2021年5月7日金曜日

Phil Lawn MMT and the Benefits of Fiscal Injections 2017

Phil Lawn MMT and the Benefits of Fiscal Injections 2017
https://love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com/2021/05/phil-lawn-mmt-and-benefits-of-fiscal.html @

40:52~



Phil Lawn MMT and the Benefits of Fiscal Injections 
2017 
https://youtu.be/zX7vavr5ncs 



40:52
 so what I've said I can spray in a diagram like this that's my bathtub diagram alright there's a lot of right so here's my bathtub I want you to imagine that there's the bathtub and that size of that bathtub represents the productive capacity economy alright.


then the capacity the economy to produce goods and services the water level represents the spending right represents if the water level is right at the top you've got full employment and an acceptable inflation rate so you got a full bathtub spending equals productive capacity this is where we basically been operating for 45 years meetups up needlessly since the early 1970s the water level below the top because the government's worried about running a budget deficit which is irrelevant so federal government spendings about 25 percent of all spending so if that's where it's spending is at present 25 percent it's federal government spending and the remainder is state local governments and private sector basically okay so if the government wants to put more water into the bathtub because the water levels too low it is and obtains water in other words money from its bottomless reservoir of Australian dollars just turns and so water flowing into the bathtub which is government spending increases the water level what attacks us Duke well there's a drain down here that just leaked that just destroys spending power so your taxes I've got a bin where water doesn't really go on a bin but I wanted something like waste so I just goes nowhere so if the government is running everything else hold constant if the government's running a balanced budget there's as much more to going in to the bathtub is coming out and the water level stays at the same level if the government if the water level is here and I'll talk about this soon and the private sector it has a balance then yeah it's a bit tricky because it I'll get to this bit later on the government the government can and in fact it wouldn't be running a balance but I'll explain that soon if it wants the water level to rise it's got to put more water in than it taxes it's got to run a budget deficit a fiscal injection so what what was Peter Costello doing who's bidding stuff on the chest he was drowning more water out of this bathtub and he was putting him and saying well what a wonderful treasure I am for running all these surpluses in actual fact the water level didn't go down the only didn't go out with the talk wasn't remained didn't mind wasn't sort of kept with it was kept up here only because and I don't have it you know I've got to say but I could have banks here and have another one going here and that's because we borrowed we can put the banks can create some water as well but it's a bit different because when banks when governments create money for spending purposes they're creating a financial asset money is a financial asset but when the federal government creates money spends in any resistance it creates a financial asset but no offsetting financial liability like I said before when the federal government prints money it doesn't owe it to anyone no more than the manufacturer of the board game Monopoly owes monopoly dollars to someone okay so it when it's spends and assuming it's it will increases its spending and it's not changing its Taxation though more net financial assets going in the economy net thing net of taxes all right and of course if when the government taxes it's destroying financial assets so when the government's running a deficit it can increase the water level it has the capacity depends again as I said on that and I'll get to this a bit later on on the private sector net savings desires but it can basically increase the water by putting more water in than it has leaking out through taxation and can someone say are now it can't do that because there's a limited amount of water for the federal government no there's as much as the federal government wants so can always keep the water level at the top of the bathtub and maintain full employment now as I said before that doesn't mean the federal government should go crazy print monies and just spend whatever because if it does the water level goes above the level of the bathtub and that's spending greater than productive capacity and there's hyperinflation so when the water level goes over the top of the bath you've got high from frozen so but anyone who would advocate function of Finance would never say the government should increase its net spending so what the water levels above the top of the bathtub.

 it would say increase it keep it there and don't go any further not a dollar for a dollar more but not a dollar less so what have I got here I've got to remember that's a leakage order and that's an injection in terms of now I've removed exports and imports because that does play a part but just assume that X this is and it's exports are equal to its imports and we don't have to worry about that okay so that makes good but well it up well okay oh well in fact it does matter the current decay yep which is even worse for Australia I kept that to explain this diagram and if you think that most of those exports imports are by the non-government sector but foreigners and people squalene citizens tractor making transactions amongst themselves so just ignore the external sector so when the government puts more water in the bathtub than its draining out through taxation that what it doesn't necessarily rise and the reason why it might not is because this is savings which is another leakage and this into our vaults that's our accumulated private-sector savings all right our savings that we have and some of this gets injected back in the form of investment okay so if the government's putting more water in than it's draining out in other words G is greater than T the water level can stay at the same level if s is greater than I of course the water level goes up in the vault doesn't it so put more in then it's draining out and the water level stays at the same level in the bathtub it goes up in the vault okay that's basically what happened for about 30 years in Australia after World War Two so this red line that's that's that's the critical point yeah because if if we drain our accumulated savings we get to some critical point something like a global financial crisis somewhere to keep that up there and in the 30 year period after World War Two the government basically ran deficits most of the time it ran deficits so the water level was pretty much up the top of the bathtub and because it was putting more water in than it was draining out that meant that the private sector water level in its vault was going up so it meant that we had lots of savings we had savings to call upon if something hit and shocked the economy okay if there was some shot to the economy that caused spending to go down a bit in there bit of income to go down what did we divided the private sector they just went and grabbed some of its savings and spent that and that and so recessions in that 30-year period there weren't really any we're incredibly short and shallow now they're more long protracted and deeper because we don't have this accumulated savings anymore so we had to dip into if the if things go well but in actual fact we don't need if we had a government that knew it had a bottomless pit of our bottom was reservoir of water it could just so even if we're in the private sector spends hardly anything the federal government can always offset it so the water levels up here so I can anyway the problem is that we get to this critical point the private sector cuts its spending the government needs to fill the gap and the Treasury goes got any money yeah and it's not just yeah Barack Obama said the same thing he said I can't do that anyway so you can see that when the when the federal government runs a deficit and the water level stays at the same level in the bathtub but goes up in the vault that explains why a government deficit is equivalent to a private sector surplus at the cup even though the water level in the bathtub staying the same level if G is greater than T it's a deficit and there's the surplus as it's accumulating over time in the form of accumulated net savings should I go into this I probably won't that's pretty much what I had to say so because people ask if injections always equal leakages because it turns out the two injections are government spending and and private sector investment back so this I for investment and G they're injections you've got injections there and the two leakages are taxation and savings those two together must equal those two all right but that doesn't mean that G so if G and I equals S Plus T that doesn't mean he has to be the same as G doesn't mean that S has to be the same as I just some other two have to be the same injections must equal leakages I so but but that suggests to you okay.


 if the water levels here and the government runs a deficit and the private sector runs a surplus okay they'll put more water in than that drains out this will go up but the water level will never reach the full employment level I'd say you like the whole idea of there being leakages equals two injections can raise the question how does how does the government get the water level up well it's what what that neglects to and I sort of alluded to this before to recognize is that when the government spends it increases the Nash Nash '''l income which not only increases its tax revenue because tax revenues tied to national income increases your income and you spend more and that's the multiplier effect of government spending so what level goes up you got more income you spend more and it goes up further so let me well just a couple things I want to get to that door and it's a horrible looking diagram but I just want to point out that don't worry about the Green Line worry about these blue bars here this was for the period so these are financial used 1953 for 2013-14 that 60 years 60 odd years the federal government ran 44 deficits in 18 surpluses in 62 years big deal I mean they're potentially there was a potential for a constraint because it was a different course a slightly different financial system then but the gap government never reached that financial constraint but the important thing is is that governments run deficits most of the time and we want them to because it allows us to net safe if we want to net safe we have to have the government running deficits so the deficit is the norm are we paying taxes now for those past deficits of course we're not a prank for them now I mean we go back to what taxations for okay if let's say we're at the full employment level of income and there's a certain amount of taxation a certain certain amount of government spending savings and investment and the government is determined doesn't think there's enough hospital beds or something and so it wants to spend more well the biggest concern is that it's gonna the water level is going to go over the top of the bathtub and the inflationary because there's no real resources available it's feelings so what does the government do as I said before it taxes the private sector so it drains so your your some of your spending power goes down here and disappears forever all right which means the government can provide more hospitals the water level can staff here without there being hyperinflation oh yes do we part because the government's generally running a deficit rather than a surplus are we paying taxes because of it now because of those past everything.

 no we're not so the only reason why we only need for the government to taxes here is related to the position in this particular year you know only has to tax us sufficiently if it wants to maintain full employment to ensure the water level doesn't go over the bath top of the bathtub and B - Flay shinri that amount that the government taxes us has nothing to do well you could say that something insofar as past deficits so if it was government spending on infrastructure what-have-you that can affect the size of the bathtub the productive capacity of the economy there's got nothing to do with past deficits so you do not pay for past deficits all right let's just gone after deficit in the classes it's just something that's disappeared Saten it's irrelevant and it's not affecting the ability of the federal government to spend today and Suffolk doesn't that's totally irrelevant it's not owed to anyone it just was a deficit in that year big deal so you know it's surpluses this idea of an intergenerational fun putting surplus I I know Norway has purchased a lot of physical assets but you've probably heard of this as a sovereign wealth fund of of Norway just imagine if it was just all of it was Norwegian kroner sitting in a vault and in a building and that building burnt down and that Norwegian kroner was was destroyed what could the Norwegian government do just printed stuff and replace it well if it can replace it why doesn't it just do it well okay yeah I peps I should get there here's a good time for that I just been Steve and I just went to a conference in the USA in Kansas City there's a branch of the Federal Reserve Bank of the USA there's a museum there we didn't actually get into the museum because we've got to take our passports you need to have a fee-only field not an American citizen you need your passport but doesn't know that the security guard gave us this which is shredded US dollars about 165 dollars worth it was interesting because Steven I asked the security guard what's the normal reaction from people and they you normally go what a waste they could thank you just give that to poor people well they probably don't know US government does give money to poor people probably not enough but it just gives them nice crisp notes instead you wouldn't do that if there was the money that was sitting in your wallet or purse would you and you're an American citizen you wouldn't do that why would you do it is you can't replace it the meaning Gavin the US government can do it because he just replaces it and and if it can replace it then then it begs the question does it have to shred some money before it can print money of course doesn't so it didn't have to shred out on $65 before I could free 165 dollars so I can print as much as it likes it's got as much money a u.s. u.s. dollars not other currency any US dollars as it as it likes okay yeah let me I know this might look a bit awkward but let me just go that's five ten minutes to go through this this is similar the bathtub type diagram but it it does help explain how the extra government spending even though injections always equal equal edges raise the water level up so the full employment level now this is a particular point in time these two here this is another point in time so forget about the bottom two here that distance there basically represents the productive capacity of the economy so I think of that is that there's the bathtub okay you've got spending and you've got a thing called national income one person spending is another person's income so they always there's two ways you've heard of gross domestic product is two ways in which they measured there's an income approach and spending approach alright doesn't matter which one you use GDP is the same so that will they 




40:52
 私が言ったことを図にしてみると、これが私のバスタブの図です。


水位は支出を表しています。水位が一番上にある場合、完全雇用と許容できるインフレ率があり、バスタブがいっぱいになっています。現在、25%が連邦政府の支出で、残りは州政府、地方自治体、民間企業となっています。つまり、水位が低すぎるために政府がバスタブに水を入れたいと思えば、政府は水、つまりオーストラリアドルという底なしの貯水池からお金を得ることができます。もし政府が他のすべてのことを一定に運営しているなら、もし政府が均衡予算を運営しているなら、バスタブに入る量と出る量は同じくらいで、水位は同じレベルのままです。政府は、水位がここにあれば、すぐにこの話をしますが、民間企業は、均衡が取れていれば、ちょっと難しいですね。水位を上げたければ、税金よりも多くの水を入れなければなりません。つまり、財政赤字を出し、財政出動をしなければならないのです。ピーター・コステロが何をしていたかというと、彼は胸に札をつけて、バスタブから水を出して溺れさせていました。実際のところ、水位は下がらず、話だけが進んでいくこともなく、気にも留められず、ここに留まっていました。それは借りたからです 銀行も水を作ることができます でもちょっと違うんです 銀行が政府が支出目的でお金を作ると金融資産を作ります お金は金融資産ですが 連邦政府がお金を作ってどんな抵抗でも使うと 金融資産を作りますが、先ほど言ったように 相殺できる金融負債はありません 連邦政府がお金を印刷しても誰にも借りていません ボードゲームのモノポリーのメーカーが モノポリードルを誰かに借りているのと同じです だからお金を使っても、使うと仮定すると と仮定すると、政府は支出を増やしますが、税金は変えません 経済に投入される正味の金融資産は増えますが、税金を差し引いた正味のものです いいですか、もちろん政府が課税すると金融資産を破壊することになるので、政府が赤字を出しているときには、水位を上げることができます その能力は、先ほど言ったように、民間部門の正味の貯蓄欲求に再び依存しますが、基本的には、課税によって流出した水よりも多くの水を入れることで水位を上げることができます 誰かが言うことができますか?連邦政府の水の量は限られているので、それはできません。連邦政府が望むだけの水があるので、水位を常にバスタブの上部に保ち、完全雇用を維持することができます。先ほど言ったように、だからといって連邦政府が狂ったようにお金を刷り、何でもかんでも使うべきだということではありません。財務機能を提唱する人は、政府が純支出を増やすべきだとは決して言いません。ですから、水位がバスタブの上部を超えたら、支出を増やしてそこにとどめ、それ以上は増やさないでください。ここで覚えておかなければならないのは、リークオーダーとインジェクションの観点から、輸出と輸入は除外しています。


…

 増やしてくれと言うだろう そこを維持してくれ それ以上はやめてくれ 1ドルでも増やしてくれ 1ドルでも減らしてくれ だからここで何を得たのか 覚えておかなければならないのは リークオーダーとインジェクションの観点から 輸出と輸入を除外したのはそれが関係しているからだ ただXを仮定してくれ これは輸出と輸入が同じで それを心配しなくてもいい 輸出と輸入が等しいと仮定すれば、心配する必要はありません。まあ、それは良いことですが、実際には現在の衰退が問題になります。 政府の輸出と輸入のほとんどは非政府部門によるものですが、外国人やスクワレン市民が自分たちの間で取引をしていますので、外部部門は無視してください。政府が課税によって排出される量よりも多くの水をバスタブに入れても、必ずしも上昇しません。なぜ上昇しないかというと、これは貯蓄であり、もう一つの漏出であり、これを金庫に入れると、蓄積された民間部門の貯蓄になります。 政府が水を入れる量が排出する量よりも多ければ、つまりGがTよりも大きければ、水位は同じレベルを保つことができますsがIよりも大きければ、もちろん水位は金庫の中で上がりますよね。第二次世界大戦後のオーストラリアでは、基本的に約30年間このような状況が続いていました。第二次世界大戦後の30年間、政府は基本的にほとんどの期間を赤字で運営していたので、水位はバスタブの上の方にありました。貯蓄がたくさんあったということです。何かが経済に衝撃を与え、それによって支出が減り、収入が減ったとしたら、民間部門は何をしたでしょうか? 実際には必要ないのですが、もし政府が底なし沼の貯水池を持っていることを知っていれば、民間企業がほとんど何も使わなくても、連邦政府がいつでもそれを相殺することができるのですから。問題は、この臨界点に達すると、民間企業は支出を削減し、政府はそのギャップを埋める必要があり、財務省にはお金がない、ということです。浴槽の水位が同じレベルであっても、GがTより大きければそれは赤字であり、蓄積された純貯蓄という形で時間をかけて蓄積された余剰があるということになります。しかし、それはGを意味するものではありません。GとIがSとTに等しい場合、GがSとIと同じでなければならないという意味ではなく、SがIと同じでなければならないという意味ではなく、他の2つが同じでなければならないという意味です。注入は漏出に等しくなければなりません。




 もし水位が上がって、政府が赤字で民間が黒字になったら、排水する水よりも多くの水を入れるので、水位は上がりますが、完全雇用のレベルには達しません。 漏れがあるということは、2回の注入に等しいという考え方が好きなのですが、政府はどうやって水位を上げるのかという疑問が出てきます。これは税収を増やすだけではありません。税収は国民の所得に結びついていますから、所得が増えれば消費も増え、これが政府支出の乗数効果です。つまり、水位が上がれば、所得も増え、消費も増え、さらに水位が上がるのです。 これまでの60年間、62年間で連邦政府は18回の黒字のうち44回の赤字を出しています。安全を確保したいのであれば、政府が赤字を出していなければなりません。つまり、赤字が普通なのです。過去の赤字に対して、私たちは税金を払っているでしょうか。政府の支出、貯蓄、投資が一定量あるとします。政府は病院のベッド数が足りないと判断し、もっと支出を増やしたいとしますが、最大の懸念は、水位がバスタブの上を超えてしまうことと、実際に利用できる資源がないためにインフレになってしまうことです。つまり、政府はハイパーインフレになることなく、より多くの病院を提供したり、水位を上げたりすることができるということです そうそう、政府は一般的に黒字ではなく赤字を出しているので、私たちはそのために税金を払っているのでしょうか?



 政府が課税する必要がある唯一の理由は、この特定の年の立場に関連しています。完全雇用を維持するために、水位がバスタブの上部を超えないようにするために、十分に課税する必要があるのです。 浴槽の大きさや経済の生産力に影響を与えるようなインフラへの政府支出であれば、過去の赤字とは何の関係もありませんので、過去の赤字分を支払うことはありません。私はノルウェーが多くの現物資産を購入していることを知っていますが、おそらくこれを聞いたことがあるでしょう。ノルウェーの政府系ファンドとして聞いたことがあると思いますが、もし、すべてのノルウェー・クローネが金庫や建物に保管されていて、その建物が焼失し、ノルウェー・クローネが破壊されたとしたら、ノルウェー政府は何ができるでしょうか?そうですね、そろそろ行かないといけませんね。 ちょうどスティーブと私はアメリカのカンザスシティで行われた会議に行ってきました。そこにはアメリカ連邦準備銀行の支店があり、そこには博物館がありました。 警備員がくれたのは、約165ドル分のシュレッダーにかけられたUSドルでした。面白かったのは、スティーブンが警備員に、人々の普通の反応はどんなものかと聞いたところ、普通は「もったいない」と言い、「ありがとう、これを貧しい人たちにあげてください」と言うのですが、彼らはおそらく知らないでしょう。もしあなたの財布に入っているお金があったとしたら......あなたはアメリカ市民ですから、そんなことはしないでしょう。なぜそんなことをするのかというと、お金を交換できないからです。 米国の米国ドル これはバスタブ型の図に似ていますが、追加の政府支出がどのようにして水位を上げ、完全雇用の水準に達するのかを説明するのに役立ちます。下の2つは、基本的には経済の生産力を表しています。つまり、バスタブがあって、支出があって、国民所得というものがあって、一人の人の支出は、もう一人の人の所得になります。


Phil Lawn MMT and the Benefits of Fiscal Injections
2017
https://youtu.be/zX7vavr5ncs JP 検索 9+ アバターの画像 Phil Lawn MMT and the Benefits of Fiscal Injections 243 回視聴•2017/10/20 12 0 共有 保存 Steven Hail チャンネル登録者数 395人 文字起こし hello it's working right okay so it's a notes on ER a Ouray was founded in 1993 when three small groups in New South Wales and South Australia came together as in basically entered intellectuals and heterodox economists who could analyze economics dispassionately which modern economics economists aren't very good at and could step outside the prevailing paradigm and can see the worldwide crisis coming also in there further in the 90s they organized three conferences called toes which is the other economic summit along the lines of similarly or main conferences held in Europe and North America and they organize them in Sydney Melbourne and Adelaide it led one was 1995 they hosted a number of other public meetings and other conferences held in Adelaide Sydney Brisbane and Canberra involving well-known heterodox economists and other reformers they established relationship and liaison with karma the Committee on monetary and economic reform which is a Ras counterpart in Canada they sponsored visits was Australian speaking tours and media interviews for several well-known economic reformers from overseas including Michael Robottom from UK prophet on Hassan for Canada from the US professors Blaine and Robert Constanza from Ireland Richard dealth wait the Honorable Paul Hillier former Deputy PM of Canada John Wright and also Stephanie diría from New Zealand and others so EA has organized and co-organized a range of seminars and presentations over the years with well-informed speakers in several capital cities and out loud there is long history and variety of such events to numerous to list he also made submissions to several government inquiries concerning financial and banking reform and produce various reports brochures and publications particularly in particular the regular IRA review now there's some copies of previous CRA reviews on the table over there which you're welcome to read and also a paper which relates to few lawns talk not directly of obvious hope because for related paper and this evening for will be discussing this the myths around sovereign debt and a misleading direction so as myths cause this is also conducted in conjunction with a home economics economics Department it can always pop in in in the Uni here and I'll be giving giving a presentation or a lecture introduction as well so I'll hand over to Phil thank you thank you [Music]

 you all right so I easy microphones I gotta say all right well today for tonight's presentation basically what I'm going to do is I'm going to talk a little bit about a thing called modern monetary theory which you may or may not be aware of I'll just say a couple of things about modern monetary theory for I give my presentation because a lot of people who may be aware of modern monetary theory think that it's some sort of new idea a framework or what-have-you that could be applied by governments well it's not government's already operate within the modern monetary theory framework it's a description of how the system actually works right so the the federal government straining federal government currently operates under a modern monetary theory type framework okay it just because it doesn't understand it it operates in adequately that's all all right so the main thing about modern monetary theory is to understand what the what what John what the spending and Taxation powers of a currencies issuing central government I'm going to make a distinction between a currency issuing central government which is like the Australian federal government which is the owner and issuer of the nation's currency and a user of a government which is a user of a currency which in fact we do have in Australia they're called state governments and local governments they're completely different they make their capacities to spend are completely different to the federal government and of course we've got the eurozone governments which because they relinquish monopoly ownership of their own currency operate the same way as state governments do in Australia their users of the currency they're not issuers of the currency and that greatly affects their ability to spend and we're seeing the results of that in Europe at present not that the federal government here in Australia is taking full advantage of its spending and Taxation powers so got to think of this modern monetary theory as something that describes the system as it is it's sort of a lens through which you look at the the financial and monetary system and I'm going to talk about why now when I say why are we benefit from a government budget deficit I'm basically saying that by and large most of the time the federal government should run a deficit that doesn't mean it's always advantageous and if it's if it does run a surplus it's not because it needs to run a surplus because it's running out of money and I'll talk about why the federal government might have to run a surplus okay the budget bottom line of the Australian federal government is entirely irrelevant and it is something that the federal government cannot control basically the federal government budget bottom line is determined by the net savings desires of the private sector and if federal treasury knew about it then every time the Treasury papers come out each year they wouldn't make outrageous predictions about the budget going back to surplus it will depend entirely upon the net savings desires of the private sector and so if the private sector wishes to positively net save out of current income the government will run a budget deficit whether it likes it or not the key thing is what sort of budget deficits should it be running okay there's such a thing as a good budget deficit and a bad budget deficit and I'll distinguish between the two tonight all right here's some facts can you read that like that's not too small the federal government that's the monopoly owner an issue of the Australian dollar AUD refers to the Australian dollar there's no spending constraint the federal government does however face a real resource constraint okay so it's got as many Australian dollars as it likes for spending purposes but it can't buy an infinite amount of stuff now we live in a world of scarcity so they they face a real resource constraint so should the federal government just go crazy print money and spending into existence no because if it prints money and spends it into existence and it exceeds the real resource constraint you just have inflation but what the federal government should be doing is it should be net spending that's government spending - taxation net spending to the level so that total spending within the Australian economy is always at the full employment level of income doesn't shouldn't go any further because it would just be inflationary but it can always spend to that level because it's irrelevant whether it's running a surplus or deficit it does not affect the federal government's ability to spend in the future so there's basically a bottomless pit of Australian dollars on Capitol Hill in Canberra so the federal government has as many Australian dollars as it likes for spending purposes what does the federal government do when it spends well in this computer age it basically spends by electronically crediting bank accounts so you know if you think of the government running the printing press in order to spend well it runs the printing press to make available cash but that's not how it spends it hasn't spent like that even prior to the computer age it used to write out checks I used to write out checks but with the computer age it doesn't have to do them it still does well that's it's it's phasing checks out so it spends by electronically crediting bank accounts every dollar of federal government spending involves the creation and spending into existence of a new dollar the new money created comes from absolutely nowhere so it comes from nowhere I might also point out that this this new money it's basically new money that it's money that hasn't previously existed that's created out of nothing and spent into existence the government doesn't need your money if it's got an infinite amount of money and explain why you pay taxes federal government taxes it's basically to regulate your demand for real stuff so there's enough real stuff available for the federal government to get hold of it without it being inflationary that's sea-salt macroeconomic purpose of taxation so does that make sense so I'm the federal government you're the private sector you demand real stuff I demand real stuff if our total demand for the real stuff that's available for sale exceeds what's available for sale will complete for it and push the price up and we'll be hyperinflationary so if that's occurring what can I do as a government well I could reduce my spending so that the total demand for the real stuff is exactly equal to the real stuff available to control inflation but what if I want to spend or a certain level to provide schools and hospitals and so forth and I want to do it in a way that's not inflationary well I reduce your spending and how do I reduce your spending I tax you I destroy some of your spending pair so call the creation of you money and example of printing money it's not real but you can call it that if you want to but the federal government no more owes someone for creating money for itself and the manufacturer of the board game Monopoly owes someone for premier printing monopoly dollars so don't think that when the federal government prints money in spending into existence it owes it to anyone I don't know who the manufacturer of the board game Monopoly is I think was John Sands used to be the company well they don't own or Oh monopoly dollars to anyone have you ever played Monopoly and thought Wow John Sands masks a lot of Monopoly dollars to someone of course you don't the federal government taxes the private sector by electronically debiting bank accounts and when you pay your taxes yeah if there's a computer hard drive with a number which is the bottom line of your bank account you pay taxes that number goes down electronically every dollar of federal government taxation involves the permanent destruction of old money or existing money right money that's already in the system the old money that is permanently destroyed by the federal government taxation goes nowhere goes the same place to where it came from when the government created and spending exists goes nowhere it's a lot different I sorry and the second point the federal government can run deficits forever so if it's got an infinite amount of money can run deficits forever and in most years should run deficits because a federal deficit constitutes a non-federal government surplus I don't in fact quite often like to use the term federal government deficit because it sounds like a bad thing all right it's really a fiscal injection when the government runs a deficit it's creating more money and spending it into existence so I'm giving you more money by buying things off you that I'm taking away from you from taxation so when I run a deficit you run a surplus so I got off and asked people would you like the federal government to run a surplus and most people say yeah would you like to run a surplus and I say yeah and I say well you can't it both there are two sides of the same coin for you to run a surplus I gotta run a deficit okay and if you run a deficit I I can potentially run a surplus well in fact I will run a surplus but if you're determined to run a surplus I end up running a deficit and that's exactly what's happening now and explain why when I say you I'm not talking about you individually some of you may not on talking but if the private sector wants to net safe okay it means me as the federal government I run a deficit no matter how hard I try to run a surplus in fact the harder I try to run a surplus if I cut my spending means we are worse off there's less spending within the economy all right because if in your attempt to save a certain amount because I spend less and that's money that goes to you as income you finance your spending and you're saving out of that income and if you want to save a certain amount and you've got less money you spend less which means there's less national income and government taxation is a positive function of national income so when I cut my spending I cut my tax revenue so that's why you can't equate in many ways the government budget with a household budget if you had $50,000 a year and you spend 60,000 yell over $10,000 deficit so you might say okay next year I'm going to spend 50,000 but when you spend $50,000 it doesn't affect the income that you but me as the government where my spending is a large component of all spending when I change my spending I changed national income which affects my tax revenue so yeah that's what the rest of us and because I'm talking it you and me small businesses large corporations and all other levels of government so I'm talking about state and local governments are users of Australian dollar we cannot run deficits forever because it leads to an unsustainable rise in private sector debt in fact I neglected to go to figure one so if you don't believe that a government deficit and a non government surplus and vice versa are two sides of the same coin there you go that blew the so that orange brown the orange colored line is general government and the blue line is non government and once it's the mirror image of the other so when the federal government runs a deficit there the non-government sector runs a service of the same amount and vice versa so you can you can see if here's the in these years here you've got the federal government running a deficit was it because the government was trying to run a deficit now if that if the non-government sector is running a surplus because it's determined to it's going to alter its discretionary spending to make sure it positively saves out of net income it's a pot then that's what's gonna happen the government budget deficit no matter how hard it tries to run a surplus and the second figure okay you can see what the effect of this is if a government in fact runs a soup or so when the federal government runs the surplus you well it depends it depends on on your spending and your your net savings desires when the government runs a surplus it's not injecting that much into the occult maybe but it's it's not injecting as much money in by way of money that's been created in spending in existence as it's taking from you so you have less income so you have less income to finance your spending and your saving so when that happens you have to make up your mind whether you're going to meet your spending desires or your savings desires you cannot meet both and when the Australian federal government ran our ten budget surpluses in 11 years that's because we said okay we're going to spend and we're gonna borrow so he ran deficits and that allowed the the government's only way it allowed the government to run a service so when Peter Costello was beating himself on the chest saying he was a friend of the taxpayer wasn't he great running surpluses well he only got that because we ran deficits but you can see the effect of deficits over time this is household debt to disposable income the ratio and you can see that in that period the ratio of household debt to disposal linked disposable income rose until it reached and this was replicated pretty much around the world to some extent until it reached an unsustainable level we can't run deficits and when that happens we switch from meeting our spending desires and and abandoning our savings desires to having to save to pay back the debt and so we stop spending and you get a collapse of spending why was and that's where you get the global financial crisis so things like the subprime mortgage crisis that was just the straw that broke the camel's back that's all it was it wasn't the cause it was the trigger the cause is the inadequate net spending of central governments which requires for the non-government sector to spend or a certain level to run deficits and build up their debt to against to an unsustainable level so why was this she sharp decline that was the little fiscal surplus by the Rudd Government it led us to spend because it was extra income coming this week it's fading so we're able to bring down our debt to some extent now I can I should have Stevie probably knows better than me this this so that's 2 mm where is it now it's it's it's up high so that's 175 percent we're at the time of the global it's around about one hundred and ninety percent so it's above in Australia pre global financial crisis levels and whilst that doesn't necessarily mean we're going to get a recession what it means is that we're about the ratio of household disposable income to debt to household disposable income where we cannot borrow more in net terms we cannot run deficits okay we can't do it because that would just push our get up to a level that is unsustainable all right so if we can't run deficits the government can't run surpluses and so the federal government won't run surpluses as far as the eye can see the only way the federal government will ever run a surplus as if this comes down about here and then we decide to borrow in the aggregate so unless this comes down to here and that will require years of the federal government running very very large deficits the government will not run a circus and will just be sort of going along at a pedestrian pace what-have-you not really spending much more not less not really saving it and so forth all right the federal government has no debt as such I mean they use his term debt that's it's it's really an inaccurate word when they talk about federal government debt what they're really talking about is the RBA is the Reserve Bank of Australia that's Australia's central bank and basically it means a case of the Reserve Bank selling federal government bonds okay selling bonds on behalf of the federal government to manage interest rates so the argument is when the government runs a deficit there's a shortfall the Reserve Bank sells bonds to get money to finance the shortfall nonsense don't even have to do it don't have to do it and in fact in the 1980s and 1990s the Japanese central government didn't do it didn't bother and I've got time I might explain what that what the implicit explain what the implications of that were I can tell you what they were that meant the interest rate went down to zero percent so it's why the right in Japan was around 0% despite the Japanese central government running huge budget deficits but they didn't matter the Japanese government is the monopoly owner and issue of the Japanese yen so it doesn't matter so you hear all this nonsense about Japan you know the so-and-so the proverbial is going to hit the fan in Japan one day it's not going to happen the Japanese central government will not run out of Japanese yen and there are people around the world more than happy to buy Japanese bonds government bonds because they know the Japanese government can pay those bonds because they're paid for in Japanese yen and the Japanese central government has got as much yen as it likes federal government gets fed and government bonds are denominated in Australian dollars so the federal government can always repay bondholders always the federal government is not strictly in debt when it sells bonds so if you you sell something in a sense and it means you you know you owe that to someone but if God as much money as your like if someone wants their money back you're not really good you're really in debt if you if you've got a text earn money borrow money or sell something to get money to pay back but if you can just dip your hand into a pool of Australian dollars and say you want you your money back and you hand me over the bond and I can I'm not really in debt mi so you might ask why why they got the Reserve Bank on behalf of the federal government sells bonds well it's to manage interest rates right you hear on the news there once a month when the Reserve Bank Board meets and they they say the Reserve Bank's kept the target cash rate at the same level hasn't moved interest rates and they are able to do that by buying and selling bonds okay and when the federal government runs a deficit it has to sell bonds to maintain its target cash rate I won't go into the explanation for that now if I could explain it perhaps in the Q&A session but so the reason why the Reserve Bank sells bonds when the government runs a deficit is so the Reserve Bank can set and maintain a a target interest the only reason why it does it and of course in Japan I didn't do it in the eighties and nineties so the interest rate just dropped down to zero percent I won't explain why it went all the way to zero percent but it did so this is this nonsense that budget deficits place an upward pressure on interest rates now they do the opposite they do the opposite if the if the central bank doesn't respond when that the central government runs our deficit if pushes puts downward pressure on the short-term interest rate not upward of course if if the government I said before the government didn't just not print money and spend ridiculously so that total spending within the economy exceeds the productive capacity the economy because that would be hyperinflationary and that might force the central bank top raise interest rates well that's an artificial raising that's not a natural raising of the it's not determined by market forces market forces would still be pushing the rate down if if the central bank wasn't intervening it just intervenes in this different way so that the target rates a bit higher this by the way when when the federal government or a central government sells bonds it doesn't sell you a bit of paper and you give money but the money I won't go into that can actually buy a government security except on the on the secondary market all right well just assume that you can okay if you buy a bond it will probably be because you can earn some interest okay now that money that be prior to you buying the bond is sitting in your bank account when it's an actual fact sitting in your bank's reserve a the exchange settlement account it's called that your bank holds with the Reserve Bank and the Reserve Bank is paying your bank interest for doing that you don't get the interest the bank doesn't pass it on to you alright so if you buy the bond right so you say I'll take the money out of my account well it the fact comes out the Reserve Bank's reserve account exchange settlement account so the bank loses it ah and you now earn the interest and your bank doesn't you know any interest in settle but the key thing is what's happened here there's money sitting in an account earning interest and which has been earned by the bank your bank and now it's being earned by you so what does the Reserve Bank done it's merely just picked up some money that was in your bank's reserve account and plunked it in a Reserve Bank term deposit account bonds are nothing more than Reserve Bank term deposits but they're saleable transferable turn deposits so when you get your you know you've got a bit of cash you perhaps I have a term deposit with your bank you can't sell that and it's a different type of term deposit bonds thing a Reserve Bank term deposit is one that you can sell that on to you because bonds can be traded but it's just it's just a Reserve Bank term deposit and of course the government doesn't have any more money that it had previously or didn't have previously sorry for spending purposes so so-called selling bonds doesn't give money doesn't come to the government the reason why the government sells bond yeah I've mentioned taxation is destroyed it's designed to destroy some of your spending power so I permanently destroy some of your person as your spending pair so my spending isn't hyperinflationary okay bonds also gets money out of the system but not permanently temporarily while you're holding it as a bond or you got it in a Reserve Bank term deposit account it's out of the system and that's that allows the central bank to target and maintain a particular interest rate it comes back alright when you redeem the bond and so forth in which case well people are returning bonds people buying bonds at the same time we have a break alright so we're just going to take a five-minute break this pizza over there there's agitator okay now now we've got some pizza in our stomach you'll probably all fall asleep now [Laughter] so I whoops what Scout it's not the slightest slides out moving well well it probably wouldn't if the air is out working all right I can yes all right okay so I've got up to this one here which is on functional finance a thing called functional finance which I guess in a sense is what you were engaging it once once you fully understand modern monetary theory and you and you and the government it fully exercises its spending and Taxation powers in a way to meet various goals without worrying about the budget bottom line it's irrelevant functional finance it's not about and what's the budget bottom line it's whatever it is because it's irrelevant what it is whether a surface does not increase the ability of the federal government to spend any more than a deficit reduces it okay if you've got a bottomless pit of Australian dollars you've got an infinite amount of dollars infinity plus X's infinity infinity minus actors infinity so surpluses and deficits don't or the fact that there's an infinite amount of money that the federal government can get in any stage now remember you've got to differentiate between what the government can access in terms of money for spending purposes and how much it should so my view is with modern monetary theory is if there's one question the Australian federal government treasure treasure it should never ask is okay that that sounds like a good policy where am I going to get the money for that the treasure is always what the federal treasure has got to ask if there's if he or she is going to ask the question is am I going to get the real resources yet will they be available to purchase in order to do policy X that's all the federal government Treasury has to think about are there enough real resource of our if there are idle resources available the federal government can dip into its bottomless pit as a bit of money and purchase it if there are no resources available because our spending yours and mine is meeting the productive capacity of the economy.

so there's no and I like I said before and I want to get hold of more resources I've got to reduce your demand for resource and that's when I start taxing in ITEX you so your demand goes down so when mine goes up if equal to the productive maximum productive capacity of the economy to keep it there if I want to increase my spending I've got to reduce yours so I use taxation to do it if the spending is below that level I can increase my spending I don't have to tax you because I can live spending up to so functional finance basically involves the federal government which is I said before the monopoly owner an issue of the Australian dollar net spending and by net spending I mean so G G represents government spending and tiers tax revenue so if G is greater than T it's what we commonly refer to as a budget deficit I don't call it that I call it a fiscal injection cuz when I spend G I put money into the I inject money in the economy and when I tax you I destroy it so money disappears if I if I spend more than I tax there there's more going in and coming out that's a fiscal injection I like that term because people see deficit as a bad thing but if you call a fiscal injection which is what it really is then people see it completely different or differently sorry so functional finance is where the federal government has their monopoly on an issue of is going on next achieve a range of economic social environmental goals right so these are the things that matter that's relevant for governments focus on this and you can you see your current affairs shows o Q and I or something like that where they're debating the budget they're debating the budget by a budget repair they're talking about this thing which is relevant when when all the debate should be about this how do we how do we achieve those goals and no one should ever say well we can't quite achieve those goals because the federal government's run out of money can't do it we won't run out of productive capacity all right so we can only produce so much to meet certain goals all right so there's always going to be limited on productive capacity but the idea that the federal government can run out of this stuff and if it's not a deficit we've got to do something about the deficit and therefore we can't achieve these goals because that's just nonsense it's counterproductive so function functional finance involves a Gavin Smith ignoring the budget bottom line which has no relevance to a currency issuing central government such as the Australian federal government since a major social goal should be full employment the federal government should always net spend to the level required to achieve and maintain full employment now you hear people say our to achieve full employment where yeah we need to get the unemployed to do more training I mean that's a bit like when you've got unemployment it's a bit like that child the children's birthday party game of musical chairs all right there's 11 kids trying to get on 10 chairs well you can make them you run around the house for a month before the birthday party so they're all better able to get a chair but I can tell you what when the music stops one won't get a chair that's the unemployed person you you can only have full employment if there are enough jobs to meet the people who want jobs and you can only get that if total spending within the economy is at the full employment level of income little our way do whatever you want because low wages just reduce spending no there's nonsense about cutting penalty rates and it will mean that small businesses will employ more people now they won't the chances are they're not selling as many cups of coffee on a weekend because people got less money because they're because their weight has been cut okay so yes so because of one of the major social goals should be full employment the the federal government could achieve full employment tomorrow in a sense anyone who wants a job it could say okay I'll put you to work not wouldn't work for the Dolf scheme it might be some decent minimum liveable wage you know thirty forty thousand dollars a year now ideally people wouldn't be on the this is referred to as a job guarantee I don't know if you've heard of this it's sort of like an employer of last resort scheme alright so if you can't get a job in the private sector and the conventional public sector you walk through the doors of a job guarantee office and they put you to work on about thirty four forty thousand dollars a year all right and then if the economy picks up so to speak and so there's more private sector vacancies at higher wages you quit that job guarantee job and you get that job instead and I'd say the job guarantee is not designed for you to stay on it alright but it's but it's designed to give people a decent income but more importantly is the psychological effect of unemployment and in terms of mental health unemployment has virtually a bigger effect than anything else on a person's mental well-being a period of lot of unemployment more so than a death of a loved one was that right and people don't recover years later studies have shown that it sounds ridiculous but one of those studies showed that even if a person EPS unemployed for twelve months goes back to work you'd have to pay them it's it outrageous I've got to say myself that you'd have to pay them on top of what they're being paid out there that ways they're earning now they're back to work an extra $100,000 a year for them to be of satisfaction that they were prior to being unemployed that's that's that gives you some idea of what the impact is so if unemployment is important because it affects people's mental health it affects the incomes that people have got so you combine home they're homeless homelessness is due to that people got sufficient income combined with a mental illness effect of unemployment it just exacerbates the problem so the government should always ensure that total spending matches the productive capacity of the economy and provided there are sufficient idle resources available for use what I can tell you this there's 1.8 million Australians that are idle at the moment they there's 800,000 unemployed people in Australia and 1 million underemployed people in Australia so ok when you employ someone you employ.

 they have to have some tool or instrument or machine or whatever and so whether there are those available to use in combination with the labourers idle labour resources to produce it's that's another matter but in terms of labour there's also there is plenty of idle resources that labor resources labour pair that the federal government could purchase and put to use to provide all sorts of community benefits and so forth so the providers sufficient resources available for use the federal government can always mobilize them can always put them to use in other words through expanding to increase the supply of public goods in the areas of health education transport communications and green infrastructure so basically when there's unemployment not only is there not enough spending to employ everyone but there is probably a hospital ward that has been built as a consequence now that that's a cost in itself you could argue that the fact that the hospital ward hasn't been built there's an environmental benefit and there is well yeah well it's a to say that that's not the case is to say that there is no cost associated with increasing output which of course there is so you have to weigh up the tube up but it's it's full employment is not about in the end ensuring that any lost output is made up by having more people employed that's not the main objective of it it's it's because people are right to work if they want it and because of the psychological effect of unemployment but bear in mind as I said when people go unemployed there's something that hasn't been built some service it hasn't been provided that could be provided they could be helping someone else all that and and all themselves

40:52
 so what I've said I can spray in a diagram like this that's my bathtub diagram alright there's a lot of right so here's my bathtub I want you to imagine that there's the bathtub and that size of that bathtub represents the productive capacity economy alright.


then the capacity the economy to produce goods and services the water level represents the spending right represents if the water level is right at the top you've got full employment and an acceptable inflation rate so you got a full bathtub spending equals productive capacity this is where we basically been operating for 45 years meetups up needlessly since the early 1970s the water level below the top because the government's worried about running a budget deficit which is irrelevant so federal government spendings about 25 percent of all spending so if that's where it's spending is at present 25 percent it's federal government spending and the remainder is state local governments and private sector basically okay so if the government wants to put more water into the bathtub because the water levels too low it is and obtains water in other words money from its bottomless reservoir of Australian dollars just turns and so water flowing into the bathtub which is government spending increases the water level what attacks us Duke well there's a drain down here that just leaked that just destroys spending power so your taxes I've got a bin where water doesn't really go on a bin but I wanted something like waste so I just goes nowhere so if the government is running everything else hold constant if the government's running a balanced budget there's as much more to going in to the bathtub is coming out and the water level stays at the same level if the government if the water level is here and I'll talk about this soon and the private sector it has a balance then yeah it's a bit tricky because it I'll get to this bit later on the government the government can and in fact it wouldn't be running a balance but I'll explain that soon if it wants the water level to rise it's got to put more water in than it taxes it's got to run a budget deficit a fiscal injection so what what was Peter Costello doing who's bidding stuff on the chest he was drowning more water out of this bathtub and he was putting him and saying well what a wonderful treasure I am for running all these surpluses in actual fact the water level didn't go down the only didn't go out with the talk wasn't remained didn't mind wasn't sort of kept with it was kept up here only because and I don't have it you know I've got to say but I could have banks here and have another one going here and that's because we borrowed we can put the banks can create some water as well but it's a bit different because when banks when governments create money for spending purposes they're creating a financial asset money is a financial asset but when the federal government creates money spends in any resistance it creates a financial asset but no offsetting financial liability like I said before when the federal government prints money it doesn't owe it to anyone no more than the manufacturer of the board game Monopoly owes monopoly dollars to someone okay so it when it's spends and assuming it's it will increases its spending and it's not changing its Taxation though more net financial assets going in the economy net thing net of taxes all right and of course if when the government taxes it's destroying financial assets so when the government's running a deficit it can increase the water level it has the capacity depends again as I said on that and I'll get to this a bit later on on the private sector net savings desires but it can basically increase the water by putting more water in than it has leaking out through taxation and can someone say are now it can't do that because there's a limited amount of water for the federal government no there's as much as the federal government wants so can always keep the water level at the top of the bathtub and maintain full employment now as I said before that doesn't mean the federal government should go crazy print monies and just spend whatever because if it does the water level goes above the level of the bathtub and that's spending greater than productive capacity and there's hyperinflation so when the water level goes over the top of the bath you've got high from frozen so but anyone who would advocate function of Finance would never say the government should increase its net spending so what the water levels above the top of the bathtub it would say increase it keep it there and don't go any further not a dollar for a dollar more but not a dollar less so what have I got here I've got to remember that's a leakage order and that's an injection in terms of now I've removed exports and imports because that does play a part but just assume that X this is and it's exports are equal to its imports and we don't have to worry about that okay so that makes good but well it up well okay oh well in fact it does matter the current decay yep which is even worse for Australia I kept that to explain this diagram and if you think that most of those exports imports are by the non-government sector but foreigners and people squalene citizens tractor making transactions amongst themselves so just ignore the external sector so when the government puts more water in the bathtub than its draining out through taxation that what it doesn't necessarily rise and the reason why it might not is because this is savings which is another leakage and this into our vaults that's our accumulated private-sector savings all right our savings that we have and some of this gets injected back in the form of investment okay so if the government's putting more water in than it's draining out in other words G is greater than T the water level can stay at the same level if s is greater than I of course the water level goes up in the vault doesn't it so put more in then it's draining out and the water level stays at the same level in the bathtub it goes up in the vault okay that's basically what happened for about 30 years in Australia after World War Two so this red line that's that's that's the critical point yeah because if if we drain our accumulated savings we get to some critical point something like a global financial crisis somewhere to keep that up there and in the 30 year period after World War Two the government basically ran deficits most of the time it ran deficits so the water level was pretty much up the top of the bathtub and because it was putting more water in than it was draining out that meant that the private sector water level in its vault was going up so it meant that we had lots of savings we had savings to call upon if something hit and shocked the economy okay if there was some shot to the economy that caused spending to go down a bit in there bit of income to go down what did we divided the private sector they just went and grabbed some of its savings and spent that and that and so recessions in that 30-year period there weren't really any we're incredibly short and shallow now they're more long protracted and deeper because we don't have this accumulated savings anymore so we had to dip into if the if things go well but in actual fact we don't need if we had a government that knew it had a bottomless pit of our bottom was reservoir of water it could just so even if we're in the private sector spends hardly anything the federal government can always offset it so the water levels up here so I can anyway the problem is that we get to this critical point the private sector cuts its spending the government needs to fill the gap and the Treasury goes got any money yeah and it's not just yeah Barack Obama said the same thing he said I can't do that anyway so you can see that when the when the federal government runs a deficit and the water level stays at the same level in the bathtub but goes up in the vault that explains why a government deficit is equivalent to a private sector surplus at the cup even though the water level in the bathtub staying the same level if G is greater than T it's a deficit and there's the surplus as it's accumulating over time in the form of accumulated net savings should I go into this I probably won't that's pretty much what I had to say so because people ask if injections always equal leakages because it turns out the two injections are government spending and and private sector investment back so this I for investment and G they're injections you've got injections there and the two leakages are taxation and savings those two together must equal those two all right but that doesn't mean that G so if G and I equals S Plus T that doesn't mean he has to be the same as G doesn't mean that S has to be the same as I just some other two have to be the same injections must equal leakages I so but but that suggests to you okay.


 if the water levels here and the government runs a deficit and the private sector runs a surplus okay they'll put more water in than that drains out this will go up but the water level will never reach the full employment level I'd say you like the whole idea of there being leakages equals two injections can raise the question how does how does the government get the water level up well it's what what that neglects to and I sort of alluded to this before to recognize is that when the government spends it increases the Nash Nash '''l income which not only increases its tax revenue because tax revenues tied to national income increases your income and you spend more and that's the multiplier effect of government spending so what level goes up you got more income you spend more and it goes up further so let me well just a couple things I want to get to that door and it's a horrible looking diagram but I just want to point out that don't worry about the Green Line worry about these blue bars here this was for the period so these are financial used 1953 for 2013-14 that 60 years 60 odd years the federal government ran 44 deficits in 18 surpluses in 62 years big deal I mean they're potentially there was a potential for a constraint because it was a different course a slightly different financial system then but the gap government never reached that financial constraint but the important thing is is that governments run deficits most of the time and we want them to because it allows us to net safe if we want to net safe we have to have the government running deficits so the deficit is the norm are we paying taxes now for those past deficits of course we're not a prank for them now I mean we go back to what taxations for okay if let's say we're at the full employment level of income and there's a certain amount of taxation a certain certain amount of government spending savings and investment and the government is determined doesn't think there's enough hospital beds or something and so it wants to spend more well the biggest concern is that it's gonna the water level is going to go over the top of the bathtub and the inflationary because there's no real resources available it's feelings so what does the government do as I said before it taxes the private sector so it drains so your your some of your spending power goes down here and disappears forever all right which means the government can provide more hospitals the water level can staff here without there being hyperinflation oh yes do we part because the government's generally running a deficit rather than a surplus are we paying taxes because of it now because of those past everything no we're not so the only reason why we only need for the government to taxes here is related to the position in this particular year you know only has to tax us sufficiently if it wants to maintain full employment to ensure the water level doesn't go over the bath top of the bathtub and B - Flay shinri that amount that the government taxes us has nothing to do well you could say that something insofar as past deficits so if it was government spending on infrastructure what-have-you that can affect the size of the bathtub the productive capacity of the economy there's got nothing to do with past deficits so you do not pay for past deficits all right let's just gone after deficit in the classes it's just something that's disappeared Saten it's irrelevant and it's not affecting the ability of the federal government to spend today and Suffolk doesn't that's totally irrelevant it's not owed to anyone it just was a deficit in that year big deal so you know it's surpluses this idea of an intergenerational fun putting surplus I I know Norway has purchased a lot of physical assets but you've probably heard of this as a sovereign wealth fund of of Norway just imagine if it was just all of it was Norwegian kroner sitting in a vault and in a building and that building burnt down and that Norwegian kroner was was destroyed what could the Norwegian government do just printed stuff and replace it well if it can replace it why doesn't it just do it well okay yeah I peps I should get there here's a good time for that I just been Steve and I just went to a conference in the USA in Kansas City there's a branch of the Federal Reserve Bank of the USA there's a museum there we didn't actually get into the museum because we've got to take our passports you need to have a fee-only field not an American citizen you need your passport but doesn't know that the security guard gave us this which is shredded US dollars about 165 dollars worth it was interesting because Steven I asked the security guard what's the normal reaction from people and they you normally go what a waste they could thank you just give that to poor people well they probably don't know US government does give money to poor people probably not enough but it just gives them nice crisp notes instead you wouldn't do that if there was the money that was sitting in your wallet or purse would you and you're an American citizen you wouldn't do that why would you do it is you can't replace it the meaning Gavin the US government can do it because he just replaces it and and if it can replace it then then it begs the question does it have to shred some money before it can print money of course doesn't so it didn't have to shred out on $65 before I could free 165 dollars so I can print as much as it likes it's got as much money a u.s. u.s. dollars not other currency any US dollars as it as it likes okay yeah let me I know this might look a bit awkward but let me just go that's five ten minutes to go through this this is similar the bathtub type diagram but it it does help explain how the extra government spending even though injections always equal equal edges raise the water level up so the full employment level now this is a particular point in time these two here this is another point in time so forget about the bottom two here that distance there basically represents the productive capacity of the economy so I think of that is that there's the bathtub okay you've got spending and you've got a thing called national income one person spending is another person's income so they always there's two ways you've heard of gross domestic product is two ways in which they measured there's an income approach and spending approach alright doesn't matter which one you use GDP is the same so that will they will always come side with each other here we've obviously got the amount of national income and spending this is private sector spending this is government spending the blue the blue is government the income of course this is private-sector income and government income I guess you could call red tax revenue although it's not really income but let's just call it that for now okay and so total spending is less than the productive capacity so this shaded bit here represents unemployment because the water level is not at the top you can see here that the private sector spending is less than its income well if you spend less than you earn you say don't you so s is greater than I so that debt that bit there which is this plus that sorry this this plus that so this Plus that - it gives you the him getting it confused myself but you can see if the private sectors income exceeds its spending it's going to be net saving they can only occur if the government's been it's revenue so that is the government deficit and that is the private sector surplus okay they must match hefty okay so what if the government isn't happy with unemployment and we're assuming that the productive capacity economy that by the way it's called a bad deficit the government running a deficit okay spending is greater than its revenue but it's a bad one because you've got unemployment there's things called bad gifts so not all differences are good cameras running a deficit now it's not a good one cuz it's not big enough that's basically what it means um okay so the government decides to increase its spending so it increases total spending up to the full employment level of of spending and income okay so what happens the government spends more as I said before that increases income which if I spend more your income goes up so you spend more I also earn more taxes but you can also not only spend more you can also save a bit more so I've given you extra money you can spend a bit more and save a little bit more safely you have a look here this is the spending of the private sector so it's a little bit more than was here so it's just so spending is going up because you've got more income you're spending a little bit more your your income has gone up and I've drawn it in such way as and and I've need to do it in factual fact it this this has to be larger than that in order for this to rise if I'd have done it in such a way that that and that were the same size that wouldn't have changed all right so the deficit actually gets bigger not by the size of the increase in government spending I said people think government's running a deficit of so much increases spending the difficult go by there much it doesn't spending goes up but its revenue goes up alright because it increases national income and that also gives us more income to consume more and say more so in the end you've got your full import there that's what this is a good budget deficit well the government under the principles of functional finance net spins to the level required in this case the chief achieve full employment it's got a deficit big deal and this is basically how economy should operate most of the time the government needs to run a deficit because it allows us to net safe because if they try to run surpluses we don't have enough money to spend and save if we choose to spend we go into debt because we can't save we have to borrow if we choose to save instead we have to reduce our spending and so you have a recession so deficits are good and we don't probably recognize it but we we've given currency issuing central governments are given the power to run deficits for our benefit for our benefit I mean the federal government is effectively the only legal counterfeiter of the Australian dollar and we need someone to be a counterfeiter a counterfeiter means they produce but they can generate more financial assets than they create new financial liabilities you've got because in order for us to be safe we have to require more financial assets than we take on new financial liabilities so someone's going to create the difference and the only entity that can do that is the Australian federal government and it can only do that by spending on real goods and services labor capital and so forth so we need the federal government most of the time to run at it now other occasions where it might be worth running a surplus well it's your name's research generally when the government runs a surplus it wasn't even trying if I go back to that last figure I had okay here with E so these are the deficits there and he hears some surpluses this is the one in the late 1980s the Labour government back to that 1990 the Labour government was running a surplus he wasn't even trying Inca GDP was strong enough at the time the unemployment rate filled about 5% which is still not falling for something high and the government had coffers we're not tax revenue went up exceeded the government spending and and but it also me what we're doing thank they only they date they heard this surplice because without even trying because we decided to run a deficit where he decided we'll spend a lot and we'll increase our debt by borrowing well that's the only way they can run a surpluses for us to run a deficit only way remit their two sides of the same coin here you've got in the early 1970s a surplus and of course here's the Costello years and what do they have in common what what happened in the mid 70s recession what happened in the early 1990s following all these recession what happened it were we avoided it to some extent in Australia only cuz the the stimulus package of the Rudd Government if we hadn't done what every other country did we would have had unemployment up around 10% as well so you can see that when governments run surpluses and we run deficits inevitably it leads to a recession where you get to the point where our debts build up and in order to service them because we can't increase our debts anymore they get to a critical level we have to start saving in other words paying the debt back we reduce our spending now that doesn't necessarily cause the recess because we didn't actually have a recession Global post global financial crisis only because when our spending crashed the federal government filled the gap to some extent not enough but to some it fact it wasn't enough because it should fill the gap sufficiently their full employment you can do it and in fact we haven't had full employment for 45 years means that the deficit has been big in our or the surplus has been too small right yeah but but no but I mainly sorry the government service has been too big if the deficit has been big enough and the government surpluses has been too big if if it's run a surplus because you can get a situation where the government will run a surplus if so if we get to a point so let me go back to this don't my gran here let's just assume that the government kevin rudd was still in the prime minister of the counter he's been running these huge deficits since 2008 and big deal doesn't reduce the capacity of the federal government to suspend and because they state only did it for a brief period so we're able to bring our debt down for appear and then I stopped the stimulus package I shouldn't have like let's say they continued I'd drive it down to here now we're in a position where if we want to for a year or two we could spend a lot and get an end perhaps Boren in net terms well because we're well short of the critical rail if we do that the gum will run a circles he'll run a surplus even but tries to run a deficit um but we're not in this position we're up here for the federal government to run a surplus that's got to rise and it's not gonna rise and until it comes down cuz that's got to rise in order for the government run a service until it comes down somewhere around here which will require gum to run large deficits for a long period of time then the federal government won't be running a surplus for the foreseeable future not that that matters that's the problem if so caught up with this idea of having to Vincey run the budget back to surplus there's no need for it it's not going to so as it tries to run a surplus you get this situation your bear deficit it'll ends up running a deficit anyway because to run a surplus we have to run deficits we're not willing to run deficits so they can't run surpluses they're stuck with a deficit but because they cut their spending to try and go back to surplus this creeps down here and we get more unemployment so we get a bad deficit yeah yes is that enough I think that's pretty much it yeah that's fine not now it's well what I'm describing is a system that we have right now that is not being fully exploited by the federal government so what do you mean could happen what do you mean by that he means no no no no it's happening right now yeah yes so and because it's you know I say this about if we got a bad deficit because of modern monetary theory and the government not thinking that it has all these powers what does it need to borrow money for yeah so no it doesn't I know it does it doesn't know it doesn't do it doesn't borrow from the bank's over its got no idea what he's talking about yeah it taking funds away from the private sector forcing up interest rate this is nonsense in fact so one of the interesting because the argument is when the government spends its it's got to compete for funds and that drives up interest rates well in actual fact when the government spends because I mentioned that if it runs a deficit has to sell bonds which brings money out of the system temporarily rather than permanently that money that's coming out of the system is money injected in there in the first place where its own spending so it's spent it you've given me the physical stuff me to build hospitals and if you've bought bonds you've gone okay on a pocket in the Reserve Bank term deposit that's all it is and that money is not money that is being taken away from here there are everywhere it's money I put into the system that previously didn't exist in the system it's only in the system because I spent it into existence I don't know how much these people know or don't know this we talk about Steven I talk about we think there are people working on a desk probably 23 years of age with the Reserve Bank know how the Reserve Bank functions better than the Reserve Bank governor you know I think the current Reserve Bank governor's worked his way up through the Reserve Bank but quite often they come across from Sur and they have no idea about central banking but there's a 23 year old who's dealing with an exchange settlement accounts of all the banks when the government runs our deficit okay as I said it's injecting more money into the system this is the reason why the government sells bonds and it injects money in the system when it taxes it it destroys some so when it runs a deficit more goes into the system where does that end up that ends up in the exchange sediment accounts of all the banks remember I said if you've got money sitting in a bank account it's really sitting in your banks reserve a count okay so that's that's just sitting there and if that is earning it I said before it's earning interest okay that's the system changed that much I can I can give that explanation look so but the target cash rate that you hear on the news is 1.5 percent okay if there is an excess of reserves in the system and it's left overnight in exchange settlement accounts banks leave them there they will earn one point two five interest its point two five percent less than the target rate now some banks will have excess reserves some will have a shortage of reserves okay so these banks that have got and of course if you've got a shortage of reserves as if you can you can borrow from other banks or you can borrow from the Reserve Bank if you borrowed from the Reserve Bank you pay point two five percent above the target rate one point seven five percent that's the banks not you the banks okay so you're about you've got excess reserves and you can leave it in overnight at one point two five percent and but there's another bank that shortage of reserves and if it borrows from the Reserve Bank it'll play 1.75 percent so what do you say to that Bank you say how would you like to borrow the excess reserves we don't need this you've got a short at one point seven four percent okay yeah okay that's lower than one point seven five percent and and your bank will be making a profit because it won't be getting one point two five percent but one point seven four percent but there's another Bank with excess reserves going well hang on we want to get rid of Alex's will will lend it at one point seven three percent and then there's a counter off when I talked about Japan zero percent is because the default rate pay in fact it's now negative but let's say zero the default rate paid on funds left in what they I'm not sure what they call the exchange it's a reserve account in banks at in Japanese Bay is zero percent the government runs a deficit in Japan the central bank hasn't got a target cash rate it doesn't sort bans two bonds to drain these excess reserves what happens to the cash rate it goes down to zero percent because the government does and then because when people getting back to your question Andrew you're saying how that those bonds playing so it looks like the government's borrowing the money you know it's it's virtually equal to the size of the deficit they are well that's but they're no and it's not because as I said before the government doesn't have to do it and Japan is an example of it it didn't do it so it was short fall and there was no money yen coming from anyway because the central bank wasn't selling bonds because the central bank had a policy short-term interest rate fall to zero percent whatever we have a a Reserve Bank that does have a target cash rate and so if there is a deficit there has to be bonds sold to soak up the excess reserves so that the target cash rate can be me otherwise it will drop to 1.25 C so what looks like borrowing from the bank's the gap is in fact none other than a mechanism for the reserve bank to set and maintain a target interest rate when the government's running a deficit it's not borrowing at all but and but surendra you're talking about the the interest paid on those bonds I said before they became bonds that were in fact reserve bank term deposits earning interest what we were they before they were in those reserve accounts earning interest they're really paying interest on it they just pick it up and go back a bit and by doing that the this system when it's in the reserve accounts in the system driving the cash right now so bonds gets picked up goes out of the system and the interest rate target is met it's a temporary removal whereas taxes you get the money back by earning money but you won't get the taxes back it's gone forever it so that sort of answer you could say they're not borrowing at all hahaha let's anyone want to tell this I have no idea who's next oh okay yeah yeah he can well well perhaps it's not the best to talk in terms of look the cook basically I think you're right what you're trying to say is I've said that if the private sector runs a surplus so it's not saving the the federal government central dome has to run a deficit that's not entirely true if where can the extra revenue come from the by by the country net exporting all right so we get extra income which means that that provides that but of course those those financial assets we earn are denominated in a foreign currency so we save basically in the form of foreign currency denominated finance financial assets now I didn't say anything about net exports because it would've come but even if you do that here's a question why because most people think that exporting is good the most fundamental principle in economics is the opportunity cost principle and the opportunity cost principle is based on the idea that the cost is what you give up and the benefit is what you receive so what you give up is the opportunity cost when a nation exports it gives up goods that's a cost it's only seen as a benefit because when you calculate GDP its plus X because GDP only measures what you produce not what you consume okay so when you export you give something up to the rest of the world you never see it again you use your labor your scarce resources to produce it and to give it to the rest of the world when you import something the rest the world give something to you okay now government can run a circus if the private sectors running a circus if the trade surface is big enough if we're giving enough to the rest of the world or over and above what the rest of the world is giving to us now why would you want to do that why would you because let's let's assume that X is exceeding okay wouldn't it make sense for because what it basically the only reason why it really I've got a country near exports is because the central government is not net spending to the level required for us to meet our savings desires and there's still some idle capacity and we use that to produce goods which we need export to the rest of the world now why would you do that wouldn't it be better the difference between exports and imports if the central the federal government purchased that paid the same price GDP is exactly the same our incomes the same what happens to the stuff that the government purchases purchases stays in Australia and he can use it to build schools hospital and bridges instead of us producing things that suit the demands of people oversee so it makes no sense it is a way you can get around it but you only need export as a country in order in order to overcome the fact that the net that the central government's not net spending enough to give us enough income for us to meet our spending a net savings desires if we don't get enough income and there's idle capacity and we're not going to spend any more and the government's not one of you spending more we produce the stuff and we send it overseas and we the government can always the difference what a piece of paper what you get something in return but it's and in many cases in the case of China accumulating US federal government bonds okay and handing stuff over the USA vogue those bonds that they bikini line if that if the Chinese top if China wants to redeem the value of their bonds the fewest federal government is to them and for all those years China has been stupid enough to be exporting to they know they're now they've now a new policy to increase domestic consumption alright because China consumption is a ratio and it makes no sense well if you if well it depends if you've got a flexible exchange rate and you've got a gate well and if you end up with a current account surplus you'll have a capital account deficit well cap again the worst services that can be misleading it's a capital account deficit in that if you're a net exporter the rest of the world oh you more money then you owe to them and so you then to you end up being a lender so capital flows out we lend it to them okay but in actual fact we're in the advantageous position when we've got well strategy opposite we generally have a perpetual current account deficit and a capital account surplus okay so what does that mean so just quick what does that mean it means that we're not in that position where we can have the private sector with a surplus in the government with a surplus I've just been teaching in Singapore I didn't talk about things slightly differently there because that is a part of the world where the government can run a surplus the private sector can run a surplus because they need exports so much but you know Singapore who which is a fairly wealthy country could be even wealthier if it was consuming the stuff themselves and the pouring government was buying those real resources are different we exports and imports infrastructure goods to the Singaporean people yep sorry well I'm next him before grief you know people say ah strategy can't run deficits for too long or will end up like Greece I mentioned before I don't know if you but that the Greek government is in terms of its capacity to spend is no different to the South Australian government it's a user of the euro a regional currency it can't print euros to spend to offset a decline in private sector spending I mean it could if the European Central Bank gave them but they're not giving them the money they've got an austerity sort of approach and so that's why why a country would give up its own its monopoly ownership and issuance of its own currency is beyond me it just doesn't make sense whatsoever yeah but even that's not enough if so the unemployment rate in the eurozone is still incredibly high so there's not enough spending within the zone itself all the conventional economics books should be you used to stoke a fire I mean that's a bad yep it's not a theory by the way it's a description yep yep actually how it is well the government's not really saying it's a it's it's the private sector that's it that's selling assets to the rest of the world ah okay yeah well it really has no different impact to the the government privatizing it and selling it to us okay so it's capacity its capacity to but that's not that that's not the real issue the real issue is that a lot of these things that are sold off have what are called public goods characteristics and if there is a part of mainstream economics that makes a bit of sense its public goods public goods a particular characteristics such that if you allow the private sector to provide them you won't get them provided in sufficient quantities which is why to do them so if you privatize public goods okay then you don't get sufficient public goods so that's the real problem it's not the revenue issue that's privatized I think it's a big con I mean and it's made worse by the fact that the things that have been sold off things with public goods characteristics augment natural monopoly characteristics it's a form of market failure and there's no evidence to suggest when we talk about large-scale production that the private sector is any more efficient than the public sector okay this idea that if you got a public sector hat on yes it and you drink coffee or go behind a desk and then you take that off and put affright private sector hat on and you're all ready to go I'm efficient now this is just absolute garbage I mean in fact I've got a lot of friends are in the in the public sector if you could probably earn a lot more money in the private sector and they're incredibly committed people so this idea that the public sector is inefficient is just sheer utter nonsense okay because well they don't understand it either yeah I don't do they're not fully conversant with the economics or even if they did well it's a chance to score a political point because the public don't know well well it just goes to show they they they well you could argue that I don't know these people personally so I don't know how much they actually know and what they don't yes but but but one of the things that modern monetary theory can do as I said you can be I don't write so bad news but this imagine a real horrible person on the far right okay they can operate they can even learn the principles of modern monetary theory apply them and still implement right-wing policies if they want to it doesn't mean that you once you've got this knowledge you obligated to run left-wing tight policies but the thing is what is the problem with those people on the far right is that when they do something and it might mean well you're not doing enough to reduce unemployment they say well the government hasn't enough money yeah the gun could spin and reduce okay once everyone knows about modern monetary theory people go no no no no that's that's that's not so what's your real reason for unemployment so modern monetary theory offers an opportunity to lift the veil of all these ideological nonsense they hide behind our ignorance what they say done any kind of full employment run out of money sorry miss Li well I guess see that I don't know if these people even know what they're and I don't know well federal treasury sorry it speaks it the federal Treasury every year publishes the budget papers forecasting budget surpluses in the future you have to ask the question is it anyone in federal treasury who knows if I became prime minister I would save the people in federal treasury don't like sacking people you can have your job but only if you're willing to be retrained if you're not off you go sorry Judy got more designs .
 
 
 
hail:90:30
we have tried I did a talk similar to Phil's not as good as Phil's but similar to Phil's about four years ago which was organized by the South Australian Greens I rewrote the economic policy of the Australian Greens when I was a member of that party the South Australian Greens National Party completely blocked any discussion of it because they don't dare and discuss these ideas Richard Di Natale basically blocked it we've done an interview we've done interviews with people from the Labour Party on video they never published the interviews and they are terrified of discussing these kind of ideas because they're afraid that they'll be crucified in the press 


91:00
and one of our colleagues stephanie kelton was the chief she was the chief economist and the Senate Budget Committee in Washington DC for the Democrats she was Bernie Sanders chief economic adviser Bernie Sanders perfectly well understands these ideas but basically refused to discuss them during the election campaign for the same reason is because I've had to say something that immediately in your mind you said you're a lunatic I go into politics and I say this I don't have an hour now to explain it I look like before so that's why the politicians aren't interested in even saying a bit of knowledge of it all right here no the if if the they federal camera just runs a surplus okay that's a good point well hmm well it doesn't so long as the water level doesn't go over the top of the but how do you stop doing that I mentioned the thing called a job guarantee yeah so if you've got private sector spending that's fallen and the government has to fill the gap the government doesn't estimate how much it needs to fit somewhere near then it relies upon the job guarantee to get it right at the top not a dollar more not a dollar less how does it ensure that it's at the top because the amount of spending that's required to achieve full employment with a job guarantee depends upon the number of people who walk through the job guarantee offices so if you need to spend so much to put ten thousand people have lost their jobs yesterday into a ten thousand people will walk in the government doesn't have to calculate what it is so at the margin they find the job guarantee does the fine-tuning okay to ensure and whatever that wall and if that water level you right the the private sector is gone in a massive deficit the government runs a surplus as I said the budget bottom line the government isn't worried about is what it is so when the private sector runs a deficit wallet it runs a surplus I spent eight years in the Senate and when the then Labour government wanted to privatize CSL and I said to the in the Senate I said there was no need to privatize CSL you could easily create the credit to refinance a hill and keep it in government ownership Peter Walsh was the Minister of Finance and Peter Walsh said that is an old-fashioned idea he didn't say there was anything wrong with it who is just that it was old-fashioned but fill that there's one factor that I think you've left out of your talk I accept that governments can create whatever it needs up to the limit of available labour and available resources without that being inflationary however there is another restriction in the system and that is the environmental restriction Australians for instance at the present time if the whole world used resources like we do we'd need five point two earths so we need to cut down our use of resources to roughly 20 percent of what we're currently using if we're going to be equitable and fair with the rest of the world so weird as where does that come in does it come in by way of a a tax on resources or allocation of resources by some sort of a government system but the thing is okay this is another and I've got to say there are some people who support the job guarantee don't like me saying this because a lot of these people don't even they talk about a constraint they obviously there's only so much available even if you don't think about ecological constraints these people don't think enough about ecological constraints and so they're of the view that the sole purpose of the job guarantee if there's unemployment is to increase spending so that the my now if you happen to be a country where your resource uses is within some ecological construct so you can afford to have a bit more resources the job guarantee is an ideal way of increasing spending up to the full employment level I like the job guarantee because I think it is a wonderful way because if we are going to have to shrink the economy but still have full employment we've got to find a really good way of rationing you can come through work and job guarantee you can do that you'd obviously have to cut the heads off the rich super rich but but not to pay for anything that's that's one of the people and the progressive say are you know the rich after the tax I that government's got money to spend on the poor well it doesn't need that at all it needs to cut their heads off the rich because it's the rich yeah and when I say to you I've got nothing against rich people but but but well it's not just that I'm of there's a thing called economic rent it's it's a horrible okay what it's not the rent you pay on a house I'll get an example of it it's a best way to do it okay a sports people earn economic rents think if the I don't know what this training captain's cricket captain's on they say it's a three million dollar contract okay uh if you started taxing away the Australian captain's cricket captain's income would he start doing something else and how far could you reduce his income through taxation to he gets the point he says I'm applying for strategy man how to do that well I reckon you could probably tax if it's streaming in I reckon you could probably tax away point sixty point seven million dollars before he changes his labor supply and you can do a talk about the same with Natural Resources so until that person switches what they're doing that amount okay that you can tax away is an economic rent it represents unknown income because income really is the minimum amount that you have to be paid to provide your labor or your resources anything above that is an economic rent the government can tax it away and it won't affect the supply of that resource or that person whatsoever they'll keep doing it it's another Steve Smith Steve Smith he by getting a three million dollar contract he's claim on real goods and services as three million dollars but he's really income it's probably three or four hundred thousand dollars okay so the only way he can have that extra claim on rural sources and it not be inflationary is there must be other people who are getting paid less than what they contribute so they out their heads cut off because they're earning economic rents and you know some people say where do you really think it or I'm of the view that the Prime Minister's job is probably the most important job in the land Prime Minister's own about five hundred thousand dollars a year well I don't believe anyone's worth more than five hundred thousand dollars a year and you have a hundred percent income tax rate at five hundred thousand because I think anything above that is an economic rent but I stopped not just yeah I can already political language of politicians I think sorry thanks I think one of the things that I know it sounds a bit harsh I think we've got to call politicians to account in a more serious way we don't we don't know much about new they may not be a single neurologist in this in
 
 
 Phil LawnMMTと 2017 年度財政注入のメリット https://youtu.be/zX7vavr5ncs JPk9 +収益の道具PhilLawnMMTとFiscalInjectionsのメリット243回放送•2017/10/20120共有れStevenHailチャンネル登録者数395人 ステージコピーこんにちは、正常に動作しているので、ERに関するメモです。ユーレイは1993年にニューサウスウェールズと南オーストラリアの3つの小グループが集まったときに設立されました。基本的には、現代経済学者ではない経済学を冷静に分析できる異端派経済学者です。非常に得意であり、一般的なパラダイムの外に出ることができ、90年代にはさらに世界的な危機が発生するのを見ることができます。彼らは、ヨーロッパと北で開催された同様のまたは主要な会議に沿ったもう1つの経済サミットであるtoesと呼ばれる3つの会議を開催しました。アメリカと彼らはシドニーメルボルンとアデレードでそれらを組織し、1995年にアデレードシドニーブリスベンとキャンベラで開催された他の多くの公開会議や他の会議を主催し、有名な異端派経済学者や他の改革者がカルマとの関係と連絡を確立しました。彼らが訪問を後援したカナダのラスのカウンターパートである通貨と経済改革に関する委員会は、英国の預言者のマイケル・ロボトムを含む海外からのいくつかの有名な経済改革者のためのオーストラリアの講演ツアーとメディアインタビューでした米国のブレイン教授とアイルランドのロバート・コンスタンザ教授によるカナダのハッサンは、カナダのジョン・ライト元副首相とニュージーランドなどのステファニー・ディリア氏を待っているため、EAはさまざまなセミナーやプレゼンテーションを開催しました。何年にもわたって、いくつかの首都で十分な情報に基づいた講演者がいて、そのようなイベントの長い歴史と多様性が数多くあり、彼はまた、金融および銀行改革に関するいくつかの政府の問い合わせに提出し、特に特に定期的なIRAレビューでは、以前のCRAレビューのコピーがテーブルにいくつかあります。読むことを歓迎します。また、いくつかの芝生に関連する論文は、明白な希望について直接話しません。関連する論文と今夜は、これについてソブリン債務に関する神話と誤解を招く方向について議論するため、神話がこれを引き起こすように、これも一緒に行われます。家庭経済学部では、いつでもここのユニに立ち寄ることができます。プレゼンテーションや講義の紹介も行いますので、フィルにお譲りします。ありがとうございます[音楽]

よろしくお願いします。簡単なマイク今日は今夜のプレゼンテーションで大丈夫だと言わざるを得ません基本的に私がやろうとしていることは、現代貨幣理論と呼ばれるものについて少し話します。現代貨幣理論を知っているかもしれない多くの人々が、それはある種の新しいアイデアの枠組みまたはあなたが持っているものであると考えているので、私は私のプレゼンテーションをするために現代貨幣理論についていくつかのことを言います政府は現代貨幣理論の枠組みの中ですでに運営されているわけではないので、システムが実際にどのように正しく機能するかを説明しているので、連邦政府に負担をかけている連邦政府は現在、現代貨幣理論タイプの枠組みの下で運営されています。それは適切に機能しているので、それで大丈夫です。現代貨幣理論の主な目的は、ジョンが何を、何を、中央政府を発行する通貨の支出と課税権を理解することです。m国の通貨の所有者および発行者であるオーストラリア連邦政府のような通貨発行中央政府と、実際にオーストラリアにある通貨のユーザーである政府のユーザーとを区別する予定です。彼らは州政府と地方政府と呼ばれ、彼らは彼らの支出能力を連邦政府とは完全に異なっています、そしてもちろん私たちはユーロ圏政府を持っています、彼らは彼ら自身の通貨の独占所有権を放棄するので同じように動作します州政府がオーストラリアで行っているように、彼らは通貨の発行者ではなく、その通貨のユーザーであり、それは彼らの支出能力に大きく影響します。現在のヨーロッパでの結果を見ると、ここオーストラリアの連邦政府はその支出と課税の権限を最大限に活用しているわけではないので、この現代貨幣理論は、一種のシステムを説明するものとして考える必要があります。金融と金融のシステムを見るレンズと私は今、なぜ私たちが政府の財政赤字から利益を得るのかを言うとき、私は基本的にほとんどの場合連邦政府がそれを言っているのかについて話します常に有利であるとは限らない赤字を実行する必要があります。それが黒字を実行する場合、それはお金が不足しているために黒字を実行する必要があるためではありません。連邦政府が余剰を実行しなければならない理由について説明しますオーストラリア連邦政府の予算の収益はまったく無関係であり、連邦政府が基本的に制御できないものです連邦政府の予算の収益は純貯蓄の欲求によって決定されます連邦財務省がそれを知っていれば、毎年財務省の書類が出てくるたびに、予算が黒字に戻ることについて法外な予測をすることはなく、それは完全に民間部門の純貯蓄欲求に依存します。民間部門が現在の収入から積極的に純貯蓄を望んでいる場合、政府はそれが好きかどうかにかかわらず予算赤字を実行します重要なことはそれがそこでうまく実行されるべきであるかどうかです」良い予算不足と悪い予算不足のようなもので、今夜は2つを区別します。ここにいくつかの事実があります。それは、オーストラリアドルの独占所有者である連邦政府が小さすぎないように読むことができます。 AUDはオーストラリアドルを指します。連邦政府は支出の制約はありませんが、実際のリソースの制約に直面しているので、支出目的で好きなだけオーストラリアドルを持っていますが、それは可能です。無限の量の物を買う今、私たちは不足している世界に住んでいるので、彼らは本当の資源の制約に直面しているので、連邦政府がお金を印刷してそれを存在に費やすのであれば、連邦政府はお金を印刷して存在に費やす必要がありますインフレだけの実際の資源制約を超えていますが、連邦政府がすべきことは、政府支出である純支出である必要があります-オーストラリア経済内の総支出が常に収入の完全な雇用レベルになるように、レベルまでの課税純支出それは単にインフレになるのでこれ以上進むべきではありませんが、それが黒字か赤字かは関係がないので常にそのレベルまで使うことができますそれは将来の連邦政府の支出能力に影響を与えないのでそこにあります」s基本的にキャンベラのキャピトルヒルにある底なしのオーストラリアドルの穴なので、連邦政府は支出目的で好きなだけオーストラリアドルを持っていますこのコンピューター時代に連邦政府がよく使うとき、連邦政府は基本的に銀行口座に電子的にクレジットすることによって費やしますですから、政府がうまく使うために印刷機を動かしていると思うなら、それは現金を利用できるように印刷機を動かしますが、それはそれが書いていたコンピュータ時代の前でさえそのように使われていなかった方法ではありません私は小切手を書き出すのに使用しましたが、コンピューターの時代ではそれを行う必要はありません。それでもうまくいきます。s段階的にチェックアウトするので、連邦政府の支出の1ドルごとに銀行口座に電子的にクレジットを入れることで、新しいドルの作成と支出が含まれます。作成された新しいお金はどこからも来ないので、これはどこからも来ないことも指摘できます。新しいお金それは基本的に新しいお金ですそれは何もないところから作成されて存在するために使われた以前には存在しなかったお金ですそれが無限の金額を持っているなら政府はあなたのお金を必要としませんそしてあなたが税金を払う理由を説明します連邦政府の税金それは基本的にあなたの本物の需要を規制するために、連邦政府がそれを手に入れるのに十分な本物があります。それは課税の海塩マクロ経済的目的であり、それは理にかなっているので私はそうします。連邦政府では、あなたは本物を要求する民間部門です。販売可能な本物の総需要が販売可能なものを超える場合、私は本物を要求します。それが完了し、価格が押し上げられ、超インフレになります。ですから、それが起こっている場合、私は政府として何ができるのでしょうか。実際の物の総需要がインフレを制御するために利用できる実際の物と正確に等しくなるように支出を減らすことができますが、支出したい場合、または特定のレベルを提供する場合はどうなりますか学校や病院など、インフレがうまくいかない方法でやりたい私はあなたの支出を減らし、どうすればあなたの支出を減らすことができますか私はあなたに課税します私はあなたの支出ペアのいくつかを破壊するのであなたのお金の創造とお金を印刷する」本当ではありませんが、あなたが望むなら、連邦政府はもはや自分のためにお金を稼ぐために誰かを借りておらず、ボードゲームモノポリーのメーカーは独占ドルを印刷するプレミアのために誰かを借りているので、連邦政府が政府は、ボードゲームのモノポリーのメーカーが誰であるかを知らない人にそれを支払う義務があります。ジョン・サンズはかつて彼らが所有していない会社だったと思います。モノポリーをプレイしたことがあり、Wow John Sandsが誰かに多くのモノポリードルを隠していると思ったことはありません。もちろん、連邦政府が銀行口座から電子的に借方に記入することで民間部門に課税することはありません。あなたが税金を払うあなたの銀行口座の一番下の行である番号を持つコンピュータハードドライブその番号は電子的に減少します連邦政府の課税のすべてのドルは古いお金またはシステムにすでにある古いお金の永久的な破壊を含みます古いお金連邦政府の課税によって永久に破壊されたものは、政府が創設したときと同じ場所には行きませんし、支出はどこにもありませんそれは大きく異なります申し訳ありませんが、連邦政府は永久に赤字を実行できるので、連邦政府の赤字は私がしない非連邦政府の黒字を構成するので、無限の金額は永久に赤字を実行する可能性があり、ほとんどの年で赤字を実行する必要があります。実際、連邦政府の赤字という用語を使用するのはよくあることです。それは悪いことのように聞こえますが、政府が赤字を出しているときは本当に財政注入であり、より多くのお金を生み出し、それを実現するために費やしているので、私はあなたにもっとお金を与えています私があなたから課税から奪っている物を買うことによって、私が赤字を実行するとあなたは黒字を実行するので、私は降りて、連邦政府に黒字を実行してほしいと人々に尋ねました、そしてほとんどの人はそう言います余剰を実行するために私はそう言いますそして私はあなたが余剰を実行するために同じコインの両面があることはできません私は赤字を実行する必要がありますそしてあなたが赤字を実行する場合IIは潜在的に黒字を実行することができます実際、私は黒字を出しますが、あなたが黒字を出すと決心した場合、私は赤字を出します。s正確に今何が起こっているのか、そして私があなたのことを個別に話していないと言うとき、あなたの何人かは話をしていないかもしれませんが、民間部門が安全を確保したいのであれば、それは連邦政府として私が赤字を出していることを意味します余剰を実行しようとするのがどれほど難しいか実際に支出を削減した場合に余剰を実行しようとするのが難しいということは、経済内の支出が少なくなることを意味します。そしてそれはあなたがあなたの支出を賄う収入としてあなたに行くお金であり、あなたはその収入から節約していますそしてあなたが特定の金額を節約したいそしてあなたがより少ないお金を持っているならあなたはより少ないお金を使うことを意味します国民所得と政府課税の減少は国民所得のプラスの機能であるため、支出を削減するときに税収を削減します。そのため、年間5万ドルの場合、政府予算と家計予算を多くの点で同等にすることはできません。あなたは$ 10,000の赤字を超えて60,000を費やしているので、来年は50,000を使うつもりですが、$ 50,000を使うと、あなた以外の政府としての私がすべての支出の大部分を占める政府としての収入には影響しません。私が支出を変えるとき、私は税収に影響を与える国民所得を変えました。そうそう、それは私たちの残りの部分です。私が話しているので、あなたと私は中小企業、大企業、そして他のすべてのレベルの政府です。m州政府と地方政府はオーストラリアドルの利用者であり、それは民間部門の債務の持続不可能な増加につながるため、私たちは永遠に赤字を実行することはできません。非政府の黒字とその逆は、あなたが行った同じコインの両面であり、オレンジブラウンのオレンジ色の線は一般政府であり、青い線は非政府であり、かつては他の政府の鏡像であるため、連邦政府の場合政府はそこで赤字を出し、非政府部門は同じ金額のサービスを実行し、逆もまた同様です。そのため、ここ数年でここにあるかどうかを確認できます。連邦政府が赤字を出しているのは、政府が赤字を出しているのは、非政府部門が黒字を出している場合、裁量支出を変更して確実に確実に節約できると判断したためです。純収入のそれはポットですそれはそれが黒字を実行しようとしても政府の財政赤字が起こることになるでしょうそして2番目の数字は政府が実際にスープを実行した場合にこれがどのような影響を与えるかを見ることができます連邦政府は黒字をうまく実行しますそれはあなたの支出とあなたの純貯蓄の欲求に依存します政府が黒字を実行するときそれはおそらくオカルトにそれほど多くを注入していませんがそれはお金としてそれほど多くのお金を注入していませんそれ'sは、あなたから取っているので、存在する支出で作成されます。そのため、収入が少なくなり、支出と貯蓄の資金を調達するための収入が少なくなります。その場合、支出の欲求を満たすかどうかを判断する必要があります。またはあなたの貯蓄はあなたが両方を満たすことができないことを望みますそしてオーストラリア連邦政府が11年間で私たちの10の予算黒字を実行したときそれは私たちが使うつもりだと私たちが言ったので私たちは借りるつもりなので彼は赤字を実行しましたそしてそれは政府だけを許しました政府がサービスを実行できるようにしたので、ピーター・コステロが納税者の友人だと言って胸を殴っていたときはそうではありませんでした。大きなランニング黒字は、私たちが赤字を出したためにそれを手に入れましたが、時間の経過とともに赤字の影響を見ることができますこれは可処分所得に対する家計債務の比率であり、その期間の処分にリンクされた処分に対する家計債務の比率を見ることができます収入はそれが達するまで上昇し、これは持続不可能なレベルに達するまである程度世界中で複製され、赤字を実行することはできません。それが起こったとき、私たちは支出の欲求を満たし、貯蓄の欲求を放棄することから貯蓄をしなければならないことに切り替えます借金を返済するために私たちは支出をやめ、あなたは支出の崩壊を経験しますなぜそうだったのか、そしてそれはあなたが世界的な金融危機を経験する場所ですそれでサブプライム住宅ローン危機のようなものはラクダの背中を壊したただのわらでしたそれだけでしたなかったそれが引き金となった原因は、中央政府の不十分な純支出であり、非政府部門が赤字を出し、持続不可能なレベルまで債務を積み上げるために一定のレベルを費やす必要があるので、なぜこれが彼女だったのかラッド政権によるわずかな財政黒字であった急激な減少は、今週の追加収入であったため、私たちが支出することになりました。それは衰退しているので、ある程度債務を減らすことができます。スティービーにもっとよく知ってもらう必要があります。私よりもこれは2mmなので、今はどこにあるのか、それは高いので、世界の時点で175%であり、約190%であるため、オーストラリアの世界的な金融危機前のレベルを上回っています。それは必ずしも私たちが景気後退に陥るということは、家計の可処分所得と債務の比率についてであり、純額でこれ以上借りることができない場合、赤字を実行することはできません。私たちの取得を持続不可能なレベルまで押し上げて、赤字を実行できない場合、政府は黒字を実行できないため、連邦政府は連邦政府が黒字を実行する唯一の方法を目で見ることができる限り、これがここで下がったかのように黒字を実行し、それから私たちは総計で借りることを決定します。非常に大きな赤字を抱えている連邦政府は、サーカスを運営せず、歩行者のペースで進んでいくだけです。政府には債務がないので、彼の用語の債務を使用しているということです。つまり、連邦政府の債務について話すとき、それは本当に不正確な言葉です。彼らが実際に話しているのは、RBAはオーストラリアの準備銀行です。中央銀行とは基本的に、準備銀行が連邦政府の債券を販売し、連邦政府に代わって金利を管理するために債券を販売する場合を意味します。したがって、政府が赤字を出した場合、準備銀行が取得する債券を販売する不足があります。不足しているナンセンスに資金を提供するためのお金は、それをする必要はありません。実際、1980年代と1990年代には、日本の中央政府はそれをしませんでした。暗黙のうちに何が意味するのかを説明するそれが何であるかを説明することができますそれは金利がゼロパーセントに下がったことを意味したので、日本の中央政府が巨額の予算赤字を実行しているにもかかわらず、日本の権利は約0%でしたしかし、彼らはしませんでした日本政府が日本円の独占所有者であり発行者であるかどうかは関係ありませんので、問題ではないので、日本についてのこのようなナンセンスをすべて聞いてください。日本の中央政府は日本円を使い果たすことはなく、日本政府が日本国債を支払うことができることを知っているので、日本国債を購入することを喜んでいる人々が世界中にいます。日本の円で返済され、日本の中央政府は連邦政府が供給され、国債はオーストラリアドル建てであるため、連邦政府は常に債券保有者に返済することができます。ある意味で何かを売って、それはあなたが誰かにそれを借りていることをあなたが知っていることを意味するが、誰かが彼らのお金を取り戻したいと思っているならあなたが好きなだけのお金を神が持っているならあなたは本当に良くないあなたがテキストを持っているならあなたはお金を稼ぐかお金を借りるか何かを売ってお金を返済するためにお金を稼ぐがあなたがオーストラリアドルのプールに手を浸してあなたにあなたのお金を返して欲しいと言ってあなたが私に債券を渡すことができるならそして、私はできます」m本当に借金がないので、なぜ彼らが連邦政府に代わって準備銀行を手に入れたのかと疑問に思うかもしれません。準備銀行が目標現金金利を同じレベルに維持したことは金利を動かしておらず、彼らは債券を売買することでそれを行うことができ、連邦政府が赤字を出したとき、目標現金を維持するために債券を売らなければならないと言います金利Q&Aで説明できれば、今は説明しませんが、政府が赤字を出しているときに準備銀行が債券を売るのは、準備銀行が目標金利を設定して維持できるようにするためです。それがそれをする唯一の理由、そしてもちろん日本では私はしませんでした80年代と90年代にそれを行ったので、金利はちょうどゼロパーセントに下がった。なぜそれがゼロパーセントに下がったのか説明しないが、それはそうだったので、財政赤字が金利に上向きの圧力をかけるのはこのナンセンスである今、彼らは反対のことをします。もし中央銀行が応答しないなら、中央政府が赤字を出しているなら、プッシュが短期金利に下向きの圧力をかけるなら、もちろん、私が前に言ったなら、彼らは反対です。政府は単にお金を印刷してばかげて支出するだけでなく、経済内の総支出が経済の生産能力を超えるようになりました。それは超インフレであり、中央銀行のトップが金利を引き上げることを余儀なくされる可能性があるためです。これは自然ではない人為的な引き上げです。それを上げる」市場の力によって決定されない中央銀行が介入していなかった場合、市場の力は依然として金利を押し下げているので、中央銀行がこのように異なる方法で介入しているため、連邦政府または中央政府は債券を売っていますそれはあなたに少しの紙を売らずそしてあなたはお金を与えますしかし私が入らないお金は実際に政府の証券を買うことができます債券を購入した場合、それはおそらく、債券を購入する前のお金が銀行口座にあるのに、銀行の準備金にある交換決済口座にあるので、ある程度の利息を稼ぐことができるからでしょう。あなたの銀行がリザーブバンクを保有していて、リザーブバンクがあなたの銀行の利息を支払っていると言われています。私は私の口座からお金をうまく取り出します。事実は予備銀行の予備口座交換決済口座から出てくるので、銀行はそれを失い、あなたは今利息を稼いでいます、そしてあなたの銀行は決済への利害を知りませんが、重要なのは、ここで何が起こっているのかというと、口座に利息を稼いでいるお金があり、それはあなたの銀行が稼いでいるのですが、今はあなたが稼いでいるので、準備銀行は何をしているのですか? 'sリザーブ口座とリザーブバンクのタームデポジット口座の債券はリザーブバンクのタームデポジットにすぎませんが、売却可能な譲渡可能なターンデポジットなので、あなたがあなたを得るとき、あなたはあなたが少しの現金を持っていることを知っていますあなたはおそらく私が持っていますあなたの銀行へのタームデポジットあなたはそれを売ることができませんそしてそれは別のタイプのタームデポジット債ですリザーブバンクタームデポジットは債券が取引できるのであなたにそれを売ることができるものですがそれはただのリザーブバンクタームです預金、そしてもちろん、政府は以前に持っていた、または以前に支出目的で申し訳なかったお金をもう持っていないので、いわゆる債券の販売はお金を与えません政府が政府に来る理由はありません債券を売るええ、私は課税が破壊されると言いました」sはあなたの支出力の一部を破壊するように設計されているので、私はあなたの支出ペアとしてあなたの人の一部を永久に破壊するので、私の支出は超インフレではありません大丈夫債券もシステムからお金を引き出しますが、あなたがそれを債券として保持している間は一時的にではありませんまたは、リザーブバンクのタームデポジットアカウントで取得した場合、システムから外れているため、中央銀行は特定の金利をターゲットにして維持することができます。これにより、債券の償還などで問題なく返済されます。債券を購入する人々が債券を購入すると同時に休憩がありますので、5分間休憩しますこのピザはあそこにありますアジテーターは大丈夫です今私たちは胃の中にピザを持っていますあなたはおそらくすべて落ちるでしょう今眠っている[笑い]だから私はそれをスカウトするものをフープしますほんの少しのスライドがうまく動いているわけではありません。空気がうまく機能していなければ、おそらくうまくいかないでしょう。はい、大丈夫です。ここで、機能的財政について説明します。これは、機能的財政と呼ばれるものです。ある意味では、現代貨幣理論を完全に理解し、あなたとあなたと政府が、予算の収益を気にせずにさまざまな目標を達成する方法で支出と課税の権限を完全に行使すると、それは無関係な機能です。財政それは問題ではなく、予算の収益は何であるかそれが何であるかは関係ありません。なぜなら、表面が赤字以上を費やす連邦政府の能力を増加させないかどうかは無関係なので、底なしの穴があれば大丈夫ですあなたがオーストラリアドルの無限の金額の無限大に加えてXの無限大の無限大マイナス俳優の無限大を持っているので、黒字と赤字はありません。政府が支出目的でお金の観点からアクセスできるものと、現代貨幣理論での私の見解は、オーストラリア連邦政府の宝物が決して尋ねるべきではない質問が1つある場合、それは良い政策のように聞こえますが、私はそのお金を手に入れるつもりですか?その宝物は常に連邦政府の宝物が尋ねなければならないものです彼または彼女が質問するつもりかどうかは私が実際の資源を手に入れるつもりですか?ポリシーXを実行するために 'sすべての連邦政府財務省は、利用可能なアイドルリソースがある場合、私たちの十分な実際のリソースがあるかどうかを考えなければなりません。連邦政府は、少しのお金として底なしの穴に浸り、利用可能なリソースがない場合はそれを購入できます。私は経済の生産能力を満たしているので、ありません。前に言ったように、より多くのリソースを手に入れたいので、リソースの需要を減らす必要があります。それが、ITEXで課税を開始するときです。経済の生産最大生産能力に等しい場合は私が上がると、支出を増やしたい場合はそれを維持するために私はあなたを減らす必要があるので、支出がそのレベルを下回っている場合は課税を使用してそれを行います私は自分の支出を増やすことができます」機能的な財政は基本的に連邦政府に関係しているので、私はあなたに課税する必要があります。これは、独占所有者の前にオーストラリアドルの純支出の問題であり、純支出とは、GGが政府支出と階層税を表すことを意味します。収入なので、GがTより大きい場合、それは私たちが一般的に財政赤字と呼ぶものです。私はそれを財政注入とは呼びません。私がGIを使うとき、私は経済にお金を注入し、私は課税するときにそれを財政注入と呼びますあなたは私がそれを破壊するので、私が税金よりも多くを費やすとお金が消えます。財政注入私はその用語が好きです。なぜなら、人々は赤字を悪いことと見なしているからです。しかし、財政注入を実際のところと呼ぶと、人々はそれをまったく異なる、または別の方法で申し訳ないものと見なすので、機能的財政は連邦政府が独占しているところです。次の問題は、さまざまな経済的社会環境目標を正しく達成するために行われているので、これらは政府がこれに焦点を当てることに関連する重要なことであり、あなたはあなたの現在の情勢がQと私またはそれらがいるようなものを示しているのを見ることができます彼らが予算を議論している予算の修復によって予算を議論している彼らはこのことについて話しているこれは、すべての議論がこれについてあるべきときに、どのように私たちがそれらの目標を達成するのか、そして誰も私たちができると言うべきではないときに関連しています'連邦政府の資金不足ではそれができないため、これらの目標を完全に達成することはできません。生産能力が不足することはありません。特定の目標を達成するために生産できる量は限られているため、常に制限があります。生産能力ですが、連邦政府がこのようなものを使い果たす可能性があるという考えと、それが赤字でなければ、私たちは赤字について何かをしなければならず、したがって、それは単にナンセンスであるため、これらの目標を達成することはできません」s逆効果の機能的財政には、オーストラリア連邦政府などの通貨発行中央政府とは関係のない予算の収益を無視するGavin Smithが関与します。これは、主要な社会的目標は完全雇用である必要があるため、連邦政府は常にレベルまで純支出を行う必要があるためです。完全雇用を達成し維持するために必要な今あなたは人々が完全雇用を達成するために私たちが言うのを聞きますええ私たちは失業者にもっと訓練をする必要があります私はあなたが失業しているときそれは子供の誕生日のようなものですミュージカルチェアのパーティーゲーム大丈夫11人の子供が10個のチェアにうまく乗ろうとしているので、誕生日パーティーの前に1か月間家の中を走り回って、彼らを作ることができます。椅子を手に入れることができますが、音楽が止まると失業者の椅子が手に入らないのは、仕事をしたい人とあなたに会うのに十分な仕事がある場合にのみ完全雇用できるということです。経済内の総支出が完全雇用レベルの収入である場合にのみ、低賃金は支出を減らすだけであり、ペナルティ率を下げることについてのナンセンスはなく、中小企業は今より多くの人々を雇用することを意味するので、私たちのやり方はほとんど何もしません彼らは週末にそれほど多くのコーヒーを売っていないという可能性はありません。なぜなら人々は彼らがなぜなら、彼らの体重は大丈夫に減ったからです。そうです。主要な社会的目標の1つは完全雇用でなければならないので、連邦政府は、仕事をしたい人なら誰でも大丈夫だと言うことができるという意味で、明日完全雇用を達成することができます。仕事はドルフスキームではうまくいかないでしょうそれはあなたが知っているある程度の最低生活賃金かもしれませんあなたが今年間3万ドルを知っている理想的には人々はこれに参加しないでしょうこれは仕事の保証と呼ばれます私はあなたかどうかわかりません「これを聞いたことがありますが、それは最後の手段の雇用者のようなものです。できれば」民間部門と従来の公共部門で仕事を得るには、失業保証事務所のドアを通り抜けると、彼らはあなたに年間約34.4万ドルの仕事をさせてくれます。ですから、より高い賃金でより多くの民間部門の欠員があり、あなたはその仕事保証の仕事を辞め、代わりにその仕事を手に入れます、そして私は仕事保証はあなたがそれをうまく続けるように設計されていないと思いますが、それは人々にまともなものを与えるように設計されています収入ですが、もっと重要なのは失業の心理的影響であり、精神的健康の観点から、失業は人の精神的幸福に他の何よりも実質的に大きな影響を及ぼします。そして人々はしません数年後の回復研究はそれがばかげているように聞こえることを示しましたが、それらの研究の1つは、12か月間失業しているEPSが仕事に戻ったとしても、彼らに支払う必要があることを示しました。彼らが失業する前に彼らが満足していたことを彼らが満足するために、彼らが今稼いでいる方法で彼らが今稼いでいる方法に加えて彼らに年間10万ドルの追加の仕事に戻る必要があるでしょうそれはそれです失業が人々のメンタルヘルスに影響を与えるために重要である場合、それは人々が得ている収入に影響を与えるので、あなたは彼らを家にまとめます」ホームレスのホームレスは、人々が十分な収入を得たことと失業の精神病の影響が原因で問題を悪化させるだけなので、政府は常に総支出が経済の生産能力と一致し、使用可能な十分なアイドルリソースがあることを確認する必要があります私が言えることは、オーストラリアには80万人の失業者がいて、オーストラリアには100万人の不完全雇用者がいる現在、180万人のオーストラリア人がアイドル状態になっているので、雇用する人を雇うときは、道具、器具、機械などが必要です。


ですから、それを生み出すために労働者のアイドル状態の労働資源と組み合わせて使用​​できるものがあるかどうかは別の問題ですが、労働に関してはそこにあります」■また、連邦政府があらゆる種類のコミュニティの利益などを提供するために購入して使用できる労働資源と労働ペアのアイドル状態のリソースがたくさんあるため、連邦政府が使用できる十分なリソースを提供者は常に動員できます。言い換えれば、健康教育輸送通信やグリーンインフラストラクチャの分野で公共財の供給を増やすために拡大することでそれらを使用するので、基本的に失業があるときは、すべての人を雇用するのに十分な支出がないだけでなく、おそらく病棟があります結果として建設されたので、それ自体がコストであるため、病棟が建設されていないという事実には環境上の利点があり、そうですね、それはそう言うことです」もちろん、出力の増加に関連するコストがないということではないので、チューブの重量を量る必要がありますが、最終的には完全雇用ではなく、失われた出力を確実に補うことはできません。より多くの人を雇用することはそれの主な目的ではありませんそれは人々がそれを望むなら働く権利があるからであり、失業の心理的影響のためですが、人々が失業するとき私が言ったように心に留めておいてください提供されていないサービスが提供されていて、他の誰かや自分自身を助けている可能性があるので、

40:52

私が言ったことは、このような図にスプレーすることができます。これは私の浴槽の図です。たくさんの権利があるので、ここにあります。

私の浴槽私はあなたにそこにあることを想像してほしいs浴槽とその浴槽のサイズは、生産能力の経済を表しています。次に、経済が商品やサービスを生産する能力は、水位が支出の権利を表し、水位が完全な雇用を持っている場合、許容可能なインフレ率で、フルバスタブの支出は生産能力に等しいこれは、1970年代初頭以来、政府が無関係な連邦政府の財政赤字を実行することを懸念しているため、基本的に45年間の会合を不必要に運営している場所です。政府支出は全支出の約25%なので、それが現在の支出である場合は25%です。連邦政府の支出と残りは州の地方自治体と民間部門が基本的に大丈夫なので、水位が低すぎるために政府がより多くの水を浴槽に入れたい場合、つまり水を底なしのオーストラリアドルの貯水池から取得しますちょうど向きを変えて、政府支出である浴槽に流れる水は私たちを攻撃する水位を増加させますデュークよくここに排水口があり、それはちょうど支出力を破壊するのであなたの税金私は水が実際にはないビンを持っていますビンに行きますが、私は無駄のようなものが欲しかったので、私はどこにも行きません。政府が水位をここに持っていれば、浴槽に入るのと同じくらい多くのことが出てきて、水位は同じレベルにとどまります。これについてはすぐに話しますが、民間部門はバランスが取れています。少しトリッキーです。政府は後でこのことを説明しますが、実際にはバランスが取れていないのですが、水位を上げたい場合は、もっと水位を上げる必要があることをすぐに説明します。税金よりも水を入れると、財政赤字が発生するので、胸に何かを入札しているピーター・コステロは、この浴槽からより多くの水を溺れさせていました。彼は彼を入れて、なんて素晴らしい宝物だとよく言っていました。実際には、これらすべての余剰分を実行するためのものです。実際には、水位は下がっていませんでした。話をしに行くのは残っていませんでした気にしないでくださいそれはここで維持されていたので私はあなたが言わなければならないことをあなたが知っているのですが私はここに銀行を持つことができましたもう1つここに行くと、それは私たちが借りたので、銀行は水を作ることもできますが、政府が支出目的でお金を作るとき、銀行が金融資産を作るときは金融資産ですが、連邦政府は、金融資産を生み出すあらゆる抵抗にお金を費やしますが、連邦政府がお金を印刷するときに私が前に言ったように、それを相殺する金銭的責任はありません。誰かに大丈夫なので、それが費やされ、それを仮定するときにそれはsそれは支出を増やし、課税を変更しませんが、より多くの純金融資産が経済に流れ込みますが、税金を差し引いたものは大丈夫です。もちろん、政府が課税するときに金融資産を破壊するので、政府が赤字を出しているときにそれは増える可能性があります容量のある水位は、私が言ったように再び依存します。これについては、後で民間部門の純貯蓄の要望について説明しますが、基本的には、漏出するよりも多くの水を投入することで水を増やすことができます。課税と誰かが言うことができます今では連邦政府のための限られた量の水があるのでそれはできません」s連邦政府が望む限り、常に浴槽の上部の水位を維持し、今は完全な雇用を維持することができます。前に言ったように、それは連邦政府が狂った印刷物のお金を使って何でも使うべきだという意味ではありません。水位が浴槽の水位を上回り、それが生産能力を超えて支出し、過膨張があるので、水位が浴槽の上部を超えると、凍った状態から高くなりますが、財務の機能を提唱する人は誰でも政府が純支出を増やすべきだと決して言わないでください。そうすれば、浴槽の上部の水位を上げると、それを維持し、それ以上進まないでください。私はここに着きました私はそれを覚えていなければなりません」漏れの注文とそれは今のところ注入ですそれは役割を果たしているので私は輸出と輸入を削除しましたがXこれはそうであり、その輸出はその輸入と等しいと仮定してくださいそして私たちはそれについて心配する必要はありませんですから、それはうまくいきますが、うまくいきます。実際、オーストラリアにとってはさらに悪い現在の崩壊は問題ではありません。私はこの図を説明するためにそれを維持しました。これらの輸出入のほとんどが非政府によるものだと思うならセクターですが、外国人と人々は彼らの間で取引をしている市民トラクターを不平を言うので、外部セクターを無視するだけです。政府が課税によって排出するよりも多くの水を浴槽に入れるとき、それは何をしませんか?必然的に上昇し、そうでない理由は、これが別の漏出である貯蓄であり、これが私たちの金庫に蓄積された民間部門の貯蓄であり、私たちが持っている貯蓄であり、その一部は投資の形で注入されるためです政府が排水よりも多くの水を投入している場合、つまりGがTよりも大きい場合、sがIよりも大きい場合、水位は同じレベルにとどまることができます。もちろん、水位は金庫室で上昇します。だからもっと入れて、それは排水され、水位は浴槽の中で同じレベルにとどまりますそれは金庫室で上がります大丈夫それは基本的に第二次世界大戦後のオーストラリアで約30年間起こったことですs重要なポイントええ、蓄積された貯蓄を使い果たすと、どこかで世界的な金融危機のような重要なポイントに到達し、それを維持し、第二次世界大戦後の30年間、政府は基本的にほとんどの時間赤字を出しました。それは赤字を出していたので、水位は浴槽の上部にかなり上がっていました、そしてそれが排出されていたよりも多くの水を入れていたので、それはその金庫の民間部門の水位が上がっていたことを意味しました、それは私たちがたくさん持っていたことを意味しました貯蓄の中に何かが打撃を与えて経済に衝撃を与えた場合に必要な貯蓄がありました経済に打撃があった場合、支出が少し減り、収入が少し減りました。そしてその貯蓄のいくらかをつかんで、それとあれとそれとその中での不況を使いました30年間、私たちが信じられないほど短くて浅いものは実際にはありませんでしたが、この蓄積された貯蓄がもうないため、より長く長く深くなっています。私たちの底に底なしの穴があることを知っている政府があれば、実際の事実は必要ありません。私たちが民間部門にいるとしても、連邦政府が常にそれを相殺できるものはほとんど何も費やしていません。ここで水位が上がるので、とにかく問題は、民間部門が政府がギャップを埋めるために必要な支出を削減し、財務省がお金を稼ぐというこの重要なポイントに到達することです。バラク・オバマは同じことを言っただけではありません。


彼が私にできると言ったこととにかくそうすることで、連邦政府が赤字を出し、水位が浴槽内で同じレベルにとどまっているが、金庫室で上昇したときに、政府の赤字が民間部門の黒字と同等である理由を説明することがわかります。 GがTより大きい場合、浴槽の水位は同じレベルのままですが、それは赤字であり、累積純貯蓄の形で時間の経過とともに蓄積されるため、余剰があります。これに入ると、おそらくそうではありません。私が言わなければならなかったのは、2つの注入が政府支出と民間部門の投資であることが判明したため、注入が常に漏れと等しいかどうかを尋ねられるためです。そこに注射があり、2つの漏れは課税と節約ですこれらの2つを一緒にするとそれらの2つに等しくなければなりませんがそれはGを意味するわけではないのでGとIがSプラスTに等しい場合それは彼が同じでなければならないという意味ではありませんGは、Sが私と同じである必要があるという意味ではありません。他の2つは同じである必要があります。


注入は同じである必要があります。セクターは余剰を実行します大丈夫彼らはそれが排出するよりも多くの水を入れますこれは上がりますが水位は完全な雇用レベルに達することは決してありません政府はどのようにして水位を上手く上げるのかという質問sそれが無視していること、そして私が以前に認識したことは、政府が支出するとナッシュナッシュの収入が増えるということです。これは、国の収入に関連する税収があなたの収入を増やすので、税収を増やすだけではありません。あなたはより多くを費やし、それは政府支出の乗数効果ですので、どのレベルが上がるとあなたはより多くの収入を得て、それはさらに上がるので、私がそのドアに行きたいいくつかのことをうまくしましょう、そしてそれは恐ろしい見た目の図ですがグリーンラインについて心配しないでくださいここでこれらの青いバーについて心配する必要はありませんこれは期間でしたので、これらは2013-14年に1953年に財政的に使用されました60年60奇数年連邦政府は18年に44の赤字を実行しました62年間の黒字は大したことですそれは別のコースであり、わずかに異なる金融システムであったため、潜在的に制約の可能性がありましたが、ギャップ政府はその金融制約に到達しませんでしたが、重要なことは、政府がほとんどの時間赤字を実行していることです。ネットセーフをしたいのなら、政府に赤字を出さなければならないので、赤字は当たり前のことです。過去の赤字に対して今は税金を払っています。もちろん、私たちは彼らのためにいたずらではありません。私たちが完全な雇用レベルの収入にあり、一定額の課税があり、一定額の政府支出の節約と投資があり、政府がそこにあるとは思わないと判断した場合、どのような課税に戻るか十分な病院のベッドか何かがあり、よりよく過ごしたいので、

最大の懸念は、水位が浴槽とインフレの上部を超えることになるということです。利用できる実際のリソースがないため、政府はどうしているのでしょうか。前に言ったように、民間部門に課税するので、あなたの支出力の一部がここで下がり、永久に消えてしまいます。つまり、政府は、ハイパーインフレが発生することなく、ここにスタッフが配置できる病院を増やすことができます。私たちは、政府が一般的に黒字ではなく赤字を出しているので、私たちは税金を払っています。政府がここで課税する必要がある唯一の理由は、水位が上がらないように完全な雇用を維持したい場合にのみ十分に課税する必要があることを知っているこの特定の年の立場に関連していますバスタブのバストップとB-政府が私たちに課税する金額のフレイシンリは何の役にも立たないので、過去の赤字に関する限り、政府がインフラストラクチャに費やしているのであれば、サイズに影響を与える可能性がありますバスタブの経済の生産能力は過去の赤字とは何の関係もないので、過去の赤字の代金を払わないでください。クラスの赤字の後で行ってみましょう。それは消えたものです。サテンそれは無関係であり、それは関係ありません。連邦政府の今日の支出能力に影響を与えておらず、サフォークはそれはまったく無関係ではありません。それは誰にも負っていません。それはその年の大した赤字だったので、余剰IIを知っている世代間の楽しみのこの考えは余剰です。ノルウェーは多くの物的資産を購入しましたが、これはノルウェーのソブリンウェルスファンドとして聞いたことがあると思いますが、それがすべてノルウェークローネが金庫室や建物に座っていて、その建物が全焼し、ノルウェークローネが破壊されたということは、ノルウェー政府が印刷物を印刷して、それをうまく置き換えることができれば、それをうまく置き換えることができるのはなぜですか。スティーブだったので、カンザスシティでアメリカの会議に行ったところです。アメリカ連邦準備銀行の支店があります。そこには博物館があります。私たちのパスポートを取る必要がありますあなたはあなたのパスポートを必要とするアメリカ市民ではなく有料のフィールドを持っている必要がありますが、警備員が私たちにこれを与えたことを知りません警備員は人々からの通常の反応は何ですか、そして彼らは通常あなたが彼らが感謝できることを無駄にします貧しい人々にそれを与えるだけです彼らはおそらく米国政府が貧しい人々にお金を与えることをおそらく知らないでしょうがそれは彼らに与えるだけです代わりにあなたがしない素敵な鮮明なメモあなたの財布や財布にお金が入っていて、あなたがアメリカ市民であるなら、あなたはそうしないでしょう、なぜあなたはそれをするのですか?


あなたはそれを置き換えることができないという意味です米国政府ができるギャビン彼はそれを交換するだけなので、それを交換することができれば、それは質問をしますそれはお金を印刷する前にいくらかのお金を細断する必要がありますもちろんそうではないので私が前に65ドルで細断する必要はありませんでした165ドルを解放できるので、好きなだけ印刷できます。他の通貨ではなく、米ドルではなく、好きなだけお金を稼ぐことができます。 '■これを通過する5〜10分は、浴槽タイプの図に似ていますが、注入が常に等しいエッジに等しい場合でも、追加の政府支出が水位を上げる方法を説明するのに役立ちます。したがって、完全雇用レベルは、これが特定のポイントです。この2つは別の時点なので、下の2つは忘れてください。そこの距離は基本的に経済の生産能力を表しているので、支出しても大丈夫なバスタブがあり、国民所得と呼ばれるものは、ある人が別の人の収入であるため、国内総生産について聞いたことがある2つの方法があります。それは、収入アプローチと支出アプローチがあることを測定した2つの方法です。どちらを使用してもGDPは同じなので、ここでは常に互いに並んでいます。明らかに国民所得の額があり、これは民間部門の支出です。これは政府支出です。青は政府支出です。収入もちろんこれは民間部門の収入と政府の収入です。実際には収入ではありませんが、赤税収入と呼ぶことができると思いますが、今のところは大丈夫であり、総支出は生産能力よりも少ないので、ここでこの影付きのビットは水位が最高ではないために失業しているので、ここでは、収入よりも支出が少ない場合、民間部門の支出は収入よりも少ないことがわかります。あなたは私よりも大きいので、そこにある借金はこれに加えて申し訳ありませんがこれに加えてこれに加えてそれはあなたにそれを混乱させますが、民間部門の収入がその支出を超えているかどうかを見ることができます純貯蓄になるのは、政府が歳入であり、それが政府の赤字であり、それが民間部門の黒字である場合にのみ発生する可能性があります。ちなみにそれが悪い赤字と呼ばれる生産能力経済を仮定すると、赤字を実行している政府はその収入よりも大きいですが、失業しているので悪いものです悪い贈り物と呼ばれるものがあるので、すべての違いが良いカメラではありません今赤字を実行している」それは基本的にそれが意味するのは十分な大きさではないので、政府は支出を増やすことを決定し、総支出を支出と収入の完全な雇用レベルまで増やします。私がもっと使うと収入が増えるのであなたがもっと使うと私ももっと税金を稼ぐだけでなくあなたはもっと使うことができるだけでなくもう少し節約することもできるのであなたが使うことができる余分なお金をあなたに与えましたもう少し安全にもう少し節約してくださいここを見てくださいこれは民間部門の支出なので、ここにあったよりも少し多いので、収入が増えているので支出が増えていますあなたの収入がもう少し増えて、私はそれを次のように描きました。実際にそれを行う必要があります。これは、これが上昇するためには、それよりも大きくなければなりません。これは、同じサイズで、問題なく変更されなかった場合に発生します。ですから、赤字は実際には政府支出の増加の大きさではなく大きくなります私は人々が政府が非常に多くの赤字を実行していると人々が思うと言いました国民所得を増やし、それはまた私たちにより多くを消費し、より多くを言うためのより多くの収入を与えるので、最終的にあなたはそこにあなたの完全な輸入を持っていますそれはこれが機能的財政の原則の下で政府が十分に良い財政赤字であるものですこの場合、チーフは完全な雇用を達成する必要があります。sは赤字を大きく抱えており、これは基本的に、政府が赤字を実行する必要があるほとんどの場合、経済がどのように機能するかです。なぜなら、彼らが黒字を実行しようとすると、支出して節約するのに十分なお金がないためです。私たちが支出することを選択した場合、私たちは貯蓄できないために借金をします。代わりに貯蓄することを選択した場合、私たちは支出を削減する必要があります。私たち私たちは通貨を発行する中央政府には、私たちの利益のために赤字を実行する権限が与えられています。つまり、連邦政府は事実上、オーストラリアドルの唯一の合法的な偽造者であり、偽造者である必要があります。私たちが安全であるためには、私たちが新しい金融負債を引き受けるよりも多くの金融資産を必要としなければならないので、彼らがあなたが持っている新しい金融負債を作成するよりも多くの金融資産を生成します。それはオーストラリアの連邦政府であり、実際の商品やサービスの労働資本などに投資することによってのみそれを行うことができるので、余剰をうまく実行する価値があるかもしれない他の機会に連邦政府を実行する必要がありますそれ'sあなたの名前の調査は一般的に政府が黒字を出しているとき、私がここでEで大丈夫だった最後の数字に戻っても試みていなかったので、これらはそこでの赤字であり、彼はいくつかの黒字を聞いていますこれは1980年代後半のものです労働党政権は1990年にさかのぼり、労働党政権は彼が試みさえしなかった黒字を実行していました。失業率が約5%に達したとき、インカのGDPは十分に強力でした。税収が政府支出を上回ったわけではありませんが、私たちが行っていることは、私たちが赤字を実行することを決めたので、私たちが多くを費やすと決めたので、彼らがこのサプリを聞いた日付だけに感謝しますそして私達はそれをよく借りることによって私達の借金を増やすでしょう」s私たちが赤字を実行するために彼らが黒字を実行できる唯一の方法は、1970年代初頭に黒字を獲得した同じコインの両面を送金する唯一の方法です。もちろん、ここにコステロの年と彼らの共通点があります。 70年代半ばの不況で何が起こったのかこれらすべての不況に続いて1990年代初頭に何が起こったのかオーストラリアではある程度回避したのは、他のすべての国で何もしなかった場合にのみ、ラッド政府の刺激策でした。失業率も約10%上昇したとしたら、政府が黒字を出し、赤字を出すと必然的に景気後退につながり、債務が積み重なってサービスを提供することになります。できる'債務を増やして危機的なレベルに達した場合は、貯蓄を開始する必要があります。言い換えれば、債務を返済する必要があります。支出を削減しますが、実際には景気後退がなかったため、必ずしも景気後退を引き起こすわけではありません。私たちの支出が墜落したとき、連邦政府がギャップをある程度埋めただけでは十分ではありませんでしたが、完全雇用を十分に埋める必要があるため、実際には十分ではありませんでした。 45年間の雇用は、赤字が大きいか、黒字が小さすぎることを意味しますが、そうではありませんが、赤字が十分に大きく、政府の黒字が大きすぎる場合は、主に政府サービスが大きすぎます。もしそうなら大きい政府が黒字になる状況が発生する可能性があるため、黒字を出します。もしそうなら、私たちがポイントに達した場合、これに戻りましょう。ここで私のおばあちゃんは、政府のケビン・ラッドがまだ残っていたと仮定しましょう。カウンターの首相は2008年以来これらの巨額の赤字を抱えており、大したことで連邦政府の一時停止能力が低下することはありません。表示された後、刺激パッケージを停止しました。彼らが続けたとしましょう。今はここまでドライブします。1、2年は、たくさんの時間を費やして取得できる位置にいます。私たちがガムが円を描くようにすると、クリティカルレールが十分に不足しますが、彼は黒字を実行しますが、赤字を実行しようとしますが、私たちはこの位置にいません私たちは連邦政府が実行するためにここにいます増加しなければならない黒字は増加しませんそしてそれが減少するまで政府がサービスを実行するために増加しなければならないこのあたりのどこかで減少するまでそれはガムが長期間大きな赤字を実行することを必要としますそうすれば、連邦政府は当面の間黒字を出すことはないでしょう。それは問題ではありません。ヴィンシーが予算を黒字に戻さなければならないというこの考えに追いついた場合、それは必要ありません。それはあなたがこの状況をあなたのクマの赤字にする余剰を実行しようとします」とにかく赤字を実行することになります。なぜなら、黒字を実行するには赤字を実行する必要があるため、赤字を実行するつもりはないので、黒字を実行することはできません。これを余剰にするためにここに忍び寄り、失業率が高くなるので、悪い赤字になりますええ、それで十分だと思います。それで十分だと思います。今は問題ありません。私が説明しているのは、今私たちが持っているシステムです。連邦政府によって十分に活用されていないので、どういう意味で起こる可能性がありますか?現代貨幣理論のために私たちがひどい赤字になり、政府がこれらすべての力を持っているとは考えていない場合、私はこれを言います。銀行から借りていないのかわからない彼が何を話しているのかわからないええそれは民間部門から資金を奪って金利を押し上げるこれは実際にはナンセンスなので興味深いのは議論は、政府がそれを使うとき、それは資金を求めて競争しなければならず、それは実際に政府が使うとき、金利をうまく押し上げるということです。永久にそのお金」システムから出てくるのは、そもそもそこに注入されたお金であり、それはそれ自身の支出であるため、病院を建設するために私に物理的なものを与えてくれました。債券を購入した場合は、ポケットに入れても大丈夫です。リザーブバンクのタームデポジットでは、それだけで、お金はここから奪われているお金ではありません。以前はシステムに存在していなかったシステムに入れたお金はどこにでもあります。私はこれらの人々がどれだけ知っているか知らないか私たちはスティーブンについて話します私は話します私たちはおそらく23歳の準備銀行と一緒に机で働いている人々が準備銀行の機能を知っていると思いますあなたが知っている準備銀行の知事よりも優れている私は現在の準備銀行の知事だと思いますsは準備銀行を通り抜けましたが、Surから出くわすことがよくあり、中央銀行についてはわかりませんが、政府が赤字を処理しているときにすべての銀行の為替決済口座を扱っている23歳の人がいます。私はそれがシステムにより多くのお金を注入していると言いましたこれが政府が債券を販売する理由であり、それが課税するときにシステムにお金を注入し、それがいくつかを破壊するので、赤字を実行するとシステムにさらに入り、それは最終的に終わりますすべての銀行の取引所の堆積物口座にあることを覚えていますあなたが銀行口座にお金を持っているならそれは本当にあなたの銀行に座っているのは大丈夫ですそれはただそこに座っているだけですそしてそれがそれを稼いでいるなら私はそれが前に言った興味を持っても大丈夫です」sシステムが大幅に変更されたので、その説明を見ることができますが、ニュースで聞く目標キャッシュレートは、システムに超過準備があり、銀行が残す取引所決済口座に一晩放置されている場合、1.5%で問題ありません。そこに彼らは1ポイント25の利息を獲得し、そのポイントは目標レートより5パーセント低くなります。一部の銀行は超過準備金を持ち、一部の銀行は準備金が不足します。他の銀行から借りることができるかのように準備金が不足している、または準備銀行から借りている場合は準備銀行から借りることができる場合は、目標レートより2 5%高いポイントを支払います。大丈夫だからあなたはあなたのことだ」超過準備金があり、ある時点で2〜5%で一晩置いておくことができますが、準備金が不足している別の銀行があり、準備銀行から借りた場合は1.75%になるので、その銀行に何と言いますか余剰準備金をどのように借りたいですか?これは必要ありません。1ポイント7 4%で不足しています。1ポイント7 5%未満で、銀行は勝ったので利益を上げます。 1ポイント25パーセントではなく1ポイント74パーセントを取得していませんが、余剰準備金が順調に進んでいる別の銀行があります。アレックスの意志を取り除きたいと考えています。私が日本について話しましたが、ゼロパーセントはデフォルトの金利が実際に支払うからです。s現在はマイナスですが、彼らが交換と呼んでいるものに残っている資金に支払われるデフォルトレートがゼロであるとしましょう。それは日本の湾の銀行の予備口座です。政府が日本で赤字を出しているのはゼロパーセントです。中央銀行目標のキャッシュレートを持っていないので、これらの超過準備を排出するために2つの債券を禁止しません。政府がそうしているので、そして人々があなたの質問に戻ったときにアンドリューあなたが政府がお金を借りているように見えるので、それらの債券がどのように機能しているのかを言い換えると、それは実質的に赤字の大きさに等しいですが、そうではありません。前に言ったように、政府がそうしないからではありません。それをしなければなりません、そして日本はそれがしなかったその例です」そうすることで、それは短期間の落ち込みであり、中央銀行が債券を販売していなかったため、とにかくお金の円はありませんでした。中央銀行は、準備銀行が何をしていても、短期金利がゼロパーセントに下がるという方針を持っていたからです。目標の現金金利を持っているので、不足がある場合は、超過準備を吸収するために債券を販売する必要があります。そうしないと、目標の現金金利が1.25 Cに低下するため、銀行のギャップから借りているように見えます。実際、政府が赤字を出しているときに、準備銀行が目標金利を設定して維持するためのメカニズムに他なりません。債券になる前に私が言ったこれらの債券に支払われた利子について話し直すと、実際には予備の銀行のターム預金であり、予備の口座に入る前の私たちと同じように利子を稼いでいます。それを上げて少し戻って、それを行うことによって、システムの予備口座にあるときにこのシステムが現在現金を駆動しているので、債券がピックアップされ、金利目標が達成されますが、それは一時的な削除です。税金あなたはお金を稼ぐことでお金を取り戻すが、あなたは税金を取り戻すことはできないそれは永遠になくなっているので、彼らはまったく借りていないと言うことができるような答えははははは誰もがこれを言いたいと思うああ、そうそう、そうそう、彼はおそらくそれをうまくやることができる」基本的に料理人の見た目に関して話すのは最善ではないと私はあなたが言おうとしていることは正しいと思います私は民間部門が黒字を出しているならそれは連邦政府の中央ドームを救っていないと言った完全に真実ではない赤字を実行するために、国の純輸出によって追加の収入がどこから来るのか、それで私たちは追加の収入を得ることができますが、それはもちろんそれを提供しますが、もちろん私たちが稼ぐそれらの金融資産は外国建てです通貨なので、基本的に外貨建ての金融金融資産の形で貯蓄します。今は純輸出については何も言わなかったのですが、ここでそれを行ったとしても」ほとんどの人が輸出は良いと考えているので、経済学の最も基本的な原則は機会費用の原則であり、機会費用の原則は、費用はあなたが諦めるものであり、利益はあなたが受け取るものであるという考えに基づいているのはなぜですか?あきらめることは、国が輸出するときの機会費用であり、それはそれがかかる費用である商品をあきらめることです。GDPを計算するとき、そのプラスXは、消費するものではなく、生産するものだけを測定するため、利益としてのみ見られます。したがって、輸出するときは、他の世界に何かをあきらめ、二度と見ることはありません。それを生産し、あなたが何かを輸入するときにそれを世界の他の地域に与えるための乏しい資源世界はあなたに何かを与える大丈夫今、私たちが貿易面が十分に大きければ、民間部門がサーカスを運営している場合、政府はサーカスを運営することができます「世界の他の地域に十分な量を与えているか、世界の他の地域が私たちに与えているものを超えて、なぜあなたはそれをしたいのですか?なぜあなたはそうしますか?Xが大丈夫を超えていると仮定しましょうそれは意味がありませんそれが基本的にそれが本当に私である唯一の理由だからです輸出に近い国を持っているのは、中央政府が私たちの貯蓄欲求を満たすのに必要なレベルの純支出がなく、まだいくらかの遊休能力があり、それを使って世界の他の地域に輸出する必要のある商品を生産しているからです。なぜあなたはそうしないのですか?同じ価格のGDPを支払った連邦政府が購入した中央政府が私たちの収入とまったく同じである場合、輸出と輸入の違いはより良いです政府が購入したものに何が起こるかはオーストラリアにとどまり、彼はそれを使用することができます私たちの代わりに学校の病院と橋を建設し、監督する人々の要求に合ったものを生産するので、それを回避する方法は意味がありませんが、ネットという事実を克服するために必要なのは国としての輸出だけです十分な収入がなく、空き容量があり、これ以上政府と支出するつもりがない場合、中央政府は、純貯蓄の欲求を満たすのに十分な収入を私たちに与えるのに十分な純支出ではないということです。あなた方の一人ではなく、私たちはものを生産し、それを海外に送ります、そして私たち政府はあなたが何かを返すものを一枚の紙で常に区別することができますが、それは多くの場合、中国が米国連邦政府を蓄積している場合です債券は大丈夫で、米国に物を渡すと、ビキニラインの債券が流行します。中国が債券の価値を償還したい場合、中国が彼らにとって最も少ない連邦政府であり、それらすべての年の間、中国は十分に愚かでした。中国の消費は比率であり、柔軟な為替レートを持っているかどうかに依存しているのかどうかは意味がありません。ゲートがうまくできていて、経常収支が黒字になったら資本収支の赤字は再び上限に達するだろう誤解を招く可能性のある最悪のサービスそれは資本収支の赤字であり、あなたが世界の他の地域の純輸出国であるなら、あなたはより多くのお金を借りているので、あなたはあなたに借りている結局は貸し手になるので資本が流出するので大丈夫ですが実際には反対の戦略を立てているときは有利な立場にあります一般的には永久的な経常赤字と資本勘定の黒字がありますつまり、私たちがシンガポールで教えていたばかりの黒字で、政府に黒字の民間部門を置くことができる立場にないということです。政府が黒字を出すことができる世界の一部であるため、そこでは少し違った話をします。民間部門は輸出が非常に必要なために黒字を出すことができますが、かなり裕福な国であるシンガポールはさらに裕福になる可能性がありますそれが自分たちで物を消費していて、注ぐ政府がそれらの実際の資源を購入していた場合、私たちはシンガポールの人々にインフラ商品を輸出入しますうん申し訳ありません長すぎるか、前に述べたギリシャのようになってしまうかどうかはわかりませんが、ギリシャ政府は支出能力の点で南オーストラリア州政府と何ら変わりはありません。 '民間部門の支出の減少を相殺するために費やすユーロを印刷する欧州中央銀行が彼らに与えたが、彼らは緊縮財政のようなアプローチを持っているお金を彼らに与えていないので、それが国がそうする理由です独自の独占所有権を放棄し、自国通貨の発行は私を超えていますそれはまったく意味がありませんが、それでも十分ではありませんそれでもユーロ圏の失業率はまだ信じられないほど高いので、ゾーン内の十分な支出はありませんそれ自体、従来の経済学の本はすべて、火をつけるために使用する必要があります。つまり、それは悪いことです。理論ではありません。説明です。そうです。実際、政府は実際にはそれを言っていません。それは民間部門です。それだ」s資産を世界の他の地域に販売するああ、そうだね、それは政府がそれを民営化して私たちに販売することにまったく違いはないので、その能力は能力があるが、それは本当の問題ではないということではない。売却されたこれらのものの多くは、いわゆる公共財の特徴を持っており、主流の経済学の一部がその公共財の公共財に少し意味をなす場合は、民間部門に提供を許可した場合などの特定の特徴がありますそれらは十分な量で提供されないので、そうする理由です。公共財を民営化すると、十分な公共財が得られないので、それが本当の問題です。民営化されたのは収入の問題ではありません。それは大きなことだと思います。 conつまり、それは」公共財の特性を備えたものが売却されたものが自然独占の特性を増強するという事実によって悪化し、それは市場の失敗の一形態であり、大規模生産について話すときに民間部門がもはや存在しないことを示唆する証拠はありません公共部門よりも効率的です。公共部門の帽子をかぶってコーヒーを飲むか机の後ろに行ったら、それを外して民間部門の帽子をかぶれば、準備は万端です。 「効率的です。これは絶対的なゴミです。つまり、民間部門でもっと多くのお金を稼ぐことができれば、実際には公共部門にたくさんの友達がいます。」信じられないほど献身的な人々であるため、公共部門が非効率的であるというこの考えは、まったく意味がありません。彼らはそれをよく理解していないからです。国民がよく知らないので政治的ポイントを獲得するチャンスそれは彼らに彼らをよく知っていることを示すだけですあなたは私がこれらの人々を個人的に知らないので彼らが実際にどれだけ知っているかそして何を知っているかわからないと主張することができます彼らはそうはしませんが、しかし、私が言ったように、現代貨幣理論ができることの1つは、私ができないことです。とても悪いニュースを書くが、これは彼らが操作できる極右の本当の恐ろしい人を想像します彼らは現代貨幣理論の原則を学ぶことさえできますそれらを適用し、彼らが望むならそれでも右翼政策を実行することはあなたを意味しませんこの知識を得ると、左翼の厳格な政策を実行する義務がありますが、右端の人々の問題は、彼らが何かをするとき、それはあなたが減らすのに十分なことをしていないことを意味するかもしれないということです失業率は政府が十分なお金を持っていないと言っていますええ、現代貨幣理論について誰もが知っていれば、銃は回転して大丈夫です。人々はノーノーノーノーそれはそうではありません」s失業の本当の理由現代貨幣理論は、これらすべてのイデオロギー的ナンセンスのベールを持ち上げる機会を提供します。彼らが言うことは、私たちの無知の背後に隠れています。これらの人々が彼らが何であるかさえ知っているかどうかわからない、そして私は連邦財務省をよく知らない申し訳ありませんが連邦財務省は毎年予算の黒字を​​予測する予算書を発行していますあなたは質問をしなければなりません私が首相になったのかどうかを知っている連邦財務省は、連邦財務省の人々を救うだろうあなたが仕事をすることができる人々を解雇するのは好きではありませんが、あなたがオフでない場合は再訓練する意思がある場合にのみ、ジュディはもっと得ました私たちが試したデザイン
 
ヘイル:
私はフィルに似た話をしましたフィルほど良くはありませんが、南オーストラリア緑の党によって組織された約4年前のフィルと同様です。私がその党のメンバーだったときにオーストラリア緑の党の経済政策を書き直しました。南オーストラリア緑の党は、彼らはあえてこれらのアイデアについて話し合っていないので、リチャード・ディ・ナターレは基本的にそれをブロックしました私たちはインタビューをしました労働党の人々とのインタビューをビデオで行いました彼らはインタビューを公開しませんでした彼らは彼らが恐れているのでアイデアマスコミで十字架につけられ、
 
91:00
同僚の1人であるステファニーケルトンがチーフエコノミストであり、ワシントンDCの上院予算委員会でバーニーサンダースのチーフエコノミックアドバイザーでしたバーニーサンダースはこれらのアイデアを完全に理解していますが、基本的に拒否しました同じ理由で選挙運動中に彼らについて話し合うのは、あなたが狂人だとすぐに頭に浮かんだことを言わなければならなかったからです。私は政治に入ります。これを説明する時間はありません。私は以前のように見えるので、政治家はここでそれについて少しでも知識を言うことに興味がないのです。もし彼らの連邦カメラが余剰を実行するだけなら、それは良い点です。水位がない限りとはいえ、どうやってやめるのか、私は雇用保証と呼ばれるものについて言及したので、民間部門の支出が減少し、政府がギャップを埋めなければならない場合、政府はどのくらいの金額を見積もっていませんそれはその近くのどこかに収まる必要がありますそれはそれをトップに正しくするために仕事の保証に依存しています就職保証は、就職保証事務所を通り抜ける人の数に依存するので、昨日失業した人を1万人にするために多額の費用をかける必要がある場合、政府を歩く人は1万人になります。それが何であるかを計算する必要がありますマージンで彼らは仕事の保証が確実に微調整を行うことができ、その壁が何であれ、あなたが正しいその水位が民間部門が巨額の赤字になっている場合、政府は黒字を実行します私が言ったように、政府が心配していない予算の収益はそれが何であるかということです。民間部門が赤字の財布を実行するとき、それは私が上院で8年間過ごした黒字を実行します。上院で私は、CSLを民営化する必要はなく、丘を借り換えて政府の所有権を維持するためのクレジットを簡単に作成できると述べました。ピーター・ウォルシュは財務大臣であり、ピーター・ウォルシュはそれは昔ながらの考えだと言いました。しませんでした昔ながらのことだけで何か問題があったと言っても、話を忘れたと思う要素が1つあることを記入してください。政府は、利用可能な労働力の限界まで必要なものを何でも作成できることを認めます。インフレを伴わない利用可能な資源ですが、システムには別の制限があります。たとえば、現時点でオーストラリア人が環境制限を行っている場合、私たちのように全世界が資源を使用する場合、5ポイント2の地球が必要になるため、削減する必要があります。リソースの使用量を、現在使用しているものの約20%に減らします。世界の他の地域と公平で公平になるのは、それがどこから来るのかというように奇妙なことです。それは、資源への課税やある種の政府システムによる資源の割り当てによってもたらされますが、これは問題ありません。別の人と私は、仕事の保証を支持する人の中には、私がこれを言うのを嫌う人がいると言わざるを得ません。なぜなら、これらの人の多くは、制約についてさえ話さないからです。生態学的制約について考えないでくださいこれらの人々は生態学的制約について十分に考えていないので、彼らは仕事の唯一の目的があれば保証するという見解です」失業は支出を増やすことです。そうすれば、あなたがたまたまあなたの資源が使用されている国が何らかの生態学的構造の範囲内にあるので、もう少し多くの資源を手に入れる余裕があります。完全雇用レベル私は雇用保証が好きです。なぜなら、経済を縮小しなければならないが、それでも完全雇用を維持しなければならない場合、仕事を通じて得られる本当に良い配給方法を見つけなければならないからです。あなたができる仕事の保証あなたは明らかに金持ちの超金持ちから頭を切り落とさなければならないでしょうが、それは人々の一人であり、進歩的な言い方はあなたが税の後に金持ちを知っているということです私は政府がお金を持っていると言います貧しい人々によく使うためにそれはしません」それは金持ちだから彼らの頭を切り落とす必要がありますええそして私があなたに言うとき私は金持ちに対して何も持っていませんがそれは私が経済と呼ばれるものがあるというだけではありません家賃それは恐ろしいことですあなたが家に支払う家賃ではないことは大丈夫です私はそれを行うための最良の方法ですそれは大丈夫ですスポーツの人々が経済的な家賃を稼ぐのは私がこのトレーニングキャプテンが何であるかわからない場合クリケットキャプテンは、300万ドルの契約だと言っています。オーストラリアのキャプテンのクリケットキャプテンの収入に課税し始めたら、彼は何か他のことを始めますか。mストラテジーマンにそれをうまくやる方法を申請するそれが流れているならおそらく課税できると思う彼が労働供給を変える前におそらく6700万ドルを課税することができると思うそしてあなたはNaturalと同じことについて話すことができるその人が彼らがしていることを切り替えるまで、あなたが課税できるのは経済的な家賃であり、それは未知の収入を表します。なぜなら、収入は実際にあなたがあなたの労働またはあなたの資源をそれ以上に提供するために支払わなければならない最低額だからです政府が課税できる経済的賃貸料であり、その資源やその人の供給に影響を与えることはありません。彼らがそれを続けようとすると、300万ドルの契約を結ぶことによって彼は別のスティーブスミススティーブスミスです。sは実際の商品やサービスを300万ドルと主張していますが、彼は実際の収入はおそらく30万ドルから40万ドルで大丈夫なので、地方の情報源に対してその余分な主張をすることができる唯一の方法は、インフレではないということです。彼らが貢献する金額よりも少ない収入を得ているので、彼らは経済的な家賃を稼いでいるので頭を切り落とされます、そしてあなたは何人かの人々があなたが本当にそれをどこで考えているかを言うか、首相の仕事がおそらく最も重要であると私は考えています土地での仕事首相自身の年間約50万ドルよく私は誰も信じていません」年間50万ドル以上の価値があり、50万ドルの所得税率があります。それ以上のものは地代だと思いますが、やめただけではありません。すでに政治家の政治用語を使用できます。申し訳ありません。私が知っていることの1つは、少し厳しいように聞こえると思います。政治家にもっと真剣に説明するよう呼びかけなければならないと思います。新しいことについてはあまり知らないのですが、彼らは単一の神経学者ではないかもしれません。これで


JP 検索 9+ アバターの画像 Phil Lawn MMT and the Benefits of Fiscal Injections 243 回視聴•2017/10/20 12 0 共有 保存 Steven Hail チャンネル登録者数 395人 文字起こし 00:10 hello it's working right okay so it's a 00:18 notes on ER a Ouray was founded in 1993 00:21 when three small groups in New South 00:24 Wales and South Australia came together 00:26 as in basically entered intellectuals 00:29 and heterodox economists who could 00:31 analyze economics dispassionately which 00:34 modern economics economists aren't very 00:37 good at and could step outside the 00:40 prevailing paradigm and can see the 00:43 worldwide crisis coming also in there 00:46 further in the 90s they organized three 00:51 conferences called toes which is the 00:54 other economic summit along the lines of 00:57 similarly or main conferences held in 00:59 Europe and North America and they 01:01 organize them in Sydney Melbourne and 01:03 Adelaide it led one was 1995 they hosted 01:08 a number of other public meetings and 01:10 other conferences held in Adelaide 01:11 Sydney Brisbane and Canberra involving 01:14 well-known heterodox economists and 01:16 other reformers they established 01:19 relationship and liaison with karma the 01:22 Committee on monetary and economic 01:23 reform which is a Ras counterpart in 01:26 Canada they sponsored visits was 01:30 Australian speaking tours and media 01:32 interviews for several well-known 01:34 economic reformers from overseas 01:36 including Michael Robottom from UK 01:39 prophet on Hassan for Canada from the US 01:42 professors Blaine and Robert Constanza 01:46 from Ireland Richard dealth wait the 01:49 Honorable Paul Hillier former Deputy PM 01:53 of Canada John Wright and also Stephanie 01:55 diría from New Zealand and others so EA 02:00 has organized and co-organized 02:02 a range of seminars and presentations 02:05 over the years with well-informed 02:07 speakers in several capital cities and 02:09 out loud there is long history and 02:10 variety of such events to numerous to 02:13 list 02:14 he also made submissions to several 02:16 government inquiries concerning 02:18 financial and banking reform and produce 02:21 various reports brochures and 02:23 publications particularly in particular 02:25 the regular IRA review now there's some 02:30 copies of previous CRA reviews on the 02:32 table over there which you're welcome to 02:34 read and also a paper which relates to 02:39 few lawns talk not directly of obvious 02:42 hope because for related paper and this 02:46 evening for will be discussing this the 02:48 myths around sovereign debt and a 02:50 misleading direction so as myths 02:52 cause this is also conducted in 02:57 conjunction with a home economics 03:02 economics Department it can always pop 03:06 in in in the Uni here and I'll be giving 03:10 giving a presentation or a lecture 03:12 introduction as well so I'll hand over 03:15 to Phil thank you thank you 03:40 [Music] 03:47 you 04:24 all right so I easy microphones I gotta 04:31 say all right well today for tonight's 04:35 presentation basically what I'm going to 04:37 do is I'm going to talk a little bit 04:39 about a thing called modern monetary 04:41 theory which you may or may not be aware 04:43 of I'll just say a couple of things 04:45 about modern monetary theory for I give 04:47 my presentation because a lot of people 04:50 who may be aware of modern monetary 04:52 theory think that it's some sort of new 04:55 idea a framework or what-have-you that 04:59 could be applied by governments well 05:01 it's not government's already operate 05:04 within the modern monetary theory 05:05 framework it's a description of how the 05:07 system actually works right so the the 05:10 federal government straining federal 05:11 government currently operates under a 05:13 modern monetary theory type framework 05:16 okay it just because it doesn't 05:17 understand it it operates in adequately 05:20 that's all all right so the main thing 05:22 about modern monetary theory is to 05:23 understand what the what what John what 05:34 the spending and Taxation powers of a 05:39 currencies issuing central government 05:41 I'm going to make a distinction between 05:42 a currency issuing central government 05:44 which is like the Australian federal 05:46 government which is the owner and issuer 05:49 of the nation's currency and a user of a 05:52 government which is a user of a currency 05:54 which in fact we do have in Australia 05:55 they're called state governments and 05:56 local governments they're completely 05:58 different they make their capacities to 06:00 spend are completely different to the 06:02 federal government and of course we've 06:04 got the eurozone governments which 06:07 because they relinquish monopoly 06:09 ownership of their own currency operate 06:12 the same way as state governments do in 06:14 Australia their users of the currency 06:15 they're not issuers of the currency and 06:17 that greatly affects their ability to 06:19 spend and we're seeing the results of 06:21 that in Europe at present not that the 06:25 federal government here in Australia is 06:27 taking full advantage of its spending 06:29 and Taxation powers 06:30 so got to think of this modern monetary 06:33 theory as something that describes the 06:36 system as it is it's sort of a lens 06:38 through which you look at the the 06:40 financial and monetary system and I'm 06:44 going to talk about why now when I say 06:47 why are we benefit from a government 06:48 budget deficit I'm basically saying that 06:52 by and large most of the time the 06:54 federal government should run a deficit 06:55 that doesn't mean it's always 06:57 advantageous and if it's if it does run 07:00 a surplus it's not because it needs to 07:03 run a surplus because it's running out 07:04 of money and I'll talk about why the 07:07 federal government might have to run a 07:09 surplus okay the budget bottom line of 07:12 the Australian federal government is 07:14 entirely irrelevant and it is something 07:16 that the federal government cannot 07:17 control basically the federal government 07:21 budget bottom line is determined by the 07:24 net savings desires of the private 07:26 sector and if federal treasury knew 07:28 about it then every time the Treasury 07:31 papers come out each year they wouldn't 07:33 make outrageous predictions about the 07:36 budget going back to surplus it will 07:38 depend entirely upon the net savings 07:40 desires of the private sector and so if 07:43 the private sector wishes to positively 07:45 net save out of current income the 07:48 government will run a budget deficit 07:50 whether it likes it or not the key thing 07:53 is what sort of budget deficits should 07:55 it be running okay there's such a thing 07:57 as a good budget deficit and a bad 07:59 budget deficit and I'll distinguish 08:00 between the two tonight all right here's 08:06 some facts can you read that 08:09 like that's not too small the federal 08:12 government that's the monopoly owner an 08:14 issue of the Australian dollar AUD 08:15 refers to the Australian dollar 08:16 there's no spending constraint the 08:21 federal government does however face a 08:23 real resource constraint okay so it's 08:26 got as many Australian dollars as it 08:28 likes for spending purposes but it can't 08:30 buy an infinite amount of stuff now we 08:33 live in a world of scarcity so they they 08:35 face a real resource constraint so 08:37 should the federal government just go 08:39 crazy print money and spending into 08:42 existence no because if it prints 08:44 money and spends it into existence and 08:47 it exceeds the real resource constraint 08:50 you just have inflation but what the 08:53 federal government should be doing is it 08:55 should be net spending that's government 08:57 spending - taxation net spending to the 09:01 level so that total spending within the 09:03 Australian economy is always at the full 09:05 employment level of income doesn't 09:07 shouldn't go any further because it 09:09 would just be inflationary but it can 09:12 always spend to that level because it's 09:15 irrelevant whether it's running a 09:16 surplus or deficit it does not affect 09:18 the federal government's ability to 09:20 spend in the future so there's basically 09:23 a bottomless pit of Australian dollars 09:25 on Capitol Hill in Canberra so the 09:27 federal government has as many 09:29 Australian dollars as it likes for 09:31 spending purposes what does the federal 09:33 government do when it spends well in 09:35 this computer age it basically spends by 09:39 electronically crediting bank accounts 09:40 so you know if you think of the 09:43 government running the printing press in 09:45 order to spend well it runs the printing 09:47 press to make available cash but that's 09:50 not how it spends it hasn't spent like 09:51 that even prior to the computer age it 09:54 used to write out checks 09:55 I used to write out checks but with the 09:57 computer age it doesn't have to do them 09:58 it still does well that's it's it's 10:01 phasing checks out so it spends by 10:06 electronically crediting bank accounts 10:07 every dollar of federal government 10:10 spending involves the creation and 10:11 spending into existence of a new dollar 10:14 the new money created comes from 10:17 absolutely nowhere so it comes from 10:19 nowhere I might also point out that this 10:26 this new money it's basically new money 10:29 that it's money that hasn't previously 10:32 existed that's created out of nothing 10:34 and spent into existence the government 10:36 doesn't need your money if it's got an 10:38 infinite amount of money and explain why 10:40 you pay taxes federal government taxes 10:43 it's basically to regulate your demand 10:46 for real stuff so there's enough real 10:49 stuff available for the federal 10:50 government to get hold of it without it 10:52 being inflationary that's sea-salt 10:54 macroeconomic purpose of taxation 10:58 so does that make sense so I'm the 11:00 federal government you're the private 11:01 sector you demand real stuff I demand 11:04 real stuff if our total demand for the 11:06 real stuff that's available for sale 11:08 exceeds what's available for sale will 11:10 complete for it and push the price up 11:12 and we'll be hyperinflationary so if 11:15 that's occurring what can I do as a 11:17 government well I could reduce my 11:18 spending so that the total demand for 11:21 the real stuff is exactly equal to the 11:22 real stuff available to control 11:24 inflation but what if I want to spend or 11:27 a certain level to provide schools and 11:29 hospitals and so forth and I want to do 11:31 it in a way that's not inflationary well 11:33 I reduce your spending and how do I 11:35 reduce your spending I tax you I destroy 11:37 some of your spending pair so call the 11:42 creation of you money and example of 11:44 printing money it's not real but you can 11:46 call it that if you want to but the 11:49 federal government no more owes someone 11:51 for creating money for itself and the 11:53 manufacturer of the board game Monopoly 11:55 owes someone for premier printing 11:57 monopoly dollars so don't think that 11:58 when the federal government prints money 12:00 in spending into existence it owes it to 12:02 anyone I don't know who the manufacturer 12:05 of the board game Monopoly is I think 12:07 was John Sands used to be the company 12:09 well they don't own or Oh monopoly 12:11 dollars to anyone have you ever played 12:12 Monopoly and thought Wow 12:14 John Sands masks a lot of Monopoly 12:16 dollars to someone of course you don't 12:21 the federal government taxes the private 12:23 sector by electronically debiting bank 12:25 accounts and when you pay your taxes 12:27 yeah if there's a computer hard drive 12:31 with a number which is the bottom line 12:34 of your bank account you pay taxes that 12:35 number goes down electronically every 12:39 dollar of federal government taxation 12:41 involves the permanent destruction of 12:43 old money or existing money right money 12:45 that's already in the system the old 12:48 money that is permanently destroyed by 12:49 the federal government taxation goes 12:51 nowhere goes the same place to where it 12:54 came from when the government created 12:55 and spending exists goes nowhere it's a 12:59 lot different I sorry and the second 13:02 point the federal government can run 13:03 deficits forever 13:04 so if it's got an infinite amount of 13:06 money can run deficits forever and in 13:09 most years should run deficits because a 13:11 federal 13:12 deficit constitutes a non-federal 13:14 government surplus I don't in fact quite 13:17 often like to use the term federal 13:19 government deficit because it sounds 13:20 like a bad thing 13:21 all right it's really a fiscal injection 13:24 when the government runs a deficit it's 13:27 creating more money and spending it into 13:29 existence so I'm giving you more money 13:30 by buying things off you that I'm taking 13:33 away from you from taxation so when I 13:36 run a deficit you run a surplus so I got 13:39 off and asked people would you like the 13:41 federal government to run a surplus and 13:43 most people say yeah would you like to 13:45 run a surplus and I say yeah and I say 13:47 well you can't it both there are two 13:49 sides of the same coin 13:51 for you to run a surplus I gotta run a 13:53 deficit okay and if you run a deficit I 14:00 I can potentially run a surplus well in 14:03 fact I will run a surplus but if you're 14:05 determined to run a surplus I end up 14:09 running a deficit and that's exactly 14:10 what's happening now and explain why 14:12 when I say you I'm not talking about you 14:15 individually some of you may not on 14:17 talking but if the private sector wants 14:19 to net safe okay it means me as the 14:24 federal government I run a deficit no 14:26 matter how hard I try to run a surplus 14:28 in fact the harder I try to run a 14:31 surplus if I cut my spending means we 14:34 are worse off there's less spending 14:36 within the economy all right because if 14:38 in your attempt to save a certain amount 14:41 because I spend less and that's money 14:43 that goes to you as income you finance 14:47 your spending and you're saving out of 14:48 that income and if you want to save a 14:51 certain amount and you've got less money 14:52 you spend less which means there's less 14:56 national income and government taxation 15:00 is a positive function of national 15:02 income so when I cut my spending I cut 15:05 my tax revenue so that's why you can't 15:08 equate in many ways the government 15:10 budget with a household budget if you 15:13 had $50,000 a year and you spend 60,000 15:16 yell over $10,000 deficit so you might 15:19 say okay next year I'm going to spend 15:20 50,000 but when you spend $50,000 it 15:24 doesn't affect the income that you 15:26 but me as the government where my 15:29 spending is a large component of all 15:30 spending when I change my spending I 15:32 changed national income which affects my 15:34 tax revenue so yeah that's what the rest 15:41 of us and because I'm talking it you and 15:43 me small businesses large corporations 15:45 and all other levels of government so 15:47 I'm talking about state and local 15:48 governments are users of Australian 15:51 dollar we cannot run deficits forever 15:53 because it leads to an unsustainable 15:55 rise in private sector debt in fact I 15:59 neglected to go to figure one so if you 16:02 don't believe that a government deficit 16:05 and a non government surplus and vice 16:08 versa are two sides of the same coin 16:10 there you go 16:11 that blew the so that orange brown the 16:14 orange colored line is general 16:16 government and the blue line is non 16:18 government and once it's the mirror 16:20 image of the other so when the federal 16:22 government runs a deficit there the 16:26 non-government sector runs a service of 16:28 the same amount and vice versa 16:32 so you can you can see if here's the in 16:36 these years here you've got the federal 16:38 government running a deficit was it 16:40 because the government was trying to run 16:42 a deficit now if that if the 16:44 non-government sector is running a 16:46 surplus because it's determined to it's 16:48 going to alter its discretionary 16:50 spending to make sure it positively 16:52 saves out of net income it's a pot then 16:55 that's what's gonna happen the 16:57 government budget deficit no matter how 16:59 hard it tries to run a surplus and the 17:03 second figure okay you can see what the 17:06 effect of this is if a government in 17:08 fact runs a soup or so when the federal 17:11 government runs the surplus you well it 17:15 depends it depends on on your spending 17:17 and your your net savings desires when 17:20 the government runs a surplus it's not 17:22 injecting that much into the occult 17:24 maybe but it's it's not injecting as 17:26 much money in by way of money that's 17:29 been created in spending in existence as 17:31 it's taking from you so you have less 17:33 income so you have less income to 17:36 finance your spending and your saving so 17:39 when that happens you have to make up 17:41 your mind whether you're going to meet 17:44 your spending desires or your savings 17:47 desires you cannot meet both and when 17:49 the Australian federal government ran 17:51 our ten budget surpluses in 11 years 17:54 that's because we said okay we're going 17:58 to spend and we're gonna borrow so he 18:01 ran deficits and that allowed the the 18:04 government's only way it allowed the 18:06 government to run a service so when 18:07 Peter Costello was beating himself on 18:09 the chest saying he was a friend of the 18:10 taxpayer wasn't he great running 18:12 surpluses well he only got that because 18:14 we ran deficits but you can see the 18:17 effect of deficits over time this is 18:19 household debt to disposable income the 18:22 ratio and you can see that in that 18:25 period the ratio of household debt to 18:28 disposal linked disposable income rose 18:30 until it reached and this was replicated 18:32 pretty much around the world to some 18:34 extent until it reached an unsustainable 18:36 level we can't run deficits and when 18:40 that happens we switch from meeting our 18:43 spending desires and and abandoning our 18:44 savings desires to having to save to pay 18:48 back the debt and so we stop spending 18:49 and you get a collapse of spending why 18:52 was and that's where you get the global 18:54 financial crisis so things like the 18:56 subprime mortgage crisis that was just 18:58 the straw that broke the camel's back 19:00 that's all it was it wasn't the cause it 19:02 was the trigger the cause is the 19:05 inadequate net spending of central 19:07 governments which requires for the 19:10 non-government sector to spend or a 19:12 certain level to run deficits and build 19:14 up their debt to against to an 19:15 unsustainable level so why was this she 19:18 sharp decline that was the little fiscal 19:20 surplus by the Rudd Government it led us 19:24 to spend because it was extra income 19:25 coming this week it's fading so we're 19:28 able to bring down our debt to some 19:31 extent now I can I should have Stevie 19:34 probably knows better than me this this 19:35 so that's 2 mm where is it now it's it's 19:39 it's up high so that's 175 percent we're 19:43 at the time of the global it's around 19:45 about one hundred and ninety percent so 19:46 it's above in Australia pre global 19:50 financial crisis levels and 19:52 whilst that doesn't necessarily mean 19:54 we're going to get a recession what it 19:57 means is that we're about the ratio of 20:00 household disposable income to debt to 20:04 household disposable income where we 20:06 cannot borrow more in net terms we 20:12 cannot run deficits okay we can't do it 20:15 because that would just push our get up 20:18 to a level that is unsustainable all 20:21 right so if we can't run deficits the 20:23 government can't run surpluses and so 20:26 the federal government won't run 20:28 surpluses as far as the eye can see the 20:32 only way the federal government will 20:33 ever run a surplus as if this comes down 20:36 about here and then we decide to borrow 20:39 in the aggregate so unless this comes 20:41 down to here and that will require years 20:43 of the federal government running very 20:45 very large deficits the government will 20:49 not run a circus and will just be sort 20:52 of going along at a pedestrian pace 20:56 what-have-you 20:57 not really spending much more not less 20:59 not really saving it and so forth all 21:07 right the federal government has no debt 21:08 as such I mean they use his term debt 21:10 that's it's it's really an inaccurate 21:12 word when they talk about federal 21:15 government debt what they're really 21:16 talking about is the RBA is the Reserve 21:18 Bank of Australia that's Australia's 21:20 central bank and basically it means a 21:24 case of the Reserve Bank selling federal 21:26 government bonds okay selling bonds on 21:30 behalf of the federal government to 21:32 manage interest rates so the argument is 21:35 when the government runs a deficit 21:37 there's a shortfall 21:38 the Reserve Bank sells bonds to get 21:41 money to finance the shortfall nonsense 21:44 don't even have to do it don't have to 21:47 do it and in fact in the 1980s and 1990s 21:50 the Japanese central government didn't 21:52 do it didn't bother and I've got time I 21:56 might explain what that what the 21:58 implicit explain what the implications 22:00 of that were I can tell you what they 22:01 were that meant the interest rate went 22:03 down to zero percent so it's why the 22:06 right in Japan was around 0% despite the 22:09 Japanese central government running huge 22:11 budget deficits but they didn't matter 22:13 the Japanese government is the monopoly 22:16 owner and issue of the Japanese yen so 22:18 it doesn't matter so you hear all this 22:20 nonsense about Japan 22:22 you know the so-and-so the proverbial is 22:25 going to hit the fan in Japan one day 22:26 it's not going to happen the Japanese 22:29 central government will not run out of 22:30 Japanese yen and there are people around 22:33 the world more than happy to buy 22:35 Japanese 22:36 bonds government bonds because they know 22:39 the Japanese government can pay those 22:41 bonds because they're paid for in 22:43 Japanese yen and the Japanese central 22:45 government has got as much yen as it 22:47 likes federal government gets fed and 22:52 government bonds are denominated in 22:54 Australian dollars so the federal 22:56 government can always repay bondholders 22:57 always the federal government is not 23:00 strictly in debt when it sells bonds so 23:02 if you you sell something in a sense and 23:05 it means you you know you owe that to 23:07 someone but if God as much money as your 23:09 like if someone wants their money back 23:11 you're not really good you're really in 23:13 debt if you if you've got a text earn 23:16 money borrow money or sell something to 23:20 get money to pay back but if you can 23:22 just dip your hand into a pool of 23:24 Australian dollars and say you want you 23:27 your money back and you hand me over the 23:28 bond and I can I'm not really in debt mi 23:30 so you might ask why why they got the 23:33 Reserve Bank on behalf of the federal 23:35 government sells bonds well it's to 23:37 manage interest rates right you hear on 23:40 the news there once a month when the 23:43 Reserve Bank Board meets and they they 23:45 say the Reserve Bank's kept the target 23:49 cash rate at the same level hasn't moved 23:50 interest rates and they are able to do 23:53 that by buying and selling bonds okay 23:56 and when the federal government runs a 23:58 deficit it has to sell bonds to maintain 24:01 its target cash rate I won't go into the 24:03 explanation for that now if I could 24:05 explain it perhaps in the Q&A session 24:07 but so the reason why the Reserve Bank 24:12 sells bonds when the government runs a 24:14 deficit is so the Reserve Bank can set 24:16 and maintain a a target interest 24:19 the only reason why it does it and of 24:22 course in Japan I didn't do it in the 24:23 eighties and nineties so the interest 24:26 rate just dropped down to zero percent I 24:29 won't explain why it went all the way to 24:31 zero percent but it did so this is this 24:35 nonsense that budget deficits place an 24:38 upward pressure on interest rates now 24:40 they do the opposite they do the 24:42 opposite if the if the central bank 24:43 doesn't respond when that the central 24:48 government runs our deficit if pushes 24:49 puts downward pressure on the short-term 24:51 interest rate not upward of course if if 24:56 the government I said before the 24:58 government didn't just not print money 24:59 and spend ridiculously so that total 25:02 spending within the economy exceeds the 25:03 productive capacity the economy because 25:05 that would be hyperinflationary and that 25:07 might force the central bank top raise 25:09 interest rates well that's an artificial 25:11 raising that's not a natural raising of 25:13 the it's not determined by market forces 25:15 market forces would still be pushing the 25:18 rate down if if the central bank wasn't 25:23 intervening it just intervenes in this 25:24 different way so that the target rates a 25:26 bit higher this by the way when when the 25:32 federal government or a central 25:35 government sells bonds it doesn't sell 25:37 you a bit of paper and you give money 25:40 but the money I won't go into that can 25:46 actually buy a government security 25:49 except on the on the secondary market 25:52 all right well just assume that you can 25:55 okay if you buy a bond it will probably 25:58 be because you can earn some interest 26:02 okay now that money that be prior to you 26:06 buying the bond is sitting in your bank 26:08 account when it's an actual fact sitting 26:10 in your bank's reserve a the exchange 26:14 settlement account it's called that your 26:17 bank holds with the Reserve Bank and the 26:19 Reserve Bank is paying your bank 26:21 interest for doing that you don't get 26:24 the interest the bank doesn't pass it on 26:26 to you alright so if you buy the bond 26:29 right so you say I'll take the money out 26:31 of my account well it the fact comes out 26:32 the 26:33 Reserve Bank's reserve account exchange 26:35 settlement account so the bank loses it 26:38 ah and you now earn the interest and 26:42 your bank doesn't you know any interest 26:46 in settle but the key thing is what's 26:48 happened here there's money sitting in 26:50 an account earning interest and which 26:54 has been earned by the bank your bank 26:56 and now it's being earned by you so what 26:59 does the Reserve Bank done it's merely 27:00 just picked up some money that was in 27:02 your bank's reserve account and plunked 27:04 it in a Reserve Bank term deposit 27:06 account bonds are nothing more than 27:09 Reserve Bank term deposits but they're 27:11 saleable transferable turn deposits so 27:14 when you get your you know you've got a 27:16 bit of cash you perhaps I have a term 27:21 deposit with your bank 27:22 you can't sell that and it's a different 27:25 type of term deposit bonds thing a 27:27 Reserve Bank term deposit is one that 27:30 you can sell that on to you because 27:32 bonds can be traded but it's just it's 27:34 just a Reserve Bank term deposit and of 27:38 course the government doesn't have any 27:40 more money that it had previously or 27:43 didn't have previously sorry for 27:46 spending purposes so so-called selling 27:49 bonds doesn't give money doesn't come to 27:52 the government the reason why the 27:55 government sells bond yeah I've 27:56 mentioned taxation is destroyed it's 27:58 designed to destroy some of your 28:00 spending power 28:01 so I permanently destroy some of your 28:03 person as your spending pair so my 28:06 spending isn't hyperinflationary okay 28:08 bonds also gets money out of the system 28:11 but not permanently temporarily while 28:13 you're holding it as a bond or you got 28:15 it in a Reserve Bank term deposit 28:18 account it's out of the system and 28:20 that's that allows the central bank to 28:23 target and maintain a particular 28:24 interest rate it comes back alright when 28:28 you redeem the bond and so forth in 28:30 which case well people are returning 28:33 bonds people buying bonds at the same 28:35 time we have a break alright so we're 28:43 just going to take a five-minute break 28:44 this pizza over there there's agitator 28:53 okay now now we've got some pizza in our 28:57 stomach you'll probably all fall asleep 28:59 now 28:59 [Laughter] 29:03 so I whoops what Scout it's not the 29:11 slightest slides out moving well well it 29:22 probably wouldn't if the air is out 29:23 working all right I can yes all right 29:32 okay so I've got up to this one here 29:34 which is on functional finance a thing 29:36 called functional finance which I guess 29:38 in a sense is what you were engaging it 29:42 once once you fully understand modern 29:44 monetary theory and you and you and the 29:46 government it fully exercises its 29:50 spending and Taxation powers in a way to 29:51 meet various goals without worrying 29:55 about the budget bottom line it's 29:57 irrelevant functional finance it's not 29:59 about and what's the budget bottom line 30:01 it's whatever it is because it's 30:03 irrelevant what it is whether a surface 30:05 does not increase the ability of the 30:08 federal government to spend any more 30:10 than a deficit reduces it okay if you've 30:13 got a bottomless pit of Australian 30:14 dollars you've got an infinite amount of 30:16 dollars infinity plus X's infinity 30:19 infinity minus actors infinity so 30:22 surpluses and deficits don't or the fact 30:24 that there's an infinite amount of money 30:26 that the federal government can get in 30:28 any stage now remember you've got to 30:31 differentiate between what the 30:33 government can access in terms of money 30:36 for spending purposes and how much it 30:37 should so my view is with modern 30:41 monetary theory is if there's one 30:42 question the Australian federal 30:45 government treasure treasure it should 30:47 never ask is okay that that sounds like 30:50 a good policy where am I going to get 30:52 the money for that the treasure is 30:54 always what the federal treasure has got 30:57 to ask if there's if he or she is going 30:59 to ask the question is 31:00 am I going to get the real resources yet 31:03 will they be available to purchase in 31:06 order to do policy X that's all the 31:09 federal government Treasury has to think 31:11 about are there enough real resource of 31:14 our if there are idle resources 31:16 available the federal government can dip 31:19 into its bottomless pit as a bit of 31:21 money and purchase it if there are no 31:23 resources available because our spending 31:27 yours and mine is meeting the productive 31:30 capacity of the economy so there's no 31:32 and I like I said before and I want to 31:35 get hold of more resources I've got to 31:37 reduce your demand for resource and 31:39 that's when I start taxing in ITEX you 31:42 so your demand goes down so when mine 31:44 goes up if equal to the productive 31:50 maximum productive capacity of the 31:52 economy to keep it there if I want to 31:54 increase my spending I've got to reduce 31:56 yours so I use taxation to do it if the 31:59 spending is below that level I can 32:01 increase my spending I don't have to tax 32:02 you because I can live spending up to so 32:09 functional finance basically involves 32:11 the federal government which is I said 32:13 before the monopoly owner an issue of 32:15 the Australian dollar net spending and 32:17 by net spending I mean so G G represents 32:19 government spending and tiers tax 32:22 revenue so if G is greater than T it's 32:25 what we commonly refer to as a budget 32:27 deficit I don't call it that I call it a 32:30 fiscal injection cuz when I spend G I 32:34 put money into the I inject money in the 32:36 economy and when I tax you I destroy it 32:38 so money disappears if I if I spend more 32:42 than I tax there there's more going in 32:45 and coming out that's a fiscal injection 32:47 I like that term because people see 32:50 deficit as a bad thing but if you call a 32:52 fiscal injection which is what it really 32:55 is then people see it completely 32:57 different or differently sorry so 33:01 functional finance is where the federal 33:03 government has their monopoly on an 33:05 issue of is going on next 33:16 achieve a range of economic social 33:18 environmental goals right so these are 33:22 the things that matter that's relevant 33:25 for governments focus on this and you 33:27 can you see your current affairs shows o 33:30 Q and I or something like that where 33:32 they're debating the budget they're 33:34 debating the budget by a budget repair 33:37 they're talking about this thing which 33:39 is relevant when when all the debate 33:42 should be about this how do we how do we 33:46 achieve those goals and no one should 33:48 ever say well we can't quite achieve 33:50 those goals because the federal 33:51 government's run out of money can't do 33:54 it we won't run out of productive 33:55 capacity all right so we can only 33:57 produce so much to meet certain goals 33:59 all right so there's always going to be 34:01 limited on productive capacity but the 34:03 idea that the federal government can run 34:05 out of this stuff and if it's not a 34:07 deficit we've got to do something about 34:08 the deficit and therefore we can't 34:11 achieve these goals because that's just 34:13 nonsense it's counterproductive so 34:19 function functional finance involves a 34:24 Gavin Smith ignoring the budget bottom 34:26 line which has no relevance to a 34:28 currency issuing central government such 34:29 as the Australian federal government 34:31 since a major social goal should be full 34:35 employment the federal government should 34:37 always net spend to the level required 34:39 to achieve and maintain full employment 34:40 now you hear people say our to achieve 34:43 full employment where yeah we need to 34:46 get the unemployed to do more training I 34:47 mean that's a bit like when you've got 34:51 unemployment it's a bit like that child 34:53 the children's birthday party game of 34:56 musical chairs all right 34:58 there's 11 kids trying to get on 10 35:00 chairs well you can make them you run 35:02 around the house for a month before the 35:04 birthday party so they're all better 35:06 able to get a chair but I can tell you 35:09 what when the music stops one won't get 35:11 a chair that's the unemployed person you 35:15 you can only have full employment if 35:17 there are enough jobs to meet the people 35:19 who want jobs and you can only get that 35:21 if total spending within the economy is 35:24 at the full employment level of income 35:26 little our way 35:27 do whatever you want because low wages 35:29 just reduce spending no there's nonsense 35:32 about cutting penalty rates and it will 35:34 mean that small businesses will employ 35:36 more people now they won't the chances 35:39 are they're not selling as many cups of 35:40 coffee on a weekend because people got 35:43 less money because they're because their 35:44 weight has been cut okay so yes so 35:50 because of one of the major social goals 35:52 should be full employment the the 35:54 federal government could achieve full 35:56 employment tomorrow in a sense anyone 35:59 who wants a job it could say okay I'll 36:02 put you to work not wouldn't work for 36:06 the Dolf scheme it might be some decent 36:08 minimum liveable wage you know thirty 36:10 forty thousand dollars a year now 36:15 ideally people wouldn't be on the this 36:18 is referred to as a job guarantee I 36:19 don't know if you've heard of this it's 36:20 sort of like an employer of last resort 36:22 scheme alright so if you can't get a job 36:26 in the private sector and the 36:28 conventional public sector you walk 36:30 through the doors of a job guarantee 36:33 office and they put you to work 36:35 on about thirty four forty thousand 36:37 dollars a year all right and then if the 36:39 economy picks up so to speak and so 36:41 there's more private sector vacancies at 36:43 higher wages you quit that job guarantee 36:45 job and you get that job instead and I'd 36:47 say the job guarantee is not designed 36:49 for you to stay on it alright but it's 36:51 but it's designed to give people a 36:53 decent income but more importantly is 36:58 the psychological effect of unemployment 37:01 and in terms of mental health 37:03 unemployment has virtually a bigger 37:09 effect than anything else on a person's 37:12 mental well-being a period of lot of 37:15 unemployment more so than a death of a 37:18 loved one was that right and people 37:28 don't recover years later studies have 37:31 shown that it sounds ridiculous but one 37:34 of those studies showed that even if a 37:36 person EPS unemployed for twelve months 37:38 goes back to work you'd have to pay them 37:40 it's 37:41 it outrageous I've got to say myself 37:42 that you'd have to pay them on top of 37:46 what they're being paid out there that 37:48 ways they're earning now they're back to 37:50 work an extra $100,000 a year for them 37:53 to be of satisfaction that they were 37:57 prior to being unemployed that's that's 38:00 that gives you some idea of what the 38:01 impact is 38:02 so if unemployment is important because 38:04 it affects people's mental health it 38:10 affects the incomes that people have got 38:12 so you combine home they're homeless 38:15 homelessness is due to that people got 38:17 sufficient income combined with a mental 38:19 illness effect of unemployment it just 38:23 exacerbates the problem so the 38:28 government should always ensure that 38:30 total spending matches the productive 38:31 capacity of the economy and provided 38:35 there are sufficient idle resources 38:37 available for use what I can tell you 38:39 this 38:39 there's 1.8 million Australians that are 38:42 idle at the moment they there's 800,000 38:46 unemployed people in Australia and 1 38:48 million underemployed people in 38:50 Australia so ok when you employ someone 38:53 you employ they have to have some tool 38:56 or instrument or machine or whatever and 38:58 so whether there are those available to 39:03 use in combination with the labourers 39:07 idle labour resources to produce it's 39:09 that's another matter but in terms of 39:11 labour there's also there is plenty of 39:15 idle resources that labor resources 39:18 labour pair that the federal government 39:20 could purchase and put to use to provide 39:23 all sorts of community benefits and so 39:25 forth so the providers sufficient 39:29 resources available for use the federal 39:32 government can always mobilize them can 39:34 always put them to use in other words 39:35 through expanding to increase the supply 39:37 of public goods in the areas of health 39:39 education transport communications and 39:42 green infrastructure 39:43 so basically when there's unemployment 39:45 not only is there not enough spending to 39:47 employ everyone but there is probably a 39:50 hospital ward that has been built as a 39:53 consequence 39:54 now that that's a cost in itself you 39:58 could argue that the fact that the 39:59 hospital ward hasn't been built there's 40:02 an environmental benefit and there is 40:04 well yeah well it's a to say that that's 40:07 not the case is to say that there is no 40:09 cost associated with increasing output 40:11 which of course there is so you have to 40:13 weigh up the tube up but it's it's full 40:17 employment is not about in the end 40:20 ensuring that any lost output is made up 40:24 by having more people employed that's 40:26 not the main objective of it it's it's 40:28 because people are right to work if they 40:31 want it and because of the psychological 40:34 effect of unemployment but bear in mind 40:38 as I said when people go unemployed 40:40 there's something that hasn't been built 40:42 some service it hasn't been provided 40:44 that could be provided they could be 40:47 helping someone else all that and and 40:49 all themselves.


 so what I've said I can 40:52 spray in a diagram like this that's my 40:55 bathtub diagram alright there's a lot of 40:57 right so here's my bathtub I want you to 41:00 imagine that there's the bathtub and 41:01 that size of that bathtub represents the 41:05 productive capacity economy alright then 41:09 the capacity the economy to produce 41:11 goods and services the water level 41:14 represents the spending right represents 41:18 if the water level is right at the top 41:20 you've got full employment and an 41:23 acceptable inflation rate so you got a 41:25 full bathtub spending equals productive 41:28 capacity this is where we basically been 41:30 operating for 45 years meetups up 41:32 needlessly since the early 1970s 41:34 the water level below the top because 41:37 the government's worried about running a 41:39 budget deficit which is irrelevant so 41:42 federal government spendings about 25 41:44 percent of all spending so if that's 41:46 where it's spending is at present 25 41:48 percent it's federal government spending 41:49 and the remainder is state local 41:51 governments and private sector basically 41:56 okay so if the government wants to put 42:00 more water into the bathtub because the 42:02 water levels too low it is 42:08 and obtains water in other words money 42:10 from its bottomless reservoir of 42:13 Australian dollars just turns and so 42:16 water flowing into the bathtub which is 42:18 government spending increases the water 42:20 level what attacks us Duke well there's 42:23 a drain down here that just leaked that 42:25 just destroys spending power so your 42:28 taxes I've got a bin where water doesn't 42:30 really go on a bin but I wanted 42:31 something like waste so I just goes 42:33 nowhere so if the government is running 42:36 everything else hold constant if the 42:37 government's running a balanced budget 42:38 there's as much more to going in to the 42:40 bathtub is coming out and the water 42:42 level stays at the same level if the 42:45 government if the water level is here 42:47 and I'll talk about this soon and the 42:50 private sector it has a balance then 42:55 yeah it's a bit tricky because it I'll 42:59 get to this bit later on the government 43:01 the government can and in fact it 43:03 wouldn't be running a balance but I'll 43:05 explain that soon if it wants the water 43:07 level to rise it's got to put more water 43:08 in than it taxes it's got to run a 43:10 budget deficit a fiscal injection so 43:13 what what was Peter Costello doing who's 43:15 bidding stuff on the chest he was 43:17 drowning more water out of this bathtub 43:18 and he was putting him and saying well 43:21 what a wonderful treasure I am for 43:23 running all these surpluses in actual 43:27 fact the water level didn't go down the 43:30 only didn't go out with the talk wasn't 43:31 remained didn't mind wasn't sort of kept 43:34 with it was kept up here only because 43:36 and I don't have it you know I've got to 43:37 say but I could have banks here and have 43:39 another one going here and that's 43:40 because we borrowed we can put the banks 43:43 can create some water as well but it's a 43:46 bit different because when banks when 43:48 governments create money for spending 43:51 purposes they're creating a financial 43:53 asset money is a financial asset but 43:56 when the federal government creates 43:58 money spends in any resistance it 44:00 creates a financial asset but no 44:01 offsetting financial liability like I 44:04 said before when the federal government 44:05 prints money it doesn't owe it to anyone 44:07 no more than the manufacturer of the 44:09 board game Monopoly owes monopoly 44:12 dollars to someone okay so it when it's 44:15 spends and assuming it's it will 44:18 increases its spending and it's not 44:19 changing its Taxation though 44:21 more net financial assets going in the 44:23 economy net thing net of taxes all right 44:27 and of course if when the government 44:31 taxes it's destroying financial assets 44:33 so when the government's running a 44:36 deficit it can increase the water level 44:41 it has the capacity depends again as I 44:43 said on that and I'll get to this a bit 44:45 later on on the private sector net 44:47 savings desires but it can basically 44:49 increase the water by putting more water 44:51 in than it has leaking out through 44:53 taxation and can someone say are now it 44:56 can't do that because there's a limited 44:58 amount of water for the federal 44:59 government no there's as much as the 45:00 federal government wants so can always 45:03 keep the water level at the top of the 45:05 bathtub and maintain full employment now 45:07 as I said before that doesn't mean the 45:09 federal government should go crazy print 45:10 monies and just spend whatever because 45:13 if it does the water level goes above 45:15 the level of the bathtub and that's 45:17 spending greater than productive 45:19 capacity and there's hyperinflation so 45:21 when the water level goes over the top 45:22 of the bath you've got high from frozen 45:24 so but anyone who would advocate 45:27 function of Finance would never say the 45:30 government should increase its net 45:32 spending so what the water levels above 45:34 the top of the bathtub it would say 45:37 increase it keep it there and don't go 45:38 any further 45:39 not a dollar for a dollar more but not a 45:41 dollar less so what have I got here I've 45:46 got to remember that's a leakage order 45:49 and that's an injection in terms of now 45:51 I've removed exports and imports because 45:54 that does play a part but just assume 45:56 that X this is and it's exports are 45:59 equal to its imports and we don't have 46:01 to worry about that okay so that makes 46:03 good but well it up well okay oh well in 46:07 fact it does matter 46:09 the current decay yep which is even 46:11 worse for Australia I kept that to 46:14 explain this diagram and if you think 46:23 that most of those exports imports are 46:25 by the non-government sector but 46:29 foreigners and people squalene citizens 46:35 tractor making transactions amongst 46:37 themselves so just ignore the external 46:40 sector so when the government puts more 46:43 water in the bathtub than its draining 46:47 out through taxation that what it 46:49 doesn't necessarily rise and the reason 46:52 why it might not is because this is 46:55 savings which is another leakage and 46:57 this into our vaults that's our 46:59 accumulated private-sector savings all 47:02 right our savings that we have and some 47:05 of this gets injected back in the form 47:07 of investment okay so if the 47:11 government's putting more water in than 47:13 it's draining out in other words G is 47:15 greater than T the water level can stay 47:18 at the same level if s is greater than I 47:21 of course the water level goes up in the 47:23 vault doesn't it so put more in 47:26 then it's draining out and the water 47:28 level stays at the same level in the 47:29 bathtub it goes up in the vault 47:32 okay that's basically what happened for 47:34 about 30 years in Australia after World 47:36 War Two so this red line that's that's 47:41 that's the critical point yeah because 47:43 if if we drain our accumulated savings 47:46 we get to some critical point something 47:50 like a global financial crisis somewhere 47:52 to keep that up there and in the 30 year 47:54 period after World War Two the 47:56 government basically ran deficits most 47:58 of the time it ran deficits so the water 48:01 level was pretty much up the top of the 48:04 bathtub and because it was putting more 48:07 water in than it was draining out that 48:09 meant that the private sector water 48:12 level in its vault was going up so it 48:14 meant that we had lots of savings we had 48:18 savings to call upon if something hit 48:22 and shocked the economy okay if there 48:25 was some shot to the economy that caused 48:26 spending to go down a bit in there bit 48:28 of income to go down what did we divided 48:30 the private sector 48:31 they just went and grabbed some of its 48:33 savings and spent that and that and so 48:35 recessions in that 30-year period 48:37 there weren't really any we're 48:39 incredibly short and shallow now they're 48:43 more long protracted and deeper because 48:45 we don't have this 48:48 accumulated savings anymore so we had to 48:51 dip into if the if things go well but in 48:54 actual fact we don't need if we had a 48:57 government that knew it had a bottomless 48:59 pit of our bottom was reservoir of water 49:02 it could just so even if we're in the 49:05 private sector spends hardly anything 49:07 the federal government can always offset 49:10 it so the water levels up here 49:11 so I can anyway the problem is that we 49:15 get to this critical point the private 49:17 sector cuts its spending the government 49:19 needs to fill the gap and the Treasury 49:21 goes got any money yeah and it's not 49:24 just yeah Barack Obama said the same 49:26 thing he said I can't do that anyway so 49:36 you can see that when the when the 49:41 federal government runs a deficit and 49:44 the water level stays at the same level 49:48 in the bathtub but goes up in the vault 49:51 that explains why a government deficit 49:54 is equivalent to a private sector 49:55 surplus at the cup even though the water 49:58 level in the bathtub staying the same 49:59 level if G is greater than T it's a 50:01 deficit and there's the surplus as it's 50:05 accumulating over time in the form of 50:07 accumulated net savings should I go into 50:12 this I probably won't that's pretty much 50:15 what I had to say so because people ask 50:20 if injections always equal leakages 50:22 because it turns out the two injections 50:25 are government spending and and private 50:28 sector investment back so this I for 50:32 investment and G they're injections 50:35 you've got injections there and the two 50:39 leakages are taxation and savings those 50:43 two together must equal those two all 50:46 right but that doesn't mean that G so if 50:49 G and I equals S Plus T that doesn't 50:52 mean he has to be the same as G doesn't 50:54 mean that S has to be the same as I just 50:56 some other two have to be the same 50:58 injections must equal leakages I 51:02 so but but that suggests to you okay 51:05 if the water levels here and the 51:07 government runs a deficit and the 51:09 private sector runs a surplus okay 51:12 they'll put more water in than that 51:14 drains out this will go up but the water 51:17 level will never reach the full 51:18 employment level I'd say you like the 51:21 whole idea of there being leakages 51:24 equals two injections can raise the 51:26 question how does how does the 51:28 government get the water level up well 51:30 it's what what that neglects to and I 51:34 sort of alluded to this before to 51:37 recognize is that when the government 51:38 spends it increases the Nash Nash '''l 51:43 income which not only increases its tax 51:45 revenue because tax revenues tied to 51:46 national income increases your income 51:48 and you spend more and that's the 51:50 multiplier effect of government spending 51:52 so what level goes up you got more 51:54 income you spend more and it goes up 51:56 further so let me well just a couple 52:04 things I want to get to that door and 52:06 it's a horrible looking diagram but I 52:07 just want to point out that don't worry 52:11 about the Green Line worry about these 52:12 blue bars here this was for the period 52:17 so these are financial used 1953 for 52:21 2013-14 that 60 years 60 odd years the 52:26 federal government ran 44 deficits in 18 52:28 surpluses in 62 years big deal I mean 52:33 they're potentially there was a 52:35 potential for a constraint because it 52:38 was a different course a slightly 52:39 different financial system then but the 52:41 gap government never reached that 52:42 financial constraint but the important 52:45 thing is is that governments run 52:48 deficits most of the time and we want 52:51 them to because it allows us to net safe 52:53 if we want to net safe we have to have 52:56 the government running deficits so the 53:00 deficit is the norm are we paying taxes 53:03 now for those past deficits of course 53:05 we're not a prank for them now I mean we 53:10 go back to what taxations for 53:13 okay if let's say we're at the full 53:16 employment level of income and there's a 53:18 certain amount of taxation a certain 53:19 certain amount of government spending 53:21 savings and investment and the 53:23 government is determined doesn't think 53:25 there's enough hospital beds or 53:27 something and so it wants to spend more 53:28 well 53:29 the biggest concern is that it's gonna 53:31 the water level is going to go over the 53:34 top of the bathtub and the inflationary 53:36 because there's no real resources 53:37 available it's feelings so what does the 53:41 government do as I said before it taxes 53:43 the private sector so it drains so your 53:46 your some of your spending power goes 53:47 down here and disappears forever 53:49 all right which means the government can 53:52 provide more hospitals the water level 53:53 can staff here without there being 53:56 hyperinflation oh yes do we part because 54:08 the government's generally running a 54:09 deficit rather than a surplus are we 54:12 paying taxes because of it now because 54:15 of those past everything no we're not so 54:17 the only reason why we only need for the 54:20 government to taxes here is related to 54:24 the position in this particular year you 54:28 know only has to tax us sufficiently if 54:31 it wants to maintain full employment to 54:34 ensure the water level doesn't go over 54:36 the bath top of the bathtub and B - Flay 54:39 shinri that amount that the government 54:41 taxes us has nothing to do well you 54:44 could say that something insofar as past 54:47 deficits so if it was government 54:49 spending on infrastructure what-have-you 54:51 that can affect the size of the bathtub 54:53 the productive capacity of the economy 54:55 there's got nothing to do with past 54:57 deficits so you do not pay for past 54:59 deficits all right let's just gone after 55:02 deficit in the classes it's just 55:04 something that's disappeared 55:06 Saten it's irrelevant and it's not 55:08 affecting the ability of the federal 55:09 government to spend today and Suffolk 55:11 doesn't that's totally irrelevant it's 55:13 not owed to anyone it just was a deficit 55:15 in that year big deal so you know it's 55:20 surpluses this idea of an 55:21 intergenerational fun putting surplus I 55:23 I know 55:25 Norway has purchased a lot of physical 55:28 assets but you've probably heard of this 55:29 as a sovereign wealth fund of of Norway 55:32 just imagine if it was just all of it 55:34 was Norwegian kroner sitting in a vault 55:37 and in a building and that building 55:39 burnt down and that Norwegian kroner was 55:43 was destroyed what could the Norwegian 55:45 government do just printed stuff and 55:48 replace it well if it can replace it why 55:50 doesn't it just do it 55:55 well okay yeah I peps I should get there 55:57 here's a good time for that I just been 56:01 Steve and I just went to a conference in 56:03 the USA in Kansas City there's a branch 56:07 of the Federal Reserve Bank of the USA 56:09 there's a museum there we didn't 56:11 actually get into the museum because 56:12 we've got to take our passports you need 56:13 to have a fee-only field not an American 56:15 citizen you need your passport but 56:17 doesn't know that the security guard 56:18 gave us this which is shredded US 56:21 dollars about 165 dollars worth it was 56:25 interesting because Steven I asked the 56:27 security guard what's the normal 56:29 reaction from people and they you 56:31 normally go what a waste 56:33 they could thank you just give that to 56:34 poor people well they probably don't 56:37 know US government does give money to 56:38 poor people probably not enough but it 56:40 just gives them nice crisp notes instead 56:42 you wouldn't do that if there was the 56:46 money that was sitting in your wallet or 56:47 purse would you and you're an American 56:48 citizen you wouldn't do that why would 56:50 you do it is you can't replace it the 56:53 meaning Gavin the US government can do 56:55 it because he just replaces it and and 56:58 if it can replace it then then it begs 57:01 the question does it have to shred some 57:04 money before it can print money of 57:05 course doesn't so it didn't have to 57:08 shred out on $65 before I could free 165 57:10 dollars so I can print as much as it 57:12 likes it's got as much money a u.s. u.s. 57:15 dollars not other currency any US 57:18 dollars as it as it likes 57:21 okay yeah let me I know this might look 57:25 a bit awkward but let me just go that's 57:28 five ten minutes to go through this this 57:30 is similar the bathtub type diagram but 57:33 it it does help explain how the extra 57:37 government spending even though 57:39 injections always equal equal edges 57:42 raise the water level up so the full 57:44 employment level now this is a 57:48 particular point in time these two here 57:50 this is another point in time so forget 57:51 about the bottom two here that distance 57:55 there basically represents the 57:57 productive capacity of the economy so I 57:59 think of that is that there's the 58:00 bathtub okay you've got spending and 58:04 you've got a thing called national 58:05 income one person spending is another 58:08 person's income so they always there's 58:10 two ways you've heard of gross domestic 58:12 product is two ways in which they 58:14 measured there's an income approach and 58:16 spending approach alright doesn't matter 58:18 which one you use GDP is the same so 58:21 that will they will always come side 58:24 with each other here we've obviously got 58:27 the amount of national income and 58:29 spending this is private sector spending 58:32 this is government spending the blue the 58:34 blue is government the income of course 58:36 this is private-sector income and 58:39 government income I guess you could call 58:41 red tax revenue although it's not really 58:43 income but let's just call it that for 58:46 now okay and so total spending is less 58:50 than the productive capacity so this 58:51 shaded bit here represents unemployment 58:53 because the water level is not at the 58:54 top you can see here that the private 58:58 sector spending is less than its income 59:00 well if you spend less than you earn you 59:03 say don't you so s is greater than I so 59:06 that debt that bit there which is this 59:10 plus that sorry this this plus that so 59:16 this Plus that - it gives you the him 59:20 getting it confused myself but you can 59:22 see if the private sectors income 59:25 exceeds its spending it's going to be 59:27 net saving they can only occur if the 59:30 government's been 59:33 it's revenue so that is the government 59:36 deficit and that is the private sector 59:38 surplus okay they must match hefty okay 59:42 so what if the government isn't happy 59:44 with unemployment and we're assuming 59:47 that the productive capacity economy 59:49 that by the way it's called a bad 59:51 deficit the government running a deficit 59:54 okay spending is greater than its 59:55 revenue but it's a bad one because 59:57 you've got unemployment there's things 59:59 called bad gifts so not all differences 60:00 are good cameras running a deficit now 60:02 it's not a good one cuz it's not big 60:04 enough that's basically what it means um 60:07 okay so the government decides to 60:09 increase its spending so it increases 60:12 total spending up to the full employment 60:14 level of of spending and income okay so 60:19 what happens the government spends more 60:21 as I said before that increases income 60:24 which if I spend more your income goes 60:28 up so you spend more 60:29 I also earn more taxes but you can also 60:34 not only spend more you can also save a 60:36 bit more so I've given you extra money 60:38 you can spend a bit more and save a 60:40 little bit more safely you have a look 60:42 here this is the spending of the private 60:48 sector so it's a little bit more than 60:49 was here so it's just so spending is 60:52 going up because you've got more income 60:53 you're spending a little bit more your 60:56 your income has gone up and I've drawn 60:59 it in such way as and and I've need to 61:02 do it in factual fact it this this has 61:05 to be larger than that in order for this 61:09 to rise if I'd have done it in such a 61:12 way that that and that were the same 61:14 size that wouldn't have changed all 61:17 right so the deficit actually gets 61:19 bigger not by the size of the increase 61:22 in government spending I said people 61:24 think government's running a deficit of 61:25 so much increases spending the difficult 61:28 go by there much it doesn't spending 61:30 goes up but its revenue goes up alright 61:33 because it increases national income and 61:34 that also gives us more income to 61:38 consume more and say more so in the end 61:40 you've got your full import there that's 61:42 what this is a good budget deficit well 61:43 the government under the principles of 61:45 functional finance 61:47 net spins to the level required in this 61:50 case the chief achieve full employment 61:51 it's got a deficit big deal and this is 61:57 basically how economy should operate 62:00 most of the time the government needs to 62:02 run a deficit because it allows us to 62:05 net safe because if they try to run 62:07 surpluses we don't have enough money to 62:09 spend and save if we choose to spend we 62:12 go into debt because we can't save we 62:14 have to borrow if we choose to save 62:16 instead we have to reduce our spending 62:19 and so you have a recession so deficits 62:23 are good and we don't probably recognize 62:27 it but we we've given currency issuing 62:31 central governments are given the power 62:33 to run deficits for our benefit for our 62:38 benefit I mean the federal government is 62:40 effectively the only legal counterfeiter 62:43 of the Australian dollar and we need 62:44 someone to be a counterfeiter a 62:46 counterfeiter means they produce but 62:49 they can generate more financial assets 62:51 than they create new financial 62:52 liabilities you've got because in order 62:55 for us to be safe we have to require 62:58 more financial assets than we take on 63:00 new financial liabilities so someone's 63:02 going to create the difference and the 63:04 only entity that can do that is the 63:06 Australian federal government and it can 63:07 only do that by spending on real goods 63:10 and services labor capital and so forth 63:12 so we need the federal government most 63:16 of the time to run at it now other 63:19 occasions where it might be worth 63:21 running a surplus 63:21 well it's your name's research generally 63:24 when the government runs a surplus it 63:26 wasn't even trying if I go back to that 63:29 last figure I had okay here with E so 63:34 these are the deficits there and he 63:35 hears some surpluses this is the one in 63:37 the late 1980s the Labour government 63:40 back to that 1990 the Labour government 63:42 was running a surplus he wasn't even 63:44 trying Inca GDP was strong enough at the 63:49 time the unemployment rate filled about 63:51 5% which is still not falling for 63:53 something high and the government had 63:55 coffers we're not tax revenue went up 63:57 exceeded the government spending and 64:00 and but it also me what we're doing 64:04 thank they only they date they heard 64:08 this surplice because without even 64:11 trying because we decided to run a 64:13 deficit where he decided we'll spend a 64:16 lot and we'll increase our debt by 64:21 borrowing well that's the only way they 64:22 can run a surpluses for us to run a 64:24 deficit only way remit their two sides 64:26 of the same coin here you've got in the 64:29 early 1970s a surplus and of course 64:33 here's the Costello years and what do 64:36 they have in common 64:37 what what happened in the mid 70s 64:40 recession what happened in the early 64:42 1990s following all these recession what 64:45 happened it were we avoided it to some 64:47 extent in Australia only cuz the the 64:49 stimulus package of the Rudd Government 64:51 if we hadn't done what every other 64:53 country did we would have had 64:54 unemployment up around 10% as well so 64:56 you can see that when governments run 64:58 surpluses and we run deficits inevitably 65:01 it leads to a recession where you get to 65:05 the point where our debts build up and 65:09 in order to service them because we 65:12 can't increase our debts anymore they 65:15 get to a critical level we have to start 65:17 saving in other words paying the debt 65:18 back we reduce our spending now that 65:23 doesn't necessarily cause the recess 65:25 because we didn't actually have a 65:26 recession Global post global financial 65:28 crisis only because when our spending 65:30 crashed the federal government filled 65:32 the gap to some extent not enough but to 65:35 some it fact it wasn't enough because it 65:38 should fill the gap sufficiently their 65:41 full employment you can do it and in 65:43 fact we haven't had full employment for 65:44 45 years means that the deficit has been 65:48 big in our or the surplus has been too 65:52 small right yeah but but no but I mainly 65:59 sorry the government service has been 66:01 too big if the deficit has been big 66:03 enough and the government surpluses has 66:05 been too big if if it's run a surplus 66:07 because you can get a situation where 66:10 the government will run a surplus if so 66:13 if we 66:14 get to a point so let me go back to this 66:17 don't my gran here let's just assume 66:19 that the government kevin rudd was still 66:22 in the prime minister of the counter 66:24 he's been running these huge deficits 66:26 since 2008 and big deal doesn't reduce 66:30 the capacity of the federal government 66:32 to suspend and because they state only 66:35 did it for a brief period so we're able 66:37 to bring our debt down for appear and 66:39 then I stopped the stimulus package I 66:41 shouldn't have like let's say they 66:44 continued I'd drive it down to here now 66:47 we're in a position where if we want to 66:48 for a year or two we could spend a lot 66:51 and get an end perhaps Boren in net 66:55 terms well because we're well short of 66:57 the critical rail if we do that the gum 66:59 will run a circles he'll run a surplus 67:02 even but tries to run a deficit um but 67:06 we're not in this position we're up here 67:09 for the federal government to run a 67:11 surplus that's got to rise and it's not 67:13 gonna rise and until it comes down cuz 67:18 that's got to rise in order for the 67:19 government run a service until it comes 67:20 down somewhere around here which will 67:22 require gum to run large deficits for a 67:24 long period of time then the federal 67:27 government won't be running a surplus 67:29 for the foreseeable future 67:31 not that that matters that's the problem 67:35 if so caught up with this idea of having 67:38 to Vincey run the budget back to surplus 67:40 there's no need for it it's not going to 67:42 so as it tries to run a surplus you get 67:47 this situation your bear deficit 67:50 it'll ends up running a deficit anyway 67:52 because to run a surplus we have to run 67:55 deficits we're not willing to run 67:56 deficits so they can't run surpluses 67:59 they're stuck with a deficit but because 68:01 they cut their spending to try and go 68:03 back to surplus this creeps down here 68:06 and we get more unemployment so we get a 68:07 bad deficit yeah yes is that enough 68:16 I think that's pretty much it 68:21 yeah that's fine not now it's well what 68:48 I'm describing is a system that we have 68:51 right now that is not being fully 68:53 exploited by the federal government so 69:02 what do you mean could happen what do 69:03 you mean by that he means no no no no 69:07 it's happening right now yeah yes so and 69:10 because it's you know I say this about 69:13 if we got a bad deficit because of 69:15 modern monetary theory and the 69:16 government not thinking that it has all 69:18 these powers what does it need to borrow 69:31 money for yeah so no it doesn't I know 69:34 it does it doesn't know it doesn't do it 69:37 doesn't borrow from the bank's over its 69:44 got no idea what he's talking about 69:55 yeah it taking funds away from the 69:59 private sector forcing up interest rate 70:01 this is nonsense 70:02 in fact so one of the interesting 70:04 because the argument is when the 70:05 government spends its it's got to 70:08 compete for funds and that drives up 70:09 interest rates well in actual fact when 70:12 the government spends because I 70:14 mentioned that if it runs a deficit has 70:17 to sell bonds which brings money out of 70:19 the system temporarily rather than 70:21 permanently that money that's coming out 70:24 of the system is money injected in there 70:26 in the first place where its own 70:27 spending so it's spent it you've given 70:31 me the physical stuff 70:33 me to build hospitals and if you've 70:35 bought bonds you've gone okay on a 70:37 pocket in the Reserve Bank term deposit 70:39 that's all it is and that money is not 70:42 money that is being taken away from here 70:46 there are everywhere it's money I put 70:47 into the system that previously didn't 70:49 exist in the system it's only in the 70:51 system because I spent it into existence 71:07 I don't know how much these people know 71:12 or don't know this we talk about Steven 71:17 I talk about we think there are people 71:20 working on a desk probably 23 years of 71:22 age with the Reserve Bank know how the 71:25 Reserve Bank functions better than the 71:27 Reserve Bank governor you know I think 71:29 the current Reserve Bank governor's 71:31 worked his way up through the Reserve 71:32 Bank but quite often they come across 71:34 from Sur and they have no idea about 71:36 central banking but there's a 23 year 71:38 old who's dealing with an exchange 71:40 settlement accounts of all the banks 71:44 when the government runs our deficit 71:47 okay as I said it's injecting more money 71:49 into the system this is the reason why 71:51 the government sells bonds and it 71:53 injects money in the system when it 71:55 taxes it it destroys some so when it 71:58 runs a deficit more goes into the system 72:00 where does that end up that ends up in 72:02 the exchange sediment accounts of all 72:05 the banks remember I said if you've got 72:07 money sitting in a bank account it's 72:08 really sitting in your banks reserve a 72:11 count okay so that's that's just sitting 72:14 there and if that is earning it I said 72:21 before it's earning interest okay that's 72:26 the system changed that much 72:27 I can I can give that explanation look 72:29 so but the target cash rate that you 72:32 hear on the news is 1.5 percent okay if 72:37 there is an excess of reserves in the 72:40 system and it's left overnight in 72:42 exchange settlement accounts banks leave 72:44 them there they will earn one point two 72:46 five 72:47 interest its point two five percent less 72:49 than the target rate now some banks will 72:52 have excess reserves some will have a 72:55 shortage of reserves okay so these banks 72:58 that have got and of course if you've 73:00 got a shortage of reserves as if you can 73:02 you can borrow from other banks or you 73:04 can borrow from the Reserve Bank if you 73:06 borrowed from the Reserve Bank you pay 73:08 point two five percent above the target 73:10 rate one point seven five percent that's 73:12 the banks not you the banks okay so 73:15 you're about you've got excess reserves 73:16 and you can leave it in overnight at one 73:19 point two five percent and but there's 73:21 another bank that shortage of reserves 73:24 and if it borrows from the Reserve Bank 73:25 it'll play 1.75 percent so what do you 73:28 say to that Bank you say how would you 73:30 like to borrow the excess reserves we 73:33 don't need this you've got a short at 73:35 one point seven four percent okay yeah 73:37 okay that's lower than one point seven 73:39 five percent and and your bank will be 73:41 making a profit because it won't be 73:43 getting one point two five percent but 73:44 one point seven four percent but there's 73:46 another Bank with excess reserves going 73:48 well hang on we want to get rid of 73:50 Alex's will will lend it at one point 73:53 seven three percent and then there's a 73:55 counter off when I talked about Japan 74:11 zero percent is because the default rate 74:15 pay in fact it's now negative but let's 74:18 say zero the default rate paid on funds 74:21 left in what they I'm not sure what they 74:23 call the exchange it's a reserve account 74:26 in banks at in Japanese Bay is zero 74:29 percent the government runs a deficit in 74:32 Japan the central bank hasn't got a 74:34 target cash rate it doesn't sort bans 74:36 two bonds to drain these excess reserves 74:40 what happens to the cash rate it goes 74:42 down to zero percent because the 74:44 government does and then because when 74:47 people getting back to your question 74:48 Andrew you're saying how that those 74:51 bonds playing so it looks like the 74:52 government's borrowing the money you 74:54 know it's it's virtually equal to the 74:56 size of the deficit they are well that's 74:58 but they're no and 75:01 it's not because as I said before the 75:03 government doesn't have to do it and 75:05 Japan is an example of it it didn't do 75:07 it 75:07 so it was short fall and there was no 75:09 money yen coming from anyway because the 75:12 central bank wasn't selling bonds 75:14 because the central bank had a policy 75:19 short-term interest rate fall to zero 75:22 percent whatever we have a a Reserve 75:25 Bank that does have a target cash rate 75:26 and so if there is a deficit there has 75:29 to be bonds sold to soak up the excess 75:32 reserves so that the target cash rate 75:35 can be me otherwise it will drop to 1.25 75:38 C so what looks like borrowing from the 75:42 bank's the gap is in fact none other 75:45 than a mechanism for the reserve bank to 75:48 set and maintain a target interest rate 75:51 when the government's running a deficit 75:53 it's not borrowing at all but and but 75:56 surendra you're talking about the the 75:58 interest paid on those bonds I said 76:01 before they became bonds that were in 76:04 fact reserve bank term deposits earning 76:07 interest what we were they before they 76:09 were in those reserve accounts earning 76:11 interest they're really paying interest 76:13 on it they just pick it up and go back a 76:17 bit and by doing that the this system 76:20 when it's in the reserve accounts in the 76:22 system driving the cash right now 76:25 so bonds gets picked up goes out of the 76:28 system and the interest rate target is 76:30 met it's a temporary removal whereas 76:33 taxes you get the money back by earning 76:39 money but you won't get the taxes back 76:41 it's gone forever 76:43 it so that sort of answer you could say 76:45 they're not borrowing at all hahaha 76:49 let's anyone want to tell this I have no 76:51 idea who's next 76:52 oh okay 77:07 yeah yeah he can well well 77:23 perhaps it's not the best to talk in 77:25 terms of look the cook basically I think 77:28 you're right what you're trying to say 77:29 is I've said that if the private sector 77:32 runs a surplus so it's not saving the 77:36 the federal government central dome has 77:39 to run a deficit that's not entirely 77:41 true 77:43 if where can the extra revenue come from 77:46 the by by the country net exporting all 77:50 right so we get extra income which means 77:54 that that provides that but of course 77:58 those those financial assets we earn are 78:00 denominated in a foreign currency so we 78:02 save basically in the form of foreign 78:05 currency denominated finance financial 78:07 assets now I didn't say anything about 78:10 net exports because it would've come but 78:12 even if you do that here's a question 78:16 why because most people think that 78:20 exporting is good the most fundamental 78:23 principle in economics is the 78:24 opportunity cost principle and the 78:27 opportunity cost principle is based on 78:29 the idea that the cost is what you give 78:31 up and the benefit is what you receive 78:34 so what you give up is the opportunity 78:35 cost when a nation exports it gives up 78:38 goods that's a cost it's only seen as a 78:40 benefit because when you calculate GDP 78:42 its plus X because GDP only measures 78:46 what you produce not what you consume 78:49 okay so when you export you give 78:52 something up to the rest of the world 78:54 you never see it again 78:55 you use your labor your scarce resources 78:58 to produce it and to give it to the rest 79:00 of the world when you import something 79:03 the rest the world give something to you 79:05 okay now 79:08 government can run a circus if the 79:10 private sectors running a circus if the 79:12 trade surface is big enough if we're 79:14 giving enough to the rest of the world 79:16 or over and above what the rest of the 79:18 world is giving to us now why would you 79:20 want to do that why would you because 79:24 let's let's assume that X is exceeding 79:29 okay wouldn't it make sense for because 79:34 what it basically the only reason why it 79:36 really I've got a country near exports 79:38 is because the central government is not 79:42 net spending to the level required for 79:45 us to meet our savings desires and 79:47 there's still some idle capacity and we 79:49 use that to produce goods which we need 79:51 export to the rest of the world now why 79:53 would you do that wouldn't it be better 79:54 the difference between exports and 79:56 imports if the central the federal 79:58 government purchased that paid the same 80:00 price GDP is exactly the same our 80:04 incomes the same what happens to the 80:06 stuff that the government purchases 80:07 purchases stays in Australia and he can 80:10 use it to build schools hospital and 80:13 bridges instead of us producing things 80:15 that suit the demands of people oversee 80:19 so it makes no sense it is a way you can 80:22 get around it but you only need export 80:24 as a country in order in order to 80:28 overcome the fact that the net that the 80:31 central government's not net spending 80:33 enough to give us enough income for us 80:36 to meet our spending a net savings 80:38 desires if we don't get enough income 80:39 and there's idle capacity and we're not 80:42 going to spend any more and the 80:43 government's not one of you spending 80:45 more we produce the stuff and we send it 80:47 overseas and we the government can 80:50 always the difference what a piece of 80:59 paper what you get something in return 81:18 but it's and in many cases in the case 81:21 of China 81:22 accumulating US federal government bonds 81:24 okay and handing stuff over the USA 81:28 vogue those bonds that they bikini line 81:31 if that if the Chinese top if China 81:33 wants to redeem the value of their bonds 81:35 the fewest federal government is to them 81:39 and for all those years China has been 81:41 stupid enough to be exporting to they 81:46 know they're now they've now a new 81:49 policy to increase domestic consumption 81:52 alright because China consumption is a 81:55 ratio and it makes no sense well if you 82:16 if well it depends if you've got a 82:17 flexible exchange rate and you've got a 82:19 gate well and if you end up with a 82:21 current account surplus you'll have a 82:23 capital account deficit well cap again 82:31 the worst services that can be 82:34 misleading it's a capital account 82:37 deficit in that if you're a net exporter 82:39 the rest of the world oh you more money 82:42 then you owe to them and so you then to 82:46 you end up being a lender so capital 82:48 flows out we lend it to them okay but in 82:51 actual fact we're in the advantageous 82:53 position when we've got well strategy 82:55 opposite we generally have a perpetual 82:58 current account deficit and a capital 83:01 account surplus okay so what does that 83:04 mean so just quick what does that mean 83:06 it means that we're not in that position 83:08 where we can have the private sector 83:13 with a surplus in the government with a 83:16 surplus 83:16 I've just been teaching in Singapore I 83:18 didn't talk about things slightly 83:20 differently there because that is a part 83:21 of the world where the government can 83:23 run a surplus the private sector can run 83:25 a surplus because they need exports so 83:27 much but you know Singapore who which is 83:30 a fairly wealthy country could be even 83:32 wealthier if it was consuming the stuff 83:33 themselves and the 83:35 pouring government was buying those real 83:36 resources are different we exports and 83:38 imports infrastructure goods to the 83:43 Singaporean people yep sorry 84:09 well I'm next him before grief you know 84:12 people say ah strategy can't run 84:14 deficits for too long or will end up 84:15 like Greece I mentioned before I don't 84:18 know if you but that the Greek 84:21 government is in terms of its capacity 84:23 to spend is no different to the South 84:26 Australian government it's a user of the 84:28 euro a regional currency it can't print 84:31 euros to spend to offset a decline in 84:35 private sector spending I mean it could 84:38 if the European Central Bank gave them 84:40 but they're not giving them the money 84:41 they've got an austerity sort of 84:43 approach and so that's why why a country 84:46 would give up its own its monopoly 84:49 ownership and issuance of its own 84:51 currency is beyond me it just doesn't 84:54 make sense whatsoever yeah but even 85:01 that's not enough if so the unemployment 85:03 rate in the eurozone is still incredibly 85:05 high so there's not enough spending 85:06 within the zone itself all the 85:11 conventional economics books should be 85:12 you used to stoke a fire I mean that's a 85:16 bad yep it's not a theory by the way 85:25 it's a description yep yep actually how 85:28 it is 85:48 well the government's not really saying 85:51 it's a it's it's the private sector 85:53 that's it that's selling assets to the 85:55 rest of the world ah okay yeah well it 86:01 really has no different impact to the 86:03 the government privatizing it and 86:05 selling it to us okay so it's capacity 86:08 its capacity to but that's not that 86:14 that's not the real issue the real issue 86:16 is that a lot of these things that are 86:19 sold off have what are called public 86:21 goods characteristics and if there is a 86:25 part of mainstream economics that makes 86:27 a bit of sense its public goods public 86:29 goods a particular characteristics such 86:32 that if you allow the private sector to 86:35 provide them you won't get them provided 86:37 in sufficient quantities which is why to 86:40 do them so if you privatize public goods 86:43 okay then you don't get sufficient 86:45 public goods so that's the real problem 86:48 it's not the revenue issue that's 86:55 privatized I think it's a big con I mean 86:58 and it's made worse by the fact that the 87:01 things that have been sold off things 87:03 with public goods characteristics 87:04 augment natural monopoly characteristics 87:06 it's a form of market failure and 87:08 there's no evidence to suggest when we 87:11 talk about large-scale production that 87:13 the private sector is any more efficient 87:15 than the public sector okay 87:17 this idea that if you got a public 87:19 sector hat on yes it and you drink 87:22 coffee or go behind a desk and then you 87:24 take that off and put affright private 87:25 sector hat on and you're all ready to go 87:27 I'm efficient now this is just absolute 87:30 garbage I mean in fact I've got a lot of 87:34 friends are in the in the public sector 87:35 if you could probably earn a lot more 87:36 money in the private sector and they're 87:38 incredibly committed people so this idea 87:40 that the public sector is inefficient is 87:42 just sheer utter nonsense okay because 88:03 well they don't understand it either 88:06 yeah I don't do they're not fully 88:10 conversant with the economics or even if 88:14 they did well it's a chance to score a 88:16 political point because the public don't 88:18 know well well it just goes to show they 88:25 they they well you could argue that I 88:29 don't know these people personally so I 88:31 don't know how much they actually know 88:32 and what they don't 88:33 yes but but but one of the things that 88:38 modern monetary theory can do as I said 88:40 you can be I don't write so bad news but 88:51 this imagine a real horrible person on 88:53 the far right okay they can operate they 88:56 can even learn the principles of modern 88:58 monetary theory apply them and still 89:00 implement right-wing policies if they 89:02 want to it doesn't mean that you once 89:04 you've got this knowledge you obligated 89:07 to run left-wing tight policies but the 89:10 thing is what is the problem with those 89:13 people on the far right is that when 89:16 they do something and it might mean well 89:19 you're not doing enough to reduce 89:20 unemployment they say well the 89:23 government hasn't enough money yeah the 89:25 gun could spin and reduce okay once 89:27 everyone knows about modern monetary 89:29 theory people go no no no no that's 89:31 that's that's not so what's your real 89:33 reason for unemployment so modern 89:35 monetary theory offers an opportunity to 89:38 lift the veil of all these ideological 89:40 nonsense they hide behind our ignorance 89:43 what they say done any kind of full 89:46 employment run out of money sorry miss 89:53 Li well I guess see that I don't know if 89:57 these people even know what they're and 89:59 I don't know well federal treasury sorry 90:03 it speaks it the federal Treasury every 90:06 year publishes the budget papers 90:10 forecasting budget surpluses in the 90:12 future you have to ask the question is 90:14 it anyone in federal treasury who knows 90:18 if I became prime minister I would save 90:21 the people in federal treasury don't 90:23 like sacking people you can have your 90:25 job but only if you're willing to be 90:28 retrained if you're not off you go sorry 90:34 Judy got more designs.
 
 
hail:
 we have tried I 90:39 did a talk similar to Phil's not as good 90:42 as Phil's but similar to Phil's about 90:44 four years ago which was organized by 90:46 the South Australian Greens I rewrote 90:50 the economic policy of the Australian 90:52 Greens when I was a member of that party 90:54 the South Australian Greens National 91:02 Party completely blocked any discussion 91:04 of it because they don't dare and 91:06 discuss these ideas Richard Di Natale 91:08 basically blocked it we've done an 91:11 interview we've done interviews with 91:13 people from the Labour Party on video 91:14 they never published the interviews and 91:17 they are terrified of discussing these 91:20 kind of ideas because they're afraid 91:22 that they'll be crucified in the press 


91:25 and one of our colleagues stephanie 91:27 kelton was the chief she was the chief 91:30 economist and the Senate Budget 91:33 Committee in Washington DC for the 91:35 Democrats she was Bernie Sanders chief 91:38 economic adviser Bernie Sanders 91:41 perfectly well understands these ideas 91:42 but basically refused to discuss them 91:44 during the election campaign for the 91:46 same reason is because I've had to say 91:53 something that immediately in your mind 91:55 you said you're a lunatic I go into 92:01 politics and I say this I don't have an 92:03 hour now to explain it I look like 92:05 before so that's why the politicians 92:11 aren't interested in even saying a bit 92:13 of knowledge of it all right here 92:41 no the if if the they federal camera 92:47 just runs a surplus okay that's a good 92:55 point 92:55 well hmm well it doesn't so long as the 93:05 water level doesn't go over the top of 93:07 the but how do you stop doing that I 93:09 mentioned the thing called a job 93:10 guarantee yeah so if you've got private 93:13 sector spending that's fallen and the 93:15 government has to fill the gap 93:16 the government doesn't estimate how much 93:19 it needs to fit somewhere near then it 93:23 relies upon the job guarantee to get it 93:25 right at the top not a dollar more not a 93:27 dollar less how does it ensure that it's 93:29 at the top because the amount of 93:31 spending that's required to achieve full 93:33 employment with a job guarantee depends 93:35 upon the number of people who walk 93:36 through the job guarantee offices so if 93:39 you need to spend so much to put ten 93:41 thousand people have lost their jobs 93:42 yesterday into a ten thousand people 93:44 will walk in the government doesn't have 93:46 to calculate what it is so at the margin 93:48 they find the job guarantee does the 93:51 fine-tuning okay to ensure and whatever 93:55 that wall and if that water level you 93:57 right the the private sector is gone in 94:02 a massive deficit the government runs a 94:04 surplus as I said the budget bottom line 94:07 the government isn't worried about is 94:08 what it is so when the private sector 94:11 runs a deficit wallet it runs a surplus 94:24 I spent eight years in the Senate and 94:31 when the then Labour government wanted 94:36 to privatize CSL and I said to the in 94:41 the Senate I said there was no need to 94:44 privatize CSL you could easily create 94:47 the credit to refinance a hill and keep 94:52 it in government ownership Peter Walsh 94:55 was the Minister of Finance and Peter 94:58 Walsh said that is an old-fashioned idea 95:02 he didn't say there was anything wrong 95:04 with it who is just that it was 95:06 old-fashioned but fill that there's one 95:11 factor that I think you've left out of 95:13 your talk 95:14 I accept that governments can create 95:23 whatever it needs up to the limit of 95:28 available labour and available resources 95:31 without that being inflationary however 95:35 there is another restriction in the 95:37 system and that is the environmental 95:39 restriction Australians for instance at 95:42 the present time if the whole world used 95:45 resources like we do we'd need five 95:48 point two earths so we need to cut down 95:52 our use of resources to roughly 20 95:55 percent of what we're currently using if 95:58 we're going to be equitable and fair 95:59 with the rest of the world so weird as 96:03 where does that come in does it come in 96:06 by way of a a tax on resources or 96:09 allocation of resources by some sort of 96:11 a government system but the thing is 96:18 okay this is another and I've got to say 96:21 there are some people who support the 96:23 job guarantee don't like me saying this 96:25 because a lot of these people don't even 96:27 they talk about a constraint they 96:30 obviously there's only so much available 96:33 even if you don't think about ecological 96:35 constraints these people don't think 96:37 enough 96:37 about ecological constraints and so 96:41 they're of the view that the sole 96:43 purpose of the job guarantee if there's 96:45 unemployment is to increase spending so 96:48 that the my now if you happen to be a 97:00 country where your resource uses is 97:03 within some ecological construct so you 97:06 can afford to have a bit more resources 97:07 the job guarantee is an ideal way of 97:10 increasing spending up to the full 97:13 employment level I like the job 97:15 guarantee because I think it is a 97:17 wonderful way because if we are going to 97:21 have to shrink the economy but still 97:22 have full employment we've got to find a 97:24 really good way of rationing you can 97:27 come through work and job guarantee you 97:29 can do that you'd obviously have to cut 97:30 the heads off the rich super rich but 97:33 but not to pay for anything that's 97:37 that's one of the people and the 97:38 progressive say are you know the rich 97:40 after the tax I that government's got 97:42 money to spend on the poor well it 97:44 doesn't need that at all it needs to cut 97:46 their heads off the rich because it's 97:48 the rich yeah 97:50 and when I say to you I've got nothing 97:51 against rich people but but but well 97:54 it's not just that I'm of there's a 97:58 thing called economic rent it's it's a 98:00 horrible okay what it's not the rent you 98:03 pay on a house I'll get an example of it 98:06 it's a best way to do it okay a sports 98:09 people earn economic rents think if the 98:12 I don't know what this training 98:13 captain's cricket captain's on they say 98:15 it's a three million dollar contract 98:16 okay uh if you started taxing away the 98:21 Australian captain's cricket captain's 98:24 income would he start doing something 98:27 else and how far could you reduce his 98:30 income through taxation to he gets the 98:32 point he says I'm applying for strategy 98:34 man how to do that well I reckon you 98:36 could probably tax if it's streaming in 98:38 I reckon you could probably tax away 98:42 point sixty point seven million dollars 98:44 before he changes his labor supply and 98:47 you can do a talk about the same with 98:48 Natural Resources so until that person 98:52 switches what they're doing that amount 98:56 okay that you can tax away is an 98:58 economic rent it represents unknown 99:00 income because income really is the 99:03 minimum amount that you have to be paid 99:05 to provide your labor or your resources 99:08 anything above that is an economic rent 99:09 the government can tax it away and it 99:11 won't affect the supply of that resource 99:13 or that person whatsoever they'll keep 99:15 doing it it's another Steve Smith Steve 99:23 Smith he by getting a three million 99:26 dollar contract 99:28 he's claim on real goods and services as 99:32 three million dollars but he's really 99:34 income it's probably three or four 99:36 hundred thousand dollars okay so the 99:39 only way he can have that extra claim on 99:43 rural sources and it not be inflationary 99:47 is there must be other people who are 99:49 getting paid less than what they 99:51 contribute so they out their heads 99:54 cut off because they're earning economic 99:57 rents and you know some people say where 99:59 do you really think it or I'm of the 100:00 view that the Prime Minister's job is 100:04 probably the most important job in the 100:05 land Prime Minister's own about five 100:07 hundred thousand dollars a year well I 100:09 don't believe anyone's worth more than 100:10 five hundred thousand dollars a year and 100:12 you have a hundred percent income tax 100:14 rate at five hundred thousand because I 100:15 think anything above that is an economic 100:17 rent but I stopped not just yeah 100:33 I can already political language of 100:36 politicians 100:55 I think sorry thanks I think one of the 101:50 things that I know it sounds a bit harsh 101:54 I think we've got to call politicians to 101:57 account in a more serious way we don't 102:01 we don't know much about new they may 102:04 not be a single neurologist in this in 1:10:36 再生中

0 件のコメント:

コメントを投稿