| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Global Inflation Today: What Is to Be Done?
Friday, December 2: 9:30am to 5:30pm
Saturday, December 3: 9:00am to 3:00pm
Gordon Hall, Third Floor Conference Room
Participants:
Eileen Appelbaum, Michael Ash, Kate Bahn, Nelson Barbosa Filho, Josh Bivens, Hanae Bouazza, CP Chandrasekhar, Hasan Comert, Gerald Epstein, Lawrance Evans, Tom Ferguson, James Galbraith, Jayati Ghosh, James Heintz, Marc Jarsulic, Robert Kuttner, Jesus Lara, Mike Madowitz, Josh Mason, Aaron Medlin, Ozlem Onaran, Robert Pollin, Gregor Semieniuk, Jae Sim, William Spriggs, Servaas Storm, Isabella Weber
>> Click here for conference event page
Breakfast and lunch served onsite, breakfast starting at 8:30am on 12/2 and 8:00am on 12/3.
For more information, contact Nicole Dunham at .
~~~
https://youtu.be/gQoTYRiH0Bk
Isabella Weber,
0:04:00~0:29:20






okay hello everyone my name is kevin harris i'm a professor in sociology at the university of california los angeles hello from los angeles welcome to this event on the politics of inflation uh it's a excellent panel and on behalf of my colleagues ck lee and robert brenner i'd like to welcome everyone to the center for social theory and comparative history here at ucla if you are not uh following us on various social media we have social media accounts that are more active these days and um almost all of our panels that are zoom presented end up on our youtube page including the panel we held on april 4th the political economy of russia's war in ukraine which was a why they attended an excellent panel so as was in the financial times yesterday morning the headlines are routinely covering the topic of inflation or even worse the um possibility of stagflation meaning low growth and high inflation prompting all kinds of handwringing from different sectors of the [Music] of the economic elite so um given that uh alongside discussion of inflation in in headline news and discussion by the federal reserve about what to do about it there's been a robust debate about drivers of inflation drawing both on um you know heterodox economics as well as historical comparative accounts of driver's inflation across space and time so you know we're very excited to have a panel today of speakers on the topic given that you know the term itself is thrown around as an excuse uh to engage in all types of policy uh proposals so let me introduce the speakers uh and our discussant and remind everyone that everyone in the room right now is a participant in our panel uh and after the speakers and our discussant uh we'll open it up for q a and you'll be able to share uh your video if you like and ask questions uh via audio to our participants um so we're looking forward to that our panel uh is uh very excited to have uh our speakers today uh first step is going to be professor isabella webber uh she's a political economist um an assistant professor of economics at the university of massachusetts amherst she's the author of 2021's how is china escaped shock therapy the market reform debate which is winner of the joan robinson prize um and is being translated into numerous languages as i can attest next we are going to have uh a presentation by tim barker who's finishing up his phd in history at harvard he's on the editorial board of phenomenal world uh kind of uh blog out of the out of the bagrun institute think tank uh and dissent uh and actually last year he wrote an excellent essay called preferred shares inflation of wages in the 50-year crisis uh on phenomenal world and then our discussion is going to be ucla's alum aaron banana who's an economic historian and social theorist currently aaron is a postdoc at humble university but he's an incoming assistant professor at the department of sociology at the maxwell's and the maxwell school at syracuse university and he is the author of the equally well translated automation and the future of work which came out in 2020 on verso so we're going to have presentations by isabella and then tim and then a discussion by aaron and then we'll open up to the audience and i'll be moderating uh thanks to bob and ck for co-organizing this panel and to roman ivani our graduate student organizer as well who's going to be running behind the scenes so let's get started with isabella welcome.
オーケー、こんにちは皆さん、私の名前はケビン・ハリスです。私はカリフォルニア大学ロサンゼルス校の社会学の教授です。ロサンゼルスからこんにちは。インフレの政治に関するこのイベントへようこそ。ええと、それは素晴らしいパネルであり、同僚の ck lee と robert を代表してブレナー ここ ucla の社会理論と比較歴史センターに皆さんを歓迎したいと思います。さまざまなソーシャル メディアで私たちをフォローしていない場合は、ソーシャル メディア アカウントが最近より活発になっています。 4 月 4 日に開催したロシアの政治経済に関するパネルを含むズーム プレゼンテーションが YouTube ページに表示されます。ウクライナでの戦争が、彼らが優れたパネルに参加した理由であり、昨日の朝のファイナンシャル タイムズと同様に、見出しは日常的にインフレのトピックを取り上げています。さらに悪いことに、スタグフレーションの可能性は、低成長と高インフレを意味し、あらゆる種類の面倒を引き起こしています。経済エリートの [音楽] のさまざまなセクターから、ええと、ヘッドライン ニュースでのインフレに関する議論と、連邦準備制度理事会によるそれについてどうするかについての議論に加えて、ええと、両方に引き寄せられたインフレの要因について活発な議論があったことを考えるとあなたは異端の経済学と、空間と時間にわたるドライバーのインフレの歴史的な比較説明を知っているので、私たちは知っています.今日、このトピックに関するスピーカーのパネルを開催できることに非常に興奮しています。この用語自体が、あらゆる種類の政策提案に関与するための言い訳として投げかけられていることを知っているので、スピーカーと討論者を紹介し、皆さんに次のことを思い出させてください現在この部屋にいる全員が私たちのパネルの参加者です。講演者と討論者の後、QA のために公開します。必要に応じてビデオを共有したり、音声で質問したりできます。参加者の皆さん、私たちのパネリストはとても楽しみです。今日の講演者は非常に興奮しています。最初のステップは、イザベラ ウェバー教授です。彼女は政治経済学者であり、マサチューセッツ大学の経済学の助教授です。 amherst 彼女は 2021 年の著者です」中国はどのようにしてショック療法を免れたのか ジョーン・ロビンソン賞を受賞した市場改革論争は、私が証明できるように、多くの言語に翻訳されています 次に証明できるように、歴史の博士号を取得しているティム・バーカーによるプレゼンテーションがあります.ええと、驚異的な世界について、そして私たちの議論は、経済史家であり社会理論家であるUCLAのミョウバンであるアーロン・バナナになります。現在、アーロンは謙虚な大学のポスドクですが、マクスウェルの社会学科の次期助教授です.S とシラキュース大学のマクスウェル スクールであり、彼は 2020 年に出版された同様によく翻訳された「automation and the future of work」の著者でもあります。そして、私たちは聴衆に門戸を開いて、モデレーターを務めます。このパネルを共同開催してくれた bob と ck と、大学院生のオーガナイザーである roman ivani に感謝します。イザベラとようこそ
0:02okay hello everyone my name is kevin harris i'm a professor in sociology at the
0:08university of california los angeles hello from los angeles welcome to this event on the politics of
0:14inflation uh it's a excellent panel and on behalf of my colleagues ck lee and robert
0:22brenner i'd like to welcome everyone to the center for social theory and comparative history here at ucla
0:28if you are not uh following us on various social media we have social media accounts that are
0:34more active these days and um almost all of our panels that are zoom presented end up on
0:41our youtube page including the panel we held on april 4th the political economy of russia's war in ukraine which was a
0:48why they attended an excellent panel so as was in the financial times yesterday
0:54morning the headlines are routinely covering the topic of inflation or even
1:00worse the um possibility of stagflation meaning low growth and high inflation prompting all
1:07kinds of handwringing from different sectors of the [Music] of the economic elite
1:14so um given that uh alongside discussion of inflation in in
1:20headline news and discussion by the federal reserve about what to do about it there's been a robust debate
1:26about drivers of inflation drawing both on um you know heterodox economics as well
1:32as historical comparative accounts of driver's inflation across space and time
1:39so you know we're very excited to have a panel today of speakers on the topic given that you
1:45know the term itself is thrown around as an excuse uh to engage in all types of policy uh
1:52proposals so let me introduce the speakers uh and our discussant and remind everyone that
1:58everyone in the room right now is a participant in our panel uh and after the speakers and our discussant
2:06uh we'll open it up for q a and you'll be able to share uh your video if you
2:11like and ask questions uh via audio to our participants um
2:16so we're looking forward to that our panel uh is uh very excited to have uh our speakers today uh first step is
2:23going to be professor isabella webber uh she's a political economist
2:29um an assistant professor of economics at the university of massachusetts amherst she's the author of 2021's how is china
2:37escaped shock therapy the market reform debate which is winner of the joan robinson
2:43prize um and is being translated into numerous languages as i can attest
2:49next we are going to have uh a presentation by tim barker who's finishing up his phd in history at
2:54harvard he's on the editorial board of phenomenal world uh kind of uh blog out
3:00of the out of the bagrun institute think tank uh and dissent uh and actually last
3:06year he wrote an excellent essay called preferred shares inflation of wages in the 50-year crisis uh on phenomenal world
3:13and then our discussion is going to be ucla's alum aaron banana who's an economic historian
3:20and social theorist currently aaron is a postdoc at humble university but he's an
3:25incoming assistant professor at the department of sociology at the maxwell's and the maxwell school
3:32at syracuse university and he is the author of the equally well translated
3:37automation and the future of work which came out in 2020 on verso
3:42so we're going to have presentations by isabella and then tim and then a discussion by aaron and then
3:49we'll open up to the audience and i'll be moderating uh thanks to bob and ck for co-organizing this panel
3:56and to roman ivani our graduate student organizer as well who's going to be
4:02running behind the scenes so let's get started with isabella welcome
4:10thanks so much for having me this is exceedingly exciting thank you so much to the organizing team and to this kind
4:18invitation it's hard to think of a more pressing issue these days and as someone who has
4:24mainly worked historically it's very thrilling to try to make sense of an issue that is really at the edge of our
4:30time my talk is titled politics and economics of the post shutdown inflation and i'm
4:38basically trying to address the three broad questions which is what drives
4:43inflation how can we make sense of this inflationary dynamic secondly what are the social and political implications of
4:50this inflation i'm looking both at the us and internationally and thirdly what
4:55can be done and i'm saying here some thoughts because i think it's really a very very difficult question has to be
5:01acknowledged as such which requires for us to have an open debate about what can be done rather than to
5:08revert to some sort of standard answers of one kind or another
5:15i'm proposing what i'm here preliminarily calling a caldorian baratheon perspective as a framework to
5:23make sense of the inflationary dynamic kaido famously had two pricing regimes
5:29the first for for the raw materials sector where he basically sees the raw material or commodity sector as the
5:37marshallian kind of sector or supply and demand in the world commodity markets
5:42would be determining prices since the adjustment of supply in these
5:50very very capital intensive sectors is very slow this means that you have inherently
5:57volatile prices which resides in a constant destabilizing dynamic
6:04both for the economies of the global north and the global south so both for the economies that are highly commodity
6:11dependent as well as for the economies that are importing these raw materials
6:17for their industrial um production thinking broadly speaking in in in a
6:24north-south kind of view of the world the second pricing regime is that for
6:30the industrial sector where the basic rule is one of cost plus markup pricing
6:37the idea is that you have very highly concentrated sectors large corporations that are basically more or less planning
6:44their production um in in kaidor's time yet not yet in international um uh uh
6:50supply networks but nevertheless in highly concentrated sectors where an increase in cost
6:57induces an increase in prices so in other words in other words cost increases are handed down to consumers
7:06and these cost increases tend to be more than the initial cost increase since
7:11firms are hedging their profit margins against future increases so there's an
7:16assumption if raw material prices are going up then they tend to keep going up for a while so since industrial firms
7:24are only setting their prices relatively infrequently they price in future cost
7:30increases in their price increases that being said in quote unquote normal
7:37or stable times an increase in demand does not increase
7:42and does not induce an increase in prices in cairo's thinking
7:47instead an increase in demand resides in an increase in supply to satisfy this
7:54demand so a quantity response which means that the prices are largely
7:59stable as long as these firms can respond to an increased demand by simply increasing
8:07their capacity utilization and in fact in many ways in our just
8:12entire production network's word that we have inherited and that seems to be crumbling in front of our eyes
8:19um this logic of just in time increase in supply was if anything stronger than
8:26it would have been in kaidor's times so in many ways be while these trust and
8:32time production networks were working as they were designed to work efficiently um and swiftly they were basically even
8:40more sensitive to increases in demand than um the old kind of model however in
8:46the older model that slower responsiveness would have been compensated with inventories whereas now
8:53inventories tend to be lower than in the world that kaido was describing
8:59for the industrial sector i think we can extend the kaidorian view
9:04with call breaths analysis of inflation where goldberg points out that
9:10corporations always have a latent tendency to use their market power in
9:16order to take advantage of opportunities that arise in order to increase prices
9:21and thus increase um profits however without any kind of pretext if a firm
9:29unilaterally increases prices in normal times this would be to their
9:35disadvantage in terms of their market position or in other words they would harm their competitive
9:41position this is why sector riot events serve as some sort of a legitimation and
9:48coordination device for price hikes and the example that goldberg gave was that
9:54wage rises um result in price rises not because
9:59there's some sort of a universal economic law that waged increases always
10:04must reside in increases in prices in fact ricardo of course argued exactly
10:09the opposite but rather because union sectoral bargaining
10:16creates a pre-tax for the whole sector to increase its prices which means that
10:21they are coordinatedly increasing prices which means that one firm increasing prices will not harm its competitive
10:28position towards another firm now in the context that we are living in
10:35i think we can think of the cost push dynamic that we have observed together
10:40with the broken supply chains as such a pretext that functions in a similar kind
10:45of way as what golbrath describes for union
10:50bargaining agreements for whole sector of course we have to add in terms of the
10:56institutional environment shareholder premise primacy and and the role of asset managers as a new kind of
11:02institutional context which to some degree can also function as a sector
11:08sectoral coordinating kind of dynamic the argument that i'm making in a
11:15nutshell is then that there is a cost push dynamic from increased commodity
11:20prices which started long before the war and has accelerated sharply since
11:27secondly that supply chain issues imp impede the supply adjustments that we
11:33would be seeing in normal times where an increase in demand or even a falling
11:39short of supply in relation to demand would be compensated for by an expansion
11:45of demand so therefore the same mechanisms that before the crisis
11:50created pretty stable and often even slightly falling prices now reside in a
11:57dynamic that creates increasing prices commodity price increases in broken
12:03supply chains then present a pretext for synchro synchronized price increases
12:10across sectors where you basically have a switch from competition over increased market shares
12:17to competition over short-term price hikes which intensifies some
12:23pre-pandemic trends of shareholder and asset manager primacy
12:28initially this was i think predominantly a sanctorial story a story of specific
12:35price increases however as these profit and price hikes have become more
12:40widespread it seems that we are entering more and more into a generalized dynamic
12:45of price increases and profit hikes so far price increases have largely been
12:52accommodated by demand in particular prices of many goods for
12:57which demand is relatively inelastic have been going up things like fuel food
13:02and shelter and their consumers or
13:07i mean whatever you want to call people who are demanding these things um naturally don't have a lot of
13:14bigger room to escape so in other words in some sense forced to accommodate
13:19these kind of price increases so in some sense i'm presenting here a
13:25story that is predominantly supply driven highly institutionally dependent and at the
13:33same time one that can reside in a in a
13:39spiraling dynamic that is fairly difficult to control
13:46i'm now going to zoom in a little bit in into some data um i realized that tim also has some of this of some similar
13:54data um in his presentation so i hope that overlap won't be um too much
13:59so first of all i think it's important to acknowledge that even though we have now all started to talk about commodity
14:05prices the commodity price increases predate the war and this is the case not
14:10only for the energy index this is your imf data but also for things like food
14:16but also important industrial inputs such as metals so we can see here that the non-fuel index also had a pretty
14:23sharp increase not quite as sharp as the energy index but nevertheless pretty intense increases
14:30and this has been the case for a whole range of important industrial inputs
14:36then of course as we are all aware in the context of the war this um these commodity price increases have have just
14:44gone through the roof so famously in early march there was this weekly price on
14:50largest weekly rise on record and importantly um food prices have just
14:55are basically skyrocketing now most of the discussion around these
15:03increasing commodity prices um is some has some implicit assumptions on
15:10input output relationships but i have seen very very little work that actually looks at these input output
15:16relationships and this is something that i've started doing um i'm still at the very beginning since the data is just
15:22coming out and so on and this is work um jointly with a number of co-authors
15:28so on the left-hand side here you can see a scatter plot of industries um ranked based on their upstreamness on
15:35the horizontal axis where upstream has very loosely speaking basically measures
15:41um to how for how many industries good is an input and how important of an
15:47input it is so if you compare for example um a a a
15:53chocolate and oh then chocolate would be much much more downstream than than oil
15:58because oil is of course an input to many more things than chocolate so um the further out you get the more you
16:05get into stuff like oil the further um to the left the more you get into stuff
16:11like chocolate and on the um vertical axis here i've plotted um the the yearly um price
16:17changed in in 2020 to 2021 for quarter four
16:23and we can see that some industries stand out so for example for oil and gas extraction um we have very high
16:30upstreamness and very high priced increase above 60 similarly for primary methods but also
16:36for importantly transportation both products fabricated matters and a range
16:42of other upstream goods now what one can do with input output
16:47models is to estimate what the impact of such upstream price increases on the
16:53consumer price index would be and there's basically a direct impact and an indirect impact where the direct
17:00impact is for example if you take if you take fuel is the impact on the
17:05fuel price that you get at the gas station but then there's of course also a very large indirect impact because
17:12pretty much everything that we are consuming has a component of um fuel and we have now started to rank um
17:19industries by their combined cpi impact taking account of the of the indirect
17:26and direct effects and what we can see is that petroleum and coal products are of course the
17:31first and most important industry utilities more generally are incredibly important
17:37chemical products housing because of the very large direct effect
17:42food beverages and tobacco so these are the top five industries which basically
17:49have enormous impacts on the cpi even though we would not be thinking of them immediately if we think about consumer
17:56prices okay um when prices go up in in such a way um
18:03on the commodity markets there are of course always some winners so you can see here on the upper left hand side a
18:10graph where we are plotting the input prices and output prices um for for oil
18:16and gas extraction and you can see that the output price is um shooting up um
18:22towards the end of the graph here um and this is only for 2021 so we we haven't
18:27even included the 2022 ukraine war contacts prices yet um and
18:33this increase is much larger than the increase in input prices which of course means that someone must be reaping that
18:40difference and in fact as the profit numbers are readily coming out we can see that the oil um the fossil fuel
18:48industry has um has uh of course benefited massively from this but this
18:53does not only go for fossil fuel this also goes for grains so for example the um the giant corporation cargill had the
19:01best year in 156 years in 2021 this is from august
19:062021 so before the price explosions in the context of the ukraine and russian
19:11war and um similarly this family i mean relatedly this family
19:17now has actually ascended to some of the richest people in the world um in this context i think the
19:24groundwork collaborative should really be mentioned here since they have done relentless work to um scan through skim
19:31through earnings calls and have basically shown that around across a whole range of sectors we can find again
19:38and again this story that there's a broad-based passing on of cost increases
19:44which is completely consistent with the kaidorian story that i have presented and also
19:49proud announcements of profit increases that go beyond the increase in costs
19:55which then reside in price hikes and profit hikes in fact also if we look at studies as for example by mckinsey and
20:01company we can find consulting documents that promise
20:07to win the race with inflation the pricing opportunity for industrial companies to increase prices more than
20:13cost so within the business world if we look closely this is pretty explicit
20:19we can also see this in the national income data so this is here plotting profits
20:26with inventory adjustment um after tax on
20:32in the upper part and before tax in the lower part which um you will see that
20:37obviously the tax rates have declined dramatically which makes the before tax distribution
20:45look a little bit less dramatic in terms of the increase in profit margins but if we do care what ends up in in corporate
20:54balance sheets at the end of the day so if we do care about after tax then we can see that basically profit margins
21:00are as high as they haven't been since the immediate um post-war period
21:06there is an interesting curiosity in the data which is that basically the inventory
21:12adjustment became very large in 2021 which i think is pretty consistent with
21:18the theoretical framework that i've presented for you where basically as supply chains started to become unstable
21:26corporations have switched to some sort of auctioning of the inventories which means that in while in normal times we
21:33want to extract the value of inventories from our accounting for profits in the particular 2021 context the very sharp
21:42increase in prices for inventories was actually part of the story of inflation
21:48this erases the question of historical analogies and of course there has been a lot of debate around this i personally
21:55have been arguing in agreement with the white house council of economic advisers that
22:01there's some parallel with the inflationary episode after world war ii when price controls were re
22:07released and um basically there was a relatively strong demand thanks to savings during the war and there were
22:14very widespread supply chain issues which resided in inelastic supply and
22:20relatively high demand which resided in windfall profits in the shooting app of specific prices however as all
22:27historical analogies this is an imperfect historical analogy since overlapping with this we have this
22:34very widespread commodity price explosion which has some resemblance
22:40with the oil shock in the 1970s but it's not just about oil but it's really very very very broad based and then unlike
22:47after the war um in in 1946 47 ambiance
22:52of course at the beginning of a war so um we are not and the pandemic is also not over so in that sense we are in a
23:00much more erratic kind of scenario than this clear end of the war post-war um
23:05inflation boom and then sharp downturn as regards the outlook i'm rather
23:12pessimistic and i think we have to recognize that the increasing cost pressures from these
23:20enormous increases in raw material prices and continuously breaking supply
23:25chains i mean china is only now entering into forward 19 shutdowns
23:30is only about to percolate through the system and then it might well be the case that um cost increases are so sharp
23:38that not the whole cost increase can be passed on which could result in us in a
23:44situation where even though prices are con continue to be increased by firms
23:50they nonetheless end up seeing diminishing margins which could add to its deflationary dynamic
23:59um being mindful of time i just very quickly um skip through this so
24:05basically we see that income inflation specific inflation impacts in the united states have been
24:11to the detriment of lower income groups not only have they seen higher inflation rates
24:17but also lower income groups and middle-income curbs and were less
24:23able to make up for increased inflation with higher earnings
24:28this i think is politically extremely explosive and i think that what happened with the pension could really stand as a
24:35warning for all of us where basically her catch up in the last months has been
24:40driven by her capitalizing on the cost of living crisis
24:46the food price crisis is a global enormous crisis i think has to be taken
24:52absolutely seriously not least because of the enormous
24:57explosive nature of such um of of of of these food price increases but of course
25:03also simply because the u.n has been warning of an imminent famine and starvation
25:09so what is to be done rising interest rates seems to be the default option that economists revert to
25:17however this is of course based on inducing economic hardship by lowering aggregate demand basically by trying to
25:24manufacture unemployment i personally think that it's more likely that this policy will succeed in manufacturing
25:31unemployment but will not necessarily succeed in bringing down inflation since inflation is coming from this massive
25:38cost push dynamic it would also likely be detrimental to investments where
25:44investments would be what we need to fix some of the issues that have come up in those prices
25:50importantly rising interest rates is extraordinarily dangerous for the global
25:55south and might well produce a debt crisis um on on a scale that is simply
26:02terrifying and if we take this together with the looming um uh food security
26:08crisis then i think this this should really make us think twice
26:13income transfers in rich countries are of course nice and welcome however they
26:18do not stop the inflationary dynamic went for profits tax and anti-trust are
26:24important policy tools but they tend to be retroactive and they're really in an emergency situation so in many ways we
26:31would need to act quickly food aid and loans programs to the develop to developing countries
26:37can play an important role in buffering um the impact of the rising um food prices
26:43however the terms of such loans would be absolutely crucial since in particular
26:49if we see rising interest rates it seems the likely outcome then we don't want to
26:56further exacerbate the already looming debt crisis i think that the stabilization of global
27:01commodity markets should have happened before one imposes sanctions on the scale in which they have been imposed
27:08um and of course stocks have been released um in the realm of oil but much more would
27:14need to be done in the rearm of food and also in the realm of of oil and metals and other basic commodities and
27:22um we would need to think about measures that can limit market fluctuations in the context of this enormous volatility
27:29that we have observed the eu commission has recommended gas price a gas price control plan on the european level
27:37which is an interesting proposal price caps for basic needs in essential
27:43rearms could also play a role where as regards co2 intensive goods such as fuel
27:50one could think of a sliding scale where basically some sort of basic consumption need is
27:57covered at a low price but then the more you consume the higher the price gets
28:02so that those who are consuming much um have to pay a very high price that reflects the high environmental costs
28:09from a long run perspective i think we really need to think about uh regimes that can stabilize global commodity
28:16prices um one idea that has been around for a very long time the idea of global
28:22buffer stocks and finally in uh and relatedly as regards supply chains i
28:28personally don't think that trying to rip supply chains apart in the middle of
28:34this enormous crisis would be a good idea but rather that global coordination
28:39is necessary in order to stabilize supply chains in some um i am of the opinion that um
28:46that inflation is an enormously difficult um challenge and that it has
28:51to be taken seriously and that we really need a broad discussion around different
28:57tools and how they can can can can be part of the broader
29:02policy response rather than to search for some sort of one magic bullet or to
29:08revert to knee-jerk reactions based on some sort of one standard model or
29:14another thank you very much thank you
29:21thanks isabella so let's turn it over to tim barker um
29:27who's gonna follow up tim are you are you ready yeah are there slides showing up
29:32you got it yeah okay
29:41okay um well thanks kevin and uh rowan and uh everyone at the center uh for bringing
29:47this

