love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com
Money Marketeers of NYU - Professor Stephanie Kelton, "Awash in Debt: Will there be a Reckoning?"2021/03/11
41 ~ 51 分
Money Marketeers of NYU - Professor Stephanie Kelton, "Awash in Debt: Will there be a Reckoning?"2021/03/11
https://love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com/2021/03/money-marketeers-of-nyu-professor.html?m=1 @
https://youtu.be/34VeCTJlSXM
um they're here to share the success of our work um hope for the future and we may um note some past mistakes for not more than seven minutes and i will enforce that i want to apologize in advance it helps with the panel it helps with our technical person hello michael behind the scenes thank you from i.t by the way um we have deidre mccloskey who is a distinguished professor emeritus of economics and of history and a professor emerita of english and of communication at the university of illinois in chicago her most recent book is titled why liberalism works and was published by yale university press our own professor of economics at the new school for social research my friend anwar sheikh his most recent book is titled capitalism competition conflict and crisis the professor of economics at stony brook university a sepa senior fellow a good friend of us all is stephanie kelton her most recent book the deficit myth is a fantastic book and many um also here mark setterfield is the chair of the economics department and he will help me today moderate the panel after their remarks so after our panelists give remarks and as you hear them talk to each other and questions from the audience i would like you all to answer a poll question that we've been talking about for years and now i want to ask you the poll question is should we abandon the name head or docs economics and it's a poll question you get yes or no there is a polling but button at the bottom of your zoom window where you could answer please answer after you've heard the discussion and thought about it and you can put your questions um in the q a box at the bottom of your screen mark thanks teresa i'll just say a very quick word of hello and welcome to everybody also a special word of thanks of course to our four panelists for uh helping making this event happen and uh deidre and stephanie uh great to see you back at the new school welcome back to both of you um anwar please uh is that you want me to start you can start yes okay well let me say i'm honored to be on this panel with such eminent colleagues and i want to thank sipa and teresa for organizing this and for the huge audience they've gathered for it let me start about with the question about heterodox economics i was once at a reception with joan robinson and she was asked to come up and they introduced her as one of the world's most eminent woman economists and she got offended and said i'm not a woman economist i'm an economist and i feel the same way i would like to be called just an economist actually a real economic economist as opposed to those who work on the fictitious ideal but i have to say that hydrodox economics is necessary because we're not allowed in orthodox departments anywhere in the world and therefore we have to have some kind of name to encompass the wide variety of things what i do is i study real patterns and i try to theorize them my book is a hundred thousand eleven pages and fifty percent of it is empirical because i'm not interested in theory unless it can understand and explain patterns that exist and by the way harvard business review is a very good source of such analysis because they're quite hard nosed about what businesses really do and of course the data itself as we know is constructed it's not lying on the beach as pebbles as alcazar once said but it has to be understood deconstructed and reconstructed if necessary my work is motivated by the fact that so-called practical economists often rely on some part of orthodox by which i mean neoclassical economics and i believe that if we're going to address the world as we see it then we should not have to dip back into a framework which is constructed in such a strange and highly improbable way and this point of view by the way is shared even in the financial times so it's not as if it's a point of view in academia so then the raise a question arises there's pluralism in economics by which i mean a pluralism of framework of course neoclassical economics dominates it absolutely but as our department tries to exemplify we all also have classical political economies smith and ricardo we have marx hayek post kings and economics and then there's a pluralism of topics race class gender nationality ethnicity inequality on national and international scale and many many others and these are all phenomena of the world that we have to construct and uh try to explain but here it seems to me that a crucial difference arises between pluralism and eclecticism incredibleism eclecticism i mean that mixing and matching theoretical frameworks which are often antithetical to each other in order to get an answer which seems plausible i don't know of any other discipline uh well let's say in the sciences because otherwise in anthropology or uh other disciplines mixing and matching is perfectly appropriate i would argue it's not a good idea it's not a good idea because even though you draw on some aspect of a discipline to validate your own reading other aspects will contradict other parts of the reading and so it basically leaves you so to speak without a home and i won't have time to elaborate on this but for instance uh in neoclassical theory a rise in wages will lower demand for labor and lead to unemployment in post-keynesian theory and speaking here of normal circumstances not culvert circumstances by the way a rise in real wages will raise consumer demand and raise output employment and in what i would call classical political economy as i classify myself there's an interesting difference because an exogenous rise in real wages will lower the profit rate it'll slow down the demand for labor and undermine the strength of labor which is a very important source of higher wages and expand the pool of normally unemployed people there's an important aspect of this that unemployment is normal in the sense that capitalism creates and maintains it now these are empirically addressable issues they're not just theoretical and much of my work has been involved in addressing just these kinds of issues they also have strong policy implications and i want to elaborate on that but if you look at the history of you explain one explain why hitler's germany and roosevelt's uh post-depression and then pre-war activities did not lead to inflation in higher wages and so on and yet after that they did lead to it in the 70s to inflation and stagnation you have to understand how these mechanisms actually work so i believe that one approach which is unfortunately dominant is to mix and match theories as you see a fit to give you an answer and then with another empirical phenomena you mix and match something else on the other hand one can also take orthodox economics and add imperfections frictions lack of knowledge this is the standard now in among orthodox economists themselves or and this is the task i set myself a long time ago one can try to explain these by developing a coherent alternative framework what i like about neoclassical economics it is coherent at least in theory it's somewhat incoherent in the empirical and real world but it's coherent in theory and this for me meant going back to marx keynes rafa harrod and excavating from their work a systematic framework and in my book uh i want to make sure i don't run over time my clock just went how much time do i have tourism i have a minute according to me i try to explain empirically and theoretically the laws of demand and supply microeconomics consumer behavior wages and profit rates technological change relative prices interest rate bond and equity prices ala schiller and nutshiller alla soros exchange rates trade balance growth unemployment inflation and long booms culminating in recurrent crises microeconomics is derived from real consumer behavior and real business behavior under the ruthless influence of competition as a war macroeconomics from the uh aggregate effect of interactive aggregate effective demand and profitability which was keynes's key point and i tried to do this without any reference to hyper rationality optimization perfect competition perfect information representative agents and so-called rational expectations nor imperfect competition and so on monopoly power my book just came out in chinese three four days ago i would hold up a copy but i don't have one yet uh it's been translated to turkish and uh the spanish one is almost done so if you're interested in this kind of bizarre approach take a look at the book you can actually buy it you don't have to a russian website but hey whatever you can't thank you thank you thank you honor i hope people buy your book that's what we can do for each other um deidra may i turn to you please muted you're muted muted mute yeah the audience will have to for forgive my speech defect i stutter on the words stutter so i i can't say it straightforwardly as so joe biden does that i agree with anwar enthusiastically that economics especially here in the united states and thankfully not so much elsewhere is highly and intolerantly and indeed foolishly orthodox there's one way of doing economics a famous example in my lifetime is the uh the destruction of the heterodox economics department at the university of of notre dame and that's bad it's bad for the uh science it's bad for the ethics of the science it's bad for for a policy however i think that heterodoxy ought to include but does not ordinarily austrian economics ted denison university is a rare ex ex option to the f failure to have marx confront hayek for example and now i think it should also include what is called humanomics and vernon smith and and and i are exponents of humanomics and it says or it it urges us in a heterodox way to go on with what we can learn from the other kinds of economics of the mathematics and the statistics and the observations the aggregate and individual observations but add the humanities this sounds hard to do but it's easier than you might uh think my view is that there's a certain a certain amount of clanking machinery in the way economics is conventionally done that i would like to uh i would like to contextualize with your human experience more broadly with jane austen and shakespeare with a and aristotle with the historians with the cultural anthropologists now as anwar said the proof is in the is in the loop is in the pudding are there are are there are other insights or i should say more exactly scientific findings that can be attributed to this new humanomics it's very new we have a long way to go but yes i i think there are now for instance i would argue and have on the basis of wide evidence that is quantitative but also qualitative that the 3 000 increase in the real incomes of ordinary folk among them the even very poor people in places like japan and finland since say 1800 can be shown to not come from changes in law and investment as the right side of politics claims or from slavery and exploitation as the left side would like to claim but from an and an opening for human create creativity that came with the coming in the 18th century rather suddenly in northwestern europe to the idea of liberal equality of liberal permissions i'm thinking more of the uh of the scottish side of the enlightenment than the uh uh uh french i would argue that you can show in empirically allowing yourselves all the evidence not just the quantitative evidence or the or the orthodox uh um sorts of evidence but all the evidence that this is true i i could go on and have uh you're in invited to go to my website for uh it's all it's marvelous findings like anwar i wish you would buy my my books you don't need to read my books but you do need to buy the books to speak in a community capitalist way so that's my plug humanomics oh deidre thanks very much um i'll now turn to stephanie well thank you and again uh i share the enthusiasm of the two previous speakers it's very nice to be with them again i know we've done things in the past together and thank you to teresa for including me uh in this important conversation so uh you know i thought i would just talk a little bit about i guess what heterodoxy has meant to me uh you know i i started off not intending to study economics at all i was sort of on a path to studying finance i like the idea of thinking about financial markets i like the idea i think i thought i liked the idea of being able to help people and so i imagine that one day i would probably be a financial uh planner you know help people figure out their retirement and that sort of thing and i ended up uh stumbling into an economics course because it was required it was a micro theory course intermediate level and it was taught by john henry and i know that that's a name that uh is familiar to deirdre and to anwar and uh i think i have memories of both of you being at one of my previous universities at umkc when john was there and you know john taught a straight neoclassical uh econ course there was absolutely nothing inspiring whatsoever about that course in terms of the content um but john was inspiring and he was masterful in the classroom and on the very last day of that class he used the opportunity to finally allow us to think critically about what we had been presented with over the course of you know 15 weeks because if we pushed back at all during course during the course he would say no no no don't do that because we'd say well in the real world i said no no don't do that he wouldn't let us ask questions or challenge the underlying assumptions the models we could not uh do that and on the last day i remember this very clearly he said look if you've got a good theoretical model if the model works you should be able to begin to relax the assumptions and the things should more or less still hold together so john started relaxing assumptions and here we were you know finally allowed to really kick the tires on this thing and the whole class just ended up trying to defend it and to push back against him and i didn't realize until some years later that what john did in that final lecture was to introduce us to the capital controversies without ever calling it that and so i got you know more interested once i realized that you know i i wasn't just doing economics as an indoctrination program that i i had to take these models and accept everything that had been presented no questions asked uh and i took the history of economic thought with him and that's where things really opened up for me and that's when i kind of started to fall in love with the idea of studying economics john took me to someone at some point he said listen you ought to go to graduate school and so i did and i didn't know where i wanted to go so john had me talk with another economist i won't name him um and he said go to harvard and he said if you go to harvard you won't suffer the slings and arrows that you would suffer if you went through a sort of heterodox economics program and i thought yeah but i have to go to i have to do a mainstream you know program and how am i going to write a dissertation he said no you write it you throw it away and i just knew that i didn't have it in me to go through a program like that make that kind of commitment get up every day write a dissertation that i probably uh you know didn't believe was really very worthwhile and then just walk away from it all so i applied to a number of other schools and it came down to two for me uh i think that the the new school probably financially is why it wasn't in the final two but it was either notre dame which deirdre mentioned earlier because i would have studied with uh marty wolfson or cambridge and i had this idea that i could go to cambridge university i could expose myself to the rich traditions and you know i understood that you know keynes and joan robinson and mickey calder and srafa weren't walking the halls but i figured there was enough left of that tradition there that i could benefit from that and still come out with a degree from cambridge and and maybe that would somehow serve me well but the reality was that the program was a one-year talk program is how they referred to it four courses at the graduate level and you write a dissertation and you're done and that made me nervous because i wasn't sure i could uh consider myself a real economist with just four graduate courses under my belt so anyway i got a fellowship and it took me to the levy economics institute and levy is just upstate from manhattan and that allowed me to jump on a train once a week and travel down to the city and sit in on ednell's class at the new school and you know i've probably told this in forums like this with you guys because you know it's one of my best memories and it changed the trajectory of of my life and my own career i sat at the new school and i listened to students you know in a sort of coffee shop cafeteria i forget what you called it back then and i could just hear the conversations taking place at the tables around me and i'd never heard anything like it it didn't happen at cambridge it was otherworldly people were thinking deeply about the world around them they were having philosophical conversations they were having class conscious conversations race con i i i loved it and it energized me and for me it was what i was what economics was supposed to do was supposed to get your juices going and get you really thinking and challenging uh things and so i i decided that you know i there was so much more that i needed to know and uh so i ended up joining the new school and finishing my phd there i think anwar you were on sabbatical and i really was only there for one year and you were on sabbatical that year so i didn't get an opportunity to take your course which i was always um you know i always regret it not overlapping with you then um but i i finished i didn't suffer the slings and arrows i came out of a heterodox program i took a position at the university of missouri in kansas city and when i joined i joined with matt forstadter who's another new school alum and randy ray and a couple of years later we got fred lee to come on board and we had this incredible department very intellectually diverse john henry joined us later we had institutionalists like jim sturgeon we had old labor erp people like gene wagner we had um marxists we had post keynesians we we were an eclectic and we had neoclassical economists so we it was an incredible place to be because somehow someway we all managed to get along swimmingly there was no infighting i i can't recall a single time when uh there was real discord among the faculty and i think the students we had a very large phd program at one point i think we had 83 students in the master's program and 60 in the phd program and we had about 12 faculty members so we were small but we built an interdisciplinary phd program which meant that you did you know economics and you did a secondary discipline and it really meant something uh and so students could pair their econ with philosophy or psychology or political science or sociology anthropology math whatever it was um and you know i always just i guess i felt like because economists are given this preferred status right that you don't often hear you're not going to hear president biden often maybe stand up on stage and say leading sociologists say but it's economists what economists are telling us what economists say and we have this outsized voice in the debates especially you know with respect to policy and i guess i always just felt a sense of responsibility in um the way that i approached the you know hiring decisions and and in the classroom and teaching that it was important to recognize that we were training the next generation of people who economists who were going to have one day possibly uh an outsized influence in these debates and so um you know i always wanted to try to create better frameworks more relevant frameworks um better ways to analyze the workings of a capitalist economy and at the end of the day to remember why it is that we do this work and it's got to be about more than elegance and and the beauty of our our models but the ways in which they impact and and matter to real people so i mean stop there that's just wonderful thank you stephanie uh what a great um my still what a great um bright spot uh and with that um gustavo it turns out people come to the new school for not the faculty but for the students so um mixed news for me but i'm very i'm not surprised um please go ahead thank you for inviting me to be part of this uh distinguished uh pen also share my background and pose a question for discussion so i'm a third year phd student in economics at the new school entering the academic job market this fall my master's degree is from the university of sao paulo in brazil which is a mainstream program with a small heterodox section and like most economic curriculums the core courses heavily rely on mathematical frameworks such as the general equilibrium theory which assumes independent profit seeking agents who make optimal decisions across time theories that are presented as true economics and realities fitted to the textbook framework and not the other way around conflicts over distribution and financial crisis for example are not usually addressed for mathematical tractability and research that does not use this math rigor is considered soft science or not economics in my professional work the mismatch between textbooks and reality was striking so first in class the economy was explained with only three equations influential economists debated economic growth models were the only relevant variable was the saving rate fiscal policy had no impact on economic activity the labor market was always in full employment and monetary policy assumed money neutrality and the impossibility of financial crisis i came to the new school mostly influenced by my professors from the university of sao paulo such as laura carvalho anusco alumnus and i came here not expecting a single true economic approach instead i was looking for an academic environment such as the one that we have here today to discuss the relevance and shortcomings of different schools of thought and of course i expect to bring those values to academia and policy debates back in brazil although i understand the difficulties of being a heterodox economist in environments dominated by mainstream ideologists so with this in mind i have two questions here for the panel first universities require professors to publish in top economic journals but they reject pluralism so how does a heterodox economist follow a relevant research agenda and thrive in the face of the existing uh pro mainstream incentives and my second question here is to what extent should a heterodox economist keep up with the mainstream literature when most mainstream economists do not follow the heterodox literature should heterodox economists always develop the research in contrast to this mainstream literature or can they follow their own path so again thank you all for the great debate today and your contributions oh thanks very much gustavo um i will ask the panelists to keep gustavo's questions in their mind but right now some of the most valuable aspect of these panels is when the panelists get to speak to each other we would be doing this much more naturally if we were all together and i want you to know that you're talking to over 300 people now um they range from reporters from japan to a high school student so you have a ver you have imagine your audience and i'd like you to talk to each other in a particular way i would like you to and i'll ask you to go in the order that you spoke what is it that you like about each other's work or what each other just said today and where do you respectfully disagree and if you can respond to gustavo's questions now or in the q a that would be great too um we have some time you were all very terrific and respectful to each other on the time so let's let's start and mark um when you need to jump in um please do yeah thanks teresa i picked up on a couple of themes uh including themes from the questions but uh let's hear from the panelists first okay um i'm just going to point to anwar since you spoke first you have to unmute everybody including you onward okay well it's such a pleasure to be on a panel with such interesting and literate people as you know our profession does not always generate that uh cohort i i agree with daedra on so many almost everything actually that she said but let me just mention one thing it's absolutely important that austrian economics and hayek have been excluded i recently uh rediscovered that connection and what i found i gave a lecture at the new school in the economics department on marx and hayek and my emphasis was not on their opposition but on their similarity it's astonishingly it's astonishing how similarly they see capitalism and how it works and certainly marx talks about the great wealth that capitalism has brought to society it's emphatic on that so the difference was really about whether it's possible to go beyond capitalism and that's a relatively important difference obviously but anyway and i agree totally with the idea that economics should have uh humanity literature human experience i want someone else at cambridge mass i found a book that said that game theory could explain shakespeare and alas i didn't buy the book i should have because i thought the concept was appalling but i should have read it i did read part of it but i didn't buy it on the issue of capitalism's strong positive impact on humanity that's of course true but i come from a former colonial uh country i was born in india and i grew up in pakistan and we must not forget the bitter struggles against colonialism that capitalism was part of uh in in creating but also the bitter struggles of labor against the conditions of kaplan's uh uh effort i mean china is an example of that now bangladesh and vietnam but it's an old history and of course it's a history that has the strongest origins in manchester in the in the uk on stephanie's point that i wanted to just as you mentioned the point about john henry really resonated with me my micro teacher was gary becker and he was a hell of a good teacher also really difficult and didn't allow you to question things along the way so one day we're sitting there and by the way the important thing is he applied his arguments to real world phenomena his theory of marriage and of discrimination or really dominate the profession even on the left but one day we were sitting there and becker came in and he abandoned everything he'd been saying and showed us how to derive stochastically the laws of demand and supply very simple principle i didn't see this stochastic until later but it was a very simple principle and i never forgot it i went and sat down on the steps of low library i wrote out the argument i added one little thing that there has to be a minimum income for people i was just coming from my development class and i found that i could explain all of the empirical phenomena of microeconomics about demand and supply elasticities and all that from the extension of this framework it's a chapter in my book and without becker i would not have found it um and just one more point which is that and and the point there is that we have to treat people we don't agree with that some people we can learn from in fact indeed have to learn from because they don't agree with us and how else we're going to confront that if we don't uh on gustavus question uh first of all i want to take in a reverse order heteroeconomics should follow neoclassical economics well here's how i do it i'm interested in a particular topic let's say inequality which happens to be current interests of mine raise gender then i look at what uh the empirical evidence is first because i can't judge the models by just the models i want to judge what they're trying to explain i'm not intimidated by the math they have an engineering background so the question is what's the substance of the argument and that's a lesson i learned from becca but in the end i i have this bizarre commitment to trying to fit it together in a coherent framework so i have to go back so if i may i know i'm running on but let's give you an example of this i've long been interested in race class and gender we had a whole program at the musical for 10 or 15 years very prominent uh women economists who've gone on to make big names for themselves and i thought i ran across a discipline called econophysics and was really about startling patterns in economics patterns are really couldn't be explained so i thought okay i will do this for race and gender and i'm sure the patterns will be different the pattern is the income of workers follows a law called an exponential law or in physics of thermal distribution and the data shows that everywhere go to the irs you can find the data again and again but i thought okay cannot be true of by gender or race so i had the data and i did it and i found of course women's incomes were lower blacks incomes are lower than whites but astonishingly the distribution of income within each group was essentially the same and that led me to think well how could that be we intervene in so many different ways and i realized that what i was looking at is outcomes generated by the market then the question is how do you explain it how do you explain it coherently for within a framework and i discovered that going back to adam smith's idea that labor migrates from low-wage to high-wage areas turns out if you put it in a framework which is a familiar one in physics you can generate these patterns and the framework is very simple people call on or can i that you have to look at what others have done but you don't have to simply start there or okay um deidra what do you like about each other's work i i i like very much um ebony's inspiration to help people and to and to um follow her own star and in reply to gustavo on that i would say that you you you should focus as onward does and as i do on problems on on peculiarities of oddnesses of things that on their face seem strange and then explain them and explain them with uh supply and demand curves if that seems to work or with uh the history of all hitherto existing societies is the history of class struggles if that seems to work and solve the problem and then write a book don't bother with the with the two top journals that that i i heard for a while on the editorial um committee of the american economic review um when jose jose stiglitz was the editor and i can only stand it for a couple of years because practically every paper i encountered was in my view and this is the view of the american statistical associate association misusing tests of statistical significance and and virtually all of them were appallingly written and and i got tired of saying this this paper isn't any good don't publish it and and of course they were all highly orthodox so our way for forward is is so to speak as as as as effingham has done right beyond the orthodoxy right to an audience slightly beyond it but what i'm not so sh sure about in my esteemed colleagues here is a convention that you find in in standard issue what i would prefer to call samuelssonian economics not so much neoclassical because that also includes austrians but okay same with sony economics and in in marxist economics and institutional economics and so forth this idea that there are terrible imperf imp imperfect imperfections in the in the way cute capitalism um operates that it fails to set satisfy the supposed us assumptions on which it's justified and the problem is that practically no one has shown this to be true empirically one courageous attempt in 1966 was put was by a couple of marxist paul they failed but they tried so i i would urge i would urge people to look into how close these arguments these models that we talk about whether heterodex and docs or orthodox how close they are quantitatively speaking actual economy thank you i'm stephanie well i mean i think that you know the advice that deirdre just gave and i'm speaking to gustavo really um about you know finding something that you really care about your passion and write about that it's very hard i couldn't write for the purpose of you know ticking the boxes and jumping through the hoops for the ten process and and i know that it's part of the it's part of the game right as an academic there is an expectation that you're going to have a certain number of publications in order to get promotion and tenure and here i just think it's so important that when the decision is made you know about which programs to apply to you know where which department do you want to be in what do you want to find as your academic home which who who do you want for your colleagues that's such an important part of the consideration that you know if you are aiming for the so-called top then you have an understanding of what those expectations are i can remember many years ago being in a in a pub with a group of uh economists journalists uh and others there was a blogging conference taking place and there was an economist there i won't give too much away so people can't figure out who it is but he was at uh you know a second tier like a very highly ranked um but not a harvard sort of thing uh and he had just been told that he was being that he was being denied tenure and he had a wife and a five-year-old daughter and he could not get an article in the qje or the jel and they told him you've got to have one in one of these three journals or you're out that kind of pressure and he sat sobbing you know in a room full of mostly other economists and it i felt so so bad for him you know um but in my department and it's funny because fred lee took on this project of the journal rankings and he you know theresa you know this you know i'm sure maybe others do as well fred did this kind of probably year-long research where he redid the assessment and re-ranked the articles and the departments based on you know his array of um factors and considerations and what do you think he found you know it it basically inverted the hierarchy it inverted the hierarchy and he all of a sudden is showing that you know programs like yours at the new school and ours at umkc were really among the highest ranked departments when you take into account you know number of publications and so forth you're not heavily weighting this small number of of publications so you know writing you you you gotta i couldn't write i couldn't wake up and sit in front of a computer and write about something that i wasn't truly passionate about so finding a home and a group of colleagues who will respect and support your work and your research even if it's a far departure from what they're uniquely interested in but you know support you through that process nothing's more important because in all likelihood you do have to jump through those hoops early on and then you can do what you want after that can i make a comment on that i jumped through the hoops not because i i was compromising but because i was stupid and and i i believed in the hoops so i jumped through them i got the tenure at the university of chicago but five years later tiring of uh the atmosphere in economics at chicago i moved to the university of iowa uh which is not even uh ranked you know in in what stephanie is calling that that's that um econ group and i was free i was i was i in fact formed a group entered disciplinary group i was the only economist in the group english professors professors of hydrology and so forth and i made an intellectual life because i was able to i was i and it's not because i'd been at chicago or published a lot it was because i was at what stephanie is describing and i found these people i'm i'm deidre i'm going to interrupt you because not because i'm rude but i want to i want to keep up with the audience and with our time we're going to end on when we said we would um mark would you like to start the questions yeah i i just wanted to introduce a couple of uh broad questions if i could that are partly inspired by some of the audience commentary uh one is all three of you have touched upon things like neglect of the object of analysis lack of intellectual breadth um are economists just bad social scientists and and if so is is the fix easy we have history departments we have psychology departments maybe they can tell us something maybe they should and then secondly we all get caught up in ideas because we're all economists but when we're thinking about the future of heterodox economics or the future of economics we're at large should we should we be operating at the level of ideas or is the problem at its core for example the sociology of the economics profession or the influence of private wealth or something externally on what gets funded and what research gets done i think it's extraordinary how orthodox american economics is and how hierarchical it is this foolish talk about the top journals if the deans required people in an economics department to read the work of the candidate instead of just scoring them with a hasty look at their cv it would revolutionize economics um stephanie and anwar quickly please i want to get to these questions i don't i mean i think the problem mark and we all know this is that for the most part economists don't think of themselves as part of a social science no they don't yeah right yeah they they're for example they scorn sociology anwar you're on mewtanwa uh let me remind you that we've all mentioned how important the history of economic thought was in our understanding and the whole point is that economists were not like this before this is a degeneration yeah you're right and a retreat from reality and i always attributed to the fact that the neoclassical framework is a framework that uh presents a perfect and ideal vision of capitalism and that's why people like hayek and marx just rejected it from the start because this is an ideological construction but it's very popular for the same reason that the version the church's version of uh garden of eden was popular if it could be enforced by a few burning of the stakes so uh i think from that point of view this we should and must be connected to other social sciences but it does not mean that we can arbitrarily rush together at the new school we're always being told it's time for interdisciplinary and you go yay okay all of you have to be like anthropologists wait a minute they don't study our data they don't ask our questions well that's not that you have to move over and that i reject okay um i have a question i have a question that's a real swerve but um it comes up over and over in in the chat and i think one of the reasons why people tuned in um which framework orthodox a version of orthodoxy your own frameworks a better addresses and understands the climate crisis should we use heterodox or orthodox economics um stephanie i'll start with you in reverse order well what am i going to say and why why i you know i would point people i'm not i always try to stay in my lane i have my framework i have my lane i try to respect what i don't know i'm not a climate or an environmental economist but um you know people like steve keane steve's done incredible work lately and i will sit in and sometimes listen to his online talks where he went after nordhouse so you know you have the orthodox uh premier kind of orthodox example and approach to the questions of the application of the orthodox framework to questions of climate change and so forth and steve i think steve just demolished it from a non-orthodox uh perspective so yeah um i know i don't think any of us are climate change but it's the prevailing problem of our day um deidre well i i i would then uh speak up for bill nordhaus i i'm i'm perfectly prepared to hear out the criticisms of his argument but i think we all agree that if you're going to criticize an argument you should understand it i was when i was a kid i was a kind of a unscholarly marxist um and i've read a lot of marks so you know maybe i'm in a position to to argue with some marxists but it won't do and i don't think is proposing it to just sort of sweep aside cost and benefit um well let me start by saying what i said about hayek and marks both would agree that uh capitalism is very efficient it's certain and certain things that's obviously but its efficiency comes from profit making and the consequences of profit making and you can actually see where it's not profit making like the environment you can dump all kinds of stuff in the river well that's good it's efficient and so we have to understand that this is not an externality it's an internality it's as internal as the consequences of profit making on human behavior when i was a graduate student i was completely repulsed by this definition and representation of human behavior i mean it didn't fit my family that's for sure any culture that i've ever heard of so i started to study anthropology and sociology and effort but the gap between those two still was huge and it took a lot of work to make it up oh we have two two minutes left um yeah theresa a question that has come up that i think might be nice to put to the panel is what if any idea from orthodoxy would you retain and what if any idea from heterodox economics however define would you be eager to discard well i would be eager to i would be eager to discard the conflictual bias in among the among the left wing i think it it drives you away from the very the very common cases in which cooperation is is what's actually happening i'm stephanie i i don't know i'm still noodling i want to pick i i wanted to pick something really smart uh yeah i don't know about discarding from heterodoxy i hadn't my mind hadn't gone to that yet i was still fixated i can go to onward want me to put it to anwar and let you noodle yeah i mean some level of scarcity i guess i would retain i'll come back to you you get you get a chance anwar i think for me what i retain from orthodox economics is the importance of markets especially competition because that's a theme that is central to the classical tradition also and secondly what i reject is a reduction therefore on the left of capitalism to monopoly i've never believed that and baran and sweeney as as dieter said and great work but in my opinion one of his defects was that monopoly is too easy a target for you to sweep everything you have to understand that competition bothers real capitalists they're always worried that any minute someone's going to eat them and they're not wrong about that so competition definitely and now stephanie meg their minds work more quickly than mine i i guess on the orthodoxy i i keep some uh i keep the idea of trade-offs the importance of of centering our thinking around the importance of trade-offs but i'm not i'm not committed yet on the header docs question i'm sorry we will do this next year okay right right right together together thank you all very much i would like to ask the panelists before we leave and sign off to answer the poll we are going to post many of these remarks on the after action website we have a paper um on heterodox economics on the website as well and we will publish your questions on the website and then i will sort through them and ask that the uh that they be answered again on the website or a team will answer them so it's not really over we have um after event um um living and the videos will also be posted so tell your friends thank you uh very much from the new school and thank you my friends who have come i'm back bye-bye thank you everyone yeah bye-bye see you later stephanie take it easy but take it as we say in chicago
love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com
Money Marketeers of NYU - Professor Stephanie Kelton, "Awash in Debt: Will there be a Reckoning?"2021/03/11
17 ~ 21 分
ニューヨーク大学のマネーマーケッター-ステファニーケルトン教授、「債務の氾濫:レコニングはありますか?」2021/03/11
https://love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com/2021/03/money-marketeers-of-nyu-professor.html?m=1 @
https://youtu.be/34VeCTJlSXM
ええと、彼らは私たちの仕事の成功を共有するためにここにいますええと、将来への希望と私たちは7分以内にいくつかの過去の間違いに気付くかもしれません、そして私はそれが助けるパネルで役立つことを前もって謝罪したいことを強制します私たちの技術者こんにちはマイケル舞台裏で私からありがとう。ちなみに、シカゴのイリノイ大学で経済学と歴史の名誉教授であり、英語とコミュニケーションの名誉教授であるdeidre mccloskeyがいます。彼女の最新の本は、なぜリベラリズムが機能するのかというタイトルで、エールから出版されました。大学は社会研究のための新しい学校で私たち自身の経済学教授をプレスします私の友人anwarsheikh彼の最新の本は「資本主義競争の対立と危機」と題されていますストーニーブルック大学の経済学教授セパシニアフェロー私たち全員の良い友達はステファニーケルトンです彼女の最新の本赤字神話は素晴らしい本であり、ここでも多くの人が経済学部の議長を務めています。彼は今日、パネリストが発言した後、彼らが話しているのを聞いて、パネルをモデレートするのを手伝ってくれます。各 その他の質問と聴衆からの質問私たちが何年も話してきた世論調査の質問に答えてほしいのですが、今私はあなたに世論調査の質問をしたいと思います。はいまたはいいえが表示されます。ズームウィンドウの下部にある投票ボタンがありますが、回答できるボタンは、ディスカッションを聞いて考えた後で回答してください。質問は、下部のqaボックスに入力できます。あなたのスクリーンマークありがとうテレサイ '非常に簡単な挨拶をします。皆さんへようこそ。もちろん、このイベントの実現を支援してくれた4人のパネリスト、そして新しい学校でお会いできてうれしいです。両方ともアンウォーお願いしますええと、あなたは私に始めてほしいということですあなたはそう始めますはい大丈夫そうですね私はこのような著名な同僚とこのパネルに参加できて光栄ですそして私はこれを組織してくれたsipaとteresaに感謝したいと思います彼らが集まった膨大な数の聴衆から、異端派経済学についての質問から始めましょう。私はかつてジョーンロビンソンとのレセプションにいましたが、彼女は立ち上がるように頼まれ、彼女を世界で最も著名な女性経済学者の1人として紹介しました。気分を害し、私は女性経済学者ではないと言ったmエコノミストであり、架空の理想に取り組む人々とは対照的に、実際には単なるエコノミストと呼ばれたいのと同じように感じますが、私たちが許可されていないため、ハイドロドックス経済学が必要であると言わなければなりません世界のどこにでもある正統派の部門なので、私がしていることの多種多様なことを網羅するために、ある種の名前を付ける必要があります。私は実際のパターンを研究し、それらを理論化しようとしています。私の本は10万11ページでその50%です。存在するパターンを理解して説明できない限り、理論には興味がないので経験的です。ちなみに、ハーバードビジネスレビューは、ビジネスが実際に何をしているのか、そしてもちろん、私たちが知っているデータ自体は構築されています」かつてアルカサルが言ったように小石のようにビーチに横たわっていないが、必要に応じて分解して再構築することを理解する必要がある私の仕事は、いわゆる実用的な経済学者がしばしば新古典派経済学を意味する正統派の一部に依存しているという事実によって動機付けられています私たちが見ているように世界に取り組むつもりなら、私たちはそのような奇妙で非常にありそうもない方法で構築されたフレームワークに戻る必要はないはずであり、ちなみにこの視点は経済の時代なので、それが学界の視点であるかのようではないので、そこで疑問が生じます。経済学における多元論、つまり新古典派経済学の枠組みの多元論は絶対にそれを支配しますが、私たちの部門が例証しようとすると、私たち全員が古典派政治経済学のスミスとリカルドを持っています私たちはマルクスハイエクポストキングと経済学を持っていますそしてそれからトピックレースクラス性別国籍民族性国内および国際規模での不平等および他の多くのこれらはすべて私たちが構築しなければならない世界の現象であり、説明しようとしますが、ここでは多元論と折衷主義の信じられないほどの間に決定的な違いが生じるようです折衷主義私は、もっともらしい答えを得るために、しばしば互いに反対である理論的枠組みを混ぜ合わせて一致させることを意味します。私は他の分野を知りません。科学では、他の人類学や他の分野では混合とマッチングが完全に適切であるため、私はそれは良い考えではないと主張します。なぜなら、あなたが分野のある側面を利用して他の側面を読んでいることを検証したとしても、それは良い考えではないからです。読書の他の部分と矛盾するので、基本的に家なしでいわばあなたを残し、私はこれについて詳しく説明する時間がありませんが、例えば新古典派理論では、賃金の上昇は労働需要を低下させ、失業につながりますポストケインジアン理論では、ここで通常の状況について話すと、実質賃金の上昇は消費者の需要を高め、産出雇用を増やすという方法で状況を悪化させません。興味深い違いは、実質賃金の外生的な上昇は利益率を低下させ、労働需要を減速させ、より高い賃金の非常に重要な源である労働力を弱体化させ、通常の失業者のプールを拡大するからです。資本主義がそれを生み出し維持するという意味で失業は正常であるというこの重要な側面これらは経験的に対処可能な問題であり、理論的であるだけでなく、私の仕事の多くはこれらの種類の問題に対処することに関与しており、それらはまた強い政策的意味を持っていますそれについて詳しく説明したいのですが、あなたの歴史を見て、なぜヒットラーのドイツとルーズベルトなのかを説明してください。ええと、うつ病後、そして戦前の活動は、高賃金などのインフレにつながりませんでしたが、その後、70年代にインフレと停滞につながりました。これらのメカニズムが実際にどのように機能するかを理解する必要があるので、私は信じています残念ながら支配的なアプローチの1つは、答えを出すのに適していると思われる理論を組み合わせて一致させることです。次に、別の経験的現象を使用して、他の何かを組み合わせて一致させることもできます。一方、正統な経済学を採用し、インフレの欠如を追加することもできます。知識のこれは正統派経済学者自身の間の現在の標準であるか、これは私がずっと前に自分で設定したタスクです。新古典派経済学について私が好きな一貫した代替フレームワークを開発することによってこれらを説明しようとすることができます少なくとも理論的には一貫していますそれ'経験的および現実の世界ではやや一貫性がありませんが、理論的には一貫性があり、これは私にとってマルクス・ケインズ・ラファ・ハロッドに戻って彼らの仕事から体系的な枠組みを発掘することを意味しました。時間の経過とともに私の時計はちょうどどのくらいの時間がかかりましたか私は私によると1分があります私は経験的および理論的に需要と供給の法則を説明しようとしますミクロ経済学消費者行動賃金と利益率技術変化相対価格金利債と株価アラシラーとナッツシラーアラソロス為替レート貿易収支成長失業インフレと再発危機で最高潮に達する長いブームミクロ経済学は、インタラクティブのええと総計効果からの戦争マクロ経済学としての競争の冷酷な影響下での実際の消費者行動と実際のビジネス行動から派生していますケインズの有効需要と収益性の総計sキーポイントと私は超合理性の最適化完全競争完全情報代表的エージェントといわゆる合理的期待や不完全競争などを参照せずにこれをやろうとしました独占力など私の本はちょうど3、4日前に中国語で出ましたコピーを作成しましたが、まだ持っていません。中国語に翻訳されており、スペイン語はほぼ完成しているので、このような奇妙なアプローチに興味がある場合は、実際に購入できる本をご覧ください。ロシアのウェブサイトに行く必要はありませんが、あなたが感謝できないものは何でもありがとうありがとうありがとう私は人々があなたの本を買うことを願っていますそれは私たちがお互いのためにできることですre muted muted muteええ、聴衆は私のスピーチの欠陥を許さなければならないでしょう私は言葉が途切れるので私はそれを率直に言うことができないので私はジョービデンがそうするので私は熱心にその経済学に同意します他の場所ではそれほど多くはありませんが、非常に不寛容で、実際に愚かな正統派です。私の生涯で有名な例は、ノートルダム大学の異端派経済学部の破壊です。それは悪いことです。それは科学にとって悪いことです。それは科学の倫理にとって悪いことです」政策にとっては悪いですが、異教は含めるべきだと思いますが、通常はオーストリア学派のテッドデニソン大学は、たとえばマルクスがハイエクに立ち向かわないことに対するまれな例外的な選択肢であり、今ではそれが何であるかを含めるべきだと思います人文科学とバーノンスミスと呼ばれ、そして私は人文科学の指数であり、それは私たちが数学の他の種類の経済学と統計と観察から学ぶことができることを異教的な方法で続けるように私たちに促しますと個々の観察が、これを行うのは難しいように聞こえますが、私の見解はそこにあるとあなたが思うよりも簡単です。経済学が従来行われている方法で特定の量のクランキング機械がありますが、私はあなたの人間の経験をジェーン・オースティンとシェイクスピアでより広く文脈化し、文化人類学者と一緒に歴史家とアリストテレスをします。アンワーは、証拠はループにあり、プリンにあり、他の洞察があるか、この新しいヒューマノミクスに起因する可能性のあるより正確な科学的発見を言うべきだと述べました非常に新しいので、まだまだ先は長いですが、そうです。たとえば、私は、定量的であると同時に定性的な幅広い証拠に基づいて、一般の人々の実質所得が3000増加していると主張し、持っていると思います。 1800年以降の日本やフィンランドのような場所の非常に貧しい人々でさえ、政治の右側が主張するような法と投資の変化から、または左側が主張したい奴隷制と搾取からではなく、 18世紀に北西ヨーロッパで、リベラルな許可のリベラルな平等という考えに突然来た、人間が創造性を創造するための入り口です。啓蒙主義のスコットランド側のことをフランス人よりも考えているのですが、量的証拠だけでなく、正統な種類の証拠だけでなく、すべての証拠を経験的に許可することで示すことができると私は主張します。これが真実であるという証拠iiは続く可能性があり、私のウェブサイトに招待されているのですが、それはすべて、私の本を読む必要はないが、私の本を購入したいというアンワルのような素晴らしい発見です。コミュニティ資本主義の方法で話すには本を購入する必要があります。それが私のプラグヒューマノミクスです。ありがとうございます。ステファニーに目を向けます。ありがとうございます。前の2人のスピーカーの熱意を共有します。とてもいいです。彼らと再び一緒にいることは私たちが知っていることです過去に一緒に物事を行ったことがあります。この重要な会話に私を含めてくれたテレサに感謝します。だから、私は少し話をしたいと思っていたので、異端性が私にとって何を意味していたのかを推測します。経済学を勉強するために、私は金融を勉強する道を進んでいました。金融市場について考えるという考えが好きです。人々を助けることができるという考えが好きだと思ったので、いつの日か私は想像します。おそらくあなたが知っている金融のプランナーは人々が彼らの退職とそのようなことを理解するのを助けるでしょうそして私はそれがミクロ理論コースの中級レベルである必要がありそしてそれがジョン・ヘンリーとによって教えられたので経済学コースにつまずいたのです私はそれを知っています」ええと、deirdreとanwarに馴染みのある名前で、ジョンがそこにいたとき、私はあなたの両方がumkcの私の前の大学の1つにいたことを覚えていると思います、そしてあなたはジョンがまっすぐな新古典主義のええとeconコースを教えたことを知っています内容に関しては、そのコースについて何でも刺激を受けましたが、ジョンは刺激的で、教室で見事でした。そのクラスの最後の日に、彼は私たちが提示されたものについて批判的に考えることを最終的に可能にする機会を利用しました。あなたのコースは15週間知っています。なぜなら、コース中にコース中にまったくプッシュバックした場合、彼はノーノーノーノーそれをしないと言うでしょう。だろう」質問したり、モデルができなかったという根本的な仮定に異議を唱えたりしましょう。最終日、彼はこれを非常にはっきりと覚えています。モデルが機能する場合は、優れた理論モデルがあるかどうかを確認してください。仮定を緩和するために、物事は多かれ少なかれまだ一緒になっているはずなので、ジョンは仮定をリラックスし始めました、そしてここで私たちはあなたが最終的にこのことで本当にタイヤを蹴ることを許されたことを知っていました、そしてクラス全体がちょうどそれを守りそして押し戻すことを試みました彼に対して、そして私は数年後まで、ジョンがその最後の講義で私たちに資本論争を紹介することであることに気づかなかったので、あなたがiiがそうではないことを知ったら、私はあなたにもっと興味を持ってもらいました。経済学を教化プログラムとしてやっているだけで、私はこれらのモデルを取り、提示されたすべてのものを受け入れる必要がありました。質問はありませんでした。私は彼と一緒に経済思想の歴史を取りました。経済学を勉強するという考えに恋をし始めたジョンは、ある時点で私を誰かに連れて行ってくれました。大学院に行くべきだと聞いたので、行きたい場所がわからなかったので、ジョンに話してもらいました。別の経済学者と一緒に私は彼に名前を付けません、そして彼はハーバードに行くと言いました、そしてあなたがハーバードに行くならあなたはそうするだろうと彼は言いましたある種の異端派経済学プログラムを経験した場合に苦しむであろうスリングと矢に苦しんでいて、私はそう思ったが、私は行かなければならない私はあなたが知っている主流のプログラムをしなければならず、彼が言った論文をどのように書くつもりですかいいえ、あなたはそれを書きますあなたはそれを捨てますそして私は私がそのようなプログラムを経験することを私に持っていなかったことを知っていましたそのようなコミットメントを毎日起こさせます私はおそらくあなたが信じていなかったことを知っている論文を書きます本当にとても価値があったので、そこから離れていくと、他の多くの学校に応募しましたが、2つになりました。新しい学校はおそらく経済的にそうだったと思います。最後の2つでは、先に述べたのはノートルダムでした。マーティウルフソンかケンブリッジで勉強していたので、ケンブリッジ大学に行くことができると思っていたので、豊かな伝統に触れることができました。ケインズとジョーンロビンソンとミッキーカルダーとスラファがホールを歩いていなかったことを知っていますが、私はそこにその伝統が十分に残っているので、それから利益を得ることができ、それでもケンブリッジから学位を取得することができます。どういうわけか私には役立っていますが、実際には、プログラムは1年間のトークプログラムであり、大学院レベルで4つのコースを参照し、論文を書いて完了しました。私はそうではなかったので、緊張しました。確かに私は自分自身を私のベルトの下にたった4つの大学院コースを持つ本当の経済学者と見なすことができたので、とにかく私はフェローシップを得ました、そしてそれは私を徴収経済研究所に連れて行きました一週間、街に行って、新しい学校のエドネルのクラスに座ってください。これは私の最高の思い出の1つであり、私の人生と自分のキャリア私は新しい学校に座って、ある種のコーヒーショップのカフェテリアであなたが知っている学生の話を聞きました。当時あなたがそれを呼んだことを忘れて、私の周りのテーブルで行われている会話を聞くことができました。 「そのようなことは聞いたことがない」ケンブリッジで起こったのは、異世界の人々が自分たちの周りの世界について深く考えていたということでした。彼らは哲学的な会話をしていました。階級意識のある会話をしていました。レースcon iiiはそれを愛し、それは私を活気づけました。あなたのジュースを動かして、あなたが本当に考えて挑戦するようになるはずだったので、私はあなたが知っている必要があることがたくさんあることを知っていると決めました、そして私は新しい学校に参加してそこで博士号を取得することになりましたあなたがサバティカルにいて、私は本当に1年間しかそこにいなかったし、あなたはその年にサバティカルにいたので、私はいつもあなたのコースを受講する機会がなかったと思います。ええと、しかし、私は終わった私はしませんでした私は異教のプログラムから出てきたスリングと矢に苦しんでいます私はカンザスシティのミズーリ大学に就職しました、そして私が参加したとき私は別の新しい学校の卒業生とランディレイであるマットフォーシュタッターと一緒になりましたそして数年後に私たちは得ましたフレッド・リーが参加し、この信じられないほどの部門に非常に知的に多様なジョン・ヘンリーが加わりました。後にジム・スタージョンのような制度主義者がいました。新古典派経済学者がいたので、どういうわけか私たち全員が水泳でうまくやっていくことができたので、私たちは信じられないほどの場所でした。ある時、教員の間で本当の不一致があったことを思い出してください。ある時点で非常に大規模な博士課程の学生がいたと思います。修士課程の学生は83人、博士課程の学生は60人で、約12人でした。教員だったので私たちは小さかったのですが、学際的な博士課程プログラムを構築しました。つまり、経済学を知っていて、二次的な分野を学びました。それは本当に何かを意味し、学生は自分の経済学を哲学や心理学、政治学や社会学の人類学と組み合わせることができました。経済学者にはこの好ましいステータスが与えられているので、ビデン大統領がステージに立って一流の社会学者と言うのを聞くことはあまりないので、私はいつもそう感じたと思います。言うが、それは」sエコノミストエコノミストが私たちに言っていることエコノミストが言っていることと私たちは議論の中でこの特大の声を持っています特にあなたは政策に関して知っていますそして私はいつもあなたが知っている雇用決定にアプローチした方法で責任感を感じたと思います教室で、私たちが次世代の人々を訓練していることを認識することが重要であると教えました。経済学者は、これらの議論に大きな影響を与える可能性があります。より良いフレームワークより適切なフレームワークは、資本主義経済の働きを分析し、一日の終わりに、なぜ私たちがこの仕事をしているのかを思い出すためのより良い方法です。私たちのモデルの優雅さと美しさ以上のものになる必要がありますが、モデルが実際の人々に影響を与え、重要にする方法は、そこで停止することを意味します。ステファニーに感謝します。ええと、明るいスポットええと、そのum gustavoで、人々は教員ではなく学生のために新しい学校に来ることがわかりました。私にとっては混合ニュースですが、私は非常に驚いていません。私はこのええと著名なええとペンの一部になることも私の背景を共有し、議論のための質問を提起するので、私はこの秋にアカデミックジョブマーケットに参入する新しい学校の経済学の3年生の博士課程の学生です学位はブラジルのサンパウロ大学からのもので、これは小さな異端セクションを持つ主流のプログラムであり、ほとんどの経済カリキュラムと同様に、コアコースは最適な決定を行う独立した利益追求エージェントを想定する一般的な平衡理論などの数学的フレームワークに大きく依存しています教科書の枠組みに適合した真の経済学と現実として提示され、たとえば流通と金融危機をめぐる対立を回避するものとして提示されない時間の経過に伴う理論は、通常、数学的な扱いやすさについては扱われず、この数学の厳密さを使用しない研究はソフトサイエンスと見なされます私の専門的な仕事の経済学は、教科書と現実の不一致が目立っていたので、クラスで最初に経済学は、影響力のある経済学者が議論した3つの方程式だけで説明されました 経済成長モデルが唯一の関連変数でした。貯蓄率財政政策は経済活動に影響を与えませんでした。労働市場は常に完全雇用であり、金融政策はお金の中立性と金融危機の不可能性を前提としていました。ローラ・カルヴァーリョ・アヌスコの卒業生など、サンパウロ大学の教授と私は、真の経済的アプローチを期待せずにここに来ました。代わりに、さまざまな学校の関連性と欠点について話し合うために、今日ここにあるような学術環境を探していました。主流のイデオロジストが支配する環境で異端経済学者になることの難しさを理解しているが、私はこれらの価値観を学界に持ち帰り、ブラジルで政策論争に戻すことを期待しているので、これを念頭に置いて パネルの最初の大学に対する2つの質問は、教授が一流の経済ジャーナルに掲載することを要求しますが、異端派経済学者は関連する研究アジェンダに従い、既存の主流派経済学のインセンティブに直面してどのように繁栄するのでしょうか。ほとんどの主流派経済学者が異端派経済学に従わない場合、異端派経済学者はどの程度主流派経済学に遅れずについていくべきか異端派経済学者は常にこの主流派経済学とは対照的に研究を発展させるべきか、それとも彼らは独自の道をたどることができるので、もう一度ありがとう今日の議論とあなたの貢献はどうもありがとうグスタボええと私はパネリストにグスタボを維持するように頼みますsの質問が頭に浮かびますが、現在、これらのパネルの最も価値のある側面のいくつかは、パネリストが互いに話すようになったときに、私たち全員が一緒にいれば、これをはるかに自然に行うことになるでしょう。今では300人以上の人と話をしているのですが、日本から高校生までの記者がいるので、聴衆を想像したようなverがあります。お互いの仕事について好きなこと、今日言ったこと、そしてどこで敬意を表して反対するのか、そしてグスタボの質問に今またはqaで答えることができるかどうかを話した順番で行ってください。とても素晴らしいですええと、私たちはあなたがすべて非常に素晴らしく、その時間にお互いに敬意を払っていた時間がありますので、しましょう」ジャンプする必要があるときに開始してマークを付けてくださいええありがとうテレサ私は質問からのテーマを含むいくつかのテーマを取り上げましたが、最初にパネリストから聞いてみましょうあなたが最初に話したので、あなたはあなたを含むすべての人のミュートを解除する必要があります大丈夫ですあなたが知っているように、私たちの職業が必ずしも多くのほとんどすべてについてdaedraに同意することを生成するとは限らないので、そのような興味深くそして読み書きのできる人々と一緒にパネルにいることはとても嬉しいです実際に彼女が言ったことですが、私はそれを1つだけ言及させてください」オーストリアの経済学とハイエクが除外されていることは絶対に重要です私は最近その関係を再発見しましたそして私が見つけたものはマルクスとハイエクについて経済学部の新しい学校で講義をしましたそして私の強調は彼らの反対ではなくそれらの類似性にありました驚くべきことに、彼らが資本主義をどのように見ているのか、そしてそれがどのように機能するのかは驚くべきことであり、マルクスは確かに資本主義が社会にもたらした大きな富について語っています。比較的重要な違いは明らかですが、とにかく、経済学には人類文学の人間の経験が必要であるという考えに完全に同意しますケンブリッジの大衆で誰か他の人が欲しい私はゲーム理論がシェイクスピアを説明できると言った本を見つけましたそして悲しいかな私は購入しませんでしたコンセプトがぞっとするようなものだと思ったので持っておくべき本それを読むべきだった私はその一部を読んだが資本主義の人類への強いプラスの影響の問題でそれを購入しなかった植民地時代のええと国私はインドで生まれ、パキスタンで育ちました。資本主義が創造の一部であった植民地主義に対する苦闘だけでなく、カプランの条件に対する労働の苦闘も忘れてはなりません。ええと、努力、つまり中国は今やバングラデシュとベトナムの例ですが、それは古い歴史であり、もちろん、あなたが言ったように、ステファニーの点で英国のマンチェスターで最も強い起源を持っている歴史ですジョン・ヘンリーについてのポイントは私に本当に共感しました私のマイクロ教師はゲーリー・ベッカーでした、そして彼はまた本当に難しい良い教師の地獄でした、そしてあなたが途中で物事を質問することを許さなかったので、ある日私たちはそこに座っています重要なのは、彼の議論を現実世界の現象に適用したことです。彼の結婚と差別の理論は、左側でも職業を支配していましたが、ある日、私たちはそこに座っていて、ベッカーがやって来て、彼はすべてを放棄しました。dは、需要と供給の法則を確率的に導き出す方法を教えてくれました。非常に単純な原則です。この確率論は後になるまで見られませんでしたが、非常に単純な原則であり、忘れることはありませんでした。ライブラリ私は議論を書きました私は開発クラスから来たばかりの人々のために最低収入がなければならないという小さなことを1つ追加しましたそして私は需要と供給の弾力性とすべてについてミクロ経済学の経験的現象のすべてを説明できることがわかりましたこのフレームワークの拡張から、それは私の本の章であり、ベッカーがなければ私はそれを見つけることができなかったでしょう、そしてそれはそれであり、私たちがそれに同意しない人々を扱わなければならないという点がもう1つあります実際、私たちが学ぶことができる人の中には、実際には学ばなければならない人もいます。私たちに同意し、他にどのように直面するのか、私たちがガスタバスの質問に答えない場合は、まず逆の順序で取りたいですヘテロ経済学は新古典派経済学によく従うべきですここに私が興味を持っている方法があります特定のトピックで、たまたま私の現在の利益である不平等が性別を高めるとしましょう、そして私は彼らが何をしようとしているのかを判断したいモデルだけではモデルを判断できないので、経験的証拠が最初に何であるかを調べます私は彼らが工学的背景を持っている数学に恐れていないので、問題は議論の本質は何であるかであり、それは私がベッカから学んだ教訓ですが、最終的にはそれを首尾一貫したものにまとめようとするこの奇妙なコミットメントを持っていますフレームワークなので、戻る必要があります。mは実行中ですが、この例を挙げましょう。私は長い間レースクラスと性別に興味を持っていました。ミュージカルで10年から15年の間、プログラム全体を行ってきました。自分自身と私は経済物理学と呼ばれる分野に出くわしたと思っていましたが、経済学の驚くべきパターンについては本当に説明できなかったので、人種と性別でこれを行うと思いました。パターンは異なると確信しています。パターンは、労働者の収入が指数法と呼ばれる法則または熱分布の物理学に従うことであり、データはどこにでもデータを見つけることができることを示していますが、性別や人種によっては大丈夫だとは思いませんでした私はデータを持っていました、そして私はそれをしました、そして私はもちろん女性を見つけました黒人の収入は白人よりも低かったが、驚くべきことに、各グループ内の収入の分布は本質的に同じであり、それは私たちが非常に多くの異なる方法で介入することができる方法をよく考えさせられ、私が見ているものに気づきました市場によって生み出された結果である場合、問題は、フレームワーク内でそれをどのように首尾一貫して説明するかということです。アダム・スミスの考えに戻ると、労働力が低賃金地域から高賃金地域に移行することが判明しました。物理学でおなじみのフレームワークに入れると、これらのパターンを生成できます。フレームワークは、人々が求める非常に単純なものです。または、他の人が行ったことを確認する必要がありますが、単にそこから始める必要はありません。または大丈夫umdeidraあなたはお互いについて何が好きですか?sは、人々を助け、彼女自身の星をフォローするための非常に多くのum ebonyのインスピレーションのように、そしてgustavoに応えて、あなたは先に進むように、そして私が彼らの顔に奇妙に見えるものの奇妙さは、それがうまくいくようであれば、それらを説明し、需要曲線で説明します。または、これまでのすべての社会の歴史は、それがうまくいき、解決するようであれば、階級闘争の歴史です。問題を抱えてから本を書くな」jose jose stiglitzが編集者だったときに、アメリカ経済レビューの編集委員会でしばらく聞いた2つのトップジャーナルに悩まされています。事実上すべての論文が遭遇したのは私の見解であり、これは統計的有意性のテストを誤用しているアメリカの統計協会の見解であり、事実上すべてがひどく書かれていて、この論文は役に立たないと言うのにうんざりしました。そしてもちろん、それらはすべて非常にオーソドックスだったので、私たちの前進の道は、エフィンガムがオーソドックスな権利を少し超えて、それを少し超えた聴衆に行ったのと同じように言えますが、私は何ですか?私の尊敬する同僚の中で、ここにある慣習は、標準的な問題で、私がサミュエルソニアン経済学と呼ぶのが好きなものです。これは、オーストリア人も含まれますが、ソニー経済学やマルクス経済学でも同じです。制度派経済学など、かわいい資本主義が機能する方法にひどい不完全な不完全な不完全性があるというこの考えは、それが仮定された私たちの仮定を満たすように設定することができません。正当化され、問題は、事実上誰もこれが真実であることを経験的に示していないということです1966年に1つの勇気ある試みが行われたのは彼らが失敗したマルクス主義のポールのカップルによるものでしたが、彼らは試みたので、私は人々にこれらがどれほど近いかを調べるように促しますヘテロデックスとドキュメントまたはオーソドックスが実際の経済を定量的に話しているかどうかについて私たちが話しているこれらのモデルの議論私はステファニーですありがとう私はあなたがdeirdreがちょうど与えたアドバイスを知っていると思いますそして私は本当にグスタボに話しているあなたが本当にあなたの情熱を気にかけている何かを見つけて、それが非常に難しいことについて書くことを知っていることについて私はあなたがボックスをチェックして10のプロセスのためにフープを飛び越えることを知っているという目的のために書くことができませんでしたそして私はそれがの一部であることを知っていますそれ」アカデミックとしてのゲームの一部として、昇進とテニュアを取得するために一定数の出版物を用意することが期待されています。ここでは、決定が下されたときにどちらかを知ることが非常に重要だと思います。あなたに適用するプログラムは、あなたがどの学部になりたいかを知っていますあなたはあなたが目指しているかどうかを知っている考慮事項の非常に重要な部分であるあなたの同僚のためにあなたが誰を望んでいるのかあなたのアカデミックホームとして何を見つけたいですかいわゆるトップそれならあなたはそれらの期待が何であるかを理解しています私は何年も前にええとエコノミストジャーナリストのグループと一緒にパブにいたことを覚えていますええと他の人はブログ会議が行われ、そこにエコノミストがいました私はあまり多くを与えないので、人々はそうすることができます」それが誰であるかを理解しますが、彼は非常にランクの高いumのような2番目の層を知っていますが、ハーバードのようなものではありませんでした。妻と5歳の娘で、彼はqjeまたはjelに記事を掲載できず、これら3つのジャーナルの1つに掲載する必要があると言われました。そうしないと、そのようなプレッシャーがなくなり、彼はほとんど他のエコノミストでいっぱいの部屋であなたが知っていることをすすり泣きながら座っていました、そしてそれはあなたがあなたが知っている彼にとってとても悪いと感じました、しかし私の部門では、フレッド・リーがジャーナルランキングのこのプロジェクトを引き受けたのでそれは面白いですあなたは私を知っていますおそらく他の人もそうするでしょうフレッドはこの種のおそらく1年にわたる調査を行い、評価をやり直し、あなたに基づいて記事と部門を再ランク付けしました。それが基本的に階層を逆転させたことを知っていますそれは階層を逆転させましたそして彼は突然あなたが新しい学校であなたのようなプログラムを知っていることをあなたが知っていることを示していますそしてあなたが出版物の数を知っていることを考慮するとumkcで私たちのプログラムは本当に最高ランクの部門の中にありましたなど、あなたはこの少数の出版物に重きを置いていないので、あなたはあなたがあなたを書くことを知っていますあなたは私が書くことができなかった私は目を覚ましてコンピュータの前に座って私がそうでなかった何かについて書くことができませんでした自分の仕事や研究を尊重し、サポートしてくれる家や同僚のグループを見つけることに真に情熱を注いでいます。たとえ彼らが独自に興味を持っているものから遠く離れていても、そのプロセスを通じてあなたをサポートすることは重要です。おそらくあなたは早い段階でそれらのフープを飛び越えなければならず、その後あなたはあなたがやりたいことをすることができます私は私がフープを飛び越えたのはiiが妥協していたからではなく、私が愚かだったのでそしてiiがフープだから私はそれらを飛び越えてシカゴ大学に在籍しましたが、5年後にシカゴの経済学の雰囲気に疲れました私はイオワ大学に引っ越しましたそれだ」そのumeconグループと私は自由だった私は実際に私は懲戒グループに入ったグループを形成しました私はグループの中で唯一の経済学者でした英語の教授水文学などの教授そして私は私ができたので知的生活をしました私だったのですが、シカゴに行ったり、たくさん出版したりしたからではなく、ステファニーが説明しているところにいて、これらの人々を見つけたからです。失礼ですが、私は聴衆と私たちの時間についていくことを望んでいます」質問を始めたいと言ったときに終わりになりますええiiは、聴衆のコメントの一部に触発された可能性がある場合は、いくつかの幅広い質問を紹介したいと思います。あなたは分析の対象を無視するなどのことに触れました。知的幅の欠如は経済学者であり、悪い社会科学者です。そうであれば、簡単に修正できます。歴史学部があります。心理学部があります。次に、私たちはすべて経済学者であるため、私たち全員がアイデアに巻き込まれますが、異端派経済学の未来または経済学の未来について考えるとき、私たちは全体として、私たちがアイデアのレベルで活動しているべきか、それともその核心にある問題であるか、たとえば、経済学の専門家の社会学、私的財産の影響、または外部からの資金提供や研究の影響などです。驚くべき正統なアメリカの経済学と階層性トップジャーナルについてのこの愚かな話は、学部長が経済学部の人々に彼らのcvを急いで見るのではなく、候補者の仕事を読むことを要求した場合、それは経済学に革命をもたらすでしょうええと、ステファニーとアンワーはすぐにこれらの質問に答えたいと思います。私は問題の印だとは思いません。これは、ほとんどの場合、経済学者は自分たちを社会科学の一部とは考えていないということです。そうそうそうそう彼らはそうしないでくださいたとえば、彼らはあなたがメウタンワにいる社会学を軽蔑しているのですが、経済思想史が私たちの理解においてどれほど重要であるかについて私たち全員が言及したことを思い出させてください。ええ、あなたは正しいです、そして現実からの後退です、そして私は常に新古典主義の枠組みが資本主義の完璧で理想的なビジョンを提示する枠組みであるという事実に帰しました、そしてそれがハイエクやマルクスのような人々が最初からそれを拒否した理由ですはイデオロギー的な構造ですが、教会のバージョンと同じ理由で非常に人気があります。エデンの庭のバージョンは、ステークを数回燃やすことで強制できるのであれば人気があったので、その観点から、これは他の社会科学に接続する必要があり、接続する必要があると思いますが、それは私たちが恣意的にできるという意味ではありません新しい学校で一緒に急いでください私たちは常に学際的な時間だと言われていますそしてあなたは大丈夫ですあなたはすべて人類学者のようでなければなりません彼らは私たちのデータを研究しません彼らは私たちの質問をよくしませんそれはそうではありませんあなたは移動する必要があり、私は大丈夫を拒否しますええと、私は質問があります私は質問があります」本当の変化ですが、それはチャットで何度も出てきます。私は、人々がどのフレームワークのオーソドックスなバージョンのオーソドックスなあなた自身のフレームワークがより適切に対処し、異教徒を使用する必要があるかを理解している理由の1つだと思います。オーソドックスな経済学umステファニー私は逆の順序であなたから始めます私が何を言おうとしているのか、そしてなぜあなたが私が人々を指すことを知っているのか私はいつも私のレーンに留まろうとはしていません私は私のフレームワークを持っています私は私のレーンを持っています私は自分が気候や環境経済学者ではないことを知らないことを尊重しようとしていますが、スティーブキーンスティーブのような人々を知っています」sは最近信じられないほどの仕事をしました、そして私は座って時々彼がノードハウスを追いかけた彼のオンライントークを聞くでしょう、それであなたは正統なuh最高の種類の正統的な例と正統なフレームワークの質問への適用の質問へのアプローチを持っていることを知っています気候変動などとスティーブ私はスティーブが非正統的な視点からそれを破壊したと思うので、ええと私は私たちの誰もが気候変動だとは思わないことを知っていますが、それは私たちの日の一般的な問題ですええと、ビル・ノードハウスのために声を上げてください。私は彼の議論の批判を聞く準備ができていますが、あなたが議論を批判するつもりなら、私が子供の頃だったことを理解する必要があることに私たちは皆同意すると思います私は一種の非学術的なマルクス主義者でした。たくさんのマークを読んだので、私は一部のマルクス主義者と議論する立場にあるかもしれませんが、それはうまくいきませんし、コストと利益を一掃することを提案しているとは思いません。私がハイエクとマークについて言ったことは、資本主義が非常に効率的であることに同意することから始めます。それは確かですが、その効率は利益を生み出すことと利益を生み出すことの結果から来ており、実際には利益を上げていない場所を見ることができます。川にあらゆる種類のものをうまく捨てることができる環境それは効率的であり、それでこれは外部性ではなく内部性であることを理解する必要があります」私が大学院生だったときの人間の行動に対する利益創出の結果と同じくらい内部的な私は人間の行動のこの定義と表現に完全に反発しました私はそれが私の家族に適合しなかったことを意味します聞いたことがあるので、人類学と社会学と努力を勉強し始めましたが、それらの2つの間のギャップはまだ大きく、それを補うのに多くの作業が必要でした。パネルに載せるのがいいと思うのは、正統派のアイデアを保持し、異端派経済学のアイデアを定義すると、うまく破棄したいと思うだろうか、破棄したいと思うだろうかということです。左翼の間での対立バイアス私はそれが協力が実際に起こっていることである非常に一般的なケースからあなたを遠ざけると思います私はステファニーですii私はまだうなずいているのか分かりません私はiiを選びたいです本当に賢いものを選びたかったええと、私は異端派からの廃棄について知りませんでした」私の心はまだそれには行きませんでしたが、私はまだ固執していました私はそれを戦争に入れてあなたにヌードルをさせて欲しいですええ私は私が保持すると思うある程度の不足を意味します私はあなたに戻ってきます正統な経済学から私が保持しているのは、市場、特に競争の重要性であると私は思います。それは古典的な伝統の中心でもあるテーマであり、次に私が拒否するのは資本主義の左側の削減です。独占私はそれを信じたことがありませんでしたそしてダイエットが言ったようにバランとスウィーニーと素晴らしい仕事ですが私の意見では彼の欠点の1つは独占があなたが競争が本当の資本家を悩ませていることを理解しなければならないすべてを一掃するにはあまりにも簡単なターゲットでしたいつでも誰かがそれらを食べようとしていることを常に心配しているそれについては間違いではないので、競争は間違いなく、今ではステファニーは私のものよりも速く彼らの心を動かしますii正統派を推測しますiiいくつかを維持しますええと私はトレードオフの考えを維持しますトレードオフの重要性に私たちの思考を集中させることの重要性しかし、私はまだヘッダードキュメントの質問にコミットしていません。申し訳ありませんが、来年は一緒に大丈夫です。パネリストに質問してから出発してサインオフします。世論調査に答えるために、これらの発言の多くをアフターアクションのウェブサイトに投稿します。ウェブサイトにも異端派経済学に関する論文があります。質問をウェブサイトに公開してから、それらを整理して質問します。ええと、彼らがウェブサイトで再び答えられるか、チームが彼らに答えるので、それは」本当に終わったわけではありません。イベントの後にはうーん、ビデオも投稿されますので、友達に教えてください。新しい学校からありがとうございました。また来てくれた友達に感謝します。さようなら、みんなありがとう。ええさようならまた後でステファニーはそれを楽にしますが、シカゴで言うようにそれを取ります
JP
検索
9+
アバターの画像
kelton2021 0312 SD 480p
限定公開
1 回視聴•2021/03/19
0
0
共有
保存
me com
チャンネル登録者数 79人
文字起こし
00:00
um they're here to share the success
00:03
of our work um hope for the future
00:06
and we may um note some past mistakes
00:09
for not more than seven minutes and i
00:13
will enforce that i
00:14
want to apologize in advance it helps
00:16
with the panel it helps with
00:18
our technical person hello michael
00:20
behind the scenes thank you from
00:22
i.t by the way um we have deidre
00:25
mccloskey
00:26
who is a distinguished professor
00:28
emeritus of economics
00:30
and of history and a professor emerita
00:33
of
00:33
english and of communication at the
00:35
university of illinois in chicago
00:38
her most recent book is titled why
00:40
liberalism works
00:41
and was published by yale university
00:43
press
00:44
our own professor of economics at the
00:46
new school for social research my friend
00:48
anwar
00:49
sheikh his most recent book is titled
00:52
capitalism competition conflict and
00:55
crisis
00:57
the professor of economics at stony
00:59
brook university
01:00
a sepa senior fellow a good friend of us
01:03
all
01:03
is stephanie kelton her most recent book
01:06
the deficit myth
01:07
is a fantastic book and many um also
01:11
here
01:12
mark setterfield is the chair of the
01:14
economics department and he will help me
01:16
today
01:17
moderate the panel after their remarks
01:20
so after our panelists give remarks and
01:23
as you hear them talk to each other and
01:26
questions from the audience i would like
01:28
you all
01:29
to answer a poll question that we've
01:32
been talking about for years and now i
01:34
want to ask you
01:36
the poll question is should we abandon
01:39
the name head or docs economics
01:41
and it's a poll question you get yes or
01:43
no
01:44
there is a polling but button
01:48
at the bottom of your zoom window where
01:50
you could answer please answer after
01:51
you've heard the discussion and thought
01:53
about it
01:54
and you can put your questions um in the
01:56
q a box at the bottom of your screen
02:00
mark thanks teresa i'll just say a very
02:03
quick word of hello and welcome to
02:05
everybody
02:07
also a special word of thanks of course
02:09
to our four panelists for
02:11
uh helping making this event happen and
02:14
uh deidre and stephanie uh great to see
02:17
you back at the new school welcome back
02:18
to both of you
02:21
um anwar please uh
02:24
is that you want me to start you can
02:26
start yes okay
ANWAR:
02:28
well let me say i'm honored to be on
02:30
this panel with such eminent
02:32
colleagues and i want to thank sipa and
02:35
teresa for organizing this
02:36
and for the huge audience they've
02:39
gathered for it
02:41
let me start about with the question
02:42
about heterodox economics
02:44
i was once at a reception with joan
02:46
robinson and she was asked to come up
02:48
and
02:49
they introduced her as one of the
02:51
world's most eminent
02:53
woman economists and she got offended
02:56
and said i'm not a woman economist i'm
02:58
an economist
03:00
and i feel the same way i would like to
03:03
be called just an economist actually a
03:05
real economic economist as opposed to
03:08
those who work on the fictitious ideal
03:11
but i have to say that hydrodox
03:13
economics is necessary because we're not
03:15
allowed
03:16
in orthodox departments anywhere in the
03:18
world
03:19
and therefore we have to have some kind
03:22
of name
03:23
to encompass the wide variety of things
03:27
what i do is i study real patterns and i
03:30
try to theorize them
03:32
my book is a hundred thousand eleven
03:34
pages
03:35
and fifty percent of it is empirical
03:37
because i'm not interested in theory
03:39
unless it can understand and explain
03:41
patterns that exist
03:43
and by the way harvard business review
03:45
is a very good source
03:46
of such
03:50
analysis because they're quite hard
03:52
nosed about what businesses really
03:55
do and of course the data itself as we
03:58
know is constructed it's not
04:00
lying on the beach as pebbles as alcazar
04:03
once said
04:03
but it has to be understood
04:06
deconstructed and reconstructed if
04:07
necessary
04:10
my work is motivated by the fact that
04:13
so-called practical economists often
04:15
rely
04:16
on some part of orthodox by which i mean
04:19
neoclassical economics
04:23
and i believe that if we're going to
04:25
address the world
04:26
as we see it then we should not have to
04:29
dip
04:29
back into a framework which is
04:32
constructed in such a
04:33
strange and highly improbable way and
04:36
this point of view by the way
04:38
is shared even in the financial times so
04:40
it's not as if it's a point of view in
04:42
academia
04:45
so then the raise a question arises
04:49
there's pluralism in economics by which
04:52
i mean a pluralism of framework
04:55
of course neoclassical economics
04:57
dominates it absolutely but as our
04:59
department
05:00
tries to exemplify we all also have
05:03
classical political economies smith and
05:05
ricardo we have marx
05:06
hayek post kings and economics
05:10
and then there's a pluralism of topics
05:13
race class gender nationality ethnicity
05:16
inequality on national and international
05:18
scale and many many others
05:21
and these are all phenomena of the world
05:23
that we have to construct
05:26
and uh try to explain
05:30
but here it seems to me that a crucial
05:33
difference arises
05:35
between pluralism and eclecticism
05:37
incredibleism
05:38
eclecticism i mean that
05:42
mixing and matching theoretical
05:43
frameworks which are often antithetical
05:45
to each other
05:46
in order to get an answer which seems
05:49
plausible
05:50
i don't know of any other discipline uh
05:53
well
05:53
let's say in the sciences because
05:55
otherwise in anthropology or
05:57
uh other disciplines mixing and matching
05:59
is perfectly appropriate
06:01
i would argue it's not a good idea it's
06:04
not a good idea because even though you
06:06
draw on some aspect of a discipline to
06:08
validate your
06:10
own reading other aspects will
06:12
contradict other parts of the
06:14
reading and so it basically leaves you
06:17
so to speak without a home
06:20
and i won't have time to elaborate on
06:22
this but
06:23
for instance uh in neoclassical theory a
06:26
rise in wages
06:28
will lower demand for labor and lead to
06:30
unemployment
06:31
in post-keynesian theory and speaking
06:33
here of normal circumstances not culvert
06:35
circumstances by the way
06:38
a rise in real wages will raise consumer
06:40
demand
06:41
and raise output employment and in what
06:44
i would call
06:44
classical political economy as i
06:47
classify myself
06:49
there's an interesting difference
06:51
because an exogenous rise in real wages
06:54
will lower the profit rate it'll slow
06:57
down
06:58
the demand for labor and undermine the
07:01
strength of labor
07:02
which is a very important source of
07:04
higher wages
07:05
and expand the pool of normally
07:08
unemployed people there's an important
07:10
aspect of this that
07:11
unemployment is normal in the sense that
07:14
capitalism
07:15
creates and maintains it now these are
07:18
empirically addressable
07:20
issues they're not just theoretical and
07:23
much of my work has been involved in
07:25
addressing just these kinds of issues
07:27
they also have strong policy
07:29
implications
07:30
and i want to elaborate on that but if
07:32
you look at the history of
07:34
you explain one explain why hitler's
07:36
germany and roosevelt's
07:38
uh
07:42
post-depression and then pre-war
07:44
activities did not lead to inflation
07:47
in higher wages and so on and yet after
07:49
that
07:50
they did lead to it in the 70s to
07:52
inflation and stagnation
07:54
you have to understand how these
07:55
mechanisms actually work
07:58
so i believe
08:01
that one approach which is unfortunately
08:04
dominant is to mix and match theories
08:06
as you see a fit to give you an answer
08:09
and then with another
08:10
empirical phenomena you mix and match
08:12
something else
08:13
on the other hand one can also take
08:16
orthodox economics and add
08:18
imperfections frictions lack of
08:20
knowledge this is the standard now
08:22
in among orthodox economists themselves
08:25
or and this is the task i set myself a
08:28
long time ago
08:29
one can try to explain these by
08:31
developing a coherent alternative
08:33
framework what i like about neoclassical
08:35
economics it is coherent
08:37
at least in theory it's somewhat
08:39
incoherent in the empirical
08:40
and real world but it's coherent in
08:42
theory and this for me meant
08:44
going back to marx keynes rafa harrod
08:48
and
08:48
excavating from their work
08:51
a systematic framework and
08:55
in my book uh i want to make sure i
08:57
don't run over time my
08:59
clock just went how much time do i have
09:00
tourism i have
09:02
a minute according to me
09:05
i try to explain empirically and
09:09
theoretically the laws of demand and
09:11
supply
09:11
microeconomics consumer behavior wages
09:14
and profit rates technological change
09:16
relative prices interest rate bond and
09:19
equity prices ala schiller
09:22
and nutshiller alla soros exchange rates
09:25
trade balance growth unemployment
09:27
inflation and long booms culminating in
09:30
recurrent crises
09:33
microeconomics is derived from real
09:34
consumer behavior and
09:37
real business behavior under the
09:38
ruthless influence of competition as a
09:40
war
09:42
macroeconomics from the uh aggregate
09:44
effect of
09:45
interactive aggregate effective demand
09:47
and profitability which was keynes's key
09:49
point
09:50
and i tried to do this without any
09:52
reference to
09:54
hyper rationality optimization perfect
09:56
competition
09:57
perfect information representative
09:59
agents and so-called rational
10:01
expectations
10:02
nor imperfect competition and so on
10:05
monopoly power
10:07
my book just came out in chinese three
10:09
four days ago i would hold up a copy but
10:12
i don't have one yet
10:13
uh it's been translated to turkish and
10:16
uh the spanish one
10:17
is almost done so if you're interested
10:21
in this kind of bizarre
10:22
approach take a look at the book
10:26
you can actually buy it you don't have
10:27
to a russian website but hey
10:31
whatever you can't thank you thank you
10:34
thank you honor
10:35
i hope people buy your book that's what
10:37
we can do for each other
10:38
um deidra may i turn to you please
10:45
muted you're muted
D:
10:49
muted mute yeah the audience will have
10:52
to
10:53
for forgive my speech
10:56
defect i stutter on the words stutter
11:00
so i i can't say it straightforwardly as
11:02
so
11:04
joe biden does that i
11:09
agree with anwar enthusiastically
11:13
that economics especially here in the
11:17
united states and
11:21
thankfully not so much elsewhere
11:25
is highly and intolerantly
11:28
and indeed foolishly
11:31
orthodox there's one way of
11:35
doing economics a famous example
11:40
in my lifetime is the uh the
11:44
destruction of the heterodox
11:48
economics department at the university
11:50
of
11:51
of notre dame
11:56
and that's bad it's bad for the uh
11:59
science
12:00
it's bad for the ethics of the science
12:03
it's bad for
12:04
for a policy
12:07
however i think that
12:10
heterodoxy ought to include but
12:14
does not ordinarily
12:18
austrian economics
12:22
ted
12:28
denison university is a rare
12:31
ex ex
12:34
option to the f failure to have
12:38
marx confront hayek
12:41
for example and now
12:46
i think it should also include what is
12:49
called
12:50
humanomics
12:59
and vernon smith and and
13:03
and i are
13:08
exponents of humanomics
13:12
and it says or it it urges us in a
13:15
heterodox way
13:18
to go on with what we can learn from
13:23
the other kinds of economics of the
13:27
mathematics and the statistics and the
13:30
observations the
13:32
aggregate and individual observations
13:35
but add the humanities
13:38
this sounds hard to do but it's
13:42
easier than you might uh think
13:45
my view is that there's
13:49
a certain a certain amount of clanking
13:52
machinery in the way economics
13:56
is conventionally done that i would like
14:00
to uh
14:05
i would like to contextualize with
14:09
your human experience more broadly
14:13
with jane austen and shakespeare
14:16
with a and
14:22
aristotle with the historians
14:26
with the cultural
14:31
anthropologists now
14:34
as anwar said
14:37
the proof is in the is in the loop
14:41
is in the pudding are there are
14:44
are there are other insights or i should
14:47
say more exactly
14:48
scientific findings that can be
14:51
attributed to this new humanomics
14:55
it's very new we have a long way to go
14:58
but
14:59
yes i i think there are
15:02
now for instance i would argue
15:06
and have on the basis of
15:10
wide evidence that is quantitative
15:13
but also qualitative
15:17
that the 3 000 increase
15:21
in the
15:25
real incomes of ordinary
15:28
folk among them the
15:31
even very poor people in places like
15:35
japan and finland
15:38
since say 1800
15:42
can be shown to not come from changes in
15:46
law and investment as the right side of
15:51
politics claims or from
15:58
slavery and exploitation
16:02
as the left side would
16:07
like to claim but from
16:10
an and an opening for human create
16:17
creativity that came with the coming in
16:20
the 18th century
16:22
rather suddenly in northwestern europe
16:25
to the idea of liberal equality
16:29
of liberal permissions
16:33
i'm thinking more of the uh
16:36
of the scottish side of the
16:38
enlightenment
16:41
than the uh uh uh french
16:48
i would argue that you can show in
16:52
empirically allowing yourselves
16:56
all the evidence not just the
16:57
quantitative evidence or the
16:59
or the orthodox uh um sorts of evidence
17:04
but
17:05
all the evidence that this is true
17:09
i i could go on and have
17:12
uh you're in invited to go to my
17:16
website for uh it's all it's
17:22
marvelous findings like anwar i wish you
17:25
would buy my
17:26
my books you don't need to read my books
17:29
but you do need to
17:31
buy the books to speak in a community
17:34
capitalist
17:35
way so that's my plug
17:40
humanomics.
17:45
oh deidre thanks very much um i'll now
17:48
turn to stephanie.
Kelton:
17:51
well thank you and again uh i share
17:55
the enthusiasm of the two previous
17:58
speakers it's very nice to be
18:00
with them again i know we've done things
18:02
in the past together and thank you to
18:04
teresa for
18:05
including me uh in this important
18:08
conversation
18:08
so uh you know i thought i would just
18:12
talk a little bit about i guess what
18:14
heterodoxy has meant to me
18:16
uh you know i i started off
18:21
not intending to study economics at all
18:23
i was
18:24
sort of on a path to studying finance i
18:27
like the idea
18:28
of thinking about financial markets i
18:30
like the idea
18:31
i think i thought i liked the idea of
18:33
being able to help people and so
18:35
i imagine that one day i would probably
18:37
be a financial
18:39
uh planner you know help people figure
18:41
out their retirement and that sort of
18:43
thing and
18:43
i ended up uh stumbling into an
18:46
economics course because it was required
18:48
it was a micro theory course
18:49
intermediate
18:50
level and it was taught by john henry
18:53
and i know that that's a name
18:55
that uh is familiar to deirdre and to
18:58
anwar and
18:59
uh i think i have memories of both of
19:02
you being at one of my previous
19:03
universities at umkc
19:05
when john was there and you know john
19:08
taught a
19:09
straight neoclassical uh econ course
19:12
there was
19:13
absolutely nothing inspiring whatsoever
19:15
about that course
19:17
in terms of the content um but john was
19:20
inspiring
19:21
and he was masterful in the classroom
19:23
and on the very last day
19:25
of that class he used the opportunity
19:29
to finally allow us to
19:32
think critically about what we had been
19:35
presented with over the course of you
19:37
know 15 weeks because
19:39
if we pushed back at all during course
19:42
during the course he would say no no no
19:45
don't do that
19:46
because we'd say well in the real world
19:48
i said no no don't do that
19:49
he wouldn't let us ask questions or
19:52
challenge the underlying assumptions the
19:55
models
19:56
we could not uh do that and on the last
19:58
day
19:59
i remember this very clearly he said
20:02
look
20:02
if you've got a good theoretical model
20:05
if the model
20:06
works you should be able to begin to
20:08
relax the assumptions
20:10
and the things should more or less still
20:11
hold together so
20:13
john started relaxing assumptions and
20:15
here we were
20:16
you know finally allowed to really kick
20:19
the tires on this thing and
20:21
the whole class just ended up trying to
20:23
defend it and to push back against him
20:25
and i didn't realize until some years
20:28
later
20:29
that what john did in that final lecture
20:32
was to introduce us to the capital
20:34
controversies without ever calling it
20:36
that and so i got
20:39
you know more interested once i realized
20:42
that
20:43
you know i i wasn't just doing economics
20:47
as an indoctrination program
20:49
that i i had to take these models and
20:51
accept everything that had been
20:52
presented
20:53
no questions asked uh and i took the
20:56
history of economic thought
20:57
with him and that's where things really
21:00
opened up for me and
21:02
that's when i kind of started to fall in
21:04
love with the idea of studying
21:06
economics john
21:09
took me to someone at some point he said
21:11
listen you ought to go to graduate
21:12
school
21:13
and so i did and i didn't know where i
21:16
wanted to go
21:17
so john had me talk with another
21:19
economist i won't name him
21:21
um and he said go to harvard and he said
21:24
if you go to harvard you won't suffer
21:27
the slings and arrows
21:28
that you would suffer if you went
21:30
through a sort of heterodox economics
21:32
program
21:33
and i thought yeah but i have to go to i
21:35
have to do a mainstream
21:37
you know program and how am i going to
21:39
write a dissertation he said no you
21:40
write it you throw it away
21:42
and i just knew that i didn't have it in
21:44
me to
21:45
go through a program like that make that
21:47
kind of commitment
21:49
get up every day write a dissertation
21:51
that i probably
21:52
uh you know didn't believe was
21:55
really very worthwhile and then just
21:57
walk away from it all so
21:59
i applied to a number of other schools
22:01
and it came down to two for me
22:02
uh i think that the the new school
22:05
probably financially
22:06
is why it wasn't in the final two but it
22:08
was either notre dame
22:10
which deirdre mentioned earlier because
22:12
i would have studied with
22:13
uh marty wolfson or cambridge and i had
22:16
this idea that i could go to cambridge
22:18
university
22:20
i could expose myself to the rich
22:23
traditions and you know i
22:24
understood that you know keynes and joan
22:27
robinson and
22:28
mickey calder and srafa weren't walking
22:30
the halls but i figured there was enough
22:32
left of that tradition there that i
22:34
could benefit from that
22:36
and still come out with a degree from
22:38
cambridge and and maybe that would
22:40
somehow
22:40
serve me well but the reality was that
22:44
the program was a one-year talk program
22:46
is how they
22:47
referred to it four courses at the
22:49
graduate level and you write a
22:50
dissertation and you're done
22:52
and that made me nervous because i
22:54
wasn't sure i could
22:55
uh consider myself a real economist with
22:58
just four
22:58
graduate courses under my belt so anyway
23:01
i got a fellowship
23:02
and it took me to the levy economics
23:04
institute
23:05
and levy is just upstate from
23:08
manhattan and that allowed me to jump on
23:11
a train once a week
23:13
and travel down to the city and sit in
23:15
on ednell's class at the new school
23:18
and you know i've probably told this in
23:21
forums like this with
23:22
you guys because you know it's one of my
23:24
best memories and it changed the
23:26
trajectory of of my life and my own
23:28
career
23:29
i sat at the new school and i listened
23:31
to students
23:32
you know in a sort of coffee shop
23:34
cafeteria i forget what you
23:36
called it back then and i could just
23:38
hear the conversations taking place
23:40
at the tables around me and i'd never
23:42
heard anything like it it didn't happen
23:44
at cambridge
23:44
it was otherworldly people were thinking
23:47
deeply
23:48
about the world around them they were
23:50
having
23:51
philosophical conversations they were
23:53
having class conscious conversations
23:56
race con
23:57
i i i loved it and it energized me
24:01
and for me it was what i was
24:04
what economics was supposed to do was
24:06
supposed to get your juices going and
24:08
get you really thinking and challenging
24:10
uh things and so i i decided that
24:14
you know i there was so much more that i
24:16
needed to know and uh
24:18
so i ended up joining the new school and
24:21
finishing my phd there i think anwar you
24:24
were on
24:24
sabbatical and i really was only there
24:26
for one year and you were on sabbatical
24:28
that year so i didn't get an opportunity
24:30
to take your course which
24:31
i was always um you know i always regret
24:35
it not
24:35
overlapping with you then um but i
24:38
i finished i didn't suffer the slings
24:41
and arrows i came out of a
24:42
heterodox program i took a position at
24:45
the university of missouri in kansas
24:47
city
24:48
and when i joined i joined with matt
24:50
forstadter who's another
24:52
new school alum and randy ray
24:55
and a couple of years later we got fred
24:57
lee to come on board and we had this
25:00
incredible department
25:02
very intellectually diverse john henry
25:04
joined us later we had
25:06
institutionalists like jim sturgeon we
25:09
had old
25:10
labor erp people like gene wagner we had
25:14
um marxists we had
25:17
post keynesians we we were an eclectic
25:20
and we had
25:21
neoclassical economists so
25:24
we it was an incredible place to be
25:26
because somehow someway
25:29
we all managed to get along swimmingly
25:32
there was no infighting i i can't recall
25:35
a single time
25:37
when uh there was real discord among the
25:39
faculty and i think the students
25:42
we had a very large phd program at one
25:44
point i think we had 83 students in the
25:46
master's program and 60
25:48
in the phd program and we had about 12
25:50
faculty members so we were
25:52
small but we built an interdisciplinary
25:56
phd program which meant that you did
25:59
you know economics and you did a
26:01
secondary
26:02
discipline and it really meant something
26:05
uh
26:06
and so students could pair their econ
26:08
with philosophy or psychology or
26:11
political science or sociology
26:13
anthropology math whatever it was
26:16
um and you know i always just
26:19
i guess i felt like because
26:23
economists are given this preferred
26:25
status
26:26
right that you don't often hear you're
26:29
not going to hear president biden often
26:31
maybe stand up on stage and say
26:33
leading sociologists say but it's
26:35
economists what economists are telling
26:37
us what economists say
26:39
and we have this outsized voice
26:42
in the debates especially you know with
26:45
respect to policy
26:46
and i guess i always just felt a sense
26:49
of responsibility
26:51
in um the way that i approached the you
26:54
know hiring decisions and
26:56
and in the classroom and teaching that
26:58
it was important to recognize that we
26:59
were training the next generation
27:02
of people who economists who were going
27:04
to have
27:05
one day possibly uh an outsized
27:08
influence
27:09
in these debates and so um
27:12
you know i always wanted to try to
27:14
create better frameworks
27:16
more relevant frameworks um better
27:20
ways to analyze the workings of a
27:21
capitalist economy and
27:23
at the end of the day to remember why it
27:25
is that we do this work
27:27
and it's got to be about more than
27:29
elegance and
27:31
and the beauty of our our models but
27:34
the ways in which they impact and and
27:37
matter to real people so
27:40
i mean stop there.
T:
27:43
that's just wonderful thank you
27:44
stephanie uh what a great
27:46
um my still what a great um bright spot
27:51
uh and with that um gustavo it turns out
27:54
people come to the new school for not
27:56
the faculty
27:57
but for the students so um
28:01
mixed news for me but i'm very i'm not
28:04
surprised
28:05
um please go ahead
.
G:
28:09
thank you for inviting me to be part of
28:10
this uh distinguished uh pen also share
28:13
my background
28:14
and pose a question for discussion so
28:17
i'm a third year phd student in
28:19
economics at the new school
28:20
entering the academic job market this
28:22
fall
28:24
my master's degree is from the
28:25
university of sao paulo in brazil
28:28
which is a mainstream program with a
28:30
small heterodox section
28:32
and like most economic curriculums the
28:34
core courses
28:35
heavily rely on mathematical frameworks
28:38
such as the general equilibrium theory
28:40
which assumes independent profit seeking
28:43
agents who make optimal decisions across
28:45
time
28:46
theories that are presented as true
28:49
economics
28:50
and realities fitted to the textbook
28:52
framework
28:53
and not the other way around conflicts
28:56
over distribution and financial
28:58
crisis for example are not usually
29:00
addressed
29:01
for mathematical tractability and
29:03
research that does not use this math
29:05
rigor is considered
29:07
soft science or not economics
29:10
in my professional work the mismatch
29:12
between textbooks and reality was
29:15
striking so
29:16
first in class the economy was explained
29:18
with only three equations
29:20
influential economists debated economic
29:23
growth models were the only relevant
29:25
variable was
29:26
the saving rate fiscal policy had no
29:28
impact
29:29
on economic activity the labor market
29:31
was always in full employment
29:33
and monetary policy assumed money
29:35
neutrality
29:36
and the impossibility of financial
29:38
crisis
29:40
i came to the new school mostly
29:42
influenced by
29:43
my professors from the university of sao
29:46
paulo
29:46
such as laura carvalho anusco alumnus
29:50
and i came here not expecting a single
29:52
true economic approach
29:54
instead i was looking for an academic
29:55
environment such as the one that we have
29:58
here today
29:59
to discuss the relevance and
30:00
shortcomings of different
30:02
schools of thought and of course i
30:05
expect to bring those values to academia
30:07
and policy debates back in brazil
30:09
although i understand the difficulties
30:11
of being a heterodox economist
30:14
in environments dominated by mainstream
30:16
ideologists
30:18
so with this in mind i have two
30:20
questions here for the panel
30:22
first universities require professors
30:26
to publish in top economic journals but
30:29
they reject pluralism
30:31
so how does a heterodox economist follow
30:34
a relevant research agenda
30:36
and thrive in the face of the existing
30:39
uh pro
30:40
mainstream incentives and my second
30:43
question here is
30:45
to what extent should a heterodox
30:47
economist keep up with the mainstream
30:49
literature
30:50
when most mainstream economists do not
30:54
follow the heterodox literature
30:56
should heterodox economists always
30:58
develop the research in contrast
31:01
to this mainstream literature or can
31:03
they follow their own path
31:05
so again thank you all for the great
31:07
debate today and your contributions
31:16
oh thanks very much gustavo um i will
31:18
ask the panelists to keep gustavo's
31:21
questions in their mind
31:22
but right now some of the most valuable
31:25
aspect of these panels is when the
31:27
panelists
31:28
get to speak to each other we would be
31:31
doing this
31:32
much more naturally if we were all
31:33
together and i want you to know that
31:35
you're talking to over 300 people now
31:38
um they range from reporters from japan
31:40
to a high school student
31:42
so you have a ver you have imagine your
31:44
audience
31:45
and i'd like you to talk to each other
31:47
in a particular way
31:49
i would like you to and i'll ask you to
31:51
go in the order that you spoke
31:53
what is it that you like about each
31:54
other's work or
31:56
what each other just said today and
31:59
where do you respectfully disagree
32:01
and if you can respond to gustavo's
32:04
questions now or in the
32:05
q a that would be great too um we have
32:08
some time you were all
32:09
very terrific and respectful to each
32:11
other on the time
32:13
so let's let's start and mark um when
32:16
you need to jump in um please do
32:22
yeah thanks teresa i picked up on a
32:24
couple of themes uh
32:25
including themes from the questions but
32:28
uh let's hear from the panelists first
32:31
okay um i'm just going to point to anwar
32:33
since you spoke first
32:37
you have to unmute everybody
32:40
including you onward
32:46
okay well
32:49
it's such a pleasure to be on a panel
32:52
with such
32:53
interesting and literate people as you
32:55
know our profession does not always
32:57
generate that uh cohort
33:01
i i agree with daedra on
33:04
so many almost everything actually that
33:06
she said but let me just mention one
33:08
thing
33:09
it's absolutely important that austrian
33:11
economics and hayek
33:13
have been excluded i recently uh
33:16
rediscovered that connection and what i
33:18
found i gave a lecture at the new school
33:20
in the economics department on marx and
33:22
hayek and my emphasis was not
33:24
on their opposition but on their
33:25
similarity
33:27
it's astonishingly it's astonishing how
33:29
similarly they see capitalism and how it
33:31
works
33:32
and certainly marx talks about the great
33:36
wealth that capitalism has brought to
33:38
society it's
33:39
emphatic on that so the difference was
33:42
really about whether it's possible to go
33:44
beyond capitalism
33:46
and that's a relatively important
33:48
difference obviously but
33:50
anyway and i agree totally with the idea
33:53
that
33:53
economics should have uh humanity
33:56
literature human experience i want
33:59
someone else at
34:00
cambridge mass i found a book that said
34:03
that
34:03
game theory could explain shakespeare
34:06
and alas i didn't buy the book i should
34:08
have because
34:09
i thought the concept was appalling but
34:11
i should have read it
34:12
i did read part of it but i didn't buy
34:14
it
34:16
on the issue of capitalism's strong
34:19
positive
34:20
impact on humanity that's of course true
34:22
but i come
34:23
from a former colonial uh
34:26
country i was born in india and i grew
34:28
up in pakistan
34:30
and we must not forget the bitter
34:33
struggles
34:34
against colonialism that capitalism was
34:37
part of
34:38
uh in in creating but also the bitter
34:40
struggles
34:41
of labor against the conditions of
34:43
kaplan's
34:44
uh uh effort i mean china is an example
34:46
of that now
34:48
bangladesh and vietnam but it's an old
34:51
history
34:52
and of course it's a history that has
34:54
the strongest origins in manchester
34:56
in the in the uk
35:00
on stephanie's point that i wanted to
35:02
just as you mentioned the point about
35:04
john henry really
35:05
resonated with me my micro teacher was
35:08
gary becker
35:10
and he was a hell of a good teacher also
35:12
really difficult and didn't allow you to
35:14
question
35:15
things along the way so one day we're
35:18
sitting there and by the way the
35:20
important thing is he applied his
35:21
arguments to real world phenomena his
35:23
theory of marriage and
35:25
of discrimination or really dominate the
35:27
profession even on the left
35:29
but one day we were sitting there and
35:31
becker came in and he
35:33
abandoned everything he'd been saying
35:36
and showed us how to derive
35:38
stochastically the laws of demand and
35:40
supply
35:42
very simple principle i didn't see this
35:43
stochastic until later
35:45
but it was a very simple principle and i
35:47
never forgot it
35:48
i went and sat down on the steps of low
35:50
library i
35:51
wrote out the argument i added one
35:54
little thing that there has to be a
35:55
minimum income
35:57
for people i was just coming from my
35:59
development class
36:00
and i found that i could explain all of
36:03
the empirical phenomena of
36:05
microeconomics about demand and supply
36:07
elasticities and all that from the
36:09
extension of this framework
36:10
it's a chapter in my book and without
36:13
becker i would not have found it
36:16
um and just one more point which is that
36:21
and and the point there is that we have
36:22
to treat people we don't agree with that
36:26
some
36:26
people we can learn from in fact indeed
36:28
have to learn from because they don't
36:30
agree with us and how else we're going
36:31
to confront that if we don't
36:33
uh on gustavus question uh first of all
36:37
i want to take in a reverse order
36:39
heteroeconomics should follow
36:41
neoclassical economics well here's how i
36:44
do it i'm interested in a particular
36:45
topic
36:46
let's say inequality which happens to be
36:48
current interests of mine raise gender
36:50
then i look at what uh
36:54
the empirical evidence is first because
36:56
i can't judge
36:58
the models by just the models i want to
37:00
judge what they're trying to explain i'm
37:02
not intimidated by the math they have an
37:03
engineering background
37:05
so the question is what's the substance
37:08
of the argument
37:09
and that's a lesson i learned from becca
37:12
but
37:12
in the end i i have this bizarre
37:16
commitment to trying to fit it together
37:17
in a coherent framework so i have to go
37:19
back
37:20
so if i may i know i'm running on but
37:22
let's give you an example of this
37:25
i've long been interested in race class
37:28
and gender we had a whole program at the
37:29
musical for 10 or
37:30
15 years very prominent uh
37:34
women economists who've gone on to make
37:36
big names for themselves
37:39
and i thought i ran across a discipline
37:43
called econophysics
37:45
and was really about startling patterns
37:48
in economics
37:48
patterns are really couldn't be
37:50
explained so i thought okay
37:52
i will do this for race and gender and
37:54
i'm sure the patterns will be different
37:56
the pattern is
37:57
the income of workers follows
38:00
a law called an exponential law or in
38:03
physics of thermal distribution
38:05
and the data shows that everywhere go to
38:07
the irs you can find the data again and
38:09
again
38:10
but i thought okay cannot be true of
38:13
by gender or race so i had the data
38:16
and i did it and i found of course
38:18
women's incomes were lower blacks
38:20
incomes are lower than whites
38:22
but astonishingly the distribution of
38:24
income within each group
38:25
was essentially the same and that led me
38:28
to think well how could that be we
38:30
intervene in so many different ways
38:32
and i realized that what i was looking
38:33
at is outcomes generated by the market
38:36
then the question is how do you explain
38:38
it how do you explain it
38:40
coherently for within a framework and i
38:42
discovered that going back to adam
38:44
smith's
38:45
idea that labor migrates from low-wage
38:48
to high-wage areas
38:49
turns out if you put it in a framework
38:52
which is a familiar one in physics
38:54
you can generate these patterns and the
38:56
framework is very simple people call
38:57
on or can i
39:03
that you have to look at what others
39:05
have done but you don't have to simply
39:07
start there or okay
39:11
um deidra what do you like about each
39:13
other's work
39:15
i i i
39:18
like very much
39:22
um
39:26
ebony's inspiration
39:29
to help people
39:32
and to and to um follow
39:36
her own star and
39:39
in
39:43
reply to
39:46
gustavo on that i would say that
39:51
you you you should
39:54
focus as
39:58
onward does and as i do on
40:01
problems on on
40:05
peculiarities of oddnesses
40:09
of things that on their face seem
40:12
strange
40:13
and then explain them and explain them
40:17
with uh
40:18
supply and demand curves if
40:22
that seems to work or with uh the
40:24
history of all hitherto existing
40:26
societies is the history of class
40:28
struggles if that seems to work
40:31
and solve the problem and then write a
40:33
book
40:36
don't bother with the with the two top
40:40
journals that that i i
40:43
heard for a while on the
40:47
editorial um committee of the american
40:50
economic
40:55
review um when
40:59
jose jose stiglitz was the editor
41:03
and i can only stand it for a couple of
41:05
years
41:07
because practically every paper i
41:10
encountered was in my view and this is
41:13
the view of the american
41:15
statistical associate association
41:18
misusing tests of statistical
41:21
significance
41:23
and and virtually all of them were
41:25
appallingly written
41:28
and and i got tired of saying this
41:32
this paper isn't any good
41:35
don't publish it and and of course
41:39
they were all highly orthodox
41:42
so our way for forward
41:45
is is so to speak
41:49
as as as
41:53
as effingham has done
41:56
right beyond
41:59
the orthodoxy right to an audience
42:03
slightly beyond it
42:07
but what i'm not so sh
42:11
sure about in my esteemed colleagues
42:14
here
42:16
is a convention that you find in in
42:19
standard issue what i would prefer to
42:21
call samuelssonian economics not so much
42:24
neoclassical
42:25
because that also includes austrians but
42:27
okay same with sony economics and in
42:30
in marxist economics and institutional
42:32
economics and so forth
42:35
this idea that there are
42:39
terrible imperf imp
42:42
imperfect imperfections
42:47
in the in the way cute capitalism
42:51
um operates that it fails
42:55
to set satisfy
42:58
the supposed us
43:02
assumptions on which it's justified
43:06
and the problem is that practically no
43:10
one
43:10
has shown this to be true empirically
43:15
one courageous attempt in 1966
43:19
was put was by a couple of marxist
43:23
paul
43:32
they failed but they tried so i
43:35
i would urge i would urge people to
43:39
look into how close
43:43
these arguments these models that we
43:46
talk about
43:47
whether heterodex
43:50
and docs or orthodox how close they are
43:55
quantitatively speaking
43:59
actual economy thank you i'm stephanie
44:04
well i mean i think that
44:08
you know the advice that deirdre just
44:10
gave
44:11
and i'm speaking to gustavo really um
44:14
about you know finding something that
44:17
you really care about
44:19
your passion and write about that it's
44:21
very hard i couldn't write
44:23
for the purpose of you know ticking the
44:26
boxes and jumping through the hoops
44:28
for the ten process and and i know that
44:31
it's part of the it's part of the game
44:33
right as
44:34
an academic there is an expectation that
44:37
you're going to have a certain number of
44:38
publications
44:40
in order to get promotion and tenure and
44:43
here i just think it's so important that
44:46
when the decision is made you know about
44:49
which programs to apply to you know
44:52
where which department do you want to be
44:53
in
44:54
what do you want to find as your
44:55
academic home which who who do you want
44:58
for your colleagues
44:59
that's such an important part of the
45:01
consideration
45:03
that you know if you are aiming for the
45:06
so-called top
45:07
then you have an understanding of what
45:10
those expectations are i can remember
45:14
many years ago being in a in a pub
45:17
with a group of uh economists
45:20
journalists uh and others there was a
45:23
blogging conference taking place
45:25
and there was an economist there i won't
45:29
give too much away so people can't
45:30
figure out who it is but
45:32
he was at uh you know
45:35
a second tier like a very highly ranked
45:39
um but not a harvard sort of thing uh
45:42
and he had just been told that he was
45:44
being that he was being denied tenure
45:46
and he had a wife and a five-year-old
45:48
daughter
45:49
and he could not get an article in the
45:52
qje or the jel and they told him
45:54
you've got to have one in one of these
45:56
three journals or you're out
45:58
that kind of pressure and he sat sobbing
46:00
you know in a room
46:01
full of mostly other economists and
46:05
it i felt so so bad for him you know
46:08
um but in my department and it's funny
46:10
because fred lee
46:11
took on this project of the journal
46:14
rankings
46:15
and he you know theresa you know this
46:17
you know i'm sure
46:18
maybe others do as well fred did this
46:21
kind of
46:21
probably year-long research where he
46:24
redid the assessment and re-ranked the
46:28
articles
46:29
and the departments based on you know
46:31
his array of
46:32
um factors and considerations and what
46:35
do you think he found
46:36
you know it it basically inverted the
46:39
hierarchy
46:40
it inverted the hierarchy and he all of
46:42
a sudden is showing that
46:43
you know programs like yours at the new
46:45
school and ours at umkc
46:47
were really among the highest ranked
46:50
departments when you take into account
46:52
you know number of publications and so
46:53
forth you're not heavily weighting this
46:55
small number
46:56
of of publications so you know writing
46:59
you you you gotta i couldn't write i
47:01
couldn't wake up and
47:02
sit in front of a computer and write
47:04
about something that i wasn't truly
47:06
passionate
47:06
about so finding a home
47:10
and a group of colleagues who will
47:12
respect and support
47:14
your work and your research even if it's
47:17
a
47:18
far departure from what they're uniquely
47:21
interested in
47:22
but you know support you through that
47:24
process
47:25
nothing's more important because in all
47:27
likelihood you do have to jump through
47:29
those hoops
47:30
early on and then you can do what you
47:32
want after that
47:34
can i make a comment on that
47:38
i jumped through the hoops
47:42
not because i i was compromising but
47:44
because i was stupid
47:46
and and i i believed in the hoops
47:51
so i jumped through them i got the
47:54
tenure
47:55
at the
47:59
university of chicago but five years
48:02
later tiring of
48:06
uh the atmosphere in economics at
48:08
chicago
48:09
i moved to the university of iowa
48:13
uh which is not even
48:16
uh ranked you know in in what
48:19
stephanie is calling that that's that
48:23
um econ group
48:26
and i was free i was
48:30
i was i in fact formed a group
48:33
entered
48:38
disciplinary group i was the only
48:41
economist in the group
48:42
english professors professors of
48:44
hydrology and so forth
48:46
and i made an intellectual life
48:49
because i was able to i was i
48:52
and it's not because i'd been at chicago
48:55
or published a lot
48:57
it was because i was at what
49:00
stephanie is describing and i found
49:03
these people
49:04
i'm i'm deidre i'm going to interrupt
49:06
you because not because i'm rude
49:08
but i want to i want to keep up with the
49:10
audience and with our time we're going
49:12
to end
49:13
on when we said we would um mark would
49:15
you like to start the questions
49:17
yeah i i just wanted to introduce a
49:18
couple of uh broad questions
49:20
if i could that are partly inspired by
49:22
some of the audience commentary
49:24
uh one is all three of you have touched
49:27
upon things like
49:29
neglect of the object of analysis lack
49:31
of intellectual breadth
49:33
um are economists just bad social
49:35
scientists and
49:37
and if so is is the fix easy we have
49:39
history departments we have psychology
49:42
departments maybe they can tell us
49:43
something
49:44
maybe they should and then secondly we
49:46
all get caught up in ideas because we're
49:48
all
49:49
economists but when we're thinking about
49:51
the future of heterodox economics or the
49:53
future of economics we're at large
49:55
should we
49:56
should we be operating at the level of
49:58
ideas or is the problem at its core for
50:00
example
50:01
the sociology of the economics
50:03
profession
50:04
or the influence of private wealth or
50:07
something externally on
50:09
what gets funded and what research gets
50:11
done
50:13
i think it's extraordinary how orthodox
50:16
american economics is and how
50:19
hierarchical it is
50:22
this foolish talk about the top journals
50:26
if the deans required people in an
50:29
economics department
50:30
to read the work of the candidate
50:36
instead of just scoring them with a
50:39
hasty look at their cv it would
50:42
revolutionize economics
50:47
um stephanie and anwar quickly please i
50:49
want to get to these
50:50
questions i don't i mean i think the
50:52
problem mark and
50:54
we all know this is that for the most
50:56
part economists don't think of
50:57
themselves as
50:58
part of a social science no they don't
51:01
yeah
51:02
right yeah they they're for example
51:05
they scorn sociology
51:09
anwar
51:12
you're on mewtanwa
51:16
uh let me remind you that we've all
51:19
mentioned how important the history of
51:20
economic thought was in
51:22
our understanding and the whole point is
51:23
that economists were not like this
51:25
before
51:26
this is a degeneration yeah you're right
51:28
and a retreat from reality
51:31
and i always attributed to the fact that
51:35
the neoclassical framework is a
51:37
framework
51:38
that uh presents a perfect and ideal
51:42
vision of capitalism
51:43
and that's why people like hayek and
51:45
marx just rejected it from the start
51:47
because this is an ideological
51:49
construction
51:50
but it's very popular for the same
51:53
reason that the version
51:54
the church's version of uh
51:57
garden of eden was popular if it could
52:00
be enforced by a few
52:01
burning of the stakes so uh i think
52:05
from that point of view this we should
52:08
and
52:08
must be connected to other social
52:10
sciences but it does not mean
52:12
that we can arbitrarily rush together at
52:14
the new school we're always being told
52:17
it's time for interdisciplinary and you
52:19
go yay okay all of you have to be like
52:21
anthropologists wait a minute
52:22
they don't study our data they don't ask
52:24
our questions well that's not
52:26
that you have to move over and that i
52:28
reject okay
52:29
um i have a question i have a question
52:33
that's a real swerve
52:34
but um it comes up over and over in in
52:37
the chat
52:38
and i think one of the reasons why
52:39
people tuned in
52:41
um which framework orthodox
52:44
a version of orthodoxy your own
52:46
frameworks
52:48
a better addresses and understands the
52:50
climate crisis
52:52
should we use heterodox or orthodox
52:54
economics
52:56
um stephanie i'll start with you in
52:57
reverse order
52:59
well what am i going to say and why
53:03
why i you know i would point people i'm
53:06
not i always try to stay in my lane i
53:08
have my framework i have my lane
53:09
i try to respect what i don't know i'm
53:12
not a
53:13
climate or an environmental economist
53:15
but
53:16
um you know people like steve keane
53:19
steve's done
53:19
incredible work lately and i will sit in
53:22
and
53:23
sometimes listen to his online talks
53:24
where he went after nordhouse
53:26
so you know you have the orthodox uh
53:30
premier kind of orthodox example and
53:32
approach to the questions of the
53:34
application of the orthodox framework to
53:36
questions of climate change and so forth
53:38
and steve
53:40
i think steve just demolished it from a
53:43
non-orthodox
53:44
uh perspective so yeah
53:47
um i know i don't think any of us are
53:49
climate change but it's the
53:51
prevailing problem of our day um deidre
53:54
well i i i would then uh
53:58
speak up for bill nordhaus
54:03
i i'm i'm perfectly prepared to
54:06
hear out the criticisms of his argument
54:11
but i think we all agree that if you're
54:13
going to
54:15
criticize an argument you should
54:17
understand it i was
54:19
when i was a kid i was a kind of a
54:22
unscholarly marxist
54:24
um and i've read a lot of marks so you
54:27
know maybe i'm in a position to
54:30
to argue with some marxists
54:34
but it won't do and i don't think
54:38
is proposing it to just sort of sweep
54:40
aside
54:42
cost and benefit um
54:46
well let me start by saying what i said
54:49
about hayek and marks both would agree
54:51
that
54:52
uh capitalism is very efficient it's
54:55
certain and certain things that's
54:56
obviously
54:57
but its efficiency comes from profit
55:00
making and the consequences of profit
55:02
making and you can actually see
55:04
where it's not profit making like the
55:07
environment you can dump
55:08
all kinds of stuff in the river well
55:10
that's good it's efficient
55:11
and so we have to understand that this
55:13
is not an externality
55:15
it's an internality it's as internal as
55:18
the consequences of profit making on
55:20
human behavior
55:21
when i was a graduate student i was
55:23
completely
55:25
repulsed by this definition and
55:28
representation of human behavior i mean
55:30
it didn't fit my family that's for sure
55:32
any culture that i've ever heard of so i
55:34
started to study anthropology and
55:36
sociology and effort
55:37
but the gap between those two still was
55:40
huge and it took a lot of work
55:42
to make it up oh we have two
55:46
two minutes left um yeah theresa a
55:50
question that has come up that i think
55:52
might be nice to put to the panel
55:54
is what if any idea from orthodoxy would
55:57
you
55:57
retain and what if any idea from
56:00
heterodox economics however define would
56:02
you be
56:03
eager to discard
56:06
well i would be eager to i would be
56:09
eager to
56:10
discard the conflictual
56:14
bias in
56:17
among the among the left wing
56:21
i think it it drives you away
56:25
from the very the very common cases in
56:29
which
56:30
cooperation is is what's actually
56:33
happening
56:35
i'm stephanie i i don't know i'm still
56:38
noodling i want to pick
56:40
i i wanted to pick something really
56:43
smart
56:44
uh yeah i don't know about discarding
56:46
from heterodoxy i hadn't
56:48
my mind hadn't gone to that yet i was
56:50
still fixated
56:51
i can go to onward want me to put it to
56:53
anwar and let you noodle
56:55
yeah i mean some level of scarcity i
56:58
guess i would retain
57:00
i'll come back to you you get you get a
57:01
chance anwar
57:03
i think for me what i retain from
57:05
orthodox economics is the importance of
57:07
markets especially competition because
57:09
that's a theme that is central to the
57:11
classical tradition also
57:13
and secondly what i reject is a
57:16
reduction
57:17
therefore on the left of capitalism to
57:20
monopoly
57:22
i've never believed that and baran and
57:23
sweeney as as dieter said and great
57:26
work but in my opinion one of his
57:27
defects was that monopoly is too easy a
57:30
target
57:30
for you to sweep everything you have to
57:32
understand that competition bothers
57:34
real capitalists they're always worried
57:37
that any minute someone's going to
57:38
eat them and they're not wrong about
57:40
that so competition definitely
57:44
and now stephanie meg their minds work
57:48
more quickly than mine
57:49
i i guess on the orthodoxy i i keep some
57:52
uh i keep the idea of trade-offs the
57:54
importance of of
57:56
centering our thinking around the
57:57
importance of trade-offs but i'm not
57:59
i'm not committed yet on the header docs
58:01
question i'm sorry we will do this next
58:02
year
58:03
okay right right right together
58:06
together thank you all very much i would
58:10
like
58:10
to ask the panelists before we leave and
58:12
sign off to
58:13
answer the poll we are going to post
58:16
many of these remarks on the after
58:18
action website
58:20
we have a paper um on heterodox
58:23
economics on the website as well
58:25
and we will publish your questions on
58:28
the website
58:29
and then i will sort through them and
58:31
ask
58:32
that the uh that they be answered again
58:35
on the website
58:37
or a team will answer them so it's not
58:40
really over
58:40
we have um after event um
58:44
um living and the videos will also be
58:47
posted so tell your friends
58:48
thank you uh very much from the new
58:50
school and thank you my friends
58:52
who have come i'm back bye-bye thank you
58:55
everyone
58:56
yeah bye-bye see you later stephanie
58:59
take it easy but take it as we say in
59:02
chicago
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿