2022年12月2日金曜日

Dirk Ehntsさんのツイート Ernst


In the fall of 1757 the Council felt that changing the law to provide

some way of burning all bills after their return to the treasury would pro-

tect the value of Virginia currency and remove any doubts about the

retired money getting back into circulation through loss or fraud. It

seems the Council anticipated the Robinson Scandal of 1766 when after

the Treasurer's death Virginians learned that Robinson had used some

£100,000 of public funds to make private loans to friends and political

supporters. Apparently Robinson loaned out some £20,000 between 1755

and 1757, about £60,000 between 1757 and 1763, and another £20,000 from

1763 until his death in 1766.52 For the time being, the move to burn all

paper coming into the treasury got nowhere. The House having already

repudiated the Board's additional instructions lost no time in rejecting

the Council plan as an infringement of the Burgesses' control of the

purse.5

53


1757年秋、評議会は、すべての紙幣を国庫に戻した後、何らかの方法で焼却するように法律を改正することが、バージニアの通貨価値を保護し、消失や不正によって退蔵された紙幣が再び流通することへの疑念を取り除くことになると考えたのである。1766年、財務長官の死後、ロビンソンが約10万ポンドの公的資金を友人や政治的支援者に私的に貸し付けていたことを知ったヴァージニア人は、評議会はロビンソンのスキャンダルを予期していたようである。ロビンソンは、1755 年から 1757 年にかけて約 2 万ポンド、1757 年から 1763 年にかけて約 6 万ポンド、1763 年から 1766 年に亡くなるまでさらに 2 万ポンドを貸し付けていたようである52 。下院は、理事会の追加指示をすでに否定していたため、時間を置かず、評議会の計画 を、両院の財政管理を侵害するものとして拒否した53 。




Joseph Albert Ernst 1965


The William and Mary Quarterly 
Vol. 22, No. 1 (Jan., 1965), pp. 33-74 (42 pages) 
Published By: Omohundro Institute of Early American History and Culture 
The William and Mary Quarterly



https://doi.org/10.2307/1920767
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1920767


参考 
ミッチェル2019

References Grubb, F. (2015) “Colonial Virginia’s Paper Money Regime, 1755–1774: A Forensic Accounting Reconstruction of the Data”, Working paper No. 2015-11. Available at: http://lerner.udel.edu/sites/default/files/ECON/PDFs/RePEc/dlw/WorkingPapers/2015/UDWP2015-11.pdf, accessed 16 May 2017. Smith, A. (1937[1776]) The Wealth of Nations, 5th edn, London: Methuen. Available at: http://www.econlib.org/library/ Smith/smWNCover.html, accessed 4 April 2017.


Farley Grubb, 2015 歴史的な紙幣:植民地アメリカにおける紙幣と税の償還





カブー 2022 Mark Flowerchild #MMT #RealProgressivesさんのツイート

MMT For M4A with Fadhel Kaboub
Macro N Cheese

Economics professor Fadhel Kaboub explains MMT to a group of activists fighting for free universal healthcare and demonstrates that economic literacy is a powerful weapon.

Apple Podcastでお聴きください: https://podcasts.apple.com/jp/podcast/macro-n-cheese/id1453085489?i=1000581236171

The movement for free universal healthcare is under attack. Groups like March for Medicare for All, National Single Payer, and others, have been criticized for not buying into the Democratic Party's agenda promoting individual state healthcare initiatives. The party wants us to stop pressuring Congress. They tell us to go home. They say there's more likelihood of success in our statehouses.

Well, MMT-informed activists can see through the party's obfuscation. The single-state solution is no solution at all. The US federal government is the currency issuer; it creates US dollars by spending them into existence. States and cities are currency users. Before they can spend, they must somehow earn or borrow that money, ultimately placing the burden onto the citizens, whether through taxes or cuts to other programs. It doesn't matter how fat their tax base is, even the state of California and the city of New York must balance their budgets. The difference between currency issuer and currency user is at the heart of the matter.

Since its founding, Real Progressives' stated mission has been to help arm activists with a useful understanding of Modern Monetary Theory.

"We're not going to move the needle unless we mobilize and organize. And as I say, sometimes it's not enough to be angry and it's not enough to raise the pitchforks. We want not just organized pitchforks but well-informed pitchforks. And I think MMT provides the right framing to mobilize this movement."

This week's episode comes from the webinar we hosted as part of our RP Live series for our friends at M4M4ALL. It gave them the opportunity to talk with one of our favorite economists, Fadhel Kaboub, who spent the hour answering their questions and arming them against the "taxpayer dollars" bamboozlement of those in power. In the Macro N Cheese clubhouse, we like to say we're weaponizing knowledge.

*****

Be sure to check out our website, realprogressives.org, where you will find additional resource material. Use the Media drop-down menu and select Macro N Cheese to access past episodes of this podcast (192 so far!), each accompanied by a transcript and an "Extras" page of useful links.

Visit m4m4all.org to learn how you can help their efforts.

Dr. Fadhel Kaboub is an Associate Professor of Economics at Denison University and President of the Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity.

@FadhelKaboub on Twitter

Something I've Always Wanted To Do - by Stephanie Kelton

Something I've Always Wanted To Do - by Stephanie Kelton

Something I've Always Wanted To Do

A TED talk

I've long wanted to give a TED talk. So when Chris Anderson's team reached out to tell me that they'd read my book and that MMT was an idea worth spreading, I jumped at the chance to appear in the red circle.

A TED talk isn't like giving a classroom lecture. And it's not like giving a keynote address or delivering other remarks before a large audience. It takes some degree of preparation to do any of those things well, but it's nothing like preparing for TED. A TED talk is a tightly-scripted articulation of some big idea that you hope will captivate, educate, and inspire your audience. In about twelve minutes. Without notes.

I joked on Twitter that writing a 1,700-word script for the TED talk was harder than writing the book. By far, the most painstaking part was deciding what to leave out.

The event took place last week, in Monterey, California. It was like nothing I'd ever experienced. The support. The camaraderie. The excitement. It made weeks of grueling preparation totally worthwhile.

It will be some time before the video is available online, but here's the script.


When things break, we have an opportunity. We can pick up the pieces and put them back together the old way, or we can look for better ways to build. COVID broke everything. It put a spotlight on the many deficits in our economy – in employment, education, health care, housing. And it showed how inequality made it all worse.

Here in the US and around the world, governments did some extraordinary things. They sent money to people—directly—to help them buy food and pay rent. They provided free COVID testing and expanded health care to cover more of the population. They gave money to businesses to help them stay afloat while much of the economy was temporarily shut down. They offered debt relief to millions of people who borrowed money to go to college. They did all of this—and more—without raising taxes or having a prolonged battle over the usual question of how to "pay for" it.

Congress simply voted for the spending and calmly allowed it to increase the fiscal deficit. To me, this was exciting. And I'm an economist, so I don't say that a lot. 

But as someone who's been trying to change the way we think about deficits and government spending, I saw this as an opportunity to show why government budgets don't work like household budgets, why all of their red ink is really our black ink, and why our nation can afford to keep investing in the things we need, even after spending trillions to fight the pandemic.

For a while, it looked like the US and other countries were starting to break the mold on the old way of thinking about deficits and taxes. But now here we are—just a handful of months after all of that bold action—and we're sliding back into our old habits of thought. Can we build affordable housing and repair our crumbling infrastructure? Can we expand Medicare to include dental, vision, and hearing? Can we tackle our climate crisis? As Congress debates these questions, everyone is back to asking, "How will we pay for it?" 

It's the wrong question. In fact, the right questions aren't about money at all. Instead of asking where the financing will come from, we should be asking: Are these things worth doing and do we have the real resources—the people, the equipment, the raw materials, and the technology—to do them? Will they make society better off, and do we have the political will to act? 

I am one of a small number of economists who contributed to the body of academic scholarship that's known as MMT, or Modern Monetary Theory. MMT provides an accurate description of how a fiat currency—like the US dollar or the British pound—actually works. It reminds us that we're no longer on a gold-standard, so "finding the money" to pay for the things we need is never an issue for countries like the US or the UK.

If we're going to fix what's broken in our economy, we have to fix the way we think about the limits on government spending. Let me give you an example of the kind of broken, gold-standard thinking that still permeates our discourse.

Back in 1983, the Prime Minister of Great Britain--Margaret Thatcher--said these words:

"If the state wishes to spend more, it can do so only by borrowing your savings or by taxing you more. And it's no good thinking that someone else will pay, that someone else is you. There is no such thing as public money, there is only taxpayer's money."

Maybe you've heard the contemporary version of Thatcher's dictum? 

"There is no magic money tree." 

It's just another way of saying that everything must be "paid for" and that the taxpayer is ultimately on the hook for whatever the government spends.

It sounds worrying. 

As individuals, we know from our own experience that when we borrow money to go to college, start a business, or buy a home, we're personally saddled with that debt. We have to find the money to pay it back. Taking on too much personal debt can lead to all sorts of problems. Even small businesses and large corporations have to walk a fine line when it comes to debt. But the federal government is fundamentally different. 

Unlike the rest of us, Congress never has to check the balance in its bank account to figure out whether it can afford to spend more. As the issuer of the currency, it doesn't have to worry about running out of money. It can afford to buy whatever is available and for sale in its own currency. That might involve spending on roads and bridges, a military arsenal, or hospitals and schools. Finding the votes to pass a spending bill can be hard, but finding the money is never a problem. They just create it.

Here's how it works. Whenever Congress and the president agree to spend more, the government's bank—the Federal Reserve—works with the rest of the financial system to get that money into our accounts. Everything happens electronically, so there's no physical "printing" of money involved. If you got a $1,400 check from the federal government earlier this year, or if your company received money to help cover payroll and other expenses, then you got some of the newly-minted digital dollars that were created to support our economy. No taxpayers were involved in the process. It was all done using nothing more than a computer keyboard. 

So why are we hearing so much about the need to raise taxes to "pay for" infrastructure and make other investments in our economy? In a word….deficits.

We've all been conditioned to worry about deficits, so lawmakers are looking for ways to spend more without adding to the deficit. That's what this whole "pay for" game is about. Unfortunately, government deficits have gotten a bad rap. They're almost always seen in a negative light. 

I'd like to change that.

When we hear the word deficit, we probably think of a shortfall or a deficiency. A deficit always sounds ominous. So when we hear that the government just ran a $3 trillion budget deficit, it can spark worry and even outrage. But there's another way to think about government deficits.

Just as a 6 becomes a 9 when you view it from a different angle, a government deficit becomes a financial surplus when you look at it from another perspective. A deficit hawk might look at this picture and see nothing but a sea of worrying red ink.

That's not how I look at it. 

Here's what I see. 

I see what's happening on the other side of the government's ledger. 

When the government spends more than it taxes away from us, it makes a financial contribution to some other part of the economy. Their red ink is our black ink! When you look at it this way, it becomes clear that every deficit is good for someone! 

The question is, for whom? And what are those deficits being used to accomplish? It matters how the money is spent and who ends up with the resulting surplus. Tax cuts that create huge windfalls for those at the top without spurring investment and opportunities for the rest of the population don't make good use of deficits. On the other hand, spending trillions to support our economy during the pandemic, put the deficit to good use. We just had the shortest recession in US history!

To me, that was fiscally responsible. Being responsible shouldn't mean running the government's finances like a household. Instead of trying to keep the deficit in check, Congress should be focused on keeping inflation in check. That's the real limit on spending. And it's the thing to watch out for if you're aiming to spend trillions on things like infrastructure, health care, and free college.

Instead of asking, "How will we pay for it?" Congress should be asking, "How will we resource it?"

To answer that question, we need to think of people, factories, equipment, and natural resources like iron and wood. If we're going to build high-speed rail, fix crumbling roads and bridges, and green our economy, we'll need steel, concrete, and lumber. We'll need construction workers, architects and engineers. We'll need companies that can fill thousands of orders for solar panels, EV charging stations, and electric school buses. If our economy has the productive capacity to quickly supply all of those things, then we can easily resource it.  

Or take health care. Or free college. Paying the bills to expand Medicare so that it includes dental, vision, and hearing is easy. The challenge is making sure we have enough dentists, optometrists, and audiologists to treat everyone who needs care. And if you want to resource free college, then you need the faculty, the classrooms, and the dormitories to teach and house additional students.

In a full employment economy, all of these resources are... well...fully employed. There's no spare capacity anywhere in the system. So if the government suddenly tried to make all of these investments at once, it would quickly discover that it doesn't have the people or the building materials to do the work. To get the resources it needs, it would have to compete with the private sector, bidding up wages and prices. That would be inflationary, and it would be fiscally irresponsible.

We're a long way from full employment. We have the resources we need to begin repairing our broken systems. But we have to believe it's possible. We shouldn't let words like "debt" and "deficits" hold us back. With a better understanding of public money—where it comes from and how it works—we can take aim at the many real deficits that are bearing down on us. In every crisis lies an opportunity. We can pick up the pieces and try to reassemble the fragile systems that were in place before the pandemic. Or we can build anew, shaping our bountiful resources into the kind of world we want to inhabit. One that cares for our people and our planet. I truly hope we choose to be bold.

THANK YOU!

ミッチェルのラムルへの懸念|🦉ゲーテちゃん🦉|note

ミッチェルのラムルへの懸念|🦉ゲーテちゃん🦉|note

"この本では、ラムルのプロ・ビジネス (=ビジネス擁護) 的な主張が際立

っており、 労働組合は民間企業の「民間政府」 としての役割を損ない、 利益

を圧迫する存在であるとしている。”


"ラムルは政府支出がクラウディング・アウトを起こすことも肯定していた

り、「公的債務の金利」は「課税によって賄わな」 ければならず、 国債の償

還期間中は「税金の必要性はかつてないほど高まっている」とまで主張して

いる。


"こうした彼のビジネスへの姿勢や、 財政観の自己矛盾から、ミッチェルは

以下のように結論づけている。 「ラムルが主張していたのは、税金は何の財

源にもならないということではなく、 企業ではなく個人にのみ税金をかけて

ほしいということだったのである。」 "


"ラムルは大規模な公共事業にも批判的で、大好況時の事業は特に無駄が多

く、公共雇用プログラムは「世間の嘲笑と罵倒」に値するとまでこき下ろし

ている”


ラムルは企業への二重課税が不当だと述べている。
ただし日本の場合には個人が二重課税を受けている場合が多い。
還付金など輸出大企業も優遇されている。

ミッチェルのラムルへの懸念

見出し画像

 租税の役割の文脈でMMTの文献に登場するビアズリー・ラムルだが、ミッチェルはMMTの命題の正当化にラムルの主張を選択的に援用することに懸念があるようだ。(ミッチェルのブログエントリ:Reading Beardsley Ruml carefully 〔ビアズリー・ラムルを慎重に読む〕)

 もちろん、ラムルの見解は部分的にはラーナーの機能的財政に共鳴しているのだが、一方で同意しかねる点も多くあるとミッチェルは指摘している。例えば、ラムルは連邦政府には支払いのための課税は必要ではないとしながら、「借入」については足りない税収を補うための代替手段であるとしている。政府が主権通貨の発行を行うということは、自らの通貨を借りて支出を賄う必要性はないことを意味する。資金調達手段としての税金の役割を否定したのと同じ理屈で、借入の必要性も否定されるはずなのだが、ラムルはここへきてまた財源論に立ち返っているのである。

 またラムルの法人税(法人所得税)への反対について、ミッチェルは、ラムルの発言は「明らかに企業部門を代表しており、法人税を下げるための政治的なロビー活動だった」と見ている。本当だろうか?ランダル・レイなどは、法人税の問題については、純粋に税制の問題として議論を展開しているはずだが(もちろんレイの法人税論はラムルだけではなく、ミンスキーの影響もあるわけだけれども)。

 ミッチェルは、1945年に書かれたラムルの著作「Tomorrow's Business」に注目している。この本では、ラムルのプロ・ビジネス(=ビジネス擁護)的な主張が際立っており、労働組合は民間企業の「民間政府」としての役割を損ない、利益を圧迫する存在であるとしている。「利益は高い方が良い」という露骨な表現もあり、ミッチェルは法人税の廃止は企業の利益擁護のためではないのかという疑いをかけている。

 他にも、ラムルは政府支出がクラウディング・アウトを起こすことも肯定していたり、「公的債務の金利」は「課税によって賄わな」ければならず、国債の償還期間中は「税金の必要性はかつてないほど高まっている」とまで主張している。ラムルは資金調達手段としての課税の役割を否定していたのではなかったのか、ということだ。

 こうした彼のビジネスへの姿勢や、財政観の自己矛盾から、ミッチェルは以下のように結論づけている。「ラムルが主張していたのは、税金は何の財源にもならないということではなく、企業ではなく個人にのみ税金をかけてほしいということだったのである。」

 ラムルはまた、「経済が好調なときには、政府は多額の財政黒字を出し、国の債務残高を返済すべきである」と主張しており、MMTの立場とは真逆である。MMTでは、そうした特定の財政状態の達成は財政政策の目標ではない。むしろ、完全雇用と物価安定を維持するための手段として財政状態を調整すべきである。

 ラムルは大規模な公共事業にも批判的で、大好況時の事業は特に無駄が多く、公共雇用プログラムは「世間の嘲笑と罵倒」に値するとまでこき下ろしている(ミッチェル爺、恐らくこの部分に一番キレているんじゃないか笑)。

 特に法人税の是非については日本でも意見が分かれており、法人増税の支持者からは法人税廃止を主張する(、というか法人所得を株主に帰属させ、それに累進所得税を課税する税制にシフトすることを提案する)MMT派もいることに対して疑念を持たれることもある。ミッチェルの言うようにラムルはただの企業利益の代弁者なのかはともかく、MMTとラムルの見解との齟齬は頭に入れておいた方が良さそうだ。

 ラーナーの機能的財政にしても、彼自身の主張には矛盾している点もいくつかある(『MMT=FFT?現代貨幣理論とラーナーの機能的財政論って何が違うの?』を参照)。MMTの学者が書いた文献を読むのに手一杯で、影響を与えたとする「巨人たち」の著作には手付かずとなりがちだが、こうした共通点や相違点の整理はしておく必要があると思う。(了)