[Applause] [Music] [Music] whose money raised here because it is something which everybody thinks is a good idea we're all talking if we all think about how much money we have in our bank accounts what are our houses working and things like that and what the mentality we've got is which state saving for a rainy day you say for a time at your safe or unexpected event you've got the money there to spend when you need it and the holiday or about it is you're going to spend less than your income or the modern day you buy an asset that grows faster than your income unfortunate let's become more dominant but that's that's the way we think about it and this is an incredibly frustrating thing for people who work at macroeconomics and understand money which is about 13 people not quite a bit larger than that but we're trying to explain what this actually doesn't work at the national level.
and I thought I'll give a simple illustration of that to show that saving money is a great idea for individuals and disastrous for the collective why it doesn't work so just mentally to divide the you know the country into three large groups lots and lots of poor households very few rich households and the corporate sector so poor households rich households and firms going to aggregate all the money together and just pretend that each group has got say 100 billion pounds and savings costs for the poor that would be very large numbers of small bank accounts and for the rich a small number of very large bank accounts so I'm not saying there's a equal distribution of money but just imagine that seem out of money in each of those three buckets and they're all spending on each other well if you have have a hundred hundred billion pounds in your account and you spend that twice a year you're generating 200 billion pounds worth of spending and that spending as somebody else's income okay what you spend whatever you spend on if you give somebody that money something you are buying something off them your expenditure is their income and that's the thing you have to start off and thinking about at the macroeconomic level so what I'm doing here is showing that in a simple little diagram and saying here looking at expenditure so the poor families poor households are spending a hundred billion dollars or pounds a year on the rich families and a hundred billion on the firm's and I've got the rich spending the same on the poor and the firm's and the third spending the same on the other two groups and you look at that what you just down this diagonal here what I've got in red that's the money coming out of the bank accounts and that sums to 600 billion pounds a year so 300 billion pounds if money is generating 600 billion pounds per year of spending and then of course because every road obviously sums to zero that if I add the off-diagonal elements there that's income so the rich are getting a hundred billion pounds and income per year from the poor and 100 billion pounds from the firm's etc etc but everybody in the aggregate is saving zero okay noticed imagine the poor households have a campaign encouraging the to save money and the thing is you know save responsibly spend less than your income well let's say they start doing that and they decide to save five percent of their income per year which would be to ten billion pounds a year that's the time well the easiest way to do that is spend five billion a year less on the rich and fire doing in a year and less on the poor and you do that and yes you have expenditure of a hundred and ninety billion you get income of two hundred billions till you save ten that's great what's happened to the fit of firms I know I'm not going to get my sympathy for the rich household team but nonetheless because you've saved ten more the poor you necessarily generate minus five in the other two okay your decision to save money simply means existing stock of money part of it accumulates in your account and has to come from somewhere it comes out of the other bank accounts so they're not deciding to spend more than they earn they're spending more than they own because you're spending less than you own and the aggregate they must be identical okay simple little principle they say what's the total GDP now well you add up the diagonals again the negative of the diagonals here and you're down by 10 million pounds ten billion pounds a year they've made a surface of ten million ten billion but average GDP has fallen from 600 billion to five hundred and ninety billion so saving at the individual level has become a fallen income at the national level now this is what people don't get their heads around when the heap you're saving is a good idea it's good to accumulate money but you can't take in like more money than exists you can only ki make more money if somebody's creating it which is what I'm going to get onto so here's the first stage of this the savings by the poor households has increased their bank balances by ten billion pounds but it's reduced GDP by ten billion pound filled pounds per year I don't need to give you an idea of what's going to happen to your incomes in that situation okay over time I haven't taken a look at the feedback there.
but you can imagine what's going
to happen and the aggregate savings are
still zero you haven't saved any money
in fact you can't save any money in the
aggregate you can't increase the amount
of money by saving what you do is you
slow down how fast that money turns over
and you therefore reduce income
now let's say the rich households and
the firms decide to get back to balance
they've been losing five billion pounds
a year now so they decide they'll spend
five billion less but because they spend
less on each other as well they only get
halfway there so you've now got the poor
household spending 190 billion the rich
and the ferns spending a hundred and
ninety five billion the poor have still
got another surplus that next year
there's a matching deficit still on the
other two so now ten to five hundred and
eighty billion jjjp another ten to a
billion pound fall so there's an equal
fall in GDP for the increase in savings
a ten
increase in savings which of course does
not happen they're all failing to meet
their savings target system ajan now
finally the frictions up in the polls
rich and the firm and the well the poor
decide to overshoot and spend ten less
again and the firms are half there have
passed their way again once more you get
another fall so the poor have got their
surplus back again but the rich are back
and the deficits that they wanted to
avoid so let's say they decide we're
going to spend less to we're going to
save more money so they decided knock
off another ten worth and Rea we finally
get balanced we now have aggregate
savings of zero once more and GDP is
fallen by ten percent now I think that
summarizes Tory economic policy but if
you're going to go in the opposite
direction you've got to argue for doing
the opposite and saying first of all you
want them to spend turning over money
more rapidly rather than spending less
I'm leaving aside ecological issues here
obviously but that's part of it but also
if you're going to have aggregate
savings and obviously all of us do have
a desire to accumulate and net increase
in our financial assets so the question
is how do you do it if that's the
problem when you've got a fixed amount
of money how do you actually create more
save more money well the only way you
can do that is by having some other
group of creating money in the in the
economy and I just want to quickly show
you which is to illustrate what I'm
smoking about there because one thing I
found this issue is so hard to get
through to people particularly
economists okay not just the public
economists are far worse because they've
learned the theory of economics to lose
money and banks and debt completely out
of the picture and then they advise how
to manage government they go to the
economy using monetary policy which is
sounds insane that's because it is but I
you you have to be able to see the stuff
in some sort of mathematical way to
understand what they're doing so this is
a software package I've designed I
didn't write the code but I designed it
lets me build models of the economy
looking at the financial flows between
different groups using the accountant
school
double-entry bookkeeping to explain
what's going on so here I've got the
poor spending on the rich hundred pounds
hundred billion pounds each year the
poor spending on firms the rich spending
on the poor through depending on firms
the third spending on the poor the third
spinning on the rich exactly what I
explained to you a moment ago just in
text times I want to show how it
actually works when I simulate it so I
can set this up and say let's start see
what happens when we spend at that rate
and what you have is the bank about
where they come from pardon me the bank
balances remain conservative at a
hundred billion pounds each savings is
zero and GDP is six six hundred billion
now if the third poor firm's aside has
been five less on the rich and five less
on the poor their savings account
increases so you can see down goes GDP
okay and this is the sort of thinking we
need to get into economics so you
actually think this way and so well
here's let's say that the rich decide to
spend less down it goes again with the
pause the firm's decide to spend less
down you go again that is not a recipe
for a growing economy okay so that's
that's one reason I've invented this
software and I wanted to show you can
actually put what I've shown you in
verbal terms there into a mathematical
model of the economy which is the sort
of thing we need so that's what I've
just shown you in that particular
simulation there so how can you save in
the aggregate well that little table I
showed you beforehand
notice all the rows sum to zero because
I'm saying spending from here to there
it necessarily sums to zero
and when I showed you this other table
let's go back a screen here and bring it
up again
this one here all the savings sum to
zero
anything aggregate nobody can save okay
so how do you achieve savings then there
must be some group in society that's
dist saving the only way you can have an
increase in your bank accounts is if
somebody else some of the system is dis
saving all the time so the question is
who can afford to dis save not us
obviously if we all spent more than we
got back in income every
we'd go bankrupt finally a bank you'd be
hitting the credit card the bank would
reach a popular say no more money for
you and bang you're gonna go bankrupt
what about the government spending more
than it takes back in taxes and people
think this is impossible I want to show
it's been happening for hundred and
twenty years in America in a moment but
this is if you put the government in the
system and say well let's imagine as
well as I've got the 100 being spent on
each group as I showed you before hand
but I've got the government taxing 20
off the poor 20 off the rich and 20 off
the firms but then spending 30 on each
of them which means each of them can
save 10 so long as the government's
going down by minus 30 okay unless you
have that you're not going to get any
savings out of it and that's a simple
little fact no method there's no
ideology in that it's simply tracking
spending from one spot to another so the
government if the government spend 30
billion on each of those groups in tax
at 20 billion on each of them they could
each save 10 billion while the
government was dis saving 30 billion so
how does the government decide how can I
do that well the simple story is banks
and governments are two independent ways
of creating money in a market economy
the banks create money by lending out
more than they get back in repayments
they don't need reserves to lend out if
that's all the myth and I'm happy to
talk about that in question time later
but banks can do that they can lend out
more than they get back in repayments
because of a banking license which isn't
the right to do it but when they do that
they can give you a loan if you get a
loan from a bank
you do get a zero increase in your net
assets okay because when you borrow the
money let's say you're buying a house in
Bournemouth what does a house here at
cost 250,000 reasonable guess couple of
million unreasonable yes let's
compromise on a million the bank gives
you a line of a million dollars which
means they credit your account for a
million which you then spend on the give
to the to the seller of the house of
course you get a debt of a million at
the same at the same time there's no
change
the change will occur if prices modify
things over time and that's a trap by
the way but there's no change in your
net asset so you have saves zero by
taking money off a bank but if a
government creates money by paying you a
welfare check or by buying services off
you are paying you a wage that does not
come with a matching debt for you okay
the government's got to handle it but
you get something which is free of debt
when they give you that money
whoever babba they might do it and so on
and so forth so the government is
financing and buy a debt to itself now
I've made it incredibly complicated with
all sorts of rules of the desert the
Bank of England can't buy debt off the
Treasury but it can buy debt that's been
bought by somebody else off the Treasury
well duh it has the same effect over
time and people have them sell but the
governor's got to pay it back at some
stage well I want to I like answering
questions with empirical statements and
if that was true then gives anybody here
willing to regard 120 years as roughly
the long run okay this is America for
the last hundred and twenty years it's
net position noticed by all the rhetoric
and all the nonsense you hear coming out
of Washington about balancing the budget
yadda-yadda-yadda
that is the zero level there anything
above that line as a surplus think you
can tell most of the time they're below
it in fact the average is minus 2.4
percent of GDP so on average every year
the governor spent 2.4 percent more than
it's got back in taxes if you leave out
the first in the second world war its
2.3 percent ok it's not mainly war
spending it might look like it on the
graph but that they make minor increases
in the aggregate level over time now
part of the logic for that is simply
that a growing economy needs a growing
amount of money the government taxes on
the basis of income and spends on the
basis of to some extent need because the
economy is growing at about say 5
percent per annum and the money turns
over twice a year the government is
effectively forced to create half that
much every year in new money two and a
half
JPG roughly despite all the rhetoric the
mechanics perforce them into that
situation and they don't have to pay it
back because that debt is actually an
asset matching your asset if that debt
wasn't there you wouldn't have your
savings either okay and that's the
simple point that what's called modern
monetary theory has been trying to get
through to politicians and economists
and journalists as well I take a
slightly more complicated approach than
that but that's I think the key point to
get through and it's simply shown just
draw up a table showing somebody
expenditure in income and show the
aggregate has to be zero in terms of
savings and say how are you going to
save more money and that's a question
they can only answer by saying if the
government creates it now of course
that's a complete inversion of the
emphasis that the Tories and the
previous Labour government had here
anybody read the manifesto from 2015
anybody take a look at the bloody thing
four times in the first paragraph it
says if Labour government will reduce
the surface every year four times in one
paragraph the whole thing is about
reducing the deficit been increasing
we're getting back to surplus which is a
fairly the same thing as saying we're
going to drive the household sector into
deficit okay that's the impact of it now
if that does happen to you how can you
counteract that we might go and borrow
money from the gut of the banks and
speculate on rising house prices to get
house price bubbles out of it it's not a
good management at all
it's that partial thinking of thinking
like you are a household which can have
a difference in its income and
expenditure but you're part of an
overall system that can't unless you
think that way you're going to make huge
mistakes which is what the Miliband
Miliband a government did brought to
attempted government did though I was
very happy not to vote in that election
I voted about in the next one but it's
just this lack of awareness about simple
monetary dynamics we have to get that
through and get people past the belief
the government should be saving because
the government savings are you're
destroying your money that's what it
comes down to him and people will say
the government does these things then
efficiently and they're right
okay but the government's role is to
create the stock of money that we've
spent that's our role to turn that money
over and generate the GAAP
and separating those two roles makes it
much much easier to understand what the
government should do now one thing I
find remarkable is how well the Tories
made the case that the Labour
government's spending caused the crisis
in 2008 which is fascinating I mean
that's I mean I'm sure that that would
have been a great thing to George Bush
we had to go on argue that the crisis in
America was caused by the labor
government surplus in the UK and the
same in Spain in the same in Ireland etc
etc it was all a huge debt bubble ah so
stop that for a second visits it's quite
remarkable this particular chart because
what is one of what I focus on is it's
not government debt that's matters it's
private debt that's the one that's
dangerous because and also the trade
deficit those two those are the
important ones the unimportant one is
the government because the government's
deficit creates your surplus but if
you're if you're borrowing money and
going into debt that will make youth
look fine until you max out your credit
card and then the economy crashes and I
was aware of this trend in using using
largely American and Australian data but
I graph the UK data for this book and it
was stunning so the red line you're
about to see is the ratio of private
debt to GDP starting in 1880 and going
forward to 2020 roughly and the blue
line is the annual change in that debt
which is positive and negative various
times guess when it changes okay that's
all gone on in broad daylight out of
sight because with all the obsession
about government debt nobody in the
mainstream nobody in the politics nobody
in in the media focus upon this enormous
explosion and private debt that began
right after what was the name got
elected Saturday night and 82 which is
pretty much when they deregulated
building a mortgage lending here and the
bank's muscled in on building societies
and you went from having a debt level of
about four
85% of GAAP to 195 percent of GDP now
when that was expanding you had a boom
this is the bottom line here when the
root blues above the little dotted line
here that's where you've got positive
credit when the crisis hits because you
went from positive to negative credit
and the same ruff the same dynamic is
here
applies in America it applies in ireland
applies in spain that's what caused the
crisis and credit is actually driving
the ups and downs of the economy so what
I've done here I've taken the annual
change in private did the blue line you
saw in the previous graph
I'm just graphing that small bit of the
data now and graphing the unemployment
rate with four percent up here and
twelve percent down here just to show
how strongly correlated there are so the
burns and slumps won't cause what the
Labour government was doing all the all
the Tories for that matter but they've
certainly made it worse since the crisis
it's changes in credit and the same
thing unfortunately people say how
irresponsible and how hopeless the
government is at spending money and
doing things no argument are the banks
any better what did the ballot what did
the bench give you money to do to gamble
on a house prices that's the red line
there is a level of household debt from
1965 to 1980 never book more than 30
percent of GDP after the deregulation of
lending for mortgages bang it goes from
30 percent of GDP to 95 percent and up
go house prices in the process now again
it's a very simple relationship between
credit and house prices you think about
the demand for the monetary demand for
houses it's the annual change in
mortgage debt new mortgages or what buy
houses so they like all new mortgages
mortgage credit and if you want to work
out how many prices can be bought for
that amount of money then you divide
that new more those new mortgages by the
price level so you get a link between
new mortgages and the price level either
for the link between changing new
mortgages and change in the price level
and that's what's making housing
unaffordable and we take a look at the
relationship according to conventional
economic theories don't they have any
there supposed to be no relationship
there at all can you spot a relationship
you can out there most economists they
don't even look at this data it's
outside their mindset this is like
showing me showing us to a bunch of
mainstream economists is like Copernicus
showing of Newton showing gravity to
Ptolemaic astronomers they don't know
what it is plays no role in their model
and that's why we got caught in this
trap now the reason that we've had such
a crash now whereas we didn't have a
crash on this scale and previous decades
is because to turn over the demand comes
from two sources ultimately demand of
can turn over existing money plus new
money being created by the banking
sector that's the sum of demand and if
you have a low level of private debt
then big changes in credit aren't all
that important if you go back to when
you had a 50% of GDP debt level it
didn't particularly matter so if you had
an economy with a hundred billion say a
trillion dollars worth of turnover for a
year growing at 10% per annum which is
pretty much the rate of money that the
GDP was growing back in the 60s and 70s
and you have private debt 50 percent of
GDP growing at 20% per annum so it's
quite twice as fast as the economy
itself is expanding you get an extra 100
billion dollars or pounds worth of
demand from credit see total demand of
the economy is 600 billion now if you go
forward one year and GDP continues
growing at the same rate so it's no 1.1
trillion and debt slows down to only
growing at the same rate as GDP ten
percent ten percent of 600 billion is
another sixty billion dollars and your
total demand has gone up by 60 billion
you've still got growing demand even
though credit slowed down now when you
get to the level we are now when you
have debt being twice GDP so the debt
levels two hundred two thousand billion
dollars which is again roughly the ratio
that the UK found itself in in 2008 and
that's growing a 20% per annum and
credits adding four hundred billion
pounds worth of demand every year which
is huge so you look I've got a booming
economy this is think a Celtic Tiger
this is the Irish economy in that sense
thinking a stirring
well now if next year the GDP still
grows at the same rate so 1.1 trillion
dollars in turnover existing money and
the growth of debt slows to 10 percent
per annum ten percent of two point four
trillion to what you've got to is one
point three four trillion dollars you've
actually had a 16 billion dollar drop in
demand
so simply stabilizing the debt level can
cause a fallen total demand and that's
why it comes out of the blue that's why
it knocks you so badly so that's the
situation we've got ourselves trapped in
now I've got such a high level of
private debt you're not going to get
much credit demand and therefore demand
is sluggish then the economy grows
slowly which is what's been happening
for the last 10 years and globally this
book actually shouldn't be sort of can
we avoid or where can we avoid would
have been a better start because
countries like the UK and the USA that
have been through this crisis aren't
about to have another one because you've
got to jump off a cliff to break your
legs
effectively jumping off the steps not so
dangerous so because you've got such a
high level of debt you haven't got a
high level of credit anymore after the
crisis and therefore the fallen demand
is going to be from a not particularly
high level to a low level whereas
countries that borrowed their way
through the crisis like Canada Australia
China when they slow down they're
jumping off a cliff so they're the ones
which are going to see a fall so I broke
the world into two groups I call
countries like the UK the walking dead
of debt okay we've already had the
crisis in order being zombified you
can't party that much when you're a
zombie so there's not a great deal of
demand in those economies and they're
going to fluctuate up and down in and
out of booms and slumps but not
particularly big booms and not
particularly deep slumps but the ones
that they're going to have a real slump
are the ones that borrowed their way
through the crisis back in 2008 China
was the obvious major candidate that
this special factors about China of
course Canada this is not an order of
size of G repaying South Korea Australia
Belgium Hong Kong Singapore Norway
Sweden Ireland again if you can trust
the numbers and France and the other
ones are the ones who've already had the
crisis like Japan the USA UK Spain
Portugal and Greece then are going to
have another one so this
a little chart here which is part of the
part of the book shows debt as a
percentage of private debt as a
percentage of GDP along here and credit
as a as a percentage of GDP up here zero
and below that's we've got a slump going
on above you've got credit adding to
demand the danger zone is up here we're
credits adding more than 10% of GDP per
per annum to demand and those are all
the countries that I was data fine as
being in that zone where they're likely
to have a crisis like Japan had and the
US and the UK and Portugal and Spain and
so on so that's the situation we're in
let's have some chat questions thank you
[Music]
//////
27:00
現在のキーンは債務対GDP比を重視しない。
それは財政出動の少なさとして認識される。
////////
[拍手] [音楽] [音楽]ここで集められたお金は、誰もが考えていることなので、銀行口座にどれだけのお金があるかを考えれば、私たち全員が話しているのは良い考えです。そのように、そして私たちが持っている精神は、あなたが安全なまたは予期しないイベントで一時的に言う雨の日のためにどの州を節約するかですあなたはそれを必要とするときに使うお金を持っていますそして休日またはそれについてはあなたです収入よりも少ないお金を使うか、収入よりも速く成長する資産を購入する現代では、残念ながら支配的になりましょう。しかし、それは私たちの考え方であり、これはマクロ経済学で働く人々にとって非常に苛立たしいことです。約13人のお金を理解しますが、それよりもそれほど大きくはありませんが、私たちはこれが実際に国レベルで機能しないことを説明しようとしています。
お金を節約することは個人にとっては素晴らしいアイデアであり、集団にとっては悲惨なことであり、なぜそれがうまくいかないのかを示すために、その簡単な例を挙げようと思いました。貧しい家庭がたくさんある裕福な家庭や企業部門が非常に少ないので貧しい家庭裕福な家庭や企業はすべてのお金を集めて、各グループが1000億ポンドと非常に多くの貧しい人々のための貯蓄費用を持っているふりをします小さな銀行口座の数と非常に大きな銀行口座の数が少ないので、お金が均等に分配されているとは言いませんが、これら3つのバケットのそれぞれでお金が不足しているように見えると想像してみてください。アカウントに1,000億ポンドがあり、それを年に2回費やすと、2,000億ポンド相当の支出が発生し、他の誰かの収入としての支出は、あなたが何を費やしても大丈夫です。あなたが誰かにそのお金を与えるなら、あなたは彼らから何かを買っていますあなたの支出は彼らの収入ですそしてそれはあなたがマクロ経済レベルで始めて考えなければならないことですそれで私がここでしていることはそれを簡単な小さな図で示していますそして、ここで支出を見て、貧しい家庭の貧しい家庭は、裕福な家庭に年間1,000億ドルまたはポンドを費やし、会社に1,000億ドルを費やしていると言います。私は、貧しい人々と会社に同じように豊かな支出をしています。sと3番目のグループが他の2つのグループに同じ金額を費やしているので、この対角線のすぐ下にあるものを見てください。私が赤字で示しているのは、銀行口座から出てくるお金で、合計で年間6,000億ポンドになります。お金が年間6000億ポンドの支出を生み出している場合、3000億ポンド、そしてもちろん、すべての道路の合計が明らかにゼロになるため、非対角要素を追加すると収入が得られるため、金持ちは年間1,000億ポンドの収入を得ています貧しい人々から、会社などから1,000億ポンドが節約されていますが、全体としては誰もがゼロを節約しています。貧しい家庭がお金を節約することを奨励するキャンペーンを行っていることを想像してみてください。彼らはそれを始め、年間収入の5%を節約することに決めたと言います。これは年間100億ポンドになります。これは、金持ちと火事に費やす費用を年間50億ドル減らすのが最も簡単な方法です。 1年以内に貧しい人々にそれをしますそしてあなたはそうしますそしてあなたは1000億の支出を持っていますあなたが10を救うまであなたは2000億の収入を得ますそれは私が行かないことを知っている会社の健康に起こったことは素晴らしいです裕福な家計チームに同情するためですが、それでもなお、貧しい人々をさらに10人節約したので、他の2つでマイナス5を生成する必要があります。お金を節約するという決定は、単に既存のお金の一部がアカウントに蓄積され、どこかから来るので、他の銀行口座から出てくるので、あなたが所有しているよりも少ないお金を使っているので、彼らが稼いでいるよりも多く使うことを決めないでください。あなたが所有しているよりも少ないお金を使っているので、彼らは同じでなければなりません。ここでも対角線の負の値であり、年間1,000万ポンド100億ポンド減少し、表面は1,000万100億になりましたが、平均GDPは6,000億から590億に減少したため、個人レベルは全国レベルで収入が減少している今、これはあなたが貯蓄しているヒープが良い考えであるときに人々が頭を悩ませないものですお金を貯めるのは良いことですがあなたはより多くのお金のように取り入れることはできません誰かがいる場合にのみ、より多くのお金を稼ぐことができます。これを作成するので、これが最初の段階です。貧しい世帯による貯蓄によって銀行の残高が100億ポンド増加しましたが、GDPは年間100億ポンド減少しました。その状況であなたの収入に何が起こるかについてあなたに考えを与える必要はありません。私はそこでのフィードバックを見ていません。
年間GDPの10%以上を需要に追加しているクレジットを再クレジットします。これらはすべて、日本、米国、英国、ポルトガルのように危機に瀕している可能性が高いゾーンにいると私がデータ的に問題がなかった国です。とスペインなどそういう状況ですチャットで質問させていただきますありがとうございます【音楽】/// / / / ///// / JPK9 +ビニールの画像スティーブ・キーン:別の金融を避けられますか?危機?25,151回放送•2018/06/06311 14共有的オルダニー労働党3月22日、ボーンマス労働党は、2008年の金融危機を予測した数少ない経済学者の1人である世界的に有名な経済学者であるスティーブキーン教授とのメンバー会議を主催しました。90さらにのコメントmecom公開コメントを入力... Ray Maritz Ray Maritz 2年前テーブルには、貧しい人々の貯蓄を相殺するためのお金の印刷機がありません。正しいGDP数に到達するために、それを金持ちの列に追加します。2 daydreams4rockdaydreams4rock2年前スティーブの理論が真実であることを証明するために使用される基本的な数学を理解できない人々による驚くべき量の虐待。私たちは政府の人々が支出と債務を理解する必要があります。2 RCPanzerタンクRCPanzerタンク2年前スティーブ最高の状態で!7 klobasa007007 2年前短い答え:いいえ!長い答え:絶対にありません!1マークカルピネッリ2年前あなたは素晴らしいスティーブです、おそらくノーベル賞に値します、すべてが洋ナシ型になったら、彼らはすべてあなたのアドバイスを探しに来ます、混乱を整理するためにオンスに戻ってください、アデレードの大ファン7アダムチャイルズ2年前スティーブ・キーンは、ビットコインが進歩的な経済モデルのどこにあるのかを尋ねることができます。これを主張する人は数人いるようですが、彼らはお金を稼いだので興奮しすぎています。この限定された分散型ビットコインマイニングの目的が実際にはお金の創出であることがわかりません。ビットコインの作成が制限されている場合、それは価値を維持する可能性がありますが、それが国全体でどのように機能する可能性がありますか。私はビットコインのリバータリアンの何人かを考えずにはいられません、銀行家の批判は実際にはかなり偽物です。1ジェイソンジョンソン2年前10セント硬貨を保存しないでください、あなたが作るすべてを吹き飛ばしてください!私はアメリカのために得たすべてのccを最大限に活用したいです!!!!! 私はこの男が大好きです1RobertMOdell 2年前このビデオはどういう意味ですか?現在のバブルの中での住宅は危機です。価格が通常に戻るまで、それは危機にとどまります。2エイドリアンI2年前華麗なミスターキーン!この講演もありがとうございました!1ローレンスチュー2年前私は、生産者と消費者が同様に、住宅、教育、株式、債券などに投資するために貯蓄に依存するのではなく、借入(別名債務)に依存するため、景気循環は定期的に(または必然的に)一巡すると思いますお金を稼ぐの。私が間違っている場合は私を訂正してください。Jetee Phillips 2年前(編集編集)この男は、通常のフォロワーエコノミストや中央銀行家よりもはるかに多くのことを知っています。。別の財政危機の可能性は100パーセントです。現代のサイクル(1800年以降)の期間は18年で、次の危機は2025年になります。この不況は4年続きます。このリセットは保証されており、明らかに必要です。3 sophrapsune 2年前なぜこれらの分析カテゴリーは有効であり、経済的現実に関連しているのですか?これはケインズ経済学以外はどうですか、今80歳?1よそ2年前政府債務を完全に割り引くことはできないと思います。実際、私は総債務があなたにもっと正確な絵を与えるだろうと思います。政府が引き締まると、それが社会的プログラムであろうと、あらゆる支出であろうと、それは国内総生産に影響を及ぼします。1月1日ArieGutter2年前MrKeen。富の生産または創造(農業、鉱業、製造)は、モデルのどこで機能しますか。redfox435cat 2年前これが米国で当てはまる唯一の理由は、生産産業の減少によるものです。鉱業、農業、原材料製造、ガラス、鉄鋼、鉛、アルミニウム、プラスチック)はすべて削減され、ほとんど排除されて海外に送られました。これらの産業は、堅実な取引可能な資産を導入することによって富を生み出します。3 Yoso 2年前過剰な債務は、労働者階級が2倍懸命に働き、再び半分長く働くことによって解決されます。それ以外の方法で解決できることに騙されないでください。Baron von Limbourgh 2年前スティーブは伝説です1スティーブンシャープ2年前スティーブは2015年に投票しませんでした。DifferentialTim2年前(編集者)私はスティーブキーンが好きで、彼のビデオを見て好きです-彼は少し過激で私は彼が彼の思考において少し「社会主義者」であると思います、そして多分個人主義(リベラル、保守的)は彼を怖がらせます(確かではありません)私自身の決定を下し、数ヶ月後に決定を下すために委員会やそのすべてのナンセンスを要求しないでください!。米国でのGFCの墜落から私が学んだことの一つは、生き残ったのはCASHを持っていた会社だけだったということです。すべての資産(富?)が墜落したため、大企業は全滅しました。ここで、キーン氏が個人のために貯蓄することは必ずしも良いことではない/必ずしも良いことではないと言っていることに対処しましょう。ギブアンドテイクの動きは理にかなっていますが、労働者階級の人がいくらかの現金を節約した場合、彼はドールを必要とする可能性が低くなります。はは。また、誰かが節約するときはいつでも、彼らは学び、多額のお金を失い、-5の費用がかかる福祉サービス/警察に負担をかけるギャンブルの電気ショック療法に対してより敏感になる傾向があります。はい、麻薬、飲酒、ギャンブルの「楽しい」世界での仕事は落ちますが、それは悪いことです。日本はそのような「規律のある」人々と非常にうまくやっているようであり、それらの怠惰な人々は仕事を得る可能性が高くなり、今ではより多くの税金がそれを和らげるのに役立ちます-5。OMOと私は、2018年7月に住宅市場に過度にさらされている人々に、ポジティブを見る時間が過ぎ、スティーブ・キーンがこれについて強く警告し、彼が教授なので、彼の警告を非常に真剣に受け止め、他のすべての資格のある/賢い人々だけでなく、すべての警告が今や大規模な問題/損失などになっています... 1 ReginaldMorton2年前なんてMuthafxckinビデオ..... !!!! !!書き00:00 [拍手] 00:02 [音楽] 00:37 [音楽] 00:42 00:46だからここでお金を稼いだのは、誰もが思うことです00:48みんなが話しているのはいい考えです私たち全員00:49は、00:51にいくらのお金があるかを考えます。私たちの銀行口座は、私たちの家は何ですか00:53は機能していて、そのようなことは何ですか。
だから私は25:34を2つのグループに分けました私は英国のような25:36の国を25:39の借金で死んでいると呼びますあなたが25:45のゾンビであるとき、それだけパーティーをするので、それらの経済では25:47の需要はそれほど多くなく、25:49は上下に変動し、25:51はブームとスランプから外れますが25:52の特に大きなブームではなく、25:54の特に深いスランプではありませんが、25:56で実際のスランプが発生するのは、2008年の危機で25:58を借りたものです。中国26:01は、26:03この26:05コースの中国に関する特別な要因カナダこれは26:07サイズのGの返済韓国オーストラリア26:10ベルギー香港シンガポールノルウェー26:13スウェーデンアイルランド26:16の数字を信頼できれば、フランスと他の26:19の数字は、日本、アメリカ、イギリス、スペインの26:24ポルトガル、ギリシャのようにすでに26:21の危機に直面しているものです。 26:25までは別のものがあるので、本の26:29の部分の一部であるこの26:28の小さなチャートは、ここに沿ってGDPの26:35パーセントとして民間債務の26:32パーセントとして債務を示しています。クレジット26:38をGDPのパーセンテージとしてここでゼロ26:41以下にすると、26:43にスランプが発生し、クレジットを26:46に追加して、危険ゾーンがここにあることを要求します。需要に年間26:51あたりGDPの10%以上を追加する26:49クレジットであり、それらはすべて26:53であり、26:55がそのゾーンにいる可能性が高い26:55としてデータが良好だった国です。 57日本が持っていたような危機を抱えていることと26:59米国と英国、ポルトガルとスペイン、27:02など、27:05の状況です。チャットで質問してみましょう。ありがとうございます。27:27 [音楽]次の蛍光36:14再生中スティーブキーン: People'sQEと債務ジュビリーMoneyWeek6.2万回放送4年前で次の金融危機を回避する
//////
JP
検索
9+
アバターの画像
Steve Keen: Can we avoid another financial crisis?
25,151 回視聴•2018/06/06
311
14
共有
保存
Alderney Labour
On the 22nd March Bournemouth Labour Party hosted their members’ meeting with world renowned economist, Professor Steve Keen, one of the few economists to predict the 2008 financial crisis.
90 件のコメント
me com
公開コメントを入力...
Ray Maritz
Ray Maritz
2 年前
The table is missing the money printing machine to offset the savings of the poor, adding it to the columns of the rich in order to arrive at the correct GDP number.
2
daydreams4rock
daydreams4rock
2 年前
Amazing the amount of abuse by those who cannot understand the basic maths used to prove Steve's theory as true. We need people in the government to understand spending and debt.
2
RCPanzer Tank
RCPanzer Tank
2 年前
Steve at his best!
7
klobasa007007
2 年前
Short answer: NO!
Long answer:
Definitely NO!
1
Mark Carpinelli
2 年前
You are brilliant steve, prob deserve a nobel, once it all goes pear shaped they will all come looking for your advice, come back to oz to sort out the mess please, big fan in adelaide
7
Adam Childs
2 年前
Steve keen could i ask you wether bitcoin has any place in a progressive economic model. There seems to be a a few people claiming this but are they just over excited because they have made money. I can't see the purpose of this limited decentralised bitcoin mining which is actually money creation. If the creation of bitcoin is limited it may preserve value but how can that possibly work for a country as a whole . I can't help thinking some of the bitcoin libertarians, critism of the bankers is actually quite fake.
1
jason johnson
2 年前
Don't save a dime, blow everything u make!! I'm ganna max out every cc I got for the good of America!!!!! I love this guy
1
RobertMOdell
2 年前
What does this video even mean? Housing in it's current bubble IS a crisis. Until prices return back to normal, it will remain in a crisis.
2
Adrian I
2 年前
brilliant mr Keen! thank you for this lecture too!
1
Lawrence Chew
2 年前
I think economic cycles regularly (or inevitably ) come full circles because producers and consumers alike depend less on savings and more on borrowings (a.k.a. debts) to invest in housing, education, stocks, bonds, etc in the hope of making money. Please correct me if I am wrong.
Jetee Phillips
2 年前(編集済み)
This man knows much more than usual follower economists & central bankers. . The chance of another fiscal crisis is 100 percent. Modern cycles (since 1800) are of 18 years duration, and the next crisis will be in 2025 - this downturn will last 4 years. This reset is guaranteed & is clearly necessary.
3
sophrapsune
2 年前
Why are these analytic categories valid and relevant to economic reality?
How is this anything other than Keynesian economics, now 80 years old?
1
Yoso
2 年前
I don’t think you can just completely discount government debt. In fact, I think total debt would give you a more accurate picture. When the gov tightens, be it social programs, any spending, it will impact gdp.
1
Jan Arie Gutter
2 年前
Mr Keen. Where does production or creation of wealth ( agriculture, mining, manufacturing) come into play in your model.
redfox435cat
2 年前
The only reason this is true in the US is because of the reduction in production industries. Mining, farming, raw material manufacturing, Glass, steel, lead, aluminum, plastics) have all been reduced some almost eliminated and sent overseas. These industries create wealth by introducing solid tradable assets.
3
Yoso
2 年前
Excess debt is resolved by the working class working twice as hard and half again longer. Don’t be fooled that it can be resolved otherwise.
Baron von Limbourgh
2 年前
Steve is a legend
1
Stephen Sharp
2 年前
Steve didn't vote in 2015.
DifferentialTim
2 年前(編集済み)
I like Steve Keen and have seen his videos and like them - he a little radical and i do think he is a little "socialist" in his thinking and maybe individualism (liberal, conservative) frightens him (not sure) haha and they prefer everyone combining their money and working for the common good .hmm- i prefer to be individual and make my own decisions and dont require committees and all that nonsense to make a decision months later!.
The one thing i learnt from the GFC crash in the US, is the only companies that survived were the ones that had CASH. All the properties (wealth?) crashed so the biggest companies were wiped out. Now lets deal with what Mr Keen is saying that saving for individuals is not/not always a good thing. The movement of give and take makes sense BUT, if a working class person has saved some cash it less likely he will require the dole which means less loss at the govt/rich level that he illustrates as losing -5.. so it balances out haha. ALSO anytime someone saves, they LEARN and tend to be more responsive on gambling ect that loses large sums of money and puts a load on the welfare services/police that cost that -5 so much. YES the jobs in the "fun" world of drugs, drinking, gambling will drop off but is that a bad thing. Japan seems to get on very well with such "discipline" people and those lazy people will be more likely to get a job and now more tax dollars helping to relieve that -5 . OMO and i recommend people overly exposed to the housing market now JUL2018 to really think of what will happen to them IF a crash/downturn occurs as the time of looking at the positives have now passed and Steve Keen warns strongly of this and he is a professor so you better take his warning very seriously and all other qualified/smart people as well as they all warning now massive problems/losses ect...
1
Reginald Morton
2 年前
What a Muthafxckin video.....!!!!!
文字起こし
00:00
[Applause]
00:02
[Music]
00:37
[Music]
00:42
whose money raised here because it is
00:46
something which everybody thinks is a
00:48
good idea we're all talking if we all
00:49
think about how much money we have in
00:51
our bank accounts what are our houses
00:53
working and things like that and what
00:55
the mentality we've got is which state
00:57
saving for a rainy day you say for a
00:59
time at your safe or unexpected event
01:01
you've got the money there to spend when
01:03
you need it and the holiday or about it
01:04
is you're going to spend less than your
01:06
income or the modern day you buy an
01:08
asset that grows faster than your income
01:10
unfortunate let's become more dominant
01:12
but that's that's the way we think about
01:14
it and this is an incredibly frustrating
01:17
thing for people who work at
01:19
macroeconomics and understand money
01:20
which is about 13 people not quite a bit
01:23
larger than that but we're trying to
01:26
explain what this actually doesn't work
01:27
at the national level and I thought I'll
01:29
give a simple illustration of that to
01:31
show that saving money is a great idea
01:33
for individuals and disastrous for the
01:35
collective why it doesn't work
01:37
so just mentally to divide the you know
01:41
the country into three large groups lots
01:43
and lots of poor households very few
01:45
rich households and the corporate sector
01:47
so poor households rich households and
01:49
firms going to aggregate all the money
01:51
together and just pretend that each
01:53
group has got say 100 billion pounds and
01:55
savings costs for the poor that would be
01:57
very large numbers of small bank
01:59
accounts and for the rich a small number
02:01
of very large bank accounts so I'm not
02:03
saying there's a equal distribution of
02:05
money but just imagine that seem out of
02:06
money in each of those three buckets and
02:09
they're all spending on each other
02:10
well if you have
02:12
have a hundred hundred billion pounds in
02:14
your account and you spend that twice a
02:16
year you're generating 200 billion
02:19
pounds worth of spending and that
02:21
spending as somebody else's income okay
02:23
what you spend whatever you spend on if
02:25
you give somebody that money something
02:27
you are buying something off them your
02:29
expenditure is their income and that's
02:32
the thing you have to start off and
02:33
thinking about at the macroeconomic
02:34
level so what I'm doing here is showing
02:36
that in a simple little diagram and
02:38
saying here looking at expenditure so
02:40
the poor families poor households are
02:43
spending a hundred billion dollars or
02:46
pounds a year on the rich families and a
02:48
hundred billion on the firm's and I've
02:50
got the rich spending the same on the
02:52
poor and the firm's and the third
02:54
spending the same on the other two
02:55
groups and you look at that what you
02:58
just down this diagonal here what I've
03:00
got in red that's the money coming out
03:02
of the bank accounts and that sums to
03:04
600 billion pounds a year so 300 billion
03:07
pounds if money is generating 600
03:10
billion pounds per year of spending and
03:13
then of course because every road
03:15
obviously sums to zero that if I add the
03:18
off-diagonal elements there that's
03:20
income so the rich are getting a hundred
03:23
billion pounds and income per year from
03:25
the poor and 100 billion pounds from the
03:27
firm's etc etc but everybody in the
03:30
aggregate is saving zero okay noticed
03:33
imagine the poor households have a
03:35
campaign encouraging the to save money
03:37
and the thing is you know save
03:39
responsibly spend less than your income
03:41
well let's say they start doing that and
03:44
they decide to save five percent of
03:45
their income per year which would be to
03:48
ten billion pounds a year that's the
03:50
time well the easiest way to do that is
03:52
spend five billion a year less on the
03:54
rich and fire doing in a year and less
03:57
on the poor and you do that and yes you
04:00
have expenditure of a hundred and ninety
04:01
billion you get income of two hundred
04:04
billions till you save ten that's great
04:07
what's happened to the fit of firms I
04:09
know I'm not going to get my sympathy
04:10
for the rich household team but
04:12
nonetheless because you've saved ten
04:14
more the poor you necessarily generate
04:18
minus five in the other two okay your
04:23
decision to save money simply means
04:25
existing stock of money part of it
04:27
accumulates in your account and has to
04:29
come from somewhere it comes out of the
04:30
other bank accounts so they're not
04:32
deciding to spend more than they earn
04:34
they're spending more than they own
04:36
because you're spending less than you
04:37
own and the aggregate they must be
04:39
identical okay simple little principle
04:42
they say what's the total GDP now well
04:45
you add up the diagonals again the
04:47
negative of the diagonals here and
04:49
you're down by 10 million pounds ten
04:51
billion pounds a year they've made a
04:53
surface of ten million ten billion but
04:55
average GDP has fallen from 600 billion
04:58
to five hundred and ninety billion so
05:01
saving at the individual level has
05:02
become a fallen income at the national
05:05
level now this is what people don't get
05:07
their heads around when the heap you're
05:09
saving is a good idea it's good to
05:11
accumulate money but you can't take in
05:13
like more money than exists you can only
05:16
ki make more money if somebody's
05:18
creating it which is what I'm going to
05:20
get onto so here's the first stage of
05:22
this the savings by the poor households
05:25
has increased their bank balances by ten
05:27
billion pounds but it's reduced GDP by
05:30
ten billion pound filled pounds per year
05:32
I don't need to give you an idea of
05:35
what's going to happen to your incomes
05:36
in that situation okay over time I
05:38
haven't taken a look at the feedback
05:39
there but you can imagine what's going
05:40
to happen and the aggregate savings are
05:42
still zero you haven't saved any money
05:46
in fact you can't save any money in the
05:49
aggregate you can't increase the amount
05:53
of money by saving what you do is you
05:54
slow down how fast that money turns over
05:56
and you therefore reduce income
05:59
now let's say the rich households and
06:01
the firms decide to get back to balance
06:03
they've been losing five billion pounds
06:06
a year now so they decide they'll spend
06:07
five billion less but because they spend
06:10
less on each other as well they only get
06:13
halfway there so you've now got the poor
06:16
household spending 190 billion the rich
06:18
and the ferns spending a hundred and
06:19
ninety five billion the poor have still
06:21
got another surplus that next year
06:23
there's a matching deficit still on the
06:26
other two so now ten to five hundred and
06:29
eighty billion jjjp another ten to a
06:32
billion pound fall so there's an equal
06:35
fall in GDP for the increase in savings
06:38
a ten
06:38
increase in savings which of course does
06:40
not happen they're all failing to meet
06:44
their savings target system ajan now
06:46
finally the frictions up in the polls
06:48
rich and the firm and the well the poor
06:52
decide to overshoot and spend ten less
06:54
again and the firms are half there have
06:56
passed their way again once more you get
06:59
another fall so the poor have got their
07:03
surplus back again but the rich are back
07:05
and the deficits that they wanted to
07:06
avoid so let's say they decide we're
07:08
going to spend less to we're going to
07:10
save more money so they decided knock
07:12
off another ten worth and Rea we finally
07:16
get balanced we now have aggregate
07:19
savings of zero once more and GDP is
07:21
fallen by ten percent now I think that
07:24
summarizes Tory economic policy but if
07:28
you're going to go in the opposite
07:29
direction you've got to argue for doing
07:31
the opposite and saying first of all you
07:35
want them to spend turning over money
07:37
more rapidly rather than spending less
07:40
I'm leaving aside ecological issues here
07:42
obviously but that's part of it but also
07:45
if you're going to have aggregate
07:46
savings and obviously all of us do have
07:49
a desire to accumulate and net increase
07:52
in our financial assets so the question
07:55
is how do you do it if that's the
07:57
problem when you've got a fixed amount
07:58
of money how do you actually create more
08:01
save more money well the only way you
08:03
can do that is by having some other
08:06
group of creating money in the in the
08:08
economy and I just want to quickly show
08:09
you which is to illustrate what I'm
08:10
smoking about there because one thing I
08:13
found this issue is so hard to get
08:16
through to people particularly
08:17
economists okay not just the public
08:19
economists are far worse because they've
08:21
learned the theory of economics to lose
08:23
money and banks and debt completely out
08:25
of the picture and then they advise how
08:27
to manage government they go to the
08:28
economy using monetary policy which is
08:31
sounds insane that's because it is but I
08:33
you you have to be able to see the stuff
08:36
in some sort of mathematical way to
08:38
understand what they're doing so this is
08:39
a software package I've designed I
08:41
didn't write the code but I designed it
08:43
lets me build models of the economy
08:45
looking at the financial flows between
08:47
different groups using the accountant
08:49
school
08:49
double-entry bookkeeping to explain
08:51
what's going on so here I've got the
08:54
poor spending on the rich hundred pounds
08:56
hundred billion pounds each year the
08:58
poor spending on firms the rich spending
09:01
on the poor through depending on firms
09:02
the third spending on the poor the third
09:05
spinning on the rich exactly what I
09:07
explained to you a moment ago just in
09:09
text times I want to show how it
09:10
actually works when I simulate it so I
09:13
can set this up and say let's start see
09:15
what happens when we spend at that rate
09:17
and what you have is the bank about
09:19
where they come from pardon me the bank
09:21
balances remain conservative at a
09:23
hundred billion pounds each savings is
09:26
zero and GDP is six six hundred billion
09:28
now if the third poor firm's aside has
09:31
been five less on the rich and five less
09:33
on the poor their savings account
09:36
increases so you can see down goes GDP
09:39
okay and this is the sort of thinking we
09:42
need to get into economics so you
09:44
actually think this way and so well
09:45
here's let's say that the rich decide to
09:48
spend less down it goes again with the
09:51
pause the firm's decide to spend less
09:53
down you go again that is not a recipe
09:56
for a growing economy okay so that's
09:59
that's one reason I've invented this
10:01
software and I wanted to show you can
10:03
actually put what I've shown you in
10:04
verbal terms there into a mathematical
10:07
model of the economy which is the sort
10:09
of thing we need so that's what I've
10:10
just shown you in that particular
10:12
simulation there so how can you save in
10:16
the aggregate well that little table I
10:17
showed you beforehand
10:19
notice all the rows sum to zero because
10:21
I'm saying spending from here to there
10:23
it necessarily sums to zero
10:26
and when I showed you this other table
10:27
let's go back a screen here and bring it
10:30
up again
10:30
this one here all the savings sum to
10:34
zero
10:34
anything aggregate nobody can save okay
10:40
so how do you achieve savings then there
10:43
must be some group in society that's
10:45
dist saving the only way you can have an
10:49
increase in your bank accounts is if
10:51
somebody else some of the system is dis
10:53
saving all the time so the question is
10:55
who can afford to dis save not us
10:58
obviously if we all spent more than we
11:00
got back in income every
11:01
we'd go bankrupt finally a bank you'd be
11:04
hitting the credit card the bank would
11:06
reach a popular say no more money for
11:08
you and bang you're gonna go bankrupt
11:12
what about the government spending more
11:14
than it takes back in taxes and people
11:16
think this is impossible I want to show
11:18
it's been happening for hundred and
11:19
twenty years in America in a moment but
11:22
this is if you put the government in the
11:23
system and say well let's imagine as
11:26
well as I've got the 100 being spent on
11:29
each group as I showed you before hand
11:30
but I've got the government taxing 20
11:33
off the poor 20 off the rich and 20 off
11:36
the firms but then spending 30 on each
11:38
of them which means each of them can
11:40
save 10 so long as the government's
11:43
going down by minus 30 okay unless you
11:48
have that you're not going to get any
11:49
savings out of it and that's a simple
11:52
little fact no method there's no
11:54
ideology in that it's simply tracking
11:57
spending from one spot to another so the
12:00
government if the government spend 30
12:02
billion on each of those groups in tax
12:04
at 20 billion on each of them they could
12:06
each save 10 billion while the
12:09
government was dis saving 30 billion so
12:12
how does the government decide how can I
12:13
do that well the simple story is banks
12:17
and governments are two independent ways
12:19
of creating money in a market economy
12:22
the banks create money by lending out
12:24
more than they get back in repayments
12:26
they don't need reserves to lend out if
12:28
that's all the myth and I'm happy to
12:30
talk about that in question time later
12:32
but banks can do that they can lend out
12:34
more than they get back in repayments
12:35
because of a banking license which isn't
12:38
the right to do it but when they do that
12:39
they can give you a loan if you get a
12:42
loan from a bank
12:43
you do get a zero increase in your net
12:45
assets okay because when you borrow the
12:48
money let's say you're buying a house in
12:50
Bournemouth what does a house here at
12:51
cost 250,000 reasonable guess couple of
12:57
million unreasonable yes let's
13:00
compromise on a million the bank gives
13:03
you a line of a million dollars which
13:04
means they credit your account for a
13:05
million which you then spend on the give
13:07
to the to the seller of the house of
13:09
course you get a debt of a million at
13:11
the same at the same time there's no
13:13
change
13:14
the change will occur if prices modify
13:16
things over time and that's a trap by
13:18
the way but there's no change in your
13:21
net asset so you have saves zero by
13:23
taking money off a bank but if a
13:25
government creates money by paying you a
13:29
welfare check or by buying services off
13:31
you are paying you a wage that does not
13:33
come with a matching debt for you okay
13:36
the government's got to handle it but
13:38
you get something which is free of debt
13:39
when they give you that money
13:41
whoever babba they might do it and so on
13:44
and so forth so the government is
13:45
financing and buy a debt to itself now
13:48
I've made it incredibly complicated with
13:51
all sorts of rules of the desert the
13:53
Bank of England can't buy debt off the
13:54
Treasury but it can buy debt that's been
13:57
bought by somebody else off the Treasury
13:59
well duh it has the same effect over
14:02
time and people have them sell but the
14:04
governor's got to pay it back at some
14:05
stage well I want to I like answering
14:07
questions with empirical statements and
14:09
if that was true then gives anybody here
14:13
willing to regard 120 years as roughly
14:15
the long run okay this is America for
14:19
the last hundred and twenty years it's
14:21
net position noticed by all the rhetoric
14:24
and all the nonsense you hear coming out
14:25
of Washington about balancing the budget
14:27
yadda-yadda-yadda
14:29
that is the zero level there anything
14:33
above that line as a surplus think you
14:34
can tell most of the time they're below
14:36
it in fact the average is minus 2.4
14:39
percent of GDP so on average every year
14:43
the governor spent 2.4 percent more than
14:45
it's got back in taxes if you leave out
14:48
the first in the second world war its
14:49
2.3 percent ok it's not mainly war
14:53
spending it might look like it on the
14:54
graph but that they make minor increases
14:56
in the aggregate level over time now
14:59
part of the logic for that is simply
15:02
that a growing economy needs a growing
15:04
amount of money the government taxes on
15:07
the basis of income and spends on the
15:09
basis of to some extent need because the
15:13
economy is growing at about say 5
15:15
percent per annum and the money turns
15:17
over twice a year the government is
15:20
effectively forced to create half that
15:23
much every year in new money two and a
15:24
half
15:25
JPG roughly despite all the rhetoric the
15:28
mechanics perforce them into that
15:29
situation and they don't have to pay it
15:32
back because that debt is actually an
15:34
asset matching your asset if that debt
15:36
wasn't there you wouldn't have your
15:37
savings either okay and that's the
15:41
simple point that what's called modern
15:42
monetary theory has been trying to get
15:44
through to politicians and economists
15:46
and journalists as well I take a
15:48
slightly more complicated approach than
15:50
that but that's I think the key point to
15:51
get through and it's simply shown just
15:53
draw up a table showing somebody
15:55
expenditure in income and show the
15:58
aggregate has to be zero in terms of
16:00
savings and say how are you going to
16:01
save more money and that's a question
16:03
they can only answer by saying if the
16:05
government creates it now of course
16:08
that's a complete inversion of the
16:10
emphasis that the Tories and the
16:12
previous Labour government had here
16:14
anybody read the manifesto from 2015
16:17
anybody take a look at the bloody thing
16:21
four times in the first paragraph it
16:24
says if Labour government will reduce
16:27
the surface every year four times in one
16:30
paragraph the whole thing is about
16:32
reducing the deficit been increasing
16:33
we're getting back to surplus which is a
16:36
fairly the same thing as saying we're
16:37
going to drive the household sector into
16:38
deficit okay that's the impact of it now
16:42
if that does happen to you how can you
16:44
counteract that we might go and borrow
16:45
money from the gut of the banks and
16:46
speculate on rising house prices to get
16:49
house price bubbles out of it it's not a
16:51
good management at all
16:52
it's that partial thinking of thinking
16:55
like you are a household which can have
16:57
a difference in its income and
17:00
expenditure but you're part of an
17:02
overall system that can't unless you
17:04
think that way you're going to make huge
17:06
mistakes which is what the Miliband
17:08
Miliband a government did brought to
17:10
attempted government did though I was
17:12
very happy not to vote in that election
17:13
I voted about in the next one but it's
17:18
just this lack of awareness about simple
17:21
monetary dynamics we have to get that
17:23
through and get people past the belief
17:25
the government should be saving because
17:27
the government savings are you're
17:29
destroying your money that's what it
17:31
comes down to him and people will say
17:33
the government does these things then
17:34
efficiently and they're right
17:36
okay but the government's role is to
17:37
create the stock of money that we've
17:39
spent that's our role to turn that money
17:41
over and generate the GAAP
17:43
and separating those two roles makes it
17:46
much much easier to understand what the
17:48
government should do now one thing I
17:51
find remarkable is how well the Tories
17:53
made the case that the Labour
17:55
government's spending caused the crisis
17:58
in 2008 which is fascinating I mean
18:01
that's I mean I'm sure that that would
18:02
have been a great thing to George Bush
18:03
we had to go on argue that the crisis in
18:06
America was caused by the labor
18:07
government surplus in the UK and the
18:10
same in Spain in the same in Ireland etc
18:12
etc it was all a huge debt bubble ah so
18:15
stop that for a second visits it's quite
18:17
remarkable this particular chart because
18:19
what is one of what I focus on is it's
18:21
not government debt that's matters it's
18:23
private debt that's the one that's
18:24
dangerous because and also the trade
18:28
deficit those two those are the
18:30
important ones the unimportant one is
18:31
the government because the government's
18:33
deficit creates your surplus but if
18:35
you're if you're borrowing money and
18:37
going into debt that will make youth
18:40
look fine until you max out your credit
18:42
card and then the economy crashes and I
18:44
was aware of this trend in using using
18:47
largely American and Australian data but
18:49
I graph the UK data for this book and it
18:52
was stunning so the red line you're
18:54
about to see is the ratio of private
18:56
debt to GDP starting in 1880 and going
19:00
forward to 2020 roughly and the blue
19:03
line is the annual change in that debt
19:05
which is positive and negative various
19:07
times guess when it changes okay that's
19:16
all gone on in broad daylight out of
19:19
sight because with all the obsession
19:21
about government debt nobody in the
19:23
mainstream nobody in the politics nobody
19:25
in in the media focus upon this enormous
19:29
explosion and private debt that began
19:31
right after what was the name got
19:35
elected Saturday night and 82 which is
19:38
pretty much when they deregulated
19:40
building a mortgage lending here and the
19:43
bank's muscled in on building societies
19:46
and you went from having a debt level of
19:48
about four
19:49
85% of GAAP to 195 percent of GDP now
19:54
when that was expanding you had a boom
19:57
this is the bottom line here when the
19:59
root blues above the little dotted line
20:01
here that's where you've got positive
20:03
credit when the crisis hits because you
20:05
went from positive to negative credit
20:06
and the same ruff the same dynamic is
20:09
here
20:10
applies in America it applies in ireland
20:12
applies in spain that's what caused the
20:14
crisis and credit is actually driving
20:17
the ups and downs of the economy so what
20:19
I've done here I've taken the annual
20:21
change in private did the blue line you
20:22
saw in the previous graph
20:23
I'm just graphing that small bit of the
20:25
data now and graphing the unemployment
20:27
rate with four percent up here and
20:29
twelve percent down here just to show
20:31
how strongly correlated there are so the
20:34
burns and slumps won't cause what the
20:35
Labour government was doing all the all
20:37
the Tories for that matter but they've
20:39
certainly made it worse since the crisis
20:40
it's changes in credit and the same
20:47
thing unfortunately people say how
20:49
irresponsible and how hopeless the
20:51
government is at spending money and
20:52
doing things no argument are the banks
20:54
any better what did the ballot what did
20:57
the bench give you money to do to gamble
20:59
on a house prices that's the red line
21:02
there is a level of household debt from
21:05
1965 to 1980 never book more than 30
21:09
percent of GDP after the deregulation of
21:11
lending for mortgages bang it goes from
21:14
30 percent of GDP to 95 percent and up
21:18
go house prices in the process now again
21:20
it's a very simple relationship between
21:22
credit and house prices you think about
21:26
the demand for the monetary demand for
21:28
houses it's the annual change in
21:30
mortgage debt new mortgages or what buy
21:32
houses so they like all new mortgages
21:35
mortgage credit and if you want to work
21:38
out how many prices can be bought for
21:39
that amount of money then you divide
21:41
that new more those new mortgages by the
21:43
price level so you get a link between
21:45
new mortgages and the price level either
21:47
for the link between changing new
21:49
mortgages and change in the price level
21:51
and that's what's making housing
21:53
unaffordable and we take a look at the
21:55
relationship according to conventional
21:57
economic theories don't they have any
21:58
there supposed to be no relationship
22:00
there at all can you spot a relationship
22:02
you can out there most economists they
22:05
don't even look at this data it's
22:06
outside their mindset this is like
22:09
showing me showing us to a bunch of
22:11
mainstream economists is like Copernicus
22:14
showing of Newton showing gravity to
22:17
Ptolemaic astronomers they don't know
22:20
what it is plays no role in their model
22:22
and that's why we got caught in this
22:24
trap now the reason that we've had such
22:26
a crash now whereas we didn't have a
22:28
crash on this scale and previous decades
22:30
is because to turn over the demand comes
22:34
from two sources ultimately demand of
22:37
can turn over existing money plus new
22:39
money being created by the banking
22:41
sector that's the sum of demand and if
22:43
you have a low level of private debt
22:45
then big changes in credit aren't all
22:47
that important if you go back to when
22:49
you had a 50% of GDP debt level it
22:51
didn't particularly matter so if you had
22:53
an economy with a hundred billion say a
22:54
trillion dollars worth of turnover for a
22:56
year growing at 10% per annum which is
22:59
pretty much the rate of money that the
23:00
GDP was growing back in the 60s and 70s
23:03
and you have private debt 50 percent of
23:06
GDP growing at 20% per annum so it's
23:09
quite twice as fast as the economy
23:12
itself is expanding you get an extra 100
23:14
billion dollars or pounds worth of
23:16
demand from credit see total demand of
23:18
the economy is 600 billion now if you go
23:22
forward one year and GDP continues
23:24
growing at the same rate so it's no 1.1
23:26
trillion and debt slows down to only
23:29
growing at the same rate as GDP ten
23:32
percent ten percent of 600 billion is
23:34
another sixty billion dollars and your
23:36
total demand has gone up by 60 billion
23:40
you've still got growing demand even
23:42
though credit slowed down now when you
23:45
get to the level we are now when you
23:47
have debt being twice GDP so the debt
23:51
levels two hundred two thousand billion
23:53
dollars which is again roughly the ratio
23:55
that the UK found itself in in 2008 and
24:01
that's growing a 20% per annum and
24:03
credits adding four hundred billion
24:05
pounds worth of demand every year which
24:07
is huge so you look I've got a booming
24:10
economy this is think a Celtic Tiger
24:12
this is the Irish economy in that sense
24:14
thinking a stirring
24:15
well now if next year the GDP still
24:18
grows at the same rate so 1.1 trillion
24:21
dollars in turnover existing money and
24:23
the growth of debt slows to 10 percent
24:25
per annum ten percent of two point four
24:27
trillion to what you've got to is one
24:29
point three four trillion dollars you've
24:32
actually had a 16 billion dollar drop in
24:34
demand
24:35
so simply stabilizing the debt level can
24:37
cause a fallen total demand and that's
24:39
why it comes out of the blue that's why
24:41
it knocks you so badly so that's the
24:44
situation we've got ourselves trapped in
24:45
now I've got such a high level of
24:47
private debt you're not going to get
24:49
much credit demand and therefore demand
24:51
is sluggish then the economy grows
24:52
slowly which is what's been happening
24:54
for the last 10 years and globally this
24:58
book actually shouldn't be sort of can
25:00
we avoid or where can we avoid would
25:02
have been a better start because
25:03
countries like the UK and the USA that
25:06
have been through this crisis aren't
25:08
about to have another one because you've
25:09
got to jump off a cliff to break your
25:10
legs
25:11
effectively jumping off the steps not so
25:13
dangerous so because you've got such a
25:15
high level of debt you haven't got a
25:17
high level of credit anymore after the
25:19
crisis and therefore the fallen demand
25:22
is going to be from a not particularly
25:23
high level to a low level whereas
25:26
countries that borrowed their way
25:27
through the crisis like Canada Australia
25:28
China when they slow down they're
25:31
jumping off a cliff so they're the ones
25:32
which are going to see a fall.
so I broke 25:34 the world into two groups I call 25:36 countries like the UK the walking dead 25:39 of debt okay we've already had the 25:41 crisis in order being zombified you 25:44 can't party that much when you're a 25:45 zombie so there's not a great deal of 25:47 demand in those economies and they're 25:49 going to fluctuate up and down in and 25:51 out of booms and slumps but not 25:52 particularly big booms and not 25:54 particularly deep slumps but the ones 25:56 that they're going to have a real slump 25:57 are the ones that borrowed their way 25:58 through the crisis back in 2008 China 26:01 was the obvious major candidate that 26:03 this special factors about China of 26:05 course Canada this is not an order of 26:07 size of G repaying South Korea Australia 26:10 Belgium Hong Kong Singapore Norway 26:13 Sweden Ireland again if you can trust 26:16 the numbers and France and the other 26:19 ones are the ones who've already had the 26:21 crisis like Japan the USA UK Spain 26:24 Portugal and Greece then are going to 26:25 have another one so this 26:28 a little chart here which is part of the 26:29 part of the book shows debt as a 26:32 percentage of private debt as a 26:35 percentage of GDP along here and credit 26:38 as a as a percentage of GDP up here zero 26:41 and below that's we've got a slump going 26:43 on above you've got credit adding to 26:46 demand the danger zone is up here we're 26:49 credits adding more than 10% of GDP per 26:51 per annum to demand and those are all 26:53 the countries that I was data fine as 26:55 being in that zone where they're likely 26:57 to have a crisis like Japan had and the 26:59 US and the UK and Portugal and Spain and 27:02 so on so that's the situation we're in 27:05 let's have some chat questions thank you 27:27 [Music] 次の動画 36:14 再生中 Steve Keen: Avoid the next financial crisis with People’s QE and a debt jubilee MoneyWeek 6.2万 回視聴 4 年前

0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿