2021年4月18日日曜日

2021/04/16 クライン、ヴァルファキス、ケルトン、(&Lawn's GPI)

短縮版2
Towards a geniune progress indicator - Yanis Varoufakis, Naomi Kelin & S...
元動画の50:00頃

N:
how important is it to fight for different economic indicators in a moment like this because so long as gdp is the measure of success this will be wielded against us as a weapon.
kelton:
definitely i mean there are um people i think it's important and there are people like there's a very uh interesting guy named phil philip lawn he's an australian economist and he has developed uh an alternative um measure of well-being he calls it the gpi the genuine progress indicator takes into account a variety of things uh including benefits surrounding investments in climate cost benefits uh you know a more comprehensive way to think about you know how to how to talk about a country's improvements in national well-being over time and he's trying to get the oecd world bank others to you know adopt this is because he's built this stuff out and it's sort of there for the taking if he could get um you know broader interest in disseminating and tracking measures like this i think it's important.
V:
 something that can i can i'm sorry right no you go ahead go ahead no i i just wanted to play devil's advocate for just a second stephanie on this you see the problem with capitalism is that whatever indicators you and i create and follow uh the fact of the matter is that if you are indebted as an individual as a company as a household and you have a mortgage that is um non-performing and you have people trying to foreclose on your house or if you are a finance minister because i've had a terrible experience and you have to grow your tax revenue in order to try to pretend that you're repaying a debt that can never be repaid then whatever indicators wonderful economies come up with they're irrelevant so the the this is me playing the davis advocate we need far more radical change than that we need to have major debt restructuring both at the private and the public level for countries that don't have the exhibit and privilege of the united states you know our country here cannot print their own currency as you know therefore we cannot go through the process of creating money the way you described the fed being able to um there are many countries around the world either because they're not printing their own currency or because they are borrowing in the currency that they are not printing so i will shut up with two questions the first one is primarily for naomi we have three economic blocks we have the united states major economic blocks the united states the european union and china how far away are each one of them or how close are they to your right notion of a green new deal and that's yeah that's one question the second question is can we ever imagine being able through simply macroeconomic means to ameliorate for the fact that the missed appeals of the world given the ownership structure of capitalist corporations will always have the power and the motivation to be austerian in order to prevent the masses the many from gaining power.

kelton: 
 i'm going to push back on giannis pushback because to say that we need different metrics is not to say choosing a different metric and then you you're done right switch metrics said you don't have to do anything else to make material improvements the idea of the genuine progress indicator the way i think about it is that it helps to do what brian is talking about right we have to see each other and we have to see the problem so if we had you know i'm just using the genuine progress indicator in his example.
 but it's like a mirror it forces you to hold a mirror up to the country and to evaluate where are you falling short across a whole range of things that you're paying attention to and in terms of you know the idea that capitalism is always going to be you know riddled with these flaws that it is by design a system which is oppressive to those who find themselves at will workers right you you are you are a worker who um off you know usually has your health care tied to your employment you are um you can you know wake up one morning with a job and wake up the next day without a job and without the health care and all the other things so one of the things that i would love to see us making more progress on is moving toward you know something like an fdr economic bill of rights where you do establish public options a public option in the labor market public option in banking so that you have you know the freedom to opt out of uh financial relationships with wall street banks or whatever it is public option in education public colleges and universities becoming tuition free gives agency right um knowing that you have a secure retirement that you don't have to depend upon 401ks and other uh investment schemes to try to build some sense of security for you know your later years in life this is what and and and a right to a clean environment a job at a decent wage you know all of the things that fdr talked about those were things that senator sanders in his campaign you know put forward as part of his platform that people ought to have basic rights secured in these areas.
 and i think you know it's still capitalism but i i guess i was brought up very much on minsky and hyman minsky i think one of the great economists of the last century minsky used to say there are as many varieties of capitalism as heinz has pickles you know and the heinz pickles slogan is 57 varieties so you have the kinds of capitalism that failed badly leading up to the great depression the kind of capitalism that fdr helped to build that you know produced better outcomes for millions of people rising incomes and and better economic conditions and better labor conditions and so forth and then as we whittle those away over the years from reagan especially on uh then finance capitalism and and a harsher version and so i think there are just ways to um to you know introduce safeguards various protections for people that get us to um you know the kind of a world that i think we're all talking about trying to build.
V:
except stephanie that if you give a public option to the labor market you're effectively allowing workers to do what mr appeals workers did and therefore collapse capitalism i don't believe you can give a genuine public option and i'm all for it giving a giant public option to workers in the labor market without actually collapsing the labor market that's why you know my dogma if you want because i'm not we don't have time to discuss it is that you can't really get rid of austerity until you get rid of tradable shares but that's another discussion i'm sure 英語 (自動生成)

N:
gdpが成功の尺度である限り、これは武器として私たちに対して使用されるため、このような瞬間にさまざまな経済指標のために戦うことはどれほど重要です。
ケルトン:
確かに私はそれが重要だと思う人がいることを意味しますそして彼がオーストラリアの経済学者である限りフィルフィリップという名前の非常に面白い人がいるような人がいますそして彼は彼がそれを本物のgpiと呼んでいる幸福の代替のum測定を開発しました進捗指標は、気候コスト便益への投資を取り巻く便益を含むさまざまなことを考慮に入れています。あなたは、国の長期にわたる国民の幸福の改善について話す方法を知っていることについて、より包括的な考え方を知っています。 oecdの世界銀行に他の人にこれを採用してもらうのは、彼がこのようなものを作り上げたからです。彼がこのような対策の普及と追跡に幅広い関心を持っていることを知ってもらうことができれば、それは重要だと思います。
V:
 申し訳ありませんが、申し訳ありませんが、先に進んでください。これについて、悪魔の代弁者を2番目のステファニーで演じたかっただけです。資本主義の問題は、あなたと私が作成し、事実に従うことです。問題の問題は、あなたが個人として、会社として、家計としてお世話になっていて、住宅ローンが不良で、人々があなたの家を差し押さえようとしている場合、またはあなたが財務大臣である場合、ひどい経験をしたので、返済できない借金を返済しているふりをするために税収を増やす必要があります。無関係なので、これは私がデイビスの提唱者を演じているので、米国の展示と特権を持たない国のために、民間レベルと公的レベルの両方で大規模な債務再編を行う必要があるよりもはるかに根本的な変更が必要ですあなたが知っているように、ここの私たちの国は自国の通貨を印刷できないことを知っています。したがって、FRBが説明したようにお金を稼ぐプロセスを通過することはできません。自国通貨を印刷しない、または印刷していない通貨で借りているため、2つの質問で締めくくります。最初の質問は主にナオミのためです。3つの経済ブロックがあります。米国には主要な経済ブロックがあります。欧州連合と中国は、それぞれがどれだけ離れているか、またはグリーンニューディールの正しい概念にどれだけ近いかということです。2番目の質問は、単純にマクロ経済的手段で改善できることを想像できるかどうかです。資本主義企業の所有構造を考えると、世界の見落とされた魅力は、大衆が権力を獲得するのを防ぐために、常に権力とオーストラリア人になる動機を持っているという事実。ええ、それは1つの質問です。2番目の質問は、資本主義企業の所有構造を考えると、世界の見落とされた魅力が常にオーストラリア人になる力と動機を持っているという事実を改善するために、単にマクロ経済的手段を通じてできることを想像できますか?大衆が権力を獲得するのを防ぐために。ええ、それは1つの質問です。2番目の質問は、資本主義企業の所有構造を考えると、世界の見落とされた魅力が常にオーストラリア人になる力と動機を持っているという事実を改善するために、単にマクロ経済的手段を通じてできることを想像できますか?大衆が権力を獲得するのを防ぐために。

ケルトン: 
 異なるメトリックが必要であると言うことは、異なるメトリックを選択することではなく、適切な切り替えメトリックが完了したため、giannisプッシュバックをプッシュバックします。マテリアルを改善するために他に何もする必要はないと述べました。本物の進行状況インジケーターの考え方は、ブライアンが話していることを正しく行うのに役立つということです。お互いを確認する必要があり、問題を確認する必要があるため、私が使用しているのは彼の例では、本物の進行状況インジケーター。
 しかし、それは鏡のようなものであり、それはあなたに鏡を国に向けて持ち、あなたがしていることの全範囲にわたってどこに足りないのかを評価することを強制します。資本主義は常にこれらの欠陥に満ちていることを知っているという考えに注意を払い、あなたの観点から知っているのは、それは設計上、意のままに労働者であることに気付く人々に抑圧的なシステムであるということです。あなたが知っている労働者は通常あなたのヘルスケアがあなたの雇用に結びついていることを知っていますあなたはあなたが知っていることができます仕事である朝目を覚まし、仕事なしでそしてヘルスケアと他のすべてのものなしで翌日目を覚ます私たちがさらに進歩することを望んでいることの1つは、あなたが知っているように、あなたが労働市場の公共オプションで公共オプションを確立するfdr経済的権利章典のようなものを知っていることです。ウォールストリートバンクまたはそれが公開されているものとの金銭的関係をオプトアウトする自由教育公立の大学で授業料が無料になるオプションは、あなたが安全な退職をしていることを知っている代理店に、あなたが晩年を知っているためにある程度の安心感を構築しようとするために401ksや他の投資スキームに依存する必要がないことを知っています人生において、これは何であり、そしてきれいな環境への権利であり、まともな賃金での仕事あなたはfdrがそれらについて話したことのすべてがあなたが知っている彼のキャンペーンで上院議員が彼のプラットフォームの一部として提唱したことを知っていますこれらの分野で基本的な権利を確保する必要があります。あなたが人生の晩年を知っているために、ある程度の安心感を構築しようとするために、401ksや他の投資スキームに依存する必要がありますこれは何であり、そしてあなたがすべて知っているまともな賃金での仕事をきれいな環境にする権利ですfdrがそれらについて話したのは、あなたが知っている彼のキャンペーンで上院議員がサンダース上院議員が彼のプラットフォームの一部として提唱したものであり、人々はこれらの分野で基本的権利を確保すべきである。あなたが人生の晩年を知っているために、ある程度の安心感を構築しようとするために、401ksや他の投資スキームに依存する必要がありますこれは何であり、そしてあなたがすべて知っているまともな賃金での仕事をきれいな環境にする権利ですfdrがそれらについて話したのは、あなたが知っている彼のキャンペーンで上院議員がサンダース上院議員が彼のプラットフォームの一部として提唱したものであり、人々はこれらの分野で基本的権利を確保すべきである。
 そして私はあなたがそれを知っていると思います」まだ資本主義ですが、私はミンスキーとハイマンミンスキーで非常に育ちました。前世紀のミンスキーの偉大な経済学者の一人は、ハインツがあなたが知っているピクルスとハインツピクルスのスローガンと同じくらい多くの種類の資本主義があると言っていたと思いますは57種類あるので、大不況に至るまでひどく失敗した種類の資本主義があります。fdrが構築に役立った種類の資本主義は、何百万人もの人々の収入を増やし、より良い経済状況とより良い労働条件を生み出したことを知っています。等々、そして私たちが何年にもわたってリーガンからそれらを削り取るにつれて、特にええと、資本主義とより厳しいバージョンに資金を提供するので、私たちをあなたに連れて行く人々のためのさまざまな保護を導入することを知っている方法があると思います私がそのような世界の種類を知っている私たち全員が構築しようとしていると思います。
V:
ステファニーを除いて、労働市場に公的オプションを与えると、労働者が労働者に訴えることを効果的に行うことができるようになり、資本主義が崩壊するので、本物の公的オプションを与えることができるとは思わない。実際に労働市場を崩壊させることなく労働市場の労働者に巨大な公的選択肢を提供するので、私は議論する時間がないので、必要に応じて私のドグマを知っています。緊縮財政を本当に取り除くことはできないということです。あなたが取引可能な株を取り除くまで、しかしそれは私が確信している別の議論です 

Genuine progress indicator - Wikipedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genuine_progress_indicator

Genuine progress indicator

GDP vs GPI in US.jpg

Genuine progress indicator (GPI) is a metric that has been suggested to replace, or supplement, gross domestic product (GDP).[1] The GPI is designed to take fuller account of the well-being of a nation, only a part of which pertains to the size of the nation's economy, by incorporating environmental and social factors which are not measured by GDP. For instance, some models of GPI decrease in value when the poverty rate increases.[2] The GPI separates the concept of societal progress from economic growth.


Philip Lawn - Wikipedia

Philip Lawn

Philip Lawn is a former associate professor at Flinders University and is currently a visiting lecturer in environmental and ecological economics at The University of Adelaide, South Australia.[1]

The main topics of his work are sustainable development and Genuine Progress Indicator studies.

Contents

  • 1 Publications
  • 2 Career
  • 3 References
  • 4 External links

Publications

Lawn has written and edited books and articles on the notions, benchmarks, and policy aspects of sustainable development, including:

  • Sustainable Development Indicators in Ecological Economics (Edward Elgar Publishing, 2006)
  • Frontier Issues in Ecological Economics (Edward Elgar, 2007)
  • Sustainable Welfare in the Asia-Pacific (Edward Elgar, 2008, co-edited with Matthew Clarke)
  • Environment and Employment: A Reconciliation.[1]

Career

Lawn began his teaching career as a Research Officer at the Southgate Institute for Health, Society, and Equity at Flinders University. He moved to The University of Adelaide in 2017/2018 to teach the course 'East Asian Economies'. This course also includes some South-East-Asian countries, and focuses on genuine progress of these countries.[2]

Dr. Lawn founded The International Journal of Environment, Workplace, and Employment (Inderscience) in 2004 and served as the founding editor of the journal until 2009. He is also a guest editor of the International Journal of Environment and Sustainable Development.[3]

Lawn developed and advances the use of the Genuine Progress Indicator(GPI) as a more indicative indicator of social well-being to Gross Domestic Product, and has developed a set of consistent indicators for most countries.[4]

Lawn is also Research Scholar at the Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity, and a member of the Wakefield Futures Group of Concerned Scientists.[5]

References

  1. ^ a b Philip, Lawn. "Philip Lawn". Center for Humans & Nature. Retrieved 2018-10-24.
  2.  "East Asian Economies course page". University of Adelaide: MyUni. Retrieved 2018-10-24.
  3.  "Philip Lawn". Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity. Retrieved 2020-03-26.
  4.  "Philip Lawn – Sustainable Prosperity Conference". Retrieved 2020-03-26.
  5.  "Macro n Cheese: Sustainability in a Modern Money Economy with Steven Hail & Phil Lawn". macroncheese.com. Retrieved 2020-03-26.

External links


Genuine Progress Indicator GPI vs GDP in South Asia - Philip Lawn -  July 2018

Resolving the Climate Change Crisis: The Ecological Economics of Climate Change (English Edition) 1st ed. 2016 版, Kindle版


短縮版1
Did the new deal fail? Naomi Klein, Yanis Varoufakis & Stephanie Kelton ...
元動画の48:00頃


N:
something i've been thinking about around when people talk about the new deal um they often say but yeah but it failed right it failed because actually it didn't pull the us into a growth position so because and because we define failure as anything short of growth right um and we define success a successful economy as an economy that's in a boom you know we all know the narrative right it wasn't the new deal that pulled the that ended the the the great depression it was the second world war the post-war boom that was also what set off suburban sprawl and and a level of consumption that is at the heart of the climate crisis so did and i always kind of accepted this idea that the green that the new deal failed but i guess i want to ask the economist like did it fail because it did create jobs and it pulled a lot of people out of poverty do we have to start telling people that it didn't fail?
V:
of course it didn't fit.
Kelton:
no i agree with i agree with the honest no i did not say that it failed of the millions of people and people talk that way about japan.

V:
i was just going to say stephanie talk to the descendants of the millions of people oh okay go .
Kelton:
no no no i i i think you could probably talk a lot more about that i was just going to say you know it's in some ways it reminds me of the discussion that we keep hearing about japan today that um japan has you know been growing very slowly has very uh low inflation uh you know usually around one percent or less than one percent and somehow we've decided we you know uh the profession academic economist in particular policymakers that japan is is uh is a fail it's it's a failure that they don't have rapid growth and i and i go to japan and i look around that everything is beautiful the infrastructure is is first-rate things work people are happy you know it's it's not evident that uh that japan is experiencing deep economic difficulties uh it's just that people have decided that economies are supposed to grow faster than two percent and inflation is supposed to be a little bit higher and if you don't achieve those metrics then somehow you know it's it's viewed upon it's viewed as a as a failure in some sense failure of policy.

V:
just a a quick snippet um i think i have the right to speak on this matter because i'm calling you from the epicenter from ground zero of austerity and of the dead spiral that you were describing stephanie here our 1933 moment came in 2014 you know three years after our 1929 moment which was you know uh in 2011 here in greece we already had lost 28 25 of gdp right um now if there was a new deal at that moment and things that they stabilized and started improving on a per capita basis and people actually you know had fewer wrinkles on their faces and could sleep at night without worrying how you know what kind of day they would have the next morning that would have been a majestic success and we didn't have that we had a continuation of the downward spiral which we still have today so if the new deal did for americans that we you know the favor that we um failed to provide to our people in 2014 it was a major success also soil conservation the sense of community all those intangibles that effectively stopped america from becoming a fascist country america would have become a fascist country without the new deal how do you measure the value of having avoided fascism.

N:
私がずっと考えていたのは、人々がニューディールについて語るとき、よくこう言うのですが、そうですね、でも失敗したんですよ。実際には、アメリカを成長軌道に乗せられなかったので、失敗したんです。 しかし、私がエコノミストに聞きたいのは、ニューディールは失敗だったのか?
V:
もちろん、失敗だったと思います。
ケルトン:
いや、正直なところ、私は失敗したとは言っていません。
V:
何百万人もの人々や人々が日本についてそのように話していますが、私はstephanieが何百万人もの人々の子孫と話していると言おうとしていました。
ケルトン :
日本は非常にゆっくりとした成長を続けており、インフレ率も非常に低く、通常は1%前後、あるいは1%未満ですが、どういうわけか、学術的な経済学者、特に政策立案者は、日本は急速な成長を遂げていないのは失敗だと決めつけています。 日本が深刻な経済的困難に直面していることは明らかではありません。ただ、経済成長率は2%を超え、インフレ率はもう少し高くなるはずだと人々が決めていて、その基準を達成できなければ、ある意味では政策の失敗だと見られているのです。

V:
私は緊縮財政の震源地からあなたに電話をしているので、この問題について話す権利があると思います。そして、あなたが説明したデッドスパイラルの震源地から電話をしています。2011年にギリシャではすでにGDPの28 25を失っていました もしその時にニューディールがあったとしたら......もし安定して一人当たりの状況が改善され、人々は実際に顔のしわが減り、夜も心配なく眠れるようになりました。もしニューディールがアメリカ人のために行われたとしたら、それは大きな成功だったと言えるでしょう。しかし、私たちにはそれがなかったので、今日のような下降スパイラルが続いています。

www.DeepL.com/Translator(無料版)で翻訳しました。














22:20〜28:30, 31:40~36:00
43:40〜46:10
ケルトン

53:55~
ブライアン・イーノ

抜粋
"There is no planet B" - Fascinating exchange between Naomi Klein and St...




 
 LTIO#3 The Austerity Doctrine in the Time of Coronavirus 5,797 回視聴
•2021/04/16 にライブ配信 486 3 共有 保存 DiEM25 チャンネル登録者数 8.46万人 For the 3rd episode of Let's Talk It Over, Naomi Klein, Stephanie Kelton, Yanis Varoufakis, Brian Eno and Frank Barat discuss what impact the coronavirus crisis as had on world economy and how it has been used to further entrench world inequality. They will also talk about how another virus, austerity, as enabled this crisis to happen in the first place. Make sure to subscribe to our page not to miss future shows. SUBSCRIBE --------------------- DiEM25: https://www.youtube.com/c/DiEM25offic...​ SUPPORT US --------------------- Join DiEM25: https://diem25.org/join​​ Donate to DiEM25: https://diem25.org/donate​

approach

 

21:00~48:00

 whereby governments now yes they learned the lesson of fairly wages of boosting demand during this pandemic and they will continue to do this uh especially the united states boris johnson talks talks the talk in britain i haven't seen the numbers to back it up the european union also talks the talk but it is of course absolutely and totally exterior in its practice but nevertheless there is this discussion that coronavirus sort of alluding to what brian said before may be giving us a new turning point where austerity is no longer in vogue uh i am very skeptical about this i'm not going to explain why this is time for me to shut up and pass the button i think i'm stephanie should come in because i can feel the pulsating need to answer brian's questions okay well i wish that i had been as smart as naomi who i think was jotting down brian's questions and i just sat here and listened to them so i don't i don't have uh i don't have where did that money come from that's what's quick with the question where did the money come from oh well where is it is it are we going to have to pay it back in the future you know so these are liquid.

 

ケルトン:

 let's do let's do that where did the money come from because um you know i think we have right now in the rear view mirror just very very clear examples of exactly how governments muster the fire power to commit to spending trillions and trillions of dollars when just months before everybody was talking about you know if we want to spend money we have to find money how will you pay for it i mean if you think back to you know 2019 and um the presidential campaign and the democratic primaries and you know we had a very crowded uh slate of democratic presidential hopefuls you you yanez naomi and i know well uh some of the people who were vying for the vice president for the presidential nomination on the democratic side and people had you know platforms that ranged in ambition from very very progressive um big ticket things you know a 16 trillion dollar green new deal uh cancelling all student loan debt i mean very ambitious all the way down you know the scale to the other end the the more moderate sort of things but every single candidate at every turn was dogged by the question how will you pay for it where will the money come from and every candidate attempted to demonstrate where the revenue would come from how the taxes would be increased to generate the revenue to allow for this spending to take place everything happened in this sort of a budgeting framework right the idea that you have to find the money and pay for your spending and then it happened right and this is just months later really and it's march of 2020 and all of a sudden without really a moment's hesitation congress begins spinning out multi-trillion dollar spending packages and not just in the us not just congress but around the world governments are committing huge sums of money and so when we say you know how did they do it where did the money come from here's what happens congress writes a bill and in our case in march the biggest bill was known as the cares act that was a 2.2 trillion dollar piece of legislation that legislation is congress's way of ordering up okay 2.2 trillion dollars from its bank from the federal reserve congress did not go out hat in hand to china or to the investor class or to anyone else and raise up 2.2 trillion they don't have to congress has the power of the purse congress can commit to spending money that they do not have right what they do is pass the bill and if the votes are there the money follows in a in a very real sense the votes are the pay for the votes are where the money comes from once the bill is is drafted and once the votes are there and the legislation is passed the spending happens as the central bank the government's fiscal agent carries out the payments that have been authorized by congress on behalf of the u.s treasury now how do they carry out payments wait for this hey i can't hold up my keyboard because.

 ケルトン:

 そうしよう そうしよう そのお金はどこから来たのか なぜなら......今、バックミラーに映っているのは、ほんの数ヶ月前には誰もが「お金を使いたければお金を探さなければならない」と話していたのに、政府が何兆ドルも何十兆ドルものお金を使うことを約束する火力をどうやって集めたのかという、非常に明確な例だからです つまり、もしあなたが 2019年の大統領選挙と民主党の予備選を思い出してみてください 民主党の大統領候補者は非常に混雑していました ヤネス・ナオミさんや私もよく知っていますが 民主党側で大統領候補の副大統領を争っていた人たちの中には 非常に進歩的なものから大口のものまで様々な野心的なプラットフォームを持っている人がいました 16兆ドルのグリーンニューディールや学生ローンの帳消しなど、非常に野心的なものから、穏健派のものまで、さまざまなスケールのものがありましたが、どの候補者もあらゆる場面で「どうやってお金を払うのか」という質問に悩まされていました。支出を可能にするための収入を得るために、どのように増税するのかを説明しようとしました すべてはこのような予算編成の枠組みの中で起こりました お金を見つけて、支出のために支払わなければならないという考えです そして、それが起こったのです ほんの数ヶ月後の2020年3月、突然、一瞬のためらいもなく、議会は何兆ドルもの支出を始めました。 アメリカだけでなく、議会だけでなく、世界中の政府が巨額の資金を投入しています。どうやって資金を調達したのかというと、議会が法案を作成します。私たちの場合、3月の最大の法案は「ケアズアクト」と呼ばれる2兆2千億円の法案でした。 2兆2千億ドルの法案です。この法案は、議会が連邦準備銀行に2兆2千億ドルを発注するためのもので、議会は中国や投資家層などに2兆2千億ドルを調達したわけではありません。 議会は財布の権限を持っています 議会は持っていないお金を使うことを約束することができます 何をするかというと、法案を可決して、票があればお金がついてきます 非常に現実的な意味で、票がお金の出所となります 法案が起草され、票があって法案が可決されると、支出が起こります 中央銀行として、政府の財政代理人として、米国の国庫に代わって議会が承認した支払いを行います。 どうやって支払いを行うのでしょうか?これを待っていたのですが、私はキーボードを持ち上げることができません。

www.DeepL.com/Translator(無料版)で翻訳しました。

 i'm using my laptop but if i could hold up my keyboard i would hold up my keyboard because that's how the payments are carried out the federal reserve uses nothing more than a computer keyboard to credit the appropriate bank accounts with digital dollars that are known as reserves and then the recipient of those funds has their account credited by their bank so this is all done electronically through crediting of bank accounts and that's where the money comes from so we've seen it we saw it with the 2.2 trillion in march they did it again in december of last year a 900 billion dollar package and then just last month congress came in with one more cove rescue package 1.9 trillion again a piece of legislation that sent just one set of instructions to the federal reserve go change the numbers up in the appropriate bank accounts if you got that 1400 check you got a credit to your account the key board uh did the work and the digital dollars appeared in your account if you're getting extra unemployment compensation that's how that's happening so what we're entering now is a different phase and i think this is where i'm going to wrap up with this giannis but this is where i'm i'm in agreement with you i don't think that we have you know broken the austerity mindset altogether because what democrats are talking about now with this climate slash infrastructure package is you know something that's been proposed by the white house something on the order so far of 2.25 trillion but this time they want to quote unquote pay for it they don't want to pass this bill the way the last three bills that i just described were passed they want to offset the spending which means they want to send two sets of instructions to the central bank one set of instructions that tells them to go out and credit the bank accounts of the workers who will do the work repairing america's crumbling infrastructure putting up electric vehicle charging stations and doing care work and all the rest.

 

 those people will get credits to their accounts the other set of instructions would tell the central bank to debit mark down the numbers in the accounts of many corporations because congress has decided that it wants to write a bill that says we're going to spend money but we're also going to raise taxes so two sets of instructions and this is falling more into a kind of i don't want to necessarily call it austerity but when biden went before the american people and talked about this he said that his plan would raise more revenue than he is even proposing to spend and he added that that would help reduce the deficit and debt long term so when you hear stuff like that that's definitely beginning to sound an awful lot like uh an administration that's starting to worry about deficits and debt.

 28:40

 私はノートパソコンを使っていますが、もしキーボードを掲げることができたら、キーボードを掲げたいと思います。連邦準備銀行は、コンピュータのキーボードだけを使って、準備金として知られるデジタル・ドルを適切な銀行口座に入金し、資金を受け取った人は銀行から口座に入金されます。 3月には2兆2,000億円、昨年12月には9,000億円、そして先月、議会はさらに1兆9,000億円の救済策を打ち出しました。 9兆ドルです。これも1つの法案で、連邦準備銀行に、該当する銀行口座の数字を変更するよう指示しました。今、私たちが入っているのは別の段階で、私はここでジャニスの話を終えようと思うのですが、ここで私はあなたに同意します。私たちは緊縮財政の考え方を完全に断ち切ったわけではないと思うのです。というのも、民主党が気候変動対策やインフラの削減などについて話しているのは、ホワイトハウスが提案した2兆2500億円規模のものです。 民主党が今話しているこの気候変動対策とインフラ整備のパッケージは、ホワイトハウスが提案した2兆2500億ドル規模のものですが、今回は「言葉」ではなく「お金」で賄おうとしています。先ほど説明した過去3回の法案のようにこの法案を通すのではなく、支出を相殺しようとしているのです。

 もう1つの指示は、中央銀行に多くの企業の口座の数字を引き下げるように指示しています。議会は、お金を使うが増税もするという法案を書きたいと決めているので、2つの指示があり、これは必ずしも緊縮財政とは呼びたくありませんが。緊縮財政とは必ずしも言いたくありませんが、バイデン氏が米国民の前でこの話をした際には、自分の計画では支出を提案するよりも多くの収入を得ることができ、それが長期的には赤字や債務の削減につながると付け加えました。このような話を聞くと、確かに赤字や債務を心配し始めている政権のように思えてきます。

 28:40

www.DeepL.com/Translator(無料版)で翻訳しました。

man:

 NAOMI?

  NAOMI:

 yeah um i mean i feel like stephanie and i have had this debate a little bit where i i just am like i'm really in favor of raising taxes on corporations and the wealthy and i work i get the and i think i think you are too like in theory um we want to do it not because we need it to pay for this but because we have absolutely untenable levels of inequality and we need redistributive policies because inequality of the kind that we have is a moral hazard it's it's it's it's it's epically dangerous that we have a billionaire class with so much excess capital that they're able to not only buy off our political class but build multiple escape routes including literally their planet bees right the the uh the uh the slogan of the climate justice movement is there is no planet planet b but um jeff bezos and elon musk beg to differ because they're they're building rocket ships to go there uh to escape the mess they've made and i think that that's um it is it's a moral hazard for the wealthy to not have to live in the mess that they create the the rockets to mars are an extreme expression of this but i think we're seeing the retreat of the wealthy into sort of gated castles of various kinds um in extreme forms throughout the pandemic right and i think the sort of stay at home orders have really accelerated that process where it's like you know the home has the classroom the home has the boardroom the home has everything that you need and anything that you don't have can be delivered by drone or through some no touch technology and so on so i i don't i i'm interested stephanie that you that you feel that that that the that the tax increase is the tell that we are going to face austerity because my fear is that if we don't have the tax increase that it increases our chances of a couple years down the road being told oh we've we've driven up the deficit so much that now we can't do anything more and we know that even though two point you said two five is a staggering sum it's also not enough um you know if we want to have uh climate action on this at the speed and scale that we actually need to to to prevent catastrophic warming it's about a third of the size of the spending that we need so i'm worried that if we don't increase taxes and increase revenue that it accelerates the point at which we get told sorry coffers are empty we can't do anything um but but uh tell me why i'm wrong stephanie because.

 NAOMIさん?

  NAOMI:

 ステファニーと私は、企業や富裕層への増税に賛成していますが、あなたも理論的にはそうだと思います。私たちが再分配政策を必要としているのは、絶対に手に負えないレベルの不平等を抱えているからです。気候正義運動のスローガンは「プラネットBは存在しない」ですが、ジェフ・ベゾスとエロン・マスクはそれとは異なり、自分たちが作った混乱から逃れるために、プラネットBに行くロケットを作っています。富裕層が自分たちの作った混乱の中で生活しなくて済むようにするためのモラルハザードだと思います 火星へのロケットはその極端な表現ですが、パンデミックの中で、富裕層が様々な種類の門構えの城のようなものに退避するのを極端な形で見ていると思います。つまり、家には教室があり、家には会議室があり、家には必要なものがすべて揃っていて、必要のないものはドローンやノータッチの技術を使って届けられる、というような状況です。私が興味を持ったのは、ステファニーさんが、増税は緊縮財政に直面することを告げるものだと感じていることです。また、あなたが言った2ポイントの2.5ドルは驚異的な金額ですが、それだけでは十分ではありません......壊滅的な温暖化を防ぐために必要なスピードと規模で気候変動対策を行いたいのであれば 壊滅的な温暖化を防ぐために必要な支出の3分の1程度なので、増税して収入を増やさないと、「財源が空っぽなので何もできません」と言われる時期が早まるのではないかと心配しています......でも、なぜ私が間違っているのか教えてください。

 31:40

 

kelton:

 all right so here's the thing i think that almost no one any longer believes the coffers are bare the deficits of the past constrain the spending capacity of the future we were told that with the obama deficits we need a simpson polls commission we have to have austerity we're not going to be able to survive my god the deficit the deficit so we got austerity and we got the pivot to austerity we got trump trump comes in and he wants to do these huge tax cuts and people like larry summers right who was treasury secretary under president clinton he was obama's senior economic advisor head of the national economic council larry goes ballistic larry hates the idea of the republican tax cuts he does one of his interventions he goes all over the media in november of 2017. larry's all over the place and he's saying if the republicans pass these tax cuts these are his words we will be living on a shoestring for decades to come because of the increase in the deficits we will be living on a shoestring for decades to come republicans pass the tax cuts the following month deficits increase cbo says by 1.9 trillion over 10 years we have a huge increase in deficit what happens growth picks up a little bit unemployment goes down a little bit inequality widens inflation stays low coronavirus comes and we're spending trillions and trillions of dollars so what i'm saying first is i think everyone can now see that you know the government doesn't have to keep its powder dry we don't have to run small deficits or anything like that in order to be able to afford to do things in the future now the bigger point for me naomi is this and i did a thread yesterday.

 
https://twitter.com/stephaniekelton/status/1382045472580366344?s=21

 because i get really agitated about where i think this administration is going right now and the mistakes i see them making so here's what we have the buying administration says 2.25 that's what they come out with and they want to pay for every penny of it mostly through increased taxes on corporations they want to take the corporate income tax rate from 21 percent back up uh up to 28 right republicans dropped it from 35 percent to 21. democrats won't go from 21 to 28. well biden does but already a number of democrats are saying no they're pushing back they don't want to go to 28 they're buying into this we'll lose competitiveness and all that sort of stuff maybe we'll go to 25. now as soon as you do that you've given up some revenue so then what do you do do you then scale down the ambition of your spending package because you've lost some revenue so you say well we can only do a smaller package now do you start fighting over different taxes to increase do you really think do you really think that in this senate that we have today that you have 50 democrats who will vote for a slew of tax increases i guarantee you there is no there is not support for a wealth tax forget about it impossible what about all the rest of the things that you might imagine that democrats could do that you're gonna have a hell of a fight i'm i'm seriously concerned that the votes aren't there if the votes are there terrific go for it they're not there joe manchin is not going to vote for a tax increase yeah so so here's the thing that i said in this thread i said if the votes are there great go knock yourselves out push taxes up do your offsets and and you know play play the pay for game go do it but what if the votes aren't there i want to know that there's a plan b and so i suggested a plan b yesterday the irs commissioner testified yesterday before i think the senate finance committee uh senator wyden's committee the irs commissioner comes in and he sits down and he says you know if we had enough funding to enforce the tax laws that are already on the books we could get an extra one trillion dollars a year that's 10 trillion over 10 years which by the way is the same number that people like ed markey and aoc are saying we should be 10 trillion not 2.25 so kelton comes on and does a big twitter thread and says hey has anybody noticed that there's 10 trillion in low hanging fruit here you don't have to vote to raise a single tax give the irs the resources they need let them go out and generate you 10 trillion and go for the much bigger package so that's where i am.

 36:00

  31:40

ケルトン

 過去の赤字が将来の支出能力を制約するということを、もはや誰も信じていないのではないでしょうか。オバマ政権の赤字については、シンプソン調査委員会が必要だと言われました。ラリー・サマーズはクリントン大統領の下で財務長官を務め、オバマ大統領の上級経済顧問として国家経済会議の議長も務めました。ラリーは共和党の減税案を嫌っており、2017年11月にはメディアで大騒ぎしました。共和党がこの減税案を可決したら、赤字が増えて今後何十年も細々と暮らしていくことになるだろう、というのがラリーの言葉です。 10年間で1兆9000億ドルの赤字増加です。成長が少し回復し、失業率が少し下がり、格差が広がり、インフレ率は低いままです。コロナウィルスが発生し、何兆ドルものお金を使うことになります。

 
https://twitter.com/stephaniekelton/status/1382045472580366344?s=21

 私は、今の政権がどこへ行こうとしているのか、そして彼らが犯している間違いについて、本当に腹が立っているのです。しかし、すでに多くの民主党員が、28%にはしたくない、競争力が失われるとか、そういう話を信じているので、25%にしようと言っています。そうするとすぐに歳入が減ってしまうので、歳出パッケージの野心を縮小することになります。増税に賛成する民主党員が50人もいると思っているのでしょうか?富裕層税は絶対に賛成されません。このスレッドで私が言ったことは、もし票があれば、自分たちで頑張って税金を上げて、オフセットをして、ペイフォーゲームをやってくださいということです。しかし、もし票がなければ、私はプランBがあることを知りたいのです。昨日、私はプランBを提案しました。IRS長官がやってきて、座ってこう言いました。「もし、すでに施行されている税法を施行するのに十分な資金があれば、年間1兆ドルの追加が可能です。 25 そこでケルトンが登場し、ツイッターで大々的に語りました。「誰もが気付いたと思いますが、ここには10兆ドルもの低空飛行の果実があります。

 36:00

 

 私は今、この政権がどこに向かっているのか、そして彼らが犯すであろう過ちについて、本当に腹を立てています。しかし、すでに多くの民主党員が、28%にはしたくない、競争力が失われるとか、そういう話を信じているので、25%にしてはどうかと言っています。そうするとすぐに歳入が減ってしまうので、歳出パッケージの野心を縮小することになります。増税に賛成する民主党員が50人もいると思っているのでしょうか?富裕層税は絶対に賛成されません。このスレッドで私が言ったことは、もし票があれば、自分たちで頑張って税金を上げて、オフセットをして、ペイフォーゲームをやってくださいということです。しかし、もし票がなければ、私はプランBがあることを知りたいのです。昨日、私はプランBを提案しました。IRS長官がやってきて、座ってこう言いました。「もし、すでに施行されている税法を施行するのに十分な資金があれば、年間1兆ドルの追加が可能です。 25 そこでケルトンが登場し、ツイッターで大々的に語りました。「誰もが気付いたと思いますが、ここには10兆ドルもの低空飛行の果実があります。

 36:00

 

/////

ケルトン:

 やろう」お金はどこから来たのですか。私たちが今リアビューミラーにいるのは、ほんの数か月前に政府が何兆ドルも何兆ドルも費やすことを約束するために火力を集める方法の非常に明確な例です。誰もがあなたのことを話していました私たちがお金を使いたいのなら私たちはお金を見つけなければなりませんあなたはそれをどのように支払うのですかええと、民主的な大統領候補のスレート、あなたはyanez naomiであり、私はよく知っています。民主的な側の大統領指名のために副大統領を争っていた人々の何人かは、非常に進歩的なumbigから野心に及ぶプラットフォームを知っていました。あなたが知っているチケットのこと16兆ドルの緑の新しい取引すべての学生ローンの借金をキャンセルする私は非常に野心的であることを意味しますあなたはもう一方の端までの規模がより穏やかな種類のものであることを知っていますが、あらゆるターンのすべての候補者はあなたがそれをどこで支払うのかという質問に夢中になりましたお金はどこから来て、すべての候補者は、この支出が行われることを可能にするために税金がどのように増額されるかから収入がどこから来るのかを実証しようとしました。お金を見つけてあなたの支出を支払うと、それは正しく起こりました、そしてこれは本当に数ヶ月後ですそしてそれは2020年の行進でありそして本当に瞬間なしで突然ですためらい議会は数兆ドルの支出パッケージをスピンアウトし始め、米国だけでなく議会だけでなく世界中の政府が巨額の資金を投入しているので、あなたがそれをどのように行ったかを知っていると言うと、お金はどこから来たのですか?これが議会が法案を書くことであり、私たちの場合、3月の最大の法案は、2.2兆ドルの法案であるケア法として知られていました。議会は、中国や投資家クラス、あるいは他の誰かに手を差し伸べて、2.2兆ドルを調達しませんでした。議会は財布の力を持っている議会は彼らが正しいことをしていないお金を使うことを約束することができます法案を可決し、投票があればお金は非常に現実的な意味で続きます投票は支払いです投票は、法案が起草され、投票が行われ、法律が可決されると、中央銀行が議会に代わって議会によって承認された支払いを実行するときに支出が発生する場所です。私たちの財務省は今、彼らがどのように支払いを実行するのか、これを待っていますねえ、私はキーボードを持ち上げることができません。

 

 私はラップトップを使用していますが、キーボードを持ち上げることができれば、キーボードを持ち上げることになります。これは、支払いが行われる方法であるためです。連邦準備制度は、コンピューターのキーボードを使用して、既知のデジタルドルを適切な銀行口座に入金します。準備金として、そしてそれらの資金の受取人は彼らの銀行によって彼らの口座に貸方記入されるので、これはすべて銀行口座の貸方記入を通して電子的に行われ、そこからお金が来るので、私たちは彼らが行進する2.2兆でそれを見たのを見ました昨年の12月に9000億ドルのパッケージで再びそれを行い、それからちょうど先月の会議でもう1つの入り江救助パッケージ1が入ってきました。連邦準備制度に1セットの指示だけを送った9兆の法律は、1400の小切手を受け取った場合、適切な銀行口座の番号を変更します。あなたが追加の失業補償を受け取っている場合、デジタルドルがあなたの口座に現れたので、私たちが今入っているのは別の段階であり、これが私がこのジャンニで締めくくるところだと思いますが、これは私がいるところです私はあなたに同意しているのですが、緊縮財政の考え方を完全に破ったことを私たちが知っているとは思いません。なぜなら、この気候スラッシュインフラストラクチャパッケージで民主党が今話しているのは、ホワイトハウスによって提案された何かを知っているからです。これまでの注文は2です。25兆ですが、今回は見積もりなしの支払いを見積もりたいのですが、今説明した最後の3つの法案が通過した方法でこの法案を通過させたくないので、支出を相殺したいので、2セットの指示を送信したいのです。中央銀行に、電気自動車の充電ステーションを設置し、その他すべてのケア作業を行うアメリカの崩壊しつつあるインフラストラクチャを修復する作業を行う労働者の銀行口座に入金するように指示する一連の指示。私が今説明した最後の3つの法案が可決された方法でこの法案を可決したいのですが、支出を相殺したいのです。つまり、中央銀行に2セットの指示を送信して1セットの指示を送信して外出してクレジットするように指示します。アメリカの崩壊しつつあるインフラを修理し、電気自動車の充電ステーションを設置し、介護作業などを行う労働者の銀行口座。私が今説明した最後の3つの法案が可決された方法でこの法案を可決したいのですが、支出を相殺したいのです。つまり、中央銀行に2セットの指示を送信して1セットの指示を送信して外出してクレジットするように指示します。アメリカの崩壊しつつあるインフラを修理し、電気自動車の充電ステーションを設置し、介護作業などを行う労働者の銀行口座。

 

 それらの人々は彼らの口座にクレジットを得るでしょう他の一連の指示は中央銀行に多くの企業の口座の数字を借方に記入するように指示するでしょうしかし、私たちは税金も引き上げるつもりなので、2セットの指示とこれは私が必ずしもそれを厳格とは言いたくない種類に陥っていますが、ビデンがアメリカ人の前に行ってこれについて話したとき、彼は彼の計画を言った彼は支出を提案しているよりも多くの収入を上げるだろうし、それは長期的に赤字と債務を減らすのに役立つだろうと彼は付け加えた。と借金。

 28:40

おとこ:

 NAOMI?

  NAOMI:

 ええと、私はステファニーのように感じます、そして私はこの議論を少ししました、私はちょうど私が企業と裕福な人々に税金を上げることに本当に賛成しているようですそして私は働いていますそして私はあなたもそうだと思います理論的には、これを支払う必要があるからではなく、絶対に受け入れられないレベルの不平等があり、私たちが持っている種類の不平等はモラルハザードであるため、再分配ポリシーが必要なため、それをやりたいのです。余剰資本が多すぎるビリオネアクラスがあるのは危険です。私たちの政治的階級を買収するだけでなく、文字通り彼らの惑星の蜂を含む複数の脱出ルートを構築することができますええと、ええと、気候正義運動のスローガンは、惑星の惑星bはありませんが、ジェフ・ベゾスとイーロン・マスクは違うように頼みます彼らは彼らが作った混乱から逃れるためにそこに行くためにロケット船を作っているので、私はそれが彼らが作成する混乱に住む必要がないことは裕福な人にとってモラルハザードだと思います火星へのロケットはこれの極端な表現ですが、私たちは、パンデミックの権利全体で、富裕層がさまざまな種類のゲート付きの城に極端な形で後退しているのを見ていると思います。それがどこにあるそのプロセス家には教室があり、家には会議室があり、家には必要なものがすべてあり、持っていないものはドローンやノータッチテクノロジーなどで配達できます。ステファニーに興味があるのは、増税が緊縮財政に直面することを示しているとあなたが感じていることです。増税がなければ、2、3年のチャンスが増えるのではないかと心配しています。将来的には、赤字を大幅に増やしたため、これ以上何もできないと言われています。2ポイント、2、5は驚異的な金額だと言っていても、それだけでは十分ではありません。壊滅的な温暖化を防ぐために実際に必要な速度と規模で、これに対して気候変動対策を実施したい場合は、必要な支出の約3分の1なので、税金を増やさずに収入を増やさないと、申し訳ない財源が空であると言われるポイントが加速するのではないかと心配しています。しかし、ええと、なぜ私がステファニーが間違っているのか教えてください。

 

 31:40

ケルトン:

 さて、これが私が思うことです。過去の赤字が裸であるともはや信じている人はほとんどいないと思います。将来の支出能力を制約します。オバマの赤字では、緊縮財政が必要であると言われました。私たちは私の神の赤字を生き残ることができないので、私たちは緊縮財政を手に入れました、そして私たちは緊縮財政へのピボットを手に入れました私たちはトランプの切り札が入って来ましたそして彼はこれらの大幅な減税とラリーサマーズのような人々を望んでいましたクリントン大統領の下で財務長官を務めた彼は、オバマの上級経済顧問であり、国家経済評議会の長でした。ラリーは弾道になります。ラリーは、2017年11月にメディア全体に行った介入の1つを行う共和国の減税のアイデアを嫌います。場所と彼は」共和党がこれらの減税を通過した場合、これらは彼の言葉です。赤字が増加するため、私たちは今後数十年にわたって減税を通過します。共和党は翌月の減税を通過します。赤字の増加cboによると、赤字は10年間で1.9兆増加し、成長は少し増加し、失業率は少し低下し、不平等は拡大し、インフレは低水準にとどまります。私が最初に言っているのは、政府がその粉末を乾燥状態に保つ必要がないことをあなたが知っていることを誰もが見ることができると思うということです」将来何かをする余裕があるためには、小さな赤字などを実行する必要があります。今、私にとって大きなポイントはこれです。昨日、この政権がどこにあると思うかについて本当に興奮しているので、スレッドをやりました。

 

今行って、私が彼らが犯しているのを見た間違いは、これが私たちが持っているものです購入管理局は2.25と言っていますそれは彼らが出てきたものであり、彼らは主に法人税を取りたい企業への増税を通じてそれのすべてのペニーを支払いたいと思っています21%から28までの税率が上昇しました。右の共和党員は35%から21にそれを落としました。民主党員は21から28になりません。彼らがこれに買い込んでいる28に行きたい競争力を失い、25に行くかもしれません。そうするとすぐにいくらかの収入をあきらめたので、あなたは何をしますか。それからあなたはあなたの支出パッケージの野心を縮小します。収入を失ったので、今はもっと小さなパッケージしかできないと言いますが、増税のためにさまざまな税金をめぐって争い始めますか?今日のこの上院には50人の民主党員が投票すると本当に思いますかたくさんの増税のために私はあなたに富裕税のサポートがないことを保証しますそれは不可能であることを忘れてくださいあなたが民主党員があなたが地獄を持っているだろうと想像するかもしれない他のすべてのことについてはどうですか戦い私は投票がそこにあるのなら投票がないのではないかと真剣に心配していますジョー・マンチンは増税に投票するつもりはないので、このスレッドで私が言ったことは、投票があれば素晴らしいと言ったのですが、税金を押し上げてオフセットを行い、プレイプレイを知っていますゲームの支払いはそれを行いますが、投票がない場合は、プランbがあることを知りたいので、昨日irsコミッショナーが証言したプランbを提案しました。 irsコミッショナーがやって来て、彼は腰を下ろし、すでに帳簿に載っている税法を施行するのに十分な資金があれば、10年間で10兆ドル、年間1兆ドルを追加で得ることができると言います。 ed markeyやaocのような人々が言っ​​ているのと同じ数で、私たちは2ではなく10兆になるべきだと言っています。25ケルトンがやって来て、大きなツイッタースレッドを実行し、ここに10兆の低ぶら下がっている果物があることに誰もが気づいたと言います。単一税を上げるために投票する必要はありません。彼らが必要とするリソースを与えて、彼らを外に出させてください。あなたに10兆を生成し、はるかに大きなパッケージを選択するので、私はそこにいます。

 

woman:

 yeah that sounds great to me and i i definitely think strategically the push needs to be to just spend and don't hold it back just spend improve people's material lives and get a bigger majority um because this is just too close it gives way too much power to certain people um and and and and they will fight that too because of what jana said earlier about what austerity is really about it's about disciplining uh a workforce and you know as you were talking honest about mr peel i was remembering this quote from a dupont executive in 1933 opposing fdr's new deal and i think it was 33 maybe it was 34 where he was complaining that he had lost five servants because the government was paying uh such good wages for people to uh to build things and paint things um and he wasn't able to hold on to his household staff it was just a disaster for him right and i think if we think about that as a microcosm for what um silicon valley is really going to be worried about and think about the the recent union drive at an amazon warehouse that failed but it failed in a context where there was no competition if you listen to workers in bessemer who voted against the union it's like look this is a an abusive job it's punishing on the body but it pays 15 an hour and it has some benefits and they're the only ones offering it right um so you know we need to be thinking about front loading um the the direct creation of well-paying job in part because that empowers workers to demand more right because they're going to be the force that are going to be demanding and related to this is the push for um better protections for for unionization under the pro act which um i think is another really key piece of this so how how do we change the dynamics so that we can win that full 10 10 trillion to actually um deal with the climate crisis yeah you know just earlier today i read that um on this very day a number of republicans in the senate are introducing a bill to establish one of these fiscal responsibility commissions like a simpson bulls 2.0 and they want this this they want to assemble a bipartisan commission and charge them with the mandate of working together on a plan to balance the budget so if you're when you say they're going to fight back and make sure that that money is not spent on poor people on improving the lives materially of people and dealing with climate this is all part of the way that they're laying attempting to lay the foundation for that now i hope that they won't find a single democrat to sign on you know to that uh legislation but you know you've got a number of these people who for many years have flexed their you know fiscal hockey bonafides and and viewed themselves as you know hawkish on uh the budget and so forth so i get worried about you know a number of of democratic senators who might align with these republicans around the establishment of a commission like this which would just undermine completely the progressive agenda and and i think we need to um be really clear that whether we're talking about the us or we're talking about the uk or or certainly in i'm in canada right now um you know austerity a lot of it plays out not at the federal level right i mean it's about cities it's about it's about provinces and states and you know this is what's determining education budgets which and we're already starting to hear the first cries of look you know we lost our tax base we can't afford public transit we can't afford to pay for education and brian i really want to come back to your question around what about growth because i think we haven't tackled that and i think that that is the elephant in the room and it's actually weirdly possible that we could spend trillions of dollars building out green infrastructure and increase carbon emissions because um if we aren't dealing with consumption um it it it's possible to have a a green carbon boom as as contradictory as that is so what we need to be doing is investing in low-carbon sectors we need to be um we need to be looking at what actually improves quality of life um and investing in uh you know access to nature recreation um giving people shorter work weeks um really investing in well-being and the care economy and moving away from from endless consumption fighting for the right to repair um and and and and dealing with the the mentality that we can just shift from fossil fuel extraction to green energy and live exactly how we're living as our daddy roy says you know middle-class environmentalists ask the question how do we change without changing um and the answer is we don't we actually have to change how we live um and so um so i think that that's that that's a really really key question um and yeah i i i also think that whether we're dealing with a revenge of the real is another important question because i think in some ways we are and in another way we're dealing with a retreat into screens um and this brings up my other austerity fear which is what the agenda is of silicon valley and all this um because what i worry about is cities going broke and um and then smart cities coming in as the fix and i'll give an example from toronto where uh google tried to um uh they tried to use toronto as this laboratory for the smart city idea so they tried to um do this thing called google has this division called sidewalk labs and they were going to do sidewalk toronto basically their pitch was to the toronto city council you can't fix the potholes you can't invest in green energy you can't invest in in in public transit we'll do it all we'll build a beautiful emerald green city but we're also going to put you all under the most intense surveillance of data extraction you know that we see anywhere outside of china um and thankfully toronto fought back and in the middle of the pandemic and it was just a little you know footnote to all the drama um google pulled out of the sidewalk labs cancelled their toronto contract but the ceo of sidewalk labs when they pulled out said we don't think we got off on the right foot with toronto but we see all kinds of post-pandemic opportunities and what i read between the lines there is cities around the world are going to be dead broke and we're going to come in and save the day and we just have to have this on our radar in how we think about what what the next phase of austerity looks like it's trading our privacy for um you know this kind of tech enclosure and privatization through the back door.


kelton:

one thing i would add on um on the growth issue is this you know for so many years the obsession was with that so-called debt sustainability and with debt to gdp ratios right this idea that there was some for a while we were told tipping points that if countries allow their debt relative to their gdp to reach 90 this is a threshold of some kind you tip over the 90 uh level and then a lot of bad things happen the risk of fiscal crises and slower growth and all this stuff right so the countries that saw their debt may be approaching that so-called tipping point then become obsessed with trying to wrestle the debt ratio down and giannis talked in the opening about you know that how counterproductive austerity is so you start focusing on the numerator the debt how do we bring the debt down austerity so you start cutting spending but one person spending is another person's income and so you undermine the ability of that person to spend in an economy that runs on sales right capitalism runs on sales which generate revenue which generates the profit that makes capitalism viable so you you adopt austerity to try to target the numerator the debt as in an attempt to reduce the numerator to bring the whole ratio down but what happens is you crush the economy so gdp falls so the ratio actually gets bigger so austerity doesn't work but the other piece is that we become obsessed with the idea of growing our way out of debt so if you focus on the denominator instead of the numerator then the strategy the economic strategy can become we just need to grow really fast and if we can grow fast enough we can outrun our debt problem and so i think in a lot of ways for many countries the the obsession with growth is very much bound up with this obsession that countries have about the idea that the debt is unsustainable that it represents a burden on the future and that you've got to get the you know get the ratio down in order to you know a fiscally sustainable um sort of situation and and i think that that then feeds this um this growth obsession which naomi's talking about we have to get away from.


kelton:


成長の問題について一つ付け加えるとすれば、これまで何年もの間、いわゆる債務の持続可能性やGDPに対する債務の比率に執着してきたということがあります。 緊縮財政がいかに逆効果であるかということを、冒頭のGiannisの話では、分子である債務に焦点を当て始めました。資本主義は売上で成り立っています。売上が収入を生み、それが資本主義を成り立たせるための利益を生むのです。そこで、緊縮財政を採用して、分子である債務をターゲットにし、分子を減らして全体の比率を下げようとします。緊縮財政はうまくいきません。しかし、もう一つの問題は、負債から抜け出すために成長するという考えに取りつかれてしまうことです。分子ではなく分母に焦点を当てれば、経済戦略は、とにかく急成長する必要があり、急成長できれば負債の問題を乗り越えることができる、というものになります。多くの国にとって、成長への執着は、「債務は維持できない」「将来への負担になる」「財政的に持続可能な状況にするためには、比率を下げなければならない」という考えに強く結びついていると思います。

このことが、naomiさんがおっしゃっている「成長への強迫観念」を助長しているのだと思います。


www.DeepL.com/Translator(無料版)で翻訳しました。


クライン

well you know it and that really um reminds me of something i've been thinking about around when people talk about the new deal um they often say but yeah but it failed right it failed because actually it didn't pull the us into a growth position so because and because we define failure as anything short of growth right um and we define success a successful economy as an economy that's in a boom you know we all know the narrative right it wasn't the new deal that pulled the that ended the the the great depression it was the second world war the post-war boom that was also what set off suburban sprawl and and a level of consumption that is at the heart of the climate crisis so did and i always kind of accepted this idea that the green that the new deal failed but i guess i want to ask the economist like did it fail because it did create jobs and it pulled a lot of people out of poverty do we have to start telling people that it didn't fail of course it didn't fit no i agree with i agree with the honest no i cannot say that it failed of the millions of people and people talk that way about japan i was just going to say stephanie talk to the descendants of the millions of people oh okay no no i i i think you could probably talk a lot more about that i was just going to say you know it's in some ways it reminds me of the discussion that we keep hearing about japan today that um japan has you know been growing very slowly has very uh low inflation uh you know usually around one percent or less than one percent and somehow we've decided we you know uh the profession academic economist in particular policy makers that japan is is is a fail it's it's a failure that they don't have rapid growth and i and i go to japan and i look around that everything is beautiful the infrastructure is is first-rate things work people are happy you know it's it's not evident that uh that japan is experiencing deep 

 

政府は今、このパンデミックの間に需要を押し上げるかなりの賃金の教訓を学びました、そして彼らはこれを続けますええと、特に米国のボリス・ジョンソンの話は英国での話を話します私は数字を見ていませんそれを裏付ける欧州連合も話をしますが、それはもちろんその実践において絶対的かつ完全に外部的ですが、それにもかかわらず、コロナウイルスはブライアンが前に言ったことをほのめかしているようなものが緊縮財政がない新しいターニングポイントを私たちに与えるかもしれないというこの議論があります流行が長引くええと、私はこれについて非常に懐疑的です。なぜ今が私が黙ってボタンを渡す時であるかを説明するつもりはありません。ブライアンの質問を書き留めていたと思うナオミと同じくらい頭が良かったらいいのにと思います。ここに座って聞いていたので、持っていません。どこに行ったのかわかりません。

 

ケルトン:

お金はそこから来ますそれはお金がどこから来たのかという質問で速いですそれはどこにありますかそれはあなたが知っている将来それを返済しなければならないのでこれらは流動的ですお金はどこから来たのですか。私たちが今リアビューミラーにいるのは、ほんの数か月前に政府が何兆ドルも何兆ドルも費やすことを約束するために火力を集める方法の非常に明確な例です。誰もがあなたのことを話していました私たちがお金を使いたいのなら私たちはお金を見つけなければなりませんあなたはそれをどのように支払うのですかええと、民主的な大統領候補のスレート、あなたはyanez naomiであり、私はよく知っています。民主的な側の大統領指名のために副大統領を争っていた人々の何人かは、非常に進歩的なumbigから野心に及ぶプラットフォームを知っていました。

あなたが知っているチケットのこと16兆ドルの緑の新しい取引すべての学生ローンの借金をキャンセルする私は非常に野心的であることを意味しますあなたはもう一方の端までの規模がより穏やかな種類のものであることを知っていますが、あらゆるターンのすべての候補者はあなたがそれをどこで支払うのかという質問に夢中になりましたお金はどこから来て、すべての候補者は、この支出が行われることを可能にするために税金がどのように増額されるかから収入がどこから来るのかを実証しようとしました。お金を見つけてあなたの支出を支払うと、それは正しく起こりました、そしてこれは本当に数ヶ月後ですそしてそれは2020年の行進でありそして本当に瞬間なしで突然ですためらい議会は数兆ドルの支出パッケージをスピンアウトし始め、米国だけでなく議会だけでなく世界中の政府が巨額の資金を投入しているので、あなたがそれをどのように行ったかを知っていると言うと、お金はどこから来たのですか?これが議会が法案を書くことであり、私たちの場合、3月の最大の法案は、2.2兆ドルの法案であるケア法として知られていました。議会は、中国や投資家クラス、あるいは他の誰かに手を差し伸べて、2.2兆ドルを調達しませんでした。議会は財布の力を持っている議会は彼らが正しいことをしていないお金を使うことを約束することができます法案を可決し、投票があればお金は非常に現実的な意味で続きます投票は支払いです投票は、法案が起草され、投票が行われ、法律が可決されると、中央銀行が議会に代わって議会によって承認された支払いを実行するときに支出が発生する場所です。私たちの財務省は今、どのように支払いを実行するのですか?これを待ってくださいねえ、私はラップトップを使用しているのでキーボードを持ち上げることができませんが、キーボードを持ち上げることができればキーボードを持ち上げます」■連邦準備制度は、コンピューターキーボードを使用して、準備金と呼ばれるデジタルドルを適切な銀行口座に入金し、それらの資金の受取人は銀行から口座に入金されるため、これはすべて完了します。銀行口座への入金を通じて電子的に資金が発生するので、昨年の12月に9千億ドルのパッケージで2.2兆ドルの行進が行われ、先月の会議が開催されました。もう1つの入り江レスキューパッケージ1。連邦準備制度に1セットの指示だけを送った9兆の法律は、1400の小切手を受け取った場合、適切な銀行口座の番号を変更します。あなたが追加の失業補償を受け取っている場合、デジタルドルがあなたの口座に現れたので、私たちが今入っているのは別の段階であり、これが私がこのジャンニで締めくくるところだと思いますが、これは私がいるところです私はあなたに同意しているのですが、緊縮財政の考え方を完全に破ったことを私たちが知っているとは思いません。なぜなら、この気候スラッシュインフラストラクチャパッケージで民主党が今話しているのは、ホワイトハウスによって提案された何かを知っているからです。これまでの注文は2です。25兆ですが、今回は見積もりなしの支払いを見積もりたいのですが、今説明した最後の3つの法案が通過した方法でこの法案を通過させたくないので、支出を相殺したいので、2セットの指示を送信したいのです。中央銀行に、電気自動車の充電ステーションを設置し、ケア作業を行うアメリカの崩壊しつつあるインフラストラクチャを修復する作業を行う労働者の銀行口座に出かけてクレジットするように指示する一連の指示があり、残りのすべての人々はクレジットを受け取ります彼らの口座に対して、他の一連の指示は中央銀行に多くの企業の口座の数字を借方に記入するように指示するでしょう。なぜなら議会は私たちがお金を使うつもりであると言う法案を書きたいと決定したからです。また、増税するので、2セットの指示があります。これは、必ずしも緊縮財政とは言いたくないのですが、ビデンがアメリカの人々の前に行ってこれについて話したとき、彼は彼の計画がもっと上がるだろうと言いました彼が使うことを提案しているよりも収入があり、それは長期的に赤字と債務を減らすのに役立つだろうと彼は付け加えたので、そのようなことを聞​​いたとき、それは間違いなく赤字と債務について心配し始めている政権のようにひどく聞こえ始めています私はええと、私はステファニーのように感じていることを意味します、そして私は私がちょうど私のようであるところでこの議論を少ししましたm本当に企業や裕福な人々への増税に賛成で、私は仕事をしています。あなたは理論的にはあまりにも似ていると思います。私たちはこれを支払う必要があるからではなく、絶対に受け入れられないからです。私たちが持っている種類の不平等はモラルハザードであるため、再分配政策が必要です。それは、私たちが政治を買収するだけでなく、過剰な資本を持つ億万長者のクラスを持っていることは、非常に危険です。クラスですが、文字通り彼らの惑星の蜂を含む複数の脱出ルートを構築しますええと、気候正義運動のスローガンは、惑星の惑星bはありませんが、ジェフ・ベゾスとイーロン・マスクはロケットを作っているので違うように頼みます混乱から逃れるためにそこに行く船作ったし、それは、富裕層が火星へのロケットを作成する混乱に住む必要がないことはモラルハザードだと思いますが、これは極端な表現ですが、私たちはさまざまな種類のゲート付きの城のようなものに富んでいて、パンデミックの権利全体で極端な形をしています。外出禁止令は、家に教室があり、家に会議室があるようなプロセスを本当に加速させたと思います。必要なものすべてと持っていないものはすべて、ドローンやノータッチテクノロジーなどで提供できるので、私はステファニーに興味がありません。私の恐れは、私たちがそうしなければ、緊縮財政に直面するだろうということです。増税により、数年後には赤字が大幅に増加したため、これ以上何もできないと言われる可能性が高くなります。 2つ5つは驚異的な金額であり、壊滅的な温暖化を防ぐために実際に必要な速度と規模で気候変動対策を実施したい場合は、支出の約3分の1の規模です。税金を増やさず、収入を増やさないと、申し訳ありませんが金庫が空であると言われるポイントが加速するのではないかと心配していますが、ええと、なぜ私が間違っているのか教えてくださいステファニー大丈夫だからここに」s私が思うに、過去の赤字が裸であるともはや信じている人はほとんどいないと思います。将来の支出能力を制約します。オバマの赤字では、緊縮財政が必要であると言われました。私の神の赤字を生き残ることができないので、私たちは緊縮財政を手に入れました、そして私たちは緊縮財政へのピボットを手に入れました私たちはトランプの切り札が入って来ましたそして彼はこれらの大幅な減税をしたいと思っていますクリントン大統領は、オバマの上級経済顧問であり、国家経済評議会の長でした。ラリーは弾道になりますラリーは、2017年11月にメディア全体に行った介入の1つを行う共和国の減税のアイデアを嫌っています。 '共和党がこれらの減税を通過した場合、これらは彼の言葉です。赤字が増加するため、私たちは今後数十年にわたって減税を通過します。共和党は翌月の減税を通過します。赤字の増加cboによると、赤字は10年間で1.9兆増加し、成長は少し増加し、失業率は少し低下し、不平等は拡大し、インフレは低水準にとどまります。私が最初に言っているのは、政府がその粉末を乾燥状態に保つ必要がないことをあなたが知っていることを誰もが見ることができると思うということです」将来何かをする余裕があるためには、小さな赤字などを実行する必要があります。今、私にとって大きなポイントはこれです。昨日、この政権がどこにあると思うかについて本当に興奮しているので、スレッドをやりました。今行って、私が彼らが犯しているのを見た間違いは、これが私たちが持っているものです購入管理局は2.25と言っていますそれは彼らが出てきたものであり、彼らは主に法人税を取りたい企業への増税を通じてそれのすべてのペニーを支払いたいと思っています21%から28までの税率が上昇しました。右の共和党員は35%から21にそれを落としました。民主党員は21から28になりません。彼らがこれに買い込んでいる28に行きたい競争力を失い、25に行くかもしれません。そうするとすぐにいくらかの収入をあきらめたので、あなたは何をしますか。それからあなたはあなたの支出パッケージの野心を縮小します。収入を失ったので、今はもっと小さなパッケージしかできないと言いますが、増税のためにさまざまな税金をめぐって争い始めますか?今日のこの上院には50人の民主党員が投票すると本当に思いますかたくさんの増税のために私はあなたに富裕税のサポートがないことを保証しますそれは不可能であることを忘れてくださいあなたが民主党員があなたが地獄を持っているだろうと想像するかもしれない他のすべてのことについてはどうですか戦い私は投票がそこにあるのなら投票がないのではないかと真剣に心配していますジョー・マンチンは増税に投票するつもりはないので、このスレッドで私が言ったことは、投票があれば素晴らしいと言ったのですが、税金を押し上げてオフセットを行い、プレイプレイを知っていますゲームの支払いはそれを行いますが、投票がない場合は、プランbがあることを知りたいので、昨日irsコミッショナーが証言したプランbを提案しました。 irsコミッショナーがやって来て、彼は腰を下ろし、すでに帳簿に載っている税法を施行するのに十分な資金があれば、10年間で10兆ドル、年間1兆ドルを追加で得ることができると言います。 ed markeyやaocのような人々が言っ​​ているのと同じ数で、私たちは2ではなく10兆になるべきだと言っています。25ケルトンがやって来て、大きなツイッタースレッドを実行し、ここに10兆の低額の果物があることに誰もが気づいたと言います。単一税を上げるために投票する必要はなく、必要なリソースをirsに与えて外に出させます。あなたに10兆を生み出し、はるかに大きなパッケージを選ぶので、私はそうです、それは私にとって素晴らしいことだと思います。私は間違いなく戦略的にプッシュする必要があると考えています。これが近すぎるので、大多数のええと、それは特定の人々にあまりにも多くの力を与えますええとそしてそしてそして彼らはまた、緊縮財政が本当にそれについて何であるかについてジャナが以前に言ったことのためにそれと戦うでしょう」労働者の懲戒についてです。ピール氏について正直に話していたので、1933年にfdrのニューディールに反対したデュポンの幹部からのこの引用を覚えていました。彼が負けたと不平を言っていたのは、33歳だったと思います。政府が物を作ったり塗ったりするために人々にこんなに良い賃金を払っていて、彼が家のスタッフを握ることができなかったので、5人の使用人は彼にとってただの惨事でした。それは、シリコンバレーが本当に心配していることの縮図として、アマゾン倉庫での最近の組合ドライブが失敗したことを考えますが、投票したベッセマーの労働者の話を聞くと、競争がなかった状況で失敗しました組合に対しては、これは虐待的な仕事のように見えます」体に罰を与えるが、それは1時間に15を支払い、いくつかの利点があり、それを提供しているのは彼らだけなので、フロントローディングについて考える必要があることを知っています。なぜなら、それは労働者がより多くの権利を要求することを可能にするからです。なぜなら、彼らは要求し、これに関連する力になるからです。これは、共和党の下での組合のためのより良い保護の推進であり、これはもう一つの本当に重要な部分だと思います。だから、どうやってダイナミクスを変えて、10兆10兆ドルを勝ち取って、気候危機に実際に対処できるようにするのか。ええ、今日、私はこの日に、上院の多くの共和党員がシンプソンブルズのようなこれらの財政責任委員会の1つを設立する法案を導入する2。0そして彼らはこれを望んでいます彼らは超党派の委員会を集めて予算のバランスをとる計画に一緒に取り組むという任務を彼らに課したいのであなたが言うとき彼らは反撃しそしてそのお金を確かめるつもりです貧しい人々が人々の生活を物質的に改善し、気候に対処することに費やされていないこれはすべて、彼らがその基盤を築こうとしている方法の一部です今、彼らが署名する単一の民主党員を見つけられないことを願っていますあなたはそのええと法律を知っていますが、あなたはあなたを知っています何年もの間、財政ホッケーのボナフィドを知っていて、予算などでタカ派を知っているように自分自身を見ているこれらの人々の数がいるので、私はあなたが整列するかもしれない多くの民主的な上院議員を知っているのではないかと心配していますこのような委員会の設立をめぐるこれらの共和党員とは、進歩的な議題を完全に損なうだけであり、私たちが私たちについて話しているのか、英国について話しているのか、それとも確かに話しているのかを本当に明確にする必要があると思います私は今カナダにいますが、緊縮財政は連邦レベルではなく、多くの場合、都市に関するものであり、州や州に関するものであり、これが教育予算を決定するものであることを知っています。私たちが課税基盤を失ったことを知っている最初の叫び声をすでに聞き始めています私たちは公共交通機関を買う余裕がありません私たちは教育とブライアンにお金を払う余裕がありません私は本当に成長についてのあなたの質問に戻りたいです私たちはそれに取り組んでいないと思います。それは部屋の中の象だと思います。実際には、グリーンインフラストラクチャを構築し、二酸化炭素排出量を増やすために数兆ドルを費やす可能性があります。それだ」グリーンカーボンブームがそれと同じくらい矛盾している可能性があるので、私たちがしなければならないことは、低炭素セクターに投資することです。私たちは、実際に生活の質を改善するものを見て、ええと投資する必要があります。自然レクリエーションへのアクセスが人々に短い労働週を与え、幸福とケア経済に本当に投資し、無限の消費から離れて、修復する権利を求めて戦い、そして私たちができる精神に対処することを知っています化石燃料の抽出からグリーンエネルギーに移行し、私たちの生活を正確に生きるパパ・ロイは、中流階級の環境保護主義者が、ええとを変えずにどのように変えるのかという質問をしていることを知っています。答えは、実際に変える必要はないということです。私たちの生き方ええと、ええと、私はそれがそれだと思います」sa本当に本当に重要な質問ええとええiiiまた、私たちが本当の復讐を扱っているかどうかは別の重要な質問だと思います。これは私の他の厳粛な恐怖を引き起こします。それはシリコンバレーとこのすべての議題です。なぜなら、私が心配しているのは、都市が壊れて、スマートシティが修正として入ってくることです。トロントからの例を示します。ええと、グーグルはスマートシティのアイデアのためにこの実験室としてトロントを使おうとしたので、グーグルと呼ばれるこのことをやろうとしました。市議会あなたができる穴を修正することはできません」公共交通機関に投資できないグリーンエネルギーに投資する私たちはすべてを行い、美しいエメラルドグリーンの都市を構築しますが、あなたが知っているデータ抽出の最も強力な監視下にあなた全員を置きますチャイナウムの外のどこかで見られ、ありがたいことにトロントは反撃し、パンデミックの真っ只中にありました。歩道の実験室から引き出されたすべてのドラマの脚注は、トロントの契約をキャンセルしましたが、歩道の最高経営責任者は彼らが撤退したときのラボは、トロントで右足で降りたとは思わないと言ったが、パンデミック後のあらゆる種類の機会があり、世界中の都市の境界線の間に読んだものは完全に壊れてしまうだろうと私は言った我々'来て、その日を救うつもりです。緊縮財政の次の段階がどのように見えるかについて、私たちがどのように考えるかについて、これをレーダーに載せる必要があります。私たちのプライバシーを、この種の技術的囲い込みと裏口からの民営化と交換することを知っています。成長の問題について私が付け加えたいことの1つは、長年にわたって、いわゆる債務の持続可能性と債務とGDPの比率は、しばらくの間、国がGDPに対する債務を90に達することを許可している場合、これは90 uhレベルを超えて転倒するある種のしきい値であり、その後多くの転倒があると言われたという考えに基づいています。悪いことが起こると、財政危機や成長の鈍化などのリスクが発生するため、債務を見た国は、いわゆる転換点に近づき、債務比率を下げようとすることに夢中になり、ジャンニスは冒頭で話しました。あなたについては、緊縮財政がいかに逆効果であるかを知っているので、あなたは焦点を合わせ始めます分子の債務緊縮財政をどのように引き下げるかで、支出を削減し始めますが、ある人の支出は別の人の収入であり、その人が販売で実行される経済で過ごす能力を損なう権利資本主義は、生成する販売で実行されます資本主義を実行可能にする利益を生み出す収入なので、緊縮財政を採用して分子を減らして全体の比率を下げるように債務をターゲットにしようとしますが、経済を粉砕してgdpが低下し、比率が下がるのです実際には大きくなるので、緊縮財政はしません」うまくいきますが、もう1つは、債務から抜け出すという考えに夢中になっていることです。分子ではなく分母に焦点を当てると、経済戦略が実現できる戦略は、本当に速く成長する必要があります。十分に速く成長できるので、債務問題を乗り越えることができるので、多くの国にとって、成長への執着は、債務が持続不可能であるという考えについて国が持っているこの執着と非常に結びついていると思います。将来への負担と、財政的に持続可能なumのような状況を知るためには、比率を下げる必要があることを知っておく必要があります。それが、naomiが話しているこの成長への執着をこのumに与えると思います。


クライン

よく離れるためにあなたはそれを知っていますそしてそれは本当にええと私に何かを思い出させます人々がよく言うニューディールについて話すとき、よく考えていましたが、そうですが、失敗したのは、実際には私たちを成長ポジションに引き込まなかったためです。ええと、私たちは成功を成功した経済と定義します。それはブームにある経済であり、私たちは皆、それがそうではなかった物語の権利を知っています。大恐慌を終わらせたニューディール政策は、第二次世界大戦であり、戦後のブームであり、郊外のスプロール現象を引き起こし、気候危機の中心にある消費レベルも同様でした。ニューディールが失敗したというグリーンという考えをいつも受け入れていましたが、それが雇用を生み出し、多くの人々を貧困から救ったので、失敗したのかとエコノミストに尋ねたいと思います。もちろん失敗しなかったという人々フィットしない同意する同意する正直に同意する何百万人もの人々が失敗したとは言えず、人々は日本についてそのように話します私はステファニーが何百万人もの人々の子孫に話すと言うつもりでしたiiiあなたはおそらくもっと多くのことを話すことができると思います私はあなたがそれがいくつかの点であなたが知っていると言うつもりだったと思いますそれは私たちが今日日本について聞いている議論を思い出させますインフレええと、あなたは通常約1パーセントか1パーセント未満を知っています、そしてどういうわけか私たちはあなたが知っていると決めましたええと、日本がそうである特定の政策立案者の専門の学術エコノミストは失敗ですそれは彼らがしないのは失敗です急成長していて、私と私は日本に行きます。すべてが美しいことを周りを見回しています。インフラストラクチャは一流のものです。人々は幸せです。日本が深い音楽を経験していることは明らかではありません 文字起こし 04:03 i can't stand 04:09 no i just can't stand 04:14 [Music] 04:24 [Music] 04:27 can't you see can't you see 04:30 the tails and mine 04:33 [Music] 04:36 baby please 04:43 [Music] 04:53 without you baby 05:04 according to oxfam the world's 10 05:07 richest billionaires have collectively 05:10 seen their wealth grow by 540 billion 05:13 over the period of covet 19. 05:17 their increase in wealth would be more 05:19 than enough to pay 05:20 for kovid 19 vaccine for all 05:25 while these people got immensely richer 05:27 the poorer 05:28 the less privileged have suffered 05:30 immensely 05:31 and inequalities have increased pretty 05:33 much everywhere on the planet 05:36 also the austerity measures put in place 05:38 in the last few decades 05:40 are at least partly responsible for the 05:43 scale 05:43 of the crisis we have been facing since 05:45 the pandemic 05:46 started so the question we're asking 05:50 ourselves tonight is 05:52 what is really austerity on and what is 05:55 really austerity 05:56 about welcome everyone it's uh 06:01 let's talk it over three and to discuss 06:04 this 06:05 and more we have an amazing panel 06:07 tonight but before 06:08 i introduce them i wanted to quickly 06:10 remind you 06:12 to like the video share it and subscribe 06:15 to our page 06:16 i do not like to have to say this over 06:18 and over again but it will 06:20 help the show to grow so thanks very 06:23 much 06:24 so again tonight uh an incredible panel 06:27 uh i feel very privileged uh to be able 06:30 to share 06:30 the next hour with naomi klein 06:34 stephanie kelton and my two fantastic 06:37 uh partners and co-hosts yanis varufakis 06:41 and briannino 06:43 brian i think you're going to start 06:47 they're going to start the show and 06:48 you're going to get the ball rolling so 06:49 i'll give you 06:50 the floor now thank you um 06:55 so despite the figures that you cited 06:59 showing the huge increase of wealth for 07:01 a small number of people 07:03 i'm still hopeful that covid will prove 07:06 to be 07:07 a different kind of turning point 07:10 there's a book i've been reading for the 07:12 last couple of years which 07:15 i don't think has had much take up but i 07:17 think is a very interesting book 07:18 called the great leveler by walter 07:20 scheidel 07:22 and the thesis of that book is that 07:25 inequality is only ever corrected by 07:29 violence effectively it's a 07:32 strange echo john can you hear that 07:35 it's slightly disturbing 07:38 okay well i'll just be disturbed 07:43 i can hear my voice echoing oh yes there 07:46 it is 07:47 anyway the thesis of the book is that 07:55 inequality will tend to rise because the 07:57 powerful 07:59 are in a position to take more and more 08:00 for themselves and will do so 08:03 but the only times it stops rising 08:06 decisively 08:07 is either when there's a war or a plague 08:09 or 08:10 state collapses so 08:13 in those cases suddenly the tables can 08:16 turn 08:16 for instance after the black death 08:20 because so many people died labor became 08:23 much more expensive and 08:25 for the first time in english history 08:28 laborers had some bargaining power 08:33 now we haven't had 08:36 a plague exactly not as bad as that one 08:38 anyway 08:39 but i still think that it's possible 08:41 that we will 08:42 experience a kind of a different kind of 08:44 leveling 08:45 and the form that that will take i think 08:49 is possibly the end of magical thinking 08:53 now magical thinking is what i call 08:56 the phase of post-modern politics that 08:59 we've seen for the last 20 years or so 09:01 since about the iraq war since the 09:04 neocon 09:05 era basically there's been an assumption 09:08 that 09:08 you could create politics by wanting it 09:11 hard enough and saying it over and over 09:13 again 09:16 there's a new book by benjamin bratton 09:18 which is due out in 09:19 a couple of months in which he says that 09:22 um 09:23 he the subtitle of the book is uh 09:26 no the title is revenge of the real and 09:29 he says that 09:30 the interesting effect of covid is that 09:32 it's shown that 09:34 uh the kind of macho authoritarian 09:38 i say it so it will be true thinking 09:40 didn't work 09:42 all the countries that suffered worst 09:44 including mine 09:46 um were led by those kinds of leaders 09:50 who thought that there by the sheer 09:52 power of their will 09:53 the strength of their will they could 09:55 create reality 09:56 well it turned out that they couldn't um 10:00 so this brings us to the question of 10:04 uh what effects we can have on societies 10:07 and what effects 10:09 we can't control um which 10:12 brings us nicely to austerity i think i 10:15 think we are also going to see a 10:17 revolution in economics 10:18 it's a one that started or became 10:21 conspicuous i should say in 10:23 in 2008 when there was the 10:26 crash when it suddenly became clear that 10:30 history hadn't 10:31 ended as it had been predicted to do and 10:34 it was still alive and well and 10:37 guaranteed to surprise us 10:40 and of course at that from that point on 10:43 people started asking 10:45 serious questions about capitalism even 10:47 capitalists started asking those kinds 10:49 of questions 10:52 and a few paradoxes or 10:55 incomprehensible things started to 10:57 appear like 11:00 for the last 10 years or so 11:03 we've been suffering versions of 11:05 austerity until suddenly when kovid 11:07 comes along 11:09 there are vast amounts of money 11:10 available 11:13 so we had been told in the english 11:15 newspapers over and over again by the 11:16 tories 11:18 as they laughed at jeremy corbyn there's 11:20 no such thing as a money tree 11:22 we can't just make money well it turns 11:25 out you can just make money 11:28 and everybody's been doing it very 11:30 happily trillions and trillions of money 11:33 so what happened did did our ideas just 11:36 change 11:37 um and are we going to have a terrible 11:40 reckoning when it turns out that these 11:41 new 11:42 ideas aren't correct or can we just make 11:45 money 11:46 this this is the kind of question that 11:48 lay people like me really don't know the 11:50 answer to 11:51 where all this money come from is it 11:54 debt 11:55 and if it's debt who owes it who is 11:58 going to be responsible for paying it 12:00 which generation of the future is going 12:03 to be responsible for 12:05 are we borrowing from the future or are 12:07 we not i don't know the answer to that 12:10 um what's the effect of this in the long 12:12 term 12:14 um are we just are we piling debts onto 12:18 our grandchildren 12:19 or is that not really um what we assume 12:23 it to be are we not 12:25 are we doing something different from 12:26 what we would do in our personal 12:28 finances 12:29 well of course we are but i i'm sure a 12:32 lot of people would like that to be 12:34 spelled out 12:35 but the the main question i would ask in 12:39 in this particular time when we're now 12:41 facing 12:43 the climate crisis are we actually 12:45 committing to 12:46 a future which demands 12:50 constantly accelerating growth is it 12:53 possible to 12:54 create money like this without 12:58 the assumption of constant 13:01 accelerating growth so that's 13:04 those are the questions that i would 13:06 personally like answered 13:08 and i'm i'm sure many of the members of 13:11 the audience who are as 13:12 economically naive as me would like them 13:14 answered too 13:22 okay that's i suppose that's my cue 13:25 brian 13:26 sorry i'm sorry i should have said that 13:27 yes sorry yes 13:30 well uh good evening everyone everyone 13:32 who's watching it's 13:34 indeed a great pleasure to um be 13:37 together with uh 13:38 with naomi and with stephanie even if it 13:42 is yet another bloody room 13:43 but nevertheless it's better to be 13:46 together in a zoom than not to be 13:47 together 13:48 at all and it is wonderful that i'm not 13:51 the only economist on the panel and that 13:52 i do not have to answer 13:54 brian's questions because you know i can 13:55 see stephanie is you know 13:57 eager to get stuck into these questions 14:00 and now 14:00 instead i'm going to let you answer 14:02 these questions because 14:04 you will do a fantastic much better job 14:07 than me 14:07 uh so because somebody else is going to 14:09 be answering um 14:11 these economic key questions allow me to 14:13 start with a story that karl marx 14:16 scribbled in the margins of his 14:19 grundrisa which 14:20 was never published until 1939. he tells 14:23 the story of a certain mr peale 14:25 i don't know whether you the rest of you 14:26 remember that story i said 14:28 mr peale who was in the 1840s uh an 14:31 english businessman 14:33 who could uh sense that a 14:37 massive financial crisis was about hit 14:39 in 14:40 early english capitalism as it did hit 14:43 in the late 1840s so he decided 14:46 to cash in his shares 14:49 and buy three ships like three or four 14:52 ships load them up with seeds food 14:55 equipment 14:56 everything including 300 workers 15:00 men women and children his family 15:03 and they sailed off to western australia 15:06 where he was going to build his own 15:08 utopian capitalist world he would be you 15:11 know the the 15:12 capitalist ruler of western australia um 15:15 and he managed to get to western 15:17 australia to disembark to set up shop to 15:19 start 15:20 the you know to build buildings and so 15:22 on but within a few months 15:24 suddenly he was left alone suddenly the 15:27 workers disappeared 15:29 suddenly the fact that he had 50 000 15:31 pounds that's how much he took with him 15:33 met absolutely nothing because the 15:35 workers simply 15:37 walked off there was plenty of fertile 15:39 land and they went to do business for 15:40 themselves 15:42 and you know marx's 15:46 cynical line was that mr peale though he 15:48 took with him money 15:49 equipment and the workforce could not 15:52 take capitalism with him 15:54 now why am i recounting this story 15:56 because you know 15:57 when when when we try to understand why 16:00 are the powerful 16:01 so in and numbered of austerity why do 16:04 they hate public debt so much they don't 16:06 care about private debt 16:08 okay i think that's the answer because 16:10 we must not think of debt 16:12 and public spending as simply numbers on 16:15 a 16:15 spreadsheet there may be numbers of the 16:18 spreadsheet but for mr peale the 16:21 experience was a reminder of the fact 16:23 that his power did not come from the 16:26 money it came from the fact that the 16:28 workers 16:28 in england didn't have an alternative 16:31 and muslim would say they had an 16:33 alternative and that's the nightmare of 16:34 the powerful 16:35 that the weak are going to have 16:37 alternatives so when they hear about you 16:39 know 16:40 universal basic incomes and you know job 16:43 creation schemes and job guarantee 16:45 schemes and you know 16:47 money that goes to public education 16:48 public health public this public ground 16:50 they think 16:50 my god you know mr peale's 16:54 uh nightmare is going to be become our 16:57 nightmare 16:59 and of course when you ask them they 17:00 will talk about public debt 17:02 and you know in debt indebting the 17:05 future generations and inflation and so 17:07 on 17:07 but in the final analysis 17:11 i think they're following the right 17:13 instinct 17:14 as powerful people as oligarchs they 17:17 understand 17:18 that using the monetary that brian 17:20 mentioned 17:21 in order to empower the poor is 17:24 seriously 17:25 circumscribing their own power and 17:28 that's why they love austerity 17:30 because they they of course they love 17:33 the state to spend money but not on the 17:34 little people not on the poor people 17:37 um and all this uh becomes 17:40 presented as commonsensical ideology of 17:44 austerity 17:45 now just a few words for our audience 17:48 what exactly do we mean by your state a 17:51 monster it is a policy 17:52 of cutting government spending in order 17:55 to 17:56 [Music] 17:57 reduce the budget deficit so as not to 17:59 allow 18:00 the public debt to accumulate uh and 18:03 even to 18:03 run a budget surplus so as to shrink the 18:07 debt 18:08 that that's what austerity you know 18:10 tightening the belt 18:11 in order to shrink the debt or to shrink 18:13 the rate of english of growth 18:15 of that now of course you know 18:18 we all know or we should know that there 18:21 is a 18:22 basic motivated error in this idea 18:26 and that is because they're using their 18:27 own allegory uh for you and me 18:30 if we don't spend money on shoes 18:31 tomorrow or on going to the theater 18:34 after the pandemic ends okay that money 18:37 saved 18:38 but for the government that is not the 18:39 case because the government does not 18:41 have the luxury 18:42 of the independence between its income 18:45 and its expenditure you and i 18:48 we have this independence when we don't 18:51 spend money 18:52 the money is left in our pocket or bank 18:53 account but when the government 18:55 is reducing public spending at the time 18:58 when private the private sector 19:00 is not spending or is reducing its 19:02 private spending 19:03 then the total the sum of public and 19:05 private expenditure 19:06 shrinks and that's total income in other 19:08 words society's income 19:10 thinks that government tax base shrinks 19:13 uh so that's why it's a bad idea 19:16 austerity doesn't work we know 19:18 it has never worked it never will work 19:21 um 19:21 but it doesn't matter because 19:25 this allegory is functional to the 19:27 interests of the 19:28 strong who fear that their fate is going 19:31 to be that of mr peale 19:34 so in a sense it's a class war and it's 19:37 a war against the environment 19:39 that's what austerity is because you 19:42 know 19:43 let's face it capitalism and the profit 19:46 motive the motive of capital 19:47 accumulation in the leftist language 19:50 can never can never value and then 19:54 you know clean air when clean air 19:56 doesn't have a price 19:57 it's priceless it can never be valued 19:59 and therefore it has to be the result of 20:01 public expenditure 20:02 public investment if we're going to save 20:04 the the planet 20:06 so austerity is a war on on the lower 20:09 classes 20:10 and on the planet it's really very 20:11 simple and it is a war which 20:13 the mr peels of the world are quite 20:16 happy to wage 20:17 so that they maintain the power on the 20:19 many in the way that mr peel failed to 20:22 do 20:23 so that's all i wanted to say 20:26 and i i shall conclude with um 20:30 a point that naomi and stephanie 20:33 stephanie naomi are going to take up 20:36 with joe biden in particular but also 20:38 boris johnson in 20:40 in britain there is a narrative that 20:43 austerity is now finished it was a bad 20:45 idea 20:47 and they change the mind and we are 20:49 going back to a kind of new deal 20:50 approach whereby governments now 20:54 yes they learned the lesson of fairly 20:57 wages of 20:59 boosting demand during this pandemic 21:02 and they will continue to do this uh 21:04 especially the united states boris 21:05 johnson talks 21:06 talks the talk in britain i haven't seen 21:08 the numbers to back it up 21:09 the european union also talks the talk 21:11 but it is of course 21:13 absolutely and totally exterior in its 21:15 practice 21:17 but nevertheless there is this 21:19 discussion that coronavirus 21:21 sort of alluding to what brian said 21:23 before may 21:25 be giving us a new turning point where 21:28 austerity is no longer 21:30 in vogue uh i am very skeptical about 21:33 this 21:34 i'm not going to explain why this is 21:36 time for me to shut up 21:37 and pass the button i think i'm 21:40 stephanie should come in because 21:42 i can feel the pulsating need to answer 21:45 brian's questions 21:47 okay well i wish that i had been as 21:49 smart as naomi who i think was 21:51 jotting down brian's questions and i 21:53 just sat here and listened to them so i 21:54 don't 21:55 i don't have uh i don't have where did 21:57 that money come from 21:58 that's what's quick with the question 22:00 where did the money come from oh well 22:01 where is it 22:03 is it are we going to have to pay it 22:05 back in the future 22:06 you know so these are liquid let's do 22:09 let's do that where did the money come 22:11 from because 22:12 um you know i think we have right now 22:16 in the rear view mirror just very very 22:19 clear 22:20 examples of exactly how governments 22:23 muster the fire power 22:25 to commit to spending trillions and 22:27 trillions of dollars 22:28 when just months before everybody was 22:31 talking about 22:32 you know if we want to spend money we 22:34 have to find money how will you pay for 22:36 it 22:37 i mean if you think back to you know 22:39 2019 22:40 and um the presidential campaign and 22:44 the democratic primaries and you know we 22:46 had a very crowded 22:47 uh slate of democratic presidential 22:50 hopefuls you 22:51 you yanez naomi and i know well 22:54 uh some of the people who were vying for 22:57 the 22:57 vice president for the presidential 22:59 nomination on the democratic side 23:00 and people had you know platforms that 23:04 ranged in ambition from very very 23:08 progressive um big ticket things you 23:10 know a 16 trillion dollar green new deal 23:13 uh cancelling all student loan debt i 23:15 mean very ambitious 23:16 all the way down you know the scale to 23:18 the other end the the more moderate sort 23:20 of things but 23:21 every single candidate at every turn was 23:24 dogged by the question how will you pay 23:27 for it where will the money come from 23:28 and every candidate attempted 23:30 to demonstrate where the revenue would 23:33 come from how the taxes would be 23:34 increased to generate 23:36 the revenue to allow for this spending 23:38 to take place 23:39 everything happened in this sort of a 23:42 budgeting 23:43 framework right the idea that you have 23:45 to find the money 23:46 and pay for your spending and then it 23:49 happened 23:50 right and this is just months later 23:53 really and it's march of 2020 and all of 23:56 a sudden 23:57 without really a moment's hesitation 24:00 congress begins spinning out 24:02 multi-trillion dollar spending packages 24:04 and not just in the us not just congress 24:06 but around the world 24:07 governments are committing huge sums of 24:10 money 24:11 and so when we say you know how did they 24:13 do it where did the money come from 24:14 here's what happens congress writes a 24:17 bill 24:18 and in our case in march the biggest 24:20 bill 24:21 was known as the cares act that was a 24:23 2.2 24:24 trillion dollar piece of legislation 24:27 that legislation is congress's way 24:30 of ordering up okay 2.2 trillion dollars 24:35 from its bank from the federal reserve 24:39 congress did not go out hat in hand to 24:42 china or 24:42 to the investor class or to anyone else 24:45 and raise up 2.2 trillion they don't 24:47 have to 24:48 congress has the power of the purse 24:51 congress can commit to spending money 24:53 that they 24:54 do not have right what they do is pass 24:57 the bill and if the votes are there 24:59 the money follows in a in a very real 25:02 sense the votes are the pay for the 25:05 votes are where the money comes from 25:07 once the bill is is drafted and once the 25:10 votes are there 25:11 and the legislation is passed the 25:14 spending happens 25:15 as the central bank the government's 25:17 fiscal agent 25:19 carries out the payments that have been 25:21 authorized by congress 25:23 on behalf of the u.s treasury now how do 25:25 they carry out payments 25:26 wait for this hey i can't hold up my 25:28 keyboard because i'm using my 25:30 laptop but if i could hold up my 25:32 keyboard i would hold up my 25:34 keyboard because that's how the payments 25:36 are carried out 25:37 the federal reserve uses nothing more 25:39 than a computer keyboard 25:41 to credit the appropriate bank accounts 25:44 with digital dollars that are known as 25:46 reserves 25:47 and then the recipient of those funds 25:49 has their account credited 25:51 by their bank so this is all done 25:53 electronically 25:54 through crediting of bank accounts and 25:57 that's where the money comes from 25:59 so we've seen it we saw it with the 2.2 26:01 trillion in march 26:03 they did it again in december of last 26:05 year a 900 billion dollar package 26:08 and then just last month congress came 26:10 in with 26:11 one more cove rescue package 1.9 26:14 trillion 26:14 again a piece of legislation that sent 26:17 just one set of instructions 26:19 to the federal reserve go change the 26:21 numbers up 26:22 in the appropriate bank accounts if you 26:24 got that 1400 check 26:26 you got a credit to your account the key 26:28 board uh 26:29 did the work and the digital dollars 26:32 appeared in your account if you're 26:33 getting extra unemployment compensation 26:36 that's how that's happening so what 26:38 we're entering now 26:39 is a different phase and i think this is 26:41 where i'm going to wrap up with this 26:43 giannis but this is where i'm i'm in 26:45 agreement with you i don't 26:47 think that we have you know broken 26:50 the austerity mindset altogether because 26:53 what democrats are talking about now 26:55 with this 26:56 climate slash infrastructure package is 27:00 you know something that's been proposed 27:02 by the white house something on the 27:03 order so far of 2.25 27:06 trillion but this time they want to 27:09 quote unquote pay for it 27:11 they don't want to pass this bill the 27:12 way the last three bills that i just 27:15 described were passed 27:16 they want to offset the spending which 27:18 means they want to send two sets of 27:21 instructions 27:22 to the central bank one set of 27:24 instructions that tells them to go out 27:26 and 27:26 credit the bank accounts of the workers 27:29 who will 27:30 do the work repairing america's 27:32 crumbling infrastructure putting up 27:33 electric 27:34 vehicle charging stations and doing care 27:37 work and all the rest 27:38 those people will get credits to their 27:40 accounts the other set of instructions 27:43 would tell the central bank to 27:46 debit mark down the numbers in the 27:49 accounts 27:49 of many corporations because congress 27:52 has decided that 27:53 it wants to write a bill that says we're 27:56 going to spend money but we're also 27:58 going to raise 27:59 taxes so two sets of instructions and 28:01 this is 28:02 falling more into a kind of 28:06 i don't want to necessarily call it 28:07 austerity but when biden went 28:10 before the american people and talked 28:12 about this he said 28:13 that his plan would raise more revenue 28:15 than he is even proposing to spend 28:18 and he added that that would help reduce 28:20 the deficit 28:21 and debt long term so when you hear 28:24 stuff like that 28:24 that's definitely beginning to sound an 28:28 awful lot like uh 28:30 an administration that's starting to 28:32 worry about deficits and debt 28:38 know me 28:41 yeah um i mean i feel like stephanie and 28:43 i have had this debate a little bit 28:45 where 28:45 i i just am like i'm really in favor of 28:48 raising taxes on corporations and the 28:50 wealthy and 28:51 i work i get the and i think i think you 28:54 are too like in theory 28:56 um we want to do it not because we need 28:59 it to pay for this 29:01 but because we have absolutely untenable 29:03 levels of inequality 29:05 and we need redistributive policies 29:07 because inequality of the kind that we 29:10 have 29:10 is a moral hazard it's it's it's 29:13 it's it's epically dangerous that we 29:16 have 29:16 a billionaire class with so much excess 29:19 capital 29:20 that they're able to not only buy off 29:22 our political class 29:24 but build multiple escape routes 29:27 including literally their planet bees 29:30 right the the uh 29:31 the uh the slogan of the climate justice 29:33 movement is there is no planet 29:34 planet b but um jeff bezos and elon musk 29:38 beg to differ because they're they're 29:41 building rocket ships to go there 29:43 uh to escape the mess they've made and i 29:45 think that that's 29:46 um it is it's a moral hazard for the 29:49 wealthy to not have to live 29:51 in the mess that they create the the 29:53 rockets to mars 29:54 are an extreme expression of this but i 29:57 think we're seeing 29:59 the retreat of the wealthy into 30:02 sort of gated castles of various kinds 30:05 um 30:07 in extreme forms throughout the pandemic 30:09 right and i think the sort of stay at 30:10 home orders have really accelerated that 30:12 process where it's like 30:14 you know the home has the classroom the 30:16 home has the boardroom the home has 30:18 everything that you need and anything 30:20 that you don't have can be delivered 30:22 by drone or through some no touch 30:24 technology and so on 30:26 so i i don't i i'm interested 30:29 stephanie that you that you feel that 30:31 that that the 30:32 that the tax increase is the 30:36 tell that we are going to 30:39 face austerity because my fear is that 30:41 if we don't 30:42 have the tax increase that 30:46 it increases our chances of a couple 30:48 years down the road being told oh we've 30:51 we've driven up the deficit so much that 30:53 now 30:54 we can't do anything more and we know 30:56 that even though 30:57 two point you said two five is a 31:00 staggering sum 31:01 it's also not enough um you know if we 31:05 want to have uh climate action 31:08 on this at the speed and scale 31:12 that we actually need to to to prevent 31:14 catastrophic warming 31:15 it's about a third of the size of the 31:17 spending that we need 31:19 so i'm worried that if we don't increase 31:22 taxes 31:23 and increase revenue that it accelerates 31:27 the point at which we get told sorry 31:29 coffers are empty we can't do anything 31:31 um but but uh tell me why i'm wrong 31:34 stephanie because 31:36 all right so here's the thing i think 31:39 that almost no one any longer believes 31:43 the coffers are bare the deficits of the 31:46 past constrain the spending capacity of 31:48 the future 31:49 we were told that with the obama 31:51 deficits we need a simpson polls 31:53 commission we have to have austerity 31:55 we're not going to be able to survive my 31:56 god the deficit the deficit so we got 31:58 austerity 31:59 and we got the pivot to austerity we got 32:01 trump trump comes in 32:03 and he wants to do these huge tax cuts 32:05 and people like larry summers 32:07 right who was treasury secretary under 32:09 president clinton he was obama's senior 32:12 economic advisor head of the national 32:13 economic council 32:15 larry goes ballistic larry hates the 32:17 idea of the republican tax cuts he does 32:19 one of his interventions he goes 32:21 all over the media in november of 2017. 32:25 larry's all over the place and he's 32:27 saying if the republicans pass these tax 32:29 cuts 32:30 these are his words we will be living on 32:32 a shoestring 32:34 for decades to come because of the 32:36 increase 32:37 in the deficits we will be living on a 32:39 shoestring for decades to come 32:41 republicans pass the tax cuts the 32:43 following month 32:44 deficits increase cbo says by 1.9 32:47 trillion over 10 years 32:49 we have a huge increase in deficit what 32:51 happens growth picks up a little bit 32:53 unemployment goes down a little bit 32:54 inequality widens 32:56 inflation stays low coronavirus comes 32:59 and we're spending trillions and 33:01 trillions of dollars so what i'm saying 33:02 first is i think everyone can now see 33:05 that you know the government doesn't 33:08 have to keep its powder dry we don't 33:09 have 33:10 to run small deficits or anything like 33:12 that in order to be able to afford to do 33:14 things in the future now the bigger 33:16 point for me naomi is this and i did a 33:18 thread yesterday 33:19 because i get really agitated about 33:22 where i think this administration 33:24 is going right now and the mistakes i 33:26 see them making 33:27 so here's what we have the buying 33:31 administration says 2.25 33:33 that's what they come out with and they 33:34 want to pay for every penny of it 33:36 mostly through increased taxes on 33:39 corporations they want to take the 33:40 corporate income tax rate from 21 33:42 percent 33:43 back up uh up to 28 right republicans 33:46 dropped it from 35 percent to 21. 33:48 democrats won't go from 21 33:50 to 28. well biden does but already 33:53 a number of democrats are saying no 33:56 they're pushing back they don't want to 33:57 go to 28 they're buying into this 33:59 we'll lose competitiveness and all that 34:01 sort of stuff maybe we'll go to 25. 34:04 now as soon as you do that you've given 34:06 up some revenue 34:08 so then what do you do do you then scale 34:10 down the ambition of your spending 34:12 package because you've lost some revenue 34:14 so you say well we can only do a smaller 34:17 package now do you start fighting over 34:19 different taxes to increase do you 34:21 really think 34:22 do you really think that in this senate 34:25 that we have today 34:26 that you have 50 democrats who will vote 34:30 for a slew of tax increases i guarantee 34:33 you 34:34 there is no there is not support for a 34:36 wealth tax forget about it 34:38 impossible what about all the rest of 34:40 the things that 34:41 you might imagine that democrats could 34:43 do that you're gonna have a hell of a 34:45 fight 34:45 i'm i'm seriously concerned that the 34:48 votes aren't there 34:49 if the votes are there terrific go for 34:51 it they're not there joe manchin is not 34:53 going to vote for a tax increase 34:54 yeah so so here's the thing that i said 34:56 in this thread i said if the votes are 34:58 there great go 34:59 knock yourselves out push taxes up do 35:01 your offsets and 35:03 and you know play play the pay for game 35:05 go do it 35:06 but what if the votes aren't there i 35:08 want to know that there's a plan b 35:10 and so i suggested a plan b yesterday 35:13 the irs commissioner 35:14 testified yesterday before i think the 35:16 senate finance committee uh senator 35:18 wyden's committee 35:19 the irs commissioner comes in and he 35:22 sits down and he says you know 35:24 if we had enough funding to enforce the 35:27 tax laws that are 35:28 already on the books we could 35:31 get an extra one trillion dollars a year 35:35 that's 10 trillion over 10 years 35:38 which by the way is the same number that 35:40 people like ed markey and aoc 35:42 are saying we should be 10 trillion not 35:45 2.25 so kelton comes on 35:48 and does a big twitter thread and says 35:49 hey has anybody noticed 35:51 that there's 10 trillion in low hanging 35:53 fruit here you don't 35:54 have to vote to raise a single tax give 35:57 the irs the resources they need 35:59 let them go out and generate you 10 36:01 trillion and go for the much bigger 36:03 package so that's where i am 36:05 yeah that sounds great to me and i i 36:07 definitely think strategically 36:10 the push needs to be to just spend and 36:12 don't hold it back 36:13 just spend improve people's material 36:16 lives and get a bigger majority 36:18 um because this is just too close it 36:20 gives way too much power to certain 36:22 people 36:22 um and and and and they will fight that 36:26 too 36:27 because of what jana said earlier about 36:30 what austerity is really about it's 36:31 about disciplining 36:33 uh a workforce and you know as you were 36:35 talking honest about mr peel i was 36:37 remembering 36:39 this quote from a dupont executive 36:43 in 1933 opposing fdr's new deal 36:46 and i think it was 33 maybe it was 34 36:49 where he was complaining that he had 36:52 lost 36:53 five servants because the government was 36:56 paying 36:56 uh such good wages for people to 37:00 uh to build things and paint things um 37:02 and he wasn't able to hold on to his 37:04 household staff it was just a disaster 37:06 for him right 37:08 and i think if we think about that as a 37:09 microcosm for what 37:11 um silicon valley is really going to be 37:13 worried about and 37:14 think about the the recent union drive 37:17 at an amazon 37:18 warehouse that failed but it failed in a 37:20 context where there was no competition 37:23 if you listen to workers 37:24 in bessemer who voted against the union 37:27 it's like look this is a 37:28 an abusive job it's punishing on the 37:31 body 37:32 but it pays 15 an hour and it has some 37:34 benefits and they're the only ones 37:36 offering it 37:37 right um so you know we need to be 37:40 thinking about 37:40 front loading um the the direct 37:44 creation of well-paying job in part 37:46 because 37:48 that empowers workers 37:51 to demand more right because they're 37:53 going to be the force 37:54 that are going to be demanding and 37:56 related to this is the push for 37:58 um better protections for for 38:00 unionization 38:01 under the pro act which um i think is 38:04 another really key piece of this so how 38:05 how do we change the dynamics so that we 38:08 can win that full 38:09 10 10 trillion to actually um 38:13 deal with the climate crisis yeah you 38:15 know just earlier today i read that 38:18 um on this very day a number of 38:20 republicans 38:21 in the senate are introducing a bill to 38:24 establish 38:25 one of these fiscal responsibility 38:27 commissions like a simpson bulls 2.0 38:31 and they want this this they want to 38:33 assemble a bipartisan commission 38:35 and charge them with the mandate of 38:37 working together 38:38 on a plan to balance the budget 38:42 so if you're when you say they're going 38:44 to fight back and make sure that 38:45 that money is not spent on poor people 38:48 on improving the lives materially of 38:50 people and dealing with climate 38:52 this is all part of the way that they're 38:54 laying attempting to lay the foundation 38:56 for that now i hope that they won't find 38:58 a single democrat 38:59 to sign on you know to that uh 39:02 legislation but 39:04 you know you've got a number of these 39:05 people who for many years have 39:08 flexed their you know fiscal hockey 39:12 bonafides and and viewed themselves as 39:15 you know hawkish on uh the budget and so 39:18 forth so 39:19 i get worried about you know a number of 39:22 of democratic senators who might 39:25 align with these republicans around the 39:27 establishment of a commission like this 39:29 which would just 39:30 undermine completely the progressive 39:33 agenda 39:34 and and i think we need to um be really 39:38 clear that whether we're talking about 39:39 the us or we're talking about the uk 39:41 or or certainly in i'm in canada right 39:43 now 39:44 um you know austerity 39:48 a lot of it plays out not at the federal 39:50 level right i mean it's about cities 39:52 it's about 39:53 it's about provinces and states and you 39:55 know this is what's determining 39:57 education budgets which and we're 39:59 already starting to hear 40:00 the first cries of look you know we lost 40:03 our tax base 40:04 we can't afford public transit we can't 40:06 afford to pay for education 40:08 and brian i really want to come back to 40:10 your question around 40:12 what about growth because i think we 40:13 haven't tackled that and i think that 40:15 that is 40:16 the elephant in the room and it's 40:17 actually 40:20 weirdly possible that we could spend 40:22 trillions of dollars building out green 40:24 infrastructure 40:25 and increase carbon emissions because um 40:28 if we aren't dealing with consumption 40:30 um it it it's possible to have 40:34 a a green carbon boom as as 40:38 contradictory as that is so what we need 40:40 to be doing is investing 40:42 in low-carbon sectors we need to be um 40:45 we need to be looking at what actually 40:47 improves quality of life 40:49 um and investing in uh 40:53 you know access to nature 40:56 recreation um giving people shorter work 41:00 weeks 41:00 um really investing in well-being and 41:03 the care economy 41:05 and moving away from from endless 41:07 consumption 41:08 fighting for the right to repair um and 41:11 and and and dealing with the the 41:14 mentality that we can just shift 41:17 from fossil fuel extraction to green 41:19 energy and live 41:20 exactly how we're living as our daddy 41:22 roy says you know middle-class 41:24 environmentalists ask the question how 41:25 do we change without changing 41:28 um and the answer is we don't 41:31 we actually have to change how we live 41:33 um 41:34 and so um so i think that that's that 41:36 that's a really really key 41:38 question um and 41:41 yeah i i i also think that whether we're 41:44 dealing with a revenge of the real 41:46 is another important question because i 41:48 think in some ways we are 41:49 and in another way we're dealing with a 41:51 retreat into 41:53 screens um and this 41:56 brings up my other austerity fear which 41:59 is 42:00 what the agenda is of silicon valley and 42:02 all this 42:03 um because what i worry about is cities 42:05 going broke 42:07 and um and then smart cities 42:10 coming in as the fix and i'll give an 42:13 example from toronto where uh 42:15 google tried to um uh 42:19 they tried to use toronto as this 42:21 laboratory for the smart city idea so 42:23 they tried to 42:24 um do this thing called google has this 42:26 division called sidewalk labs 42:28 and they were going to do sidewalk 42:29 toronto basically their pitch was 42:32 to the toronto city council you can't 42:35 fix the potholes 42:36 you can't invest in green energy you 42:38 can't invest 42:39 in in in public transit 42:42 we'll do it all we'll build a beautiful 42:44 emerald green city but we're also going 42:46 to put you all 42:47 under the most intense surveillance of 42:49 data extraction you know that 42:51 we see anywhere outside of china um and 42:54 thankfully toronto fought back and in 42:55 the middle of the pandemic and it was 42:57 just a little 42:58 you know footnote to all the drama um 43:00 google 43:01 pulled out of the sidewalk labs 43:03 cancelled their toronto contract but the 43:04 ceo of sidewalk labs when they pulled 43:06 out 43:06 said we don't think we got off on the 43:09 right foot with toronto but we see 43:12 all kinds of post-pandemic opportunities 43:15 and what i read between the lines there 43:18 is 43:18 cities around the world are going to be 43:20 dead broke and we're going to come in 43:22 and save the day 43:23 and we just have to have this on our 43:25 radar in how we think about what 43:27 what the next phase of austerity looks 43:28 like it's trading our privacy 43:31 for um you know this kind of 43:34 tech enclosure and privatization through 43:37 the back door 


ケルトン

43:40 one thing i would add on um 43:44 on the growth issue is this you know 43:48 for so many years the obsession was 43:51 with that so-called debt sustainability 43:54 and with debt to gdp ratios 43:56 right this idea that there was some 43:59 for a while we were told tipping points 44:01 that if countries 44:02 allow their debt relative to their gdp 44:05 to reach 44:06 90 this is a threshold of some kind you 44:09 tip over the 44:10 90 uh level and then a lot of bad things 44:13 happen the risk of fiscal crises and 44:15 slower growth and all this stuff right 44:16 so 44:17 the countries that saw their debt may be 44:20 approaching 44:21 that so-called tipping point then become 44:23 obsessed 44:24 with trying to wrestle the debt ratio 44:27 down 44:28 and giannis talked in the opening about 44:30 you know that how counterproductive 44:32 austerity 44:33 is so you start focusing on the 44:35 numerator 44:36 the debt how do we bring the debt down 44:38 austerity so you start cutting spending 44:40 but one person spending is another 44:42 person's income and so you undermine the 44:44 ability of that person to spend in an 44:46 economy that runs on sales right 44:48 capitalism 44:49 runs on sales which generate revenue 44:51 which generates the profit that makes 44:53 capitalism viable so you you 44:57 adopt austerity to try to target the 45:00 numerator the debt 45:02 as in an attempt to reduce the numerator 45:05 to bring the whole ratio down 45:07 but what happens is you crush the 45:08 economy so gdp 45:10 falls so the ratio actually gets bigger 45:12 so austerity doesn't work but the other 45:14 piece 45:15 is that we become obsessed 45:19 with the idea of growing our way out of 45:21 debt 45:22 so if you focus on the denominator 45:24 instead of the numerator 45:26 then the strategy the economic strategy 45:29 can become 45:29 we just need to grow really fast and if 45:32 we can grow 45:33 fast enough we can outrun our debt 45:35 problem 45:36 and so i think in a lot of ways for many 45:39 countries 45:39 the the obsession with growth is very 45:42 much bound up 45:43 with this obsession that countries have 45:46 about 45:46 the idea that the debt is unsustainable 45:49 that it represents a burden on the 45:51 future and that you've got to get the 45:52 you know get the ratio down in order to 45:56 you know a fiscally sustainable um sort 45:59 of situation 46:00 and and i think that that then feeds 46:02 this 46:03 um this growth obsession which naomi's 46:06 talking about we have to get away from .

クライン

46:08 well you know it and that really um 46:11 reminds me of something i've been 46:13 thinking about around when people talk 46:15 about the new deal 46:16 um they often say but yeah but it failed 46:19 right it failed because actually it 46:21 didn't pull 46:22 the us into a growth position 46:25 so because and because we define failure 46:28 as anything short of growth 46:30 right um and we define success a 46:33 successful economy as an economy that's 46:35 in a boom 46:36 you know we all know the narrative right 46:38 it wasn't the new deal that pulled the 46:39 that ended the 46:40 the the great depression it was the 46:42 second world war the post-war boom 46:44 that was also what set off suburban 46:46 sprawl and and a level of consumption 46:48 that is at the heart of the climate 46:50 crisis so 46:52 did and i always kind of accepted this 46:54 idea that the green 46:55 that the new deal failed but i guess i 46:58 want to ask the economist like did it 47:00 fail because it did create jobs and it 47:02 pulled a lot of people out of poverty 47:05 do we have to start telling people that 47:07 it didn't fail of course it didn't fit 47:12 no i agree with i agree with the honest 47:14 no i cannot say that it failed 47:18 of the millions of people and people 47:21 talk that way about japan 47:22 i was just going to say stephanie talk 47:24 to the descendants of the millions of 47:25 people 47:26 oh okay no no i i i think 47:29 you could probably talk a lot more about 47:31 that i was just going to say you know 47:32 it's 47:33 in some ways it reminds me of the 47:34 discussion that we keep hearing about 47:36 japan today 47:38 that um japan has you know been growing 47:41 very slowly 47:42 has very uh low inflation uh 47:45 you know usually around one percent or 47:48 less than one percent and somehow 47:49 we've decided we you know uh the 47:52 profession 47:53 academic economist in particular policy 47:55 makers that 47:56 japan is is is 47:59 a fail it's it's a failure that they 48:02 don't have 48:03 rapid growth and i and i go to japan and 48:05 i look around that 48:06 everything is beautiful the 48:08 infrastructure is is first-rate things 48:10 work 48:11 people are happy you know it's it's not 48:13 evident 48:14 that uh that japan is experiencing deep 48:18 economic difficulties uh it's just that 48:21 people have decided that 48:22 economies are supposed to grow faster 48:24 than two percent and inflation is 48:26 supposed to be a little bit higher and 48:27 if you don't 48:28 achieve those metrics then somehow you 48:30 know it's 48:32 it's viewed upon it's viewed as a as a 48:34 failure in some sense 48:36 failure of policy 48:40 just a a quick snippet um 48:43 i think i have the right to speak on 48:45 this matter because i'm calling you from 48:48 the epicenter from ground zero of 48:50 austerity 48:51 and of the dead spiral that you were 48:54 describing stephanie 48:58 here our 1933 moment 49:02 came in 2014 you know three years 49:06 after our 1929 moment which was you know 49:09 uh in 2011 here in greece we already had 49:12 lost 49:13 28 25 percent of gdp right 49:17 um now if there was a new deal at that 49:19 moment 49:20 and things had stabilized and started 49:22 improving on a per capita basis 49:25 and people actually you know had fewer 49:27 wrinkles on their faces and could sleep 49:29 at night without worrying how you know 49:31 what kind of day they would have the 49:33 next morning 49:34 that would have been a majestic success 49:36 and we didn't have that 49:38 we had a continuation of the downward 49:39 spiral which we still have today 49:41 so if the new deal did for americans 49:45 that we you know the favor that we 49:49 um man failed to provide to our people 49:53 in 2014 49:54 it was a major success also soil 49:57 conservation 49:58 uh the the sense of community all those 50:01 intangibles 50:02 that effectively stopped america from 50:05 becoming a fascist country 50:07 uh america would have become a fascist 50:08 country without the new deal how do you 50:11 measure the value of having avoided 50:13 fascism 50:17 so how important is it to fight for 50:19 different economic indicators 50:21 in a moment like this because so long as 50:24 gdp is the measure of success 50:26 this will be wielded against us as a 50:28 weapon definitely 50:29 i mean there are um people i think it's 50:32 important 50:32 and there are people like there's a very 50:35 uh interesting guy 50:36 named phil philip long he's an 50:38 australian economist and he has 50:40 developed 50:41 an alternative measure of well-being he 50:45 calls it the gpi 50:46 the genuine progress indicator it takes 50:49 into account a variety of things 50:52 including benefits surrounding uh 50:54 investments in climate 50:56 cost benefits uh you know a more 50:59 comprehensive 51:00 uh way to think about you know how to 51:03 how to talk about a country's 51:06 improvements 51:07 in national well-being over time and 51:09 he's trying to get the oecd world bank 51:11 others to you know adopt he says because 51:14 he's built this stuff out and it's sort 51:16 of there for the taking if he could get 51:18 um you know broader interest in 51:21 disseminating and tracking 51:22 measures like this i think it's 51:24 important 51:26 something that can i can i'm sorry brian 51:29 no you go ahead go ahead no i i just 51:31 wanted to play devil's advocate for just 51:33 a second stephanie on this 51:35 you see the problem with capitalism is 51:36 that whatever indicators you and i 51:38 create 51:39 and follow the fact of the matter is 51:41 that if you are indebted 51:44 as an individual as a company as a 51:45 household and you have a mortgage that 51:48 is 51:49 non-performing and you have people 51:51 trying to foreclose on your house 51:53 or if you are the finance minister 51:55 because i've had a terrible experience 51:57 and you have to grow your tax 52:01 revenue in order to try to pretend that 52:03 you're repaying a debt that can never be 52:05 repaid 52:06 then whatever indicators uh wonderful 52:08 economists come up with they're 52:09 irrelevant 52:10 uh so the the this is me playing 52:14 davis advocate we need far more radical 52:18 change than that we need to have major 52:20 debt restructuring both at the private 52:22 and the public 52:23 level for countries that don't have the 52:26 exorbitant privilege of the united 52:27 states you know 52:28 our country here cannot print their own 52:30 currency as you know therefore we cannot 52:32 go through the process 52:33 of creating money the way you described 52:36 um the fed being able to 52:39 there are many countries around the 52:41 world either because they're not 52:42 printing their own currency or because 52:43 they're borrowing in the currency that 52:45 they are not printing 52:47 so i will 52:51 shut up with two questions the first one 52:54 is 52:55 primarily for naomi we have three 52:57 economic blocks we have the united 52:59 states major economic blocks 53:01 the united states the european union and 53:02 china 53:04 how far away are each one of them or how 53:07 close are they 53:08 to your right notion of a green new deal 53:12 and that's yeah that's one question the 53:13 second question is can we ever imagine 53:17 being able through simply macroeconomic 53:20 means to ameliorate for the fact that 53:23 the missed appeals of the world 53:26 given the ownership structure of 53:28 capitalist corporations 53:30 will always have the power and the 53:32 motivation 53:35 to be austerian in order to 53:38 prevent the masses the many from gaining 53:41 power 53:44 um okay those are great big questions 53:48 um and i want to know what brian was 53:51 about to say too 53:52 what were you about yeah we do okay yes 53:54 well maybe maybe that connects somewhat 53:56 with um 53:57 what janus was just saying i wanted to 53:59 go back to kovid and 54:01 to say that could it be that one of the 54:03 legacies of kovid is that 54:05 they've che it has changed our sense of 54:07 values 54:08 for instance in england we suddenly 54:11 discovered that there was a class of 54:12 people called 54:13 essential workers and we also discovered 54:16 that those were the people who 54:17 consistently earn less than 54:19 everybody else so these people who we 54:22 suddenly 54:23 all depended on for our lives literally 54:26 are the lowest paid people in 54:27 in the british economy and 54:30 the other thing we discovered that was 54:32 that we 54:34 cared about other people in ways that we 54:37 had perhaps 54:38 forgotten you know we've been for 10 54:40 years in the grip of a kind of media 54:42 system that 54:43 has basically been monetized by hate and 54:46 anger 54:48 that's that's where the money is in 54:50 social media and 54:51 actually in straightforward television 54:54 and newspapers as well 54:56 more and more you know there's some very 54:58 interesting writing about this 55:00 more and more we've been encouraged to 55:02 to be 55:03 hating each other and to be angry with 55:05 each other and 55:06 certainly what has happened in england 55:09 over the last year 55:11 is is the funnily enough even though 55:14 we've all been in lockdown and isolation 55:16 is the rediscovery of a sense of 55:18 community people have been 55:20 helping each other um realizing that 55:24 they 55:24 actually liked each other they miss each 55:27 other 55:27 when they they don't meet up and 55:31 this the thing you mentioned the care 55:33 economy 55:34 seems to me the place that we should 55:36 really be 55:38 looking at now um this this re 55:41 reconnecting because this atomization 55:45 has been catastrophic not only for our 55:48 social relationships but also for 55:51 our environmental impact if we're all 55:54 going to have 55:55 all of these wonderful new products um 55:58 because we're all individuals and we 56:00 deserve them um 56:02 there's no future in that so um 56:05 i'm i'm wondering whether 56:09 the the kind of combination of that and 56:12 the disenfranchisement of the 56:14 magical thinking leaders means that we 56:18 really are on a different 56:19 on a new path now 56:24 i think i think there are a couple of 56:26 paths before us 56:28 um and right now we're trying to go down 56:31 both at the same time 56:33 um and we have to choose and and i think 56:36 that that this should sort of inform 56:38 what we prioritize because i agree 56:40 entirely with you brian that 56:42 there is that that this period has been 56:47 a period of revelation of 56:49 interconnection in lots of ways and i 56:51 don't think that it's 56:53 um it's i don't think it's a coincidence 56:56 that we've 56:56 also seen this huge racial justice 56:59 uprising 57:00 and that it has been more multiracial 57:03 than previous 57:04 moments like this at the moment where we 57:07 have felt 57:08 our interdependencies more and also how 57:11 racialized those inequalities are of who 57:14 who those essential workers are and who 57:16 who is most 57:17 unpaid and unvalued among them 57:21 and so um 57:24 i think as we as we move out of this 57:27 the lockdown period um and some of us 57:30 are still very much in it 57:32 um what what do we prioritize and i 57:36 think that what we want we should 57:38 prioritize 57:38 are those projects that 57:42 build on these revelations of community 57:45 like so just 57:46 um thinking about the new deal right i i 57:49 i think 57:50 um some of the programs of that era 57:54 that are would be most important to to 57:56 revive 57:57 are the funding funding for the arts 57:59 funding for theater 58:01 funding for public mural projects 58:04 funding for 58:05 um uh like like the civilian 58:08 conservation corps that 58:09 that that built um hundreds 800 58:13 state parks and and and and enshrined 58:16 the right to nature 58:17 or and and treated depression not just 58:21 as an economic 58:22 state with all respect to the economists 58:24 but as a 58:25 but as a psychic and psychological state 58:28 and so we need to invest in the things 58:29 that pull people 58:30 literally out of depression right um but 58:33 also 58:34 things we do together so that we 58:36 continue to build 58:37 on this experience of yeah we actually 58:39 like each other we want to spend time 58:40 with each other 58:42 because we can't do everything at once 58:44 so let's really prioritize those things 58:46 that are going to deepen those lessons 58:48 because 58:48 there's also a way in which i really 58:50 fear them being 58:52 swamped away by this kind of get 58:55 shopping again america and we have to 58:57 revive the economy 58:59 yeah can can i just add one thing to 59:02 that 59:04 what has happened in the last year 59:06 partly because of zoom and partly 59:08 because 59:09 we've had no choice other than to use 59:10 zoom for many things 59:13 is that there's been an incredible 59:15 thickening 59:16 of relationships on quite a global level 59:19 so i'm i'm involved in the environmental 59:22 movement 59:23 and i have to say i do 59:26 6 12 15 20 zooms a week 59:30 talking with people like all of you who 59:33 i could never meet in normal life 59:35 in this little village in norfolk where 59:37 i'm living um 59:39 suddenly there's a i think there's a 59:43 huge 59:43 i think of it like the mycorrhizal 59:45 connections 59:47 underneath a forest you know we see the 59:49 trees and it all looks pretty much like 59:51 it's looked for years and years 59:52 but underneath there's this incredible 59:56 thickening and coalescence of thoughts 59:59 and conversations and so on going on 60:01 so i think we're in the middle of a kind 60:03 of revolution which hasn't 60:05 quite been noticed yet it's not on the 60:07 media radar because 60:09 as so often is the case the the radar is 60:11 pointing in the wrong direction 60:13 it's pointing at politics and it's 60:15 pointing at 60:16 uh pundits and media and so on so it's 60:20 it's telling those stories but there's 60:22 another story happening now 60:24 i'm very aware of it because i seem to 60:27 be woven into it now 60:29 which is absolutely dramatic there is so 60:32 much 60:32 intellectual activity going on of a kind 60:35 that 60:36 wasn't apparent at all two years ago 60:39 so i i've become much more optimistic as 60:42 a result of that 60:43 um as i say it's not showing up yet but 60:47 when it does that's like the ignition 60:50 point 60:50 then there's liftoff when when people 60:52 become aware of each other 60:54 you know there's this huge movement as i 60:57 keep saying the biggest movement in 60:58 human history 61:00 the the fight to save the planet there's 61:02 never been anything like it in terms of 61:05 the number of people involved but we're 61:08 we're not quite self-aware yet it's a 61:10 movement that isn't quite self-aware 61:13 oh shut up can i 61:16 let me i'm going to push back on giannis 61:18 pushback 61:19 because to say that we need different 61:22 metrics is not to 61:24 say choosing a different metric and then 61:27 you 61:27 you're done right switch metrics said 61:29 you don't have to do 61:30 anything else to make material 61:31 improvements the idea of the genuine 61:34 progress indicator 61:35 the way i think about it is that it 61:38 helps to do what brian 61:39 is talking about right we have to see 61:42 each other and we have to see the 61:43 problem so if we had 61:46 you know i'm just using the genuine 61:47 progress indicator in his example but 61:49 it's like a mirror it forces you to hold 61:51 a mirror 61:52 up to the country and to evaluate where 61:56 are you falling short 61:57 across a whole range of things that 62:00 you're paying attention to 62:01 and in terms of you know the idea that 62:04 capitalism is always going to be you 62:07 know riddled with these flaws that it is 62:09 by design a system which is oppressive 62:13 to those who find themselves at will 62:16 workers 62:16 right you you are you are a worker who 62:19 um 62:20 off you know usually has your health 62:22 care tied to your employment 62:24 you are um you can you know wake up one 62:27 morning with a job and wake up the next 62:29 day without a job and without the health 62:30 care and all the other things so 62:32 one of the things that i would love to 62:35 see us making more progress on 62:37 is moving toward you know something like 62:40 an fdr 62:41 economic bill of rights where you do 62:43 establish 62:44 public options a public option in the 62:46 labor market public 62:48 option in banking so that you have 62:51 you know the freedom to opt out of uh 62:53 financial 62:54 relationships with wall street banks or 62:56 whatever it is public option 62:58 in education public colleges and 63:00 universities becoming tuition free 63:03 gives agency right um knowing that you 63:06 have a secure retirement 63:07 that you don't have to depend upon 401ks 63:10 and other 63:11 investment schemes to try to build some 63:14 sense of security 63:15 for you know your later years in life 63:18 this is what and and and a right to a 63:20 a clean environment a job at a decent 63:22 wage you know all of the things that fdr 63:24 talked about 63:25 those were things that senator sanders 63:28 in his campaign 63:29 you know put forward as part of his 63:31 platform that 63:32 people ought to have basic rights 63:35 secured 63:36 in these areas and i think you know it's 63:38 still capitalism 63:39 but i i guess i was brought up 63:42 very much on minsky and hyman minsky i 63:45 think one of the great economists of the 63:46 last century minsky used to say there 63:48 are 63:49 as many varieties of capitalism as heinz 63:51 has pickles 63:52 you know and the heinz pickles slogan is 63:54 57 varieties 63:56 so you have the kinds of capitalism that 63:59 failed 63:59 badly leading up to the great depression 64:02 the 64:02 kind of capitalism that fdr helped to 64:04 build that 64:05 you know produced better outcomes for 64:08 millions of people 64:10 rising incomes and and better economic 64:12 conditions and better labor conditions 64:14 and so forth and then 64:15 as we whittle those away over the years 64:17 from reagan especially on 64:19 uh then finance capitalism and and a 64:22 harsher 64:23 version and so i think there are just 64:24 ways to um 64:27 to you know introduce safeguards 64:31 various protections for people that get 64:33 us 64:34 to um you know the kind of a world that 64:36 i think we're all talking about trying 64:38 to build 64:41 except stephanie that if you give a 64:43 public option to the labor market 64:46 you're effectively allowing workers to 64:49 do what 64:50 mr appeals workers did and therefore 64:52 collapse capitalism 64:54 i don't believe you can give a genuine 64:56 public option and i'm all for it 64:58 giving a giant public option to workers 65:00 in the labor market without actually 65:02 collapsing the labor market that's why 65:04 you know 65:05 my dogma if you want because i'm not we 65:08 don't have time to discuss it is that 65:10 you can't really get rid of austerity 65:12 until you get rid 65:13 of tradable shares but that's another 65:16 discussion i'm sure 65:18 part two just for one sec i know naomi's 65:21 gotta 65:21 go so we we just want i would just okay 65:24 you guys figure this out 65:26 put in a word for ecosocialism and tell 65:28 you all that i love talking with you 65:31 and um i look forward to too much much 65:34 more and 65:35 i love that image of yours brian um of 65:38 uh 65:39 of where the network under the trees i 65:41 love that 65:42 i love that um beautiful 65:45 okay thank you thanks naomi you made me 65:53 to wrap it up i mean obviously 65:56 we could go on for for another two hours 65:59 but it's been uh 66:02 an incredibly interesting and dense chat 66:06 we've had um i want to apologize to uh 66:08 people that have actually asked 66:10 a lot of questions on the chat but we 66:12 won't have time to answer all of your 66:15 questions 66:17 i wanted to um to thank you stephanie 66:21 for taking part and um enlighting us 66:25 enlightening us on um on 66:28 economics and and many other things 66:31 i mean i had one question which was more 66:34 a comment actually 66:35 uh someone wrote um everything you say 66:38 is right 66:38 but unless we can organize into a 66:40 powerful mass 66:41 movement will it mean anything um 66:45 are we not bored of being merely correct 66:49 and that's i guess a key question that 66:50 we won't have to answer tonight but uh 66:52 brian 66:52 touch upon it we obviously need to you 66:55 know 66:56 educate mobilize organize so uh i don't 67:00 know if yannis brian you want to 67:02 say a quick word to wrap it up but um 67:07 i will just say reiterate quickly that 67:10 it is happening i think there is a 67:11 coalescence going on 67:13 and it's happening very very fast 67:17 and it will suddenly become apparent and 67:19 we'll suddenly look around and think 67:21 jesus the world is a completely 67:22 different place from what i imagined 67:25 um we're used to thinking of ourselves 67:27 as the outsiders 67:29 as the people who are sort of the 67:31 resistance to this huge 67:33 system that is eternal that is strong 67:36 and has lobbyists and lots of money and 67:39 we're the outsiders kind of chinking 67:40 away at it but but 67:42 i think what we're soon going to do is 67:43 look around and realize that 67:45 actually they're the minority we are a 67:48 vast majority 67:49 and we're actually comparatively well 67:51 organized so i i think it will be a 67:53 little bit like um what happened at the 67:56 end of the soviet union where 67:59 the system collapsed and everybody just 68:02 got on with life 68:03 they were ready for it people had 68:06 actually prepared themselves for it 68:08 they had got in place all their work 68:10 around 68:12 and the system didn't actually do much 68:14 any longer 68:15 so i i think i hope that that's where 68:19 we're going 68:21 um stephanie is probably somebody must 68:24 have the last word but let me just say 68:26 quickly regarding organizing 68:28 we are organizing um yeah stephanie is 68:30 part of a movement in the united states 68:33 you know bernie sanders aoc and so on 68:36 elected joe biden 68:38 when bernie was effectively blocked yet 68:41 again 68:41 um in europe we have dm-25 68:45 across the world uh we're open army is 68:48 part of the progressive international 68:49 we're together in this so we are 68:51 organizing this is not idle talk 68:53 it is essential talk because with you 68:56 cannot organize unless you also organize 68:58 your thoughts 68:59 uh around the campaigns and the actions 69:02 that are necessary stephanie 69:04 no i i would just say thank you to all 69:07 of you for the 69:08 opportunity to join you and uh yes i 69:11 mean 69:11 you know i worked for for bernie so uh 69:14 i heard him say if i heard it once i 69:16 heard it a thousand times you know 69:18 change never comes from the top 69:19 down it always comes from the bottom up 69:21 and uh and i think 69:23 that's exactly what brian is is saying 69:25 that's what we all understand and 69:27 so i think you know we're throwing our 69:29 shoulders into these movements 69:31 uh around the world and and trying to be 69:34 part of 69:34 you know uh accelerating that change 69:37 that brian thinks 69:39 we're inevitably on the cusp of and i i 69:42 hope you're right 69:43 so do i thank you so much stephanie 69:47 thanks 69:48 thanks again everyone and thanks for 69:50 everyone watching of course 69:52 the next show will be on may 13th so 69:54 we'll send more info about this 69:56 uh soon um again 69:59 thanks thanks a million everyone all 70:02 right good night 70:03 and thanks to joanne at the who's been 70:05 uh thank you 70:07 good job 70:22 [Music] 70:41 [Music] 70:56 foreign 71:00 [Music] 71:03 foreign 1:30:38 再生中

5 件のコメント:

  1. 69:04 no i i would just say thank you to all 69:07 of you for the 69:08 opportunity to join you and uh yes i 69:11 mean 69:11 you know i worked for for bernie so uh 69:14 i heard him say if i heard it once i 69:16 heard it a thousand times you know 69:18 change never comes from the top 69:19 down it always comes from the bottom up 69:21 and uh and i think 69:23 that's exactly what brian is is saying 69:25 that's what we all understand and 69:27 so i think you know we're throwing our 69:29 shoulders into these movements 69:31 uh around the world and and trying to be 69:34 part of 69:34 you know uh accelerating that change 69:37 that brian thinks 69:39 we're inevitably on the cusp of and i i 69:42 hope you're right

    返信削除
  2. 69:04 いや、私はただ、69:07皆さんに69:08参加する機会を与えてくれたことに感謝したいと思います。
    69:18 変化は決して上から来るものではなく、69:19 下から来るものなのです 69:21 .
    そして、69:23 ブライアンが言っていることはまさにその通りで、69:25 それは私たち全員が理解していることであり、69:27 だからこそ、私たちはこれらの動きに69:29 肩を投じているのだと思います。
    そして、69:34の一部になろうとしています。69:34つまり、ブライアンが考えている69:37の変化を加速させるために、69:39私たちは必然的にその入り口に立っているのであり、私はあなたが正しいことを願っています。

    返信削除
  3. 69:04 no i i would just say thank you to all 69:07 of you for the 69:08 opportunity to join you and uh yes i 69:11 mean 69:11 you know i worked for for bernie so uh 69:14 i heard him say if i heard it once.
    i 69:16 heard it a thousand times you know 69:18 change never comes from the top 69:19 down it always comes from the bottom up 69:21 .
    and uh and i think 69:23 that's exactly what brian is is saying 69:25 that's what we all understand and 69:27 so i think you know we're throwing our 69:29 shoulders into these movements 69:31 .
    uh around the world and and trying to be 69:34 part of 69:34 you know uh accelerating that change 69:37 that brian thinks 69:39 we're inevitably on the cusp of and i i 69:42 hope you're right

    返信削除
  4. 69:04 no i i would just say thank you to all 69:07 of you for the 69:08 opportunity to join you and uh yes i 69:11 mean 69:11 you know i worked for for bernie.
    so uh 69:14 i heard him say if i heard it once.
    i 69:16 heard it a thousand times you know 69:18 change never comes from the top 69:19 down it always comes from the bottom up 69:21 .
    and uh and i think 69:23 that's exactly what brian is is saying 69:25 that's what we all understand and 69:27 so i think you know we're throwing our 69:29 shoulders into these movements 69:31 .
    uh around the world and and trying to be 69:34 part of 69:34 you know uh accelerating that change 69:37 that brian thinks 69:39 we're inevitably on the cusp of and i i 69:42 hope you're right

    69:04 いや、私はただ、69:07皆さんに69:08参加する機会を与えてくれたことに感謝したいと思います。
    69:11 つまり、69:11 私はバーニーのために働いていました。
    69:18 変化は決して上から来るものではなく、69:19 下から来るものなのです 69:21 .
    そして、69:23 ブライアンが言っていることはまさにその通りで、69:25 それは私たち全員が理解していることであり、


    69:27 だからこそ、私たちはこれらの動きに69:29 肩を投じているのだと思います。
    そして、69:34の一部になろうとしています。69:34つまり、ブライアンが考えている69:37の変化を加速させるために、69:39私たちは必然的にその入り口に立っているのであり、私はあなたが正しいことを願っています。

    返信削除
  5. There is no planet B Fascinating exchange between Naomi Klein and Ste...
    https://youtu.be/du5bQBRpEYQ

    返信削除