行うことを確認する必要があります。それから、私が言いたい最後のことは、テレビで頭を話していることを知っているあなたから聞いたこのことです。特にエコノミストは、人々を懲戒するために失業が必要なため、仕事の保証はありません。そうしないと、システム全体で、失業なしで生産的な労働者がいないことがわかります。これは、私たちが持っているのでナンセンスです。誰を雇いたいのかと尋ねると、実際には失業者を雇っていないと実際に言っている企業の雇用主によるたくさんの研究は、すでに競争相手のために働いている人であり、彼らは特に長い間見ていません-失業者の2番目の選択肢は誰かです。働いていますが、同じ関連業界の3番目でもない別の業界でも、おそらく若い大学卒業生か、ほんの数週間前のように最近失業している人などですが、長期失業に陥った場合はコードは失業中です。つまり、女性の少数派が資格や教育の高校の学位を知らない人や障害のある人を市民に返すことを意味します。これは、あなたが通常最後に知っている個人の保証として仕事の保証が入る場所です。景気循環の間に雇用され、不況の間に最初に解雇されるので、パブリナが以前に話していた種類のバッファー自動安定装置は、民間部門が何を考えていても雇用を保証します。教育を受け、失業のこの無限のサイクルで競争するためのスキルを取得するためにあなたの負担をシフトしないでください私たちはあなたが移行し、市場が無視していて興味がないコミュニティが必要とするリソースを構築するのを助けることを保証します州または連邦政府がこれを作成することに興味がないことを作成する際に、私たちはあなたが知っている人々を職業訓練で行っている場所で使用する方法であり、コミュニティが必要とするリソースとそのすべてを今日作成しますその大部分はグリーントランジションエリアにあり、地球をケアする人々をケアするケアエコノミーで子供をケアする高齢者をケアするので、グリーンニューディールの核となる特徴として私たちはニューディール時代にこれを以前に行ったことがありますが、今日それをより良くする方法を知っています。本当の障害は政治的障害、イデオロギー的障害です。そのため、私たち全員が同じことを推進するための一貫したビジョンを持つためにこれらの会話をすることが重要です。方向性ええと、それで私はここで立ち止まり、コメントと議論のためにそれを開きますこのセッションをもう一度ありがとうええと、更新するので、本当にええと私のために出てきたいくつかのコンテキストがあります1つは、ソースがええと、このタイプのええと集団のこれらのタイプのイベントのより多くを期待できるかどうかにかかわらず、私たちの瞬間の固有の不安定性です将来の経験は、この通常の状態への復帰は、まさにそこにある神話だと思います。そのようなものにはならないでしょう、そして第二に、基本的人権としての威厳のある仕事のこの考えは、この会話全体を組み立てて、それについて考えることが非常に重要だと思います。ケアは今とても重要であり、私たちは新しいイングランドを更新することと、この地域のコミュニティ全体で州レベル、地方レベルで行う必要のある作業について考えているので、この会話にその視点をもたらすことに本当に興奮していますそれは私が行きたいところですそしてここから会話を始めたいです私はまた人々を私達に招待します私達は素晴らしい人々がチャットにええと質問を書くことができるかそうでなければあなたの手を上げることができる小さなグループですそして私達は「ええと、いくつかの議論を共有する機会がありますが、私は」dその質問から始めて、おそらくジョシュを呼び戻したいと思います。それから、私たちのパネルの誰でも、ケアワークが出てきて現れているのをどのように見ていますか?このタイプのプロジェクトのある種の民主的な傾向について書いたコミュニティのポーリナは、コミュニティ自体がこのuhの仕事にどのように関与しているかを保証しているので、実際に行う必要のある作業であると確信できます。はその瞬間に反応するので、ジョシュ多分私はあなたから始めますそしてそれから私たちは誰にでもそれを開くことができますええええと私はええと私が始める場所だと思います良い質問ですが、出発点は、パブリナが言ったことを知っていると思います。仕事は非常に政治的に人気があり、そのように整理するのに良い問題は、世論調査に反映されていますが、私自身にも非常に反映されています。私はほとんどの場合オーガナイザーであり、私がしていることはコミュニティの組織化です。キャンペーン中のドアでのコミュニティミーティングで、すべての人にとって良い仕事が本当にうまくいくことを知っているのは本当に興味深いことです。人々のような1対1の会話では、実際にはすでにこのアイデアに非常に賛成していますが、これらの会話であなたが知っている課題は、通常、私が主な反対意見と話している多くの人々のように、何が可能かについて人々の期待を高めることです。彼らはただしません何でも可能だと思うし、それは正直言って驚くことではない。50年のネオリベラリズムは、可能性についての私たちの想像力のすべてが根本的に制約されていることを意味する。だからこそ、私たちが作成し、導入し、組織している法律を知っていると思う。そのため、法律は非常に具体的であることがわかっているので、法律は非常に役立つと思います。会話を地球に戻し、マサチューセッツ州でそのような法律を通過した場合、数万を作成するように見えるからです。エネルギー効率を高め、齧歯類の糞便やアスベストを取り除くなど、家をより健康で安全なものにするために、今後10年間で100万戸の住宅を改造する仕事の数は、たとえばロードアイランドでこの他の法律を通過した場合などです。dすべての汚染産業を閉鎖し、労働者が彼らに与える移行を使用するのと同じように、フィデルが言っていたように、無料の職業訓練のように彼らに年金を与えるように、彼らと一対一で話し合うように彼らに年金を与えるあなたがやりたい仕事の種類は何ですか、そしてあなたがそれを実際のように非常に特定のレベルに下げるのが好きなときにコミュニティ組織化の人々の会話を具体化するときあなたは知っていますこの法律の一部がxyとzをするようにそして、これを仕事に近づけると、人々は、可能なことに関して人々の想像力を拡大するようなものであり、それは、彼らが集合的に勝つことができるもののような人々の認識を変えるような、深いコミュニティ組織化のようなものです。私はそれが私がいるところだと思いますd開始ありがとうございます他の誰かがそれをフォローしたいと思うかもしれません私は何かを追加します私がそうすることができれば私はまた、プロセスの問題のいくつかと邪魔になるすべてのもののこのテーマを聞いています人々が何を達成することに興味を持っているのか、そして実際に何が起こっているのか、そして私はそれをバーモント州議会議事堂の非常に小規模な規模のようなものと見なしていることを知っていると思います。物事の余白をかじるようなもので、私はそれがほとんどではないことを知っています」それの最も興味深い部分ではありませんが、それらのものがどのように運用可能になるかというプロセスの質問は、私もそれに関連する部分だと思います私の経験では、公共部門がちょうど行くことができるという考えでこのumについて何かを言うことができます何らかの理由でいくつかの木を植えて植えるのは、人々が持っているように遠隔地に非常に似ているので、地元の雇用創出について考えるとき、彼らはよく考えます。あなたが知っているインフラストラクチャーは、あなたが構築することを知っているような伝統的なインフラストラクチャーがあるように見えますが、公共部門が何ができるかについて話すとき、社会的および環境的作業が最初に頭に浮かぶことではありません。私の学生の何人かとプロジェクトをしているあなたは地元の町の提案を知っていますそして私たちの会話の中で突然の政策立案者のコメントの1つは彼らが電球を持っているようでしたコミュニティがアーティストと出会うことを知っていて、放課後の活動のようなものがあることを知っている場所であるパビリオンを長い間持つことを考えていました、そしてそれはちょうどええと、仕事の保証が開くと思いますこの種の仕事のビジョンを上げて、私はそう思います」なぜなら、人々が実際にそうだと気付いたとき、それは私たちがこれらの機会を作り出す方法を優先することができる仕事である可能性があり、人々がどのようにあなたをなだめるかについてのストレートジャケットを残すことができることを知っているからです。あなたが適切な研修生を知っているか、正確な仕事の配置と仕事の開発のための適切な助成金を得るために彼らに与える会社ですが、私たちは地方レベルでプッシュしなければならず、これらの地方にはコストがかかるため、私たちは少し問題に直面しています彼らは失業、貧困、ホームレスに対処しているため、雇用を創出することで削減できるコストがあり、彼らが運営する物理的スペースにはいくつかの制限があります。つまり、バーモントはユニークなケースです。あなたはバランスの取れた予算修正に縛られていないので、それは」予算を適切に割り当て、地域の機会を創出することを知っていることを知っているので、実際に始めるのに最適な場所ですが、資金調達の問題は、はるかに外科的に実施する必要があり、ビデンのパッケージを知っていて、ここでいくつかの雇用を創出し、地元の雇用創出のためにそれらの資金を展開できると言っている連邦資金を持っている場合よりもはるかに慎重な方法で飛び込むが、実験室としてのバーモントは、私たちがそれについて話し、それについて考える方法のようなものであることがよくあることを知っているので、私はこれらのいくつかの規模を認識している一方で、私たちも知っていると思いますこれらの連邦資金を触媒としてどのように使用するかについて、これらのいくつかをジャンプスタートするようなものと、それがどのように見えるかについて多くのことを話します。また、バーモントを言い訳の後ろに隠さないようにします。私たちにできることはもっとたくさんあり、お金がないものは何でも人々はそれを望んでおらず、言い訳の後ろに隠れているというこの考えに賛成することもできます。誰かがそれを始めなければならないようにどこかでそれを始めようと私が知っているようにバーモントに行きましょうそれでそれを正しく試してみましょうええあなたが話し合うパブリナに感謝しますそして誰もがこの質問に飛びつくことができます実装の観点から見た非営利モデルと社会的企業モデルすぐにここのチャットに人々のための他のいくつかのリソースをドロップしますが、草の根のコミュニティ主導の雇用保証アプローチについてのあなたの見解についてもう少し説明していただけませんか?組織化の視点とええと、あなたは地域的に適切な視点を知っていますええ、私は国の地方レベルで雇用保証を実施するだけで多面的なアプローチが必要だと思いますこれには複数のアプローチが必要になることを念頭に置いてください。雇用創出を行い、多くの連邦雇用を提供する連邦機関があり、連邦政府が地方自治体に資金を提供し、誰でも大丈夫だと言うことができます。する必要がありますあなたがしていることをするために雇う、そしてあなたは人員配置の必要性と資金源を持っていないが、すでに社会的剥奪に対処している地上の組織があり、すでに社会的剥奪をしているコミュニティグループがあるという他の現実もある放課後の活動をしているコミュニティガーデンは、ナーシングホームを知っているので、協同組合に力を与えて動員してみませんか。サポートや雇用創出などの範囲外にすべきではありません。ある意味では、私たちは車輪を再発明する必要はなく、地元の可能性とリソースを利用するだけで、雇用創出のためのサイトとしてそれらを使用することを知っていますが、それはもっと多くのことだと思いますあなたが知っているコースのようなアプローチのための馬若者の失業について考え直すと、非常に具体的な見習いについて考えているかもしれないので、民間のええと企業がこれらの実地訓練のいくつかに参加することに完全に反対しているのかわかりませんが、ここで私たちは本当に話していることを知っています公益のための公的資金についてそしてあなたは不足しているギャップを知っていますあなたは私が非営利と地方自治体の仕事の両方で満たすことができると思う公共サービスを知っていますそしてあなたは雇用がここに間違いなく強い焦点があったことを知っています緑の仕事とええと、そして例えば生態系の回復に関連するチャットでも、私はこれの多くが仕事の種類と仕事の種類と私たちの現在の瞬間と何が必要かということを意味します。人々がどこにいるのか、そしてコミュニティのニーズに再び応えるという観点から、どのような特定の種類の仕事を優先して整理できるのか、そしてこれがインフラストラクチャの仕事だけではないことを認識しているのはどのような種類の仕事なのかを知っているのだろうか。従来の考え方では、人々がすぐにできるようにする必要のある仕事がありますが、特に環境に配慮した仕事など、私たちが本当にすべき仕事の種類については、必ずしも多くのトレーニングを必要としません。優先順位を付けて、どのように人々をそのタイプの仕事に関与させるのか、私はこれらのええとの質問のいくつかに喜んで答えますので、私は私ですここアパラチアの連合の一部であるreimagineappalachiaは、オハイオウェストバージニアペンシルベニアとケンタッキー州の約100の組織であり、reimagine appalachiaのWebサイトを見ると、青写真はこの地域のミニグリーンニューディールのようなものです。これには、ccc管理とi 'の再起動が含まれます。21世紀のccc政権が、前世紀の被害を修復し、これら4つの州だけで数千人の雇用を創出し、再生農業と地元に投資する法案がまもなく発表されることを喜んで報告します。ええと、輸送のための二酸化炭素排出量を削減するええと、ええと、これはほんの一例です。このccc法案の別のコンポーネントは、人々が解放された後ではなく、投獄の初日に職業訓練プログラムが開始される再入国コンポーネントです。仕事も住居もないので、それはまた、失業のメンタルヘルスなどに関連する他の問題にも対処するので、私たちは人々が尊厳を持ってまともな仕事とまともな賃金に戻ることを可能にするだけでなく、前世紀の被害の一部を修復するのに役立つ人々を支える仕事を生み出す包括的なビジョンを再検討することで、グリーンジョブ提案の別の要素連合による再想像アパラチアはブロードバンドインフラストラクチャの第3であり、ローカルでの技術の製造を含む再生可能エネルギーの生産にローカルで投資しているのです。s輸送の両方の脱炭素化をどのように加速するか消費者の電力使用の脱炭素化と加熱と冷却だけでなく、工業生産生産自体の脱炭素化とこれを工業規模で行うには、グリーンニューディールのような国家的枠組みが必要です。これは、消費主義についてのチャットのいくつかの質問に対処します。アメリカ社会は消費者社会であるため、この速度で消費し続けると、運命にある地球を救うことはできません。グローバルレベルは、あなたがエネルギーの使用を減らすことと関係があります。無駄を減らすために、なぜカリフォルニアから東海岸までずっと運転されるサラダが必要なのかということです。地元の農業は重要ですが、今日の技術であるソーラーパネルと風力タービンを使用しても、研究開発に投資する必要があります。実際にこれをスケールアップして、私たちと世界の他の地域のエネルギー需要を満たすために、特に南の世界で抽出主義の観点から生態学的災害が発生するため、材料科学研究の研究開発に投資する必要がありますサーキュラーエコノミーと呼ばれるものを実際に生産するための開発と開発。購入するすべての製品には、これが私の生活であると言う数ページを含むユーザーマニュアルが付属しています。これは、私を処分する方法です。これは、私を元に戻す方法です。サーキュラーエコノミーへの人生は本当に私たちです正直に言うと、ソーラーパネルが40年で廃止されたときに、ソーラーパネルをどうするかさえわかりません。十分な研究開発を行っていないので、これは答えの一部は、私たちが持っているテクノロジーは優れていますが、十分ではありません。この移行をすぐに開始できますが、真にサーキュラーエコノミーを作成する方法を理解するためにリソースを投入する必要があります。一部の人々がチャットで「はい」と言われているように、私たちはインフレのリスクに対処し、「はい」と言います。政府支出は安全にもっと使うことができますが、生態系と同じペースでもっとお金を使い、もっと消費する必要があるという意味ではありません。私たちに影響を与える人々を月に送ったのと同じように私たちには能力があると言いますが、同じことをして、サーキュラーエコノミーを発明する方法と、被害を修正する方法を理解して、ツールを手に入れることができますが、あなたが知っているとは言いません同じ速度で消費しましょう、そしてあなたは私たちが望むなら私たちができることを地球から燃やし尽くすことを知っていますがそれは私たちが提唱していることではありません多分私はあなたがそれを持って行きたいならあなたの質問に答えることもできるかもしれません私が言ったように、私が言ったように、私は私の学生がニューヨークの2つのコミュニティを見ていて、ニューヨークはかつてニューディールの先駆者だったという考えを持っていることを知っています。それでも、私たちは今、先駆者となるためにニューディールプロジェクトを行っていませんが、ええと、彼らがしていることは、ステフのようです」分析によると、失業者は誰なのか、不完全雇用者は誰なのかがわかります。つまり、誰が雇用を創出するのかなど、知る必要のある最初のステップは、非常に具体的な剥奪を検討していたことです。たとえば、コミュニティには失業している独身の母親がたくさんいます。失業している独身の母親がたくさんいるこのコミュニティには、汚染の問題がたくさんあり、喘息は全国平均をはるかに上回っています。他のコミュニティは実際にメンタルヘルスの問題でもっと多くの問題を抱えていますそしてそれからもっと健康なメンタルヘルスの問題を抱えているコミュニティは実際に彼らが実際に持っているようにもっと多くの環境グループを持っています彼らはしませんメンタルヘルス支援の仕事は十分にできているので、仕事で取り組むギャップや社会的ニーズなどを把握するために、地域レベルでできることだと思います。作成とumiiは、この議論がビデンのインフラストラクチャ計画について知っている場合、インフラストラクチャのようなものを知っていると思います。インフラストラクチャのようなものは非常に重要です。線を引くことを知っておく必要があります。私はグリーンについて話したいのと同じように感じます。仕事なので、本の中で私はあなたがする仕事は常に緑であると主張します。なぜなら、あなたが知っているように緑のような人の世話をするなら、あなたは本質的にあなたが私たちが持っているような社会階級を無視することを人間の無駄に許さないことを知っているからですもちろん、私たちが知っているエンベロープについても考える必要があります。自然環境と有機的につながっていますが、それは私たちでもあるので、すべての家を風化させたとしましょう。ホームレスの人々は、すべての家が風化したようにグリーンポリシーになりますが、通りに人がいるか、おそらく誰もが良い人でした。仕事ですが、私たちは、ボックス内のコメントのように環境を汚染していました。それは、分離できないというだけです。したがって、グリーンワークについて話すとき、ケアのニーズに対処することは、グリーンワークに該当すると思います。環境ケアだけでも他の人のケアが必要なので、あなたが考えたいのであれば、ビデンからパイプラインにどのような資金が流れてくるのかを知っています。政治がどのように展開するかを見ていきますが、予防接種率があることを知っているからといって、公衆衛生危機が明日なくなることはないなど、進行中のことがいくつかあることを知っています。私たちがそれについて考え続けることができるように、ある種の政治的支援をしなければなりません、そしてそれは私が地元の場所でお金があると思う明白な場所になるでしょう、それでこれらはあなたが地元の仕事のように考えるかもしれない方法のほんの一例ですパブリックサービスである作成それはあなたがそれを知っているのではなく、それはいくつかの特定のニーズに対処していますありがとうパブリナそして私はあなたがおそらくすぐに行く必要があることを知っています電話で入って来ましたが、コンピューターから離れる必要があります。楽しんでいただけたでしょうか。ありがとうございます。」参加していただきありがとうございました。アンドリューに質問がありました。パネリストのいずれかがお互いに質問するように招待したいと思います。それから、おそらくそれをラップします。アップアンドリュー先に進みましょうこんにちはありがとうございます私を聞くことができますはい大丈夫素晴らしいええと私はチャットで書いていましたええと私は州の従業員組合と全国組合の両方の役割に非常に興味があります連邦の雇用保証プログラムと地域の雇用保証プログラムで遊ぶことができる私も興味がありますええと、パヴリーナは連邦機関が設立されていることや、連邦政府が州や非営利団体にお金を与えていることについて話していたと思います仕事の保証と私への3つの異なる種類のパスとして一緒に組合が他の雇用保証プログラムでどのように役割を果たしたのか、そして新しい雇用保証プログラムでどのように役割を果たしたのかについて興味があります。一度にいくつかの質問がある場合は申し訳ありません。それでよければ、これは実際に私がここバーモントでアメリコーの眺望を務めたときの私の日々を思い出させてくれます。アメリコーの眺望について知らない人のために、それは非常に低賃金の若者に、ケア経済に該当するあらゆる種類の仕事を手伝ってもらうための追加の人員配置。侵入種の除去と図書館のサポートを知っています。これが私がやったことです。m継続教育プログラムを知っている、食品棚をストックし、食品棚を整理しているので、これらの仕事の役割を知っているが、私たちがこれと同じフレームワークを使用しているとは言っていないが、残念ながら、これらの仕事は非常に低賃金である有給で家族やそのようなものを維持することができないので、私たちはあなたがフレームを知っていると話しましたええと、最低でも15時間の利益のパブリナを設定することから始まりますが、多くの組合員にとって、特にそうではないことを私たちは知っています非常に多くの人にとって魅力的なものになるので、組合の役割は、雇用保証の下で作成される公的部門の仕事を含め、利用可能なすべての仕事を本当に改善することです。s実際には、この種のケア作業を行っている非営利団体の全国的な組織化がたくさん行われていますが、残念ながら、彼らの労働者は通常低賃金であることがわかっています。残念ながら、これはミッション主導の作業であるため、これを知っていることを残念ながら言い訳することがあります。あなたは仕事の性質のためにそこにいるべきであり、お金のためではないことを知っています問題の事実は私たちがまだ頭の上に屋根を置き、私たちのテーブルに食べ物を置くことを知っている必要があることを知っていますそしてあなたはあなたが必要であることを知っていますステフがここバーモントで私たちに示したように、最近は賃金が低いことで有名です。組合は組織化するためだけのものだと思います。そのため、仕事を保証するだけでなく、その重要性も強調しました。だけでなく、それを組織する権利を拡大し、保護します」s新しい取引を実際に最高潮に引き上げたものであり、それが私たちが本当に堅固な仕事を保証するために必要なものです私は絶対にこれにいくつかの考えを追加します私はこれにいくつかの考えを追加します今月、特に今日のパネルをやり直すことを強くお勧めします。そこでは、労働運動の観点から、労働党の指導者がなぜ、どのように雇用保証を組織するかについて具体的に話しているのを聞いたアンドリューを見てください。今日の午後は、労働運動を構築するための共感ストライキの法的権利のために戦っていると述べたので、ある産業が打撃を受けたときに1つの組合が打撃を受けたとき、残りの労働運動はええとを支援するためにそこにあります。今日は合法ではありません。sちょうど正しくないええと、これらの規制のこれらの法律に反対するためにこれを取得するために組織する場合、私たちはこれを構築するという点で何かに言及します。たとえば、賃金の特定の基準を維持する一般的な賃金法を保護する労働組合の役割の観点から、この運動を構築します。これは、州ごとに攻撃を受けていることを知っています。建設業界だけでなく、全面的に組織化された労働運動がある場合、全国でそれらの最低基準を設定することができ、雇用保証はそれに向けて構築するのに役立ちますので、あなたが地方レベルで雇用保証プログラムを作成するときそしてあなたは技術的に建設タイプの仕事をする数人を雇うことになります彼らは彼らが組合に参加できる彼らの賃金の基準として一般的な賃金法を主張することを知っています彼らは組合見習いプログラムに参加することができます組合は設計の一部になることができます構築する雇用保証のコミュニティのためのリソースと実地訓練を行うこれは、私たちの世代が、人々が初日に組合に参加して見習いになるのは普通だったことを完全に忘れていたことをあなたが知っていることです仕事は行きません。それに対するトレーニングの支払いをポケットから出してください。運が良ければ仕事を見つけることができるので、この役割は、建設や製造だけでなく、見習いや職業訓練プログラムにおける組合の役割を取り戻すことができます。業界ではありますが、高齢者ケアやチャイルドケアを含むヘルスケアを含む全面的に、これは私たちが想像し、創造することを許されるべき世界です。問題は、私たちが人々のように殴打され、弱体化したことです。私たちが何十年もの間運動している私たちがこのumをどのように編成するかについて考えることさえ許されていないので、労働組合がどのように彼らがどのような役割を果たすことができるかについて、そして来週までにどのように議論するべきかについて、たくさんの追加の議論があることに任せます。午後1時に、このシリーズの3回目で最後の記事があり、分科会セッションになります。皆さんを招待します。多くの労働者リーダーが参加し、学者や政策担当者が参加します。主催者は、アンドリューが今日尋ねていた質問を含め、これらの質問の多くを開梱しました。ファレルに感謝し、他にもいくつか追加しました。そのum uhroseluxセッションへのリンクも追加しました。プレス発表とニューイングランドの更新、そして仕事に関するいくつかのよくある質問は、本当に多くの基本を提供することを保証しているので、私たちが扱っている体系的な問題の種類に焦点を当てていることに本当に感謝しています。私たちが提案しているのは、再想像の基本的なuh制約のような文化的な作品であり、その一部が非常に文化的なuhレベルでどれほど深くなっているのか、そして私たちは皆、マスとリズメディナのラジオをチェックする必要があることを知っていますその詳細については労働ラジオなので、簡単に時間切れになりますが、最後の言葉を言いたい場合はパネリストのいずれかを簡単に招待してから、ゲイリー・スチュワードに引き渡します組織委員会のメンバーで、バーモント州が更新され、ゲイリーが更新されました。」人々がニューイングランドの更新に関与し続ける方法についていくつかのアイデアを提供するので、steph lizfadellまたはjosh追加するものはあまりありません。本当に本当に豊かな仲間のパネリストに感謝したいだけです。ディスカッション私は確かにたくさんのことを学びましたそしてええ本当に本当にあなたの時間のすべてに感謝しますええそして私は間違いなくあなたに感謝しますポッドキャストのリンクに立ち寄ってくれたlizは、実際にそれを聴きながらチェックしてください。外に出て、それがいいでしょう。ゲイリー、私たちを閉じて、もう一度ありがとう。一緒にこの仕事を続けることを楽しみにしています。ありがとう。素晴らしいパネルに感謝します。素晴らしいパネリストに、信じられないほど豊かな対話をしてくれてすみません。ええと、元気になりますので、楽しみにして生産的な仕事をやり直すための素晴らしい方法を提供してくれてありがとうございます私はゲイリースチュワードです私はエコ社会主義ワーキンググループと社会主義教育のシャンプランバレーGSAのアクティブメンバーですワーキンググループと私更新バーモントが含まれている更新ニューイングランド同盟は、化石燃料経済と搾取経済から1つへの裁判官の移行に焦点を当てた少なくとも150の異なる組織で構成されていますそれは、仕事の正義、環境の正義、人種の正義、ジェンダーの正義に焦点を当てて、生態学的に公正で持続可能な社会を作り上げ、バーモント州を更新することが関係していることのいくつかをあなたに知らせることに本当に興奮しています。この立法上の法案の数ええと、私はセッションを許しますええと、主な焦点はコビットにあるので、ええと、今年は、承認された後でも、これらの法案の多くは勝ちます」来年まで行動を起こすことはできませんが、いくつかの大きな法案が提出されており、来年に基づいて構築することができます。繁栄する議題ええと、チャットルームに置くことができますええと、繁栄する議題は基本的に私たちがここで話しているものと同じですそしてええと、導入された法案があり、議会でこのセッションに投票する必要がありますここでそれを取得させてくださいあなたにとって、そして実際にはそれは基本的に労働者にとってグリーンニューディールですので、私に戻ってみましょうそれをクリックして署名するだけで非常に簡単ですそしてええと私たちは上院議員リーヒの良い同盟国を持っているのでそれはとても良いです」また、バーモント州のバイポッド主導の土地へのアクセスと機会の行為をサポートし、それを使って議員にメールを送ります。コピーを作成してからここに接続します。そうすれば、それに参加することもできます。あなたは私がここに行くだけで大丈夫だと思ったので、それのコピーを作成してここに来るだけでそれをクリックするだけでそれを行うことができますそして私に再び戻ることができますそれはあなたが努力が導いたことを知っているジョイントです権力バーモントに着席することにより、一般住宅および軍事問題に関する下院委員会に住宅法案273を取り上げるよう要請することにより、バーモント州のバイポック主導の土地アクセスおよび機会は、uhコミュニティ内のuhコミュニティが実際の土地を取得するためのより良いアクセスを得るのを助けるために行動するここでの問題は、バーモント州内で、次は私たちの再生経済法案をサポートすることです。それも非常に深く関わっており、それが導入されました。バーモント州にいる場合は、立法者に連絡してサポートするためのリンクを共有しましょう。ここで確認しましょう。本当に良い仕事をしています。ここバーモント州の再生農業と再生経済学に取り組むために、私たちの立法機関では、グリーンニューディールを聞くのは好きではありませんが、基本的にバーモント州を更新し、ニューイングランド同盟を更新することは、グリーンニューディールです。私はここに本当に早く着きましょうそして私たちの住宅正義の請願はいすべてのバーモント州の住宅の正義を再検討すると、これはすべてのバーモント州の手頃な価格の安全で公平で健康的な住宅を支援する人々を必要とする問題であり、これもまた、新たなニューイングランド同盟内のすべての加盟国が同様に支援している問題です。それをここに置いてみましょう。最後に、もう1つのイベントが開催されます。これはメーデーであり、メーデーにはいくつかのエキサイティングなイベントが予定されています。これは、移行とバーモントだけに焦点を当てています。これはその一部です。繁栄するアジェンダと私は私のコンピュータが少しスピードアップしたらそのイベントへのリンクを置くつもりですええと今は少し遅いですええとここに行きますがとにかく私たちは後でええと来るイベントがありますメーデーとええと、もしあなたがそうなら、みんながそれに参加したいと思います。バーモント州では、コンピューターが進むのを待つ必要があります。今は少し遅いので申し訳ありませんが、とにかくそれはほとんどそれであり、私が言う他の唯一のことは、あなたがre in new englandええと、あなたのuh組織の姉妹組織が何をしているのかを確認してください。もしそれが新しいnew englandアライアンスの一部であるなら、グリーンジャスティスゾーンに焦点を当てる彼らの努力にプラグインしてください。これらに取り組んでいる作業委員会があり、私たちはこれらの組織とこれらの作業グループに参加する人々を探していますので、興味があればマットに連絡するか、私に連絡してください私は私のメールを入れて探していますコミュニティリーダーのために何でも」このプロセスに参加するのは正しいので、ありがとうございます。ここで私の情報を入力することをお許しください。お気軽にご連絡ください。この機会に感謝します。本当にありがとうございました。キャプション作成者に感謝します。ええと、私はあなたの助けに感謝しますl4eチーム全体ともちろん私たちのパネリストとええとあなたにフィデルがちょうどここに落としたいくつかの音楽を残してくれてありがとう[笑い]私もあなたが画面を共有すれば音は良くなるでしょう私たちはそれを地面に置いておく必要がありますあなたは自分自身を救う私たちが必要とする新しい取引が必要です私たちが必要とする新しい取引が必要です自分でどれだけのお金を使うことができるかをぶらぶらする必要があります私たちは新しいものが必要ですs必要なもの[音楽]グリーンディールが必要ですクリーンになります今すぐ会います[音楽]必要なものが必要です[音楽]それが必要なものですええええ大丈夫それはラリーソングでしたムーブメントすべてのムーブメントを見つけたのはこれが私の友達で、それは私のリビングルームに記録されています。アレンはコミュニティオーガナイザー、レイバーオーガナイザー、アーティストシンガーソングライターとして、あなたがとても特別なゲストである曲を書いたのです。今日も特別なパネルをオフにします共有していただきありがとうございますありがとうございます保存して再生したい場合はここにリンクがあります自分のコンピュータで再生するとより良い品質になりますどうもありがとうございましたありがとうございましたプレゼンテーションありがとうございましたここにいることができて光栄でした本当にありがとうございましたありがとうございますプレゼンテーションをありがとうございましたここにいることができて光栄でした JP 検索 9+ アバターの画像 JGP 2021/04/08 限定公開 11 回視聴•2021/04/09 0 0 共有 保存 slow slow 1 件のコメント me com 公開コメントを入力... me com me com 3 時間前(編集済み) 39:35 チャーネバ 56:35 (~ 1:15:05 )カブー 1:29:55 カブー 1:33:24 チャーネバ 文字起こし 00:00 okay that's okay we're gonna give people 00:02 another minute or two to join and then 00:04 we'll get started 00:29 you're now live on facebook okay 00:36 thank you 02:06 if everyone had the same opinions idea 02:20 sorry 02:37 okay why don't we begin and people to 02:39 come in it's a 02:41 beautiful day where i am um in the 02:44 champlain valley 02:46 of uh vermont um abnaki 02:51 territory and uh my name is matthew 02:54 burke 02:55 i am a postdoc at the university of 02:58 vermont with the gund institute 03:00 and uh this is a project of uh or a 03:03 program put together by the ecozoic for 03:05 policy ecozoic policy project leadership 03:08 for the ecozoic 03:10 with support from the gund institute um 03:12 [Music] 03:14 and i'm so excited to have this this 03:16 group and i know 03:18 people continue to pile in we also have 03:21 uh 03:22 facebook live going now so 03:25 we'll have people joining in in 03:26 different ways 03:29 we are recording and the chat 03:32 is functional we're going to ask though 03:35 if people can keep their questions 03:37 toward the end we'll do a series of 03:40 presentations from our 03:41 our panelists and then we'll begin to 03:44 take questions 03:45 and we're going to try to leave plenty 03:47 of time for 03:49 a discussion and a question and answer 03:52 and we should wrap up around a quarter 03:55 to six 03:58 so this session is called renew new 04:00 england 04:01 jobs guarantee and 04:04 we're looking especially at the proposal 04:07 coming out of 04:09 renew new england alliance that's 04:11 centered on a jobs guarantee to meet 04:13 basic human needs 04:16 this is a multi-state coalition and 04:19 we have joshua kesten here today 04:23 who's going to say a little bit about 04:26 renew new england and kind of get us 04:29 going 04:31 with this proposal and what this 04:33 coalition is all about 04:35 josh kesten is the policy director at 04:38 renew new england 04:40 and is also organizing at the state 04:42 local and regional level for a 04:44 transformative green new deal 04:46 centered around both racial justice and 04:49 a jobs guarantee 04:51 and josh will i'll hand it over to josh 04:54 who will present uh some intro comments 04:58 on renew new england and then 04:59 introduce our panelists so thank you so 05:02 much 05:03 josh it's you 05:10 thanks so much uh matthew and uh really 05:13 super excited to be here 05:14 um so yeah so my primary 05:18 uh background in this work 05:22 is uh actually as an organizer with the 05:24 sunrise movement and now 05:26 um as matthew mentioned i'm i'm 05:28 currently working at renew 05:30 um so i'm just gonna give a quick intro 05:33 on 05:33 uh renew just to give everyone a sense 05:35 of like what we're up to here in new 05:37 england and then 05:38 i've been yeah and then i'll uh 05:40 introduce the other panelists um we've 05:41 got a really incredible 05:43 panel up here today and um yeah after 05:45 that i'm really looking forward to 05:46 hearing 05:47 what everyone has to say and hopefully 05:49 we can have a lively 05:51 discussion um so okay so 05:55 what is renew um 05:58 so renew was formed uh early on last 06:01 year 06:02 um in order to address uh the 06:06 overlapping crises of you know racism 06:10 justice mass unemployment um 06:13 widespread economic exploitation and 06:16 deprivation 06:17 uh as well as the coronavirus uh 06:19 pandemic and of course 06:21 um you know the very the very real 06:25 uh an imminent prospect of um 06:29 severe and irreversible ecological 06:31 collapse 06:32 uh and our premise you know for 06:34 launching renew 06:36 was that these social uh 06:39 social and environmental crises that i 06:41 just mentioned are you know routinely 06:43 treated as 06:49 and distinct problems um 06:52 but we thought uh when we factored a 06:54 series of problems that 06:55 have to be addressed holistically um so 06:58 we brought oh i just got uh the notice 07:00 that 07:00 my internet connection is unstable can 07:02 everyone hear me okay 07:04 yeah okay here now it's coming and going 07:06 but for now it seems okay 07:09 or or maybe not go ahead 07:12 okay cool feel free to just cut in and 07:15 i'll 07:15 connect on my phone it'll be okay um 07:19 so uh yeah so as i was saying we we 07:22 brought together 07:23 over 150 organizations across new 07:25 england into a coalition 07:27 so we're talking about frontline 07:28 communities racial justice advocates 07:32 labor unions indigenous nations 07:35 housing justice organizers youth climate 07:37 activists 07:39 and we're guided by a majority by park 07:42 regional council that represents uh the 07:45 coalition members in all six 07:46 uh new england states and we 07:50 as the coalition went through an 07:52 extensive 07:54 grassroots-led process to determine 07:57 our shared policy goals for the region 07:59 and then we produced 08:00 a really detailed map of what a serious 08:03 green new deal for new england would 08:05 actually look like 08:07 and unsurprisingly you know that map 08:10 that vision 08:10 revolves around a jobs guarantee 08:14 uh and so i should say a little bit 08:15 about why 08:17 we saw the jobs guarantee as so uh 08:20 so central to our project and what you 08:22 know concretely it could look like 08:24 right here where we live um 08:28 so so so here's the thing 08:31 like the way we've all been conditioned 08:33 to think about labor 08:34 is just completely backwards and we're 08:37 so used to the backwards narrative that 08:39 it sometimes feels like 08:40 kind of natural or even inevitable um 08:43 okay so so what do i mean by that so 08:45 well we're used to just reflexively 08:47 assuming 08:48 um 08:52 jobs are always scarce asking why 08:56 people think that's the case and when 08:57 you really start thinking about it 08:59 one fact that like immediately pops out 09:01 at you is that 09:02 it can't be the case the job scarce plot 09:05 of work that needs to be done 09:07 like all you have to do 09:11 is glance around at society right now 09:15 there's just 09:16 huge building energy efficient housing 09:18 to make sure everyone has a home 09:20 for example or manufacturing and 09:22 installing solar panels and wind 09:24 turbines 09:25 for another example or you know here's 09:27 another huge chunk of work 09:28 retrofitting homes and buildings to be 09:31 like just dramatically more energy 09:33 efficient and then of course like we 09:35 haven't even gotten into 09:37 all of the work that would be required 09:38 to design and build 09:40 a regional mass transit system that's 09:42 like efficient and convenient enough to 09:45 supplant personal vehicles 09:47 and then of course there's just you know 09:48 the massive expansion of care work and 09:51 social reproduction 09:52 that really needs to be done like you 09:54 know elder care providers school 09:56 teachers 09:56 uh home health aides nurses etc like 09:59 because you know like there are lots of 10:01 older people 10:04 why are medical care mental health care 10:05 and lots of younger people 10:07 who require education and child rearing 10:11 work 10:11 those 10:16 needs 10:19 not 10:23 being met right now that's a lot of 10:25 addition work needs to be done 10:28 for global uh anxiety you know 10:31 uh parks and and libraries and 10:34 community centers and public spaces you 10:37 know for no other 10:38 because we want people to be able to 10:40 enjoy those things 10:41 um so you know the point that i'm trying 10:44 to make is that it simply can't be the 10:45 case 10:46 the jobs are scarce because there isn't 10:48 enough work to be done like there's so 10:49 much work to be done 10:51 so so what does that mean um well i 10:54 think it means we're kind of in 10:56 a strange situation right now and i 10:58 think you know interestingly i think 10:59 it's stranger than we often recognize 11:01 you know in which on the one hand we 11:03 have mass unemployment and on the other 11:05 hand we've got huge amounts of essential 11:07 work that just isn't getting done 11:09 and so that's the reason that 11:12 the renew coalition decided to put the 11:14 jobs guarantee 11:16 right at the center of you know our 11:18 great new deal policy framework because 11:21 really what the green new deal means 11:24 you know in a deep sense is like just 11:26 it's about reversing our backwards 11:28 understanding of what work is 11:30 like we can either have you know an 11:33 economy 11:34 designed like as it currently is to 11:35 create jobs only when doing so 11:38 would further enrich people and 11:41 corporations that are already extremely 11:42 wealthy 11:43 or on the other hand we can have an 11:46 economy designed to create jobs in order 11:48 to meet 11:49 social needs uh health care child care 11:52 food like transportation clean air and 11:55 of course like the enormous unmet need 11:57 um to provide a livable climate that 12:00 minimizes 12:01 um you know the frequency and the 12:03 severity of 12:05 of droughts famines climate displacement 12:09 uh 12:10 wars over increasingly scarce resources 12:13 extreme weather events and so forth like 12:15 we're all familiar with the standard 12:16 catalog 12:17 of terrors that we'll be confronting if 12:19 we don't rapidly get commission 12:21 emissions under control um so anyway so 12:24 our work at renew and and 12:25 and i think at the green with with green 12:27 new deal at organizers more generally is 12:29 really i think 12:30 at its most fundamental level um a 12:33 challenge 12:34 to uh you know the prevailing right-wing 12:37 conception of what work is 12:39 and what it should mean and of course 12:41 it's also a challenge not just to the 12:43 kinds 12:43 of things that we consider as work or 12:46 the kinds of work we do but also to the 12:47 way that we treat workers 12:49 which is why um you know strong 12:52 labor practices so i'm talking about 12:54 good salaries high quality benefits 12:57 collective bargaining rights it's why 12:58 all of that stuff is baked into 13:00 all of the pieces of legislation that 13:03 we've written and that we're fighting 13:04 for all across the region 13:07 um okay so that feels like a good segue 13:09 for me to introduce 13:10 uh the other panelists um all of whom 13:15 have thought really really deeply about 13:17 the meaning of work and the way 13:18 that workers are treated and i'm really 13:21 like genuinely really excited to be part 13:23 of a discussion with all of them 13:25 this afternoon um so first up we've got 13:28 uh stephanie yoo who's the deputy 13:30 director of the public assets institute 13:33 which is a montpelier based 13:35 non-partisan non-profit fiscal policy 13:38 think tank working to improve the lives 13:41 of everyday vermonters 13:43 and stephanie has worked as a fiscal 13:46 analyst for the michigan senate 13:48 a private sector financial analyst and 13:51 in state government 13:52 as a budget manager for the michigan 13:54 department 13:55 of treasury um and executive director of 13:58 the west virginia 13:59 commission for national and community 14:00 service 14:02 and then next up is liz medina 14:05 who's the executive director of the 14:08 vermont state labor council 14:10 afl-cio and has previously served as the 14:13 co-chair of the goddard 14:15 college staff union uaw 2322 14:19 and then last year liz launched an oral 14:22 history podcast called on mass 14:24 which is part of the labor radio network 14:27 in an effort to build up 14:29 working class culture so next up 14:33 we've got pavlina cerneva 14:37 who is an associate professor of 14:40 economics at bard college and a research 14:42 scholar at the levy economics institute 14:44 in new york 14:45 specializing in modern monetary theory 14:47 and public policy 14:49 and her book which is called the case 14:51 for a jobs guarantee for a job guarantee 14:54 which is was was released last year is 14:56 really the ultimate guide 14:58 to the benefits of one of the most 15:01 uh transformative public policies being 15:04 discussed 15:04 today and then we have 15:08 fadel kaboob who's an associate 15:11 professor of 15:12 economics at denison university and the 15:14 president of the global institute 15:16 for sustainable prosperity um 15:19 his research focuses on the political 15:22 economy of the middle east 15:23 and the fiscal and monetary policy 15:25 dimensions of job 15:27 creation programs so clearly like an 15:29 extremely qualified panel 15:31 um and uh yeah so happy to pass it off 15:35 to 15:36 any of these uh other panelists for 15:38 their 15:39 thoughts 15:43 okay i think i'm up am i up yes please 15:46 go ahead steph thank you 15:48 thanks for the introduction and for that 15:49 good food for thought josh i appreciate 15:51 it um 15:53 so as josh said public assets institute 15:56 is really thinking about state level um 15:58 economic fiscal policy from the 16:00 perspective 16:01 of of everyday people and so what are 16:03 the impacts so 16:04 so you know the the economy is not the 16:06 stop stock market what is happening to 16:08 people and how are they experiencing the 16:09 economy 16:10 um and i think one of the things that 16:12 that josh just made me think of 16:14 is um is part of that conversation 16:16 around what we think of as work or or 16:18 jobs what we think of as good jobs how 16:20 we value those jobs 16:22 also thinking about why we think private 16:24 jobs are somehow better than public jobs 16:26 or or we treat them like those are real 16:28 jobs and public jobs are less real 16:30 and less valuable and less worth 16:32 protecting um 16:33 so i think it's you know i think this is 16:34 a great conversation i'm glad to be a 16:36 part of it 16:37 so i think my my role here is to kind of 16:40 ground the the like the labor landscape 16:43 in vermont what it's looked like over 16:44 the last 16:45 decade or more and sort of set the stage 16:48 for for what that means in terms of 16:50 thinking about where 16:51 um where something like a jobs guarantee 16:53 might make the biggest difference and 16:54 sort of where the holes are 16:56 but i think any conversation about the 16:59 labor landscape 17:00 um really has to start with this with 17:03 with the the issue that the pandemic has 17:05 obviously thrown things into just a lot 17:07 of turmoil and we're really talking 17:08 about a very different world 17:10 than than it was a year ago so i think 17:13 that's 17:13 that's sort of the kind of starting 17:15 place which is that we don't quite know 17:17 what it where we'll land after this 17:19 um i think one good thing about that is 17:21 that it really opens up the 17:22 possibilities for a lot of conversations 17:24 we're having conversations about 17:26 the role of government and about sort of 17:28 our obligations to one another and 17:30 what work is important what's essential 17:32 um so i think that really does open up 17:34 the possibilities for a lot of 17:35 conversations 17:37 i do always come bearing charts so i 17:39 will share my screen 17:40 and and sort of start to jump into that 17:43 and try to kind of give you a quick 17:44 overview of the labor landscape 17:46 in vermont 17:52 all right so um the 17:55 the uh sort of starting off with this 17:58 idea that the pandemic has really 18:00 thrown things into just chaos i think 18:03 this really gives you a sense i'm sure 18:04 you've all seen some chart like this 18:06 right where it's like this giant spike 18:07 in unemployment 18:09 unprecedented scale but i think the 18:11 thing to note about this is that we're 18:13 still you know we're still sort of way 18:15 above the worst of the great recession 18:16 so this is still at a scale even though 18:18 we've come 18:19 way way down from the peak we're still 18:21 at a scale that is really 18:23 pretty extreme for what we're talking 18:24 about um 18:26 so so but i also want to bring this 18:29 conversation back to sort of state 18:31 policy in the role of government vermont 18:32 is one of the few states 18:34 that has something like this enshrined 18:36 in statute which is the purpose of the 18:37 state budget right and the state's 18:38 obligations to its citizens 18:40 and so one of the and they list these 18:42 things that every that you know that 18:43 citizens are that 18:44 not citizens i don't want to limit 18:46 limited to citizens but that vermonters 18:48 residents of vermont you know are 18:50 entitled to these things which includes 18:52 dignified work right 18:53 uh so the three i have sort of three 18:57 main takeaways that uh for this 19:01 that i'd like to make here sort of what 19:02 are the main points um 19:04 the first is that the labor market in 19:06 vermont is is pretty uneven right like 19:08 it's not 19:09 one labor market it's not one labor 19:11 landscape what's happening in the 19:12 northwest corner 19:14 is very different from what's happening 19:15 in the south or the northeast kingdom 19:17 so that's the first point the second 19:19 point is that wages are low in vermont 19:21 which is a big part of the problem when 19:22 we talk about 19:23 what the what the labor market what 19:25 looks like what what jobs there are 19:27 the third thing is that there's lots of 19:29 people that are left out of the 19:30 traditional labor market 19:32 so so we talk a lot about sort of the 19:34 increasing gig workers or self-employed 19:36 people 19:38 vermonters with disabilities are another 19:40 group that often gets overlooked in the 19:41 labor market 19:42 and then you know i'm sure again you've 19:44 sort of seen the stories and the 19:45 headlines of 19:46 the pandemic's disproportionate impact 19:48 on women which is also holds true in 19:49 vermont 19:51 so just to kind of dig into each of 19:52 these things a little bit more 19:54 um so the labor market is uneven and so 19:58 throughout the state so much of vermont 20:00 hasn't recovered from the great 20:01 recession and by recovered we mean 20:03 you know they're still below they 20:04 haven't they haven't recovered the lost 20:06 ground the number of jobs or the people 20:07 employed that they 20:08 lost during the great recession and 20:10 obviously and that was sort of going 20:12 into this pandemic 20:13 pandemic recession and the pandemic has 20:16 has obviously worsened conditions 20:18 throughout the state 20:20 so you can see um really only half the 20:23 counties have gained jobs since the 20:24 great recession and again you know 20:26 there's a conversation about 20:28 what you know what does it mean to add 20:31 jobs if the jobs that you're adding 20:32 aren't that 20:33 you know aren't good quality jobs what 20:34 does that mean for people but again sort 20:36 of you see this real 20:37 really big difference between different 20:39 parts of the state 20:41 and and similarly the employment piece 20:43 so again the jobs are sort of the 20:44 payroll based jobs 20:46 and then employment is the people 20:47 working so it's not sort of a one-to-one 20:49 map because the jobs piece 20:51 is where the jobs are located and the 20:52 employment piece is where the employees 20:54 live 20:54 right so so you're not going to see 20:56 exactly the same pattern but you do see 20:58 this 20:58 this this unevenness the fact that in 21:00 some areas there's growth and in some 21:02 areas they're really struggling 21:04 and continue to struggle um post-grade 21:06 recession 21:09 and then i think sort of just going back 21:12 for 30 years a lot of the jobs that 21:13 we've been adding over the last 30 years 21:15 or really 21:15 in the service services jobs and so 21:17 while they're while it's not always true 21:19 it's pretty true that most of those jobs 21:21 tend to pay less 21:22 tend to have more turnover right so 21:24 these are sort of jobs that you wouldn't 21:25 necessarily expect people to be in 21:27 long term and so you can kind of see 21:29 from this all of that job growth over 21:31 the last 30 years is really in the 21:32 services and then you can clearly see 21:34 sort of the fall off 21:35 in 2020 as a result of the pandemic 21:38 and and the other piece where it's not 21:41 where it hasn't been especially even is 21:42 obviously the pandemic has had 21:44 disparate impacts on different sectors 21:46 right like we know that there are 21:47 certain sectors that 21:48 pretty much shut down completely um or 21:50 that had really big impacts and while 21:52 many of them have recovered some ground 21:55 it you know they're still well below 21:57 where they were pre-pandemic 22:00 so the the second point this idea that 22:02 that wages are low 22:04 so again i think sort of going to the 22:05 spirit of the conversation i think 22:08 you know we certainly believe that 22:09 vermonters and everyone else right 22:10 should have a livable income 22:12 at every stage of their lives so when 22:13 they're kids if they're working 22:15 full-time 22:16 if they're temporarily unemployed if 22:18 they're permanently unable to work 22:19 and you know up to and including a 22:21 secure retirement 22:22 right so at every phase of their lives 22:24 they should have enough to meet their 22:26 basic needs 22:27 and so that involves sort of a lot of 22:29 levels of wage policy which 22:31 you know starting with sort of the floor 22:32 that minimum wage should be a livable 22:33 wage 22:34 but i think this slide really gets to 22:36 this idea that even the average 22:38 wages in vermont are pretty low so this 22:40 is so this line represents the u.s 22:42 average of both 22:43 wages and prices of things and this sort 22:46 of price 22:46 price basket includes housing which so 22:49 you know vermont's prices are pretty 22:51 average relative to the rest of the us 22:52 but wages are really low and 22:56 and again we know that that rents do 22:58 tend to be a little bit higher than 22:59 average 23:00 in vermont but uh only about a third of 23:02 vermont households are renters 23:07 so and and again it's it's pretty 23:10 different across the landscape of 23:11 vermont so you can see how that 23:13 chittenden average wage really 23:15 brings up the average wage for the state 23:17 and that you see a lot of the 23:18 the other counties um wages are much 23:20 lower than that 23:24 so on the third point i think you know 23:26 this idea that 23:27 that many are left out of the vermont 23:29 labor force so 23:31 just to kind of give sort of the 23:33 baseline demographics for the vermont 23:34 labor force i think people hear a lot 23:36 about sort of the aging of the workforce 23:37 in vermont 23:38 you know i what i see here is the 23:40 biggest difference is really the racial 23:42 demographics in vermont obviously 23:43 compared to the rest of the country we 23:45 really our demographics really haven't 23:46 changed 23:47 that much over the last 30 years unlike 23:49 the rest of the country as a whole 23:51 and then you also see that the education 23:53 level that vermonters tend to be 23:56 tend to have more bachelor's degrees per 23:58 capita than 24:00 the us as a whole so 24:03 so that just sort of gives you a sense 24:04 of who we're talking about and 24:06 and you know part of this this is 24:08 relevant vermont um 24:10 so we we look at the uh vermonters with 24:13 disabilities pictures and only 24:14 about half of them are working and of 24:16 the the half that are working only half 24:18 are working full-time so that's 24:19 one big group that tends to get 24:21 overlooked in the labor market 24:23 um we mentioned this issue of 24:26 the pandemic having a disproportionate 24:28 effect on women 24:30 that's been true that the that of the 24:32 traditionally unemployed people 24:34 in vermont that that among the states 24:36 actually vermont has the highest share 24:37 that are women so about 24:39 70 of those unemployed of those 24:41 collecting traditional unemployment 24:42 benefits are women 24:43 in vermont and so that's um a big group 24:47 again it's sort of a question of 24:49 what happens from here vermont was 24:51 starting from a pretty good place and 24:52 that we have pretty good labor force 24:54 participation by women 24:55 relative to the rest of the country but 24:57 um you know sort of how long it takes to 24:59 this to recover and how much of this has 25:01 to do with caregiving responsibilities 25:03 and some of those other things that 25:04 again sort of tend not to have monetary 25:07 value in our economy but 25:08 but are obviously work that needs doing 25:10 and has needed doing this year 25:12 especially 25:14 um so so that's another piece and then 25:17 the other piece which we don't tend to 25:19 have a lot of 25:21 uh hard data for but is true in the rest 25:24 of the country and is true here as well 25:25 which is that bypoc vermonters tend to 25:28 tend to stay unemployed longer after 25:31 recessions 25:32 and you know there's more of an impact 25:34 on buyback vermonters in terms of 25:36 the job prospects after you know after a 25:39 recession 25:41 and then the last point i think in terms 25:43 of the uneven 25:44 sort of picture of this this is the same 25:47 sort of 25:47 this is the same unemployment claims 25:49 chart that i showed at the beginning but 25:50 what i 25:51 what we did here is sort of break it out 25:52 by the type of unemployment benefits 25:54 that people are receiving so what you 25:56 see there is that the red band 25:58 is those that aren't traditionally 26:00 covered by unemployment and this is sort 26:01 of another area where that term is even 26:03 sort of misleading right 26:05 um where in general a lot of workers 26:08 don't qualify 26:08 in normal times a lot of workers don't 26:10 qualify for unemployment benefits and 26:12 even if those who qualify many don't get 26:14 them 26:15 but in this case you know there was this 26:17 expansion by the federal government to 26:19 open it up to more and a lot of that ban 26:21 that self-employed and gig workers 26:23 so you can see that sort of red band 26:24 stays pretty steady and there's quite a 26:26 few of those people who wouldn't 26:27 normally be part of the unemployment 26:29 system 26:30 who are still requiring benefits now so 26:32 again sort of coming back to this 26:33 still 30 000 vermonters receiving 26:36 unemployment 26:37 benefits um and 26:40 um and you know again a pretty big 26:43 number and a good chunk of them 26:45 are these people who wouldn't 26:46 traditionally be included in that 26:48 so sort of a quick overview of of sort 26:51 of where we've been 26:52 and and where we are and how much the 26:54 pandemic has just sort of 26:55 thrown things into upheaval but so so i 26:58 think that we're still sort of absorbing 27:00 the impact of 27:01 of the pandemic but i think there's also 27:03 opportunity in that 27:04 you know there's a lot of gaps in labor 27:06 policy i think that josh called out and 27:08 then i'm sure 27:08 many of you will will bring up but again 27:11 what what we choose to call work 27:13 how we value it you know the 27:14 undervaluing of caregiving and other 27:16 essential work i mean we clearly saw 27:18 this you know 27:19 vermont actually did provide some hazard 27:21 pay to essential workers unlike a lot of 27:22 states but it was still relatively 27:24 minimal um vermont also provided some 27:28 you know comparable stimulus payments to 27:30 undocumented workers which not a lot of 27:32 states did so you know there are 27:34 again sort of these gaps where where 27:35 people get missed and left out 27:37 but i think um you know and then there's 27:40 also this question of what 27:41 what are the why are vermont's wages low 27:44 what are the forces that keep those 27:45 wages low that push those wages low 27:47 that stop them from going and what can 27:49 we do about that and a lot of that has 27:50 to do with labor policy 27:52 i think you also mentioned the child 27:54 care system which it which again we know 27:56 it's 27:57 both too expensive for parents and not 27:59 paying and can't pay 28:00 the workers a livable wage the 28:01 provider's livable wage so you know that 28:03 child care system is broken in 28:05 in multiple ways and the unemployment 28:07 system as well this is a temporary 28:09 expansion of it it's certainly 28:11 i mean i think the goal and what you're 28:12 talking about in terms of a jobs 28:13 guarantee is that 28:15 you know going forward you have minimal 28:17 use minimal need for the unemployment 28:18 system i mean there's probably always 28:20 some 28:20 need um but that you you really minimize 28:24 the use because you keep people 28:25 connected 28:26 to to the labor market as much as 28:29 possible 28:30 um and that people who want to work can 28:31 work so you know i think that's really 28:33 the goal and sort of what we're talking 28:35 about here 28:36 there's kind of a long list and a quick 28:38 overview but hopefully that help 28:39 that's helpful to sort of set the stage 28:41 of of this conversation 28:44 thank you so much steph that was 28:46 fantastic and uh 28:48 it's really helpful to to get these 28:50 numbers in vermont and understand where 28:52 where we are at the moment especially uh 28:55 given all the 28:56 the struggles that you you brought to 28:58 the table here i'd like to 28:59 go to liz medina welcome liz 29:03 thank you um thank you stephanie that 29:05 was really insightful we have a lot of 29:07 work clearly it's still to do here in 29:08 vermont 29:10 so um thank you for having me here my 29:12 name is liz medina i am the executive 29:13 director of vermont state labor council 29:16 afl-cio 29:17 which is our state's federation of labor 29:19 unions 29:20 um i also produce as mentioned a podcast 29:23 featuring 29:23 workers oral histories called on mass 29:26 and my first season 29:27 actually focused on depression era oral 29:30 histories funded by the federal writers 29:32 project 29:32 which was under the ewpa 29:35 and bringing people together to read and 29:37 perform those stories was a wonderful 29:39 rich experience for those involved and 29:41 hopefully for people who listened as 29:43 well 29:44 so therefore when i heard that a jobs 29:46 guarantee 29:47 was at the heart of the renew coalition 29:50 of which the vermont afl-cio is part 29:52 it felt like kismet a jobs guarantee has 29:55 been 29:56 a dream of labor of every leader we 29:59 cherish 30:00 of every person who has had to work for 30:02 a living 30:03 and knows the pain of not having work it 30:06 took over a quarter of our country being 30:09 out of work during the great depression 30:11 starving standing in bread lines and 30:13 thousands marching in the streets for 30:14 our country to do 30:15 something substantial for working people 30:18 in 1933 30:20 the national industrial recovery act or 30:21 nera was passed which recognized the 30:24 right to organize and launch the pwa 30:26 which was 30:27 followed by the wpa the right to 30:29 organize 30:30 combined with a federal jobs program 30:33 albeit temporary created the conditions 30:36 necessary 30:37 for workers to organize on mass and in 30:40 1934 30:42 over 1.4 million workers were involved 30:44 in strike actions 30:46 a mass labor movement was forming 30:49 creating a power base 30:50 for fdr and the new deal democrats to 30:53 pass the kind of bold legislation 30:56 that made the post-war period the most 30:58 prosperous in our nation's history with 31:00 the lowest levels of income inequality 31:02 we've seen since we've begun measuring 31:03 them in 1915 31:05 which lasted until the 1980s 31:08 and so the growth of the labor movement 31:10 and the successes of the wpa led to 31:12 bolder visions 31:14 in particular vision for a future in 31:15 which one's ability to make a living 31:17 wasn't dependent upon the manipulations 31:20 of the market by a few 31:22 a philip randolph president of the 31:23 brotherhood of sleeping car 31:25 porters began developing proposal for a 31:27 jobs guarantee 31:29 an idea that catalyzed the march on 31:30 washington for jobs and freedom in 1963. 31:34 there were also several legislative 31:36 efforts that enshrined the notion that 31:38 every american ought to have the right 31:40 to a job with dignity 31:41 such as the employment act of 1946 and 31:43 the humphrey hawkins full employment act 31:45 of 1970 31:47 but unfortunately they remain toothless 31:49 and aspirational in their final forms 31:52 an intense backlash from the capitalist 31:54 class and their captured politicians has 31:56 resulted in the steady decline 31:58 of union density since its peak in 1954. 32:02 this decline has marginalized our 32:04 country's 32:05 only movement capable of realizing a 32:08 jobs guarantee 32:09 one which is broad diverse and moreover 32:12 labor-based 32:14 so i'm briefly rehashing this history 32:17 which i'm sure all of you know 32:18 um to remind us that we need to rebuild 32:21 the labor movement 32:22 in order to win a jobs guarantee a jobs 32:25 guarantee has 32:26 overwhelming majority support among u.s 32:28 voters so we've won the narrative 32:31 however instead of following the 32:33 direction of the rank and file 32:35 too many unions in labor organizations 32:38 have instead obsiquisly followed the 32:40 direction 32:41 of the corrupt and corporatized 32:43 democratic party 32:45 we don't want to merely catch a coin 32:47 that is flung at us once in a while 32:50 especially when we're facing multiple 32:52 global crises 32:53 such as a global pandemic nor should we 32:56 be satisfied with only a universal basic 32:59 income we need dignity and democracy in 33:02 our workplaces and communities 33:05 rather than trusting the democratic 33:06 party and a few tech ceos to determine 33:09 our future 33:10 working people deserve to not only be 33:12 included but to be 33:13 leaders in such decisions and that means 33:17 we need to retain our strategic role at 33:20 the point of production 33:23 rebuilding the labor movement means 33:25 rediscovering and reigniting our true 33:27 source of power 33:28 which is us the working class we know 33:31 what we want 33:32 we want comfortable homes nutritious 33:34 food for our families excellent health 33:36 care for all 33:37 clean air and water the irony is that we 33:39 can produce everything we need 33:41 but we have an oligarchy in this country 33:44 hoarding resources in power 33:46 with a jobs guarantee we can redirect 33:49 these desperately needed resources 33:51 back into our communities creating as 33:53 many jobs as we need 33:55 to provide for our basic needs 33:58 we need to have conversations about why 34:00 we need a jobs guarantee with our union 34:02 brothers 34:03 sisters and siblings to start we need to 34:06 seize 34:07 every moment and platform to highlight 34:09 the need for a jobs guarantee 34:12 on a national level this pandemic has 34:14 shown the need for more health care 34:16 workers 34:16 social workers and many other essential 34:19 workers who are being stretched then 34:21 working without reprieve in dangerous 34:23 conditions 34:25 on a local level we need to seize any 34:27 opportunities in our workplace struggles 34:30 for instance back in 2018 the 34:33 aft-affiliated vermont federation of 34:35 nurses and healthcare professionals went 34:37 out on strike 34:39 the nurses didn't solely focus on wages 34:41 and benefits important as those are 34:44 they also highlighted the issue of an 34:46 alarmingly high 34:47 patient to nurse ratio at the university 34:50 of vermont medical center 34:52 nurses gained vast community support 34:55 over the issue of safe staffing 34:57 which enabled them to win community 34:59 support to go 35:00 on strike the strike made everyone in 35:03 the state 35:04 aware of the need for more well-paid 35:07 nursing jobs 35:08 in vermont it's only a small step 35:12 to go from that issue of safe staffing 35:15 to a call 35:16 for a jobs guarantee 35:19 we need to talk to our co-workers 35:20 friends and neighbors 35:22 i've spoken with too many working 35:24 vermonters who are given 35:25 impossible workloads a conversation with 35:29 a diversion case manager 35:30 in very stands out in particular 35:34 when collecting oral histories of 35:35 working vermonters this person 35:37 shared that they were close to reaching 35:39 100 cases 35:42 they were called to do social work it 35:44 ran deep into their family's upbringing 35:46 and ethos however they were constantly 35:49 stressed out 35:50 by the fact that they couldn't offer as 35:52 much help as was needed 35:53 for each client because of the 35:56 overwhelming caseload they worked around 35:59 the clock 36:00 coming home only to do more work never 36:03 even having the chance to settle down 36:05 and hang out with their partner during 36:07 their evenings 36:10 it was a pattern in the field and they 36:12 were close to completely burning out 36:15 because of chronic understaffing and 36:17 lack of resources 36:19 our social work system ends up serving 36:21 no one 36:23 meanwhile we have thousands of 36:25 vermonters 36:26 out of work feeling rejected and without 36:29 purpose 36:31 the reality of our oppressive capitalist 36:33 system in our lives 36:35 is dark and painful despite the many 36:38 fictions our oppressors tell us 36:40 we are made to believe we live in a 36:42 meritocracy but most of us are barely 36:45 getting by 36:45 despite our best efforts and the vast 36:48 wealth that we produce 36:50 perhaps the hardest part is to stop 36:53 putting 36:54 all the blame on ourselves and to 36:56 realize 36:57 we are all connected to other forces and 37:00 people 37:00 beyond ourselves i've been on this 37:03 journey myself 37:05 like many others in my generation i 37:08 struggled with a period of unemployment 37:11 in my early stages of my career i had to 37:14 move back home 37:16 and for me back home is returning to an 37:19 economically depressed 37:20 rust belt town where empty buildings and 37:23 storefronts 37:24 loom large that period 37:28 remains the darkest in my life yet i 37:31 refuse 37:32 to let shame and fear control me and 37:35 that is why i am personally invested 37:38 in the fight for a jobs guarantee 37:41 so a jobs guarantee can prevent our 37:44 brothers 37:45 sisters siblings union and non-union 37:47 from being worked to death 37:49 a jobs guarantee could counter the 37:52 despotic power of employers 37:53 by giving choices to workers a jobs 37:56 guarantee could help 37:58 to build unity among unemployed 38:01 and employed workers whom employers 38:03 often pit against each other in order to 38:05 maintain their power 38:07 a jobs guarantee could help build unity 38:09 among all kinds of workers 38:11 the kind of unity we need to rebuild the 38:14 labor movement 38:15 and make a jobs guarantee a reality 38:19 in the words of a philip randolph 38:21 salvation 38:22 for a race nation or class must come 38:24 from within 38:26 freedom is never granted it is one 38:28 justice is never given 38:30 it is exacted randall's ultimate vision 38:34 was a freedom budget the center of which 38:37 was a jobs guarantee 38:39 the time has come to honor both 38:42 ourselves 38:42 and our movement for bearers the time 38:45 has come 38:46 for us to win a jobs guarantee and the 38:48 freedom and justice that comes with it 38:51 thank you we have a lot of talking to do 38:56 thank you so much liz that was fantastic 38:59 and i really appreciate 39:00 this the deep historical knowledge that 39:03 you bring to this 39:04 this conversation um and appropriate to 39:07 connect freedom to unity 39:09 as we're talking about it here in 39:10 vermont um 39:12 [Music] 39:13 from this specific angle right so 39:16 so so appreciate it thank you liz uh 39:19 i'd like to invite uh pablina chernova 39:23 um to uh uh 39:28 provide some comments and then from 39:30 there we'll go to uh 39:31 farrell caboodle thank you pablina
チャーネバ:
39:34 thank you everyone uh thank you so much 39:37 for the invitation for the comments you 39:40 set the stage 39:41 for what i'm going to say and i think my 39:45 job here is to bring the bird's eye view 39:47 picture the macro picture 39:49 to the analysis but 39:52 i just think um the themes are so 39:56 important and the first of course is 39:59 that the scarcity of job is really 40:01 not because there's no work to do as 40:03 josh was pointing out 40:04 we've got ton more than we have people 40:07 to do them 40:08 um my perspective would be that the 40:11 scarcity of jobs is there 40:13 um not just because of lack of vision 40:16 that we are not 40:17 valuing the public sector work and the 40:19 importance of 40:20 um the direct contribution that 40:23 government can make 40:25 but doesn't but the scarcity is there 40:28 also because of 40:30 inaction because of a mission and also 40:34 because of policy 40:35 specific policy so i want to bring that 40:38 perspective how economists think about 40:39 unemployment 40:40 how they reproduce these false frames 40:43 that it is 40:44 natural that it is unavoidable and even 40:47 perhaps even necessary 40:49 i think this is really important to 40:52 debunk 40:53 the second thing i want to talk about is 40:55 that 40:56 there is a certain sense in which 40:58 unemployment is 41:00 perennial it is with us it is typical to 41:03 this economic system 41:04 the system that has this very peculiar 41:07 heartbeat 41:08 a system that grows and shrinks and 41:10 grows and shrinks and it's subject to 41:12 all sorts of 41:13 uh vagaries of market vigor is from 41:16 trade to technology etc 41:17 and the collateral damage is always 41:19 people it's always 41:21 jobs but there's nothing unavoidable 41:24 about that 41:24 you know that we do have very direct 41:27 means and methods of creating employment 41:29 when jobs are sacrificed for 41:32 one reason or another right um so that's 41:35 that's the second 41:36 uh part this this the the third the 41:40 third 41:40 uh issue i want to discuss is how i i'm 41:44 hearing 41:45 um in this conversation this dire need 41:48 to create um support 41:52 for ongoing essential work that is be 41:55 that is not being done that our society 41:58 needs 41:59 and that we are regularly told that we 42:01 can't have these things from child care 42:03 to elderly care 42:04 to infrastructure to social care to 42:06 environmental work we're constantly told 42:08 we can't 42:08 have those things and this is extremely 42:11 important 42:12 to keep in mind as we re-envision the 42:15 future of work 42:16 what kind of society we have but i want 42:18 to also shine 42:19 a light on another aspect of the job 42:22 guarantee 42:22 and that is that it is a public option 42:26 it is that ultimate guarantee 42:29 that whatever your circumstance whoever 42:31 you are um 42:33 they will be uh an option in the public 42:36 sector at a 42:37 basic dignified wage benefit package so 42:40 those 42:41 those i think in the discussion we can 42:42 proceed to talk about that they 42:44 they probably should be seen as somewhat 42:46 separate things because 42:48 essential ongoing permanent sector work 42:51 must be there at all times but there 42:53 will always be 42:54 this heartbeat to the economy that will 42:57 mean that some people will be losing 42:58 their jobs and 42:59 gaining their jobs and we want to also 43:01 make sure that that is no longer part 43:03 of our macroeconomic world right that we 43:06 have an option 43:07 for people who need jobs whatever the 43:10 circumstance 43:11 and and finally i want to say a few 43:13 things about how 43:14 just like liz was saying how once you 43:17 imagine 43:18 a world in which the employment is a 43:21 right 43:21 and everyone has access to that right 43:23 that really represents a new social 43:25 contract 43:26 and it it does um change the rules of 43:30 the game 43:31 the labor market how we live how we 43:33 relate to each other 43:34 but very important point that was made 43:36 is that in fact the fates of the working 43:38 people and the unemployed are 43:40 indelibly intertwined they cannot be 43:42 separated 43:43 so i had a powerpoint presentation but 43:45 i'm not going to do this it's just 43:46 going to be dull and boring but i think 43:48 it's um you know several things to to 43:50 point out 43:52 it is absolutely essential that we 43:54 organize around this idea 43:56 because it is extremely popular and i 44:00 have numbers and i'm happy to share them 44:02 um that it's not just popular but it is 44:04 the job guarantee 44:06 garners bipartisan support even 44:08 conservative support is 44:10 upwards of fifty percent and um 44:13 uh this these surveys are recent and 44:15 being replicated around the world just 44:17 this morning i was 44:18 looking at a new one from france 79 44:20 support for a green job guarantee in 44:23 france 44:23 yougov did a survey last year 70 plus 44:26 percent 44:27 in the uk in the united states in the 44:29 recent years it's been consistently in 44:30 the 70 percent 44:31 so it is even though at the federal 44:34 level we might 44:35 there are there are movements at the 44:36 federal level right um 44:38 whether the federal government pursues a 44:41 job guarantee policy i think it's still 44:43 good local politics to organize around 44:46 it 44:47 okay so the next thing that i wanted to 44:49 say 44:50 is that um from a macro bird's eye view 44:55 perspective there are a couple of things 44:57 to keep in mind 44:58 um of course each of our struggles is 45:00 going to be much easier and each of our 45:02 um our activism is going to be easier if 45:06 of course we have the umbrella policy 45:08 which can kind of empower the local job 45:11 guarantees if we have the federal policy 45:14 and in the recent resolution that was 45:17 advanced by 45:18 a representative ayanna presley they 45:20 were like three core components that we 45:22 want to keep in mind first that the 45:24 right to employment is a basic human 45:26 right but also that it is paid by public 45:28 money 45:29 and that it is for public employment for 45:31 the public good 45:32 so that would be kind of the 45:33 aspirational at the aspirational context 45:37 and then there's the macroeconomic 45:38 context 45:39 and here i just want to spend a few 45:41 minutes to talk a little bit about 45:43 um how economists i'm sorry to say are 45:48 the villain 45:49 um and we got to reject the frame that 45:53 unemployment is natural and where it 45:55 comes from 45:56 is these um old calcified theoretical 45:59 notions that 46:00 unemployment is just something that is 46:02 unavoidable that the market can create 46:04 only so many 46:05 jobs that um policy really does not have 46:09 a lot of levers to push 46:11 unemployment below what the market deems 46:14 to be the natural level 46:17 because if policy attempts to do that it 46:19 might generate 46:20 undesirable inflation some people are 46:24 familiar with this 46:25 some people who don't watch the feds are 46:27 surprised to hear this 46:29 that actually the central bank has a 46:31 unemployment rate that's a policy 46:33 that's a positive unemployment rate of 46:35 some percentage 3.5 4.5 percent 46:38 that is the policy guide that tells them 46:40 when they need to step on the brakes 46:42 and remove whatever stimulus they might 46:44 be offering in the economy 46:46 for fear of seeing inflation and of 46:49 course when you think about this you 46:50 know what the channel is 46:51 that too many people have jobs too many 46:53 people have incomes 46:54 too much spending power and perhaps too 46:57 much to eat 46:58 and thus we have to fight inflation by 47:01 actually 47:01 um sacrificing employment or tolerating 47:04 some positive level of unemployment 47:07 that is so ingrained in the 47:09 macroeconomic model in the way 47:12 orthodox economists think the way models 47:15 are put together whether they're the 47:16 congressional budget office whether 47:18 they're the central bank 47:19 there is this notion lurking in these 47:22 macro models that unemployment is 47:24 natural 47:24 and is desirable for macroeconomic 47:26 stability and price stability 47:28 and so in my work and you know worker 47:31 fidel and our colleagues you know we try 47:32 to debunk this idea that in fact we do 47:34 have alternatives we can create 47:38 jobs we can use the job guarantee itself 47:41 to provide the kind of economic 47:43 stabilization and 47:44 even price stabilization that currently 47:47 unemployment is used for 47:51 um and so in our work we at the macro 47:54 level the policy level we reject the 47:56 necessity of an unemployment as a policy 47:59 tool 47:59 and that we we argue that the unknown 48:01 that the job guarantee will be that 48:03 buffer 48:04 it will be that powerful force that will 48:07 increase when there are recessions just 48:09 naturally it's a demand given 48:11 policy when when people need work they 48:13 tap into the job guarantee 48:14 it is that very expenditure by the 48:16 public sector that provides 48:18 economic stability and it's so much 48:20 better than 48:21 just throwing money at the problem right 48:23 when the person has employment 48:25 the whole world is different and when 48:27 they rely on unemployment however 48:29 generous it is 48:32 and so um the job guarantee is the 48:34 stabilizer that grows in downturns 48:37 um that provides employment 48:40 when jobs flee due to trade or whatever 48:43 and that shrinks when economic life 48:46 returns to the community 48:48 when the private firms and mom and pop 48:50 shops start springing up and they start 48:52 offering employment so it is actually 48:54 that buffer that 48:55 that increases and and shrinks 49:01 in the same way that unemployment does 49:03 and so 49:04 from the really the bird's eye view 49:06 picture um 49:07 the public sector is always responsible 49:10 for unemployment 49:11 the public sector is always responsible 49:13 uh for the social costs of unemployment 49:16 for providing however meager 49:18 support and assistance um for the 49:20 unemployed you know for anti-poverty 49:22 programs 49:23 the unemployed are part and parcel of 49:26 the public sector whether the government 49:28 recognizes this or not 49:30 we are responsible collectively for the 49:33 social 49:33 fallout of unemployment and all of the 49:35 human costs 49:36 in my work i kind of catalog and 49:39 document them and they are very large 49:41 it is a very expensive proposition to 49:43 tolerate unemployment and its social 49:45 costs 49:45 it is a much better policy to inoculate 49:49 against those 49:50 and provide a job to a job seeker a good 49:53 job a decent pay 49:54 with good benefits okay so uh so at the 49:57 macro level we have two choices we 49:59 either either tolerate the 50:01 system based on unemployment that you 50:03 know unemployment 50:04 yo-yos it grows rings or we have a 50:06 public option that provides the 50:08 requisite 50:09 missing job opportunities that kind of 50:12 policy commitment that this would be 50:13 done at all times not just in the middle 50:15 of a pandemic but also in the so-called 50:17 full fully employed economy right 50:20 there's still people seeking work 50:22 even in the best of times that kind of 50:24 policy commitment that 50:25 they will be employment opportunities 50:27 there at all times does represent a new 50:29 social contract 50:31 and so i want to just run through what i 50:33 think might be some of these pillars 50:35 of the social of the new social contract 50:39 and the first one is based on this 50:41 discussion that we've we've had so far 50:43 that unemployment 50:44 is really vandalism um this is a term 50:47 that uh 50:48 bill victoria an economist used to argue 50:50 unemployment is vandalism it's 50:52 we you know we accept uh from the 50:55 macro level or the policy level this 50:57 vandalism is some sort of necessary 50:59 and because we have direct employment 51:02 and direct action 51:03 um it is certainly not necessary 51:06 um the second part is that if the public 51:09 sector is responsible for the social 51:11 cost then 51:11 it actually has an obligation to do 51:14 things better 51:15 to not quote unquote support a system 51:18 based on neglect and devastation whether 51:20 it's environmental whether it is human 51:22 and then you know pay for the costs 51:26 real or financial for this kind of um 51:28 neglect but it actually has 51:30 a responsibility and obligation to pay 51:32 for investment in those communities for 51:34 investment 51:35 in in people um in our most precious 51:39 resources 51:41 this the the next part of the social 51:45 contract is that yes the job guarantee 51:46 is our economic stabilizer 51:50 which means that our overall economy is 51:53 more stable 51:54 with with direct employment than without 51:57 it 51:58 and by by 52:01 by implementing it we actually can 52:05 establish a new labor standard what that 52:08 means is 52:09 when a person has a public option for a 52:12 job that pays 52:13 15 an hour at a minimum with 52:17 medicare with social security with paid 52:20 vacation 52:21 that's the standard the person who 52:23 doesn't have that 52:24 they have an option and if the employer 52:27 who doesn't offer those benefits wish to 52:29 retain those workers 52:31 they have to match the standard so it is 52:34 it is important 52:35 it is foundational to establish a 52:38 standard 52:39 through employment in addition to the 52:42 other ways in which we attempt to 52:44 establish the labor standard 52:46 in other words we have a minimum wage 52:48 policy 52:49 all well and good we have to raise the 52:51 minimum wage but if you can get a 52:53 minimum wage policy 52:55 minimum wage job you don't benefit from 52:57 that standard 52:59 so we need both the legal legislated 53:02 wage but we also need the employment 53:03 option that you can access that 53:05 right we can have i mean i think you 53:07 know healthcare needs to be 53:09 separate from employment that has to be 53:10 part of the social wage that has to be 53:12 part of the standard that we aspire to 53:15 but if you're working you should have 53:18 days of rest 53:19 and you should have paid leave right and 53:21 then that becomes the standard okay 53:23 so the public option establishes the 53:25 minimum floor of what we consider to be 53:26 a dignified work 53:28 the second aspect is you explain it very 53:30 well that 53:31 when we have public um employment 53:34 we actually value different things we 53:36 value socially useful things 53:38 we value people we value the public good 53:41 the environment 53:42 uh the very many things that don't have 53:44 immediate commercial return 53:46 profit return and must be done 53:48 nonetheless in fact 53:50 that's what our care economy is right 53:52 the environment doesn't pay 53:54 but the environment um nurtures us 53:57 so we are we have neglected in fact what 54:00 seems to be important 54:02 okay uh all right finally um we 54:05 reject the threat of unemployment i 54:07 think here liz 54:08 talked very articulately about how we 54:11 are connected 54:11 if we if we refuse this idea that 54:15 unemployment is necessary 54:17 to discipline workers we have a 54:18 completely different paradigm of how we 54:20 value workers and how 54:22 we um support them in their jobs and how 54:25 we promote them 54:26 it's not the threat and fear of losing 54:27 your livelihood but there are other ways 54:29 in which now 54:30 we are you know quote unquote motivate 54:33 if you will right it becomes not a 54:35 punitive 54:35 uh paradigm uh but also as we said you 54:39 know it's 54:40 we we we remove an important power of 54:43 the firm 54:44 um that the unemployment um 54:48 in sort of pitting workers against each 54:50 other and preventing or organization so 54:53 i think 54:53 that this is i just really loved 54:55 listening to you know uh 54:57 this is recognition that you know you 54:59 union work is so 55:01 um in a way contingent on having tight 55:03 full employment 55:04 okay um next we reject trade-offs you 55:07 know we're told 55:08 technology is going to take away your 55:10 jobs uh trade is going to take you away 55:11 your jobs 55:12 the green transition is going to take 55:13 you away your jobs and people are 55:15 fearful of that and they don't pursue 55:17 the kind of policies we need but now we 55:20 have 55:21 we have an answer and fidel will talk 55:22 about the importance of the job 55:24 guarantee 55:24 in the environmental movement um 55:28 and finally um we embrace democratic 55:32 design 55:32 that in fact these policies must be uh 55:35 implemented from the ground up 55:37 in in cities in towns and localities 55:40 where people know exactly what they need 55:42 the kind of work that must be done who 55:43 can do it and 55:45 can do this the assessment and 55:47 implementation that is necessary to make 55:49 these 55:49 policies resilient and to address uh 55:52 specific community needs 55:54 so i think that um last but not least 55:57 we kind of reinstate and reinform our 55:59 commitment to this basic human right 56:02 that was part of the conversation a new 56:04 deal it was 56:05 the economic bill of rights had the 56:06 right to employment as the first pillar 56:09 and we left that conversation um 56:12 i think in part because uh economists 56:15 convinced us that full employment is 56:17 three percent unemployment and there's 56:18 the most that we can do 56:20 uh but we need to sort of return to that 56:22 uh commitment 56:23 and um re-articulate it through through 56:26 the job guarantee 56:27 so i'm just gonna end here and 56:31 pass it on to fidel
カバーブ:
56:34 thank you pavlina this was a wonderful 56:37 set of 56:38 presentations really enjoyed it and i'd 56:41 like to 56:41 add a few more components and transition 56:44 us into talking more about the job 56:46 guarantee in the context of a green new 56:48 deal 56:48 at the national level or at the at the 56:50 local level 56:51 um but first i'd like to comment on on a 56:54 few of the things that that were already 56:56 said 56:56 i mean the the mainstream economist that 56:59 pavlino was referring to let's remember 57:01 that these guys were wrong about 57:02 inequality they were wrong about climate 57:04 change they're wrong about inflation 57:06 they're wrong about 57:07 almost everything that they're wrong 57:08 about the financial crisis 57:10 call their bluff i mean why are we still 57:12 listening to these guys and giving them 57:13 air time on on bloomberg 57:15 so that's number one number two um 57:18 the main argument that they have which 57:21 is 57:21 you know too much government spending on 57:23 unemployment 57:24 on climate action we'll just bankrupt 57:27 the country we'll have hyperinflation 57:29 we'll turn into a venezuela 57:31 well the last 10 years have demonstrated 57:33 that large government deficits 57:35 you know large government spending in 57:36 the u.s in europe and japan and the uk 57:39 did not lead to inflation you know japan 57:42 has the highest debt to gdp ratio in the 57:44 world 260 percent 57:46 and they have negative interest rates 57:47 and they have deflation for the last 30 57:49 years 57:50 so call their bluff they have no idea 57:52 what they're talking about the ecb has 57:53 acknowledged this finally they said 57:55 we really don't know what determines 57:57 interest rates and why are these things 57:59 happening we thought it was just japan 58:00 something strange happening there but 58:02 apparently it's deeper than that 58:04 the fed also here in the us said we 58:06 don't actually have a reliable 58:08 theory of inflation translation in plain 58:10 english we have no idea what 58:12 how these things work so call their 58:14 bluff and and let's have a progressive 58:17 movement that tackles the issues that 58:18 matter 58:20 we're told that you know we have 58:21 millions of people who actually want to 58:23 work 58:24 we have the planet is on fire we have 58:26 the technology the resources the brain 58:28 power to get things done 58:30 and somehow we're told we can't do any 58:32 of this right 58:33 we've done it before during the the new 58:35 deal and 58:36 uh and liz presentation was a wonderful 58:39 reminder 58:39 of what we're capable of doing we've 58:42 done it with pen and paper we didn't 58:43 have the logistical capabilities 58:46 and and it wasn't just building bridges 58:48 it was taking care of people 58:50 something that a lot of people don't 58:52 remember from 58:53 about the wpa workers they made 58:56 something like more than two million 58:58 home visits 58:59 wellness checks taking care of people 59:01 people who were 59:02 you know coming back from uh surgery um 59:05 mothers that recently delivered or 59:07 people who just needed elderly care or 59:09 child care 59:10 this was part of building infrastructure 59:13 and i'm glad that we're 59:15 sort of coming back to this conversation 59:17 this week that infrastructure is also 59:19 people it's also the care economy 59:21 and to to look at the the numbers of 59:24 people that we currently have 59:26 not just during the pandemic 59:27 pre-pandemic when we were so-called 59:29 close to full employment or at full 59:31 employment the lowest 59:32 level since the 60s when you actually 59:34 dig into 59:35 the hidden unemployment statistics right 59:37 before the pandemic 59:39 there were not only millions of people 59:40 who are still officially unemployed 59:42 but millions of people who couldn't take 59:44 a job not because they didn't want to 59:46 didn't have the skills 59:47 because they didn't have reliable 59:49 transportation and the job didn't pay 59:51 enough for them to 59:52 to buy a car or to have access to public 59:55 transportation 59:56 millions of people couldn't take jobs 59:58 not because they didn't want to didn't 59:59 have the skills but because 60:01 the jobs didn't pay enough for somebody 60:03 to take care of their kids or take care 60:05 of their elderly family members 60:07 to so we're excluding millions of people 60:10 from the economy because of how low the 60:13 standards are the labor standards so 60:15 completely applaud the calls for 60:19 uh a labor movement to be at the center 60:22 of this discussion and 60:23 and some of you have have seen the 60:25 series that we've been doing this uh 60:26 month with the rosa luxembourg 60:28 foundation i'm happy to drop the the 60:30 links 60:32 on the chat and this afternoon we just 60:33 had a a fantastic panel with sarah 60:36 nelson 60:37 with carl rosen and and keon 60:41 laboratory all of them from the labor 60:45 movement are saying we can't have the 60:47 pro 60:47 act we can't have none of the 60:50 all the big things that we're calling 60:52 for without a united movement 60:54 that recognizes who is us and who is 60:56 them it's not this union against that 60:58 union is not this 61:00 it's us against the vested interests 61:02 that are controlling and suffocating the 61:04 system 61:05 so i'll say a few words about the the 61:07 big thing that they usually push back on 61:10 on the job guarantee in the green deal 61:11 i'm dropping this link in the chat that 61:13 for people who are interested in some of 61:15 the details this is part of the kind of 61:17 job guarantee 61:18 mmt literature that paulina and 61:20 stephanie kelton and others are part of 61:23 which is the simple message that we're 61:26 told 61:26 that the government doesn't have the 61:28 resources to pay for this 61:30 it's got to be the private sector 61:31 creating jobs that the government is 61:33 limited in terms of its spending 61:35 capacity 61:36 by tax revenues and a little bit of 61:38 borrowing whatever wall street will let 61:40 the government borrow 61:41 or we're disciplined by wall street 61:43 beyond that if the government spends 61:44 more it's going to cause hyperinflation 61:46 well what mmt and what the job guarantee 61:48 literature is is teaching 61:50 us is that there's plenty of additional 61:52 spending capacity 61:53 that the federal government can tap into 61:55 that's how we tapped into it during 61:57 world war ii 61:58 during the new deal era during 62:01 financing the care paying for the cares 62:03 act paying for the 1.9 trillion dollars 62:05 and paying for all the wars and all the 62:07 tax cuts 62:08 we have that additional spending 62:09 capacity we're just told 62:11 every time it's about jobs it's about 62:13 the middle class that this is going to 62:15 bankrupt the country we're going to turn 62:16 into a venezuela or something like that 62:19 so call their bluff on that because what 62:21 we know 62:22 from the mmt literature the job 62:23 guarantee literature is that what 62:25 determines how much additional spending 62:27 we can 62:27 safely have is the potential risk of 62:30 inflation 62:31 which is determined by two very 62:32 important things for for all of us to 62:34 have 62:35 on the map here one is if we run out of 62:38 productive capacity 62:40 we hit the inflation risk meaning if we 62:43 run out of skilled workers if we run out 62:45 of materials and equipment and 62:46 technology and 62:48 we want to spend more will cause 62:49 inflation the good news about that is 62:51 that productive capacity is producible 62:54 we can train more people we can bring 62:55 more people into the labor force 62:57 and this is how the job guarantee 62:59 becomes a guarantee 63:00 against the risk of inflation because it 63:03 helps us produce the things that we 63:05 need to become a resilient society 63:07 resilient economy 63:09 um the second thing that determines the 63:11 risk of inflation which is very 63:12 important for 63:13 for this conversation and for this 63:15 movement is what we call 63:17 abusive market power concentration of 63:20 market power within 63:22 key sectors within key corporations that 63:24 allows them to raise prices simply 63:26 because they can 63:27 and exclude people simply because they 63:29 can't think of health insurance 63:30 companies think of 63:32 your your telecom companies josh was 63:34 having internet issues earlier 63:36 i was having internet issues earlier you 63:38 complain all you want it's the same 63:40 crappy service the bill goes up every 63:42 other month 63:42 and there's nothing you can do about it 63:44 because they divided the country into 63:46 little territories 63:47 and they do as they please that kind of 63:50 inflation 63:51 and abusive pricing behavior in the 63:53 healthcare industry 63:55 and the oil and gas industry the energy 63:57 sector 63:58 it's not going to go away if we 63:59 eliminate the job guarantee or not have 64:01 a green new deal 64:02 that type of inflation goes away if you 64:04 tax 64:05 and regulate it out of existence in 64:07 other words the 535 people we elect in 64:10 this democracy 64:11 if they do their job they can eliminate 64:14 that 64:14 kind of inflation from the system by 64:16 democratizing the system 64:18 if we have a government of the people by 64:20 the people for the people 64:21 but if it's you know brought to you by 64:23 super pacs then this is what we get 64:26 so if we're successful at having a clear 64:28 vision about 64:29 what the additional spending capacity is 64:32 and set the priorities straight in terms 64:34 of how to decarbonize what kind of 64:36 infrastructure we need 64:37 what kind of care economy we need we do 64:39 have the spending capacity 64:41 but we're only going to tap into it if 64:43 we recognize 64:44 that you know we have these forces that 64:46 suffocate that spending capacity 64:49 by causing inflation and risking 64:52 additional inflation 64:54 if we attempt to spend on the things 64:56 that matter to us 64:57 but every time we spend on the things 64:58 that matter to them 65:00 a war a tax cut whatever it is 65:03 it's not inflationary but if we spend on 65:05 the things that matter to millions of 65:07 people 65:08 for the planet all of a sudden it's 65:10 unaffordable and all that so 65:12 it's important for the movement to 65:13 recognize what their 65:15 line of defense is what their arguments 65:18 are and 65:19 call their bluff and change the 65:20 narrative and part of changing the 65:22 narrative 65:23 is this tagline uh that my colleagues 65:26 and i are working on kind of to quantify 65:29 this which is the following 65:30 the cost of doing nothing is way more 65:33 expensive 65:34 than the cost of doing the right thing 65:36 which is a green new deal and a job 65:37 guarantee and a care economy and all of 65:39 that 65:40 so when you quantify it you actually 65:42 realize we're spending already trillions 65:44 of dollars 65:45 on the opioid crisis alone just in the 65:48 last four years there's a white house 65:50 report that put it at 2.5 trillion 65:52 dollars 65:53 in the last four years of of the report 65:55 this came out in 2017 or 18. 65:58 2.5 trillion dollars that's the cost of 66:00 doing nothing that's just dealing with 66:01 the negative consequences 66:03 of the you know the the diseases of 66:06 despair and 66:07 all of that and we know as as uh it was 66:10 mentioned earlier every time we have 66:12 higher unemployment than any part of the 66:14 country in any part of the world 66:17 you know crime goes up uh depression 66:20 suicide uh anxiety 66:24 all kinds of child abuse domestic 66:26 violence the divorce 66:27 all of these social costs we're already 66:30 paying for it 66:31 right it's just not and and when you 66:34 introduce a job guarantee when you 66:35 address the root causes of poverty and 66:37 unemployment and 66:39 we're not saying we're going to 66:40 eliminate all of these social problems 66:42 but you're going to put a major major um 66:46 you know downward pressure on all of 66:48 those costs and all of that economic and 66:49 social 66:50 social pain so the job guarantee within 66:53 the green new deal 66:54 movement is not a nice add-on feature 66:57 to put into it it's a core component of 67:00 a green new deal 67:01 because the green new deal is about two 67:03 things in the u.s context about 67:05 addressing inequality and addressing the 67:07 climate crisis these are the two 67:09 biggest crises that we have and related 67:11 to it is the 67:12 crisis of socio-economic exclusion for 67:14 millions of people 67:16 so how do we engage in this massive 67:19 decarbonization and transformation of 67:21 the economy 67:21 and do it in a way that brings millions 67:24 of people 67:25 into a prosperous and sustainable 67:29 and dignified work environment and 67:30 living conditions 67:32 and the job guarantee is a core feature 67:34 of that and that includes the millions 67:36 of people 67:37 who will lose jobs during this 67:39 transition 67:40 and the fossil fuel industry in the 67:42 transportation industry 67:44 but the thing that we have to recognize 67:46 is that when 67:47 we transform an economy whether it's a 67:50 green new deal or an industrial 67:51 revolution or a fourth industrial 67:53 revolution as they call it this 67:54 internet of things and all that all of 67:56 these transformation 67:58 technological transformations are not 67:59 new they started with the industrial 68:01 revolution and the industrial revolution 68:03 did displace 68:04 workers but you know we're not going to 68:07 turn into luddites and stop 68:08 technology we should be embracing 68:11 technological transformation we should 68:13 be embracing 68:14 robotics and automation as long as we 68:17 know why we're doing it 68:19 so i'm all for having robots do all the 68:23 repetitive and dangerous and precarious 68:25 work 68:26 but have people do the care work the 68:28 meaningful dignified work 68:30 with decent wages and benefits and 68:32 retirement and pension and all of that 68:35 so that becomes a social and political 68:38 discourse that we must have 68:40 instead of saying let's build walls 68:42 let's stop technological innovation 68:44 so we can preserve painful precarious 68:47 low-paying jobs 68:48 so we have to have a clear vision about 68:50 what we want in this 68:52 energy transition that being said 68:55 when we transition to decarbonize the 68:57 economy away from fossil fuels there 68:59 will be 69:00 resistance and there is resistance from 69:02 workers in those 69:03 industries and it's completely 69:05 understandable because they've been 69:07 thrown under the bus before not 69:09 necessarily just them but other workers 69:11 and other 69:12 manufacturing and so on because they're 69:14 being told 69:16 we want you to transition with us to 69:18 this new economy green economy 69:20 and we promise there will be jobs in the 69:22 solar industry there'll be jobs and 69:25 and wind turbines in this new economy of 69:27 the future 69:28 but we're not guaranteeing that those 69:31 jobs will actually be there for them in 69:33 their own communities 69:35 so the job guarantee vision is take 69:38 people 69:38 as they are where they are and 69:42 do on the job paid training to 69:44 transition 69:45 the economy so we're not telling people 69:48 learn how to code move to san francisco 69:50 and maybe there'll be a job for you in 69:51 the it sector 69:53 so take people as they are where they 69:55 are that has to be part of 69:57 our vision for every local community 70:00 to rethink and reimagine and redesign 70:03 its own economy based on 70:06 that core element which says we're not 70:10 going to throw people under the bus 70:12 we're not going to tell people to move 70:15 out of town and go find a job somewhere 70:17 else in the private sector pay for your 70:19 training and education out of pocket 70:21 get into student debt and then maybe and 70:23 how are you going to do this for workers 70:24 who are 70:25 relatively close to retirement they have 70:28 a major pension maybe 70:29 waiting for them in the fossil fuel 70:31 industry we have to have the federal 70:34 government 70:34 under right and guarantee a just 70:37 transition not with empty words 70:39 but by saying you're transitioning with 70:41 the same pension plan 70:42 you're going to have a jobs and and 70:44 benefits package and income package 70:46 that's comparable 70:47 to your fossil fuel employment right now 70:50 yes it's going to be expensive 70:52 which means unions are not going to be 70:54 able to pay for it employers are not 70:55 going to be able to pay for it 70:57 and the only way we rapidly transition 70:59 into this new universe 71:00 is for the federal government to 71:02 underwrite and guarantee that transition 71:05 states can participate in this guarantee 71:08 it could be part state part federal 71:10 but the federal government can afford it 71:12 can do this tomorrow 71:14 and when you talk to fossil fuel workers 71:17 and other labor unions who are 71:19 publicly you know hesitant to endorse a 71:22 job guarantee or especially the green 71:23 new deal 71:24 behind closed doors they say we've been 71:27 burned before 71:28 you know the labor movement in general 71:30 so all of these political empty words 71:32 about a just transition and 71:34 of course we want to clean energy and we 71:36 want the clean air we want we drink the 71:38 water we 71:38 we breathe the air of course we want the 71:40 future clean energy system 71:43 but not on our backs right 71:46 you have to guarantee this transition so 71:49 i think this applies not just to fossil 71:51 fuel workers but other industries that 71:53 will be 71:54 affected in the transportation industry 71:57 um 71:57 and in other industries the dairy 71:59 industry 72:00 whatever industry we see as uh at risk 72:05 in this in this category we can't throw 72:07 people 72:08 under the bus and we have to make sure 72:10 we we do this 72:11 on on a massive and rapid scale 72:14 and then the final thing i want to say 72:16 which was brought up earlier 72:18 this this thing that you hear from you 72:20 know talking heads on tv and economist 72:23 in particular who say well 72:24 you can't have a job guarantee because 72:26 we need unemployment to discipline 72:27 people 72:28 otherwise you know the the whole system 72:30 will you know 72:31 we're not going to have productive 72:32 workers without unemployment 72:34 which is bs nonsense because we have 72:37 tons of studies 72:39 by businesses employers who actually 72:42 tell you 72:42 we don't actually hire the unemployed 72:45 when you ask them who do you want to 72:46 hire 72:47 their top choice is somebody who's 72:49 already working for a competitor 72:51 right they're not even looking at the 72:53 especially long-term unemployed 72:55 their number two choice is somebody 72:57 who's working but maybe in another 72:59 industry not even in the same 73:01 related industry number three they say 73:03 well maybe 73:04 young college graduates uh or somebody 73:06 who's recently unemployed like recently 73:08 just a few weeks ago 73:09 or something like that but if you go 73:11 into long-term unemployment 73:13 the code is unemployable by which they 73:16 mean 73:17 women minorities returning citizens 73:19 people without 73:22 you know qualifications or education 73:25 high school degrees 73:26 or or people with disabilities and so on 73:30 this is where the job guarantee comes in 73:32 as a guarantee for 73:33 those individuals who are you know 73:35 typically 73:36 last to be hired during the economic 73:38 boom and first to be fired during a 73:41 recession 73:42 so that's the the kind of the buffer 73:45 automatic stabilizer that pavlina was 73:47 talking about 73:47 earlier it's guaranteeing employment no 73:50 matter what the private sector thinks 73:52 and we're not shifting the burden on you 73:54 to get the skills to get the education 73:55 and to compete 73:56 in this endless cycle of unemployment 73:59 we're guaranteeing that 74:01 you transition and help us build the 74:03 resources that the community needs 74:05 that the market is neglecting and is not 74:08 interested in producing 74:09 that the state or the federal government 74:11 is not interested in 74:12 in producing this is how we use 74:15 the you know people as they are where 74:17 they are do on the job training 74:19 so that we produce the resources that 74:21 the community needs 74:23 and all of it today the majority of it 74:25 will be in the green 74:27 transition area will be in the care 74:29 economy caring for people caring for the 74:31 planet caring for the elderly for 74:33 children 74:34 so i see that as a core feature of the 74:36 green new deal 74:37 we've we've done this before in the the 74:40 new deal era 74:41 we know how to do it better today the 74:44 the real 74:44 obstacles are political obstacles 74:47 ideological obstacles 74:49 which is why it's important to have 74:50 these conversations 74:52 to have a coherent vision for all of us 74:54 to push in the same direction 74:56 um and and with that i'll i'll stop here 74:58 and open it up for 74:59 for comments and and discussion thank 75:01 you again for for this session
:カバーブ
75:04 thank you so much fidel that was that 75:05 was outstanding 75:07 yeah um i want to bring this back to 75:10 uh renew um so we've got a couple of 75:14 contexts that really 75:16 uh have come out for me one is the 75:18 inherent instability of our 75:20 moment right whether whatever the source 75:24 is 75:25 um we can expect more 75:29 of these types of events of this type of 75:32 uh 75:32 collective experience in the future 75:35 right this return to normal i think is 75:37 is is is a myth right there 75:42 there's not going to be anything that 75:44 that looks like that 75:45 and secondly this idea of 75:48 of dignified work as a basic human right 75:52 i think it's so key to sort of frame 75:54 this whole conversation 75:56 and thinking about it especially i think 75:59 in terms of the 76:00 the work of care is so key right now 76:04 and i'm really excited about bringing 76:06 that that perspective to this 76:07 conversation 76:09 as we're thinking about renew new 76:11 england 76:13 and the work that needs to be done 76:15 across 76:16 communities of this region at the state 76:19 level 76:20 at the local level that's where i'd like 76:22 to go 76:24 and and start with a conversation um 76:26 from here 76:28 i'll also invite people to we're a small 76:30 group that's great 76:32 people can write in uh questions into 76:35 the 76:35 the chat or otherwise just raise your 76:38 hand and we'll have an opportunity 76:39 to uh to share some discussion 76:42 uh but i'd like to start with with that 76:44 question and maybe 76:46 bringing josh back in and then whomever 76:50 among our panel how do you see that 76:53 care work um coming out 76:56 and being manifested i guess 77:00 from the in the relationship between the 77:03 federal 77:04 project the federal work right getting 77:08 into the communities 77:09 paulina you've written about sort of a 77:10 democratic tendency 77:13 of of this type of project how are the 77:16 communities themselves 77:17 engaging with this uh job guarantee 77:21 directing the work so that we can be 77:23 sure that it's actually the work that 77:25 needs done 77:26 and uh that is responsive to the moment 77:30 so josh maybe i'll start with you and 77:32 then we can we can open it up to anyone 77:42 yeah um i mean i think the place 77:46 to start uh with 77:49 with that i mean there's a lot on the 77:51 table there it's a good question but i 77:52 think the place to start 77:54 is that um 77:57 you know what what pavlina said about uh 78:00 a jobs guarantee being extremely 78:03 politically popular and a good issue to 78:05 organize around 78:07 like that's reflected in polls but it's 78:08 also like very much reflected in my own 78:11 personal experience like i'm 78:12 i'm an organizer for the most part and 78:14 what i do is community organizing and 78:17 you know i think it's really interesting 78:20 that um uh 78:23 you know good jobs for all plays really 78:26 well 78:27 in community meetings on the doors 78:28 during campaigns just in one-on-one 78:30 conversations like 78:31 people actually are already very much in 78:34 favor of this idea but the challenge 78:37 you know in these conversations is 78:38 typically about raising 78:40 people's expectations about what's 78:42 possible like lots of people 78:44 who i talk to the main objection is that 78:47 they just don't think anything 78:48 is possible and that's not too 78:50 surprising honestly like 78:52 50 years of neoliberalism means like all 78:55 of our imaginations about what is 78:56 possible is just radically constrained 78:59 and and that's why i think you know the 79:02 legislation 79:03 that we've written and introduced and 79:04 are organizing around that's why i think 79:06 that legislation is so helpful because 79:09 you know the legislation is so concrete 79:11 uh because you can bring the 79:13 conversation back down to earth and say 79:15 look like if we passed such and such a 79:18 law in massachusetts we'd create 79:20 tens of thousands of jobs retrofitting a 79:22 million homes 79:23 uh over the next decade to increase 79:25 energy efficiency 79:26 and make homes healthier and safer safer 79:29 like removing 79:30 rodent feces and asbestos uh and like if 79:33 we pass this other law in rhode island 79:35 for example 79:36 we'd shut down all polluting industries 79:38 and like 79:39 use the and transition the workers give 79:42 them 79:43 uh as as fidel was saying like give them 79:46 um like free job training give them 79:49 pensions during 79:50 the job training like work with them 79:51 one-on-one to talk about 79:53 like what is the kind of work you'd like 79:55 to do and you know when you concretize 79:57 the conversation 79:58 in those in with community organizing 80:01 when you like bring it down to the 80:02 actual 80:03 like very specific level of like this 80:06 piece of legislation would do x y and z 80:08 and would get this closer to a jobs 80:10 guarantee 80:11 people that's how you sort of like 80:13 expand people's 80:14 imagination in terms of what's possible 80:17 and that's how you 80:18 it's it's that sort of like deep 80:20 community organizing that changes 80:22 people's perceptions of like what they 80:24 can win collectively 80:26 um yeah i think that's where i'd start 80:35 thank you uh could someone else like to 80:38 follow 80:38 on that 80:43 okay i would add something i mean i if i 80:46 could 80:47 yeah i'm also hearing this theme of sort 80:49 of um 80:50 some of the process issues and all the 80:52 things that get in the way of 80:54 what people are interested in achieving 80:55 and what actually happens and i think 80:57 you know 80:58 i look at it as sort of the the very 81:01 small scale 81:01 scale of the vermont state house and 81:03 sort of why business as usual is all 81:05 that ever sort of happens and sort of 81:06 really sort of nibbling around the 81:08 margins of things and i just 81:09 you know i it's not the most it's not 81:12 the most interesting part of it but the 81:14 process questions of sort of how those 81:15 things get 81:16 operationalized i think are a relevant 81:18 piece of it too 81:25 maybe i can say something about this um 81:28 in my experience um 81:32 the idea that the public sector can 81:35 just go out and plant some trees for 81:37 some reason 81:38 is very like remote like 81:42 people have so when they think about 81:43 local job creation 81:45 they think well which is the company 81:46 that creates the jobs you know how can 81:48 we get 81:49 more people in that company like okay if 81:51 we do infrastructure you know 81:52 like there is some infrastructure 81:53 traditional like you know to build but 81:56 the social and environmental work 81:59 is not the first thing that comes to 82:01 mind when 82:03 we talk about what the public sector can 82:05 do 82:06 and so you know i'm doing a project with 82:07 some of my students you know are doing 82:10 um you know proposals for local towns 82:12 and 82:14 you know in our conversation all of a 82:15 sudden one of the policy makers 82:18 comments was like they had a light bulb 82:19 it's like oh yeah i would i've been 82:20 thinking about having a pavilion for 82:22 such a long time 82:23 where it's a place where you know the 82:25 community would meet an artist and 82:26 you know uh there would be like 82:28 after-school activities and it's just 82:30 um it's i think that the job guarantee 82:34 opens up this vision of the kind of work 82:37 and i think that's a place also to go to 82:38 because 82:39 when when people realize that actually 82:41 yeah that is a job it can be a job that 82:44 could prioritize 82:45 um the way we go about creating these 82:48 opportunities and 82:49 we you know people can leave the 82:52 straight jacket 82:53 of how do you appease a company to give 82:55 them the you know the right trainees or 82:57 get the right grant for the 82:59 exact jobs placement and job development 83:01 but 83:02 we do face a bit of a problem because um 83:04 while we must push 83:06 at the local level and there are costs 83:07 that these localities are bearing 83:09 because they're dealing with 83:10 unemployment and with poverty and with 83:11 homelessness and all of that 83:13 there are costs that we can um reduce by 83:16 creating jobs 83:17 there are some limits to the physical 83:20 space 83:20 that that they operate with i mean 83:23 vermont is a unique case because you're 83:25 not 83:25 tied to the balanced budget amendment 83:27 and so it's a perfect place to really 83:29 begin 83:30 um you know to you know you know to 83:33 appropriate some budgets and create some 83:34 local opportunities but 83:35 there is there is i think that funding 83:37 issue that um 83:38 it has to be much more surgically 83:41 implemented and it has to be crafted in 83:43 a 83:43 in a much more careful way than if we 83:46 had 83:46 federal funding that comes from you know 83:48 biden's packages and says here you go 83:50 create some jobs and now we can deploy 83:53 those funds 83:54 for local job creation i mean i i'm 83:57 sorry if somebody else wants to jump in 83:58 but 83:59 you know i vermont as laboratory is 84:02 often sort of the way we talk about it 84:04 and think about it because 84:05 and so i think that while i recognize 84:08 the scale of some of these things i also 84:10 think you know we're talking about 84:11 a lot about how we use these federal 84:12 funds as a catalyst right like to sort 84:14 of jump start some of these things and 84:16 what that might look like 84:17 and also just not letting vermont hide 84:20 behind the excuse either that we don't 84:21 have the fiscal capacity that there's a 84:23 whole lot more we could do 84:25 and that we also sort of buy into this 84:27 idea that 84:28 whatever the money's not there the 84:30 people don't don't want it 84:31 whatever and sort of hide behind those 84:33 excuses so you know i 84:35 just like let's go vermont like i'm you 84:38 know 84:39 start it somewhere like somebody's got 84:40 to start it so let's try it right 84:45 yeah thank you um 84:49 you pablina you you'd discuss and anyone 84:52 can jump on this question as well 84:54 um you discussed the idea of 84:58 a non-profit model and a social 85:01 enterprise model in terms of 85:03 implementation right um and i'll drop a 85:06 few other resources for folks into the 85:08 chat here in a moment 85:09 but i wonder if you could just describe 85:11 a little bit more on your view 85:14 on a grassroots community-led jobs 85:17 guarantee 85:19 approach which seems like it would be 85:22 especially relevant 85:24 both from an organizing perspective and 85:27 from uh you know a regionally 85:30 appropriate perspective yeah i think 85:33 that 85:34 just implementing a job guarantee 85:37 at a national local level would need to 85:40 have a multi-prong 85:42 approach and that in some ways you 85:45 because we are thinking about 85:47 creating employment opportunities with 85:48 the person in mind 85:50 that there will have to be multiple 85:52 approaches to this 85:54 you know you could have a federal agency 85:56 that does the job creation and provides 85:58 a lot of 85:58 federal employment we could have federal 86:00 government providing funding to 86:02 localities and municipalities and say 86:04 okay hire 86:06 anyone you need to hire to do what you 86:08 are doing and you don't have the 86:10 staffing needs and the funding resources 86:12 but there's also that other 86:16 reality that there are on the ground 86:18 organizations that are already dealing 86:20 with social deprivations and there are 86:22 already community groups who are doing 86:24 the community gardens 86:25 who are doing the after-school 86:27 activities who are going to 86:29 you know nursing homes and 86:32 you know and so why not empower and 86:35 mobilize 86:36 them uh cooperatives too um you know 86:39 should not be outside the purview of 86:41 kind of support 86:42 and job creation and so in a way the 86:45 idea was that 86:47 we don't have to reinvent the wheel and 86:49 we can simply tap in the local potential 86:51 and resources 86:52 and um uh you know create you know use 86:56 those 86:56 as sites for job creation but 87:00 um i think again it's more of a horses 87:02 for courses kind of approach you know if 87:04 you're thinking about youth unemployment 87:06 you know you might be thinking about 87:08 very specific apprenticeships so i'm not 87:10 you know entirely opposed to having uh 87:13 private 87:14 uh companies participate in some of 87:16 these on-the-job training but you know 87:18 here we're really talking about public 87:19 money 87:19 for the public good and uh 87:23 you know the missing gaps sort of you 87:25 know the public services i think can be 87:27 filled with 87:28 both non-profit and municipal work and 87:32 federal 87:35 employ you know employment 87:43 there was a definitely a strong focus 87:45 here on 87:46 on the green jobs and uh on and then 87:49 also in the chat related to 87:51 ecological restoration for example i 87:53 mean 87:54 a lot of this does come around to the 87:56 type of work 87:58 and the type of jobs and our current 88:00 moment and what's needed 88:01 um so i'm wondering 88:05 you know in terms of meeting people 88:08 where they are 88:09 and meeting the needs again of of 88:11 communities 88:13 um what what specific type of work 88:17 might we prioritize and organize around 88:22 and what what types of jobs 88:24 recognizing that this isn't all about 88:26 infrastructure jobs 88:28 and in the way it's conventionally 88:30 thought of right 88:32 there's there's work that people need to 88:35 be able to do 88:36 immediately that doesn't necessarily 88:38 require a lot of training 88:41 what type of work especially in in the 88:43 in 88:44 green jobs the environment and so on 88:47 that we really ought to be prioritizing 88:49 and then how do we get people 88:51 involved with that type of work 88:56 um i'm happy to address some of these uh 88:59 questions so i'm i'm part of a 89:00 coalition here in appalachia called 89:02 reimagine appalachia which is 89:04 ohio west virginia pennsylvania and 89:07 um in kentucky about 100 organizations 89:11 and the blueprint if you if you look at 89:13 the reimagine appalachia website the 89:15 blueprint 89:16 is sort of a mini green new deal for the 89:18 region which includes 89:19 restarting the ccc administration and 89:22 i'm 89:23 happy to report that there will be a 89:24 bill coming out soon 89:26 uh for a 21st century ccc administration 89:30 uh to uh repair the damage 89:33 of of the last century and create 89:36 thousands of jobs in 89:37 in these four states alone and to invest 89:40 in regenerative agriculture and local 89:42 uh food production uh which reduces the 89:45 carbon footprint for transportation and 89:47 so on 89:47 uh so this is just one example another 89:49 component of this ccc bill will be a 89:52 re-entry component where the jobs 89:54 training program
カバーブ:
89:55 starts on day one of incarceration not 89:58 after people are released with no jobs 90:00 no housing no 90:02 so it reduces also it addresses other 90:04 issues related to unemployment 90:06 mental health and so on so we're looking 90:08 at a comprehensive vision 90:10 that creates jobs that sustain people 90:13 that allow people to transition 90:15 back into decent jobs and decent wages 90:18 with dignity 90:20 but also helps us repair some of the 90:22 damage of the last 90:23 century and so so another component of 90:26 of the green jobs proposal by 90:28 by the coalition reimagine appalachia is 90:31 broadband infrastructure number three 90:34 it's the uh investing in renewable 90:38 energy production 90:39 locally which includes the manufacturing 90:41 of the technology 90:43 locally so that's how you accelerate the 90:45 decarbonization 90:46 both of transportation the 90:49 decarbonization of 90:50 consumer use of electricity and heating 90:53 and cooling 90:53 but also decarbonization of industrial 90:56 production production itself 90:57 and doing this on an industrial scale 91:00 this also requires 91:02 i mean on a green new deal kind of 91:03 national framework and and this 91:05 addresses some of the questions in the 91:06 chat 91:07 about consumerism and all that because 91:09 american society is a consumer society 91:11 if we continue to con consume at this 91:13 rate we're not going to save the planet 91:16 we're doomed so a lot of it at the 91:18 global level has to do with 91:20 reducing uh use of energy you're 91:23 reducing waste 91:24 i mean why do we need a piece of salad 91:26 driven all the way from california to 91:28 the east coast right so local 91:30 agriculture is important 91:32 but also investing in research and 91:35 development 91:36 because even if we take today's 91:37 technology solar panels and wind 91:39 turbines and we actually scale this up 91:42 to meet the energy needs 91:43 of the us and and the rest of the world 91:46 we're going to have an ecological 91:47 disaster in terms of extractivism 91:49 especially in the global south 91:50 so we need to invest in research and 91:52 development in material science 91:54 research and development so that we 91:56 actually produce 91:58 what we call a circular economy where 92:00 every product you buy 92:02 comes with a user manual that includes a 92:04 few pages to say this is my living will 92:06 this is how you dispose of me this is 92:08 how 92:08 you bring me back into life into a 92:10 circular economy 92:11 that's really and we're not there yet to 92:13 be honest we don't even know what we're 92:14 going to do with the solar panels 92:16 when they go you know obsolete in 40 92:18 years landfills 92:20 we haven't invested enough research and 92:22 development 92:23 into that so this has to be part of the 92:26 answers 92:27 the technology we have is good but not 92:29 good enough we can go far with what we 92:31 have we can 92:32 jump start this transition but we also 92:34 have to commit 92:35 the the resources to figure out how do 92:38 we create a truly circular economy 92:40 so mmt as some people are said in the in 92:43 the chat 92:44 yes we deal with the risk of inflation 92:46 and we we say yes government spending we 92:48 can safely spend more 92:49 but we're not implying we should spend 92:51 more and consume more 92:52 at the same pace with the ecological 92:54 impact we're saying we have the capacity 92:57 just like we sent people to the moon we 92:59 can do the same and figure out how to 93:01 invent a circular economy 93:03 and how would how to fix the the damage 93:06 so we have the tools but we're not 93:08 saying you know let's consume at the 93:10 same rate 93:11 and and you know burn the hell out of 93:13 the planet 93:14 which we could do if we wanted but 93:16 that's not what we're 93:17 advocating for maybe 93:22 i mean maybe i can also uh answer your 93:24 question
チャーネバ:
93:25 if you want to bring it to the you know 93:27 even smaller 93:28 area like a town level like what would 93:31 you do 93:32 um so as i said i you know i have my 93:35 students looking at two communities 93:36 uh in new york with the idea that new 93:39 york was once the forerunner of the new 93:41 deal 93:42 and yet we're not doing the new deal 93:44 projects now 93:45 to be a forerunner but um but what 93:47 they're doing is uh 93:48 just like steph's analysis showed you 93:50 know who are the unemployed 93:52 you know who are the underemployed i 93:54 mean that's i think the first step 93:55 you need to know like who you're going 93:56 to be creating jobs for 93:59 um then we were looking at very specific 94:01 deprivation so one of the communities 94:03 for example 94:04 has a lot of single moms that are 94:05 unemployed another community 94:07 it's not the case um um this community 94:10 that has a lot of single moms that are 94:11 unemployed 94:12 has a lot of pollution issues and asthma 94:14 way above national average 94:16 okay the other another the other 94:18 community actually has a lot more 94:19 problems with mental health 94:20 issues okay and then the community that 94:23 has more health mental health issues 94:25 actually have a lot more environmental 94:26 groups like they actually 94:27 do have like these non-profits and 94:29 social groups that are doing 94:30 environmental work but they don't 94:31 actually have enough 94:32 doing sort of the mental health support 94:34 work and so i think that these are the 94:36 sort of things that you could do 94:37 at the local level to figure out like 94:40 what are the gaps and the social 94:41 needs that you uh might address 94:44 with job creation and um i i do 94:48 think that um if this debate you know 94:51 about biden's infrastructure plan you 94:53 know what's like infrastructure like 94:54 it's so important 94:55 like it's just we just have to you know 94:57 draw the line and i feel the same way i 94:59 want to talk about green jobs 95:01 so in a book i argue the job you do is 95:02 always green because if you take care of 95:05 a person 95:06 like that's green like you know you you 95:09 are 95:10 essentially you know not allowing human 95:12 waste to neglect the sort of social 95:14 class that we have 95:15 and of course you have to also think 95:17 about the envelope within which you know 95:18 we're organically connected to the 95:20 natural environment but it's also us 95:22 and so like suppose we weatherized all 95:24 homes 95:25 but we had homeless people would that be 95:28 a green policy like they all weatherized 95:29 but we've got 95:30 people on the street right or supposedly 95:32 everybody had a good job 95:34 but we were polluting the environment 95:35 just like the comment uh you know in the 95:37 in the box 95:38 um so it's just they're not separable 95:40 and 95:41 so when we talk about green work i think 95:44 uh 95:45 addressing care needs very much falls 95:48 under green work it's not just 95:49 environmental care needs other people 95:51 care and so if you want to think about 95:54 you know what kind of funding might be 95:55 coming down the pipeline from 95:57 from biden and we'll see how the 95:58 politics play out but uh you know there 96:00 will be some things that will be ongoing 96:02 like the public health crisis is not 96:03 going to go away tomorrow just because 96:04 you know we have 96:05 vaccination rates um there will be 96:07 people on the ground that will have to 96:09 do some sort of logistical support so we 96:10 can keep thinking about that and that 96:12 would be an obvious place where i think 96:13 there will be money 96:14 uh at the local place so these would be 96:17 just some examples of how you might 96:18 think about like local job creation that 96:20 is public service 96:21 it's not you know it and it is 96:24 addressing some specific need 96:28 thank you pablina and i know you 96:29 probably need to go soon 96:31 uh so i i do want to say thank you so 96:33 much for joining us 96:36 yeah i'll try to tune in through the 96:39 phone but um i do need to step away from 96:40 my computer 96:41 um i hope you enjoyed this thank you so 96:43 it's been fantastic to have you join us 96:45 so thank you so much 96:47 um we'll go to andrew had a question and 96:50 then i'd like to invite uh any of the 96:52 panelists to 96:53 ask one another a question and then 96:55 we'll probably wrap it up 96:57 andrew go ahead hi thank you so much can 97:00 you hear me 97:02 yes okay great um i wanted i was just 97:06 writing in the chat that um i'm very 97:09 interested in the role 97:11 um both state employees unions 97:14 as well as the national unions um 97:19 might be able to play in 97:22 a federal jobs guarantee program 97:25 as well as a regional jobs guarantee 97:29 program 97:30 i'm i'm also interested 97:33 uh i think uh pavlina 97:37 talked about a federal agency being 97:39 created 97:40 or the federal government giving money 97:41 to states or non-profits joining 97:44 together 97:45 as three different sorts of paths to a 97:48 job guarantee 97:49 and i'm interested in how unions 97:53 may have played a part in other job 97:54 guarantee programs 97:56 and how they might play a part in a new 97:59 job guarantee program 98:01 i'm sorry if that's several questions at 98:03 once 98:05 yeah um i'll take a stab at some of that 98:07 if that's all right 98:09 um so i this is actually making me think 98:12 of my 98:12 days when i served as americorps vista 98:14 here in vermont actually 98:16 and um for those of you who may not know 98:18 about americorps vista 98:20 um it's a way for various non-profits 98:22 who need additional staffing 98:24 to get an extremely low paid young 98:27 person to 98:28 help them with all kinds of uh work 98:31 that would fall under the care economy 98:33 um you know removing invasive species 98:36 working and supporting a library which 98:38 is what i did 98:39 i'm putting on um you know continuing 98:41 education programs 98:43 um stocking food shelves and organizing 98:45 food shelves um 98:46 so you know the role of these jobs 98:50 however 98:50 you know i'm not saying we use this same 98:52 framework but these jobs are 98:54 unfortunately 98:54 not well paid very very low paid and 98:57 cannot sustain a family or anything like 98:59 that 99:00 and so um we talked about you know frame 99:02 uh 99:03 starting at a minimum setting a minimum 99:05 pavlina of 15 99:06 an hour in benefits but we know that 99:10 for a lot of unionized workers in 99:11 particular um that is not 99:14 going to be attractive for for so many 99:17 um and so the role of unions 99:19 is to really improve all the jobs that 99:21 are available 99:22 including possibly any jobs in the 99:24 public sector 99:26 that would be created under a job 99:27 guarantee 99:29 and um you know right now there's 99:31 actually a lot of organizing happening 99:33 nationally of non-profits um who are 99:36 doing this kind of care work but 99:38 unfortunately um 99:39 you know their workers are usually 99:40 underpaid uh 99:42 with the you know sometimes 99:44 unfortunately excuse that 99:45 you know this because this is mission 99:46 driven work um you know you should be in 99:49 it um 99:50 for the nature of the work and not for 99:52 the money well the 99:53 fact of the matter is we still need to 99:55 you know um put a roof over a head and 99:56 food on our tables um 99:58 and you know you need a better paying 100:00 job increasingly to do that these days 100:03 um wages are notoriously low as steph 100:06 showed us here in vermont so um you know 100:09 i think the unions are just to organize 100:10 organize and that's why i also 100:12 highlighted the importance of not only 100:14 having a jobs guarantee but also 100:16 expanding and protecting the right to 100:17 organize that's what really 100:19 brought the new deal to its height and 100:21 that's what we need 100:23 to really make a robust jobs guarantee i 100:26 believe 100:31 absolutely i'll i'll add a few 100:35 thoughts to this i mentioned earlier 100:37 this rosa luxembourg series that we're 100:39 we're doing this month 100:41 especially today's panel i highly 100:43 recommend taking a look at that 100:44 andrew where you heard labor leaders 100:48 talking specifically about why and how 100:51 to organize for a job guarantee 100:53 from a from a labor movement perspective 100:56 one of the 100:56 one of the things that we was mentioned 100:58 this afternoon 101:00 is fighting for the legal right for 101:03 sympathy strikes to build the labor 101:05 movement so that 101:06 you know when when one union takes a hit 101:08 when one industry takes a hit 101:10 the rest of the labor movement is there 101:12 to support uh and that is 101:14 that is not legal today and and that's 101:16 just not right uh 101:18 and if we organize to get this to push 101:20 back against these laws in these 101:22 regulations 101:23 then we're on to something in terms of 101:25 building this uh this movement 101:26 in terms of the role of labor unions for 101:29 example 101:30 in protecting um prevailing wage laws 101:34 which sustain certain standards for 101:36 wages and and 101:38 and this has been you know under attack 101:40 in state after state after state 101:42 across the country when you have an 101:45 organized 101:46 labor movement not just in the 101:47 construction industry but across 101:49 the board we can set those minimum 101:51 standards and the job guarantee 101:53 can help us build towards that so when 101:56 you when you create a job guarantee 101:57 program at the local level 101:59 and you end up hiring a few people who 102:01 will be technically doing construction 102:03 type work 102:04 they can you know claim the prevailing 102:07 wage 102:09 legislation as the standard for their 102:11 wages they can 102:12 join a union they can join a union 102:15 apprenticeship program 102:16 unions can be part of the design of a 102:19 job guarantee to build resources for the 102:21 community 102:23 and do the on-the-job paid training this 102:25 is something that 102:26 you know our generation completely 102:27 forgot that it used to be normal 102:30 for people to get a job join a union 102:33 on day one and become an apprentice 102:36 learn the skills on the job 102:37 not go get the training pay for it out 102:40 of pocket and then maybe if you're lucky 102:41 you find a job 102:42 so this role we can reclaim the role of 102:45 unions 102:46 in the apprenticeship and the job 102:47 training program not just in 102:48 construction and manufacturing and 102:50 in the trades but across the board 102:53 including healthcare including 102:55 elderly care child care this is the the 102:58 world that we 102:59 should be allowed to imagine and to 103:02 create 103:03 uh the the the problem is that we have 103:06 we have been 103:06 so beaten and weakened as 103:10 as people as a movement for for decades 103:13 that we're not even 103:14 allowed to think about the possibilities 103:16 of how we organize this 103:18 um so i'll leave it at that there's 103:19 there's plenty of uh 103:21 additional discussion to be had about 103:23 how labor unions should 103:25 um what role they they can play in and 103:28 next week by the way at 1pm 103:30 we're having the third and final 103:32 installment of this series and will be 103:33 breakout sessions 103:35 so that i would invite all of you to 103:37 join us and we'll have a lot of labor 103:38 leaders joining us 103:40 and academics and policy people and 103:42 organizers to unpack a lot of these 103:44 questions including 103:45 the question that andrew was asking 103:47 today 103:49 thanks so much farel and i added a few 103:51 other i added a link to that um 103:54 uh roselux session also 103:57 um to ayanna presley's uh 104:01 press announcement and the renew new 104:03 england as well as 104:05 several faqs on the jobs guarantee 104:09 uh that really provide a lot of the the 104:11 basics 104:12 um so i really appreciate the focus here 104:15 on sort of the systemic 104:17 issue that we're both dealing with and 104:20 that we're proposing 104:22 um and also the cultural piece right 104:24 like really the 104:25 the fundamental uh constraint of 104:27 reimagining 104:28 and and how deep some of this goes at a 104:31 very cultural 104:32 uh level and i know that's we should all 104:36 check out on mass 104:37 and liz medina's 104:40 radio labor radio for more on that 104:45 so i'd like to briefly we're just about 104:48 out of time but briefly 104:49 invite any of the panelists if you'd 104:52 like to 104:52 say a last word um and then 104:56 i'll turn it over to gary steward who's 104:58 with the organizing 105:00 committee with uh vermont renews 105:04 and uh gary's gonna provide some ideas 105:06 about how people can 105:07 continue to get involved with renew new 105:09 england 105:11 so steph liz fadell or josh 105:20 i don't i don't have all that much to to 105:22 add just want to thank the 105:24 fellow panelists for a really really 105:26 rich discussion 105:28 i certainly learned a lot and yeah 105:30 really really appreciate 105:32 all of your time 105:36 thank you yeah and i will definitely 105:39 second that thank you all so much for 105:40 taking some time out on a 105:42 well what is here at least a very 105:44 beautiful afternoon 105:46 and uh thanks also liz for 105:49 dropping in the podcast link check it 105:52 out you can actually listen to that 105:53 while you're outside so 105:55 that will be nice uh gary please close 105:58 us off and thank you all once again 106:00 and i look forward to continuing this 106:02 work 106:04 together 106:07 thanks man and thanks for the 106:10 extraordinary panel excuse me 106:13 extraordinary panelists for 106:14 just an incredibly rich dialogue 106:18 uh so much to uh 106:21 get galvanized about so thank you so 106:23 much for uh 106:25 contributing a great way of looking 106:27 forward 106:28 and doing some productive work again i'm 106:31 gary steward 106:32 i'm an active member of champlain valley 106:35 gsa 106:38 with the ecosocialist working group as 106:40 well as 106:41 the socialist education working group 106:44 and i've been very active 106:45 with renewed new england vermont 106:49 again for those who may not be familiar 106:51 renew new england alliance 106:53 which renew vermont is part of is 106:56 composed of 106:57 at least 150 different organizations 107:00 focusing on a judge transition from 107:02 fossil fuel 107:02 economy and an exploitive economy to one 107:06 that 107:06 focuses on job justice 107:10 environmental justice racial justice 107:13 gender justice 107:14 to create an ecologically just and 107:17 sustainable society 107:19 and really excited to let you know 107:22 some of the things that renew vermont is 107:25 involved with uh just a sec here 107:30 uh first um we've been introducing 107:33 a number of bills um in this legislative 107:37 excuse me session uh since the main 107:40 focus will be on kobit 107:42 uh this year um a lot of these bills 107:46 even once they get approved won't be 107:48 able to be acted on until next year but 107:50 we have some 107:52 great bills coming in and that we can 107:55 build on next year there are some things 107:59 that people 107:59 can actually become involved with 108:03 one we're asking people to sell senator 108:06 leahy to back the thrive 108:08 agenda uh i can put that 108:12 in the chat room 108:16 um the thrive agenda is basically the 108:19 same what we've been talking about here 108:22 and uh there's a bill that has been 108:25 introduced and should be voted on 108:28 this session in congress 108:32 let me get that here to you 108:36 and really it is basically a green new 108:38 deal 108:39 um for workers 108:43 so uh let me go back 108:47 so it's just very easy just click on 108:49 that and 108:51 sign it and uh and we have a good ally 108:54 in senator leahy 108:56 so that is very good we're also 108:59 supporting 109:00 a vermont bipod led and 109:03 land access and opportunity act and with 109:06 that one you would email your legislator 109:09 uh let me make a copy of that and then 109:13 connect you here so then 109:16 you can participate in that as well 109:22 let me uh get that for you i thought 109:24 that 109:25 okay just a sec here we go 109:33 may make a copy of that and come here 109:41 just click on that and you'll be able to 109:44 do that 109:46 and let me go back again um 109:49 again that is uh a joint you know 109:52 effort led by seating power vermont to 109:54 urge the house committee on general 109:56 housing and military affairs 109:58 to take up house bill 273 the vermont 110:02 bipock-led land access and opportunity 110:04 act 110:05 to help uh communities within the 110:09 uh community to have better access to 110:13 getting land which is a real issue here 110:16 uh within vermont um 110:19 the next is to support our regenerative 110:23 economy bill i know matt you've been 110:25 very involved with that 110:27 as well and that 110:30 is has been introduced let me 110:34 uh share this link to where you can 110:39 contact your legislator if you're in 110:41 vermont 110:42 to support that 110:48 let's see here okay 110:55 so we've been doing some really good 110:57 work to address 110:59 um regenerative agriculture and 111:01 regenerative 111:02 uh economics here in vermont uh 111:06 in in our legislation legislative body 111:08 they don't like hearing the green new 111:10 deal but what 111:11 basically what renew vermont and renew 111:14 new england alliance are doing 111:15 is a green new deal uh and 111:19 lastly let me get 111:22 here real quick 111:28 and our housing justice petition 111:38 yes we're looking at housing justice for 111:41 all vermonters 111:42 this is a issue that we do need people 111:45 to support 111:46 for affordable safe equitable and 111:49 healthy housing 111:50 for all vermonters and again this 111:54 is something that all the member states 111:56 within 111:57 the renewed new england alliance are 111:59 supporting 112:01 as well and let me put that right here 112:05 and then really lastly 112:09 is that we have one more coming event 112:12 that's coming up and which is may day 112:16 and we have some exciting things coming 112:19 up 112:19 for mayday uh which is focusing 112:22 on just transition and vermont this is 112:25 part of the thrive 112:27 agenda and i'm going to put a link 112:30 to that event once my 112:33 computer uh speeds up 112:37 a bit uh it's a little bit slow right 112:41 now 112:41 uh okay here we go 112:47 but anyway we do have an event that is 112:50 coming up 112:51 um later uh for may day 112:55 and uh we would like for y'all to 112:57 participate 112:59 uh in that if you're in the state of 113:01 vermont i'll just have to wait 113:04 for the computer to proceed i'm sorry 113:06 about that 113:07 it's a little slow right now but uh 113:11 anyway that's pretty much it and the 113:13 only other thing i would say 113:15 is if if you're in new england 113:19 uh check what your uh organization 113:22 sister organization is doing 113:24 that if it's part of the renew new 113:26 england alliance then 113:27 plug in to their efforts on focusing on 113:30 green justice zones 113:32 uh sustainable will 113:36 green retrofitting of housing and food 113:38 security 113:39 here in vermont we have working 113:41 committees who are working on these and 113:43 we are looking for people to participate 113:46 in these organ and these working groups 113:49 so if you are interested um you can 113:52 contact matt 113:54 or you can contact me i'll put my email 113:56 in 113:57 and we're looking for community leaders 114:00 um 114:02 whatever's right uh to be part of this 114:05 process 114:06 so uh thank you very much 114:10 uh let's see here forgive me 114:13 putting in my information and uh 114:17 feel free to contact us thank you man 114:18 for this opportunity 114:20 absolutely thank you so much gary and uh 114:23 thanks to our captioner 114:25 um so i appreciate your help thank you 114:29 so much to the whole l4e team and of 114:31 course our panelists 114:33 and uh leaving you with uh some music 114:35 that fidel just dropped in here so 114:41 all right thanks a lot everyone 114:45 thank you everyone thank you 114:58 i love the music 114:59 [Laughter] 115:02 me too 115:11 if you share your screen the sound will 115:13 be better 115:18 we've got to leave it in the ground you 115:20 solar all around 115:22 save ourselves 115:41 we need a new deal 115:46 that's what we need we 115:52 need a new deal 115:55 we need 116:11 we don't need you hanging around 116:16 how much money can you use yourself 116:39 we need a new 116:52 it was 117:07 that's what we need 117:19 that's what we need 117:26 [Music] 117:33 we need a green deal come on 117:36 get clean we meet it up right now 117:52 [Music] 118:03 we need what we need 118:20 [Music] 118:24 that's what we need 118:35 yeah yeah all right 118:38 all right that was the rally song for 118:41 the movement 118:42 where did you find every movement 118:45 this is my friend and that's uh recorded 118:48 in my living room there 118:50 wow allen is a as a community organizer 118:54 labor organizer and um 118:56 artist singer songwriter so he wrote the 119:00 song 119:01 you're a very special guest in a very 119:02 special panel today 119:04 and still going here let me turn that 119:08 off 119:10 thank you for sharing that thank you 119:12 yeah here's 119:13 here's the link if you want to save it 119:15 and play it it's 119:17 cool better quality when you play it on 119:18 your own computer 119:22 all right y'all thanks so much thank you 119:25 yeah thank you so much 119:27 for your presentation it was a pleasure 119:29 to be here thank you 119:30 all right bye bye


0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿