kelton How MMT Can Help Us Understand the Economy
2019/10/08
https://youtu.be/QwbDETx3zo0
文字起こし
I think unless you've been living under
a rock over the last year or so you've
probably heard in the news a lot of
debate and discussion about modern
monetary theory prior a lot of it
he's been caricature as like other
people would just say print the money
they kind of do but also so it's also
kind of cured caricatured anyway tonight
we have with us the person who I think
has done more than anyone else these
these days to be a proponent and an
advocate and a voice for mmt and that is
a stephanie kelton she is a professor at
Stony Brook she's also an economic
adviser to the Bernie Sanders campaign
and in addition to talking a little bit
about what mmt is we're going to get her
perspective on the state the economy and
economics right now because we live in
interesting times large deficits by
historical standards very low interest
rates by historical standards and yet
things aren't working we're not having
inflation like people would have
expected wage growth has been poor GDP
growth across the developed world very
mediocre since the crisis so I won't
know you know economists are scratching
their head so looking forward to hearing
how a mmt economist examines some of
these puzzles of modern economic life so
I'm Stephanie Kelly
[Applause]
whoops I'm great I'm breaking stuff what
are you saying when people say that
about mmt like oh yeah just print the
money well you just said it I'm out of
here what do I say I don't know what
else to say except you know what we've
been saying for now two decades and I
thought it just started in the last
couple years you guys have been at it
for a while we've been at it for a
little while and as far as I can tell
none of us has ever said mmm tea is
about you know printing the money but it
gets short-handed that way and it's like
nails on a chalkboard every time I do an
interview now I sit down and I say okay
we're gonna do this on the understanding
that you're not gonna run a story that
says mm T's about printing money until
we do the interview and the headline
reads economists says print more money
you know okay I'm nothing I can do I'm
gonna take the bait in that case what is
mm tea about and why has it suddenly
sort of exploded into maybe not entirely
the public consciousness but certainly
this demographic well it's like the
impossible question to say you know what
is mm tea about because it's it's a
group project that started more than two
decades ago with maybe a half a dozen
economists in the early years producing
scholarship on questions from you know
the eurozone to trade to Social Security
to government financed it deficits to
the you know I mean it's this enormous
project so there's no way to just say
this is what mmm tea is and like a you
know a soundbite but I think most people
when they think of mm tea they think of
it as an analytic framework so it's a
Mac where macro economist so it's an
analytic framework that tries to update
the lens through which we understand the
monetary system and the policy options
that are available I guess in the post
Bretton Woods post gold standard era and
so we're basically saying look there's
policy space that has opened up around
us since we have gone off of the gold
standard or fixed exchange rates and
we're not taking full advantage of that
space we could be
doing better and so we're trying to you
know shine a light on some of those
things so what was the impetus when when
this first started was it that something
has changed about either the financial
system or the economy and we want to
understand the existing world better or
was it the policy prescription that you
were after because I think nowadays lots
of people here mmt they think full
employment they think universal health
care that sort of thing which was the
inspiration behind I don't think it was
either actually I mean I think back to
you know when I started training as an
economist from undergrad to graduate
school it was the mid-90s and you know
there were already different schools of
thought out there the post-keynesian
were saying very different things from
more mainstream types of economists and
especially when it came to the financial
system to banking and finance and those
sort of questions so we were always kind
of agitated by the way that mainstream
economists describe how finance works in
particular so we had a different
narrative set up from the very beginning
but then you know with mmt I think it
started evolving as we started to think
differently about the role of taxes and
the relationship between money and taxes
and state finance and it kind of opened
up around the question of launching the
Euro I think really because we were
looking at countries that were making a
decision to abandon their currencies and
adopt a common currency and that's sort
of I think sparked the broader interest
so you mentioned that essentially it's
an analytical framework and as I
mentioned in the intro I think where
people would agree we're at a moment
where a lot of people feel unsatisfied
with the existing answers that
economists have given or that mainstream
economists have given on things like the
recovery why hasn't growth been faster
why hasn't inflation picked up just
despite cutting rates and these trillion
dollar deficits what's your answer to
that what is the let's start with that
why hasn't inflation picked up despite
all these things that economists would
have said oh yeah
they cause inflation well I think the
models are too mechanistic and they lead
us to too simple and understanding of
really complex phenomenon like inflation
and so if you're trained like I was
maybe in the early years to think that
you know money is inflation is something
that happens when you print too much
money or you know the Milton Friedman
inflation is always in everywhere a
monetary phenomenon so if you seek
central bank's doing things like QE
and people say quantitative easing is
printing money and printing money leads
to inflation then we all come to expect
that if you believe that inflation
automatically picks up because the labor
market gets tight and your market your
model tells you that tight labor markets
working through a phillips curve sort of
relationship lead to pressure on wages
that then lead to increased price it's
basically that the models are too simple
and we have too much faith in them well
actually on that point because I get the
logic of this idea that ok unemployment
Falls and then workers have more
borrowing bargaining power and then that
leads to higher wages and then they have
more you know more purchasing power and
so on what is the conceptual flow
because we haven't even really seen
robust wage growth by any stretch even
though the unemployment rate is below 4%
so just like breaking it down like why
does even the most simple seemingly
logical idea that low unemployment would
have all these positive effects on
prices why does that not even seem to be
work well I think most of it has to do
with one key phrase that you just use
which is bargaining power and how is
bargaining power exercised the reunions
and what's happened to unions over the
course of the last 30 years
I mean they've mostly been decimated so
it's pretty hard to tell a rational
story about how even as the labor market
tightens workers are supposed to
exercise the power in the negotiating
process if they don't have union
representation what are they supposed to
do walk in and just sit down with the
boss kick their feet up on the table and
say I'm here for the raise you know
labor markets tight let's go it's just
not there the the the mechanisms aren't
in place for that to happen for for huge
swaths of the American workforce so
here's one thing I sometimes
but if everyone in the u.s. at least
woke up tomorrow and accepted mmt as the
analytical framework for the economy
what would change like what would that
world look like and what would that
change from the current scenario
actually tell us about what's wrong with
the way we think about economics I mean
honestly I think the biggest thing that
changes is the conversation that we have
I mean if if we had a better set of
lenses and we were able to see more
clearly you know the nature of the space
around us the monetary system the way it
works I just think that a lot of the
questions we asked today and a lot of
the things that we presume stand in the
way of you know Congress passing
legislation that would do something more
ambitious like what we can't because
trillion-dollar deficits or we can't
because China has all this debt or we
can't because look what happened to
Greece or we can't get right at least
that would go away and then we would
have a very different conversation even
the tax cuts right if we were looking
through an mmt lens and we said the
Republicans are looking to do between a
trillion and a half or two trillion
depending on how you want to cost it out
in tax cuts instead of saying we can't
afford it it'll blow a hole in the
budget and all this kind of stuff we
would have a different conversation it
would be about you know the presumed
effectiveness in terms of job creation
and the potential inflation risk in an
economy that may or may not be closer to
full employment so I just think you know
Social Security are we really gonna have
a conversation about the government's
ability to keep its promise to future
retirees their dependents and the
disabled if we're not afraid of running
out of money then the conversation
changes that it becomes about
demographics and inflation risk and I
just think we have a richer more
substantive national debate than this
you know
arbitrary frivolous conversation about
you know entitlements driving us into a
death crisis which is know as I
mentioned ensure you are on one of the
teams in the primary and you met
speaking of like the sound of like
screeching chalkboards how much does it
hurt you when you hear Democratic
candidates blast the tax cuts on the
grounds that it blew out the deficit it
would it does but I haven't heard that
much of it and I'm encouraged you know
way it's funny joke because what I hear
Democrat
saying is that they would like to repeal
all or much of the Republican tax cuts
not because they blew a hole in the
deficit we got to repair that damage but
because they want to use those tax cuts
to quote pay for something else in other
words it's the same as saying I want to
use the deficit to build infrastructure
it's no different it's tantamount to
saying I want to keep the deficit but I
want to direct it toward some other aim
right I mean so even though we have some
Democrats complaining about Republicans
expanding the deficit for very specific
purposes there are quite a few high
profile Democrats who seem to be
embracing mmt whereas Republicans who
actually have a de facto history of
loads of embracing mmt haven't done that
why do you think that is
you mean openly invoking No so they'll
expand the deficit for their pet
projects in a sort of mmt way but they
don't seem to embrace the theory in the
way that some Democrats well it's better
to embrace it actively than to embrace
it rhetorically so I guess it's some
sense you know it's more encouraging to
see someone pushing through an agenda
that doesn't hew to the hysteria around
debt and deficits is this my preferred
set of policies no but you know it's not
as if it's encouraging just because a
few Democrats have invoked mmt because
at the same time you know the Speaker of
the House has reinstated pay-go
and that's not terribly encouraging if
you're looking at the potential to take
the House and the Senate and then move
ambitious progressive legislation you're
not going to do it in an environment in
which Pago is in place which is a rule
that exists in the House of
Representatives today that says you
can't add to the deficit so everything
has to be deficit-neutral so I mean it's
it's good and bad it's there's progress
for sure being made now one of the
policy agendas that's likely to be on
the plate of a theoretical Democratic
administration particularly if it's of
the more progressive weighing or of it
if it is Bernie would be a green new
deal and something that you hear people
say is
some people how can we afford it and the
response is often well you know we
didn't ask that question we didn't we
didn't choose to fight the world war is
based on whether we could afford to we
figured out a way to do it so what are
the lessons from the wars and I mean I
think Keynes wrote a pamphlet how to pay
for the war that applied today towards
something as ambitious as a green new
deal yeah I I mean I think that Keynes
is little book which was called how to
pay for the war that's literally the
title of the little pamphlet and you
would think just based on a name of it
that this must be a book about where to
get all the money to finance world war
two and this is Keynes was British
economist of course so this was you know
advice for the British government and it
turns out you read this thing and has
nothing to do with where the British
government is going to get all the money
to finance the war effort it's about
understanding that this is going to be a
massive endeavor that it's going to
involve transforming the economy away
from one that's oriented around
producing for the consumer to one that's
oriented around winning the war right
transforming the entire economy and
Keynes was mindful of the inflation
risks because the government was gonna
have to ramp spending way up and in
order to do that it was going to have to
take resources away from other uses and
so you're elbowing out the private
sector in order to bring people and
industries into public service and to
orient you know for the war effort
so the whole book is about how to do
that in a way that avoids to the extent
possible creating an inflation problem
it turns out it was really effective it
was a very careful analysis of how to
allow the government to spend into the
economy while removing enough purchasing
power strategically right it was really
important to Keynes that removed the
purchasing power from the right hands
because if you remove purchasing power
from the wrong hands you might not do
much to mitigate the inflation risk in
other words if all you do is tax the
very richest people who weren't gonna
spend much of that money in the first
place then you run the risk of a real
inflation problem so he understood that
this had to be done really strategically
so with a green new deal
same thing right the same principle
applies if you're gonna do something
that is truly transformative that you're
not just talking about transforming the
way we deliver energy but the way we
build housing and transportation and the
way we deal with food production
agriculture you're gonna touch nearly
every piece of the US economy and so the
lesson is to look back at what Keynes
told us and to figure out if you're
gonna go that big and you're gonna make
that kind of investment in the US
economy over a short period of time 10
years or so right that there are
important lessons to learn from what
Keynes was doing in that little pamphlet
and inflation is the major risk not
bankruptcy or financing so this sort of
connects with one of the criticisms that
you often hear about mmt which is it's
actually not that different to
Keynesianism in various ways how would
you respond to that how would you lay
out the differences explicitly well I
think there are a lot of them and you're
right I mean there are examples like the
one I just gave where I'm saying
basically when it comes to the green New
Deal listen to Keynes
okay that was about inflation risk but
there are very substantive differences
between the way that we analyze some big
questions and the way that some headline
Keynesian I mean I don't know how much I
want to pick on certain people and give
specific examples I was a contributor at
Bloomberg for a period of time I got
into a little back-and-forth with Paul
Krugman we traded some columns him in
the New York Times me writing for
Bloomberg and there we teased out I
think some of the important differences
I mean you know the conventional
Keynesian models tell you that deficits
are supposed to drive interest rates up
that's the way it works in normal times
and that when the government increases
its deficit asked increased borrowing
and as it borrows more that gobbles up
private savings that are no longer
available to finance private investment
leaving companies with fewer resources
to invest and so investment goes down
and his investment goes down you get a
slower growing more lethargic economy
mmt this is just one example but mmt
says no no no hang on deficits don't
gobble up savings they augment savings
if the government spent
a hundred dollars into the economy and
only taxes $90 back out we label that a
government deficit but what we forget is
that I just deposited $10 into some part
of the economy my deficit if I'm
government I'm Uncle Sam my deficit
becomes a surplus in some other part of
the economy so from the very beginning
of this crowding out story we're
deficits become the villains of progress
in the economy mmt says no no hang on
you're getting it wrong from that very
first step right deficits add to savings
and then we could go on about the
relationship between interest rates and
investment they think that they are
obviously inversely related we say
interest rates are policy variable not
something determined by market forces or
at least they always can be so they're
just we go on and on another thing that
people say about mmt is that like well
yeah sure because the u.s. is the
world's reserve currency so the US has a
lot of policy flexibility other
countries don't have it but I don't know
how much you were paying attention we
were talking about Argentina what is the
sort of mmt if you were you know if ma
pre had brought in you instead of the
IMF and said what should I do to make my
economy more stable what if what would
have been the mmm tears advice well I
mean I think the last discussion was was
really good and very much on point in
many ways in the sense that to the
extent that you're able to avoid doing
so you should avoid borrowing in a
foreign currency and not every country
has the capacity to unilaterally just
say I am NOT going to the international
markets at all I'm only borrowing in my
own currency some countries can't do
that but Argentina could do less of that
and that would be advisable for first
start yeah I mean obviously the the
reserve currency status gives us an
additional degree of freedom there is
you know an extra benefit to being the
world's reserve currency but you know I
was just in Japan not too long ago and
yeah there was a controversy about that
okay I don't know if that's not okay
that's Matt right now I'm not the oxygen
it's on the Internet but but there's a
country that is not the world's reserve
currency that has a debt to GDP ratio if
you go grouse terms of like two hundred
and forty percent right and I go over
there and the biggest question I got
from all of Japanese press everyone I
talked to how do we get inflation what
can we do to cause inflation like
they're desperate to create inflation
their debt ratio is the you know highest
in the world interest rates are right
where the Bank of Japan puts them at
very low inflation slow it's just you
know wait before you go I'm not gonna
say I know we're not gonna get into the
controversy but for those curious there
I discovered through learning about this
there is a libertarian caucus within the
Democratic Socialist of America I didn't
know that either but if you google some
of those key words together you'll
figure out what's going on I had no idea
Tracy
well now I've completely forgotten what
I was about to ask now I just want to
know about the caucus on the topic well
actually I was going to ask about some
of the chaos that we've seen in money
markets this week and part of that was
said to have been caused by this ramp up
in T bill issuance by the government
which sort of bled through into money
markets I guess I'm curious how much
does MMT sort of reflect on the existing
banking system and regulations when it
comes to gauging its own impact oh I
mean I mean I think that the if you ask
me what's the greatest strength of mmt
you know I'll be a little bit brazen
here I think we've gotten all the big
stuff right there's nothing that has
been major that we've gotten wrong
nothing
III think it's an a pretty impeccable
record and I think the strength is that
we have a superior understanding of
monetary operations and that is we dig
deep into the weeds on some of this
stuff monetary operations that other
people kind of superficially understand
but mmm tears are really in the wheat so
you're both very on Twitter very online
and you probably saw some of the
conversation from the folks in the MMT
community nathan is sitting over there
scott full Weiler
Rowen gray these guys were tweeting out
you know I was trying to write a book
and so trying as much as possible not to
get too involved in what was happening
with you know financial markets in the
last couple of days and fed
interventions and so forth but these
guys were all over it in a deep way and
yeah we have a DM group that we were all
going back and forth and trying in real
time to you know make full sense of it
because it's very much in the weeds
well more generally so we don't you know
get to in the weeds on the operations
and money markets and the repo markets
which I don't even understand myself
just generally speaking what is it what
do you make of like sort of mainstream
Fed policy do rate cuts stimulate the
economy it depends it depends where you
are and and in which cycle I think I
mean right now we've embarked on yet
another cutting cycle we don't know how
long it's gonna be but since the summer
the Fed for the first time since before
the crisis is cut again twice now is
that the kind of action that you think
could have a positive impact on the
economy no I mean not much it it's
unlikely to do a lot of harm if war and
Mosler we're sitting here he'd say
they've got the brake and the gas pedals
mixed up in other words Warren has for a
long time this is a sort of founding
father of mmt so for those that aren't
familiar with the name Warren actually
makes the argument and I think Randy Ray
does as well it's a pretty compelling
argument if you actually do I wrote a
paper on this when I was a lot younger
and published it and there's some
empirical support for the idea that
central banks when they raise interest
rates they think they're tightening when
they cut interest rates they think
they're easing they think it stimulates
the economy to lower rates but in some
countries where the debt is very large
interest is somebody's income right
bondholders receive interest as income
and raising rates as bonds are rolled
over and interest rates are going up is
tantamount to fiscal expansion in other
words it's an increase in income right
interest income so there is the
possibility that raising interest rates
has a stimulative effect now against
that
obviously credit becomes more expensive
so interest-sensitive sectors like home
buying and durable goods like
automobiles and stuff maybe people
borrow less to buy a home or a car in an
environment in which interest rates are
rising but to think that this one price
in the entire US economy the overnight
interest rate the feds policy tool one
price that if they just move it 25 basis
points here in 25 basis points there
that they can steer this enormous
economic ship called the United States
economy is pretty much a stretch for me
so but that's it that's what we believe
that's what he Congress believe right
the Fed the dual mandate song it will go
through your head tonight right the doom
and the feds got into a mandate and
they're supposed to use this one price
and make these modest adjustments to
bring about you know a broad equilibrium
in the economy where we get low
inflation and high levels of employment
and growth so one thing we're hearing a
lot about now to the point where it's
becoming cliche is that fiscal policy is
the new monetary and Joe and I heard
this several times today alone it is
that the right direction or do you worry
that we're just going to assume that any
form of fiscal stimulus is going to be
the the panacea that we've been seeking
well I think that you know this is
textbook stuff right there are two
levers if you're doing macroeconomic
policy you you either pull the monetary
policy lever which is conventional
policy it's tweaking the interest rate
or you pull the fiscal policy lever and
that's taxes and government spending and
for the last 30 years we have leaned
extremely heavily on central bank's not
just here in the US but around the world
right the central banks were the only
game in town fiscal policy is that thing
that sits behind the glass with the
break in case of emergency cover on it
and central banks are supposed to to
steer economies right and that hasn't
worked all that well for 30 years you
know Larry Summers says the last three
expansions in the US were bubble driven
I mean all three right the left from the
savings alone to the
subprime to the.com in the 1990 so
that's kind of how we do it and now
everybody's sort of waking up to this
idea that there's another lever that we
we have to become more reliant upon but
does that mean that any fiscal policy is
good fiscal policy and it all has good
effects no you know it's got to be
targeted and just have a few moments
left but I think this is one of the main
things they say yeah it makes sense that
fiscal policy makers should run the show
more often in terms of demand management
but then they look at what that means
and no one actually looks at DC right
now and think oh this is a Congress that
is capable of working with the president
that could deliver anything meaningful
in any period of time or timely manner
that seems like a real problem just from
a practical standpoint that it's all
nice to say that fiscal policy is the
lever that should be pulled but that
applies politics for better or worse is
there how do you address that concern
that it's like okay maybe monetary
policy is not that effective but at
least they could do something well so I
know how I I would address it by putting
it on automatic pilot to a large extent
in other words take the responsibility
away from Congress to act in real time
to make smart decisions with tax policy
and spending and to do that through a
federal job guarantee which is to say
that in the last downturn you know we
were losing 800,000 jobs a month at the
height of the Great Recession
and if we had had something in place a
program in place to absorb workers into
employment instead of allowing them to
fall into unemployment it would have
provided a cushion for the economy to
recover more quickly so you know Janet
Yellen several years ago at Jackson Hole
the big meeting that takes place between
fed officials and invited academics and
others she said we need to strengthen
the automatic stabilizers we need better
automatic stabilizers and a federal job
guarantee is like turbocharging the
automatic stabilizers we have today and
that's what I would do stephanie kelton
thank you very much
so long we've tried a bunch of time sex
should get you to come on the podcast
itself something glad we finally I made
it happen I'm glad to thank you for
having me
[Applause]
英語 (自動生成)
How MMT Can Help Us Understand the Economy
34,256 回視聴•2019/10/07
695
89
共有
保存
Bloomberg Markets and Finance
チャンネル登録者数 86.9万人
チャンネル登録
On September 19, 2019, Odd Lots hosted its first-ever live event at the WNYC Greene Space in downtown New York City. With an all-star lineup of guests, the show featured convicted white-collar criminal Sam Antar, a panel on sovereign debt with Lee Buccheit and Brad Setser, and a discussion on MMT with Stephanie Kelton. We even had a surprise guest, SPY kid Kevin McGrath, not to mention two musical acts: country-singing economist Merle Hazard and a performance by Joe himself.
もっと見る
次の動画
1:10:20
再生中
L. Randall Wray - Modern Money Theory for Beginners
St. Francis College
9.8万 回視聴
2 年前
1:24:37
再生中
中学数学からはじめる複素数
予備校のノリで学ぶ「大学の数学・物理」
21万 回視聴
1 か月前
1:22:23
再生中
Chris Hedges' Empire of Illusion | The New School
The New School
81万 回視聴
11 年前
51:10
再生中
【ダイジェスト】アメリカ大統領選挙を側で操るロスチャイルド家とゴールドマンサックス(三橋貴明×林千勝)
「新」経世済民新聞 三橋貴明 公式チャンネル
20万 回視聴
1 日前
新着
1:26:43
再生中
Stephanie Kelton: The Public Purse
UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose
4.9万 回視聴
2 年前
14:59
再生中
Poverty isn't a lack of character; it's a lack of cash | Rutger Bregman
TED
133万 回視聴
3 年前
36:30
再生中
Ray Dalio's introspective look at financial world order, inequality and capitalism: Full interview
Yahoo Finance
69万 回視聴
2 か月前
59:27
再生中
Zachary Carter, "The Price of Peace" and Stephanie Kelton, "The Deficit Myth"
Politics and Prose
4357 回視聴
7 か月前 に配信済み
8:24
再生中
意外と知らない?将棋界のルールを解説します【将棋】四段vs九段どっちが強い?!昇段するには……? 私にも〇年振りのチャンス到来です
女流棋士・香川愛生チャンネル
6.4万 回視聴
3 日前
新着
1:25:34
再生中
Democracy at Work: Curing Capitalism | Richard Wolff | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
175万 回視聴
3 年前
再生中
Bloomberg Global Financial News
Bloomberg Quicktake
2618 人が視聴中
ライブ配信中
42:26
再生中
Huawei: A global force — high tech giant and suspected spy | DW Documentary
DW Documentary
111万 回視聴
2 週間前
1:03:29
再生中
The Deficit Myth | Stephanie Kelton
TheAusInstitute
7036 回視聴
7 か月前
28:07
再生中
伝説のアマ強豪と対局してみた
将棋放浪記【プロ棋士】
3.3万 回視聴
2 日前
新着
57:24
再生中
Stephanie Kelton -- MMT and the Deficit Myth (w/ Marshall Auerback)
Real Vision Finance
3.8万 回視聴
6 か月前
13:21
再生中
イチローさん 野球人生第2章 高校球児に伝えたかったこと【news23】
TBS NEWS
143万 回視聴
1 週間前
18:34
再生中
Bernie Sanders' 2016 Advisor On Modern Monetary Theory
CNBC
15万 回視聴
1 年前
7:38
再生中
なぜスニーカー、藤井聡太二冠「革靴は…」~対局前にインタビュー~【第14回朝日杯将棋オープン戦】=高津祐典撮影
囲碁将棋TV -朝日新聞社-
3.3万 回視聴
1 日前
新着
8:45
再生中
藤井聡太七段が自戦解説「あと…そうですね30手ぐらい」~聞き手・室田伊緒女流二段、朝日おやこ将棋フェスティバル~【アーカイブ】
囲碁将棋TV -朝日新聞社-
43万 回視聴
2 か月前
42:26
再生中
Solar storms — a threat from space | DW Documentary
DW Documentary
68万 回
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿