2021年10月3日日曜日

ピケティとチャーネバ 2021/10/05 Thomas Piketty & Pavlina Tcherneva Pavlina R Tchernevaさんのツイート


公式


Thomas Piketty and Pavlina Tcherneva






ーー

Tcherneva: 
19:30
so i i do want to thank you for for you know first your your enormously influential work i remember a time in the 90s where people would not talk a lot about inequality and and luckily that has changed um and that has become very important i want to just give you a chance to uh maybe uh say any concluding thoughts um that you may have.


Piketty: 
 19:49 
yeah well let me simply say that you know we need collective uh movement we need collective organization (and this is why i think you know this you know the democratizing work project is so is so important you know) it's it's okay it's useful to write book and you know individual researchers write book and that's okay and that's useful but you know that's not going to be enough you know we need we need this kind of collective movement like the one we've been created and of course that's not going to be enough either we also need you know collective organization in the form of you know trade unions political parties a platform of transformation you know this is in the end what has made a difference in the 20th century you know how did we get to a more equal more prosperous society well you know it was a trade union movement uh labour parties socialist participants so you know we are not going to have the same kind exactly of party and collective organization in the future but it will be another set of uh more you know you know in line with the with the big issues of the day you know uh you know climate change development at the world level uh migration you know all but you know it will also take you know this kind of big collective movement and so everybody is part of the solution and i think what's really important is not to be impressed by you know conservative economic thinking you know people who pretend you know they have built a science that is so scientific that nobody else can understand you know we know this is a big joke you know i think uh you know economics is a social science you know we all have something to bring sociologists anthropologists political scientists historians looking carefully at the values historical experience and and you know every citizens you know needs to sort of appropriate for herself himself you know this body of knowledge in order to participate to collective action so thanks a lot for you know contributing so much to this with democratizing work.


Tcherneva: 
 21:51 
(thank you so very much i i think that's a great note to end on i appreciate your time and your work as well and um i will urge our um our viewers to come and join uh the movement uh democratizing our democratizingwork.org )thank you so very much thomas.

Piketty: 
 yeah thank you very much.

チャーネバ:
最初にあなたの非常に影響力のあることを知っていただきありがとうございます仕事私は90年代に人々が不平等についてあまり話さなかった時期を覚えています、そして幸いにもそれはええと変わりました、そしてそれは非常に重要になりました持ってる。

ピケティ: 
 19:49 
ええ、簡単に言えば、私たちには集合的な運動が必要です。私たちは集合的な組織が必要です。(これが、民主化作業プロジェクトが非常に重要であることを知っている理由です。)本を書くことは大丈夫です。個々の研究者が本を書いていることを知っていて、それは大丈夫です。それは便利ですが、それだけでは十分ではないことを知っています。十分ではありません。労働組合の政党を知っているという形で集合組織を知っている必要もあります。これが最終的に20世紀に違いをもたらしたのは、私たちがどのようにして得たのかを知っている変革のプラットフォームです。より平等でより繁栄した社会にとって、それは労働党の社会主義者の参加者であったことをよく知っているので、将来的にはまったく同じ種類の党と集団組織を持つことはないでしょうが、それは別のセットになるでしょうあなたが知っている日の大きな問題に沿ってあなたが知っていることをもっと知っているあなたは世界レベルでの気候変動の発展を知っている誰もが解決策の一部であり、私は何を考えていますか?本当に重要なのは、保守的な経済的思考に感銘を受けないことです。あなたが知っているふりをしている人々は、科学的な科学を構築したことを知っているので、他の誰も理解できないことを知っています。経済学は社会科学であることを知っています私たちは皆、社会学者、人類学者、政治科学者、歴史家に歴史的経験の価値を注意深く見させる何かを持っています、そしてあなたが知っているすべての市民は自分自身に適切である必要があることを知っています集団行動に参加することで、民主化の仕事でこれに多大な貢献をしていることを知ってくれてありがとう。

チェルネバ: 
 21:51 
どうもありがとうございました(ii最後に素晴らしいメモだと思いますあなたの時間とあなたの仕事にも感謝しますそしてええと私は私たちの視聴者に来て私たちの民主化する運動に参加するように促します)トーマス。

ピケティ: 
 ええ、どうもありがとうございました[拍手] [音楽]


Global Forum on Democratizing Work - Oct 05 | Hopin
[Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] uh [Music] 

Tcherneva: 
hello um my name is pavlina chernova and i direct the economic democracy initiative at the open society university network i teach economics at bard college and i'm a research scholar at the leave economics institute today i am delighted to speak with thomas a scholar who perhaps single-handedly changed the global conversation on inequality he is professor of economics at the paris school of economics and the school for advanced studies in the social sciences and his co-director of the world inequality lab and the world inequality database tama thank you so much for joining me today thank you for inviting me um thank you last year a group of female scholars including myself published a manifesto on the need to democratize work after the pandemic um today the the manifesto was published in around the world and many uh papers in and today uh we are following on that momentum with a global forum uh on democratizing work to take place uh during october fifth or seventh um and uh the basic premise of that work was that people are not simple uh resources that human well-being cannot be governed by market forces alone and we highlighted three principles of the manifesto the first one is that it's time to democratize firms by involving employees in decisions relating to their lives and the future of the workplace the second was the need to decommodify work by collectively guaranteeing useful uh dignified employment employment opportunities to all and of course to decarbonize the planet to marshal our collective resources and address climate change and i want to thank you very much for your support from the very beginning of this journey so today i just wanted to talk briefly about how the manifesto resonates with your work are there specific aspects or principles that specifically connect to your research.

Piketty:
 yes sure so first let me say you know how glad i am to you know participate to this movement which you know i think is really fantastic you know i've been in touch with isabel dominique and many other participants the project for for many years now and some of you in the group i met more recently and i discovered their work more recently but you know i think what you've put together is extremely important so you know i don't know where to start there are many proposals which to me are absolutely central and certainly you know the sharing of power within companies and giving more power and and to participate to decision making for workers representatives absolutely central and and you know been following the proposal of isabel in this direction for a long time i think you know this this is a central discussion we need to have i you know i would say and you know i'm not saying this because i'm talking with you but i think you know the job guarantee uh proposal you know is at least as important because you know i i it took me some time you know to sort of fully understand the the you know the importance of this but but the more i think about it and you know i've read your book and and i think it's it's really one of the sort of very powerful ways that can contribute both to the decommodification and to the decarbonization of the economy so you know it's not there's no magic bullet you know it's not that there's not going to be one policy that's going to do it all you know it's really a set of policies it involves the sharing of power in companies it involves a basic income you know basic income is important but you know basic income is is very basic you know in the sense that the kind of amount of income that people have in mind when they talk about the basic income is typically you know between 50 percent or 75 percent of a full-time minimum wage you're not going to go very far with this and so that's very important we need to have it to some extent we already have it in a number of european countries it needs to be more universal but i think it's important to call it basic income results and universal income because sort of universal income is sort of promising more than what it is really and basic income is more you know that's a minimum guarantee that's good but you know that's all for three quarters of minimum wage income the job guarantee is more ambitious so we need to have both at the same time because the job guarantee you know is offering us the idea of you know a full-time job at at least a minimum wage you know at least full-time minimum wage with a minimum wage itself which should be you know increased you know in particular of the federal minimum wage in the u.s but more generally depending on the possibility in each country this needs to be a decent living wage this is a full-time income and and most importantly it comes together with with the process uh by which you empower you know local actors association municipalities new actors to redefine what economic value is and what we define our priorities so you know i think that to me that's a very important component i would add that you know we also together with you know basic income job guarantee we also need to redistribute property rights you know we cannot continue with this kind of concentration of property even if we give more work more more power or voting rights to workers you know you will still have shareholders and you don't want you know shareholders to have such a concentrated structure of of share ownership and so to me this you know if you look at the long-run evolution of the concentration of wealth you know there's there's been very limited progress in the long run you know the the top one percent or ten percent share it may be smaller today than what it was in the 19th century but the bottom 50 percent is just as small you know in the u.s it could be two percent of total wealth in france it could be four percent but you know it's just ridiculously small and so the the middle the forty percent in between the top tens of the fifty are you know have a bigger share today than in the 19th century that if you look at the 150 percent you know it's it's still close to zero and even the intermediate 40 percent their share has been declining so we cannot just wait for growth competition to to spread the weight you know we need to think of other mechanisms i have to talk about you know the redistribution of inheritance or the diffusion of waste but you know in any case this would have to come you know the top of a long sequence of transformation institutional transformation and you know i think the job guarantee is really one of the key steps which probably should be put in place you know before really you know thinking about the redistribution of property or together you know in terms of sequencing of reform that should be really high a priority you know together with with of course more worker rights in companies as workers independently from any any right so yes that's for me you know that's one of the one of the key proposals which i which i i support a lot.


Tcherneva:
i really appreciate uh you're saying that and i have uh you know taken a lot of inspiration from tony x ethnicity's work uh that i know you have worked with him and i also owe you a bit of debt of gratitude too because uh your data on inequality was so important and uh when it came out i was curious to see what happens during periods of growth the old argument that a rising tide lifts all boats and when i consider just the growth periods using your data it was very clear that growth actually delivered more inequality but the manifesto and our work is a recognition that these are multi-dimensional battles that are all connected they have the same route that when we talk about uh democratic workplace it is so dependent on how people experience economic insecurity uh whether you have just precarious job or you have no job and that our fates in a sense are intertwined the fates of the working people and those who are not working and those who are working without pay um and so that um the job guarantee is one way to secure a basic um basic uh human right but that also is intimately connected with the nature of work how we work in the workplace and whether we have power decision making power which is why this this uh union of forces has been so uh wonderful for all of us in the research team and i wanted to connect that a bit more to your own research because um you have you know you have put a spotlight on this uh the discussion on distribution and pre-distribution and that so often um our attention is directed to tax policies redistributive tax policies and they certainly have an important role to play um especially in reducing power and the economy um the concentration of capital but when you say um that you know the focus also needs to be placed on pre-tax inequality how do you think about those processes and the kind of policies that might move us forward.

Piketty: 
 10:24 
okay so pre-distribution you know getting to a more equitable pre-distribution requires deep structural change in you know in the distribution of power in society in general so this can this include you know more more workers rights to negotiate you know better wages better working condition uh you know another organization of of labor this includes uh you know more educational justice so you know access to education is one you know of course of the key dimension that historically as broad both more equality and more prosperity the problem is that you know there's still today and there's always been a lot of hypocrisy about you know the idea of equal opportunity equal access to to education when we look at actual data you know today in the united states and we look at you know percentile of parental income and probability to access higher education you know you get almost a straight line you know going from you know probability to access higher education a little more than 20 percent for for children with very poor parents and and you know 95 percent for children with very rich parents and it's almost a straight line and of course real inequality is even bigger than that because the universities you go to you know when you're at the top of nothing to do with the kind of funding you have for you know people at the bottom so you know educational justice and a measurable way to be able to assess whether we are moving towards educational justice you know today we sort of assume that okay if we just set abstract principles about educational equality and we are all in favor of the equality of opportunity and blah blah blah you know that this is going to happen but we need to be able you know to measure to set targets and and and to construct some some collective sense of what educational justice should be i i also want to stress that you know a big part of what the progressive taxation has been doing historically is actually to improve the pre-distribution and and that's really important because this means that the opposition that we make between pre-distribution and redistribution sometimes is in part artificial first you know when you have progressive taxation of wealth and inner returns especially if you were using these resources to to to to finance a minimum inheritance for all in effect you are getting to a better pre-distribution next generation so so you use progressive taxation in order to improve equality of opportunities and equality of rights for the following generation this is also true in fact with progressive taxation of income what we've what we've shown with emmanuel says that you know the primary impact of the roosevelt type uh top income tax rate of 80 percent or 90 percent you know between 1930 and 1970 1980 has been you know to reduce uh pre-tax inequality of labor income at the very top end why is it so well because you know when you know when you when you're a manager and you always want to be paid one million more of course but you know when you have a top tax rate of 90 percent you know everybody knows you know your subordinates your shareholders that you know they know that 90 percent of it are going to go straight to the treasury so at some point you know everybody is going to tell you well you know you should calm down you know we're going to find other ways to you know make you happy or whatever but you know we're in effect we are going to reduce the salary scale and historically you know this has been the main impact and and this has been very important because this is uh also you know what we will need i think in the future you know if we want to reduce structurally the pre-tax salary scale is you know in some cases you want to make illegal you know wages above you know 10 times minimum wage or whatever but i think it will always have to come with a very progressive tax system at the upper end so that people don't try to get you know extra payments through other shell companies or bonuses or consulting fees so you need at some point you know even if you have a strict salary scale at the company level if you really want to enforce it you have to do it with very sharp progressive taxation so that's going to have an impact on free tax inequality and historically this is also yeah you know what has made possible the movement the world you know the construction of a social state uh you know the development of social security the development of more public education spending uh of course relied on more taxation for everybody from the middle class from the lower class it cannot just come from the rich but in order to have the middle class accept to put more resources in common to the to social security to the education system you have to guarantee that people at the top you know are going to pay more than the middle class and i think you know this is of course the problem we have today which is that this is not the case anymore and if we want to have a new a new step in the in the construction of your social state which also is the construction of decommodification in the sense that we need to have sectors like education health but also you know energy transportation culture which work outside the profit material and work outside the market system and in fact work very well you know public health systems are more efficient and you know than private health system in education you know people who have tried to use a profit maximizing uh shareholder companies in higher education like your trump university you know this has been a disaster because in fact you are killing the kind of ethical behavior that you need in many of these areas and i think this could apply to more sectors in the future but in order for this new step to be possible i think this will have to come with also a new step in progressive taxation which is both the force that can reduce pre-tax gap and that's very important you know you want gaps from one to four one to five some people will say one to ten you know i would say more one two four one two five but in any case you know one two fifty one to one hundred is completely useless you know historically if i compare different societies different level of inequality different level of prosperity of innovation you know the idea that we need gaps of 150 100 is just completely wrong it just doesn't work if you make proper historical comparison between these different societies so you know we that's again it's a package of solution.
 uh where you know each ingredient is is very is very is very important.

Tcherneva: 
17:40 
yeah thank you i in our work of course we call on governments to uh lead the way in especially in decarbonizing the planet but also in putting the kind of public investments that have been neglected for such a long time um and you know the covet crisis for us was this kind of wake up moment not only because it exposed how vulnerable uh working people are and you know crisis after crisis we are presented with teachable moments and we hope that we can seize this and really reflect on the most important um aspects of our life uh people who are working who are supporting um us and of course the nature but the other thing that i think that that covet um demonstrated is that governments on short order can do very major big investments when presented with with a shared concern um in in europe there were ways to find uh and fund uh large-scale programs in the united states we overnight spend um well upwards of 20 of gdp in uh less than a year and so um there is a decoupling uh between in public expenditure um and taxation as a practical matter but also in terms of mission the mission of the public sector and nevertheless we still recognize the enormous power of of influence um that wealth has on the political process and the necessity to remove it uh from having such a outsized voice in policymaking so i i do want to thank you for for you know first your your enormously influential work i remember a time in the 90s where people would not talk a lot about inequality and and luckily that has changed um and that has become very important i want to just give you a chance to uh maybe uh say any concluding thoughts um that you may have.


Piketty: 
 19:49 
yeah well let me simply say that you know we need collective uh movement we need collective organization and this is why i think you know this you know the democratizing work project is so is so important you know it's it's okay it's useful to write book and you know individual researchers write book and that's okay and that's useful but you know that's not going to be enough you know we need we need this kind of collective movement like the one we've been created and of course that's not going to be enough either we also need you know collective organization in the form of you know trade unions political parties a platform of transformation you know this is in the end what has made a difference in the 20th century you know how did we get to a more equal more prosperous society well you know it was a trade union movement uh labour parties socialist participants so you know we are not going to have the same kind exactly of party and collective organization in the future but it will be another set of uh more you know you know in line with the with the big issues of the day you know uh you know climate change development at the world level uh migration you know all but you know it will also take you know this kind of big collective movement and so everybody is part of the solution and i think what's really important is not to be impressed by you know conservative economic thinking you know people who pretend you know they have built a science that is so scientific that nobody else can understand you know we know this is a big joke you know i think uh you know economics is a social science you know we all have something to bring sociologists anthropologists political scientists historians looking carefully at the values historical experience and and you know every citizens you know needs to sort of appropriate for herself himself you know this body of knowledge in order to participate to collective action so thanks a lot for you know contributing so much to this with democratizing work.


Tcherneva: 
 21:51 
thank you so very much i i think that's a great note to end on i appreciate your time and your work as well and um i will urge our um our viewers to come and join uh the movement uh democratizing our democratizingwork.org thank you so very much thomas.

Piketty: 
 yeah thank you very much [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] you
 
 /////
 

チェルネバ: 
こんにちは、私の名前はpavlina chernovaです。私は、バード大学で経済学を教えているオープンソサエティ大学ネットワークで経済民主主義イニシアチブを指揮しています。本日、休暇経済研究所の研究者であるトーマスと、パリ経済学校と社会科学高等研究学校の経済学教授である不平等に関する世界的な会話を片手で変えた学者とお話しできることをうれしく思います。そして彼の世界不平等研究所と世界不平等データベースの共同ディレクタータマ今日は私に参加してくれてありがとう私を招待してくれてありがとう昨年私を含む女性学者のグループが仕事を民主化する必要性についてのマニフェストを発表しました今日のパンデミックウムの後、マニフェストは世界中で公開され、多くの論文が発表されました。今日は、10月5日または7日の間に行われる民主化作業に関するグローバルフォーラムでその勢いを追っています。その前提仕事は、人は単純なものではなく、人間の幸福は市場の力だけでは管理できないということでした。マニフェストの3つの原則を強調しました。最初の原則は、従業員を自分たちの生活と職場の未来2つ目は、すべての人に有用な威厳のある雇用雇用機会を集合的に保証することによって仕事を解体する必要性であり、もちろん、地球を脱炭素化して私たちの集合的な資源を整理し、気候変動に対処する必要があります。この旅の最初から、今日はマニフェストがあなたの仕事とどのように共鳴するかについて簡単に話したいと思いました。あなたの研究に特に関連する特定の側面や原則があります。

ピケティ:
 はい、確かに最初に、私がこの運動に参加することを知ってうれしいことを教えてください。私はイザベルドミニクや他の多くの参加者と長年連絡を取り合っていることを知っています。私が最近会ったグループの何人かは最近彼らの仕事を発見しましたが、あなたはあなたがまとめたものが非常に重要だと思うのであなたは私が知らないことを知っていますどこから始めればよいかわからない私にとって絶対的に中心的な提案がたくさんあります。確かにあなたは企業内で権力を共有し、より多くの権力を与え、労働者代表の意思決定に参加することを知っています。長い間この方向にイザベルこれは私たちが持っている必要がある中心的な議論であることをあなたは知っていると思います私が言うことを知っていますそしてあなたは私があなたと話しているので私がこれを言っていないことを知っています仕事の保証ええと、あなたが知っている提案は少なくとも同じくらい重要です。なぜなら、あなたがこれの重要性を知っていることを完全に理解するのに時間がかかったからです。あなたの本と私はそれだと思います」経済の脱商品化と脱炭素化の両方に貢献できる非常に強力な方法の1つであるため、魔法の弾丸がないことはわかりません。それを実行する1つのポリシーがないことはありません。ベーシックインカムが重要であると知っているが、ベーシックインカムは非常に基本的であるという意味で、ベーシックインカムは非常に基本的であるという意味で、ベーシックインカムについて話すとき、人々は通常、フルタイムの最低賃金の50%から75%の間で、これであまり遠くまで行かないことを知っていることを念頭に置いています。非常に重要ですある程度持っている必要がありますすでに多くのヨーロッパ諸国で持っている必要がありますより普遍的である必要がありますが、ある種の普遍的な収入は一種の有望であるため、基本的な収入の結果と普遍的な収入と呼ぶことが重要だと思いますそれが実際に何であるかよりも、基本的な収入が多いほど、それは良い最低保証ですが、それはすべて最低賃金収入の4分の3であり、仕事の保証はより野心的であるため、仕事のために両方を同時に持つ必要がありますあなたが知っていることを保証することはあなたが少なくとも最低賃金でフルタイムの仕事を知っているという考えを私たちに提供しているあなたが知っている最低賃金で少なくともフルタイムの最低賃金それ自体があなたが知っているべきであるuの賃金。sしかし、より一般的には、各国の可能性に応じて、これはまともな生活賃金である必要があります。これはフルタイムの収入であり、最も重要なことは、地元の俳優協会自治体の新しい俳優を知るためのプロセスと一緒になります。経済的価値とは何か、そして私たちが優先順位を定義するものを再定義するために、それは私にとって非常に重要な要素だと思います。私たちもあなたと一緒に基本的な収入の仕事の保証を知っています。たとえあなたがまだ株主を持っていて、あなたが持っていないことを知っている労働者に、より多くの仕事、より多くの権力または投票権を与えたとしても、私たちはこの種の財産の集中を続けることはできません。株主が株式所有のこのような集中構造を持っていることを知ってほしいので、私にとってこれは、富の集中の長期的な進化を見ると、あなたが知っている長期的には非常に限られた進歩しかなかったことを知っています上位1%または10%のシェアは、今日では19世紀よりも小さい可能性がありますが、下位50%は、米国の総資産の2%であり、4%である可能性があります。パーセントですが、それはとてつもなく小さいので、50の上位10の中間の40パーセントは、19世紀よりも今日のシェアが大きいことを知っています。150パーセントを見ると、それだとわかります。」sはまだゼロに近く、中間の40%でさえシェアが低下しているため、成長競争が重みを広げるのを待つことはできません。継承の再分配を知っている他のメカニズムについて考える必要があります。廃棄物の拡散ですが、いずれにせよ、これは、変革の長いシーケンスのトップを知っている必要があることを知っています。制度改革とあなたは、仕事の保証が本当にあなたに配置されるべき重要なステップの1つであると思います。財産の再分配について考えることを実際に知っている前に、または改革の順序付けの観点から一緒に知っていることは、あなたが知っている非常に高い優先順位であり、もちろん、いかなる権利からも独立した労働者としての企業におけるより多くの労働者の権利と一緒に知っているので、そうです'私にとって、それは私が大いに支持する重要な提案の1つであることをあなたは知っています。


チェルネバ:
私はあなたがそれを言っていることを本当に感謝しています、そして私はあなたがトニーx民族性から多くのインスピレーションを得たことを知っています」仕事はあなたが彼と一緒に仕事をしたことを知っています。また、不平等に関するあなたのデータが非常に重要だったので、私もあなたに少しの感謝の気持ちを負っています。上昇する潮流がすべてのボートを持ち上げるという古い議論とあなたのデータを使用して成長期間だけを考えると、成長が実際により多くの不平等をもたらしたことは非常に明白でしたが、マニフェストと私たちの仕事はこれらがすべて接続されている多次元の戦いであるという認識です彼らは、私たちが民主的な職場について話すとき、人々が経済的不安をどのように経験するかに大きく依存しているのと同じルートを持っています。働いていない人と働いていない人仕事の保証は基本的な人権を確保するための1つの方法ですが、それは私たちが職場でどのように働くか、そして私たちが力の意思決定力を持っているかどうかにも密接に関連しています。これが理由ですこの力の連合は、研究チームの私たち全員にとってとても素晴らしいものでした。私はそれをあなた自身の研究にもう少し結び付けたいと思いました。なぜなら、あなたはこれにスポットライトを当てていることを知っているからです。事前分配とその多くの場合、私たちの注意は税政策再分配税政策に向けられており、それらは確かに、特に電力と経済の削減、資本の集中において重要な役割を果たしていますが、あなたが焦点を知っていると言うときまた、税引き前の不平等に置かれる必要がありますあなたはそれらについてどう思いますかプロセスと私たちを前進させる可能性のある種類のポリシー。

ピケティ: 
 10:24 
さて、あなたが知っている事前分配は、より公平な事前分配に到達するために、社会における権力の分配においてあなたが知っている深い構造的変化を必要とするので、これはあなたが交渉するより多くの労働者の権利を知っていることを含むことができます条件ええと、あなたは別の労働組織を知っています。これには、より多くの教育的正義を知っているので、教育へのアクセスはもちろん、歴史的に平等と繁栄の両方が広いという重要な側面を知っています。問題は、そこにあることを知っているということです。まだ今日もあります」米国で今日知っている実際のデータを見ると、教育への平等な機会の平等なアクセスのアイデアを知っていることについて常に多くの偽善があり、親の収入のパーセンタイルと高等教育にアクセスする確率を知っています。非常に貧しい親を持つ子供たちの高等教育にアクセスする確率は20%強であり、非常に裕福な親を持つ子供たちの95%はほぼ直線であり、ほぼ直線であり、もちろん、実際の不平等はそれよりもさらに大きくなります。なぜなら、あなたが行く大学はあなたがいつ一番上にあるのは、あなたが持っている資金の種類とは何の関係もありません。一番下にいる人々を知っているので、教育の正義と、今日私たちが知っている教育の正義に向かっているかどうかを評価できる測定可能な方法を知っています。教育の平等について抽象的な原則を設定し、機会の平等に賛成しているなら、それは大丈夫です。これが起こることはわかっていますが、目標を設定するために測定することを知っている必要があります。教育的正義がどうあるべきかについての集合的な感覚を構築するために、iiはまた、累進課税が歴史的に行ってきたことの大部分が実際に事前分配を改善することであり、それを知っていることを強調したい。これは、事前分配と再分配の間で私たちが行う反対が、富と内部利益の累進課税がある場合、特にこれらのリソースを最小限の資金調達に使用している場合に、最初に部分的に人為的なものになることがあることを意味するため、非常に重要ですすべての人の相続は事実上、次世代のより良い事前分配に到達しているので、次の世代の機会の平等と権利の平等を改善するために累進課税を使用します。これは実際、所得の累進課税にも当てはまります。 「私たちが何をしているのか」エマニュエルと一緒に示したように、ルーズベルトタイプの主な影響は、1930年から1970年の間に80%または90%の最高所得税率であることがわかっています。1980年は、税引き前の労働所得の不平等を非常に減らすことがわかっています。トップエンドなぜそれはとても良いのですか?あなたがマネージャーであるときあなたがいつ知っているかを知っていて、もちろん常に100万以上の支払いを望んでいるのですが、最高税率が90%のときは誰もが知っていることを知っていますあなたは部下の株主を知っています。彼らはその90%が国庫に直行することを知っているので、ある時点で誰もがあなたに落ち着くべきだとあなたに言うでしょう。あなたがあなたを幸せにするか何かを知っている他の方法を見つけてください、しかしあなたは私たちが知っている事実上、私たちは給与の規模を減らすつもりです。歴史的に、これが主な影響であり、これは非常に重要でした。これは、私たちが必要とするものを知っているからです。税引き前の給与スケールを構造的に削減する場合によっては、違法にしたい場合があります。最低賃金の10倍などを知っている以上の賃金を知っていますが、常に上限に非常に累進的な税制が必要になると思います。人々が他のシェル会社やボーナスやコンサルティング料金を通じて追加の支払いを知らされないようにするため、本当にそれを強制したいのであれば、会社レベルで厳格な給与スケールを持っていても、ある時点で知っておく必要があります非常に鋭い累進課税でそれをしなければならないので」自由税の不平等に影響を与えるだろうそして歴史的にこれはまたあなたが社会的国家の建設を知っている世界の運動を可能にしたものを知っているあなたは社会的安全の発展を知っているもちろん、中産階級から下層階級までのすべての人に、より多くの課税に依存していました。それは金持ちから来るだけでなく、中産階級が社会的安全に共通するより多くの資源を教育システムに投入することを受け入れるためにあなたが知っているトップの人々が中産階級よりも多く支払うことを保証します、そして私はあなたがこれがもちろん今日私たちが抱えている問題であることを知っていると思います建設でもあるあなたの社会的状態の建設のステップ教育保健のようなセクターが必要であるという意味での非商品化のことですが、利益材料の外で機能し、市場システムの外で機能するエネルギー輸送文化を知っています。教育における民間の医療制度よりも、トランプ大学のような高等教育で利益を最大化する株主企業を利用しようとした人々を知っています。実際、あなたは多くの人に必要な種類の倫理的行動を殺しているので、これは惨事でした。これらの分野の中で、これは将来より多くのセクターに適用される可能性があると思いますが、この新しいステップを可能にするためには、これは進歩的な課税の新しいステップも伴う必要があると思います。税のギャップとそれ」非常に重要なのは、1から4までのギャップが必要だということです。1から5までのギャップが必要な人もいます。1から10と言う人もいます。異なる社会を比較すると、異なるレベルの不平等、異なるレベルのイノベーションの繁栄を歴史的に知っています。150100のギャップが必要であるという考えは完全に間違っていることを知っています。これらの異なる社会間で適切な歴史的比較を行うと、機能しません。これもソリューションのパッケージです。
 ええと、あなたが各成分が非常にあることを知っているところは非常に非常に重要です。

チェルネバ: 
17:40 
ええ、私たちの仕事に感謝します。もちろん、私たちは政府に、特に地球の脱炭素化だけでなく、長い間無視されてきた種類の公共投資を行うことにおいても先導するように呼びかけます。私たちはこの種の目覚めの瞬間でした。それは、働く人々がどれほど脆弱であるかを明らかにしただけでなく、危機後の危機を知っているからです。私たちはこれをつかみ、私たちの最も重要な側面について本当に考えることができることを願っています。人生私たちともちろん自然を支えている働いている人々ですが、私がその切望が示したと思う他のことは、短期間の政府は、共通の懸念を提示されたときに非常に大きな大きな投資を行うことができるということですヨーロッパでは、ええと、大規模なプログラムに資金を提供する方法がありました米国では、1年以内に20 gdpをはるかに超える額を一晩で費やしているため、実際問題として、また公的部門の使命という観点からも、公的支出と課税の間に分離があります。それでもなお、富が政治プロセスに与える多大な影響力と、それを政策立案におけるそのような大規模な発言から排除する必要性を認識しているので、最初にあなたの非常に影響力のあることを知っていただきありがとうございます仕事私は90年代に人々が不平等についてあまり話さなかった時期を覚えています、そして幸いにもそれはええと変わりました、そしてそれは非常に重要になりました持ってる。


ピケティ: 
 19:49 
ええ、簡単に言えば、私たちには集合的な運動が必要です。私たちは集合的な組織が必要です。これが、民主化作業プロジェクトが非常に重要であることを知っている理由です。本を書くことは大丈夫です。個々の研究者が本を書いていることを知っていて、それは大丈夫です。それは便利ですが、それだけでは十分ではないことを知っています。十分ではありません。労働組合の政党を知っているという形で集合組織を知っている必要もあります。これが最終的に20世紀に違いをもたらしたのは、私たちがどのようにして得たのかを知っている変革のプラットフォームです。より平等でより繁栄した社会にとって、それは労働党の社会主義者の参加者であったことをよく知っているので、将来的にはまったく同じ種類の党と集団組織を持つことはないでしょうが、それは別のセットになるでしょうあなたが知っている日の大きな問題に沿ってあなたが知っていることをもっと知っているあなたは世界レベルでの気候変動の発展を知っている誰もが解決策の一部であり、私は何を考えていますか?本当に重要なのは、保守的な経済的思考に感銘を受けないことです。あなたが知っているふりをしている人々は、科学的な科学を構築したことを知っているので、他の誰も理解できないことを知っています。経済学は社会科学であることを知っています私たちは皆、社会学者、人類学者、政治科学者、歴史家に歴史的経験の価値を注意深く見させる何かを持っています、そしてあなたが知っているすべての市民は自分自身に適切である必要があることを知っています集団行動に参加することで、民主化の仕事でこれに多大な貢献をしていることを知ってくれてありがとう。


チェルネバ: 
 21:51 
どうもありがとうございましたii最後に素晴らしいメモだと思いますあなたの時間とあなたの仕事にも感謝しますそしてええと私は私たちの視聴者に来て私たちの民主化する運動に参加するように促しますトーマス。

ピケティ: 
 ええ、どうもありがとうございました[拍手] [音楽]
 
////
 
 00:00 [Music] 00:00 [Applause] 00:00 [Music] 00:00 [Applause] 00:03 [Music] 00:03 [Applause] 00:07 uh 00:08 [Music] 
 
Tcherneva:
00:20 hello um my name is pavlina chernova and 00:24 i direct the economic democracy 00:26 initiative at the open society 00:28 university network i teach economics at 00:30 bard college and i'm a research scholar 00:33 at 00:34 the leave economics institute today i am 00:37 delighted to speak with thomas 00:40 a scholar who perhaps single-handedly 00:43 changed the global conversation on 00:46 inequality 00:48 he is professor of economics at the 00:50 paris school of economics and the school 00:52 for advanced studies in the social 00:54 sciences 00:55 and his co-director of the world 00:57 inequality lab 00:59 and the world inequality database tama 01:03 thank you so much for joining me today 01:05 thank you for inviting me 01:07 um 01:08 thank you last year a group of female 01:12 scholars including myself published a 01:14 manifesto on the need to democratize 01:17 work after the pandemic 01:19 um today the the manifesto was published 01:22 in around the world and many uh papers 01:25 in and today uh we are following on that 01:28 momentum with a 01:30 global forum uh on democratizing work to 01:32 take place uh during october fifth or 01:35 seventh 01:36 um and uh the basic premise of that work 01:39 was that people are not simple uh 01:42 resources 01:43 that human well-being cannot be governed 01:47 by market forces alone 01:50 and 01:51 we highlighted three 01:53 principles of the manifesto 01:56 the first one is that 01:58 it's time to democratize firms by 02:01 involving employees in decisions 02:04 relating to their lives and the future 02:07 of the workplace 02:09 the second was the need to decommodify 02:11 work 02:12 by collectively guaranteeing useful uh 02:15 dignified employment employment 02:17 opportunities to all 02:18 and of course to decarbonize the planet 02:21 to marshal our collective resources and 02:24 address climate change and i want to 02:26 thank you very much for your support 02:28 from the very beginning of this journey 02:31 so today i just wanted to 02:33 talk briefly 02:35 about how 02:37 the manifesto resonates with your work 02:40 are there specific aspects or principles 02:43 that specifically 02:44 connect 02:45 to your research.
Piketty:
 02:48 yes sure so first let me say you know 02:50 how glad i am to you know participate 02:53 to this movement which you know i think 02:55 is really fantastic you know i've been 02:57 in touch with 02:58 isabel dominique and many other 03:01 participants the project for for many 03:03 years now and some of you in the group i 03:06 met more recently and i discovered their 03:08 work more recently but you know i think 03:10 what you've put together is extremely 03:12 important so you know i don't know where 03:14 to start there are many proposals which 03:17 to me are absolutely central and 03:18 certainly you know the sharing of power 03:22 within companies and giving more 03:25 power and and to participate to decision 03:27 making for workers representatives 03:29 absolutely 03:31 central and and you know been following 03:33 the proposal of isabel in this direction 03:35 for a long time i think you know this 03:37 this is a central discussion we need to 03:39 have 03:40 i you know i would say and you know i'm 03:42 not saying this because i'm talking with 03:43 you but i think you know the job 03:44 guarantee uh proposal you know is at 03:48 least as important because you know i i 03:50 it took me some time you know to sort of 03:52 fully understand the 03:54 the 03:55 you know the importance of this but but 03:57 the more i think about it and you know 03:59 i've read your book and and i think it's 04:03 it's really one of the sort of very 04:05 powerful ways that can contribute both 04:07 to the decommodification and to the 04:09 decarbonization of the economy so you 04:12 know it's not 04:13 there's no magic bullet you know it's 04:15 not that there's not going to be one 04:16 policy that's going to do it all you 04:18 know it's really a set of policies it 04:20 involves 04:21 the sharing of power in companies it 04:24 involves a basic income you know basic 04:26 income is important but you know basic 04:28 income is is very basic you know in the 04:31 sense that the kind of amount of income 04:34 that people have in mind when they talk 04:35 about the basic income is typically you 04:37 know between 04:38 50 percent or 75 percent of 04:41 a full-time minimum wage 04:44 you're not going to go very far with 04:45 this and so that's very important we 04:47 need to have it to some extent we 04:49 already have it in a number of european 04:50 countries it needs to be more universal 04:53 but i think it's important to call it 04:55 basic income results and universal 04:57 income because sort of universal income 04:59 is sort of promising 05:00 more than what it is really and basic 05:03 income is more you know that's a minimum 05:05 guarantee that's good but you know 05:06 that's all for three quarters of minimum 05:09 wage income the job guarantee is more 05:11 ambitious so we need to have both at the 05:14 same time because the job guarantee 05:16 you know is offering us the idea of you 05:19 know a full-time job at at least a 05:21 minimum wage you know at least full-time 05:23 minimum wage with a minimum wage itself 05:25 which should be 05:26 you know increased you know in 05:27 particular of the federal minimum wage 05:29 in the u.s but more generally depending 05:32 on the possibility in each country this 05:34 needs to be a decent living wage 05:37 this is a full-time income and and most 05:40 importantly it comes together with with 05:42 the process uh by which you empower 05:46 you know local actors association 05:49 municipalities new actors to redefine 05:51 what economic value is and what we 05:54 define our priorities so you know i 05:56 think that to me that's a very important 05:59 component i would add that you know we 06:02 also together with you know basic income 06:04 job guarantee we also need to 06:06 redistribute 06:08 property rights you know we cannot 06:09 continue with this kind of concentration 06:12 of property even if we give more work 06:14 more more power or voting rights to 06:16 workers 06:18 you know you will still have 06:19 shareholders and you don't want you know 06:21 shareholders to have such a concentrated 06:25 structure of of share ownership and so 06:28 to me this you know if you look at the 06:30 long-run evolution of the concentration 06:33 of wealth 06:34 you know there's there's been very 06:36 limited progress in the long run you 06:37 know the the top one percent or ten 06:40 percent share it may be smaller today 06:43 than what it was in the 19th century but 06:45 the bottom 50 percent is just as small 06:48 you know in the u.s it could be two 06:49 percent of total wealth in france it 06:51 could be four percent but you know it's 06:53 just ridiculously small and so the the 06:56 middle the forty percent in between the 06:58 top tens of the fifty are you know have 07:01 a bigger share today than in the 19th 07:03 century that if you look at the 150 07:05 percent you know it's it's 07:07 still close to zero and even the 07:09 intermediate 40 percent their share has 07:11 been declining so we cannot just wait 07:13 for growth competition to to spread the 07:16 weight you know we need to think of 07:18 other mechanisms i have to talk about 07:20 you know the redistribution of 07:21 inheritance or the diffusion of waste 07:23 but you know in any case this would have 07:25 to come you know the top 07:27 of a long sequence of 07:30 transformation institutional 07:31 transformation and you know i think the 07:33 job guarantee 07:35 is really one of the key steps which 07:38 probably should be put in place you know 07:40 before really you know thinking about 07:42 the redistribution of property or 07:43 together 07:44 you know in terms of sequencing of 07:46 reform that should be really high a 07:49 priority you know together with with of 07:51 course more worker rights in companies 07:54 as workers independently from any any 07:58 right so yes that's for me you know 08:01 that's one of the one of the key 08:03 proposals which i which i i support a 08:05 lot.
 
Tcherneva:
 i really appreciate uh you're saying 08:08 that and i have uh you know taken a lot 08:11 of inspiration from tony x ethnicity's 08:13 work uh that i know you have worked with 08:15 him and i also owe you a bit of debt of 08:18 gratitude too because uh your data on 08:20 inequality was so important and uh when 08:23 it came out i was curious to see 08:27 what happens during periods of growth 08:29 the old argument that a rising tide 08:32 lifts all boats and when i consider just 08:36 the growth periods using your data it 08:37 was very clear that growth actually 08:39 delivered 08:40 more inequality 08:42 but 08:43 the 08:44 manifesto and our work 08:47 is a recognition that these are 08:48 multi-dimensional 08:51 battles that are all connected they have 08:53 the same route that when we talk about 08:56 uh democratic workplace it is so 08:58 dependent on how people experience 09:00 economic insecurity uh whether you have 09:04 just precarious job or you have no job 09:06 and that our fates in a sense are 09:09 intertwined the fates of the working 09:10 people and those who are not working and 09:12 those who are working without pay um and 09:16 so 09:17 that um the job guarantee is one way to 09:21 secure a basic um basic uh human right 09:24 but that also is intimately connected 09:27 with the nature of work how we work in 09:29 the workplace and whether we have power 09:31 decision making power which is why this 09:34 this uh union of forces has been so uh 09:37 wonderful for all of us in the research 09:38 team and i wanted to connect that a bit 09:41 more to your own research because um you 09:43 have 09:44 you know you have put a spotlight on 09:47 this uh the discussion on distribution 09:49 and pre-distribution 09:51 and that so often um our attention is 09:55 directed to tax policies redistributive 09:57 tax policies and they certainly have an 09:59 important role to play um especially in 10:02 reducing 10:03 power and the economy um the 10:05 concentration of capital but when you 10:08 say um 10:09 that 10:10 you know 10:11 the focus also needs to be placed on 10:14 pre-tax inequality 10:17 how do you think about those processes 10:19 and the kind of policies that might move 10:22 us forward.
Piketty:
 10:24 okay so pre-distribution you know 10:26 getting to a more equitable 10:28 pre-distribution requires deep 10:31 structural change in you know in the 10:33 distribution of power in society in 10:35 general so this can this include you 10:37 know more more workers rights to 10:39 negotiate 10:41 you know better wages better working 10:42 condition uh you know another 10:44 organization of of labor this includes 10:47 uh 10:48 you know more educational justice so you 10:50 know access to education is one 10:53 you know of course of the key dimension 10:56 that historically as 10:58 broad 10:59 both more equality and more prosperity 11:03 the problem is that you know there's 11:05 still today and there's always been a 11:07 lot of hypocrisy about you know the idea 11:09 of equal opportunity equal access to to 11:13 education when we look at actual data 11:15 you know today in the united states and 11:17 we look at you know percentile of 11:18 parental income and probability to 11:21 access higher education you know you get 11:23 almost a straight line you know going 11:25 from you know probability to access 11:28 higher education a little more than 20 11:30 percent for for children with very poor 11:32 parents and and you know 95 percent for 11:35 children with very rich parents and it's 11:37 almost a straight line and of course 11:39 real inequality is even bigger than that 11:41 because the universities you go to 11:44 you know when you're at the top of 11:45 nothing to do with the kind of funding 11:46 you have for 11:48 you know people 11:49 at the bottom so you know educational 11:51 justice and 11:53 a measurable way to be able to assess 11:57 whether we are moving towards 11:59 educational justice you know today we 12:01 sort of assume that okay if we just 12:04 set abstract principles about 12:06 educational equality and we are all in 12:09 favor of the equality of opportunity and 12:11 blah blah blah you know that this is 12:13 going to happen but we need to be able 12:15 you know to measure to set targets and 12:17 and and to construct some some 12:20 collective sense of what educational 12:22 justice 12:23 should be i i also want to stress that 12:27 you know a big part of what the 12:29 progressive taxation has been doing 12:32 historically 12:34 is actually to improve the 12:35 pre-distribution and and that's really 12:38 important because this means that the 12:39 opposition that we make between 12:40 pre-distribution and redistribution 12:42 sometimes is 12:43 in part artificial 12:45 first you know when you have progressive 12:47 taxation of wealth and inner returns 12:50 especially if you were using these 12:52 resources to to to to finance a minimum 12:56 inheritance for all in effect you are 12:59 getting to a better pre-distribution 13:01 next generation so so you use 13:03 progressive taxation in order to improve 13:06 equality of 13:07 opportunities and equality of rights for 13:10 the following generation this is also 13:12 true in fact with progressive taxation 13:15 of income what we've what we've shown 13:17 with 13:18 emmanuel says that you know the primary 13:21 impact of the roosevelt type uh 13:24 top income tax rate of 80 percent or 90 13:27 percent you know between 1930 and 13:30 1970 1980 has been you know to reduce 13:35 uh pre-tax inequality of labor income at 13:38 the very top end why is it so well 13:40 because you know when you know when you 13:43 when you're a manager and you always 13:45 want to be paid one million more of 13:46 course but you know when you have a top 13:48 tax rate of 90 percent you know 13:51 everybody knows you know your 13:52 subordinates your shareholders that you 13:54 know they know that 90 percent of it are 13:56 going to go straight to the treasury so 13:58 at some point you know everybody is 14:00 going to tell you well you know you 14:01 should calm down you know we're going to 14:03 find other ways to you know make you 14:05 happy or whatever but you know we're in 14:07 effect we are going to reduce the salary 14:10 scale and historically you know this has 14:13 been the main impact and and this has 14:15 been very important because this is uh 14:17 also you know 14:19 what we will need i think in the future 14:21 you know if we want to reduce 14:23 structurally the pre-tax salary scale is 14:26 you know in some cases you want to make 14:28 illegal 14:30 you know wages above you know 10 times 14:33 minimum wage or whatever but i think it 14:35 will always have to come with a very 14:37 progressive tax system at the upper end 14:40 so that people 14:41 don't try to get you know extra payments 14:44 through 14:45 other shell companies or bonuses or 14:48 consulting fees so you need at some 14:49 point you know even if you have a strict 14:51 salary scale 14:52 at the company level if you really want 14:55 to enforce it you have to do it with 14:57 very sharp progressive taxation so 15:00 that's going to have an impact on free 15:01 tax 15:02 inequality and historically this is also 15:07 yeah you know what has made possible the 15:10 movement the world 15:12 you know the construction of a social 15:14 state uh you know the development of 15:16 social security the development of more 15:18 public education spending uh of course 15:21 relied on more taxation for everybody 15:24 from the middle class from the lower 15:26 class it cannot just come from the rich 15:28 but in order to have the middle class 15:31 accept to put more resources in common 15:35 to the to 15:36 social security to the education system 15:39 you have to guarantee 15:40 that people at the top you know are 15:42 going to pay more than the middle class 15:44 and i think you know this is of course 15:46 the problem we have today which is that 15:48 this is not the case anymore and if we 15:51 want to have a new 15:53 a new step 15:54 in the in the construction of your 15:57 social state which also is the 15:59 construction of decommodification in the 16:01 sense that we need to have sectors like 16:04 education health but also you know 16:06 energy transportation culture which work 16:10 outside the profit material and work 16:12 outside the market system and in fact 16:15 work very well you know public health 16:16 systems are more efficient 16:19 and you know than private health system 16:21 in education you know people who have 16:23 tried to use a 16:25 profit maximizing uh 16:27 shareholder companies in higher 16:29 education like your trump university you 16:31 know this has been a disaster because in 16:33 fact you are killing the kind of 16:35 ethical behavior that you need in many 16:38 of these areas and i think this could 16:40 apply to more sectors 16:42 in the future but in order for this new 16:44 step to be possible 16:46 i think this will have to come with also 16:48 a new step in progressive taxation which 16:52 is 16:52 both the force that can reduce pre-tax 16:56 gap and that's very important you know 16:58 you want gaps from one to four one to 17:00 five some people will say one to ten you 17:03 know i would say more one two four one 17:04 two five but in any case you know one 17:06 two fifty one to one hundred is 17:08 completely useless you know historically 17:10 if i compare 17:12 different societies different level of 17:14 inequality different level of prosperity 17:17 of innovation you know the idea that we 17:19 need gaps of 150 100 is just completely 17:22 wrong it just doesn't work if you make 17:25 proper historical comparison between 17:27 these different 17:28 societies so you know we that's again 17:32 it's a package of solution uh where you 17:35 know each ingredient is is very 17:38 is very is very important .
Tcherneva:
17:40 yeah thank you i in our work of course 17:42 we call on governments to uh lead the 17:45 way in especially in decarbonizing the 17:48 planet but also in putting the kind of 17:50 public investments that have been 17:53 neglected for such a long time 17:55 um 17:56 and you know the covet crisis for us was 17:59 this kind of wake up moment 18:02 not only because it exposed how 18:04 vulnerable uh working people are and you 18:08 know crisis after crisis 18:10 we are presented with teachable moments 18:13 and we hope that we can seize this and 18:15 really reflect on the most important 18:18 um aspects of our life uh people who are 18:20 working who are supporting um us and of 18:23 course the nature but the other thing 18:26 that i think that 18:27 that covet um demonstrated is that 18:30 governments on short order can do very 18:33 major big investments when presented 18:36 with with a shared concern um in in 18:40 europe there were ways to find uh and 18:43 fund uh large-scale programs in the 18:45 united states we overnight spend 18:48 um well upwards of 20 of gdp 18:51 in 18:52 uh less than a year and so um there is a 18:56 decoupling uh 18:58 between in public expenditure um and 19:02 taxation as a practical matter but also 19:05 in terms of mission the mission of the 19:07 public sector and nevertheless we still 19:11 recognize the enormous power of of 19:14 influence um that wealth has on the 19:16 political process and the necessity 19:19 to remove it uh from having such a 19:22 outsized voice 19:24 in policymaking 19:27 so i i do want to thank you for for you 19:29 know first your your enormously 19:32 influential work i remember a time in 19:35 the 90s where people would not talk a 19:36 lot about inequality and 19:38 and luckily that has changed um and that 19:41 has become very important i want to just 19:42 give you a chance to uh maybe uh say any 19:45 concluding thoughts um that you may have.
Piketty:
 19:49 yeah well let me simply say that you 19:51 know we need collective uh movement we 19:53 need collective organization and this is 19:55 why i think you know this you know the 19:58 democratizing work project is so is so 20:01 important you know it's it's okay it's 20:02 useful to write book and you know 20:04 individual researchers write book and 20:06 that's okay and that's useful but you 20:08 know that's not going to be enough you 20:09 know we need we need this kind of 20:11 collective movement like the one we've 20:13 been created and of course that's not 20:15 going to be enough either we also need 20:16 you know collective organization in the 20:18 form of you know trade unions political 20:21 parties a platform of transformation you 20:24 know this is 20:25 in the end what has made a difference in 20:27 the 20th century you know how did we get 20:29 to a more equal more prosperous society 20:33 well you know it was a trade union 20:35 movement uh 20:36 labour parties socialist participants so 20:39 you know we are not going to have the 20:40 same kind exactly of party and 20:42 collective organization in the future 20:44 but it will be another set of 20:47 uh 20:48 more you know 20:49 you know in line with the with the big 20:51 issues of the day you know uh 20:54 you know climate change development at 20:56 the world level uh migration you know 20:59 all but you know it will also take you 21:01 know this kind of big collective 21:02 movement and so everybody is part of the 21:05 solution and i think what's really 21:06 important is not to be 21:09 impressed by you know conservative 21:11 economic thinking you know people who 21:13 pretend you know they have built a 21:15 science that is so scientific that 21:17 nobody else can understand you know we 21:19 know this is a big joke you know i think 21:22 uh you know economics is a social 21:24 science you know we all have something 21:26 to bring sociologists anthropologists 21:28 political scientists historians 21:30 looking carefully at the values 21:32 historical experience and and you know 21:35 every citizens you know needs to 21:37 sort of 21:38 appropriate for herself himself you know 21:41 this body of knowledge in order to 21:43 participate 21:44 to collective action so thanks a lot for 21:47 you know contributing so much to this 21:49 with 21:50 democratizing work.
Tcherneva:
 21:51 thank you so very much i i think that's 21:53 a great note to end on i appreciate your 21:56 time and your work as well and um i will 21:59 urge our um 22:01 our viewers to come and join uh the 22:04 movement uh democratizing our 22:06 democratizingwork.org 22:08 thank you so very much thomas .
Piketty:
yeah thank 22:11 you very much.
 
 22:15 [Applause] 22:15 [Music] 22:17 [Applause] 22:18 [Music] 22:18 [Applause] 22:23 [Music] 22:34 you
–
06P41 - Full Employment and a Job Guarantee
Phil Harvey (Rutgers University; National Jobs for All Coalition), Trudy Goldberg (Adelphi University; Chair, National Jobs For All Coalition), Charles Bell (Consumer Reports), Noreen Connell, (Former Exec. Dir. Educational Priorities Panel, NY State; former Pres. of NOW, NY State; former Assist. Commissioner, NY State Dept. of Labor), Gregory N. Heires (Former Sr. Assoc. Editory, Public Press, DC 37, American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, New York City), Logan Martinez (National Jobs For All Coalition), Bich Ha Pham (Former Dire. of Public Policy, New York City Public Advocate's Office Frank Stricker, (California State University, Dominguez Hills), Stephen Monroe Tomczak (Southern Connecticut State University)
https://hopin.com/events/global-forum-on-democratizing-work#speakers

Global Forum on Democratizing Work

Before starting, here are some tips that might be of interest to you once registered:

  • The time zone in the schedule area automatically adapts to yours thanks to your VPN.
  • The full program is available in PDF via this link.
  • This is a fully online conference.
  • Every session is going to take place on this platform - there is no need for specific links, you can access all the sessions on this link.
  • You can watch a short tutorial on how to use this immersive platform here.
  • If you have any doubts, please have a look at the FAQs.
  • Click on this link to make a quick connectivity test and ensure you can access the platform smoothly: https://hopin.com/pre-event-check/

ENGLISH    The first-ever Global Forum on Democratizing Work will take place on 5–7 October 2021. It will allow building the future of the #DemocratizingWork movement, across geographical and disciplinary boundaries. The Global Forum will gather participants from universities, trade unions, progressive businesses, public institutions, environmental and human rights NGOs, the media. Beyond these communities, activists or concerned citizens who are interested in the message encapsulated in the manifesto is welcome. With such a transdisciplinary exchange of perspectives, we hope to fuel a productive and inclusive learning process about the Manifesto's principles. Participants will have the opportunity not only to attend sessions with prominent figures whose work focuses on the three core principles (DEMOCRATIZE, DECOMMODIFY, DECARBONIZE), but also to discuss ideas and initiatives in smaller groups, based on common but diverse interests.

FRANÇAIS    Le tout premier Forum mondial sur la démocratisation du travail se tiendra du 5 au 7 octobre 2021. Il représente l'occasion de construire ensemble le futur du mouvement #DemocratizingWork, au-delà des frontières géographiques et disciplinaires. Ce Forum mondial rassemblera des participants d'horizons divers : universités, syndicats, entreprises progressistes, institutions publiques, organisations non gouvernementales pour l'environnement et les droits humains, les médias, etc. Et toute autre citoyen.ne et militant.e qui, par-délà ces communautés, partagent le message véhiculé par le Manifeste Travail sont les bienvenu.e.s également. Nous espérons que ces différentes perspectives et échanges interdisciplinaires permettront d'alimenter et de soutenir un processus d'apprentissage des principes du Manifeste, qui se veut productif et inclusif. Les participant.e.s auront non seulement l'opportunité d'assister à des sessions lors desquelles interviendront des figures éminentes dont les travaux portent sur l'un ou l'autre des principes fondamentaux du Manifeste (DÉMOCRATISER, DÉMARCHANDISER, DÉPOLLUER), mais également d'échanger et de discuter à propos d'idées et d'initiatives au sein de groupes plus restreints, sur base de leurs intérêts communs mais variés.

ESPAÑOL    El primer Foro Mundial por la Democratización del Trabajo tendrá lugar del 5 al 7 de octubre de 2021. Permitirá construir el futuro del movimiento #DemocratizingWork, más allá de las fronteras geográficas y disciplinarias. El Foro Mundial reunirá a participantes de universidades, sindicatos, empresas progresistas, instituciones públicas, ONGs medioambientales y de derechos humanos, y medios de comunicación. Más allá de estas comunidades, serán bienvenidos y bienvenidas los y las activistas, ciudadanas/os interesadas/is en el mensaje del manifiesto. Con este intercambio de perspectivas transdisciplinar, esperamos alimentar un proceso de aprendizaje productivo e inclusivo sobre los principios del Manifiesto. Las y los participantes tendrán la oportunidad no sólo de asistir a sesiones con figuras destacadas cuyo trabajo se centra en los tres principios fundamentales (DEMOCRATIZAR, DESMERCANTILIZAR, DESCONTAMINAR), sino también de debatir ideas e iniciativas en grupos más pequeños, basados en intereses comunes pero diversos.

 

養老孟司「私は経済全く知りませんが、国に何百兆の借金があるとか言われてるでしょ? アレ全く心配してない。借金があるって事は誰かが貸してるんですよ。そんなお金持ちは誰? 皆さんですよ」

 

 『都市緑地の重要性』養老孟司×新里 達也 司会 関野吉晴 
2020

 養老孟司「私は経済全く知りませんが、国に何百兆の借金があるとか言われてるでしょ? アレ全く心配してない。借金があるって事は誰かが貸してるんですよ。そんなお金持ちは誰? 皆さんですよ」

MMT and Marxist monetary theory – a reply to Bill Mitchell by a man with no name – Michael Roberts Blog

MMT and Marxist monetary theory – a reply to Bill Mitchell by a man with no name – Michael Roberts Blog
参考

完全雇用の財政学― ウィリアム・ヴィックリーの完全雇用の経済学の検討 岡本英男
https://repository.tku.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/11150/10895/1/keizai293-12.pdf

https://twitter.com/_luminous_woman/status/1444221603500290052?s=21

《以上見てきたヴィックリーの完全雇用の経済学を要約すれば,次のようになる。
 インフレと政府の財政赤字を有害なものと考えることはやめなければならない。むしろ,
財政赤字は政府が可処分所得に貢献した指標と見なしうる。国債は退職時に備えるために
ますます大きくなる個人の貯蓄が安心して投資できる対象である。生産性の上昇にとって
妨害となるのは,インフレの水準ではなく,インフレの不確実性である。》


以下は左派によるMMT批判。安定が利益をもたらすという視点がない。

The  profit-investment nexus:  Keynes  or  Marx? By  Michael Roberts Paper  to Historical  Materialism New  York, April  2017 


 CONCLUSION The  Keynesians see  the  economy  as  a  money  economy  but  forget  that  it is  a  money-making economy.  "It is  not  the  ownership  of  the instruments  of production  which  it  is  important  for  the State  to  assume. If the  State  is able  to  determine  the  aggregate  amount  of  resources  devoted  to augmenting  the  instruments  and  the  basic  rate  of reward  to  those  who  own  them, it  will have accomplished  all  that  is  necessary."   (Keynes).   This paper  has argued: 1)  The  Keynesian  view  that effective  demand  and  investment  drive  profits is  logically  weak  and empirically  unproven. 2)  The Marxist  view  is  that  profitability  and  profits  drive  investment  in  a  capitalist  economy.  This is theoretically  logical  and  empirically  supported. 3)  This implies that  it  is  the  Marxist  multiplier  (the  changes  in  real  GDP  relative  to  profitability) that is a  better  guide  to  any  likely  recovery  in a  capitalist economy  than  the Keynesian multiplier  (changes  in  real  GDP  relative  to  government  net  spending  -  dissaving). 4)  Keynesian  fiscal  (and  monetary)  stimulus policy  prescriptions are  unlikely  to  work  in restoring  investment, growth and  employment in a  capitalist  economy  –  indeed  they  could even delay  recovery. 1Robert  Eisner  Factors  in  Business  Investment  (1978) 

 結論 ケインジアンは、経済を貨幣経済と見なしているが、貨幣経済であることを忘れている。 「国家が担うことが重要なのは、生産手段の所有権ではない。国家が、道具の増強に充てられる資源の総量と、道具を所有する者への基本的な報酬率を決定することができれば、必要なことはすべて達成されたことになる」。  (ケインズ)と述べている。)   本稿では、以下のことを主張した。1) 有効需要と投資が利益を促進するというケインズ派の見解は、論理的に弱く、経験的にも証明されていない。2)資本主義経済においては、収益性と利益が投資を促進するというマルクス主義的な考え方がある。 これは、理論的に論理的であり、経験的にも支持されている。3) このことは、資本主義経済の回復の可能性を示すよりも、マルクス主義の乗数(収益性に対する実質GDPの変化)の方が、ケインズ主義の乗数(政府純支出に対する実質GDPの変化)よりも優れていることを意味する。4) ケインズ主義的な財政(および金融)刺激政策の処方箋は、資本主義経済における投資、成長、雇用を回復させるためには機能しそうになく、むしろ回復を遅らせる可能性がある。1Robert Eisner Factors in Business Investment (1978) 

MMT and Marxist monetary theory – a reply to Bill Mitchell by a man with no name

Bill Mitchell is a Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at the University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia. Professor Mitchell is one of the world's leading exponents of what is called Modern Monetary Theory (MMT).  MMT has gained traction in the labour movement in recent years on the grounds that it provides powerful new arguments to refute the claims of mainstream economics that governments need to balance their books ie keep spending in line with tax revenues and not allow government debt to spiral.  In order to balance the books, so the mainstream argument goes, government spending must be cut, taxes raised and debt levels reduced, even if that means more poverty and worse public services.  There is no alternative – as Margaret Thatcher once said.

However, MMT is supposed to offer the answers to the Austerians, both theoretically and in alternative policies.  Professor Mitchell, among other MMT supporters, has tirelessly campaigned for the adoption of MMT measures in the labour movement as the key answer to ending unemployment and austerity as policies that must be accepted by the labour movement.

Now I have spent much ink on my blog and in papers discussing and debating the merits of MMT as the answer to capitalist policies of austerity and unemployment.  In my humble opinion, MMT falls short of achieving its claims and objectives because it ignores the social structure of a capitalist economy and argues that the recognition and manipulation of the monetary system can solve the problems without ending capitalism.

At a recent fringe meeting at the UK Labour party conference, I was invited to debate the merits of MMT with Professor Mitchell contributing by zoom from Australia.  Shortly after the debate, Professor Mitchell posted on his blog, the following:

"I gave a talk at the Resist Event in Brighton UK last Sunday evening. On the panel was a person who dismissed Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) as irrelevant to the real challenges that arose under capitalism and he invoked Marx a lot. It was not a very illuminating interchange because not only did he misrepresent what MMT was but, in my view, he also seemed to think that we could extrapolate Marx's scant ideas of money directly into the situation faced by nations today."

Well guess what? This 'a person' was me, but I shall remain nameless as far as Professor Mitchell was concerned.  And it was not strictly true that Professor Mitchell "gave a talk" to which we all listened.  It was a discussion or debate with three speakers: Mitchell, myself (suitably named at the event) and Carlos Gonzales of 'fiat socialism' fame.

In his posts, Professor Mitchell seeks to dismiss my arguments that MMT does not take us very far in explaining the nature of a capitalist economy or providing decisive economic policies that will help labour. Professor Mitchell thinks that I have not only "misunderstood MMT but also have a scant understanding of Marx's monetary theory".  He says Marx would never have agreed that government spending could not end unemployment or that capitalists would not increase production and employment if government spending orders came in. 

In the debate I said that Marx attacked the idea that, just by manipulating money, governments could solve unemployment and poverty.  This was the view of Pierre Proudhon, the leading socialist of the mid-19th century. Marx responded: "Can the existing relations of production and the relations of distribution which correspond to them be revolutionized by a change in the instrument of circulation, in the organization of circulation? Further question: Can such a transformation of circulation be undertaken without touching the existing relations of production and the social relations which rest on them?"

In his post, Professor Mitchell refers to Professor Duncan Foley (at least he gets named!) who asserts that for Marx, "the movement of commodities is largely determined outside the monetary sphere, and that movements of money in most cases are determined by those commodity movements…..The theoretical question then arises as to which is the determining factor. Does the movement of money determine the movement of commodities or the movement of commodities determine the movement of money?" Mitchell rejects Foley's approach to money and reckons that Marx is out of date with this critique of Proudhon because back then money was gold or backed by gold, which meant its value was anchored to the production cost of gold mining.  Now, in the modern world of 'fiat currencies', the state can create money that is not tied to the value or price of gold and therefore the state can increase the amount of money at will. 

I do not agree that this makes Marx out of date. Contrary to the view of MMT, fiat money does not change the role or nature of money in a capitalist economy. Its value is still tied to the labour time taken in capitalist accumulation. Commodity money (gold) contains value while non-commodity money represents/reflects value, and because of this, both can measure the value of any other commodities and express it in price-form. Modern states are clearly crucial to the reproduction of money and the system in which it circulates. But their power over money is quite limited – and as Marx would have said, the limits are clearest in determining the 'value' of money. The state mint can print any numbers on its bills and coins, or the central bank add any number of digits to the government's bank account, but that cannot decide what those numbers refer to. That is determined in countless price-setting decisions by mainly private firms, reacting strategically to the structure of costs and demand they face, in competition with other firms.

The MMT supporters, in effect, reckon that any reduction in private sector investment can be replaced or added to by government investment 'paid for' by the 'creation of money out of thin air'. But this money will lose its value (ie purchasing power) if it does not bear any relation to value created by the productive sectors of the capitalist economy, which determine the amount to value generated and still dominate the economy. Instead, the result will be rising prices and/or falling profitability that will eventually choke off production in the private sector. Unless the MMT proponents are then prepared to move to a Marxist policy conclusion: namely the appropriation of the finance sector and the 'commanding heights' of the productive sector through public ownership and a plan of production, thus curbing or ending the law of value in the economy, the policy of government spending through unlimited money creation will fail.

As far as I can tell, MMT exponents studiously avoid and ignore such a policy conclusion – perhaps because like Proudhon they misunderstand the reality of capitalism, preferring 'tricks of circulation'; or perhaps because they actually oppose the abolition of the capitalist mode of production (indeed, that is the view of most MMT exponents, although not Professor Mitchell).  You see, MMT is not relevant to a social transformation of society, Professor Mitchell argued in the debate – that is a separate question.  Right-wing, pro-capitalists can and do accept MMT.

Professor Mitchell goes on to highlight something in a post by this unnamed "critic on the panel".  Yes, it's me again – at least I am now on the panel.  In one of my blog posts on MMT HERE, I had a plotted figure that shows that there is no inverse correlation between increased government spending and unemployment.  On the contrary, among OECD countries, the higher the level of government spending, the higher unemployment!  

Professor Mitchell now applied his superior understanding of statistics to this result.  "In Statistics 101 or Econometrics 101, one of the first things students learn is to be careful in attributing causality. Correlation is not causality."  Indeed, how could I be so stupid! But I'm not.  Of course, this correlation does not prove causation.  Indeed, that is what I conclude in the post: namely that there must be other reasons than the amount of state spending to explain unemployment rates.  As Mitchell says: "We would expect government spending to be higher in nations that had higher unemployment because of increases in welfare outlays and other non-discretionary responses to declining non-government spending (that was driving up unemployment)." Exactly, because what drives unemployment rates in a capitalist economy is the rate of investment and employment made by the capitalist sector.  When there is a slump in investment and people are laid off to join what Marx called "the reserve of army of labour", government spending rises as benefit spending increases.  Having said that, the graph suggests that there is no evidence that unemployment falls when government spending rises, because there are much more compelling causes that affect employment.

In his second post dealing the views of the unnamed 'critic' of MMT, Professor Mitchell claims that he can show "how nonsensical it is to claim that capitalist firms will not expand production if they have idle capacity and can increase profits by responding to increased sales orders." And that "the government sector is not bound by the so-called dynamics of private capital accumulation and under certain conditions can typically command productive resources from the non-government sector through increased spending without introducing inflationary pressures."

In this post, Professor Mitchell takes us through a short course on the history of crisis theory, from Say and Ricardo's views that general overproduction was impossible, to the underconsumption theories of Sismondi, Luxemburg and others.  And then he says: "Marx considered the accumulation process would lead to an excessive build-up of capital which would suppress the rate of profit and it was this dynamic that generated the crisis."  Well yes, that was Marx's theory of crises, more or less in a nutshell. 

But having said this, Mitchell quickly takes a step back: "But, we need to be careful in unpicking the logic here. Yes, the owners of capital control production and employment and their expectations of future returns dictate the rate at which the capital stock accumulates over time. But equally, when considering the causes of crises, we cannot avoid focusing on the realisation issue because it was through market exchange that capitalists were able to realise the surplus value they had expropriated in the production process by exploiting their workers into the monetary form of profit."  Mitchell then claims Marx for his own theory of crises "As we move through history, the scholars that followed Marx clearly understood that effective demand was a causal factor in determining unemployment and recession."  So there we have it.  Forget Marx's profitability theory as the driver of accumulation and thus investment demand.  Let's revert to the same position as orthodox Keynesians: that crises are due to a lack of 'effective demand'.

Now I have spent much print and digital inputs from my computer showing that the Keynesian-Mitchell lack of effective demand theory is an inadequate explanation of regular and recurring crises in capitalist production. You can read my arguments here.  https://thenextrecession.files.wordpress.com/2017/06/the-profit-investment-nexus-michael-roberts-hmny-april-2017.pdf

But in this post let me mention just one point.  Why does capitalist production seem to have enough effective demand for years or even a decade, and then suddenly investment and production collapses, unemployment rockets and there is a 'lack of effective demand'?  The Keynesian/MMT has no answer to this question. The answer lies in the contradictions within the capitalist mode of production, specifically in the tendency for the profitability of capital to fall over time and eventually lead to a fall in total profits and value creation.  Then investment demand collapses, leading to a lack of aggregate demand so that capitalist production cannot be 'realised'. This is the causal sequence in crises.

Mitchell invokes the post-Keynesian arguments of Michel Kalecki to justify his view that it is aggregate demand that drives sales, production and profits.  Professor Mitchell quotes Kalecki: "to offset any tendency for the rate of profit on the expanded capital stock to fall and thus offset the possibility of a crises (so very Marxian – really MR?), Kalecki wrote (page 87): "… if effective demand adequate to secure full employment is created by stimulating private investment the devices which we use for it must cumulatively increase to offset the influence of the falling rate of profit."

Talking again of correlation, identities and causation, there is the Kalecki identity (investment = profits); and there is the correlation (investment moves with profits); but which is the causal direction?  Kalecki argues that investment drives profits, but this is back to front.  In my view, Marx correctly argued that, in a capitalist economy, profits drive investment, not vice versa as Kalecki argues. Kalecki's view is that of the capitalist, namely that to quote him, the capitalist 'earns what he spends' while the worker 'spends what he earns'.  But Marxist economic theory denies this.  The capitalist can only spend (invest or consume) what is extracted from the work force in surplus value or profit.  Profits call the tune, not investment or consumption. 

That is why boosting government spending, either by traditional borrowing methods (buying bonds held by the finance sector) or by 'printing money' (sorry, I meant making digital keystrokes into government accounts) will not guarantee expansion of employment or faster growth – if the profitability of capital is low and/or falling. 

As Cullen Roche, an orthodox Keynesian, put it: "MMT gets the causality backwards here by starting with the state and working out….. The proper causality is that private resources necessarily precede taxes. Without a highly productive revenue generating private sector there is nothing special about the assets created by a government and it is literally impossible for these assets to remain valuable. We create equity when we produce real goods and services or increase the market value of our assets relative to their liabilities via productive output. It is completely illogical and beyond silly to argue that one can just "print" equity from thin air. Government debt is, logically, a liability of the society that creates it. In the aggregate government debt is a liability that must be financed by the productive output of that society."

Indeed, with government investment averaging just 2-3% of GDP in most major economies and capitalist investment averaging 15-20%, it is going to take a huge jump in government spending (particularly) investment to replace capitalist investment – indeed to the point of ending the dominance of capitalist investment entirely.

That's the theory, but is there any empirical proof that profits lead investment and a fall in profits, and it is not the 'lack of effective demand' that leads to slumps?  Oh yes, there is.  Let me just cite one study by Jose Tapia.  Investment, profits and crises, Chapter Three of World in Crisis.  See p115.  Is there any empirical evidence showing that increased government spending has little or no effect on boosting 'aggregate demand'?  Oh yes there is.  Again, Jose Tapia has done the stats – and these are not correlations but applied causal analysis ("Direct acyclic graphs (DAGs) are used for identification purposes, i.e., as tool to elucidate causal issues").

Tapia finds that: "overall these results seem quite inconsistent with the hypothesis that an increase in government spending will pump-prime the economy by raising private investment and overall, the results of the models seem consistent with a null unconditioned association between lag government expenditure and present consumption incompatible with a causal effect.  So that "the Keynesian view that government expenditure may pump-prime the economy by stimulating private investment is also inconsistent with the finding that the net effect of lagged government expending on private investment is rather null or even significantly negative in recent decades."

Professor Mitchell is convinced that "capitalist firms will respond to increased sales demand by producing goods and services.  If they think the demand is stable, they will invest and build productive capacity if they are currently at full capacity."  But just in case, "if they decide for any reason not to respond, then the government can always employ and produce itself." So we have a sort of two stage policy. As Professor Mitchell said in the debate in answering the unnamed 'person' and 'critic' of MMT: first we must break with the policies of austerity coming from the mainstream by adopting MMT policies; and then and afterwards, because it is a separate issue, we must look at changing the social structure as good socialists (as indeed Professor Mitchell is). 

I take this to mean that in applying MMT to government policies, we can ignore (for now) the continuance of fossil fuel production, big pharma control on health, the reckless greed of capitalist banking, the dominance of the tech and media monopolies.  These niceties of capitalism are irrelevant to the aims of MMT as MMT has nothing to say on these economic formations.  But precisely because MMT ignores that very social structure, its pursuit of achieving full employment through the 'tricks of circulation' of money will fail. 




以下は紹介記事

Michael Roberts — MMT and Marxist monetary theory – a reply to Bill Mitchell by a man with no name ~ Mike Norman Economics
http://mikenormaneconomics.blogspot.com/2021/10/michael-roberts-mmt-and-marxist.html

Michael Roberts — MMT and Marxist monetary theory – a reply to Bill Mitchell by a man with no name

Important. Here is the beginning of a debate over MMT and Marx, if Bill (and perhaps other MMT economists) take up the challenge. But I think Bill is much more acquainted with Marx than other MMT economists — excepting Peter Cooper, of course, but I am not sure how he would characterize himself. Hopefully, Peter will join in the debate at his blog (heteconomist.com), which is the premier site treating MMT and Marx.

There are a lot of details in the post and I would like to hear an exchange over these issues among the relevant parties, that is economists familiar with both MMT and Marx, which I realize is probably only a few.

Michael Roberts (as I understand him from a quick reading) claims that Marx hold that the the profit motive is the driver of capitalism and that Marx further held that investment drives profits. Therefore, he disputes the MMT (Keynesian) claim that effective demand drives profits since, in his view, effective demand depends on investment. 

What he appears to overlook that profit is not the only source of investment (re-investment) nor are firm disbursements (wages and dividends) the sole source of effective demand. 

MMT points out that both firms and consumers also borrow on credit and credit is really the basis for circulation in a monetary production economy. Minsky showed that financial (credit) cycles drive the business cycles, introducing instability as credit issuance runs up against it the limit and the cycle climaxes in a debt crisis.

In addition, government is a major player in modern economics, so understanding its influence as a primary factor in capitalist economies is crucial.  

This is the dynamic that MMT addresses. It seems to me that MMT economists hold that the cycle can be smoothed and downturns ameliorated, but I don't think that they claim that the financial/business cycle can be eliminated.

I think that MMT economists, Marxians and other heterodox economists are close to being in the same page regarding the outcome of liberal economics on ecology and that only state interference can adequately approach the issues, which will necessitate changing the basic nature of economic liberalism one way or other in the direction of socialism. The only way to preserve a modicum of economic liberalism is by imposing true cost accounting that takes externality into account rigorously. Would that be enough? Not really, since there are other isuues.

There are the social consequences of rising inequality. Obviously, the only adequate answer to this is more socialism involving distributive justice aimed at producing common (distributive) prosperity as a public good and a necessity condition for social cohesion.

I am in basic agreement with Michael Roberts' main point, that "capitalism" as economic liberalism (laissez-faire) is the problem and there is no way to fix it and have it remain economic liberalism. This is a key fundamental in the paradox of liberalism, in which social, political and economic liberalism cannot be resolved. Either economic liberalism will dominant at the expense of social and political liberalism, or social and political liberalism will result on the imposition of socialism on capitalism. 

This is happening in China, ironically, since China is not socially and economically liberal in the Western sense. But the Chinese government realizes that to stay in power it needs popular approval and adjust its policy based on public opinion, which it researches carefully. As a result the China government has the overwhelming approval of the populace, while the opposite is the case in the West.

However, it must also be noted that in the West, economic liberalism as laissez-faire is no longer the case, even though the principles are advocated. Rather, the reality now is neoliberalism, which is state capture by capital through institutional arrangement that class power is used to impose to its advantage. This is the basis issue facing the world today, since neoliberalism is joined at the hip with neo-imperialism and neocolonialism. 
I credit Marxists and Marxians for calling attention to this. Most conventional economists are working within the paradigm of economic liberalism — spontaneous order as general equilibrium arising from rational maximization in markets that are shaped by market forces involving unrealistic assumptions.

Michael Roberts Blog — blogging from a marxist economist
MMT and Marxist monetary theory – a reply to Bill Mitchell by a man with no name
Michael Roberts

2021年10月2日土曜日

ABEMA将棋ch(アベマ)さんのツイート

2016ケルトンMMT Is How It Already Works

2016ケルトンMMT Is How It Already Works

これはMMTの本質の一部ですが、多くの人々がMMTは金銭的資金調達の体制への切り替えについてであると考えています。いいえ! MMTは、私たちがすでにその体制にあることを示しています。私たちdo *秘密の*金銭的資金調達であり、量的緩和とは何の関係もありません。


2016
MMT Is How It Already Works


Stephanie Kelton -The Economic Movement of Bernie Sanders
2016/10/18
43:25~

{We just talked about the free public education. Could MMT be a way to finance this... this initiative by just like the government-run a budget deficit? Very practically, like, could such an example for example, free public education... Could MMT be a way... to finance this... this project? Is it...} Well, I wouldn't say.... {other way, actually a different way, to say has it been tried in practice, this MMT theory?}


Kelton:
 Okay, so here... It's a great question. I'm really glad that you asked it because MMT isn't something that you try or don't try. It's a description of how things already work. So what what I've tried to do in my scholarly work, and a number of other academics who contribute to this literature have tried to do, is to explain that this is already the way government finance works. We're not making a proposal to change the way we finance spending. So for example, the Iraq war, okay? How did we pay for the iraq war and the answer is we paid for it exactly the same way we pay for everything. Congress goes in and authorizes the spending and so what it would take to get for example free college is for Congress to go in and authorize the spending and if you had a piece of legislation that was as we call it a clean bill which didn't include these "pay-fors" -- where're you going to find the money? -- we just say here's a proposal. We're going to spend 75 billion a year, providing a college tuition at all public colleges and universities to anybody who wants to go. If enough members raise their hand and vote for that legislation it triggers the payments. The payments just happen by virtue of the authorization to spend and then you get whatever revenue you get and at the end of the fiscal year you find out whether you had a surplus or deficit. {okay} 英語



MMT Is How It Already Works
https://youtu.be/3zpPi30Bheo
{無料の公教育について話しました。MMTは、政府が財政赤字を運営するように、この...この構想を資金調達する方法ではないでしょうか?非常に現実的な話ですが、例えば公教育の無償化のような例は... MMTはこの...このプロジェクトの資金を調達するための方法なのでしょうか?それは...?} まあ、私は言いません.... {このMMT理論が実際に試されているかどうかは、別の言い方をすれば、実際に試されていると言えるでしょう。}


Kelton:
 さて、それでは... これは素晴らしい質問ですね。なぜなら、MMTは試すとか試さないとかいうものではないからです。MMTは、試すか試さないかの問題ではなく、物事がすでにどのように機能しているかを説明するものなのです。ですから、私が学者として試みたこと、そしてこの文献に寄稿している他の多くの学者が試みたことは、政府の財政はすでにこのように機能しているということを説明することです。私たちは、支出を賄う方法を変える提案をしているわけではありません。例えば、イラク戦争ですね。イラク戦争の費用はどうやって捻出したかというと、答えは、すべての費用を捻出するのとまったく同じ方法で捻出しました。例えば、大学の無償化を実現するためには、議会が支出を承認する必要があります。そして、私たちがクリーンな法案と呼んでいるものがあれば、このような「ペイ・フォア」(どこでお金を調達するのか?-- 私たちはただ、ここに提案があると言うだけです。年間750億ドルを投じて、すべての公立大学の授業料を希望者に提供するのです。その法案に多くの議員が手を挙げて投票すれば、支払いが開始されます。支払いは支出許可によって行われ、その後はどんな収入でも得られ、会計年度末には黒字か赤字かが判明します。{OK]をクリックしてください。


全体
Stephanie Kelton -The Economic Movement of Bernie Sanders
2016/10/18
43:25~

インフレ率 雑食さんのツイート