Kelton 2018年3月 JGP
https://love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com/2021/01/kelton-20183jgp.html?m=1 @
https://www.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/2133355681582705445/7266112598884057775
https://x.com/fukuko2025/status/1922750331076657551?s=61
モズラー2013
https://youtu.be/FR-BZLAxB9M?si=wil0wO84HGjCPYol
https://x.com/tiikituukahana/status/1194572916286840832?s=61
ビル・ミッチェル2020
https://youtu.be/RYFWf-Ebvx0?si=SOtdwjJwgf-rrxcQ
https://x.com/TiikituukaHana/status/1268348412086214656
チャーネバ2020
https://youtube.com/shorts/unrzHjjwAO8?si=xpsqTiiyPnLjToql
https://vt.tiktok.com/ZShH3qNp7/

https://i.gyazo.com/5d3047f079109f54883f07b55a117c4e.gif
https://i.gyazo.com/e0999514be55f94230453bf9c539846a.gif
https://x.com/fukuko2025/status/1922750331076657551?s=61
https://bsky.app/profile/yojiseki.bsky.social/post/3lp5tgshzjk27
JGP雇用保証プログラムのイメージ:
アルゼンチンの"Plan Jefes” の詳細 2
Figure 5 Reasons why Jefes beneficiaries are satisfied with the program
I have an income
I do what is required
I can do something
I help the community
It provides a good environment
I learn Reasons Why You Are Satisfied With the Program
SOURCE: Ministry of Labor, Employment and Social Security, Argentina
アルゼンチンの「プラン・ジェフェス」の詳細 2
図 5 Jefes の受益者がプログラムに満足している理由
収入がある
求められていることはやります
何かできるよ
私はコミュニティを助けます
良い環境を提供してくれます
あなたがプログラムに満足している理由がわかりました
出典: アルゼンチン労働・雇用・社会保障省
Public Employment and Women: The Impact of Argentina's Jefes Program on Female Heads of Poor Households
Levy Economics Institute Working Papers Series No. 519
41 PagesPosted: 13 Nov 2007
Date Written: November 12, 2007
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1029661
Public Employment and Women: The Impact of Argentina's Jefes Program on Female Heads of Poor Households
Levy Economics Institute Working Papers Series No. 519
41 Pages
Posted: 13 Nov 2007
Pavlina R. Tcherneva
Bard College - The Levy Economics Institute
L. Randall Wray
University of Missouri at Kansas City; Bard College - The Levy Economics Institute
Date Written: November 12, 2007
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1029661
https://i.imgur.com/piqQDda.jpg
3. Beneficiaries’ Satisfaction with the Program 2005 FemaleMale The response of the beneficiaries to the Jefes plan has also been positive. As Figure 6 shows, only a small fraction of Jefes workers have said that they are dissatisfied with the program, while 90% are either satisfied or very satisfied with it. When asked how they felt when requesting the program, most people (over 70%) reported “respected,” as opposed to “undervalued” or “politically used” (Figure 7). Some of the reasons for this satisfaction include the opportunity “to do something” and “help the community,” but note that the second largest reason for satisfaction that people report is the good environment that Jefes jobs provide (Figure 8). It is especially significant that participants rate these reasons far above “I have an income.” When asked what they would prefer to do as part of Jefes, most people stated that they would like to be involved in training and community projects (Figure 9). 9 Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1029661
3. 受益者のプログラムに対する満足度 2005年 女性男性 Jefesプランに対する受益者の反応もポジティブである。図6に示すように、ジェフェス従事者のうち、プログラムに不満があると答えた人はごく一部であり、9割が満足または非常に満足している。また、プログラムを依頼する際にどのように感じたかという質問に対しては、「過小評価されている」「政治的に利用されている」ではなく、「尊重されている」と答えた人が70%以上と多い(図7)。その理由として、「何かできる」「地域の役に立てる」などが挙げられていますが、「ジェフェスの仕事が与えてくれる環境の良さ」が2番目に多く挙げられていることに注目しましょう(図8)。特に、これらの理由が "収入がある "を大きく上回っていることは、大きな特徴です。Jefesの一員として何をしたいかという質問に対しては、ほとんどの人がトレーニングやコミュニティプロジェクトに関わりたいと答えている(図9)。 9 電子版は https://ssrn.com/abstract=1029661 で入手可能です。
Public Employment and Women 2007
Tcherneva & Wray
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1029661
Reasons why Jefes beneficiaries are satisfied with the program
https://i.imgur.com/piqQDda.jpg
《I can do something》
SOURCE: Ministry of Labor, Employment and Social Security, Argentina
Public Employment and Women: The Impact of Argentina's Jefes Program on Female Heads of Poor Households
Levy Economics Institute Working Papers Series No. 519
41 Pages
Posted: 13 Nov 2007
Pavlina R. Tcherneva
Bard College - The Levy Economics Institute
L. Randall Wray
University of Missouri at Kansas City; Bard College - The Levy Economics Institute
Date Written: November 12, 2007
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1029661
https://i.imgur.com/piqQDda.jpg
Ministry of Labour, Employment and Social Security (Argentina) - Wikipedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ministry_of_Labour,_Employment_and_Social_Security_(Argentina)
Ministry of Labour and Social Security Sectoral 2022-2023
ジャマイカ
John Henry 2017 Vested Interest and Limits to Reform - MMT
https://love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com/2021/07/john-henry-2017.html
:ケルトンの大学時代の師匠ジョン・ヘンリーがJGPの重要性について語っている。
https://love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com/2021/05/jgpsadie-tanner-mossell-alexander.html
https://love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com/2021/05/httpspodcasts.html
╋ ビーバー
A Job Guarantee Costs Far Less Than Unemployment
https://nam-students.blogspot.com/2019/11/the-tale-of100-dogs-and-95-bones.html
作業中:
https://iitomo2010.blogspot.com/2020/12/national-job-guarantee-by-professor.html?m=0
National Job Guarantee by Professor Stephanie Kelton at the Sanders Institute - March 2018
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qoMamSmsAIM ☆
サンダース研究所のステファニーケルトン教授による全国雇用保証-2018年3月
National Job Guarantee by Professor Stephanie Kelton at the Sanders Institute - March 2018 9,256 回視聴•2018/03/26 293 35 共有 保存 Michabo Sustainable Harmony チャンネル登録者数 6400人 コメントはオフになっています。詳細 文字起こし
Q:Q:
こんにちは私はジェーンサンダースの創設者です。私は今日ここに私たちの見つけた仲間の一人と一緒にいることをとても嬉しく思います。ストーニーブルック大学の公共政策と経済学の教授であり、米国上院予算委員会のチーフエコノミストであったステファニーケルトン。
に:
ジェーン、来てくれてありがとう私はあなたと話すことにとても興奮しているので、あなたは国の雇用保証についての論文を完成させたばかりですこれがどのように始まったのか、そしてあなたがこの大胆なイニシアチブの追求にどのように関与したのか教えてください
に:
さて、これは私が取り組んできたものであり、私の学歴全体の研究の一部でした。そのため、20年近くも長い間信じられませんでしたが、これは私にとって非常に長い間重要でした。サンダース上院議員が上院予算委員会のチーフエコノミストとして私にインタビューを求めたとき、私は長い会話をしました。会話のある時点で、彼は私にあなたが私であるならどうしますかと尋ねました。と思いました。
私はサンダース上院議員です。私にできることはクールで大きなことをすることができます。2番目の権利章典を言ったところ、彼は教えてくれたので、FDRについて話し始めました。これは常に民主党にとって未完成のビジネスのようなものでした。これは、FDRが、アメリカ人に基本的権利の1つであるヘルスケアの権利だけでなく、教育の権利も与えるべきであるというこの考えを提唱するのをやめた場所です。そして雇用の権利とそれは続いていますそしてあなたは実際にFDRがリストの最初に雇用の権利を置いたことを知っていますそれはそれが議題の彼のトップアイテムでしたそしてそれは私が非常に長い間取り組んできたものですそしてそれは民主党の中心に直行するか、少なくとも一度にそうしましたmm-うーん、なぜですか?今日アメリカで起こっていることから始めましょう。
そして、なぜ今それをすべきなのか多くのエコノミストは、2008年の危機前の状態の近くで完全雇用になっていると言うでしょう。危機以来、1500万人の雇用が回復しているのはなぜですか。
に:
ええ、それは人々がお尻をする質問です、そして私が答えるいくつかの異なる方法があります1つはある意味で次の危機の保護手段として機能するプログラムを導入するより良い時期ですそれに沿って、私たちの経済は良い時があり、良い時は悪い時が続き、幸いなことに私たちは常に悪い時から回復しますが、私たちが経験した最後の不況は大恐慌以来の記録で最悪でした。
そして、雇用主が最後に雇用したいのは失業者であり、すでに働いている人々がトップから雇用したいと思っていることを知っているので、私たちはすぐに彼らを雇用しました。彼らは、自分たちが最下位であると認識しているものを採用したくないのですが、働いていない人は、積極的に何かをしていることを示すために利用できる記録がありません。したがって、このようなプログラムは人々の保護手段であり、経済の保護手段でもあるので、正しい人々はこの経済を見て、1700万人ほどのアメリカ人を除いて完全雇用だと言うでしょう。 t完全雇用。あなたは公式に失業している人々を持っています誰もがそれらの公式の失業者に注意を払っている人々ですがそれならあなたは 本当にフルタイムの仕事をしたいアルバイトで立ち往生している人がたくさんいますが、上司がフルタイムの労働者にするための時間を与えないため、彼らはそれを得ることができません。本当に欲しくて、彼らはフルタイムの仕事でしばしば行く利点を欠いています、そしてあなたは彼らが諦めた落胆したアメリカ人の実際には何百万もの人々を持っています。彼らは労働力から脱落し、もはや仕事を探していませんが、あなたが彼らに仕事をしたいのか、そして私たちがあなたに利用可能であるなら明日仕事をするのかと尋ねると、彼らは絶対に何を言うでしょう多くのエコノミストが見て、完全雇用だと言う経済の中でも、忘れられて取り残された1,600万から1,700万人の人々を見ています。
Q:就職難の多くはデータに表示されないか、本当に望まない仕事に行き詰まっている人や、専門知識が提供できる範囲をはるかに下回っている人は、別のWPAについて話しているように聞こえます。 ?
K:
そうですね、そういうモデルです。21世紀には、1930年代から1940年代にかけてFDRがあった場所を超えなければならないと思いますが、政府が人々に仕事をさせる大規模なWPAをモデルにしています。さまざまなプロジェクト人々がWPAを聞くと、道路や橋などのことを考えることがよくあると思います。これは確かにこのようなプログラムの一部になる可能性があります。CCC市民保全部隊は別のニューディールプログラムでした。そしてそれは環境問題に多くの方法で対処しました。それはニューディール政策のアルファベットスーププログラムの1つでした。
Q:
全国的な雇用プログラムを理解していないかもしれない私たちのために、一言で言えばそれを私たちに与えてください。
K:
コミュニティの労働者が発言権を持ち、人々が仕事に就くことが何であるかを再確認し、あなたは他のあなたを持っている人々に対応するためにパートタイムで仕事をすることができます。方法を知っているかもしれません彼らは学校に行くかもしれません多分彼らは子供を持っているかもしれません多分彼らは数時間欲しいかもしれませんがフルタイムの仕事ではないかもしれません他の人々はフルタイムの仕事を望んでいます そして、あなたはそれらの仕事がそれらを望む人々のために利用可能であることを確認しなければなりません。
Q:そして、人々が1時間あたり8ドルで仕事に行く賃金に関して、あなたはどうしますか?彼らは今働いています。これはどのように機能しますか?
K:
休暇は、これらのメリットが後で決定される可能性があることを知っていますが、ヘルスケアを含める必要があるとも述べました。それをこのプログラムの費用に含めたので、私たちは本当に大きくなり、意図的にそれを行いました。いつでも1,500万から2,000万人のアメリカ人を雇用するこの規模の何かを実行できることを実証できるようにしたかったからです。景気循環に間に合うように、彼らに生活賃金を支払い、ヘルスケアを含む利益を提供します。全体的な経済状況を改善するだけでなく、何百万人もの人々を貧困や子供たちからも解放する方法でそれを行います。それをこのプログラムの費用に含めたので、私たちは本当に大きくなり、意図的にそれを行いました。いつでも1,500万から2,000万人のアメリカ人を雇用するこの規模の何かを実行できることを実証できるようにしたかったからです。景気循環に間に合うように、彼らに生活賃金を支払い、ヘルスケアを含む利益を提供します。全体的な経済状況を改善するだけでなく、何百万人もの人々を貧困や子供たちからも解放する方法でそれを行います。それをこのプログラムの費用に含めたので、私たちは本当に大きくなり、意図的にそれを行いました。いつでも1,500万から2,000万人のアメリカ人を雇用するこの規模の何かを実行できることを実証できるようにしたかったからです。景気循環に間に合うように、彼らに生活賃金を支払い、ヘルスケアを含む利益を提供します。全体的な経済状況を改善するだけでなく、何百万人もの人々を貧困や子供たちからも解放する方法でそれを行います。
Q:
ステファニーの考え方に感謝します。なぜなら、あまりにも多くの人が低く目指しており、残念ながらそれを達成しているからです。それで十分だと思っているので、あなたが話しているのは、実際には、現在の進歩的な政策の3つの進歩的な柱のうちの2つです。皆のためのヘルスケア最低賃金15ドル今あなたは再生可能な100%再生可能エネルギーを追加します。それはあなたのインフラストラクチャプログラムで機能する可能性があり、FDRが話しているように、人々が幸せな生活を送り、健康的な生活を送るための非常に優れた基盤があります。
K:
正確に正しく、私たちが想定していることの大部分は、このプログラムの一環として話している種類の仕事の多くがその種類の構築に向けられている、よりクリーンでより持続可能な未来に向かって移行しているグリーン経済です。将来のmm-hmbrmの。
Q:<>非常に興味をそそられるように聞こえますが、多くの人が非常に興味を持っていると思います。そうすると、どうしてこれが起こるのか、私たちには余裕がないと言う批判者がいるでしょう。おそらく混乱するでしょう。ベーシックインカムがあるので、これら2つのプログラムの違いについて少し話していただけますか。
K:
sこの提案について私が懸念していることは、あなたが生活賃金で小切手を提供するつもりだと言うなら、最初にいくつかのことです、そして時々彼らは年に3万ドルと言うでしょう大丈夫誰もが年に3万ドルを得るそれは無料のお金ですそれは素晴らしいように聞こえますが、それはあなたがそれを手に入れ、私がそれを手に入れ、ビル・ゲイツがそれを手に入れ、オプラ・ウィンフリーがそれを手に入れ、誰もが彼らの3万ドルを手に入れることを意味します。今、あなたはそれに対してどのように支払うのか、またはこの計画を推進する人々はしばしば、私たちがヘルスケアを排除する他のすべてのプログラムを削減するつもりだと言いますメディケアメディケイド私たちはフードスタンプを削減するつもりです今日あるすべての社会的安全プログラムを削減するつもりです。社会保障がなくなったので、あなたが健康上の緊急事態に備えていくらかのお金を取っておくことを忘れないでください。中産階級と貧しい人々があなたに対処する方法を理解するのに苦労している間、それはあなた次第なので、言うことを忘れないでください。これらの他のすべてのプログラムの喪失を知っています。そして彼らは3万ドルを持っており、金持ちは3万ドルを費やして株式を購入するか、時間の経過とともに高く評価される他の資産を購入します。ですから、富の不平等からの収入は、実際には私の手が十分に高くならないように見えますが、このように見え、UBIは基本的な収入ですべての人に30を与えます。
Q:そうです
、それはまだ福祉プログラムとして見られ、資格としての景品として見られます。それはいつでも正確にカットされ、それを手に入れる人を減らしています。つまり、誰もが望む軽い生計のために働きたいと思っているのです。社会に貢献し、あなたが家にいて小切手を集めるだけではそれほど衰弱しないこともあるので、
K:
ええ、私はあなたが人々がしばしばアラスカを指すことを知っている例があることを知っていることを意味しますそして私はアラスカで人々は彼らが正しく配当を得る小切手を得ると言いますしかしそれは生活賃金ではありませんそれは控えめな小切手です石油収入の権利に応じて、このような市民配当を定期的に行うために人々の収入を補充するために行うのは良いことかもしれませんが、社会的セーフティネットを明らかにするためにこのようなことをする他の国があります心配しないで今日存在するという約束で、次の議会が通過するとすぐに最初にカットされるものは何であるかを推測して小切手を送ります。それは無料のお金になるでしょう。それは」s認識がうまくいくことをあなたが知っている最後のことは、なぜ私たちはそれを削減しなければならない無料のお金を送っているのか、そしてその間にあなたは社会保障をあきらめるでしょう。そして、それらは失われてしまうので、ボトムアッププログラムを採用するというアイデアを絶対に好みます。連邦政府の雇用保証は、それを最も必要としている人々を直接対象とし、失業者を獲得して賃金を引き上げ、単に浮浪者を増やすだけで所得と富の不平等を減らすことです。正しい。そして、それはその問題に対処し、悪化する不平等の問題を回避します。連邦政府の雇用保証とは、それを最も必要としている人々を直接対象とし、失業者を獲得することで賃金を引き上げ、単に浮浪者を増やすだけで所得と富の不平等を減らすことです。正しい。そして、それはその問題に対処し、悪化する不平等の問題を回避します。連邦政府の雇用保証とは、それを最も必要としている人々を直接対象とし、失業者を獲得することで賃金を引き上げ、単に浮浪者を増やすだけで所得と富の不平等を減らすことです。正しい。そして、それはその問題に対処し、悪化する不平等の問題を回避します。
Q:
訓練を受けていない失業者のために、悪魔の代弁者を少し演じさせてください。これには多くの訓練が含まれていますか。
K:
特定の労働者がその労働者について何かを学ぶことができるように、これはクッキーカッターのようなプログラムではないので、専門的な訓練の見習いでそのようなプログラムを感じている人がいる場合は、ワーカーをすばやく移行できる場合は、このプログラムの一部である必要があります。この種の雇用から民間部門に戻るか、スキルのアップグレードや最小限の投資で他の種類の雇用に戻ることは確かに私たちにとって理にかなっていますが、あなたがしたくないのはあなたが存在しない仕事のために人々を訓練することですそれらを失敗のために設定したくないし、あなたが失業している理由を言いたくないあなたはあなたがあなたを欠いているのです」
歴史の仕事の紹介はあなたができるすべての予防策を参照しますが、あなたは私たちの学校、私たちの保育園、彼らが故意に人員不足である私たちの高齢者施設を知っています、そしてあなたが望むのはあなたがあなたと一緒に働く人々です部屋とそれで多くの見落としがあるでしょう大丈夫経済について話しましょう。州の地方予算に影響を与えるかどうかにかかわらず、経済にどのようなプラスの影響があるかを教えてください。次に、カウンターウェイトとして、どのようなマイナスの影響があり、どのように軽減するのでしょうか。私たちがこの論文で見ているのは、やはり非常に野心的であり、1500万から1900万人を雇用すると、その多くの人々に追加の収入がもたらされるということです。
あなたが1500万人かそこらの人々を1時間あたり15ドルで雇用して利益を得ていると思うなら、それは本当にかなり控えめです。とヘルスケアとあなたが言うとそれは私たちの国のGDPの1.5パーセントしかかかりませんそれはかなりお得ですええええあなたはトリクルダウンではなくトリクルダウンについて話しているように聞こえますそしてこれらのことを議論するのは素晴らしいことです彼らが減税について話しているとき、経済を助け、平均的なアメリカ人を助けるのではなく、上位1パーセントと同じくらいの費用がかかりますそうです、私たちはすでに何か大きくて野心的な問題を行うことについて話しているのです私たちは
共和党員に大胆になっているので、今すぐ何かを与える必要があります。私の意見では間違っていますが、大胆になっているので、もっと効果的に行う必要があります。彼らが販売している方法の面で面白いことを知っています。彼らはこれをマーケティングしていますそれは非常に楽観的で非常に野心的ですそして彼らは私たちが持っているものは十分ではなく、私たちは速く成長することができる、あるいは私たちが4%の成長をすることができる私たちがより多くの仕事を持つことができると言っています人々がそのように聞こえるのが好きで、誰かよりも良い音がすることを知っているなら、より高い賃金を得ることができます経済はすでに完全雇用されていると私は思いますこれはあなたが知っていることを得るのと同じくらい良いので最低賃金はこの国は1時間あたり7.25ドルではありません。最低賃金はゼロです。なぜなら、それが人々が得た賃金だからです。失業者の場合、彼らは1時間に7ドルも95セントも得られず、ゼロになります。このようなプログラムは、最低賃金を真の最低賃金にします。これは、すべての人にとって事実上の最低賃金になります。働く意欲は1時間に15ドルです。このアイデアは、このアプローチ全体をまとめるという点であなたの発案によるものかもしれませんが、今では多くの人が出てきて言っていることを意味します。仕事をしたいと思っているのは1時間あたり15ドルです。このアイデアは、このアプローチ全体をまとめるという点であなたの発案によるものかもしれませんが、今では多くの人が出てきて言っていることを意味します。仕事をしたいと思っているのは1時間あたり15ドルです。このアイデアは、このアプローチ全体をまとめるという点であなたの発案によるものかもしれませんが、今では多くの人が出てきて言っていることを意味します。
私たちは全国的な仕事プログラムの仕事を必要としているので、彼らが出てくる可能性が低い人々の何人かについて聴衆に伝えてください、そしてそれはあなたが私の同僚を知っていることを確信している確かな兆候ですそして私はこれに取り組んできました長い間ですが、他にもありますが、それらのいくつかは重要です。そのうちの1つは、デューク大学のエコノミストです。彼の名前は砂の汚れウィリアム砂の汚れで、彼は頻繁に新しい別のエコノミストと共著していますエリックハミルトンとデレクハミルトンとサンディダレディという名前の学校は、長年にわたって連邦政府の雇用保証の執拗なチャンピオンであり、ついにポリティコに認められました。
今年はPolitico50の1つとして、政治的言説に最も影響を与えている50人の1人であるため、そのような国の舞台に立つという点ではかなり大きな問題でしたが、最近ではKevinHassettが経済諮問委員会の現在の大統領は、私たちが必要だと信じているのは新しい新しい取引であるとコメントしました。これはトランプ政権です。そうです、これはドナルド・トランプの経済諮問委員会の長に任命されたので、彼の経済アドバイスには、ニューディールを改訂して、連邦政府が直接人々を雇用することについて考え始める必要があるかもしれません。これは、政府が雇用を創出できないことで知られている党からのかなりクレイジーなものです。実は私たちは直接雇用を創出すべきだと言っているので、それがケビン・ハセットであり、その数日後、ビル・クリントン・ルービンの下で財務長官を務めたボブ・ルービンがニューヨークタイムズで論説を書いています。
そして彼は連邦政府が資金提供する雇用プログラムを主張している。
そして彼はそれが利益を含むべきである生活賃金にあるべきでありそしてそれが含まれるべきであった以前に投獄された権利に開かれているべきであると言います現在の共和党政権は両方とも話している。
これを装う必要性は、多くの人が私たちが完全雇用であると言う経済ではありません。これは、この会話が行われているときに人々が考え始めているときです。
確実にするために何をするつもりですか。
そして、人々が何かが正しくないと感じているというこのポピュリストのような泡立ちと関係があるのではないかと思います。私たちは対処し始めなければなりません。これが私たちの仕事の組織化の方法に根本的な変化を必要とするかどうかこの国は人々に機会があることを保証するために、そして私たちはそれをシステムに組み込む必要がありますそれはあなたが入って仕事を得る権利を持っているという点でそれを焼き上げる必要がありますそして私たちはあなたを除外するつもりはありませんあなたを置き去りにするつもりです。経済が提供しない場合、私たちはあなたのために作品を作成します。それはあなたがそれを持っていることを確認します。
そしてそれは今、かなりありそうもない場所から来ています。
Q:Q:
それは希望に満ちているように思えます。私たちの誰もが私たちのコミュニティを見回して、やらなければならない仕事がたくさんあることを知ることができると思います。これは良い答えのようです。
この野心的なアイデアを議論するためのパブリックスペースを作り、政策立案者に真剣に受け止めてもらいたいと思います。難しいことの1つは、常に乗り越えようとすることだと思います。
最初の最初の応答は、進行性が高すぎるか、コストがかかりすぎます。
ですから、私と一緒にそのスペースの作成を手伝ってください。そして、経済に関する継続的な取り組みに感謝します。
K:
ジェーン、どうもありがとう。
☆
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qoMamSmsAIM
National Job Guarantee by Professor Stephanie Kelton at the Sanders Institute - March 2018 9,256 回視聴•2018/03/26 293 35 共有 保存 Michabo Sustainable Harmony チャンネル登録者数 6400人 コメントはオフになっています。詳細 文字起こし
Q:
hi I'm Jane Sanders founder of the I'm so pleased to be here today with one of our found fellows dr. stephanie kelton who was a professor of public policy and economics at Stony Brook University and has been chief economist in the US Senate Budget Committee.
K:
thank you Jane thanks for coming I'm so excited to talk with you so now you have just completed a paper about a national jobs guarantee tell me how this all started and how you got involved in in pursuing this bold initiative
K:
well this has been something that I've been working on it's been part of my research for my entire academic career so almost 20 years of it's hard to believe that it's been that long but this is something that's been important to me for a really long time and you know I remember actually when senator Sanders called to interview me for the position as chief economist on the Senate Budget Committee and we had a long conversation and at one point in the conversation he asked me what would you do if you were me and I thought.
wow okay I'm senator Sanders well I get you know I get to do something cool and big what can I do and I said the second bill of rights and he said tell me and so we started to talk about FDR and you know for me this was always kind of like unfinished business for the Democratic Party this is where FDR left off putting forward this idea that Americans should be afforded certain fundamental rights not just the right to health care which is one of those fundamental rights but a right to an education and a right to employment and it goes on and on and you know in fact FDR put the right to employment first on the list it was his top item on the agenda and so it's something I've been working on for a very long time and it goes straight to the heart of the Democratic Party or at least it did at one time mm-hmm why don't we start with what is happening in America today.
and why we should be doing it now a lot of economists will be saying that we're at full employment near the 2008 pre-crisis state that the recovery is going on quite well 15 million jobs created since the crisis why now.
K:
yeah it's it's a question people do ass and the there are different couple of different ways that I would answer that one is what better time in some sense then to put in place a program that will work as a safeguard for the next crisis when it comes along so you know our economy goes through cycles there are good times and the good times are followed by bad times and fortunately we always recover from the bad times but you know the last recession that we had was the worst on record since the Great Depression.
and because we don't have a program like this in place our economy suffered in ways that it never would have had to suffer if we had programs like this one in place to absorb people when they lose their jobs when the economy turns down instead of throwing millions of people into the unemployment lines and and having a recovery that's so slow because people lose their job they lose their income and the economy doesn't recover and it doesn't recover you know it took us nine years to claw back the jobs that were lost in the Great Recession and if we had a program that took people when when the economy turns down and instead of saying you're gonna be unemployed for a while maybe a really long while we took them in . and we employed them right away because we know that employers the last person they want to hire is the unemployed person they want people who are already working they want to hire off the top. they don't want to hire off of what they perceive to be the bottom somebody who hasn't been working doesn't have a record to draw on to show that they've been actively doing something . and so a program like this is a safeguard for people and it's a safeguard for the economy as well so you're right people will look at this economy and they'll say this is full employment except for seventeen million or so Americans this isn't full employment. you've got people who are officially unemployed the people that everyone pays attention to those official unemployed folks but then you've got lots of people who are stuck in part-time jobs who really want full-time work but they can't have it because their bosses won't give them hours to make them full-time workers so they lack the income that they really want and they lack the benefits that go often with full-time work and then you've got lots and lots of people millions in fact of Americans who got discouraged they gave up. they dropped out of the labor force and they're no longer looking for work but if you ask them would you like a job and would you take a job tomorrow if it will we're available to you they'll say absolutely what so you're looking at 16 to 17 million people who are just forgotten and left behind even in an economy that many economists will look at and tell you is full employment
Q: right many of the underemployed just never show up in the data or the people that are stuck in jobs that they really don't want or that are way below what their expertise can can offer it sounds like you're talking about another WPA?
K:
yeah well that's kind of the model I mean I think in the 21st century we have to go beyond where FDR was in the 1930s 1940s but it did it would be modeled on the WPA something massive in scale where the government puts people to work doing a variety of projects I think a lot of times when people hear WPA they think roads and bridges and that sort of thing and that can certainly be part of a program like this the CCC the Civilian Conservation Corps was another New Deal program right . and that dealt in many ways with environmental concerns the nya the National Youth administration was one of the alphabet soup programs in the New Deal and that's jobs programs for youth so we have very high unemployment rates for young people in this country we have an environmental catastrophe you there are ways to put people to work caring for our planet caring for one another rebuilding roads and infrastructure and caring for our community so you know you can think very imaginatively the way they did in the WPA where people were performing Public Theater the arts were part of it recording oral histories I mean it isn't just a shovel and you know something to fill in a road we can think very very creatively about the kinds of jobs we want to create for people in the 21st century.
Q:
so for those of us who might not understand a national jobs program give it to us in a nutshell.
K:
so the idea would be that anyone who wants to work and contribute but can't find any way to do that in the economy has a place to go and so you can imagine taking the unemployment offices that exist all over this country today and just taking the you and the end off of the sign and turning them into employment offices so it's a one-stop shopping kind of a thing person walks in and says I'm looking for work and they sit down and they talk with someone and they find out you know what kind of experience do you have you don't want to take someone who's got skills that could be used in one way and put them into employment where you're not kind of getting the benefit that you could from their own experience and training and so you're fitting the job to the worker and you're allowing the worker in the community to have a say and what it is that people are going to be put put to work to do and you can be as flexible as you want you can make work part-time to accommodate people who have other you know way maybe they're going to school maybe they have a child maybe they want some hours but not a full-time job other people want full-time work. and you've got to make sure that those jobs are available for people who want them.
Q: and what would you do in terms of wages people are going to jobs at $8 an hour no benefits right now they they're working how would you approach it how would this work?
K:
so what we did in this study was go really big and we took an ambitious wage and benefit package and we said what we believe is that anyone who's working full-time in America should not be living in poverty and that means choosing a wage that will allow family of three or four to have one person working and to pull that family out of poverty so we start at $15 an hour and then we said you know what we want not just a living wage but we want people to have some benefits as well so we offer a package that includes a $15 an hour minimum wage and then we costed out some benefits it would be up to the community and and government in the process of implementing this whether that looks like paid family leave whether it looks like sick pay whether it's vacation you know what those benefits are could be determined later but we also said it ought to include health care . and so we included that in the cost of this program so we really did go big and we did it on purpose because we wanted to be able to demonstrate that you could do something of this magnitude that would employ 15 to 20 million Americans at any point in time in the business cycle and pay them a living wage and provide benefits that include health care . and do it in a way that improves the overall economic condition as well as lifting millions of people out of poverty and children as well.
Q:
I appreciate how you think Stephanie because too many people aim low and unfortunately they achieve that and then they think that's that's enough so what you're talking about is actually two of the three progressive pillars of progressive policy right now Medicare for all or healthcare for everybody $15 minimum wage now you add in renewable 100% renewable energy. and that could work in your infrastructure program and we've got a very good foundation for people to have happy life a healthy living just like FDR talked about .
K:
exactly exactly right and a big part of what we envision is a green economy that we are transitioning toward a cleaner more sustainable future where many of the kinds of jobs that we're talking about as part of this program would be oriented toward building that kind of a future mm-hmbrm.
Q:<> it sounds very very intriguing and I would think that a lot of people would be extremely interested in it and then there will be the detractors who say we can't afford it how can this happen and we'll probably confuse it with a basic income so can you talk a little bit about the difference between those two programs .
K:
what FDR had in mind and what we do in this paper is we say what we want to do is guarantee a right to employment to anyone who wants work and can't find it elsewhere in the economy so this isn't something that directly touches everyone this is something that directly touches only those who are currently not working but who won't work and so you know a universal basic income is something that you're hearing I think more and more people talk about and this is something that we touch everyone at least if that's if that's the way they truly envision it it's universal in nature so imagine this is what people say they say the future of work is uncertain the robots are coming there isn't going to be enough work for people to do and so we've got to figure out how in a future in which we don't really need people doing much of anything because the robots will do it but what businesses definitely know that they need our customers and so the solution to their problem is just send everybody a check and tell them to go shopping right you don't have anything to do all day you're gonna be really depressed and you're gonna be lonely you're not gonna feel a sense of connection to the community or the broader you know world in which we operate but that's ok you stay home and we'll send you a check and don't forget to go shopping because at the end of the day corporations still want to make a profit on whatever it is these robots are producing that's the universal basic income it's money that goes at least the way they normally describe it everyone gets a check now here's what concerns me about this this proposal a number of things first if you say that you're gonna provide a check at a living wage and sometimes they'll say thirty thousand dollars a year okay everybody gets thirty thousand dollars a year it's free money it sounds great but that means you get it and I get it and Bill Gates gets it and Oprah Winfrey gets it everybody gets their thirty thousand dollars. now you said how do you pay for it or something along those lines the people who push this scheme often say well we're gonna cut all the other programs we're gonna eliminate health care Medicare Medicaid we're gonna cut food stamps we're gonna cut all the social safety programs that are there today and we're just gonna give everybody a check and say figure it out no forget to save for your retirement because Social Security is gone don't forget to put aside some money in case you have a health emergency . don't forget to say so it's up to you right so while the middle class and the poor are struggling to figure out how to deal with you know the loss of all these other programs . and they've got their thirty thousand dollars the rich are doing what take their thirty thousand dollars and they buy shares of stock right or they buy you know some other asset that's gonna appreciate over time. so you say we have income from wealth inequality that looks like this actually my hands won't go high enough right but it looks like this and the UBI the basic income gives everybody 30,000 and so you would think it does nothing to diminish the inequality but my concern is it actually exacerbates the inequality why because the rich are going to invest and their wealth is going to grow as a result of this and the poor are going to eat their apples not buy shares of Apple.
Q:
right and it will still be looked at as a welfare program as a giveaway as an entitlement which will be cut at any point exactly right and it's diminishing the person that gets it I mean everybody wants to work for their light livelihood they want to contribute to society and as you said staying at home and just collecting a cheque is not very it's sometimes very debilitating so
K:
yeah I mean there you know there are examples you know people will often point to Alaska and I say well in Alaska people get a check they get a dividend well right but it's not a living wage it's a modest check maybe it's 1200 1400 and it varies depending upon oil revenues right and there are other countries that do something like this a citizen dividend something like that that could be a fine thing to do to sort of top up the incomes of people on a periodic basis but to eviscerate the social safety nets that exist today on the promise that don't worry we're gonna send you a check guess what's gonna be the first thing that gets cut by the next Congress as soon as it passes it's gonna be the free money. because that's the last thing you know that the perception is going to be well why are we sending free money we have to cut that and meanwhile you will have given up Social Security. and they'll swil have been lost so I definitely prefer the idea of going in with a bottom up program . and that's what the federal job guarantee would be it aims directly at the people who need it most and gets the unemployed it lifts their wages and so it reduces income and wealth inequality simply by raising the floo. right. and and so it addresses that problem and avoids the problem of a exacerbating inequality.
Q:
let me play devil's advocate in a bit for the people that are unemployed that are not they don't have any training do you have much training involved in this .
K:
we envision that so there can be for certain workers right you got to kind of learn something about the worker this is not a cookie cutter kind of a program so if there's someone that you feel with some specialized training apprenticeships that sort of a thing those programs should be available and part of this program if you can transition a worker quickly. from this kind of employment back into private sector or other types of employment with some skill upgrades or minimal sorts of investments then that certainly makes sense to us but what you don't want to do is train people for jobs that don't exist you don't want to set them up for failure and you don't want to say the reason that you're unemployed something wrong with you you're you're lacking you're deficient and then you change the worker in certain ways and you send them back out there and they fail again and if the problem isn't the worker the problem is the economy itself there's something wrong with the system that can't generate employment for everybody in the economy and that's the problem that we have and have always had in quite frankly will always have in a market economy a certain segment of the population will always be unuseful in the sense that private employers don't want to hire all of the labor that wants to work and so you've got to figure out how to deal with that do you just allow them to sit unemployed you send them unemployment compensation or do you do something else that gives them a better shot makes better use of them brings them in is more inclusive makes them feel part of the economy and allows them to contribute because you're right they would rather contribute then sit home and collect a check you know in some countries the government the industry and the unions get together and they actually plan in advance what the needs are for the country for the industry and train.
people so that they don't go through the pain of getting these pink slips and then they're out of work and then they have to go look for work but they plan ahead and say okay we're going to retrain you while you have this job which is going to be obsolete at some point we're going to train you for this future job have you envisioned anything like that I think that that is definitely part of what we envision because again as you transition toward green energy you're gonna have to have workers with different skill sets and as we close coal plants and transition away from fossil fuels we're gonna need workers with a different skill set okay. and so some of what you can have people doing in this program is retraining in a way that prepares them for the kind of work around which you want to center your economic activity okay we've talked about infrastructure we've talked about renewables you also mention care caring for elders for children teachers aides again devil's advocate how are you going to vet the job seekers to make sure that our children and our elders are safe and that they are qualified to take care of them good question and an important concern right you you definitely want to be careful about the kinds of people that you're putting into facilities where children and elderly folks and so you do it the way you do it today background checks careful scrutinize ation of an individual's prior employment record. and history job referrals references all you take every precaution that you can but you know our schools our nurseries our elder facilities they're willfully understaffed and so what you want are people working alongside you know you want aides you want an extra pair of hands in the room and so there's going to be lots of oversight okay let's talk about the economy. can you tell me what positive effects there would be on the the economy whether or not it would affect state local budgets and then as a counterweight what negative effects might there be and how would you mitigate them so if we were to do this in the way that we look at in the paper which again is really ambitious right what we find is that employing 15 to 19 million people puts additional income into that many people's hands which then the most most of that gets spent into the economy which through secondary effects has you know positive spillover to the economy right yeah I get a job I currently don't now I have a job and I have an income I go out and I spend now some restaurant gets you know some revenue that they wouldn't have gotten otherwise in profit so they hire another busboy and you you know how the the multiplier works in economics you know you get a benefit to the economy as a whole so our research says that this kind of program would add 500 to 600 billion dollars a year on average to real GDP so it's a real shot in the arm for the economy and of course if you take 15 million or so people and give them an income that they then start spending into the economy you would expect a pretty significant boost to economic activity the concern would be but what if you overheat things what if all of that spending is just too much and the economy can't accommodate all of that additional demand .
then you'd end up with an inflation problem which would be potentially disastrous depending on how bad it got but what we were able to show is that there's so much slack in the economy today businesses are operating with all kinds of extra unused capacity there's plenty of room to ramp up demand without creating an inflation problem there you know people will say the economy is close to full employment but if you actually look at how much spare capacity there is we can fill huge void adding to real GDP raising incomes boosting economic output with a modest increase in inflation and so that's what we would be looking at that would be the risk how much will this cost well it depends how many people take it up but our estimates are between 1 and 1/2 percent of GDP and 3 percent of GDP so it's really fairly modest if you think you're getting 15 million or so people employed at $15 an hour with benefits. and healthcare and you say and it costs only one and a half percent of our national GDP that's a pretty good deal yeah yeah it sounds like you're talking about trickle across rather than trickle down and it would be great to have these things be discussed at the table when they're talking about tax cuts which will cost just as much for the top one percent instead of helping the economy and helping the average American exactly yeah that's exactly right we're already talking about doing something big and ambitious the problem is we're talking about doing it for the people who are already extremely well-off and so the tax cuts that are being pushed on the hill right now overwhelmingly benefit those at the very top but the price tag is not dissimilar so if you say well we're willing to do a trillion and a half right adding to the deficit in order to do tax cuts what else could we do if we're willing to do that what else could we do and and this is the kind of thing if you were comparing it side-by-side which one has the greater potential to boost employment to raise wages all the things that they tell us the tax cuts are going to do they're gonna lead to job creation and wages are going to go up and all this kind of stuff side by side this is clearly the plan that gets you there most directly Stephanie this is a very ambitious plan and it is something that we should be talking about and as you said across from other issues what we I find very difficult is that too often people are on the defensive and saying no we can't we can't do that that's terrible but never offering ambitious ideas we're setting much lower setting our sights much lower and accepting much less.
you have to give the Republicans something right now that they are being bold they're wrong in my opinion but they're being bold and we need to do that much more effectively yeah you know it's funny they're selling in terms of the way they're marketing this it's very optimistic and it is very ambitious and they're saying what we have isn't good enough and we can grow fast or even have three and a half we can have 4% growth we can have more jobs we can have higher wages if people like the way that that sounds and you know it sounds better than someone I think saying the economy is already at full employment this is as good as it gets what are you talking about you know so the the minimum wage in this country isn't $7.25 an hour the minimum wage is zero because that's the wage that people get if they're unemployed they don't get $7 and ninety-five cents an hour they get zero and a program like this makes the minimum wage a genuine minimum wage it becomes the de-facto minimum wage for everyone the least you can get if you're willing to work is 15 bucks an hour this idea I mean this is might be your brainchild in terms of putting together this whole approach but it seems to be in the ether now I mean a number of people are coming out and saying.
we need a jobs a national jobs program so tell our audience about some of the folks that are coming out they're unlikely and so that's a good sign some are unlikely that is for sure you know my colleagues and I have been working on this for a long time but there are others and they're important I'd like to just mention a couple of them one is an economist at Duke University his name is sandy dirty William sandy dirty and he frequently co-authors with another economist from the new school named Eric Hamilton and Derek Hamilton and Sandy daredi have been just relentless champions for a federal job guarantee for so many years and they were finally recognized by Politico.
this year as one of the Politico 50 so one of the 50 people who are most having an impact on the political discourse so that was a pretty big deal in terms of getting that kind of on the national stage but more recently Kevin Hassett who is the current President of the Council of Economic Advisers made comments that what he believes that we need is a new New Deal now these are and that's the Trump administration yes this is Donald Trump's appointee to be the head of the Council of Economic Advisors and so his economic advice includes in part maybe we should revise the New Deal and start thinking about federal government directly employing people now this is pretty crazy stuff from a party that is you know known for telling us the government can't create jobs and here's a guy saying actually we should be creating jobs directly and so that's Kevin Hassett one and then just days later Bob Rubin who was Treasury secretary under Bill Clinton Rubin writes an op-ed in The New York Times.
and he makes the case for a Fed funded job program.
and he says it ought to be at a living wage it ought to include benefits and it should be open to the formerly incarcerated right it should include so this is like yeah really crazy stuff bipartisan you've got a Democrat former you know Democrat Democratic administration current Republican administration both of them talking about .
the need to pretend this isn't an economy in which many people say we're at full employment and this is when this conversation is taking place so people are starting to think.
what are we going to do to ensure.
and I think it has maybe something to do with this populist kind of bubbling up that people are sensing that something's not right and and we have to begin to address and if this is going to require fundamental change in the the way that we organize work in this country to ensure that people have opportunities and we have to just build it into the system it's got to be baked in that you have a right to come in and and get a job and we're not gonna leave you out we're not gonna leave you behind we're gonna create the work for you if the economy doesn't offer it will make sure that you have it.
and it's coming from some pretty unlikely places right now.
Q:
that sounds hopeful I think that any of us can look around our communities and see that there's a lot of work that needs to be done and this seems to be a good answer.
I hope that we will be able to create a public space for discussion and debate on this ambitious idea and have the policymakers really take it seriously I think one of the things that's difficult is always to try to get beyond.
the first initial response which is oh that's too progressive or that is going to cost too much.
so join me in helping create that space and thank you so much for your ongoing work on the economy.
K:
thank you very much Jane.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
https://twitter.com/motidukinoyoru/status/1349959420231368705?s=21





