文字起こし
[Music]
economists would argue that debt is
basically a tax on the poor and I just
kind of wanted to know what you know
from an economists standpoint why that
isn't right and you know maybe relatedly
why fiscal policy that involves creating
large amounts of debt wouldn't you know
usually that would create inflation and
inflation we think of as hurting the
poor more than the rich because the poor
have less money to actually buy things
why why why is this not a system that
would hurt the poor more rather than
less well it's so let's I think
recognize that you can write a budget
that results in a deficit that vastly
improves life for the broad majority
including the poor or you can write a
budget that generates the same deficit
in absolute terms but serves a very
different constituency right benefits a
very different constituency in other
words not all deficits are going to be
created equal even if they result in the
same addition to the national debt and
so forth so I just wonder if it might be
OK for me to just very quickly make
clear to everybody who's with us tonight
what the deficit actually is because
that'll be helpful people don't know or
they conflate the deficit with the debt
and so I like to try to you know define
my terms and maybe even with a simple
example like I do in the book so we've
been taught to have a visceral reaction
to the idea of government having a
fiscal deficit say oh my god that's
evidence of you know mismanaging the
nation's finances you've done something
wrong if the budget ends up in deficit
that's not true at all we shouldn't
think like that so a government deficit
simply means that the government is
spending more dollars into the economy
then it is subtracting away mainly by
taxing okay so if the government spends
$100 into the Canadian economy and it
only taxes $90 out of people's hands
then by definition it has left $10
somewhere in the economy so now we start
getting to your question right who's
benefiting from that deposit because
every deficit is good for someone the
government deficit is a is nothing more
than a financial contribution it is a
dollar contribution being made to some
other part of the economy the question
is for whom and for what purpose right
what is the deficit doing so now let's
do the borrowing part so so far let's
say the government spends a hundred in
hiring people to repair infrastructure
build you know modernize upgrade green
infrastructure whatever the case is so
you pay those folks now some people lost
their dollars because ninety two dollars
were taxed away but you left ten extra
dollars in somebody's hands somebody's
got that those dollars now they're gonna
travel around the economy there's people
are gonna spend them and then they're
gonna fall into somebody else's hands
and then they can spend them and so
forth right but when the government runs
a deficit it typically coordinates its
deficit spending with bonds sales so now
watch what I do
I spend a hundred dollars into the
economy I tax ninety dollars back out
I've made a ten dollar deposit only now
I say well I ran a deficit so I'm going
to match up my deficit spending with
what we call borrowing and I'm gonna
sell government bonds so I've got ten
government bonds now I take the ten
dollars back out of the economy and I
replace those ten dollars with
government bonds which are interest
bearing currency okay that's an
interest-bearing form of canadian
dollars now I've chopped up somebody's
bank account I've taken away your
non-interest bearing currency I gave you
currency that pays interest so now
somebody's kind of lucky right because
they have a reward they have an interest
payment coming to them without needing
to take on risk because it's a risk-free
asset so this is where the question of
the borrowing and the debt becomes
interesting because who holds those
bonds they're getting an interest
payment and if you're wealthy and you're
able to invest significantly in
government bonds and those bonds happen
to pay high rates of interest over time
well it's a very nice subsidy to you but
again there's no inherent reason that
the deficit has to result in you no ill
effects for lower-income people and only
benefit higher income people it depends
on the kind of deficit you're running
[Music]
英語 (自動生成)
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿