2023年5月4日木曜日

Public Budgets with Stephanie Kelton

Public Budgets with Stephanie Kelton
https://youtu.be/IJQvSccXGWM

追加:

 ex.Ep 1. The MMT Lens with Special Guest Stephanie Kelton (FULL EPISODE)

https://love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com/2023/05/ep-1.html 

50:55~

2023/04/29 Funny Moneyさんのツイート Up on YouTube now with our first big episode with special guest ⁦‪@StephanieKelton‬⁩! 


Ep 1. The MMT Lens with Special Guest Stephanie Kelton (FULL EPISODE)


元動画の11:00から

B:
I want to start at the very beginning. It's a good place to start. Stephanie. What is the federal deficit?

K:
 Okay. It's the difference between two numbers. Like in this thing that you hear, you see headlines, media hand-wringing, this word that's like omnipresent, Right. And at the end of the day, it boils down to this rather benign thing. It's literally the difference between two numbers. One of the numbers is, how many dollars the government puts out there each year. So we call that outlays. If you go to the Congressional Budget Report, you look up the tables, it'll say total outlays, and it will give you a number. And those outlays could be for things like military spending, health care, infrastructure and all that. So think of dollars flowing out of government. That's one number. The other number is total revenue. That's mostly through taxation. So it's how much the government collects in personal income tax, corporate income tax, payroll tax, so how much comes in each year. So the difference between what goes out and what comes in. So if outlays are greater, then receipts, then revenues, then we record on the ledger a deficit. So putting really simple numbers to it, you guys, if the government outlays are 100 and revenues are 90, then we call that a deficit and we record somewhere that the government has run a deficit. Somebody writes minus ten on the books. So that's the definition. That's what we're talking about. But what we forget and it's really, really important and you would think somebody would take the trouble to mention this is that if the government puts out more than it takes away from us, that it's really just making a deposit. So if it puts a hundred in and only takes 90 out, what it's really doing is depositing $10 into some other part of the economy. In other words, the government's deficit is always matched dollar for dollar by a financial surplus. On the other side of every deficit lies a surplus of equal size that goes into some other part of the economy. So when people get very upset at the notion that the government has done this awful thing called running a fiscal deficit, what they really failed to recognize, and it's partly due to the economics profession, which doesn't do a good job informing people, journalists, pundits, talking heads on TV. What people don't realize is that the government's deficit is a financial contribution to some other part of the economy. So in a financial sense, every deficit is good for someone. The question is, you know, for whom? What are those deficits being used to accomplish and who's on the other side of that windfall? Where are those dollars going? Who has them now? 

B:
So a lot of people think of the word deficit and they imagine their own household budget. If I take out your credit card and I spend a bunch of money on it's money I don't have, I have to pay that money back. Now, you make this great distinction that the government is not a household. We have a fiat currency. The U.S. government is a currency issuer. I love that. You say their red ink is our black ink to describe that, a lot of people hear deficit and assume debt. And moreover, they assume foreign debt like we've taken out a credit card with the Bank of China. Can you make the distinction for everyone? Because it's unfortunately a super common one between foreign debt and the national deficit. 
4:00
K:
Yeah. Even, you know, journalists and pundits and members of Congress will sometimes conflate the deficit and the debt. And I have to tell you, Jessica, I think I wish we didn't use either of these words. I think both are poor words to use to describe what's really happening. So I would prefer to just use the term net spending for the outcome. Whatever the difference between outlays and revenues is each year, we just call it net spending. Sometimes it's positive, sometimes it's negative. The debt so called is the cumulative running total of all of the prior instances where the government engaged in net spending of a plus or minus. So let me give you an example. If the government puts in 100 and takes out 90. We've already established that we call that a fiscal deficit. We write minus ten. Now, if they do that year after year after year after year, we'll have a different number. We'll add up all those minus tens, and that will give us what we refer to as the so-called national debt. What happens is that each year the government's budget happens to end in a deficit, the government sells treasuries. These are financial instruments that are available to the rest of us, including to China. People who have dollars can trade those dollars in for what I think amounts to a just another kind of dollar. It's an interest bearing US dollar called a government bond, a U.S. treasury. And so China has access to that market. You and I have access to that market either investors, pension funds and the like. And it's the total outstanding stock of U.S. Treasuries that we call the national debt. And that word is so loaded, right, because people hear the word debt and they think, oh, my God, I know if I took on trillions of dollars of debt, it would be the end of the world for me personally. But the federal government, as you just said, doesn't have a budget that operates like a household. This thing called the debt is not akin to personal debt. It doesn't work like when we take on personal debt. If you got yourself in a pickle with credit card debt, you've got to find dollars to repay your creditor, Visa, MasterCard, whoever. When the federal government sells treasuries, what is it obligated to pay at the end of the day, U.S. dollars to bondholders? Well, where do U.S. dollars come from? Well, it turns out the US government is the issuer of the US dollar, so it's a very different beast. When we talk about debt for a household versus this thing that we unfortunately call debt for the federal government, what it really is is just a financial asset for the rest of us, part of our wealth, part of our savings. If you're lucky to get lucky enough to own some of these congratulations. Right. This is a safe financial instrument that pays you interest for the benefit of parting with your dollars for some period of time. 

A:
That's a great distinction. And so when we think about the deficit being the difference between these two numbers, we think about the debt being these treasuries. Right. Both of those are coming from the federal government. One thing that helped me when I first started learning about this is a visual that really kind of brings in this paradigm shift. And one of the classic ones for those that are learning this perspective, this lens into public budgets is this classic sectoral balances image. Can you tell us a little bit about this image and what it's what it's showing us? 




K:
Yep. So what it's showing you, I'm going to just take one quick step back and say something else about the debt, so-called, which I think it's important to say when I said it's the cumulative total. So what we want to recognize is that those are all of the dollars that the government has spent into the economy over the history of the country's existence and not taxed back. So that's what it is, right? It's the dollars that have been spent by government and not taxed back. It's really just part of the broader U.S. money supply. Those treasuries are really interest bearing dollars. They circulate. They function in many ways like money. So when you look at this graph, what do you see? All right. This is a graph. It's actual data. Nobody made this up. Okay. This is real historical data going back to the 1950s, early 1950s. And what the graph does is to break the economy into three big chunks. We could disaggregate it further, but this makes the point pretty clearly and nicely. One chunk here that you see depicted in blue is the U.S. private sector. That's all the households and all the businesses in the U.S. economy, our private sector. What you see depicted in red here is the government sector. That's federal, state and local. That's government here in the U.S. And then there's everything else, which is what's outside of the U.S. that's shown in green, and that's the rest of the world. So what the graph shows you is how dollars flow in and out of sectors over time. So if a sector if one part of the economy experiences net outflows, in other words, it pays out more dollars than come in during that period of time, you're going to see that sector below zero. It's going to have a deficit. If a sector is receiving more dollars than it is paying out, it's going to have a surplus as you're going to see it above zero there. So the graph is neat and tidy and it may strike people who are watching this that, you know, wow, they're kind of a mirror of one another. And that's an important part of the story because every payment that flows out of one sector has to go somewhere, right? And it has to be received by some other sector. So any deficit has to result in, as we said earlier, a surplus in some other part of the economy. And so everything has to net to zero. Another striking feature, remember this goes back to the early 1950s so that you notice the government is almost always in red. Government is almost always the one in the deficit position, whereas the private sector is almost always above zero with a surplus and we don't have the time, I don't think, to get into the whole rest of the world and trade imbalances and why that changes over time. But the important point here is that those government deficits are the thing that is producing the surpluses that you see above zero. So if you just look, let's see how far back this goes. There you go. So you have the covered spending, right? Those enormous deficits that were run to try to support the economy through the pandemic and so forth. And people really got concerned at the size of the government's deficit during that period. But if you look at this in the context of the whole picture, not just what's happening to the government's budget, but look up, right, look what's happening to everybody else, and you'll see that those government deficits were instrumental in keeping the private sector afloat. Right. So you can see that big spike in the private sector's financial surplus in that period, while those surpluses were made possible by virtue of the government outlays greater than receipts. So the government's deficit is producing those surpluses. 


A:
And I think what's really key that you mentioned is that this is not a fixed thing, but rather it's up for grabs. Right. That that deficit could be going to one place to the to the most wealthy, the most powerful, to the military, whatever, or it could be going to the things we need to improve quality of life and and improve the standard of living for working people, for communities of color, historically marginalized communities, whoever that may be. Right. Like, it's a political question of where those deficits go. And I think that's so vital. 


K:
And the answer is you're right for sure. And just to be clear, in the pandemic, they went to both places, right? They went to both. It wasn't as if Congress said, well, we're going to have to respond to this, you know, health crisis and this economic crisis. And so we're going to make a commitment to with the CARES Act, $2.2 trillion in March of 2020. They didn't say, I guess it's time to finally cut the military budget because we're going to have to, you know, commit a lot of money to supporting the economy because of the pandemic and the economic fallout and so forth. Now, they continued to fund and even more generously so when the defense reauthorization Act comes up, they put more money into the military and supported the economy with, you know, fiscal package after fiscal package after fiscal package, some 5 trillion, even more than 5 trillion in the span of about 12 months time. 

A:
Yeah. So, I mean, you know, that really kind of for the organizers and people in politics listening right like that just shows that it's up for grabs. And like some like AOC and some other public officials say these budgets are in many ways moral documents that say, you know, what do we want to prioritize. 

K:
You bet.


ステファニー・ケルトンとの公共予算
https://youtu.be/IJQvSccXGWM


2023/04/29 Funny Moneyさんのツイート Up on YouTube now with our first big episode with special guest ⁦‪@StephanieKelton‬⁩! 


Ep 1. The MMT Lens with Special Guest Stephanie Kelton (FULL EPISODE)


元動画の11:00から

B:
最初から始めたいです。始めるには良い場所です。ステファニー。連邦赤字とは.

K:
 わかった。2 つの数値の差です。あなたが耳にするこのことのように、あなたは見出し、メディアの手の震え、どこにでもあるようなこの言葉を見ます。そして結局のところ、それはこのどちらかといえば無害なことに行き着きます。文字通り、2 つの数値の差です。数字の 1 つは、政府が毎年そこに出す金額です。だから私たちはそれを支出と呼んでいます。議会予算報告書にアクセスして表を調べると、総支出が表示され、数字が表示されます。そして、それらの支出は、軍事費、ヘルスケア、インフラストラクチャーなどに向けられる可能性があります. ですから、政府から流出するドルについて考えてみてください。それが1つの数字です。もう 1 つの数字は総収入です。それは主に税金によるものです。つまり、政府が個人所得税で徴収する金額です。法人所得税、給与税、毎年どれだけ入ってくるか。つまり、出て行くものと入ってくるものの差です。したがって、支出が大きく、次に収入、次に収入が多い場合、元帳に赤字を記録します。非常に単純な数字で言えば、政府の支出が 100 で歳入が 90 の場合、それを赤字と呼び、政府が赤字を出していることをどこかに記録します。誰かが本にマイナス10と書いています。それが定義です。それが私たちが話していることです。しかし、私たちが忘れていること、それは本当に、本当に重要であり、政府が私たちから奪う以上のものを出している場合、それは本当に預金をしているだけだということを誰かがわざわざ言及するだろうと思うでしょう. 100 を入れて 90 しか出さないとしたら、実際に行っているのは、経済の他の部分に 10 ドルを預けることです。言い換えれば、政府の赤字は、常に財政黒字と一致します。すべての赤字の反対側には、同規模の黒字があり、経済の他の部分に流れ込んでいます。人々が政府が財政赤字という恐ろしいことをしたという考えに非常に腹を立てているとき、彼らは本当に認識できていませんでした。それは部分的には経済専門家によるものであり、人々に適切な情報を提供していません.ジャーナリスト、評論家、テレビの話題。人々が気付いていないのは、政府の赤字が経済の他の部分への財政的貢献であるということです。したがって、財政的な意味では、すべての赤字は誰かにとって良いことです。問題は、あなたが知っている、誰のため?これらの赤字は何を達成するために使用されており、その棚ぼたの反対側にいるのは誰ですか? それらのドルはどこに行くのですか?誰が今持っていますか? 

B:
多くの人が赤字という言葉を思い浮かべ、自分の家計を想像します。私があなたのクレジットカードを取り出し、私が持っていないお金にたくさんのお金を使ったら、私はそのお金を返さなければなりません. さて、あなたは政府が家庭ではないことを大きく区別しています。私たちは法定通貨を持っています。米国政府は通貨発行体です。私はそれが好きです。あなたは彼らの赤いインクが私たちの黒いインクであることを説明すると言いますが、多くの人が赤字を聞いて借金を想定しています. さらに、中国銀行でクレジット カードを利用したように、彼らは対外債務を想定しています。みんなの見分け方は?残念ながら、それは対外債務と国家赤字の間の非常に一般的なものだからです. 
4:00
K:
うん。ご存知のように、ジャーナリストや専門家、国会議員でさえ、赤字と債務を混同することがあります。そして、ジェシカ、あなたに言わなければならないのですが、これらの言葉のどちらも使わなければよかったと思います. どちらも、実際に起こっていることを説明するのに使うには不適切な言葉だと思います。したがって、私は結果に対して単に純支出という用語を使用したいと思います。毎年の支出と収入の差が何であれ、私たちはそれを純支出と呼んでいます。ポジティブな時もあれば、ネガティブな時もある。いわゆる債務は、政府がプラスまたはマイナスの純支出に関与した以前のすべてのインスタンスの累計です。では、例を挙げましょう。政府が 100 を入れて 90 を出すとしたら、それを財政赤字と呼ぶことはすでに確立しています。マイナス10と書きます。今、彼らが毎年それを毎年行うと、異なる数になります。これらのマイナス 10 をすべて合計すると、いわゆる国家債務と呼ばれるものが得られます。何が起こるかというと、毎年政府の予算がたまたま赤字になり、政府は国庫を売却します。これらは、中国を含む私たちの残りの部分が利用できる金融商品です。ドルを持っている人は、そのドルを別の種類のドルに交換することができます。それは、国債、米国財務省と呼ばれる米ドルの利子です。そのため、中国はその市場にアクセスできます。あなたと私は、投資家、年金基金などの市場にアクセスできます。そして、私たちが国債と呼んでいるのは、米国債の未払い残高の合計です。そして、その言葉はとてもロードされていますね。人々は借金という言葉を聞いて、ああ、なんてこった、何兆ドルもの借金を背負ったら、それは私個人にとって世界の終わりになるだろうと思うからです. しかし、あなたが今言ったように、連邦政府には家計のような予算はありません。この負債と呼ばれるものは、個人の負債とは異なります。私たちが個人的な借金を負うときのようには機能しません。クレジット カードの借金で窮地に立たされた場合、Visa や MasterCard などの債権者に返済するための資金を見つけなければなりません。連邦政府が国庫を売却するとき、最終的に国債保有者に支払う義務があるのは米ドルですか? では、米ドルはどこから来るのでしょうか。米国政府が米ドルの発行者であることが判明したため、これは非常に異なる獣です。残念ながら連邦政府の借金と呼ばれるものに対して、家計の借金について話すとき、それは実際には私たちの残りの部分のための単なる金融資産であり、私たちの富の一部であり、私たちの貯蓄の一部です. 運が良ければ、これらのお祝いの言葉をいくつか所有できます。右。これは、一定期間ドルを手放す利益のために利息を支払う安全な金融商品です。 

A:
それは大きな違いです。赤字がこれら 2 つの数値の差であると考えると、債務は国庫であると考えることができます。右。どちらも連邦政府からのものです。これについて学び始めたときに役立ったことの 1 つは、このパラダイム シフトを実際にもたらすビジュアルです。そして、この視点を学んでいる人々にとって古典的なものの 1 つは、この公的予算へのレンズがこの古典的な部門別収支のイメージです。この画像と、それが私たちに見せているものについて少し教えていただけますか? 




K:
うん。それがあなたに示していることは、私は一歩下がって、債務について別のことを言うつもりです. したがって、私たちが認識したいのは、これらは国の存在の歴史を通じて政府が経済に費やしてきたすべてのドルであり、課税されていないということです. そういうことですよね?それは、政府によって費やされ、課税されていないドルです。それは実際には、より広範な米国のマネーサプライの一部にすぎません。それらの国庫は、実際には利子付きのドルです。それらは循環します。それらはお金のように多くの点で機能します。では、このグラフを見ると、何が見えますか? わかった。これはグラフです。実際のデータです。誰もこれを作りませんでした。わかった。これは 1950 年代にさかのぼる実際の履歴データです。1950年代初頭。グラフが行うことは、経済を 3 つの大きな塊に分割することです。さらに細分化することもできますが、これにより要点がかなり明確かつ適切になります。ここで青色で示されているチャンクの 1 つは、米国の民間部門です。それは、米国経済、私たちの民間部門のすべての世帯とすべての企業です。ここで赤く描かれているのは政府部門です。それは、連邦、州、および地方です。それはここ米国の政府です そしてそれ以外のすべてがあります 緑色で示されているのは米国以外のものです それは世界の残りの部分です グラフが示すのは、時間の経過とともにどのようにドルがセクターに出入りするかです。したがって、セクターが経済の一部で純流出を経験した場合、つまり、その期間中に入ってくるよりも多くのドルを支払う場合、あなたは. そのセクターがゼロ以下になることを確認します。赤字になります。セクターが支払いよりも多くのドルを受け取っている場合、ゼロより上に表示されるため、黒字になります。グラフはきちんと整理されており、これを見ている人は、うわー、彼らはお互いの鏡のようなものだと思うかもしれません。あるセクターから流出するすべての支払いはどこかに行かなければならないので、それは物語の重要な部分ですよね? そして、それは他のセクターによって受け取られなければなりません。したがって、赤字は、先に述べたように、経済の他の部分で黒字にならなければなりません。したがって、すべてがゼロになる必要があります。もう 1 つの顕著な特徴は、これが 1950 年代初頭にさかのぼることを思い出してください。そのため、政府はほとんどの場合赤字であることがわかります。ほとんどの場合、政府は赤字の立場にあります。一方、民間部門はほとんどの場合黒字でゼロを超えており、残りの世界全体と貿易の不均衡、そしてそれが時間とともに変化する理由について理解する時間はないと思います. しかしここで重要な点は、政府の赤字がゼロを超える黒字を生み出しているということです。ですから、これがどこまでさかのぼるか見てみましょう。ほらね。それで、あなたはカバーされた支出を持っていますよね?パンデミックなどを通じて経済を支えようとして実行された巨額の赤字。そして人々は、この時期の政府の赤字の大きさに本当に懸念を抱きました。しかし、これを全体像の文脈で見ると、政府の予算に何が起こっているかだけでなく、他のすべての人に何が起こっているかを見てください。そして、これらの政府の赤字が民間部門を存続させるのに役立ったことがわかります。右。この期間に民間部門の財政黒字が急増したことがわかりますが、これらの黒字は、政府の歳出が収入を上回ったおかげで可能になりました。つまり、政府の赤字が黒字を生み出しているのです。 


A:
そして、あなたが言及した本当に重要なことは、これは固定されたものではなく、手に入れることができるということだと思います. 右。その赤字は、最も裕福な、最も強力な、軍隊などに行く可能性があるか、生活の質を改善し、働くための生活水準を向上させるために必要なものに行く可能性があります人々、色のコミュニティ、歴史的に周縁化されたコミュニティ、それが誰であれ。右。同様に、これらの赤字がどこに行くかというのは政治的な問題です。そして、それはとても重要なことだと思います。 


K:
そして答えは、あなたが確かに正しいということです。はっきりさせておくと、パンデミックでは、彼らは両方の場所に行きましたよね? 彼らは両方に行きました。議会が、健康危機と経済危機に対応しなければならないと言っているわけではありませんでした。そこで、2020 年 3 月に CARES 法で 2 兆 2,000 億ドルを投入することを約束します。 、パンデミックや経済的影響などのために、経済を支えるために多額のお金を費やしています。現在、彼らは資金提供を続けており、さらに寛大に防衛再認可法が制定されると、軍により多くの資金を投入し、財政パッケージを次から次へと財政パッケージで経済を支えました。 

A:
うん。つまり、つまり、主催者や政治家がそのように正しく聞いていることは、それが手に入るということを示しているだけです。そして、AOCのような一部や他の公務員は、これらの予算は多くの点で道徳的な文書であり、何を優先したいかを述べていると言っています. 

K:
あなたは賭けます。





0:02I want to start at the very beginning.
0:04It's a good place to start.
0:06Stephanie.
0:07What is the federal deficit?
0:11Okay.
0:13It's the difference between two numbers.
0:15Like in this thing that you hear, you see headlines,
0:19media hand-wringing, this word that's like omnipresent, Right.
0:24And at the end of the day, it boils down to this rather benign thing.
0:30It's literally the difference between two numbers.
0:33One of the numbers is,
0:35how many dollars the government puts out there each year.
0:40So we call that outlays.
0:42If you go to the Congressional Budget Report, you look up the tables,
0:45it'll say total outlays, and it will give you a number.
0:48And those outlays could be
0:49for things like military spending, health care, infrastructure and all that.
0:53So think of dollars flowing out of government.
0:56That's one number.
0:58The other number is total revenue.
1:00That's mostly through taxation.
1:02So it's how much the government collects in personal income tax,
1:05corporate income tax, payroll tax, so how much comes in each year.
1:11So the difference between what goes out and what comes in.
1:14So if outlays are greater, then receipts, then revenues,
1:20then we record on the ledger a deficit.
1:25So putting really simple numbers to it, you guys, if the government outlays are
1:30100 and revenues are 90, then we call that a deficit
1:35and we record somewhere that the government has run a deficit.
1:39Somebody writes minus ten on the books.
1:43So that's the definition.
1:45That's what we're talking about.
1:47But what we forget and it's really, really important and you would think
1:51somebody would take the trouble to mention this is that if the government puts out
1:56more than it takes away from us, that it's really just making a deposit.
2:01So if it puts a hundred in and only takes 90 out,
2:04what it's really doing is depositing $10 into some other part of the economy.
2:11In other words, the government's deficit is always matched
2:14dollar for dollar by a financial surplus.
2:18On the other side of every deficit lies a surplus of equal size
2:24that goes into some other part of the economy.
2:26So when people get very upset at the notion that the government has done
2:31this awful thing called running a fiscal deficit,
2:35what they really failed to recognize, and it's
2:39partly due to the economics profession, which doesn't do a good job informing
2:43people, journalists, pundits, talking heads on TV.
2:47What people don't realize is that the government's deficit
2:51is a financial contribution to some other part of the economy.
2:54So in a financial sense,
2:58every deficit is good for someone.
3:01The question is, you know, for whom?
3:03What are those
3:03deficits being used to accomplish and who's on the other side of that windfall?
3:07Where are those dollars going? Who has them now?

B:
3:11So a lot of people think of
3:12the word deficit and they imagine their own household budget.
3:17If I take out your credit card and I spend a bunch of money on it's money
3:22I don't have, I have to pay that money back.
3:25Now, you make this great distinction that the government is not a household.
3:30We have a fiat currency.
3:32The U.S. government is a currency issuer.
3:34I love that.
3:35You say their red ink is our black ink to describe that,
3:39a lot of people hear deficit and assume debt.
3:44And moreover, they assume foreign debt
3:46like we've taken out a credit card with the Bank of China.
3:49Can you make the distinction for everyone?
3:52Because it's unfortunately a super common
3:54one between foreign debt and the national deficit.


3:58Yeah.
3:58Even, you know, journalists and pundits and members of Congress
4:02will sometimes conflate the deficit and the debt.
4:05And I have to tell you, Jessica,
4:06I think I wish we didn't use either of these words.
4:09I think both are poor
4:13words to
4:13use to describe what's really happening.
4:17So I would prefer to just use the term net spending for the outcome.
4:22Whatever the difference between outlays and revenues is each year,
4:26we just call it net spending.
4:28Sometimes it's positive, sometimes it's negative.
4:31The debt so called is the cumulative
4:37running total of all of the prior instances
4:42where the government engaged in net spending of a plus or minus.
4:47So let me give you an example.
4:49If the government puts in 100 and takes out 90.
4:52We've already established that we call that a fiscal deficit.
4:55We write minus ten.
4:57Now, if they do that year after year after year after year,
5:01we'll have a different number.
5:03We'll add up all those minus tens, and that will give us what we refer to
5:07as the so-called national debt.
5:09What happens is that each year the government's budget happens
5:13to end in a deficit,
5:15the government sells treasuries.
5:18These are financial instruments that are available to the rest of us,
5:22including to China.
5:24People who have dollars can trade those dollars in
5:27for what I think amounts to a just another kind of dollar.
5:32It's an interest bearing US dollar called a government bond, a U.S.
5:37treasury.
5:38And so China has access to that market.
5:41You and I have access to that market either investors, pension funds
5:45and the like.
5:46And it's the total outstanding stock of U.S.
5:51Treasuries that we call the national debt.
5:55And that word is so loaded, right, because people hear the word debt
5:59and they think, oh, my God, I know if I took on trillions of dollars of debt,
6:03it would be the end of the world for me personally.
6:07But the federal government, as you just
6:08said, doesn't have a budget that operates like a household.
6:12This thing called the debt is not akin to personal debt.
6:16It doesn't work like when we take on personal debt.
6:19If you got yourself in a pickle with credit card debt,
6:22you've got to find dollars to repay your creditor, Visa, MasterCard, whoever.
6:27When the federal government sells treasuries,
6:30what is it obligated to pay at the end of the day, U.S.
6:33dollars to bondholders?
6:35Well, where do U.S.
6:36dollars come from?
6:37Well, it turns out the US government is the issuer of the US dollar,
6:42so it's a very different beast.
6:47When we talk about debt for a household versus
6:50this thing that we unfortunately call debt
6:53for the federal government, what it really is is just
6:56a financial asset for the rest of us, part of our wealth, part of our savings.
7:00If you're lucky to get lucky enough to own some of these congratulations.
7:05Right.
7:05This is a safe financial instrument
7:09that pays you interest for the benefit of
7:15parting with your dollars
7:16for some period of time.

A:
7:19That's a great distinction.
7:20And so when we think about the deficit being the difference between
7:24these two numbers, we think about the debt being these treasuries.
7:29Right.
7:29Both of those are coming from the federal government.
7:32One thing that helped me when I first started learning about
7:35this is a visual that really kind of brings in this paradigm shift.
7:39And one of the classic ones for those that are learning this perspective,
7:43this lens into public budgets is this classic sectoral balances image.
7:49Can you tell us a little bit about
7:51this image and what it's what it's showing us? 

K:
Yep.
7:55So what it's showing you,
7:58I'm going to just take one quick step back
8:00and say something else about the debt, so-called,
8:03which I think it's important to say when I said it's the cumulative total.
8:07So what we want to recognize is that those are all of the dollars that
8:12the government has spent into the economy
8:15over the history of the country's
8:19existence and not taxed back.
8:22So that's what it is, right?
8:23It's the dollars that have been spent by government and not taxed back.
8:27It's really just part of the broader U.S.
8:29money supply.
8:30Those treasuries are really interest bearing dollars.
8:32They circulate.
8:34They function in many ways like money.
8:37So when you look at this graph, what do you see?
8:39All right.
8:40This is a graph. It's actual data.
8:42Nobody made this up. Okay.
8:44This is real historical data going back to the 1950s, early 1950s.
8:49And what the graph does is to break the economy into three big chunks.
8:55We could disaggregate it further, but this makes the point
8:58pretty clearly and nicely.
9:00One chunk here that you see depicted in blue is the U.S.
9:05private sector.
9:06That's all the households and all the businesses in the U.S.
9:09economy, our private sector.
9:12What you see depicted in red here is the government sector.
9:16That's federal, state and local.
9:17That's government here in the U.S.
9:20And then there's everything else, which is what's outside of the U.S.
9:24that's shown in green, and that's the rest of the world.
9:28So what the graph shows you is
9:32how dollars flow
9:35in and out of sectors over time.
9:39So if a sector if one part of the economy experiences
9:44net outflows, in other words, it pays out more dollars than come in during
9:49that period of time, you're going to see that sector below zero.
9:52It's going to have a deficit.
9:54If a sector is receiving more dollars than it is paying out, it's
9:59going to have a surplus as you're going to see it above zero there.
10:03So the graph is neat and tidy and it may strike people
10:07who are watching this that, you know, wow, they're kind of a mirror of one another.
10:12And that's an important part of the story because every payment
10:16that flows out of one sector has to go somewhere, right?
10:20And it has to be received by some other sector.
10:23So any deficit has to result
10:28in, as we said earlier, a surplus in some other part of the economy.
10:32And so everything has to net to zero.
10:35Another striking feature, remember this goes back to the early 1950s
10:39so that you notice the government is almost always in red.
10:42Government is almost always the one in the deficit position,
10:45whereas the private sector is almost always above zero with a surplus
10:51and we don't have the time, I don't think, to get into the whole rest
10:55of the world and trade imbalances and why that changes over time.
10:58But the important point here is that those government deficits
11:04are the thing that is producing the surpluses that you see above zero.
11:09So if you just look, let's see how far back this goes.
11:14There you go.
11:14So you have the covered spending, right?
11:17Those enormous deficits that were run to try
11:20to support the economy through the pandemic and so forth.
11:24And people really got concerned at the size of the government's
11:28deficit during that period.
11:30But if you look at this in the context of the whole picture,
11:35not just what's happening to the government's budget,
11:38but look up, right, look what's happening to everybody else,
11:42and you'll see that those government deficits were instrumental
11:46in keeping the private sector afloat. Right.
11:50So you can see that big spike in the private sector's financial surplus
11:54in that period, while those surpluses were made possible
11:57by virtue of the government outlays greater than receipts.
12:02So the government's deficit is producing those surpluses.

A:
12:06And I think what's really key that you mentioned
12:09is that this is not a fixed thing, but rather it's up for grabs.
12:14Right.
12:14That that deficit could be going to one place to the to the most wealthy,
12:19the most powerful, to the military, whatever, or it could be going
12:23to the things we need to improve quality of life and and improve
12:27the standard of living for working people, for communities
12:30of color, historically marginalized communities, whoever that may be.
12:33Right.
12:33Like, it's a political question of where those deficits go.
12:37And I think that's so vital.

K:
12:39And the answer is you're right for sure.
12:42And just to be clear, in the pandemic, they went to both places, right?
12:48They went to both.
12:49It wasn't as if Congress said, well, we're going to have to respond
12:54to this, you know, health crisis and this economic crisis.
12:58And so we're going to make a commitment to with the CARES
13:01Act, $2.2 trillion in March of 2020.
13:04They didn't say, I guess it's time
13:07to finally cut the military budget because we're going to have to,
13:10you know, commit a lot of money to supporting the economy
13:14because of the pandemic and the economic fallout and so forth.
13:18Now, they continued to fund and even more generously
13:22so when the defense reauthorization
13:24Act comes up, they put more money into the military
13:27and supported the economy with, you know, fiscal package
13:32after fiscal package after fiscal package, some 5 trillion,
13:36even more than 5 trillion in the span of about
13:41   12 months time.

A:
13:43Yeah.
13:44So, I mean, you know, that really kind of for the organizers and people
13:47in politics listening right like that just shows that it's up for grabs.
13:50And like some
13:51like AOC and some other public officials say these budgets are in many ways
13:55moral documents that say, you know, what do we want to prioritize. 

K:
You bet.


2023年5月3日水曜日

Debt Ceiling Crisis and Social Security with Stephanie Kelton


Debt Ceiling Crisis and Social Security with Stephanie Kelton


元動画の

29:21~

So I want to turn to the debt ceiling crisis, how they've made all of us afraid of this looming scenario where what's going to happen if we raise the debt limit? Have we ever done that before? Many, many times. Over 70 times since 1960. Can you talk a little bit about just the debt limit crisis and how you see it? 

Well, sure. I see it as a crisis of its own making. It's political theater, but this time it's gotten to the point that you know, people are starting to, I think, take very seriously the possibility that you might well have enough people in Congress who think that this is actually some sort of innocent or benign game that you can just refuse to raise the debt limit and nothing terribly bad will happen. I don't know how to explain it. You know, we've been here before where it started to feel pretty serious. And I think in your intro, you had some references to what did you show a video clip that referenced, you know, downgrading. The Angry Birds. 

The zombies. Yeah, yeah, yeah. They'll downgrade the debt. 

Well, that happened before. Okay. That happened after the housing bubble burst and the financial crisis. We toyed around. We -- members of Congress -- toyed around with the idea of not raising the debt ceiling limit in a timely enough fashion and risking a potential default. And Standard and Poor's downgraded U.S. Treasuries from a AAA rating, which is the highest that you can have to one notch below. And, you know, yesterday I was teaching my graduate students here at Stony Brook, and I showed a video of a clip, of some of the conversations that were going on around that time. And one of the people who spoke was Warren Buffett, who's, of course, billionaire investor Berkshire Hathaway and so forth. And Warren Buffett was saying, how on earth is S&P downgrading U.S. Treasuries? This makes no sense whatsoever. And he said, these are his words, not mine. He said the U.S. government can print money. What do they think there's going to be a point at which, you know, you have to make interest in principal payments to bondholders and you don't know where to get the money. I mean, he's saying this is insane. It's our currency. And he said, they asked him, do you disagree then with the downgrade? He said, of course, he said in here in Omaha, because Berkshire in Omaha, Nebraska, he said the U.S. treasuries would have a AAAA rating. There is no reason to question the validity of the of the U.S. government so-called debt, as we've referred to it. So lawmakers recognize this. I think they know it, Jessica. I don't think there's confusion about this. I think that they know that there's always that they always have the ability to pay. I heard one member of the House on television the other morning say he is a Republican from Arkansas, and he said, these were his exact words, He said the debt ceiling is an anachronism financially. But he said, but the reason I like it And then he went on to explain that the reason he likes it is because it presents these moments where you can use the debt limit as leverage to try to extract the kinds of things you were just talking about. Make people go try to find extra hours in order to get their SNAP benefits, make people jump through extra hoops and and hurdles and, you know, get an opportunity maybe to take a whack at Social Security and Medicare or or something else, you know, get your pound of flesh in exchange for doing something that you aught not even have to do because we shouldn't have the damn thing. We're one of maybe two countries in the world that even has a debt limit. So but here we are. Here we are. 


A:
It's almost as if constructing a sense of knowledge and a sense of truth that everybody, the public kind of internalizes is as a very effective political tool to win the kinds of things that those that want to privatize that those that want some kind of market fundamentalist economy to function use very effectively. And speaking of that leverage, one of the things we hear over and over again is that if the GOP and many Democrats, quite frankly, will sometimes argue that if we're going to raise the debt ceiling, then we'll only do it because we will cut it from somewhere else. Social Security comes up all the time here. Right. They say it's going to go broke. It's: there's no way that it's going to stay solvent. And so we got to find a way to privatize it or cut funding. We actually have a quick clip. Mike, can we can we get that up of one that you've used as well many times. 



R:
So having personal retirement accounts is another way of making a future Retiree benefits more secure for their retirement. And also, do you believe that personal retirement accounts as a component to a system of solvency does help improve solvency? Because when you have a personal retirement account policy, it it's a company with a benefit offset. Would that feature in place? Do you believe that personal retirement accounts can help us achieve solvency for the system and make those future retiree benefits more secure?  
G:
Well, I wouldn't say that the pay as you go benefits are insecure in the sense that, there's nothing to prevent the federal government from creating as much money as it wants and paying it to somebody. The question is, how do you set up a system which assures that the real assets are created, which those benefits are employed to purchase? So it's not a question of security, it's a question of the structure of a financial system which ensures that the real resources are created for retirement as distinct from the cash, the cash itself. It's nice to have, but it's got to be in the context of the real resources being created at the time those benefits are paid so that you can purchase real resources with the benefits, which of course are cash. 


So we're hearing about personal retirement accounts. Give us give us a sense of what's going on at that hearing in that video. 

(

R:
つまり、個人退職金口座を持つことは、将来のRetireeの退職金をより安全にするためのもう一つの方法なのです。また、ソルベンシーシステムの構成要素としての個人退職勘定は、ソルベンシーの向上に役立つとお考えでしょうか?なぜなら、個人退職口座の契約がある場合、それはベネフィット・オフセットがある会社だからです。その機能が備わるのでしょうか?個人退職勘定は、システムのソルベンシーを達成し、それらの将来の退職者給付をより安全にするのに役立つとお考えでしょうか? 
G:
連邦政府が好きなだけお金を作って、誰かに支払うことを妨げるものは何もないという意味では、Pay as you goの給付が安全でないとは言いません。問題は、給付金を購入するために使用される実物資産が作られることを保証するシステムをどのように構築するかということです。つまり、セキュリティの問題ではなく、現金そのものとは異なる、退職のための真の資源が創出されることを保証する金融システムの仕組みの問題なのです。現金があるに越したことはないのですが、それは、退職金が支払われる時点で、退職金で現実の資源を購入できるように、現実の資源が創出されているという文脈でなければなりません(もちろん、退職金は現金です)。


そこで、個人退職金についてお聞きします。このビデオで、この公聴会で何が起こっているのか、教えてください。
)


K:
So it's funny because I also showed that clip in my class yesterday, my graduate students, and we deconstructed. And so I'm well equipped to do it again here. It's one of my favorites because, you know, Alan Greenspan, just to be clear. So everybody who's watching knows that that was Congressman Paul Ryan, right. Who became speaker of the House and former Fed Chair Alan Greenspan. So you would think maybe Alan Greenspan would know a little something about the monetary system and where money comes from, given the nature of the Federal Reserve. And it turns out he gave what I think was just about the perfect answer to this question, not, however, the answer that Paul Ryan desperately wanted, because Ryan was trying to toss him a softball and just really meant right. You heard him use the term personal retirement accounts at least four times I counted. And that's all he wanted. He wanted affirmation from Alan Greenspan that Social Security is in trouble. That it would make sense to move today gradually toward a system of personal retirement accounts. That's code for privatizing Social Security. And so don't you agree with me, Chairman Greenspan, that it's time to begin to take these steps? That's the question. And instead of agreeing, Alan Greenspan simply leans into the microphone and begins by taking off the table the question of affordability. He just takes it right off, he said. I wouldn't say that there's anything problematic with the system the way it's set up today, he said. And I quote, There's nothing to prevent the federal government from creating as much money as it wants and paying it to someone full stop. Okay. So what he's saying is you have benefits that are promised to future retirees, their dependents and the disabled. You're worried that you're not going to have the money to pay those benefits when they come due. Don't worry. This is Greenspan. Don't worry. The money is the easy part. The cash itself is the easy part. Then he goes on to say the really important part. He said, the question is, how do you set up a system which assures that the real assets are created, which those benefits are employed to purchase? Now, what does that mean? It means how do you know that when you mail those checks out, or more appropriately, when you digitally credit people's accounts and they have their Social Security benefits, how do you know in 10, 20, 30 years time that they're going to be able to turn around and spend that money into an economy that is productive enough, that is producing enough goods and services of the right mix, that they can buy things without having to compete with everyone else for a shrinking supply of real goods and services. Therefore, driving up wait for it inflation because that is public enemy number one for every central banker. And so what Greenspan was really doing was just explaining to Paul Ryan that it's inflation you have to watch out for not running out of money, not, you know, a trust fund that goes to zero. That's easy to deal with. It's inflation that we should be focused on.


ステファニー・ケルトンによる債務上限危機と社会保障

では債務上限危機に目を向けたいと思います 債務上限を引き上げるとどうなるかという この差し迫ったシナリオを どのように私たち全員に恐れさせたのでしょうか? 私たちは今までにそれをしたことがありますか?何度も何度も。1960 年以来 70 回以上。債務限度危機とそれをどのように見ているかについて少しお話しいただけますか? 

そうですね。私はそれを、それ自体が作り出した危機だと考えています。これは政治的な演劇ですが、今回は、これが実際にはある種の無実または無害であると考える十分な数の人々が議会にいる可能性を人々が非常に真剣に受け止め始めているという点に達しています。借金の上限を上げることを拒否するだけで、何もひどく悪いことは起こらないゲーム. どう説明したらいいのかわからない。ご存知のように、私たちはかなり深刻に感じ始める前にここにいました。そして、あなたのイントロで、ダウングレードに言及したビデオクリップを示したものへの言及がいくつかあったと思います。怒っている鳥。

ゾンビ。ええ、ええ、ええ。彼らは債務を格下げします。

まあ、それは前に起こりました。わかった。それは、住宅バブルが崩壊し、金融危機が発生した後に起こりました。私たちはもてあそびました。私たち議会のメンバーは、債務上限を十分にタイムリーに引き上げず、潜在的な債務不履行の危険を冒すという考えをいじくり回しました。そしてスタンダード アンド プアーズは米国債を AAA 格付けから格下げしました。そして、昨日、私はここストーニーブルックで大学院生に教えていて、その頃に行われていた会話のいくつかのクリップのビデオを見せました。話をした人の一人は ウォーレン・バフェットでした もちろん、億万長者の投資家、バークシャー・ハサウェイなど。ウォーレン・バフェットは、一体どうして S&P が米国債を格下げしているのかと言っていた。これでは何の意味もありません。そして彼は言った、これは彼の言葉であり、私のものではありません。彼は、米国政府はお金を印刷できると言いました。彼らは、債券保有者への元本の支払いに関心を持たなければならず、どこでお金を手に入れるかわからないという点があるとどのように考えているのでしょうか。つまり、彼はこれが非常識だと言っています。それは私たちの通貨です。そして彼は言った、彼らは彼に尋ねた、あなたは格下げに反対しますか? 彼はもちろん、ここオマハで言った、ネブラスカ州オマハのバークシャーだから、米国債は AAAA の格付けを持つだろうと彼は言った。私たちが言及したように、米国政府のいわゆる債務の有効性を疑う理由はありません。したがって、議員はこれを認識しています。彼らはそれを知っていると思います、ジェシカ。これで迷う事はないと思います。彼らは常に支払い能力があることを知っていると思います。ある朝、下院議員の一人がアーカンソー州出身の共和党員であるとテレビで言っているのを聞きました。しかし、彼は言った、しかし私がそれを好きな理由は、それがあなたがちょうど話していた種類のものを抽出しようとするためのレバレッジとして債務制限を使用できるこれらの瞬間を提示するからです.だいたい。SNAPのメリットを得るために、人々に余分な時間を見つけさせ、余分なフープやハードルを飛び越えさせます。たぶん、社会保障やメディケア、または何か他のことを強打する機会を得てください。私たちは、世界でおそらく 2 つの国のうちの 1 つです。しかし、ここにいます。ここにいます。

A:
あたかも誰もが、一般の人々がある種の内面化する知識感覚と真実感覚を構築することは、ある種の市場原理主義者を必要とする民営化を望む人々を獲得するための非常に効果的な政治的ツールであるかのようです。機能するための経済性が非常に効果的に使用されます。そして、そのレバレッジについて言えば、私たちが何度も耳にすることの1つは、共和党と多くの民主党員が率直に言って、私たちが「債務上限を引き上げるつもりなら、どこかから削減するので、それを行うだけです。社会保障はここでいつも出てきます。右。彼らはそれが壊れるだろうと言います。それは:それが溶剤のままになる方法はありません。そのため、民営化するか、資金を削減する方法を見つけなければなりませんでした。実際には簡単なクリップがあります。マイク、あなたも何度も使ったことのあるものをアップできますか。

したがって、個人の退職金口座を持つことは、将来の退職者の退職金をより安全にするもう 1 つの方法です。また、ソルベンシーのシステムの構成要素としての個人の退職金勘定が、ソルベンシーの改善に役立つと思いますか? 個人の退職金口座ポリシーがある場合、それは福利厚生を備えた会社だからです。その機能は実装されますか?個人の退職口座は、システムの支払い能力を達成し、将来の退職金をより安全にするのに役立つと思いますか? 

まあ、私は、連邦政府が望むだけのお金を作り、それを誰かに支払うことを妨げるものは何もないという意味で、pay as you goの利点が安全でないとは言いません. 問題は、実際の資産が作成され、それらの利益が購入に使用されることを保証するシステムをどのように設定するかです。つまり、これはセキュリティの問題ではなく、現金とは異なり、実際のリソースが退職のために作成されることを保証する金融システムの構造の問題です。現金自体です。あるのはいいけどね」s は、これらの利益が支払われるときに作成される実際のリソースのコンテキストにある必要があり、その利益で実際のリソースを購入できるようにする必要があります。これはもちろん現金です。

そこで、個人の退職金口座について聞いています。そのビデオで、その公聴会で何が起こっているのかを感じてください。

おもしろいことに、昨日のクラスで大学院生にもそのクリップを見せて、解体しました。そして、ここで再びそれを行う準備が整っています。はっきり言って、アラン・グリーンスパンだからです。ですから、見ている人なら誰でも、それが下院議員のポール・ライアンだったことを知っています。下院議長となり、元FRB議長のアラン・グリーンスパン。アラン・グリーンスパンなら、通貨制度やお金の出所について少しは知っていると思うかもしれません。連邦準備制度の性質を考えると。そして、彼はこの質問に対するほぼ完璧な答えであると私が思うものを与えたことが判明しましたが、ライアンがソフトボールを彼に投げようとしていて、本当に正しいことを意味していたので、ポール・ライアンが必死に望んでいた答えではありませんでした. あなたは、彼が私が数えた少なくとも 4 回、個人退職口座という用語を使用したと聞きました。そしてそれは彼が望んでいたすべてです。彼は、社会保障が問題を抱えているというアラン・グリーンスパンからの断言を求めていました。今日、個人の退職金口座のシステムに徐々に移行することは理にかなっています。それは社会保障を民営化するためのコードです。それで、グリーンスパン議長、これらの措置を講じる時が来たことに同意しませんか? それが問題です。そして、同意する代わりに、Alan Greenspan は単にマイクに寄りかかり、手頃な価格の問題をテーブルから外すことから始めます。彼はただそれをすぐに取り去る、と彼は言った。現在のシステムの設定方法に問題があるとは言いません、と彼は言いました。そして私は、連邦政府が望むだけのお金を生み出し、それを誰かに完全に支払うことを妨げるものは何もない. わかった。彼が言っているのは、将来の退職者、その扶養家族、障害者に約束された福利厚生があるということです。給付金の期限が来たら、その給付金を支払うお金がないのではないかと心配しています。心配しないで。グリーンスパンです。心配しないで。お金は簡単な部分です。現金自体は簡単な部分です。それから彼は本当に重要な部分を言い続けます。彼は言った、問題は、実物資産が作成され、それらの利益が購入に使用されることを保証するシステムをどのようにセットアップしますか? さて、それはどういう意味ですか?つまり、小切手を郵送するとき、またはより適切には、人々のアカウントにデジタルで入金し、社会保障給付を受けているとき、10年、20年、30年後に彼らがそのお金を好転させ、十分に生産的な経済、適切な組み合わせの十分な商品やサービスを生産する経済、実際の商品やサービスの供給の縮小を求めて他の人と競争する必要なく物を購入できる経済に費やすことができる. したがって、すべての中央銀行家にとってそれが最大の敵であるため、インフレを待ちます。グリーンスパンが実際に行っていたのは、ポール・ライアンに説明したことでした。ゼロになる信託基金ではなく、お金が不足しないように注意する必要があるのはインフレです。それは簡単に対処できます。注目すべきはインフレです。



0:02では
0:03債務上限の危機に目を向けたいと思います
0:08この差し迫ったシナリオを恐れて 0:08どのようにして私たち全員を恐怖に陥れた
のか 0:11債務上限を引き上げたら何が起こるのでしょうか? 
0:14そんなことしたことある?
0:16何度も何度も。
0:171960 年以来 70 回
以上
。
0:27そうですね。
0:28私はそれを、それ自体が作り出した危機だと考えています。
0:33これは政治的な演劇ですが、今回はポイントに達しました
0:38ご存知のように、人々は非常に真剣に受け止め始めていると思い
ます
0:48これは実際にはある種の罪のない、または良性のゲームだと思っている
人 0:53借金の上限を上げることを拒否するだけでよい
0:57ひどい悪いことは何も起こらない. 
1:01 どう説明したらいいのかわからない。
1:04 ご存じのように、私たちはかなり深刻に感じ始める前にここに来ました。
1:08イントロでいくつか言及していたと思います
が 
1:16アングリーバード。
1:18ゾンビ。
1:19ええ、ええ、ええ。
1:21 彼らは債務を格下げします。
1:22まあ、それは前に起こりました。わかった。
1:24それは、住宅バブルがはじけて金融危機が起こった後に起こりました。
1:29いじくり回しました。
1:31私たち議会のメンバーは、借金の
上限を適切な時期に引き上げず、潜在的な債務不履行のリスクを冒すという考えをもてあそびました。
1:41 そしてスタンダード アンド プアーズは米国債を
AAA 格付けから 1:44格下げしまし
た。
1:50そして、昨日、私はここ
ストーニーブルックで大学院生に教えていて 1:54ビデオクリップを見せました
その頃に行われていた会話の一部です 
2:01 話をした人の 1 人はウォーレン バフェットでした
。
2:08そしてウォーレン・バフェットはこう言っていまし
た
2:15国庫?これでは何の意味もありません。
2:18 彼は言った、「これは彼の言葉であって、私の言葉ではありません」。
2:20彼は、米国政府はお金を印刷できると言いました。
2:23彼らはどう思うでしょうか
2:24債券保有者への元本の支払いで利息を支払わなければならない時点があり、
どこでそのお金を手に入れたらよいかわかりません。
2:32 つまり、彼はこれは非常識だと言っているのです。
2:34それは私たちの通貨です。
2:36そして彼は言った、彼らは彼に尋ねた、あなたは格下げに反対ですか?
2:40 もちろん、彼はここオマハで言った、なぜなら
2:44 ネブラスカ州オマハのバークシャー、彼は米国債は
AAAA の格付けを持つだろうと言ったからです。
2:51米国の有効性を疑う理由はありません
2:57 政府のいわゆる債務です。
3:00議員はこれを認識しています。
3:03ジェシカ、彼らはそれを知っていると思います。
3:04これについて混乱があるとは思いません。
3:07彼らは、
いつでも支払う能力があることを 3:09常に知っていると思います。
3:12 下院議員の 1 人がテレビで
3:16 先日の朝、彼は共和党員だと言っているのを聞き
ました 3:19 アーカンソー州出身で、彼はこう言いました、これはまさに彼の言葉でし
た 
3:29しかし、彼は言った、しかし、私がそれを好きな理由は、彼
がそれを好きな理由は、それがこれらの瞬間を提示するからである
と説明し続けました。
3:43 今話していた種類のものを抽出しようとします。
3:46 SNAP 給付金を受け取るために、人々に余分な時間を見つけてもらい、
3:52 人々に余分なハードルを飛び越えさせ、
3:57 社会保障やメディケア、または
4:02または他の何か、 4:03ご存知のように、あなたがする必要のないことをする代わりに、1ポンド
の肉を手に入れてください。4:12 私たちは、世界でおそらく 2 つの国のうちの 1 つです。4:18でもここまで来ました。4:20 到着しました。4:21まるで知識の感覚を構築しているかのようです





4:24そして、誰もが、公共の種類の内面化する真実の感覚は、ある種の市場原理主義者を望む人々と、民営化を望む人々を獲得するため
の非常に効果的な政治的ツールです。機能するために非常に効果的に使用します。4:42 そして、そのレバレッジについて言えば、私たちが4:46 何度も何度も耳にすることの 1 つは、共和党と多くの民主党員が、4:51 率直に言って、債務上限を引き上げるつもりなら、 :55それなら他所からカットするからやるしかない。4:59 社会保障はここでよく出てきます。5:03そうですね。彼らはそれが壊れるだろうと言います。5:06それは: 溶剤のままでいる方法はありません。









5:09 それで、私たちはそれを民営化するか、資金を削減する方法を見つけなければなりませんでした。
5:13 実は簡単なクリップがあります。5:14Mike、あなたが何度も 5:17同じよう
に使用したものをアップできますか。


5:24したがって、個人の退職金口座を持つことは、将来の退職者の退職金をより安全にするもう 1 つの方法です。5:33 また、ソルベンシーのシステムの構成要素として、個人の退職金勘定がソルベンシーの向上に役立つと思いますか? 5:40なぜなら、5:41個人の退職金口座ポリシーを持っている場合、それは福利厚生を備えた会社だからです。5:45その機能は実装されますか? 5:46個人の退職金口座が支払い能力を達成するのに役立つと思いますか









5:50システムを改善し、将来の退職金をより安全にしますか? 
5:53ええと、
5:57pay as you goのメリットが
5:58安全でないとは言いません
.6:04連邦政府が
望むだけのお金を作成し、それを支払うことを妨げるものは何もない.誰か。
6:09問題は、 6:11実物資産が作成され、それらの利益が購入に使用されることを 6:14
保証するシステムをどのようにセットアップするかということです。6:23つまり、これはセキュリティの問題ではなく、6:28実際のリソースが退職のために作成されることを保証する金融システムの構造の問題です6:36現金とは異なり、現金そのものです。







6:39 あるのはいいことですが、
6:42実際のリソースのコンテキストにある必要があります
6:46その時点で作成されている 6:50これらの
特典は支払われるため
、 6:53特典付きの実際のリソースを購入できます。現金です。
7:04そこで、
7:04個人の退職金口座について聞いています。
7:07そのビデオで、その公聴会で何が起こっているのかを感じてください。
7:12 面白いのは、
昨日のクラスで 7:15 大学院生にこのクリップを見せたからです。
7:19 そして、ここで再びそれを行う準備が整いました。
7:23 これは私のお気に入りの 1 つです。
7:27だから、見ている人は誰でも、それが下院議員のポール・ライアンだったことを知っています。
7:32下院議長となり、元FRB議長のアラン・グリーンスパン。7:37ですから、アラン・グリーンスパンなら 7:41金融システムやお金がどこから来るのか7:44連邦準備制度の性質を考えると 7:41
少しは知っていると思うかもしれません。7:46 そして、彼は私が思うに7:48 はこの質問に対するほぼ完璧な答えでしたが、7:52 しかし、ポール・ライアンが必死に望んでいた答えではありませんでした。本当に正しいことを意味しました。7:59あなたは彼が8:01私が数えた少なくとも4回は個人退職口座という言葉を使っているのを聞いた. 8:05そして、それが彼が望んでいたすべてです。8:06彼は、社会保障が問題を抱えているというアラン・グリーンスパンからの確認を求めていました。










8:11 今日
8:15 個人退職口座のシステムに徐々に移行することは理にかなっているでしょう。
8:18これは社会保障を民営化するためのコードです。
8:22そして、グリーンスパン議長、
8:25これらの措置を講じ始める時が来たことに同意しませんか? 
8:27それが質問です。
8:29そして、同意する代わりに、アラン・グリーンスパンは単にマイクに寄りかかって
8:33、手頃な価格の問題をテーブルから外すことから始めます。
8:38彼はただそれを脱ぐだけだと彼は言った。
8:42
今日のシステムのセットアップ方法に8:45問題があるとは言いません、と彼は言いました。
8:48引用します 連邦政府を妨げるものは何もありません
8:51好きなだけお金を作り、誰かに全額を支払うことから。
8:57わかりました。
8:58つまり、彼が言っているのは、将来の
退職者、その扶養家族、障害者に約束された利益があるということです。
9:07
給付金の期限が来たら 9:09給付金を支払うお金がないのではないかと心配しています。
9:11心配しないでください。
9:12 グリーンスパンです。
9:13心配しないでください。
9:13 お金は簡単な部分です。
9:15 現金自体は簡単な部分です。
9:18 それから彼は本当に重要な部分を言い続けます。
9:21彼は言った、問題は、どのようにシステムを設定するか
ということです。

9:32さて、それはどういう意味ですか? 
9:33それは、あなたがそれらの小切手を郵送するとき、
9:38またはより適切には、人々の口座にデジタルで入金するとき、
9:42彼らが社会保障給付を受けていることをどうやって知ることができるかを意味します
.9:46in 10, 20, 30彼らが
9:50好転し、そのお金を十分に生産的な経済に費やすことができるようになる
9:55 適切な組み合わせの十分な商品やサービスを生産している
9:59
本物の商品やサービスの供給が減るのを 10:03 他の人と競争することです。
10:08したがって、上昇はインフレを待ちます
10:12これは、すべての中央銀行にとって最大の敵です。
10:16 そして、グリーンスパンが実際に行っていたことは、ポール・ライアンに
10:21 気をつけなければならないのはインフレであり
、 10:24 お金がなくなるのではなく、信託基金がゼロになるのではないと説明しただけです。
10:29対処は簡単です。
10:31注目すべきはインフレです。

0:02So I want to turn to
0:03the debt ceiling crisis, how they've made all of us
0:08afraid of this looming scenario
0:11where what's going to happen if we raise the debt limit?
0:14Have we ever done that before?
0:16Many, many times.
0:17Over 70 times since 1960.
0:21Can you talk a little bit about just the debt
0:24limit crisis and how you see it?
0:27Well, sure.
0:28I see it as a crisis of its own making.
0:33It's political theater, but this time it's gotten to the point
0:38that you know, people are starting to, I think, take very seriously
0:43the possibility that you might well have enough people in Congress
0:48who think that this is actually some sort of innocent or benign game
0:53that you can just refuse to raise the debt limit
0:57and nothing terribly bad will happen.
1:01I don't know how to explain it.
1:04You know, we've been here before where it started to feel pretty serious.
1:08And I think in your intro, you had some references to
1:12what did you show a video clip that referenced, you know, downgrading.
1:16The Angry Birds.
1:18The zombies.
1:19Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:21They'll downgrade the debt.
1:22Well, that happened before. Okay.
1:24That happened after the housing bubble burst and the financial crisis.
1:29We toyed around.
1:31We -- members of Congress -- toyed around with the idea of not raising the debt
1:36ceiling limit in a timely enough fashion and risking a potential default.
1:41And Standard and Poor's downgraded U.S.
1:44Treasuries from a AAA rating, which is the highest
1:47that you can have to one notch below.
1:50And, you know, yesterday I was teaching my graduate students
1:54here at Stony Brook, and I showed a video of a clip,
1:57of some of the conversations that were going on around that time.
2:01And one of the people who spoke was Warren Buffett, who's, of course,
2:05billionaire investor Berkshire Hathaway and so forth.
2:08And Warren Buffett was saying,
2:11how on earth is S&P downgrading U.S.
2:15Treasuries? This makes no sense whatsoever.
2:18And he said, these are his words, not mine.
2:20He said the U.S. government can print money.
2:23What do they think
2:24there's going to be a point at which, you know, you have to make interest
2:28in principal payments to bondholders and you don't know where to get the money.
2:32I mean, he's saying this is insane.
2:34It's our currency.
2:36And he said, they asked him, do you disagree then with the downgrade?
2:40He said, of course, he said in here in Omaha, because
2:44Berkshire in Omaha, Nebraska, he said the U.S.
2:47treasuries would have a AAAA rating.
2:51There is no reason to question the validity of the of the U.S.
2:57government so-called debt, as we've referred to it.
3:00So lawmakers recognize this.
3:03I think they know it, Jessica.
3:04I don't think there's confusion about this.
3:07I think that they know that there's
3:09always that they always have the ability to pay.
3:12I heard one member of the House on television
3:16the other morning say he is a Republican
3:19from Arkansas, and he said, these were his exact words,
3:24He said the debt ceiling is an anachronism financially.
3:29But he said, but the reason I like it And then he went on to explain that
3:35the reason he likes it is because it presents these moments
3:39where you can use the debt limit as leverage
3:43to try to extract the kinds of things you were just talking about.
3:46Make people go try to find extra hours in order to get their SNAP benefits,
3:52make people jump through extra hoops and and hurdles and, you know,
3:57get an opportunity maybe to take a whack at Social Security and Medicare or
4:02or something else,
4:03you know, get your pound of flesh in exchange for doing something that you
4:08aught not even have to do because we shouldn't have the damn thing.
4:12We're one of maybe two countries in the world that even has a debt limit. So
4:18but here we are.
4:20Here we are.

A:
4:21It's almost as if constructing a sense of knowledge
4:24and a sense of truth that everybody, the public kind of internalizes
4:28is as a very effective political tool to win the kinds of things that those
4:34that want to privatize that those that want some kind of market fundamentalist
4:38economy to function use very effectively.
4:42And speaking of that leverage, one of the things we hear over
4:46and over again is that if the GOP and many Democrats,
4:51quite frankly, will sometimes argue that if we're going to raise the debt ceiling,
4:55then we'll only do it because we will cut it from somewhere else.
4:59Social Security comes up all the time here.
5:03Right. They say it's going to go broke.
5:06It's: there's no way that it's going to stay solvent.
5:09And so we got to find a way to privatize it or cut funding.
5:13We actually have a quick clip.
5:14Mike, can we can we get that up of one that you've used
5:17as well many times.


5:24So having personal retirement accounts is another way
5:28of making a future Retiree benefits more secure for their retirement.
5:33And also, do you believe that personal retirement accounts
5:36as a component to a system of solvency does help improve solvency?
5:40Because when you
5:41have a personal retirement account policy, it it's a company with a benefit offset.
5:45Would that feature in place?
5:46Do you believe that personal retirement accounts can help us achieve solvency
5:50for the system and make those future retiree benefits more secure?
5:53Well, I wouldn't say that the
5:57pay as you go benefits are
5:58insecure in the sense that,
6:04there's nothing to prevent the federal government
6:06from creating as much money as it wants and paying it to somebody.
6:09The question is,
6:11how do you set up a system which assures
6:14that the real assets
6:17are created, which those benefits
6:20are employed to purchase?
6:23So it's not a question of security, it's a question of the structure
6:28of a financial system which ensures that the real resources
6:33are created for retirement
6:36as distinct from the cash, the cash itself.
6:39It's nice to have, but
6:42it's got to be in the context of the real resources
6:46being created at the time
6:50those benefits are paid so that you can purchase
6:53real resources with the benefits, which of course are cash.

7:04So we're
7:04hearing about personal retirement accounts.
7:07Give us give us a sense of what's going on at that hearing in that video.


7:12So it's funny because I also showed that clip
7:15in my class yesterday, my graduate students, and we deconstructed.
7:19And so I'm well equipped to do it again here.
7:23It's one of my favorites because, you know, Alan Greenspan, just to be clear.
7:27So everybody who's watching knows that that was Congressman Paul Ryan, right.
7:32Who became speaker of the House and former Fed Chair Alan Greenspan.
7:37So you would think maybe Alan Greenspan would know a little something about
7:41the monetary system and where money comes from,
7:44given the nature of the Federal Reserve.
7:46And it turns out he gave what I think
7:48was just about the perfect answer to this question, not,
7:52however, the answer that Paul Ryan desperately wanted,
7:55because Ryan was trying to toss him a softball and just really meant right.
7:59You heard him use the term
8:01personal retirement accounts at least four times I counted.
8:05And that's all he wanted.
8:06He wanted affirmation from Alan Greenspan that Social Security is in trouble.
8:11That it would make sense to move today
8:15gradually toward a system of personal retirement accounts.
8:18That's code for privatizing Social Security.
8:22And so don't you agree with me, Chairman Greenspan,
8:25that it's time to begin to take these steps?
8:27That's the question.
8:29And instead of agreeing, Alan Greenspan simply leans into the microphone
8:33and begins by taking off the table the question of affordability.
8:38He just takes it right off, he said.
8:42I wouldn't say that there's anything
8:45problematic with the system the way it's set up today, he said.
8:48And I quote, There's nothing to prevent the federal government
8:51from creating as much money as it wants and paying it to someone full stop.
8:57Okay.
8:58So what he's saying is you have benefits that are promised to future
9:04retirees, their dependents and the disabled.
9:07You're worried that you're not going to have the money
9:09to pay those benefits when they come due.
9:11Don't worry.
9:12This is Greenspan.
9:13Don't worry.
9:13The money is the easy part.
9:15The cash itself is the easy part.
9:18Then he goes on to say the really important part.
9:21He said, the question is, how do you set up a system
9:25which assures that the real assets
9:28are created, which those benefits are employed to purchase?
9:32Now, what does that mean?
9:33It means how do you know that when you mail those checks out,
9:38or more appropriately, when you digitally credit people's accounts
9:42and they have their Social Security benefits, how do you know
9:46in 10, 20, 30 years time that they're going to be able to turn around
9:50and spend that money into an economy that is productive enough,
9:55that is producing enough goods and services of the right mix,
9:59that they can buy things without having to compete
10:03with everyone else for a shrinking supply of real goods and services.
10:08Therefore, driving up wait for it inflation
10:12because that is public enemy number one for every central banker.
10:16And so what Greenspan was really doing was just explaining to Paul Ryan
10:21that it's inflation you have to watch out for
10:24not running out of money, not, you know, a trust fund that goes to zero.
10:29That's easy to deal with.
10:31It's inflation that we should be focused on.