2021年5月6日木曜日

Debunking the Deficit Myth to Help Save the Planet with Dr. Stephanie Kelton 2021/04/22



 Debunking the Deficit Myth to Help Save the Planet with Dr. Stephanie Kelton 2021/04/22 (03/10)  

https://love-and-theft-2014.blogspot.com/2021/05/debunking-deficit-myth-to-help-save.html @

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bb9MC2QYbB0 


 参考:

2012/07/08

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qnj1ofZ8S3w

__ 

https://theclimatepod.libsyn.com/debunking-the-deficit-myth-to-save-the-planet

Mar 10, 2021

 

This week, Dr. Stephanie Kelton joins the show to discuss how American politicians totally misunderstand the national debt and how the Federal government can use fiscal policy to create a just and sustainable society. Her book, The Deficit Myth, explains Modern Monetary Theory and shows why America can and must spend big on just climate solutions or we'll create the real intergenerational debt that matters.

Buy The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People's Economy

Subscribe to our new Substack newsletter "The Climate Weekly": https://theclimateweekly.substack.com/

As always, follow us @climatepod on Twitter and email us at theclimatepod@gmail.com. Our music is "Gotta Get Up" by The Passion Hifi, check out his music at thepassionhifi.com. Rate, review and subscribe to this podcast on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, and more! Subscribe to our new YouTube channel! Join our Facebook group. Check out our updated website!

 

 

 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/debunking-deficit-myth-to-help-save-planet-w-dr-stephanie/id1469270123?i=1000512372982

Kelton:52:26
yes and fortunately there are many good ones out there i mean you know kate raw worth uh mariana matsukato both of friends of mine kate with um you know the donut economics is a book that has i think had a tremendous impact and influences policy making around the world you know you've got cities and nations committing to trying to you know operate within the safe part of what she calls the donut right not pushing beyond the boundaries and also not uh doing things that would so deprive you of a good life but to keep you in that in that safe place mariano with her you know mission economy and the entrepreneurial state.
 um naomi klein steve keane i mean naomi's not an economist obviously but you know has done a lot of work here as an academic as well steve keane an economist who has really taken apart the nord house uh nobel prize-winning economists work on uh climate and and so forth and and steve does great work and there are so many others and yes it's incumbent upon us because for better or worse.
 and it's usually i'm afraid to say for worse economists have an outsized voice in the public debates they do you know you will listen to a president they don't often stand up and say well leading sociologists tell us or leading anthropologists say it's always what economists are telling us you know economists are saying so we enjoy.
 um this you know status of somehow being the ones who are supposed to know and provide you know the proper guidance to policymakers and so forth so yes it's important for economists to to do the work to step up to help push policy thinking in that ambitious direction to to allow leaders to see that you know things are achievable.
 because so much of what they're presented with from economists is what you can't do it's why you can't do things it's you know the cost benefit analysis say no or the cbo report says no or this says no and you need people who are willing and able to step forward and push back against those dominant themes that well interest rates are going to prevent it or markets will prevent it or investors won't allow it or something you got to be able to demonstrate why those arguments are are flawed.

 

ケルトン:52:26 はい、そして幸いなことに、そこにはたくさんの良いものがあります。つまり、ドーナツの経済学は、ドーナツの経済学が多大な影響を与え、周りの政策立案に影響を与えたと思う本です。彼女がドーナツと呼んでいるものの安全な部分の中で、境界を越えて押したり、あなたの良い生活を奪うようなことをしたりするのではなく、あなたがミッション経済と起業家の状態を知っている彼女と一緒にその安全な場所マリアーノであなたをその中に保ちなさい。 um naomi klein steve keaneつまり、naomiは明らかにエコノミストではありませんが、ここでは学者として多くの仕事をしてきました。また、ノーベル賞を受賞したエコノミストは、気候となどなど、スティーブは素晴らしい仕事をしていて、他にもたくさんあります。そうです、良くも悪くも、それは私たちの義務です。 そして、通常、より悪い経済学者が公の議論で大げさな声を上げていると言うのは怖いです彼らはあなたが彼らがしばしば立ち上がることのない大統領に耳を傾け、優れた社会学者が私たちに言うか、または一流の人類学者がそれは常にだと言うことを知っていますかエコノミストが私たちに言っていることは、エコノミストが言っていることを知っているので、私たちは楽しんでいます。 ええと、これはどういうわけかあなたが知っているはずの人であり、政策立案者などに適切なガイダンスを提供することになっているというステータスを知っているので、そうです、経済学者がその野心的な方向に政策思考を推進するのを助けるためにステップアップするための仕事をすることが重要ですリーダーがあなたが物事が達成可能であることを知っていることを確認できるようにするため。 エコノミストから提示されたものの多くはあなたができないことであるため、あなたは物事を行うことができない理由ですそれはあなたが費用便益分析がノーと言うか、cboレポートがノーと言うかこれがノーと言うことを知っているのであなたは人々を必要とします金利がそれを妨げるか、市場がそれを妨げるか、投資家がそれを許可しないか、またはあなたがそれらの議論がなぜであるかを示すことができるようになった何かを、進んで前進し、押し戻すことができる人欠陥があります。 

 

ケルトン:52:26

幸いなことに、世の中には優れたものがたくさんあります。私の友人であるケイト・ロー・ワースやマリアナ・マツカトもそうですが、ケイトが書いた「ドーナツ経済学」は、世界中の政策立案に多大な影響を与えた本だと思っています。彼女がドーナツ経済学と呼ぶ安全な部分で活動しようとすることにコミットしています。
 naomi klein steve keane naomiは明らかに経済学者ではありませんが、学者としてここで多くの仕事をしてきましたし、steve keaneは経済学者で、ノードハウスやノーベル賞を受賞した経済学者の気候に関する仕事などを実際に解明してきました。
 悪く言えば、経済学者は公共の場での議論において圧倒的な発言力を持っています。あなたも大統領の話を聞くでしょうが、彼らが立ち上がって、「一流の社会学者が言っていることだ」とか「一流の人類学者が言っていることだ」と言うことはあまりありません。
 ですから、経済学者が仕事をして、政策思考を野心的な方向に推し進め、リーダーたちに物事が達成可能であることを理解してもらうことは重要です。
 なぜなら、エコノミストから提示されることの多くは、できないこと、できない理由、つまり、費用対効果分析がダメだとか、CBレポートがダメだとか、これがダメだとかいうものだからです。

www.DeepL.com/Translator(無料版)で翻訳しました。

 

 #deficitmyth #modernmonetarytheory #kelton Debunking the Deficit Myth to Help Save the Planet with Dr. Stephanie Kelton 26 回視聴•2021/04/22 4 0 共有 保存 The Climate Pod チャンネル登録者数 24人 #deficitmyth​ #modernmonetarytheory​ #kelton​ #climatechange​ Dr. Stephanie Kelton joins the show to discuss how American politicians totally misunderstand the national debt and how the Federal government can use fiscal policy to create a just and sustainable society. Her book, The Deficit Myth, explains Modern Monetary Theory and shows why America can and must spend big on just climate solutions or we'll create the real intergenerational debt that matters. Be sure to subscribe to The Climate Pod YouTube channel! Listen to the full episode of The Climate Pod featuring Dr. Kelton here: iTunes: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...​ Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/4v3f...​ The Climate Pod is a weekly conversation on the latest climate issues with the journalists, activists, academics, and artists at the center of the story. Follow us on social media! Twitter: https://twitter.com/climatepod​ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/climatepod/​ Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/climatepod/​ Subscribe to our new Substack newsletter "The Climate Weekly": https://theclimateweekly.substack.com/​ Website: www.theclimatepod.com 

 

文字起こし [Music] 

T:

well dr stephanie kelton welcome to the climate pod thank you so much for having me well after reading the deficit myth i am confident that if america is going to really take the steps to address the climate crisis at the scale and at the speed necessary then our policy makers must understand the core tenets of modern monetary theory and really disregard their flawed and antiquated views on america's debt and deficit so in order to understand the climate implications of all this i really want to first help the audience understand mmt so if you could just summarize at a pretty high level the core principles of modern monetary theory.

 

Kelton:

 okay sure so what mmt is about is giving uh an explanation of how a sovereign currency works okay now you say all right well what's a sovereign currency right so what we're talking about are um the policy options let's say that are available to countries that have a sovereign currency what is that what does that mean it means countries that issue a currency that is their own currency the us issues the dollar uh the japanese government issues the yen the british government issues the pound these are governments that issue their own unique currency they receive payments in that same currency they tax in that currency they never need to borrow their own currency from anyone in order to be able to spend it if they do choose to sell bonds this thing we call government borrowing then that is an optional thing and they can also determine the interest rate that they are willing to pay on any bonds that they choose to issue what it means is that you know a few things follow from that one the government can never run out of money you can't run out of the thing that you and only you have the legal authority to create to issue so the us government's never going to run out of dollars and that's not what barack obama told us when he was president he had just taken office and he was asked in an interview you know the wheels were coming off the economy we had the financial crisis and the great recession and he was asked in an interview at what point does the government run out of money and his response was well we're out of money now and it wasn't the case and it can't be the case and we drew so many wrong lessons from the experience of you know 2010 watching many countries in europe um get very much embroiled in a debt crisis countries like greece people might remember having debts come due that they weren't able to pay and many people said listen if the u.s isn't careful we're next we're going to end up like greece no wrong greece got into trouble spain got into trouble italy got into trouble and in other european countries because they were borrowing in a currency that they don't issue greece gave up the dragma in order to join economic and monetary union and began using the euro so we want to pay a very close attention to the nature of the monetary system because that has important implications for how much policy space is available to governments and then we can begin to talk about how governments can manage their budgets can use their spending capacity in ways that reflect the fact that they're currency issuers whereas countries that aren't currency issuers like greece and others they have to manage their budgets differently and so we hear these household analogies right that the government should balance its budget just like you and i just just like a household that's not right not for a currency issuing government like japan or the u.s or the uk or australia or many others but it is closer to true when you're talking about countries that borrow in foreign currencies that don't have what what i've described as a sovereign currency so that's a starting point you can afford these governments can afford to buy whatever is both available and for sale in their own unique currency so when you say what can the us government afford to do it can afford to hire to purchase whatever is available and for sale in us dollars and it turns out that's a lot and importantly it includes all unemployed labor which means that mmt teaches us that unemployment is always a policy choice because it can easily be eliminated.

ケルトン

 mmtとは、主権通貨がどのように機能するのかを説明することです さて、あなたは「主権通貨とは何か」とおっしゃいますが、私たちが話しているのは、主権通貨を持つ国が利用できる政策オプションのことです つまり、独自の通貨を発行している国のことです 米国はドルを発行しています 日本政府は円を発行しています 英国政府はポンドを発行しています これらは、独自の通貨を発行している政府です。

 その通貨で支払いを受け、その通貨で税金を納め、その通貨を使うために誰かから借りる必要はありません。もし政府が国債の発行を選択した場合、それは任意のことです。バラク・オバマは、大統領に就任したばかりの頃、インタビューで、経済の歯車が狂い始めていたこと、金融危機と大不況があったことを聞かれました。
 2010年にヨーロッパの多くの国が債務危機に巻き込まれたのを見て、多くの間違った教訓を得ました。ギリシャのような国は、支払えないほどの債務を抱えていたことを覚えているかもしれません。

 ギリシャは経済通貨同盟に参加するためにドラグマを放棄し、ユーロを使い始めました。ですから、通貨システムの性質には細心の注意を払いたいと思います。政府がどのように予算を管理し、通貨発行国であるという事実を反映した方法で支出能力を利用できるかについて話し始めることができます。一方、ギリシャなどの通貨発行国ではない国は、異なる方法で予算を管理しなければなりません。 日本やアメリカ、イギリス、オーストラリアなどのように通貨を発行している政府にとっては正しくありませんが、私がソブリン通貨と表現したものを持たない外国通貨で借金をしている国について言えば、より真実に近いと言えますので、これが出発点となります。つまり、米国政府には何ができるかというと、米ドルで購入できるものなら何でも購入するために雇う余裕があるということです。

www.DeepL.com/Translator(無料版)で翻訳しました。

T:

 so if the united states is not going to run out of money if we can create more money to solve a lot of these problems then you know why are we paying taxes what is the purpose of taxes well there are lots of reasons so there's like you know an origin story and we could talk about if you wanted to start up a currency from scratch a tax or something that works like a tax fees fines other obligations these are ways that governments historically have introduced a currency to a population to start up a currency from scratch so very quick brush of history here right you could imagine uh in the case of of uh britain great britain for example you know countries were colonized these are colonizing countries uh you go in and you say sail over to africa and you land and you look around and you find a lot of things that you'd like to have that you don't have access to back at home and you think well how can i get these people to give me their real you know resources that i'm after there are a number of ways you could go about it some very unpleasant uh one way to do it that masks some of the unpleasant trees is to impose a tax and so you say to the population listen you are now the subject of the crown what does that mean well that means that periodically somebody's going to come around and they're going to collect attacks and so what we're going to be looking for is for you to settle your obligation to the crown well what's how do i settle the tax oh well you're going to need some british currency and that's what you'll use to settle i don't have british currency we can help right all you have to do is produce some of the things that we're after sell them to us we'll buy them provide you with the currency that you need to settle your obligation to the state now the people have a need for the currency why because if you don't settle the tax obligation if you don't pay your tax they will burn your hut down they will right there's a punishment so in other words the taxes away through enforcement right making and enforcing tax laws to give value to a currency that would otherwise have no value to those people and so that's an origin story but once a once a monetary system is up and running like we have in the us today then we don't think about the tax as playing that role even though it's still important we think about tax as a way for the government to um impact the distribution of wealth and income we see that now with this 1.9 trillion dollar uh coveted relief package that includes tax cuts and tax effectively rebates and and so it is a way to funnel right cash into people's hands it can also be a way to take cash away from people you could push taxes up on higher income individuals and say well i'm doing this because i want to kind of rebalance the distribution of wealth and income also every dollar that is taxed away from us is a dollar that we don't have and can't therefore spend chasing after goods and services in the economy so taxes are like a release valve right they relieve some pressure by removing dollars from our hands the government can then spend dollars into the economy maintaining the value of the currency without creating an inflation problem so they can add with their spending and subtract dollars by taxing and calibrate the spending and taxing so that they are managing inflationary pressures so when you think about taxing that's the now the government raises revenue right through taxing and they spend on all kinds of federal programs things like that and every year when the government spends more than it takes in it creates a deficit so so what actually happens when when the federal government spends more in a given year than it brings back in well a lot of things happen the most important and straightforward of which is that somebody ends up with that currency somebody ends up with the money so if you know the deficit is just this misunderstood concept it has it carries this connotation because the word itself is kind of inherently suggests that there's a problem a deficit means a shortfall um people immediately think deficit bad surplus good right but when the government is running a fiscal deficit it simply means that they are spending more dollars into the economy than they are subtracting back out mostly through taxation so another way to refer to deficit spending is to call it net spending right because if the government spends 100 in and only taxes 90 out we call that a deficit but it masks what's happening on the other side if they put 100 in and only take 90 out somebody's getting 10. so on the other side of every government deficit lies a financial surplus equal and opposite in size right their red ink is our black ink their deficits are our financial surpluses which is why every deficit is good for someone the question is always for whom and for what right this 1.9 trillion dollar coveted relief package that just made it through the senate and well in all likelihood go to the president's desk and become uh law this 1.9 trillion coveted relief package is putting money into the hands of health care providers to help roll out vaccines it's putting 350 billion in for state and local governments to help shore up budgets there and prevent further job losses it's sending 1400 checks to most americans it's providing unemployment uh insurance support for people who are still unemployed and so forth and so on right that money is going into the hands of people who are really hurting in this economy counter that with the 1.9 trillion dollar tax cuts the republicans passed in december of 2017. these were both pieces of legislation that cost 1.9 trillion dollars but the republicans used the deficit to funnel a financial windfall mostly to people who are already doing really well in this economy so both 1.9 trillion packages produce financial surpluses on the other side but they went to very different groups of people in in our economy and so every deficit is good for someone question is for whom and for what purpose is the deficit being used are we doing infrastructure and education and health care and covert relief or are we doing you know tax breaks for corporations and people who frankly are already doing phenomenally well uh in this economy so yeah i mean when you think about taxes as a way to redistribute wealth and you look at america's you know income and wealth inequality has grown so much over the last century it really makes you realize that we've really messed up the taxation in this country because it's doing the exact opposite thing that it's uh that it's supposed to do yeah i mean you know we got sold a bill of goods right for our for 40 plus years really with this supply side and trickle down and this idea that you know the real job creators in the economy are the people at the very top and that you have to do everything you can to tickle their bellies and incentivize them and and treat them very very gently and kindly and if you do all the right things then they will rain down jobs and benefits to everybody else and you know we have done this we have run this experiment time after time after time reagan thatcher all across the world this isn't unique to the us right this supply side idea that tax cuts for the rich have um trickle-down effects and that you end up you know lifting everyone from the bottom the the evidence is in it it does not work and there are recent studies out a big one actually from i think a couple of economists at the london school of economics if i'm not mistaken and they have done a a very interesting study looking at the past 40 years 18 countries that have pursued supply-side trickle-down tax cut uh kind of policies and what they concluded is it's a colossal failure that in every instance it has not produced the benefits that it purported to produce and i i think that most of the people who pushed um this sort of supply side stuff knew all along that it doesn't generate those benefits but it was a marketing you know it's like you know the narrative was we do this for the job creators and it benefits everyone and for for many years and across many nations governments voted for these kinds of policies and you're right what they did was widen the inequities and not deliver uh the broader-based benefits that were promised yeah so much of this uh after reading the book it does feel like a you know marketing campaign to you know not only redistribute wealth but to limit that government spending and using this idea that we should all be worried about a growing national debt um as the as a rationale for for not spending on things that clearly our society needs so um why shouldn't we listen to anyone that's telling us to to be afraid about the the current size or increasing the america's national debt okay so now we're shifting to the the debt right because you know and you're right you know these uh these people who push tax cuts tax cuts tax cuts as always and everywhere the right policy move no matter what the situation is tax cuts are the are the solution right whatever problem we face cut taxes uh and that will fix things and so we do this republicans do this in particular conservative governments tend to do this and then you get an increase in the deficit because the tax cuts don't deliver the growth that then delivers higher revenues that then make the tax cuts pay for themselves as they like to say so what you're left with are larger deficits that increase the national debt and then republicans will turn around when they're no longer in office and say to democrats you can't spend any money now because look at that huge debt right and then democrats say oh my god usually you're right you know they'll say something like you're right we have this huge fiscal crisis uh but you did it right so then it becomes uh the blame game is over who caused the problem and so what i try to do in the book is to just you know fundamentally question the premise is there really a problem are we facing a long-term fiscal uh problem and my answer is no that there is not evidence that we here in the u.s or many other major countries that have long believed that they face a looming fiscal crisis that's just simply not true and you know both democrats and republicans for the most part accept the premise they say we have a long-term fiscal crisis and they disagree about what to do about it and who caused it right there's a lot of finger pointing and the blame game uh and then they point to different culprits so for example you know if your listeners are interested i i would suggest googling um you can google the name jason furman or even janet yellen because they both signed their names to an op-ed just a few years ago two and a half three years ago maybe the op-ed ran in the washington post and the op-ed was titled a debt crisis is coming but don't blame entitlements in other words don't blame social security and medicare medicaid uh but a debt crisis is coming and they this was an op-ed signed on to by five former heads of the council of economic advisers the president's council of economic advisors including jenna yellen right the current treasury secretary former fed chair uh and other obama advisers and so forth so five of them put their name on this thing a debt crisis is coming but don't you republicans blame entitlements they're only part of the problem and they were writing in response to an op-ed also published in the washington post written by five conservative i believe all economists um from the hoover institution and the five conservatives from hoover said a debt crisis is coming it's mainly entitlements and we have to cut social security and medicare to fix the problem so what i'm saying is that for a very very long time economists on the left and the right democrats republicans we call them fiscal hawks the conservatives and fiscal doves the democrats they have all agreed that yes we're in trouble we're in trouble but they disagree over how we got in trouble and what to do about it and democrats say mostly we don't tax enough and you guys start too many wars and don't pay for them so this is how the disagreement goes so to your question now you know how do i deal with this in the book i look at the national debt so-called very differently and in fact i titled the chapter the national debt and in parentheses that isn't it's a national debt that isn't so what is this thing that we refer to as the national debt that we talk about as uh representing a real burden on our futures this is the thing we're leaving to our children and our grandchildren this is what they inherit this is what's going to make their lives harder uh and and less prosperous in the future because we've handed them these these shackles and now they're responsible for paying off this debt so i don't look at it like that at all here's how i look at it um the government as i said before chooses chooses to sell government bonds securities known as u.s treasuries in this country some are short-term some are longer term government treasury sells these things how do they sell them and why what happens when they do that so the government is matching its deficit spending by offering u.s treasury so whenever the government's budget is in deficit an equivalent amount of government debt bonds are sold so let's do the numbers the government spends a hundred dollars into the economy it only taxes ninety dollars back out it has run a deficit it's placed ten dollars in the system as it runs a deficit it sells government bonds so now it's got 10 government bonds and it says who wants to buy these okay and what happens 10 comes back out of the economy and 10 treasuries go in what is a us treasury it's an interest bearing dollar it's an interest bearing dollar i took out a currency i took out a non-interest faring dollar i replaced it with an interest bearing dollar i didn't have to do it and the person who got it is pretty lucky because they have a risk-free asset it's a very safe risk-free government bond that pays them interest while they take no risk it's a subsidy right it's it's a way to subsidize people who already have money you let them give you some of their cash and you replace it with interest bearing cash it's a pretty sweet deal the problem is that we refer to the outstanding stock of u.s treasuries as the national debt instead of calling it part of the u.s money supply or u.s wealth and savings right those treasuries are part of somebody's accumulated savings and wealth they're not on the hook for that it's not their liability it's their asset so you know we don't have a debt problem we don't have a deficit problem we have a communications problem and and which is the the language that we choose to use government borrowing debt those are words that are appropriate if we're talking about household budget but they're inapplicable once we move to the currency issuer and start talking about what what is happening at that level so then what should policymakers be thinking about when they're deciding you know how much money to put into the economy this year is there something that they should be concerned about if not the debt something else that could that should constrain how much we spend well look i mean i wouldn't ask i wouldn't approach the question in terms of how much money should we put in to the economy i try to say you know in the book i say the goal is not to achieve any particular budget balance the goal is to achieve a healthy balanced economy so what does that look like so you know i want to i have a chapter in the book chapter seven is called the deficits that matter so in that chapter i talk about climate i talk about infrastructure i talk about education and healthcare and other you know uh shortfalls deficiencies the real deficits in our economy and the way that i would approach the budgeting process is to identify those deficits right to figure out what problems are we trying to solve and how do we fit the budget to the problem so if we're trying to deal with climate change if we're trying to deal with you know uh infrastructure that is poorly managed and outdated and and so forth how much would we need to invest to bring our infrastructure grade up from a c or whatever it currently is c plus to let's say a b plus or an a minus over time this covert relief package i'll keep coming back to it because it serves as a good example in so many ways the covert relief package is going to lift half of all the kids who today are in poverty will be lifted out of poverty as a result of some of the things that are being done in that covid relief package right if we can lift half of the kids out of poverty what about the other half you know what i mean so for me it's about you know figuring out what problems you want to solve and then fitting the budget to address those problems and there's not a right number out there lurking what there is is uh you know a limited um array of resources that you can tap to solve real problems if you want to make public colleges and universities tuition free for everybody in this country what you need are enough faculty right you need graduate students you need structures so that people can sit in classrooms and get to universities and colleges and so forth so you need to be able to deliver on that promise in real terms and so the question is how do you resource that right and and that's how i think about the federal budgeting process the dollars are the easy part to figure out managing inflationary pressures and working within the constraints that you face because resources aren't aren't infinite they're finite and you do have to budget your priorities and you do have to make choices so you know it's about prioritizing budgets are moral documents but they also force us to prioritize and to make choices you mentioned man managing inflationary pressures how do we know when we're we're approaching too high inflation levels well we don't necessarily know um we can take the economy's temperature in different ways look i i don't think that anybody is talking about sitting down and starting from scratch from zero imagine building out a five trillion dollar federal government budget so much of the federal government's budget is locked in place right it is mandatory spending non-discretionary the vast majority of the dollars that the federal government spends on an annual basis you can't play with their social security their medicare right their uh interest payments on the so-called national debt and so forth the discretionary budget is pretty small so when we talk about making changes to spending discretionary more spending on infrastructure education health care that sort of thing then i think actually it gets easier to answer your question about you know the marginal dollar the next dollar spent are we at greater risk of inflation accelerating if we put another you know 50 billion in pell grants that's probably a very straightforward and and safe calculation right but if we were to move to if we were to do four trillion dollar uh infrastructure climate package would that uh invite greater inflationary pressures and then you have to really drill down right you have to say well what is it we're going to try to do with that infrastructure climate package oh we're going to try to build high-speed rail and we're going to do solar and we're going to do broadband and we're going to do energy you know and then you have to start going deeper and deeper and deeper to say what are the resource needs to do that high-speed rail and how quickly do you want to build it and what about the broadband and how quickly and then you say do we have companies that are uh you know equipped to supply us with cranes and concrete trucks and machines and the things we need or if i pick up the phone and call caterpillar and i say could you fill an order for these things if i were to place an order do we have the steel do we have the machines they said no i have a huge backlot i couldn't get to that for another year at best that tells you right then that if you were to try to do that much spending the capacity constraint is binding that you know the resource capacity oh um i think you have to evaluate proposed new spending on you know a case-by-case basis and you have to look very closely at what it is you're proposing to spend over how long a period of time and then get a sense of whether um industries have capacity to meet those orders whether you have enough unemployed construction workers architects engineers can you mobilize the real resources that you would need to you know achieve what it is you're you're trying to achieve and if not you have to make choices right you can always wrestle the resources away from the private sector if if there's you know construction workers are being used to build residential housing for example and you don't have the people that you would need for a large-scale climate infrastructure program you could choose hey climate is is a priority and we're going to take workers away we'll bid them away you can do that right now that's going to create some inflationary pressures and at that point it it becomes a decision about you know how much inflation do you think that would likely um create additional inflationary pressure and do you think it's worth it for the sake of getting those resources to you know away from building whatever it is they're currently building to doing climate and related we've talked a lot about fiscal policy to this point but there's a flip side that there's a monetary policy and we know that you know the way that the fed rains in inflation or forecasted inflation is by increasing interest rates and when you have higher interest rates businesses aren't able to borrow as much and they aren't able to spend as much and we also know that we need this mix of private and public investment in new climate solutions but you argue and the deficit myth that government you know government spending government deficits will not lead to a decrease in private investment so can you explain why that why that is well i don't rule out the possibility in fact i just gave you an example of how government spending could crowd out elbow out some uh private sector endeavors and i was giving an example of how it could be done quite deliberately uh but this question about interest rates so you know um the usual argument in economics and one that i attempt to debunk in that chapter that you're referring to is the idea that when the government runs a deficit it has to go out and find the money to cover the shortfall so it goes to savers and they've got dollars and the government says i want some of those dollars because i need to finance my deficit and the textbook story is that now there are fewer dollars left and available to the private sector for their endeavors so as you said businesses when the supply of available funds shrinks then the cost of those funds goes up so the government deficit is driving the interest rate up and you're saying well if interest rates go up then businesses can't afford to borrow and so some private investment doesn't get undertaken and that could and that's what economists refer to as crowding out that the government's deficit crowds out private sector spending and leads to slower growth over time because the private sector is assumed to be more efficient and their investments would have uh you know enhanced productivity and growth whereas government spending less efficient all that stuff so but in the book i say listen what about the possibility that instead of crowding out private sector investments government deficits actually crowd in private sector spending and investment sure that happens think about it so when government is running a deficit and putting income into people's hands we're seeing it again i'll come back to the cove relief package fourteen hundred dollars going to almost every uh person in this country right uh and and the other uh money as well what are people gonna do well a lot of people are gonna turn around and spend dollars those dollars back into the economy and what happens now you've created demand now you're a customer for some business what do businesses do when they're swamped with customers they hire more people right you don't fire the bus boy if the line to get in your restaurant is wrapped around the building and so businesses will hire and invest when they're swamped with customers and so it's easy to i think to see and understand how government spending puts income into our hands that then allows us to be good consumers right to have robust consumption that then encourages businesses because they see their sales and their revenues and their profits going up to say i gotta invest in some new equipment i gotta hire uh some additional workers right and so that's what i mean by by crowding in but it's not that only crowding in is possible it's just that the usual narrative about deficits are bad because they push up interest rates and rising interest rates leads to less investment and less investment leads to lower growth that i think is very wrong so when i read that or when i read the deficit myth and i talked to you now this all seems perfectly clear like this is the you know you talk about the moment of you know clarity uh that people have when this kind of clicks and it's clicked with me because you've explained it so well but why do you think i mean we we just don't hear it talked about this way by politicians and definitely not in the media um why do you think it is it continues to be framed as the national debt is a is a problem for for the for america well listen it you i had a colleague back at my previous university his name's bill black he's a law and economics professor and bill used to you used to refer to these things as uh career limiting gestures he would talk about bill was a white-collar criminologist okay so he went after a prosecuted white-collar crime uh and there are certain things that when you do them or say them uh they do limit your career potential and so he coined this phrase career limiting gestures uh you know it is very hard to take a narrative that is a significant departure from the norm and you know you're sticking your neck out you're going against the mainstream orthodox views on these things you're rebutting people with very fancy degrees from very fancy universities sometimes nobel prizes and so forth and then what you're going to stand up and make the counter argument that we shouldn't be hysterical about the long-term trajectory of the debt to gdp ratio or something and you want to try to soothe and calm and people will point to all the expertise and say oh so they're all wrong right are they all wrong well there aren't a lot of people in you know journalists or other academics who i think are prepared to risk it's a career limiting gesture you know you you are risking uh to some extent your credibility in the eyes of those who decide who's credible and who isn't so it's a it's getting easier i will say it's getting easier and i think part of the reason it's getting easier is because all of the chicken littles remember the fiscal hawks and the fiscal doves have been telling us for decades that a debt crisis coming attack crisis i just referred to the washington post piece all these top economists all saying a debt crisis is coming they said it 10 years ago they said it five years ago they said it three years ago they said it 20 years ago and it never happens and at some point the credibility i think theirs begins to be compromised because why do you keep telling us that all these terrible things are going to happen because of deficits and debt they don't happen and now we're watching you folks in real time change your own stories to try to fit the the empirics which are that interest rates have gone down not up as deficits exploded and the debt went up you know all the stuff that you warned about high inflation and so forth it just the reality is the opposite has happened in almost every case so you're seeing a lot of people softly uh soften their own narrative right they're trying to figure out how to distance themselves from their prior um statements about this stuff and and i think we're getting we're making progress definitely some progress but then you go back and listen to you know the media commentator media commentators on this coven stimulus bill this 1.9 trillion dollar code stimulus mill a lot of people are complaining about how this is going to increase further increase the national debt and i think we're going to continue to hear this or or even worse as president biden puts forward his you know multi-trillion dollar climate bill are you concerned that democrats not republicans democrats are going to give in to fears about further increasing the the debt and not vote for an appropriately sized climate bill and if so how do we convince them otherwise you bet i'm concerned i'm deeply concerned we got 50 uh 50 votes in the senate uh and you can't lose a single one and um you know yeah i'm concerned i saw a comment just this morning i guess senator manchin did an interview i think with uh like axios hbo or something like that and he said he's very excited about what comes next after the covet relief comes the next big package he said oh i'm super excited about it i've been wanting to do infrastructure for a long time i think that you know i'm i don't want to get rid of the filibuster i think we can get 60 votes on this stuff i think we can probably get 4 trillion 4 trillion uh but we got to pay for it all we 100 of it we can we can pay for now it doesn't pass the laugh test it just doesn't the the reality is i'm sorry but you're never going to get 60 votes that means 10 republicans would have to if all the democrats voted for it you'd need 10 republicans and you're gonna propose um four trillion or so in spending on infrastructure and infrastructure related investments and you want to fully offset it with new revenue you're find me 10 republicans who are going to vote for all those tax increases they don't exist and by the way i don't think that you can find 50 democrats who will vote for the tax increases to fully offset 4 trillion so am i worried yes i'm i'm quite worried how do we get them to pass something well you ain't going to get there with 60 votes that's not a reality so you're going to do it if it's going to be done at all through reconciliation which is the same process that was just used to move the coveted relief 1.9 trillion you use exactly the same uh process budget reconciliation um you can do it without offsetting all the spending which means you you could just commit the spending you could offset some of it maybe none of it uh we didn't offset anything from march of last year to march of this year congress has just been doing multi-trillion dollar spending packages no offsets no quote-unquote pay fors no new taxes um how much more of that would they be willing to do and you know you just asked the million dollar or trillion dollar question right which is um how do you get congress to vote to pass these things if some people are starting to find their fiscal um hawkish their inner fiscal hawk is coming out right and you know i hear democrats i've heard uh house members say at some point you have to start paying for your spending you can't keep and this is what mmt is all about mmt is all about helping us to ask and answer the question you know whether and when and how to offset spending because as long as there's some low hanging fruit left and low hanging fruit means the government can safely spend into the economy without offsetting that spending by higher taxes or cuts to some other part of the budget you can just spend the dollars and the word safely is important right because the low-hanging fruit means that there's fiscal space it means that there is enough room in the budget to allow you not in the budget i shouldn't say it like that it means that there is enough slack in the economy that you can spend money in without creating inflationary problems so at some point that fiscal space starts to diminish and you have to know when you're running out of low hanging fruit and that's when the offsets become important but my god why pick an unnecessary fight you know if there's some low hanging fruit and you can come in on the back of this relief package and get a re recovery package in place where you you know you can commit the spending without picking the secondary fight which is the tax fight that's going to make it ten times harder to collect the votes you need to pass the legislation then you know why do that you saw this firsthand both as chief economist for the democrats and the senate budget committee but also as you were serving as senator bernie sanders economic adviser during his 2020 presidential run um obviously senator sanders is a huge progressive and proponent of government spending to make the lives of americans so much better but you know in the book that even he gets the deficit problem wrong when he tries to fund these programs by raising taxes i mean that's that's been a big part of his messaging did you see his thinking shift though on this um over your time you know with him working with him well not over my well look uh it has shifted i think that the evidence that it is that it has shifted is that he is now the chairman of the budget committee i was once the chief economist for the democrats on the u.s uh senate budget committee and he hired me for that position and you're right in the book i write about some of what uh you know i witnessed in 2015-16 and then on the presidential campaigns where let's be you know let's recognize that every democratic candidate tried to pay for their entire agenda there was enormous pressure to lay out a blueprint to say you wanted you want to do all of these things these are your policy proposals show me how you're going to pay for it a press would not have tolerated anything less so that was the game and everybody attempted to play it now however uh he is chairman of the senate budget committee and he just helped to usher through the reconciliation process this 1.9 trillion dollar package with no offsets so you know he didn't hold it up saying wait a minute the deficit we have to offset the spending we must pay for our things you know he didn't do that right so we're in a very different place today compared to the way that and and that's true of house democrats as well uh a lot has changed i think the trump tax cuts helped uh and when i say helped i mean helped shift democrats own thinking you know i used to i can remember going into more than one meeting with members of congress in just the last two years and sitting down and saying you know just kind of poking fun and saying are you yet tired of playing charlie brown to lucy in the football i mean every time they run the same play they get the republicans get the house and the senate and and the white house and the deficit concerns are out the window they pass their agenda if it adds to the deficit so be it they are laser focused on passing their agenda democrats come in and say oh we're the fiscally responsible party we hold ourselves to a different and we think higher standard we pay for our priorities and then whoop lucy in the football lucian you know and and so i kind of tease them a little bit and say are we are is we learning you know are we are we figuring this stuff out uh and the good news is that they are and that's so much of the thinking uh inside staffers and members of congress it's it has changed cove it helped change it a lot more good well senator sanders obviously a supporter of the green new deal and the green new deal calls for a federal jobs guarantee which i was really happy to see in your book that so does mmt so how would a federal jobs guarantee work and and what are some of the the potential environmental benefits yeah so a a federal job guarantee is what it sounds like right it is the federal government guaranteeing that anybody who wants to work but can't find a job anywhere else in the economy can always be assured a job right at a basic wage and benefit package so a living think of a living wage and benefit package um and so it is a standing job offer people hear about health care we hear about sometimes a public option in health care this is like a public option in the labor market right it's available to everyone it doesn't go away it's a standing offer if for any reason uh you should want to be in that program you can be in that program maybe you have an employer who constantly messes with your hours you don't know from one day to the next you know what days you're supposed to show up for work and what times when you're trying to arrange child care and it's just a nightmare and you're making minimum wage or whatever and you say i've had maybe i'm being harassed at work maybe you know for any reason you want into that program you have a job in that program federally funded locally administered so you ask about how it relates to climate what we imagine is that the jobs are oriented broadly around uh building a care economy so you're caring for people caring for planet caring for your community in one way or another all of the jobs should be oriented to do one of you know contribute in one of those three ways so you know your imagination is kind of the limit i write some about this in the book i co-authored a report a few years ago for the levy economics institute i think it was called guaranteed employment a pathway to full employment there are five or so of us authoring that we get into a lot of detail there about the kinds of jobs and another mmt economist named pavlina chernova has a book that came out around the same time as my book hers is called the case for a federal job guarantee so i just want to point those out because people who want more than i can do in a short time here might find it interesting but you know the communities themselves they decide on the kinds of jobs that they want performed um you know you you think about pavlina will sometimes talk about uh invasive species and you know if some people could be responsible for monitoring invasive species and why is that of benefit well because farmers crops feed the rest of us and if they are struggling uh with invasive species and that sort of thing climate you know tree planting we can think of of a million and one different things that people might propose that are valuable that would be valuable to the community that help us shore up uh coastal lines clean up environmental cleanup community gardens you can have neighborhood beautification projects and the really the sky is is sort of the limit performing the the arts you know when fdr was president and he uh had a huge unemployment problem on his hands and he came up with a similar idea and he said we should just directly put people to work we should employ them and so we got an alphabet soup of jobs programs we got the works progress administration the civilian conservation corps the national youth administration a jobs program for young people um the ccc was mostly environmental uh oriented around environmental concerns but workers in the wpa uh program did everything from building and construction oriented things to uh oral histories recording oral histories uh performance art street performances theater you know i mean it was you can be very very inclusive and the idea is to take people as they are and where they are right and to fit the job to the person with two of the i'd say most talked about solutions to decarbonizing our electric electricity grid uh that have been put forth are a federal clean energy standard and a price on carbon um these solutions either you know require a reward they either reward utilities uh for for decarbonizing or they require them to do it um by switching over from these fossil fuel burning assets to clean energy assets right but you write in the deficit myth that both of these solutions have flaws clean energy standard may place a higher cost burden on ratepayers and carbon price may not push utilities to act fast enough so how does what would the mmt approach be to a you know to the federal government solving this electricity decarbonization problem well look i i'm not an environmental economist so i you know i point to some things in the book you just read a passage there um but i do try to stay in my lane i'm not trying to offer a solution or a set of solutions that are direct pathways to getting us to where we need to be on climate i uh definitely defer to climate experts in this space and you know i've done a number of talks on uh the green new deal and that sort of thing but my area of expertise is on the mechanics of the financing so where i can be helpful i think is in reminding folks that it's about our real resources that if we have the technological know-how and we have the real resources the money can always be made available and i think you know time is of the essence and so where so often we want to go slower than we need to go proceed at a slower pace more incremental and so forth is because of the budgetary concerns and so again you know i where my area of expertise can be helpful in pushing us to where i hope we will go is with a bold ambitious action plan to you know uh hold carbon emissions to keep us within our carbon budget to uh do the sort of things that climate experts tell us we need to do and i can help you know lay out the the economic argument for why we can afford to move much more quickly that it's the the real challenge is managing the inflationary pressures yeah you mentioned the carbon budget i mean we have real natural constraints i mean the carbon budget the amount of natural resources that we can extract before you know they no longer able to regenerate themselves do you think that there's a responsibility among other economists to recommend policy that that reflects these real natural constraints and talk in these terms ?

 

Kelton:52:26

yes and fortunately there are many good ones out there i mean you know kate raw worth uh mariana matsukato both of friends of mine kate with um you know the donut economics is a book that has i think had a tremendous impact and influences policy making around the world you know you've got cities and nations committing to trying to you know operate within the safe part of what she calls the donut right not pushing beyond the boundaries and also not uh doing things that would so deprive you of a good life but to keep you in that in that safe place mariano with her you know mission economy and the entrepreneurial state um naomi klein steve keane i mean naomi's not an economist obviously but you know has done a lot of work here as an academic as well steve keane an economist who has really taken apart the nord house uh nobel prize-winning economists work on uh climate and and so forth and and steve does great work and there are so many others and yes it's incumbent upon us because for better or worse and it's usually i'm afraid to say for worse economists have an outsized voice in the public debates they do you know you will listen to a president they don't often stand up and say well leading sociologists tell us or leading anthropologists say it's always what economists are telling us you know economists are saying so we enjoy um this you know status of somehow being the ones who are supposed to know and provide you know the proper guidance to policymakers and so forth so yes it's important for economists to to do the work to step up to help push policy thinking in that ambitious direction to to allow leaders to see that you know things are achievable because so much of what they're presented with from economists is what you can't do it's why you can't do things it's you know the cost benefit analysis say no or the cbo report says no or this says no and you need people who are willing and able to step forward and push back against those dominant themes that well interest rates are going to prevent it or markets will prevent it or investors won't allow it or something you got to be able to demonstrate why those arguments are are flawed.

 

T:

 we talked earlier about america being one of the few countries that has monetary sovereignty so does that give us you think that gives us an advantage when it comes to really being leaders on the global scale or on the global stage for climate policy well of course it does but the us is not one of i wouldn't say we're one of a few um you know i mentioned australia and canada new zealand the uk japan i mean there are a lot of countries actually and we can include europe as long as the ecb is a willing partner because the european central bank is the issuer of the currency that is where you know if you have an ecb willing to backstop in a sense to to coordinate with and to allow the 19 countries that compromise their sovereignty by giving up their currencies and adopting the euro if the ecb will um will work as a partner with those 19 countries then you can include you know europe uh as part of that and now and you know it's most of the the industrialized wealthy world and yes they have uh an important role to play and they need to step up and um and shoulder that their share of this burden going forward well the deficit myth really opened my eyes to what is possible and it really forced me to to not only question what i what i thought i knew about how our economy works but also just reframe how i think about fiscal policy overall and i i cannot recommend this book anymore i mean so if you're listening to this please go out and get the deficit myth it's available now and paperback and it really is an incredibly important book to read and understand and really use it as a tool in crafting a more sustainable and just future so dr kelton is is there anywhere else that our listeners can follow your work online or on social media well i'm on twitter uh that's about the only social media platform i understand and so it's the one i use uh and i i tweet under the um name just at stephanie kelton um i i will write periodically for the new york times and outlets like that i've got a piece coming out soon with the times um but the twitter feed is where i would share appearances in anything i write so well it is a fantastic book dr stephanie kelton thank you again for joining the climate pod thank you so much for having me you 1:21:15

 

ファニー・ケルトン博士と一緒に地球を救うために赤字の神話を暴く2021/04/22

https://theclimatepod.libsyn.com/debunking-the-deficit-myth-to-save-the-planet

2021年3月10日

 

今週、ステファニーケルトン博士がショーに参加し、アメリカの政治家が国の債務を完全に誤解している方法と、連邦政府が財政政策を利用して公正で持続可能な社会を構築する方法について話し合います。彼女の著書「TheDeficitMyth」は、現代貨幣理論を説明し、アメリカが気候変動の解決策だけに多額の費用をかけることができ、またそうしなければならない理由を示しています。    

赤字の神話を買う:現代の通貨理論と人々の経済の誕生 

新しいサブスタックニュースレター「 TheClimateWeekly 」を購読する:https:  //theclimateweekly.substack.com/ 

いつものように、 Twitterで@climatepodをフォローし、  theclimatepod @ gmail.comにメールを送信してください。私たちの音楽は ThePassionHifiの「GottaGetUp」です。thepassionhifi.comで彼の音楽をチェックしてください。iTunes、Spotify、  Stitcherなどで このポッドキャストを評価、レビュー、購読して ください!新しいYouTubeチャンネルに登録してください !Facebookグループに参加してください 。更新されたウェブサイトをチェックしてください !

 

 

 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/debunking-deficit-myth-to-help-save-planet-w-dr-stephanie/id1469270123?i=1000512372982


 

解説[音楽]

T:

ステファニー・ケルトン博士、気候ポッドへようこそ赤字の神話を読んだ後、私を元気にしてくれてありがとう。アメリカが大規模かつで気候危機に対処するための措置を本当に講じるなら、私は確信しています。必要なスピード私たちの政策立案者は現代貨幣理論の核となる信条を理解し、アメリカの債務と赤字に関する彼らの欠陥のある時代遅れの見解を本当に無視しなければならないので、これらすべての気候への影響を理解するために、私は最初に聴衆がmmtを理解するのを本当に助けたいと思いますですから、現代​​貨幣理論のコア原則をかなり高いレベルで要約できれば、

ケルトン:

mmtの目的は、ソブリン通貨がどのように機能するかを説明することです。我々'について話しているのは、ポリシーオプションです。ソブリン通貨を持っている国が利用できるとはどういう意味ですか?それは、自国通貨である通貨を発行する国を意味します。米国はドルを発行します。日本政府は円を発行します。英国政府はポンドを発行します。独自の通貨を発行する政府は、その通貨で課税するのと同じ通貨で支払いを受け取ります。債券を販売することを選択した場合に使用できるようにするために、誰からも自分の通貨を借りる必要はありません。これを政府と呼びます。借りることはオプションであり、彼らはまた、彼らが発行することを選択した債券に支払うことをいとわない金利を決定することができます。それは、政府が決して不足することのないものからいくつかのことが続くことを知っているということです。あなたができるお金」あなたとあなただけが発行するために作成する法的権限を持っているものが不足しているので、米国政府は決してお金を使い果たすことはありません、そしてそれは彼が就任したばかりの大統領だったときにバラクオバマが私たちに言ったことではありませんインタビューで、私たちが財政危機と大不況に見舞われた経済から車輪が外れていることを知っていると尋ねられました。彼はインタビューで、政府はどの時点で資金が不足しているのかと尋ねられました。今ではそうではなく、そうではありません。2010年にヨーロッパの多くの国が債務危機に巻き込まれているのを見て、ギリシャの人々が覚えているかもしれないような国の経験から、多くの間違った教訓を引き出しました。彼らが支払うことができなかったために借金を抱えていること、そして多くの人々があなたがそうなら聞くと言いました。sは注意していません次はギリシャのようになります間違ったギリシャはトラブルに巻き込まれませんスペインはトラブルに巻き込まれましたイタリアはトラブルに巻き込まれましたそして他のヨーロッパ諸国では​​彼らが発行しない通貨で借りていたのでギリシャは経済と通貨の連合に参加するためにドラグマをあきらめ、ユーロを使い始めました。それは政府が利用できる政策スペースの量に重要な影響を与えるため、通貨システムの性質に非常に細心の注意を払いたいと思います。政府がどのように予算を管理できるかについて話し始めることができます。政府は通貨発行者であるのに対し、そうでない国は通貨発行者であるという事実を反映する方法で支出能力を使用できます。ギリシャなどの通貨発行者は予算を異なる方法で管理する必要があるため、政府はあなたと同じように予算のバランスを取る必要があるというこれらの世帯の類似性を聞いています。私は日本のような通貨発行政府に適していない世帯のようです。または私たちまたは英国またはオーストラリアまたは他の多くの人が、私がソブリン通貨として説明したものを持っていない外貨で借りている国について話しているとき、それはあなたの出発点ですこれらの政府は、利用可能なものと独自の通貨で販売されているものの両方を購入する余裕があるので、

 T:

米国政府ができることを言うと、利用可能なものと米ドルで販売されているものを購入するために雇う余裕があります。それが判明しました」多くの、そして重要なことに、それはすべての失業労働を含みます。つまり、mmtは、失業は簡単に排除できるので、失業は常に政策の選択であると教えてくれます。これらの問題の多くは、なぜ私たちが税金を払っているのかを知っています。税金の目的は何ですか。理由はたくさんあるので、あなたが起源の話を知っているように、あなたが最初から通貨を始めたいかどうかについて話すことができます税金または税金のように機能するものは他の義務を罰金しますこれらは政府が歴史的に開始するために人口に通貨を導入した方法です通貨をゼロから上げるので、ここで非常に迅速な歴史の筆を想像することができます。たとえば、英国の場合、国が植民地化されたことを知っています。これらは植民地化された国です。土地とあなたは周りを見回します、そしてあなたはあなたが家に帰ることができないことをあなたが望んでいる多くのものを見つけます、そしてあなたはどうすればこれらの人々に彼らの本当のあなたが知っているリソースを私に与えることができるかよく考えます'mいくつかの非常に不快な方法があった後、不快な木のいくつかを隠す方法の1つは税金を課すことです。そうすれば、あなたは今や王冠の対象になっていると人々に聞いてください。それはどういう意味ですか?それは定期的に誰かがやって来て攻撃を集めることを意味しますそして私たちが探しているのはあなたが王冠へのあなたの義務をうまく解決することです私はどのように解決しますか税金まあ、あなたはいくつかの英国の通貨が必要になるでしょう、そしてそれはあなたが解決するために使うものです私は英国の通貨を持っていません私たちがあなたがしなければならないすべては私たちがそれらを売った後に私たちが持っているもののいくつかを生産することです私たちにとって私たちはそれらを購入することはあなたが州へのあなたの義務を解決するために必要な通貨をあなたに提供します今人々はあなたがあなたの税金を支払わないならあなたが納税義務を解決しないなら彼らはあなたを燃やすのでなぜ通貨の必要性を持っていますつまり、税法を施行し、施行することで、他の方法ではそれらの人々にとって価値のない通貨に価値を与えることで、税金が払拭されるということです。これは起源の話ですが、かつては金銭的でした。今日の私たちのようにシステムが稼働しているので、税金がその役割を果たすとは考えていませんが、政府が富と収入の分配に影響を与える方法として税金を考えることは依然として重要です。これで今それを見てください1。減税と効果的なリベートを含む9兆ドルの切望された救済パッケージであり、それは人々の手に正しい現金を注ぎ込む方法であり、高所得の個人に税金を押し上げることができる人々から現金を奪う方法でもあります富と収入の分配のバランスを取り直したいので、私はこれをやっているとよく言います。また、私たちから課税されるすべてのドルは、私たちが持っていない、できないドルです。したがって、経済の商品やサービスを追いかけるのに費やすので、税金は解放弁のようなものです。税金は私たちの手からドルを取り除くことによって圧力を和らげ、政府はインフレの問題を引き起こすことなく通貨の価値を維持するために経済にドルを使うことができます。彼らは彼らの支出を加算し、課税することによってドルを差し引くことができ、支出と課税を調整して、インフレ圧力を管理しているので、あなたがそれを課税することを考えるとき」s現在、政府は課税を通じて歳入を増やしており、そのようなあらゆる種類の連邦プログラムに費やしています。毎年、政府がそれよりも多くを費やすと赤字が発生するため、連邦政府がより多くを費やすと実際に何が起こるか与えられた年にそれがうまく戻るよりも多くのことが起こります最も重要で簡単なことは誰かがその通貨で終わるということです誰かがお金で終わるのであなたが赤字がちょうどこの誤解された概念であると知っているならそれはそれを持っています単語自体が本質的にあることを示唆しているので、この意味合いを持っています問題の赤字は、人々がすぐに赤字の悪い黒字を良い権利だと考える不足を意味しますが、政府が財政赤字を実行しているとき、それは単に彼らが主に課税によって差し引くよりも多くのドルを経済に費やしていることを意味します。赤字支出とは、それを純支出と呼ぶことです。政府が100を費やし、90を課税するだけの場合、それを赤字と呼びますが、100を投入し、誰かが10を取得するだけで、反対側で起こっていることを覆い隠します。 。したがって、すべての政府赤字の反対側には、同じサイズで反対のサイズの財政黒字があります。彼らの赤字は私たちの黒インクです。彼らの赤字は私たちの財政黒字です。これは何が正しいか1。上院を通過したばかりの9兆ドルの切望された救済パッケージは、おそらく大統領の机に行き、法律になります。この1.9兆ドルの切望された救済パッケージは、医療提供者の手にお金を入れて、それが置いているワクチンの展開を支援しています州政府と地方政府がそこでの予算を支え、さらなる失業を防ぐために3500億ドルを費やし、ほとんどのアメリカ人に1400の小切手を送り、失業を提供しています。この経済で本当に傷ついている人々の手は、1.9兆ドルの減税で、共和党員が2017年12月に可決したことに対抗します。これらは両方とも1の費用がかかる法律の一部でした。9兆ドルですが、共和党は赤字を利用して、主にこの経済ですでに非常にうまくやっている人々に財政的急落を注ぎ込んだので、1.9兆のパッケージは両方とも反対側で財政的黒字を生み出しますが、彼らは私たちの中で非常に異なる人々のグループに行きました経済とだからすべての赤字は誰かにとって良い質問は誰のためにそしてどのような目的で赤字が使われているのか私たちはインフラストラクチャと教育とヘルスケアと秘密の救済を行っていますかこの経済では驚異的な成果を上げているので、税金を富の再分配の方法として考え、アメリカを見ると、前世紀に所得と富の不平等が非常に大きくなっていることがわかります。この国の課税を本当に台無しにしたのは、それがそうなるはずだというのとは正反対のことをしているからです。つまり、この供給サイドとトリクルで、40年以上にわたって私たちにぴったりの商品の請求書を販売したことを知っているということです。経済の本当の雇用創出者は一番上の人々であり、彼らの腹をくすぐり、彼らにインセンティブを与え、そして彼らを非常に優しくそして親切に扱うためにあなたができるすべてのことをしなければならないというこの考えすべての正しいことをすれば、彼らは仕事と利益を他のすべての人に降らせるでしょう、そしてあなたは私たちがこれをしたことを知っています私たちはこの実験を何度も何度も実行しました富裕層の減税にはトリクルダウン効果があり、最終的にはすべての人を下から持ち上げることができるというこの供給サイドの考えは、私たちに固有のものです。証拠は機能せず、最近の研究があります。私が間違っていなければ、ロンドン・スクール・オブ・エコノミクスのエコノミストのカップルが、過去40年間、サプライサイドのトリクルダウン減税を追求してきた18か国を見て非常に興味深い研究を行ったと思います。ええと、ある種の政策と彼らが結論付けたのは、すべての場合において、それが生み出すと主張した利益を生み出していないというのは巨大な失敗であり、iiこの種の供給サイドのものを押したほとんどの人々はそれをずっと知っていたと思いますそれらの利益を生み出しませんが、それはあなたがそれを知っているマーケティングでした」ご存知のように、私たちは雇用創出者のためにこれを行っており、それはすべての人に利益をもたらし、長年にわたって多くの国で政府がこの種の政策に投票しました。この本を読んだ後、この多くのことを約束されたより広範な利益は、あなたが知っているマーケティングキャンペーンが富を再分配するだけでなく、その政府支出を制限し、私たち全員が心配すべきであるというこの考えを使用することを知っているように感じます明らかに私たちの社会が必要としているものに支出しない理由として、国債の増加について、現在の規模を恐れたり、アメリカの国債を増やしたりすることを恐れるように言っている人の話を聞いてはいけません。さて、今私たちはあなたが知っている、そしてあなたが正しいので、あなたはこれらのええと、減税を推進するこれらの人々がいつものように減税を押し、そしてどこでも正しい政策がどのような状況であっても正しい政策が動くので、借金の権利に再びシフトすることが解決策です私たちが直面している問題が何であれ、減税は問題を解決するので、私たちはこの共和党員がこれを行います。特に保守的な政府はこれを行う傾向があり、減税はその時の成長をもたらさないため、赤字が増加します。彼らが言うように減税が彼ら自身のために支払うようにするより高い収入を提供するので、あなたが残しているのは国債を増やすより大きな赤字であり、そして共和党員は彼らがもはや在職していないときに向きを変えて民主党員に言いますあなたはできる'その巨額の借金を正しく見て、民主党員が「ああ、私の神は通常あなたが正しい」と言うので、今はお金を使いません。誰が問題を引き起こしたのかは責任ゲームが終わったので、私が本でやろうとしていることは、基本的にあなたが前提を疑問視することです。本当に問題があるのか​​、長期的な財政問題に直面しているのか、私の答えはいいえ、私たちがここ米国や他の多くの主要国で、迫り来る財政危機に直面していると長い間信じてきたという証拠はありません。それは単に真実ではなく、民主党と共和党の両方がほとんどの場合、私たちが言う前提を受け入れていることを知っています長期的な財政危機があり、彼らはそれをどうするか、そして誰がそれをその場で引き起こしたかについて意見が分かれています。たくさんの指差しと非難ゲームええと、彼らは別の犯人を指しています。たとえば、リスナーが興味を持っているかどうかを知っているので、グーグルを提案します。ジェイソン・ファーマン、さらにはジャネット・イエレンという名前をグーグルで検索できます。ほんの数年前の論説2年半3年前、おそらく論説はワシントンのポストで実行され、論説は債務危機が来ているというタイトルでしたが、資格を非難しないでください。社会保障とメディケアメディケイドを非難するが、債務危機が来ており、これは大統領経済諮問委員会の5人の元首長によって署名された論説であった。ジェナ・イエレンを含む経済諮問委員会は、現在の財務長官の元連邦準備制度理事会や他のオバマ顧問などを右に置いているので、5人は債務危機が来ていることについて彼らの名前を付けましたが、共和党は彼らの資格を非難しませんか問題の一部に過ぎず、5人の保守派が書いたワシントンの投稿にも掲載されたオバマに応えて書いていた私はフーバー機関のすべてのエコノミストとフーバーの5人の保守派が債務危機が来ていると言ったそして私たちは問題を解決するために社会保障とメディケアを削減しなければならないので私はm言っているのは、非常に長い間、左派と右派の民主党共和党員は、彼らを財政ホーク保守派と財政ハトと呼んでいるということです。私たちがどのように問題を抱え、それをどうするかについて、そして民主党員はほとんど私たちが十分に課税しておらず、あなたたちはあまりにも多くの戦争を始めて彼らにお金を払っていないと言います。私は本の中でこれをどのように扱うのですか?私はいわゆる国債を非常に異なって見ています、そして実際私は章に国債と題し、括弧内にそれはそうではない国債ではありませんそれで、私たちが国債と呼んでいるこのことは、私たちの未来への本当の負担を表していると私たちが話しているのです。これは私たちが子供たちと孫たちに残しているものです。これは彼らが受け継いでいるものですこれは起こっていることです私たちがこれらの束縛を彼らに手渡したので、彼らの生活をより困難にし、将来的に繁栄させるために、そして今、彼らはこの借金を返済する責任があるので、私はそれをまったく見ていませんここに私が見る方法があります前に言ったように、政府はこの国で私たちの国債として知られている国債を売却することを選択します。短期的なものもあれば、長期的なものもあります。政府はこれらのものをどのように販売し、なぜそうするとどうなるのでしょうか。政府はuを提供することによってその赤字支出と一致しています。s財務省なので、政府の予算が不足しているときはいつでも、同額の国債が売られているので、政府が経済に100ドルを費やし、90ドルしか課税せず、10ドルの赤字を出している数字を見てみましょう。不足しているシステムは国債を販売しているので、今では10の国債があり、誰がこれらを購入したいかを示しています。10は経済から戻ってきて、10の財務省は米国の財務省になります。ベアリングドルそれは利子付きドルです私は通貨を取り出しました私は無利子の運賃ドルを取り出しました私はそれを利子付きドルに置き換えました私はそれをする必要はありませんでしたそしてそれを手に入れた人は彼らが持っているのでかなり幸運ですリスクのない資産それ」非常に安全なリスクのない国債で、リスクを冒さずに利子を支払うのは助成金です。すでにお金を持っている人に助成金を支給する方法です。現金の一部を渡して、利子付きの現金に置き換えます。問題は、米国債の発行済み株式を、米国債や米国債の一部と呼ぶのではなく、国債と呼ぶことです。これらの国債は、誰かが蓄積した貯蓄と富の一部です。それは彼らの責任ではなく、彼らの資産であるため、私たちには債務問題がないことを知っています。赤字の問題があり、通信の問題があります。これは、政府の借入債務を使用するために選択する言語です。これらは、家計について話している場合は適切ですが、通貨に移行すると適用されなくなります。発行者とそのレベルで何が起こっているかについて話し始めるので、今年の経済にどれだけのお金を投入するかを知っていると決定するときに政策立案者は何を考えるべきですか?私たちがよく使う金額を制約する可能性のある他の何か私は私がそうしないと尋ねないことを意味します経済にどれだけのお金を投入すべきかという観点から質問にアプローチします。本の中であなたが知っていると言いたいのですが、目標は特定の予算バランスを達成することではなく、健全なバランスの取れた経済を達成することです。そのように見えるので、私は本の第7章に章を持ちたいと思っています。それは重要な赤字と呼ばれているので、その章では、気候について話します。インフラストラクチャについて話します。教育とヘルスケアについて話します。私たちの経済の本当の赤字と私が予算編成プロセスに取り組む方法は、私たちが解決しようとしている問題と、問題に予算をどのように適合させるかを理解する権利を特定することです。私たちが管理が不十分で時代遅れのインフラストラクチャなどに対処しようとすると、インフラストラクチャのグレードをacから、または現在cプラス、たとえばabプラスまたはマイナスにアップグレードするためにどれだけの投資が必要になるかなどがわかります。時間が経つにつれて、この秘密の救済パッケージは、今日貧困にあるすべての子供たちの半分を持ち上げる多くの点で良い例として役立つので、私はそれに戻ってきます。子供たちの半分を貧困から救うことができれば、そのcovid救済パッケージで行われているいくつかのことの結果あなたは私が何を意味するのか知っているので、私にとってはあなたがあなたの問題を理解していることですそれらの問題に対処するために解決してから予算を調整したいのですが、この国のすべての人に公立の大学の授業料を無料にしたい場合は、実際の問題を解決するために利用できるリソースの数が限られていることを知っています。必要なもので十分です。教員の権利には大学院生が必要です人々が教室に座って大学や大学などに行くことができるように構造が必要ですそのためあなたはその約束を実際に果たすことができる必要がありますそして問題はあなたがその権利をどのようにリソースするかですそして、それが私が連邦予算プロセスについて考える方法です。ドルは、インフレ圧力を管理し、リソースが無限ではないために直面​​する制約の範囲内で作業することを理解するのに簡単な部分です。有限であり、あなたはあなたの優先順位を予算化する必要があり、あなたはそれが道徳的な文書である予算を優先することについて知っているようにあなたは選択をしなければなりませんが、彼らはまた私たちに優先順位を付けさせ、あなたが言及した選択をすることを強制します「私たちは高すぎるインフレレベルに近づいていますか?私たちは必ずしも経済の温度をさまざまな方法でとることができるかどうかわかりませんii誰もが座ってゼロから始めることについて話しているとは思わない5兆ドルの連邦政府の予算は、連邦政府の予算の大部分が適切に固定されているため、連邦政府が毎年費やすことができるドルの大部分を非裁量で支出することが義務付けられています。彼らの社会保障と遊ぶ彼らのメディケアは、いわゆる国債などに対する彼らの利子の支払いはかなり小さいので、私たちが裁量的支出に変更を加えることについて話すとき、インフラ教育ヘルスケアへのより多くの支出そのようなものそれなら、実際には、次のドルが費やす限界ドルがインフレが加速するリスクが高いことを知っているというあなたの質問に答えるのが簡単になると思います。しかし、もし私たちが4兆ドルのインフラストラクチャー気候パッケージを実行することに移行したとしたら、それはより大きなインフレ圧力を招き、それからあなたは本当にドリルダウンしなければなりません。そのインフラストラクチャの気候パッケージを試してみようと思います。高速鉄道を建設しようとしています。ソーラーを使用し、ブロードバンドを使用し、ご存知のエネルギーを使用します。次に、高速鉄道を実現するために必要なリソースと、それを構築する速度、ブロードバンドについて、そしてどのくらいの速さであるかを言うために、どんどん深くなっていく必要があります。クレーンやコンクリートのトラックや機械など、必要なものを私たちに提供する設備が整っていることを知っている会社、または電話をかけてキャタピラーに電話した場合、注文する場合はこれらのものを注文できますか?私たちは鋼を持っていますか私たちは彼らが言った機械を持っていますか私は私ができなかった巨大なバックロットを持っていますせいぜいもう1年間は、その時点で、容量の制約が拘束力を持っていることを示しています。リソース容量を知っていることを知っています。提案された新しい支出を評価する必要があると思います。ケースバイケースで、あなたはあなたがどのくらいの期間にわたって費やすと提案しているのかを非常に綿密に調べて、それからあなたが十分であるかどうかにかかわらず、um産業がそれらの注文を満たす能力を持っているかどうかの感覚を得る必要があります失業者の建設労働者建築家エンジニアは、あなたが達成しようとしていることを達成するために必要な実際のリソースを動員することができます。そうでない場合は、正しい選択をする必要がない場合は、いつでもプライベートからリソースを奪うことができますある場合はセクターたとえば、建設労働者が住宅の建設に使用されていることを知っていて、大規模な気候インフラストラクチャプログラムに必要な人員がいないことを知っています。離れた労働者たちに入札しますあなたは今それをすることができますそれはいくつかのインフレ圧力を生み出すでしょうそしてその時点であなたはあなたがどれだけのインフレを生み出すと思うかを知っているという決定になりますそれらのリソースを、現在構築しているものを構築することから離れて、気候を実行するために知ってもらうために価値があると思います。これまで財政政策について多くのことを話しましたが、そこには裏返しがあります。金融政策と私たちはあなたがインフレまたは予測されるインフレの供給された雨が金利を上げることによる方法を知っていることを知っていますそしてあなたがより高い金利を持っているとき企業は多くを借りることができずそして彼らは多くのこと、そして私たちは新しい気候ソリューションへの民間投資と公的投資のこの組み合わせが必要であることも知っていますが、あなたは政府が政府の赤字を支出することは民間投資の減少につながらないことを知っているという赤字の神話を主張します。それはよく私はしません」実際、可能性を排除するために、政府支出が民間部門の取り組みを圧倒する方法の例を示しました。それを非常に慎重に行う方法の例を示しましたが、金利についてのこの質問はあなたに経済学の通常の議論を知っていて、あなたが言及しているその章で私が非難しようとしているのは、政府が赤字を出しているとき、それは出て行き、不足を補うためのお金を見つけなければならないという考えです。セーバーと彼らはドルを持っていて、政府は私が赤字を賄う必要があるのでそれらのドルのいくつかが欲しいと言います、そして教科書の話はあなたが利用可能な資金が減少すると、それらの資金のコストが上昇するため、政府の赤字が金利を押し上げます。金利が上昇すると、企業は借りることができず、一部の民間投資が行われないとよく言われます。そしてそれは可能であり、それはエコノミストが政府の混雑と呼んでいるものです」s赤字は民間部門の支出を圧倒し、時間の経過とともに成長の鈍化につながります。民間部門はより効率的であると想定されており、その投資は生産性と成長の向上を知っているはずですが、政府支出はそれらすべての効率が低いので、本では民間部門の投資を混雑させる代わりに、政府の赤字が実際に民間部門の支出と投資に集中する可能性について聞いてください。政府が赤字を出し、人々の手に収入を与えているとき、私たちは再びそれを見ています。 '入り江の救済パッケージに戻ってきます1400ドルはこの国のほぼすべてのええと人に行きますええと他のええとお金も同様に人々はうまくいくでしょう多くの人々は振り返ってそれらのドルを使うつもりです経済に参入し、今何が起こっているのかあなたは需要を生み出しましたあなたはいくつかのビジネスの顧客です彼らが顧客でいっぱいになったときにビジネスは何をしますか彼らはより多くの人を雇いますあなたのレストランは建物の周りを包んでいるので、企業は顧客でいっぱいになったときに雇って投資するでしょう。政府支出がどのように収入を私たちの手に渡しているかを見て理解するのは簡単だと思います。それにより、私たちは良い消費者になる権利があり、それは彼らの売上と収入と利益が上がるのを見てビジネスを奨励します。いくつかの新しい機器に投​​資しなければならない私はいくつかの追加の労働者を正しく雇わなければならないので、それは私が混雑することによって意味することですが、混雑することだけが可能であるというわけではありません」ただ、赤字についての通常の説明は、金利を押し上げ、金利の上昇は投資の減少につながり、投資の減少は成長の低下につながるため、非常に間違っていると思うので、それを読んだり、赤字の神話を読んだりすると、私は今あなたに話しましたこれはすべて完全に明確に見えますこれはあなたがあなたがそれをとてもよく説明したので人々がこの種のクリックとそれが私と一緒にクリックされたときにあなたが明確さを知っている瞬間について話していることを知っていますあなたは私たちがそれが政治家によってこのように話されているのを聞いていないことを意味すると思いますそして間違いなくメディアではありませんええとあなたはなぜそれが国債がアメリカにとって問題であるとしてそれが組み立てられ続けていると思いますか以前の大学に同僚がいたので、よく聞いてください。彼の名前は黒字です。法と経済学の教授と法案は、これらのことを、彼が法案について話すキャリア制限のジェスチャーとして言及していたので、ホワイトカラー犯罪学者だったので、起訴されたホワイトカラー犯罪を追跡しました。あなたがそれらを行うか、それらを言うとき、彼らはあなたのキャリアの可能性を制限します、そして彼はこのフレーズのキャリア制限ジェスチャーを作り出しました、あなたは標準からの重要な逸脱である物語をとることが非常に難しいことを知っています、そしてあなたはあなたがあなたを固執していることを知っています非常に派手な大学からの非常に派手な学位を持つ人々に反論しているこれらのことについての主流の正統な見解に反対していることを否定し、時にはノーベル賞など、そしてあなたが立ち上がって私たちが反論することを主張しますすべきではない債務とgdpの比率などの長期的な軌跡についてヒステリックになり、落ち着かせて落ち着かせたいと思うと、人々はすべての専門知識を指摘し、ああ、彼らはすべて間違っていると言うでしょう。あなたの中には、ジャーナリストや他の学者がリスクを冒す準備ができていることを知っている人はあまりいません。それは、誰が信頼できるのか、誰が信頼できないのかを決定する人々の目から見て、ある程度リスクを冒していることを知っている、キャリアを制限するジェスチャーです。そうではないので、簡単になっていると思いますが、その理由の一部だと思います」簡単になっているのは、すべてのニワトリが財政のタカを覚えていて、財政の鳩が何十年もの間、債務危機が来る攻撃の危機を私たちに伝えてきたからです。彼らはそれを10年前に言った彼らはそれを5年前に言った彼らはそれを3年前に言った彼らはそれを20年前に言ったそしてそれは決して起こらないそしてある時点で彼らの信頼性が損なわれ始めたと思うこれらのひどいことは、それらが起こらない赤字と借金のために起こるでしょう、そして今、私たちは人々がリアルタイムであなた自身の話を変えて、赤字が爆発し、債務が増えたので金利が下がらず、高インフレなどについて警告したすべてのことを知っているという経験に合うようにしようと再観察します現実はほとんどすべての場合に逆のことが起こっているので、多くの人が自分の物語を柔らかくしているのを見ています。彼らはこのことについての以前のumステートメントから自分自身を遠ざける方法を理解しようとしています。私たちは確かにある程度の進歩を遂げていると思いますが、それから戻って、この契約刺激に関するメディアコメンテーターのメディアコメンテーターがこの1を請求するのを聞いてください。9兆ドルのコード刺激工場多くの人々が、これがどのように増加して国債をさらに増加させるかについて不満を述べています。兆ドルの気候法案は、共和党の民主党員ではなく民主党員が債務をさらに増やすことへの恐れに屈し、適切なサイズの気候法案に投票しないことを懸念しています。上院で50票、50票を獲得したことを深く懸念しています。1つも失うことはありません。今朝コメントを見たのではないかと心配しています。マンチン上院議員がインタビューを行ったと思います。 axios hboまたはそのようなもののように、彼は彼が言った切望された救済が来た後、次に来るものに非常に興奮しています彼は言ったああ私はそれについてとても興奮しています私は長い間インフラストラクチャをやりたいと思っていました議事妨害を取り除きたい私はこのようなもので60票を得ることができると思います私たちはおそらく4兆4兆を得ることができると思います笑いテストに合格するのは現実ではありません申し訳ありませんが、60票を獲得することは決してありません。つまり、すべての民主党員が投票した場合、10人の共和党員が必要になります。 「インフラストラクチャおよびインフラストラクチャ関連の投資に4兆程度の支出を提案し、それを新しい収益で完全に相殺したい」存在しないすべての増税に投票する10人の共和党員を見つけてください。ちなみに、4兆を完全に相殺するために増税に投票する50人の民主党員を見つけることはできないと思います。心配しているはい私はどうやって彼らに何かをうまく通過させるのかとても心配していますあなたは60票でそこに到達するつもりはありませんそれは現実ではないのでそれが行われるのであればあなたはそれをするつもりです切望された救済を移動するために使用されたのと同じプロセスである調整を通じて、1.9兆を使用すると、すべての支出を相殺せずにそれを行うことができます。つまり、支出を相殺することができます。たぶんそれのどれもええと、私たちはしませんでした」昨年の3月から今年の3月まで、議会は数兆ドルの支出パッケージを行ってきました。オフセットなし、見積もりなし、見積もりなしの支払い、新しい税金はありません。あなたはちょうど百万ドルまたは兆ドルの質問をしました。これは、一部の人々が財政のタカ派を見つけ始めた場合、議会にこれらのことを通過させるためにどのように投票させるのですか?家のメンバーが、ある時点であなたが維持できない支出の支払いを開始しなければならないと言うのを聞いたことがあります。これがmmtのすべてです。mmtは、私たちがあなたが知っている質問に答えるのを助けることです。ある限り、支出を相殺する方法■いくつかの低いハンギングフルーツと低いハンギングフルーツは、政府がより高い税金や予算の他の部分の削減によって支出を相殺することなく安全に経済に費やすことができることを意味します。ぶら下がっている果物は財政スペースがあることを意味しますそれはあなたが予算内にいないことを可能にするのに十分な余地があることを意味します私はそれがあなたがお金を使うことができる経済に十分な余裕があることを意味するように言うべきではありませんインフレの問題を引き起こすことなく、ある時点で財政スペースが減少し始め、低水準の成果が不足しているときを知る必要があります。それはオフセットが重要になるときですが、私の神はなぜあなたが知っている不必要な戦いを選ぶのですか?sいくつかの低ぶら下がっている果物とあなたはこの救済パッケージの後ろに来て、あなたがそれを10にする税の戦いである二次的な戦いを選ぶことなくあなたが支出をコミットすることができるとあなたが知っている場所で再回復パッケージを手に入れることができます法案を可決するために必要な票を集めるのが何倍も難しいなら、なぜこれを民主党と上院予算委員会のチーフエコノミストとしてだけでなく、2020年の大統領選挙でバーニーサンダース上院議員の経済顧問を務めていたのかを知っています。明らかに上院議員サンダースは、アメリカ人の生活をより良くするための政府支出の巨大な進歩的で支持者ですが、彼が増税によってこれらのプログラムに資金を提供しようとすると、彼でさえ赤字問題を誤解することを本で知っています。それ'彼のメッセージの大部分を占めていましたが、彼の考え方が変わったのを見ましたか?このええと、あなたは彼と一緒に仕事をしていることを知っていますが、私の見た目ではありません。彼は現在、予算委員会の委員長です。私はかつて米国上院予算委員会の民主党のチーフエコノミストでした。彼は私をその役職に雇いました。あなたは私が書いた本の中にあります。私が2015-16年に目撃したことを知って、それから大統領選挙で、すべての民主党候補者が議題全体にお金を払おうとしたことを認識しましょう。これらはあなたの政策提案であり、あなたがどのようにそれを支払うつもりだったので、マスコミはそれ以上のことを容認しなかったので、それはゲームであり、誰もが今それをプレイしようとしましたが、彼は上院予算委員会の委員長であり、この1.9兆ドルの和解プロセスを案内するのを手伝っただけですオフセットのないパッケージなので、彼がそれを我慢しなかったので、ちょっと待ってください。私たちが支払わなければならない支出を相殺する必要があります。彼が正しくしなかったので、私たちは非常に異なる場所にいます。今日はその方法と比較して家の民主党員にも当てはまりますええと、多くの変化がありました。トランプの減税が助けになったと思います。私が助けたと言うとき、私はあなたが知っていると思って民主党員をシフトするのを助けたということです。ちょうど過去2年間で、座って、ちょっと突っついた楽しみを知っていると言って、サッカーでチャーリーブラウンをルーシーにプレイするのにまだうんざりしていると言っています。つまり、同じプレイを実行するたびに、共和党員が家を手に入れ、上院とホワイトハウスと赤字の懸念は、それが赤字に追加された場合、彼らが議題を通過する窓の外にあるので、彼らは彼らの議題を通過することに焦点を当てているので、民主党員が入って来て、ああ私たちと言います財政的に責任のある政党について、私たちは自分たちを別のものに保持し、私たちが優先順位に支払うより高い基準、そしてあなたが知っているサッカーのルシアンでルーシーを叫ぶと思うので、私は彼らを少しからかって、私たちは私たちが学んでいると言いますあなたは私たちがこのことを理解していることを知っています、そして良いニュースはそれらがそうであるということですそしてそれはそれがスタッフと議会のメンバーの中でええと考えていることの多くです」sそれは入り江を変えましたそれはそれをもっとよく変えるのを助けました上院議員サンダーは明らかにグリーンニューディールの支持者であり、グリーンニューディールは連邦政府の仕事の保証を求めています連邦政府の仕事はどのように仕事を保証するのでしょうか、そして潜在的な環境上の利点のいくつかはそうですそうです、連邦政府の仕事の保証は正しいように聞こえますそれは仕事をしたいがどこにも仕事を見つけることができない人を保証する連邦政府です他の経済では、基本的な賃金と福利厚生のパッケージで常に仕事を保証できるので、生活者は生活賃金と福利厚生のパッケージを考えます。それは、人々がヘルスケアについて聞く常勤の仕事です。ヘルスケアでは、これは労働市場における公的な選択肢のようなものです。誰もが利用できるので、消えることはありません。何らかの理由でそのプログラムに参加したい場合は、そのプログラムに参加できます。知らない時間を常に混乱させている雇用主がいる可能性があります。ある日から次の日まで、あなたはあなたが仕事に現れることになっている日とあなたが育児を手配しようとしているときを知っています、そしてそれはただの悪夢であり、あなたは最低賃金か何かを作っています、そしてあなたは私が言ったと言います多分私は仕事で嫌がらせを受けていたかもしれませんあなたはそのプログラムに参加したい理由であなたがそのプログラムで仕事をしていることを知っているかもしれませんケアエコノミーを構築しているので、何らかの形であなたのコミュニティを世話する惑星を世話する人々の世話をするすべての仕事は、あなたの想像力が私がいくつか書いている限界のようなものであることを知っているように、あなたが知っているいずれかがこれらの3つの方法のいずれかに貢献するように向けられるべきですこれは私が数年前にレビーエコノミックスインスティテュートのためにレポートを共同執筆した本の中で、完全雇用への道は保証された雇用と呼ばれたと思います。ある種の仕事と、pavlina chernovaという名前の別のmmtエコノミストが、私の本とほぼ同時期に出版された本を持っています。彼女は連邦雇用保証のケースと呼ばれているので、私ができる以上のことをしたい人は、それらを指摘したいと思います。短時間でここは面白いと思うかもしれませんが、コミュニティ自体が種類を決定することを知っています彼らが実行したい仕事の中で、パブリナについて考えると、侵入種について話すことがあり、侵入種の監視に責任を持つ人がいるかどうか、そして農民の作物が私たちの残りの部分を養うので、なぜそれが利益になるのかを知っています。彼らが侵入種と闘っているなら、そしてあなたが植樹を知っているそのようなものの気候は、私たちが沿岸に上陸するのを助けるコミュニティにとって価値がある価値があると人々が提案するかもしれない百万と1つの異なることを考えることができますラインは環境浄化コミュニティガーデンをクリーンアップしますあなたは近所の美化プロジェクトを持つことができますそして本当に空はfdrが大統領だったときにあなたが知っている芸術を実行する限界のようなものですそして彼は彼の手に大きな失業問題を抱えていましたそして彼は思いついた同様の考えと彼私たちは人々を直接働かせるべきだと言ったので、彼らを雇うべきでした。それで私たちは仕事プログラムのアルファベットのスープを手に入れました。私たちは公共事業促進局に市民保全部隊を手に入れました。環境問題を中心にしていますが、wpa uhプログラムの労働者は、建築や建設を重視することから、口頭の歴史を記録する口頭の歴史まで、あらゆることを行いました。現状の人々と彼らが正しい場所、そして2つのi 'を持つ人に仕事を合わせるためにdは、私たちの電力網を脱炭素化するための解決策について最も話題になっているのは、連邦のクリーンエネルギー基準と炭素の価格です。これらの解決策には、脱炭素化に対してユーティリティに報酬を与えるか、またはそれらを必要とする報酬が必要です。これらの化石燃料燃焼資産からクリーンエネルギー資産に切り替えることでそれを行うには、これらのソリューションには両方とも欠陥があるという赤字の神話を書いていますクリーンエネルギー基準は料金支払者に高いコスト負担をかける可能性があり、炭素価格はユーティリティをプッシュしない可能性があります十分に速く行動するために、この電力脱炭素問題を解決する連邦政府にあなたが知っているmmtアプローチはどのように見えるでしょうかii 'mは環境経済学者ではないので、本の中でいくつかのことを指摘しているのは知っていますが、私は自分のレーンに留まろうとしています。直接的な解決策や一連の解決策を提供しようとはしていません。私たちが気候に必要な場所にたどり着くまでの道のり私は間違いなくこの分野の気候の専門家に任せています。あなたは私がグリーンニューディールとそのようなことについて多くの話し合いをしたことを知っていますが、私の専門分野は資金調達の仕組みについて、私が役立つことができる場所は、人々にそれを思い出させることだと思います」私たちの実際のリソースについては、技術的なノウハウがあり、実際のリソースがあれば、いつでもお金を利用できるようになります。時間が重要であることがわかっているので、必要以上に遅くなりたいことがよくあります。より遅いペースでより段階的に進むことなどは、予算上の懸念のためです。したがって、私の専門分野が、私たちが行くことを望んでいる場所に私たちをプッシュするのに役立つ可能性がある場所は、大胆な野心的な行動計画です。気候の専門家が私たちにやらなければならないと言っているようなことをするために、私たちを炭素予算内に保つために炭素排出量を保持していることを知っています。すぐにそれはs本当の課題はインフレ圧力を管理することですええあなたは炭素収支について言及しました私たちは本当の自然の制約があることを意味します私は炭素収支がもはや自分自身を再生できないことを知る前に抽出できる天然資源の量を意味しますあなたは思いますか他のエコノミストの間では、これらの本当の自然の制約を反映するポリシーを推奨し、これらの用語で話す責任があります。幸いなことに、そこには多くの良いものがあります。ドーナツ経済学は、あなたが知っている世界中の政策立案に多大な影響を与え、影響を与えたと私が思う本です。彼女がドーナツと呼んでいるものの安全な部分の中で、境界を越えて押したり、あなたの良い生活を奪うようなことをしたりせずに、あなたをその中に保つことを約束している都市や国がありますその安全な場所マリアーノは彼女と一緒にミッションエコノミーと起業家精神を知っていますumnaomi klein steve keaneつまり、naomiは明らかにエコノミストではありませんが、ここでは学者として多くの仕事をしており、実際に分解したエコノミストもスティーブキーンですノーベル賞を受賞したエコノミストは、気候などに取り組んでいます。スティーブは素晴らしい仕事をしています。他にもたくさんありますが、良くも悪くも、通常は私です。悪いエコノミストは公の議論で大げさな声を上げていると言うのを恐れて、彼らはしばしば立ち上がらない大統領に耳を傾け、一流の社会学者が私たちに言うか、一流の人類学者がそれは常にエコノミストが私たちに言っていることだと言うことを知っていますかあなたはエコノミストが言っていることを知っているので、私たちはこれを楽しんでいますあなたはどういうわけかあなたが知っているはずの人であるというステータスを知っており、政策立案者などに適切なガイダンスを提供します経済学者から提示されたものの多くはあなたができないことであり、それがあなたがそれを行うことができない理由であるため、リーダーがあなたが物事が達成可能であることを知っていることを確認できるように、その野心的な方向に政策思考を推進するのを助けてください費用便益分析が「いいえ」と言っているか、cboレポートが「いいえ」と言っているか、これが「いいえ」と言っていることを知っています。それを防ぐか、投資家がそれを許可しないか、なぜそれらの議論に欠陥があるのか​​を示すことができるようになった何かを先に話しましたが、アメリカは金銭的主権を持っている数少ない国の1つであるため、もちろん、気候政策の世界規模または世界的な舞台で本当にリーダーであるということになると、それは有利ですが、私たちの一人ではありません。私がオーストラリアとカナダ、ニュージーランド、英国、日本について言及した数少ないumの1つです。つまり、実際には多くの国があり、欧州中央銀行が発行者であるため、ecbが積極的なパートナーである限り、欧州を含めることができます。ある意味でバックストップする意思のあるECBがあるかどうかを知っている通貨は、通貨を放棄し、ECBがUMになる場合はユーロを採用することで、主権を危うくする19か国と調整して許可することを可能にします。それらの19か国と提携すれば、その一部としてヨーロッパを知っていることを含めることができます。工業化された裕福な世界のほとんどであり、そうです、彼らは果たすべき重要な役割を持っており、彼らはステップアップして、この負担の彼らの分担がうまくいくことを肩に乗せる必要があります。本当に私は私が私たちの経済がどのように機能するかについて私が知っていると思ったことを質問するだけでなく、財政政策全体について私がどのように考えるかを再構成することを余儀なくされました、そして私はもうこの本を推薦することはできません。現在入手可能な赤字の神話とペーパーバックを入手してください。これを読んで理解し、より持続可能でちょうど未来を作るためのツールとして実際に使用することは非常に重要な本です。オンラインまたはソーシャルメディアであなたの仕事をよくフォローしてくださいツイッターのmええと、それは私が理解している唯一のソーシャルメディアプラットフォームについてです、そしてそれは私がええとiiを使っているものですステファニーケルトンでumの名前でつぶやきますumiiは私が持っているようなニューヨークタイムズとアウトレットのために定期的に書きますタイムズですぐに出てくる作品ですが、ツイッターフィードは私が書いたものすべてに出演を共有する場所ですそれは素晴らしい本ですステファニーケルトン博士ステファニーケルトン気候ポッドに参加してくれてありがとう私を持ってくれてありがとう1 :21:15タイムズですぐに作品が出てきますが、ツイッターフィードは私が書いたものすべての外観を共有する場所ですそれは素晴らしい本ですステファニーケルトン博士気候ポッドに参加してくれてありがとう私を持ってくれてありがとうあなた1:21:15タイムズですぐに作品が出てきますが、ツイッターフィードは私が書いたものすべての外観を共有する場所ですそれは素晴らしい本ですステファニーケルトン博士気候ポッドに参加してくれてありがとう私を持ってくれてありがとうあなた1:21:15

 

JP アズちゃんねる 将棋 9+ アバターの画像 #deficitmyth #modernmonetarytheory #kelton Debunking the Deficit Myth to Help Save the Planet with Dr. Stephanie Kelton 26 回視聴•2021/04/22 4 0 共有 保存 The Climate Pod チャンネル登録者数 24人 #deficitmyth​ #modernmonetarytheory​ #kelton​ #climatechange​ Dr. Stephanie Kelton joins the show to discuss how American politicians totally misunderstand the national debt and how the Federal government can use fiscal policy to create a just and sustainable society. Her book, The Deficit Myth, explains Modern Monetary Theory and shows why America can and must spend big on just climate solutions or we'll create the real intergenerational debt that matters. Be sure to subscribe to The Climate Pod YouTube channel! Listen to the full episode of The Climate Pod featuring Dr. Kelton here: iTunes: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...​ Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/4v3f...​ The Climate Pod is a weekly conversation on the latest climate issues with the journalists, activists, academics, and artists at the center of the story. Follow us on social media! Twitter: https://twitter.com/climatepod​ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/climatepod/​ Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/climatepod/​ Subscribe to our new Substack newsletter "The Climate Weekly": https://theclimateweekly.substack.com/​ Website: www.theclimatepod.com 0 件のコメント me com 公開コメントを入力... 文字起こし 00:00 [Music] 

T:

00:10 well dr stephanie kelton 00:12 welcome to the climate pod thank you so 00:14 much for having me 00:15 well after reading the deficit myth i am 00:19 confident that if america is going to 00:22 really take the steps 00:23 to address the climate crisis at the 00:26 scale and at the speed 00:28 necessary then our policy makers must 00:31 understand the core tenets of modern 00:34 monetary theory 00:35 and really disregard their flawed and 00:38 antiquated 00:39 views on america's debt and deficit so 00:42 in order to understand the climate 00:44 implications of all this 00:45 i really want to first help the audience 00:47 understand mmt 00:49 so if you could just summarize at a 00:52 pretty high level 00:53 the core principles of modern monetary 00:56 theory.

Kelton:

 00:57 okay sure so what mmt is about 01:01 is giving uh an explanation 01:04 of how a sovereign currency works okay 01:07 now you say all right well what's a 01:08 sovereign currency 01:09 right so what we're talking about are 01:12 um the policy options let's say 01:16 that are available to countries that 01:19 have a sovereign currency what is that 01:21 what does that mean 01:22 it means countries that issue a currency 01:26 that is their own currency the us issues 01:29 the dollar 01:30 uh the japanese government issues the 01:32 yen the british government 01:34 issues the pound these are governments 01:36 that issue 01:37 their own unique currency they receive 01:40 payments in that same currency they tax 01:43 in that currency they never need to 01:46 borrow their own currency 01:47 from anyone in order to be able to spend 01:50 it 01:51 if they do choose to sell bonds this 01:54 thing we call government borrowing 01:56 then that is an optional thing and they 01:58 can also 02:00 determine the interest rate that they 02:02 are willing to pay on any bonds that 02:04 they choose 02:05 to issue what it means is that 02:09 you know a few things follow from that 02:10 one the government can never run out of 02:12 money 02:13 you can't run out of the thing that you 02:15 and only you 02:16 have the legal authority to create to 02:18 issue so the us government's never going 02:20 to run out of dollars 02:21 and that's not what barack obama told us 02:23 when he was president he had just taken 02:25 office and 02:26 he was asked in an interview you know 02:28 the wheels were coming off the economy 02:30 we had the financial crisis and the 02:31 great recession 02:32 and he was asked in an interview at what 02:34 point does the government 02:36 run out of money and his response was 02:38 well we're out of money now 02:41 and it wasn't the case and it can't be 02:43 the case and we drew 02:44 so many wrong lessons from the 02:47 experience of you know 2010 02:50 watching many countries in europe um 02:53 get very much embroiled in a debt crisis 02:57 countries like greece people might 02:59 remember 03:00 having debts come due that they weren't 03:02 able to pay and many people said listen 03:04 if the u.s isn't careful we're next 03:07 we're going to end up like greece 03:08 no wrong greece got into trouble spain 03:12 got into trouble 03:13 italy got into trouble and in other 03:15 european countries because they were 03:17 borrowing 03:18 in a currency that they don't issue 03:20 greece gave up the dragma 03:22 in order to join economic and monetary 03:24 union and began using the euro 03:27 so we want to pay a very close attention 03:30 to the nature of the monetary system 03:32 because that has important implications 03:34 for how much policy space is available 03:37 to governments 03:38 and then we can begin to talk about how 03:40 governments can 03:41 manage their budgets can use their 03:43 spending capacity 03:45 in ways that reflect the fact that 03:47 they're currency issuers 03:48 whereas countries that aren't currency 03:50 issuers like greece and others 03:52 they have to manage their budgets 03:54 differently and so we hear these 03:55 household analogies right that the 03:57 government should 03:58 balance its budget just like you and i 04:00 just just like a household 04:02 that's not right not for a currency 04:04 issuing government like japan or the u.s 04:05 or the uk or australia or many others 04:08 but it is closer to true when you're 04:10 talking about countries that borrow in 04:12 foreign currencies 04:14 that don't have what what i've described 04:16 as a sovereign currency 04:17 so that's a starting point you can 04:19 afford these governments can afford to 04:21 buy 04:22 whatever is both available and for sale 04:26 in their own unique currency so when you 04:28 say what can the us government afford to 04:30 do 04:31 it can afford to hire to 04:34 purchase whatever is available and for 04:37 sale in us dollars and it turns out 04:39 that's a lot and importantly it includes 04:42 all unemployed labor 04:43 which means that mmt teaches us that 04:46 unemployment 04:47 is always a policy choice because it can 04:50 easily be eliminated .

T:

04:52 so if the united states is not going to 04:54 run out of money if we can create more 04:56 money 04:57 to solve a lot of these problems then 04:59 you know why are we paying taxes what is 05:01 the purpose of taxes 05:03 well there are lots of reasons so 05:05 there's like you know an 05:06 origin story and we could talk about if 05:09 you wanted to 05:10 start up a currency from scratch a tax 05:13 or something that works like a tax 05:14 fees fines other obligations these are 05:18 ways that governments historically 05:20 have introduced a currency to a 05:22 population to start up a currency from 05:24 scratch 05:25 so very quick brush of history here 05:28 right 05:28 you could imagine uh in the case of of 05:32 uh britain great britain for example you 05:34 know 05:35 countries were colonized these are 05:37 colonizing countries 05:39 uh you go in and you say sail over to 05:42 africa 05:42 and you land and you look around and you 05:44 find a lot of things that you'd like to 05:46 have that you don't have 05:47 access to back at home and you think 05:50 well how can i get 05:51 these people to give me their real you 05:53 know resources that i'm after 05:55 there are a number of ways you could go 05:57 about it some very unpleasant 05:59 uh one way to do it that masks some of 06:03 the unpleasant trees 06:04 is to impose a tax and so you say to the 06:07 population listen 06:08 you are now the subject of the crown 06:10 what does that mean well that means that 06:11 periodically somebody's going to come 06:13 around 06:14 and they're going to collect attacks and 06:15 so what we're going to be looking for is 06:17 for you to settle your obligation to the 06:18 crown 06:19 well what's how do i settle the tax oh 06:22 well you're going to need some british 06:23 currency 06:24 and that's what you'll use to settle i 06:25 don't have british currency 06:27 we can help right all you have to do is 06:30 produce some of 06:31 the things that we're after sell them to 06:33 us we'll buy them 06:35 provide you with the currency that you 06:36 need to settle your obligation to the 06:39 state 06:39 now the people have a need for the 06:42 currency why 06:43 because if you don't settle the tax 06:44 obligation if you don't pay your tax 06:46 they will burn your hut down they will 06:48 right there's a punishment 06:49 so in other words the taxes away through 06:52 enforcement right making and enforcing 06:55 tax laws 06:56 to give value to a currency that would 07:00 otherwise have no value to those people 07:02 and so that's an origin story but once a 07:04 once a monetary system is up and running 07:06 like we have in the us 07:08 today then we don't think about the tax 07:11 as playing that role even though it's 07:13 still important 07:14 we think about tax as a way for the 07:16 government to 07:17 um impact the distribution of wealth and 07:20 income 07:21 we see that now with this 1.9 trillion 07:24 dollar 07:24 uh coveted relief package that includes 07:27 tax cuts and 07:29 tax effectively rebates and and so it is 07:32 a way to 07:32 funnel right cash into people's hands it 07:36 can also be a way 07:37 to take cash away from people you could 07:39 push taxes up on higher income 07:41 individuals and say well i'm doing this 07:43 because i want to kind of rebalance the 07:45 distribution of wealth and income 07:47 also every dollar that is taxed away 07:50 from us 07:51 is a dollar that we don't have and can't 07:52 therefore spend chasing after goods and 07:55 services in the economy 07:56 so taxes are like a release valve right 07:59 they relieve some pressure by removing 08:02 dollars from 08:03 our hands the government can then spend 08:05 dollars into the economy 08:07 maintaining the value of the currency 08:10 without creating an inflation problem so 08:12 they can add 08:13 with their spending and subtract dollars 08:15 by taxing 08:16 and calibrate the spending and taxing so 08:19 that 08:20 they are managing inflationary pressures 08:23 so when you think about taxing that's 08:25 the now the government 08:27 raises revenue right through taxing and 08:29 they spend 08:30 on all kinds of federal programs things 08:33 like that 08:34 and every year when the government 08:37 spends 08:38 more than it takes in it creates a 08:39 deficit so so what actually 08:42 happens when when the federal government 08:45 spends more in a given year than it 08:47 brings back in 08:49 well a lot of things happen the most 08:52 important and straightforward of which 08:53 is that somebody ends up with that 08:55 currency somebody ends up with the money 08:57 so if you know the deficit is 08:59 just this misunderstood concept it has 09:02 it carries this connotation because the 09:04 word itself 09:05 is kind of inherently suggests that 09:07 there's a problem a deficit means a 09:09 shortfall 09:10 um people immediately think deficit bad 09:14 surplus good right but when the 09:16 government is 09:17 running a fiscal deficit it simply means 09:21 that they are spending more dollars into 09:23 the economy than they are subtracting 09:25 back out 09:25 mostly through taxation so another way 09:28 to refer 09:29 to deficit spending is to call it net 09:31 spending right 09:32 because if the government spends 100 in 09:34 and only taxes 90 out 09:37 we call that a deficit but it masks 09:40 what's happening on the other side 09:42 if they put 100 in and only take 90 out 09:44 somebody's getting 09:45 10. so on the other side of every 09:48 government deficit 09:49 lies a financial surplus equal 09:52 and opposite in size right their red ink 09:56 is our black ink their deficits are 09:58 our financial surpluses which is why 10:02 every deficit is good for someone the 10:04 question is always for whom 10:05 and for what right this 1.9 trillion 10:08 dollar coveted relief package that just 10:10 made it through the senate 10:12 and well in all likelihood go to the 10:14 president's desk and become 10:16 uh law this 1.9 trillion coveted relief 10:19 package 10:19 is putting money into the hands of 10:22 health care providers to help roll out 10:24 vaccines it's putting 350 billion 10:27 in for state and local governments to 10:29 help shore up budgets there and 10:31 prevent further job losses it's sending 10:33 1400 10:34 checks to most americans it's providing 10:37 unemployment 10:38 uh insurance support for people who are 10:41 still unemployed and so forth and so on 10:42 right 10:43 that money is going into the hands of 10:45 people who are really hurting 10:46 in this economy counter that with the 10:49 1.9 trillion dollar 10:50 tax cuts the republicans passed in 10:53 december of 2017. 10:55 these were both pieces of legislation 10:57 that cost 10:58 1.9 trillion dollars but the republicans 11:02 used the deficit to funnel a financial 11:05 windfall 11:06 mostly to people who are already doing 11:08 really well in this economy 11:10 so both 1.9 trillion packages 11:14 produce financial surpluses on the other 11:16 side but they went to 11:17 very different groups of people 11:20 in in our economy and so every deficit 11:23 is good for someone 11:24 question is for whom and for what 11:25 purpose is the deficit being used are we 11:27 doing infrastructure and education and 11:29 health care and covert relief 11:31 or are we doing you know tax breaks for 11:33 corporations and 11:35 people who frankly are already doing 11:37 phenomenally well 11:38 uh in this economy so yeah i mean when 11:41 you think about 11:42 taxes as a way to redistribute wealth 11:45 and you look at america's you know 11:48 income and wealth inequality 11:50 has grown so much over the last century 11:52 it really makes you 11:53 realize that we've really messed up the 11:55 taxation in this country because it's 11:57 doing the exact 11:58 opposite thing that it's uh that it's 12:00 supposed to do 12:02 yeah i mean you know we got sold a bill 12:04 of goods 12:05 right for our for 40 plus years 12:08 really with this supply side and trickle 12:11 down and this idea that 12:13 you know the real job creators in the 12:15 economy are the people at the very top 12:17 and that you have to do everything you 12:19 can to tickle their bellies and 12:21 incentivize them and and treat them very 12:24 very gently and kindly and if you do all 12:26 the right things 12:27 then they will rain down jobs and 12:30 benefits to everybody else 12:32 and you know we have done this we have 12:34 run this experiment 12:35 time after time after time reagan 12:38 thatcher 12:38 all across the world this isn't unique 12:40 to the us right this supply side idea 12:43 that tax cuts for the rich have um 12:46 trickle-down effects 12:47 and that you end up you know lifting 12:49 everyone from the bottom 12:50 the the evidence is in it it does not 12:53 work 12:54 and there are recent studies out a big 12:56 one actually 12:57 from i think a couple of economists at 12:59 the london school of economics if i'm 13:01 not mistaken and they have done a 13:04 a very interesting study looking at the 13:06 past 40 years 13:07 18 countries that have pursued 13:10 supply-side trickle-down 13:12 tax cut uh kind of policies and what 13:15 they concluded is it's a colossal 13:16 failure 13:17 that in every instance it has not 13:19 produced 13:21 the benefits that it purported to 13:23 produce and i 13:24 i think that most of the people who 13:25 pushed um this sort of supply side stuff 13:28 knew all along 13:30 that it doesn't generate those benefits 13:32 but it was a marketing 13:34 you know it's like you know the 13:35 narrative was we do this for the job 13:37 creators and it benefits everyone and 13:40 for for many years and across many 13:42 nations 13:43 governments voted for these kinds of 13:44 policies and you're right what they did 13:46 was widen 13:47 the inequities and not deliver uh the 13:50 broader-based benefits that were 13:52 promised 13:53 yeah so much of this uh after reading 13:55 the book it does feel like 13:56 a you know marketing campaign to 13:59 you know not only redistribute wealth 14:01 but to limit that government spending 14:04 and using this idea that we should all 14:06 be worried about a growing 14:08 national debt um as the as a rationale 14:11 for for not spending on things that 14:13 clearly our society needs so um 14:17 why shouldn't we listen to anyone that's 14:19 telling us to to be afraid 14:21 about the the current size or increasing 14:24 the 14:24 america's national debt okay so now 14:27 we're shifting 14:28 to the the debt right because you know 14:31 and you're right you know these 14:32 uh these people who push tax cuts tax 14:35 cuts tax cuts 14:36 as always and everywhere the right 14:39 policy 14:40 move no matter what the situation is tax 14:42 cuts are the are the solution 14:44 right whatever problem we face cut taxes 14:46 uh 14:47 and that will fix things and so we do 14:49 this republicans do this in particular 14:51 conservative governments 14:53 tend to do this and then you get an 14:55 increase in the deficit because the tax 14:57 cuts 14:58 don't deliver the growth that then 15:01 delivers higher revenues that then make 15:03 the tax cuts pay for themselves as they 15:05 like to say 15:06 so what you're left with are larger 15:09 deficits 15:10 that increase the national debt and then 15:13 republicans will turn around when 15:14 they're no longer in office and say 15:16 to democrats you can't spend any money 15:18 now because look at that huge debt 15:20 right and then democrats say oh my god 15:22 usually you're right you know they'll 15:24 say something like you're right we have 15:25 this huge fiscal crisis 15:27 uh but you did it right so then it 15:29 becomes uh 15:30 the blame game is over who caused the 15:32 problem and so what i try to do in the 15:35 book is 15:35 to just you know fundamentally question 15:38 the premise 15:39 is there really a problem are we facing 15:41 a long-term 15:43 fiscal uh problem and my answer is no 15:46 that there is not evidence that we here 15:49 in the u.s or 15:50 many other major countries that have 15:52 long believed that they face a looming 15:55 fiscal crisis that's just simply not 15:57 true 15:58 and you know 16:01 both democrats and republicans for the 16:04 most part 16:05 accept the premise they say we have a 16:07 long-term fiscal 16:08 crisis and they disagree about 16:11 what to do about it and who caused it 16:14 right there's a lot of finger pointing 16:16 and the blame game uh and then they 16:19 point to different culprits so 16:21 for example you know if your listeners 16:23 are interested i 16:25 i would suggest googling um 16:30 you can google the name jason 16:33 furman or even janet yellen because they 16:36 both 16:36 signed their names to an op-ed just a 16:39 few years ago 16:40 two and a half three years ago maybe 16:43 the op-ed ran in the washington post and 16:45 the op-ed was titled 16:47 a debt crisis is coming but don't blame 16:51 entitlements in other words don't blame 16:53 social security and medicare medicaid 16:55 uh but a debt crisis is coming and they 16:58 this was 16:59 an op-ed signed on to by five 17:02 former heads of the council of economic 17:05 advisers the president's council of 17:07 economic advisors 17:08 including jenna yellen right the current 17:10 treasury secretary former fed chair 17:12 uh and other obama advisers and so forth 17:15 so five of them put their name on this 17:17 thing 17:17 a debt crisis is coming but don't you 17:19 republicans blame entitlements they're 17:21 only 17:22 part of the problem and they were 17:24 writing in response 17:25 to an op-ed also published in the 17:28 washington post 17:28 written by five conservative i believe 17:31 all economists 17:33 um from the hoover institution and the 17:36 five conservatives from hoover said 17:38 a debt crisis is coming it's mainly 17:40 entitlements and we have to cut 17:42 social security and medicare to fix the 17:44 problem so what i'm saying is 17:47 that for a very very long time 17:50 economists on the left and the right 17:52 democrats republicans we call them 17:54 fiscal hawks 17:55 the conservatives and fiscal doves the 17:58 democrats they have all agreed that 18:01 yes we're in trouble we're in trouble 18:04 but they disagree over 18:05 how we got in trouble and what to do 18:07 about it and democrats say mostly we 18:09 don't tax enough 18:10 and you guys start too many wars and 18:12 don't pay for them so this is how the 18:14 disagreement goes so 18:16 to your question now you know how do i 18:18 deal with this in the book 18:19 i look at the national debt so-called 18:23 very differently 18:24 and in fact i titled the chapter 18:28 the national debt and in parentheses 18:30 that isn't 18:32 it's a national debt that isn't so what 18:34 is this thing 18:35 that we refer to as the national debt 18:37 that we talk about 18:39 as uh representing a real burden on our 18:42 futures 18:43 this is the thing we're leaving to our 18:45 children and our grandchildren this is 18:47 what they inherit this is what's going 18:48 to make 18:48 their lives harder uh and and less 18:52 prosperous in the future because we've 18:53 handed them 18:54 these these shackles and now they're 18:57 responsible for paying off this debt 18:59 so i don't look at it like that at all 19:01 here's how i look at 19:02 it um the government as i said before 19:06 chooses chooses to sell government 19:10 bonds securities known as u.s treasuries 19:12 in this country 19:13 some are short-term some are longer term 19:16 government 19:16 treasury sells these things how do they 19:19 sell them and why 19:20 what happens when they do that so the 19:23 government 19:24 is matching its deficit spending 19:27 by offering u.s treasury so whenever the 19:29 government's budget is in deficit 19:31 an equivalent amount of government 19:35 debt bonds are sold 19:38 so let's do the numbers the government 19:40 spends a hundred dollars into the 19:41 economy 19:42 it only taxes ninety dollars back out it 19:45 has run a deficit 19:46 it's placed ten dollars in the system 19:50 as it runs a deficit it sells government 19:53 bonds 19:54 so now it's got 10 government bonds and 19:56 it says who wants to buy these 19:58 okay and what happens 10 20:01 comes back out of the economy and 10 20:04 treasuries 20:04 go in what is a us treasury it's an 20:08 interest bearing dollar it's an interest 20:10 bearing dollar 20:11 i took out a currency i took out a 20:14 non-interest faring dollar i replaced it 20:16 with an 20:16 interest bearing dollar i didn't have to 20:19 do it and the person who got it is 20:21 pretty lucky 20:22 because they have a risk-free asset it's 20:24 a very safe risk-free 20:26 government bond that pays them interest 20:29 while they take no risk 20:30 it's a subsidy right it's it's a way to 20:33 subsidize people who already have money 20:36 you let them give you some of their cash 20:37 and you replace it with interest bearing 20:39 cash 20:40 it's a pretty sweet deal the problem is 20:42 that we refer 20:44 to the outstanding stock of u.s 20:46 treasuries 20:47 as the national debt instead of calling 20:50 it 20:51 part of the u.s money supply or u.s 20:54 wealth and savings right those 20:57 treasuries are part of somebody's 20:58 accumulated 20:59 savings and wealth they're not on the 21:02 hook 21:03 for that it's not their liability it's 21:05 their asset 21:06 so you know we don't have a debt problem 21:08 we don't have a deficit problem we have 21:10 a communications problem 21:12 and and which is the the language that 21:15 we choose to use 21:16 government borrowing debt those are 21:20 words that are appropriate if we're 21:21 talking about household budget 21:23 but they're inapplicable once we move to 21:26 the currency issuer 21:27 and start talking about what what is 21:29 happening at that level 21:30 so then what should policymakers be 21:33 thinking about 21:34 when they're deciding you know how much 21:35 money to put into the economy this year 21:38 is there something that they should be 21:39 concerned about if not the debt 21:42 something else that could 21:43 that should constrain how much we spend 21:46 well look i mean i wouldn't ask 21:50 i wouldn't approach the question in 21:52 terms of how much 21:54 money should we put in to the economy 21:57 i try to say you know in the book i say 21:59 the goal is not 22:01 to achieve any particular budget balance 22:04 the goal is to achieve 22:05 a healthy balanced economy so what does 22:08 that look like 22:09 so you know i want to i have a chapter 22:11 in the book chapter seven is called the 22:13 deficits that matter 22:14 so in that chapter i talk about climate 22:17 i talk about infrastructure i talk about 22:20 education and healthcare and other 22:22 you know uh shortfalls deficiencies the 22:25 real 22:26 deficits in our economy and the way that 22:28 i would approach the budgeting process 22:30 is to identify those deficits 22:34 right to figure out what problems are we 22:36 trying to solve 22:37 and how do we fit the budget to the 22:40 problem so if we're trying to deal with 22:42 climate change 22:43 if we're trying to deal with you know uh 22:45 infrastructure 22:46 that is poorly managed and outdated and 22:49 and so forth how much would we need to 22:52 invest 22:53 to bring our infrastructure grade up 22:55 from a c 22:56 or whatever it currently is c plus to 22:59 let's say a b 22:59 plus or an a minus over time this covert 23:02 relief package i'll keep coming back to 23:04 it because 23:05 it serves as a good example in so many 23:06 ways the covert relief package 23:09 is going to lift half of all the kids 23:11 who today are in poverty will be lifted 23:13 out of poverty 23:14 as a result of some of the things that 23:17 are being done 23:18 in that covid relief package right if we 23:21 can lift half of the kids 23:22 out of poverty what about the other half 23:24 you know what i mean so 23:26 for me it's about you know figuring out 23:28 what problems you want to solve 23:30 and then fitting the budget to address 23:34 those problems and there's not a right 23:37 number out there lurking what there is 23:40 is uh you know a limited um 23:44 array of resources that you can tap 23:47 to solve real problems if you want to 23:49 make public colleges and universities 23:51 tuition free 23:52 for everybody in this country what you 23:54 need are enough 23:55 faculty right you need graduate students 23:58 you need structures so that people can 24:00 sit in classrooms and get to 24:02 universities and colleges and so forth 24:04 so you need to be 24:05 able to deliver on that promise in real 24:08 terms and so the question is 24:10 how do you resource that right and and 24:13 that's how i think about the 24:14 federal budgeting process the dollars 24:16 are the easy part to figure out 24:18 managing inflationary pressures and 24:21 working within the constraints that you 24:23 face because 24:24 resources aren't aren't infinite they're 24:26 finite and you do have to budget your 24:29 priorities and you do have to make 24:30 choices 24:31 so you know it's about prioritizing 24:34 budgets are 24:35 moral documents but they also force us 24:37 to prioritize and to make choices 24:40 you mentioned man managing inflationary 24:42 pressures 24:44 how do we know when we're we're 24:46 approaching 24:47 too high inflation levels well 24:52 we don't necessarily know um 24:56 we can take the economy's temperature in 24:59 different ways 25:00 look i i don't think that anybody is 25:02 talking about 25:03 sitting down and starting from scratch 25:06 from 25:07 zero imagine building out a five 25:10 trillion dollar federal government 25:12 budget so much of the federal 25:13 government's budget 25:14 is locked in place right it is mandatory 25:17 spending non-discretionary the vast 25:20 majority 25:21 of the dollars that the federal 25:22 government spends on an annual basis 25:25 you can't play with their social 25:27 security their medicare right their 25:29 uh interest payments on the so-called 25:31 national debt and so forth the 25:33 discretionary budget is pretty small 25:35 so when we talk about making changes 25:38 to spending discretionary more spending 25:42 on infrastructure 25:43 education health care that sort of thing 25:45 then i think actually it gets 25:46 easier to answer your question about you 25:49 know the marginal dollar the next dollar 25:51 spent 25:52 are we at greater risk of inflation 25:55 accelerating 25:57 if we put another you know 50 billion in 26:00 pell grants 26:01 that's probably a very straightforward 26:04 and 26:04 and safe calculation right but if we 26:06 were to move to 26:08 if we were to do four trillion dollar uh 26:11 infrastructure 26:11 climate package would that 26:15 uh invite greater inflationary pressures 26:18 and then you have to really drill down 26:19 right you have to say well what is it 26:21 we're going to try to do 26:22 with that infrastructure climate package 26:24 oh we're going to try to build 26:25 high-speed rail and we're going to do 26:26 solar and we're going to do broadband 26:28 and we're going to do energy you know 26:30 and then you have to start going deeper 26:32 and deeper and deeper to say 26:34 what are the resource needs to do that 26:37 high-speed rail and how quickly do you 26:38 want to 26:39 build it and what about the broadband 26:41 and how quickly and then you say do we 26:42 have 26:43 companies that are uh you know equipped 26:46 to supply us with 26:47 cranes and concrete trucks and machines 26:49 and the things we need 26:51 or if i pick up the phone and call 26:52 caterpillar and i say could you fill an 26:55 order for these things if i were to 26:57 place an order do we have the steel do 26:58 we have the machines they said no i have 27:00 a huge backlot i couldn't get to that 27:02 for another year at best that tells you 27:04 right then 27:05 that if you were to try to do that much 27:07 spending the capacity constraint 27:09 is binding that you know the resource 27:12 capacity oh 27:13 um i think you have to evaluate proposed 27:16 new spending on you know a case-by-case 27:20 basis 27:21 and you have to look very closely at 27:23 what it is you're proposing to spend 27:24 over how long a period of time and then 27:27 get a sense 27:28 of whether um industries have capacity 27:32 to meet those orders 27:33 whether you have enough unemployed 27:35 construction workers architects 27:36 engineers 27:38 can you mobilize the real resources that 27:40 you would need 27:41 to you know achieve what it is you're 27:44 you're trying to achieve and if not you 27:46 have to 27:47 make choices right you can always 27:49 wrestle the resources away from the 27:51 private sector 27:52 if if there's you know construction 27:54 workers are being used to 27:56 build residential housing for example 27:59 and you don't 27:59 have the people that you would need for 28:01 a large-scale climate infrastructure 28:03 program 28:04 you could choose hey climate is 28:07 is a priority and we're going to take 28:10 workers away we'll bid them away 28:12 you can do that right now that's going 28:14 to create some inflationary 28:16 pressures and at that point it it 28:19 becomes a decision about 28:21 you know how much inflation do you think 28:22 that would likely 28:24 um create additional inflationary 28:26 pressure and do you think it's worth it 28:28 for the sake of getting those resources 28:31 to 28:31 you know away from building whatever it 28:34 is they're currently building to doing 28:36 climate and related we've talked a lot 28:39 about 28:40 fiscal policy to this point but there's 28:42 a flip side that there's a monetary 28:43 policy and we know that 28:45 you know the way that the fed rains in 28:48 inflation or forecasted inflation is by 28:51 increasing interest rates and when you 28:54 have higher interest rates 28:56 businesses aren't able to borrow as much 28:58 and they aren't able to 28:59 spend as much and we also know that we 29:03 need this 29:03 mix of private and public investment 29:07 in new climate solutions but you argue 29:10 and the deficit myth 29:11 that government you know government 29:13 spending government deficits 29:15 will not lead to a decrease in private 29:18 investment so can you explain why that 29:20 why that is well i don't rule out the 29:23 possibility 29:24 in fact i just gave you an example of 29:26 how government 29:27 spending could crowd out elbow out 29:30 some uh private sector endeavors and i 29:33 was giving an example of how it could be 29:34 done quite deliberately 29:36 uh but this question about interest 29:38 rates so 29:39 you know um the usual argument 29:43 in economics and one that i attempt to 29:46 debunk 29:47 in that chapter that you're referring to 29:49 is the idea that when the government 29:51 runs a deficit 29:52 it has to go out and find the money to 29:55 cover the shortfall 29:56 so it goes to savers and they've got 29:59 dollars and the government says 30:01 i want some of those dollars because i 30:02 need to finance my deficit 30:04 and the textbook story is that now there 30:08 are fewer dollars left and available 30:10 to the private sector for their 30:12 endeavors so as you said 30:14 businesses when the supply of available 30:17 funds 30:18 shrinks then the cost of those funds 30:21 goes up so the government deficit is 30:22 driving the interest rate up 30:24 and you're saying well if interest rates 30:26 go up then 30:28 businesses can't afford to borrow and so 30:31 some private investment doesn't get 30:33 undertaken and that could and that's 30:35 what economists refer to as crowding out 30:37 that the government's deficit crowds out 30:39 private sector spending 30:41 and leads to slower growth over time 30:43 because the private sector is assumed 30:45 to be more efficient and their 30:47 investments would have uh 30:48 you know enhanced productivity and 30:50 growth whereas government spending 30:53 less efficient all that stuff so but in 30:55 the book i say listen 30:57 what about the possibility that instead 30:59 of crowding out 31:00 private sector investments government 31:02 deficits actually crowd 31:04 in private sector spending and 31:06 investment sure that happens 31:08 think about it so when government is 31:10 running a deficit 31:12 and putting income into people's hands 31:14 we're seeing it again i'll come back to 31:16 the cove 31:16 relief package fourteen hundred dollars 31:18 going to almost 31:19 every uh person in this country right uh 31:23 and and the other uh money as well what 31:25 are people gonna do 31:26 well a lot of people are gonna turn 31:28 around and spend dollars those dollars 31:30 back into the economy 31:32 and what happens now you've created 31:34 demand now you're a customer for some 31:36 business what do businesses do when 31:37 they're swamped with customers 31:39 they hire more people right you don't 31:41 fire the bus boy 31:43 if the line to get in your restaurant is 31:45 wrapped around the building and so 31:47 businesses will hire and invest when 31:49 they're swamped with customers 31:51 and so it's easy to i think to see and 31:55 understand how 31:56 government spending puts income into our 31:59 hands that 32:00 then allows us to be good consumers 32:02 right to have 32:03 robust consumption that then encourages 32:06 businesses because they see their 32:08 sales and their revenues and their 32:09 profits going up to say i gotta invest 32:12 in 32:12 some new equipment i gotta hire uh some 32:15 additional workers right 32:17 and so that's what i mean by by crowding 32:19 in but it's not that 32:20 only crowding in is possible it's just 32:23 that the usual narrative 32:24 about deficits are bad because they push 32:27 up interest rates and rising interest 32:28 rates 32:29 leads to less investment and less 32:30 investment leads to lower growth that i 32:32 think is very wrong 32:34 so when i read that or when i read the 32:37 deficit myth and i talked to you now 32:39 this all seems perfectly clear like this 32:43 is the you know you talk about the 32:44 moment of you know clarity 32:46 uh that people have when this kind of 32:48 clicks and it's clicked with me 32:50 because you've explained it so well but 32:54 why do you think i mean we we just don't 32:57 hear 32:58 it talked about this way by politicians 33:01 and definitely not in the media 33:04 um why do you think it is it continues 33:08 to be framed as 33:09 the national debt is a is a problem for 33:13 for the for america 33:16 well listen it you i had a colleague 33:20 back at my previous university his 33:21 name's bill black he's a law and 33:23 economics professor and bill used to 33:25 you used to refer to these things as uh 33:28 career limiting gestures 33:29 he would talk about bill was a 33:31 white-collar criminologist 33:33 okay so he went after a prosecuted 33:35 white-collar 33:36 crime uh and there are certain things 33:39 that 33:39 when you do them or say them uh they do 33:43 limit 33:43 your career potential and so he coined 33:46 this phrase career limiting gestures 33:48 uh you know it is very hard 33:52 to take a narrative that is a 33:54 significant departure 33:56 from the norm and you know you're 33:58 sticking your neck out 33:59 you're going against the mainstream 34:02 orthodox views on these things you're 34:04 rebutting 34:05 people with very fancy degrees from very 34:07 fancy universities sometimes nobel 34:09 prizes and so forth 34:11 and then what you're going to stand up 34:12 and make the counter argument 34:15 that we shouldn't be hysterical about 34:17 the long-term 34:18 trajectory of the debt to gdp ratio or 34:21 something and you want to try to soothe 34:22 and calm 34:23 and people will point to all the 34:24 expertise and say oh so they're all 34:26 wrong 34:26 right are they all wrong well there 34:28 aren't a lot of people 34:30 in you know journalists or other 34:32 academics 34:33 who i think are prepared to risk 34:37 it's a career limiting gesture you know 34:39 you you are risking 34:41 uh to some extent your credibility in 34:45 the eyes of those who 34:46 decide who's credible and who isn't so 34:51 it's a it's getting easier 34:54 i will say it's getting easier and i 34:56 think part of the reason it's getting 34:57 easier 34:58 is because all of the chicken littles 35:00 remember the fiscal hawks 35:02 and the fiscal doves have been telling 35:05 us 35:06 for decades that a debt crisis coming 35:08 attack crisis i just referred to the 35:10 washington post 35:11 piece all these top economists 35:14 all saying a debt crisis is coming they 35:17 said it 10 years ago 35:18 they said it five years ago they said it 35:20 three years ago they said it 20 years 35:21 ago 35:22 and it never happens and at some point 35:25 the credibility i think theirs 35:28 begins to be compromised because why do 35:32 you keep telling us 35:33 that all these terrible things are going 35:35 to happen because of deficits and debt 35:37 they don't happen and now we're watching 35:39 you folks in real time 35:41 change your own stories to try to fit 35:44 the 35:45 the empirics which are that interest 35:48 rates have gone down 35:49 not up as deficits exploded and the debt 35:52 went up you know all the stuff that you 35:54 warned about high 35:55 inflation and so forth it just the 35:57 reality is the opposite has happened 35:59 in almost every case so you're seeing 36:03 a lot of people softly 36:06 uh soften their own narrative right 36:09 they're trying to figure out how to 36:11 distance themselves 36:12 from their prior um statements about 36:15 this stuff 36:16 and and i think we're getting we're 36:18 making progress 36:21 definitely some progress but then you go 36:23 back and listen to 36:24 you know the media commentator media 36:26 commentators on 36:28 this coven stimulus bill this 1.9 36:31 trillion dollar 36:32 code stimulus mill a lot of people are 36:34 complaining about 36:35 how this is going to increase further 36:37 increase the national debt 36:39 and i think we're going to continue to 36:41 hear this or or 36:43 even worse as president biden puts 36:46 forward 36:47 his you know multi-trillion dollar 36:50 climate bill are you concerned that 36:53 democrats not republicans democrats 36:56 are going to give in to fears about 36:59 further increasing 37:00 the the debt and not vote for 37:03 an appropriately sized climate bill and 37:06 if so 37:07 how do we convince them otherwise 37:10 you bet i'm concerned i'm deeply 37:13 concerned we got 37:14 50 uh 50 votes in the senate 37:18 uh and you can't lose a single one and 37:21 um 37:23 you know yeah i'm concerned i saw 37:26 a comment just this morning i guess 37:29 senator manchin 37:30 did an interview i think with uh like 37:32 axios hbo or something like that and he 37:35 said 37:36 he's very excited about what comes next 37:39 after the covet relief comes the next 37:41 big package he said oh i'm super excited 37:43 about it 37:44 i've been wanting to do infrastructure 37:46 for a long time i think that 37:47 you know i'm i don't want to get rid of 37:48 the filibuster i think we can get 60 37:50 votes on this stuff 37:51 i think we can probably get 4 trillion 37:54 4 trillion uh but we got to pay for it 37:57 all we 37:58 100 of it we can we can pay for now 38:02 it doesn't pass the laugh test it just 38:04 doesn't the 38:05 the reality is i'm sorry but you're 38:08 never going to get 60 votes that means 38:11 10 republicans would have to if all the 38:13 democrats voted for it you'd need 10 38:15 republicans 38:16 and you're gonna propose um four 38:18 trillion or so 38:19 in spending on infrastructure and 38:22 infrastructure related investments 38:24 and you want to fully offset it with new 38:26 revenue 38:27 you're find me 10 republicans who are 38:29 going to vote for all those tax 38:30 increases they don't exist 38:32 and by the way i don't think that you 38:34 can find 50 38:35 democrats who will vote for the tax 38:38 increases to fully offset 4 trillion 38:40 so am i worried yes i'm i'm quite 38:43 worried how do we get them 38:45 to pass something well you ain't going 38:47 to get there with 60 votes 38:49 that's not a reality so you're going to 38:51 do it if it's going to be done at all 38:53 through reconciliation which is the same 38:56 process that was just used 38:58 to move the coveted relief 1.9 trillion 39:01 you use exactly the same uh process 39:05 budget reconciliation um you can do it 39:08 without offsetting all the spending 39:11 which means 39:12 you you could just commit the spending 39:14 you could offset some of it 39:15 maybe none of it uh we didn't offset 39:18 anything 39:19 from march of last year to march of this 39:21 year congress has just been doing 39:23 multi-trillion dollar 39:24 spending packages no offsets no 39:27 quote-unquote pay fors 39:28 no new taxes um how much more of that 39:32 would they be willing to do and you know 39:34 you just asked the million dollar 39:36 or trillion dollar question right which 39:39 is 39:40 um how do you get 39:43 congress to vote to pass these things 39:47 if some people are starting to find 39:49 their fiscal 39:50 um hawkish their inner fiscal hawk is 39:53 coming out 39:54 right and you know i hear democrats i've 39:56 heard 39:57 uh house members say at some point you 39:59 have to start paying for your spending 40:01 you can't 40:02 keep and this is what mmt is all about 40:06 mmt is all about helping us to ask and 40:09 answer the question 40:10 you know whether and when and how to 40:13 offset spending 40:15 because as long as there's some low 40:16 hanging fruit left 40:18 and low hanging fruit means the 40:20 government can 40:21 safely spend into the economy 40:25 without offsetting that spending by 40:27 higher taxes or cuts to some other part 40:30 of the budget 40:30 you can just spend the dollars and the 40:32 word safely is important 40:34 right because the low-hanging fruit 40:37 means that there's fiscal space 40:39 it means that there is enough room in 40:41 the budget 40:43 to allow you not in the budget i 40:44 shouldn't say it like that 40:46 it means that there is enough 40:50 slack in the economy that 40:54 you can spend money in without creating 40:57 inflationary problems so at some point 41:01 that fiscal space starts to diminish 41:04 and you have to know when you're running 41:07 out of low hanging fruit 41:08 and that's when the offsets become 41:10 important but my god 41:12 why pick an unnecessary fight you know 41:15 if there's some low hanging fruit and 41:17 you can come in 41:18 on the back of this relief package and 41:20 get a re recovery package in place 41:23 where you you know you can commit the 41:26 spending 41:27 without picking the secondary fight 41:30 which is the tax fight that's going to 41:32 make it 41:33 ten times harder to collect the votes 41:35 you need to pass the legislation 41:38 then you know why do that 41:41 you saw this firsthand both as chief 41:44 economist for the 41:45 democrats and the senate budget 41:47 committee but also 41:48 as you were serving as senator bernie 41:51 sanders economic adviser 41:53 during his 2020 presidential run um 41:56 obviously senator sanders 41:57 is a huge progressive and proponent of 42:01 government spending to make the lives of 42:03 americans 42:04 so much better but you know in the book 42:06 that even he gets the deficit problem 42:09 wrong 42:09 when he tries to fund these programs by 42:12 raising taxes i mean that's that's been 42:13 a big 42:14 part of his messaging did you see his 42:17 thinking 42:18 shift though on this um over your time 42:21 you know with him working with him 42:24 well not over my well look uh 42:29 it has shifted i think that the evidence 42:32 that it is 42:32 that it has shifted is that he is now 42:35 the chairman of the budget committee 42:37 i was once the chief economist for the 42:39 democrats on 42:40 the u.s uh senate budget committee and 42:42 he hired me for that 42:44 position and you're right in the book i 42:46 write about 42:47 some of what uh you know i witnessed in 42:51 2015-16 42:52 and then on the presidential campaigns 42:54 where let's be you know 42:55 let's recognize that every democratic 42:59 candidate 43:00 tried to pay for their entire agenda 43:02 there was enormous pressure to lay out a 43:04 blueprint 43:05 to say you wanted you want to do all of 43:07 these things these are your policy 43:09 proposals 43:09 show me how you're going to pay for it a 43:11 press would not have tolerated 43:13 anything less so that was the game 43:17 and everybody attempted to play it now 43:20 however uh he is chairman of the senate 43:23 budget committee 43:24 and he just helped to usher through the 43:26 reconciliation process 43:28 this 1.9 trillion dollar package with no 43:31 offsets 43:32 so you know he didn't hold it up saying 43:34 wait a minute 43:35 the deficit we have to offset the 43:37 spending we must pay for our things you 43:38 know he didn't do that right 43:40 so we're in a very different place today 43:44 compared to the way that and and that's 43:46 true 43:47 of house democrats as well uh 43:50 a lot has changed i think the trump tax 43:53 cuts 43:54 helped uh and when i say helped i mean 43:56 helped shift 43:57 democrats own thinking you know i used 44:00 to 44:00 i can remember going into more than one 44:02 meeting with members of congress 44:04 in just the last two years and sitting 44:07 down 44:08 and saying you know just kind of poking 44:09 fun and saying are you yet 44:11 tired of playing charlie brown to lucy 44:14 in the football i mean every time 44:16 they run the same play they get the 44:19 republicans get the house and the senate 44:20 and 44:21 and the white house and the deficit 44:23 concerns are out the window they pass 44:25 their agenda if it adds to the deficit 44:27 so be it they are laser focused on 44:30 passing their agenda democrats come in 44:32 and say oh 44:33 we're the fiscally responsible party we 44:36 hold ourselves to a different 44:38 and we think higher standard we pay for 44:40 our priorities 44:41 and then whoop lucy in the football 44:43 lucian you know 44:44 and and so i kind of tease them a little 44:48 bit and say are we 44:49 are is we learning you know are we are 44:51 we 44:52 figuring this stuff out uh and the good 44:55 news is that they are 44:56 and that's so much of the thinking uh 44:59 inside staffers and members of congress 45:01 it's 45:02 it has changed cove it helped change it 45:05 a lot more 45:06 good well senator sanders obviously a 45:08 supporter of the green new deal 45:10 and the green new deal calls for a 45:13 federal jobs guarantee which i was 45:15 really happy to see in your book that so 45:18 does 45:18 mmt so how would a federal jobs 45:21 guarantee work and 45:22 and what are some of the the potential 45:24 environmental benefits 45:27 yeah so a a federal job guarantee is 45:30 what it sounds like 45:31 right it is the federal government 45:33 guaranteeing 45:35 that anybody who wants to work but 45:38 can't find a job anywhere else in the 45:39 economy can always be assured 45:42 a job right at a basic wage and benefit 45:45 package 45:46 so a living think of a living wage and 45:48 benefit package 45:49 um and so it is a standing job offer 45:52 people hear about health care we hear 45:54 about sometimes a public option 45:56 in health care this is like a public 45:58 option in the labor market 46:00 right it's available to everyone it 46:01 doesn't go away it's a standing offer if 46:04 for any reason 46:06 uh you should want to be in that program 46:09 you can be in that program maybe you 46:10 have an 46:10 employer who constantly messes with your 46:13 hours you don't know from one day to the 46:15 next 46:15 you know what days you're supposed to 46:17 show up for work and what times when 46:19 you're trying to arrange 46:20 child care and it's just a nightmare and 46:21 you're making minimum wage or 46:23 whatever and you say i've had maybe i'm 46:25 being harassed at work maybe you know 46:27 for any reason you want into that 46:29 program 46:30 you have a job in that program federally 46:32 funded 46:33 locally administered so you ask about 46:36 how it relates to climate 46:37 what we imagine is that the jobs are 46:41 oriented 46:42 broadly around uh building a care 46:45 economy 46:46 so you're caring for people caring for 46:48 planet 46:49 caring for your community in one way or 46:51 another 46:52 all of the jobs should be oriented 46:56 to do one of you know contribute in one 46:58 of those three ways 46:59 so you know your imagination is kind of 47:02 the limit i 47:03 write some about this in the book i 47:05 co-authored 47:06 a report a few years ago for the levy 47:08 economics institute 47:10 i think it was called guaranteed 47:13 employment a pathway to full employment 47:15 there are 47:15 five or so of us authoring that we get 47:19 into a lot of detail there about the 47:21 kinds of jobs 47:22 and another mmt economist named pavlina 47:25 chernova 47:26 has a book that came out around the same 47:28 time as my book 47:30 hers is called the case for a federal 47:32 job guarantee 47:33 so i just want to point those out 47:35 because people who want more than i can 47:37 do in 47:38 a short time here might find it 47:40 interesting 47:41 but you know the communities themselves 47:44 they decide on the kinds of jobs that 47:47 they want 47:47 performed um you know you you think 47:50 about pavlina will sometimes talk about 47:52 uh invasive species and you know if 47:56 some people could be responsible for 47:57 monitoring invasive species and 48:00 why is that of benefit well because 48:02 farmers crops feed the rest of us and if 48:04 they are struggling uh with invasive 48:06 species and that sort of thing 48:08 climate you know tree planting we can 48:11 think 48:11 of of a million and one different things 48:14 that 48:15 people might propose that are valuable 48:18 that would be valuable to the community 48:20 that help us shore up uh coastal lines 48:23 clean up environmental cleanup community 48:26 gardens you can have neighborhood 48:27 beautification projects and 48:29 the really the sky is is sort of the 48:32 limit performing the the arts 48:34 you know when fdr was president and he 48:36 uh had a huge unemployment problem on 48:38 his hands and he came up with a similar 48:41 idea and he said we should just directly 48:43 put people to work we should employ them 48:45 and so we got an alphabet soup of jobs 48:48 programs we got the works progress 48:49 administration the civilian conservation 48:51 corps the national youth administration 48:53 a jobs program for young people 48:55 um the ccc was mostly environmental uh 48:59 oriented around environmental concerns 49:01 but workers in the wpa 49:03 uh program did everything from building 49:06 and construction oriented things to 49:09 uh oral histories recording oral 49:11 histories 49:12 uh performance art street performances 49:15 theater you know 49:16 i mean it was you can be very very 49:18 inclusive and 49:20 the idea is to take people as they are 49:23 and where they are right and to fit the 49:26 job 49:26 to the person with 49:30 two of the i'd say most talked about 49:32 solutions.

 T:

 49:34 to decarbonizing our electric 49:36 electricity grid 49:37 uh that have been put forth are a 49:39 federal clean energy standard 49:42 and a price on carbon um these solutions 49:45 either 49:45 you know require a reward they either 49:47 reward utilities 49:48 uh for for decarbonizing or they require 49:51 them to do it 49:52 um by switching over from these fossil 49:55 fuel burning assets to 49:56 clean energy assets right but you write 49:59 in the deficit myth 50:00 that both of these solutions have flaws 50:03 clean energy standard 50:04 may place a higher cost burden on 50:06 ratepayers and 50:08 carbon price may not push utilities to 50:11 act fast enough 50:12 so how does what would the mmt approach 50:15 be 50:16 to a you know to the federal government 50:18 solving this electricity decarbonization 50:20 problem 

Kelton:

50:21 well look i i'm not an environmental 50:24 economist 50:24 so i you know i point to some things in 50:27 the book you just read 50:28 a passage there um but i do try to stay 50:32 in my lane 50:33 i'm not trying to offer a solution or a 50:36 set of solutions that 50:38 are direct pathways to getting us to 50:40 where we need to be on climate i 50:42 uh definitely defer to climate experts 50:46 in this space and 50:47 you know i've done a number of talks on 50:49 uh the green new deal and that sort of 50:51 thing but my 50:52 area of expertise is on the mechanics of 50:54 the financing so 50:56 where i can be helpful i think is in 50:58 reminding 50:59 folks that it's about our real resources 51:02 that 51:02 if we have the technological know-how 51:05 and we have the real resources the money 51:07 can always be made available 51:08 and i think you know time is of the 51:10 essence and so 51:12 where so often we want to go slower 51:16 than we need to go proceed at a slower 51:18 pace 51:19 more incremental and so forth is because 51:22 of the budgetary concerns 51:24 and so again you know i where my area of 51:27 expertise can 51:28 be helpful in pushing us to where i hope 51:31 we will go 51:32 is with a bold ambitious action plan 51:36 to you know uh hold carbon emissions to 51:39 keep us within our carbon budget 51:41 to uh do the sort of things that climate 51:43 experts tell us we need to do 51:46 and i can help you know lay out 51:50 the the economic argument for why we can 51:53 afford 51:54 to move much more quickly that it's the 51:56 the real challenge is 51:58 managing the inflationary pressures yeah.

T:

 52:01 you mentioned the carbon budget 52:02 i mean we have real natural 52:06 constraints i mean the carbon budget the 52:09 amount of natural resources that we can 52:10 extract before 52:11 you know they no longer able to 52:13 regenerate themselves 52:14 do you think that there's a 52:15 responsibility among other economists 52:19 to recommend policy that that reflects 52:21 these 52:22 real natural constraints and talk in 52:24 these terms.

Kelton:

 52:26 yes and fortunately there are many good 52:29 ones out there i mean 52:30 you know kate raw worth uh mariana 52:33 matsukato both 52:34 of friends of mine kate with um 52:37 you know the donut economics is a book 52:40 that has 52:40 i think had a tremendous impact and 52:43 influences policy making 52:45 around the world you know you've got 52:47 cities and nations committing to trying 52:49 to 52:50 you know operate within the safe part of 52:52 what she calls the donut right not 52:54 pushing beyond the boundaries and also 52:56 not 52:56 uh doing things that would so deprive 52:59 you of 53:00 a good life but to keep you in that in 53:02 that safe place mariano with 53:04 her you know mission economy and the 53:07 entrepreneurial state 53:08 um naomi klein steve keane i mean 53:11 naomi's not an economist obviously but 53:13 you know has 53:14 done a lot of work here as an academic 53:16 as well steve keane an economist who 53:18 has really taken apart the nord house uh 53:21 nobel prize-winning economists work 53:23 on uh climate and and so forth and and 53:26 steve does great work and there are so 53:28 many others and 53:29 yes it's incumbent upon us because for 53:32 better or worse and it's usually 53:33 i'm afraid to say for worse economists 53:35 have an outsized voice 53:37 in the public debates they do you know 53:40 you will listen to a president 53:42 they don't often stand up and say well 53:43 leading sociologists tell us or leading 53:46 anthropologists say 53:47 it's always what economists are telling 53:49 us you know economists are saying so 53:51 we enjoy um 53:55 this you know status of somehow 53:58 being the ones who are supposed to know 54:00 and provide 54:01 you know the proper guidance to 54:03 policymakers and so forth so yes 54:05 it's important for economists to to do 54:08 the work to 54:08 step up to help push policy 54:12 thinking in that ambitious direction to 54:15 to allow leaders to see that 54:19 you know things are achievable because 54:20 so much of what they're presented with 54:22 from economists 54:23 is what you can't do it's why you can't 54:26 do things it's 54:27 you know the cost benefit analysis say 54:29 no or the cbo report says no or this 54:31 says no and you need people who are 54:34 willing and able to step forward and 54:37 push 54:38 back against those dominant themes that 54:42 well interest rates are going to prevent 54:43 it or markets will prevent it or 54:44 investors won't allow it or 54:46 something you got to be able to 54:47 demonstrate why those arguments are 54:49 are flawed.

T:

 we talked earlier about 54:52 america being one of the few countries 54:55 that has monetary sovereignty so does 54:58 that give us you think that gives us an 54:59 advantage when it comes to really 55:02 being leaders on the global scale or on 55:04 the global stage 55:05 for climate policy?

Kelton:

 well of course it 55:09 does but the us is not 55:11 one of i wouldn't say we're one of a few 55:13 um you know i mentioned australia 55:16 and canada new zealand the uk 55:20 japan i mean there are a lot of 55:22 countries 55:23 actually and we can include europe 55:27 as long as the ecb is a willing partner 55:31 because the european central bank is the 55:33 issuer of the currency 55:35 that is where you know if you have an 55:38 ecb willing to backstop in a sense 55:42 to to coordinate with and to allow the 55:45 19 countries 55:47 that compromise their sovereignty by 55:49 giving up their currencies and 55:51 adopting the euro if the ecb will um 55:55 will work as a partner with those 19 55:58 countries then you can include 56:00 you know europe uh as part of that and 56:02 now and you know it's most of the 56:04 the industrialized wealthy world and yes 56:08 they have uh an important role to play 56:11 and 56:11 they need to step up and um 56:15 and shoulder that their share of this 56:18 burden going forward .

T:

56:20 well the deficit myth really opened my 56:24 eyes to what is possible and it really 56:26 forced me to 56:27 to not only question what i what i 56:29 thought i knew about how our 56:31 economy works but also just reframe how 56:34 i think about 56:35 fiscal policy overall and i i cannot 56:38 recommend 56:38 this book anymore i mean so if you're 56:41 listening to this 56:42 please go out and get the deficit myth 56:44 it's available now and paperback and it 56:46 really is 56:47 an incredibly important book to read and 56:50 understand 56:50 and really use it as a tool in crafting 56:54 a more sustainable 56:55 and just future so dr kelton is is there 56:58 anywhere else 56:59 that our listeners can follow your work 57:01 online or on social media?

 

Kelton:

 57:03 well i'm on twitter uh that's about the 57:05 only social media platform i understand 57:08 and so it's the one i use 57:10 uh and i i tweet under the um name just 57:13 at stephanie kelton 57:14 um i i will write periodically for the 57:18 new york times and 57:19 outlets like that i've got a piece 57:20 coming out soon with the times 57:23 um but the twitter feed is where i would 57:24 share appearances in anything i write so.

T:

 57:29 well it is a fantastic book dr stephanie 57:32 kelton 57:33 thank you again for joining the climate 57:34 pod.

 

Kelton:

 thank you so much for having me 57:45   

 

 

JPアズちゃんねる将棋9+ビニールの道具#deficitmyth#modernmonetarytheory #keltonステファニー・ケルトン博士と一緒に地球を救うために赤字の神話を暴く26回放送•2021/04/22 40共有ポッド気候ポッドチャンネル登録者数24人#deficitmyth#modernmonetarytheory #kelton #climatechangeステファニー・ケルトン博士がショーに参加し、アメリカの政治家が国債を完全に誤解している方法と、連邦政府が財政政策を使用して公正で持続可能な社会を構築する方法について話し合います。彼女の著書「赤字神話」は、現代貨幣理論を説明し、アメリカが気候変動の解決策だけに多額の費用をかけることができ、またそうしなければならない理由を示しています。必ずTheClimate PodYouTubeチャンネルに登録してください。ケルトン博士をフィーチャーしたTheClimate Podの全エピソードをここで聞いてください:iTunes:https://podcasts.apple。com / us / podcast ... Spotify:https://open.spotify.com/episode/4v3f ... Climate Podは、ジャーナリスト、活動家、学者、アーティストとの最新の気候問題に関する毎週の会話です。物語の中心に。ソーシャルメディアでフォローしてください!Twitter:https://twitter.com/climatepod Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/climatepod/ Instagram:https://www.instagram.com/climatepod/新しいサブスタックニュースレター「The Climate Weekly ":https://theclimateweekly.substack.com/ウェブサイト:www.theclimatepod.com 0 00:12気候ポッドへようこそありがとうございます00:14私を持ってくれてありがとう00:15赤字の神話を読んだ後私は00:19アメリカが00:22に行くなら本当にステップを踏むと確信しています00:23 00時の気候危機に対処する:

 T:

 49:34私たちの電気を脱炭素化する49:36電力網49:37ええと、49:39連邦クリーンエネルギー基準49:42とこれらのソリューションの炭素の価格49:45どちらか49:45あなたが知っている49:47報酬ユーティリティ49:48ええと、脱炭素化のために彼らに報酬を要求するか、49:51これらの化石49:55燃料燃焼資産から49:56クリーンエネルギー資産に切り替えることによってそれを行うために49:52umを要求しますそうですが、赤字の神話で49:59と書いています50:00これらのソリューションには両方とも欠陥があります50:03クリーンエネルギー基準50:04は50:06の料金支払い者に高いコスト負担をかける可能性があり、50:08の炭素価格はプッシュしない可能性があります50:11へのユーティリティは十分に速く50:12に行動するので、mmtが50:15に近づくのはどのように50:16になるのか、連邦政府に知っている50:18この電力の脱炭素化50:20の問題を解決する 

ケルトン:

50:21よく見てください私は環境学者ではありません50:24エコノミスト50:24だから私は50:27であなたが読んだ本のいくつかのことを指摘していることを知っています私のレーンの50:3250:33私は解決策または50:36の解決策のセットを提供しようとはしていません。50:38は私たちが気候にいる必要がある50:40に到達するための直接的な経路です。 42ええと、間違いなく気候の専門家に任せてください50:46このスペースで50:47あなたは私が50:49ええとグリーンニューディールとそのような50:51のことで多くの話をしたことを知っていますが私の50:52エリア専門知識は50:54の資金調達の仕組みにあるので、私が役立つと思う50:56は50:58にあると思いますが、50:59の人々に、それは私たちの実際のリソースに関するものであることを思い出させます51:02私たちが持っている場合は51:02技術的ノウハウ51:05そして私達はお金51の本当の資源を持っています:07はいつでも利用可能にすることができます51:08そして私はあなたが時間を51:10の本質であると知っていると思いますそして51:12私達がより遅い51:18で進む必要があるよりも51:16遅く行きたいことがよくありますペース51:19の増分などは、予算の51:22が51:24に関係しているためです。また、51:27の専門分野の51:28が、51:28が希望する場所に私たちをプッシュするのに役立つことがわかります。 31私たちは行きます51:32は大胆な野心的な行動計画を持っています51:36あなたはええと51:39に炭素排出量を保持することを知っています私たちを私たちの炭素予算内に保ちます51:41ええと気候51:43専門家のようなことをします51:46を実行する必要があることを教えてください。51:50をレイアウトするのを手伝うことができます。51:53が51:56よりもはるかに高速に移動できる理由についての経済的な議論は、51:56が本当の課題です。 51:58ええインフレ圧力を管理します。08そして私はあなたが時間を51:10の本質であると知っていると思うので51:12私たちはより遅い51:18ペースで進む必要があるよりも51:16遅く行きたいことがよくあります51:19より増分など4つ目は、予算上の懸念の51:22が51:24であるためです。また、51:27の専門分野である51:28が、51:31に進むことを希望する場所に私たちをプッシュするのに役立つことがわかります。51:32は大胆な野心的な行動計画51:36で、炭素排出量を51:39に抑え、気候51:43の専門家が私たちに51:43を行う必要があると言っているようなことを行うために、私たちを炭素予算51:41の範囲内に保ちます。 46と私はあなたが51:50をレイアウトするのを助けることができますなぜ私たちが51:53が51:56よりもはるかに速く動くことができるのかについての経済的議論51:56本当の課題は51:58インフレ圧力を管理することですええ。08そして私はあなたが時間を51:10の本質であると知っていると思うので51:12私たちはより遅い51:18ペースで進む必要があるよりも51:16遅く行きたいことがよくあります51:19より増分など4つ目は、予算上の懸念の51:22が51:24であるためです。また、51:27の専門分野である51:28が、51:31に進むことを希望する場所に私たちをプッシュするのに役立つことがわかります。51:32は大胆な野心的な行動計画51:36で、炭素排出量を51:39に抑え、気候51:43の専門家が私たちに51:43を行う必要があると言っているようなことを行うために、私たちを炭素予算51:41の範囲内に保ちます。 46と私はあなたが51:50をレイアウトするのを助けることができますなぜ私たちが51:53が51:56よりもはるかに速く動くことができるのかについての経済的議論51:56本当の課題は51:58インフレ圧力を管理することですええ。12予算の51:22が51:24に関係しているため、51:16のペースを遅くする必要があるよりも、51:16のペースを遅くしたい場合があります。私の51:27の専門分野は、51:28が私たちを希望の場所に押し上げるのに役立つ可能性があります51:31私たちが行くことを願っています51:32は大胆な野心的な行動計画を持っています51:36あなたはええと51に炭素排出を保持することを知っています:39私たちを二酸化炭素排出量の範囲内に保つ51:41気候51:43の専門家が私たちに51:46を行う必要があると言っているようなことをするために、私はあなたが51:50の理由の経済的議論をレイアウトするのを助けることができます51:53は、51:56よりもはるかに速く移動する余裕があります。51:56本当の課題は、51:58インフレ圧力を管理することです。12予算の51:22が51:24に関係しているため、51:16のペースを遅くする必要があるよりも、51:16のペースを遅くしたい場合があります。私の51:27の専門分野は、51:28が私たちを希望の場所に押し上げるのに役立つ可能性があります51:31私たちが行くことを願っています51:32は大胆な野心的な行動計画を持っています51:36あなたはええと51に炭素排出を保持することを知っています:39私たちを二酸化炭素排出量の範囲内に保つ51:41気候51:43の専門家が私たちに51:46を行う必要があると言っているようなことをするために、私はあなたが51:50の理由の経済的議論をレイアウトするのを助けることができます51:53は、51:56よりもはるかに速く移動する余裕があります。51:56本当の課題は、51:58インフレ圧力を管理することです。19の増分などは、予算の51:22が51:24に関係しているためです。また、51:27の専門分野の51:28が、51:31を希望する場所に私たちをプッシュするのに役立つことがわかります。行く51:32は大胆な野心的な行動計画を持っています51:36あなたはええと51:39に炭素排出量を保持することを知っています私たちを私たちの炭素予算の範囲内に保つ51:41ええと気候51:43の専門家が私たちに言うようなことをする51:46を実行する必要があります。51:50をレイアウトするのを手伝うことができます。51:53が51:56よりもはるかに高速に移動できる理由についての経済的な議論は51:56です。本当の課題は51:58です。ええ、インフレ圧力を管理します。19の増分などは、予算の51:22が51:24に関係しているためです。また、51:27の専門分野の51:28が、51:31を希望する場所に私たちをプッシュするのに役立つことがわかります。行く51:32は大胆な野心的な行動計画を持っています51:36あなたはええと51:39に炭素排出量を保持することを知っています私たちを私たちの炭素予算の範囲内に保つ51:41ええと気候51:43の専門家が私たちに言うようなことをする51:46を実行する必要があります。51:50をレイアウトするのを手伝うことができます。51:53が51:56よりもはるかに高速に移動できる理由についての経済的な議論は51:56です。本当の課題は51:58です。ええ、インフレ圧力を管理します。36あなたはええと51:39に炭素排出量を保持することを知っています私たちを私たちの炭素予算の範囲内に保ちます51:41ええと気候51:43の専門家が私たちに51:46をする必要があると私たちに言うようなことをします51:50アウト51:53なぜ51:53が51:54をはるかに速く動かすことができるのかという経済的議論は、51:56が本当の課題は51:58インフレ圧力を管理することです。36あなたはええと51:39に炭素排出量を保持することを知っています私たちを私たちの炭素予算の範囲内に保ちます51:41ええと気候51:43の専門家が私たちに51:46をする必要があると私たちに言うようなことをします51:50アウト51:53なぜ51:53が51:54をはるかに速く動かすことができるのかという経済的議論は、51:56が本当の課題は51:58インフレ圧力を管理することです。

T:

 52:01あなたは炭素収支について言及しました52:02私たちは本当の自然の制約があることを意味します52:06私は炭素収支を意味します52:13自分自身を再生することができます52:14他のエコノミストの間で52:15の責任があると思いますか52:21これらの52:22の本当の自然の制約を反映するポリシーを推奨し、52:24これらの用語で話します。

ケルトン:

 52:26はい、幸いなことにたくさんの良い52:29があります52:30あなたはケイト生の価値を知っていますええとマリアナ52:33松加藤両方52:34私の友人のケイトとええと52:37あなたはドーナツを知っています経済学は52:40の本です52:40は途方もない影響を与えたと思いますそして52:43は世界中の政策立案に影響を与えます52:47あなたが52:49を試みることにコミットしている52:47の都市と国を持っていることを知っています52:50あなたが知っている52:52の安全な部分の中で動作するのは彼女がドーナツと呼んでいるものです52:54境界を越えて押すのではなく52:56ええと52:59あなたから53を奪うようなことをしている:00良い人生ですが、53:02に安全な場所のマリアーノと53:04の彼女は、ミッション経済と53:07の起業家精神を知っています53:08 um naomi klein stevekeaneつまり53:11naomiはそうではありません明らかに経済学者ですが53:13あなたが知っている53:14はここで学者として多くの仕事をしました53:16そして53:18が実際に北の家を分解した経済学者をスティーブキーン53:21ノーベル賞を受賞した経済学者は53:23に取り組んでいますええと、気候などと53:26スティーブは素晴らしい仕事をしていて、53:28は他にもたくさんあり、53:29はい、53:32は良くも悪くも、通常は53:33なので、私たちの責任です。悪い経済学者のために言うのを恐れて53:35彼らが知っている公開討論で53:37特大の声を持っている53:40あなたは大統領に耳を傾ける53:42彼らはしばしば立ち上がってよく言う53:43リード社会学者は私たちに言うか、53:46人類学者は53:47と言います53:49それは常に経済学者が言っていることです53:49あなたは経済学者が言っていることを知っています58は54:00を知り、54:01を提供することになっているので、54:03の政策立案者などに適切なガイダンスを知っているのでそうです54:05エコノミストが54:08から54までの作業を行うことが重要です。 08ステップアップして、ポリシー54:12をその野心的な方向に54:15にプッシュし、リーダーが54:19に提示されたものの多くが54:22であるため、54:19が達成可能であることを確認できるようにします。エコノミスト54:23はあなたができないことですそれはあなたが54:26ができないことをする理由ですそれは54:27あなたは費用便益分析が54:29いいえと言うかcboレポートがいいえと言うかこの54:31がいいえと言うことを知っていますそして、54:34は進んで前進し、54:37は54:38を押し戻し、54:42の高金利は54:43を阻止する、または市場はそれを阻止する、または54 :44人の投資家が勝ちますそれを許可するか、54:47にできるようになった54:46の何かが、なぜそれらの議論が54:49であるのかを示しています。

T:

 先ほど、54:52アメリカが金銭的主権を持っている数少ない国の1つであると話しましたが、54:58は、実際に55:02がリーダーであるということになると、54:59のアドバンテージを与えてくれると思います。世界規模ですか、それとも55:04に気候政策の世界的な段階55:05ですか?

ケルトン:

 もちろん、55:09はそうですが、私たちは55:11ではありません。私たちが55:13であるとは言えませんが、オーストラリア55:16とカナダニュージーランド英国55:16について言及しました。 20 japanつまり、55:22の国がたくさんあるということです55:23実際には、欧州中央銀行が55:33の発行者であるため、ecbが喜んでパートナーである55:31である限り、ヨーロッパ55:27を含めることができます。通貨55:35それはあなたが55:49までに彼らの主権を危うくする55:4519カ国55:47と調整しそして許可するためにある意味で55:42バックストップすることをいとわない55:38ecbを持っているかどうかあなたが知っているところです彼らの通貨をあきらめ、55:51がユーロを採用する場合、ECBは55:55がそれらの19の55:58の国とのパートナーとして機能します、そしてあなたはその一部としてヨーロッパを知っている56:00と56:02を含めることができます今、あなたはそれが56のほとんどであることを知っています:04工業化された裕福な世界、そしてそうです56:08彼らは56:11と56:11を演じるのに重要な役割を担っています。そして、56:15にステップアップし、この56:18の負担の分担を今後負担する必要があります。

T:

56:20まあ、赤字の神話は本当に私の56:24の目を開いて、何が可能かを考えました。56:26は、56:29が私たちの56:31について知っていると思ったことだけでなく、56:27に私を強制しました。経済は機能しますが、56:34私は56:35の財政政策について全体的に考えていますが、56:38はもうこの本を56:38推奨することはできません。 56:44現在入手可能でペーパーバックです。56:46は本当に56:47読むのに非常に重要な本であり、56:50は56:50を理解し、56:54を作成するためのツールとして実際に使用します。より持続可能な56:55そしてちょうど未来なので、ケルトン博士は56:58他のどこかに56:59あり、リスナーはあなたの仕事をオンラインまたはソーシャルメディアでフォローできますか?

 

ケルトン:

 57:03ええと、私はツイッターにいます。57:05だけのソーシャルメディアプラットフォームです。57:08を理解しているので、57:10ええと、ステファニーケルトンで57:13という名前でツイートします。 57:14 um iiは、57:18ニューヨークタイムズと57:19アウトレットについて定期的に書き込みます。57:23 umのタイムズで、57:20が間もなくリリースされますが、Twitterフィードは私が行う場所です。 57:24私がそう書いたものは何でも出演を共有します。

T:

 57:29それは素晴らしい本です。ステファニー博士57:32

ケルトン

57:33気候57:34ポッドに参加していただきありがとうございます。

 

0 件のコメント:

コメントを投稿